Professional Documents
Culture Documents
E'e&ents o$ a !recedent )
*a+ Concrete decision ) bindin, "!on !arties
*b+ Abstract Princi!'e ) bindin, as an a"thority on a s"bse("ent
-"d,e.
1ts decisions bind a'' co"rts be'o# it. 1ts decisions bind a'' co"rts be'o# it.
Not bo"nd #hen decision is &ade in i,norance o$ stat"te, or #here Not bo"nd #hen decision is &ade in i,norance o$ stat"te, or #here
the !rinci!'e is obsc"re, or #here it is o"t o$ 'ine #ith estab'ished the !rinci!'e is obsc"re, or #here it is o"t o$ 'ine #ith estab'ished
!rinci!'es and other a"thorities. ?Decided in !rinci!'es and other a"thorities. ?Decided in Scr"ttons Ltd. @.Mid'and Scr"ttons Ltd. @.Mid'and
Si'icones Ltd. ) *59A<+ AC BBA *0L+ Si'icones Ltd. ) *59A<+ AC BBA *0L+C C
Not bo"nd by its o#n decisions, b"t ,reat res!ect is !aid. Not bo"nd by its o#n decisions, b"t ,reat res!ect is !aid.
4inds a'' in$erior civi' co"rts. 4inds a'' in$erior civi' co"rts.
4o"nd by its o#n decisions *Decided in 59BB+ 4o"nd by its o#n decisions *Decided in 59BB+
con$'ict bet#een its o#n decisions ) it has to chose. con$'ict bet#een its o#n decisions ) it has to chose.
When decisions tho",h not overr"'ed, cannot stand #ith the When decisions tho",h not overr"'ed, cannot stand #ith the
decisions o$ the 0o"se o$ Lords. decisions o$ the 0o"se o$ Lords.
1$ ,iven in i,norance o$ a stat"te or r"'e havin, stat"tory e$$ect. 1$ ,iven in i,norance o$ a stat"te or r"'e havin, stat"tory e$$ect.
?0e'd in the ?0e'd in the 4risto' Aero!'ane Case ) *59BB+ 5 K4 D56+ 4risto' Aero!'ane Case ) *59BB+ 5 K4 D56+C C
Presented by Mr. M.S.Krishnan, Senior Advocate Presented by Mr. M.S.Krishnan, Senior Advocate
E
Co"rt o$ Cri&ina' A!!ea'
Carries ,reater #ei,ht than the decisions o$ a !"isne -"d,e, b"t cannot
overr"'e that.
Pre/1nde!endence
Accordin, to S.<5< o$ the 2ovt o$ 1ndia Act, 59GH / La# 'aid do#n by
Federa' Co"rt and any -"d,&ent o$ the Privy Co"nci' is bindin, on a''
co"rts o$ 4ritish 1ndia ) Privy Co"nci' #as s"!re&e -"dicia' a"thority )
A1R 59<H PC <D<.
Post/1nde!endence
SC beca&e the s"!re&e -"dicia' a"thority ) strea&'ined syste& o$
co"rts estab'ished.
S"!re&e Co"rt
0i,h Co"rts
Lo#er co"rts
Art. 5B5 states, :he 'a# dec'ared by the SC sha'' be bindin, on a''
co"rts #ithin the territory o$ 1ndia.
0o#ever, Art. 5B5 does not &ean or i&!'y that the 'a# once dec'ared
by the SC cannot be a'tered by a co&!etent 'e,is'at"re ) A1R 59H5
4o&. BG6. 1$, by an a&end&ent the 'a# is chan,ed, the a&end&ent
#o"'d not a$$ect Art. 5B5 beca"se the dec'aration itse'$ #o"'d co&e to
an end #ith the chan,e o$ the 'a#.
1n 599H *A+ SCC A5B, the SC dec'ared, 7he co"rt, as a #in, o$ a state,
is itse'$ a so"rce o$ 'a#. he 'a# is #hat the SC says it is8. his $a&o"s
state&ent o$ the co"rt has been ,reat'y criticiFed as it ,ives e%cess
!o#er to the co"rts, and ne,'ects the conce!t o$ se!aration o$ !o#ers.
