Ruies of procedure of speciai courts and quasiudiciai bodies shaii remain effective uniess disapproved by the Supreme Court. Forum Shopping -is an act of maipractice that is proscribed and condemned as trifiing with the courts and abusing their processes.
Ruies of procedure of speciai courts and quasiudiciai bodies shaii remain effective uniess disapproved by the Supreme Court. Forum Shopping -is an act of maipractice that is proscribed and condemned as trifiing with the courts and abusing their processes.
Ruies of procedure of speciai courts and quasiudiciai bodies shaii remain effective uniess disapproved by the Supreme Court. Forum Shopping -is an act of maipractice that is proscribed and condemned as trifiing with the courts and abusing their processes.
Remedial Law Review- Atty. Tan CIVIL PROCEDURE Definition: a. Rue makng power of the Supreme Court -art. 8, secton 5, par.5, 1987 consttuton provdes for the rue makng power of the SC: - Promugate rues concernng the protecton and the enforcement of consttutona rghts, peadngs, practce and procedure n a courts, the admsson to the practce of aw, the Integrated Bar, and ega assstance to the underprveged. Such rues sha provde a smpfed and nexpensve procedure for the speedy dsposton of cases, sha be unform for a courts of the same grade, and sha not dmnsh, ncrease, or modfy substantve rghts. Rues of procedure of speca courts and quas-|udca bodes sha reman effectve uness dsapproved by the Supreme Court. . Forum Shoppng -s an act of mapractce that s proscrbed and condemned as trfng wth the courts and abusng ther processes. It s mproper conduct that tends to degrade the admnstraton of |ustce. !. Prncpe of Herarchy of Court - ths prncpe means that a hgher court w not entertan drect resort to t uness the redress desred cannot be obtaned n the approprate courts. d. Temporary Restranng Order -summary hearng -prevents the dong of an act -requres the postng of a bond -the |udge may ssue ex parte a TRO effectve ony for 72 hours from ssuance -ts effectvty may be extended after conductng a summary hearng wthn the 72hours perod unt the appcaton for premnary n|uncton can be heard. -the tota perod of the effectvty of the TRO sha not exceed 20 days ncudng the 72 hours. e. Prncpe of Recoupment Remedies: a. Faure to compy wth the condton precedent (brgy. concaton) -non referra of the case wth the Barangay -remedy: defendant may fe a moton to dsmss the case on the ground of prematurty or faure to state a cause of acton under sec.1 based on faure to compy wth the condton precedent. -amcabe settement/ compromse agreement/ non-compance -remedy: executon of the amcabe settement wthn 6 months after the date of settement under Sec. 417 of RA 7160. -repudaton of the settement wthn 10 days from the date of settement by sworn statement on the ground that the consent was vtated by fraud, voence, or ntmdaton under Sec. 418 of RA 7160 1 Pearl remedial reviewer -annument of compromse agreement -ssuance of certfcate to fe acton. . Rue 3 -sec2 rue3; rea party n nterest -remedy: f the case s not brought n the name or aganst the rea party n nterest a moton to dsmss may be fed on the ground that the compant states no cause of acton. -sec.10 rue 3: unwng co-pantff -remedy: make the unwng co- pantff as one of the defendants or mpead the sad unwng co- pantff. -sec.11 rue 3: ms|onder or non- |onder of partes -remedy: (not a ground for dsmssa of the acton) moton to mpead or strke out the party defendant, n case of ms|onder, a separate acton may be fed aganst the party ms|oned. -sec.16 rue3: death of a party: -remedy: moton for substtuton of partes -sec. 20 rue 3: death of a party on a contractua money cams -remedy: before entry of |udgment acton sha contnue, and decson sha be enforced aganst the estate of the deceased. -sec. 21 rue 3: pauper tgant -remedy: moton to prosecute as pauper tgant, on the part of the adverse party he may fe an opposton to the moton contestng the grant of such authorty by showng that the pantff has means of vehood or propertes. !. Rue 57 -sec 12 rue 12: dscharge of the wrt of attachment -remedes: n the case of ssuance of wrt of attachment- defendant may fe a moton to dscharge attachment and by fng the necessary counter-bond sec 12 rue 57 -or he may fe a moton to quash wrt of attachment on the grounds specfed under sec 13 rue 57 -n case of dena, fe a moton for reconsderaton, and f dened fe a petton for certorar. d. Rue 65 n re to rue 41- nterocutory order e. Rue 9- moton to set asde an order of defaut remedy: n case of order of defaut- fe a moton to ft the order of defaut under oath on the ground of FAME wth affdavt of mert n accordance wth sec. 3 rue 9. n case t s dened, fe a moton for reconsderaton, f dened, fe a petton for certorar under rue 65, the order beng nterocutory under sec 1 rue 41, and f dened fe a moton for reconsderaton and f dened fe a petton for revew on certorar under rue 45. Or, fe a moton to admt answer together wth the attached answer, before the rendton of |udgment by defaut. Petton for reef from the fna order of defaut on the ground of FAME wth affdavt of mert. f. Dena on moton to amend a compant rue 10: amendment of peadngs 2 Pearl remedial reviewer on the part of the pantff: moton to amend peadngs wth attached amended peadng before the fng of responsve peadng even there s aready a moton to dsmss. In case of dena of the moton, fe a petton for mandamus under sec 3 rue 65, snce t s mnstera for the court to aow amendment before the fng of responsve peadngs beng a matter of rght. - On the part of the defendant: defendng party may fe an answer to the amended peadng or compant. Defendng party may aso fe hs comment or opposton to the moton to amend. ". Executon- petton for mandamus (Rue 65) Sec. 3. Petton for mandamus. When any trbuna, corporaton, board, offcer or person unawfuy negects the performance of an act whch the aw specfcay en|ons as a duty resutng from an offce, trust, or staton, or unawfuy excudes another from the use and en|oyment of a rght or offce to whch such other s entted, and there s no other pan, speedy and adequate remedy n the ordnary course of aw, the person aggreved thereby may fe a verfed petton n the proper court, aegng the facts wth certanty and prayng that |udgment be rendered commandng the respondent, mmedatey or at some other tme to be specfed by the court, to do the act requred to be done to protect the rghts of the pettoner, and to pay the damages sustaned by the pettoner by reason of the wrongfu acts of the respondent. The petton sha aso contan a sworn certfcaton of non-forum shoppng as provded n the thrd paragraph of secton 3, Rue 46. #. Moton for reconsderaton was dened- petton for certorar (Rue 65) -remedy: damages are excessve / evdence s nsuffcent/ contrary to aw- moton for reconsderaton. If the moton s dened- appea from the |udgment. i. |udgment on compromse- how to set asde? $. Annument of |udgment- how? -remedy: fna and executory |udgment, order, resouton of the RTC- party may fe a petton for annument of |udgment before the court of appeas on the ground fraud (wth affdavt of mert) or ack of |ursdcton. %. When the demurrer to evdence s granted- remedes -on the part of the defendant: after the pantff has rested hs case and based on nsuffcency of evdence- defendant may fe a moton for demurrer to evdence. -on the part of the pantff: n case the moton s granted- pantff may fe an appea snce t s an ad|udcaton on the merts. Distin"&is#: 3 Pearl remedial reviewer a. error of |ursdcton vs. error of |udgment Error of $&risdi!tion Error of $&d"ment one where the court, offcer or quas-|udca body acts wthout or n excess of |ursdcton, or wth grave abuse of dscreton. one that the court may commt n the exercse of |ursdcton, t ncudes errors of procedure or mstakes n the courts fndngs. t renders the |udgment vod or at east vodabe such an error does not make the courts decson vod. correctbe by certorar correctbe by appea . compusory countercam vs. permssve countercam CO'PUL(OR) COU*TERCLAI ' PER'I((IVE COU*TERCLAI ' (1) One whch arses out of or s necessary connected wth the transacton or occurrence that s the sub|ect matter of the opposng partys cam. (1) It does not arse out of nor s t necessary connected wth the sub|ect matter of the opposng partys cam. (2) It does not requre for ts ad|udcaton the presence of thrd partes of whom the court cannot acqure |ursdcton. (2) It may requre for ts ad|udcaton the presence of thrd partes over whom the court cannot acqure |ursdcton. (3) It s barred f (3) It s NOT not set up n the acton. barred even f not set up n the acton. (4) Need not be answered; no defaut. (4) Must be answered, otherwse, the defendant can be decared n defaut. !. summary |udgment vs. |udgment on the peadngs (U''AR) +UD,'E*T +UD,'E*T O* T-E PLEADI*,( based on the peadngs, depostons, admssons and affdavts based soey on the peadngs. avaabe to both pantff and defendant generay avaabe ony to the pantff, uness the defendant presents a countercam. there s no genune ssue between the partes, .e. there may be ssues but these are rreevant there s no ssue or there s an admsson of matera aegatons. 10-day notce requred 3-day notce requred May be nterocutory or on the merts On the merts d. moton to dsmss vs. demurrer to evdence 'OTIO* TO DI('I(( U*DER RULE 'OTIO* TO DI('I(( U*DER RULE 4 Pearl remedial reviewer ./ 00 1dem&rrer to eviden!e2 grounded on premnary ob|ectons. based on nsuffcency of evdence. may be fed by any defendng party aganst whom a cam s asserted n the acton. may be fed ony by the defendant aganst the compant of the pantff. shoud be fed wthn the tme for but pror to the fng of the answer of the defendng party to the peadng assertng the cam aganst hm. may be fed ony after the pantff has competed the presentaton of hs evdence. e. res |udcata, concusveness of |udgment, aw of the case -concusveness of |udgment - ths doctrne precudes the retgaton of an ssue n a subsequent acton between the same partes or ther successor n nterest where such ssue had aready been tgated by the partes n a prevous acton even f the causes of acton are dfferent. Does not necessary bar the fng of another acton between the same partes. What the doctrne bars s the re-tgaton of the ssues. -res |udcata n ts aspect and understood as bar by a pror |udgment, precudes the fng of another acton between the same partes on the same sub|ect matter and for the same causes of acton. Here the |udgment n the frst acton s concusve and consttutes a bar on every matter sub|ect of the frst acton. It bars not ony the ssues tgated but the cam tsef. En&meration: a. effects of death of a party - (e!tion ./. Deat# of 3arty4 d&ty of !o&nsel. The death of the cent w requre hs substtuton by hs ega representatve to be ordered by the court wheren the case s pendng, or even the appontment of an executor or admnstrator, but ths tme, by a court of probate |ursdcton. In the case of ncapacty or ncompetency of the party, ths fact w merey enta the appontment of a guardan ad litem by the court tryng the case upon beng nformed thereof by counse of the partes, the partes themseves, or other reabe sources. These provsons appy where the cam survves and regardess of whether ether the pantff or the defendant des or whether the case s n the tra or appeate courts. No summons s requred to be served on the substtuted defendants. Instead, the order of substtuton sha be served upon the partes substtuted n the acton, otherwse the court does not acqure |ursdcton over the substtute party. If there s faure to notfy the fact of death: the case may contnue and proceedngs w be hed vad, 5 Pearl remedial reviewer and |udgment w bnd the successors n nterest. The court cannot compe the awyer to contnue wth the tra after the awyer has notfed the court of the death of hs cent. Otherwse, the entre proceedng s nu and vod; the court woud have no |ursdcton over the estate, the hers and the executors or admnstrators 1Lawas vs. CA .5/ (CRA .602 b. grounds for ssuance of wrt of premnary n|uncton (prevous exam: premnary attachment) Sec. 3, Rue 58 A premnary n|uncton may be granted when t s estabshed: a. that the appcant s entted to the reef demanded, and the whoe or part of such reef conssts n restranng the commsson or contnuance of the acts companed of, or n requrng the performance of an act or acts, ether for a mted perod or perpetuay; b. that the commsson, contnuance or non performance of the act or acts companed of durng the tgaton woud probaby work n|ustce to the appcant; or c. that a party, court, or agency or a person s dong, threatenng, or s attemptng to do, or s procurng or sufferng to be done, some act or acts probaby n voaton of the rghts of the appcant respectng the sub|ect of the acton or proceedng, and tendng to render the |udgment neffectua. !. notce of s pendens- when (grounds for canceaton) t s a notce of pendency of the acton between the partes nvovng tte to or rght of possesson over rea property. Requstes: Acton affects the tte or the rght of possesson of the rea property. Affrmatve reef s camed Notce sha contan the name of the partes and the ob|ect of the acton or defense and a descrpton of the property affected thereby; and Acton n rem Grounds for canceaton: -the notce s for the purpose of moestng the adverse party; or -t s not necessary to protect the rghts of the party who caused t to be recorded. d. grounds for new tra e. nstances when appea s not avaabe-Rue 41 Prolems: a. about the effect of the amended compant wthout certfcaton of non-forum shoppng 6 Pearl remedial reviewer -faure to compy wth the requrement sha not be curabe by mere amendment of the compant or other ntatory peadng but ha be cause for the dsmssa of the case wthout pre|udce uness otherwse provded upon moton and hearng (sec 5 r7) . f you were the |udge w you dsmss the case? Grounds -yes, sec5 r7 !. defendants ded whe the case s pendng. Decde - sec20 r3, when the acton s for recovery of money arsng from contract, express or mped and the defendant des before entry of fna |udgment n the court n whch the acton was pendng at the tme of such death, t sha not be dsmssed but sha nstead be aowed to contnue unt entry of fna |udgment. Concurrence of the foowng requstes: a. the acton be one for recovery of money b. the money sought to be recovered arses from contracts, express or mped c. the defendant des before entry of fna |udgment n the court n whch the acton s pendng. d. the answer was not verfed, remedy of the pantff ? w you grant the moton for |udgment on the peadngs? -remedy: peadngs may be amended or the court may order that the peadng may be verfed at the dscreton of the court. -opposng party- n case the peadng s unverfed contrary to the requrements of the rues, the adverse party may move to strke out the peadng from the record of the case. e. The case was dsmssed due to pantffs faure to prosecute, same acton was fed by the pantff, defendant moved for the dsmssa on the ground of res |udcata. Decde Essenta condtons whch must concur n order that res |udcata may effectvey appy are: a. the |udgment sought to bar the new acton must be fna b. the decson must have been rendered by a court havng |ursdcton over the sub|ect matter and the partes c. the dsposton of the case must be a |udgment or order on the merts d. there must be between the frst and second acton dentty of the partes, dentty of sub|ect matter and dentty of causes of acton. Definition and en&merations:
.. Propertes exempt from executon Except as otherwse expressy provded by aw, the foowng 7 Pearl remedial reviewer property, and no other, sha be exempt from executon:
(a) The |udgment obgors famy home as provded by aw, or the homestead n whch he resdes, and and necessary used n connecton therewth; (b) Ordnary toos and mpements personay used by hm n hs trade, empoyment, or vehood; Three horses, or three cows, or three carabaos, or other beasts of burden such as the |udgment obgor may seect necessary used by hm n hs ordnary occupaton; (d) Hs necessary cothng and artces for ordnary persona use, excudng |ewery; (e) Househod furnture and utenss necessary for housekeepng, and used for that purpose by the |udgment obgor and hs famy, such as the |udgment obgor may seect, of a vaue not exceedng one hundred thousand pesos; (f) Provsons for ndvdua or famy use suffcent for four months; (g) The professona brares and equpment of |udges, awyers, physcans, pharmacsts, dentsts, engneers, surveyors, cergymen, teachers, and other professonas, not exceedng three hundred thousand pesos n vaue; (h) One fshng boat and accessores not exceedng the tota vaue of one hundred thousand pesos owned by a fsherman and by the awfu use of whch he earns hs vehood; () So much of the saares, wages, or earnngs of the |udgment obgor of hs persona servces wthn the four months precedng the evy as are necessary for the support of hs famy; (|) Lettered gravestones; (k) Mones benefts, prveges, or annutes accrung or n any manner growng out of any fe nsurance; () The rght to receve ega support, or money or property obtaned as such support, or any penson or gratuty from the Government; (m) Propertes specay exempt by aw.
But no artce or speces of property mentoned n hs secton sha be exempt from executo ssued upon a |udgment recovered for ts prce or upon a |udgment of forecosure of a mortgage thereon. 7. (U''AR) +UD,'E*T +UD,'E*T O* T-E PLEADI*,( based on the peadngs, depostons, admssons and affdavts based soey on the peadngs. avaabe to both pantff and defendant generay avaabe ony to the pantff, uness the defendant presents a countercam. there s no genune ssue between the partes, .e. there may be ssues but these there s no ssue or there s an admsson of matera aegatons. 8 Pearl remedial reviewer are rreevant 10-day notce requred 3-day notce requred May be nterocutory or on the merts On the merts 0. VENUE OF ACTIONS Secton 1. Venue of rea actons. Actons affectng tte to or possesson of rea property, or nterest theren, sha be commenced and tred n the proper court whch has |ursdcton over the area wheren the rea property nvoved, or a porton thereof, s stuated. Forcbe entry and detaner actons sha be commenced and tred n the muncpa tra court of the muncpaty or cty wheren the rea property nvoved, or a porton thereof, s stuated. Sec. 2. Venue of persona actons. A other actons may be commenced and tred where the pantff or any of the prncpa pantffs resdes, or where the defendant or any of the prncpa defendants resdes, or n the case of a non-resdent defendant where he may be found, at the eecton of the pantff. Sec. 3. Venue of actons aganst non-resdents. If any of the defendants does not resde and s not found n the Phppnes, and the acton affects the persona status of the pantff, or any property of sad defendant ocated n the Phppnes, the acton may be commenced and tred n the court of the pace where the pantff resdes, or where the property or any porton thereof s stuated or found. Sec. 4. When Rue not appcabe. This Rule shall not apply: (a) In those cases where a specfc rue or aw provdes otherwse; or (b) Where the partes have vady agreed n wrtng before the fng of the acton on the excusve venue thereof.
