Professional Documents
Culture Documents
&GA ratio
'tate#ent a is false. The $A)) does not necessarily increase. Ae#e#ber/ you
are relacing high cost e*uity with low cost debt. $hen there is very little
debt in the caital structure/ the $A)) will actually decrease. ('ee the
diagra# above.! The caital structure that #a(i#i4es stock rice is not
necessarily the caital structure that #a(i#i4es 56'/ so state#ent b is false.
If the cororate ta( rate increases/ co#anies will obtain a bigger ta(
advantage for their interest ay#ents. Thus/ they #ay increase their debt
levels to take advantage of this situation/ and this would raise debt ratios.
Therefore/ the correct answer is state#ent c.
1>. Capital structure and WACC Answer: e Diff: E
'tate#ent a is false; if you are to the left of the fir#,s oti#al caital
structure on the $A)) curve/ increasing a co#any,s debt ratio will actually
decrease the fir#,s $A)). 'tate#ent b is false; if you are to the right of the
fir#,s oti#al caital structure on the $A)) curve/ increasing a co#any,s debt
ratio will actually increase the fir#,s $A)). 'tate#ent c is false; as you
increase the fir#,s debt ratio the cost of debt will increase because you,re
using #ore debt. Because you,re using #ore debt the cost of e*uity also
increases because the fir#,s financial risk has increased. Fro# state#ents a
and b you can see that whether the $A)) is increased deends on where you are
on the $A)) curve relative to the fir#,s oti#al caital structure. Therefore/
the correct answer is state#ent e.
1=. Capital structure, OA, and OE Answer: d Diff: E
'tate#ents a and b are correct; therefore/ state#ent d is the aroriate
choice. A1A 8 NIGTA. If total assets re#ain the sa#e/ but NI decreases
(because of the new interest ay#ent!/ A1A will decrease. NI will fall/ but not
as #uch in co#arison to the a#ount that co##on e*uity will fall because B56 X
k
d
/ thus A15 8 NIG)5 will rise. B56 will re#ain the sa#e. B56 8 5BITGTA/ where
TA and 5BIT re#ain the sa#e (which was given in the roble#!.
"9
. Capital structure, WACC, T!E, and E"# Answer: a Diff: E
'tate#ent a is correct; the other state#ents are false. The caital structure
that #a(i#i4es the fir#,s stock rice generally calls for a debt ratio that is
lower than the one that #a(i#i4es 56'. The fir# could #a(i#i4e its TI5 by
having no debt (that is 4ero interest ay#ents!. But/ this caital structure
would robably not #a(i#i4e the fir#,s stock rice.
"1. Capital structure t$e%r& Answer: d Diff: E
'tate#ents a and c are correct; therefore/ state#ent d is the correct choice.
An increase in the cororate ta( rate reduces the after3ta( cost of debt #aking
it #ore attractive relative to e*uity. Thus/ fir#s #ight be e(ected to use
#ore debt in their caital structure rather than less debt.
"". 'iscellane%us capital structure c%ncepts Answer: c Diff: E N
The correct answer is state#ent c. 'tate#ent a is not correct. @ust the
oosite is true33we would e(ect co#anies to use less debt. 'tate#ent b is
not correct. The additional debt would result in an increase in interest
e(ense and a decrease in net inco#e. 'ince assets are unchanged/ the
co#anyPs A1A #ust decrease. 'tate#ent c is correct. The additional debt
would be used to urchase additional assets. $e are told that the A1A stays
the sa#e. Therefore/ if assets increase/ it #ust #ean that net inco#e also
increases. There is no change in e*uity/ so the A15 of the fir# #ust increase.
"+ . (inancial leverage and E"#
Answer: a Diff: E
'tate#ent a is true; a higher 56' does not always #ean that the stock rice
will increase. 'tate#ent b is false; a lower $A)) will #ean a higher stock
rice. 'tate#ent c is false; 56' can increase 0ust because shares outstanding
decline. (The fir#,s net inco#e will decline because its interest e(ense
increases.!
"-. (inancial leverage and E"# Answer: c Diff: E
'tate#ent a is false because B56 8 5BITGTotal assets. The e(tent to which the
fir# uses debt financing does not affect 5BIT or total assets. 'tate#ent b is
false because fir#s with a high ercentage of fi(ed costs have a high degree of
oerating leverage by definition.
"2. (inancial leverage and rati%s Answer: d Diff: E
B56 8 5BITGTA. 'ince they both have the sa#e total assets and the sa#e B56/
then 5BIT #ust be the sa#e for both co#anies. If A has a higher debt ratio
and higher interest e(ense than B/ and they both have the sa#e 5BIT and ta(
rate/ then A #ust have a lower NI than B. Therefore/ state#ent a is true. If
A has a lower NI than B but both have the sa#e total assets/ then A,s A1A
(NIGTA! #ust be lower than B,s A1A. Therefore/ state#ent b is true. If both
co#anies have the sa#e total assets but A,s debt ratio is higher than B,s/
then A,s e*uity #ust be lower (since Total assets 8 Total debt U Total e*uity!.
If A has less e*uity/ and a lower NI than B/ it is not ossible to 0udge which
co#any,s A15 (NIG5Q! is higher.
