SEQUENCE STRATIGRAPHIC INTERPRETATION INTEGRATED WITH 3-D SEISMIC ATTRIBUTE ANALYSIS IN AN INTRACRATONIC SETTING: TOOLACHEE FORMATION, COOPER BASIN, AUSTRALIA
By Lukasz Krawczynski B.App.Sc.Dist (QUT)
Supervisors Dr. Gary Huftile Queensland University of Technology (QUT)
Dr. Gregg Webb Queensland University of Technology (QUT)
Irwan Djamaludin Santos Ltd.
Stephen Taylor Santos Ltd.
I ABSTRACT
This study integrates sequence stratigraphy of the Late Permian Toolachee Formation in the non-marine intracratonic Permian-Triassic Cooper Basin, Australia with 3-D seismic attribute analysis to predict the extent of depositional environments identified on wireline and well core data. The low resolution seismic data (tuning thickness 23 - 31 m) comprised of six seismic horizons allowed the successful testing of sequence stratigraphic interpretations of the productive Toolachee Formation that were based on wireline data. The analysis of 29 well logs and three 20 m core intervals resulted in the identification of eleven parasequences that comprise the building blocks of an overall transitional systems tract, characterised by a gradual increase in accommodation. The parasequences reflect cyclic transitions between braided and meandering fluvial systems as a result of fluctuations in sediment flux, possibly driven by Milankovitch climatic-forcing. The seismic horizon attribute maps image mostly the meandering fluvial bodies within the upper parts of the parasequences, but some maps image the lower amalgamated sand sheets and show no channel structures. Categorisation of the fluvial bodies in the overbank successions reflects a gradual decrease in sinuosity, channel width, and channel belt width up-section, supporting the overall increase in accommodation up-section. Similar acoustic impedance values for shales and sands do not suggest successful seismic forward modelling between the two lithologies. Geological interpretations suggest most imaged channel fill to be made up predominantly of fine sediments, as channel avulsion and abandonment is common and increases with time. Seismic forward modelling resulted in the interpretation of carbonaceous shale as a possible channel fill, supporting the geological interpretations. The three major identified fluvial styles; braided, meanders, and distributaries are potential targets for future exploration. Extensive sand sheets deposited from braided fluvial systems require structural traps for closure. Meandering and anastomosing channel systems represent excellent stratigraphic traps, such as the basal sands/gravels of laterally accreted point bars.
II
STATEMENT OF ORIGINAL WORK The work contained in this thesis has not been previously submitted for a degree or diploma at any other higher education institution. To the best of my knowledge and belief, the thesis contains no material previously published or written by another person except where due reference is made.
Signed: ..
Date: ..
III ACKNOWLEDGEMENT This project was made possible by Santos Ltd, providing the dataset, office space, plotters, hardware, and softwares.
I am very grateful to my supervisors Dr Gary Huftile and Dr Gregg Webb for invaluable guidance and support. Both have been tremendous, helping me when ever and where ever they could.
I would also like to thank a number of people in Santos Ltd. First of all, Irwan Djamaludin and Stephen Taylor for their time and assistance throughout the last two years. Thank you: Patrick McEffer, Zsolt Baumgartner Hamerli, for introducing me to the geophysical softwares. Trinetta Herdy, Olaf Kloss for reviewing my sequence stratigraphy. Gregg Spencer, for reviewing my geophysical interpretations and numerous drafts. Ray Spicer, for helping me to find my way around Geolog. Werner Dutler, for training me to become the first Who wants to be a millionaire winner in Australia. From the inventor of the first jet engine to the inventor of the radio, he knows them all!
And of course, special thanks go to Natasha Hui who assisted and guided me with all the above and more. Thank you for all the food, especially the home-baked biscuits. Thank you for the lifts home. Thank you for showing me you water polo skills in the hall ways. Thank you, Tash.
Thank you to all the people who contributed to this project and made it a valuable experience.
1 TABLE OF CONTENTS
ABSTRACT.............................................................................................. I STATEMENT OF AUTHORSHIP...................................................... II ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS ................................................................. III INTRODUCTION.................................................................................... 4 GEOLOGICAL SETTING..............................................................................................5 METHODOLOGY AND BACKGROUND........................................ 10 DATA.........................................................................................................................10 WELL LOG DESCRIPTIONS........................................................................................10 WELL CORE DESCRIPTIONS......................................................................................10 SEQUENCE STRATIGRAPHY......................................................................................11 3-D SEISMIC ATTRIBUTE ANALYSIS..........................................................................12 MODERN FLUVIAL ANALOGUES ...............................................................................14 CATEGORISATION OF SEDIMENTARY FEATURES.....................................................14 CROSS PLOTS............................................................................................................14 RESULTS: STRATIGRAPHIC SETTING AND CORRELATION15 WELL LOG DESCRIPTIONS........................................................................................15 WELL CORE DESCRIPTIONS......................................................................................17 INTERPRETATION OF WELL CORES AND LOGS ........................................................20 3-D SEISMIC ATTRIBUTE ANALYSIS ........................................... 30 SEISMIC RESOLUTION ..............................................................................................30 ATTRIBUTES .............................................................................................................32 COMPARISON OF ATTRIBUTE IMAGES TO MODERN FUVIAL ANALOGUES...............32 INTERPRETATION OF SEDIMENTARY FEATURES .....................................................33 CATEGORISATION OF SEDIMENTARY FEATURES.....................................................41 CROSS PLOTS............................................................................................................43 DISCUSSION......................................................................................... 45 EXPLORATION POTENTIAL.......................................................................................50 CONCLUSIONS .................................................................................... 54 REFERENCES....................................................................................... 57
2
LIST OF FIGURES FIGURE 1 LOCATION OF THE PROJECT AREA ..................................................................6 FIGURE 2 OUTLINE AND GEOLOGICAL SETTING OF THE PROJECT AREA ..............................7 FIGURE 3 PERMIAN PALYNOSTRATIGRAPHY OF THE COOPER BASIN ...................................9 FIGURE 4 WELL LOG DESCRIPTION OF JUDGA NORTH 1 ..................................................16 FIGURE 5 INTERPRETED CORE LOGS ...........................................................................18 FIGURE 6 CHRONOSTRATIGRAPHIC FRAMEWORK A A.................................................24 FIGURE 7 SYNTHETIC SEISMOGRAM SUPERIMPOSED ON A SEISMIC TRACE.........................31 FIGURE 8 MODERN FLUVIAL ANALOGUE OF A CHANNEL BELT .........................................33 FIGURE 9 ISOCHRON, AMPLITUDE WIDTH, DIP AND TWT STRUCTURE EXAMPLES ................34 FIGURE 10 SEISMIC FEATURE 1..................................................................................36 FIGURE 11 SEISMIC FEATURES 2, 3, AND 4....................................................................37 FIGURE 12 SEISMIC FEATURE 5..................................................................................38 FIGURE 13 SEISMIC FEATURE 6..................................................................................39 FIGURE 14 DUPLICATE OF SEISMIC FEATURE 1 .............................................................40 FIGURE 15 CATEGORISED FLUVIAL BODIES ON P3 AMPLITUDE HORIZON MAP.....................42 FIGURE 16 ACOUSTIC IMPEDANCE VS GAMMA RAY........................................................43 FIGURE 17 FORWARD MODELLING .............................................................................48 FIGURE 18 RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN CHANNEL MORPHOLOGY AND RESERVOIR GEOMETRY51
LIST OF TABLES TABLE 1 LITHOFACIES DESCRIPTION...........................................................................19 TABLE 2 CHRONOSTRATIGRAPHIC NOMENCLATURE OF THE TOOLACHEE FORMATION AND THEIR CORRESPONDING SEISMIC HORIZONS......................................................................30 TABLE 3 CATEGORISATION OF FLUVIAL BODIES ...........................................................41
3
LIST OF APPENDICES APPENDIX 1 FLUVIAL SYSTEMS AND MODERN FLUVIAL ANALOGUES APPENDIX 2 SEQUENCE STRATIGRAPHIC CORRELATIONS APPENDIX 3 SANTOS LTD. WELL CUTTINGS DESCRIPTIONS APPENDIX 4 WELL CORE DESCRIPTIONS AND PHOTOS APPENDIX 5 SANTOS LTD. ROCK TYPING APPENDIX 6 TUNING THICKNESS CALCULATIONS APPENDIX 7 HORIZON ATTRIBUTE MAPS APPENDIX 8 CATEGORISATION OF FLUVIAL BODIES APPENDIX 9 ACOUSTIC IMPEDANCE VS GAMMA RAY CROSS PLOT DATA
4 INTRODUCTION 3-D seismic attribute maps are becoming increasingly important for interpretations of depositional environments and sedimentary features. In the past, high to medium resolution 3-D seismic data successfully assisted in the development of sequence stratigraphic and reservoir models at relatively shallow depths (Posamentier, 2001; Miall, 2002; Carter, 2003). Those authors were able to image fluvial architecture on attribute maps, allowing testing of specific sequence stratigraphic interpretations. However, most exploration targets occur at depths where seismic data are generated with lower frequencies. The 3-D seismic data at the depth of the Toolachee Formation (>2200 m) reflect more typical depths for hydrocarbon reservoirs. This work successfully tested 3-D seismic attribute analysis from relatively low frequency seismic data in the non-marine Upper Permian Toolachee Formation of the intracratonic Cooper Basin, Australia against a new sequence stratigraphic interpretation.
This study identified eleven parasequences with alternating channel sand-rich and overbank-rich successions that correlate over the entire project area, representing the building blocks of a larger transitional systems tract. The interpreted depositional environments include several cyclic transitions between braided and meandering systems, both vertically and horizontally, changing up-section to a more overbank- and lacustrine-dominated environment. The sequence stratigraphic interpretation is based on detailed well log and core analysis. The cyclic transitions in depositional environment reflect relative changes between subsidence and sediment flux. Milankovitch-induced climatic forcing may be the main driving mechanism for cyclic sedimentation within this intracratonic setting. Images of meandering fluvial bodies within the upper parts and continuous sand sheets within the lower parts of the parasequences, visible on the 3-D attribute horizon maps aided in the sequence stratigraphic interpretation. The categorisation of the fluvial bodies reflects an overall increase in accommodation as the sinuosity of the identified fluvial bodies decreases up-section. Geological interpretations were compared to seismic forward modelling in order to determine possible channel fills. The combination of the results obtained from the different methods resulted in a detailed sequence stratigraphic model for the
5 Toolachee Formation in the North Naccowlah study area that can be used for the prediction of hydrocarbon / seal distribution within the identified fluvial bodies. . The results are significant in: 1) showing the value of 3-D seismic attribute analysis, even in low frequency data generated at considerable depth; 2) documenting the occurrence of repetitive parasequences in an intracratonic setting that was probably not influenced by eustacy; and 3) in locating and defining different types of targets for exploration, and in particular, isolated stratigraphic traps.
GEOLOGICAL SETTING The intracratonic Permian-Triassic Cooper Basin is a northeast trending structural depression covering approximately 130000 km in northeastern South Australia and southwestern Queensland (Figure 1). The basin incorporates Permo- Triassic glacial, fluvial, and lacustrine origin (Kantsler et al., 1983; Heath, 1989; Apak et al., 1997). Permian strata unconformably overlie eroded Cambrian-Devonian clastics and volcanics of the Warburton Basin and Carboniferous igneous rocks (Battersby, 1976; Gatehouse, 1986). The Permian-Triassic sequence, which attains a maximum thickness of 2 km, is unconformably overlain by J urassic-Cretaceous sequences of the Eromanga Basin (Kantsler et al., 1983; Heath, 1989; Apak et al., 1997). The Cooper Basin developed under a mild compressional regime represented predominantly by two arcuate anticlinal trends, the northeast trending Gidgealpa- Merrimelia- Innamincka (GMI) and the subparallel Nappacoongee-Murteree trends. Adjacent to the trends are the Patchawarra, Nappameri and Tenappera troughs. Both types of structural trend are related to fault-controlled basement highs that were reactivated during Permian deposition (Hamerli, 1999). The North Naccowlah study area is situated in the southwestern Queensland portion of the Cooper Basin. It comprises the area covered by the North Naccowlah 3-D dataset, situated within the northern ATP259P, 30 km east of Ballera (Figures 1 and 2).
Geologically, the area is characterised by northeast trending structures, such as the 23 km long and 5 km wide Wippo-J udga trough in the centre, the Roti-Mookoo and the Yumba structural trends to the east, as well as the Tartulla structural trend in the
6
FIGURE 1 - Outline of the Cooper Basin showing major structural elements and exploration blocks. Location of the Cooper Basin is indicated by the white box within the sub-map. Red symbol represents approximate location of the North Naccowlah 3-D survey (Santos, 2004).
This figure is not available online. Please consult the hardcopy thesis available from the QUT Library
7
FIGURE 2 Outline and geological setting of the North Naccowlah 3-D seismic survey that defines the study area. Inset shows major structural trends within the study area. Arrows mark locations of seismic features within the survey. Line A A represents path of cross section from Judga North 1 Mookoo 1; line B B from Judga 2 to Tartulla 2 (Appendix 2); and line C C from Costa South 1 to Mookoo 1 (Appendix 2).
This figure is not available online. Please consult the hardcopy thesis available from the QUT Library
8 northern part. The southern part of the study area is characterised by the northwest- trending J udga-North / Windigo fault trend (Figure 2).
The Toolachee Formation represents the beginning of the second fluviatile cycle in the Cooper Basin (Figure 3). It consists of several sub-cycles of sandstone, shale, and coal deposited during overall rising base level conditions (Kloss, 1999). Following the Daralingie Uplift and erosional period that effectively peneplaned the Cooper Basin, deposition occurred in a more tectonically quiescent environment (Apak et al., 1997). The <200 m thick Toolachee Formation has been interpreted to represent a meandering river floodplain environment (Kantsler et al., 1983). Hughes (1999) interpreted the Toolachee Formation as a series of sand-rich amalgamated crevasse splay deposits correlating over basin-wide distances within lowstand and transgressive systems tracts. Additionally, Kloss (1999) suggested that during the deposition of the Toolachee Formation, Daralingie transpressional structuring resulted in the rejuvenation of older basement structures and the development of localised topographic relief that was subsequently filled or onlapped by the various stratigraphic units of this formation. The formation is present throughout most of the southern Cooper Basin, except at the Murteree high and along the GMI trend where it pinches out (Figure 1).
9 FIGURE 3 Permian / Triassic palynostratigraphy of the Cooper Basin. Palynological zones define chronostratigraphic units of the Toolachee Formation (PC). Major unconformities represent sequence boundaries. R* represents the Daralingie Unconformity, the base of the Toolachee Formation. Location of seismic horizons is indicated with regards to chronostratigraphic units of the respective formations. Subdivision of Toolachee Formation using the nomenclature by Kloss (1999) for the Queensland sector of the Cooper Basin, but with horizons picked for this study.
LATE CARBONIFEROUS/PERMIAN PALYNOSTRATIGRAPHY OF THE COOPER BASIN AGE (HARLANDETAL, 1989) PALYNOLOGICAL ZONE COOPER BASIN LITHOSTRATIGRAPHY SEQUENCE BOUNDARIES SEISMIC HORIZONS PT3 PT2 PT1 PP6 PP3.2 PP5 PP4.3 PP4.2 PP4.1 PP3.3 260 250 240 DOONMULLAMBR. PANINGMBR. CALLAMURRAMEMBER TOOLACHEE FM. N3* R* P S T U V L* P1 P2 P4 P3 N2 DARALINGIEFM. ROSENEATH SHALE EPSILON FM. MURTEREE SHALE GILPEPPEE SHALE WIMMASST. N SantosLtd, A.C.N. 007550923 CHRONOSTRATI- GRAPHIC UNITS PC10 PU70 PC60 PC50 PC40 PC30 PC20 PC00 TC00 TC90 TC80 TC50 TC40 TC20 LATE PERMIAN / TRIASSIC PALYNOSTRATIGRAPHY OF THE COOPER BASIN P E R M I A N
E A R L Y
DARALINGIE UNCONFORMITY
10 METHODOLOGY AND BACKGROUND This study utilised wireline, well core, and 3-D seismic data.
DATA The North Naccowlah 3-D seismic survey was acquired in 2001 and covers an area of 718 km with grid lines positioned at approximately 40 m spacings in two directions. It has undergone various processing sequences to produce a high quality data set. The fully migrated, spectrally whitened 8-60 Hz seismic volume was used for seismic interpretation. From this volume a tuning thickness range from 23 m to 32 m was obtained for the Toolachee Formation (Appendix 6). The data from this area also include 29 wireline logs and well completion reports (Appendix 3), as well as three 20 m cores.
WELL LOG DESCRIPTIONS The analysis of logs of the 29 wells located in the study area resulted in the interpretation of a similar suite of correlatable depositional environments. Parasequence boundaries were determined as flooding surfaces for each well. The J udga North 1 well was described in detail and the depositional environments and parasequences were interpreted from their gamma ray and sonic log expressions.
WELL CORE DESCRIPTIONS The analysis of limited well cores was used to reconstruct a detailed vertical lithological profile. Where petrophysical logs and attribute maps are available, it is important to correlate core lithology with the geophysical data. The ground truthing of the geophysical data resulted in an understanding of the variations seen on the attribute maps and different gamma ray log responses on the petrophysical logs, suggesting the causes of these patterns. However, certain limitations must be taken into account.1) Core is not available for most intervals of interest. 2) It is not always possible to determine sedimentary structures that are larger than the core sample from a 10 cm diameter core.
11 20 m core intervals from Tartulla 1 and 5, and Wippo South 1 were evaluated to identify the lithology and depositional environments of the given wells as a test of the sequence stratigraphic interpretation (Appendix 4). The lithofacies in the Toolachee Formation were classified using the scheme of Miall (1978) with minor modifications and additions.
SEQUENCE STRATIGRAPHY The concept of sequence stratigraphy has become a valuable tool for predicting the occurrence and geometry of sedimentary strata. On the basis of studies of marine rocks, sequence stratigraphic concepts have commonly been proposed for and applied to fluvial-dominated non-marine basins. The sequence stratigraphy of intracratonic basins differs from that of marine basins primarily in the source of accommodation. Within intracratonic basins, changes in accommodation on a regional scale are controlled by tectonism, subsidence and climate. The stratigraphy of marine basins primarily reflects changes in eustacy. Currie (1997) proposed a terminology for sequences in intracratonic settings that avoids reference to sea level. The degradational systems tract that develops during times of decreased or negative accommodation generation in intracratonic sequences is equivalent to the falling- stage and lowstand systems tracts of marine sequences. The transitional systems tract corresponds to the early transgressive systems tract. This systems tract is characteristic of the beginning of accommodation generation. Fluvial styles may undergo major architectural changes during this phase. The aggradational systems tract is comparable to the late transgressive to highstand systems tracts. Detailed discussions of sequence stratigraphy within non-marine basins are given by Shanley and McCabe (1994) and Miall (1996).
For this study, three cross sections, involving 29 wells were correlated on the basis of observed sequences (Appendix 2). Sections were chosen to run south-north, west- east, and southwest-northeast, respectively, to cover most of the project area (Figure 2). Correlation is based on the identification and interpretation of apparent parasequences that occur in wells over the entire project area (Figure 4). The correlation is of great significance, as it constrained the location of horizons used for
12 the 3-D seismic attribute analysis.
Van Wagoner et al. (1988) used the term parasequences to describe the basic building blocks of sequences. By definition a parasequence is a relatively conformable succession of genetically related beds or bedsets bounded by flooding surfaces or their correlative surfaces. In special positions within a sequence, parasequences may be bounded above or below by sequence boundaries (modified from Van Wagoner et al., 1990). Aggradation, progradation, and retrogradation of parasequences may be related to base level change, although parasequence stacking patterns are significantly affected by sediment supply and climate. The identification and interpretation of depositional environments and facies from well logs assists in the correlation of sedimentary features visible on seismic attribute maps and the determination of parasequences and continental system tracts.
The chronostratigraphic nomenclature developed by Santos Ltd. for the Cooper Basin has expanded on the generic palynostratigraphic scheme originally outlined by Price et al. (1985). The naming system for key stratigraphic surfaces is alphanumeric. The prefix is based on traditional seismic horizon nomenclature conventions in the Cooper Basin, here (P) for Toolachee Formation. The suffix denotes the type of surface, regional unconformity (U), regional chronostratigraphic marker (C), and local chronostratigraphic marker (L). A number that increases with depth denotes the relative stratigraphic position (Strong et al., 2002). The Santos terminology was applied to the sequence stratigraphic framework developed by the author, but chronostratigraphic horizons were picked independently for the present study.
3-D SEISMIC ATTRIBUTE ANALYSIS In comparison to the 2-D seismic method, the 3-D method is a different way of gathering and presenting seismic data. Instead of showing the subsurface beneath a profile line, 3-D displays give an areal picture from the shallowest reflector to the deepest one that can be imaged seismically (Walton, 1972). The general aim of 3-D surveys is to achieve a higher degree of resolution of the subsurface geology as well as more accurate structural geometries by eliminating out of plane reflectors.
13
Seismic horizons for this study were picked as flooding surfaces in a sequence stratigraphic framework. 3-D seismic attribute analysis was used as the major interpretation tool. It assists in the interpretation of a sequence stratigraphic framework, as it constrains the geometry and extent of sedimentary features, as well as that of structural features absent from geological correlations made from well data or isolated outcrops. Knowledge of such factors improves well locations for more efficient hydrocarbon exploration. The ability to improve channel and sandstone body geometry also provides a better understanding of the processes that prevailed during deposition.