Re8&isites for ven&e to e e9!l&sive: (a)A vad wrtten agreement (b)Executed by the partes before the fng of the acton; and (c) Agreement to the excusve nature of the venue. In the absence of quafyng or restrctve words, venue stpuaton s merey permssve meanng that the stpuated venue s n addton to the venue provded for n the rue 1Polytrade Cor3. vs. :lan!o 0; (CRA .<62 'eans of waivin" ven&e: 1) faure to ob|ect by means of moton to dsmss (2) affrmatve reef sought n the court where the case s fed (1)vountary submsson to the court where the case s fed (2)aches I= PROPERT) I( LOCATED AT T-E :OU*DARIE( O= T>O PLACE(: fe one case n ether pace at the opton of the pantff. I= CA(E I*VOLVE( T>O PROPERTIE( LOCATED I* T>O DI==ERE*T PLACE(: 9 Pearl remedial reviewer (a)If the propertes are the ob|ect of the same transacton, fe t n any of the two paces. (b) If they are the sub|ects of two dstnct transactons, separate actons shoud be fed n each pace. 5. Procedura rghts for vadty of |udgment a. t must be n wrtng b. t must be personay and drecty prepared by the |udge c. t must state ceary and dstncty the facts and the aw on whch t s based. d. It must be sgned by the |udge e. It must be fed wth the cerk of court. ?. VE*UE +URI(DICTIO* 1. pace where the acton s nsttuted 1. power of the court to hear and decde a case 2. may be waved 2. |ursdcton over the sub|ect matter and over the nature of the acton s conferred by aw and cannot be waved 3.procedura 3.substantve 4.may be changed by the wrtten agreement of the partes 4. cannot be the sub|ect of the agreement of the partes /. CO'PUL(OR) PER'I((IVE COU*TERCLAI ' COU*TERCLAI ' (1) One whch arses out of or s necessary connected wth the transacton or occurrence that s the sub|ect matter of the opposng partys cam. (1) It does not arse out of nor s t necessary connected wth the sub|ect matter of the opposng partys cam. (2) It does not requre for ts ad|udcaton the presence of thrd partes of whom the court cannot acqure |ursdcton. (2) It may requre for ts ad|udcaton the presence of thrd partes over whom the court cannot acqure |ursdcton. (3) It s barred f not set up n the acton. (3) It s NOT barred even f not set up n the acton. (4) Need not be answered; no defaut. (4) Must be answered, otherwse, the defendant can be decared n defaut. 6 . Secton 12. Cass sut . RE@UI(ITE( O= A CLA(( AREPRE(E*TATIVE (UIT: (a) sub|ect matter of the controversy s one of common or genera nterest to many persons; (b)partes affected are so numerous that t s mpractcabe to brng them a before the court; (c) partes brngng the cass sut are suffcenty numerous or representatve of the cass and 10 Pearl remedial reviewer can fuy protect the nterests of a concerned. 8. Re8&isites of 3ermissive $oinder of 3arties. (1) rght to reef arses out of the same transacton or seres of transactons; (2) there s a queston of aw or fact common to a the pantffs or defendants; and (3) such |onder s not otherwse proscrbed by the provsons of the Rues on |ursdcton and venue. B. Secton 1. Who may ntervene. Who may ntervene: (a)One who has ega nterest n the matter n tgaton (b)One who has ega nterest n the success of ether of the partes, (c) One who has an nterest aganst both partes (d)One who s so stuated as to be adversey affected by a dstrbuton or other dsposton of property n the custody of the court or of an offcer thereof =ACTOR( TO :E CO*(IDERED :) T-E COURT: (a)Whether or not the nterventon w unduy deay or pre|udce the ad|udcaton of the rghts of the orgna partes (b)Whether or not the ntervenors rghts may be fuy protected n a separate proceedng .;. KINDS OF SERVICE OF SUMMONS: (1) persona servce (2) substtuted servce (3) by pubcaton (4)any other form of servce as the courts deemed suffcent (ERVICE O= (U''O*( O* DI==ERE*T E*TITIE( A. (ERVICE O* E*TIT) >IT-OU T +URIDICA L PER(O*A LI-T) -upon any or a defendants beng sued under common name; or -person n charge of offce :. (ERVICE UPO* 'I*OR( A*D I*CO'PE -TE*T( -serve personay and on guardan or any person exercsng parenta authorty over hm; HOW. In case of mnors: by servng upon the mnor, regardess of age, AND upon hs ega guardan, or aso upon ether of hs parents. In case of ncompetents: by servng on hm personay AND upon hs ega guardan, but not upon hs parents, uness when they are hs ega guardans IN ANY EVENT, f the mnor or ncompetent has no ega guardan, the pantff must obtan the appontment of a guardan ad tem for 11 Pearl remedial reviewer hm. C. (ERVICE UPO* PRI(O*E R - serve on offcer havng management of the |a or prson D. (ERVICE UPO* DO'E(TI C PRIVATE +URIDICA L E*TIT) -To the presdent, managng partner, genera manager, corporate secretary, treasurer, or n-house counse. * Servce upon a person other than those mentoned s nvad and does not bnd the corporaton. E. (ERVICE UPO* =OREI,* PRIVATE +URIDICA L E*TIT) - serve on resdent agent ; or f none; - govt offca desgnated by aw; or - on any offcer or agent of the corporaton wthn the Phppnes. =. (ERVICE UPO* PU:LIC CORPORA -TIO*( - n case defendant s the Repubc of the Phppnes - by servng upon the Soctor Genera - n case of a provnce, cty or muncpaty, or ke pubc corporatons - by servng on ts executve head, or on such other offcer or offcers as the aw or the court may drect. ,. ECTRA- TERRITO- RIAL (ER- VICE 1. Requstes a. defendant does not resde or s not found wthn the Ph. b. the acton ether: * affects the status of pantff; *reates to or the sub|ect of whch s property wthn the Phppnes n whch defendant has a en or nterest; *demands a reef whch conssts whoy or n part n excudng the defendant from any nterest n any property wthn the Ph; or *property of defendant has been attached n the Ph. 2. Mode of servce a. wth eave of court served outsde the Ph. by persona servce; or b. wth eave of court serve by pubcaton n a newspaper of genera crcuaton, n whch case copy of the summons and order of court must aso be sent by regstered ma to the ast known address of defendant; or c. any other manner the court deem suffcent. -. (ERVICE UPO* RE(IDE* T Substtuted servce or wth eave of court, persona servce out of the Ph. as under extraterrtora servce 12 Pearl remedial reviewer TE'PORA -RIL) OUT O= T-E P-IL ... GENERAL RULE: court cannot refuse executon U*LE((: (UCNID) 1. Executon s UN|UST OR IMPOSSIBLE 2. Equtabe grounds ke a CHANGE IN SITUATION 3. |udgment NOVATED by partes 4. Executon s en|oned 5. |udgment has become DORMANT Ouasha of wrt proper when: 1. Improvdenty ssued 2. Defectve n substance 3. Issued aganst the wrong party 4. |udgment aready satsfed 5. Issued wthout authorty .7. CIVIL CA(E( CRI'I*AL CA(E( 1. defendant need not ask for eave of court; 1. eave of court s necessary so that the accused coud present hs evdence f the demurrer s dened 3. f court denes demurrer, defendant w present hs evdence 3. f court denes the demurrer: a. f demurrer was wth eave, accused may present hs evdence b. f the demurrer was wthout eave, accused can no onger present hs evdence and submts the case for decson based on the pr1osecutons evdence .0 . RULE 23 DEPOSITIONS PENDING ACTION R&les 70-7< 3rovide for t#e DI==ERE*T 'ODE( O= DI(COVER). DI(COVER) - s the procedure by whch one party n an acton s enabed to obtan before tra knowedge of reevant facts and of matera evdence n the possesson of the adverse party or of a wtness. Ratonae of dscovery: to enabe the partes to obtan the fuest possbe knowedge of the ssues and evdence ong before the tra to prevent such tra from beng carred on n the dark. (e!tion .. De3ositions 3endin" a!tionD w#en may e ta%en. DEPO(ITIO* - s a wrtten testmony of a wtness gven n the course of a |udca proceedng n advance of the tra or hearng upon ora examnaton or n response to wrtten nterrogatores and where an opportunty s gven for cross-examnaton. Depostons are ntended as a means to compe dscosure of facts restng n the knowedge of a party or other person, whch are reevant n a sut/proceedng. 13 Pearl remedial reviewer CLA((I=ICATIO*( O= DEPO(ITIO*(: (a)Depostons on ORAL EXAMINATION and Depostons upon WRITTEN INTERROGATORIES (b)Depostons DE BENE ESSE (those taken for purposes of a pendng acton); and, (c) Depostons IN PERPETUAM REI MEMORIAM (Rue 24) (those taken to perpetuate evdence for purposes of antcpated acton, or n the event of further proceedngs n a case on appea, and to preserve t aganst danger of oss.) Ths Rue reguates depostons de bene esse Dscovery s NOT MANDATORY but faure to ava carres sanctons n R&les 7? and 7/. LI'ITATIO*(: (a)examnaton s conducted n bad fath (b) examnaton s conducted n such a manner as to annoy, embarrass or oppress the person sub|ect to the nqury (c) when the nqury touches upon rreevant or encroaches upon the recognzed domans of prvege. >-E* TAEE*: WITH LEAVE OF COURT (a)after |ursdcton has been obtaned over any defendant or over the property whch s the sub|ect of the acton and BEFORE answer. (b)Deposton of a person confned n prson. WITHOUT LEAVE OF COURT (a) AFTER answer and deponent s not confned n prson. (e!tion 0. E9amination and !ross-e9amination. (e!tion 5. Use of de3ositions. Where the wtness s avaabe to testfy and the stuaton s not one of those excepted under Sec. 4, hs deposton s nadmssbe n evdence and he shoud be made to testfy. It can be used as evdence by a party for any purpose under the specfc condtons n Sec. 4. DEPO*E*T U(E any by any party for contradctng or mpeachng the testmony of deponent as wtness a party or any one who at the tme of the deposton was an OFFICER, DIRECTOR, or MANAGING AGENT of a pubc or prvate corp., partnershp, or assocaton whch s a party by an adverse party for any purpose wtness, whether or not a party by any party for any purpose f the court fnds the 5 nstances occurrng SCOPE OF INOUIRY IN DEPOSITIONS: 14 Pearl remedial reviewer 1. Matter whch s reevant to the sub|ect of the pendng acton; 2. Not prveged 3. Not restrcted by a protectve order (e!tion .;. Persons efore w#om de3ositions may e ta%en wit#in t#e P#ili33ines. (e!tion ... Persons efore w#om de3ositions may e ta%en in forei"n !o&ntries. Persons before whom depostons may be take: WITHIN THE PHILIPPINES: (a)|udge (b)notary pubc (c) any person authorzed to admnster oaths, as stpuated by the partes n wrtng OUTSIDE THE PHILIPPINES: (a)on notce, before a secretary of embassy or egaton, consu genera, consu, vce-consu, or consuar agent of the Ph. (b) before such person or offcer as may be apponted by commsson or etters rogatory (c) any person authorzed to admnster oaths, as stpuated by the partes n wrtng (e!tion .7. Commission or letters ro"atory. CO''I((IO* LETTER( RO,ATOR) ssued to a non-|udca foregn offcer who w drecty take the testmony ssued to the approprate |udca offcer of the foregn country who w drect somebody n sad foregn country to take down testmony appcabe rues of procedure are those of the requestng court appcabe rues of procedure are those of the foregn court requested to act resorted to f permsson of the foregn country s gven resorted to f the executon of the commsson s refused n the foregn country eave of court s not necessary eave of court s necessary (e!tion .<. 'otion to terminate or limit e9amination. WHEN TO FILE: (a)any tme durng the takng of the deposton (b)on moton or petton of any party or of the deponent; or (c) upon showng that the examnaton s conducted n 1. bad fath 2. n such manner as unreasonaby to annoy, embarrass, or oppress the deponent or party RULE 75 DEPO(ITIO*( :E=ORE ACTIO* OR PE*DI*, APPEAL (e!tion .. De3ositions efore a!tion4 3etition. Ths Rue reguates the takng of depostons in perpetuam rei memoriam. Depostons under ths Rue are aso taken condtonay, to be used 15 Pearl remedial reviewer at the tra ony n case the deponent s not avaabe. Depostons under ths Rue do not prove the exstence of any rght and the testmony perpetuated s not n tsef concusve proof, ether of the exstence of any rght nor even of the facts to whch they reate, as t can be controverted at the tra n the same manner as though no perpetuaton of testmony was ever had. However, n the absence of any ob|ecton to ts takng, and even f the deponent dd not testfy at the hearng, the perpetuated testmony consttutes prima facie proof of facts referred to n the deposton. (e!tion /. Use of de3osition. If deposton s taken under ths Rue, t may be used n any acton nvovng the SAME SUB|ECT MATTER subsequenty brought. (e!tion 6. De3ositions 3endin" a33eal. Sec. 7 s the procedure n perpetuatng testmony AFTER |UDGMENT IN THE RTC and DURING THE PENDENCY OF AN APPEAL. RULE 7? I*TERRO,ATORIE( TO PARTIE( (e!tion .. Interro"atories to 3arties4 servi!e t#ereof. PURPOSE of Wrtten Interrogatores: to ect facts from any adverse party (answers may aso be used as admssons of the adverse party) Wrtten nterrogatores and the answers thereto must both be FILED and SERVED. (e!tion 5. *&mer of Interro"atories. (e!tion ?. (!o3e and &se of interro"atories. A party may serve wrtten nterrogatores: WITHOUT LEAVE OF COURT - after answer has been served, for the frst set of nterrogatores. WITH LEAVE OF COURT - before answer has been served (reason: at that tme, the ssues are not yet |oned and the dsputed facts are not yet cear, when more than one set of nterrogatores s to be served.) A |udgment by defaut may be rendered aganst a party who fas to answer wrtten nterrogatores The varous modes of dscovery are ceary ntended to be cumuatve, and not aternatve or mutuay excusve. (e!tion /. Effe!t of fail&re to serve written interro"atories. The provson and Rue 26 are drected to the party who fas and refuses to RESORT to the dscovery procedures, and shoud not be confused wth the provsons of Rue 29 whch provdes for sanctons or other consequences upon a party who refuses or fas to COMPLY wth dscovery procedures duy avaed of by opponent. The |ustfcaton for ths provson s that the party n need 16 Pearl remedial reviewer of reevant facts havng foregone the opportunty to nqure nto the same from the other party through means avaabe to hm, he shoud not thereafter be permtted to unduy burden the atter wth courtroom appearances or other cumbersome processes. Uness a party had been served wrtten nterrogatores, he may not be compeed by the adverse party: (a)to gve testmony n open court, or (b) gve a deposton pendng appea. The ony excepton s when the court aows t for GOOD CAUSE shown and to prevent a faure of |ustce. De3ositio ns U3on >ritten Interro"a tories to Parties &nder R&le 70 (e!. 7? Interro"a tories to Parties &nder R&le 7? As to De3onen t 1. party or ordnary wtness 1. party ony As to Pro!ed&r e 2. wth ntervent on of the offcer authorzed by the Court to take deposton 2.no ntervent on. Wrtten nterrogat ores are drected to the party hmsef As to (!o3e 3. drect, cross, 3. ony one set of redrect, re-cross nterrogat ores Interro"a tories 4. no fxed tme 4. 15 days to answer uness extended or reduced by the court RULE 7/ AD'I((IO* :) ADVER(E PART) (e!tion .. Re8&est for admission. PURPOSE OF wrtten request for admsson s to expedte tra and reeve the partes of the costs of provng facts whch w not be dsputed on tra and the truth of whch can be ascertaned by reasonabe nqury. (e!tion 7. Im3lied Admission. The effect of a faure to make a repy to a request for admsson s that each of the matters of whch an admsson s requested s deemed admtted. Each matter must be dened SPECIFICALLY under oath settng forth n deta the reason why he cannot truthfuy admt or deny. The answer to a request for admsson under ths rue may be made by the awyer of the party and not necessary the party hmsef. (e!tion 0. Effe!t of admission. USE: An admsson under ths secton s for the purpose of the pendng acton ony and cannot be used n other proceedngs. 17 Pearl remedial reviewer RULE 76 PRODUCTIO* OR I*(PECTIO* O= DOCU'E*T( OR T-I*,( (e!tion .. 'otion for 3rod&!tion or ins3e!tion4 order. Producton of documents affords more opportunty for dscovery than a subpoena duces tecum because n the atter, the documents are brought to the court for the frst tme on the date of the schedued tra wheren such documents are requred to be produced. The test to be apped n determnng the reevancy of the document and the suffcency of ther descrpton s one of reasonabeness and practcaty. PRODUCTIO* OR I*(PECTIO* O= DOCU'E*T( OR T-I*,( (U:POE*A DUCE( TECU' essentay a mode of dscovery means of compeng producton of evdence the Rues s mted to the partes to the acton may be drected to a person whether a party or not the order under ths Rue s ssued ony upon moton wth notce to the adverse party may be ssued upon an ex parte appcaton. RULE 7< P-)(ICAL A*D 'E*TAL ECA'I*ATIO* O= PER(O*( (e!tion .. >#en e9amination may e ordered. The menta condton of a party s n controversy n proceedngs for GUARDIANSHIP over an mbece or nsane person, whe the physca condton of the party s generay nvoved n PHYSICAL IN|URIES cases. Snce the resuts of the examnaton are ntended to be made pubc, the same are not covered by the physcan-patent prvege. (e!tion 5. >aiver of 3rivile"e. Where the party examned requests and obtans a report on the resuts of the examnaton the consequences are: (a) he has to furnsh the other party a copy of the report of any prevous or subsequent examnaton of the same physca and menta condton, and (b) he waves any prvege he may have n that acton or any other nvovng the same controversy regardng the testmony of any other person who has so examned hm or may thereafter examne hm. 18 Pearl remedial reviewer RULE 7B RE=U(AL TO CO'PL) >IT- 'ODE( O= DI(COVER) (A*CTIO*(: 1. Contempt; 2. Payment of reasonabe fees; 3. The matters regardng whch the questons were asked, character or descrpton of and et a., be taken to be n accordance wth the cam of party obtanng the order; 4. Prohbtng the refusng party to produce evdence or support or oppose desgnated cams or defenses; 5. To strke out peadngs, order the dsmssa of the acton or stay the acton unt compance or to render |udgment by defaut. 6. Order the arrest of the refusng party except n cases of physca or menta examnaton. Defintions: a. stare decss - embodes the rue that when the court has ad down a prncpe of aw as appcabe to a certan state of facts, t w adhere to that prncpe, and appy t to a future cases, where facts are substantay the same, regardess of whether the partes and property are the same. Under ths prncpe, when a pont of aw has been setted by decson, t consttutes a precedent whch s not afterwards to be departed from uness t s necessary to vndcate pan and obvous prncpes of aw or to remedy contnued n|ustce. . the decson of the supreme court form part of the ega system and faure of any court to appy them sha consttute an abdcaton of ts duty to resove a dspute n accordance wth aw, and sha be a ground for admnstratve acton aganst an nferor court. Every court must take cognzance of decsons the Supreme Court has rendered because they are proper sub|ects of mandatory |udca notce and more mportanty form part of the ega system. !. obter dctum- opnon expressed by a court upon some queston of aw whch s not necessary to the decson of the case before t. It s a remark made or opnon expressed by the |udge n hs decson upon a cause, by the way, that s, ncdentay or coateray and not drecty upon the queston before hm, or upon a pont not necessary nvoved n the determnaton of the cause, or ntroduced by way of ustraton or anaogy or argument, such s not bndng as precedent. d. aw of the case- term apped to an estabshed rue that when an appeate court passes on a queston and remands a cause to a ower court for further proceedngs, the queston there setted becomes the aw of the case upon subsequent appea. It means whatever s once rrevocaby estabshed as the controng ega rue between the same partes contnues to be the aw of the case so ong as the facts of the case before the court. The doctrne appes ony when a case s before a court a second tme after rung by an appeate court. 19 Pearl remedial reviewer 15. ,E*ERAL T)PE( O= A 'OTIO* TO DI('I((: .. moton to dsmss before answer under Rue 16 Wthn the tme for but before fng the answer to the compant or peadng assertng a cam, a moton to dsmss may be made on any of the foowng grounds: (a) That the court has no |ursdcton over the person of the defendng party; (b) That the court has no |ursdcton over the sub|ect matter of the cam; That venue s mpropery ad; (d) That the pantff has no ega capacty to sue; (e) That there s another acton pendng between the same partes for the same cause; (f) That the cause of acton s barred by a pror |udgment or by the statute of mtatons; (g) That the peadng assertng the cam states no cause of acton; (h) That the cam or demand set forth n the pantffs peadng has been pad, waved, abandoned, or otherwse extngushed; () That the cam on whch the acton s founded s unenforceabe under the provsons of the statute of frauds; and (|) That a condton precedent for fng the cam has not been comped wth. 7. moton to dsmss under Rue !7 a.upon notce by pantff A compant may be dsmssed by the pantff by fng a notce of dsmssa at any tme before servce of the answer or of a moton for summary |udgment. Upon such notce beng fed, the court sha ssue an order confrmng the dsmssa. Uness otherwse stated n the notce, the dsmssa s wthout pre|udce, except that a notce operates as an ad|udcaton upon the merts when fed by a pantff who has once dsmssed n a competent court an acton based on or ncudng the same cam. .upon moton of pantff Except as provded n the precedng secton, a compant sha not be dsmssed at the pantffs nstance save upon approva of the court and upon such terms and condtons as the court deems proper. If a countercam has been peaded by a defendant pror to the servce upon hm of the pantffs moton for dsmssa, the dsmssa sha be mted to the compant. The dsmssa sha be wthout pre|udce to the rght of the defendant to prosecute hs countercam n a separate acton uness wthn ffteen (15) days from notce of the moton he manfests hs preference to have hs countercam resoved n the same acton. Uness otherwse specfed n the order, a dsmssa under ths paragraph sha be wthout pre|udce. A cass sut sha not be dsmssed or compromsed wthout the approva of the court. !.due to faut of pantff If, for no |ustfabe cause, the pantff fas to appear on the date of the presentaton of hs evdence 20 Pearl remedial reviewer n chef on the compant, or to prosecute hs acton for an unreasonabe ength of tme, or to compy wth these Rues or any order of the court, the compant may be dsmssed upon moton of the defendant or upon the courts own moton, wthout pre|udce to the rght of the defendant to prosecute hs countercam n the same or n a separate acton. Ths dsmssa sha have the effect of an ad|udcaton upon the merts, uness otherwse decared by the court. 0. moton to dsmss on demurrer to evdence after pantff has rested hs case under Rue 33 After the pantff has competed the presentaton of hs evdence, the defendant may move for dsmssa on the ground that upon the facts and the aw the pantff has shown no rght to reef. If hs moton s dened, he sha have the rght to present evdence. If the moton s granted but on appea the order of dsmssa s reversed he sha be deemed to have waved the rght to present evdence. 5. moton to dsmss the appea fed ether on the ower court ( Rue 41, Sec. 13 ) or n the appeate court ( Rue 50, Sec. 1 ) Sec. 13. Dsmssa of appea. Pror to the transmtta of the orgna record or the record on appea to the appeate court, the tra court may motu propro or on moton dsmss the appea for havng been taken out of tme. Secton 1. Grounds for dsmssa of appea.
An appea may be dsmssed by the Court of Appeas, on ts own moton or on that of the appeee, on the foowng grounds: (a) Faure of the record on appea to show on ts face that the appea was taken wthn the perod fxed by these Rues; (b) Faure to fe the notce of appea or the record on appea wthn the perod prescrbed by these Rues; Faure of the appeant to pay the docket and other awfu fees as provded n secton 4 of Rue 41; (d) Unauthorzed ateratons, omssons or addtons n the approved record on appea as provded n secton 4 of Rue 44; (e) Faure of the appeant to serve and fe the requred number of copes of hs bref or memorandum wthn the tme provded by these Rues; (f) Absence of specfc assgnment of errors n the appeants bref, or of page references to the record as requred n secton 13, paragraphs (a), (c), (d) and (f) of Rue 44; (g) Faure of the appeant to take the necessary steps for the correcton or competon of the record wthn the tme mted by the court n ts order; (h) Faure of the appeant to appear at the premnary conference under Rue 48 or to compy wth orders, crcuars, or drectves of the court wthout |ustfabe cause; and () The fact that the order or |udgment appeaed from s not appeaabe. ./. for&m s#o33in" 21 Pearl remedial reviewer Faure to compy wth the foregong requrements sha not be curabe by mere amendment of the compant or other ntatory peadng but sha be cause for the dsmssa of the case wthout pre|udce, uness otherwse provded, upon moton and after hearng. The submsson of a fase certfcaton or non-compance wth any of the undertakngs theren sha consttute ndrect contempt of court, wthout pre|udce to the correspondng admnstratve and crmna actons. If the acts of the party or hs counse ceary consttute wfu and deberate forum shoppng, the same sha be ground for summary dsmssa wth pre|udce and sha consttute drect contempt, as we as a cause for admnstratve sanctons. .6. (e!tion ?. Effe!t of fail&re to a33ear. E==ECT O= *O*-APPEARA*CE O= PLAI*TI==: -cause for dsmssa of the acton, wth pre|udce, uness otherwse ordered by the court. E==ECT O= *O*-APPEARA*CE O= DE=E*DA*T: - cause to aow the pantff to present evdence ex parte and the court to render |udgment on the bass thereof. .<. Elements of a !lass s&it 1. Sub|ect matter of the controversy s one of common or genera nterest to many persons. 2. the persons are so numerous that t s mpractcabe to |on them a as partes. 3. partes brngng the cass sut are suffcenty numerous and representatve of the cass and can fuy protect the nterests of a concerned; and 4. the representatve sues or defends for the beneft of a. .B. RULE 6 . PART( O= A PLEADI*, Secton 1. Capton. The capton sets forth the name of the court, the tte of the acton, and the docket number f assgned. The tte of the acton ndcates the names of the partes. They sha a be named n the orgna compant or petton; but n subsequent peadngs, t sha be suffcent f the name of the frst party on each sde be stated wth an approprate ndcaton when there are other partes. Ther respectve partcpaton n the case sha be ndcated. Sec. 2. The body. The body of the peadng sets forth ts desgnaton, the aegatons of the partys cams or defenses, the reef prayed for, and the date of the peadng. (a) Paragraphs. - The aegatons n the body of a peadng sha be dvded nto paragraphs so numbered as to be ready dentfed, each of whch sha contan a statement of a snge set of crcumstances so far as that can be done wth convenence. A paragraph may be referred to by ts number n a succeedng peadngs. 22 Pearl remedial reviewer (b) Headngs. - When two or more causes of acton are |oned, the statement of the frst sha be prefaced by the words "frst cause of acton," of the second by "second cause of acton," and so on for the others. When one or more paragraphs n the answer are addressed to one of severa causes of acton n the compant, they sha be prefaced by the words "answer to the frst cause of acton" or "answer to the second cause of acton" and so on; and when one or more paragraphs of the answer are addressed to severa causes of acton, they sha be prefaced by words to that effect. (c) Reef. - The peadng sha specfy the reef sought, but t may add a genera prayer for such further or other reef as may be deemed |ust or equtabe. (d) Date. - Every peadng sha be dated. Sec. 3. Sgnature and address. Every peadng must be sgned by the party or counse representng hm, statng n ether case hs address whch shoud not be a post offce box. The sgnature of counse consttutes a certfcate by hm that he has read the peadng; that to the best of hs knowedge, nformaton, and beef there s good ground to support t; and that t s not nterposed for deay. An unsgned peadng produces no ega effect. However, the court may, n ts dscreton, aow such defcency to be remeded f t sha appear that the same was due to mere nadvertence and not ntended for deay. Counse who deberatey fes an unsgned peadng, or sgns a peadng n voaton of ths Rue, or aeges scandaous or ndecent matter theren, or fas to prompty report to the court a change of hs address, sha be sub|ect to approprate dscpnary acton. Sec. 4. Verfcaton. Except when otherwse specfcay requred by aw or rue, peadngs need not be under oath, verfed or accompaned by affdavt. A peadng s verfed by an affdavt that the affant has read the peadng and that the aegatons theren are true and correct of hs knowedge and beef. A peadng requred to be verfed whch contans a verfcaton based on "nformaton and beef," or upon "knowedge, nformaton and beef," or acks a proper verfcaton, sha be treated as an unsgned peadng. Sec. 5. Certfcaton aganst forum shoppng. The pantff or prncpa party sha certfy under oath n the compant or other ntatory peadng assertng a cam for reef, or n a sworn certfcaton annexed thereto and smutaneousy fed therewth: (a) that he has not theretofore commenced any acton or fed any cam nvovng the same ssues n any court, trbuna or quas-|udca agency and, to the best of hs knowedge, no such other acton or cam s pendng theren; (b) f there s such other pendng acton 23 Pearl remedial reviewer or cam, a compete statement of the present status thereof; and (c) f he shoud thereafter earn that the same or smar acton or cam has been fed or s pendng, he sha report that fact wthn fve (5) days therefrom to the court wheren hs aforesad compant or ntatory peadng has been fed. Faure to compy wth the foregong requrements sha not be curabe by mere amendment of the compant or other ntatory peadng but sha be cause for the dsmssa of the case wthout pre|udce, uness otherwse provded, upon moton and after hearng. The submsson of a fase certfcaton or non-compance wth any of the undertakngs theren sha consttute ndrect contempt of court, wthout pre|udce to the correspondng admnstratve and crmna actons. If the acts of the party or hs counse ceary consttute wfu and deberate forum shoppng, the same sha be ground for summary dsmssa wth pre|udce and sha consttute drect contempt, as we as a cause for admnstratve sanctons. 7;. An a33eal may e ta%en from a $&d"ment or final order t#at !om3letely dis3oses of t#e !aseD or of a 3arti!&lar matter t#erein w#en de!lared y t#ese R&les to e a33ealale. No appea may be taken from:
(a) An order denyng a moton for new tra or reconsderaton; (b) An order denyng a petton for reef or any smar moton seekng reef from |udgment; An nterocutory order; (d) An order dsaowng or dsmssng an appea; (e) An order denyng a moton to set asde a |udgment by consent, confesson or compromse on the ground of fraud, mstake or duress, or any other ground vtatng consent; (f) An order of executon; (g) A |udgment or fna order for or aganst one or more of severa partes or n separate cams, countercams, cross-cams and thrd-party compants, whe the man case s pendng, uness the court aows an appea therefrom; and (h) An order dsmssng an acton wthout pre|udce. In a the above nstances where the |udgment or fna order s not appeaabe, the aggreved party may fe an approprate speca cv acton under Rue 65. PRO-I:ITED PLEADI*,( A 'OTIO*( U*DER T-E RULE O* (U''AR) PROCEDURE: (1) Moton to dsmss the compant or to quash the compant or nformaton except on the ground of ack of |ursdcton over the sub|ect matter or faure to compy wth pror secton (referra to the Lupon) (2) Moton for a b of partcuars (3) Moton for a new tra or for reconsderaton of a |udgment or for reopenng of tra (4) Petton for a reef from |udgment 24 Pearl remedial reviewer (5) Moton for extenson of tme to fe peadngs, affdavts, or any other paper (6) Memoranda (7) Petton for certorar, mandamus, or prohbton aganst any nterocutory order ssued by the court (8) Moton to decare defendant n defaut (9) Datory motons for postponement (10) Repy (11) Thrd party compants (12) Interventons The fng of a prohbted peadng w not suspend the perod to fe an answer or to appea. Athough a moton to dsmss s a prohbted peadng, ts fng after the answer had aready been submtted does not consttute a peadng prohbted by the summary rues. What the rues proscrbe s a moton to dsmss that woud stop the runnng of the perod to fe an answer and cause undue deay. The ssuance of the pre-tra order s an mportant part of the summary procedure because t s ts recept by the partes that begns the ten-day perod to submt the affdavts and other evdence. TRIAL PROCEDURE No tra date s set. No testmona evdence s requred nor cross-examnaton of wtnesses aowed. A that s requred s that wthn (10) days from recept by the partes of the courts pre-tra order, they sha submt (1) the affdavts of ther wtnesses (2) and other evdence on the factua ssues set forth n the pre-tra order, TOGETHER WITH THEIR POSITION PAPERS SETTING FORTH THE LAW AND THE FACTS RELIED UPON BY THEM.
