Primary drive mechanisms

Muskat defines primary recovery as the production period "beginning with the initial
field discovery and continuing until the original energy sources for oil expulsion are no
longer alone able to sustain profitable producing rates."
[1]
Primary recovery is also
sometimes referred to as pressure depletion because it necessarily involves the decline
of the reservoir pressure. This article provides an overview of types of reservoir energy
and producing mechanisms (drive mechanisms).
Contents
1 Defining primary recovery
2 Types of reservoir energy
3 Producing mechanisms
o 3.1 Recovery ranges
4 References
5 Noteworthy papers in OnePetro
6 External links
7 See also
Defining primary recovery
Primary recovery should be distinguished clearly from secondary recovery. Muskat
defines secondary recovery as "the injection of (fluids) after the reservoir has reached a
state of substantially complete depletion of its initial content of energy available for
(fluid) expulsion or where the production rates have approached the limits of profitable
operation."
[1]
One of the most popular secondary-recovery methods is waterflooding.
Because primary recovery invariably results in pressure depletion, secondary recovery
requires "repressuring" or increasing the reservoir pressure.
Primary recovery includes pressure-maintenance methods. Muskat defines pressure
maintenance as "the operation of (fluid) injection into a reservoir during the course of
its primary-production history."
[1]
The main effect of pressure maintenance is to
mitigate the reservoirs pressure decline and conserve its energy. The purpose of
pressure maintenance is ultimately to improve oil recovery. The most common injected
fluids for pressure maintenance are water and separator or residue gas. "Partial" and
"complete" pressure maintenance describe the general effectiveness of a given pressure-
maintenance operation to retard the rate of pressure decline. Partial pressure
maintenance refers to fluid injection while a general state of pressure decline still exists.
Full or complete pressure maintenance refers to fluid injection while the reservoir
pressure remains essentially constant.
According to Muskats definition of pressure maintenance, secondary-recovery methods
such as waterflooding are not strictly pressure-maintenance operations because they
begin after pressure depletion. However, if water injection takes place before the end of
pressure depletion, which is not uncommon, it is considered a pressure-maintenance
method. If water is injected before the end of primary recovery, the reservoir is
classified as an artificial waterdrive. Since Muskat first proposed his definition, others
have loosely applied the term pressure maintenance to include any fluid-injection
strategy at any stage in the reservoirs production.
Types of reservoir energy
The following list outlines the major types of energy available for petroleum
production.
Energy of compression of the water and rock within the reservoir
Energy of compression of oil within the reservoir
Energy of compression of gas within the reservoir
Energy of compression of waters contiguous to and in communication with the
petroleum reservoir
Gravitational energy that causes the oil and gas to segregate within the reservoir
Water within the reservoir refers to the water that is originally present within the
reservoir at the time of discovery. Oil within the reservoir refers to the oil phase that is
originally present at discovery or that may form from the condensation of volatilized oil
upon pressure release. Likewise, gas within the reservoir refers to the gas phase that is
originally present at discovery or that may form subsequently from the liberation of
dissolved gas upon pressure release.
As mechanisms of energy release are provided by the drilling and operation of wells,
reservoir pressure declines, fluids expand, flow is induced, and fluids are produced. The
net volume of expansion of rock and fluids within the reservoir results in an equal
volume of expulsed fluids. The water-bearing reservoirs that adjoin petroleum
reservoirs are called aquifers. The expansion of water from the aquifer results in an
overflow of water from the aquifer into the petroleum reservoir. The net overflow of
water into the petroleum reservoir, in turn, results in an equal volume of fluid expulsion
from the petroleum reservoir. Gravity segregation does not directly result in fluid
expulsion but causes oil to settle to the bottom and gas to migrate to the top of the
reservoir. By producing from only the lower reaches of the reservoir, this process
affords a skilled operator a means to recover oil selectively and possibly recover more
oil than would otherwise be recovered.
In ranking the types of energy in order of least importance to oil recovery, the energy of
the compressed water and rock originally within the reservoir is probably the least
important because of the relatively low compressibilities of water and rock. Of equal
unimportance is the energy of the compressed oil, although the effects of compressed
oil are slightly greater than the effects of compressed water and rock, as evidenced by
the slightly greater compressibility of oil (10
5
per psi) than water (3 10
6
per psi) and
rock (6 10
6
per psi). Of the energies of the compressed fluids, the effects of
compressed gas are undoubtedly the most important because of the greater
compressibility of gas. The effects of compressed gas are important even if there is not
much free gas initially present, as in the case of an initially undersaturated oil reservoir.
In these cases, gas will appear naturally during the course of pressure depletion because
of the release of dissolved gas from the oil once the pressure falls below the bubblepoint
pressure.
Gravitational forces can be a major factor in oil recovery if the reservoir has sufficient
vertical relief and vertical permeability. The effectiveness of gravitational forces will be
limited by the rate at which fluids are withdrawn from the reservoir. If the rate of
withdrawal is appreciably greater than the rate of fluid segregation, then the effects of
gravitational forces will be minimized.
The energy from the compressed waters of aquifers also can be a major factor even
though the water has a low compressibility because the size of most aquifers tends to be
much larger than the petroleum reservoir. Most oil fields have areas of less than 10 sq
mile (6,400 acres), whereas aquifers often have areas of more than 1,000 sq mile.
[1]

