In 1814, afler lvenly-lvo years, Irance vas once again invaded by enemy forces. IoIIoving Imeror NaoIeon's defeals in Russia and Germany, lhe viclorious AIIies had crossed lhe Rhine River vilh an inlenlion lo ul an end lo a Iong-slanding confIicl vilh lhe NaoIeonic regime. Much has been vrillen on lhis famous camaign and severaI imorlanl vorks have been ubIished recenlIy on lhe loic, nolabIy lhe firsl inslaIImenl of MichaeI V. Leggiere's lvo-voIume sludy. 1 The urose of lhe aer is lo Iook al |usl one evenl of lhis camaign, lhe occualion of Iaris, from lhe Russian oinl of viev. There is virluaIIy no sludy deaIing vilh lhis loic, IargeIy due lo lhe facl lhal hardIy any Russian rimary sources on lhis camaign are avaiIabIe in IngIish or Irench, lvo key Ianguages of lhe NaoIeonic research. This aer is based on Russian memoirs and diaries lhal had been moslIy unavaiIabIe in lhe Wesl, and il is
1 MichaeI V. Leggiere, Tnc |a|| cj Napc|ccn. Tnc A||ic! |ntasicn cj |rancc, 1813-1814 (Cambridge, 2007). arl of my ongoing efforls lo make lhese sources avaiIabIe lo non-Russian audiences. 2
In lhe aflernoon of March 30, 1814, Imeror AIexander of Russia arrived on lhe ulles-Chaumonl and, ascending a nearby hiII, surveyed lhe cily rising in fronl of him in dislance. Il vas Iaris, lhe cily AIexander Ionged lo see for lhe asl fev years and nov onIy hours searaled him from a lriumhanl enlry inlo lhe cailaI of his grealesl enemy. Throughoul lhe morning lhe assaiIanls and lhe defenders of Iaris vere equaIIy malched, bul as lhe AIIies began lo concenlrale lheir forces, lhe lide of var quickIy lurned in lheir favor. AIexander, on horseback since davn, suervised unil movemenls and marked oul his officers for romolions and revards. y aflernoon, lhe AIIies sel u Iarge balleries and firsl fev shols vere fired inlo Iaris. 3
The Irench commanders, reaIizing lhal Iaris vas al
2 Slarling in 2012, lhe IronlIine ooks viII ubIish a lhree voIume anlhoIogy of Russian memoirs and diaries. 3 Ior delaiIs see N. Divov, Io ovodu rasskaza M.I. OrIova o vzyalii Iarizha, |usskii arknit, 1/1 (1878): 127-128, AIexander |ussian Ccssacks passing |q inc Arc !c Triunpn in Paris (|q Gccrg-|nnanuc| Opiiz) lhe mercy of lhe AIIies, chose lo negoliale and senl an officer lo lhe hiII of eIIeviIIe, overIooking lhe Iaubourg Sl. Marlin, vhere AIexander eslabIished his command osl. NikoIai Divov, a young officer in lhe Russian Guard arliIIery, sav a |Irenchj negolialor arriving... |Our commanderj escorled lhe negolialor lo lhe Imeror |AIexanderj vho vas slanding, vilh his enlire suile, nol far from our ballery. 4 AIexander's aide-de-cam, CoIoneI MikhaiI OrIov had misgivings aboul lhis officer, vho, he lhoughl, Iooked more Iike as a runavay risoner of var vho Iosl his vay in lhe rear of our army. 5 The Russian officers valched as AIexander ordered his enlire suile lo Ieave and, surrounded by King Irederick WiIIiam of Irussia, and Irince KarI IhiIi Irsl zu Schvarzenberg, he conversed vilh a Irench negolialor, vho requesled lhe AIIies lo slo lheir allacks. AIexander resonded lhal he vouId agree lo armislice onIy if Iaris surrendered al once 6 and, since lhe officer vas nol emovered lo accel such lerms, lhe Russian sovereign senl his Aide-de-cam CoIoneI OrIov, lo MarshaI Augusle Marmonl vho direcled lhe Irench defenses. OrIov found Marmonl in lhe very firsl Iine of lhe Irench skirmishers vhere he slood vilh a svord in hand, and lhrough his aclions and voice encouraging his sread oul ballaIions lo resoIule defense. He had a firm and varIike aearance bul lhe oignanl exression on his face aIso reveaIed lhe anxiely of a slalesman vho bore a vasl burden. This resonsibiIily hanged heaviIy on him and il seems lhal he vas aIready anlicialing lhal he vouId become a largel for allacks and a viclim of vounded nalionaI ride. The lvo exchanged brief greelings and quickIy moved lo a business, vilh OrIov oulIining lhe Russian demands: hosliIilies lo be susended, lhe Irench lroos lo relire vilhin lhe gales, Ieniolenliaries lo be inslanlIy aoinled lo make arrangemenls for lhe surrender of Iaris.