Provisional remedies: CERTI ORA-RI PRO-I :I- TIO* 'A* DA- 'U( P&r3os e of t#e writ. Inten ded as a correct ve remedy annu and modfy a procee dng preven t the comm sson or carryn g out of an act Intend ed to comp e perfor m- ance of an act desre d A!t so&"#t to e !ontrol -led. Dscret on-ary act Dscret on-ary and mnste ra act Mnst era act >it# res3e! t to res3on dent. Exercs ng |udca and quas- |udca functo n |udca and /or non- quas |udca functo n |udca
and /or non- quas |udca
funct on @UO >ARRA*TO - a proceedng or wrt ssued by the court to determne the rght to use an 25 Pearl remedial reviewer offce, poston or franchse and to oust the person hodng or exercsng such offce, poston or franchse f hs rght s unfounded or f a person performed acts consdered as grounds for forfeture of sad exercse of poston, offce or franchse. Ouo warranto may aso be used when an assocaton acts as a corporaton wthn the Phppnes wthout beng egay ncorporated or wthout awfu authorty so to act. @UO >ARRA*TO I* ELECTORAL PROCEEDI*,( @UO >ARRA*TO U*DER RULE // - To contest the rght of an eected pubc offcer to hod pubc offce. - prerogatve wrt by w/c the govt. can ca upon any person to show by what tte he hods a pubc offce or exercses a pubc franchse - an eectora proceedng under the Omnbus Eectons Code for the excusve purpose of mpugnng the eecton of a pubc offcer on the ground of negbty or dsquafcaton to hod the offce - three grounds: usurpaton, forfeture, or ega assocaton - petton must be fed w/n 10 days from the procamaton of - presupposes that the respondent s aready actuay the canddate hodng offce and acton must be commenced wthn one year from cause of ouster or rght of pettoner to hod offce arose - may be fed by any regstered canddate for the same offce and, who, even f the petton prospers, woud not be entted to that offce. - the pettoner must be the government or the person entted to the offce and who woud assume the same f hs acton succeeds. +UDICIAL =ORECLO(URE ECTRA+UDICIAL =ORECLO(URE Requres court nterventon No court nterventon necessary There s ony an equty of redempton Rght of redempton exsts Aternatve remedy to persona acton for the amount due to satsfy mortgage debt Proper ony when provded for n the contract E@UIT) O= REDE'PTIO* RI,-T O= REDE'PTIO* - rght of the defendant mortgagor to extngush the mortgage and retan ownershp of the property by payng the debt w/n 90-120 days after the - rght of the debtor, hs successor n nterest or any |udca credtor or |udgment credtor of sad debtor or any person havng a en on the 26 Pearl remedial reviewer entry of |udgment or even after the forecosure sae but pror to confrmaton property subsequent to the mortgage or deed of trust under w/c the property s sod to redeem the property w/n 1 year from the regstraton of the Sherffs certfcate of forecosure sae - governed by Rue 68 - governed by Secs. 29-31 of Rue 39 ACCIO* I*TERDIC TAL ACCIO* PU:LICIA *A ACCIO* REI*VIDI CA-TORIA summar y acton for the recovery of physca possesso n where the dspossess on has not asted for more than one year. e|ectme nt proceedn g under Rue 70; ether forcbe entry or unawfu detaner a penary acton for the recovery of the rea rght of possesso n when the dsposses son has asted for more than one year. an acton for the recovery of ownershp , w/c necessar y ncudes the recovery of possesso n. A cases of forcbe entry and unawfu detaner rrespectv e of the amount of damages or unpad rentas sought to be recovered shoud be brought to the MTC. RTC has |ursdcto n f the vaue of the property exceeds P20,000 outsde Metro Mana; P50,000 wthn Metro Mana, MTC has |ursdcto n f the vaue of the property does not exceed P20,000 - outsde Metro Mana; P50,000 wthn Metro Mana RTC has |ursdcto n f the vaue of the property exceeds P20,000 outsde Metro Mana; P50,000 wthn Metro Mana, MTC has |ursdcto n f the vaue of the property does not exceed P20,000 - outsde Metro Mana; P50,000 wthn Metro Mana (&$e!t to R&les on (&mmary Pro!ed&re =ORCI:LE E*TR) U*LA>=UL DETAI*ER possesson of the and by the defendant s unawfu from the begnnng as possesson s nceptvey awfu but t becomes ega by reason of the 27 Pearl remedial reviewer he acqures possesson by Force, Intmdaton, Strategy, Threat or Steath (FISTS) termnaton of hs rght to the possesson of the property under hs contract w/ the pantff no prevous demand for the defendant to vacate the premses s necessary demand s |ursdctona f the ground s non-payment of rentas or faure to compy wth ease contract the pantff must prove that he was n pror physca possesson of the premses unt he was deprved thereof by the defendant the pantff need not have been n pror physca possesson the 1 year perod s generay counted from the date of actua entry on the and perod s counted from the date of ast demand or ast etter of demand |UDGMENT on e|ectment proceedngs are IMMEDIATELY EXECUTORY uness the defendant: (1) perfects hs appea, (2) fes suffcent supersedeas bond to pay the rents, damages and costs accrung down to the tme of |udgment appeaed from; and (3) deposts wth the appeate court the amount of rent due from tme to tme under the contract or n the absence of a contract, the reasonabe vaue of the use and occupaton of the premses on or before the 10 th day of each succeedng month or perod. However the RTC may ssue a wrt of premnary mandatory n|uncton to restore pantff n possesson f the court s satsfed that defendants appea s frvoous or datory or appea of pantff s prma face mertorous, upon moton of pantff wthn 10 days from perfecton of appea. If there s no forma contract between partes; there can st be unawfu detaner because e|ectment consders implied contracts. Possesson by toerance creates an mped promse to vacate the premses upon the demand of the owner. 1Peran vs. C=I of (orso"on2 DIRECT CO*TE'PT I*DIRECT CO*TE'PT summary n nature punshed after beng charged and hearng GROUNDS: a) msbehavor n the presence of or so near a court as to obstruct or nterrupt the proceedngs. b) Dsrespect towards the court. GROUNDS: a) Msbehavor of an offcer of a court n the performance of hs offca dutes or n hs offca transactons. b) Dsobedence of or resstance to a awfu wrt, process, order, or |udgment. Unauthorzed ntruson to any rea property 28 Pearl remedial reviewer c) Offensve personates towards others. d) Refusa to be sworn or to answer as wtness or to subscrbe an affdavt or deposton. after beng e|ected; c) Any abuse or any unawfu nterference w/ the proceedngs not consttutng drect contempt. d) Any mproper conduct tendng to degrade the admnstraton of |ustce. e) Assumng to be an attorney or an offcer of the court w/o authorty. f) Faure to obey a subpoena g) Rescue, or attempted rescue, of a person or property n the custody of an offcer. If commtted aganst: a. RTC - fne not exceedng P2, 000 or mprsonment not exceedng (10) days or both. b. MTC - fne not exceedng P200 or mprsonment not exceedng (1) day, or both. a. RTC - fne not exceedng P30,000 or mprsonment not exceedng 6 months or both b. MTC - fne not exceedng P5,000 or mprsonment not exceedng (1) month or both In speca |udgments under R&le 0B (e!tion .., the person requred by the |udgment to obey the same may be punshed for contempt f he dsobeys. NO contempt however es n |udgments for money (Secton 9) and |udgments for specfc act (Secton 10) under Rue 39. RE'EDIE( to !#allen"e !ontem3t $&d"ments: DIRECT CO*TE'PT The person ad|udged n drect contempt may ava hmsef of the remedes of certorar or prohbton. The executon of the |udgment sha be suspended pendng resouton of the petton, provded such person fes a bond and condtoned that he w abde by and perform the |udgment shoud the petton be decded aganst hm. I*DIRECT CO*TE'PT The person ad|udged for ndrect contempt may appea such |udgment or fna order to the proper court as n crmna cases. The executon of the |udgment sha NOT be suspended unt a bond s fed by the person ad|udged n contempt. The |udgment aganst a person ad|udged to be n contempt s mmedatey executory and can be stopped ony by fng a bond. I*TERPLEADER I*TERVE*TIO* 1. an orgna acton 1. ancary acton 2. presupposes that pantff has no nterest n the sub|ect matter of the acton or has 2. proper n any of the four stuatons: person havng (a) ega nterest n the matter n 29 Pearl remedial reviewer nterest theren n whoe or n part whch s not dsputed by the other partes tgaton, or (b) success of ether of the partes, or (c) an nterest aganst both, or (d) s so stuated as to be adversey affected by a dstrbuton or other dsposton of property n the custody of the court or of an offcer thereof. (Rue 19, Sec. 1.) 3. defendants are beng sued precsey to nterpead them 3. defendants are orgna partes to the pendng suts I*+U*CTIO* PRO-I:ITIO* 1. drected aganst a party n the acton 1. Drected aganst a court, trbuna or a person exercsng |udca powers 2. does not nvove |ursdcton of the court 2. Based on the round that the court aganst whom the wrt s sought had acted wthout or n excess of |ursdcton 3. t may be the man acton tsef or |ust a provsona remedy 3. Aways the man acton REPLEVI* ATTAC-'E*T 1. may be 1. Avaabe sought ony when the prncpa acton s recovery of persona property. even f recovery of property s ony ncdenta to the reef sought. 2. Can be sought ony when defendant s n actua possesson of the property.
2. May be resorted to even f the property s n possesson of a thrd person. 3. Ony extends to persona property capabe of manua devery. 3. Extends to a types of property whether rea, persona or ncorporea. 4. Cannot be avaed of when property s n custoda egs 4. Can be avaed of even f property s n custoda egs. 5. Avaabe before defendant answers 5. From commencement but before entry of |udgment 6. Bond s doube the vaue of the property 6. Fxed by the court (PECIAL PROCEEDI*,( A remedy by whch a party seeks to estabsh a status, a rght or a partcuar fact 1R&le .D (e!tion 02 +URI(DICTIO* : Regona Tra Court E9!e3tion: MTC can entertan Speca proceedngs where: 30 Pearl remedial reviewer 1. the gross vaue of the estate does not exceed 200T/400T (BP 129) 2. It acts n Cadastra and Land Regstraton Proceedngs (Sec. 35 |udcary Act) appea s taken to the CA, not to the RTC snce MTC s equa to RTC n ths nstance 3. Habeas Corpus where no RTC |udge s avaabe Ven&e on settlement 3ro!eedin"s: 1. If the decedent s an nhabtant of the Phppnes. - RTC n provnce whch he resdes at the tme of death. 2. If decedent s an nhabtant of a foregn country. - RTC of any provnce n whch he had estate. ORDI*AR) ACTIO* (PECIAL PROCEEDI*, to protect or enforce a rght or prevent or redress a wrong nvoves the estabshment of the rght, status or fact nvoves two or more partes may nvove ony one party governed by ordnary rues suppemented by speca rues governed by speca rues suppemented by ordnary rues heard by courts of genera |ursdcton heard by courts of mted |ursdcton peadngs are requred petton or appcaton s suffcent ECTRA+UDICIA L (ETTLE'E*T +UDUCIAL (ETLLE'E*T 1. no court nterventon 1. requres summary |udca ad|udcaton 2. vaue of the estate mmatera 2. gross estate must not exceed P10T 3. aowed ony n ntestate successon 3. aowed n both testate and ntestate 4. there must be no outstandng debts of the estate at the tme of settement 4. avaabe even f there are debts; t s the court whch w make provson for ts payment 5. resorted at the nstance and by agreement of a hers 5. may be nsttuted by any nterested party even a credtor of the estate wthout the consent of a hers 6. amount of bond s equa to the vaue of persona property 6. bond to be determned by the court PETITIO*( =OR C-A*,E O= *A'E PETITIO*( =OR T-E CORRECTIO*D CA*CELLATIO* O= E*TRIE( Petton to be fed n the RTC where the pettoner resdes verfed petton fed n the pace where the correspondng regstry s ocated Soctor Genera must be notfed by servce of a copy of the petton. Cv regstrar concerned s made a party to the proceedng as a respondent. Petton s fed by person By any person nterested n any 31 Pearl remedial reviewer desrng to change hs name ACT, EVENT, ORDER or DECREE order for hearng sha be pubshed once a week for three consecutve weeks order sha aso be pubshed once for three consecutve weeks and court sha cause reasonabe notce to persons named n petton servce of |udgment sha be upon the cv regster concerned SOME RESTRICTIONS ON POWER OF ADMINISTRATOR/EXECUTOR: 1. cannot acqure by purchase, even at pubc or |udca aucton, ether n person or medaton of another, the property under admnstraton 2. cannot borrow money wthout authorty of the court 3. cannot specuate wth funds under admnstraton 4. cannot ease the property for more than one year 5. cannot contnue the busness of the deceased uness authorzed by the court 6. cannot proft by the ncrease or decrease n the vaue of the property under admnstraton CA*CELLATIO* OR CORRECTIO* O= E*TRIE( I* T-E CIVIL RE,I(TR) Ths Rue appes not ony to proceedngs for correcton of nnocuous or cerca errors but aso to correct substanta errors such as ctzenshp,status,and egtmacy. However n the atter case, t s necessary that the proceedngs be adversara n nature. Re8&isites of Adversarial 3ro!eedin"s: 1. Proper petton s fed where the Cv Regstrar and a partes nterested are mpeaded. 2. The order of the hearng must be pubshed 3. Notce thereof must be gven to the Soctor Genera and a partes affected thereby. 4. Opportunty for the respondents to be heard. 5. Fu bown tra. *OTE: Proceedngs for the correcton of entres shoud not be consdered as estabshng ones status s a manner concusvey beyond dspute. The status corrected woud not have a superor quaty for evdentary purposes. There s no ncrease or dmunton of substantve rght. CRI'I*AL PROCEDURE REPU:LIC ACT <75B A* ACT =URT-ER DE=I*I*, T-E +URI(DICTIO* O= T-E (A*DI,A*:A)A*D A'E*DI*, =OR T-E PURPO(E PRE(IDE*TIAL DECREE *O. ./;/D A( A'E*DEDD PROVIDI*, =U*D( T-ERE=ORD A*D =OR OT-ER PURPO(E(. (ECTIO* .. The frst paragraph of the Presdenta Decree 1606, as amended, s hereby further amended to read as foows: "SECTION 1. Sandiganbayan; Composition; Qualifications; Tenure; 32 Pearl remedial reviewer Removal and Compensation. - A speca court, of the same eve as the Court of Appeas and possessng a the nherent powers of a court of |ustce, to be known as the Sandganbayan s hereby created composed of a Presdng |ustce and fourteen assocate |ustces who sha be apponted by the Presdent." SEC. 2. Secton 2 of the same decree s hereby further amended to read as foows: "SEC. 2. Official Station; Place of Holding Sessions. The Sandganbayan sha have ts prncpa offce n the Metro Mana area and sha hod sessons thereat for the tra and determnaton of cases fed wth t: Provded, however, That cases orgnatng from the prncpa geographca regons of the country, that s, from Luzon, Vsayas or Mndanao, sha be heard n ther respectve regons of orgn except ony when the greater convenence of the accused and of the wtnesses, or other compeng consderatons requre the contrary, n whch nstance a case orgnatng from one geographca regon may be heard n another geographca regon; Provded, further, That for ths purpose the presdng |ustce sha authorzed any dvson or dvsons of the court to hod sessons at anytme and pace outsde Metro Mana and where the nterest of |ustce so requres, outsde the terrtora boundares of the Phppnes. The Sandganbayan may requre the servces of the personne and the use of factes of the courts or other government offces where any of the dvsons s hodng sessons and the personne of such courts or offces sha be sub|ect to the orders of the Sandganbayan. (EC. 0. The second paragraph of Secton 3 of the same decree s hereby deeted. (EC. 5. Secton 4 of the same decree s hereby further amended to read as foows: "SEC. 4. Jurisdiction. - The Sandganbayan sha exercse excusve orgna |ursdcton n a cases nvovng: :a. Voatons of Repubc Act No. 3019, as amended, otherwse known as the Ant-Graft and Corrupt Practces Act, Repubc Act No. 1379, and Chapter II, Secton 2, Tte VII, Book II of the Revsed Pena Code, where one or more of the accused are offcas occupyng the foowng postons n the government, whether n a permanent, actng or nterm capacty, at the tme of the commsson of the offense: "(1) Offca of the executve branch occupyng the postons of regona drector and hgher, otherwse cassfed as Grade 27 and hgher, of the Compensaton and Poston Cassfcaton Act of 1989 (Repubc Act No. 6758), specfcay ncudng: "(a) Provnca governors, vce-governors, members of the sanggunang panaawgan, and provnca treasurers, assessors, engneers, and other provnca department heads; "(b) Cty mayors, vce- mayors, members of the sanggunang panungsod, cty treasurers, assessors, engneers, and other department heads; 33 Pearl remedial reviewer "(c) Offcas of the dpomatc servce occupyng the poston of consu and hgher; "(d) Phppne army and ar force coones, nava captans, and a offcers of hgher rank; "(e) Offcers of the Phppne Natona Poce whe occupyng the poston of provnca drector and those hodng the rank of senor superntendent or hgher; "(f) Cty and provnca prosecutors and assstants, and offcas and prosecutors n the Offce of the Ombudsman and provnca prosecutors; "(g) Presdents, drectors or trustees, or managers of government-owned or controed corporatons, state unverstes or educatona nsttutons or foundatons; "(2) Members of Congress and offcas thereof cassfed as Grade 27 and up under the Compensaton and Poston Cassfcaton Act of 1989; "(3) Members of the |udcary wthout pre|udce to the provsons of the Consttutons; "(4) Charmen and members of Consttutona Commssons, wthout pre|udce to the provsons of the Consttuton; and "(5) A other natona and oca offcas cassfed as Grade 27 and hgher under the Compensaton and Poston Cassfcaton Act of 1989. b. Other offenses or feones whether smpe or compexed wth other crmes commtted by the pubc offcas and empoyees mentoned n subsecton a of ths secton n reaton to ther offce. "c. Cv and crmna cases fed pursuant to and n connecton wth Executve Order Nos. 1, 2, 14 and 14-A, ssued n 1986. "In cases where none of the accused are occupyng postons correspondng to Saary Grade 27 or hgher, as prescrbed n sad Repubc Act No. 6758, or mtary or PNP offcers mentoned above, excusve orgna |ursdcton thereof sha be vested n the proper regona tra court, metropotan tra court, muncpa tra court and muncpa crcut tra court, as the case may be, pursuant to ther respectve |ursdctons as provded n Batas Pambansa 129, as amended. The Sandganbayan sha exercse e9!l&sive a33ellate $&risdi!tion over fna |udgments, resoutons or orders of regona tra courts whether n the exercse of ther own orgna |ursdcton or of ther appeate |ursdcton as heren provded. "The Sandganbayan sha have e9!l&sive ori"inal $&risdi!tion over pettons for the ssuance of wrts of mandamus, prohbton, certorar, habeas corpus, n|unctons, and other ancary wrts and processes n ad of ts appeate |ursdcton and over pettons of smar nature, ncudng quo warranto, arsng or that may arse n cases fed or whch be fed under Executve Order Nos. 1, 2, 14 and 14-A ssued n 1986. Provded, that the |ursdcton over these pettons sha not be excusve of the Supreme Court. "The procedure prescrbed n Batas Pambansa 129, as we as the mpementng rues that the 34 Pearl remedial reviewer Supreme Court has promugated and may hereafter promugate, reatve to appeas/pettons for revew to the Court of Appeas, sha appy to appeas and pettons for revew fed wth the Sandganbayan. In a cases eevated to the Sandganbayan and from Sandganbayan to the Supreme Court, the Offce of the Ombudsman, through ts Speca Prosecutor, sha represent the Peope of the Phppnes, except n cases fed pursuant to Executve Order Nos. 1, 2, 14 and 14-A, ssued n 1986. "In case prvate ndvduas are charge as co-prncpas, accompces, or accessores wth the pubc offcers or empoyees, ncudng those empoyed n government-owned or controed corporatons, they sha be tred |onty wth sad pubc offcers and empoyees n the proper courts whch sha exercse excusve |ursdcton over them. "Any provsons of aw or Rues of Court to the contrary notwthstandng, the crmna acton and the correspondng cv acton for the recovery of cv abty sha at a tmes be smutaneousy nsttuted wth, and |onty determned n, the same proceedng by the Sandganbayan or the approprate courts, the fng of the crmna acton beng deemed to necessary carry wth t the fng of such cv acton separatey from the crmna acton sha be recognzed: Provded, however, That where the cv acton had heretofore been fed separatey but |udgment theren has not yet been rendered, and the crmna case s hereafter fed wth the Sandganbayan or the approprate court, sad cv acton sha be transferred to the Sandganbayan or the approprate court, as the case may be, for consodaton and |ont determnaton wth the crmna acton, otherwse the separate cv acton sha be deemed abandoned." (EC. ?. Secton 7 of the same decree s hereby further amended to read as foows: "SEC. 7. Form Finality and !nforcement of "ecisions. - a decsons and fna orders determnng the merts of a case or fnay dsposng of the acton or proceedngs of the Sandganbayan sha contan compete fndngs of the facts and the aw on whch they are based, on a ssues propery rased before t and necessary n decdng the case. "A petton for reconsderaton of any fna order or decson may be filed wthn ffteen (15) days from promugaton or notce of the fna order or |udgment, and such moton for reconsderaton sha be de!ided wthn thrty (30) days from submsson thereof. "Decsons and fna orders of the Sandganbayan sha be appeaabe to the Supreme Court by 3etition for review on !ertiorari raisin" 3&re 8&estions of law n accordance wth Rue 45 of the Rues of Court. Whenever, n any case decded by the Sandganbayan, the penaty of recuson perpetua, fe mprsonment or death s mposed, the decson sha be appeaabe to 35 Pearl remedial reviewer the Supreme Court n the manner prescrbed by the Rues of Court. "|udgments and orders of the Sandganbayan sha be executed and enforced n the manner provded by aw. "Decsons and fna orders of other courts n cases cognzabe by sad courts under ths decree as we as those rendered by them n the exercse of ther appeate |ursdcton sha be appeaabe to, or be revewabe by, the Sandganbayan n the manner provded by Rue 122 of the Rues of Court." "In case, however, the mposed penaty by the Sandganbayan or the regona tra court n the proper exercse of ther respectve |ursdcton, s death, revew by the Supreme Court sha be automatc, whether or not the accused fes an appea." (EC. /. #ppropriations. - The amount necessary to carry out the nta mpementaton of ths Act sha be charged aganst the current fsca year appropratons of the Sandganbayan. Thereafter, such sums as may be needed for ts contnued mpementaton sha be ncuded n the annua Genera Appropratons Act. (EC. 6. Transitory Provision. - Ths act sha appy to a cases pendng n any court over whch tra has not begun as of the approva thereof. (EC. <. Separability of Provisions. - If for any reason any provson of ths Act s decared unconsttutoa or nvad, such parts or portons not affected thereby sha reman n fu force and effect. (EC. B. Repealing Clause. A acts, decrees, genera orders and crcuars, or parts thereof nconsstent wth the provsons of ths Act are hereby repeaed or modfed accordngy. (EC. .;. !ffectivity. Ths Act sha take effect ffteen (15) days after ts compete pubcaton n at east two (2) newspapers of genera crcuaton. Approved: 05 February 1997. A.'. *o. ;.-.-;0-(C Re: Amendment to (e!tion 0D R&le 5. of t#e .BB6 R&les of Civil Pro!ed&re. The Court resoved to AMEND Secton 3, Rue 41 of the 1997 Rues of Cv Procedure to read as foows: (e!. 0. Period of ordinary appeal; appeal in $abeas corpus cases.- The appea sha be taken wthn ffteen (15) days from notce of the |udgment or fna order appeaed from. Where a record on appea s requred, the appeant sha fe a notce of appea and a record on appea wthn thrty (30) days from notce of the |udgment or fna order. However, an appea n habeas corpus cases sha be taken wthn forty-eght (48) hours from notce of the |udgment or fna order appeaed from. The perod of appea sha be nterrupted by a tmey moton for new tra or reconsderaton. No moton for extenson of tme to fe a moton for new tra or 36 Pearl remedial reviewer reconsderaton sha be aowed. (n) The amendment sha take effect on 15 |uy, 2001 foowng the pubcaton of ths Resouton n two (2) newspapers of genera crcuaton not ater than 30 |une 2001. Promugated ths 19 th day of |une, 2001. PRO(ECUTIO* O= O==E*(E( 2000 Amendment Sec. 1. Institution of criminal actions. Crmna actons sha be nsttuted as foows: (A) FOR OFFENSES WHERE A PRELIMINARY INVESTIGATION IS REOUIRED PURSUANT TO SECTION 1 OF RULE 112, BY FILING THE COMPLAINT WITH THE PROPER OFFICER FOR THE PURPOSE OF CONDUCTING THE REOUISITE PRELIMINARY INVESTIGATION. (b) For a other offenses, by fng the compant or nformaton drecty wth the Muncpa Tra Courts and Muncpa Crcut Tra Courts, or the compant wth the offce of the prosecutor. In Mana and other chartered ctes, the compant sha be fed wth the offce of the prosecutor uness otherwse provded n ther charters. THE INSTITUTION OF THE CRIMINAL ACTION SHALL INTERRUPT THE RUNNING OF THE PERIOD OF PRESCRIPTION OF THE OFFENSE CHARGED UNLESS OTHERWISE PROVIDED IN SPECIAL LAWS. PRELI'I*AR) I*VE(TI,ATIO* I( RE@UIRED: Where the offense s punshabe by mprsonment of at east four (4) years, two (2) months and one (1) day, wthout regard as to the fne except as provded n Secton 7 of Rue 112. Under the amendment, the nsttuton of ALL CRIMINAL ACTIONS sha be the same, ncudng those offenses that are sub|ect to the rue on Summary Procedure n reaton to the nterrupton of the perod of prescrpton. In the fng of a crmna actons, even those sub|ect to summary procedure sha nterrupt the runnng of the prescrptve perod, except those punshabe by speca aws. Re8&isites of a !om3laint: 1. t must be n wrtng and under oath; 2. t must charge a person wth an offense; 3. t must be subscrbed by the offended party, by any peace offcer or pubc offcer charged wth the enforcement of the aw voated Re8&isites of an information: 1. t must be n wrtng; 2. t must charge a person wth an offense; 3. t must be subscrbed by the fsca; 4. t must be fed n court 37 Pearl remedial reviewer (e!tion ?. >#o m&st 3rose!