CRITICAL COMPARISON OF BENJAMIN NETANYAHU AND NARENDER

MODIS UNITED NATIONS SPEECH

Aron










MODI MISSES ARAB SPRINGS AS FOUNT OF ISLAMIST RESURGENCE AND
TERROR SPRINGS


Its a telling reading in Modis speech that so called Arab Springs is exactly based
on Multi Culturalism invented by liberals to keep accommodating Militant Islam
as Moderate and offer space for them as a Democratic Change driver.

"Democracy is trying to find a voice in West Asia and North Africa; Tunisia's
success makes us believe that it is possible."

This Leftist myth of bringing about 'Democracy' by removal of seeming
'oppressive regimes' only lead to unprecedented oppression, mass displacement
of populations, grossest violations of human rights and chaos of Islamist gangs
and militias running amok all over the place.
Instead of Democracies the Arab Springs lead to Islamist militia rules and
declaration of Islamic State and return to Caliphates both in West Asia under ISIS
and Caliphate of North Africa.


Modi in fact underlines his Partys belated discovery of Multiculturalism-now
almost collapsing for its grotesque assumptions in the West implemented as
Official Policy lines of most Democracies there.


Every nation's world view is shaped by its civilization and
philosophical tradition. India's ancient wisdom sees the world as
one family. It is reflected in a tradition of openness and diversity;
co-existence and cooperation.

It is also because of this timeless current of thought that India
has an unwavering belief in multilateralism.

This is not Indias age old wisdom. In fact Vasudeva
kudumbakam the much chanted slogan is not a verse in any of
the Vedas or epics.

Its a line in Jataka Tales, taken out and magnified by Leftist
Multiculturalists, which is to accommodate the Militant Islamism
as a wise old Policy.

It is a sham Inclusion that is solely meant to accommodate the
Islamist causes and issues but not others if that finds it as not
acceptable.

This is why India speaks not just for itself, but also for the
cause of justice, dignity, opportunity and prosperity around the
world.

But it wasnt Multi Laterlaism of Indias PM that mentioned the atrocities and
injustice, violation of dignity and ruin of fortunes of Yazhidis, Mandeans, Shias and
every other minority by Islamic State so recently.
Not even an official statement had come so far for this humanity.

It was Israeli Prime ministers speech where you hear that stand for humanity.

Indias self chosen outdated Multiculturalism muted its voice for offending
Militant Islam and its sensitivities.

The mentioning of the mass killings of Yazidis by Militant Islamists who came
almost to possible near total wipe out- by the Israeli Prime Minister but not Indian
Prime Minister is doubly shameful, for Yazidis are an ancient people with very
traceable history of Indian origins.

The lament for Kashmirs victims of natural disaster of floods also adds to the
embarrassment of India- in the entire speech not a single reference was made to
the entire Kashmiri minorities who stand as refugees in their own land and in
exodus, an opportunity missed to explain why India has the obligation to Resettle
them back there, something world needs to share as moral commitment and
shared responsibility.

So much for Indias trumpeting of Multi laterlaism which fails to open mouths at
UN or so far in general, besting even Western Multi Culturalism that sees it as
Politically Incorrect.

This is one reason it soon be realized as hand out wisdom that has wrecked
Western democracies-not Indias age old wisdom at all.

It has lead to Radicalization of Western societies and Home grown terror and
emigration of Jihadis. Now they shudder what happens to Multi Culturalism when
these flowers of Multi Culturalism return home to the West and bloom.

TUNISIA GIVES US HOPE?

With Civil Wars raging endlessly, cities and towns in ruin and desolation, with
almost third of civilian populations displaced and living in massive tent
settlements, it is amazing Modi sees in all this obvious collapse of civilizations -
Democracy is trying to find a voice in West Asia and North Africa
In fact in North Africa its even worse, with another caliphate declared by Al
Shabab and Boko Haram.

Even by a stretch of imagination there is no democracy on the gain anywhere
around vicinity of West Asia and North Africa but Modi has a catch -Tunisia!

Tunisia's success makes us believe that it is possible.??"

We can try harder with him ignoring the general dismal landscape he sees as
hopes and still Tunsia has only another Arab Islamist Terror Springs story.

Tunisia had a regime that was hostile to any ostentatious Islamist activity.
That was before democracy was trying to find a voice -the chilling voice of
Islamist Brotherhood movement.
In fact wearing of Head Scarves or sporting long beards was frowned and
discouraged.