"7. (inancial leverage and rati%s Answer: ) Diff: E
B56 8 5BITGTA. If both fir#s have the sa#e B56 ratio and sa#e total assets/
then they #ust have the sa#e 5BIT. 'ince Fir# . has no debt in its caital
structure/ Fir# . will have higher net inco#e than Fir# F because . has no
interest e(ense and F does. The TI5 ratio is 5BITGInt. If the two co#anies
have the sa#e 5BIT/ the one with the lower interest e(ense (Fir# .!/ will have
a higher TI5. Therefore/ state#ent a is false. Fir#s F and . have the sa#e
5BIT/ but Fir# F has a higher interest e(ense/ so its net inco#e will be lower
than Fir# .. 'ince A1A is e*ual to NIGTA/ and the two fir#s have the sa#e total
assets/ Fir# F will have a lower A1A than Fir# .. Therefore/ state#ent b is
true. Feverage will increase A15 if B56 X k
d
. 'ince B56 is "9 ercent and k
d
is > ercent/ leverage will increase Fir# F,s A15. Therefore/ state#ent c is
false.
"?. Optimal capital structure Answer: d Diff: '
">. Operating and financial leverage Answer: e Diff: '
"=. (inancial leverage and rati%s Answer: c Diff: '
'tate#ent a is false; A,s net inco#e is lower than B,s due to higher interest
e(ense/ but its assets are e*ual to B,s/ so A,s A1A #ust be lower than B,s
A1A. 'tate#ent b is false; A has the sa#e 5BIT as B/ but higher interest
ay#ents than B; therefore/ A,s TI5 is lower than B,s. 'tate#ent c is correct.
+9. Limits %f leverage Answer: d Diff: '
+1. #ignaling t$e%r& Answer: ) Diff: '
+". Capital structure and WACC Answer: d Diff: '
'tate#ent b is false because it is not always true.
++. Capital structure and WACC Answer: ) Diff: '
'tate#ent b is true; the other state#ents are false. The cost of retained
earnings should be higher than debt financing. 56' is #a(i#i4ed at a higher
caital structure than the one that #ini#i4es the fir#,s weighted average cost
of caital. Increasing debt increases the risk of bankrutcy/ which can
increase the costs of both debt and e*uity.
+-. 'iscellane%us capital structure c%ncepts Answer: a Diff: '
'tate#ent a is true; the other state#ents are false. If the ersonal ta( rate
were increased/ investors would refer to receive less of their inco#e as
interest33i#lying fir#s would substitute e*uity for debt. Eigh business risk
is associated with high oerating leverage; therefore/ fir#s with high business
risk would use less debt.
+2
. 'iscellane%us capital structure c%ncepts Answer: c Diff: '
If cororate ta( rates were decreased while other things were held constant/
and if the MM ta(3ad0usted tradeoff theory of caital structure were correct/
cororations would decrease their use of debt because the ta( shelter benefit
would not be as great as when ta( rates are high. Business risk is the
riskiness of the fir#,s oerations if it uses no debt. The oti#al caital
structure does not #a(i#i4e 56'/ and the degree of total leverage shows how a
given change in sales will affect earnings er share.
+7
. *ariati%ns in capital structures Answer: d Diff: T
+?. Determining price fr%m EB!T Answer: e Diff: E
5BIT 8 6Q 3 DQ 3 F)
<=2/999 8 6(22/999! 3 (9.-!6(22/999! 3 <119/999
<"92/999 8 (9.7!(22/999!6
<"92/999 8 ++/9996
6 8 <7."1.
+>
. Breakeven price Answer: a Diff: E
Total costs 8 <19/999 U <"(-"/999! 8 <=-/999.
6rice 8 <=-/999G-"/999 8 <"."-.
+=
. New financing Answer: a Diff: '
1ld debt ratio 8 9.++++; New debt ratio 8 9.177?.
TA
'ales
8 ?.2.
TA 8
?.2
<?29/999
8 <199/999.
&ebt 8 9.++++(<199/999! 8 <++/+++.
New TA 8 <199/999 U <199/999 8 <"99/999.
New &ebt 8 <"99/999(9.177?! 8 <++/+++.
Alt#an,s current debt of <++/+++ reresents aro(i#ately 17.7?: of total
assets following the e(ansion/ thus the fir# should finance with 199 ercent
e*uity.
-9
. Net %perating inc%me Answer: ) Diff: '
Total cost
Method 1
8 <1.99(Q! U <19/999.
Total cost
Method "
8 <1.29(Q! U <2/999.
'et e*ual and solve for QJ
Q U <19/999 8 <1.29(Q! U <2/999
<2/999 8 <9.2(Q!
19/999 8 Q.
-1
. C$ange in )reakeven v%lume Answer: ) Diff: '
)alculate the old and new breakeven volu#es using the old data and new
ro0ectionsJ
1ld Q
B5
8 <1"9/999G(<1."9 3 <9.79! 8 <1"9/999G<9.79 8 "99/999 units.
New Q
B5
8 <"-9/999G(<1.92 3 <9.-1! 8 <"-9/999G<9.7- 8 +?2/999 units.
)hange in breakeven volu#e 8 +?2/999 3 "99/999 8 1?2/999 units.
-". Breakeven and e+pansi%n Answer: c Diff: '
)alculate the initial breakeven volu#e in dollarsJ
1ld '
B5
8
'ales
D)
3 1
F)
8
6riceGunit
D)Gunit
3 1
F)
8
<?.99
<-."9
3 1
<-99/999
8
9.79 3 1
<-99/999
8 <1/999/999.
)alculate the new breakeven volu#e in sales dollarsJ
New '
B5
8
<?.99
<-.->
3 1
<729/999
8
9.7- 3 1
<729/999
8 <1/>92/227.
The increase in '
B
8 <1/>92/227 3 <1/999/999 8 <>92/227.
-+. Breakeven Answer: d Diff: '
<?("99/999! 3 <2("99/999! 3 F 8 9
F 8 <-99/999.