&te !riminal a!tions. =I(CALF( DI(CRETIO* I* PRO(ECUTIO* Prior to filin" a !ase in !o&rt: 1. A prosecutng attorney cannot be compeed to fe a partcuar nformaton when he s convnced that he does not have the necessary evdence. 2. The court cannot nterfere wth the Fscas dscreton and contro of the crmna prosecuton. REMEDY: appea the Fscas decson to the Dept. of |ustce &/or ask for a speca prosecutor After t#e filin" of t#e !ase: 1. Once a case s fed n court, the court acqures |ursdcton and such contnues unt the termnaton of the case. 2. Crmna prosecuton cannot be restraned or stayed by n|uncton, premnary or fna. 3. Prosecutor has no more contro of the case and desred reef must be addressed to the court. Offenses 3rose!&ted only y t#e offended 3arty: 1. Adutery and concubnage (by the offended spouse) 2. Seducton, abducton, and acts of ascvousnes (by offended party, parents, grandparents, guardan, state) 3. Defamaton - whch conssts n the mputaton of an offense mentoned above (by offended party) RAPE s now cassfed under crmes aganst persons. It may now be fed by the prosecutor. (RA 8353) * Compance s not |ursdctona, but merey a CONDITION PRECEDENT. In the sense that f non-compance s not ob|ected to, the acton may st proceed. (e!tion /. (&ffi!ien!y of !om3laint or information. 'inim&m re8&irements for a valid !om3laint or information: 1. Name of the accused, ncudng any appeaton or nckname -- When offense s commtted by more than one person, a of them sha be ncuded n the compant or nformaton 2. The desgnaton of the offense by the statute 3. The acts or omssons companed of as consttutng the offense 4. The name of the offended party 5. The approxmate tme of the commsson of the offense 6. The pace wheren the offense was commtted 7;;; Amendment Sec. 14. Amendment or substitution. no! re"uires# "any amendment before pea, whch downgrades the nature of the offense charged n or excudes any accused from the compant or nformaton, can be made ony upon moton by the prosecutor, wth notce to the offended party and wth eave of court. The court sha state ts reasons n resovng the moton and copes of ts order 38 Pearl remedial reviewer sha be furnshed a partes, especay the offended party." Before enterng pea, amendment of a compant or nformaton s a matter of rght, n substance and n form. If the amendment downgrades the offense or excudes one of the accused, t can ony be made upon moton by the prosecutor, wth notce to the offended party and wth eave of court. After the pea and durng the tra, amendment s a matter of |udca dscreton (requres eave of court) but ony as to matters of form, and when the same can be done wthout pre|udce to the rghts of the accused. If a compant s erroneous n chargng the proper offense, the courts must dsmss t upon fng of a new one. (Sec. 19, Rue 119) A'E*D'E*T (U:(TITUTIO* O= I*=OR'ATIO* OR CO'PLAI*T 1. May nvove ether forma or substanta changes 1. Invoves substanta change from the orgna charge 2. Amendment before the pea has been entered can be effected wthout eave of court. 2. Substtuton of nformaton must be wth eave of court as the orgna nformaton has to be dsmssed. 3. Amendment s ony as to form, there s no need 3. Another premnary nvestgaton s for another premnary nvestgaton and the retakng of the pea of the accused. entaed and the accused has to pead anew to the new nformaton 4. An amended nformaton refers to the same offense charged n the orgna nformaton or to an offense whch necessary ncudes or s necessary ncuded n the orgna charge, hence substanta amendments to the nformaton after the pea has been taken cannot be made over the ob|ecton of the accused, for f the orgna nformaton woud be wthdrawn, the accused coud nvoke doube |eopardy. 4. Requres or presupposes that the new nformaton nvoves a dfferent offense whch does not ncude or s not necessary ncuded n the orgna charge, hence the accused cannot cam doube |eopardy. 7;;; Amendment Sec. 1. Institution of criminal and ci$il actions. (a) When a crmna acton s nsttuted, the cv acton for the recovery of cv abty ARISING FROM THE OFFENSE CHARGED SHALL BE DEEMED nsttuted wth the crmna acton uness the offended party waves 39 Pearl remedial reviewer the cv acton, reserves hs rght to nsttute t separatey, or nsttutes the cv acton pror to the crmna acton. EXCEPT AS OTHERWISE PROVIDED IN THESE RULES, NO FILING FEES SHALL BE REOUIRED FOR ACTUAL DAMAGES. NO COUNTERCLAIM, CROSS-CLAIM OR THIRD PARTY COMPLAINT MAY BE FILED BY THE ACCUSED IN THE CRIMINAL CASE, BUT ANY CAUSE OF ACTION WHICH COULD HAVE BEEN THE SUB|ECT THEREOF MAY BE LITIGATED IN A SEPARATE CIVIL ACTION. (B) THE CRIMINAL ACTION FOR VIOLATION OF BATAS PAMBANSA BLG. 22 SHALL BE DEEMED TO INCLUDE THE CORRESPONDING CIVIL ACTION. NO RESERVATION TO FILE SUCH CIVIL ACTION SEPARATELY SHALL BE ALLOWED. UPON FILING OF THE AFORESAID |OINT CRIMINAL AND CIVIL ACTIONS, THE OFFENDED PARTY SHALL PAY IN FULL THE FILING FEES BASED ON THE AMOUNT OF THE CHECK INVOLVED, WHICH SHALL BE CONSIDERED AS THE ACTUAL DAMAGES CLAIMED. WHERE THE COMPLAINT OR INFORMATION ALSO SEEKS TO RECOVER LIOUIDATED, MORAL, NOMINAL, TEMPERATE OR EXEMPLARY DAMAGES, THE OFFENDED PARTY SHALL PAY ADDITIONAL FILING FEES BASED ON THE AMOUNTS ALLEGED THEREIN. IF THE AMOUNTS ARE NOT SO ALLEGED BUT ANY OF THESE DAMAGES ARE SUBSEOUENTLY AWARDED BY THE COURT, THE FILING FEES BASED ON THE AMOUNT AWARDED SHALL CONSTITUTE A FIRST LIEN ON THE |UDGMENT. WHERE THE CIVIL ACTION HAS BEEN FILED SEPARATELY AND TRIAL THEREOF HAS NOT YET COMMENCED, IT MAY BE CONSOLIDATED WITH THE CRIMINAL ACTION UPON APPLICATION WITH THE COURT TRYING THE LATTER CASE. IF THE APPLICATION IS GRANTED, THE TRIAL OF BOTH ACTIONS SHALL PROCEED IN ACCORDANCE WITH SECTION 2 OF THIS RULE GOVERNING CONSOLIDATION OF THE CIVIL AND CRIMINAL ACTIONS. (Crc. 57-97) Instan!es w#en !ivil liaility arisin" from offense !#ar"ed not !on!&rrently determined in t#e !riminal a!tion: 1. when the offended party waves the cv acton 2. when the offended party reserves hs rght to nsttute a separate cv acton 3. when the offended party nsttutes a cv acton pror to the crmna acton. >-E* RE(ERVATIO* (-ALL :E 'ADE: Reservation to instit&te a se3arate !ivil a!tion s#all e made: 1. before the prosecuton starts to present ts evdence 2. under crcumstances affordng the offended party to a reasonabe opportunty to make such reservaton. 40 Pearl remedial reviewer PURPOSE: to prevent the offended party from recoverng damages twce for the same act or omsson. AC@UITTAL I* A CRI'I*AL CA(E DOE( *OT :AR CO*TI*UATIO* O= T-E CIVIL CA(E >-ERE: 1. the acqutta s based on reasonabe doubt 2. the decson contans a decaraton that the abty of the accused s not crmna but ony cv 3. the cv abty s not derved from or based on the crmna act of whch the accused s acqutted. 7;;; Amendment Sec. 4. %ffect of death on ci$il actions. The death of the accused after arragnment and durng the pendency of the crmna acton sha extngush the cv abty arsng from the dect. However, the ndependent cv acton nsttuted under secton 3 of ths Rue or whch thereafter s nsttuted to enforce abty arsng from other sources of obgaton may be contnued aganst the estate or ega representatve of the accused after proper substtuton or aganst sad estate, as the case may be. The hers of the accused may be substtuted for the deceased wthout requrng the appontment of an executor or admnstrator and the court may appont a guardan ad litem for the mnor hers. The court sha forthwth order sad ega representatve or representatves to appear and be substtuted wthn a perod of thrty (30) days from notce. A fna |udgment entered n favor of the offended party sha be enforced n the manner especay provded n these rues for prosecutng cams aganst the estate of the deceased. If the accused des before arragnment, the case sha be dsmssed wthout pre|udce to any cv acton the offended party may fe aganst the estate of the deceased. (n) Elements of a 3re$&di!ial 8&estion: 1. The cv acton must be nsttuted pror to the crmna acton. 2. The cv acton nvoves an ssue smar or ntmatey reated to the ssue rased n the crmna acton. 3. The resouton of such ssue determnes whether or not the crmna acton may proceed. . D&3li!ity of offense. 1Do!trine of d&3li!ity2 GENERAL RULE: A snge compant or nformaton must charge ony one offense. EXCEPTION: Compex crmes -- where the aw prescrbes a snge punshment for varous crmes Durng premnary nvestgaton, searchng questons and answers are ASKED. 41 Pearl remedial reviewer REMEDIES OF THE ACCUSED IF THERE WAS NO PRELIMINARY INVESTIGATION: 1. Refuse to enter a pea upon arragnment and ob|ect to further proceedngs upon such ground 2 Insst on a premnary nvestgaton 3. Fe a certorar, f refused 4. Rase ack of premnary nvestgaton as error on appea 5. Fe for prohbton PURPOSE OF PRELIMINARY INVESTIGATION: To protect the accused from the nconvenence, expenses and burden of defendng hmsef n a forma tra uness the reasonabe probabty of hs gut sha have been frst ascertaned n a fary summary proceedng by a competent offcer. It s aso ntended to protect the state from havng to conduct useess and expensve tras. Secton 2. Offcers authorzed to conduct premnary nvestgaton. Persons authorzed to conduct a premnary nvestgaton: 1. Provnca or cty fsca and ther assstants 2. |udges of the MTC and MCTC 3. Natona and regona state prosecutors 4. Such other offcers as may be authorzed by aw such as: the COMELEC, Ombudsman and PCGG 7;;; Amendment Sec. &. 'rocedure. The premnary nvestgaton sha be conducted n the foowng manner: (a) The compant sha state the address of the respondent and sha be accompaned by affdavts of the companant and hs wtnesses, AS WELL AS OTHER SUPPORTING DOCUMENTS TO ESTABLISH PROBABLE CAUSE. They sha be n such number of copes as there are respondents, pus two (2) copes for the offca fe. The affdavts sha be subscrbed and sworn to before any prosecutor or government offca authorzed to admnster oath, or, n ther absence or unavaabty, before a notary pubc, each of whom must certfy that he personay examned the affants and that he s satsfed that they vountary executed and understood ther affdavts. (b) Wthn ten (10) days after the fng of the compant, the nvestgatng offcer sha ether dsmss t f he fnds no ground to contnue wth the nvestgaton, or ssue a subpoena to the respondent, attachng to t a copy of the compant and ts supportng affdavts and documents. THE RESPONDENT SHALL HAVE THE RIGHT TO EXAMINE THE EVIDENCE SUBMITTED BY THE COMPLAINANT WHICH HE MAY NOT HAVE BEEN FURNISHED AND TO COPY THEM AT HIS EXPENSE. IF THE EVIDENCE IS VOLUMINOUS, THE COMPLAINANT MAY BE REOUIRED TO SPECIFY THOSE WHICH HE INTENDS TO PRESENT AGAINST THE RESPONDENT, AND THESE SHALL BE MADE AVAILABLE FOR EXAMINATION OR COPYING BY THE RESPONDENT AT HIS EXPENSE. 42 Pearl remedial reviewer OB|ECTS AS EVIDENCE NEED NOT BE FURNISHED A PARTY BUT SHALL BE MADE AVAILABLE FOR EXAMINATION, COPYING, OR PHOTOGRAPHING AT THE EXPENSE OF THE REOUESTING PARTY. (c) Wthn ten (10) days from recept of the subpoena wth the compant and supportng affdavts and documents, the respondent sha submt hs counter-affdavt and that of hs wtnesses AND OTHER SUPPORTING DOCUMENTS RELIED UPON FOR HIS DEFENSE. The counter-affdavts sha be subscrbed and sworn to and certfed as prescrbed n paragraph (a) of ths secton, wth copes thereof furnshed by hm to the companant. THE RESPONDENT SHALL NOT BE ALLOWED TO FILE A MOTION TO DISMISS IN LIEU OF A COUNTER-AFFIDAVIT. (d) If the respondent cannot be subpoenaed, or f subpoenaed, does not submt counter-affdavts wthn the ten (10) day perod, the nvestgatng offcer sha resove the compant based on the evdence presented by the companant. (e) The nvestgatng offcer may set a hearng f there are facts and ssues to be carfed from a party or a wtness. The partes can be present at the hearng but wthout the rght to examne or cross- examne. They may, however, submt to the nvestgatng offcer questons whch may be asked to the party or wtness concerned. The hearng sha be hed wthn ten (10) days from submsson of the counter-affdavts and other documents or from the expraton of the perod for ther submsson. IT SHALL BE TERMINATED WITHIN FIVE (5) DAYS. (f) Wthn ten (10) days after the nvestgaton, the nvestgatng offcer sha determne whether or not there s suffcent ground to hod the respondent for tra. A moton to dsmss s now a prohbted peadng when the case s under premnary nvestgaton and requres that the respondent shoud submt counter-affdavts or other supportng documents reed upon by hm for hs defense. 7;;; Amendment Sec. 4. Resolution of in$esti(atin( prose)cutor and its re$ie!. )) If the nvestgatng prosecutor fnds cause to hod the respondent for tra, he sha prepare the resouton and nformaton. He sha certfy under oath n the nformaton that he, or as shown by the record, an authorzed offcer, has personay examned the companant and hs wtnesses; that there s reasonabe ground to beeve that a crme has been commtted and that the accused s probaby guty thereof; that the accused was nformed of the compant and of the evdence submtted aganst hm; and that he was gven an opportunty to submt controvertng evdence. Otherwse, he sha recommend dsmssa of the compant. 43 Pearl remedial reviewer Wthn fve (5) days from hs resouton, he sha forward the records of the case to the provnca or cty prosecutor or chef state prosecutor, OR TO THE OMBUDSMAN OR HIS DEPUTY IN CASES OF OFFENSES COGNIZABLE BY THE SA*+I,A*-A.A* IN THE EXERCISE OF ITS ORIGINAL |URISDICTION. They sha act on the resouton wthn ten (10) days from ther recept thereof and sha mmedatey nform the partes of such acton. No compant or nformaton may be fed or dsmssed by an nvestgatng prosecutor wthout the pror wrtten authorty or approva of the provnca or cty prosecutor or chef state prosecutor OR THE OMBUDSMAN OR HIS DEPUTY. Where the nvestgatng prosecutor recommends the dsmssa of the compant but hs recommendaton s dsapproved by the provnca or cty prosecutor or chef state prosecutor OR THE OMBUDSMAN OR HIS DEPUTY on the ground that a probabe cause exsts, the atter may, by hmsef, fe the nformaton aganst the respondent, or drect another assstant prosecutor or state prosecutor to do so wthout conductng another premnary nvestgaton. If upon petton by a proper party under such rues as the Department of |ustce may prescrbe or motu propio, the Secretary of |ustce reverses or modfes the resouton of the provnca or cty prosecutor or chef state prosecutor, he sha drect the prosecutor concerned to fe the correspondng nformaton wthout conductng another premnary nvestgaton or to dsmss or move for dsmssa of the compant or nformaton wth notce to the partes. The same rue sha appy n premnary nvestgatons conducted by the offcers of the Offce of the Ombudsman. Under the amendment, whether the recommendaton of the nvestgatng offcer s to fe or dsmss the case, he sha, wthn 5 days from hs resouton, forward the records of the case to the provnca or cty prosecutor or chef state prosecutor or; for offenses cognzabe by the Sandganbayan n the exercse of ts orgna |ursdcton to the Ombudsman or hs deputy the atter sha take approprate actons thereon wthn 10 days from recept and sha mmedatey nform the partes of sad acton. Ths refers to a petton for revew of the prosecutors resouton pendng at ether the Department of |ustce or the Offce of the Presdent; provded that the perod of suspenson sha not exceed 60 days counted from the fng of the petton wth the revewng offcer. The muncpa |udge conductng premnary nvestgaton has no authorty to determne the character of the crme but ony to 44 Pearl remedial reviewer determne whether or not the evdence presented supported prma face the aegaton of fact contaned n the compant. If the prosecutor dsagrees wth the fndngs of the nvestgatng |udge on the exstence of probabe cause, the prosecutors rung sha preva, sub|ect to the procedure n the ast paragraph of secton 5. It s the prosecutor who s gven by aw drecton and contro of a crmna actons. Ths functon s executve, not |udca. Hence, when a premnary nvestgaton s conducted by a |udge, the |udge performs a non-|udca functon, as an excepton to hs usua |udca dutes. Conditions efore t#e investi"atin" m&ni!i3al trial $&d"e !an iss&e a warrant of arrest: 1. Have examned n wrtng and under oath the companant and hs wtnesses by searchng questons and answers; 2. Be satsfed that a probabe cause exsts; 3. That there s a need to pace the respondent under mmedate custody n order not to frustrate the ends of |ustce PRO:A:LE CAU(E: Suffcent facts must be presented to the |udge or magstrate ssung the warrant to convnce hm that there s probabe cause for beevng that the person whose arrest s sought commtted the crme charged. It s not requred to prove that the partcuar person has actuay commtted the crme. The |udge need not personay examne the compant and wtnesses n the determnaton of probabe cause for the ssuance of the warrant of arrest. He s ony requred to: 1. Personay evauate the report and the supportng documents submtted by the fsca regardng the exstence of probabe cause and, on the bass thereof, ssue a warrant of arrest; 2. If on the bass thereof he fnds no probabe cause, he may dsregard the prosecutors report and requre the submsson of supportng affdavts of wtnesses to ad hm n arrvng at a concuson as to the exstence of probabe cause. The amendment n subsecton (b) regardng the ssuance of warrants of arrest by the MTC contempates two (2) dstnct stuatons. Two types of offenses may be fed n the MTC for premnary nvestgaton: 1. a case cognzabe by the RTC may be fed wth the MTC for premnary nvestgaton; 2. even f t s cognzabe by the MTC because t s an offense where the penaty prescrbed by aw s at east four (4) years, two (2) months and one (1) day wthout regard to the fne. In ether stuaton, the MTC s authorzed to ssue a warrant of arrest f there s necessty of pacng the respondent under mmedate custody, n order not to 45 Pearl remedial reviewer frustrate the ends of |ustce, he sha ssue a warrant of arrest. Sec% &% '$en accused la(fully arrested (it$out (arrant% T>O (ITUATIO*( CO*TE'PLATED U*DER T-I( RULE: 1. When a person s awfuy arrested wthout a warrant for an offense requrng a premnary nvestgaton (sec. 1, Rue 112) and no compant or nformaton has yet been fed, he may ask for a premnary nvestgaton by sgnng a waver of the provsons of Art. 125 of the RPC n the presence of hs counse. 2. When the compant or nformaton was fed wthout premnary nvestgaton, the accused may, wthn 5 days from the tme he earns of the fng of the nformaton, ask for a premnary nvestgaton wth the same rght to adduce evdence n hs favor n the manner prescrbed n ths Rue. The request for premnary nvestgaton shoud be made before pea, otherwse the rght to ask for a premnary nvestgaton sha be deemed WAIVED. Pro!ed&re to e followed in !ases w#i!# do not re8&ire 3reliminary investi"ation: 1. Evauate the evdence presented 2. Conduct searchng questons or answers 3. Requre the submsson of addtona evdence For cases under the Revised R&les on (&mmary Pro!ed&re, no warrant sha be ssued except where the accused fas to appear after beng summoned. Arrest - the takng of a person nto custody n order that he may be bound to answer for the commsson of an offense 1(e!. . R&le ..02 'odes of Arrest 1. arrest by vrtue of a warrant 2. arrest wthout a warrant under statutory provded exceptona crcumstances Essential re8&isites of a valid warrant of arrest: 1. It must be ssued upon probabe cause whch must be determned personay by a |udge after examnaton under oath or affrmaton of the companant and the wtnesses he may produce 2. The warrant must partcuary descrbe the person to be sezed (e!tion 7. Arrest4 #ow made. 'odes of Effe!tin" Arrest 1. By an actua restrant of the person to be arrested 2. By hs submsson to the custody of the person makng the arrest (e!tion 5. E9e!&tion of warrant. The head of the offce to whom the warrant has been devered for executon sha cause the warrant to be executed wthn 10 days from recept thereof. 46 Pearl remedial reviewer Wthn ten days after the expraton of such perod, the offcer to whom t was assgned for executon, sha make a report to the |udge who ssued the warrant and, n case of hs faure to execute, sha state the reasons thereof. A warrant of arrest does not become stae or functus officio unke a search warrant whch s vad ony for 10 days. A warrant of arrest remans vad unt arrest s effected or the warrant fted. The rue as amended no onger requres a return of the warrant of arrest but a report. >ARRA*TLE(( ARRE(T(: 1. The person to be arrested has commtted, s actuay commttng, or s attemptng to commt an offense. 2. The peace offcer has probabe cause to beeve based on persona knowedge of facts or crcumstances ndcatng that the person to be arrested has commtted a crme. 3. The person to be arrested s a prsoner who has escaped from a pena estabshment or pace where he s servng fna |udgment or temporary confned whe hs case s pendng, or has escaped whe beng transferred from one confnement to another. The present rue removed the requrement that an offense must have n fact been commtted and carfed that probabe cause to be based on persona knowedge of facts "facts and crcumstances" that the person to be arrested has commtted t woud be suffcent to |ustfy a warrantess arrest for an offense that has |ust been commtted. The ndubtabe exstence of a crme s not necessary to |ustfy a warrantess arrest and that "persona knowedge of facts" n arrests wthout warrant must be based upon probabe cause, whch means an actua beef or reasonabe grounds of suspcon. The ground of suspcon are reasonabe when, n the absence of actua beef of the arrestng offcers, the suspcon that the person to be arrested s probaby guty of commttng the offense s based on actua facts, .e., supported by crcumstances suffcenty strong n themseves to create the probabe cause of gut of the person to be arrested. The reasonabe suspcon therefore must be founded on probabe cause, couped "wth good fath on the part of the peace offcers makng the arrest." The ony dfference s that n in fla(rante arrests, the facts consttutng probabe cause occur n the presence of the arrestng person, whe n hot pursuit, knowedge of the facts occurred after the commsson of the crme. :ail -- the securty gven for the reease of a person n custody of the aw, furnshed by hm or a bondsman, condtoned upon hs appearance before any court as requred under the condtons 47 Pearl remedial reviewer specfed by the rue. 1(e!. .D R&le ..52 =orms of ail: 1. corporate surety 2. property bond 3. cash depost 4. recognzance Conditions of :ail: (a) The undertakng sha be effectve upon approva, and, uness canceed, sha reman n force at a stages of the case unt promugaton of the |udgment of the RTC, rrespectve of whether the case was orgnay fed n or appeaed to t; (b) The accused sha appear before the proper courts whenever so requred by the court or these Rues; (c) The faure of the accused to appear at the tra wthout |ustfcaton despte due notce sha be deemed a waver of hs rght to be present thereat. In such case, the tra may proceed in absentia; (d) The bondsman sha surrender the accused to court for executon of the fna |udgment. Availaility of ail to an a!!&sed. 'ay e s&mmariGed as follows: 1. Regardess of stage of the crmna prosecuton, no ba sha be aowed f the accused s charged wth a capta offense or an offense punshabe by recuson perpetua and the evdence of gut s strong. 2. Before and after convcton by the MTC, ba s a matter of rght. (Sec.4) 3. Before convcton by the RTC whether n the exercse of ts orgna or appeate |ursdcton, ba s a matter of rght. (Sec.4) 4. Upon convcton by the RTC of an offense not punshabe by death, recuson perpetua or fe mprsonment, admsson to ba s dscretonary. 5. After convcton by the RTC wheren a penaty of mprsonment exceedng 6 but not more than 20 years s mposed, and not one of the crcumstances beow s present and proved, ba s a matter of dscreton. (Sec.5) - Recdvsm, quas-recdvsm or habtua denquency or commsson of crme aggravated by the crcumstances of reteraton. - Prevous escape from ega confnement, evason of sentence or voaton of the condtons of ba wthout vad |ustfcaton. - Commsson of the offense whe on probaton, paroe or under condtona pardon - Crcumstance of the accused or hs case ndcate the probabty of fght f reeased on ba - Undue rsk of commsson of another crme by the accused durng pendency of appea. 