Static reactive power compensator (SVC) is constructed by fixed capacitors (FC) snd thyristor controlled reactors (TCRs) Results from digital simulation and the implementation test show that The SVC with the PI controller can greatly enhance the damping of the systemoscillation caused by disturbances.
Static reactive power compensator (SVC) is constructed by fixed capacitors (FC) snd thyristor controlled reactors (TCRs) Results from digital simulation and the implementation test show that The SVC with the PI controller can greatly enhance the damping of the systemoscillation caused by disturbances.
Static reactive power compensator (SVC) is constructed by fixed capacitors (FC) snd thyristor controlled reactors (TCRs) Results from digital simulation and the implementation test show that The SVC with the PI controller can greatly enhance the damping of the systemoscillation caused by disturbances.
reactive power compensator with digital controller C.-J. WU, PhD Y.-S. Lee, ME Indexing terms: Generators, Control equipment and applications Abstract: A static reactive power (VAr) com- pensator (SVC), constructed by fixed capacitors (FC) snd thyristor controlled reactors (TCRs), is designed and implemented to improve the damping of the synchronous generator. A digital propotional-integral (PI) controller is synthesised by the Motorola M68HCll single chip micro- processor board to modify the reactive power compensation of the SVC fromadjusting the con- duction angle of the thyristors. The SVC is placed at the generator bus terminal with the speed devi- ation (Am) as the feedback signal for the PI con- troller. The pole assignment method is used to determine the gains of the PI controller. Results from digital simulation and the implementation test show that the SVC with the PI controller can greatly enhance the damping of the systemoscil- lation caused by disturbances. Although the PI controller is designed at a special operation point, it can also provide a good damping effect at other operation conditions. The voltage profile of the generator is also improved by the SVC. Li st of symbols =rotor speed =torque angle =conduction angle =d- and q-axis terminal voltage =generator terminal voltage and current =reference voltage for generator =d- and q-axis component of voltage behind =real power and reactive power =resistance and reactance =reactance of static reactive power com- =inductive susceptance of static reactive power =capacitive susceptance of static reactive =electrical torque =mechanical torque =per unit output voltage of the exciter =gains of the PI controller =constant matrices transient reactance pensator compensator power compensator Paper 8148C (Pl, PlO), first received 18th September 1990 and in revised form 2nd April 1991 The authon are with the Department of Electrical Engineering, National Taiwan Institute of Technology, 43 Keelung Road, Section 4, Taipei, Taiwan 10772, Republic of China IEE PROCEEDINGS-C, Vol. 138, No. 5, SEPTEMBER 1991 M, D Tw T, =sampling time K,, ' & TLo, Tb0 =d- and q-axis armature-winding transient K,, K , =thyristor gain and time constant Subscripts d, q =d-axis, q-axis 1 Introduction Static reactive power (VAr) compensators (SVCs), which are constructed by thyristor controlled reactors (TCRs) and fixed capacitors (FCs), are finding a wide employ- ment in the power industry [I-23. Many applications of the SVC have been suggested in the literature, such as reactive power compensation for the arc furnace [3], reduction of transmission line loss [4], expansion of the transfer capacity of transmission line [MI, stabilising the load bus voltage [7-91, and balancing the load bus current [lO-Il]. The SVC has also received great atten- tion in the damping of a power system[12-171. It can provide a supplementary damping torque for the syn- chronous generator and increase the damping of system oscillation. However, in the literature there are few papers with an implementation test report about the damping effect of an SVC [15-17]. The dynamic per- formance of a radial distribution line is improved by three