Before post-revolution period under Ben Ali, the country had a secular
culture where religion was separated from not only political, but in public
life. There were restrictions in the wearing of Islamic head scarves (hijab) in
government offices and on public streets and public gatherings.

The government believed the hijab is a "garment of foreign origin having a
partisan connotation".

There were reports that the Tunisian police harassed men with "Islamic"
appearance (such as those with beards), detained them, and sometimes
compelled men to shave their beards off.
[112]

In 2006, the former Tunisian president declared that he would "fight" the
hijab, which he refers to as "ethnic clothing".
[113]


Mosques were restricted from holding communal prayers or classes. After
the revolution however, a moderate Islamist government was elected
leading to more freedom in the practice of religion. It has also led to the rise
of fundamentalist groups such as the Salafists, who call for a strict
interpretation of Sharia law.
[114


This is the success that gives Modi hopes or Islamist radicalization movements
their hopes?
To get this straight- the Pre-Revolution government exiled Political dissidents,
especially Islamists.

This is the kind of democracy rising its voice now-

The Ennahada was launched first as Islamic Tendencies- to steer the society
towards Islamist Militancy through subversion of the struggle for freedom and
democracy fighting the former regimes crack down on Islamist tendencies.

Multi Culturalists world over cheered this as Democracy on the rise as Modi does
and held out high hopes.

Just as elsewhere in West Asia, the Islamists took over the control seats.

After the revolution, a number of Salafist groups emerged and in some
occasions have violently repressed artistic expression that is viewed to be
hostile to Islam.
[7


The Ennahda Movement, formerly banned under the Ben Ali regime, won a
plurality of 90 seats out of a total of 217.
[61]
On 12 December 2011, former
dissident and veteran human rights activist Moncef Marzouki was elected
president.
[62]


On 6 February 2013, Chokri Belaid, the leader of the leftist opposition and
prominent critic of Ennahda, was assassinated.
[64]


Ennahada like PLO and Hamas kept presenting a Janus face to the world of being
Moderates and doing Radicalization.

Succeeding a group known as Islamic Action, the party was founded under
the name of "The Movement of Islamic Tendency" (Arabic:
arakat al-Ittijh al-Islm) in 1981.
[12][13]
In 1989, it changed its
name to arakat an-Nahah.
[14]

The party has been described as one of many parties/movements in
Muslim states "that grew up alongside the Iranian revolution",
[15]
and it was
originally inspired by the Egyptian Muslim Brotherhood.
[16]

The group supported the 1979 takeover of the U.S. embassy in Tehran,
claiming that "It was not an embassy, but a spy centre".
[17]
Their influence
in 1984 was such that, according to Robin Wright, an unnamed British
journalist living in Tunisia stated that the Islamic Tendency was "the single
most threatening opposition force in Tunis. One word from the
fundamentalists will close down the campus or start a
demonstration."
[18]
The group, or members of it, were also responsible for
the bombing of some tourist hotels in the 1980s.
[1


It was this movements spearheading its own return after its banning for above
Islamic Tendencies of terrorism that was hailed by Leftists world over as
Democracy in rise!
For two decades the Islamists remained outsiders and for all practical purposes
non-existent. The Arab springs-boarded they have returned and even captured
power.
While liberal media keeps to lies that these are Moderates-

On 13 November 2011, the party's general secretary Hamadi Jebali held a
joint rally in Sousse together with a parliamentary deputy of the
Palestinian Hamas party.

In a tone sharply in contrast to official statements of the party, Jebali
referred to the occasion as "a divine moment in a new state, and in,
hopefully, a 6th caliphate," and that "the liberation of Tunisia will, God
willing, bring about the liberation of Jerusalem."
[37]


When Hamas leadership arrived for a visit to Tunisia, people at the airport
were heard shouting "Kill the Jews." Tunisian Jews said Ennhada
leadership was slow to condemn the shouting.
[38]


This is what Narender Modi hails as Tunisian Success!

This is what will happen if you blindly mouth Leftist fads and slogans without
scrutiny and as Indias age old Wisdom and Partyline- Multi lateralism!

Multi Culturalism labeled Multi lateralism will still be the nurse maid of all Islamist
Radical Movements and make you hail their Success and miss the point.
Narender Modi simply has his facts wrong about Arab Springs and Tunisia.


NETANYAHU SPELLS OUT THE DANGER OF NUCLEAR IRAN AND IRAN AS
TERRORIST EPICENTER

Pakistan was projected as Moderate ally in the Global War against Terrorism-but
continues to remain as safe haven that it was to Osama Bin laden.