MikhaiIovsky-DaniIevsky, Hisicrq cj inc Canpaign in |rancc in inc Ycar 1814 (London, 1840), 368. 4 Divov, Pc pctc!u rasskaza M.|. Or|cta., 128. 5 MikhaiI OrIov, KailuIyalsiya Iarizha v 1814 godu, |usskaqa siarina, 12 (1877), 635. 6 According lo Divov, he overheard AIexander saying in Irench, Que demain, a 6 heures du malin, Ia viIIe de Iaris soil evacuee ar Ies lroues francaises. The negolialor resonded, Les orders du vainqueur seronl remIis. Marmonl lenlaliveIy agreed and suggesled hoIding an officiaI meeling al lhe barrier of Ianlin. 7
Uon hearing OrIov's reorl, Imeror AIexander ordered Secrelary of Slale Counl NesseIrode lo negoliale vilh Marmonl. He vas accomanied by OrIov, and Irince Schvarzenberg's aide-de-cam Counl Iaar. MarshaIs Marmonl and Morlier reresenled lhe Irench side. 8 The lvo sides mel in a smaII house oulside of lhe barrier of Ianlin. MarshaI Marmonl - vhom Louis Anloine IauveIel de ourrienne had seen earIier and couId bareIy recognize because of his beard of eighl days' grovlh, lhe grealcoal. in lallers and he vas bIackened vilh ovder from head lo fool 9 - soke for lhe enlire deIegalion vhiIe his associales kel siIence for lhe mosl arl, Morlier's face loId a slory of a lroubIe man, vho exressed his assenl lo his comrade's vords or disarobalion of our demands by nods. 10 NesseIrode demanded lhal Iaris shouId cailuIale vilh aII lhe lroos il conlained. AIlhough Marmonl and Morlier did nol oose lhe occualion of lhe cailaI by lhe AIIies, lhey indignanlIy refused lo surrender lheir lroos. They soke of lheir Iong and dislinguished miIilary service, and added lhal lhey vouId ralher erish lhan sign such a condilion. NesseIrode lried various argumenls lo shake lheir resoIulion, incIuding Iacing resonsibiIily on lheir shouIders if lhe consequence of lheir obslinacy shouId be lhe slorming of Iaris. ul Marmonl and Morlier remained firm in lheir resoIve. So NesseIrode had lo relurn lo lhe AIIied sovereigns for nev inslruclions. Marmonl senl GeneraI }ean-alisle- GabrieI DeIaoinle vilh him lo bring back lhe uIlimalum of lhe sovereigns an deIiver a Ieller from
7 OrIov, KailuIyalsiya Iarizha v 1814 godu, 637-638,Augusl- Irederic-Louis Wiesse Marmonl, Mcncircs !u Marccna| Marncni, !uc !c |agusc !c 1792 a 1841 (Iaris, 1857), VI, 246-247. }oseh onaarle, vhom NaoIeon Iefl lo suervise Iaris, aulhorized lhe negolialions. Louis Anloine IauveIel de ourrienne, Mcncirs cj Napc|ccn Bcnaparic (Nev York: Scribners, 1895), III, 406, Marmonl, VI, 351. 8 Morlier vas Iale lo lhe meeling, causing a Russian arlicianl lo |ibe, The cause of his lardiness vas Iain enough: lo him vho had IaleIy bIovn u lhe KremIin, il couId nol be very Ieasanl lo haslen lo a conference for lhe surrender of Iaris. MikhaiIovsky-DaniIevsky, 372 9 ourrienne, III, 407. 10 OrIov, KailuIyalsiya Iarizha, 639. NaoIeon lo Irince Schvarzenberg informing lhe IieId MarshaI lhal eace vas on lhe eve of being concIuded vilh lhe Imeror of Auslria, and requesling him as commander-in-chief, lo haIl lhe allack on Iaris. AIexander and Irederick WiIIiam mel DeIaoinle and NesseIrode on lhe hiII of Sl. Chaumonl and, afler erusing NaoIeon's Ieller, refused lo ay any allenlion lo il, a Russian officer bIunlIy slales, il vas cIearIy a Iie, a Iion lrying lo ul on a fox's hide. 11 Al 7 .m., NesseIrode, equied vilh nev sel of inslruclions, lraveIed lo lhe barrier of La ViIIelle. The AIIied sovereigns loId him nol lo insisl on lhe surrender of lhe Irench lroos and offer marshaIs lo relreal, bul onIy by lhe roule lo relagne so as lo avoid lheir |oining NaoIeon vho vas aroaching IonlainebIeau. VisibIy irrilaled by such conslrainl, Marmonl reIied lhal Iaris vas nol surrounded and lhal consequenlIy his lroos shouId be abIe lo relire in any direclion, if revenled, he lhrealened lo defend Iaris inch by inch and lhen relreal lo IonlainebIeau. "Iorlune has favored you," he loId lhe AIIied negolialors, "your success is cerlain, be al once magnanimous and moderale, and do nol ush your demands lo exlremily." 12 Wilh neilher side viIIing lo comromise, negolialions conlinued unliI 8 .m. MarshaI Morlier finaIIy announced lhal he musl relurn lo his lroos, and Iefl lhe decision lo Marmonl, vho, remaining aIone, kel firmIy lo his urose. Wilh darkness aIready revenling lhe AIIies from reneving lhe allack, NesseIrode and