SVCs in Reference 17. Only the study in Reference 16 considers the damping effect on the generator, but the frequency response approach design method used in the case studied is too rough. Owing to the remarkable advances in electronic tech- niques, the microcomputers/microprocessors are also used in the power industry, such as digital relay [18], the digital power systemstabiliser [19], and the automatic meter reading system[20]. If a digital controller is syn- thesised by a software program on the microprocessor board, some advantages can beobtained. The controller can be any type and the parameters of the controller can be set at any value. Also the parameters of the controller will not drift due to the temperature effect. A micro- processor board will be used in this paper to construct a digital controller for the SVC. In this paper, a 5 kVA SVC test unit is installed in the laboratory. The SVC is placed at the generator bus ter- minal. A digital proportional-integral (PI) controller is synthesised by the software program on a Motorola M68HC11 single chip microprocessor board [22-231. With the speed deviation (Ao) as the feedback signal, the PI controller can modify the reactive power output of the 427 =moment constant and damping coefficient =washout time constant of the PI controller =exciter gain and time constant open-circuit time constant SVC and supply a damping torque to the synchronous generator. The gains of the PI controller are determined using the pole assignment method by placing the electro- mechanical mode at the prespecified position. Results fromthe digital simulation and implementation test show that the SVC with the PI controller can greatly improve the damping of the synchronous generator. Although the gains of the PI controller are designed at a special 0pe.r- ation point, it can also provide a good damping effect at other operation points. In the dynamic period, the voltage profile at the generator bus terminal is also improved because the SVC can provide a reactive power modulation to the system. 2 Problem formulation The systemconsidered in this paper can be described by the diagram as shown in Fig. 1, where a synchronous generator is connected to the infinite bus through the transmission line with a load placed at that bus. The syn- generator transmission i nf i ni t e m Fig. 1 ator bus renniMl Single machine infinite bus system with SVC placed at gener- chronous generator is a salient pole type with damper winding on the rotor shaft and driven by a large DC motor. An SVC is placed at the generator bus terminal to increase the systemdamping. The field current of the syn- chronous generator is supplied by a static exciter with the block diagram as shown in Fig. 2. Electric power is delivered from the generator to the load through a trans- mission line. All the systemdata are given in Appendix 8. "ref I - Ve I K O I Ef d - v I 1 t sT, Fig. 2 Static exciter The dynamic behaviour of the generator can be described by the two axis model [21]. All the nonlinear differential equations are (1) ( 2) (3) (4) ( 5) 15=(T, - DO - TJ/M s =Ob(W - 1) E f d =[ - E f d +Ko(%f - vI/K & =[ - E: , - ( X, - Xb ) I J / T~. pq =[E/d - Eq +( x d - X&)Id]/T;, where =EdId +E; I , - ( Xh - Xd)IdIg t: =( Vi +V y v, =E:, - R, Id - XbI, V, = E: - R, I, +XLId 428 The SVC is designed and implemented to support the reactive power compensation. The SVC is constructed by 12-pulse thyristor controlled reactors (TCRs) and fixed capacitors (FCs) as shown in Fig. 3. The TCR is con- compensated bus I v I 'i i" inductor 4 capacitor control system Fig. 3 TCR FC One line diagram of SVC with TCRs and FCs nected to the compensated bus through a triple windings transformer. The conducting of the reactors is controlled by the thyristor with continuous symmetric firing signals, such that the TCR with the FC can provide a continuous amount of reactive power compensation to the power system. The equivalent susceptance of the reactor can be obtained fromthe fundamental component of the current passing through the reactor in each phase [ I ] . The rela- tion between the equivalent susceptance BL of the reactor and the conduction angle a of the thyristor is a - sin a BL(a) =___ nXL where X , is the physical reactance of the reactor. 