SEISMIC INTERPRETATION AND RESOLUTION. The fundamental objective of the 3-D seismic method is increased resolution. Resolution has both horizontal and vertical aspects of which the latter are limited compared to well logs and core data due to the frequency content of the seismic data. Sheriff (1985) discussed in detail seismically unresolvable stratigraphic thickness changes that are less than the tuning thickness. Those stratigraphic changes are reflected as lateral amplitude changes that can be barely noticeable on seismic sections. Brown (1996), however, showed that on a horizontal section subtle and distinct changes in amplitude reflect part of an obvious pattern that may follow a thickness or lithology change in plan view. In this study, tuning thickness calculations were made to assess the resolution of the seismic data in comparison to the developed sequence stratigraphic model.
SEISMIC ATTRIBUTES. The attributes applied within this project were chosen on the basis of their outcomes in similar studies (Carter, 2003). Previous investigations in the Cooper Basin (Hamerli, 1999; Hui, 2001), and in other basins, were studied to select attributes that resulted in the best possible images of sedimentary features. Two-way time structure (TWT), reflection amplitude, variance, isochron, event width, and dip were considered to be of great success. Attributes such as two-way time residual were rejected after unsuccessful results in preliminary tests. Two-way time structure (TWT) of a horizon is used to define the shape of the three dimensional surface. Reflection amplitude measured at the maximum or minimum of an identified reflection is by far the most widely used and significant attribute. Posamentier (2001),
14 Miall (2002) and Carter (2003) successfully imaged fluvial bodies using amplitude attribute analysis. Variance, which is a volume based attribute, was used by Hui (2001) to image the difference between subtle changes of similar amplitudes. Isochron is another widely used attribute that images the TWT difference of two interpreted horizons, whereas event width measures the difference between zero crossings of a horizon. The dip parameter is the magnitude from a local reference, of the time gradient vector, calculated at each sample of the interpreted horizon (Rijks and J auffred, 1991).
MODERN FLUVIAL ANLOGUES Depositional environments associated with fluvial systems were reviewed (Appendix 1). This included the sedimentology of meandering and braided streams, floodplains, lakes and peat mires. The facies characteristics and geometries associated with modern fluvial systems were used as analogues to support the interpretation of depositional environments in the Toolachee Formation, as developed from well logs and horizon attribute maps.
CATEGORISATION OF FLUVIAL BODIES Fluvial bodies identified on the 3-D horizon amplitude maps were categorised and classified to assist in the testing and refinement of the sequence stratigraphic model (Appendix 8).
CROSS PLOTS The application of cross plots to this project aimed to use seismic attributes to predict the extent and type of lithology in locations where well data are sparse. Acoustic impedance was cross-plotted against gamma ray values to establish a possible relationship between attributes and lithologies. Successful results were considered for further forward modelling (Appendix 9).
15 RESULTS: STRATIGRAPHIC SETTING AND CORRELATION WELL LOG DESCRIPTIONS A detailed analysis of the gamma ray log (GR) and sonic log (DT) of the J udga North 1 well was conducted to assess the basic depositional environments and parasequences in the Toolachee Formation (Figure 4). J udga North 1 is representative of the wells in the study area, similar features occur in the other wells.
Generally, the gamma ray and sonic values (slowness) increase gradually towards the top of the formation indicating a change from a channel sand-rich environments to a more overbank dominated environments. Cycles of constant cylindrical low gamma ray pattern (70 - 80 GAPI), commonly with a bell-shaped pattern on top, are observed within the channel sand-rich environment. The bell shaped pattern is typically defined by a series of relatively small gamma ray spikes that show an overall increase in the gamma ray value. The cycle is either closed by an interval of constant high gamma ray values (>150 GAPI) or a wide spike (~3 m) of low gamma ray (60 GAPI), but high sonic value (>130 DT). Up-section the cylindrical patterns become thinner and are replaced gradually by more dominant bell-shaped patterns. The patterns change towards the top of the formation with small gamma ray spikes and intervals of constant high gamma ray values being more abundant and cyclicity becoming more difficult to detect. Intervals of a gradual decrease in gamma ray value also occur (Figure 4).
The constant cylindrical low gamma ray patterns were interpreted as multistorey sands representing amalgamated channel deposits. The bell-shaped pattern indicates the upward fining of a point bar. The overlying high gamma ray values are typical of overbank deposits. Low gamma ray spikes in overbank deposits are linked to possible crevasse splay deposits. Intervals of low gamma ray with high sonic values represent coals or extensive peat mires. The high gamma ray values towards the top of the Toolachee Formation are interpreted as overbank deposits, possibly with some lacustrine deposits. Intervals with decreasing gamma ray values (i.e., coarsening-up) are possible crevasse deltas in a lacustrine-dominated environment. Parasequence boundaries are located at the top of each fining-upward cycle.
D E P F T DT US/F 140 40 MFS FS FS FS FS FS FS FS FS FS FS SB 2100 2150 2200 M
FIGURE 4 Identification of parasequences and architectural elements at Judga North 1 based on the wireline character of the gamma ray (GR) and sonic logs (DT). The parasequences are bounded by regional correlative flooding surfaces (FS). The overall transitional systems tract is bounded by a sequence boundary (SB) at the bottom and a maximum flooding surface (MFS) at the top. The Toolachee Formation is subdivided into a lower and upper unit.
17 WELL CORE DESCRIPTIONS 20 m core intervals from Tartulla 1, Tartulla 5 and Wippo South 1 were evaluated to identify the lithology and depositional environments of the cored interval of the given well to test interpretations based on wireline data (Figure 5 and Appendix 4). Nine lithofacies in the Toolachee Formation were classified using the scheme of Miall (1978) with minor modifications and additions (Table 1). Lithofacies Gm and Gmg range in thickness from several centimetres up to 60 cm. Inverse and normal grading of the conglomerate is observed in lithofacies Gmg. Massive bedding is absent and crude stratification is particularly associated with distinct imbrication in lithofacies Gm. The descriptions of lithofacies Sp, Sr, Ss and Sh were adopted from Miall (1978), with the addition of mud rock laminations and inclusions of quartz pebbles. Lithofacies Sn represents sandstone with no recognisable structures and with associated soft sediment deformation and the presence of rootlets. Lithofacies Fl represents sandy laminated mud rock. Lithofacies Fm represents massive mudrock. The assessment of architectural elements of fluvial and overbank deposits was restricted owing to the small amount of available core. Altogether, three major facies association; channels (CH), crevasse splays (CS), and floodplain fines (FF) were recognized that represent fluvial and overbank depositional environments (Figure 5), containing different associations of lithofacies. The channels facies association was further subdivided into braided channels (CH-BR), meandering channels (CH-ME), and crevasse channels (CH-CV).
CHANNELS FACIES (CH). The channels identified on the well logs range from 0.6 m to 3.3 m in thickness. They are typically multistorey and are characterised by a conglomeratic lag that typically defined as lithofacies Gm or Gmg. The bases of the channels are either scoured or gradational, but the assessment is difficult due to the small core diameter. The channel fill is gradational, becoming finer towards the top and consists of lithofacies Sp, Sr, Sh and Sn. Quartz pebbles as well as mud rip-up clasts are common. Scattered mudrock laminations within the sand bodies and soft sediment deformation were also observed, predominantly towards the top of the facies.
18
FIGURE 5 Interpreted well core sections of Tartulla 1 and 5, and Wippo South 1. Respective gamma ray logs of cored intervals are shown to the left. Central column represents identified facies. Solid and dashed black lines represent parasequence boundaries.
19
TABLE 1 Lithofacies descriptions from cores within the Toolachee Formation (modified after Miall, 1978).
Lithofacies Lithofacies Description Sedimentary Structures Interpretation Gm matrix supported conglomerate weak grading, poorly sorted, sandy matrix, rip up clasts of mud coal, quartz clasts, some imbrication, crude stratification high energy traction processes, lags, longitudinal and transverse bars Gmg graded matrix supported conglomerate inverse +normal grading, poorly sorted, sandy matrix, rip up clasts of mud +coal, quartz clasts, some imbrication high energy traction processes, lag deposits, longitudinal and transverse bars Sp sandstone, fine - very coarse, in some cases pebbly planar cross bedded sand, scattered mudrock laminations and intraclasts moderate energy traction processes Sr sandstone, fine coarse ripple cross laminated sand, scattered mudrock laminations and intraclasts, lower flow regime Sh sandstone, very fine - coarse, in some cases pebbly horizontally bedded sand, parallel laminations, scattered mudrock laminations and intraclasts plane bed flow (critical flow)
Sn sandstone, fine - very coarse, in some cases pebbly massive no interpretation Ss sandstone, fine - very coarse, in some cases pebbly shallow scours, poorly sorted, mud and quartz intraclasts scour fill Fl Sandstone, silt, mud sand-laminated mud rock, fine laminations, small ripples, bioturbation, rootlets, soft sediment deformation overbank, abandoned channel, wanning flood deposits Fm massive mud, silt massive mud rock, rootlets distal overbank, abandoned channel, or drape deposits,
20
CREVASSE SPLAYS FACIES (CS). Sandstones identified as crevasse splays are predominantly located within shale-dominated successions. They range in thickness from 0.15 m to 1.8 m, and are characterised by lithofacies Sr, which is predominantly fine to medium grained sandstone. The majority of crevasse splays do not show any significant gradation in grain sizes. Mudrock laminations are common, and rootlets and flasers also occur.
FLOODPLAIN FINES (FF). The floodplain fines are fine sediments represented by lithofacies Fl and Fm. They range in thickness from 0.15 to 3.3 m. Lithofacies Fl shows a higher sand content in comparison to lithofacies Fm, which is massive mudrock. Both lithofacies are associated with rootlets. Soft sediment deformation is observed in lithofacies Fl, and scattered quartz pebbles occur within the floodplain fines.
INTERPRETATION OF WELL LOGS AND CORES INTERPRETATION OF CHANNELS (CH). The majority of channel facies identified in cores represent braided and meandering deposits, whereas crevasse channel deposits represent the minority. The channel facies, including Wippo South 1 core (7445 ft - 7466 ft), were interpreted as a braided depositional environment. The interval is characterised by seven stacked channels averaging ~1 m in thickness. The channel lags consist of lithofacies Gm and Gmg. The channel fill consists mainly of lithofacies Sl with minor lithofacies Sp and Sh present. Planar cross-bedded sands range in thickness from 0.15 m to 1.5 m and are predominantly observed overlying channel lags. Mud laminations within the channel fills are rare to absent. Mud rip-up clasts are located within lithofacies Gm and Gmg. Quartz pebbles are common. The abundance of conglomeratic fill, absence of mudrock between and within the channels, and the shallow depth and tabular cross bedding suggest a high energy environment most resembling that of a shallow perennial braided system (Miall, 1996). This interpretation is consistent with the respective cylindrical gamma ray expression that suggests amalgamated channels. The intervals between 7820 - 7830 ft and 7340 - 7858 ft of Tartulla 5 core are also interpreted as braided fluvial deposits.
21 That interpretation is supported by the low argillaceous content (2.5 - 5 %) and constant cylindrical pattern of low gamma ray values of those intervals, which are typical for braided sands. A transition from a braided to meandering environment is evidenced in Tartulla 5 at 7340 ft. The sands become finer and are dominated by lithofacies Sr, eventually grading upward into overbank-dominated successions.
The depositional environment between 7947 ft and 7955 ft in Tartulla 1 is interpreted as a point bar deposit within a meandering river system. It exhibits a bell shaped gamma ray pattern reflecting a conglomeratic lag grading into sandstone and eventually floodplain fines. The sandstone is predominantly made up of lithofacies Sr, which is characteristic of a low to moderate energy environment such as a meandering channel point bar. The increased content of fine material towards the top supports the interpretation. The channel fills located at the bottom of the cores of Tartulla 1 and 5 represent similar depositional environments (Figure 5). The gradation from lithofacies Sp into lithofacies Sr is associated with a drop in energy. Although a typical fining upward pattern was not obvious in the core, the respective gamma ray log exhibits a bell-shaped pattern.
Previous studies of the Tartulla Field by Hughes (1999) interpreted all of the channel facies as small channels and amalgamated crevasse deposits in an overall meandering floodplain. However, due to the high abundance of lithofacies Gm and Gmg representing conglomeratic channel lags, other possible depositional environments must be considered. The study of crevasse splays and crevasse channel deposits has been limited; quantitative and architectural aspects are not well known. Fielding (1986), Eberth and Miall (1991), Mjoes et al. (1993), and Farrell (2001) studied crevasse deposits in outcrop sections. Scattered conglomeratic crevasse channel lags described in those studies consist predominantly of overbank rip-up clasts as well as organic debris. Such channel lags occur in Tartulla 1 at 7941 ft, and in Wippo South 1 at 74875 ft. Crevasse channel deposits were also interpreted between 7469 and 7479 ft at Wippo South 1. However, the conglomeratic fill of the majority of channel lags consists of well rounded quartz clasts. The maturity of these lags does not support an interpretation of a crevasse channel deposit. Neither can it be assumed that any major distributary channel was capable of carrying the conglomeratic bed load at bankfull
22 depth. Detailed rock typing of core chips and cuttings of Tartulla 1 and 5 conducted by Santos Ltd. show a low argillaceous content (2.5 - 5 %) in the sandstones that make up the channel fills (Appendix 5). Crevasse deposits generally contain high argillaceous content as deposition is sudden during flooding events. Hence, the lower argillaceous content also supports the interpretation of most channels as braided stream deposits. The high correlability of the sands is also more consistent with a braided stream interpretation. The channel sands consistently correlate across the entire study area.
The sequence stratigraphic framework of the North Naccowlah study area is based on the correlation of parasequences that reflect the alternation between those braided and meandering fluvial deposits. Hughes (1999) interpreted the channel packages as major splay complexes and crevasse facies that correlate over the entire Tartulla Field within a degradational systems tract. That interpretation is rejected for reasons outlined and because crevasse deposits are generally limited in lateral extent. The interpretation of an amalgamated crevasse splay depositional environment is also disfavoured because channels tend to rework such deposits, limiting the degree to which they can be multistorey. If accommodation decrease is rapid, channels will incise and with time, flooding events are less likely to breach the banks. Reworking of crevasse splay deposits should also occur during an overall transitional systems tract. The sequence stratigraphic model shows the lower Toolache Formation to have occupied a paleohigh around the Tartulla and Wippo area, being less susceptible to flooding events, but more inclined to reworking of sediments. This is also indicated by the absence of well developed coals around these areas at that time. Hence, stacked crevasse splays deposits are unlikely to have developed.
INTERPRETATION OF CREVASSE SPLAYS (CS). Crevasse splay deposits occur on floodplains where rising floodwaters breach natural levees. They are delta-like deposits that form adjacent to the margins of main channels. As the sediments enter the floodplain through crevasse channels, deposition takes place as a result of flow expansion and loss of power forming lens-shaped bodies up to 10 km long, 5 km wide and 2 - 6 m thick (Boggs, 1995; Miall, 1996). Crevasse splay deposits interpreted from the cores are fine to medium grained sandstones that interfinger with floodplain
23 fines. The interbedded laminae of mudrock and the abundance of ripple cross laminations indicate a low energy environment such as that of a floodplain, with the scattered presence of rootlets supporting the interpretation. Crevasse splays that consist of finer grained sandstone and greater abundance of mudrock laminations are more distal to the main crevasse channel. Proximal crevasse splay deposits such as at Wippo South 1 (7469 - 7479 ft) are composed of coarser material that contains mud rip-up clasts. The higher energy is also reflected by the presence of lithofacies Sp.
INTERPRETATION OF FLOODPLAIN FINES (FF). Floodplain fines are fine grained sediments that settle out of suspension from floodwaters carried into the floodbasin. They are sheet-like units many hundreds of metres or even several kilometres in lateral extent. Sedimentation generally takes place in separate increments representing individual flood events or by continual slow settling of fine grained sediment from suspension in permanent swamps or ponds (Boggs, 1995; Miall, 1996). The sediments interpreted as floodplain fines consist of lithofacies Fl and Fm. The thinly interbedded sandstones within lithofacies Fl are associated with flooding events that introduce coarser sediments into the floodbasin. The proximal overbank environment is the site of a greater abundance of flooding events as well as crevasse splay deposits such as at Tartulla 1 (7955 - 7977 ft). The distal part of the floodbasin shows little to no influx of sand, being characterised of massive mudrock deposits such as lithofacies Fm. Rootlets, which are common within the floodplain fines, represent interfluve vegetation during periods of quiescence.
INTERPRETATION OF PARASEQUENCES. Altogether, eleven parasequences were identified by the author in the Toolachee Formation of the North Naccowlah 3- D survey (Figures 4 and 6, Appendix 2). They are separated by flooding surfaces and each parasequence basically represents a fining up succession with channel sands at the base and overbank fines and coals at the top. The analysis of palynological data shows that the regional PC 50 and PC 60 sequences are absent within the North Naccowlah study area (Kloss, 2004). Deposition of the Toolachee Formation commenced after a period of active uplift in the Cooper Basin, which generated the Daralingie Unconformity (PU 70), the lower sequence boundary.
24 FIGURE 6 Chronostraigraphic framework A A for the North Naccowlah study area based on sequence stratigraphic principles. Chronostratigraphic markers represent bounding surfaces of eleven parasequences that can be correlated on a regional scale. The wireline logs are gamma ray (left column) and sonic (right column) logs. Gamma ray response is measured in API units (GAPI). The sonic log is recorded in microseconds per foot (/F).
25 The uplift generated negative accommodation resulting in incision and erosion of the underlying siltstones, fine grained sandstones, shales and coals of the Patchawarra Formation by Toolachee braided channel systems (Beaumont-Smith, 1999). The lowest parasequence, PL 47, occurs just above the lower sequence boundary.
Parasequence PL 47. Amalgamated channels interpreted from the electronic logs (e- logs) for the base of the PL 47 parasequence reflect medium to coarse grained channel sandstones that were interpreted as braided river deposits. Initial sedimentation was restricted to the low-lying areas such as Windigo, Roti, Costa and J udga, reaching thicknesses up to 15 m. The absence of PL 47 in the wells located in the northern part of the study area is caused by its onlap onto the Tartulla, Wippo, Mookoo, and Yumba paleohighs (Figure 2). The PL 47 chronostratigraphic marker at the top of the parasequence represents the first flooding surface within the study area, and is marked by an extensive coal that reaches its maximum thickness (~3 m) towards the south.
Parasequence PL 45. Continuous infilling of the low areas allowed deposition onto the paleohighs. However, onlapping of the PL 45 still occurred at Yumba and partly around the Wippo area, which was characterised by amalgamated channels at that time. The depositional environment differed slightly from that of PL 47, with finer sediments being deposited on the floodplains, and some coal seams indicating flooding events at the top of the parasequence. Maximum thicknesses of around 11 m were attained at Costa, J udga and Carney. Meandering channels migrated across the floodplains, appearing on the logs as isolated fining up sandstone intervals interbedded with siltstones and coals, as seen around the Roti and Raworth areas. The upper part of the PL 45 parasequence is present in the core obtained from Tartulla 1. The gamma ray log of that interval shows a bell shaped pattern characteristic of the point bar of a meandering stream. The interpretation of the core supports that interpretation. The sandstone contains a greater abundance of mudrock and organic materials towards the top indicating a drop in energy such as that of channel avulsion and abandonment. The overlying floodplain fines grade from a proximal to more distal overbank environment with a decrease in sand content. The PL 45 flooding surface is indicated by a coal in the south and southwest, whereas in the remaining
26 area it shows up as a maximum gamma ray inflection in overbank deposits.
Parasequence PC 40. A similar sequence of conditions prevailed throughout the deposition of the PC 40, which onlaps onto the Yumba high. The thickest sections of the PC 40 parasequence (~16 m - 21 m) correspond to amalgamated channels visible on the logs, which represent the major depocentres in the southwest. The upper part of the PC 40 represents an increase in the deposition of finer sediments. The PC 40 marker is picked above a coal in the southwest and north, and as a maximum gamma ray inflection in the remainder of the study area.
Parasequence PL 37. The PL 37 covers the entire study area and represents a time of high sediment flux, as shown by thick amalgamated sandstone beds seen on the logs, and attaining maximum thicknesses of 20 m around the Windigo and Wippo areas. In comparison to the underlying PC 40, the depositional environment is more sand- dominated. Bell-shaped gamma ray patterns occur above multistorey amalgamated sandstone beds reflecting point bars of meandering rivers observed at the base of the overbank successions at the Costa, J udga, Roti and Mookoo areas. The PL 37 flooding surface is determined primarily on a maximum gamma ray inflection, with the exception of the Tartulla and Costa areas, where it was picked on top of a coal.
Parasequence PL 35. The initial depositional environment of the PL 35 parasequence is similar to that of PL 37 being characterised by multistorey amalgamated channel deposits. A decrease in energy is apparent by the increase of finer sediments towards the top of PL 35. The character of the sandstone intervals changes from one dominated by amalgamated channel systems to more isolated channels up section, reflecting a change to a meandering fluvial system, except in the Wippo area where the amalgamated system prevails. In the very southern and central part of the study area, the flooding surface is represented by a well developed coal. Where the coal is absent, the flooding surface reflects the boundary between the overbank and subsequent fluvial environments.
27 Parasequence PC 30. The deposition of the PC 30 parasequence is associated with a transition from channel sands at the base to an overbank-dominated depositional environment towards the top. The extensive coal seam at the top of the PC 30 can be correlated over the entire survey, representing an extensive flooding event. The considerably thinner sandstones present at the base of the PC 30 show an isolated to amalgamated channel pattern.