The energies discussed thus far represent "internal" reservoir energies (i.e., energies
originally present within the reservoir and its adjoining geological units at the time of
discovery). In addition to these energies, there may be important "external" energies
(i.e., energies that originate from outside the reservoir).External energies imply the
practice of injecting fluids into the reservoir to augment the reservoirs natural energies.
This practice is called pressure maintenance. The two most important injection fluids
are compressed water and gas. The resultant action of injected fluids once inside the
reservoir is much the same as the fluids originally present. The overall intention of
injecting fluids is to add energy to the reservoir to recover more oil or gas than would
otherwise be recovered. If gas is injected, it is clear that the intention is to recover more
oil than otherwise would be recovered. In addition, the economic attractiveness of this
practice relies on the expectation that the additional income derived from the increased
oil production will more than offset the additional expenditures and lost or deferred
revenues incurred by gas injection. The most common source of gas for gas injection is
the gas produced from the reservoir.
Producing mechanisms
The general performance characteristics of hydrocarbon producing reservoirs are largely
dependent on the types of energy available for moving the hydrocarbon fluids to the
wellbore. The predominate energy forms give rise to distinct producing mechanisms.
These producing mechanisms are used to help classify petroleum reservoirs.
In this section, these producing mechanisms are defined and delineated, although there
is not a well-established consensus for some of these definitions. A petroleum reservoir
rarely can be characterized throughout its pressure-depletion life by any single
producing mechanism. A petroleum reservoir usually is subject to several producing
mechanisms over its lifetime; nevertheless, the practice of describing a petroleum
reservoir by its predominant producing mechanism is helpful.
Broadly, all commercially productive petroleum reservoirs are divided into either
expansion drive, compaction drive, or water drive reservoirs. An expansion- or
compaction-drive reservoir is a predominantly sealed reservoir in which the expansion
of fluids and rock originally within the reservoir is responsible for petroleum expulsion
from the reservoir. Fig. 1 shows the producing-mechanism system of classification.

Fig. 1 Classification of reservoir-producing mechanisms.
In contrast, a waterdrive reservoir is an unsealed petroleum reservoir in communication
with water-bearing reservoirs and in which there is appreciable movement of water from
the water-bearing reservoir to the petroleum reservoir. If the rate of water intrusion into
the reservoir is equal to the volumetric rate of fluid withdrawal from the reservoir, then
the reservoir is more descriptively referred to as a complete-waterdrive reservoir. A
complete-waterdrive reservoir often experiences, but does not necessarily imply, very
little pressure decline. Complete-waterdrive reservoirs may require substantial pressure
decline before the water-delivery rate can balance the production rate.
If the rate of water intrusion into the reservoir is substantial but substantially less than
the volumetric rate of fluid withdrawal from the reservoir, then the reservoir is referred
to as a partial-waterdrive reservoir. In all cases, when a waterdrive is the major
producing mechanism, the reservoir pressure will be sensitive to the producing rate. If
the reservoir-producing rate is too high relative to the water-influx rate, the waterdrive
will lose its effectiveness and the reservoir pressure will decline.
Waterdrives are also classified as edgewater or bottomwater drives, depending on the
nature and location of the water encroachment into the reservoir. Fig. 2 shows a
schematic of a bottomwater-drive reservoir. Because waterdrive reservoirs experience
increasing water content and decreasing hydrocarbon content, they are referred to as
nonvolumetric reservoirs. More generally, nonvolumetric reservoirs are reservoirs in
which hydrocarbon pore volume (PV) changes during pressure depletion. Conversely,
volumetric reservoirs are reservoirs in which hydrocarbon PV does not change during
pressure depletion. Because waterdrive reservoirs involve water influx into the
reservoir, they also are referred to as water-influx reservoirs.

