CH4101 Chemical, Biological & Plant Safety Dr. Foo Swee Cheng ENGINEERING ETHNICS 1. Defend the truth 2. Expose questionable practice that will lead to unsafe product/ process Royal Academy of Engineering: http://raeng.org.uk/societygov/engineeringethics/principles.htm Accuracy and rigour Honesty and integrity Respect for life, law and public good Responsible leadership: listening and informing Discussion: Nicoll High collapse, 20 April 2004 Singapore Nicoll 40 years: http://www.nce.co.uk/features/nce-40-years/no11-nicoll-highway-collapse/8629881.article Insurance: http://news.asiaone.com/News/The+Straits+Times/Story/A1Story20080420-60781.html CH4101 FooSC SAFETY TERMS: DEFINITIONS Hazard: Potential source of harm/loss/damage Risk: Probability of a certain harm/loss/damage Individual Risk (IR): IR = (Frequency) x (Severity) Societal Risk (SR): SR = (IR) x (population) = FN Incident: The result of uncontrolled hazard(s) Accident: An incident which results in consequent loss Accident Scenario: A sequence of events which propagates the accident Accident outcome: The consequences of an accident CH4101 FooSC SHE (Safety, Health & Environment) HAZARDS Chemical hazards: Toxicity of artificial/ natural materials Physical hazards: Flammability of artificial/ natural materials Fire/ Thermal radiation: Heat Explosion: Overpressure generated by fire Biological: Living organisms e.g. bacteria, viruses, fungi Contaminants: Healthcare/ food/ animal husbandry Process materials: Vaccine production Effects: Communicable or non-communicable diseases Can reproduce itself in host Ergonomic: work load/ tools/ organization on human Force/ energy/ repetitiveness/ anthropometrics/ time CH4101 FooSC SAFETY AND HEALTH Safety: Accidental/ abnormal release of HAZARDS Acute/ high level release: large quantity in a short time High consequence: Acute damage to property/ population/ environment Health: Operational/ Fugitive release of HAZARDS Chronic/ low level emissions: Small quantity over a long time Low consequence: Chronic damage to sensitive population/ environment in continuous/ long-term exposure CH4101 FooSC PROCESS HAZARDS AND EFFECTS Fire: Thermal effects Explosion: Over-pressure effects Toxicity: Toxic/ Health effects Biological effects: Two unique features; e.g. ebola virus Communicable (person-person transmission) Reproduce itself in host (make use of host resources) Accident Type Probability of occurrence Potential for Fatalities Potential for Economic Loss Fire High Low Intermediate Explosion Intermediate Intermediate High Toxic Low High Low CH4101 FooSC COMPARING PROCESS AND PERSONAL SAFETY Equal risk curves: R = C 1 F 1 = C 2 F 2 Process Safety Hazard: Highly hazardous (GHS cat 1 & 2); large quantity Severity: High; Death/ severe disable Hazard zone: Large; zone often extends to offsite Frequency: Low; High reliability system; less no. facilities WSH personal safety Hazard: Less hazardous; Wide range; less quantity Severity: Low; Wide range Hazard zone: Small; zone confined to location of use Frequency: High; System less reliable; more no. facilities CH4101 FooSC Risk curve C F PROCESS SAFETY vs PERSONAL SAFETY
CH4101 FooSC OSH/ WSH Management Risk Curve PROCESS SAFETY MANAGEMENT (1) Reduce Loss Event Frequency Inherently safer design: moderate/ simplify Process Reliability: Reliability engineering Component reliability & System structure Process Integrity: Maintenance Prevent system failure: Reliability maintenance/ growth program Operation reliability Competency of operators Technical support for operators Human factor engineering/ Safety culture Incident management CH4101 FooSC PROCESS SAFETY MANAGEMENT (2) Reduce Loss Event Consequence Inherently safer design: minimize/ substitute/ Minimize: Reduce the quantity of hazard in loss event Amount of stock in individual storing units Amount of material in individual process units Substitute: Replace a hazardous material with less hazardous one Direct materials (incorporated into products): Use less hazardous route Less hazardous/ amount of intermediates/ by-products/ wastes Indirect materials not incorporated into products: Use less hazardous materials Solvents/ Catalysts/ Energy/ heating media CH4101 FooSC PROCESS SAFETY STRATEGY: DEFENSE IN DEPTH NORMAL OPERATIONAL CONTROL SYSTEM ALARM SYSTEM SAFETY INTERLOCK/ EMERGENCY SHUTDOWN SYSTEM RELIEF SYSTEM Seriousness of event Divert material safely Stop the operation or part of operation Bring unusual situation to the attention of a plant operator Closed-loop control to maintain process within acceptable operating region F o u r