3 Design of PI controller using pole assignment method A PI controller is used to control the compensation value of the TCR as shown in Fig. 4. The nonlinearity in eqn. 6 is removed by a linearised circuit [I], and the TCR can be represented by a simple transfer function. To deter- mine the gains of the PI controller, all the nonlinear dif- ferential equations are linearised at the initial operation point. The linear systemstate equations are X( t ) =AX( t ) +BU(t) (7) Y( t ) =CX( t ) (8) Fig. 4 Transferfunction representation of SVC where X =[Am, A& AEf d , A&, AE;, ABL]' is the state vector, U =AKm is the control signal, Y =Am is the output signal, and A, B, C are constant matrices. Because the sampling period of the microprocessor is only 1 ms, which is very small compared to the low frequency oscil- lation period [21], we can directly design the digital PI controller on the s-plane. Taking the Laplace transform of eqns. 7 and 8, weget sX(s) =AX( s) +BU(s) Y(s) =CX( s) (9) C(SI - A)-'BU(s) (10) I EE PROCEEDINGS-C, Vol. 138, No. 5, SEPTEMBER 1991 . - 1 Also the control signal fromthe PI controller can be rep resented by a set of three phase transmission line, load boxes, a speed encoder, AID and D/A convertors, and a digital PI con- troller which is synthesised by the M68HCll micro- processor board. U(s) =H(s)Y(s) 1 +sT, It is easy to see that the characteristic equation of the closed loop systemis [24] 1 - C(sl - A)-' BH(s) =0 (12) If 1 is the systemeigenvalue to beassigned, wehave (13) Assume that the value of T, is given, weneed to assign a pair of eigenvalues to obtain the values of K, and K,. Because the behaviour of the generator is dominantly represented by the electromechanical mode, we must assign this mode at the prespecified position. Let 1' and 1, be the pair of eigenvalues of electromechanical mode to be assigned, we can get two linear algebra equations fromeqn. 13 with two unknowns K, and K, . By solving this pair of algebra equations, wecan obtain the desired gains of the PI controller. At the initial operation point P =0.8 and Q =0.6P.u., we arbitrarily assign the eigenvalues of the electro- mechanical mode at I,, 1, =-4.1 +j26 The gains of the PI controller are calculated. K, =5.5 K , =64.5 Table 1 shows the eigenvalues of the systemwith and without SVC. It is observed that the electromechanical mode of the systemwith SVC is exactly at the prespeci- fied position. The damping of the synchronous generator is greatly improved by the SVC. To examine the damping effect of the SVC when the load condition is changed, the electromechanical mode at different operation points is shown in Table 2. I t is known that the SVC can also improve the systemdamping at other operation points. Tabl e 1 : Svstem eigenvalues Items Without SVC With SVC ~ ~ A,, - 1 9.87 +/70.41 -1 9.88 +/70.89 A, -1.67*j 26.19* -4.1 +j 26.0* A,, - 1 1.7 -11.6 AS" , -97.89 +j 25.9 * Electromechanical mode Tabl e 2: El ect romechani cal mode at di f f er ent oper at i on ooi nt s ~ Operation point Without SVC With SVC P=1 . 2 , 0 =0 . 8 -1.549t j 26.841 -2. 78t j 26. 0 P =OB, 0 =0 . 6 -1. 673t j 26. 193 -4.1 +j 26.0 P =0.5. 0 ~ 0 . 2 -2.896+; 25.631 -5.3+i 25.61 4 5 kVA test unit The generator systemdiagram is shown in Fig. 5 and consists of a 5 kVA synchronous generator, a set of SVCs which are constructed by TCRs and FCs, a static exciter, IEE PROCEEDINGS-C, Vol. 138, No. 5, SEPTEMBER 1991 prime mac hi ne encoder +. I I I I > > I ! I qM68HC 11 E l oad\ svc Fig. 5 5 kVA test unit 4.1 Microprocessor board The Motorola M68HCll is an HCMOS single chip microprocessor board and is suitable for the application of real time control. With the diagram shown in Fig. 6, the organisation data of the microprocessor board are as follows. 