Fig. 2 Distribution of water and oil and position of water/oil contact
(WOC) in a waterdrive reservoir (a) before production and (b) during
depletion.
Pressure depletion causes the internal stress within the reservoir rock to increase. This
change produces changes in the grain arrangement and other phenomena that ultimately
cause the pore volume of the rock to decrease. The contraction of the reservoir pore
volume aids in expelling fluids from the reservoir. The terms "pore-volume contraction"
and "rock expansion" are used interchangeably in this chapter to describe this
phenomenon, even though very little grain expansion usually takes place. If this
phenomenon is a major producing mechanism, the reservoir is a compaction-drive
reservoir. Compaction-drive reservoirs are rare because the PV compressibility is
usually less than the oil compressibility.
Expansion-drive reservoirs are further classified as oil- or gas-expansion-drive
reservoirs depending on whether the oil or gas expansion is the predominant producing
mechanism. Dry- and wet-gas reservoirs are gas-expansion-drive reservoirs because
they do not contain any free oil at reservoir conditions. More descriptively, a gas-drive
reservoir is one in which the expansion of free gas is the predominant producing
mechanism. The expanding free gas may originate as initial free gas or as dissolved gas.
An oil-drive reservoir, on the other hand, is one in which the expansion of free oil is the
predominant producing mechanism.
[1]
According to these definitions, black-oil and
volatile-oil reservoirs are not likely to be oil-drive reservoirs but gas-drive reservoirs
because the expansion of gas is ultimately much greater than the expansion of oil. The
oil in saturated, black-oil and volatile-oil reservoirs does not expand but contracts
during pressure depletion because of the release of dissolved gas. Because the
overwhelming majority of expansion-drive reservoirs are gas-drive reservoirs, the term
oil-drive reservoir is rarely used. An oil-drive producing mechanism dominates in oil
reservoirs only while they are undersaturated.
Gas drive reservoirs are further subdivided into either solution gas drive or gas cap
expansion drive reservoirs. A gas cap expansion drive reservoir is a gas cap reservoir in
which the expanding gas cap is responsible for the majority of the gas expansion. A gas
cap is a free gas zone that overlies an oil zone. The free-gas zone may be pre-existing or
may form during the depletion process. Pre-existing gas caps are called primary gas
caps. Gas caps that are not originally present but that develop during the depletion
process are called secondary or developed gas caps. Secondary gas caps can form from
the upward migration of either liberated dissolved gas or from reinjected gas. Fig. 3
shows a schematic of a gas-cap expansion-drive reservoir.

Fig. 3 Distribution of water, oil, and gas and position of gas/oil contact
(GOC) in a segregating-gas-cap reservoir: (a) before production and (b)
during depletion.
Gas caps are also classified according to their displacement efficiency. At the most
favorable extreme, the expanding gas displaces oil in a piston-like manner. At the other
limit, the expanding gas displaces oil in a totally diffuse manner. The former are
segregation drive or gravity drainage gas caps; the latter are nonsegregation-drive gas
caps. The boundary between the gas cap zone and oil zone is the gas/oil contact (GOC).
Segregation drive gas caps exhibit a GOC that moves progressively downward during
depletion. In contrast, nonsegregation drive gas caps exhibit a GOC that appears
stationary. The gas cap displacement efficiency depends on the producing rate and
vertical permeability. Segregation drive gas caps tend to have high vertical
permeability, while nonsegregation drive gas caps tend to have low vertical
permeability. These two types of gas caps represent limiting cases. In reality, there is a
continuum of character between these limits. The exact gas-cap character depends on
the actual conditions.
Gas-drive reservoirs that are not gas cap reservoirs but are dominated by the expansion
of solution gas are called solution gas drive or dissolved gas drive reservoirs. Fig. 4
shows a schematic of a solution gas drive reservoir. Gas drive reservoirs that are neither
gas-cap nor solution gas drive reservoirs are called gas-drive reservoirs. For example,
dry gas reservoirs are gas-drive reservoirs because they do not qualify as solution gas
drive or as gas cap reservoirs. The practice of reinjecting dry gas into and producing wet
gas from gas/condensate reservoirs is called gas cycling or cycling.

Fig. 4 Distribution of water, oil, and gas in a solution-gas-drive reservoir:
(a) before production and (b) during depletion.
Recovery ranges
Table 1 lists the approximate primary-recovery range for the different producing
mechanisms. The ranges reflect the rank of the reservoir energies. Black-oil reservoirs
that exclusively produce by solution-gas-drive mechanism typically recover 10 to 25%
of the OOIP by pressure depletion. The American Petroleum Institute reports an average
primary oil recovery of 20.9% for 307 solution gas drive reservoirs.
[2]
In contrast,
primary oil recovery from waterdrive, black oil reservoirs typically ranges from 15 to
50% or higher of the OOIP. Waterdrive, black oil reservoirs have yielded some of the
highest recoveries ever recorded. The primary oil recovery from gas cap, black oil
reservoirs varies widely depending on whether there is significant gravity drainage. The
primary oil recovery from nongravity drainage, gas cap, black oil reservoirs ranges from
15 to 40% of the OOIP. In contrast, the primary oil recovery from gravity drainage, gas
cap, black oil reservoirs ranges from 15 to 80% of the OOIP. Primary oil recoveries
from gravity drainage, black oil reservoirs are among the highest of any black-oil
reservoir. Pressure maintenance by gas reinjection is practiced commonly in black-oil
reservoirs to improve oil recovery. Black-oil reservoirs subject to gas reinjection
without gravity drainage typically recover 15 to 45% of the OOIP. If gas is reinjected in
a reservoir with active gravity drainage, the primary oil recovery typically ranges from
15 to 80%.

Table 1