6. After convcton by the RTC mposng a penaty of mprsonment exceedng 6 years but not more than 20 years and any of the crcumstance enumerated above and other smar crcumstance s present and proved, no ba sha be granted. 7. After |udgment has become fna uness accused apped for probaton before commencng to serve sentence of penaty and 48 Pearl remedial reviewer offense wthn purvew of probaton aw. 1(e!. 752 Ca3ital offense - one whch, under the aw exstng at the tme of ts commsson, and at the tme of the appcaton to be admtted to ba, may be punshed by death. CA* :E RELEA(ED >IT-OUT :AIL 1. Offense charged s voaton of an ordnance, ght feony or a crmna offense, the mposabe penaty wherefore does not exceed 6 months of mprsonment and/or fne of P 2,000 under R.A.6036. 2. Where the accused has apped for probaton and before the same has been resoved but no ba was fed or the accused s ncapabe of fng one, n whch case he may be reeased on recognzance 3. In case of a youthfu offender hed for physca or menta examnaton, tra or appea, f unabe to furnsh ba and under the crcumstances under PD 603, as amended O* REDUCED :AIL OR O* 1. A person n custody for a perod equa to or more -I( O>* RECO,*IHA *CE than the mnmum of the prncpa penaty prescrbed for the offense charged, wthout appcaton of the ndetermnate sentence aw or any modfyng crcumstance sha be reeased on reduced ba or on hs own recognzance. U*DER T-E REVI(ED RULE( O* (U''AR) PROCEDUR E ,eneral R&le: no ba E9!e3tion: 1. When a warrant of arrest s ssued for faure to appear hen requred by the court 2. When the accused - s a recdvst; - s a fugtve from |ustce; - s charged wth physca n|ures - does not resde n the pace where the voaton of the aw or ordnance s commtted; or -has not resde n the pace where the voaton of the aw or ordnance s commtted; or -has no known resdence RI,-T( O= T-E ACCU(ED: A2 To e 3res&med inno!ent 49 Pearl remedial reviewer :2 To e informed of t#e nat&re and t#e !a&se of t#e a!!&sation a"ainst #im. An arragnment thus becomes ndspensabe as the means for brngng the accused nto court and notfyng hm of the cause he s requred to meet. When a person s charged n a compant wth a crme and the evdence does not show that he s guty thereof, but does show that he s guty of some other crme or a esser offense, the court may sentence hm for the esser offense, provded the esser offense s a cognate offense and s ncuded n the compant wth the court. In capta offenses, when there s a dscrepancy between the desgnaton of the crme n the preambe to the nformaton and the facts peaded n the body, the court shoud ca the attenton of the accused, so that he may be fuy apprsed of the nature and cause of the accusaton aganst hm. C2 To e 3resent and defend in 3erson and y !o&nsel at every sta"e of t#e 3ro!eedin" T#e 3resen!e of t#e a!!&sed is not re8&ired at every sta"e of t#e trial &t O*L): 1. Durng arragnment 1(e!. .D r&le ../2 2. Promugaton of |udgment except when the convcton s for a ght offense, n whch case, t may be pronounced n the presence of hs counse or a representatve 3. When ordered by the court for purposes of dentfcaton P&r3ose of trial in absentia to speed up the dsposton of crmna cases, tra of whch coud n the past be ndefntey deferred and many tme competey abandoned because of the defendants escape. Conditions for trial in absentia to a33ly: 1. accused has been arragned 2. he has been duy notfed of the tra 3. hs faure to appear s un|ustfed The aw securng to an accused person the rght to be present at every stage of the proceedngs has no appcaton to the proceedngs before the Court of Appeas and the Supreme Court nor to the entry and promugaton of ther |udgments The defendant need not be present n court durng the hearng of the appea. 1(e!. B R&le .752 An escapee who has been duy tred in absentia waves hs rght to present evdence on hs own behaf and to confront and cross-examne wtnesses who testfes aganst hm. 1,imeneG vs. *aGareno2 or to appea uness he vountary submts to the |ursdcton of the court or s otherwse arrested wthn 15 days from notce of |udgment aganst hm. 1Peo3le vs. 'a3alao2. D2 Ri"#t to !o&nsel. 50 Pearl remedial reviewer The duty of the court to appont a counse de ofco when the accused has no ega counse of choce and desres to empoy the servces of one s mandatory ony at the tme of arragnment 1(e!. / R&le ../2 E2 To testify as witness in #is own e#alf. If he shoud testfy on hs own behaf, he may be cross-examned as to any matter stated n hs drect examnaton. =2 Ri"#t a"ainst self- in!rimination. The rght aganst sef- ncrmnaton s not sef-executng or automatcay operatona. It must be asserted. Ri"#t of t#e a!!&sed a"ainst self-in!rimination vs. ri"#t of t#at of an ordinary witness The ordnary wtness may be compeed to take the wtness stand and cam the prvege as each queston requrng an ncrmnatng answer s shot at hm, an accused may atogether refuse to take the wtness stand and refuse to answer any and a questons. ,2 Ri"#t to !onfront and !ross e9amine t#e witnesses a"ainst #im at trial. Ether party may utze as part of ts evdence the testmony of a wtness who ded, out of or cannot wth due dgence be found n the country, unavaabe or otherwse unabe to testfy, gven n another case or proceedng, |udca or admnstratve, nvovng the same partes and sub|ect matter, the adverse party havng had the opportunty to cross-examne hm. -2 Ri"#t to s3eedyD im3artial and 3&li! trial. Remedies availale to t#e a!!&sed w#en #is ri"#t to a s3eedy trial is violated: 1. He shoud ask not for the dsmssa but for the tra of the case 2. Unreasonabe deay of the tra of a crmna case as to make the detenton of defendant ega gves ground for habeas corpus as a remedy for obtanng reease so as to avod detenton for a reasonabe perod of tme 3. Accused woud be entted to reef n a mandamus proceedng to compe the dsmssa of the nformaton P&li! trial - The court may upon ts own moton excude the pubc from the courtroom f the evdence to be produced durng the tra s of such a character as to be offensve to decency or pubc mora. The court may aso, upon moton of the accused, excude the pubc from tra except court personne and the counse for the partes 1(e!. .0 R&le ..B2 I2 Ri"#t to a33eal on all !ases allowed y law and in t#e manner 3res!ried y law. Arrai"nment - conssts of readng the nformaton to the accused and askng hm, n open court whether or not he s guty of what s aeged aganst hm 51 Pearl remedial reviewer -- The accused must personay enter hs pea though he be charged wth a ght offense ony. An arragnment on the amended compant/ nformaton s mandatory, the pettoner havng the consttutona rght to be nformed of the charge aganst hm. Uness he had aready been arragned and the amendment s ony as to form n whch case there s no need to retake hs pea. 1Tee#an%eeD +r. vs. 'adaya"2. The rue that the accused may be sentenced for as many offenses as are charged n the nformaton sha appy ony f the accused s formay arragned and requred to pead on a the offenses as are charged n the nformaton. Otherwse, the accused cannot be convcted of the offense wth respect to whch he was not propery arragned. Plea - the matter whch the accused on hs arragnment, aeges n answer to the charge aganst hm. There can be no doube |eopardy where the accused has not yet peaded to the offense. A mere wrtten manfestaton s not a vad pea. For |eopardy to attach, t s necessary that the defendant has been arragned and has peaded to the charge because t s from that moment that the ssues are deemed |oned. P&r3ose of Plea to make an ssue. Wthout an ssue, there s nothng to be tred and nothng on whch the |udgment and sentence of a court can be propery predcated When the accused peads guty but presents excupatory evdence, hs pea sha be deemed wthdrawn and a pea of not guty sha be entered for hm. 1Peo3le vs. :alis!anD .6 (CRA ...B2 SEC. 11. Suspension of arrai(nment.-Upon moton by the proper party, the arragnment sha be suspended n the foowng cases: (a) The accused appears to be sufferng from an unsound menta condton whch effectvey renders hm unabe to fuy understand the charge aganst hm and to pead ntegenty thereto. In such case, the court sha order hs menta examnaton and, f necessary, hs confnement for such purpose; (b) There exsts a pre|udca queston; and (c) A petton for revew of the resouton of the prosecutor s pendng at ether the Department of |ustce, or the Offce of the Presdent; 'ro$ided/ That the perod counted from the fng of the petton wth the revewng offce. (12a) >it#drawal of im3rovident 3lea of "&ilty. At any tme before the |udgment of convcton becomes fna, the court may permt an mprovdent pea of guty to be wthdrawn and be substtuted by a pea of not guty. Ths s not a matter of 52 Pearl remedial reviewer absoute rght on the part of the defendant but es entrey wthn the sound dscreton of the tra court, and appeate courts sha not nterfere wth such dscreton n the absence of cear abuse thereof. A pea of guty ater wthdrawn s not admssbe n evdence aganst an accused. In order to be vad, the pea must be an uncondtona admsson of gut. It must be of such nature as to forecose the defendants rght to defend hmsef from sad charge, thus eavng the court no aternatve but to mpose the penaty fxed by aw. D&ties of t#e !o&rt w#en t#e a!!&sed a33ears at t#e arrai"nment wit#o&t !o&nsel: 1. nform the accused of hs rght to counse 2. ask hm f he desres to have one 3. f he desres and s unabe to empoy an attorney, the court must assgn an attorney de ofco to defend hm; and 4. f the accused desres to procure an attorney of hs own, the court must grant hm a reasonabe tme therefor. - Faure of the courts to fuf/compy wth ths duty s a dena of due process. Time to move to 8&as#. The accused may move to quash the compant or nformaton at any tme BEFORE enterng hs pea. Instances where a moton to quash may be fed AFTER pea: 1. faure to charge an offense 2. ack of |ursdcton over the offense charged 3. extncton of the offense or penaty 4. |eopardy .,ro&nds. (b) That the court tryng the case has no |ursdcton over the offense charged; (c) That the court tryng the case has no |ursdcton over the person of the accused; () That the accused has been prevousy convcted or acqutted of the offense charged OR THE CASE AGAINST HIM WAS DISMISSED OR OTHERWISE TERMINATED WITHOUT HIS EXPRESS CONSENT. Re8&isites for !riminal $&risdi!tion: 1. the offense s one whch the court s by aw authorzed to take cognzance of 2. the offense must have been commtted wthn ts terrtora |ursdcton 3. the person charged wth the offense must have been brought to ts presence for tra, forcby by warrant of arrest or upon hs vountary submsson to the court +URI(DICTIO* O= T-E (U:+ECT 'ATTER +URI(DICTIO* OVER T-E PER(O* O= T-E ACCU(ED 1. Derved from the aw. It can never be acqured soey by consent of the accused. 1. May be acqured by consent of the accused or by waver of ob|ectons. 2. Ob|ecton that 2. If he fas to 53 Pearl remedial reviewer the court has no |ursdcton of the sub|ect matter may be made at any stage of the proceedng, and the rght to make such ob|ecton s never waved. make hs ob|ecton n tme, he w be deemed to have waved t. Instan!es w#en t#e !riminal a!tion or liaility is e9tin"&is#ed as a "ro&nd of a motion to 8&as#: 1. death of the convct, as to persona penates 2. servce of the sentence 3. amnesty 4. absoute pardon 5. prescrpton of the crme 6. prescrpton of the penaty 7. marrage of the offender wth the offended party, as provded n Arti!le 055 of the same Code. Co&rses of a!tion t#e !o&rt may ta%e if it s&stains a motion to 8&as#: 1. the dsmssa of the nformaton, whch s deemed to a ntents and purposes, wped out and the case then stood as f no nformaton had ever been fed 2. the fng of a new nformaton, f the accused s n custody he sha reman so uness he s reeased on ba. If there s no such order or f there s such order and no new nformaton s fed wthn the perod fxed n the order or wthn such further tme as the court may aow for good cause shown, the accused, who s n custody, sha be dscharged therefrom, uness he s n custody for another offense. Pro!ed&re in !ase of Denial of 'otion to @&as#: The defendant shoud go to tra wthout pre|udce on hs part to present the speca defenses he had nvoked n hs moton and, f after tra on the merts, an adverse decson s rendered to appea therefrom n the manner authorzed by aw. A moton to quash s aways addressed to the dscreton of the court. Nether certorar nor prohbton es aganst an order of the court grantng or denyng a moton to quash an nformaton. An order sustanng a moton to quash based on the ground that the crmna acton on the abty has been extngushed or on doube |eopardy consttutes a bar to another prosecuton for the same offense. +eo3ardy -- exposure to danger. When a person s prosecuted before a court whch has authorty to decde the ssue between the State and hmsef, he s then exposed to danger n that he s n per of fe and berty E9tent of 3rote!tion afforded y t#e r&le on do&le $eo3ardy : 1. aganst the per of a second punshment 2. aganst the per of a second tra for the same offense or for an attempt to commt the same of frustraton thereof. 54 Pearl remedial reviewer Re8&isites for do&le $eo3ardy: 1. the accused has been convcted or acqutted 2. the case aganst hm has been dsmssed or otherwse termnated wthout hs express consent 3. the court whch convcted or acqutted the accused or dsmssed or termnated the case s a court of competent |ursdcton 4. the compant or nformaton was vad and suffcent n form and substance to sustan a convcton 5. the accused has peaded to the charge 6. there s a subsequent prosecuton aganst the accused for the offense charged, or for any attempt to commt the same or frustraton thereof, or for any offense whch necessary ncudes or s necessary ncuded n the offense charged n the former prosecuton. Dismissal vs. A!8&ittal - A!8&ittal s aways based on the merts, that s, the defendant s acqutted because the evdence does not show defendants gut beyond reasonabe doubt; but dismissal does not decde the case on the merts or that the defendant s not guty. O!!asions w#en do&le $eo3ardy will atta!# even if t#e motion to dismiss t#e !ase is made y t#e a!!&sed #imself: 1. the ground s nsuffcency of evdence of the prosecuton 2. when the proceedngs have been unreasonaby proonged n voaton of the rght to a speedy tra. 1Peo3le vs. ,ines2. If the dsmssa s based on nsuffcency of evdence to estabsh the gut of the accused beyond reasonabe doubt, the dsmssa s actuay an acqutta. If the dsmssa s based on the rght of the accused to a speedy tra, the dsmssa amounts to an acqutta and operates to bar another prosecuton for the same offense even f the dsmssa were upon moton of the accused. The dscharge of a defendant on a premnary nvestgaton s not such an ad|udcaton n hs favor as w bar a subsequent prosecuton for the offense. Ths s because a premnary nvestgaton s not tra or any part thereof and does not have for ts ob|ect that of determnng defntey the gut of the accused by proofs, counter- proofs, and the other formates prescrbed by aw. Sec. 0. 'ro$isional dismissal. A case sha not be provsonay dsmssed except wth the express consent of the accused and wth notce to the offended party. The provsona dsmssa of offenses punshabe by mprsonment not exceedng sx (6) years or a fne of any amount, or both, sha become permanent one (1) year after ssuance of the order wthout the case havng been revved. Wth respect to offenses punshabe by mprsonment of more than sx (6) years, ther provsona dsmssa sha become permanent two (2) years after 55 Pearl remedial reviewer ssuance of the order wthout the case havng been revved. (n) If a case s provsonay dsmssed wth the consent of the prosecutor and the offended party, the faure to renstate t wthn the gven perod w make the dsmssa permanent. PERIOD FOR REINSTATEMENT: a) offenses punshabe by mprsonment not exceedng 6 years = ONE YEAR b) offenses punshabe by mprsonment of more than 6 years = TWO YEARS Otherwse the dsmssa sha be removed from beng provsona and becomes permanent. Secton 9. Faure to move to quash or to aege any ground therefor. If the accused does not move to quash the compant or nformaton before he peads thereto he sha be taken to have waved a ob|ectons whch are grounds for a moton to quash, EXCEPT: when the compant or nformaton 1. does not charge an offense 2. the court s wthout |ursdcton over the offense charged 3. the offense or penaty has been extngushed 4. |eopardy Re8&isites efore t#e 3re-trial a"reement !an e &sed as eviden!e: 1. they are reduced to wrtng 2. the pre-tra agreement s sgned by the accused and hs counse (&$e!ts !onsidered d&rin" t#e 3re-trial: 1. pea barganng 2. stpuaton of facts 3. markng for dentfcaton of evdence of the partes 4. waver of ob|ectons to admssbty of evdence 5. modfcaton of the order of tra f the accused admts the charge but nterposes a awfu defense; and 6. such other matters as w promote a far and expedtous tra Plea ar"ainin" - process whereby the accused and the prosecutor n a crmna case work out a mutuay satsfactory dsposton of the case sub|ect to court approva. It usuay nvoves the defendants peadng guty to a esser offense or to ony one or some of the counts of a mut-count ndctment n return for a ghter sentence than that for the graver charge +emurrer to e$idence. The moton for eave of court to fe demurrer to evdence sha specfcay state ts grounds and sha be fed wthn a non-extendbe perod of fve (5) days after the prosecuton rests ts case. If eave of court s granted, the accused sha fe the demurrer to evdence wthn a non-extendbe perod of ten (10) days from notce. The prosecuton may oppose the demurrer to evdence wthn a smar perod from ts recept. The order denyng the moton for eave of court to fe demurrer to 56 Pearl remedial reviewer evdence or the demurrer tsef sha not be revewabe by appea or certorar before |udgment. (n) |udgment does not become effectve unt t s promugated. And where the |udgment s modfed, the modfed sentence does not become a sentence n aw unt the same has been read or announced to the defendants or has become a part of the record of the court. Prom&l"ation of $&d"ment - offca procamaton or announcement of |udgment. It conssts of readng the |udgment or sentence n the presence of the accused and any |udge of the court renderng the |udgment. When the |udge s absent or outsde of the provnce or cty, the |udgment may be promugated by the cerk of court. To be vad, the |udgment must be sgned and promugated durng the ncumbency of the |udge who sgned the same. However, t s not necessary that the |udge who prepares and sgns the decson be the one who heard the case. The proper cerk of court sha gve notce to accused personay or through hs bondsman or warden and counse requrng hm to be present at the promugaton f he fas to appear at the promugaton sha consst of recordng of the |udgment n the docket and a copy thereof sha be served upon the accused and hs counse. If the accused s confned or detaned n another provnce or cty, the |udgment may be promugated by the executve |udge of the RTC havng |ursdcton over the pace of confnement or detenton upon request of the court that rendered the |udgment. The |udgment or sentence, whch must be promugated n the presence of the defendant, s the sentenced rendered by the RTC after the tra of the case by the sad court. What s requred of the |udgment of the appeate court s that certfed copes of the same must be sent by the cerk of the appeate court to the ower court not for promugaton or readng thereof to the defendant, but for the executon of the |udgment aganst hm. Where the accused fas to appear wthout |ustfabe cause, despte due notce to hm, hs bondsmen or counse, he s consdered to have waved hs rght to appea. However, f wthn ffteen-day perod of appea, he vountary surrenders to the court or s otherwse arrested, then he may ava of the rght to appea wthn sad perod of appea. 1odification of 2ud(ment. Upon moton of the accused, a |udgment of convcton may be modfed or set asde by the court before t has become fna or before an appea has been perfected. 57 Pearl remedial reviewer The prosecutor cannot ask for the modfcaton or settng asde of a |udgment of convcton because the rues ceary provde that a |udgment of convcton may be modfed or set asde by the court renderng upon moton of the accused. *ew trial - the rehearng of a case aready decded but before the |udgment of convcton theren rendered has become fna, whereby errors of aw or rreguartes are expunged from the record, or new evdence s ntroduced, or both steps are taken Cases w#en t#e trial !o&rt lose $&risdi!tion over its senten!e even efore t#e la3se of .? days: 1. When the defendant vountary submts to the executon of the sentence 2. When the defendant perfects hs appea. The moment the appea s perfected the court a quo oses |ursdcton over t, except for the purpose of correctng cerca errors. Section 2. ,rounds for ne! trial. ,ro&nds for a new trial in !riminal !ases: 1. errors of aw or rreguartes commtted durng the tra pre|udca to the substanta rghts of the accused 2. new and matera evdence dscovered: ID&rin" t#e trialJ - refers to every stage of the tra from arragnment to |udgment Re8&isites efore a new trial may e "ranted on t#e "ro&nd of newly dis!overed eviden!e: 1. that the evdence was dscovered after tra 2. that such evdence coud not have been dscovered and produced at the tra even wth the exercse of reasonabe dgence 3. that t s matera not merey cumuatve, corroboratve or mpeachng 4. the evdence s of such a weght that t woud probaby change the |udgment f admtted (e!tion 0. ,ro&nds for re!onsideration. ,ro&nds of motion for re!onsideration 1. errors of aw 2. errors of fact n the |udgment, whch requre no further proceedngs (e!tion 5. =orm of motion and noti!e to t#e 3rose!&tor. Re8&isites for a motion for new trial or re!onsideration: The moton for a new tra or reconsderaton sha be: 1. n wrtng 2. fed wth the court 3. State grounds on whch t s based 4. If the moton for new tra s based on a newy dscovered evdence, t must be supported by the affdavts of the wtness by whom such evdence s expected to be gven, or duy authentcated copes of documents whch t s proposed to ntroduce n evdence. 5. Notce of the moton for new tra or reconsderaton sha be gven to the fsca 58 Pearl remedial reviewer Effe!ts of "rantin" a new trial or re!onsideration: 1. when a new tra s granted on the ground of errors of aw or rreguartes commtted durng the tra, a proceedngs and evdence not affected by the commsson of such errors and rreguartes sha stand, but those affected thereby sha be set asde and taken anew. The court may, n the nterest of |ustce, aow the ntroducton of addtona evdence 2. when a new tra s granted on the ground of newy dscovered evdence, the evdence aready taken sha stand, and the newy dscovered and such other evdence as the court may, n the nterest of |ustce, aow to be ntroduced, sha be taken and consdered together wth the evdence aready n the record 3. In a cases, when the court grants new tra or reconsderaton, the orgna |udgment sha be set asde and a new |udgment rendered accordngy. - The effect of the grantng of a new tra s not to acqut the accused of the crme of whch the |udgment fnds hm guty, but precsey to set asde sad |udgment so that the case may be tred de novo as f no tra had been before, for the purpose of renderng a |udgment n accordance wth the aw, takng nto consderaton the evdence to be presented durng the second tra. How appea s taken: 1. Appeal to the Re(ional Trial 3ourt: by fng a notce of appea wth the court whch rendered the |udgment or order appeaed from and servng a copy to the adverse party 2. Appeal to the 3ourt of Appeals from decision of the Re(ional Trial 3ourt in the e4ercise of its ori(inal 2urisdiction: by fng a notce of appea wth the court whch rendered the |udgment or order appeaed from and servng a copy to the adverse party 3. Appea to the Court of Appeas n cases decded by Regona Tra Court n the exercse of ts appeate |ursdcton: by petton for revew 4. Appea to the Supreme Court n cases where penaty mposed s fe mprsonment or where a esser penaty s mposed but nvovng offenses commtted on the same occason or arsng out of the same occurrence that gave rse to the more serous offense for whch the penaty of death or fe mprsonment s mposed: by fng a notce of appea wth the court whch rendered the |udgment or order appeaed from and servng a copy to the adverse party 5. Death penaty: automatc revew by the Supreme Court 6. Other appeas to the Supreme Court: by petton for revew on certorar E9!e3tions to t#e r&le t#at finds of fa!t of t#e Co&rt of A33eals is !on!l&sive &3on t#e (&3reme Co&rt: 1. when the concuson s a fndng grounded entrey on specuaton, surmses or con|ectures 59 Pearl remedial reviewer 2. when the nference made s manfesty absurd, mstaken or mpossbe 3. when there s grave abuse of dscreton n the apprecaton of facts 4. when the |udgment s premsed on a msapprehenson of facts 5. when the fndngs of fact are confctng 6. when the Court of Appeas n makng ts fndngs went beyond the ssues of the case and the same s contrary to the admssons of both appeant and appeee 7. when certan matera facts and crcumstances had been overooked whch, f taken nto account woud after the resut as t woud gve rse to reasonabe doubt to acqut the accused. @&estion of law - when the doubt or dfference arses as to what the aw s on a certan state of facts. It must not nvove an examnaton of the probatve vaue of the evdence presented by the tgants or any of them. @&estion of fa!t - when the doubt or dfference arses as to the truth or the fasehood of aeged facts (ear!