a) For an FMCG company of your choice analyze potential alternative
strategies with regard to substantive growth, limited growth or retrenchment. Basically all organizations will face the challenges of strategic direction. Some will wish to use the opportunities in an optimum level and others will think to solve the problems which have been identified towards the organization. To run the organization successfully it should know its strategic direction which leads to take the effective strategic decisions. This strategy can be mainly classified into three major types as corporate level, business level and functional level. Among these three, corporate level is an important level which will approach the future which involves some features such as, Evaluating they way that the customers and competitors are associated and the firm its self Focusing on the new and effective role to formulate the business Changing the policies and practices eventually which will align with the vision Under this corporate strategy it can be classified more deeply as growth, stability and retrenchment. The theory of corporate strategy is based on the growth options which are related to the range of internal and external development activities that has been invested to the future growth opportunities. Growth Strategy Every organization will think to have a victory earnings in short term. To understand the growth strategy The Ansoffs model will be the best tool which organizations has to develop market and product expansion strategies. Ansoffs model is based on the four types of strategies which are known as market penetration strategy, market development strategy, product development strategy and diversification strategy. This strategy is basically depend on company objectives which include increasing sales and profit, new entry to the market, developing new product and entering into new business. These are the main elements to consider about the growth strategy. If the companies or organizations concentrate on the growth strategy they can achieve their goals and objectives as they want. These results have wide suggestions for conduct a research in strategic management and the importance of the growth of the firm to corporate strategy will lead to utilize the resource allocation and value creation. Stability Strategy This strategy is somewhat differs from the growth strategy which simply does not like to change the current strategy of the particular organization. A stability strategy is basically characterized by the absence of prominent changes. By practicing this strategy an organization will proceed to serve its same market and customers while maintaining its market share. Basically some organizations will use this type of strategy either the organization might think that no point of going for a change or the particular organization wish to maintain a low level performances. There are three types under this stability strategy. They are, Pause or Proceed with Caution strategy No change Strategy Profit Strategy Retrenchment Strategy This is one of the corporate strategies which goes for the reduction of the size of the organizational operations or limit their profitable product lines. Basically this can happen because of the effects of technological changes, undefeatable competition and other environmental changes and that will lead to live no longer. This can be classified further as Turn around, Captive company strategy, Selling out, Bankruptcy, and Liquidation. Sometimes bankruptcy which involves giving up the management of particular organization to the courts for some settlement of the corporation obligation and that will be a better way to avoid the debt duties. Currently there are some organizations which have been pushed to follow the retrenchment strategy where there has been no way to recover again like Bajaj Auto, Mahindra & Mahindra in India and so on so forth. The Strategy of Bairaha Farms PLC According to the corporate level strategy which has been mapped down by the senior management of Bairaha Farms PLC it should be noted that firm is using Growth Strategy for the companies wellbeing. To succeed on their existing business they no need to go for the strategy of stability or the retrenchment. Because if we consider about the stability it says that it doesnt accept or adapt to the changes. But Bairahas vision and the mission relies on making a unique change among its customers perception. According to the retrenchment strategy it shows that it basically reflects the down sales and poor profit which leads to the loss. But comparing theory to practicality of Bairaha Farms PLCs scenario, its annual report shows the positive growth range of sales, profit and the net assets which has been stepped forward uniquely. So by considering about the above stated facts it can be assured that Bairaha Farms PLC is predominantly practicing Growth strategy. The below listed aspects will clearly clarify as to how and why Bairaha Farms PLC is practicing Growth Strategy. Financial View According to the Bairaha Farms PLCs financial highlights it has seen a continuous improvement in Revenue, Net Profit and Net Assets. Following figure makes this statement more clear.