<?("99/999! 3 <-("99/999! 3 F 8 9
F 8 <799/999.
<799/999 3 <-99/999 8 <"99/999.
--
. Operating decisi%n Answer: d Diff: '
)alculate 5BIT
1
at -9/999 units using the current sales riceJ
5BIT
1
8 ' 3 D) 3 F)
8 -9/999(<".12! 3 9.+9(-9/999!(<".12! 3 <-7/999
8 <>7/999 3 <"2/>99 3 <-7/999 8 <1-/"99.
)alculate 5BIT
"
at 29/999 units using the lower rice of <1.=2J
5BIT
"
8 29/999(<1.=2! 3 9.+9(29/999!(<1.=2! 3 <-7/999
8 <=?/299 3 <"=/"29 3 <-7/999 8 <""/"29.
The change in 5BIT 8 <""/"29 3 <1-/"99 8 U<>/929. Ies/ Musgrave should cut its
rice/ 5BIT increases by <>/929.
-2
. Capital structure and st%ck price Answer: c Diff: '
$e can do this roble# by using the 6G5 before and after the recaitali4ation.
Aecall that 6G5 8 6riceG56'.
Before reca. After reca.
5BIT <+99/999 <+99/999
Interest 319/999 329/999
5BT <"=9/999 <"29/999
Ta( (-9:! 117/999 199/999
NI <1?-/999 <129/999
'hares 1"9/999 199/999T
56' <1?-/999G1"9/999 8 <1.-2. <129/999G199/999 8 <1.29.
6G5 <1?.-9G1.-2 8 1".
T1"9/999 3 (<+->/999G<1?.-9! 8 199/999 shares.
As 6G5 8 1" after the recaitali4ation (recall the *uestion states that it does
not change!/ we know 1"
8
6riceG<1.29;
6rice
8
1"
<1.29
8
<1>.99.
-7. Capital structure and st%ck price Answer: e Diff: '
'te 1J Find the current nu#ber of shares outstandingJ
'hares 8 NIG56' 8 <->9 #illionG<+."9 8 129 #illion shares.
'te "J Find the nu#ber of shares after the reurchaseJ
New shares
8
129
L
<1/"99G<+"
8
129
L
+?.2
8 11".2 #illion shares.
'te +J Find the new 56' after the reurchaseJ
56' 8 V(5BIT L INT!(1 3 T!WGNew shares
8 V(<>99 L <>-! 9.7WG11".2 8 <+.>1>77?.
'te -J Find the new stock riceJ
'tock rice 8 56'GNew $A))
8 <+.>1>77?G9.11 8 <+-.?".
-?. ,amada e-uati%n and c%st %f e-uit& Answer: a Diff: T
Facts givenJ k
s
8 1":; &G5 8 9."2; k
AF
8 7:; A6
M
8 2:; T 8 -9:.
'te 1J Find the fir#,s current levered beta using the )A6MJ
k
s
8 k
AF
U A6
M
(b!
1": 8 7: U 2:(b!
b 8 1.".
'te "J Find the fir#,s unlevered beta using the Ea#ada e*uationJ
b 8 b
.
V1 U (1 3 T!(&G5!W
1." 8 b
.
V1 U (9.7!(9."2!W
1." 8 1.12b
.
1.9-+2 8 b
.
.
'te +J Find the new levered beta given the new caital structure using the
Ea#ada e*uationJ
b 8 b
.
V1 U (1 3 T!(&G5!W
b 8 1.9-+2V1 U (9.7!(1!W
b 8 1.77=7.
'te -J Find
the
fir#,s
new
cost
of
e*uity
given
its
new
beta
and
the
)A6MJ
k
s
8 k
AF
U A6
M
(b!
k
s
8 7: U 2:(1.77=7!
k
s
8 1-.+2:.
->. Optimal capital structure and ,amada e-uati%n Answer: d Diff: T
k
AF
8 2:; k
M
3 k
AF
8 7:; k
s
8 k
AF
U (k
M
3 k
AF
!b; $A)) 8 w
d
k
d
(1 3 T! U w
c
k
s
.
Iou need to use the &G5 ratio given for each caital structure to find the
levered beta using the Ea#ada e*uation. Then/ use each of these betas with the
)A6M to find the k
s
for that caital structure. .se this k
s
and k
d
for each
caital structure to find the $A)). The oti#al caital structure is the one
that #ini#i4es the $A)).
(&G5! b 8 b
.
V1 U (1 3 T!(&G5!W k
s
8 k
AF
U (k
M
3 k
AF
!b w
c
k
d
w
d
$A))
9.11 1.977? 11.-999: 9.= ?.9: 9.1 19.7>:
9."2 1.1299 11.=999 9.> ?." 9." 19.+>
9.-+ 1."2?1 1".2-"= 9.? >.9 9.+ 19.""
/.01 2.3/// 24.3/// /.0 5.5 /.3 2/.26
1.99 1.7999 1-.7999 9.2 =.7 9.2 19.1>
For e(a#le/ if the &G5 is 9.11J
b 8 1.9V1 U (1 3 T!(&G5!W 8 1.9V1 U (1 3 9.-!(9.1111!W 8 1.977?.
k
s
8 k
AF
U (k
M
3 k
AF
!b 8 2: U 7:(1.977?! 8 11.-9:.
The weights are given at 9.= and 9.1 for e*uity and debt/ resectively/ and the
k
d
for that caital structure is given as ? ercent.
$A)) 8 w
d
k
d
(1 3 T! U w
c
k
s
8 (9.1!(?:!(1 3 9.-! U (9.=!(11.-9:! 8 19.7>:.