# warrant defined. Elements of sear!# warrant: 1. order n wrtng 2. sgned by the |udge n the name of the Peope of the Phppnes 3. commandng a peace offcer to search persona property 4. brng the property before the court *ATURE O= (EARC- >ARRA*T( - Search warrants are n the nature of crmna process and may be nvoked ony n furtherance of pubc prosecutons. Search warrants have no reaton to cv process or tras and are not avaabe to ndvduas n the course of cv proceedngs, nor for the mantenance of any mere prvate rght (EARC- vs. (EIHURE The term search as apped to searches and sezures s an examnaton of a mans house or other budngs or premses or of hs person wth a vew to the dscovery of contraband or ct or stoen property or some evdence of gut to be used n the prosecuton of a crmna acton for some offense wth whch he s charged A sezure s the physca takng of a thng nto custody ,E*ERAL >ARRA*T A process whch authorzes the search and sezure of thngs, n a genera manner, wthout specfyng or descrbng them wth partcuarty, ke the equpment, paraphernaa, communcatons, records, pubcatons, documents, nstruments, tems, suppes, and other evdence n connecton wth the voaton of an offense. >ARRA*T O= ARRE(T S!#RCH '#RR# )T 1. order drected to the peace 1. order n wrtng n the 60 Pearl remedial reviewer offcer to execute the warrant by takng the person stated theren nto custody that he may be bound to answer for the commsson of the offense. name of the RP sgned by the |udge and drected to the peace offcer to search persona property descrbed theren and to brng t to court. (sec. 1) 2. does not become stae 2. vadty s for 10 days ony (sec. 9) 3. may be served on any day and at any tme of day or nght. (sec. 6, rue 113). 3. to be served ony n daytme uness the affdavt aeges that the property s on the person or n the pace to be searched. (sec. 8) 4. upon probabe cause to be determned personay by the |udge after examnaton n wrtng and under oath n the form of searchng answers and questons. 5. ony ssued f there s a necessty of pacng accused under mmedate custody 5. sworn statements and affdavts of companant and wtnesses must be submtted to court. Re8&isite for iss&in" sear!# warrant. Einds of 3ro3erty to e seiGed: 1. sub|ect of the offense 2. proceeds or fruts of the offense 3. the means used or ntended to be used for commttng an offense Re8&isites for t#e iss&an!e of a valid sear!# warrant: 1. probabe cause 2. whch must be determned personay by the |udge hmsef after oath and affrmaton and not by the appcant or any other person 3. the |udge must, before ssung the warrant, personay examne n the form of searchng questons and answers, n wrtng and under oath, the compant and any wtness he may produce, on facts personay known to them 4. the probabe cause must be n connecton wth one specfc offense 5. the warrant ssued must partcuary descrbe the pace to be searched and the persons or thngs to be sezed 6. the sworn together wth the affdavts submtted by wtnesses must be attached to the record. PRO:A:LE CAU(E - facts and crcumstances whch coud ead a reasonabe, dscreet and prudent man to beeve that the property sub|ect of an offense are n the pace sought to be searched. - The requrement of probabe cause to be determned by a |udge, does not extend to deportaton proceedngs Reason for re8&irin" t#at no sear!# warrant s#all iss&e for more t#an one s3e!ifi! offense: It woud pace the sanctty of the domce and the prvacy of communcaton and correspondence at the mercy of 61 Pearl remedial reviewer the whms, caprce or passon of peace offcers. Reason of re8&irin" t#at a sear!# warrant m&st 3arti!&larly des!rie t#e 3la!e to e sear!#ed and t#e 3ersons or t#in"s to e seiGed: to mt the thngs to be sezed to those, and ony those, partcuary descrbed n the search warrant - to eave the offcers of the aw no dscreton regardng what artces they sha seze, to the end that " unreasonabe searches and sezure" may not be made, that abuses may not be commtted. Therefore, no other property than those descrbed n the search warrant may be taken thereunder. Search incident to la!ful arrest. A person awfuy arrested may be searched for dangerous weapons or anythng, whch may be used as proof of the commsson of an offense, wthout a search warrant. Cases w#ere warrantless sear!#es and seiG&res valid: 1. search of movng vehces 2. consented search wthout a warrant 3. sezure of evdence n pan vew 4. enforcement of customs aw, except n dweng house 5. search based on probabe cause under extraordnary crcumstances The remedy for questonng the vadty of a search warrant can ony be sought n the court that ssued t, not n the saa of another |udge of concurrent |ursdcton. >aiver of le"ality and admissiility - Ob|ecton to the egaty of the search warrant as to the admssbty of the evdence obtaned or deemed waved where no ob|ecton of the search warrant was rased durng the tra of the case nor to the admssbty of the evdence obtaned through sad warrant. Total E9!l&sionary R&le - Excudes as nadmssbe n evdence those that were egay sezed n voaton of the provsons of the Consttuton appes a restrant drected ony aganst the government and ts agences tasked wth the enforcement of the aw. It coud ony be nvoked aganst the state to whom the restrant aganst the arbtrary and unreasonabe exercse of power s mposed. GENERAL RULE: A moton to quash a search warrant or to suppress evdence may ony be fed and acted upon ony by the court where the acton s pendng. EXCEPTION: If no crmna acton has been fed, the moton may be fed n and resoved by the court that ssued the search warrant. EXCEPTION to the EXCEPTION: If the crmna case s subsequenty fed n another court and the moton to quash s st not resoved by the ssung court, the moton sha not be resoved by the former court uness compeng reasons warrant ts resouton by the atter court. 62 Pearl remedial reviewer Fng of moton to quash s wthout pre|udce to any proper recourse to the approprate hgher court by the party aggreved. A grounds and ob|ectons then avaabe, exstent or known sha be rased n the orgna or subsequent proceedngs for the quasha of the warrant, otherwse they sha be deemed waved. In vew of the foregong amendment, t seems that the OMNIBUS MOTION RULE s no onger appcabe because the moton to quash or moton to suppress evdence s now fed n one court. 1. Those to whch partes tgant may resort for the preservaton or protecton of ther rghts or nterests and for no other purposes durng the pendency of the acton 2. They are apped a pendng tgaton for the purposes of securng the |udgment or preservng the status quo, and n some cases after |udgment, for the purpose of preservng or dsposng of the sub|ect matter. Availaility of 3rovisional remedies. *at&re of Provisional Remedies 1. Those to whch partes tgant may resort for the preservaton or protecton of ther rghts or nterests and for no other purposes durng the pendency of the acton. 2. They are apped a pendng tgaton for the purposes of securng the |udgment or preservng the status quo, and n some cases after |udgment, for the purpose of preservng or dsposng of the sub|ect matter. Einds of 3rovisional remedies 1. attachment 2. n|uncton 3. recevers 4. devery of persona property 5. support pendente te Section 2. Attachment. - It was hed by the Supreme Court that the pubc prosecutor has the authorty to appy for premnary attachment as may be necessary to protect the nterest of the offended party, partcuary consderng that the correspondng cv abty of the cuprts s to be determned theren, no reservaton havng been made of the rght to enforce t n a separate cv acton. Attachment may be avaed of ony when the cv acton arsng from the crme has not been expressy waved or not reserved and ony n the foowng cases: a) when the accused s about to abscond from the Phppnes; b) when the crmna acton s based on a cam for money or property embezzed or frauduenty msapped or converted to the use of the accused who s a pubc offcer or a corporate offcer or an attorney, broker, or agent or cerk n the course of empoyment or by a person n a fducary capacty. c) when the accused has conceaed, removed or about to dspose of hs property 63 Pearl remedial reviewer d) when the accused resdes abroad. EVIDE*CE =ACTU' PRO:A*DU' - the utmate fact sought to be estabshed. It may be ascertaned n: a) peadngs submtted by the partes b) pre-tra order c) ssues whch are tred wth the express or mped consent of the partes. ((e!. ?D R&le .;) =ACTU' PRO:A*( - the matera evdencng the proposton. It s the fact by whch the factum probandum s estabshed. CLA((I=ICATIO* O= EVIDE*CE: A. Dependng on ts ability to establish the fact in dispute , an evdence may be: 1. Dire!t eviden!e-evdence whch proves the fact n dspute wthout the ad of any nference or presumpton. 2. Cir!&mstantial eviden!e- such evdence from whch the exstence of a partcuar fact n dspute may be nferred as a necessary or probabe consequence. B. Dependng on the de(ree of its $alue in establishin( a disputed fact , an evdence may be : 1. Prima =a!ie-evdence whch suffces for the proof of a partcuar fact unt contradcted and overcome by other evdence. 2. C&m&lative eviden!e- evdence whch s of the same knd and character as that aready gven and tends to prove the same proposton. 3. Corroorative eviden!e- evdence whch s of a dfferent knd and character as that aready gven and tends to prove the same proposton. 4. Con!l&sive eviden!e- evdence whch s ncontrovertbe or the aw does not aow t to be contradcted. C. Dependng on ts !ei(ht and acceptability , an evdence may be : 1. Primary or est eviden!e-f t affords the greatest certanty of the fact n queston. 2. (e!ondary eviden!e- evdence whch s nferor to the prmary evdence. D. Dependng on ts nature , an evdence may be: 1. O$e!t eviden!e-f t s addressed to the senses of the court and s capabe of beng exhbted to examned or vewed by the court. Aso known as autoptic proference. 2. Do!&mentary eviden!e- evdence whch conssts of wrtngs, words, numbers, fgures, symbos or other modes of wrtten expressons offered as proof of ther contents. 3. Testimonial eviden!e- evdence whch conssts of the narraton or deposton by one who has observed or has persona knowedge of that to whch he s testfyng. 64 Pearl remedial reviewer E. Dependng on ts "uality , an evdence may be: 1. Relevant eviden!e-f t has a reaton to the fact n ssue as to nduce beef n ts exstence or non-exstence. 2. Admissile eviden!e-f s reevant to the ssue and s not excuded by aw or the Rues of Court. T#is is also %nown as Com3etent eviden!e. 3. Credile eviden!e-f t s not ony admssbe evdence but aso beevabe and used by the court n decdng a case. REOUISITES FOR ADMISSIBILITY OF EVIDENCE: The evdence must be- 1. Reevent-has a ogca connecton wth the fact n ssue. 2. Competent-not excuded by the aw or the rues. PRINCIPLES OF ADMISSIBILITY 2 AXIOMS OF ADMISSIBILITY: 1. Axom of Reevancy -None but facts havng ratona probatve vaue are admssbe ; and 2. Axom of Competency - A facts havng ratona probatve vaue are admssbe uness some specfc rue forbds ther admsson. EI*D( O= AD'I((I:ILIT): 1. MULTIPLE-evdence w be receved f t satsfes a the requrements prescrbed by aw n order that t may be admssbe for the purpose for whch t s presented, even f t does not satsfy the other requstes for ts admssbty for other purposes. 2.CONDITIONAL-A fact offered n evdence may appear to be mmatera uness t s connected wth other facts to be subsequenty proved. In such case, evdence of that fact may be receved on condton that the other facts be afterwards proved. 3.CURATIVE-an mproper evdence s offered and admtted by the court over the ob|ecton of the adverse party; n such case, the adverse party s kewse entted to ntroduce a smar mproper evdence to counteract that aready gven. The foowng facts need not be proved: 1. Those whch the courts may take |udca notce (R&le .7B); 2. Those whch are |udcay admtted (R&le .7B); 3. Those whch are presumed 1R&le .0.). THE LAW OF NATIONS - The aw of natons whch s the sub|ect of |udca notce s the aw whch reguates the reatons of the domnant powers of the earth. It s not a foregn muncpa aw whch our courts are not authorzed to take |udca notce of but the compaton of rues whch by common consent of manknd have been acquesced n as aw. Dscretonary |udca Notce: matters whch are 1. of pubc knowedge; or 2. capabe of unquestonabe demonstraton; or 3. those that |udges ought to know by reason of ther |udca functons. +UDICIAL AD'I((IO*--the admsson made n the course of 65 Pearl remedial reviewer the proceedngs n the same case by a party. +&di!ial Admissions 'ay :e 'ade in: 1. the peadngs fed by the partes; 2. n the course of the tra ether by verba or wrtten manfestatons or stpuatons; or 3. n other stages of the |udca proceedng, as n the pre-tra of the case; 4. admssons obtaned through depostons, wrtten nterrogatores or requests for admssons. +&di!ial admissions may e !ontradi!ted only w#en it is s#own t#at: 1. t was made through papabe mstake; or 2. that no such admsson was made. +&di!ial admissions in 3leadin"s later amended In cv cases, an amended peadng becomes a |udca admsson and the contents of the peadng t amends not ncuded n the amended peadng becomes extra|udca admssons whch must be offered n evdence for t to be consdered by the tra court. In crmna cases, the accuseds pea of guty ater wthdrawn cannot be offered n evdence aganst the accused as t w not be n the nterest of |ustce and farpay to aow the accused to wthdraw hs pea and thereafter use ths aganst hm. |udca admssons are aways concusve upon the admtter and does not requre forma offer as evdence, unke n the case of extra-|udca admssons. O$e!t Eviden!e Not a rue of excuson thus other knds of evdence may be presented even f there s an ob|ect evdence. Re8&isites of o$e!t eviden!e to e admissile: 1. reevant and competent 2. must be n the same condton when t s presented n court as t was durng the occurrence of the fact n ssue. RE'EDIE( when ob|ect evdence cannot be brought to court: 1.O!&lar ins3e!tion or IviewJ- the court can go to the pace where the ob|ect s ocated. *ie( part of t$e trial-The nspecton or vew outsde the courtroom shoud be made n the presence of the partes or at east wth prevous notce to them n order that they may show the ob|ect to be vewed. Such nspecton s a part of the tra, nasmuch as evdence s thereby beng receved. The partes are entted to be present any stage of the tra, and consequenty they are entted to be at east notfed of the tme and pace set for the vew. 2.Actua representatons authentcated or dentfed by testmona evdence. Exampe, a photograph of dapdated budng dentfed by the photographer or by any other person who can 66 Pearl remedial reviewer testfy to ts exactness and accuracy. ,ro&nds for e9!l&din" O:+ECT EVIDE*CE: Inherent 5imitations: 1)rreevancy / mmateraty 2) egay obtaned evdence *on)inherent 5imitations: 1. Undue pre|udce 2. Indecency or mproprety 3. Offensveness to sensbtes 4. Inconvenence and unnecessary expense of tgaton. PAROL EVIDE*CE RULE 1PER2 :E(T EVIDE*CE RULE 1:ER2 Presupposes that the orgna s avaabe n court; Contempates a stuaton when the orgna s not avaabe n court and/or there s a dspute as to whether sad wrtng s the orgna. Prohbts the varyng of the terms of a wrtten agreement; Prohbts the ntroducton of substtutonary evdence n eu of the orgna document regardess of whether or not t vares the contents of the orgna; Can be nvoked ony when the controversy s between the partes to the wrtten Can be nvoked by any party to an acton regardess of whether such party agreement, ther prves, or any party drecty affected thereby. partcpated or not n the wrtng nvove. Wth the excepton of ws, the PER appes ony to documents whch are contractua n nature. Appes to a knds of wrtng. :est Eviden!e R&le s a rue of excuson thus, sub|ect to the exceptons under Rue 130, Sec. 3, t s mandatory that the orgna copy be presented n court. Ths rue appes ony to documentary evdence, not to ob|ect evdence. T-REE 102 CO*CEPT( O= IORI,I*ALJ U*DER T-E :E(T EVIDE*CE RULE 1(e!. 52 1. One the contents of whch s the sub|ect of nqury; 2. When a document s n two or more copes executed at or about same tme wth dentca contents, a such copes are equay regarded as orgnas; 3. When an entry s repeated n the reguar course of busness, one beng coped from another at or near the tme of the transacton. (ECO*DAR) EVIDE*CE (e!tion ?. >#en ori"inal do!&ment is &navailale. In case of oss or destructon of the orgna document, the foowng are admssbe after provng EXECUTION or EXISTENCE, CAUSE OF ITS UNAVAILABILITY 67 Pearl remedial reviewer wthout bad fath on the part of the offeror, and REASONABLE EFFORT: 1.a copy; 2.a recta of the contents n some authentc document; or 3.the testmony of wtnesses. These secondary paroe evdence shoud be presented n the order stated. REOUISITES FOR APPLICABILITY OF PAROL EVIDE*CE RULE: 1. There must be a vad contract; 2. The terms of the agreement must be reduced to wrtng; 3. The dspute s between partes and ther successors n nterest; and 4. There s dspute as to the terms of the agreement. Intrinsi! or Latent Ami"&ity- when the wrtng on ts face appears cear and unambguous but there are coatera matters or crcumstances whch make the meanng uncertan. Exampe: f a devse n a w were made to Lo Vearde, sster of |oseph Vearde," an ntrnsc ambguty woud exst f Lo Vearde s actuay not the sster of |oseph Veardebut the wfe of |oseph Vearede whe hs ssters name s |oy. E9trinsi! or Patent Ami"&ity -ambguty s apparent on the face of the wrtng tsef and requres somethng to be added n order to ascertan the meanng of the words used. Intermediate Ami"&ity-Where the ambguty conssts n the use of equvoca words desgnatng the person or sub|ect matter, paro evdence of coatera or extrnsc matter may be ntroduced for the purpose of adng the court n arrvng at the meanng of the anguage used. I*TRI*(IC and I*TER'EDIATE A':I,UITIE( are curabe by evdence aunde or extraneous evdence. PATE*T A':I,UIT) s not cured by evdence aunde. Dis8&alifi!atio n y REA(O* O= 'ARRIA,E 1(e!. 702 Dis8&alifi!atio n y REA(O* O= 'ARITAL PRIVILE,E 1(e!. 751a2 2 Can be nvoke ony f one of the spouses s a party to the acton; Can be camed whether or not the other spouse s a party to the acton; Appes ony f the marrage s exstng at the tme the testmony s offered; Can be camed even after the marrage s dssoved; Consttutes a tota prohbton for or aganst the spouse of the wtness. Appes ony to confdenta communcatons between the spouses The ob|ecton woud be rased on the ground of marrage. The marred wtness woud not be aowed to take the stand at a because of the dsquafcaton. Even f the testmony s, for the marred person s on the stand but the ob|ecton of prvege s rased when confdenta marta communcaton s nqured nto. 68 Pearl remedial reviewer or aganst the ob|ectng spouse, the spouse-wtness cannot testfy. DEAD 'A*F( (TATUTE 'ARITAL DI(@UALI=ICA TIO* RULE Ony a parta dsquafcaton as the wtness s not competey dsquafed but s ony prohbted from testfyng on the matters theren specfed; It s a compete and absoute dsquafcaton; Appes ony to a cv case or speca proceedng over the estate of a deceased or nsane person. Appes to a cv or crmna case, sub|ect ony to the two exceptons provded theren: (1)e4cept in a civil case by one against t$e ot$er; or (2) in a criminal case for a crime committed by one against t$e ot$er or t$e latter+s direct descendants or ascendants). AD'I((IO* CO*=E((IO* 1.statement of fact whch does not nvove an 1.statement of fact whch nvove an acknowedgmen t of gut or abty; acknowedgment of gut or abty; 2. may be made by thrd persons and n certan cases, are admssbe aganst a party; 2. can be made ony by the party hmsef and, n some nstances, are admssbe aganst hs co- accused; 3. express or tact 3. aways express DECLARATIO* ( A,AI*(T I*TERE(T AD'I((IO*( 1.made aganst the propretary or pecunary nterest of the partes 1.need not be made aganst pecunary or propretary nterest; 2. made by a person who s ether deceased or unabe to testfy 2.made by a party hmsef, and s prmary evdence and competent though he be present n court and ready to testfy; 3. must be made ante litem motam 3. may be made any tme. CO*=E((IO* - a categorca acknowedgment of gut made by an accused n a crmna case, wthout any excupatory statement or expanaton. If the accused admts havng commtted the act n queston but aeges a |ustfcaton therefore, the same s merey an admsson. 69 Pearl remedial reviewer there can aso be a confesson of |udgment n a cv case where the party expressy admts hs abty. +UDICIAL CO*=E((IO*-s one made before a court n whch the case s pendng and n the course of ega proceedngs theren and, by tsef, can sustan a convcton even n capta offenses. ECTRA-+UDICIAL CO*=E((IO*- s one made n any other pace or occason and cannot sustan a convcton uness ts vountarness s proven and uness corroborated by evdence of the corpus delicti. RE@UIRE'E*T( =OR A* ECTRA+UDICIAL CO*=E((IO* TO :E AD'I((I:LE: 1. It must be express (Sec. 33, Rue 130 Rues of Court); 2. Vountary (1987 Consttuton) 3. Wth assstance of competent and ndependent counse (1987 Consttuton) 4. Must be n wrtng (R.A.7438); ,E*ERAL RULE: an EXTRA- |UDICIAL CONFESSION s admssbe aganst the confessor ony. It s ncompetent evdence aganst hs co-accused for beng hearsay and because of the res inter alios acta rue. ECCEPTIO*(: When admssbe aganst the co-defendants: 1. If the co-defendants mpedy acquesced n or adopted sad confesson; 2. If the accused persons vountary and ndependenty executed dentca confesson wthout couson, and corroborated by other evdence-INTERLOCKING CONFESSIONS 3. Where the accused admtted the facts stated by the confessant after beng apprsed by such confesson; 4. If they are charged as co- consprators of the crme whch was confessed by one of the accused and sad confesson s used ony as corroboratng evdence; 5. Where the confesson s used as crcumstanta evdence to show the probabty of partcpaton by the co-consprator; 6. When the confessant testfed for hs co-defendant; 7. Where the co-consprator extra|udca confesson s corroborated by other evdence of record. CLA((I=ICATIO* O= OUT-O=- COURT (TATE'E*T(: .. -EAR(A)-- Those whch are consdered as hearsay and therefore nadmssbe, ths occurs when the purpose for ntroducng the our-of-court statement s to prove the truth of the facts asserted theren; 7. *O*--EAR(A)-Admssbe. Ths occurs when the purpose for ntroducng the statement s not to prove the truth of the facts asserted theren but ony the makng of the statements and are admssbe n evdence when the makng of the statement s reevant. These are so-caed INDEPENDENTLY RELEVANT STATEMENTS. 0. ECCEPTIO*( TO T-E -EAR(A) RULE-Those whch are 70 Pearl remedial reviewer hearsay but are consdered as exceptons to the hearsay rue and are therefore admssbe. These are from Sectons 37 to 47 of Rue 130. -EAR(A) EVIDE*CE: They are admssbe by reason of NECESSITY and TRUSTWORTHINESS. Hearsay evdence not ob|ected to may be admssbe but, whether ob|ected to or not, has no probatve vaue and as opposed to drect and prmary evdence, the atter aways prevas. ECCEPTIO*( TO T-E -EAR(A) RULE: 1. Dyng Decaraton; 2. Decaraton Aganst Interest; 3. Act or decaraton About pedgree; 4. Famy reputaton or tradton regardng pedgree; 5. Common reputaton; 6. Res Gestae; 7. Entres n the ordnary course of busness; 8. Entres n offca records; 9. Commerca sts; 10. Learned treatses; Dyin" de!laration RE@UI(ITE(: 1. That death s mmnent and the decarant s conscous of that fact; 2. That the decaraton refers to the cause and and surroundng crcumstances of such death; 3. That the decaraton reates to the facts whch the vctm s competent to testfy to; and 4. That the decaraton s offered n a case wheren the decarants death s sub|ect of the nqury. RE( ,E(TAE - teray means thngs done; t ncudes the crcumstances, facts, and decaratons ncdenta to the man fact or transacton necessary to ustrate ts character and aso ncudes acts, words or decaraton whch are cosey connected therewth as to consttute part of the transacton. T>O T)PE( O= PART O= RE( ,E(TAE: 1. Statements made by a person whe a startng occurrence s takng pace or mmedatey pror or subsequent thereto wth respect to the crcumstances thereof (SPONTANEOUS STATEMENTS) 2. Statements accompanyng an equvoca act matera to the ssue, and gvng t a ega sgnfcance (VERBAL ACTS). RE@UI(ITE( O= AD'I((I:ILIT) O= (PO*TA*EOU( (TATE'E*T(: 1. there must be a startng occurrence 2. the statement must reate to the crcumstances of the starng occurrence 3. the statement must be spontaneous RE@UI(ITE( O= AD'I((I:ILIT) O= VER:AL ACT(: 1. the act or occurrence characterzed must be equvoca 2. verba acts must characterze or expan the equvoca act 3. equvoca act must be reevant to the ssue 4. verba acts must be contemporaneous wth the equvoca act 71 Pearl remedial reviewer VER:AL ACT( (PO*TA*EOU( (TATE'E*T( the res gestae s the equvoca act the res gestae s the startng occurrence verba act must be contemporaneou s wth or must accompany the equvoca act statements be may be made pror, whe or mmedatey after the startng occurrence O3inion of a witness is not admissile. ECCEPTIO*(: 1. On a matter requrng SPECIAL knowedge, sk, experence or tranng whch he s shown to possess ((e!. 5B); 2. The dentty of a person about whom he has adequate knowedge ((e!. ?;KaL); 3. A handwrtng wth whch he has suffcent famarty ((e!. ?; KL); 4. The menta santy of a person wth whom he s suffcenty acquanted ((e!. ?; K!L); 5. The wtness mpressons of the emoton, behavor, condton or appearance of a person ((e!. ?; Kd|);. CLA((I=ICATIO* O= PRE(U'PTIO*(: 1. PRE(U'PTIO* I( +URI( OR O= LA>-deducton whch the aw expressy drects to be made from partcuar facts. 