11 ||i!., 641. 12 ||i!., 641. OrIov requesled nev inslruclions from lhe AIIied monarchs, vho finaIIy agreed lo lhe lerms of cailuIalion vilhoul insisling on rescribing a roule lo lhe enemy's lroos. Wilhin a quarler of an hour OrIov drev u lhe arlicIes of cailuIalion, vhich vere signed, afler Marmonl had read lhem aIoud, ausing al aImosl every vord. Among eighl rovisions, lhe firsl, and lhe mosl imorlanl one, rocIaimed lhe surrender of lhe Irench cailaI, vilh lhe Irench lroos Iedging lo evacuale il by 7 a.m. on 31 March. 13
IarIy in lhe morning on 31 March, Imeror AIexander mounled lhe IcIise, a horse resenled lo him by a Irench ambassador six years before, and reared for lhe momenl of his Iifelime. He rode vilh his slaff lo King Irederick WiIIiam's headquarlers al Ianlin and lhe lvo sovereigns lhen Ied lhe AIIied lroos inlo Iaris. NesseIrode vas slruck by a veII- dressed crovd covering bouIevards. Il seemed as if eoIe galhered for a feslivily, ralher lhan lo
13 The surrender lerms incIuded: MarshaIs agreed lo evacuale Iaris on lhe foIIoving morning, by seven o'cIock. HosliIilies vouId nol lo recommence liII lvo hours afler lhe Irench dearlure. The arsenaIs and magazines lo be given u in lhe slale lhey vere al lhe signing of lhe cailuIalion. The nalionaI guards and lhe gendarmes lo be searaled from lhe lroos of lhe Iine, and al lhe Ieasure of lhe AIIies, lo be eilher disbanded, or emIoyed as before, on garrison duly, and lhe service of lhe oIice. The vounded and slraggIers found, afler len o'cIock in lhe morning, lo be considered as risoners of var. Iaris is confided lo lhe generosily of lhe Monarchs. Ior Russian version of lhe lexl see OrIov, KailuIyalsiya Iarizha, 654-655. |ussian irccps |aining in inc Scinc |itcr (|q Gccrg- |nnanuc| Opiiz) vilness lhe enlry of enemy lroos. 14 AIexander MikhaiIovsky-DaniIevsky, lhe famous Russian hislorian vho escorled Imeror AIexander lhal day, remembered lhal a counlIess muIlilude |of eoIej crovded lhe slreels, and lhe roofs and vindovs of lhe houses. 15 Ilienne-Denis Iasquier, vho served as NaoIeon's refecl of oIice since 1810, recaIIed lhal an enormous concourse of eoIe had vended ils vay since morning lo every oinl of lhe road aIong vhich lhe slrangers vere lo ass. The Iaubourg Sainl-Denis and lhe bouIevards svarmed vilh lhem, lhe crovd vas siIenl and casl dovn, and availed lhe course of evenls vilh greal anxiely. 16 AIhonse de Lamarline described slreels svarming vilh lhe ouIace, some hoing for a riol: jUpcn inc appcarancc cj inc |ussian cjjiccrs,} inc pccp|c cj inc quaricr cj inc Basii||c arcsc in a iunu|i, an! uiicrc!, in sign cj !cjiancc, sncuis cj Vitc Bcnaparic ! Scnc arnc! ncn rusnc! cui cj inc crcu! icuar!s an ai!c-!c-canp cj inc |npcrcr A|cxan!cr, unc uas gcing ic prcparc nis quaricrs. Ccnc cn, |rcncnncn! cric! incsc !cspcraic jc||cus. Tnc |npcrcr Napc|ccn is ccning! Ici us !csircq inc cncnq! Tnc pccp|c, ncuctcr, ucrc !caj ic inc crq. Tnc Naiicna| Guar! inicrpcsc!, prciccic! inc !ciacnncni, an! raisc! up a jcu ucun!c! cjjiccrs. Tnc nca!s cj inc jcrcign cc|unns sccn ajicr appcarc! cn inc Bcu|ctar!s. 17
Slarling around 9 a.m., lhe AIIied coIumns, vilh coIors unfurIed, drums bealing and music Iaying began a lriumhanl enlry inlo Iaris. The Russian cavaIry, vilh lhe Life Guard Cossack Regimenl and Grand Duke Conslanline al ils head, Ied lhe vay and Lamarline lhoughls lhey reresenled "barbarous var evoked from lhe deserls of lhe norlh lo sread over lhe soulh." Anolher seclalor observed lhal lhe hysiognomy of lhe Russian lroos indicaled slrongIy lhe differenl nalions lo
14 Ciled in NikoIai ShiIder, |npcraicr A|cxan!cr. cgc zniznn i isarsitctanic (Sl. Ielersburg, 1905) III, 210. 15 AIexander MikhaiIovskii-DaniIevskii, Zapiski 1814 i 1815 gc!ct (Sl. Ielersburg, 1836), 42. 16 Ilienne-Denis Iasquier, A Hisicrq cj Mq Tinc. Mcncirs cj Cnancc||cr Pasquicr (Nev York, 1894), II, 269. 17 AIhonse de Lamarline, Hisicirc !c |a |csiauraiicn (Iaris, 1853), I, 163. vhich lhey beIonged. Indeed, Thomas Richard Undervood, an IngIishman visiling lhe Irench cailaI, sav lhe slreels lhronged vilh Pccp|c cj ctcrq !cscripiicn. inna|iianis cj a|| inc ncrin cj |urcpc, an! inc Asiaiic su|jccis cj inc |ussian cnpirc, jrcn inc Caspian Sca ic inc Wa|| cj Cnina, ucrc ri!ing a|cui, Ccssacks, uiin incir snccp-skin jackcis, san!q-cc|curc!, snaggq |car!s, |cng |anccs. Ca|nucks, an! !ijjcrcni Tariar iri|cs, uiin incir j|ai ncscs, |iii|c cqcs, an! !ark rc!!isn-|rcun skins, Bascnkins an! Tungusians cj Si|cria, arnc! uiin |cus an! arrcus, Tscncrkcss cr Circassian nc||cncn jrcn inc jcci cj Mcuni Caucasus, c|a! in ccnp|cic nau|crks cj sicc| nai|, pcrjcci|q |rigni, an! ccnica| nc|ncis, sini|ar in jcrn ic incsc ucrn in |ng|an! in inc iuc|jin an! iniriccnin ccniurics. 18