1 M68CH11 ' ! Fi g. 6 Block diagram of M68HCl I microprocessor board hardware : (a) 12k bytes ROM (b) 512 bytes EPROM (c) 512 bytes RAM (d) 8 bits impulse arithmetic unit (e) 8 bits A/D convertor and data channel (f) real time interrupt request (g) enhanced 16 bits time (a) enhanced M6800/M6811 instruction set (b) 16 x 16 integer and fraction division (c) with bit operation (d) with wait mode (e) with stop mode 4.2 Digital PI controller The digital PI controller is synthesised by the software program on the microprocessor board, with the speed deviation as the input signal. The speed error signal is software: e( t ) =O(t ) - a, (14) where w, is the rating synchronous speed and o( t ) is the feedback rotor speed. The input signal to the micro- 429 I I 0 002 0 002- 2 a 3 a . 0001 =- 0 001- 0 9 s o 5 0 - e 0 0 v v u (1 VI U E -0001 - 0 001- VI - 0 002 - 0 002, processor is the sampled error signal time series e(kT), k =0, 1, 2, .. ., where k is the sampling instant and T is the sample period. Let the output control signal of the microprocessor beu(kT). Consider that the microprocessor wants to perform the digital computation of the PI controller. The control signal at the continuous time domain is u(t) =K,e(t) +K, dt (15) The integration termin the last equation is written as Z( t ) = [d~) - WJ dr +Z( t J (16) 1: Wecan use the trapezoidal integration rule here. At the time interval [(k - 1)T, k q , the definite integration in eqn. 16 is approximated by rT [ d t ) - o J dt ( k - I ) T E T/2[o(kT) +o[ ( k - 1)77] - w,T (17) Then the discrete time domain representation of eqn. 16 is ZC(k +1)77 =T/2Co(kT) +oC(k - 11771 +Z( kT) - w,T (18) The discrete version of u(t) is written as u[(k +1)T] =K, [ dkT) - WJ +K, Z[ ( k +1)T] (19) 4.3 12-Pul se TCR To reduce the harmonic current caused by the TCR, the connection type of the TCR must bewell arranged. The conduction angle of the thyristor in each phase is symmetric to cancel all the even harmonic currents. The I L I , , , , . , , reactors are divided into two separate groups, each group of reactor is a TCR. The A connection type of the reac- tors in each group can let all the triplen harmonics be absent fromthe line current. The TCRs are connected to the compensated bus through a triple windings Y - Y /Y - A connection transformer. There is a 30" phase shift between the voltages and currents of the two TCRs, and the 5th and 7th haronic currents are elimi- nated from the primary-side line current. 0 002 0 002 3 Q C 3 . oool 4 0001~ ; o c (r' P c 2 9 L e 0 TI 0 U : - 0 001 g - 0 001- 0 VI -0 002 - 0 002 5 Digital simulation and implementation test results To demonstrate the damping effect of the SVC, digital simulation and implementation test results of the system with and without SVC are compared at three different operation points. The simulations are taken on an IBM PC/AT using a fourth-order Runge-Kutta routine [26]. The step size is 1 ms. In the experiment procedures, the generator is first brought up to the synchronous speed by a DC motor, and the terminal voltage is raised to the rated voltage by an appropriate exciter output voltage. Step load change is made by changing the equivalent admittance of the load box. The dynamic behaviour of the synchronous generator is examined by a 0.2p.u. load change at three different operation points. Figs. 7, 8 and 9 show the rotor speed dynamic responses of the digital simulation at the oper- ation point (P =1.2, Q =OX), (P =0.8, Q =0.6) and (P =0.5, Q =0.2), respectively. The settling time x, defined by 1A d t ) 1 <O.ooOo5 p.u. for t >T, , of the system oscillations with and without SVC is compared in Table 3. It is observed that the SVC can greatly improve the damping of the synchronous generator. Figs. 10, 11, and 12 show the speed dynamic responses of the implementa- tion test at three operation points. The systemsettling 'I A+- \ ti me, s a Fi g. 7 (I Without SVC b WithSVC Dynamic response of simulation results at P =1.2 and Q =0.8 ti me, s b ti me, s a Fig. 8 II Without SVC Dynmnic response of simulation result at P =0.8 and Q =0.6 b With SVC ti me, s b 430 IEE PROCEEDINGS-C, Vol. 138, No. 5, SEPTEMBER 1991 0 1 2 3 L ti me, s a Fig. 9 LI Without SVC Dynamic response ofsimulation result at P =03 and Q =03 b With SVC 7 3 a 0 1 2 3 L 0001. C 0 : - 0 U p -0001- 2 -0002, time, s b I c' 0001- g 0- 0. - L : -0oG-l- 0 I U U a VI -0 002 , ' . . . , . . 