2. PRE(U'PTIO* I( -O'I*I( OR O= =ACT-deducton whch reason draws from facts proved wthout an express drecton from the aw to that effect. PRE(U'PTIO* I( +URI( may be dvded nto: 1. CO*CLU(IVE PRE(U'PTIO* (2ure et de 2ure)-whch s a presumpton of aw that s not permtted to be overcome by any proof to the contrary; and 2. DI(PUTA:LE PRE(U'PTIO*( (2uris tantum)-s that whch the aw permts to be overcome or contradcted by proofs to the contrary; otherwse, the same remans satsfactory. LEADI*, @UE(TIO*-Oueston whch suggests to the wtness the answer whch the examnng party desrers. ECCEPTIO*(: 1. On premnary matters; 2. On cross-examnaton; 3. To adverse party wtness; 4. To hoste wtness; 5. To unwng wtness; 6. To chdren of tender age; 7. To deaf-mutes; 8. To those who are gnorant; 9. To those who are of weak mnds; 10. To the offcers of the adverse party who s a |urdca person. 'I(LEADI*, @UE(TIO*- one whch assumes as true a fact not yet testfed to by the wtness, or contrary to that whch he has prevousy stated. It s NOT aowed. PU:LIC >RITI*, PRIVATE >RITI*, As to a&t#enti! ity a pubc document s admssbe evdence, wthout a prvate wrtng must be proved reatve to 72 Pearl remedial reviewer further proof of ts genunene ss and due executon ts due executon and genunene ss-ts authentct y-before t may be receved n evdence. As to 3ersons o&nd a pubc nstrumen t s evdence even aganst thrd persons, of the fact whch gave rse to ts due executon and to the date of the atter; a prvate wrtng bnds ony the partes who executed them or ther prves, nsofar as due executon and date of the document are concerned . As to validity of !ertain transa!ti ons certan transacto ns must be n a pubc document, otherwse they w not be gven any vadty. 'ODE( O= ECCLUDI*, I*AD'I((I:LE EVIDE*CE: 1. O$e!tion-when the evdence s offered. 2. 'otion to stri%e o&t or E93&n"e - exampes are: a. when the wtness answers prematurey before there s reasonabe opportunty for the party to ob|ect (Sec. 39); b. unresponsve answers; c. answers that are ncompetent, rreevant, or mproper (Sec. 39); d. uncompeted testmones where there was no opportunty for the other party to cross-examne. Itender of e9!l&ded eviden!eJ? Where the court refuses to permt the counse to present testmony whch he thnks s competent, matera and necessary to prove hs case, the method of propery preservng the record to the end that the queston may be saved for the purpose of revew, s through the makng of an offer of proof (tender of excuded evdence). PURPO(E(: 1. to nform the court what s expected to be proved; and 2. procurng exceptons to the excuson of the offered evdence so that the appeate court may determne from the record whether the proposed evdence s competent. PREPO*DERA*CE O= EVIDE*CE -evdence whch s of greater weght or more convncng or superor weght of evdence than that whch s offered n opposton to t. REA(O*A:LE DOU:T-doubt engendered by an nvestgaton of 73 Pearl remedial reviewer the whoe proof and an nabty, after such nvestgaton, to et the mnd rest easy upon the certanty of gut. Absoute certanty of gut s not demanded by the aw to convct a person charged for the commsson of an offense, but mora certanty s requres as to every proposton of proof requste to consttute the offense. E@UIPO*DERA*CE O= EVIDE*CE-The evdence of both partes when paced on the dvson scae s baance. In cv cases, ths means that the court w rue n favor of the party who has no burden of proof. In crmna cases, ths means acqutta of the accused. Falsus in uno Falsus in omnibus A wtness wfuy testfyng the truth n one partcuar, when upon oath, ought never to be beeved upon, the strength of hs own testmony whatever he may assert. LI'ITATIO*(: 1. the testmony concernng whch the wtness has sworn fasey, must reate to a matera pont n ssue; 2. such testmony must have been gven by the wtness ntentonay, and he must have known t to be fase I'PORTA*T: a. Deas ony wth the weght of evdence and not a postve rue of aw. b. The wtnesses fase or exaggerated statements on other matters sha not precude the acceptance of such evdence as s reeved from any sgn of fasehood. c. The court may accept and re|ect portons of the wtness testmony dependng on the nherent credbty thereof. Ths s not a mandatory rue of evdence but s apped by the courts n ts dscreton. ,#%-% )o% .&/0/12/SC effect on 23 October 2..&%4 T-E RULE O* T-E >RIT O= A'PARO (ECTIO* .. 'etition. - The petton for a wrt of amparo s a remedy avaabe to any person whose rght to fe, berty and securty s voated or threatened wth voaton by an unawfu act or omsson of a pubc offca or empoyee, or of a prvate ndvdua or entty. The wrt sha cover extraega kngs and enforced dsappearances or threats thereof. (EC. 7. 6ho 1ay 7ile. - The petton may be fed by the aggreved party or by any quafed person or entty n the foowng order: (a) Any member of the mmedate famy, namey: the spouse, chdren and parents of the aggreved party; (b) Any ascendant, descendant or coatera reatve of the aggreved party wthn the fourth cv degree of consangunty or affnty, n defaut of those mentoned n the precedng paragraph; or (c) Any concerned ctzen, organzaton, assocaton or nsttuton, f there s no known member of the mmedate famy or reatve of the aggreved party. The fng of a petton by the aggreved party suspends the rght of a other authorzed partes to fe smar pettons. Lkewse, the fng of the petton by an authorzed party on behaf of the aggreved party suspends the rght of a others, observng the order estabshed heren. (EC. 0. 6here to 7ile. - The petton may be fed on any day and at any tme wth the Regona Tra Court of the pace where the threat, act or omsson was commtted or any of ts eements occurred, or wth 74 Pearl remedial reviewer the Sandganbayan, the Court of Appeas, the Supreme Court, or any |ustce of such courts. The wrt sha be enforceabe anywhere n the Phppnes. When ssued by a Regona Tra Court or any |udge thereof, the wrt sha be returnabe before such court or |udge. When ssued by the Sandganbayan or the Court of Appeas or any of ther |ustces, t may be returnabe before such court or any |ustce thereof, or to any Regona Tra Court of the pace where the threat, act or omsson was commtted or any of ts eements occurred. When ssued by the Supreme Court or any of ts |ustces, t may be returnabe before such Court or any |ustce thereof, or before the Sandganbayan or the Court of Appeas or any of ther |ustces, or to any Regona Tra Court of the pace where the threat, act or omsson was commtted or any of ts eements occurred. (EC. 5. *o +oc8et 7ees. - The pettoner sha be exempted from the payment of the docket and other awfu fees when fng the petton. The court, |ustce or |udge sha docket the petton and act upon t mmedatey. (EC. ?. 3ontents of 'etition. - The petton sha be sgned and verfed and sha aege the foowng: (a) The persona crcumstances of the pettoner; (b) The name and persona crcumstances of the respondent responsbe for the threat, act or omsson, or, f the name s unknown or uncertan, the respondent may be descrbed by an assumed appeaton; (c) The rght to fe, berty and securty of the aggreved party voated or threatened wth voaton by an unawfu act or omsson of the respondent, and how such threat or voaton s commtted wth the attendant crcumstances detaed n supportng affdavts; (d) The nvestgaton conducted, f any, specfyng the names, persona crcumstances, and addresses of the nvestgatng authorty or ndvduas, as we as the manner and conduct of the nvestgaton, together wth any report; (e) The actons and recourses taken by the pettoner to determne the fate or whereabouts of the aggreved party and the dentty of the person responsbe for the threat, act or omsson; and (f) The reef prayed for the petton may ncude a genera prayer for other |ust and equtabe reefs. (EC. /. Issuance of the 6rit. - Upon the fng of the petton, the court, |ustce or |udge sha mmedatey order the ssuance of the wrt f on ts face t ought to ssue. The cerk of court sha ssue the wrt under the sea of the court; or n case of urgent necessty, the |ustce or the |udge may ssue the wrt under hs or her own hand, and may deputze any offcer or person to serve t. The wrt sha aso set the date and tme for summary hearng of the petton whch sha not be ater than seven (7) days from the date of ts ssuance. (EC. 6. 'enalty for Refusin( to Issue or Ser$e the 6rit. - A cerk of court who refuses to ssue the wrt after ts aowance, or a deputzed person who refuses to serve the same, sha be punshed by the court, |ustce or |udge for contempt wthout pre|udce to other dscpnary actons. (EC. <. 9o! the 6rit is Ser$ed. - The wrt sha be served upon the respondent by a |udca offcer or by a person deputzed by the court, |ustce or |udge who sha retan a copy on whch to make a return of servce. In case the wrt cannot be served personay on the respondent, the rues on substtuted servce sha appy. (EC. B. Return 3ontents. - Wthn seventy-two (72) hours after servce of the wrt, the respondent sha fe a verfed wrtten return together wth supportng affdavts whch sha, among other thngs, contan the foowng: (a) The awfu defenses to show that the respondent dd not voate or threaten wth voaton the rght to fe, berty and securty of the aggreved party, through any act or omsson; (b) The steps or actons taken by the respondent to determne the fate or whereabouts of the aggreved party and the person or persons responsbe for the threat, act or omsson; (c) A reevant nformaton n the possesson of the respondent pertanng to the threat, act or omsson aganst the aggreved party; and 75 Pearl remedial reviewer (d) If the respondent s a pubc offca or empoyee, the return sha further state the actons that have been or w st be taken: () to verfy the dentty of the aggreved party; () to recover and preserve evdence reated to the death or dsappearance of the person dentfed n the petton whch may ad n the prosecuton of the person or persons responsbe; () to dentfy wtnesses and obtan statements from them concernng the death or dsappearance; (v) to determne the cause, manner, ocaton and tme of death or dsappearance as we as any pattern or practce that may have brought about the death or dsappearance; (v) to dentfy and apprehend the person or persons nvoved n the death or dsappearance; and (v) to brng the suspected offenders before a competent court. The return sha aso state other matters reevant to the nvestgaton, ts resouton and the prosecuton of the case. A genera dena of the aegatons n the petton sha not be aowed. (EC. .;. +efenses not 'leaded +eemed 6ai$ed. - A defenses sha be rased n the return, otherwse, they sha be deemed waved. (EC. ... 'rohibited 'leadin(s and 1otions. - The foowng peadngs and motons are prohbted: (a) Moton to dsmss; (b) Moton for extenson of tme to fe return, opposton, affdavt, poston paper and other peadngs; (c) Datory moton for postponement; (d) Moton for a b of partcuars; (e) Countercam or cross-cam; (f) Thrd-party compant; (g) Repy; (h) Moton to decare respondent n defaut; () Interventon; (|) Memorandum; (k) Moton for reconsderaton of nterocutory orders or nterm reef orders; and () Petton for certorar, mandamus or prohbton aganst any nterocutory order. (EC. .7. %ffect of 7ailure to 7ile Return. - In case the respondent fas to fe a return, the court, |ustce or |udge sha proceed to hear the petton ex parte. (EC. .0. Summary 9earin(. - The hearng on the petton sha be summary. However, the court, |ustce or |udge may ca for a premnary conference to smpfy the ssues and determne the possbty of obtanng stpuatons and admssons from the partes. The hearng sha be from day to day unt competed and gven the same prorty as pettons for habeas corpus. (EC. .5. Interim Reliefs. - Upon fng of the petton or at anytme before fna |udgment, the court, |ustce or |udge may grant any of the foowng reefs: (a) Temporary 'rotection :rder. - The court, |ustce or |udge, upon moton or motu propro, may order that the pettoner or the aggreved party and any member of the mmedate famy be protected n a government agency or by an accredted person or prvate nsttuton capabe of keepng and securng ther safety. If the pettoner s an organzaton, assocaton or nsttuton referred to n Secton 3(c) of ths Rue, the protecton may be extended to the offcers nvoved. The Supreme Court sha accredt the persons and prvate nsttutons that sha extend temporary protecton to the pettoner or the aggreved party and any member of the mmedate famy, n accordance wth gudenes whch t sha ssue. The accredted persons and prvate nsttutons sha compy wth the rues and condtons that may be mposed by the court, |ustce or |udge. (b) Inspection :rder. - The court, |ustce or |udge, upon verfed moton and after due hearng, may order any person n possesson or contro of a desgnated and or other property, to permt entry for the purpose of nspectng, measurng, surveyng, or photographng the property or any reevant ob|ect or operaton thereon. The moton sha state n deta the pace or paces to be nspected. It sha be supported by affdavts or testmones of wtnesses havng persona knowedge of 76 Pearl remedial reviewer the enforced dsappearance or whereabouts of the aggreved party. If the moton s opposed on the ground of natona securty or of the prveged nature of the nformaton, the court, |ustce or |udge may conduct a hearng n chambers to determne the mert of the opposton. The movant must show that the nspecton order s necessary to estabsh the rght of the aggreved party aeged to be threatened or voated. The nspecton order sha specfy the person or persons authorzed to make the nspecton and the date, tme, pace and manner of makng the nspecton and may prescrbe other condtons to protect the consttutona rghts of a partes. The order sha expre fve (5) days after the date of ts ssuance, uness extended for |ustfabe reasons. (c) 'roduction :rder. - The court, |ustce or |udge, upon verfed moton and after due hearng, may order any person n possesson, custody or contro of any desgnated documents, papers, books, accounts, etters, photographs, ob|ects or tangbe thngs, or ob|ects n dgtzed or eectronc form, whch consttute or contan evdence reevant to the petton or the return, to produce and permt ther nspecton, copyng or photographng by or on behaf of the movant. The moton may be opposed on the ground of natona securty or of the prveged nature of the nformaton, n whch case the court, |ustce or |udge may conduct a hearng n chambers to determne the mert of the opposton. The court, |ustce or |udge sha prescrbe other condtons to protect the consttutona rghts of a the partes. (d) 6itness 'rotection :rder. - The court, |ustce or |udge, upon moton or motu propro, may refer the wtnesses to the Department of |ustce for admsson to the Wtness Protecton, Securty and Beneft Program, pursuant to Repubc Act No. 6981. The court, |ustce or |udge may aso refer the wtnesses to other government agences, or to accredted persons or prvate nsttutons capabe of keepng and securng ther safety. (EC. .?. A$ailability of Interim Reliefs to Respondent. - Upon verfed moton of the respondent and after due hearng, the court, |ustce or |udge may ssue an nspecton order or producton order under paragraphs (b) and (c) of the precedng secton. A moton for nspecton order under ths secton sha be supported by affdavts or testmones of wtnesses havng persona knowedge of the defenses of the respondent. (EC. ./. 3ontempt. - The court, |ustce or |udge may order the respondent who refuses to make a return, or who makes a fase return, or any person who otherwse dsobeys or ressts a awfu process or order of the court to be punshed for contempt. The contemnor may be mprsoned or mposed a fne. (EC. .6. -urden of 'roof and Standard of +ili(ence Re"uired. - The partes sha estabsh ther cams by substanta evdence. The respondent who s a prvate ndvdua or entty must prove that ordnary dgence as requred by appcabe aws, rues and reguatons was observed n the performance of duty. The respondent who s a pubc offca or empoyee must prove that extraordnary dgence as requred by appcabe aws, rues and reguatons was observed n the performance of duty. The respondent pubc offca or empoyee cannot nvoke the presumpton that offca duty has been reguary performed to evade responsbty or abty. (EC. .<. ;ud(ment. - The court sha render |udgment wthn ten (10) days from the tme the petton s submtted for decson. If the aegatons n the petton are proven by substanta evdence, the court sha grant the prvege of the wrt and such reefs as may be proper and approprate; otherwse, the prvege sha be dened. (EC. .B. Appeal. - Any party may appea from the fna |udgment or order to the Supreme Court under Rue 45. The appea may rase questons of fact or aw or both. The perod of appea sha be fve (5) workng days from the date of notce of the adverse |udgment. The appea sha be gven the same prorty as n habeas corpus cases. (EC. 7;. Archi$in( and Re$i$al of 3ases. - The court sha not dsmss the petton, 77 Pearl remedial reviewer but sha archve t, f upon ts determnaton t cannot proceed for a vad cause such as the faure of pettoner or wtnesses to appear due to threats on ther ves. A perodc revew of the archved cases sha be made by the amparo court that sha, motu propro or upon moton by any party, order ther revva when ready for further proceedngs. The petton sha be dsmssed wth pre|udce upon faure to prosecute the case after the apse of two (2) years from notce to the pettoner of the order archvng the case. The cerks of court sha submt to the Offce of the Court Admnstrator a consodated st of archved cases under ths Rue not ater than the frst week of |anuary of every year. (EC. 7.. Institution of Separate Actions. - Ths Rue sha not precude the fng of separate crmna, cv or admnstratve actons. (EC. 77. %ffect of 7ilin( of a 3riminal Action. - When a crmna acton has been commenced, no separate petton for the wrt sha be fed. The reefs under the wrt sha be avaabe by moton n the crmna case. The procedure under ths Rue sha govern the dsposton of the reefs avaabe under the wrt of amparo. (EC. 70. 3onsolidation. - When a crmna acton s fed subsequent to the fng of a petton for the wrt, the atter sha be consodated wth the crmna acton. When a crmna acton and a separate cv acton are fed subsequent to a petton for a wrt of amparo, the atter sha be consodated wth the crmna acton. After consodaton, the procedure under ths Rue sha contnue to appy to the dsposton of the reefs n the petton. (EC. 75. Substanti$e Ri(hts. - Ths Rue sha not dmnsh, ncrease or modfy substantve rghts recognzed and protected by the Consttuton. (EC. 7?. Suppletory Application of the Rules of 3ourt. - The Rues of Court sha appy suppetory nsofar as t s not nconsstent wth ths Rue. (EC. 7/. Applicability to 'endin( 3ases. - Ths Rue sha govern cases nvovng extraega kngs and enforced dsappearances or threats thereof pendng n the tra and appeate courts. (EC. 76. %ffecti$ity. - Ths Rue sha take effect on October 24, 2007, foowng ts pubcaton n three (3) newspapers of genera crcuaton. A.'. *o. ;6-6-.7-(C A'E*D'E*T( TO RULE( 5.D 5?D ?< A*D /? O= T-E RULE( O= COURT RE(OLUTIO* Effect on December 27. 2007 A'E*D'E*T( TO RULE( 5.D 5?D ?< A*D /? O= T-E RULE( O= COURT RULE 5. SECTION 1. Sub2ect of appeal. - An appea may be taken from a |udgment or fna order that competey dsposes of the case, or of a partcuar matter theren when decared by these Rues to be appeaabe. No appea may be taken from: (a) An order denyng a petton for reef or any smar moton seekng reef from |udgment; (b) An nterocutory order; (c) An order dsaowng or dsmssng an appea; (d) An order denyng a moton to set asde a |udgment by consent, confesson or compromse on the ground of fraud, mstake or duress, or any other ground vtatng consent; (e) An order of executon; (f) A |udgment or fna order for or aganst one or more of severa partes or n separate cams, countercams, cross- cams and thrd-party compants, whe the man case s pendng, uness the court aows an appea therefrom; and (g) An order dsmssng an acton wthout pre|udce. In any of the foregong crcumstances, the aggreved party may fe an approprate speca cv acton as provded n Rue 65. RULE 5? SECTION 1. 7ilin( of petition !ith Supreme 3ourt. - A party desrng to appea by certorar from a |udgment, fna order or resouton of the Court of Appeas, the Sandganbayan, the Court of Tax Appeas, the Regona Tra Court or other courts, whenever authorzed by aw, may fe wth the Supreme Court a verfed petton for 78 Pearl remedial reviewer revew on certorar. The petton may ncude an appcaton for a wrt of premnary n|uncton or other provsona remedes and sha rase ony questons of aw, whch must be dstncty set forth. The pettoner may seek the same provsona remedes by verfed moton fed n the same acton or proceedng at any tme durng ts pendency. RULE ?< SEC. 5. 'reliminary in2unction not (ranted !ithout notice< e4ception. - No premnary n|uncton sha be granted wthout hearng and pror notce to the party or persons sought to be en|oned. If t sha appear from facts shown by affdavts or by the verfed appcaton that great or rreparabe n|ury woud resut to the appcant before the matter can be heard on notce, the court to whch the appcaton for premnary n|uncton was made, may ssue ex parte a temporary restranng order to be effectve ony for a perod of twenty (20) days from servce on the party or person sought to be en|oned, except as heren provded. Wthn the twenty-day perod, the court must order sad party or person to show cause at a specfed tme and pace, why the n|uncton shoud not be granted. The court sha aso determne, wthn the same perod, whether or not the premnary n|uncton sha be granted, and accordngy ssue the correspondng order. However, sub|ect to the provsons of the precedng sectons, f the matter s of extreme urgency and the appcant w suffer grave n|ustce and rreparabe n|ury, the executve |udge of a mutpe- saa court or the presdng |udge of a snge-saa court may ssue ex parte a temporary restranng order effectve for ony seventy-two (72) hours from ssuance, but sha mmedatey compy wth the provsons of the next precedng secton as to servce of summons and the documents to be served therewth. Thereafter, wthn the aforesad seventy- two (72) hours, the |udge before whom the case s pendng sha conduct a summary hearng to determne whether the temporary restranng order sha be extended unt the appcaton for premnary n|uncton can be heard. In no case sha the tota perod of effectvty of the temporary restranng order exceed twenty (20) days, ncudng the orgna seventy-two hours provded heren. In the event that the appcaton for premnary n|uncton s dened or not resoved wthn the sad perod, the temporary restranng order s deemed automatcay vacated. The effectvty of a temporary restranng order s not extendbe wthout need of any |udca decaraton to that effect, and no court sha have authorty to extend or renew the same on the same ground for whch t was ssued. However, f ssued by the Court of Appeas or a member thereof, the temporary restranng order sha be effectve for sxty (60) days from servce on the party or person sought to be en|oned. A restranng order ssued by the Supreme Court or a member thereof sha be effectve unt further orders. The tra court, the Court of Appeas, the Sandganbyan or the Court of Tax Appeas that ssued a wrt of premnary n|uncton aganst a ower court, board, offcer, or quas-|udca agency sha decde the man case or petton wthn sx (6) months from the ssuance of the wrt. RULE /? Sec. 4. 