Parasequences PL 27 - PC 00. The parasequences from PC 00 to PL 27 are dominated by fine grained sediments and coals with scattered minor isolated channel and crevasse splay or delta deposits, characterised by an overall fining up succession. The PC 00 marker represents the maximum flooding surface that marks the top of the Toolachee Formation. The base of the overlying Nappamerri Formation was interpreted as lacustrine shale and siltstone (Battersby, 1976), which represents the beginning of an aggradational systems tract. Isolated meandering channels that are represented by gradually fining up sandstones are predominantly located within the PL 27 and PL 25 parasequences. Channel abundance decreases gradually through the remaining parasequences towards the top of the formation. The coal seams within the upper parasequences are particularly well developed along the western part of the study area around the Costa, Wippo and, to a lesser extent, J udga and Tartulla areas. They are limited in their lateral extent and do not correlate over a broad area on wireline logs. The upper unit of the Toolachee Formation shows a gradual increase in gamma ray values, suggesting possible shaley lacustrine depositional environments at the top. The flooding surfaces of the respective parasequences were in some cases difficult to determine due to the overbank-dominated environment, and are primarily represented by maximum gamma ray inflections.
INTERPRETATION OF SEQUENCE STRATIGRAPHY The depositional system represented by the Toolachee Formation involves the gradual infilling of an alluvial basin. Within the area of the North Naccowlah 3-D survey sedimentation occurred in eleven cycles or parasequences that can be correlated over the entire project area (Appendix 2). The parasequences can be further subdivided into sand-rich channel facies and overlying overbank-dominated facies. Previous
28 studies by Hughes (1999) on the Tartulla Field and Hui (2001) on the Central Fields (Figure 1) areas interpreted the Toolachee Formation to have been deposited within degradational, transitional and aggradational systems tracts. The high abundance of amalgamated channels above the Daralingie Unconformity (PL 45 - PU 70) (Figures 4 and 6) resembles the pattern of a late degradational systems tract. However, the regular occurrence of well developed coal seams and overbank deposits within this interval is more characteristic of an early transitional systems tract, where base level begins to rise. Within several of the interior basins of Argentina, Mancilla et al. (1988), Legarreta and Gulisano (1989), Kokogian (1991), and Legarreta and Uliana (1991) characterised transitional systems tracts as a mixture of bed load and suspension load deposits arranged as upward fining and upward thinning bedsets. The overall gradual increase in accommodation throughout the deposition of the Toolachee Formation is typical of such a transitional systems tract. Additionally, the change in channel pattern from braided to meandering, and increase in finer sediments in successive parasequences, reflects increasingly isolated channels that reflect frequent channel avulsion due to flooding, especially above the PC 30. Hence, the Toolachee Formation in the study area can be subdivided into two units: 1) a lower channel-dominated unit (PC 30 - PU 70), where multistorey sands represent mostly braided streams; and 2) an upper overbank-dominated unit (PC 00 - PC 30), where most channels represent isolated meandering streams. The PC 00 represents the maximum flooding surface marking the change to an aggradational systems tract of primarily lacustrine facies (Figures 4 and 6). The depositional environments of the lower unit reflects transitions between braided and meandering systems within each parasequence vertically, as well as laterally within some parasequences.
Previous studies on terrestrial channel patterns have shown that changes depend primarily on discharge, sediment load, and slope (Leopold and Wolmann, 1957). From past work (Kloss, 1999) and the presence of onlaps evident in the sequence stratigraphic framework of the Toolachee Formation, it is known that local low topographic highs, such as Tartulla and Wippo areas existed. A comparison of the channel patterns within the PL 45 and PL 47 parasequences between wells in high- and low-lying areas does not show any substantial difference, suggesting that the slope was too gentle to cause major changes. Although no significant channel pattern
29 changes were observed, sedimentation in the paleotopographically higher areas resulted in thinner deposits. A high channel-sand to overbank ratio in the Tartulla and Wippo areas suggests the bypassing and reworking of sediments to low-lying areas.
Relative changes in the ratio of accommodation and sediment flux are thought to be the main driving mechanisms for the changes in channel patterns that occurred during the deposition of the Toolachee Formation. The quiet tectonic phase that prevailed during deposition (Apak et al., 1997) is consistent with an overall gradually subsiding basin, with little or no differential subsidence. Transitions between the two systems are considered primarily a result of changes in sediment flux, possibly driven by Milankovitch climatic-forcing. Cyclic changes in subsidence are unlikely. An increase in sediment load relative to accommodation causes channels to choke and braiding to develop, as bed load is reworked. Lower sediment flux relative to accommodation results in meandering channel development in a larger floodplain that supports vertical accretion of fines. Carson (1984) documented in his studies of rivers in the Canterbury Plains area of New Zealand a transition from meandering to braided systems caused by an increase in sediment supply, and Smith and Smith (1984) demonstrated a change in fluvial pattern in the William River from meandering to braided where a large bed load is introduced as channels flow through an eolian dune field.
The high gamma ray values and regular gamma ray spikes of the upper unit of the Toolachee Formation represent overbank environments with scattered crevasse splays, coal seams and minor channels, as well as lacustrine deposits. The gradual decrease in sediment flux relative to accommodation caused an increase in flooding events. The scattered bell shaped gamma ray patterns, observed on the logs reflect isolated meandering systems, typical for this environment. Generally, the sandstones are poorly developed indicating the short duration of channel-flow due to channel avulsion and abandonment.
30 3-D SEISMIC ATTRIBUTE ANALYSIS SEISMIC RESOLUTION The sequence stratigraphic model developed from the correlation of well logs yields 12 chronostratigraphic horizons within the Toolachee Formation. The tuning thicknesses calculated for the North Naccowlah 3-D survey range from 23 m in Roti 1 to 32 m in Tartulla 4 (Appendix 6), resulting in six seismic horizons, three peaks and three troughs (Table 2, Figure 7, Appendix 7). In areas of thicker deposits, additional horizons are resolved. As those horizons are of limited extent, they were not considered to be of great assistance in the interpretation of a depositional environment. Because of the low seismic resolution, the seismic horizons do not follow particular chronostratigraphic horizons from the sequence stratigraphic framework, but are the closest reflectors to those horizons. The following table lists the chronostratigraphic nomenclature and the equivalent seismic horizons of the Toolachee Formation in the North Naccowlah study area.
TABLE 2 Chronostratigraphic nomenclature and the corresponding seismic horizons of the Toolachee Formation in the North Naccowlah study area. Chronostratigraphic Unit Seismic Horizon PC00 P Trough Below P (TBP) PC30 P2 Trough Below P2 (TBP2) PC40 P3 Trough Below P3 (TBP3)
The P, P2, and P3 horizons are identified as peaks on the zero phase seismic data and are caused by the low impedance of coals. In the North Naccowlah 3-D data, negative reflection coefficients are associated with peaks (blue) and positive reflection coefficients with troughs (red). The TBP, TBP2, and TBP3 horizons represent the adjacent troughs below the peaks. The troughs are thought to be dominated by the side lobes of the strong peaks.
31
FIGURE 7 Wippo South 1 synthetic seismogram, gamma ray log, and sonic log on to a 2-D seismic reflection profile. The P, P2, and P3 horizons are the closest reflectors of the corresponding chronostratigraphic markers (Table 2). TBP, TBP 2, and TBP 3 are the adjacent troughs. Peaks (negative RC) are colour coded as blue, whereas troughs (positive RC) are red.
P TBP P2 TBP 2 P3 TBP 3 SONIC LOG GAMMA RAY LOG SYNTHETIC SEISMOGRAM - - + +
32 ATTRIBUTES A seismic attribute is defined as the characteristic of the seismic reflection event from either a geological interface or over a constant geological interval that holds important clues as to the geological setting and / or rock properties as well as time surfaces (Sheriff, 1991; Hui 2001).
Currently, more than 300 attributes can be imaged. Similar projects in the Cooper Basin as well as in other basins were studied to select attributes that resulted in the best possible images of sedimentary features. The most successful attributes were applied to the imaged seismic horizons within the Toolachee Formation.
COMPARISON OF ATTRIBUTE IMAGES TO MODERN FLUVIAL ANALOGUES The analysis of modern fluvial analogues assisted in the identification of fluvial bodies visible on attribute maps (Appendix 1). Not only did it aid in the identification of these features, but also in the interpretation of the associated depositional environments.
Lang et al. (2002) used the Ob River in Western Siberia as a modern depositional analogue for the Cooper Basin (Figure 8). The rationale for selecting this modern, high latitude, cool temperate, peat forming fluvial system is based mainly on similarities with the paleolatitude and paleoclimatic situation of the Cooper Basin in the Permian (Veevers, 2000). In this study, satellite and areal images of fluvial elements from the Ob River as well as other modern fluvial systems were compared directly to the 3-D seismic attribute maps from the North Naccowlah area. The comparison assisted in the identification of such features as meanders and hence in the interpretation of depositional environments in the study area.
33
FIGURE 8 - Possible channel belt identified on a horizon amplitude map (a). Modern analogue from the Ob River (b) (Lang, 2002) for a. Black dashed line on the amplitude map indicates boundaries of the channel belt. Red dashed line represents an interpreted meandering channel within the channel belt.
INTERPRETATION OF SEDIMENTARY FEATURES Each attribute was applied to the six resolvable seismic horizons, resulting in different images. Attributes such as dip, TWT structure, and variance proved to be good indicators of structural features (Figure 9), whereas amplitude and isochron identified sedimentary features best. Event width also showed some good examples of well defined sedimentary features. Distinct sedimentary bodies such as major fluvial channels were captured by each attribute.
This figure is not available online. Please consult the hardcopy thesis available from the QUT Library
34 ISOCHRON, TWT STRUCTURE, DIP, AND EVENT WIDTH
FIGURE 9 Sedimentary and structural features identified in the study area on (a) isochron, (b) TWT structure, (c) dip, and (d) event width horizon maps. (a) Isochron map of P3 horizon images meandering channels due to greater vertical time thickness caused by the thickness of low impedance channel fill. (b) TWT structure map of P2 horizon identifies faults as abrupt lateral changes in two way travel time. (c) Faults on P2 dip horizon map are being displayed as features with greatest dip. (d) Event width (peak) map of P horizon shows a channel belt that is caused by greater differences in travel times between zero crossings. Vertical colour scales show an increase in value towards the bottom for each respective attribute map.
(a) (b) (c) (d) Meanders Faults Channel Belt Faults
35 AMPLITUDE. The sedimentary features observed on the attribute maps are best characterised by lateral changes in amplitude. Structural features show up as linear amplitude anomalies. The amplitude anomalies represent either higher or lower amplitude values in comparison to their surroundings (Figure 10). The identified sedimentary features are interpreted as channels, channel belts, point bars and oxbows, whereas the structural features are restricted to faults. Specific seismic features identified on attribute maps are described and interpreted below.
Seismic feature 1 (SF 1) was extracted from the P3 horizon and appears as a high amplitude sinuous body in the northern central part of the study area (Figures 2 and 10). The feature is surrounded by an area of variable, but generally lower amplitudes. It trends 110 and is approximately 150 m wide. The width of the feature increases towards the curved edges.
Seismic feature 1 is interpreted as a meandering channel. The part enclosed by the highest curvature represents a possible point bar. This is supported by the increase of channel width indicating lateral migration of the meandering system. Figure 10b shows the location of SF 1 in a seismic reflection profile, which is indicated by the yellow line in figure 10a. The identified lenticular geometry is characteristic of a channel.
36
FIGURE 10 Seismic Feature 1 (SF 1) on P3 horizon amplitude map (a) and seismic reflection profile (b) indicated by red line X-X. Figure 10a shows lateral extent of SF 1, indicated by larger amplitude values (higher RC) (blue) of the peaks in comparison to the surroundings (light blue and red). Figure 10b shows the amplitude changes as lighter or darker shades of blue.
SF 1 (a) (b) P3 Horizon SF 1 - Channel X X
37 Seismic features 2, 3, and 4 appear as sinuous bodies in the central part of the study area, just north of Roti field (Figures 2 and 11). They are visible on the P horizon as low amplitude features surrounded by generally higher amplitudes. The bodies trend 110 and are 100 m wide. Overlapping is observed between SF 2 and SF 3. Seismic features 2, 3, and 4 are interpreted as meandering channels within a channel belt. The approximate outline of the channel belt is marked by the red dashed-dotted lines which are roughly 1.5 km apart. The observed overlapping of the channels is characteristic of a meandering channel that migrates laterally within a channel belt.
FIGURE 11 Seismic features 2 (SF 2), 3 (SF 3), and 4 (SF 4) on the P horizon. The seismic features are characterised by lower amplitude values (lower RC) (white light blue) to their surroundings (dark blue). The dashed line indicates the boundaries of the channel belt.
SF 2 SF 3 SF 4
38 Seismic feature 5 is a high amplitude sinuous body that occurs between the wells Yumba 1 and Mookoo 1 to the northern end of the data set (Figures 2 and 12). It appears on the P horizon as an 150 m-wide, high amplitude anomaly surrounded by generally lower amplitudes. The high sinuosity of the feature, which is close to a complete closed oval, suggests it is an oxbow lake that was cut off from the main channel by neck cut off.
FIGURE 12 Seismic Feature 5 (SF 5) on the P horizon. The feature is identified by high amplitude values (high RC) (dark blue).
SF 5
39 Seismic feature 6 appears as a low amplitude linear to curved body on the P3 horizon (Figure 13). It is located around the Wippo and Tartulla areas in the northwestern part of the study area and is trending approximately 300 west and 40 east of Tartulla 5 (Figure 2). The greatest width (~500 m) is observed at Tartulla 5. The area surrounding SF 6 is characterised by relative low amplitude values with no major sedimentary features observed. The abrupt change in amplitude and linear geometry suggests that SF 6 is a fault. The featureless area surrounding the fault is interpreted as possibly continuous sand sheets deposited by the braided channels characteristic of that area. Hence, no individual channels were imaged.
The majority of the sedimentary features identified on the P, P2, and P3 amplitude horizon maps are characteristic of higher amplitudes values in comparison to their surroundings. The amplitude maps of the adjacent troughs display the same seismic features, with some minor alterations in relation to the amount of features and their amplitude values. FIGURE 13 Seismic feature 6 (SF 6) on the P3 horizon. The feature is identified by an abrupt change in amplitude values (dark red). The surrounding area is characterised by relatively low amplitude values (low RC) (light blue) and does not contain obvious channel features. SF 6
40 Figure 14 shows a duplicate of SF 1 (Figure 10) on the TBP3 horizon. The duplicate is characterised by higher amplitude values (grey) to its surroundings (yellow). The sedimentary features imaged on the horizons caused by the troughs (TBP, TBP2, TBP3) appear as successive features of the sedimentary features imaged on the respective overlying peaks (P, P2, P3).
FIGURE 14 Duplicate of seismic feature 1 (SF 1) on TBP3 horizon. The feature is identified by higher amplitude values (grey) in comparison to its surroundings (yellow). It is a successive feature of SF1, imaged on the overlying P3 horizon.
Duplicate of SF 1
41 CATEGORISATION OF FLUVIAL BODIES The images of the two most significant attributes, isochron and amplitude were overlain to trace each identifiable fluvial body for each given horizon. The traced channels from the seismic horizons were labelled and measured for length, width, sinuosity, trend, and channel belt width. Channels that were at least one wavelength in length were classified (Table 3, Appendix 8). Seismic reflection profiles were used to verify the existence of the channels, especially for subtle images. The verification also assisted in the differentiation between sedimentary and structural features, such as faults. The identified features were then colour coded (Figure 15). The seismic horizons that are associated with the seismic troughs were not categorised as they tend to image mostly duplicate channels, which appear on successive horizon slices.
TABLE 3 Categorisation of fluvial bodies
Horizon
Features
Length (km) Width (m) Sinuosity (P) Trend
Ch Belt Width (km) P 7 8 115 1.22 W-E & N-S 1.75 P2 11 8.9 127 1.6 W-E & N-S 2.35 P3 14 10.41 138 1.9 W-E 3.47 Table 3 shows the averaged values of channel length, width, sinuosity, trend, and channel belt width for the three peak horizons. An obvious pattern emerges that shows a gradual decrease in sinuosity, channel width, and channel belt width towards the top of the Toolachee Formation. No pattern is recognisable in regards to the lengths and trends of the fluvial bodies, which is a result of the low resolution seismic data. The application of Rusts (1978) classification of alluvial channels by geometric characteristics classifies the identified channels within the P horizon (P =1.2 - 1.5) of lower intermediate sinuosity. The channels in the P3 and P2 horizons are classified as high sinuosity, as P is greater than 1.5 (Rust, 1978). The observations are consistent with the sequence stratigraphic interpretation, suggesting a relative increase in accommodation with successive parasequences.
42
FIGURE 15 P3 horizon amplitude map showing identified fluvial bodies. Majority of fluvial bodies is imaged due to higher amplitude values of the peaks (yellow) than their surroundings, areas of generally lower amplitude values (dark grey). The identified fluvial bodies are colour coded, a solid red line for distinct channels; a dashed red line for subtle channels; a solid blue line for faults, and a solid green line for successive channels.
A B C D E F G H I J K L M N
43 CROSS PLOTS Acoustic Impedance (AI) vs Gamma Ray (GR). Anacoustic impedance versus gamma ray cross plot was generated to show variations in acoustic impedance and gamma ray values between the four major lithologies, especially sand and shale (Figure 16, Appendix 9). If successful, forward modelling of acoustic impedance logs would show a variation in amplitude between sand and shale allowing them to be independently differentiated in seismic data. The acoustic impedance values of the lithologies were then cross-plotted against the equivalent gamma ray values. The values were obtained from the PC 30 and PC 40 parasequences of 22 well logs in the study area, which contained both logs.
Acoustic Impedance (AI) vs Gamma Ray (GR) 0 5000 10000 15000 20000 25000 30000 35000 40000 0 50 100 150 200 250 Gamma Ray (GR) A c o u s t i c
I m p e d a n c e
( A I ) Coal Sand Shale Carbon. Shales FIGURE 16 Acoustic Impedance versus Gamma Ray cross plot; circles indicate the dominant values for each lithology
The cross plot shows that the lithologies are partly distinguishable on their gamma ray values. A clear difference is seen between the gamma ray values of the sands (30 - 60 GR) and shales (140 - 210 GR). This difference is very vague between the sands and coals, as they are characterised by gamma rays of similar values. The gamma ray values of the carbonaceous shales range between that of the sands and the coals (60 - 140 GR). Overlapping of gamma ray values between the carbonaceous shales and the other lithologies is linked to the respective contents of sand, shale, and
44 carbonaceous material. The acoustic impedance values indicate that carbonaceous shales range between 16000 and 28000, representing a continuum between the coals (7000 - 16000 AI) and the shales and sands. The acoustic impedance range for the sands and shales is almost identical, with sands ranging between 30000 and 37000, and shales between 33000 and 38000. These similar values are caused by the shaley sands, sandy shales, and tighter sands. Hence, reflection amplitude will not discriminate between the two lithologies. The results of the cross plot imply that, with regards to this study, it is not possible to distinguish between sand and shale on the horizon amplitude maps due to the similar acoustic impedance values. But sands and shales may be distinguished from carbonaceous shales and coals.
45 DISCUSSION 3-D seismic attribute analysis was used to test a sequence stratigraphic interpretation for the Toolachee Formation of the North Naccowlah 3-D survey. The chosen attributes successfully imaged a large number of sedimentary features, primarily including meandering channels, associated channel belts and oxbows. The fluvial bodies are visible due to either higher or lower amplitude values in comparison to the surrounding amplitudes and by variations in amplitude width. Brown (1996) successfully imaged meandering channels on amplitude horizon maps in the Gulf of Mexico region, caused by amplitude anomalies that reflected lateral changes in lithology. A similar cause of amplitude variations is considered here.
The fluvial bodies visible on amplitude maps that were extracted from the seismic troughs (TBP, TBP2, TBP3) are duplicates of the fluvial bodies that are imaged on the overlying peaks (P, P2, P3), but with the opposite sense of polarity. Generally, the amplitude maps derived from the troughs show the same features with some minor variations. The fluvial bodies imaged on the peaks are mostly defined by greater amplitudes (higher RC) in comparison to their surroundings. A similar image is observed in the horizon amplitude maps extracted from the troughs.
The average tuning thickness at target depth in the study area approximates 25 m, yielding six resolvable horizons. The large acoustic impedance contrast between the coals and the other lithologies observed in the wells is assumed to have generated the peaks. However, the coal seams are much thinner than the tuning thickness. The majority of the coals range from 1 to 8 m. Therefore the peaks and troughs do not align with the top and bottom interfaces of the seams. Because of the large tuning thickness relative to bed thickness the troughs are thought to be dominated by the side lobes of the adjacent strong peaks. This effect can be observed on the respective horizon amplitude maps in the form of duplicates.
Establishment of a direct relationship between lithologies and seismic reflection attributes was not possible. The acoustic impedance properties of shale and sand are too similar to allow discrimination between these lithologies (Figure 16). Additionally, no well penetrates any imaged channel feature. Therefore, sequence
46 stratigraphic concepts were applied to assess the possible lithologies within the channels.