0 002 0 002 3 3 a c 0 001- 2 9 4 1 a 0 . 0 001. ... - 2 0 ? > 0- U U U g -0001- ; -0 001- VI 1 1 0 2 0 2 3 -0 002 time. s time. s -0002+ . . . . , ' ' a b Fig. 10 a Without SVC Dynamic response of Implementation test result at P =1 2 and Q =0 8 b Wllh SVC 0 002 I I 00021- 0 1 2 3 L a ti me, s Fig. 12 a Without SVC IEE PROCEEDINGS-C, Vol. 138, No. 5, SEPTEMBER 1991 Dynamic response ofimplementation test result at P b With SVC 0 001 0- - 0 001- t -0002* . , , ' ' ' ' 0 1 2 3 time. s b =03 and Q =0.2 43 1 Tabl e3: Set t l i ng t i me of t he r ot or speed devi at i on (si mul at i on) Operation Settling time (s) point Without SVC With SVC 1 08- 1 08- 3 - a 1 OL- ; 106: .,I 00-- $ 1 00- : 0 84- - 5 096- =0 96- > 0 92- 1 0 92- F 0 88- E - ; 0 84- 0807 . . . . . . . 080i 0 - - 0 . p o 88: I - P =1.2. Q =0.8 3.75 1.45 P =0.8, Q =0.6 2.05 1 .o P =0.5, 0 =0.2 1.25 0.75 9 I . . I . . Tabl e 4: Set t l i ng t i me of r ot or speed devi at i on (i mpl e- ment at i on t est ) Operation Settling time (s) 108- a 104- 3 - g 100:- 0 - 5 0 9 6 - 092- 0 88- > - 0 . 5 0 EL- 0807 point Without SVC With SVC . . . . . . . ? P =1.2. a =0.8 3.25 1.75 P =0.8, 0 =0.6 1.75 1.1 P =0.5, Q =0.2 1.3 0.8 1 08. a1 04. 3 . g1 00: % 096. - 0 92- > - 5 0 88- 5 0 84. 080- time is also compared in Table 4. Figs. 13, 14 and 15 show the terminal voltage responses of the implementa- tion test at three operation points. . . . . . . . Several observations are obtained. (a) Both in the digital simulation and in the implemen- tation test, the SVC can provide a supplementary damping torque for synchronous generator and improve the systemdynamic behaviour. (b) From Figs. 13-15, the voltage profile of the gener- ation is improved by the SVC. ( c ) Although the PI controller is designed at a special operation point, it can also provide good damping effect at other operation points. 0 92- - 0 88- c E, 3 0 8 4 - 6 Conclusion An SVC is designed and implemented in this paper to improve the damping of a synchronous generator. The pole assignment method is used to determine the gains of the PI controller by placing the electromechanical mode at the prespecified position. The PI controller is simple in structure and easy to synthesise by the software program on a Motorola M68HCll single chip microprocessor board. Digital simulation and implementation test results shown that the SVC with the PI controller can greatly Fi g. 14 o Without SVC Voltage profile ofimplementation test result at P =0.8 and Q =0.6 b With SVC 5 0 8 4 ;;:LL 0 8 0 time. s b Fi g. 15 (1 Without SVC 432 Voltage profile ofimplementation test result at P =0.5 and Q =0.2 b With SVC IEE PROCEEDINGS-C, Vol. 138, No. 5, SEPTEMBER 1991 enhance the systemdamping. Although the PI controller is designed at a special operation point, it can also provide a good damping effect at other operation condi- tions. The studied systemin this paper is a single machine power system. By the modal control theory [24], The PI controller can provide two degrees of freedom. The elec- tromechanical mode can beassigned at an arbitrary posi- tion by the PI controller. If more modes are to be controlled, another PI controllers with different feedback signals such as current and electric power are needed. In a multimachine power system, many SVCs may be needed. Co-ordination tuning of the controllers of SVCs must be done such that all the synchronous machines in the systemhave good damping. 