Pakistan like Qatar and Saudi Wahabis are running with the hare and hunting with
the hound.

Netanyahu too begins with same opening statement- of Israel's desire for Peace,
but he shows clearly how this Peace isnt the priority but Islamist Jihad by
his neighbors.
While he calls for Arabs to partnership against Militant Islamism, we have Modi
articulate the same difficulty in obtaining the objective of Peace only tangentially.


While Pakistan made full use of opportunity at podium to lambaste India for its
Islamist insurgency in Kashmir valley, and Iran accuse Israel of Genocide, Modi
refuses to provide Retort and detailed Refutation to their Islamist propaganda-

"Raising issues in this forum will derail the efforts to resolve the issues between
our two countries. Instead, today, we should be thinking about the victims of
floods in Jammu and Kashmir."

As if this magnanimous gesture not Refuting Pakistan's systematic malingering
and assault on India's territorial integrity wouldnt suffice, he reminds the world of
'Victims'.

It is shocking to hear Indian Prime minister inform this Assembly of World Nations
that those 'victims' that should come to their mind are Not the entire Kashmiri
minorities just as witnessed in West Asia - the Kashmiri Pundits and Sikhs.

"In India, we have organized massive flood relief operations and have also offered
assistance for Pakistan Occupied Kashmir."

This constant Projection of Victim hood is Leftist Liberal rhetoric in Discussions
about issues with Islamist settings.


"India desires a peaceful and stable environment for its development. A nation's
destiny is linked to its neighborhood. That is why my Government has placed the
highest priority on advancing friendship and cooperation with her neighbours.

This includes Pakistan. I am prepared to engage in a serious bilateral dialogue
with Pakistan in a peaceful atmosphere, without the shadow of terrorism, to
promote our friendship and cooperation.

Terrorism is taking new shape and new name. No country, big or small, in the
north or the south, east or west, is free from its threat.

Are we really making concerted international efforts to fight these forces, or are
we still hobbled by our politics, our divisions, our discrimination between
countries, distinction between good and bad terrorists? Even today, states allow
terrorist sanctuaries on their territory or use terrorism as instruments of their
policy.

While Netanyahu alerts the world over implications of a Nuclearised Iran and its
avowed commitments to export Islamic Revolution, Indian Prime Minister could
have educated the real cause of Pakistan becoming a Safe haven and breeding
ground for Islamist terrorism-the Nuclear arsenal.

This Nuclear Black mail has cost India dearly and this Nuclear Card was what West
and United States is unable to negotiate to eradicate the Terrorist sanctuaries.

A call for Nuclear Disarmament of a dangerously failed State of Pakistan and its
linkage with Irans Nuclear quest as part of Islamic movements towards world
Domination and intimidation should have been a concern of India that must be
told as shared grave concern of world nations.

Netanyahu presents the imminent Nuclear threat from Islamist Militancy for the
global community while Modi fails to highlight the rise of Nuclear Pakistan as a
Global hub of Islamist terrorism and the catastrophe that could happen when this
failed State starts falling apart and Islamist militias gain those Weapons of Mass
destruction.

We welcome efforts to combat terrorism's resurgence in West Asia, which is
affecting countries near and far. The effort should involve the support of all
countries in the region.

In all this the call is not to lead but be lead by others initiatives and agenda.

While Netanyahu informs the real foe as having very clear identifiable traits
shared across the globe as Militant Islam and leads the General Assembly towards
that Common Denominator as Militant Islam and its movements of insurgencies
and insurrections against Free societies, he is giving a Call and leads the march to
new direction.

Modi tells us We should put aside our differences and mount a
concerted international effort to combat terrorism and extremism.
As a symbol of this effort, I urge you to adopt the Comprehensive
Convention on International Terrorism.

There will be a problem doing this with 56 countries of the Islamic
Block in UN.

United Nations itself is under the thumb of this Arab lead block.

The role of UN itself has been so far inimical to Nations best with Islamist
insurgencies such as India in Kashmir where UN role was to make it easier to
sustain that insurgency and muddle matters with its Resolutions.

Its Human Rights Commission has been reduced to script readers of Islamist
propaganda and obsessions ignoring all violations by Islamist movements such as
deployment of Human shields and extracting political advantages.

The position of United Nations agencies has been hostile to States facing such
Insurgencies of Terrorist movements such as Srilankas tackling of LTTE milking its
use of Human Shields for sympathies and smearing the State as Violating Human
Rights.