&o the sa#e calculation for each of the caital structures and find each $A)).
The oti#al caital structure is the one that #ini#i4es the $A))/ which is
19.12:. Therefore/ the oti#al caital structure is -9: debt and 79: e*uity.
-=. Capital structure and st%ck price Answer: d Diff: T
The oti#al caital structure #a(i#i4es the fir#,s stock rice. $hen the debt
ratio is "9:/ e(ected 56' is <".29. Hiven the fir#,s olicy of retaining +9:
of earnings/ the e(ected dividend er share &
1
is <".29 9.?9 8 <1.?2. The
stock rice 6
9
is <1.?2G(12: 3 ?:! or <"1.>>. $hen the debt ratio is +9:/
e(ected 56' is <+.99 and e(ected &
1
is <+.99 9.?9 8 <".19. The stock rice
6
9
is <".19G(12.2: 3 ?:! 8 <"-.?1. 'i#ilarly/ when the debt ratio is -9:/ &
1
8
<"."?2 and 6
9
8 <"2.">. $hen the debt ratio is 29:/ &
1
8 <".7"2 and 6
9
8
<"7."2. $hen the debt ratio is ?9:/ &
1
8 <".>9 and 6
9
8 <"2.-2. The stock
rice is highest when the debt ratio is 29:.
29
. Capital structure and st%ck price Answer: ) Diff: T
First/ calculate the stock rice for each debt level using the dividend growth
#odel/ 6
9
8 &
1
G(k
'
3 g!J
&ebt &ivGshare k
'
6
9
9: <2.29 11.2: <2.29G(9.112 3 9.9"! 8 <2?.>=.
76 0.// 27./ 80.//9:/.27 ; /./7< = 80/.//.
-9 7.29 1+.9 <7.29G(9.1+ 3 9.9"! 8 <2=.9=.
29 ?.99 1-.9 <?.99G(9.1- 3 9.9"! 8 <2>.++.
?2 ?.29 12.9 <?.29G(9.12 3 9.9"! 8 <2?.7=.
)learly/ <79.99 is the highest rice/ so "2: debt and ?2: e*uity is the oti#al
caital structure.
21. Capital structure and st%ck price Answer: a Diff: T
First/ find the co#any,s current cost of caital/ dividends er share/ and
stock riceJ
k
s
8 9.977 U (9.97!9.= 8 1":. To find the stock rice/ you still need the
dividends er share or &6' 8 (<"/999/999(1 3 9.-!!G"99/999 8 <7.99. Thus/ the
stock rice is 6
9
8 <7.99G9.1" 8 <29.99. Thus/ by issuing <"/999/999 in new
debt the co#any can reurchase <"/999/999G<29.99 8 -9/999 shares.
Now after recaitali4ation/ the new cost of caital/ &6'/ and stock rice can
be foundJ
k
s
8 9.977
U
(9.97!1.1
8
1+."9:. &6' for the re#aining ("99/999
3
-9/999!
8
179/999
shares are thus V(<"/999/999
3
(<"/999/999
9.19!!(1
3
9.-!WG 179/999 8 <7.?2.
And/ finally/ 6
9
8 <7.?2G9.1+" 8 <21.1-.
2". Capital structure and st%ck price Answer: a Diff: T
To answer this we need to deter#ine the followingJ
1. Eow #any shares are currently outstanding%
". $hat are the interest e(ense and net inco#e/ before and after the change%
Before recaitali4ationJ
5BIT <"9/999/999
Interest "/999/999
5BT <1>/999/999
Ta(es (-9:! ?/"99/999
NI <19/>99/999
56' 8 <+.79. 'hares outstanding 8 <19/>99/999G<+.79 8 +/999/999 shares.
After recaitali4ationJ
New shares 8 + #illion 3 1 #illion 8 " #illion shares.
Total debt 8 <"9/999/999 U (<1/999/999!(<-9! 8 <79/999/999.
Interest ay#ent 8 (<79/999/999!(9.1! 8 <7/999/999.
Net inco#eJ
5BIT <"9/999/999
Interest 7/999/999
5BT <1-/999/999
Ta(es (-9:! 2/799/999
NI < >/-99/999
56' 8 <>/-99/999G"/999/999 8 <-."9. 6G5 8 11.2. 6
9
8 (<-."9!(11.2! 8 <->.+9.
2+
. Capital structure and st%ck price Answer: d Diff: T
The bonds used in the reurchase will create a new interest e(ense for the
co#any. This will change net inco#e.
&ividends er share will
change
because
net
inco#e
changes
and
the
nu#ber
of
shares
outstanding
changes.
New interest e(enseJ <>99/999 >: 8 <7-/999.
New net inco#eJ (<"/999/999 3 <7-/999!(1 3 9.+! 8 <1/+22/"99.
'hares reurchasedJ <>99/999G>9 8 19/999 shares.
New shares outstandingJ 1?2/999 3 19/999 8 172/999 shares.
New dividends er shareJ <1/+22/"99G172/999 8 <>."1++.
$e #ust also calculate a new cost of e*uityJ 2: U (2:!1." 8 11:.
New stock riceJ <>."1G11: 8 <?-.7?.
2-. Capital structure and E"# Answer: d Diff: T
After issuing the debt/ the co#any can reurchase <19/999/999G<-9 8 "29/999
shares leaving 729/999 shares outstanding. $e still need to find the e(ected
NI after issuing the debt. $e,re given the anticiated NI is <+.7 #illion.
