Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Clinical Paper
Oral Surgery
A. J. van der Westhuijzen1,
A randomized observer blind P. J. Becker2, J. Morkel1,
J. A. Roelse3
1
Department of Maxillo-facial and Oral
Abstract. This study compares the efficacy of Tecnol1 bilateral facial ice packs
with no cold therapy in reducing pain, swelling and trismus during the first 24 h
following third molar surgery.
Sixty patients requiring general anaesthesia for removal of bilateral, impacted
third molar teeth were included and randomly assigned to one of two treatment
groups. One group received Tecnol1 bilateral facial ice packs following
surgery, while a control group received no form of cold therapy. Facial ice
packs were applied in the recovery room within 15 min of the end surgery and
patients were asked to use the ice packs continuously for the next 24 h. Surgical
and anaesthetic techniques as well as pharmacological regimens were
standardized.
Key words: cryotherapy; ice therapy; facial ice
Postoperative pain levels were compared hourly, for 4 h, then on the evening of
packs; third molar surgery; dento-alveolar
surgery and the following morning. Facial swelling and trismus were compared surgery.
preoperatively and 24 h postoperatively.
No statistically significant difference was found between the two treatment Accepted for publication 4 May 2004
groups with respect to pain, facial swelling or trismus. Available online 19 July 2004
Cryotherapy or cold therapy is the local to justify treatment that is largely Tecnol1 bilateral facial ice packs,
or systemic application of cold for ther- applied in an empirical manner. produced by Tecnol Inc., Fort Worth,
apeutic purposes and has been in use This study was performed to compare TX, were selected for use in this study.
since at least the time of Hippocrates23. the efficacy of bilateral facial ice ther- According to the manufacturer’s infor-
Local cold application is used to control apy with no ice therapy during the first mation, it is a comfortable self-con-
inflammation, pain, and edema; to 24 h following surgery, using an obser- tained product, that was designed to
reduce spasticity; and to facilitate move- ver blind randomized experimental provide up to 2 h of stay dry cold ther-
ment4,23. Despite the frequent use of design. Our hypothesis was that cold apy for relieve of pain and swelling that
cooling in orthopaedic rehabilitation and therapy, applied by means of facial ice resulted from oral surgery or other max-
physiotherapy, as evidenced by the packs, following third molar surgery, illofacial procedures.
plethora of reports in the literature, there provided postoperative control of facial Other forms of applying cold therapy
is a paucity of scientific evidence in the swelling, pain and trismus, that would to the facial area include chemical
oral and maxillofacial surgery literature6 be superior to no ice application. packs, gel packs, and rubber ice bags as
0901-5027/030281+06 $30.00/0 # 2004 International Association of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgeons. Published by Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
282 van der Westhuijzen et al.
well as improvised items such as plastic anaesthetist, surgeon, and degree of sur- kept under a continuous spray of sterile
bags and gloves filled with ice. gical difficulty were uniformly distribu- saline solution was used. Tooth delivery
ted between the two treatment groups. was followed by meticulous irrigation of
the surgical area with sterile saline solu-
Materials and methods
tion to eliminate debris. The flap was
Anaesthetic management
Outpatients between 18 and 40 years of repositioned and the wound sutured with
age who attended the dental teaching hos- All patients were treated as outpatients a continuous mattress suture using 4-0
pital of the University of Stellenbosch and discharged no sooner than 4 h post- braided Polyglactin 910 sutures and an
and who required surgical removal of operatively. No patient received antie- atraumatic needle. No infiltration with
bilateral impacted mandibular third molar metic, analgesic or anti-inflammatory local anaesthetic was allowed peri-
teeth, with or without the concomitant drugs, other than the standardized medi- operatively.
surgical removal of maxillary third molars cation at any time. In order to assess and compare the
under general anaesthesia were eligible No premedication was given. Anaes- surgical difficulty and extent of surgical
for inclusion in this study. thesia was induced with Diprivan 2 mg/ trauma between the two study groups,
Sixty patients were enrolled into two kg. Nasotracheal intubation was facili- impactions were categorized into four
treatment groups. At the 0.05 level of tated with 0,1 mg/kg vecuronium given groups, i.e. partial or complete soft tis-
significance and with a power of 90%, a intravenously. For mechanical ventilation sue impactions and partial or complete
sample of 27 patients per group was 0.3 mg/kg alcuronium was given. Nitrous bone impactions.