Figure 4.1 Comparison of Revenue, Gross Profit and net Assets 0 500 1000 1500 2000 2500 3000 2009 2010
M i l l i o n
Year Revenue Gross Profit Net Assets By analyzing this chart Bairaha Farms PLC has currently ear marked a remarkable rotation in terms of operational profit by focusing its utmost on pricing. Hence profit is derived from the price which a company sells its products to the consumer, so this automatically shows that Bairaha Farms PLC is operating under growth strategy. But by forecasting for the future of BF PLC (approximately for 5-6 years) if it confines its self more towards financial stability and performance like its present heyday which Bairaha Farms PLC is enjoying can achieve distinctively on its growth strategy. It can easily go for financial outsourcings to implement this growth strategy in future. The range of employee level This is one of the most important factors which have to be considered. To show the evidence that Bairaha Farms PLC is practicing the growth strategy this factor would be best as the total staff strength of 40 has now expanded massively to 650 plus direct employees. To decline the YoY staff turnover they have conducted many regular activities as to satisfy their dedicated employees like annual outings, karaoke, dance and drama competition and evaluation of the outstanding performances. They dont feel uneasy to allocate the money for these matters because they knew that their employees are more important when going for implementing the growth strategy. As they strongly believe that their employees are more needed to them they should care more and satisfy them by promoting some more activities than the current activities. This will definitely lead the Bairaha Farms PLC to increase the capacity of employees outcome. Currently to remain on their growth strategy Bairaha Farms PLC is conducting some compensational activities like, 1. Rewards and recognition schemes to identify the way employees has gone the extra mile in terms of performance. 2. Awarding the Employee of the month and Employee of the year (Spotlight Achievers). 3. Conducting some skill development programs to increase their productivity of employees across the organization. 4. Giving increment and bonus according to the annual appraisal and performance. 5. Arranging schemes for special loans and salary related benefits. More than the above stated activities Bairaha Farms PLC have to implement some activities in future which can help to avoid the migrations of the employees and give more outcomes that now. The content of brand name Bairaha Farms PLCs victory was really based on their brand name. The name Bairaha Farms PLC has obviously changed peoples life style. Their innovative through of their brand name has now let them to the international. According to their scenario their commitment in innovative is more high in order to grow more and more. The shape of Bairaha Farms PLC came from their unique factors such as effortless glamour, price, quality and good services to the customers. But to succeed their growth strategy in future they should exceed their expectations in above unique factors. Especially Bairaha Farms PLC should deeply concern about the quality in future years also which is currently having. Consideration on Corporate Social Responsible Activity Basically an organizations growth is majorly depended on customers reactions. If customers give a response to their activities only they can move for further development. So when organizations participate on the social activities customers will support on that particular organizations growth also that will automatically shows the organizations good position. Bairaha Farms PLC is also not an exemption in this case. Considering to all the above stated factors currently Bairaha Farms PLC have concerned more about the Corporate Social Responsible Activities. By balancing with the Bairaha Farms PLCs financial area if Bairaha Farms PLC contribute more and take part in the social activities it can earn more goodwill among the customers and can make them as pillar of their implemented growth strategy in future years. This will be possible because as the customers will believe and trust Bairaha Farms PLC through this CSR activities and automatically the customers will support their operations. So by thinking in an analytical view it has been evaluated from the corporate strategic options which are available it has been identified as the growth strategy is more suitable for Bairaha Farms PLC in present year and for future five to six years. More than this it does not think about the stability or retrenchment strategy as Bairaha Farms PLC is far from these strategies.
b) Select a future strategy for this FMCG Company while considering appropriateness, feasibility and desirability.
The value of balancing desirability, feasibility, and viability
Suitability The proposed Strategy is suitable in terms of it suitability since it addresses its strategic- objective. For to grow it needed to enter new market which happened through their differentiation strategy. Therefore, with its gaining strategy of communication operators, it was able to penetrate new and existing markets. Feasibility In terms of whether the strategy is feasible, strategy might not be feasible due to their start revenue & profits, but with its high quality and experienced staff, technology and physical resources, strategy might meet its objectives. Acceptability The strategy might not be accepted consideration those acquisitions that ended up being sold to other providers due to the decline in revenue and its cost.