The chronostratigraphic framework developed for the North Naccowlah 3-D survey shows that the Toolachee Formation was deposited in an overall transitional systems tract in eleven cycles defined as parasequences (Figures 4 and 6) that represent high to low sediment flux / accommodation cycles. In the lower unit of the Toolachee Formation, individual parasequences reflect transitions in depositional environment from braided to meandering fluvial systems. The horizon amplitude maps of the P2 and P3 horizons, which reflect the extensive coals within the PC 30 and PC 40 parasequences, image predominantly meandering channels from the upper part of those parasequences. The depositional environment above the coal is characteristic of amalgamated sandstones that reflect the braided system of the PL 37 parasequence. In the Holocene deposits of the Rhine-Meuse delta Trnqvist (1993, 1994) and Trnqvist et al. (1993) demonstrated that a rapid increase in accommodation led to the development of a distributary fluvial style with a high avulsion frequency, whereas a lower rate of accommodation generation resulted in the reworking of meandering channel systems. The abandoned channels are expected to be filled with fine sediments such as shale, carbonaceous shale or coal, whereas long-lived low accommodation amalgamated meandering channel systems are sand filled, owing to lateral reworking of bed load, which should lead to sand-choking and development of braiding.
Altogether, two orderss of cyclicity are evident in the sequence stratigraphic interpretation; 1) The Toolachee Formation as a whole reflects a gradual increase in accommodation. Increased flooding events and channel avulsion are suggested by the greater abundance of isolated channels towards the top of the formation that eventually becomes lacustrine-dominated. 2) However, the eleven identified parasequences that make up the building blocks of the Toolachee Formation reflect variations in sediment flux. Increase in sediment flux at the base of a given parasequence results in the choking and thus braiding of channels, leading to deposition of laterally continuous multistorey sand sheets. Successive decrease in sediment flux towards the top of parasequences causes meandering in an overbank-
47 dominated environment. The fluctuations in sediment flux represent more likely Milankovitch climatic-forcing than tectonic control, as tectonic quiescence prevailed during deposition of the Toolachee Formation. Unfortunately, biostratigraphic resolution will not allow the duration of cycles to be determined to test for Milankovitch periodicity.
Beresford (2002) analysed the effect of different coal thicknesses and underlying lithologies in regards to the amplitude responses observed on horizon maps (Figure 17). The results of that work shows that the effects on amplitude are less significant with an increase in coal thickness as it approaches tuning thickness. Figure 16a shows a seismic response to a 1 m thick coal, overlain by shale and underlain by a laterally repetitive pattern of carbonaceous shale and sand, where odd traces represent the sand response and even traces the carbonaceous shale response. The seismic responses are of reverse polarity to Santos seismic data. The model clearly shows that the underlying lithologies contribute to the amplitude and shape of the coal peak. If the coal is underlain by carbonaceous shale, the amplitude value increases and becomes more distinct in comparison to an amplitude response related to an underlying sand or shale. At the same time the maximum amplitude shifts downwards and broadens, and the trough below decreases in amplitude. The following figures, 17b, 17c, and 17d show that the effect on the amplitude of the peak diminishes with an increase in coal thickness. The troughs below are also affected, but the changes in their responses between the carbonaceous shale and shale traces are more recognisable than the changes in amplitude of the peaks above.
The downward shift or time sag of the peak is related to seismic resolution. In the case of a 1 m thick coal (well below tuning thickness) that is underlain by carbonaceous shale, the low seismic resolution and similar acoustic impedance values do not allow for separation between the two lithologies. The coal peak appears to be thicker and the point of symmetry of the peak is shifted downwards. The increase in amplitude of the peak is caused by the increase in thickness of the relatively low impedance coal-carbonaceous shale package. As the coal approaches tuning thickness the amplitude becomes greater. Above tuning thickness, the amplitude reaches its maximum value. At and above tuning thickness the top and the bottom
48
This figure is not available online. Please consult the hardcopy thesis available from the QUT Library
49 interfaces of the coal would eventually become resolved, showing amplitude variations between the troughs due to the two different lithologies underlying the coal.
The discussed model is very simplified and has to be applied carefully with some alterations to the observations made on the seismic horizon maps from the North Naccowlah 3-D survey. The thickness of the coals responsible for the peaks is well below tuning thickness representing the scenario in figure 17a and possibly 17b. Meandering channels and oxbows that are defined by larger amplitude values of the peaks in comparison to the surroundings are thought to be infilled by carbonaceous shales after abandonment. As these features are located within the upper parts of the parasequences, sequence stratigraphic interpretation supports this interpretation. The lateral contrast of the amplitude values reflects the lateral change in lithology between a shale prone overbank environment and the carbonaceous shale-plugged channel. The channels observed within channel belts are characterised by lower amplitude values in contrast to their surroundings. A possible explanation could be related to the thinning of the coals above the channel belts, due to either differential compaction between the sands and the coals or a change in depositional environment as channel belts tend to be more sand-rich environments. In contrast to the proposed models, the channels observed on the seismic amplitude maps extracted from the troughs are defined by higher amplitude values. This is because in this sub-tuning seismic setting a decrease in amplitude of a dominant peak will tend to increase the amplitude of the adjacent trough. Beresford (2002) used a broadband wavelet resulting in higher resolution, thus decreasing the side lobe effects on the troughs in his study. The ringy wavelets typical of the Toolachee Formation have a significant effect on the side lobes of the peaks. Because of the low resolution relative to bed thickness and separation, the troughs will increase with an increase in the amplitude of the peaks.
50 EXPLORATION POTENTIAL Exploration and development in the Cooper Basin has predominantly focused on structural traps. However, exploration for the traditional four and three-way dip closure plays in the Cooper Basin is now at a mature stage. Stratigraphic plays have received the least exploratory emphasis to date. Thus, stratigraphic and combination traps have significant potential for future exploration in this mature basin.
The sequence stratigraphic framework developed for the Toolachee Formation in the North Naccowlah 3-D survey identified several different sedimentary features that indicate locations of potential stratigraphic traps, or allow predictions of reservoir by analogy. The primary sedimentary features that were identified on the wireline logs and 3-D seismic attribute maps include channel systems such as meandering and braided streams.
Figure 18 shows the relationship between channel morphology and reservoir geometry for the channel systems identified within the Toolachee Formation of the North Naccowlah 3-D survey. The greatest interconnectivity of sandstone bodies is associated with braided systems that deposit continuous sheets of laterally extensive sandstones (Figure 18c). The sequence stratigraphic framework of the study area shows that the braided systems were deposited as amalgamated channels at the base of parasequences located in the lower unit of the Toolachee Formation. The overall high sand to shale ratios indicate good reservoir continuity. Individual braided channels are not imaged on the seismic attribute maps because the constant lateral reworking of the sands due to limited accommodation did not allow lateral facies with different seismic responses to develop. Therefore, the continuous extensive sand sheets do not show any lateral changes in lithology that could be reflected on the seismic attribute maps. Hence, sand sheets are imaged on maps, but do not show the meandering channels of the shale prone setting. Images of sand sheets are predominantly associated with the Tartulla and particularly Wippo Fields on the seismic attribute maps. The high sand to shale ratios identified within the wells of this part of the study area support this interpretation. Hence, the potentially large reservoir sizes that are sealed by overlying overbank-rich succession for each parasequence are
51
52 excellent exploration targets. However, structural traps are considered to be the prime targets for those reservoirs as they provide the required closure.
The presence of meander belts is associated with increased accommodation and decreased sandstone interconnectivity (Figure 18b). The lateral migration of the channels within fine grained overbank facies and low sand to shale ratios observed on the wireline logs indicate poor reservoir connectivity. However, the seismic attribute maps show large meandering belts up to 3 km wide located within the transitional systems tracts of individual parasequences throughout the Toolachee Formation. Possible sites for exploration may be laterally accreted point bars on the inside of meander bends such as shown by Wellington 1 in the J uno / Baryulah complex. Such reservoirs would be smaller than the amalgamated sand sheets, but they represent stratigraphic traps that may not require structural control for closure.
Distributary channels of low sinuosity were interpreted from the wireline logs as poorly developed isolated sands predominantly located within the upper part of the Toolachee Formation. The low sinuosity of those channels reflects the high accommodation that prevailed during that time (Figure 18a). These isolated features, up to 150 m wide, are not intersected by any well in the project area and hence may possibly contain different stratigraphic packages than any interpreted from wireline logs. Predictions for potential stratigraphic play types in intervals of low sandstone interconnectivity must be based solely on principles of sedimentology and sequence stratigraphic models, because forward seismic modelling to establish a relationship between lithologies and seismic attributes was not possible due to the very similar acoustic impedances of the shales and sands.
In summary, 3-D seismic attribute analysis can be used as a powerful exploration tool to test sequence stratigraphic models. The seismic horizon attribute maps extracted from the 3-D seismic North Naccowlah survey assisted in the interpretation of the depositional environments of the Toolachee Formation. The sedimentary features imaged on the seismic attribute maps are positive support for the initial sequence stratigraphic hypothesis that was based on wireline data. The prominent meandering channels reflect the depositional environment within the transitional and
53 aggradational systems tracts of the respective parasequences. The fluvial bodies show a decrease in sinuosity up-section, supporting the interpretation of an overall increase in accommodation through the larger sequence. Areas where little or no features are visible, such as the Tartulla Field, represent depositional environments of high sand contents such as amalgamated channels of a braided system. Comparison of seismic amplitudes with forward modelling of the amplitude responses to coal thickness changes suggest channel abandonment and successive infilling by carbonaceous shales. 3-D seismic attribute analysis allows observation of the extent and type of lithology, which results in a better understanding of the relationship between hydrocarbon reservoirs and fluvial bodies.
54 CONCLUSIONS Altogether, eleven parasequences were identified by the author in the Toolachee Formation of the North Naccowlah 3-D survey, comprising the building blocks of a transitional systems tract (Figures 4 and 6). They are separated by flooding surfaces and each parasequence basically represents a fining up succession with channel sands at the base and overbank fines and coals at the top. Based on seismic horizons mapped on those flooding surfaces, seismic horizon attribute maps image the depositional environments interpreted from the wireline and well core data.
The Toolachee Formation in the study area can be subdivided into two units. A lower channel-dominated unit (PC 30 - PU 70), where multistorey sands represent mostly braided streams; and an upper overbank-dominated unit (PC 00 - PC 30), where most channels represent isolated meandering streams. The PC 00 represents the maximum flooding surface marking the change to an aggradational systems tract of primarily lacustrine facies.
The depositional environment of the lower unit is reflected by transitions between braided and meandering systems within each parasequence, vertically but also laterally in some cases. The transition reflects the cyclicity of the parasequences, where braiding is followed by meandering within a given parasequence. Relative changes in the ratio of subsidence and sediment -flux are thought to be the main driving mechanisms for the changes in channel patterns that occurred during the deposition of the Toolachee Formation. The quiet tectonic phase (Apak et al., 1997) that prevailed during deposition is consistent with an overall gradually subsiding basin, with little or no differential subsidence. Transitions between the two systems are considered to be a result of changes in sediment flux rather than changes in subsidence, possibly driven by Milankovitch climatic-forcing. An increase in sediment load relative to accommodation causes channels to choke and braiding to develop, as bed load is reworked. Lower sediment flux relative to accommodation results in meandering channel development and vertical accretion on the floodplain. .
55 The high gamma ray values and regular gamma ray spikes of the upper unit of the Toolachee Formation represent an overbank-dominated environment with scattered crevasse splays / deltas, thin coal seams and minor channels as well as lacustrine deposits. The scattered bell shaped gamma ray patterns observed on the logs reflect meandering channels, typical for this environment. Generally, the sandstones are poorly developed indicating short-lived channels with common channel avulsion and abandonment.
The analysis of well cores supports the interpretation of a transition in depositional environments between braided and meandering systems within parasequences. The abundance of mature conglomeratic channel lags, low argillaceous contents in the sandstones (2.5 %), and regional correlation of the parasequences, contradict previous interpretations of the multistorey sand horizons as amalgamated crevasse splay deposits.
Tuning thicknesses calculated for the North Naccowlah 3-D survey range from 23 - 32 m, resulting in six seismic horizons. Attributes such as dip, TWT structure, and variance proved to be good indicators of structural features, whereas amplitude and isochron data imaged sedimentary features best. However, distinct fluvial channels were captured by each attribute. The sedimentary features observed on the attribute maps are amplitude anomalies that represent either higher or lower amplitude values in comparison to their lateral surroundings. The identified sedimentary features include channels, channel belts, point bars and oxbows; whereas the structural features are restricted to faults and appear as nearly linear features.
The vertical progression of fluvial bodies imaged from the upper parts of successive parasequences shows a gradual decrease in sinuosity, channel width, and channel belt width towards the top of the Toolachee Formation. Channels within the P horizon (P =1.2 - 1.5) are of intermediate sinuosity. The channels in the P2 and P3 horizons are classified as high sinuosity, as sinuosity (P) is greater than 1.5. The changes in channel patterns are consistent with gradually increasing accommodation through Toolachee time.
56 The acoustic impedance range for the sands and shales is almost identical with the sands ranging between 30000 and 37000, and shales ranging between 33000 and 38000. The similarity in impedance values of the two lithologies strongly suggests that amplitude values or seismic inversion would not be a feasible way to distinguish between the two lithologies. Forward seismic modelling of amplitude responses due to varying coal thicknesses suggests that fluvial bodies that are defined by high amplitude values and peak width are filled with carbonaceous shale. Fluvial bodies characterised by low amplitude are possibly filled with sand.
3-D seismic attribute analysis in conjunction with sequence stratigraphy allows the prediction of the extent and type of lithology, which results in a better understanding of the relationship between potential hydrocarbon reservoirs and fluvial bodies. The three major identified fluvial styles; braided, meanders, and distributaries are potential targets for future exploration. Extensive sand sheets deposited from braided fluvial systems show good reservoir continuity and require structural traps for closure. Meandering and distributary fluvial systems represent excellent stratigraphic traps, such as the insides of laterally accreted point bars.
57 REFERENCES Apak, S.N., Stuart, W.J ., Lemon, N.M., and Wood, G., 1997, Structural Evolution of the Permian-Triassic Cooper Basin, Australia: Relation to Hydrocarbon Trap Styles, American Association of Petroleum Geologists Bulletin, V81, no.4, p 533 - 555.
Battersby, D.G., 1976, Economic Geology of Australia and Papua New Guinea 3, Petroleum, The Australian Institute of Mining and Metallurgy, Australia, p321-371.
Beaumont Smith, N., 1999. Patchawarra Formation Play Analysis, V. 1 4, Santos Internal Report.
Beresford, G., 2002, Thin Bed Analysis, Coal Thickness & AVO at Beckler Bow, Santos Internal Report.
Boggs J r, S., 1995, Principles of Sedimentology and Stratigraphy, Prentice Hall, p 774.
Brown, A.R, 1996, Interpretation of Three-Dimensional Seismic Data - Fourth Edition, American Association of Petroleum Geologists Bulletin Memoir 42, American Association of Petroleum Geologists, USA, p 475.
Brown, A.R., Dahm, C.G., and Graebner, R.J ., 1981, A Stratigraphic Case History Using Three-Dimensional Seismic Data in the Gulf of Thailand, Geophysical Prospecting, p 327 - 349.
Carson, M.A., 1984, Observations on the meandering braided river transition, the Canterbury Plains, New Zealand, NZ Geography, V.40(1), p 12 - 17.
Carter, D.C., 2003, 3-D seismic geomorphology: Insights into fluvial reservoir deposition and performance, Widuri field, J ava Sea, American Association of Petroleum Geologists Bulletin, V.87, No.6, p 909 - 934.
58 Currie, B.S., 1997, Sequence Stratigraphy of nonmarine J urassic Cretaceous rocks, Central Cordilleran Foreland Basin System, GSA Bulletin, V. 109, No.9, p1206 - 1222.
Davis J r., R.A., 1992, Depositional Systems: An Introduction to Sedimentology and Stratigraphy, Prentice Hall, p 591.
Eberth, D.A., Miall, A.D, 1991, Stratigraphy, sedimentology and evolution of a vertebrate bearing, braided to anastomosed fluvial system, Cutler Formation (Permian Pennsylvanian), north central New Mexico, Sedimentary Geology, V.72, p 225 - 252.
Farrell, K.M., 2001, Geomorphology, facies architecture, and high-resolution, non- marine sequence stratigraphy in avulsion deposits, Cumberland Marshes, Saskatchewan, Sedimentary Geology, V.139, p 93 - 150.
Fielding, C.R., 1986, Fluvial channel overbank deposits from the Westphalian of the Durham coalfield, NE England, Sedimentology, V. 33, p 119 - 140.
Gatehouse, C.G., 1986, The geology of the Warburton basin in South Australia. Australian Journal of Earth Science, V.33, p.166 - 180.
Hamerli, Z., 1999, 3-D Seismic Interpretation of Paleostresses in the Challum Field, Cooper Basin, SW Queensland, Queensland University of Technology Unpublished Honours Thesis, p 114.
Heath, R.S., 1989, Exploration in the Cooper basin, Australian Petroleum Production and Exploration Association Journal, V.29, No.1, p 366 - 378.
Hughes, T.M., 1999, Reservoir sedimentology and sequence stratigraphy in an intracratonic setting, Tartulla Field Cooper Basin, Queensland University of Technology Unpublished Honours Thesis, p 102.
59 Hui, N., 2001, 3-D seismic reflection, seismic attribute and sequence stratigraphic analysis of the Toolachee Formation, Cooper Basin, SW Queensland, Queensland University of Technology Unpublished Honours Thesis, p 106.
Kantsler, A.J ., Prudence, T.J .C., Cook, A.C., Zwigulis, M., 1983, Hydrocarbon habitat of the Cooper/Eromanga basin, Australia, Australian Petroleum Production and Exploration Association Journal, V.23, No.1, p 75 - 92.
Kloss, O., 1999, Chronostratigraphic Correlation of the Late Permian Toolachee Formation of the ATP259, Santos Internal Report, p 8.
Kloss, O., 2004, personal communication.
Kokogian, D.A., 1991, Estratigrafia secuencial en cuencas continentals Cuenca Cuyana, Argentina, 4 th Simposio Bolivarians, V.4, p 14 - 30.
Lang, S.C., Kassan, J ., Benson, J .M., Grasso, C.A., and Avenell, L.C., 2000, Applications of Modern and Ancient Geological Analogues in Characterisation of Fluvial and Fluvial-Lacustrine Deltaic Reservoirs in the Cooper Basin, Australian Petroleum Production and Exploration Association Journa,l V.40 Pt.1, p 393 - 415.
Lang, S.C., 2002, Picture from the River Ob, Western Siberia, NCPPG.
Legarreta, L., and Gulisano, C.A., 1989, Analisis estrtigrafico sequencial de la cuenca Neuquina (Triasico superior Terciari inferior), Cuencas Sedimentarias Argentinas 1989, No.6, p 221 - 243. Legarreta, L., and Uliana, M.A., 1991, J urassic Cretaceous marine oscillations and geometry of back arc basin fill, central Argentine Andes, International Association of Sedimentologists Special Publication, V.12, p 429 - 450.
Leopold, L.B., and Wolman, M.G., 1957, River channel patterns; braided, meandering and straight, US Geological Survey Prof. Paper, 282-B. Mancilla, O.H.L., Barrionuevo de Arce, L., and Corsico, N., 1988, Analisis
60 estrtigrafico sequencial en el subsuelo de la Cuenca Cuyana, Prov. Mendoza, Argentina, 1 st Congresso Nacional de Exploracion de Hidrocarburos, p 715 - 737.
Miall, A.D., 1977, A review of the braided river depositional environment, Earth Science Review, V.13, p 1 - 62.
Miall, A.D., 1978, Lithofacies types and vertical profile models in braided river deposits: a summary, In: Miall, A.D., Fluvial Sedimentology, Canadian Society of Petroleum Geologist Memoir 5, p 597 - 604.
Miall, A.D., 1992, Alluvial deposits. In : Walker RG, J ames NP (eds) Facies models: response to sea level change, Geological Association of Canada, St. Johns, New- foundland, p 119 - 142.
Miall, A.D., 1996, The Geology of Fluvial Deposits Sedimentary Facies, Basin Analysis and Petroleum Geology, Springer Verlag, Berlin Heidelberg, p 616.
Miall, A.D., 2002, Architecture and sequence stratigraphy of Pleistocene fluvial systems in the Malay Basin, based on time-slice analysis, AAPG Bulletin, V.86, No.7, p 1201 - 1216.
Mjoes, R., Walderhaug, O., Prestholm, E., (1993), Crevasse splay sandstone geometries in the Middle J urassic Ravenscar Group of Yorkshire, UK, Special Pubicationls Inernational Association of Sedimenologists., V.17, p 167 - 184.
Posamentier, H.W., 2001, Lowstand alluvial bypass systems: Incised vs. unincised, American Association of Petroleum Geologists Bulletin, V.85, No.10, p 1771 - 1793.
Price, P.L., Filatoff, J ., Williams, A.J ., Pickering, S.A., and Wood, G.R., 1985, Late Paleozoic and Mesozoic palynostratigraphical units, CSR Oil and Gas Division Palynology report number 274/25, unpublished.
61
Rijks, E.J .H., and J auffred, J .E.M., 1991, Attribute extraction: An important application in any detailed 3-D interpretation study, Geophysics: The Leading Edge of Exploration, p 11 - 19.
Rust, B.R., 1978, A classification of alluvial channel systems, In: Miall, A.D., Fluvial Sedimentology, Canadian Society of Petroleum Geologist Memoir 5, p 187 - 198.
Santos Ltd., 2004, Written communication with Trinetta Herdy.
Schumm, S.A., 1977, The Fluvial System, John Wiley, New York, p 338.
Shanley, K.W., and McCabe, P.J ., 1994, Perspectives on the Sequence Stratigraphy of Continental Strata, AAPG Bulletin, V.78, No.4, p 544 - 568.
Sheriff, R.E., 1985, Aspects of Seismic Resolution, American Association of Petroleum Geologists Memoir 39, p 1 - 10.
Sheriff, R.E., 1991, Encyclopedic Dictionary of Exploration Geophysics, Society of Exploration Geophysics ,Geophysical References Series, p 384.