7 References 1 MILLER, T.J.E.: Reactivepower control in electric system (J ohn Wiley & Sons, 1982) 2 IEEE Var management working group report.: Bibliography on reactive power and voltagecontrol, IEEE Trans., 1987, PWRS2, pp. 361-370 3 COX, M.D., and MIRBOD, A.: A new static Var compensator for an arc furnace, IEEE Trans., 1986, PWRS-1, (3). pp. 1 lCL120 4 LIN, C.E., CHEN, T.C., qnd HUANG, C.L.: Optimal control of a static Var compensator for minimization of lineloss, Electr. Power Syst. Res., 1988, 15, pp. 5141 5 BYERLY, R.T., POZNANISK, D.T., and TAYLOR, E.R.: Static reactive compensation for power transmission systems, IEEE Trans., 1982, PAS-101, pp. 3997-5 6 CHOI, S.S., STEWART, J.R., SINGH, B., CARRINGTON, P.F., GODDARD, E.M., and CARTER, C.E.: Performance testing of a long distance radial static Var compensated transmission system and validation of simulation results, IEEE Trans., 1988, PWRS3, pp. 1509-1571 7 CHENG, SJ., MALIK, O.P., and HOPE, G.S.: Anexpert system for voltage and reactive power control of a power system, IEEE Trans., 1988, PWRS4, pp. 1449-1455 8 PAZIUK, L.A., CHIKHANI, A.Y., and HACKAM, R.: Anexpert microprocessor controlled voltage regulator for energy conservation and demand deduction in distribution feeders, IEEE Trans., 1989, PWRD4, pp. 2222-2228 9 HAMMAD, A.E., and EI-SADEK, M.Z.: Prevention of transient voltageinstabilities due to induction motor loads by static var wm- pensators, IEEE Trans., 1989, PWRS4, pp. 1182-1190 10 GYUGYI, L., OTTO, R.A., and PUTMAN, T.H.: Principles and application of static thyristorantrolled shunt compensators, IEEE Trans., 1978, PAS-97, pp. 19351945 1 1 GUETH, G., ENSTEDT, P., REY, A., and WENZIES, R.W.: Indi- vidual phase control of a static compensator for load compensation and voltagebalancing and regulation, IEEE Trans., 1987, PWRS2, pp. 898-905 12 OBRIEN, M., and LEDWICH, G.: Static reactive-power com- pensator controls for improved systemstability, IEE Proc. C, 1987, 134, pp. 38-42 13 PIERRE, D.A.: Nonlinear Var control for damping multivariable swing equations, IEEE Trans., 1988, PWRS-3, pp. 10331038 14 OBRIEN, M., and LEDWICH, G.: Placement of static com- pensators for stability improvement, IEE Proc. C, 1985, 132, pp. 3&35 15 GERIN-LAJ OIE, L., SCOm, G., BREAULT, S., LARSEN, E.V., BAKER, D.H., and IMECE, A.F.: Hydro-Quebec multiple SVC application control stability study, IEEE Trans., 1990, PWRD-S, pp. 1543-1551 16 SAWA, T., SHIRAI, Y., MICHIGAMI, T., SAKANAKA, Y., and UEMURA, Y.: A fieldtest of power swing damping by static Var compensator, IEEE Trans., 1989, PWRS4, pp. 1115-1120 IEE PROCEEDINGS-C, Vol. 138, No. 5, SEPTEMBER 1991 17 RAMOS, A.J.P., and TYLL, H.: Dynamic performance of a radial weak power systemwithmultiple static Var compensator. Paper 89 WM 183-5 PWRS, presented at the IEEE/PES 1989 Winter meeting New York 18 OHURA, Y., et al.: A digital distance relay using negativesequence current, IEEE Trans., 1990, PWRDS, pp. 79-84 19 MALIK, O.P., HOPE, G.S., CHENG, S.J., and HANNCOCK, G.: A multi-micro-computer based dual-rate self-tuning power system stabilizer: Paper 86 J PGC 652-2, presented at the IEEE/PES 1986 J oint Power Generation Cod, Orgon 20 LANCASTER, J.T., WEBB, M.R., MYERS, J.A., and PRIEST, K.W.: Semi-automatic meter reading, IEEE T r m. , 1987, PWRD-2, pp. 671477 21 ANDERSON, P.M., and FOUAD, A.A.: Power systemcontrol and stability (Iowa State University Press, Am-, Iowa, 1977) 22 LIPOVSKI, G.J.: Singleand multiple chip microcomputer inter- facing (Prentice-Hall, 1988) 23 MOTOROLA: M68HCll evaluation module users manual (Motorola Inc., 1988) 24 KAILATH, T.: Linear systems (Pnntice-Hall, 1980) 25 IEEE: IEEE standard proadum for obtaining synchronous machineparameters by standstill frequency responses testing. IEEE Standard 115A. 1987 26 CARNAHAN, B., LUTHER, H.A., and WILKES, J.O.: Applied numerical methods (Wiley, 1969) 8 Appendix: system data The followung data of the synchornous generator are given rated kVA =5 kVA rated voltage =220 V, Y connection excitation voltage =45 V stator current =13.5 A field current =3 A power factor =0.9 lagging rated speed =1800 RPM pole number =4 The parameters of the synchronous generator can be estimated by the IEEE 115 A standard test procedures [25]. All the systemdata are as follows: Generator (P.u.) X, =2.3 P.U. Td, =0.26 s x, =2.1p.u. Tio =0.21 s Xd =0.421 P.U. Xq =0.421 P.U. M =1.48 s D =0.12 P.U. R, =0.04727 p.u. ob =371 radJ sec Exciter (PA) K , =175 T. =0.04 s Transmission line (P.u. Re =0.02 P.U. X , =0.4 P.U. Initial operation point (PA) P =0.8 Q =0.6 & =1 svc T, = 1 ms T,= 1 ms K,=25 433