The most excellent strategy for an organization is to embrace what is the most fitting to its present strong point and its location. Into which a future strategy corresponds with the circumstances as acknowledged by a strategic analysis and how the organization is fit into maintaining, or improving its economical advantage.
A constant progression of outside changes obtains position throughout a cycle of a product, in a series of when it entered the market down to competitors entering the market and changes the customers views of buying. The life cycle of a product provides a significant idea in sustainability of an organization in terms of its weakness and strength strategy.
When looking a product, the first time round it can become popular but when time passes it loses its popularity and less selling of such product. This could be down to these few reasons.
New and better design on the market Quality of the product is better and cheaper Customer looking for new trend.
For or as a manager its very crucial to know your organization weakness and strength to be able to select an appropriate strategy for the future whereby you can tackle the threat and take the advantage of the opportunities. A company that has a future strategy has a constant routine to be better than the competitors.
Wide Market Segment
Cost Leadership Strategy It seeks to achieve the position of lowest-cost producer in the industry as a whole. By producing at the lowest cost, the manufacturer can compete on price with every other producer in the industry.
Differentiation Strategy It assumes that competitive advantage can be gained through particular characteristics of a firms products. Product differentiation fulfils a customer need and involves tailoring the products or the service to the customer.
Narrow Market segment
Cost Focus Strategy Aims to be a cost leader for a particular segment.
Differentiation focus strategy Pursue differentiation for a chosen segment. Cost leadership strategy works best for a firm in the industry in the below mentioned reasons, Price competition in the hotel industry is vigorous. Product is standardized or readily offered from many suppliers. Few ways to achieve product differentiation. Buyers use the product in similar ways. Buyers incur low switching costs. Buyers are large and have significant barraging power. Industry newcomers to use low prices to attract buyers and build customer base.
Hence the underlying reason for adopting differentiation strategies for a firm in calibre of Bairaha Farms PLC is shown below,
Firm builds up a brand image in the industry. e.g. Bairaha Farms PLC Firm can give special product features to make it standout in the industry. e.g. Bairaha Farms PLC Firm can provide unique or superior value through product quality, innovation or after sale support to the customer. If a firm has access to reliable and speedier delivery system and distribution channels. If the technology is influenced by rapid development.
Focus strategy is attractive to a particular niche or segment in the following circumstances, Niche is not crucial to the success of overall industry leaders. Its costly or hard for multi segment competitors to meet specialized needs of niche members. It offers good growth potential and high profits. Focuser has essential resources and capabilities to effectively serve a niche. Only few other rivals are specializing in the same niche. Focuser can guard against challengers via superior ability to serve niche members.
5 a) Discuss the roles and responsibilities which are necessary for strategy implementation. Implementation of strategy is a key element of a business success. A strategy should be very effective and it must naturally implement. When it comes to implement a strategy the key people who are committed with the organization should clearly identify their required resources. They should realize that to encourage successfully they should take specific actions before they implement their strategies. These implementation sessions can be made up before implement, during the implement and after the implement. The following chart explains the factors which influencing in implementing a strategy. Before the implementation During the Implementation After the Implementation
Demonstrating senior management to commit with the plan
Selecting the correct planning team members
Gather the right pre planning information
Getting the employees to involve in the planning
Encouraging the participation
Developing the objectives according to the current report system
Developing balance list of objectives
Develop the strategies to the built the companys strength
Considering the resources which are available
Develop in building up in monitoring system
Communicating the strategy
Linking the strategic plan with operational plan
Monitoring the progress quarterly
Fine tune the progress
Table 5.1 Understanding the Strategic Implementation
