User Name:

Password:
Forgot My Password
Login
Tweet Tweet
0
The benefits of I.P. ABS
By By Ron Borod, Esq.
November 15, 2004
Printer Friendly Email Reprints Comments
By Ron Borod, Esq., partner and the head of, the Structured Finance Group of Brown Rudnick Berlack Israels
LLP
Like what you see? Click here to sign up for a Structured Finance News free trial and
daily newsletter to get the latest commentary and insights on the ABS, MBS and CDO
communities.
Intellectual property securitization continues to be a
hot item in the ABS zeitgeist. Although the volume
of rated IP-backed transactions has been limited, a
sufficient variety of deals have been rated and
closed to inspire confidence that this will be a
growing asset category. The earliest ABS deals
involved music royalty securitization, beginning with
the much-heralded 1997 transaction backed by the
revenues generated by the David Bowie music
catalog, rated A3 by Moody's Investors Service.
Copyrights present both strengths and weaknesses
as an asset class for the securitization market.
Strengths include the fact that copyrights receive
relatively reliable protection from the copyright laws
for the full term of the copyright and copyright
challenges are relatively rare. Special challenges include the fact that revenues generated from music
copyrights are often derived from a complex mixture of sources, and it is often difficult to obtain reliable
historical data on revenue performance.
Other categories of intellectual property, which have also been securitized are patents and trademarks. One of
the first patent royalty securitizations was the BioPharma Royalty Trust transaction in 2000, which was backed
by royalties under a licensing agreement between Yale University, as licensor, and Bristol-Myers Squibb Co.,
as licensee.
The license involved the patent for an HIV-aids medication. The deal used a senior-subordinated structure,
consisting of $57 million in senior debt and $22 million in mezzanine debt. The senior securities, which
received an A rating from S&P, were structured with a 1.6 debt service coverage. The mezzanine securities
had a 1.3-times debt service coverage but received a double-A rating based on a third-party financial guaranty
provided by a subsidiary of Center Re. The contributed triple-A ratings of Bristol-Myers Squibb and Yale
University added credit support.
Several additional IP transactions have subsequently been rated, including film royalty receivable transactions
wrapped by MBIA and Ambac, as well as a patent license royalty transaction also wrapped by MBIA. Each of
these three transactions employed a revolving credit structure. The shadow ratings which were necessary for
the monoline wraps were obtained on the basis of a variety of factors including overcollateralization based
upon historical royalty revenues, diversity of the portfolios, credit quality of the licensees, experience of the
servicer, and structural features such as isolation of the assets from bankruptcy risk.
Perhaps the most interesting of recent IP deals was the Guess? Royalty Finance LLC transaction, involving
the securitization of the cash flow related to various licensing agreements involving the Guess? trademark.
The securities were issued unenhanced and were assigned ratings of BBB/Baa2 by Standard & Poor's and
Moody's Investors Service, respectively, which were several notches above the below-investment grade
ratings of the sponsor company's debt.
The transaction had to be structured to avoid a "core asset" problem. This was achieved by having the SPV to
which the trademarks and licenses were assigned re-license the trademarks back to the operating company,
having the SPV pledge only the cash receivables as collateral for the notes, and having the trademarks and
licenses themselves pledged only to secure the payment of principal at final maturity.
An advantage which patents and copyrights have over trademarks in a securitization context is the special
treatment afforded under Section 365(n) of the Bankruptcy Code in the case of a rejection of a copyright or
patent license by the licensor in bankruptcy. Section 365(n) provides that in the event of such rejection the
licensee may elect to retain its rights under the license and continue to use the copyright or patent, provided
that the licensee continues to perform its obligations under the license agreement.
S&P has relied on this provision in assigning a rating to the revolving patent royalty credit facility discussed
above even though the unrated originator of the patents continued to hold title to the patents and assigned
only the rights to royalty payments to the SPV. S&P concluded that even though the patents were not
assigned, the notes could be rated higher than the rating of the licensor because even if the licensor went
bankrupt and rejected the license, the licensees could continue to enforce the licenses.
The potential for IP securitization is huge. The total asset value of patents worldwide is estimated to be $1
trillion, and revenues from patent licensing alone has increased in the U.S. approximately 700 percent
between 1990 and 1998.

Home About Us Subscribe Trial Advertise Help Contact Us RSS/XML
Share Share Like Like
AMERICAN BANKER THE BOND BUYER ASSET SECURITIZATION REPORT LEVERAGED FINANCE NEWS PRIVATE PLACEMENT LETTER COLLECTIONS&CREDIT RISK MORE
The benets of I.P. ABS http://www.structurednancenews.com/issues/2004_47/1724...
1 of 2 7/25/14 7:38 PM
Securitizing royalty revenues should also become an increasingly important liquidity tool for non-profit
institutions with active technology transfer or applied research programs. Adjusted gross license income from
patent licenses and options for the non-profit sector is in excess of $1 billion annually, and monetizing this
revenue to offset predicted reductions in federal funding should be seriously considered by the CFOs of these
institutions.
Copyright 2004 Thomson Media Inc. All Rights Reserved.
http://www.thomsonmedia.com http://www.asreport.com
For more information on related topics, visit the following:
Other ABS
CDOs
Global
HOME
About Us
Contact Us
Content Licensing
Advertise with Us
Subscribe
Customer Service
My Account
Subscription Agreement
Privacy Policy
Site Map
SOURCEMEDIA
CORPORATE SITE
BANKING
American Banker
Bank Technology News
American Banker Magazine
Credit Union Journal
MORTGAGES
National Mortgage News
PAYMENTS
PaymentsSource
Collections & Credit Risk
ISO & Agent
CAPITAL MARKETS
Mergers & Acquisitions
Asset Securitization Report
Leveraged Finance News
Private Placement Letter
Traders Magazine
Securities Technology Monitor
MUNICIPAL FINANCE
The Bond Buyer
ACCOUNTING
Accounting Today
Tax Pro Today
HEALTHCARE & BENEFITS
Employee Benefit News
Employee Benefit Adviser
Health Data Management
Insurance Networking News
Information Management
INVESTMENT ADVISORY
Financial Planning
On Wall Street
Bank Investment Consultant
Money Management Executive
Investment Mgt. Mandate Pipeline
2014 SourceMedia. All rights reserved.
The benets of I.P. ABS http://www.structurednancenews.com/issues/2004_47/1724...
2 of 2 7/25/14 7:38 PM