required to detect a 1.5 mm difference oxide 60% in oxygen and isoflurane were Perioperative antimicrobial therapy
in swelling between the groups, that is, used for maintenance of anaesthesia. was standardized for all patients. Chlor-
15% of 10-mm expected maximum The electrocardiograph, peripheral hexidine gluconate 0.2% mouthwashes
swelling. A sample of 27 patients per pulse, arterial oxygen saturation and were prescribed twice daily for all
group was required to detect a 15% dif- arterial pressure were monitored con- patients. All operations were performed
ference in pain between the two groups tinuously throughout the anaesthetic in the morning and completed before
on a visual analogue scale, and a sample whilst a capnograph was used to mea- noon.
of 26 patients per group was required to sure end-tidal carbon dioxide and to
detect a difference of 3.5 mm in mouth- ensure normo ventilation.
Study design
opening ability between the two groups.
Standard deviations of 1.67 (range/ One study group had Tecnol1 bilateral
Anti-inflammatory and analgesic regimen
6 ¼ 10/6), 16.7 (range/6) and 3.75 (nor- facial ice packs (Tecnol, Inc., Fort
mal range/4 ¼ 15/4) were used respec- The peri-operative analgesic and anti- Worth, TX) fitted in the recovery room
tively for swelling, pain and mouth- inflammatory treatment was standardized within 15 min following surgery. These
opening ability. for all patients. A compound in capsular were fixed securely over the patient’s
The study was approved by the local form, each containing ibuprofen heads with the ice-cube filled pouches in
ethics committee and before entry into (200 mg), paracetamol (250 mg), and contact with the cheeks in accordance
the study, written informed consent was codeine phosphate (10 mg) was used. All with the manufacturer’s directions.
obtained from each participant. Only patients received 2 capsules with no more Patients were instructed to replace the
patients able to express and record their than 10 ml H2O 30 min prior to sur- ice-cubes in the pouches when the ice
pain accurately were included. gery and continued with two capsules had thawed and cooling became ineffec-
Before participation in this study, full every 6 h for the first 24 h following sur- tive. The control group received no form
medical histories were obtained from all gery, when they were seen for review, of cold therapy and patients in this
patients, and all were physically exam- and only then were they advised to taper group were not alerted to the use of cold
ined. Patients with a history of unusual analgesic consumption as required. Medi- therapy, but were asked at the time of
responses to cold, with known cold intol- cation times were recorded in the patient review, whether any self administered
erance or Raynaud’s phenomenon were self-assessment diary to ensure and check cold therapy had been applied.
excluded from the study, as were patients compliance. One Tramadol 50 mg capsule The bilateral facial ice pack consists
with, renal or hepatic disease, blood dys- was provided as escape analgesia to be of two ice packs bonded together with a
crasia, previous or present gastric ulcers, used for unbearable pain only. Escape strong Teclin strap that can be posi-
heart disease, or patients with know analgesic consumption was recorded for tioned across the crown of the head and
hypersensitivities, allergies, or idiosyn- comparison between the two groups. is secured with a Velcro strap. The ice
cratic reactions to any of the standardized packs are lined with puncture-resistant
medications. Female patients were vinyl which prevents leakage, a middle
Standardised surgical technique
excluded if they were pregnant or lactat- layer of polyester-rayon blended mate-
ing. In addition, any patient being treated Seven surgeons participated in this rial which serves to insulate the pack
with non-steroidal anti-inflammatory study. They rigidly adhered to a standar- and allow a proper level of cold transfer
agents, antibiotic therapy, lithium ther- dized surgical technique of mandibular and also to absorb and wick away con-
apy, anti-hypertensives or who had taken and maxillary scalpel incisions, followed densation to keep the pack dry. The
any analgesics or anti-inflammatory by raising full mucoperiosteal flaps outer layer of the ice pack, in contact
agents within a 24-h period before sur- before removal of mandibular and max- with the patient’s skin, consists of non-
gery was excluded from the study. illary third molars. In cases where max- irritating soft Teclin polyester. The
The random allocation of patients to illary third molar delivery was possible packs are ultrasonically sealed to pre-
the two treatment groups ensured that by direct elevation this was done. vent leakage and have a plastic clip to
patient and treatment variables such as When bone removal or odontectomy make opening and filling of pouches
age, sex, weight, race, preoperative pain, was required, a drill and rosehead bur with ice simple and convenient.