According to this task the requirement of resources are widely important to implement Bairaha Farms PLCs selected strategy. So if we consider about the resource requirements of Bairaha Farms PLC needs in order to put in place its chosen strategy and execute this strategy the answers are clearly analyzed below. Financial Resources Basically the financial resources are the fact which concern to implement the chosen strategy. As Bairaha Farms PLC is under growth strategy currently their product lines are having an actual growth potential. Along with the concentration of resources on their product portfolio makes to go further in their growth strategy. In Bairaha Farms PLC to implement their growth strategy which requires prominent investment in new, innovative and dynamic products, to have a best distribution lines, the maximum capacity in production and working capital will need the proper financial structure with a greater effort. This is mainly should managed by the Bairaha Farms PLC in Financial point of view. If we go in depth on financial highlights their existing finance funds like cash balance remain strong stability comparing to the past years. Especially their group revenue is not going down and smoothly increasing yearly. Also they have not fallen into the bank overdraft or other loans. So these factors show that the Bairaha Farms PLC has a better stability in finance and by identifying these factors clearly Bairaha Farms PLC can easily implement the strategy what they expected to achieve in future. According to the current situation Bairaha Farms PLC has issued the shares to the public in the year 2011 and earn more profit as they expected. By this shareholders capital Bairaha Farms PLC can plan to implement their strategy in future according to the time frame. Apart from this if the working capital like stocks, debtors will give a push to Bairaha Farms PLC when they implement a strategy and also can have the good creditors (Suppliers). So according to the financial resources on the beginning of every year Bairaha Farms PLC can easily achieve their target. Human Resources The fundamental issue of human resources is how the human resource factors are skilled to work out with the strategy which is going to be implemented. When the implementation of strategy is ready Bairaha Farms PLC has to think whether their skills are appropriate to use to implement their strategy? And should consider whether it is possible to make flexible or stretch their skills to meet the new requirements of chosen strategy. When planning for implement a strategy the Project Manager who is recognized as a main human resource for a chosen strategy should be very dynamic. Because each and every steps which he take for the selected strategy will definitely affect directly. Before they implement their strategy Bairaha Farms PLC should know about their existing staffing resources such as the number of staff by function, location, grade, experience, qualification and remuneration. By identifying this Bairaha Farms PLC can easily go for the calculation of required human resources for chosen strategy. Also they should analyze their existing rate of labour turnover, overall training and specific training for key people of Bairaha Farms PLC, BF PLCs business culture and confidence. If they do this activity according to they can have a successful strategic implementation. These aspects are most important implement the strategy which Bairaha Farms PLC have chosen. As human resource is mainly needed to implement the strategy, by exactly measuring the above stated facts Bairaha Farms PLC can easily estimate the future required sources and can get a clear idea of how can they be sourced like outsourcing, alternative include employment and etc,. Project Management Resources This is basically comes under marketing strategy implementation. As Bairaha Farms PLC has chosen the growth strategy, to have a concentration product lines Bairaha Farms PLC should deeply concern about the marketing strategy. Under this Project management resource includes the project planning, status checking, mutual work plans, timeline management factors and more. These resources will fulfil the need of marketing plan for the chosen strategy. This factor is really important to Bairaha Farms PLC as to implement their strategy according to the time frame. Now days time has recognized as a very important source in every organization. So according to the Bairaha Farms PLC this particular resource will cover to work out the strategy with the segmentation of time frame. As mentioned earlier the Project Manager is very important when going for a strategic implementation and with his background Bairaha Farms PLC can have a proper project planning with the help of checking the actual status of Bairaha Farms PLC in the market. This will automatically leads to have a mutual work plans that is aligning with the market situation and implement the chosen strategy. Physical Resources This category is satisfying the whole and broad area of operational facts which explains that can deliver the chosen strategy in order to the physical capability. According to the Scenario of Bairaha Farms PLC it can mainly focus on production facilities, Information technology applications, marketing facilities and further more. If Bairaha Farms PLC go through the current situation of production facilities which analyzes the current product quality methods (Current production process), Production capacity, and Current location of existing production facilities Bairaha Farms PLC can think about the further requirements of the chosen strategy and can measure the extend of delivering the production facilities. They can also calculate the range investment and the maintenance of the production facilities for implementing the strategy in future. According to the marketing facilities such as marketing management process, distribution channels will help to implement their growth strategy widely in future. Especially Bairaha Farms PLC must consider about these facilities which should be very efficient and effective manner in order to succeed in implementing the strategy. To mix up with customers and supplier in a unique way Bairaha Farms PLC must get the maximum use of information technology resources like IT systems. This will automatically help Bairaha Farms PLC to move further in implementing their chosen strategy according to the time frame.