But the UN is set up on the pedestal by Indian PM while Netanyahu puts it on the
dock over its Double Standards.


Today, as I stand here, I am equally aware of the hopes that are
pinned on this great assembly. I am struck by the sacred belief
that brought us together.

An extraordinary vision and a clear recognition of our shared
destiny brought us together to build this institution for advancing
peace and security, the rights of every human being and
economic development for all. From 51 nations then, today 193
sovereign flags fly at this building. Each nation, born
into FREEDOM , has sought a place here with the same belief and
hope.

We have achieved much in the past six decades in our mission in
ending wars, preventing conflict, maintaining peace, feeding the
hungry, striving to save our planet and creating opportunities for
children. 69 UN peacekeeping missions since 1948 have made the
blue helmet the colour of peace.

That much poetry doesnt measure with the colossal failures of
the UN in preventing Genocides and continuing conflicts and
spread of Islamist militancy across nations.

The only dot of realism is Indias claim to Security Council
membership.


Our efforts must begin here - in the United Nations.

We must reform the United Nations, including the Security
Council, and make it more democratic and participative.
Institutions that reflect the imperatives of 20th century won't be
effective in the 21st. It would face the risk of irrelevance; and we
will face the risk of continuing turbulence with no one capable of
addressing it.



ECONOMO-CENTRIC REFOCUS- a favorite liberal ploy to avert gazing at harsh
reality of Militant Islam

"The eradication of poverty must remain at the core of the Post-2015
Development Agenda and command our fullest attention."

This Refocus is actually a shying away from the challenge to Islamist quest for
World Domination that thwarts all economic achievements, diverts Resources to
combating its menace and undoes whatever Development already there as
precarious and wasted in conflicts.

Unless the Islamist Militancy, insurgencies and Terrorism are confronted,
defeated and removed from world scene- no amount of Economic Refocus will
lead to lasting prosperity or Peace.

The Refocus should have been on tackling Globalization of Islamist Terrorism and
Militant Islam's Expansion in order for Poverty to be fully eliminated and
economic Development be sustained free from its diversion and threat
to Destabilization and collapse of Economic edifices any time as
precarious achievements that can be toppled at ease by Conflicts kick started by
Global of Jihadis.

There can be no lasting Economic Development or Removal of Poverty unless
Global Jihad is surmounted, sidelined and eliminated.

For Economic activities to be sustained to eliminate Global poverty, Peace is
indispensable between nations and within societies.

The Peace between Nation States and within International Societies is impossible
if the Focus shifts from the International Islamist movements seeking world
domination by disrupting World Order.

To eliminate Global Poverty, the menace of Islamist quest for World Domination
diverting and draining national resources is imperative that it be first removed
from world scene.


Conclusion
I have only highlighted the shallow and unimaginative speech by Indian Prime
Minister who must do more study and arrange his ideology with more deeper
truths than Populism, Leftist canards and Liberal Myths.
I havent critically held up Netanyahus speech at the UN in contrast and have left
that for readers to check out in this video.
Modi must improve his understandings of Geopolitics and ideological matters.
Presently he is carried over the crest of euphoria but the shortcomings will come
back to haunt.
Hailing Arab Springs thats floundering in devastation, getting facts wrong on
Tunisia and West Asia and West Africa in general, reinventing Multi Culturalism
just when Western democracies are facing its ruinous payback, failing to remind
UN of its increasing obsolesce and its horrific pursuit of every terrorist movement
and insurrection and cause against Democratic States by endorsing their use of
Human Shields and Human Rights issues, failure of any Peace Keeping mission or
Intervention to rescue the Yazhidis and Mandeans and Christian minorities who
were slaughtered freely till US airstrikes by ISIS, being flowery and vague, and
distracting burning issues towards Marxist Economic factors and emancipation
since nobody would disagree with need to eliminate Poverty-any more than
anyone could disagree with need to fight Ebola or eliminate all Diseases in the
world.
If you watch the Prime Minister of Israel in the same situation and shows- and
how he has managed to articulate, without resort to such fallacies and rhetoric
borrowed from Leftism- if you listen to that historic speech where we for once
hear spade being called a spade- you will understand between the two Prime
Ministers who delivered a real speech that mattered for both their own countries
and the assembly of World that heard.


FULL SPEECH OF ISRAELI PRIME MINISTER BENJAMIN NETANYAHU AT THE UNITED
NATIONS ASSEMBLY

http://youtu.be/Cl1YsJ5V-6w