Thus/ the 5BIT (before the debt issue! can be found as followsJ <+/799/999 8
5BIT(1 3 9.+-! or 5BIT 8 <2/-2-/2-2.-2. The co#any will ay <1/999/999 in
interest after issuing the debt so the new 5BT will be <2/-2-/2-2.-2 3
<1/999/999 8 <-/-2-/2-2.-2. The new NI figure will be <-/-2-/2-2.-2(1 3 9.+-!
8 <"/=-9/999. Finally/ 56' 8 <"/=-9/999G729/999 8 <-.2" after the
recaitali4ation.
22. Capital structure and E"# Answer: a Diff: T
)aital structure AJ The fir# will have debt of <299/999(9.+! 8 <129/999 and
e*uity of <+29/999. $e,re told the shares have a book value of <19 so the
nu#ber of shares outstanding is <+29/999G<19 8 +2/999. Interest e(ense will
be <129/999(19:! 8 <12/999. $e can co#ute 5BT as 5BIT 3 I or <"99/999 3
<12/999 8 <1>2/999. Also/ we can co#ute NI as 5BT(1 3 T! or <1>2/999(1 3 9.-!
8 <111/999. Finally/ 56' 8 <111/999G+2/999 8 <+.1?.
)aital structure BJ The fir# will have debt of <299/999(9.?! 8 <+29/999 and
e*uity of <129/999. The nu#ber of shares outstanding is <129/999G<19 8 12/999.
Interest e(ense will be <+29/999(1-:! 8 <-=/999. $e can co#ute 5BT as
<"99/999 3 <-=/999 8 <121/999. Also/ we can co#ute NI as <121/999(1 3 9.-! 8
<=9/799. Finally/ 56' 8 <=9/799G12/999 8 <7.9-.
The difference in 56' between caital structure A and caital structure B is
<7.9- 3 <+.1? 8 <".>?.
27. Capital structure, leverage, and WACC Answer: d Diff: T N
Iou need to find the beta with no debt and the new k
s
with the new caital
structure before you can calculate the fir#,s $A)).
'te 1J )alculate the fir#,s unlevered beta using the Ea#ada e*uationJ
b
F
8 b
.
V1 U (1 3 T!(&G5!W
1." 8 b
.
V1 U (9.7!(<+G<?!W
1." 8 1."2?1b
.
b
.
8 9.=2-2-2.
'te "J )alculate the fir#,s new beta with the new caital structureJ
b
F
8 b
.
V1 U (1 3 T!(&G5!W
b
F
8 9.=2-2-2V1 U (9.7!(<2G<2!W
b
F
8 1.2"?+.
'te +J )alculate the fir#,s new cost of e*uity with the new caital
structureJ
k
s
8 k
AF
U (A6!b
k
s
8 7: U ?:(1.2"?+!
k
s
8 17.7=9=:.
'te -J )alculate the fir#,s new $A))J
$A)) 8 w
d
k
d
(1 3 T! U w
c
k
s
$A)) 8 9.2(>.2:!(9.7! U 9.2(17.7=9=:!
$A)) 8 19.>=22: 19.=9:.
2?. Capital structure and E"# Answer: e Diff: '
&ebt 8 ?2: 8 <+99/999; 5*uity 8 "2: 8 <199/999; BD6' 8 <19; Total assets 8
<-99/999.
Feast Fa#ine
6robability 9.7 9.-
5BIT <79/999 <"9/999
FessJ Interest +7/999 +7/999
5BT <"-/999 (<17/999!
FessJ Ta(es (-9:! =/799 (7/-99!
NI <1-/-99 (< =/799!
Y shares 19/999 19/999
56' <1.-- 3<9.=7
&ifference in 56' for aggressive caital structureJ
56'
Feast
3 56'
Fa#ine
8 <1.-- 3 (<9.=7! 8 <".-9.
2>
. Capital structure and E"# Answer: ) Diff: '
&ebt 8 "2: 8 <199/999; 5*uity 8 ?2: 8 <+99/999; BD6' 8 <19; Total assets 8
<-99/999.
Feast Fa#ine
6robability 9.7 9.-
5BIT <79/999 <"9/999
FessJ Interest 19/999 19/999
5BT <29/999 <19/999
FessJ Ta(es (-9:! "9/999 -/999
NI <+9/999 < 7/999
Y shares +9/999 +9/999
56' <1.99 <9."9
&ifference in 56' for conservative caital structureJ
56'
Feast
3 56'
Fa#ine
8 <1.99 3 <9."9 8 <9.>9.
2=
. Capital structure and C* %f E"# Answer: c Diff: '
)alculate coefficient of variation.
5(ected 56'
Aggressive
J
5(56'! 8 9.7 56'
Feast
U 9.- 56'
Fa#ine
8 (9.7!(<1.--! U 9.-(3<9.=7! 8 <9.->.
'tandard deviationJ
'&
56'3aggressive
8 V9.7(<1.-- 3 <9.->!
"
U 9.-(3<9.=7 3 <9.->!
"
W
Z
8 V9.22+9 U 9.>"=-W
1G"
8 1.1?7.
)D
Aggressive
8 1.1?7G9.-> ".-2.
79
. Capital structure and C* %f E"# Answer: a Diff: '
)alculate coefficient of variation.
5(ected 56' conservativeJ
5(56'! 8 9.7(<1.99! U 9.-(<9."9! 8 <9.7>.
'tandard deviationJ
'&
56'3)onservative
8 V9.7(<1.99 3 <9.7>!
"
U 9.-(<9."9 3 <9.7>!
"
W
Z
8 V9.971- U 9.9=""W
1G"
8 9.+=1=.
