Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Abstract
The
13.03.2008
Structure
Status
of current status
Range
Test
of approvals
program
Comparison
Comments
Conclusions
13.03.2008
13.03.2008
IEEE
13.03.2008
Standards: MV-Application
IEC
IEC 60502-4 Um 42 kV
IEC 60502-4 Um 42 kV
CENELEC
EN
HD 629 Um 42 kV
EN 61442 Um 42 kV
HD 629 Um 42 kV
EN 61442 Um 42 kV
IEEE
IEEE 48 Um 46 kV
13.03.2008
CENELEC ?
European
Committee for
Electrotechnical Standardisation
CENELEC
members
13.03.2008
affiliates
EU neighbouring countries
Standards: HV Application
Termination
IEC
CENELEC
IEEE
13.03.2008
HD 632 Um 145 kV
EN 61442
HD 632 Um 145 kV
IEEE 48 Um 550kV
EN 61442
Standards: HV Application
Splices
13.03.2008
IEC
CENELEC
HD 632 Um 145kV
IEEE
IEC Titles
10
13.03.2008
Part 2: Cables for rated voltages from 6kV (Um= 7.2 kV) up to 36 kV
(Um = 42kV)
Part 3: reserved
11
13.03.2008
12
60502-2 / HD 629-1
13.03.2008
requirements:
IEC 60502-4
13
13.03.2008
specification covers
Termination
Indoor
Outdoor
Splices
14
Rating
200/250A; 400A
600 / 630 A; 800A; 1250 A
13.03.2008
Single
Approval
15
13.03.2008
DC level is lower than from IEEE #482009 >30%, timing is the same.
16
13.03.2008
IEC 60502-4
Test voltage
2.5 U0
IEC 60502-4
17
13.03.2008
10,00
100,00
BIL/Uo
10,00
BIL/Uo
AC/Uo
AC/Uo
1,00
U0
U0
The diagrams show the different values for Bil and ACWithstand based on phase to ground voltage U0
18
13.03.2008
26,0
21,0
16,0
11,0
6,0
1,0
26,0
21,0
16,0
11,0
6,0
1,0
1,00
Time
Cycle time 8h
Temperature monitoring
2 h steady
one cycle 8h
19
13.03.2008
Time
Cycle time 24 h
6 h steady
one cycle 24h
20
13.03.2008
Other differences
IEEE 404
IEC 60502-4
170ms I 35 kA,
3 categories t = 10 ms < 60 ms
Ip>63kA,
Ip>80 kA,
Ip>125 kA
21
13.03.2008
More differences.....
IEEE
IEC
48
No weathering
60502-4
Humidity testing
22
13.03.2008
300 h @ 1.25 U0
(0.4 0.1) l/h/m Water
(70 10) mS/m
1000 h @ 1.25 U0
(0.4 0.1) l/h/m Water
(1600 200) mS/m
IEC 60840
Differences
23
It differentiates in
13.03.2008
Routine test
Type test
IEC 60840
24
13.03.2008
10,00
10,00
2.5 U0
BIL/Uo
BIL/Uo
AC/Uo
AC/Uo
1,00
The diagrams show the different values for Bil and AC- Withstand
based on phase to ground voltage U0.
The BIL due to insulation coordination IEEE 1313.1 & IEC 600711-2 is nearly equivalent.
25
13.03.2008
90,0
80,0
70,0
60,0
40,0
30,0
50,0
U0
100,0
U0
20,0
100,0
90,0
80,0
70,0
60,0
50,0
40,0
30,0
20,0
1,00
Thermal Cycling
IEC 60840
Test
Partial discharge
U0 for 30 sec,
then decreased to 1.75U0
PD q 5pC
(133kV 5sec then 114kV
PD)
26
13.03.2008
IEEE 48 /404
PD @ q 3pC
(140kV 30sec 120kV PD)
Peschke, Siemens
27
13.03.2008
Test
Heat cycle test
AC Voltage Withstand
2.5 U0 = 190 kV
30 min
1.75Uo for 10 sec,
then decreased to 1.5 U0
28
13.03.2008
Partial
Discharge
PD q 5pC
(133kV 5sec then 114kV
PD)
20kV D.C. 1min
Sheath -Sheath
10 shots 60-75 kV
Sheath Ground
10 shots 30-37.5 kV
IEEE 48 /404
2 Uo for 30 sec,
then decreased to 1.75 U0
PD q 3pC
(140kV 5sec then 124kV PD)
Sectionalizer
29
13.03.2008
IEC 62067
30
13.03.2008
10,00
10,00
BIL/Uo
BIL/Uo
AC/Uo
AC/Uo
The diagrams show the different values for BIL and AC- Withstand
based on phase to ground voltage U0.
The BIL due to insulation coordination IEEE 1313.1 & IEC 60071-1-2 is
is different, since the IEEE uses different categories.
31
13.03.2008
300,0
250,0
200,0
150,0
50,0
300,0
250,0
200,0
150,0
100,0
50,0
100,0
1,00
1,00
Comments
Up
cables
Beyond
BIL
32
13.03.2008
Comments
The
(IEEE).
The
Cable system thermal short circuit tests are not covered in the IEEE
404 & 48. The It based on level Ik 35 kA for 170 ms does provide
conductor temperatures << 250C (XLPE) lower as requested.
33
13.03.2008
Conclusion
Since
It
34
13.03.2008
35
13.03.2008