Ice therapy and third molar surgery 283
The pouches were filled with ice ably between 24 and 48 h postopera- and Stata V6 Statistical Software
cubes and repeatedly refilled when the tively. For this reason and for other packages.
ice had thawed for more prolonged cold logistical reasons, swelling recorded
therapy. Patients were asked to use the 24 h postoperatively was used to deter-
Results
ice packs continuously and sleep with mine maximal facial swelling.
the ice packs on the face during the first The maximum mouth-opening ability The demographic distribution and base-
24 h following surgery. In order to check measured in millimetres was recorded line values of the 60 patients in the trial
and evaluate compliance, the exact times between the right upper and right lower are presented in Table 1. It was con-
that the ice packs were on or off the central incisors with the use of a Ver- firmed that two groups did not differ
face during the study period were nier-calibrated sliding calliper. Mouth- with respect to age, sex, weight, or
recorded in the self-assessment diaries. opening ability was recorded preopera- degree of surgical difficulty as deter-
Patients were instructed to rate and to tively, and 24 h postoperatively when mined by the type of impaction. Thirty
record pain intensity on a continuous minimum mouth opening (maximum patients received bilateral facial ice
10-cm visual analogue scale, in which 0 trismus) was expected. packs and 30 received no ice therapy.
represented no pain and 10 equalled the All patients were asked to judge the The highest pain levels during the first
worst pain imaginable. Pain severity, if efficacy of postoperative control of their 4 h postoperatively, were recorded 1 h
any, was recorded by the patient after pain and discomfort over the first 24 h postoperatively for both treatment
admission and before surgery on the following surgery on a scale of 1–5, groups (Fig. 1). Pain levels then gradu-
morning of the operation, and then at where 1 represented excellent control, 2 ally decreased for both trial groups dur-
each of the first 4 h after the end of the good, 3 moderate, 4 poor and 5 very ing the first 4 h postoperatively. No
anaesthetic with the assistance of a poor control of pain and discomfort. statistical significant difference (P >
trained nurse observer. On the evening Before discharge from the clinic, the 0.05) was observed for parameter of
of surgery, patients recorded pain sever- investigator ensured that all patients pain during the first 4 h postoperatively
ity between 21:00 and 22:00 h, and knew how to complete the patient self- between the two treatment groups,
again between 07:00 and 08:00 h on the assessment diary and when to take the neither was a statistical significant dif-
morning following surgery. standardized medication and escape ference (P > 0.05) found for pain
Facial swelling was recorded in milli- medication. The patients returned the recordings on the evening following sur-
metres with Vernier-calibrated sliding completed form at the time of clinical gery (EVE D0) nor the following morn-
pointers attached to the horizontal exten- assessment 24 h postoperatively. All ing (MRN D1) (Fig. 1).
sions of a modified bite-fork/facebow patients were provided with home On the day following surgery, mean
appliance. The sliding pointers were instructions to ensure compliance. facial swelling of 6.0 and 4.6 mm were
adjusted until they made contact with Only side effects spontaneously per- recorded for the facial ice pack group,
the cheeks over the position of the third ceived by the patient were recorded in on the left and right sides, respectively.
molars. A thermoplastic impression the self-assessment diaries. For the group that had received no ice
recorded in centric occlusion ensured Data management and statistical ana- therapy the mean values were 6.4 and
accurate repositioning at subsequent vis- lysis were performed by the Medical 5.4 mm on the left and right sides,
its of the sliding pointers over the area Research Council using the Statistix V7 respectively (Fig. 2). Although mean
of maximal swelling.
Studies by HOLLAND12 have shown Table 1. Demographic distribution and surgical variables
that swelling after third molar surgery
Ice pack No ice therapy
occurred symmetrically around the slid-
ing pointer provided it was accurately Age (years)
positioned over the base of the external Mean 21.5 21.4
oblique ridge of the mandible. SD 3.6 3.5
As no published method satisfies all
criteria for assessing facial swelling, we Sex
decided to use the single sliding pointer Male 8 13
Female 22 17
face-bow method that records one-
dimensional change only. This portable Weight (kg)
appliance has been proven to be effec- Mean 65.7 69.9
tive in prior investigations by others SD 8.5 12.9
including ALBUM et al.1 and HOLLAND12.