)D
)onservative
8 9.+=1=G9.7> 8 9.2?7 9.2>.
71. Capital structure and WACC Answer: c Diff: E N
First/ we will calculate the cost of co##on e*uity and then use that to solve
for the $A)).
k
s
8 k
AF
U (k
M
3 k
AF
!b
k
s
8 2: U (7:!1.1
k
s
8 11.7:.
$A)) 8 w
d
k
d
(1 3 T! U w
c
k
s
$A)) 8 (9."!(?.2:!(1 3 9.-! U (9.>!(11.7:!
$A)) 8 19.1>:.
7". ,amada e-uati%n and unlevered )eta Answer: c Diff: E N
To unlever the beta/ we #ust use the Ea#ada e*uation/ substituting the known
values.
b
F
8 b
.
V1 U (1 3 T!(&G5!W
1.1 8 b
.
V1 U (1 3 9.-!(1G-!W
1.1 8 b
.
V1.12W
b
.
8 9.=272.
7+. ,amada e-uati%n and c%st %f c%mm%n e-uit& Answer: e Diff: ' N
First/ we #ust find the levered beta after the recaitali4ation/ using the
unlevered beta calculated in the revious roble#.
b
F
8 b
.
V1 U (1 3 T!(&G5!W
b
F
8 9.=272V1 U (1 3 9.-!("G+!W
b
F
8 9.=272V1.-W
b
F
8 1.++=1.
k
s
8 k
AF
U (k
M
L k
AF
!b
F
k
s
8 2: U (7:!1.++=1
k
s
8 1+.9+:.
7-. Capital structure, financial leverage, and rati%s Answer: d Diff: E N
The correct answer is state#ent d. 'tate#ent a is incorrect; since oerating
inco#e is unchanged and interest e(ense goes u/ net inco#e #ust decrease.
'tate#ent b is incorrect; if net inco#e decreases and assets re#ain the sa#e/
A1A #ust decrease. 'tate#ent c is incorrect; we are told the fir#,s basic
earning ower (B56! and assets do not change/ so oerating inco#e #ust also
re#ain the sa#e. 'tate#ent d is correct; since B56 X k
d
/ the use of debt to buy
back stock will increase A15.
72. Capital structure and E"# Answer: c Diff: T N
Total assets 8 <199/999/999; B56 8 "9:; TI5 8 1".2; T 8 -9:.
'te 1J &eter#ine the fir#,s oerating inco#eJ
B56 8 5BITGTA
9."9 8 5BITG<199/999/999
5BIT 8 <"9/999/999.
'te "J &eter#ine the fir#,s interest e(ense/ given the TI5 and 5BITJ
TI5 8
Interest
5BIT
1".2 8
Interest
999 / 999 / "9 <
1".2Interest 8 <"9/999/999
<1/799/999 8 Interest.
'te +J &eter#ine the fir#,s net inco#eJ
1erating inco#e <"9/999/999
Interest e(ense 1/799/999
5BT <1>/-99/999
Ta(es (-9:! ?/+79/999
Net inco#e <11/9-9/999
'te -J &eter#ine the nu#ber of shares outstanding after recaitali4ationJ
If the fir# reurchased <"9 #illion worth of stock and the stock
rice is <"9/ then the fir# bought 1 #illion shares. 'hares
outstanding now 8 2/999/999 L 1/999/999 8 -/999/999.
'te 2J &eter#ine the fir#,s 56' after recaitali4ationJ
56' 8 NIGY of shares
56' 8 <11/9-9/999G-/999/999
56' 8 <".?7.
77 . ,amada e-uati%n and unlevered )eta
Answer: c Diff: E N
b
F
8 b
.
V1 U (1 3 T!(&G5!W
1."8 b
.
V1 U (9.79!(9."2G9.?2!W
1."8 b
.
V1."W
b
.
8 1.99.
7? . ,amada e-uati%n and c%st %f c%mm%n e-uit&
Answer: c Diff: ' N
b
.
8 1.99 was calculated reviously in the roble# above.
'te 1J )alculate the new levered beta using the Ea#ada e*uation and the
unlevered beta calculated reviouslyJ
b
F
8 b
.
V1 U (1 3 T!(&G5!W
b
F
8 1.99V1 U (9.79!(9.-9G9.79!W
b
F
8 1.-9.
'te "J )alculate the new cost of e*uity using the )A6M e*uation and the new
levered betaJ
k
s
8 2: U (7:!1.-9 8 1+.-9:.
7>. Capital structure, leverage, and WACC Answer: c Diff: E N
w
d
8 "2:; w
s
8 ?2:; k
d
8 >:; k
s
8 19.?2:; T 8 -9:.
The after3ta( cost of debt is >.9: (1 3 9.-9! 8 -.>:. Its cost of co##on
e*uity is (given as! 19.?2:. 'o/ the $A)) 8 9."2(-.>:! U 9.?2(19.?2:! 8
=."7"2: =."7:.
7=. ,amada e-uati%n and unlevered )eta Answer: ) Diff: ' N
b
F
8 1.12; T 8 -9:; & 8 "2:; 5 8 ?2:.
b
F
8 b
.
V1 U (1 3 T!(&G5!W
1.12 8 b
.
V1 U (9.7!(9."2G9.?2!W
1.12 8 b
.
V1."W
9.=2>+ 8 b
.
.
?9. ,amada e-uati%n and c%st %f c%mm%n e-uit& Answer: d Diff: ' N
'te 1J )alculate the new levered beta for the fir#/ using the new caital
structureJ
b
.