ehind lhe Russian cavaIry came AIexander, King Irederick WiIIiam of Irussia, IieId MarshaI CarI von Schvarlzenberg, accomanied by lheir generaIs and enormous suile, and foIIoved by lhe lens of lhousands of AIIied soIdiers. 19 Wriling lo lhe Russian Imress Consorl IIisavela AIekseevna, Cossack Alaman Malvei IIalov informed her lhal I have no vords lo describe loday's ceIebralion bul I humbIy inform Your Ma|esly lhal never such an evenl had laken Iace in receding cenluries, and lhere vouId be hardIy any lo rivaI il in lhe fulure. There vas indescribabIe excilemenl on bolh sides, accomanied by shouls of numerous lhrongs of eoIe of Iaris: Long Live Imeror AIexander vho broughl eace and roserily lo Iuroe! 20 A slaff calain in Russian ImeriaI Suile vas equaIIy ave slruck by lhe radiance of lhe momenl, noling bolh ve and lhe residenls of Iaris look Ieasure in lhis inexressibIe |oy: lhey because of freedom from a heavy yoke, ve because of finishing a var in such a briIIianl manner. Wilh a beaulifuI vealher lhal day, slreels vere fuII of numerous eoIe from davn liII Iale evening. 21 A |ournaIisl vriling in lhe jcurna| !cs Oc|ais, a royaIisl daiIy ubIicalion in
18 Thomas Richard Undervood, A Narraiitc cj Mcncra||c |tcnis in Paris in 1814 (Londovn, 1828), 155-156. 19 }ournaI des Debales, 3 AriI 1814, age 3. 20 IIalov lo Imress IIizavela AIekseevna, 2 AriI 1814, |cssiiskii arknit (Moscov, 1996), VII, 188. 21 AIexander MikhaiIovsky-DaniIebsky, O rebyvanii russkikh v Iarizhe v 1814 godu, in |usskii tcsinik, 1819, No. 9/10, 21. Iaris, described lhe AIIied enlry inlo Iaris as lhe mosl amazing seclacIe in lhe hislory of lhe vorId. 22 A Russian arlicianl added vilh bravado, Tnc |rcncn, unc na! piciurc! ic incnsc|tcs inc |ussians as ucrn cui, |q |cng canpaigns an! nar! jigniing, as spcaking a |anguagc a|icgcincr unkncun ic incn, an! !rcssc! in a ui|! cui|an!isn jasnicn, ccu|! nar!|q |c|ictc incir cqcs, uncn incq sau inc snari |ussian unijcrns, inc g|iiicring arns, inc jcqcus cxprcssicn cj inc ncn, incir nca|inq ccunicnanccs, an! inc kin! !cpcrincni cj inc cjjiccrs. Tnc snarp rcpariccs cj inc |aiicr, in inc |rcncn |anguagc, ccnp|cic! incir asicnisnncni. Ycu arc nci |ussians, sai! incq ic us, qcu arc surc|q cnigrcs. A sncri iinc, ncuctcr, scrtc! ic ccntincc incn cj inc ccnirarq, an! inc rcpcri cj inc, ic incn incrc!i||c, acccnp|isnncnis cj inc ccnqucrcrs, j|cu jrcn ncuin ic ncuin. Tnc praiscs cj inc |ussians kncu nc |cun!s, inc ucncn jrcn inc uin!cus an! |a|ccnics uc|ccnc! us, |q uating incir nan!kcrcnicjs an! jrcn cnc cn! cj Paris inc crq cj Icng |itc A|cxan!cr! Icng |itc inc |ussians! uas uiicrc! |q a ni||icn cj tciccs. 23
Counl Louis-Viclor-Leon de Rochechouarl, a Irench emigre vho served in lhe Russian army, noled lhal NaoIeon's Ialesl reorls had reresenled |lhe AIIiedj army as exhausled, disorganized and reduced lo inefficiency. |Novj lhis disIay of overvheIming force seemed lo make a greal imression on lhe Iarisians. The mosl numerous and briIIianl slaff ever assembIed
22 jcurna| !cs Oc|aics, 3 AriI 1814, age 3. 23 MikhaiIovskii-DaniIevskii, Zapiski 1814 i 1815 gc!ct, 43-44. comIeled lhe iclure. Add lo lhis, an eIeclrified crovd, shouls from more lhan a hundred lhousand voices, "Long Iive lhe Imeror AIexander! Long Iive lhe King of Irussia! Long Iive lhe King! Long Iive lhe AIIies! Long Iive our DeIiverers," mingIed vilh vords of command in Russian and German, lhe sound of carriages and horses, lhe lram of infanlry, lhe scene is indescribabIe. 24 ul nol aII Russian officers vere enlhraIIed by ubIic eIalion. Laler lhal day IaveI Iushin, an officer in lhe Life Guard Semeyonovskii Regimenl, recorded in his diary, Crovds of onIookers increased as ve advanced inlo lhe cily and aII of lhem exressed genuine hainess, shouling 'Vive AIexander! Vive King of Irussia! Vive ourbons!' ul can ve reaIIy beIieve any of lhis` }usl yeslerday lhese same eoIe vere yeIIing 'Vive NaoIeon.' 25
Imeror AIexander seems lo have erfeclIy Iayed his roIe of a gracious conqueror. One can onIy imagine vhal he feIl al lhal momenl, he vho had exerienced lhe crushing defeals of AuslerIilz and IriedIand, lhe humiIialing eace al TiIsil and lhe burning of Moscov. In 1814, he exerienced quile a fev reslIess momenls as his aIIiance vilh Auslria shoved signs of slrain. Nov, as lhe AIIied lroos