Smith, N.D., and Smith, D.G., 1984, William River: An outstanding example of channel widening and braiding caused by bed-load addition, Geology, V. 12, p 78 - 82.
Strong, P.C., Wood, G.R., Land, S.C., J ollands, A., Karalaus, E., and Kassan, J ., 2002, High resolution paleogeographic mapping of the fluvial-lacustrine Patchawarra Formation in the Cooper Basin, South Australia, Australian Petroleum Production and Exploration Association Journal J ournal, p 65 - 81.
Toernqvist, T.E., 1993, Holocene alternation of meandering and anastomosing fluvial systems in the Rhine-Meuse delta (central Netherlands) controlled by sea-level rise
62 and subsoil erodibility. Journal of Sedimentary Petrology, V.63, p 683 - 693.
Toernqvist, T.E., 1994, Middle and late Holocene avulsion history of the River Rhine (Rhine-Meuse delta, Netherlands), Geology, V.22, p 711 - 714. Toernqvist, T.E., van Ree, M.H.M., Faessen, E.L.J .H., 1993, Longitudinal facies architectural changes of a Middle Holocene anastomosing distributary system (Rhine- Meuse delta, central netherlands), Sedimentary Geology, V.85, p 203 - 219.
Van Wagoner, J .C., Posamentier, H.W., Mitchum, R.M., Vail, P.R., Sarg, J .F., Loutit, T.S., and Hardenbol, J ., 1988, An Overview of the Fundamentals of Sequence Stratigraphy and Key Definitions. In: (C.K. Wilgus, B.S. Hastings, C.G. St Kendall, H. Posamentier, C.A. Ross and J . Van Wagoner) Sea Level Changes an Integrated Approach, Spec. Publ. Soc. Econ. Paleont. Miner., 42, Tulsa, p 39 - 45.
Van Wagoner, J .C., Mitchum, R.M., Campion, K.M., and Rahmanian, V.D., 1990, Siliciclastic Sequence Stratigraphy in Well Logs, Cores and Outcrop Concepts for High Resolution Correlation of Time and Facies, American Association of Petroleum Geologists Methods in Exploration Series, No.7, Tulsa, USA, p 55.
Veevers, J .J ., 2000, Permian-Triassic Pangean Basins and Fold Belts along the Panthalassam Margin of Eastern Australia. In: Veevers, J .J ., Billion year earth history of Australian neighbours in Godwanaland, Gemoc Press, Sydney, p 235 - 251.
Walton, G.G., 1972, Three-Dimensional Seismic Method, Geophysics, p 417- 429.
APPENDICES
APPENDIX 1
FLUVIAL SYSTEMS AND MODERN FLUVIAL ANALOGUES Fluvial Systems and Modern Fluvial Analogues
Braided Rivers Braided rivers are characterized by numerous channels separated by bars and small islands. Low sinuosity and coarse sediments associated with both bed load and suspended load modes of sediment movement are also highly characteristic of braided rivers (Fig. 45) (Miall, 1977). Deposition of sediments occurs in the form of channel shifting and bar aggradation on relatively steep slopes and width/depth ratios that may exceed 300. Some bars are relatively stable and develop vegetation, which can be inundated during floods (Davis J r, 1992). Braiding is inhibited in vegetated areas due to the cohesive strength of the sediments, whereas the opposite is the case in areas of loose sediments. Generally, many variables control the stream channel pattern, including discharge, sediment load, channel shape, velocity, and bed roughness as well as climate. A combination of slope and bank full discharge can be used to distinguish between braided and meandering streams. Braided streams can develop on steeper slopes than meandering streams for a given discharge (Davis J r, 1992). Thus, for a given slope, a river changes from meandering to braided as discharge is increased.
Fig. 45: Block diagram model of a braided stream reach, showing principal environments, where 1 is bars and channels; 2 sand bars; 3 vegetated bar and 4 island with abundant spruce (Williams and Rust, 1969)
Meandering Rivers Meandering occurs in all fluid systems as a result of turbulence, internal shear, and bank and bed friction (Miall, 1996). They may be also caused by variations in sediment, slope or gradient, bed roughness, and other factors (Schumm, 1977). Meandering streams are characterized by a lack of gravel, modest suspended loads and channels with a broadly meandering pattern. Point bars, levees, crevasse splays, and floodplain sediments are closely associated with meanders. This figure is not available online. Please consult the hardcopy thesis available from the QUT Library In contrast to multi channel braided streams, meanders are typical of single channels and are located downstream from braided streams on a gentler slope. The predominant geological setting is that of a coastal plain. The discharge varies and generally includes a period of overbank flooding, which typically occurs seasonally and may take place less than once each year (Davis J r, 1992).The most characteristic feature of a meandering river is its asymmetric bend with one side quite steep in comparison to the other (Fig. 46). Lateral erosion is taking place at the steep side, whereas sediments accumulate at the opposite, the gentle sloping side. The resulting migration of the channel is accompanied by channel shifting or channel abandonment leading to the development of a new channel. This is usually caused by processes like chute cutoff, neck cutoff, or avulsion which will be discussed in detail on the following pages.
Fig. 46: Facies distribution and sedimentary sequences of a meandering stream (Fraser, 1989).
This figure is not available online. Please consult the hardcopy thesis available from the QUT Library Geometries in Fluvial Systems
Channels Channels host the coarse deposits in fluvial systems. The geometry of channels is defined by depth, width/depth ratio, sinuosity, and sand body thickness. They are also characteristic of concave-up erosional bases, erosional or gradational tops, and channel margins which become gentler in slope with increasing channel width. Channel margins in form of steep banks are associated with high vegetation, whereas lower margin slopes are due to unconsolidated material.The channel cross section geometry depends on the slope, discharge, load, and the sediment into which the channel is cut. Channels are filled by simple vertical aggradation commonly show fining upward successions, reflecting one of two processes; progressive abandonment or the plugging action (flash floods) (Miall, 1996).
Point Bars Point bars are closely associated with meandering streams, and form on the convex side of the meander loop. The helical flow that is established in a meandering stream, carries sediment across the stream channel up to the sloping bank of adjacent point bars, where it is deposited under lower velocity conditions. Only the coarsest sediment accumulates as a lag deposit in the deeper part of the channel. The remaining sediment eroded from the concave bank of the meander bend is transported laterally across the stream, as the zone of maximum current velocity shifts back and forth from one outside bend to the next, and coarser bedload sediment is deposited by lateral accretion on the next downstream point bar (Fig. 47). This process causes both lateral and downstream migration of the meanders (Boggs J r, 1995).
Fig. 47: Meander bend diagram showing fining upward lateral accretion deposits of the point bar and fluid flow patterns (Allen, 1970)
Neck Cutoffs and Oxbow Lakes Continued enlargement of a meander loop results in increased sinuosity. Eventually a cutbank may incise into an adjacent reach of the channel. This typically occurs at the neck of a meander and results in a neck cut-off. Flow is diverted through the break, and the channel reach between the points of the cutoff is abandoned. Fine grained floodplain sediments or new point bar deposits then seal off the ends of the abandoned channel to form an oxbow lake (Fig. 46) (Miall, 1992).
This figure is not available online. Please consult the hardcopy thesis available from the QUT Library Levee Deposits Natural levee deposits form primarily on the concave or steep bank side of meander loops immediately adjacent to the channel as a result of sudden loss of competence of streams as they overtop their banks (Fig. 46). These deposits are thickest and coarsest near the channel bank and become thinner and finer grained toward the flood basin (Boggs J r, 1995) Sedimentary structures consist of rhythmically bedded units of silty, ripple-laminated sand a few centimetres thick with common bioturbation. Levees can be up to 3 km wide and 9 m high (Mississippi), and 700 m long (Bahmaputra). Dips of 2-4 are common (Miall, 1996).
Crevasse Splays Crevasse splays are delta like deposits, and occur on floodplains where rising flood waters breach natural levees (Fig. 46). The scale of the crevasse channel which form delta like distributary systems depends on the scale of the river They can be up to 10 km long, 5 km wide, and 2-6 m thick. Crevasse channel fills constitute of ribbon like bodies typically consisting of fine medium grained sandstone with trough cross bedding and ripple cross lamination becoming shallower away from the main channel. Internal scours are common. Generally, crevasse splays are like delta deposits. However, upward fining occurs where abandonment takes place (Miall, 1996).
Floodplain The floodplain environment is located away from the channels. It is characterized by fine grained sediments that settle out of suspension from flood waters carried into the broad flood plain (Fig. 46). The flood basin is a major feature on the flood plain and is characterized by low relief, poor drainage, and fine, organic rich sediments. These sediments commonly contain considerable plant debris and may be bioturbated by land-dwelling organisms or plant roots (Miall 1996, Boggs J r., 1995).
Modern fluvial analogues The use of analogues allows more confident mapping of sand trends in fluvial reservoirs, by providing an order of magnitude for channel belt widths, thickness to width ratios, and similar geometric parameters (Fig. 50). Modern fluvial analogues studies, such that of Fielding (1986), Olsen et al.(1995), Ashley et al.(1993), and Lang et al.(2000) were studied to get familiar with the sedimentology of meandering and braided streams, floodplains, lakes, peat mires, and crevasse splays. The facies characteristics and geometries associated with modern fluvial systems will be used as analogues to support the interpretation of depositional environments in the Toolachee Formation.
Fig. 48: Babbage River, Yukon Territory showing the laterally accreted point bars of a meandering channel (Hui, 2001)
This figure is not available online. Please consult the hardcopy thesis available from the QUT Library Yukon River, Alaska 1 0
m Thin distally over 250m Approximately 700 km to the west, at its junction with the Koyukuk River, the Yukon no longer has a braided pattern. Instead, meander scrolls and anastomosing side channels dominate the lower Yukon. The dissected plateau on the eastern side of the image is underlain by Mesozoic sedimentary rocks. The highly sinuous Black River traverses this plain in a relatively narrow valley. Where it emerges on the alluvial plains, the Black River floodplain widens and displays numerous cutoffs and oxbow lakes. Yukon River, Alaska 1 0
m Thin distally over 250m Active braided rivers Yukon River - the largest river in Alaska. Rivers range from braided to meandering with anastomosing side channels in the Lower Yukon. Floodplain is forested with numerous thaw lakes. The river transports a large volume of very coarse sediments. Yukon River, Alaska 1 0
m Thin distally over 250m A typical forested floodplain of the Yukon in the Yukon Flats. The Yukon Flats display numerous thaw lakes, presumably formed by subsidence as ground ice melted in the permafrost that underlies this region. Beaded drainage also indicates melting of permafrost ground ice, resulting in the transformation of a formerly continuous stream channel into a linear chain of thaw lakes. Other prominent lakes appear to have developed when outwash fans such as the Sheenjek advanced, blocking meltwater flow from adjacent uplands. Brahmaputra River, Tibet Stacked crevasse splays on coal 1 0
m Thin distally over 250m The main river channel displays a braided and anastomosing channel pattern. The photo to the left illustrates this type of channel morphology, showing part of a midchannel island with large bed forms in an active distributary of the Brahmaputra River. The rises and falls of the river lead to a dynamic sequence of channel adjustment throughout the year. Several varieties of bank failure occur during these flow changes, resulting in channel movement as great as 800 m (2600 ft) per year. The most significant bankline modifications occur during falling river stage, when excess bedload (predominantly fine sand) is deposited as channel bars, inducing changes in local flow direction and migration of the thalweg in a classic braided pattern. Squamish River, British Columbia 1 0
m Thin distally over 250m The transition from braided, through wandering, to meandering styles in the Squamish River, British Columbia, Canada. Fluvial Analogue models
APPENDIX 2
SEQUENCE STRATIGRAPHIC CORRELATIONS
A A JUDGA NORTH 1 MOOKOO 1 B B JUDGA 2 TARTULLA 2 C C COSTA SOUTH 1 RAWORTH 1
Chronostraigraphic frameworks and sequence stratigraphic interpretations for stratigraphic sections A A, B B, and C C for the North Naccowlah study area (Figure 2). Chronostratigraphic markers (ie, PC40) represent bounding surfaces (flooding surfaces) of eleven parasequences that can be correlated on a regional scale. The wireline logs are gamma ray (left column) and sonic (right column) logs. Gamma ray (GR) response is measured in API units (GAPI). The sonic log (DT) is recorded in microseconds per foot (/F). The lithologic colours are yellow/green = sand, blue = coal, = mudrock, and green = siltstone.
APPENDIX 3
SANTOS LTD. WELL CUTTINGS DESCRIPTIONS Ballat 1 6130 - 6372 PC00 - PC30 Siltstone with interbedded coals and minor thin sandstone 6130 - 6314 siltstone: dark grey - black, argillaceous, very carbonaceous, grades to silty coal, arenaceous in part carbonaceous flecks and laminae, subblocky to subfissile, firm - moderately hard coal: black, subvitreous, blocky - hackly, silty in part, grades into carbonaceous siltstone, brittle moderately hard sandstone: off white - light brown, clear - milky, fine - medium, moderately sorted, subang.-subround light brown argillaceous matrix, moderate siliceous cement, common carbonaceous fragments, common lithics, firm - moderately hard, very poor visual porosity, no fluorescence PC30 - PL35 Fining upwards sandstone with minor siltstone 6314 - 6356 sandstone: light brown - light brown grey, clear - medium grey, fine - medium, coarsening (very) with depth, poorly sorted, subang - subround, oil stained, argillaceous/siliceous matrix, moderate - strong siliceous cement, trace qtz overgrowths, abundant lithics, firm - hard, poor - fair visual porosity PC40 Siltstone with interbedded coal: generally as above 6356 - 6372 Judga 1 6651 - 7011 PC00 Intebedded siltstone, claystone and coal with minor sandstone laminations 6651 - 6706 coal: black, dull - subvitr., soft - brittle, silty in part - earthy text., subconchoidal fractures siltstone: medium - dark grey, carbon. - very carbon. In part, non calcerous, grading to silty coal in part, firm -hard, blocky claystone: light grey, uniform texture, carbon. In part, firm -hard, fissile sandstone: white - translucent, very fine - medium, dom. Fine, poorly sorted, subang - subround, strong silica cement and white argillaceous matrix, some unconsolidated angular medium clear grains, hard, tight porosity PC10 - PC20 Siltstone with thin interbedded sandstone and coal 6706 - 6818 siltstone: medium - dark grey, firm - moderately hard, carbon., interlaminated with coal, grading into claystone in part sandstone: off white, very fine - fine, occ. Medium, well sorted, subang - subround, minor argilla. matrix, firm - friable in part, poor visual porosity coal: black, subvitr., earthy, silty texture, blocky, conch. - subconch. fractures, grading to carbon. siltstone siltstone: as above sandstone and coal : as above PL25 Sandstone with siltstone and coal 6818 - 6850 coal: black, subvitr. - vitr., silty, grading to siltstone siltstone: as above sandstone: clear - translucent, medium - coarse, dom. Coarse, well sorted, ang. - subang., unconsolidated, no visual cement, trace dispersive white argillaceous matrix, grains conchoidally fractured in part, inferred good porosity PC30 Sandstone with siltstone 6850 - 6868 siltstone: medium - dark grey, carbon. With mottled texture, araneceous in part, brittle - moderately hard, blocky - subfissile sandstone: off white, translucent, very fine - medium, dom. Fine, moder. Sorted, subang - subround, silica cement with minor argillaceous matrix, common unconsolidated very fine - fine subround grains firm - friable, poor visual porosity, inferred poor - fair porosity PL35 Sandstone with minor interbedded siltstone and coal 6868 - 6902 coal: as above sandstone: as above but medium - coarse, dom. Medium, occ. Unconsolidated medium grains, poor visual porosity, inferred fair porosity siltstone: as above sandstone:as above PC40 Sandstone with siltstone and coal interbeds 6902 - 6976 sandstone: off white, clear - translucent, medium - coarse, becoming fine - medium with depth, moder. - poorly sorted, subang - subround, silica cement with occ. Qtz overgrowth, minor argillac. white matrix in aggregates, firm - moder. Hard in aggregates, commonly friable - unconsolidated, poor visual porosity, inferred fair - good porosity siltstone: black - brown black, occ. Dark grey, very carbon., grading to silty coal in part, araneceous in part, firm, subfissile coal: black, subvitr., silty, subconch. Fractures, blocky sandstone: clear - translucent, occ. Off white, fine - coarse, dom. Medium, poorly sorted, subang. - subround, dom. Unconsolidated with no visual matrix/cement, silica cement and minor white matrix in fine grained aggregates, qtz overgrowths in part, non calcerous, poor porosity in aggregates, inferred poor -good porosity PC50 Sandstone with minor siltstone and coal interbeds 6976 - 7011 coal: black, subvitr. - occ. Vitr., subconch. Fractures, silty in part and interlaminated with carbon. siltstone carbon. Siltstone: as above sandstone: clear - translucent, fine - medium, occ. Coarse, dom. Medium, subang. - subround, generally unconsolidated with no visual matrix/cement, minor fine - medium aggregates with silica cement, firm - hard, poor - moder. Sorted, poor visual porosity, inferred good porosity Tartulla 5 7623 - 7953 PC00 - PC10 Siltstone with minor sandstone and coal 7623 - 7700 siltstone: medium - dark brown, dark grey, occ. Greyish black, argillaceous, minor - common microcarbon. Specks, soft -firm, dispersive in part, amorphous - sub-blocky sandstone: white, clear, pale grey, occ. Light brown, pred. very fine - fine, occ. Medium, mod. Sorted weak - mod siliceous cement, rare white - off white argill matrix, firm - friable, occ loose qtz grains, very poor visual porosity, poor inferred porosity PC20 - PL25 Interbedded sand stone and siltstone with minor coal 7700 - 7805 coal: greyish black - black, sub-vit, friable, uneven, sub-blocky siltstone: brownish/grey, light grey - med grey, mottled greenish/grey in part, dark greyish black in part, argill, occ arenaceous in part, very carbon in part, grading to coal, occ soft, dispersive, amorphous, mod hard - hard, sub-blocky - sub-fissile sandstone: pale - light brown, fine, well sorted, subang - subrnd, weak - mod siliceous cement, trace light brown silty matrix, mod hard, very poor - poor visual porosity PC30 -PC40 Interbedded sandstone and siltstone 7805 - 7953 sandstone: very light grey, pale brown, very fine - fine, occ med, subang - subrnd, mod sorted, mod siliceous cement, minor kaolinitic matrix, mod hard, occ loose, poor visual porosity, fair inferred porosity sandstone: clear - very pale brown, fine - pred med, mod sorted, subang - subrnd, trace to rare weak siliceous cement, trace pale brown silty matrix, friable, loose, poor visual porosity, fair - good inferred porosity Tartulla 2 7568 - 7822 PC00 -PC10 Sandstone with minor siltstone and coal 7568 - 7665 coal: black, subvit, silty in part, irregular fracture sandstone: white, translucent, occ light brown grey, fine - occ med grained, coarse downwards, mod well sorted, ang - subrnd, mod siliceous cement, common arg matrix, friable, poor - fair porosity siltstone: med - dark grey, occ med brown grey, argill, common carbon, mod hard, subblocky PC20 - PL25 Dominantly siltstone with common coals and minor sandstone 7665 - 7740 siltstone: as above coal: as above sandstone: white, light brown grey, very fine - fine grained, occ med, mod well sorted, mod strong