Facial swelling was recorded preo- Impaction type (N)
peratively and again 24 h postopera- Mandibular 3rd molars
tively. Initial preoperative swelling Bone impactions 29 30
recordings provided a baseline reference Complete soft tissue 22 13
only. By subtracting this baseline value Partial soft tissue 9 17
Fully erupted 0 0
from the recordings after 24 h, the actual
values for maximal facial swelling were Maxillary 3rd molars
obtained. Published studies2,12,17 com- Bone impactions 16 17
monly used swelling recorded on the Complete soft tissue 26 10
first postoperative day as the measure Partial soft tissue 7 9
Fully erupted 6 17
for maximal facial swelling, even though
Missing 5 1
maximal swelling may be attained vari-
284 van der Westhuijzen et al.
Table 3. Side-effects
Ice therapy No ice therapy
Nausea 5 3
Mild oozing 2 5
Total 7 8
considered to be contraindicated in then raised as to whether some benefi- 12. Holland CS. The development of a
patients suffering from cold hypersensi- cial effects attributed to cold therapy in method of assessing swelling following
tivities and intolerances, or over regen- earlier studies, might have been due to third molar surgery. Br J Oral Surg 1979:
erating nerves, areas with impaired either the concomitant effects of com- 17: 104–114.
13. Konrath GA, Lock T, Goitz HT,
circulation or peripheral vascular dis- pression or a placebo effect in the treat- Scheidler J. The use of cold therapy
ease4. Cold therapy should be employed ment group7,8,13,22. Further study in this after anterior cruciate ligament recon-
with caution in patients with hyperten- regard will be required to reach a con- struction. A prospective, randomized
sion, poor sensation or mentation, and in clusive answer. study and literature review. Am J Sports
the very old and very young as they Med 1996: 24: 629–633.
may frequently have impaired thermal 14. Lee JM, Warren MP, Mason SM.
regulation or a limited ability to commu- Acknowledgments. The authors would like Effects of ice on nerve conduction velo-
nicate4. These contra-indications cer- to acknowledge Adcock Ingram Pharma- city. Physiotherapy 1978: 64: 2–6.
tainly apply to peripheral limbs, though ceuticals Ltd., South Africa, for donating 15. LEHMANN JF. Therapeutic Heat and Cold.
Myprodol capsules, the compound used as Baltimore: Williams and Wilkins 1990:
some of these may not be absolute con-
analgesic and anti-inflammatory in this 590–632.
tra-indications in the oral and maxillofa- 16. Lewis T. Observations upon the reaction
cial region, with its superior collateral study.
of vessels of the human skin to cold. Heart
blood supply. 1930: 15: 177–208.
Improper application of cryotherapy References 17. Llewelyn J, Ryan M, Santosh C. The
may result in tissue death due to pro- use of magnetic resonance imaging to
1. Album B, Olsen I, Løkken P. Bilateral asses swelling after the removal of third
longed vasoconstriction, ischemia, and
surgical removal of impacted mandibular
capillary thrombosis4. Cold application third molar teeth as a model for drug
molar teeth. Br J Oral Maxillofac Surg
is generally limited to 15 min in distal 1996: 34: 419–423.
evaluation: a test with oxyphenbutazone 18. LOW J, REED A. Cold therapy. In: Low J,
extremities, while longer treatment dura- (Tranderil). Int J Oral Surg 1977: 6: 177– Reed A, eds: Electrotherapy Explained.
tions may be used for other areas24. No 189. Principles and Practice. Oxford: Butter-
adverse effects to cold were reported or 2. Berge TI. The use of a visual analogue worth-Heinemann 1990: 202–220.
observed in our study, where ice therapy scale in observer assessment of post- 19. Oosterveld FGJ, Rasker JJ, Jacobs
was applied to the face and skin tem- operative swelling subsequent to third- JWG, Overmars HJA. The effect of local
perature stabilized at 21 8C, despite molar surgery. Acta Odontol Scand heat and cold therapy on the intraarticular
the fact that the ice packs were used 1989: 47: 167–174. and skin surface temperature of the knee.