0o#ever a decision is a !recedent on'y #hen it decides a ("estion 0o#ever a decision is a !recedent on'y #hen it decides a ("estion
o$ 'a# and not other#ise ) o$ 'a# and not other#ise ) 599< *5+ SLR GGH*SC+ 599< *5+ SLR GGH*SC+ Decisions o$ the Decisions o$ the
SC as to as to $acts cannot be cited as !recedents ) SC as to as to $acts cannot be cited as !recedents ) A1R 59A= SC A1R 59A= SC
59H 59H
he 0C in the na&e o$ inter!retin, the -"d,e&ent o$ the SC cannot he 0C in the na&e o$ inter!retin, the -"d,e&ent o$ the SC cannot
sit in a!!ea' and &odi$y it ) sit in a!!ea' and &odi$y it ) A1R 596A SC 5BHH A1R 596A SC 5BHH
he SC sho"'d not &aJe any !rono"nce&ent on any ("estion he SC sho"'d not &aJe any !rono"nce&ent on any ("estion
#hich is not strict'y necessary $or the dis!osa' o$ the !artic"'ar case #hich is not strict'y necessary $or the dis!osa' o$ the !artic"'ar case
be$ore it / be$ore it / A1R 59H9 SC 5B9 A1R 59H9 SC 5B9
1n the case o$ 1n the case o$ A1R 596= SC <5BD A1R 596= SC <5BD, the SC reco&&ended the $ra&in, , the SC reco&&ended the $ra&in,
o$ ,"ide'ines in the e%ercise o$ !o#er "nder Art. D< and 5A5. 1t #as o$ ,"ide'ines in the e%ercise o$ !o#er "nder Art. D< and 5A5. 1t #as
he'd that the co"rt 'aid do#n a &ere reco&&endation, not a ratio he'd that the co"rt 'aid do#n a &ere reco&&endation, not a ratio
decidendi, and there$ore did not &ind the Constit"tion bench in a decidendi, and there$ore did not &ind the Constit"tion bench in a
s"bse("ent case. A'tho",h the Co"rt &ay reco&&end the $ra&in, s"bse("ent case. A'tho",h the Co"rt &ay reco&&end the $ra&in,
o$ ,"ide'ines, s"ch a reco&&endation is not bindin, "!on the 2ovt. o$ ,"ide'ines, s"ch a reco&&endation is not bindin, "!on the 2ovt.
1n case o$ a con$'ict bet#een t#o SC -"d,&ents by benches o$ e("a' 1n case o$ a con$'ict bet#een t#o SC -"d,&ents by benches o$ e("a'
stren,th, it has been he'd that the 'ater decision has to be $o''o#ed, stren,th, it has been he'd that the 'ater decision has to be $o''o#ed,
it havin, i&!'ied'y overr"'ed the ear'ier decision ) it havin, i&!'ied'y overr"'ed the ear'ier decision ) A1R 596= SC A1R 596= SC
59HH 59HH. 0o#ever, i$ one o$ the decisions &ore '"cid'y e%!'ains the . 0o#ever, i$ one o$ the decisions &ore '"cid'y e%!'ains the
sit"ation, #hi'e the other 'eaves it o!en, the '"cid decision has to be sit"ation, #hi'e the other 'eaves it o!en, the '"cid decision has to be
taJen into acco"nt / taJen into acco"nt / A1R 596D Pat. HG. A1R 596D Pat. HG. his ho#ever, #o"'d his ho#ever, #o"'d
de!end "!on the $acts o$ each individ"a' case. de!end "!on the $acts o$ each individ"a' case.