siliceous cement, common arg matrix, poor porosity PC30 - PC40 Stacked sandstones with minor siltstone and coal 7740 - 7822 coal: as above sandstone: light brown, off white, occ translucent and milky, fine - coarse grained and occ very coarse, coarsening downwards, mod sorted, ang - subang, mod siliceous cement, trace argill matrix, trace carbon matter, friable - firm, fair porosity siltstone: as above Wippo East 2 7560 - 7904 PC00 Siltstone with thin interbedded coal 7560 - 7604 Siltstone: dark grey, dark brownish grey, argill - commonly carbon, grades to coal, micromicaceous in part, mod hard, subblocky - subfissile coal: black, very dark brownish grey, subvit - dull, firm - mod hard, subblocky - angular PC10 - PL25 Siltstone with occasional thin interbedded coal and minor sandstone 7604 - 7690 siltstone: dark grey, dark brownish grey, carbon, grades to coal, micromica in part, mod hard, subblocky - subfissile coal: black, very dark brownish grey, subvit - dull, firm - mod hard, subblocky - ang sandstone: translucent, off white, fine - very fine, mod sorted, subang, mod strong siliceous cement, siliceous overgrowth in part, white - minor pale grey kaolinitic matrix, mod hard aggregates, very poor visual porosity siltstone: med - dark grey, carbon - micromica. In part, firm -mod hard, subblocky - subfissile sandstone: translucent, off white - pale brown, fine, mod sorted, subang - subrnd, firm siliceous cement, minor kaolinitic matrix, friable - mod hard aggregates, poor - very poor visual porosity PL25 - PC30 Siltstone with well developed coal seams and minor sandstone 7690 - 7800 siltstone: med - dark grey, carbon - micromica in part, mod hard, subblocky - subfissile sandstone: translucent, pale grey - pale brown, fine - very fine, mod sorted, subang - subrnd, firm siliceous cement, minor kaolinitic matrix, silty in part, friable - mod hard aggregates, very poor visual porosity sandstone (pc30): translucent, off white, fine - very coarse, pred medium - coarse, mod - poorly sorted, subang - ang, weak - mod strong siliceous cement, siliceous overgrowths in part, some fractured grains and qtz shards, mod hard aggregates, very poor inferred porosity PL35 siltstone: dark grey, brownish grey, carbon, grades to coal, micromica in part, mod hard, subblocky - 7800 - 7837 subfissile sandstone: off white, pale grey brown, fine - pred med, minor coarse, mod sorted, subang, weak - mod strong siliceous cement, siliceous overgrowths in part, some fracturedgrains, friable - mod hard aggregates, poor - occ fair inferred porosity PC40 Finely interbedded siltstone and sandstone 7837 - 7904 siltstone: dark grey - black, dark brownish grey, carbon, very finely arenaceous - micromica in part, mod hard, subblocky - subfissile sandstone: off white - pale grey/brown, translucent, very fine - fine aggregates, minor med, mod sorted, subang, firm - mod strong siliceous cement, siliceous overgrowths, minor silty matrix, very firm aggregates, very poor visual porosity sandstone: off white, pale grey brown, fine pred med, minor coarse, mod sorted, subang, weak - mod strong siliceous cement, siliceous overgrowths in part, some fractured coarse grains, friable - mod hard aggregates, poor - occ fair inferred porosity Wippo East 1 7499 - 7778 PC00 - PC10 Siltstone with interbedded sandstone and coal 7499 - 7570 siltstone: dark grey, very dark grey, carbon in part, grading to carbon siltstone, argill in part, rare micro mica, mod hard, subfissile - subblocky coal: black, earthy - subvit, firm - brittle, blocky, uneven fracture, silty in part, common woody striations sandstone: pale brown, off white, very fine - med pred fine grained, mod well sorted, subang - subrnd, mod strong siliceous cement, common pale brown argill matrix, minor carbon fragments, trace lithics, friable - mod hard, tight - very poor inferred porosity PC20 Interbedded siltstone and sandstone 7570 - 7625 siltstone: dark grey, dark grey - black in part, carbon grading to carbon siltstone, rare micro mica, trace very fine lithics, tracenodular pyrite, mod hard, subblocky - subfissile sandstone: off white, very pale brown, very fine - pred fine grained, well sorted, subang - subrnd, mod strong siliceous cement, minor off white argill matrix, common carbon specks, trace nodular pyrite, friable - pred mod hard, very poor visual porosity coal: as below PL25 Interbedded siltstone and sandstone with minor coal 7625 - 7675 coal: black, subvit, brittle, shardy - blocky, hackly - subconchoidal fracture siltstone: as above sandstone: clear, translucent, off white, fine - medium grained, mod sorted, ang - subrnd, weak - mod strong siliceous cement, rare pale brown argill matrix, friable - occ mod hard, poor visual porosity PC30 Interbedded sandstone, siltstone and coal 7675 - 7730 coal: black, dull - earthy, subvit in part, brittle, blocky, hackly - uneven fracture, silty in part, grading to carbon siltstone siltstone: dark grey, very dark brownish grey in part, carbon in part grading to silty coal, very fine arenaceous in part, trace lithics, mod hard, subblocky sandstone: clear, translucent, off white, fine - pred med grained, trace coarse grained, mod sorted, ang - subrnd, weak siliceous cement, rare pale brown argill matrix, friable - loose, mod - good inferred porosity PL35 Siltstone with interbedded sandstone 7730 - 7770 siltstone: dark grey, very dark grey, very finely arenaceous, carbon in part, common thin very fine sandstone laminae, rare micro mica, mod hard, brittle in part, subblocky - subfissile sandstone: clear, translucent, very pale brown in part, fine - med, mod sorted, subang - subrnd, weak locally mod strong siliceous cement, rare pale brown argill matrix, friable - locally mod hard, poor inferred porosity PC40 Sandstone with minor interbedded siltstone 7770 - siltstone: as above sandstone: clear, translucent, fine - very coarse pred med grained, fair sorting, weak siliceous cement pred loose, good visual mod inferred porosity Roti West 1 7064 - 7485 PC00 - PC10 Siltstone with interbedded sandstone and coal 7064 - 7150 siltstone:carbon, dark grey - very dark grey, dark brownish grey, grading to silty coal in part, argill in part, rare micro mica, rarely very finely arenaceous, firm - pred mod hard, subblocky - subfissile coal: black, verydark grey, very dark brownish grey, earthy - subvit, silty in part grading to carbon siltstone, brittle - mod hard, uneven fracture, blocky - subconchoidal sandstone: pale - med brownish grey, very fine grained, well sorted, subang - subrnd, weak siliceous cement, common off white/pale brown argill matrix, common carbon specks and thin laminae, firm, tight visual porosity PC20 Siltstone with interbedded sandstone and coal 7150 - 7220 siltstone: carbon in part, dark grey - very dark grey, dark brownish grey, occ grading to silty coal, argill grading to claystone in part, rare micro mica, locally very finely arenaceous, firm - pred mod hard, subblocky - subfissile coal: black, verydark grey, very dark brownish grey, earthy - subvit, silty in part grading to carbon siltsone, brittle - mod hard, uneven fracture, blocky- subconchoidal sandstone: med brown - brownish grey, very fine -fine, well sorted, subang - subrnd, weak siliceous cement, common off white/pale brown argill matrix, common carbon specks and thin laminae, firm - friable, very poor - tight visual porosity PL25 Siltstone with interbedded sandstone and coal 7220 - 7284 siltstone: carbon, dark grey - very dark grey, dark brownish grey, occ grading - silty coal, trace micro mica, locally very finely arenaceous, firm - pred mod hard, subblocky - subfissile coal: black, very dark grey, very dark brownish grey, earthy - subvit, silty in part grading to carbon siltstone, brittle - mod hard, uneven fracture, blocky - subconchoidal sandstone: white, translucent, clear in part, pale brown, very fine - finegrained, well sorted, subang - subrnd, weak siliceous cement, common off white/ pale brown argillaceous matrix, common carbon specks and thin laminae, firm - friable, very poor - tight visual porosity PC30 Interbedded sandstone, coal and siltstone 7284 - 7320 coal: black, subvit, hackly - subcon fracture, occ very finely arenaceous, brit - mod hard, subblocky - splintery sandstone: translucent, clear, pale grey, very fine - med grained, becoming fine with depths, fair sorting, subang - subrnd, rare weak siliceous cement, minor pale brownish grey argill/silty matrix, rare carbon flecks, pred loose, fair inferred porosity siltstone: as above PL35 Siltstone with interbedded sandstone and coal 7320-7385 coal: black, very dark grey, very dark brownish grey, earthy - subvit, silty in part grading - carbon siltstone, brittle - mod hard, uneven fracture, blocky - subconchoidal siltstone: carbon, dark brownish grey, dark grey - pred very dark grey, occ grading to silty coal, very finely arenaceous in part, trace micro mica, firm - pred mod hard, subblocky -subfissile sandstone: translucent, off white, pale grey, very fine - fine grained, mod well sorted, subang - subrnd, strong siliceous cement, rare off white argillaceous matrix, mod hard aggregates, tight - very poor visual porosity PC40 Interbedded siltstone and sandstone 7385 - 7445 siltstone: carbon, very dark grey, very dark brownish grey, grading to silty coal in part, trace micro mica mod hard, subblocky - subfissile sandstone: clear, translucent, fine - very coarse pred med grained, subrnd - subang, weak siliceous cement, rare pale grey silty matrix, pred loose clean qtz grains, rare friable aggregates, fair - mod inferred porosity siltstone: dark grey - very dark grey, dark brownish grey, carbon occ gradin to silty coal, argill in part, trace micro mica, firm - mod hard, subblocky - subfissile sandstone: translucent, clear, very fine - very coarse pred fine - med grained, mod sorted, subang - subrnd, weak - mod strong siliceous cement, trace off white argill matrix, rare carbon flecks and thin laminae, friable - mod hard, loose in part, poor - fair inferred porosity PC50 Sandstone with interbedded siltstone and minor coal 7445 - 7485 siltstone: carbon, med - dark grey, occ very dark grey, argill, trace micro mica, firm - mod hard, subblocky - occ subfissile sandstone: pale brown, off white, translucent in part, very fine - fine becoming pred med with depth, subang - subrnd, mod strong siliceous cement, minor off white - pale brown argill matrix, rare carbon flecks and thin laminae, mod hard, tight - very poor visual porosity siltstone: carbon grading to silty coal as above coal: black, subvit, conchoidal - uneven fractue, brittle - mod hard, blocky Roti 1 6934 - 7322 PC00 Siltstone with trace sandstone and thin coal 6934 - 6990 siltstone: med grey - dark grey/black, very carbon and grading to coal, firm to brittle, subblocky - subfissile sandstone: very pale brown, off white, very fine - fine, well sorted, subang - subrnd, mod strong siliceous cement, common pale brown - off white kaolinitic matrix, mod hard aggregates, poor visual porosity coal: black, dull, silty, subblocky - uneven firm PC10 - PL25 Dominant siltstone with minor sandstone and isolated thin coal 6990 - 7132 siltstone: med grey - dark grey/black, very carbon and grading to coal, locally very finely arenaceous, firm - brittle, subblocky - subfissile sandstone: very pale brown, off white, very fine - fine aggregates, mod well sorted, subang - subrnd, mod strong siliceous cement, minor - locally common off white kaolinitic matrix, mod hard - friable aggregates, tight visual porosity PC30 Siltstone grading to sandstone with thick coal 7132 - 7162 coal: black, vitr, occ silty, subblocky - subconchoidal fracture, firm - mod hard siltstone: med grey - dark grey/ black, very carbon and grading to coal, minor arenaceous, very firm - brittle, subblocky - subfissile sandstone: milky - translucent, generallyb med - occ coarse, ang qtz fragments, mod - poorly sorted, ang - subrnd, mod strong siliceous cement with qtz overgrowths, nil matrix, mod hard - loose grains, very poor visual porosity PL35 Siltstone grading to sandstone with thick coal 7162 - 7215 coal: as above siltstone: med grey - dark grey/black, very carbon and grading to coal, minor arenaceous, very firm - brittle, subblocky - subfissile sandstone: very pale brown, off white, fine aggregates, med - occ coarse qtz fragments, mod - poorly sorted, ang - subrnd, mod strong siliceous cement, minor - locally common off white kaolinitic matrix, mod hard - friable aggregates, very poor visual porosity PC40 Interbedded siltstone and sandstone 7215 - 7285 siltstone: med grey - dark grey/black, very carbon and grading to coal, locally very finely arenaceous, firm - britle, subblocky -subfissile sandstone: milky - translucent, fine - med, occ coarse ang qtz fragments, mod - poorly sorted, ang - subrnd, mod strong siliceous cement with qtz overgrowths, nil matrix, mod hard - fine aggregates, some loose grains, very poor visual porosity siltstone: med grey - dark grey/black, carbon, very finely arenaceous, very firm - brittle, subblocky - subfissile sandstone: pale brownish grey, fine - very fine grained aggregates, mod sorted, subang, firm siliceous cement, minor silty matrix, friable - mod hard aggregates, very poor visual porosity PC50 Sandstone with minor siltstone and coal 7285 - 7322 coal: as above sandstone: pale brownish gry, fine - very fine grained aggregates, mod sorted, subang, firm siliceous cement, minor silty matrix, friable - mod hard aggregates, very poor visual porosity siltstone: med grey - dark grey/black, carbon, very finely arenaceous, very firm - brittle, subblocky - subfissile Merri 1 5928 - 6287 PC00 Fining upwards interbedded sandstones and siltstones with minor claystones and thin coals 5928 - 5970 sandstone: cream - buff, fine - very fine, subrnd - subang, mod well sorted, white argill matrix, trace carbon flecks, siliceous cement, tight - poor visual porosity siltstone: grey - dark grey/black, subblocky - subfissile, very carbon, micromica in part, fine qtz grains in part, mod - hard coal: black, dull - subvit, silty, subfissile, mod hard claystone: dark grey brown, lignitic, blocky and firm - mod hard PC10 - PC30 Siltstone with interbedded sandstone and coal 5970 - 6161 sandstone: cream - buff, fine - med, occ coarse grained, subrnd -subang, mod sorted, trace carbon flecks, cream argill matrix, siliceous cement, mod hard, poor porosity siltstone: grey - dark grey/black, blocky - subfissile, very carbon, grading to silty coal, micromica, mod hard - hard coal: as above PL35 Sandstone with interbedded siltstone 6161 - 6206 sandstone: translucent - milky - light brown, fine - coarse, pred med grained, ang - subrnd, poor - mod sorted, loose with fine grained aggregates, siliceous cement, white argill matrix in part, fair - good porosity siltstone: as above PC40 - PC50 Sandstone with interbedded siltstone and minor claystone 6206 - 6287 sandstone: cream - buff, very fine - med, becoming med - coarse with depth, subang - subrnd, poor - mod sorted, argill matrix, silliceous cement, abundant carbon laminae, loose - mod hard, poor - fair visual porosity siltstone: grey - green, mod - hard, arenaceous - argill, micromica, slightly carbon claystone: light grey - green, firm - mod hard, carbon, silty, blocky - subfissile Wippo 1 7214 - 7559 PC00 - PC10 Dominantly siltstone with minor interbeds of sandstone and coal 7214 - 7305 siltstone: dark grey, very argill, micromica, commonly carbon, occ grading to carbon siltstone, firm, blocky - subfissile sandstone: light brown, very fine, well sorted, subrnd, mod well cemented with siliceous cement, trace argill matrix, generally well consolidated, hard - occ friable, tight visual porosity coal: black, commonly silty, subbituminous, subvit, subconchoidal fracture, brittle, blocky PC20 Siltstone with minor interbeds of sandstone with trace coal beds and stringers 7305 - 7360 siltstone: med - very dark grey, occ dark greyish black, very carbon, commonly argill, micromica, grading to carbonaceous siltstone, hard, subblocky - blocky sandstone: as above, occ med grained coal: as above sandstone: off white - light brown, fine - occ very fine, rarely med, mod well sorted, weak - mod well cemented with siliceous cement, trace white - light brown argill matrix, firm - friable, poor visual porosity siltstone: as above PL25 Interbedded siltstone and sandstone with some coal beds 7360 - 7396 coal: dark greyish black - black, subbituminous - bituminous, subconchoidal fracture, subvit, silty in part, blocky, firm - hard siltstone: dark grey - occ med greyish brown, commonly argill, micromica, slight to very carbon, trace very fine sand, firm, blocky - subfissile sandstone: generally as above, very fine - fine, tight - poor visual porosity coal: as above PC30 coal: black, subvit - vit, bituminous, subconchoidal fracture, slightly silty, firm - hard, blocky 7396 - 7472 siltstone: as above sandstone: clear - light brown, fine - med grained, well sorted, subang, weak - mod siliceous cement, trace argill matrix, generally clean, loose, occ friable, tight - fair visual/inferred porosity PL35 Interbedded siltstone and sandstone 7472 - 7518 siltstone: dark grey, occ med grey, very argill, carbon, slightly arenaceous, firm - hard, blocky - subfissile sandstone: as above, fine - med grained, occ coarse siltstone: as above, grading to carbon siltstone in part sandstone: off white - light brown, fine - med, dom fin, mod sorted, subang - rnd in part, mod siliceous cement, trace argill matrix, firm, poor visual porosity PC40 Fining upwards sequence of sandstone and siltstone 7518 - 7559 siltstone: dark grey - med greyish brown, generally argill, micromica, carbon, occ very carbon and grades to carbon siltstone, mod hard, blocky - subfissile sandstone: as above Wippo 2 7220 - 7619 PC00 Siltstone with thin coal interbeds 7220 - 7275 siltstone: med - dark grey, argill, grades to claystone, abundant carbon flecks and laminations, common micromica, occ grades to coal, trace lithics, occ arenaceous, firm. Subfissile coal: dark grey brown, black, dull - subvit, rarely vit, argill and silty texture in part, occ laminations, blocky - subconchoidal fractures PC10 Sandstone with minor interbedded siltstone (fining up sandstone) 7275 - 7343 sandstone: white - light grey, common clear grains, fine - med, mod sorted, subang - subrnd, mod siliceous cement and overgrowths, common white argill matrix, common unconsolidated, clean, firm, inferred fair porosity siltstone: as above PC20 Siltstone with some coal 7343 - 7378 coal: black, subvit - vit, subcon - con fractures, blocky - subblocky, firm - occ brittle siltstone: as above, with minor sandstone PL25 Siltstone with some coal 7378 - 7425 coal: as above siltstone: as above, carbon with minor sandstone PC30 Fining upwards sequence of sandstone and siltstone 7425 - 7490 coal: as above siltstone: med - dark grey, dark grey brown in part, argill matrix, common arenaceous, abundant carbon flecks and laminations, non calcareous, common micromica, firm - mod hard, subfissile sandstone: off white - pale brown in part, pred clear - translucent qtz, fine - coarse, becoming dom med -coarse, poorly - mod sorted, angular - subang, common fractured grains up to 90% unconsolidat, common siliceous cement and overgrowths in aggregates, occ white argill matrix, non calcareous, clean qtz sandstone, mod hard - hard, poor visual porosity, inferred fair - good porosity PL35 Fining upwards sequence of sandstone and siltstone 7490 - 7557 siltstone: as above sandstone: off white - light grey - occ pale brown, common clear qtz grains, fine - occ coarse, dom med mod sorted, ang - subang, common fractured grains, common siliceous cement and overgrowths, non calcareous, minor argill matrix, unconsolidated in part, firm - mod hard, occ friable, poor visual porosity PC40 Interbedded sandstone and siltstone 7557 - 7619 siltstone: as above, becoming arenaceous and carbon, grades to argill coal in part sandstone: off white - very light grey, occ pale grey brown, common clear qtz, fine - rarely coarse, pred med, mod - well sorted, subang - subrnd, occ ang, common unconsolidated, common argill and minor siliceous cement, interlaminated with siltstone, firm - friable, poor - fair porosity Wippo South 1 7228 - 7570 PC00 - PC10 Siltstone with minor interbedded sandstone and rare coal 7228 - 7332 siltstone: dark grey, greyish/black, argill, micromica, carbon, grading to coal in part, firm - pred mod hard, subblocky - blocky sandstone: pred pale - light brown, off white, brown in part, clear and translucent, pred very fine - fine, occ clear med and trace coarse qtz grains, subang - subrnd, mod well sorted, mod