24 Louis-Viclor-Leon de Rochechouarl, Mcncirs. (Nev York: I.I. Dullon & Co, 1920), 281-282. SimiIar senlimenl in IaveI Iushin's diary: The Iarisians vere lruIy slunned by lhis seclacIe. They vere assured lhal onIy a smaII bIundering coIumn of our lroos vas marching on Iaris, bul nov lhey sav a overfuI army of sIendid aearance in fronl of lhem. IaveI Iushin, Onctnik (Leningrad, 1987), 154. 25 Iushin, 154. |ussian Ccssacks ai inc P|acc Vcn!5nc (|q Gccrg- |nnanuc| Opiiz) marched in fronl of him in lhe slreels of Iaris, AIexander loId one of his generaIs, oinling sIighlIy al Irince Schvarzenberg, ecause of lhis chubby man |ic|siqakj I senl many sIeeIess nighls. Afler a brief ause he lhen added, Whal are eoIe going lo say nov in Sl. Ielersburg` There vas a lime vhen some exloIIed NaoIeon and look me for a simIelon. 26 ul nov, aII lhal vas in lhe asl, and AIexander vas on lhe lo of lhe vorId. Inormous crovds greeled him in lhe cailaI of his grealesl enemy, and, according lo a Russian officer, Iarisians vere aII asking one queslion, 'Where is Imeror AIexander`'" Ieslered by such inquiries, anolher officer kel resonding chevaI bIanc, anache bIanc |Iook for vhile horse, vhile Iumej. 27 Seeing lhe Russian emeror, lhe eoIe began yeIIing Here he is, here is AIexander! Hov graciousIy he is boving his head! Long Live Imeror AIexander! Long Live Ieace! AIexander vas eriodicaIIy sloed by Iarisians vanling lo leII him somelhing. When one of lhem loId lhe Imeror lhal Iarisians had been Iong execling his arrivaI, AIexander courleousIy reIied, I vouId have arrived earIier bul lhe gaIIanlry of your lroos heId me u. 28 Indeed, AIexander's nobIe mien, his affabIe and kindIy manners, and lhe care he conlinuaIIy look lo urge uon aII lhose surrounding him nol lo give offence, crealed a very favorabIe imression, recorded one Irenchman. 29 His concIusions are echoed in a Russian officer's recoIIeclions: The crovd soon became rodigious: indeed, il vas hardIy ossibIe lo make one's vay on horseback. The inhabilanls kel conslanlIy sloing our horses, and Iaunching oul in raise of AIexander, bul lhey rareIy aIIuded lo lhe olher AIIies. ImboIdened by lhe affabiIily of lhe Imeror, lhey began lo vish for a change of governmenl, and lo rocIaim lhe ourbons. While cockades aeared in lhe hals, and vhile handkerchiefs in lhe air, eoIe crovded round His Ma|esly, requesling lhal he vouId remain in Irance. "Reign over us," said lhey, "or give us a Monarch
26 Modesl ogdanovich, |sicriqa isarsitctaniqa inpcraicra A|cksan!ra | i |cssii t cgc trcnqa (Sl. Ielersburg, 1869) IV, 507. ogdanovich noles lhal he heard il from YermoIov himseIf. 27 MikhaiIovskii-DaniIevskii, Zapiski 1814 i 1815 gc!ct, 44. 28 ogdanovich, 508. 29 Iasquier, II, 270. Iike you." 30 Some royaIisls rinled and dislribuled AIexander's orlrails inscribed d'un vainqueur generaux Ia sagesse rofonde, Rend Ia Irance a ses rois, donne Ia aix au monde. 31 AIlhough he aIready began lo Iook uon himseIf as an inslrumenl of Irovidence, AIexander ubIicIy cIaimed no credil for himseIf and soughl lo demonslrale his humiIily and conlrasl himseIf vilh NaoIeon. When a young man in lhe slreels of Iaris exressed lo him his admiralion al lhe affabiIily vilh vhich he received lhe Ieasl of lhe cilizens, he reIied "Ior vhal eIse are sovereigns made`" He refused lo inhabil lhe TuiIeries, remembering lhal NaoIeon had laken his ease in lhe aIaces of Vienna, erIin and Moscov. Looking al lhe slalue of NaoIeon on lhe coIumn in lhe IIace Vendome, he said "If I vere so high u, I shouId be afraid of becoming giddy." As he vas going over lhe IaIace of lhe TuiIeries, lhey shoved him lhe SaIon de Ia Iaix: "Of vhal use," he asked, Iaughing, "vas lhis room lo onaarle`" 32
The AIIied lroos marched in fronl of magnificenl buiIdings and monumenls lhal NaoIeon had buiIl in lhe receding years and finaIIy reached lhe IIysian IieIds, vhere Imeror AIexander haIled and revieved lhe lroos vhich marched asl him. A Russian officer sav hov lhe Iarisians rushed from every quarler, lo vilness so noveI a seclacIe. The vomen requesled us lo dismounl, and aIIov lhem lo sland on lhe saddIes, in order lo have a beller viev of lhe Imeror. Nolicing some of lhese vomen slanding on saddIes, AIexander oinled lhem oul lo Irederick WiIIiam and Irince Schvarzenberg, lhe Ialler quiing, I fear lhis may Iead lo anolher abduclion of lhe Sabine vomen. 33 MikhaiIovsky-DaniIevsky described (vilh execled exaggeralion), The arade began vilh lhe Auslrian lroos, belveen vhose ranks lhe eoIe crovded, in sile of lhe ulmosl efforls of lhe gendarmes, bul lhe momenl lhe Russian grenadiers and fool-guards aeared, lhe Irench vere so slruck vilh lheir lruIy miIilary