b. Discuss timescales and targets which are required for achievements in a selected organization in order to monitor a given strategy. (Do your evaluation on benchmarked outcomes in a particular period in relation to corporate and operational targets) It is important to have monitoring procedures when implementing a strategy as information can then be used to, Assess resource allocation choices Monitor implementation progress Evaluate performance of managers in achieving implementation tasks Monitor any environmental changes from those that were projected Provide a feedback mechanism Monitoring becomes increasingly important as the concept of strategy moves from being isolated to being an ongoing event.
Many businesses spend significant resources on monitoring their activities; some major organizations have complete departments whose only task is to monitor competitors. It is also a characteristic that many small businesses are also aware of any immediate competitors, their market prices and other strategic activity.
A strategic control system can be used to monitor the main elements of a strategy and its objectives. What is more crucial is that this information is available in time to be able to take action if required. Strategic controls systems will include some financial measures but will also involve looking at customer satisfaction, market share and quality measures.
It could also be necessary to apply the same indicators externally to monitor competition. This would allow the performance of the organization to be measured against others in the marketplace.
To obtain the best from a strategic control system the following guidelines can be followed Concentrate on key performance indicators If too many elements are being monitored the result will be information overload.
Distinguish between corporate, business and operating levels of information and only monitor where relevant Not everyone needs to know every piece of information. Avoid overreliance on quantitative data Although this information is easier to measure it can also be misleading. Qualitative data that is more difficult to quantify may be more relevant when monitoring.
As controls become more established give consideration to relaxing them Not doing so may interfere with the ability to explore a strategy clearly.
Be realistic of what a control system can do Some may consider strategic controls as a waste of time because of the lengthy time scales involved in seeing results. It is more beneficial to acknowledge the benefits of a control system in terms of improved strategy.
Below I will set out how Bairaha Farms PLC can use targets and timescales when implementing a new advertising strategy.
The following is a summary of the expected major focus of activities by target for the Bairaha Farms PLC Board of Directors and Staff in each year of the strategic plan. action\year 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 increasing the portfolio of organization
Opening new outlets outside of Colombo
Adding some unique brands to their products
Going for new promotional activities
Engaging with some international brands
Adopting new technology and improving the infrastructure of organization
Going for contract with new suppliers.
Moving to the European continent
This plan is simply explains how Bairaha Farms PLC can implement its selected strategy with sticking into the time frame. If Bairaha Farms PLC follows in this manner it can definitely achieves its target according to the growth strategy.
Bibliography A.A. Thompson, Jr., and A. J. Strickland, III, Strategy and Policy: Concepts and Cases (Plano, Texas: B.P.I., 1981), PP. 50-51. Comerford, R.A., Callaghan, and D.W., 1985, Strategic Management Text, Tools and Cases for Business Policy: Major Elements of Strategic Management, PP. 14, ISBN: 0-534-04518-9. Chandler, Alfred Strategy and Structure: Chapters in the history of industrial enterprise, Doubleday, New York, 1962. F. Westley, 1990, Middle Managers and Strategy (Strategic Management Journal, Vol. 11, no 5), PP. 337-351. Lorange, P., Corporate Planning: The Educative Viewpoint (Eaglewood Cliffs, N.J.: Prentice Hall, 1980), pp.18-21. M. Porter, What is strategy?, Harvard Business Review, November-December, 1996, pp. 61-78. Wheelen. L. T., Hunger. J.D., 2008, Strategic Management and Business Policy (ed- 11): Basic Concepts of Strategic Management. Williamson, D., Jenkins, J., Cooke, P., and Moreton, K.M., 2004, Strategic Management and Business Analysis: The Four Big Questions You Need To Ask, PP. 1, ISBN: 0-7506-4295-5.