siliceous cement, light brown silty matrix, minor kaolinitic matrix, mod hard, very poor visual porosity coal: black, very dark grey/black, subvit, earthy in part, soft in part, firm, uneven, silty in part PC20 - PL25 Siltstone with minor interbedded sandstone and coal 7332 - 7425 siltstone: pred dark grey, light grey, light brown, locally arebnnaceous, common carbon, grading to coal pred carbon specks, micromica, firm - soft, subblocky - blocky coal: black, subvit, occ vit, brittle - mod hard, uneven - hackly, silty in part sandstone: pale brown, light brown, pred very fine - fine, mod siliceous cement, light brown and off white silty matrix, rare med loose qtz grains, friable - mod hard, very poor visual porosity, poor inferred porosity PC30 Sandstone with interbedded siltstone 7425 - 7482 sandstone: light brown, fine - med, mod sorted, subang - subrnd, mod - strong siliceous cement, minor common light brown silty matrix, mod hard - hard, occ firm - friable, poor visual porosity siltstone: black, carbon, locally grading to coal, occ very finely arenaceous, micromica, very hard, subfissile - occ fissile PL35 Sandstone with minor interbedded siltstone 7482 - 7570 siltstone: as above sandstone: clear, translucent, opaque qtz, light grey in part, pale brown/off white, fine - pred med, rare coarse, poor - mod sorted, occ mod hard siliceous cement, rare silty matrix, pred med and locally fine clean loose qtz grains, rare qtz overgrowths, poor visual porosity, and fair - good inferred porosity sandstone: clear, translucent, med - pred coarse, occ fine, pred subang, occ angular, trace siliceous cement, loose, clean, fair - good inferred porosity PC40 Interbedded sandstone and siltstone, with minor coal 7570 - 7620 sandstone: white, pale brown, light grey, clear, translucent, very fine aggregates, occ med and coarse loose grains, mod siliceous cement, light brown silty matrix, rare kaolinitic matrix, trace dark brown lithics, trace to rare micro carbon specks, mod hard, very poor visual porosity siltstone: grey/black, carbon, grading to coal in part, micromica, occ argill, mod hard - frim, subblocky blocky coal: black, subvit, uneven - hackly, locally silty PC50 Interbedded sandstone and siltstone with rare coal 7620 - 7657 sandstone: light brown, light grey, translucent, very fine - coarse, pred fien, occ very coarse, subang - subrnd, coarse and very coarse grains are ang, weak - mod siliceous cement, light brown silty matrix, firm - loose, very poor visual porosity siltstone: greyish/black, grey - dark grey, carbon, micromica in part, grading to coal, mod hard - firm, subblocky - blocky coal: black, subvit, uneven, silty in part Windigo 1 6970 - 7437 PC00 - PL25 Interbedded siltstone, sandstone and coal 6970 - 7165 siltstone: med - dark grey, occ light grey - greyish brown, argill, carbon grading - carbon siltstone, firm- mod hard, dom subfissile sandstone: white - off white, pale grey - brownish grey, common grey - dark grey, very fine - fine, well sorted, subang - subrnd, strong - occ mod strong siliceous cement, trave white argill matrix, common grey silty matrix, trace carbon specks, mod hard - hard, poor visual porosity coal: brownish black - black, subvit, earthy in part, silty, firm, brittle in part, subblocky - dom subfissile, striated PC30 Coal and sandstone 7165 - 7200 coal: as baove sandstone: clear - translucent, med - very coarse, poorly sorted, subang - ang, weak - mod strong siliceous cement in hard aggregates, commonly loose, poor visual porosity PL35 Interbedded sandstone, siltstone and minor coal 7200 - 7310 coal: brownish black -black, subvit, earthy in part, silty, firm, brittle in part, sublocky - dom subfissile, striated siltstone: light - med grey, occ dark grey, argill, very fine arenaceous in part, carbon in part, mod hard - hard, dom subfissile sandstone: clear - translucent, fine - coarse, poorly sorted, subang - subrnd, common ang coarse grains, occ mod strong siliceous cement, common white argill matrix, mod hard - hard aggregates, common loose, poor visual porosity PC40 - PC50 Interbedded siltstone, sandstone and coal 7310 - 7437 coal: black, dull - subvit, uneven fracture, mod hard, subfissile siltstone: light - dark grey, argill, very fine arenaceous in part, firm - mod hard, subblocky - subfissile sandstone: pale grey, off white, med - coarse, poorly sorted, subang - ang, mod strong siliceous cement, trace off white argill matrix, mod hard aggregates, common loose, poor visual porosity Windigo 2 7052 - 7520 PC00 Siltstone with occasional sandstone interbeds and thin coal seams 7052 - 7102 siltstone: dark - med grey, med - dark brown grey, argill - commonly carbon and grading in part to coal, mod hard - occ firm, subfissile - subblocky sandstone: pale grey - off white, pale grey brown, translucent in part, dom very fine - fine grained, rare loose med grains, mod well sorted, subang - subrnd, mod - strong siliceous cement, common off white to pale grey argill/silty matrix, occ carbon flecks, mod hard - rare loose grains, very poor - poor visual and inferred porosity coal: black - black grey, dull - occ subvit lustre, brittle - mod hard, uneven fracture, subblocky - subfissile, commonly grading to carbon siltstone PC10 - PL25 Siltstone with occasional sandstone interbeds and coal seams 7102 - 7242 siltstone: dark grey - grey black, argill - carbon, commonly grading to coal, trace siliceous, mod hard - hard, subblocky - subfissile sandstone: translucent - clear, off white - pale grey, dom very fine - fine, occ med, mod well sorted, subang - subrnd, mod siliceous cement, common off white argill/ silty matrix, occ fine carbon flecks, mod hard - hard, poor tight visual porosity coal: black - black grey, dark brown grey, dull - subvit lustre, mod hard, subblocky, uneven fracture, silty and commonly grading to carbon siltstone PC30 - PL35 Sandstone with occasional siltstone interbeds and rare coal 7242 - 7400 coal: as above sandstone: clear - translucent, pale grey brown, locally frosted, very fine - very coarse, dom fine - coarse poorly - mod sorted, ang - subrnd, weak - mod strong siliceous cement, weak - mod off white - pale grey argill matrix, occ fine carbon flecks, friable - locally hard, common loose grains, poor - fair inferred and visual porosity siltstone: med - very dark brown grey, argill - carbon, very finely arenaceous in part, micromica in part, mod firm, subfissile - subblocky PC40 Siltstone with interbedded and interlaminated sandstone (increasing with depth) and 7400 - 7470 occasional coal seams siltstone: dark grey black - dark brown grey, occ med grey, carbon - arenaceous in part, mod hard, subblocky - subfissile sandstone: pale - med grey brown, translucent - clear, dom as fine grained aggregates, rare med - coarse loose grains and fragments, mod sorted, ang - subrnd, mod - strong siliceous cement, weak - off white argill matrix, rare carbon flecks, friable - firm, rare loose grains, very poor - poor visual and inferred porosity coal: blak - black grey, earthy lustre, mod firm, subblocky, uneven - even fracture, commonly silty and grading to a carbon siltstone PC50 Sandstone with occasional siltstone interbeds 7470 - 7524 sandstone: clear - translucent, pale grey, dom fine - med, occ coarse - very coarse, mod sorted, ang - subrnd, mod - weak siliceous cement, rare weak calcareous cement, rare pale grey argill matrix, trace qtz overgrowths, trace carbon flecks, friable - dom loose, poor visual porosity, poor - fair inferred porosity siltstone: med - dark brown grey, dark grey black, rare pale - med grey, argill - very finely arenaceous, locally carbon, micromica in part, mod firm - locally hard, blocky - subfissile Raworth 1 6140 - 6178 PC00 Dominantly siltstone with occasional sandstone interbeds and coals 6140 - 6178 siltstone: black, dark grey, arenaceous grading to sandstone in parts, locally very carbon becoming dom carbon with depth, mica, blocky - platy sandstone: generally white - pale grey, occ black, very fine - fine, subang - rnd, mod well sorted, weak siliceous cement, common kaolinitic matrix, occ carbon inclusions, mod friable, fair - poor visual porosity coal: black, dull - subvit, subcon - uneven fracture surfaces, silty in parts, blocky, firm - splintery PC10 Siltstone with rare sandstone stringers 6178 - 6214 siltstone: black, dark grey, arenaceous grading to sandstone in parts, locally very carbon becoming dom carbon with depth, mica, blocky - platy, firm - britle sandstone: as above PC20 Coarsening upward sandstones and interbedded siltstones 6214-6298 siltstone: as pc10 silt sandstone: as pc10 sand PL25 Coal overlying thin siltstone and sandstone 6298 - 6352 coal: black, dull - pred subvit, subcon - uneven fracture surfaces, banded in parts with carbon siltstones subblocky - platy, brittle - mod firm siltstone: as above sandstone: white, clear, translucent, very fine - coarse, pred fine - med, subang - rnd, mod well sorted, mainly weak - occ mod strong siliceous cement, generally clean aggregates, local kaolinitic matrix, friable, abundant loose grains, fair visual porosity, good inferred porosity PC30 Well developed sandstones with interbedded siltstones and coal 6352 - 6403 siltstone: as above but not carbon with depth sandstone (1): off white - pale grey, occ black, very fine - fine, subang - rnd, mod well sorted, weak siliceous cement, minor kaolinitic matrix, occ carbonaceous inclusions, mod friable, fair - poor visual porosity coal: black, dull - subvit, subcon - uneven fracture surfaces, silty in parts, blocky, firm - splintery sandstone (2): clear - translucent, milky white commonly frosted qtz, very fine - coarse, pred med, mainly loose - occ well cemented aggregates, kaolinitic matrix in parts, friable - mod hard, good inferred porosity, good - poor visual porosity PL35 Well developed sandstones with interbedded siltstones and coal 6403 - 6444 sandstone: dark brown/black, very fine - fine, subang - rnd, well sorted, weak - mod strong siliceous cement, abundant carbon and silt matrix, friable - occ hard, poor - tight visual porosity siltstone: as above PC40 Coarsening upward sequences of interbedded siltstone and minor sandstone 6444 - 6505 siltstone: black, dark grey, aren grading to sandstone in parts, locally very carbon, mica, blocky - platy sandstone: as (2) PC50 Sandstone with subordinate siltstone interbeds 6505 - 6533 sandstone: as (1) siltstone: as above Carney 1 6030 - 6394 PC00 Sandstone with minor siltstone interbeds 6050 - 6092 sandstone: light grey - off white, very fine - fine, subang, mod sorted, siliceous cement, carbon in part, friable, trace visual porosity siltstone: dark grey, commonly carbon, platey, hard, blocky PC10 Siltstone with minor sandstone interbeds 6092 - 6126 siltstone: as above sandstone: dom as above, very fine, grading to an arenaceous siltstone in part, tight visual porosity PC20 Interbedded siltstone, sandstone, and coal 6126 - 6202 siltstone: dark grey, commonly carbon and platey, micromica, firm - hard, blocky - subblocky sandstone: light grey, dom fine, subang - subrnd, mod well sorted, siliceous cement, carbon flecks in part, friable, trace visual porosity coal: black, subvit, hard, subcon, silty PL25 Fining upward sequences of sandstones with minor siltsone and coal 6202 - 6250 siltstone: dark grey - grey, commonly carbon and micromica, firm - hard, blocky - occ subfissile sandstone: clear - commonly off white, fine - dom very fine, mod well sorted, subang - subrnd, trace siliceous cement, friable - commonly loose, poor visual porosity coal: dark grey - black, sandy in part, blocky - subfissile, occ con fracture siltstone: as above sandstone:light grey, fine - rare med, else generally as above, poor visual porosity PC30 -PL35 Thick fining upward sandstone with minor coal and siltstone interbeds 6250 - 6314 coal: as above, firm siltstone: dark grey - grey, commonly carbon and micromica, firm - hard, blocky - occ subfissile sandstone: clear - off white, occ light brown, very fine - med, occ coarse, mod sorted, subang - subrnd, trace silica cement, loose, poor -fair visual porosity PC40 Siltstone with minor sandstone and coal interbeds and well developed sandstone at base 6314 - 6394 siltstone: dark grey, carbon, argill, hard, blocky sandstone: off white - clear, fine, mod sorted, subang - subrnd, siliceous cement, mica, qtz overgrowth cement, friable - hard, poor visual porosity coal: as above sandstone (base): as above but pred med with siliceous cement, poor visual porosity PC50 Thinly interbedded sequence of siltstones, sandstones, and coals 6394 - 6427 siltstone: dark grey, argill, commonly arenaceous, micro, carbon, firm - hard, blocky - subblocky sandstone: off white - light brown, very fine - fine, rare med, poor - mod sorted, subang - subrnd, siliceous cement, trace argill matrix, occ carbon flecks, very poor visual porosity coal: black, vit - subvit, hard, blocky - subcon
Costa 1 6701 - 7074 PC00 - PC10 Predominantly siltstone with thin coal and trace to minor sandstone 6701 - 6784 coal: black - very dark grey, dull - subvit, firm - brittle, uneven - anf fracture, earthy - silty in part siltstone: dark grey, med - dark brownish grey, argill, very finely arenaceous in part, common carbon detritus, micromica, hard - firm, subblocky sandstone: off white - pale brown, pred fine - rarely med grains, subang - subrnd, mod sorted, mod siliceous cement, common kaolinitic matrix, mod hard - friable aggregates, poor - tight visual porosity PC20 Sandstone with minor siltstone and thin coal 6784 - 6869 siltstone: as above coal: as above sandstone: pale grey, translucent - clear, fine grading to med with depth, subang - subrnd, mod well sorted, very firm grading - weak siliceous cement, trace kaolinitic matrix in part, generally clean, friable aggregates - common loose med qtz, mod inferred porosity PL25 - PC30 Predominantly sandstone with minor siltstone and coal 6869 - 6934 coal: black, subvit, dull in part, ang - subblocky fracture, mod hard, brittle in part siltstone: med - dark grey, greyish black, carbon, grading to coal in part, argill in part, minor very finely arenaceous, commonly micromica, mod hard, subblocky sandstone; off white - translucent, pale greyish brown, pred fine grained, rarely med and coarse grains, ang - subrnd, mod sorted, common strong siliceous cement and overgrowths, common dispersive kaolinitic matrix, silty in part, mod hard - friable aggregates, poor visual porosity, fair inferred porosity PL35 Sandstone 6934 - 6964 sandstone: off white, clear - translucent, fine - med, rare coarse grains and fragments, ang - subang, mod - poorly sorted, weak - mod siliceous cement, trace kaolinitic matrix, commonly clean, loose grains, mod hard - friable aggregates and loose grains, poor visual - inferred porosity PC40 - PC50 Predominantly sandstone with interbedded siltstone and coal 6964 - 7074 coal: black, subvit - vit, commonly silty, ang - subblocky, mod hard - brittle siltstone: med -dark grey brown, argill, dispersive - mod hard, finely arenaceous in part, micromica and carbon specks, subfissile - fissile sandstone: off white, translucent, fine aggregates, grading to med and rare loose coarse fragments, subang - ang grains, mod - poorly sorted, firm - strong siliceous cement, minor kaolinitic matrix, mod hard - friable aggregates, some loose grains, poor visual - fair inferred porosity coal: black, subvit - vit, commonly silty , ang - subblocky fracture, mod hard - brittle sandstone: off white, translucent, fine grading to med and coarse at base, subang - minor subrnd, mod sorted, weak - very firm siliceous cement, trace dispersive kaolinitic matrix, firm aggregates, poor visual porosity siltstone; med - dark greyish brown, argill, very finely arenaceous in part, commonly micromica, carbon specks, dispersive - mod hard, subfissile - fissile sandstone: clear - milky, very fine - fine aggregates, occ med - coarse loose grains and fragments, subang - ang , mod - poorly sorted, firm - strong siliceous cement, occ siliceous overgrowths, minor kaolinitic matrix, mod hard - friable aggregates, some loose grains, poor visual - minor inferred porosity Yumba 1 6790 - 7018 PC00 - PL25 Siltstone with minor sandstone and coal interbeds 6790 - 6938 siltstone: med - dark grey, argill, very fine arenaceous, common micromica, very carbon, firm - brittle, subblocky - subfissile, occ fissile sandstone: off white - light grey, opaque - translucent, very fine - fine, mod sorted, subang - subrnd, weak - mod siliceous cement, common off white argill matrix, occ carbon material, friable, poor visual porosity coal: black, dom subvit - dull, firm - brittle, uneven - subconchoidal fractures, slightly argill PC30 - PC40 Sandstone with minor siltstone occasional coal interbeds 6938 - 7020 sandstone: clear - off white, translucent, very fine - occ coarse, dom med, poorly sorted, ang - subrnd, weak siliceous cement, mod off white argill matrix, trace black carbon material, loose - friable, fair inferred porosity siltstone: dom as above coal: dom as above Mookoo 1 7186 - 7521 PC00 - PL25 Siltstone with interbedded sandstone and minor coals 7186 - 7370 siltstone: dark grey brown, dark grey, occ black, very argill, micromica, carbon specks, firm - mod hard, locally hard, subblocky - subfissile sandstone: med brown, off white, very fine - fine, rare med, subang - subrnd, mod sorted, strong siliceous cement, common argill matrix, abundant white, orange and brown lithics fragments, friable - mod hard, poor visual porosity coal: black, dull - subvit, silty, grading to carbon siltstone in parts, brittle, mod hard, subblocky - subfissile PC30 Sandstone with minor coal 7370 - 7432 coal: as above sandstone: white - light brown, clear - translucent, very fine - med, pred fine, subang - subrnd, mod sorted, weak - mod strong siliceous cement, common argill matrix, friable - mod hard, poor visual porosity PL35 Coal and interbedded sandstone and siltstone 7432 - 7461 coal: black, silty in parts, dull - subvit, mod hard, subfissile sandstone: light brown, clear - translucent, pred med, occ fine and coarse, ang - subrnd, mod sorted, mod strong siliceous cement, trace argill matrix, common grey and black lithics fragments, dom loose, locally friable mod hard, fair inferred porosity siltstone: off white - light brown, med - dark grey, argill, grading to claystone in parts, locally arenaceous, common carbon specks, soft - firm, amorphous - subblocky Sandstone and interbedded siltstone PC40 sandstone: light brown, clear - translucent, very fine - fine, occ med, subang - subrnd, mod sorted, mod 7461 - 7521 strong siliceous cement, common light brown argill matrix, trace grey lithics fragments, friable - mod hard, poor visual porosity siltstone: as above
APPENDIX 4