3. Bierman W, Friedlander M. The pene- Arthritis Rheum 1992: 35: 146–151.
continually for up to 21 h. trative effect of cold. Arch Phys Ther
Since, no statistical significant differ- 20. Price R, Lehmann JF, Boswell-Bes-
1940: 21: 585–592. sette S, Burleigh A, deLateur BJ.
ence was found in reduction of post- 4. CAMERON MH. Physical Agents in Reha- Influence of cryotherapy on spasticity at
operative pain, swelling or trismus bilitation—From Research to Practice. the human ankle. Arch Phys Med Rehabil
between the two treatment groups, we Philadelphia: WB Saunders 1999: 129– 1993: 74: 300–304.
could not accept the hypotheses that ice 148. 21. Rowe NL. Ankylosis of the temporoman-
therapy administered by Tecnol1 bilat- 5. COMROE Jr JH. The Lung: Clinical dibular joint. J R Coll Surg Edinb 1982: 2:
eral facial ice packs was superior to no Physiology and Pulmonary Function 67–79.
ice therapy in: (1) providing post-surgi- Tests. 2nd edn. Chicago: Year Book 22. Scarcella JB, Cohn BT. The effect of
1962. cold therapy on the postoperative course
cal analgesia, (2) reducing post-surgical
6. Courage GR, Huebsch RF. Cold ther- of total hip and knee arthroplasty patients.
swelling, and (3) reducing trismus, dur- apy revisited. JADA 1971: 83: 1070–
ing the initial 24 h following third molar Am J Orthop 1995: 24: 847–852.
1073. 23. Stangel L. The value of cryotherapy and
surgery. However, with respect to 7. Daniel DM, Stone ML, Arendt DL. thermotherapy in the relief of pain. Phy-
patients’ subjective perception of the The effect of cold therapy on pain, swel- siotherapy (Canada) 1975: 27: 135–139.
efficacy of control of postoperative pain ling, and range of motion after anterior 24. Weston M, Taber C, Casagranda L,
and discomfort over the first 24 h fol- cruciate ligament reconstructive surgery. Cornwall M. Changes in local blood
lowing surgery, Tecnol1 bilateral facial Arthroscopy 1994: 10: 530–533. volume during cold gel application to
ice packs proved to be superior to no 8. Edwards DJ, Rimmer M, Keene GCR. traumatized ankles. J Orthop Sports Phys
ice therapy. The use of cold therapy in the postopera- Ther 1994: 19: 197–199.
tive management of patients undergoing 25. Wolf SL, Letbetter WD. Effect of skin
The reasons why our study failed to arthroscopic anterior cruciate ligament
confirm the accepted view that cryother- cooling on spontaneous EMG activity in
construction. Am J Sports Med 1996: triceps surae of the decerebrate cat. Brain
apy reduces the signs and symptoms of 24: 193–195. Res 1975: 91: 151–155.
acute inflammation are unclear. This 9. Ernst E, Fialka V. Ice freezes pain? A
may be due to the fact that optimal review of the clinical effectiveness of
minimum skin temperature of 15 8C was analgesic cold therapy. J Pain Symptom Address:
not achieved or maintained, that the ben- Manage 1994: 9: 56–59. Albert J. van der Westhuijzen
efits of cold therapy were masked in the 10. Fisher ES, Frame JW, Rout PG, McEn- Department of Oral and Maxillofacial
presence of adequate analgesic/anti- tegart DJ. Factors affecting the onset Surgery
and severity of pain following the surgical Dental Faculty
inflammatory control, or that ice therapy University of Stellenbosch
removal of unilateral impacted mandibu-
applied without compression adversely lar third molar teeth. Br Dent J 1988: 164: Private Bag X1
influenced our results. Recent prospec- 351–354. Tygerberg 7505
tive orthopaedic studies, that included 11. GOODMAN A, GILLMAN L. The Pharmaco- South Africa.
placebo groups as part of these studies, logic Basis of Therapeutics. 7th edn. New Tel: þ27 21 937 3089
have similarly shown no benefit from York: Macmillan 1985 (Chapter 29): Fax: þ27 21 931 2287
cold therapy alone, and the question was 674–715. E-mail : AJVDW@sun.ac.za