8 9.=2>+; New & 8 29:; New 5 8 29:; T 8 -9:.
b
F
8 b
.
V1 U (1 3 T!(&G5!W
8 9.=2>+V1 U (9.79!(9.29G9.29!W
8 1.2+++.
'te "J )alculate the fir#,s new cost of co##on e*uityJ
k
AF
8 2:; k
M
L k
AF
8 2:; b
F
8 1.2+++.
k
'
8 2: U (2:!1.2+++ 8 1".777: 1".7?:.
?1. Capital structure, leverage, and E"# Answer: c Diff: ' N
'te 1J )alculate net inco#e under the fir#,s new caital structure as
followsJ
5BIT <+99/999 (given!
Interest "99/999 (given!
5BT <199/999
Ta(es (-9:! -9/999
NI < 79/999
'te "J )alculate 56' under the fir#,s new caital structureJ
The fir# has assets of <- #illion. 1riginally/ <+ #illion was in
co##on e*uity and <1 #illion was in debt. Now/ that a#ount is slit
evenly/ <" #illion in co##on e*uity and <" #illion in debt. The fir#
will borrow <1 #illion and use the roceeds to reurchase <1 #illion
worth of co##on e*uity. At the reurchase rice of <17Gshare/ the fir#
will buy back <1/999/999G<17 8 7"/299 shares/ leaving >9/999 L 7"/299 8
1?/299 shares outstanding.
56' 8 NIGY shares 8 <79/999G1?/299 8 <+.-">7 <+.-+.
?"24A;. DOL, D(L, and DTL Answer: c Diff: E
?+24A;. (inancial leverage Answer: e Diff: '
?-24A;. (inancial leverage Answer: d Diff: '
?224A;. (inancial risk Answer: ) Diff: '
?724A;. Operating and financial leverage Answer: a Diff: '
??24;. Operating and financial leverage Answer: e Diff: '
?>24;. DOL Answer: c Diff: '
?=24;. De)t rati% and DOL Answer: a Diff: '
'tate#ent a is correct; the other state#ents are false. After the sales
increase/ the ercentage increase in 5BIT will be the sa#e for both co#anies.
)o#any 5Ps net inco#e will rise by e(actly 19:.
>924;. Degree %f leverage Answer: a Diff: '
>124;. DOL and c$anges in EB!T Answer: a Diff: E
First/ find 5BIT before sales increaseJ
5BIT 8 'ales 3 ('ales D):! 3 F)
8 <12/999 3 (<12/999 9.79! 3 <1/999
,E/ APPE'D#0 !"A %.$&T#.'%
8 <2/999.
Now/ assu#ing sales increase by 19: or to <12/999 1.19 8 <17/299/ calculate the
new 5BIT. 5BIT 8 <17/299 3 (<17/299 9.79! 3 <1/999 8 <2/799.
'o/ the ercentage increase is V(<2/799 3 <2/999!G<2/999W 199 8 1":.
>"24;. DTL and f%recast E"# Answer: d Diff: E
56'
1
8 56'
9
U 56'
9
V&TF (ercent change in sales!W
8 <+."2V1 U (1.7!(".1!(9.2!W
8 <+."2(".7>!
8 <>.?1.
>+24;. C$ange in E"# Answer: ) Diff: E
56'
9
8 <1.99. &1F 8 1."2. 56'
1
8 %
:' 8 12:. &FF 8 +.29.
&TF 8 &1F(&FF! 8 1."2(+.29! 8 -.+?2.
56'
1
8 56'
9
V1.9 U (&TF!(:'ales!W
8 <1.99V1.9 U (-.+?2!(9.12!W
8 <1.99(1.727+! 8 <1.727+.
>-24;. DOL c$ange Answer: a Diff: '
)alculate &1F using new sales/ new variable cost ercentage/ and new fi(ed
costsJ
'
9
8 <?2/999/999; F)
9
8 <-9/999/999; D) 8 9.+9('
9
! 8 <""/299/999.
'
1
8 <199/999/999; F)
1
8 <22/999/999; D) 8 9."2('
1
! 8 <"2/999/999.
&1F (In #illions!J
&1F
'
8
199 3 "2
199 3 "2 3 22
8
?2
"9
8 +.?2.
>224;. DOL Answer: d Diff: '
These two e*uations could be usedJ
&TF 8 (&1F!(&FF!.
56'
1
8 56'
9
V1 U (&TF!(:'ales!W.
Note that 56' rises by 29 ercent/ fro# <1.99 to <1.29/ on a 19 ercent
increase in sales/ so
1.29 8 1.99V1 U (&TF!(9.1!W
1.29 8 1 U 9.1 &TF
9.1 &TF 8 9.29
&TF 8 2.99.
Now &TF 8 2 8 (&1F!(&FF!
But if &ebt 8 9/ then &FF 8 1/ so &1F 8 &TF 8 2.9.
>724;. DOL in sales d%llars Answer: c Diff: '
.se the infor#ation rovided and the for#ula for &1F in sales dollarsJ
&1F
'
8
129/999(<-! 3 9.+(129/999!(<-!
129/999(<-! 3 9.+(129/999!(<-! 3 9.2(129/999!(<-!
&1F
'
8
999 / +99 < 999 / 1>9 < 999 / 799 <
999 / 1>9 < 999 / 799 <
&1F
'
8
999 / 1"9 <
999 / -"9 <
8 +.2.
Alternate #ethodJ
5(ress 6 as 1.9 or 199: of rice and D and F) as a ercent of riceJ
&1F
Q
8
F) ! D 6 ( Q
! D 6 ( Q
8
129/999(1.9 3 9.+!