WELL CORE DESCRIPTIONS AND PHOTOS Wippo South 1 7434 - 7494 Depth Lithology Size/ Rnd / Sort Structure Composition Observations 7434 - 7436 siltstone with interlam very fine x-bedding - fine tab - 4in siltstone at shale 90-10 tang / occ trough 7435' 7 7436 - 7439' 5 interlaminated shale + very fine x-bedding -as above shale increases with siltstone 50-50 depth 7439' 5 - 7445 sandstone +cgl base medium / subrnd - large x-bedding qtz 3in cgl at base subang/ well sorted tabular occ carb shale poorly sorted - cgl laminations 7445 - 7446 sandstone with minor med - coarse / x-bedding assc with 3in coarse sand at shale bands subang / subrnd shale +coarse sand 7445' 2 well sorted tabular 7446 - 7448 sandstone with med - sand qtz pebbles 3in cgl at base grades conglomerate base med pebbles - cgl into sand well sorted - sand poorly sorted - cgl subang - subrnd 7448 - 7449 sandstone with minor med - sand qtz pebbles 4in cgl at base grades shale +cgl base med pebbles - cgl into sand / 2in shale well sorted - sand at 7448' 2 poorly sorted - cgl subang - subrnd 7449 - 7450 sandstone with cgl as above but coarser med x-bedding qtz pebbles 2in cgl at base grades base sand +cgl =granules tabular into sand / shale rip- up clasts at 7449' 3 7450 - 7450' 5 sandstone with carb fine - med med x-bedding carb shale laminaes shale laminations subang - subrnd tabular at top and base well sorted 7450' 5 - 7453 sandstone with cgl at med-coar - sand qtz pebbles 4in cgl at base grades base subang - subrnd into sand well sorted cgl - med peb 7453 - 7455' 4 sandstone with cgl at as above, cgl - fair qtz pebbles as above, 5in base base sorted carb shale lam at 54'6 7455' 4 - 7458'6 as above as above, cgl - lge qtz pebbles as above, 6in base peb to gran grading shale rip up clasts btw 57 - 57'11 occ shale lam 7458' 6 - 7459' 3 as above sand - very coarse, qtz pebbles as above, 1.5in base mod sorted sand coarsens up cgl - granules 7459' 3 - 7460' 3 as above sand - med qtz pebbles as above, 2in base cgl - lge pebs sand fines up 7460' 3 - 7463' 6 shale with minor very fine pred laminations bioturbation occurs siltstone 7463' 6 - 7465 interlaminated shale + very fine fine x-bedding siderite common siltstone pred tang siltstone inc with depth 7465 - 7466 sandstone with minor fine - med / subang - fine x-bedding from fine to med with shale bands subrnd / well sorted tabular depth / shale rip ups med from 65' 6 7466 - 7468 '6 sandstone as above but med - med x-bedding from med to coa with coarse tabular depth / 5in coa at base 7468' 6 - 7470 sandstone with minor as above but med - shale bands of 0.5 in shale bands at 2in interval disapp. at 69' 6 7470 - 7474' 6 sandstone with some as above but med- sand coarsens with shale coarse depth 1ft at base / 4in shale band at 70' 8 7474' 6 - 7474' 10 sandstone as above fine - med sand coarsens with depth 7474' 10 - 7480' 8 shale with minor very fine fine x-bedding - tab - some bioturbation siltstone 95-5 tang with sand 7480' 8 - 7482' 10 interlaminated shale + very fine x-bedding hummocky siltstone inc with depth siltstone btw 81'2 - 81'8 4in cgl at base - shale matrix - med qtz pebs 7482' 10 - 7484 sandstone with shale very fine sand / well x-bedding shale lam inc with laminaes sorted depth 7484 - 7484' 6 shale very fine siltstone rip up clast 7484' 6 - 7485' 10 sandstone with shale med sand fine x-bed / pred tan- laminaes tab 7485'10 - 7488'6 shale with minor very fine pred lam siltstone lam 95-5 7488' 6 - 7489' 8 shale with some very fine pred lam / some siltstone inc with depth siltstone lam 75-25 x-bedding 7489' 8 - 7492' 7 siltstone with shale very fine x-bedding shale inc with depth laminaes 80-20 fine - med tab 7492' 7 - 7494 shale very fine pred lam Tartulla 5 7813 - 7873 Depth Lithology Size / Rnd / Sort Structures Composition Observations 7813 - 7820' 6 sandstone med - coa / subang - some x-bedding qtz - overgrowths sand coarsens with subrnd / well sorted large - tabular depth 7820' 6 - 7823 sandstone with minor as above but coarse x-bedding as above qtz pebs common shale laminaes large - tabular sand coarsens slightly with depth 7823 - 7823' 4 conglomerate large pebbles / poorly qtz pebbles siderite common sorted / subang - sub rnd 7823' 4 - 7828' 2 shale with minor very fine x-bed - mig tab - tan siltstone inc with depth siltstone laminae 90-10 laminations - shale from 25' 6 =60-40 shale 7828' 2 - 7830' 3 siltstone with shale very fine as above common siderite interbands 70-30 7830' 3 - 7833 sandstone with minor fine - med / subang - qtz sand coarsens with shale laminaes subrnd / well sorted depth / shale rip ups 7833 - 7838' 6 sandstone as above but med - qtz sand coarsens with coarse depth / qtz pebs 7838' 6 - 7838' 9 interbedded carb shale very coarse sand pred laminations sandstone rip ups and sandstone 7838' 9 - 7839'9 conglomerate very coarse - med qtz, shale pebs + coarsens with depth pebs / subang - sub other lithics from vc sand to cgl rnd/ poorly sorted 7839' 9 - 7841 sandstone as above but vc qtz qtz pebbles common sandstone 7841 - 7842' 3 sandstone with carb as above but vc - med some x-bedding qtz sandstone fines with shale interbands tabular - med depth / 2in carb shale at 7841' 6 / carb shale rip ups / qtz pebbles / 3in coal at 41'10 btw med sand 7842' 3 - 7843' 3 conglomerate med pebs / subang - qtz, shale pebs + subrnd/ poorly sorted other lithics 7843' 3 - 7844 conglomerate with vc sandstone / med as above vc sand grades into cgl some sandstone pebs - lrge pebs cgl with depth / cgl grades from mp - lp 7844 - 7845 conglomerate with cgl - med pebs - gran as above cgl fines with depth sand interbands shale sand - coa -med sand inc with depth laminae 7845 - 7846 sandstone with some med - coa x-bedding qtz sand fines with depth shale large - tabular shale inc with depth from 45' 6 esp 2in shale band at base qtz pebs in sand 7846 - 7847'2 conglomerate and cgl - med peb - gran qtz, shale pebs + cgl grades into sand some sandstone sand - coa - med other lithics with depth / qtz +shale rip ups in sand 7847' 2 - 7847' 4 shale very fine laminated 7847' 4 - 7849' 8 sandstone with cgl at ss - med - coarse cgl - pred qtz sand coarsens with base cgl - med - lge pebs cgl - sand matrix depth grading into cgl 7849' 8 - 7850' 1 conglomerate with cgl - lge pebs shale, sand matrix large shale clats large shale clasts 7850' 1 - 7850' 5 conglomerate large pebs qtz, some shale clasts 7850' 5 - 7851 conglomerate with gran - med pebs qtz, shale vc sand 2in grades into some sandstone cgl / sand shale rip ups 7851 - 7866 sandstone with shale pred med / subang - x-bedding 0.5 - 1in shale bands at laminae +occ bands subrnd / well sorted fine tab - slight 51, 52'8, 52'10, 53'7, tan / some trough x 56'11, 58, 59'1, 62'10 7866 - 7870 as above but less as above lge x-bedding as above, at 67, 67'3, shale laminae tabular 69'4 7870 - 7872'6 sandstone with cgl at med - coarse sand matrix sand coarsens with base cgl - granules depth, at 72 cgl Tartulla 1 7930 - 7987 Depth Lithology Size / Rnd / Sort Structures Composition Observations 7930 - 7936 ' 6 shale with interlaminat very fine shale - pred lamin occ 1-2in silt bands siltstone 70-30 fine -med x-bedding some qtz clats at 30'9, pred tan - trough 33' 8 7936' 6 - 7936' 9 conglomerate vc - med pebbles siderite matrix, qtz sandstone present in subang - subrnd pebbles cgl in btw 7936' 9 - 7938' 6 sandstone with cgl at coa - vc - sand qtz clasts sand coarsens with base med pebs - lge pebs depth grades into cgl cgl / sand well sorted/ cgl poorly sorted 7938' 6 - 7942' 3 shale with interlaminat very fine shale - pred lamin siltstone inc at 41' 3 siltstone 85-15 siltstone - x-bedding 7942' 3 - 7944 sandstone with shale fine pred x-bedding siderite from 43' 6 shale inc at 43' 6 / 3in lam fine - med tabular shale band at base /qtz clast at top and 43' 9 7944 - 7946 sandstone fine - med slightly laminated sand coarsens with depth / shale lam 44- 44'2, 45'10 7946 - 7948 sandstone with cgl at sand - med pred qtz pebbles sand coarsens with base cgl - gran - med pebs depth grades into cgl subang - subrnd 2in vc sand with shale at 47' 3 7948 - 7949' 6 conglomerate cgl - granules pred qtz pebbles cgl coarsens slightly with depth 7949' 6 - 7950' 6 sandstone with shale fine x-bedding very shaley laminae 7950' 6 - 7951 shale with interlaminat very fine x-bedding siltstone inc with depth siltstone 70-30 7951 - 7951' 10 sandstone with minor fine x-bedding qtz shale lam decr with shale laminae depth 7951' 10 - 7954 siltstone/ sandstone fine - very fine x-bedding biturbation, flaser with interlam shale common 7954 - 7956 shale with interlaminat very fine lam - shale siltstone inc with depth siltstone 60-40 x-bedding - siltstone 7956 - 7957 siltstone/ ss with some very fine lam - shale 2in shale band at 56'4 shale x-bedding - siltstone bioturbation, siderite 7957 - 7961' 11 shale with interlaminat very fine as above bioturbation, siderite siltstone 80-20 7961' 11 - 7964 sandstone with some fine - med 1in shale band at 62'4 shale 2in shale band at 63'2 shale lam at 63' 11 7964 - 7965 shale with minor very fine pred lam siltstone inc with depth siltstone 95-5 7965 - 7966 interbedded shale and very fine x-bedding and lam bioturbation, more siltstone 60-40 siltstone towards base 7966 - 7967 shale very fine pred lam very fine siltstone lam 7967 - 7970' 6 shale with interlam very fine lam - shale siltstone 90-10 7970' 6 - 7971' 6 interbedded shale and fine sand/silt 50-50 7971' 6 - 7974 sandstone with some sand - fine / subrnd/ fine x-bed / tabular shale dec with depth shale well sorted 6in shale/sand band at 72'3 / 0.5in shale bands at 73'3, 73'9, 73'11 7974 - 7986' 3 sandstone with occ as above very fine - none very fine +little shale shale x-bedding / inc with lam / shale dec with depth - tab -tang depth / 2in shale band at 76'9
TARTULLA 1 7937 FT
TARTULLA 1 7957 FT
TARTULLA 1 79468
TARTULLA 5 7817
TARTULLA 5 78267
TARTULLA 5 7859
WIPPO SOUTH - 74495
WIPPO SOUTH 1 7458
WIPPO SOUTH 1 - 7435
APPENDIX 5
SANTOS LTD. ROCK TYPING; TARTULLA 1 AND TARTULLA 5 ROCK TYPING CUTTINGS SAMPLE DESCRIPTION WELL : Tartulla 1 DATE: 14th May, 2003 LOGGED BY: D.Harrison COMMENTS: FORMATION (INTERVAL): Toolachee (7870-8010) Colour Key: Whole sample described Best rock present described TOP BASE SAMPLE SHOWS LITHOLOGY GRAIN SIZE ROUNDNESS SPHERICITY SORTING DEPTH DEPTH QUALITY % % % % % % Ft Ft P o o r F a i r G o o d S t a i n N a t u r a l
F l u C u t
F l u C o n g l o m e r a t S a n d s t o n e S i l t s t o n e S h a l e C o a l L i m e s t o n e D o l o m i t e A n h y d r i t e P a l a e o s o l O t h e r 2 5 6
+ m m 1 2 8 - 2 5 6 m m 6 4 - 1 2 8 m m 3 2 - 6 4 m m 1 6
-
3 2 m m 8
-
1 6 m m 4
-
8 m m 2
-
4 m m V
C r s
U V
C r s
L C r s
U C r s
L M e d
U M e d
L F i n e
U F i n e
L V
F i n e
U V
F i n e
L S i l t
U S i l t
L A n g u l a r S u b
A n g u l a r S u b
R o u n d R o u n d W e l l
R o u n d L o w M o d e r a t e H i g h B i - m o d a l V
WELL : FORMATION TOP BASE DEPTH DEPTH Ft Ft 7860 7870 7870 7880 7880 7890 7890 7900 7900 7910 7910 7920 7920 7930 7930 7940 7940 7950 7950 7960 7960 7970 7970 7980 7980 7990 7990 8000 8000 8010 8010 8020 GRAIN CONSOLIDATION COMPACT LUSTRE FRAMEWORK POROSITY MATRIX % ROCK TYPE RELIEF % % % % % % Cement Detrital Diagenetic clay %
L o w M o d e r a t e H i g h U n c o n s o l S l i g h t l y M o d e r a t e M o d - W e l l W e l l V e r y
W e l l L o w M o d e r a t e H i g h D u l l M o d e r a t e B r i g h t Q u a r t z F e l d s p a r C h e r t S h a l e M i c a R o c k
F r a g s H e a v y
M i n s O t h e r M a c r o
E f f e c t i v e M i c r o
E f f e c t i v e M a c r o
I n e f f e c t i v e M i c r o
I n e f f e c t i v e Q u a r t z C h e r t L i m e s t o n e D o l o m i t e S i d e r i t e A n h y d r i t e P y r i t e S o l i d
H C O t h e r A r g i l l a c e o u s S i l t A r e n a c e o u s O t h e r P o r e F i l l i n g ( K a o l i n ) P o r e F i l l i n g ( U n d i f f ) G r a i n
WELL : FORMATION TOP BASE DEPTH DEPTH Ft Ft 7860 7870 7870 7880 7880 7890 7890 7900 7900 7910 7910 7920 7920 7930 7930 7940 7940 7950 7950 7960 7960 7970 7970 7980 7980 7990 7990 8000 8000 8010 8010 8020 COMMENTS 1 COMMENTS 2 COMMENTS 3 COMMENTS 4 Car bonaceous Shal e, gr eyi sh bl ack and Coal bl ack, ear t hy. Mi nor Sst , l t ol gy, vf l , cl ayey, no vi s macr o por osi t y, poor gr ai n r el i ef , non r es. Sandst one, l i ght ol i ve gr ey, l f g, cl ayey The bet t er r ock has ef f ect i ve por osi t y, l ow cl aycl ay, f ai r gr ai n r el i ef and i s coar se, l mg. Car bonaceous Shal e, gr eyi sh bl ack and Coal Sst & Cgt , l t ol gy, some ver y good r es. Lesser r ock has kaol i ni t e i n por e space. Car bonaceous Shal e, gr eyi sh bl ack. Sst & Cgt , l t ol gy, some ver y good r es. Lesser r ock has kaol i ni t e i n por e space. Shal e, medi umdar k gr ey, sl i ght l y car bonaceous Sst & Cgt , l t ol gy, some ver y good r es. Lesser r ock has kaol i ni t e i n por e space. Shal e, medi umdar k gr ey, sl i ght l y car bonaceous Sandst one, l i ght ol i ve gr ey, uf g, sl cl ayey Lesser r ock has kaol i ni t e i n por e space. Shal e, dar k gr ey, car bonaceous Car bonaceous Shal e, bl ack and Coal , bl ack Sandst one, l i ght ol i ve gr ey, uf g, sl cl ayey Sst & Cgt , l t ol gy, some ver y good r es. Lesser r ock has kaol i ni t e i n por e space. Shal e, gr ey bl ack, sl i ght l y car bonaceous Coal , bl ack Sst & Cgt , l t ol gy, some ver y good r es. Lesser r ock has kaol i ni t e i n por e space. Shal e, medi umgr ey, sl i ght l y car bonaceous Coal , bl ack, l ust r ous Sst & Cgt , l t ol gy, some ver y good r es. Lesser r ock has kaol i ni t e i n por e space. Shal e, gr ey bl ack, car bonaceous Coal , bl ack, l ust r ous Sst & Cgt , l t ol gy, some good r es. Lesser r ock has kaol i ni t e i n por e space. Shal e, dar k gr ey , car bonaceous Coal , bl ack, l ust r ous Sst & Cgt , l t ol gy, mi nor good r es. Lesser r ock has kaol i ni t e i n por e space. Shal e, dar k gr ey , sl i ght l y car bonaceous Coal , bl ack, l ust r ous Sst & Cgt , l t ol gy, mi nor good r es. Some associ at ed di cki t e and kaol i ni t e Shal e, dar k gr ey , sl i ght l y car bonaceous Sst & Cgt , l t ol gy, mi nor good r es. Kaol i ni t e & car b. mat er i al i n por e space Shal e, dar k gr ey , sl i ght l y car bonaceous Page 3
WELL : FORMATION TOP BASE DEPTH DEPTH Ft Ft 7860 7870 7870 7880 7880 7890 7890 7900 7900 7910 7910 7920 7920 7930 7930 7940 7940 7950 7950 7960 7960 7970 7970 7980 7980 7990 7990 8000 8000 8010 8010 8020 COMMENTS 5 COMMENTS 6 COMMENTS 7 Page 4 ROCK TYPING CUTTINGS SAMPLE DESCRIPTION WELL : Tartulla 1 DATE: 14th May, 2003 LOGGED BY: D.Harrison COMMENTS: FORMATION (INTERVAL): Toolachee (7870-8010) Colour Key: Whole sample described Best rock present described TOP BASE SAMPLE SHOWS LITHOLOGY GRAIN SIZE ROUNDNESS SPHERICITY SORTING DEPTH DEPTH QUALITY % % % % % % Ft Ft P o o r F a i r G o o d S t a i n N a t u r a l
F l u C u t
F l u C o n g l o m e r a t S a n d s t o n e S i l t s t o n e S h a l e C o a l L i m e s t o n e D o l o m i t e A n h y d r i t e P a l a e o s o l O t h e r 2 5 6
+ m m 1 2 8 - 2 5 6 m m 6 4 - 1 2 8 m m 3 2 - 6 4 m m 1 6
-
3 2 m m 8
-
1 6 m m 4
-
8 m m 2
-
4 m m V
C r s
U V
C r s
L C r s
U C r s
L M e d
U M e d
L F i n e
U F i n e
L V
F i n e
U V
F i n e
L S i l t
U S i l t
L A n g u l a r S u b
A n g u l a r S u b
R o u n d R o u n d W e l l
R o u n d L o w M o d e r a t e H i g h B i - m o d a l V
P o o r P o o r M o d e r a t e W e l l V e r y
W e l l Page 5
WELL : FORMATION TOP BASE DEPTH DEPTH Ft Ft GRAIN CONSOLIDATION COMPACT LUSTRE FRAMEWORK POROSITY MATRIX % ROCK TYPE RELIEF % % % % % % Cement Detrital Diagenetic clay %
L o w M o d e r a t e H i g h U n c o n s o l S l i g h t l y M o d e r a t e M o d - W e l l W e l l V e r y
W e l l L o w M o d e r a t e H i g h D u l l M o d e r a t e B r i g h t Q u a r t z F e l d s p a r C h e r t S h a l e M i c a R o c k
F r a g s H e a v y
M i n s O t h e r M a c r o
E f f e c t i v e M i c r o
E f f e c t i v e M a c r o
I n e f f e c t i v e M i c r o
I n e f f e c t i v e Q u a r t z C h e r t L i m e s t o n e D o l o m i t e S i d e r i t e A n h y d r i t e P y r i t e S o l i d
H C O t h e r A r g i l l a c e o u s S i l t A r e n a c e o u s O t h e r P o r e F i l l i n g ( K a o l i n ) P o r e F i l l i n g ( U n d i f f ) G r a i n
C o a t O t h e r 1A 1B 1C 1D II III Page 6
WELL : FORMATION TOP BASE DEPTH DEPTH Ft Ft COMMENTS 1 COMMENTS 2 COMMENTS 3 COMMENTS 4 Page 7
WELL : FORMATION TOP BASE DEPTH DEPTH Ft Ft COMMENTS 5 COMMENTS 6 COMMENTS 7 Page 8 ROCK TYPING CUTTINGS SAMPLE DESCRIPTION WELL : Tartulla 1 DATE: 14th May, 2003 LOGGED BY: D.Harrison COMMENTS: FORMATION (INTERVAL): Toolachee (7870-8010) Colour Key: Whole sample described Best rock present described TOP BASE SAMPLE SHOWS LITHOLOGY GRAIN SIZE ROUNDNESS SPHERICITY SORTING DEPTH DEPTH QUALITY % % % % % % Ft Ft P o o r F a i r G o o d S t a i n N a t u r a l
F l u C u t
F l u C o n g l o m e r a t S a n d s t o n e S i l t s t o n e S h a l e C o a l L i m e s t o n e D o l o m i t e A n h y d r i t e P a l a e o s o l O t h e r 2 5 6
+ m m 1 2 8 - 2 5 6 m m 6 4 - 1 2 8 m m 3 2 - 6 4 m m 1 6
-
3 2 m m 8
-
1 6 m m 4
-
8 m m 2
-
4 m m V
C r s
U V
C r s
L C r s
U C r s
L M e d
U M e d
L F i n e
U F i n e
L V
F i n e
U V
F i n e
L S i l t
U S i l t
L A n g u l a r S u b
A n g u l a r S u b
R o u n d R o u n d W e l l
R o u n d L o w M o d e r a t e H i g h B i - m o d a l V
P o o r P o o r M o d e r a t e W e l l V e r y
W e l l Page 9
WELL : FORMATION TOP BASE DEPTH DEPTH Ft Ft GRAIN CONSOLIDATION COMPACT LUSTRE FRAMEWORK POROSITY MATRIX % ROCK TYPE RELIEF % % % % % % Cement Detrital Diagenetic clay %
L o w M o d e r a t e H i g h U n c o n s o l S l i g h t l y M o d e r a t e M o d - W e l l W e l l V e r y
W e l l L o w M o d e r a t e H i g h D u l l M o d e r a t e B r i g h t Q u a r t z F e l d s p a r C h e r t S h a l e M i c a R o c k
F r a g s H e a v y
M i n s O t h e r M a c r o
E f f e c t i v e M i c r o
E f f e c t i v e M a c r o
I n e f f e c t i v e M i c r o
I n e f f e c t i v e Q u a r t z C h e r t L i m e s t o n e D o l o m i t e S i d e r i t e A n h y d r i t e P y r i t e S o l i d
H C O t h e r A r g i l l a c e o u s S i l t A r e n a c e o u s O t h e r P o r e F i l l i n g ( K a o l i n ) P o r e F i l l i n g ( U n d i f f ) G r a i n
C o a t O t h e r 1A 1B 1C 1D II III Page 10
WELL : FORMATION TOP BASE DEPTH DEPTH Ft Ft COMMENTS 1 COMMENTS 2 COMMENTS 3 COMMENTS 4 Page 11
WELL : FORMATION TOP BASE DEPTH DEPTH Ft Ft COMMENTS 5 COMMENTS 6 COMMENTS 7 Page 12 ROCK TYPING CUTTINGS SAMPLE DESCRIPTION WELL : Tartulla 1 DATE: 14th May, 2003 LOGGED BY: D.Harrison COMMENTS: FORMATION (INTERVAL): Toolachee (7870-8010) Colour Key: Whole sample described Best rock present described TOP BASE SAMPLE SHOWS LITHOLOGY GRAIN SIZE ROUNDNESS SPHERICITY SORTING DEPTH DEPTH QUALITY % % % % % % Ft Ft P o o r F a i r G o o d S t a i n N a t u r a l
F l u C u t
F l u C o n g l o m e r a t S a n d s t o n e S i l t s t o n e S h a l e C o a l L i m e s t o n e D o l o m i t e A n h y d r i t e P a l a e o s o l O t h e r 2 5 6
+ m m 1 2 8 - 2 5 6 m m 6 4 - 1 2 8 m m 3 2 - 6 4 m m 1 6
-
3 2 m m 8
-
1 6 m m 4
-
8 m m 2
-
4 m m V
C r s
U V
C r s
L C r s
U C r s
L M e d
U M e d
L F i n e
U F i n e
L V
F i n e
U V
F i n e
L S i l t
U S i l t
L A n g u l a r S u b
A n g u l a r S u b
R o u n d R o u n d W e l l
R o u n d L o w M o d e r a t e H i g h B i - m o d a l V
P o o r P o o r M o d e r a t e W e l l V e r y
W e l l Page 13
WELL : FORMATION TOP BASE DEPTH DEPTH Ft Ft GRAIN CONSOLIDATION COMPACT LUSTRE FRAMEWORK POROSITY MATRIX % ROCK TYPE RELIEF % % % % % % Cement Detrital Diagenetic clay %
L o w M o d e r a t e H i g h U n c o n s o l S l i g h t l y M o d e r a t e M o d - W e l l W e l l V e r y
W e l l L o w M o d e r a t e H i g h D u l l M o d e r a t e B r i g h t Q u a r t z F e l d s p a r C h e r t S h a l e M i c a R o c k
F r a g s H e a v y
M i n s O t h e r M a c r o
E f f e c t i v e M i c r o
E f f e c t i v e M a c r o
I n e f f e c t i v e M i c r o
I n e f f e c t i v e Q u a r t z C h e r t L i m e s t o n e D o l o m i t e S i d e r i t e A n h y d r i t e P y r i t e S o l i d
H C O t h e r A r g i l l a c e o u s S i l t A r e n a c e o u s O t h e r P o r e F i l l i n g ( K a o l i n ) P o r e F i l l i n g ( U n d i f f ) G r a i n
C o a t O t h e r 1A 1B 1C 1D II III Page 14
WELL : FORMATION TOP BASE DEPTH DEPTH Ft Ft COMMENTS 1 COMMENTS 2 COMMENTS 3 COMMENTS 4 Page 15
WELL : FORMATION TOP BASE DEPTH DEPTH Ft Ft COMMENTS 5 COMMENTS 6 COMMENTS 7 Page 16 ROCK CATALOGUE CORE CHIP DESCRIPTION CORE PLUG SAMPLE DESCRIPTION WELL : Tartulla 5 - Core 1 DATE: 13th May, 2003 LOGGED BY: D.Harrison CORE No/FORMATION: 1 .
The frequency ranges were obtained from the 3-D seismic data volume at the depth of the Toolachee Formation. Apparent dominant frequency represents the dominant frequency value within the frequency range of any given well. The average velocity was measured from the sonic logs within the interval of the Toolachee Formation. Wavelength is the result of velocity / dominant frequency. Tuning thickness is the result of wavelength / 4.
AMPLITUDE High amplitude values extracted from the peaks (negative reflection coefficient) are represented towards the bottom of the colour-bar (red). High amplitude values extracted from the troughs (positive reflection coefficient) are represented towards the top of the colour-bar (black).
EVENT WIDTH Measured in milliseconds. The increase in width between the 0- crossings of an event is indicated towards the bottom of the colour-bar.
DIP MAGNITUDE Measured in millisecond per meter. The increase in dip between two seismic events of a given horizon is indicated towards the bottom of the colour- bar.
ISOCHRON - Measured in milliseconds. The increase in width between two mapped horizons is indicated towards the bottom of the colour-bar.
TWT STRUCTURE Measured in milliseconds. The increase in two-way travel time to a horizon is indicated towards the bottom of the colour-bar.
VARIANCE Measured in milliseconds. The increase in variance is indicated by a darker grey.
Channels that were at least one wavelength in length were classified. The identified fluvial bodies are colour coded, a solid red line for distinct channels; a dashed red line for subtle channels; a solid blue line for faults, and a solid green line for successive channels.
A B C D E F G P Horizon A B C D E F G H H I J KK P2 Horizon A B C D E F G H I J K L M N P3 Horizon