i n d e p e n d e n t
p r o t e c t i o n
l a y e r s
( I P L )
CHEMICAL PLANT PROCESS P r o t e c t i o n
S y s t e m s
C o n t r o l
S y s t e m s
B P C S
CH4101 FooSC WSH MANAGEMENT Workplace pollution prevention Prevention system reliability Protection system reliability Operator reliability Workers exposure control/ monitor Manage exposure dose: level x time Biological/ medical control/ monitor Early detection excessive absorption Manage sensitive workers
Hierarchy of Control
Elimination Substitution Engineering control Administrative control Administrative control Personal protection Early detection/ treatment CH4101 FooSC RISK ACCEPTANCE CONCEPTS Except in extraordinary circumstances Risk reduction impractical or cost disproportionate to gain Cost of reduction exceed the improvement To ensure risk remains at this level Unacceptable region No exposure allowed ALARP region Risk is tolerated only if a benefit is desired ALARP required Broadly acceptable region ALARP not required CH4101 FooSC EXAMPLE: AN RISK ACCEPTANCE CRITERIA Public Risk Criteria Occupational Risk
Unacceptable Risk 10 -3
Unacceptable Risk Tolerable if emergency procedures and protective equipment are in place 10 -4
Acceptable for manufacturing, warehouses, open spaces, parkland, golf courses, etc. Tolerable if emergency procedures are in place 10 -5
Acceptable for commercial offices, low density residential Negligible risk 10 -6
Negligible risk - No land use restrictions
IR/yr CH4101 FooSC ACCIDENT STATISTICS Singapore, MOM: Accident frequency Rate (AFR) AFR: Accidents per 1,000,000 man-hrs worked Singapore, MOM: Accident Severity Rate (ASR) ASR: Man-days lost per 1,000,000 man-hrs worked Fatal Accident Rate (FAR) British: Fatalities per 100,000,000 man-hrs worked MOM: fatalities per 100,000 workers per year Fatality Rate (FR): Deaths per person per year Individual Risk (IR): The chance of death per person per year Relationship between (FAR) and (FR) British: (FAR)(man-hrs worked/person-year)/(10 8 ) = (FR) MOM: (FAR)/(100,000) = (FR) Read: Textbook 1 3 Accident and Loss Statistics, page 4 12 CH4101 FooSC EXAMPLE: Accident Rates Factory A (100 workers): #man-hours worked per year: 100 x 50 x 5 x 8 = 200,000 man-hrs No. of accidents: 5 per year AFR (MOM): 5 x 1,000,000 / 200,000 = 25 Total number of MC-days: 10 days per year ASR (MOM): 10 x 1,000,000 / 200,000 = 50 No. of Fatalities: 1 per year FAR (British): 1 x 100,000,000 / 200,000 = 500 FAR (MOM): 1 x 100000/100 = 1000 Fatality Rate (FR): 1/100 = 1 x 10 -2 per person per year British: man-hr worked per person = (FR)/(FAR) (1/100)/(500/100,000,000) = 2000 man-hrs per person-year CH4101 FooSC SAFETY TARGETS: FAR OR FR For planning or design To meet national or company requirements
e.g. Singapore 2018 target: FR = < 1.8 by 2018 Plant risk: Multiple/ Overall risk: (FAR) < 2 Single/ Each risk: FAR < 0.4 ACCIDENT PROCESSES Initiation: Event that starts the accident Propagation: Event/ events that maintain/ expand the accident Termination: Event/ events that stop the accident/ diminish it in size
CH4101 FooSC ACCIDENT MITIGATION PRINCIPLES
CH4101 FooSC Initiation Diminish (Prevent/ remove the potential of accident causing events) Grounding and bonding Inerting Explosion proof electrical Guardrails and guards Maintenance procedures Hot work permits Human factors design Process design Awareness of dangerous properties of chemicals Propagation Diminish (Reduce potential for accident to continue escalation) Emergency material transfer Reduce inventories of flammable materials Equipment spacing and layout Nonflammable construction materials Installation of check and emergency shutoff valves Termination Increase (Increase capacity to terminate the accident) Fire-fighting equipment and procedures Relief systems Sprinkler systems Installation of check and emergency shutoff valves JOHORE TANK FIRE CH4101 FooSC Initiation: Lightning? Propagation: Spread to another tank 1/3 of content in 2 nd tank transferred before catching fire Termination: Fire put out in 67 hours LEARNING OBJECTIVES Understand the basis concepts/ definitions of safety, health & environmental terminology/ principles in Hazards Risk: Frequency & Consequence Risk management principles Accident processes Safety performance indicators: Accident statistics The differences between Safety and health Process safety and WSH/ personal safety