129/999V(1.9 3 9.+! 3 9.2W
8
9.?
9."
8 +.29.
>?24;. DOL, D(L, and DTL Answer: c Diff: '
First/ calculate 6QAPs &FF as 5BITG(5BIT 3 I!. Interest e(ense (I! on the
debt is <1/299/999(19:! 8 <129/999. $e can work backwards fro# NI to find
5BIT as followsJ 5BT 8 NIG(1 3 T! or <799/999G9.7 8 <1/999/999. 5BIT 8 5BT U
I or <1/999/999 U <129/999 8 <1/129/999. &FF is thus <1/129/999G(<1/129/999 3
<129/999! 8 1.12. Aecogni4ing &TF 8 &FF &1F/ we can solve 1.-9 8 1.12 &1F
for &1F 8 1."".
>>24;. DTL and interest e+pense Answer: d Diff: '
Aecall that &TF 8 : change in NIG: change in sales
8 9.1?2G9.19 8 1.?2.
&TF 8
I F) D) '
D) '
1.?2 8
I 999 / 299 < 999 / 299 / > < 999 / 999 / 19 <
999 / 299 / > < 999 / 999 / 19 <
1.?2 8
I 999 / 999 / 1 <
999 / 299 / 1 <
8
<+/999/999 3 9.2(<+/999/999!
<+/999/999 3 9.2(<+/999/999! 3 <199/999 3 9.1(<1/999/999!
8
999 / +99 / 1 <
999 / 299 / 1 <
8 1.12+>.
'te "J Find ercentage increase in net inco#eJ
:NI 8 (9."9!(&TF! 8 (9."9!(1.12+>! 8 9."+9> 8 "+.9>:.
=124;. E+pected EB!T Answer: c Diff: '
&1F 8 &TFG&FF
8 ?.2G1.>?2 8 -.9.
5BIT 8 (39."9!(-.9!(<"/999/999! 8 3<1/799/999.
5BIT 8 <"/999/999 3 <1/799/999 8 <-99/999.
="24;. E+pected EB!T Answer: d Diff: '
&TF 8 :56'G:'ales 8 79:G"9: 8 +.9.
&1F 8 &TFG&FF 8 +.9G1."2 8 ".-9.
1ld 5BIT 8 <199/999GV1 U (9."9!(".-9!W 8 <199/999G1.-> 8 <7?/27>.
Alternate solutionJ
.se &FF e(ression to calculate change in 5BIT and revious 5BITJ
&FF 8 1."2 8 :56'G:5BIT
1."2 8 9.79GV5BITG(<199/999 3 5BIT!W
1."2 8 V9.79(<199/999! 3 9.79(5BIT!WG5BIT
1."25BIT 8 <79/999 3 9.79(5BIT!
1.>25BIT 8 <79/999
5BIT 8 <+"/-+".
1ld 5BIT 8 <199/999 3 <+"/-+" 8 <7?/27>.
=+24;. E+pected EB!T Answer: e Diff: '
'et u the &1F e*uation/ letting \ be the unknown new 5BITJ
Fet \ 8 New 5BIT.
&1F
Q
8 ".2 8
1"2/999
1"2/999 3 1?9/999
79/999
79/999 \
8
9.+7
79/999
79/999 \
".2(9.+7! 8
79/999
79/999 \
9.=9 8
79/999
79/999 \
<2-/999 8 \ 3 <79/999
\ 8 <11-/999.
New 5BIT 8 <11-/999.
=-24;. Degree %f financial leverage Answer: d Diff: '
&TF 8 (&1F!(&FF!
".9 8 1.7(&FF!
1."2 8 &FF.
1."2 8
<-/999/999
<-/999/999 3 I
<2/999/999 3 1."2(I! 8 <-/999/999
I 8 <>99/999.
&ebt 8
<>99/999
9.9=2
8 <>/-"1/92+.
Must retire 8 <12/999/999 3 <>/-"1/92+ 8 <7.2> #illion of debt.
=224;. (inancial leverage, DOL, and DTL Answer: a Diff: T
First/ find the new &FFJ
&TF 8 (&1F!(&FF!
".- 8 (1.-!(&FF!
&FF 8 1.?1-+.
Then/ find the new interest ay#ents in a yearJ
&FF 8 (5BIT!G(5BIT 3 I!
1.?1-+ 8 (<-/999/999!G(<-/999/999 3 I!
I 8 <1/777/7>7.11.
Finally/ solve for the new debt level/ knowing that the yield to #aturity
re#ains at 19:J
&ebt value(ITM! 8 Interest ay#ent
&ebt(9.19! 8 <1/777/7>7.11
&ebt 8 <17/777/>71.11 <17.? #illion.
=724;. DOL, D(L, and fi+ed %perating c%sts Answer: c Diff: T
$ePre given enough infor#ation to find both &FF and &TF.
&TF 8 &1F &FF
8
5BIT :
56' :
'ales :
5BIT :
8
: 56'
: 'ales
8
1>:
19:
&TF 8 1.>.
&FF 8 <"/-99/999G(<"/-99/999 3 <-99/999!
8 1.".
Hiven &TF 8 &FF &1F/ we can calculate &1F 8 1.2. Aecogni4ing ' 3 D) 3 F) 8
5BIT/ 1.2 8 (' 3 D)!G<"/-99/999 or ' 3 D) 8 <+/799/999. The difference between
(' 3 D)! and 5BIT #ust reresent fi(ed oerating costs. Thus/ F) 8 <+/799/999
3 <"/-99/999 8 <1/"99/999.