When the SC, #ith de'iberate intent o$ sett'in, the 'a#, !rono"nces When the SC, #ith de'iberate intent o$ sett'in, the 'a#, !rono"nces
"!on a ("estion, it #o"'d be 'a# "nder Art. 5B5. Once the 'a# is "!on a ("estion, it #o"'d be 'a# "nder Art. 5B5. Once the 'a# is
dec'ared, it is not !ossib'e to han, onto a contrary vie# o$ the 0C dec'ared, it is not !ossib'e to han, onto a contrary vie# o$ the 0C
&ere'y beca"se it has not been s!eci$ica''y overr"'ed by the SC. &ere'y beca"se it has not been s!eci$ica''y overr"'ed by the SC.
Presented by Mr. M.S.Krishnan, Senior Advocate Presented by Mr. M.S.Krishnan, Senior Advocate
ELEMENTS OF A JUDGEMENT RATIO DECIDENDI AND OBITER
DICTA
RA1O DEC1DEND1
A case is on'y an a"thority $or #hat it decides, and not $ro& #hat
'o,ica''y $o''o#s $ro& it ) he'd in A1R 59AD SC 5=DG
O41ER D1CA
0o#ever, the #ei,ht accorded to dicta varies #ith the ty!e o$ dict"&.
Mere cas"a' e%!ressions carry no #ei,ht at a''. Not every !assin,
e%!ression o$ a -"d,e, no &atter ho# e&inent cannot be treated as a
havin, the #ei,ht o$ a"thority. 1n so&e cases, the obiter dicta o$ the
co"rt #i'' have &ere reco&&endatory e$$ect, and the ,overn&ent or
!arties to the case are not bo"nd by the&.
1n 1ndia, it has been he'd by the 4o&bay 0C, that the obiter dicta o$ the
PC #ere bindin, on a'' co"rts in 1ndia, on the ,ro"nd that i$ the hi,hest
co"rt o$ a!!ea' had a!!'ied its &ind and decided a ("estion, -"dicia'
disci!'ine re("ired that the decision sho"'d be $o''o#ed ) HA 4o&
L.R.55HA.
1n En,'and obiter dicta are not bindin, on any co"rt ) 0a'sb"ry, @o' <<,
!. D9D.
Presented by Mr. M.S.Krishnan, Senior Advocate Presented by Mr. M.S.Krishnan, Senior Advocate
PER 1NC>R1AM
NA decision is ,iven !er inc"ria& #hen the co"rt has acted NA decision is ,iven !er inc"ria& #hen the co"rt has acted
E
1n i,norance o$ a !revio"s decision o$ its o#n or o$ a co"rt o$ co/ 1n i,norance o$ a !revio"s decision o$ its o#n or o$ a co"rt o$ co/
ordinate -"risdiction #hi'e covered the case be$ore it, in #hich case it ordinate -"risdiction #hi'e covered the case be$ore it, in #hich case it
&"st decide #hich case to $o''o#, or &"st decide #hich case to $o''o#, or
E
When it has acted in i,norance o$ a 0o"se o$ Lords decision, in When it has acted in i,norance o$ a 0o"se o$ Lords decision, in
#hich case it &"st $o''o# that decisionO or #hich case it &"st $o''o# that decisionO or
E
When the decision is ,iven in i,norance o$ the ter&s o$ a stat"te or When the decision is ,iven in i,norance o$ the ter&s o$ a stat"te or
r"'e havin, stat"tory $orce. r"'e havin, stat"tory $orce.