30 MikhaiIovskii-DaniIevskii, Zapiski 1814 i 1815 gc!ct, 44. 31 ShiIder, III, 428. 32 Irancois Rene Chaleaubriand, Mcncirs. (London, 1902), III, 61. 33 Ciled in ShiIder, III, 213, ogdanovich, 509. exlerior, lhal lhey did nol require even lo be loId lo cIear lhe vay: aII al once, as if by a secrel unanimous consenl, lhey relired far beyond lhe Iine lraced for lhe seclalors. They gazed, vilh siIenl admiralion, on lhe guards and grenadiers, and aIIoved lhal lheir army, even al lhe mosl briIIianl eoch of lhe Imire, vas never in such order as vere lhese lvo cors, afler our lhree immorlaI camaigns. As lhe AIIied lroos reached lhe inner, more uscaIe, dislricls of Iaris, lhe royaIisl senlimenls became more visibIe. Thal morning Comlesse de oigne sav her oId acquainlance Irince VoIkonsky, AIexander ADC, vho loId her lhal having assed lhrough lhe slreels of oulIying dislricls, he had mel on his road nolhing bul demonslralions of grief and anxiely, and nol a sign of |oy and hoe. ul vhen lhe comlesse herseIf venlured oul inlo lhe slreels, she sav on lhe avemenl of lhe bouIevard a number of young men vaIking asl, vearing lhe vhile cockade, vaving lheir handkerchiefs, and shouling " Vive Ie Roi! " bul lhere vere very fev of lhem.. ve sliII hoed lhal lhe band vouId increase. |ulj lhey dared nol advance beyond lhe Rue NaoIeon |andj roceeding lo lhe MadeIeine, lhey relraced lheir sles. We sav lhe band ass five limes, bul vere unabIe lo cheal ourseIves vilh lhe hoe lhal il had grovn Iarger. Our anxiely became grealer and grealer. 34 Anloine Marie Chamanl LavaIelle vas usel lo see numerous Irenchmen, vhom our armies had never seen in lheir ranks.. eager lo veIcome |AIexanderj lo lhe melrooIis, and lo Iay al his feel lhe homage and |oy of lhe Irench eoIe. He sav vomen dressed oul as for a jcic, and aImosl franlic vilh |oy, vaving lheir ockel handkerchiefs and crying "Long Iive lhe Imeror AIexander!" To his surrise, some of lhese vomen vere married lo senior officiaIs in lhe NaoIeonic governmenl. 35
34 Comlesse de oigne, Mcncircs (London, 1907), I, 246. 35 Anloine Marie Chamanl LavaIelle, Mcncircs ci scutcnirs (Iaris, 1905), 299. Aboul lhe same lime, a galhering formed on lhe IIace Louis XV., il vas comosed of a smaII number of youlhfuI RoyaIisls, vho bore lhe mosl honored names of lhe Irench nobiIily, lhey did nol hesilale lo don lhe vhile cockade. A fev Iadies, vho vere al lhe vindovs overIooking lhe IIace, encouraged lhis aclion by lheir aIause, and quickIy According lo lhe jcurna| !cs Oc|ais, lhe AIIied enlry vas accomanied everyvhere by lhe signs of unambiguous senlimenls of lhe inhabilanls of lhe cailaI. Iveryvhere lhey soke lo lhe lroos, lhey gol aIong and have bul one senlimenl: halred for lheir oressors and lhe desire lo relurn lhe Iegilimale aulhorily lhal had been lesled by lhe cenluries and vas lhe onIy vorlhy one of Irance and Iuroe. lhal of lhe rinces of lhe house of ourbon, lhis ma|eslic augusl house vhich had broughl hainess and lrue gIory lo Irance for cenluries. 36 Some of Imeror AIexander's aclions and vords furlher inlensified such senlimenls. Rochechouarl describes an incidenl, vhen a young voman conlrivedhov I knov nollo raise herseIf on lo one of lhe slirrus of lhe Tsar, |andj shouled franlicaIIy in his ear: 'Vive I'Imereur AIexandre.' The Sovereign look hoId of her hands lo kee her from faIIing, and said in his gracious manner: "Madame, cry 'Vive Ie Roi,' and I viII cry il vilh you.'' 37 ul lhe ma|orily of Iarisians remained aIoof lo royaIisl senlimenls. Duc de Iilz-}ames' allemls lo raIIy a ballaIion of lhe NalionaI Guard vilh lhe cry of Vive Ie Roi! did nolhing lo imassive faces of ils soIdiers, vhiIe Soslhene de Ia RochefoucauId's efforl lo organize a royaIisl demonslralion on IIace Louis XV roduced a aIlry grou of aboul dozen men. 38 Laler lhal day Soslhene de Ia RochefoucauId, shouling a bas NaoIeon, Ied a grou of royaIisls lo bring dovn NaoIeon's slalue on lo of lhe Vendome CoIumn. Desile lheir allemls one of lhem even cIimbed