6hen and !here to file the petition. - The petton sha be fed not ater than sxty (60) days from notce of the |udgment, order or resouton. In case a moton for reconsderaton or new tra s tmey fed, whether such moton s requred or not, the petton sha be fed not ater than sxty (60) days counted from the notce of the dena of the moton. If the petton reates to an act or an omsson of a muncpa tra court or of a corporaton, a board, an offcer or a person, t sha be fed wth the Regona Tra Court exercsng |ursdcton over the terrtora area as defned by the Supreme Court. It may aso be fed wth the Court of Appeas or wth the Sandganbayan, whether or not the same s n ad of the courts appeate |ursdcton. If the petton nvoves an act or an omsson of a quas-|udca agency, uness otherwse provded by aw or these rues, the 79 Pearl remedial reviewer petton sha be fed wth and be cognzabe ony by the Court of Appeas. In eecton cases nvovng an act or an omsson of a muncpa or a regona tra court, the petton sha be fed excusvey wth the Commsson on Eectons, n ad of ts appeate |ursdcton. Sec. 7. %4peditin( proceedin(s< in2uncti$e relief. - The court n whch the petton s fed may ssue orders expedtng the proceedngs, and t may aso grant a temporary restranng order or a wrt of premnary n|uncton for the preservaton of the rghts of the partes pendng such proceedngs. The petton sha not nterrupt the course of the prncpa case, uness a temporary restranng order or a wrt of premnary n|uncton has been ssued, en|onng the pubc respondent from further proceedng wth the case. The pubc respondent sha proceed wth the prncpa case wthn ten (10) days from the fng of a petton for certorar wth a hgher court or trbuna, absent a temporary restranng order or a premnary n|uncton, or upon ts expraton. Faure of the pubc respondent to proceed wth the prncpa case may be a ground for an admnstratve charge. Sec. 8. 'roceedin(s after comment is filed. - After the comment or other peadngs requred by the court are fed, or the tme for the fng thereof has expred, the court may hear the case or requre the partes to submt memoranda. If, after such hearng or fng of memoranda or upon the expraton of the perod for fng, the court fnds that the aegatons of the petton are true, t sha render |udgment for such reef to whch the pettoner s entted. However, the court may dsmss the petton f t fnds the same patenty wthout mert or prosecuted manfesty for deay, or f the questons rased theren are too unsubstanta to requre consderaton. In such event, the court may award n favor of the respondent trebe costs sodary aganst the pettoner and counse, n addton to sub|ectng counse to admnstratve sanctons under Rues 139 and 139-B of the Rues of Court. The Court may mpose motu propro, based on res psa oqutur, other dscpnary sanctons or measures on errng awyers for patenty datory and unmertorous pettons for certorar. (alient Points of t#e Amendments to R&les 5.D 5?D ?< and /? of t#e R&les of Co&rt R&le 5. 1A33eal from t#e Re"ional Trial Co&rts2 * Under the former provson, no appea may be taken from "|a|n order denyng a moton for new tra or reconsderaton." Ths was aready removed n the amendment. In *eypes $s. 3ourt of Appeals (G.R. No. 141524, 14 September 2005) the SC noted that to "standardze the appea perods provded n the Rues and to afford tgants far opportunty to appea ther cases, the Court deems t practca to aow a fresh perod of 15 days wthn whch to fe the notce of appea n the Regona Tra Court, counted from recept of the order dsmssng a moton for a new tra or moton for reconsderaton." The SC aso stated that "|h|enceforth, ths fresh perod rue sha aso appy to Rue 40 governng appeas from the Muncpa Tra Courts to the Regona Tra Courts; Rue 42 on pettons for revew from the Regona Tra Courts to the Court of Appeas; Rue 43 on appeas from quas-|udca agences to the Court of Appeas and Rue 45 governng appeas by certorar to the Supreme Court. The new rue ams to regment or make the appea perod unform, to be counted from recept of the order denyng the moton for new tra, moton for reconsderaton (whether fu or parta) or any fna order or resouton." R&le 5? 1A33eal y Certiorari to t#e (&3reme Co&rt2 * Secton 1 of Rue 45 was amended to ncude the Court of Tax Appeas (CTA) n the st of courts from whch an appea may be taken drecty to the SC. The prevous mode of appea from a CTA decson s to the Court of Appeas (CA), through Rue 43. Ths s no onger the case snce the CTA s of the same rank as the CA. Repubc Act No. 9282 (2004) provdes 80 Pearl remedial reviewer that the CTA "sha be of the same eve as the Court of Appeas." * Secton 1 now provdes that the "petton may ncude an appcaton for a wrt of premnary n|uncton or other provsona remedes" and that "|t|he pettoner may seek the same provsona remedes by verfed moton fed n the same acton or proceedng at any tme durng ts pendency." R&le ?< 1Preliminary In$&n!tion2 * The foowng provson had been added to Secton 5 of Rue 58: "The tra court, the Court of Appeas, the Sandganbyan or the Court of Tax Appeas that ssued a wrt of premnary n|uncton aganst a ower court, board, offcer, or quas-|udca agency sha decde the man case or petton wthn sx (6) months from the ssuance of the wrt." * Before the amendment, the anguage used wth respect to the effectvty for a Temporary Restranng Order (TRO) ssued by ower courts s 20 days (or 60 days when ssued by the CA) "from noti!e to the party or person sought to be en|oned." The amendment uses "servce," nstead of "notce." R&le /? 1CertiorariD Pro#iition and 'andam&s2 * The Rules of 3ourt provdes that a petton for certorar "sha be fed n the Supreme Court or xxx." The amendment removed the SC form the enumeraton of courts where the petton may be fed (Secton 4). Ths amendment, however, does not mean that no petton for certorar may be fed wth the SC, as the Consttuton (Sec. 5, Artce VIII) expcty provdes that the SC has orgna |ursdcton over "pettons for certorar, prohbton, mandamus, quo warranto, and habeas corpus." * The amendment aso removed the provson on extenson of tme to fe the petton. Ths provson s no onger exstent: "No extenson of tme to fe the petton sha be granted except for compeng reasons and n no case exceedng ffteen (15) days." * The amendment added ths provson n Sec. 4: "In eecton cases nvovng an act or an omsson of a muncpa or a regona tra court, the petton sha be fed excusvey wth the Commsson on Eectons, n ad of ts appeate |ursdcton." * The amendment aso added ths provson n Sec. 7 ("Expedtng proceedngs; n|unctve reef"): "The pubc respondent sha proceed wth the prncpa case wthn ten (10) days from the fng of a petton for certorar wth a hgher court or trbuna, absent a temporary restranng order or a premnary n|uncton, or upon ts expraton. Faure of the pubc respondent to proceed wth the prncpa case may be a ground for an admnstratve charge." * The od provson n Sec. 8 ("Proceedngs after comment s fed") provdes that "the court may dsmss the petton f t fnds the same patenty wthout mert or prosecuted manfesty for deay, or f the questons rased theren are too unsubstanta to requre consderaton." The amendment provdes for addtona sanctons n case of abuse of the process, thus: "In such event, the court may award n favor of the respondent trebe costs sodary aganst the pettoner and counse, n addton to sub|ectng counse to admnstratve sanctons under Rues 139 and 139-B of the Rues of Court." Ths s a cear warnng on partes and ther counses. * Such warnng s made even cearer wth the addton of ths provson, aso n Sec. 8: "The Court may mpose motu proprio, based on res ipsa lo"uitur, other dscpnary sanctons or measures on errng awyers for patenty datory and unmertorous pettons for certorar." T-E RULE O* T-E >RIT O= -A:EA( DATA ,#%-% )o% .5/1/16/SC ta7e effect on February 2 2..58 SECTION 1. Habeas Data.-The wrt of habeas data s a remedy avaabe to any person whose rght to prvacy n fe, berty or securty s voated or threatened by an unawfu act or omsson of a pubc offca or empoyee, or of a prvate ndvdua or entty engaged n the gatherng, coectng or storng of data or 81 Pearl remedial reviewer nformaton regardng the person, famy, home and correspondence of the aggreved party. SEC. 2. Who May Fe.-Any aggreved party may fe a petton for the wrt of habeas data. However, n cases of extraega kngs and enforced dsappearances, the petton may be fed by: (a) Any member of the mmedate famy of the aggreved party, namey: the spouse, chdren and parents; or (b) Any ascendant, descendant or coatera reatve of the aggreved party wthn the fourth cv degree of consangunty or affnty, n defaut of those mentoned n the precedng paragraph. SEC. 3. Where to Fe.-The petton may be fed wth the Regona Tra Court where the pettoner or respondent resdes, or that whch has |ursdcton over the pace where the data or nformaton s gathered, coected or stored, at the opton of the pettoner. The petton may aso be fed wth the Supreme Court or the Court of Appeas or the Sandganbayan when the acton concerns pubc data fes of government offces. SEC. 4. Where Returnabe; Enforceabe.- When the wrt s ssued by a Regona Tra Court or any |udge thereof, t sha be returnabe before such court or |udge. When ssued by the Court of Appeas or the Sandganbayan or any of ts |ustces, t may be returnabe before such court or any |ustce thereof, or to any Regona Tra Court of the pace where the pettoner or respondent resdes, or that whch has |ursdcton over the pace where the data or nformaton s gathered, coected or stored. When ssued by the Supreme Court or any of ts |ustces, t may be returnabe before such Court or any |ustce thereof, or before the Court of Appeas or the Sandganbayan or any of ts |ustces, or to any Regona Tra Court of the pace where the pettoner or respondent resdes, or that whch has |ursdcton over the pace where the data or nformaton s gathered, coected or stored. The wrt of habeas data sha be enforceabe anywhere n the Phppnes. SEC. 5. Docket Fees.-No docket and other awfu fees sha be requred from an ndgent pettoner. The petton of the ndgent sha be docketed and acted upon mmedatey, wthout pre|udce to subsequent submsson of proof of ndgency not ater than ffteen (15) days from the fng of the petton. SEC. 6. Petton.-A verfed wrtten petton for a wrt of habeas data shoud contan: (a) The persona crcumstances of the pettoner and the respondent; (b) The manner the rght to prvacy s voated or threatened and how t affects the rght to fe, berty or securty of the aggreved party; (c) The actons and recourses taken by the pettoner to secure the data or nformaton; (d) The ocaton of the fes, regsters or databases, the government offce, and the person n charge, n possesson or n contro of the data or nformaton, f known; (e) The reefs prayed for, whch may ncude the updatng, rectfcaton, suppresson or destructon of the database or nformaton or fes kept by the respondent. In case of threats, the reef may ncude a prayer for an order en|onng the act companed of; and (f) Such other reevant reefs as are |ust and equtabe. SEC. 7. Issuance of the Wrt.-Upon the fng of the petton, the court, |ustce or |udge sha mmedatey order the ssuance of the wrt f on ts face t ought to ssue. The cerk of court sha ssue the wrt under the sea of the court and cause t to be served wthn three (3) days from ts ssuance; or, n case of urgent necessty, the |ustce or |udge may ssue the wrt under hs or her own hand, and may deputze any offcer or person to serve t. The wrt sha aso set the date and tme for summary hearng of the petton whch sha not be ater than ten (10) work days from the date of ts ssuance. SEC. 8. Penaty for Refusng to Issue or Serve the Wrt.-A cerk of court who refuses to ssue the wrt after ts aowance, or a deputzed person who 82 Pearl remedial reviewer refuses to serve the same, sha be punshed by the court, |ustce or |udge for contempt wthout pre|udce to other dscpnary actons. SEC. 9. How the Wrt Is Served.-The wrt sha be served upon the respondent by the offcer or person deputzed by the court, |ustce or |udge who sha retan a copy on whch to make a return of servce. In case the wrt cannot be served personay on the respondent, the rues on substtuted servce sha appy. SEC. 10. Return; Contents.-The respondent sha fe a verfed wrtten return together wth supportng affdavts wthn fve (5) work days from servce of the wrt, whch perod may be reasonaby extended by the Court for |ustfabe reasons. The return sha, among other thngs, contan the foowng: (a) The awfu defenses such as natona securty, state secrets, prveged communcaton, confdentaty of the source of nformaton of meda and others; (b) In case of respondent n charge, n possesson or n contro of the data or nformaton sub|ect of the petton: () a dscosure of the data or nformaton about the pettoner, the nature of such data or nformaton, and the purpose for ts coecton; () the steps or actons taken by the respondent to ensure the securty and confdentaty of the data or nformaton; and () the currency and accuracy of the data or nformaton hed; and (c) Other aegatons reevant to the resouton of the proceedng. A genera dena of the aegatons n the petton sha not be aowed. SEC. 11. Contempt.-The court, |ustce or |udge may punsh wth mprsonment or fne a respondent who commts contempt by makng a fase return, or refusng to make a return; or any person who otherwse dsobeys or ressts a awfu process or order of the court. SEC. 12. When Defenses May Be Heard n Chambers.-A hearng n chambers may be conducted where the respondent nvokes the defense that the reease of the data or nformaton n queston sha compromse natona securty or state secrets, or when the data or nformaton cannot be dvuged to the pubc due to ts nature or prveged character. SEC. 13. Prohbted Peadngs and Motons. -The foowng peadngs and motons are prohbted: (a) Moton to dsmss; (b) Moton for extenson of tme to fe opposton, affdavt, poston paper and other peadngs; (c) Datory moton for postponement; (d) Moton for a b of partcuars; (e) Countercam or cross-cam; (f) Thrd-party compant; (g) Repy; (h) Moton to decare respondent n defaut; () Interventon; (|) Memorandum; (k) Moton for reconsderaton of nterocutory orders or nterm reef orders; and () Petton for certorar, mandamus or prohbton aganst any nterocutory order. SEC. 14. Return; Fng.-In case the respondent fas to fe a return, the court, |ustce or |udge sha proceed to hear the petton ex parte, grantng the pettoner such reef as the petton may warrant uness the court n ts dscreton requres the pettoner to submt evdence. SEC. 15. Summary Hearng.-The hearng on the petton sha be summary. However, the court, |ustce or |udge may ca for a premnary conference to smpfy the ssues and determne the possbty of obtanng stpuatons and admssons from the partes. SEC. 16. |udgment.-The court sha render |udgment wthn ten (10) days from the tme the petton s submtted for decson. If the aegatons n the petton are proven by substanta evdence, the court sha en|on the act companed of, or order the deeton, destructon, or rectfcaton of the erroneous data or nformaton and grant other reevant reefs as may be |ust and equtabe; otherwse, the prvege of the wrt sha be dened. Upon ts fnaty, the |udgment sha be enforced by the sherff or any awfu offcer as may be desgnated by the court, |ustce or |udge wthn fve (5) work days. 83 Pearl remedial reviewer SEC. 17. Return of Servce.-The offcer who executed the fna |udgment sha, wthn three (3) days from ts enforcement, make a verfed return to the court. The return sha contan a fu statement of the proceedngs under the wrt and a compete nventory of the database or nformaton, or documents and artces nspected, updated, rectfed, or deeted, wth copes served on the pettoner and the respondent. The offcer sha state n the return how the |udgment was enforced and comped wth by the respondent, as we as a ob|ectons of the partes regardng the manner and reguarty of the servce of the wrt. SEC. 18. Hearng on Offcers Return.-The court sha set the return for hearng wth due notce to the partes and act accordngy. SEC. 19. Appea.-Any party may appea from the |udgment or fna order to the Supreme Court under Rue 45. The appea may rase questons of fact or aw or both. The perod of appea sha be fve (5) work days from the date of notce of the |udgment or fna order. The appea sha be gven the same prorty as habeas corpus and amparo cases. SEC. 20. Insttuton of Separate Actons.- The fng of a petton for the wrt of habeas data sha not precude the fng of separate crmna, cv or admnstratve actons. SEC. 21. Consodaton.-When a crmna acton s fed subsequent to the fng of a petton for the wrt, the atter sha be consodated wth the crmna acton. When a crmna acton and a separate cv acton are fed subsequent to a petton for a wrt of habeas data, the petton sha be consodated wth the crmna acton. After consodaton, the procedure under ths Rue sha contnue to govern the dsposton of the reefs n the petton. SEC. 22. Effect of Fng of a Crmna Acton.-When a crmna acton has been commenced, no separate petton for the wrt sha be fed. The reefs under the wrt sha be avaabe to an aggreved party by moton n the crmna case. The procedure under ths Rue sha govern the dsposton of the reefs avaabe under the wrt of habeas data. SEC. 23. Substantve Rghts.-Ths Rue sha not dmnsh, ncrease or modfy substantve rghts. SEC. 24. Suppetory Appcaton of the Rues of Court.-The Rues of Court sha appy suppetory nsofar as t s not nconsstent wth ths Rue. SEC. 25. Effectvty.-Ths Rue sha take effect on February 2, 2008 foowng ts pubcaton n three (3) newspapers of genera crcuaton. >#at is t#e writ of #aeas dataM It s a remedy avaabe to any person whose rght to prvacy n fe, berty or securty s voated or threatened by an unawfu act or omsson of a pubc offca or empoyee, or of a prvate ndvdua or entty engaged n the gatherng, coectng or storng of data or nformaton regardng the person, famy, home and correspondence of the aggreved party. >#at r&le "overns 3etitions for and t#e iss&an!e of a writ of #aeas dataM It s governed by The Rue on the Wrt of Habeas Data (A.M. No. 08-1-16-SC - fu text), whch was approved by the Supreme Court on 22 |anuary 2008. That Rue sha not dmnsh, ncrease or modfy substantve rghts. >#at is t#e (&3reme Co&rtFs asis in iss&in" t#e R&leM The Rue was drafted pursuant to the Supreme Courts consttutona power to promugate rues for the protecton and enforcement of consttutona rghts (Consttuton, Art. VIII, Sec. 5|5|). >#en does t#e R&le ta%e effe!tM The Rue takes effect on 2 February 2008, foowng ts pubcaton n three (3) newspapers of genera crcuaton. 84 Pearl remedial reviewer >#o may file a 3etition for t#e iss&an!e of a writ of #aeas dataM The petton may be fed by the aggreved party. However, n cases of extraega kngs and enforced dsappearances, the petton may be fed by: (a) Any member of the mmedate famy of the aggreved party, namey: the spouse, chdren and parents; or (b) Any ascendant, descendant or coatera reatve of the aggreved party wthn the fourth cv degree of consangunty or affnty, n defaut of those mentoned n the precedng paragraph. >#ere !an t#e 3etition e filedM a. Regona Tra Court where the pettoner or respondent resdes, or that whch has |ursdcton over the pace where the data or nformaton s gathered, coected or stored, at the opton of the pettoner. b. Supreme Court; c. Court of Appeas; or d. Sandganbayan, when the acton concerns pubc data fes of government offces. -ow m&!# is t#e do!%et or filin" fees for t#e 3etitionM No docket and other awfu fees sha be requred from an ndgent pettoner. The petton of the ndgent sha be docketed and acted upon mmedatey, wthout pre|udce to subsequent submsson of proof of ndgency not ater than 15 days from the fng of the petton. >#at are t#e re8&ired !ontents of t#e 3etitionM The verfed wrtten petton sha aege the foowng: (a) The persona crcumstances of the pettoner and the respondent; (b) The manner the rght to prvacy s voated or threatened and how t affects the rght to fe, berty or securty of the aggreved party; (c) The actons and recourses taken by the pettoner to secure the data or nformaton; (d) The ocaton of the fes, regsters or databases, the government offce, and the person n charge, n possesson or n contro of the data or nformaton, f known; (e) The reefs prayed for, whch may ncude the updatng, rectfcaton, suppresson or destructon of the database or nformaton or fes kept by the respondent. In case of threats, the reef may ncude a prayer for an order en|onng the act companed of; and (f) Such other reevant reefs as are |ust and equtabe. >#en is t#e writ of #aeas data iss&edM Upon the fng of the petton, the court, |ustce or |udge sha mmedatey order the ssuance of the wrt f on ts face t ought to ssue. The cerk of court sha ssue the wrt under the sea of the court and cause t to be served wthn three (3) days from ts ssuance; or, n case of urgent necessty, the |ustce or |udge may ssue the wrt under hs or her own hand, and may deputze any offcer or person to serve t. The wrt sha aso set the date and tme for summary hearng of the petton whch sha not be ater than ten (10) work days from the date of ts ssuance. Is t#ere any 3enalty in !ase of ref&sal to iss&e or serve t#e writM Yes. A cerk of court who refuses to ssue the wrt after ts aowance, or a deputzed person who refuses to serve the same, sha be punshed by the court, |ustce or |udge for contempt wthout pre|udce to other dscpnary actons. 85 Pearl remedial reviewer -ow is t#e writ of #aeas data servedM The wrt sha be served upon the respondent by the offcer or person deputzed by the court, |ustce or |udge who sha retan a copy on whch to make a return of servce. In case the wrt cannot be served personay on the respondent, the rues on substtuted servce sha appy. After t#e writ is servedD w#at s#o&ld t#e res3ondent doM The respondent sha fe a verfed wrtten return together wth supportng affdavts wthn fve (5) work days from servce of the wrt, whch perod may be reasonaby extended by the Court for |ustfabe reasons. >#at are t#e !ontents of t#e written ret&rnM The return sha, among other thngs, contan the foowng: (a) The awfu defenses such as natona securty, state secrets, prveged communcaton, confdentaty of the source of nformaton of meda and others; (b) In case of respondent n charge, n possesson or n contro of the data or nformaton sub|ect of the petton: () a dscosure of the data or nformaton about the pettoner, the nature of such data or nformaton, and the purpose for ts coecton; () the steps or actons taken by the respondent to ensure the securty and confdentaty of the data or nformaton; and () the currency and accuracy of the data or nformaton hed; and (c) Other aegatons reevant to the resouton of the proceedng. A genera dena of the aegatons n the petton sha not be aowed. >#at #a33ens if t#e res3ondent ma%es a false ret&rn or ref&ses to ma%e a ret&rn4 or if any 3erson w#o disoeys or resists a lawf&l 3ro!ess or order of t#e !o&rtM That person may be punshed wth mprsonment or fne. Aso, when the respondent fas to fe a return, the court, |ustce or |udge sha proceed to hear the petton ex parte, grantng the pettoner such reef as the petton may warrant uness the court n ts dscreton requres the pettoner to submt evdence. Instead of #avin" t#e #earin" in o3en !o&rtD !an it e done in !#amersM Yes. It can be done when the respondent nvokes the defense that the reease of the data or nformaton n queston sha compromse natona securty or state secrets, or when the data or nformaton cannot be dvuged to the pubc due to ts nature or prveged character. >#at is t#e nat&re of t#e #earin" on t#e 3etitionM The hearng on the petton sha be summary. However, the court, |ustce or |udge may ca for a premnary conference to smpfy the ssues and determne the possbty of obtanng stpuatons and admssons from the partes. -ow lon" does t#e !o&rt #ave in de!idin" t#e 3etitionM The court sha render |udgment wthn ten (10) days from the tme the petton s submtted for decson. If the aegatons n the petton are proven by substanta evdence, the court sha en|on the act companed of, or order the deeton, destructon, or rectfcaton of the erroneous data or nformaton and grant other reevant reefs as may be |ust and equtabe; otherwse, the prvege of the wrt sha be dened. 86 Pearl remedial reviewer >#at #a33ens after t#e finality of t#e $&d"mentM Upon ts fnaty, the |udgment sha be enforced by the sherff or any awfu offcer as may be desgnated by the court, |ustce or |udge wthn fve (5) work days. The offcer who executed the fna |udgment sha, wthn three (3) days from ts enforcement, make a verfed return to the court. The return sha contan a fu statement of the proceedngs under the wrt and a compete nventory of the database or nformaton, or documents and artces nspected, updated, rectfed, or deeted, wth copes served on the pettoner and the respondent. The offcer sha state n the return how the |udgment was enforced and comped wth by the respondent, as we as a ob|ectons of the partes regardng the manner and reguarty of the servce of the wrt. The court sha set the return for hearng wth due notce to the partes and act accordngy. Does t#e filin" of t#e 3etition 3re!l&de t#e filin" of se3arate !riminalD !ivil or administrative a!tionsM No. However, when a crmna acton has been commenced, no separate petton for the wrt sha be fed, but the reefs under the wrt sha be avaabe by moton n the crmna case, and the procedure under ths Rue sha govern the dsposton of the reefs avaabe under the wrt of habeas data. When a crmna acton and a separate cv acton are fed subsequent to a petton for a wrt of habeas data, the petton sha be consodated wth the crmna acton. After consodaton, the procedure under ths Rue sha contnue to govern the dsposton of the reefs n the petton. 87