A decision sho"'d not be treated as ,iven !er inc"ria&, ho#ever, A decision sho"'d not be treated as ,iven !er inc"ria&, ho#ever,
si&!'y beca"se o$ a de$iciency o$ !arties, or beca"se the Co"rt had si&!'y beca"se o$ a de$iciency o$ !arties, or beca"se the Co"rt had
not the bene$it o$ the best ar,"&ent, and, as a ,enera' r"'e, the on'y not the bene$it o$ the best ar,"&ent, and, as a ,enera' r"'e, the on'y
cases in #hich decisions sho"'d be he'd to be ,iven !er inc"ria& cases in #hich decisions sho"'d be he'd to be ,iven !er inc"ria&
are those ,iven in i,norance o$ so&e inconsistent stat"te or bindin, are those ,iven in i,norance o$ so&e inconsistent stat"te or bindin,
a"thority. Even i$ a decision o$ the Co"rt o$ A!!ea' has a"thority. Even i$ a decision o$ the Co"rt o$ A!!ea' has
&isinter!reted a !revio"s decision o$ the 0o"se o$ Lords, the Co"rt &isinter!reted a !revio"s decision o$ the 0o"se o$ Lords, the Co"rt
o$ A!!ea' &"st $o''o# its !revio"s decision and 'eave the 0o"se o$ o$ A!!ea' &"st $o''o# its !revio"s decision and 'eave the 0o"se o$
Lords to recti$y the &istaJeN. Lords to recti$y the &istaJeN.
he 'a# is the sa&e in 1ndia, and a -"d,&ent rendered in i,norance he 'a# is the sa&e in 1ndia, and a -"d,&ent rendered in i,norance
o$ a re'evant constit"tiona' or stat"tory !rovision is not bindin, "!on o$ a re'evant constit"tiona' or stat"tory !rovision is not bindin, "!on
any co"rt in 1ndia. his !rinci!'e has been acce!ted by the SC in any co"rt in 1ndia. his !rinci!'e has been acce!ted by the SC in
severa' cases inc'"din, severa' cases inc'"din, *5966+ < SCC A=<, A1R 59HH SC AA5, 596H *5966+ < SCC A=<, A1R 59HH SC AA5, 596H
S"! SCC <6=, *<===+ B SCC <A< S"! SCC <6=, *<===+ B SCC <A< and recent'y in and recent'y in *<==D+ D SCC AAD. *<==D+ D SCC AAD.
Presented by Mr. M.S.Krishnan, Senior Advocate Presented by Mr. M.S.Krishnan, Senior Advocate
DOCR1NE OF SARE DEC1S1S DOCR1NE OF SARE DEC1S1S
When there is on'y one ("estion be$ore the Co"rt, #here the -"d,es
a,ree on a ,enera' !rinci!'e o$ 'a#, b"t di$$er as to its s!eci$ic
a!!'ication in the case, the ratio o$ the case &"st be identi$ied and
that a'one is bindin,.
Presented by Mr. M.S.Krishnan, Senior Advocate Presented by Mr. M.S.Krishnan, Senior Advocate
1n the De'hi La#s case ) *59HH+ 5 SCR <96, severa' Jinds o$ de'e,ation
#as "!he'd by the -"d,es, b"t no !rinci!'e co"'d be ded"ced $ro& it as
a'' the -"d,es de'ivered di$$erent o!inions. 1$ a !attern co"'d be identi$ied
$ro& s"ch a case, that a'one #o"'d be bindin, in s"bse("ent cases.
1n K"'y <==D, the co"rt !assed an order detai'in, the !rinci!'es 'aid do#n
by the 0on8b'e S"!re&e Co"rt in re'ation to Co!yri,ht in derivative #orJsO
and its o#n -"d,e&ent !"b'ications. he test $or ori,ina'ity in derivative
#orJs havin, been c'ear'y 'aid do#n, the K"d,&ent #o"'d serve as a
,"idin, $orce in the area o$ co!yri,hts.
Presented by Mr. M.S.Krishnan, Senior Advocate Presented by Mr. M.S.Krishnan, Senior Advocate
CIRCUMSTANCES WEAKENING THE BINDING FORCE OF
PRECEDENTS
5. Reversa'
<. Overr"'in,
G. Re$"sa' to $o''o#
B. Distin,"ishin,
H. 1,norance o$ Stat"te ) Per inc"ria&
A. Precedent s"b si'entio or not $"''y ar,"ed
D. inconsistency #ith ear'ier decisions o$ hi,her co"rts
6. 1nconsistency #ith ear'ier decisions o$ the sa&e ranJ
9. Decisions o$ e("a''y divided co"rts
5=. Erroneo"s Decisions