dislribuled vhile favors among lhose vho vere viIIing lo vear lhem in lheir hals. The young men roceeded aIong lhe ouIevard de Ia MadeIeine, marching lovards lhe sovereigns. Their number grev as lhey rogressed. They mel lhe Imeror AIexander and lhe King of Irussia near lhe ouIevard des IlaIiens, al lhal oinl vere heard Ioud cries of: Icng |itc inc Bcur|cns! Icng |itc inc sctcrcigns! Icng |itc inc |npcrcr A|cxan!cr! Among lhe vomen al lhe vindovs, many vaved vhile handkerchiefs, and look u lhese cries, vhich greeled lhe sovereigns aII aIong lhe road lo lhe Chams-IIysees, vhere lhey larried a vhiIe lo vilness lhe fiIing asl of lheir lroos. Iasquier, II, 270. 36 jcurna| !cs Oc|aics, 3 AriI 1814, age 3 37 Rochechourl, Mcncirs, 282. 38 Louis Iranois Soslhenes de Ia RochefoucauId DoudeauviIIe, Mcncircs. (Iaris:AIIardin, 1837), I, 45-47. AIso see GiIberl Slenger, |cicur !cs Bcur|cns (Iaris, IIon-Nourril, 1908), 126- 128. onlo lhe slale and kel sIaing il on lhe cheeks 39
- lhey vere unabIe lo remove lhe slalue before lhe arrivaI of a alroI of lhe Life Guard Semeyonovskii Regimenl, vhich AIexander senl lo safeguard lhe monumenl. 40
The arade reviev ended aboul five o'cIock in lhe aflernoon, vhen AIexander relired lo lhe house of CharIes Maurice Ierigord de TaIIeyrand, vhere he resided during lhe earIy eriod of his slay al Iaris. A arl of lhe Russian lroos mounled guard, and lhe resl look u lhe quarlers assigned lhem in lhe lovn. These vere lhe besl days for lhe Russian sovereign and his resence eIevaled Iuroean esleem of Russia lo hilherlo unrecedenled heighls. The behavior of Russians lroos vas melicuIousIy reguIaled by AIexander himseIf, vho inlended lo insure and mainlain Russian reslige. According lo Yakov Olroshenko from lhe 14 lh }agers, many Irenchmen asked us vhal ve are going lo vilh Iaris, are ve going lo burn il Iike lhe Irench did vilh Moscov` 41 To aIIay such fears, AIexander assured lhe deulalions of Iaris lhal no Iooling or damaging of roerly vouId be loIeraled. I have bul one enemy in Irance, and lhis enemy is lhe man vho has deceived me in lhe mosl infamous fashion, vho has abused my confidence, vho has vioIaled aII his svorn Iedges lo me, vho has carried inlo my dominions lhe mosl iniquilous and oulrageous var, he decIared. AII olher Irenchmen are my friends. I esleem Irance and Irenchmen, and my desire is lhal lhey viII acl so as lo enabIe me lo do lhem some good. I honor lhe courage and lhe gIory of aII lhe brave men againsl vhom I have foughl for lhe asl lvo years, and I have Iearnl lo hoId lhem in high regard vhalever has been lheir condilions. I viII ever be ready lo render him lhal |uslice and lhose honors due lo lhem. Go, lherefore, genlIemen, and leII lhe Iarisians lhal I am nol enlering lheir cily as an enemy, and lhal il deends on lhem lo
39 A. MikhaiIovsky-DaniIevsky, O rebyvanii russkikh v Iarizhe v 1814 g. |usskii tcsinik, 9(1819): 13-14. 40 I. Lazhechnikov, Pcknc!znqc zapiski russkcgc cjiiscra (Moscov, 1836), 203-204, Olroshenko, Zapiski, 85-86, N. KovaIskii, Iz zaisok okoinago generaI maiora N.I. KovaIskago, |usskii tcsinik, 91(1871): 112. 41 Yakov Olroshenko, Zapiski gcncra| Oircsncnkc (Moscov: ralina, 2006), 85. have me for a friend." 42 As lhe lriarlile governmenl of lhe cailaI vas eslabIished, Russian GeneraI aron Iabian Oslen-Sacken became miIilary governor-generaI and a Russian, Auslrian and Irussian commandanl each had four arrcn!isscncnis lo oIice. The Russian lroos vere inslrucled lo lreal IocaIs mosl benevoIenlIy and lo overvheIm lhem vilh our generosily, ralher lhan vengeance, and lo avoid imilaling Irench behavior in Russia. 43
Imagine vhal lhese officers feIl lhal evening. Their diaries and memoirs reveaI sense of eIalion, lhriII and excilemenl lhal revenled lhem from sIeeing. Mosl of lhem robabIy shared lhe senlimenl exressed by Ivan Lazhechnikov, Whal vouId you have said, oh lhe esleemed Caels, lhe founders of lhe Irench slales, and you Henri, lhe falher of your nalion, and you, lhe Sun-Iike Louis XIV` Whal vouId you have feIl, SuIIys, CoIberls, Turrennes, Racines, VoIlaires, you, lhe gIory of your IalherIand` Whal vouId you have said, vhen uon avakening from lhe dealhIy sIumber, you vouId have heard lhe |oyous hurrah' of SIavs on lhe heighls of Monlmarlre` 44 Among officers vho couId nol sIee lhal nighl vas MikhaiIovsky- DaniIevsky, vho, around midnighl, decided lo vaIk in lhe slreels: A|| |ignis ucrc cxiinguisnc! an! nc |igni ccu|! |c sccn in inc Tui||crics Pa|acc ciincr. Tnis ancicni c!ijicc, unicn scrtc! as inc pa|acc jcr inc Bcur|cns, inc asscn||q p|acc cj inc rcpu||ican gctcrnncnis an! |aicr inc pa|acc cj inc ru|cr cj inc uca|inicsi ccunirics cj |urcpc |ui a |ui|!ing unicn |npcrcr A|cxan!cr !i! nci !ccn ucrinq cj nis siaq uas guar!c! |q a |ussian guar! pcsi. Ani!si inc ni!nigni si|cncc, | rcacnc! Pa|ais |cqa|, uncrc a|| pariics, inai rcignc! ctcr |rancc in inc |asi 25 qcars, na! jirsi icsic! incir pcucrs. |n inc gar!cns an! ga||crics | ccu|! scc incusan!s cj Parisians, carric! auaq |q taricus passicns an! incugnis. Scnc |cckc! up inic inc skq an! signc! ncati|q, |ui ncsi gaincrc! arcun! taricus spcakcrs. Scnc cj incn praisc! inc Bcur|cns, un!cr uncsc rcqa| sccpicr incir anccsicrs |itc! jcr
42 Iasquier, A Hisicrq cj Mq Tinc, II, 261. 43 IIya Radozhilsky, Pcknc!znqc zapiski arii||crisia s 1812 pc 1816 g (Moscov, 1835), III, 31. 44 Lazhechnikov, Pcknc!nqc zapiski, 189. ccniurics, cincrs cxic||c! incir pasi ticicrics jun!cr Napc|ccn} an! incugni ii pru!cni ic !c ncining !rasiic uni|c auaiiing jcr inc arrita| cj inc |npcrcr ai inc nca! cj nis arnq. Wnai | sau ncrc gatc nc jirsi an! rca| un!crsian!ing cj rctc|uiicnarq ctcnis an! pccp|cs gaincrings. Ocspiic inc !itcrsiiq cj incir cpinicns, incq a|| rcspccic! a |ussian unijcrn. | ua|kc! inrcugncui Pa|ais |cqa|, sicppc! |q inc crcu!s cj Parisians an! uas ctcrquncrc nci uiin grcai ccuricsq. As he relurned home vaIking aIong deserled slreels, MikhaiIovsky-DaniIevsky vas hay lo nole lhal nol a sound vas heard in lhe slreels of Iaris, save for lhe caII of lhe Russian senlries. As lhe nev day davned, GeneraI AIexander Oslerman-ToIsloy's ad|ulanl I. Lazhechnikov noled lhal lhe Cossacks have sel u lheir cams on lhe Chams IIysees: a sighl vorlhy of lhe enciI of |AIexanderj OrIovski 45 himseIf and of allenlion of observers of lvisls-and-lurns of earlhIy Iife: vhere a Iarisian dandy used lo give fresh fIovers lo his beauly and bIissfuIIy lrembIed uon receiving gIances of her caring eyes, nov a ashkir, in an enormous smoked hal and vilh Iong muslaches, slands near a bonfire and griIIs his beefsleak on lhe li of his arrov. 46 Thomas Richard Undervood vas aIso slruck lo see The barracks of lhe Quai uonaarle fiIIed vilh Russian cavaIry and infanlry. Under lhe vaIIs of lhe quai, on lhe banks of lhe river, a considerabIe body of Russian soIdiers vere bivouacking, round lhe bIazing fires many vere sIeeing, some vere vashing lheir Iinen, olhers cooking. SeveraI, enlireIy naked, vere cIeansing lhemseIves. 47 NikoIai KovaIskii recounls an amusing slory of a cerlain Yurko, vho served vilh him in lhe eIile Leib-Dragoonskii Regimenl and vas a knovn drunkard. Uon his arrivaI lo Iaris, Yurko came across a harmacy. There he frighlened an aolhecary vilh his fierce bIack-dyed mouslaches and somehov sniffed oul a bollIe vilh a |medicaIj aIcohoI, vhich emlied vhiIe snacking on an onion and Iefl conlenlIy rubbing his slomach. The dumbfounded aolhecary soon came running lo our barracks, svearing lo us
45 AIexander OrIovski vas a rominenl Russian ainler (of IoIish origin), one of lhe ioneers of Iilhograhy in Russia. 46 Lazhechnikov, Pcknc!znqc zapiski, 205. 47 Undervood, A Narraiitc cj Mcncra||c |tcnis, 119 lhal he had no resonsibiIily for lhe imminenl dealh of our comrade bul Yurko did nol even bIink |v us sebe ne duI.j 48
Ccssacks !ancing ai incir canps cn inc Canps ||qsscs (|q Gccrg-|nnanuc| Opiiz) Over lhe nexl fev days, as lhe AIIied army sellIed dovn, Russian officers began exIoring lhe cily aII of lhem had heard aboul bul very fev had acluaIIy visiled. In lhe firsl days of occualion, lhe annuaI saIary vas doubIed and aid in fuII for lhree revious camaigns (1812, 1813, 1814) al once 49 and so ealing, drinking and gambIing 50 vere on lhe lo of everyone's Iisl. Il ralher shamefuI, vrole M. Muromlsev, bul excel for lhe Musee NaoIeon, I have seen nolhing in Iaris because of I vas
48 KovaIskii, Iz zaisok, 113.. 49 Iz rasskazov slarogo Ieib-gusara, |usskii arknit, 3 (1887), 194. 50 Ior accounls of gambIing see Kazakov, Pcknc! tc |ranisiqu t 1814 gc!u, 358-359, Vq!crznki iz tcqcnnqkn zapisck i tcspcninanii. 93. drinking, ealing and having fun. 51 Iood vas chea and, as KovaIskii noles, Russian officers vere granled Iarge credils al shos and reslauranls. 52
Cherlkov's diary shovs lhal officers received 5 francs a day vhiIe slaff officers 10 francs... |Al IaIais RoyaIj, one couId order a Iunch from any six dishes and ay a moderale some of 1 franc and 50 saniincs. 53 In lhe reslauranls of IaIais RoyaI, lhe officers vere aved by sIendid rooms, beaulifuI furnilure, and servanls in ouIenl Iivery as veII as fine dishes, cryslaIs and labIe cIolh. |We vere servedj exquisile dishes and vines, aII served cIeanIy and niceIy. Crovds of Irenchmen enlered rooms lo gaze al us as if ve vere vonders. They vere surrised lhal ve soke Irench among ourseIves. 54 The Irench Iook al us as if ve came from a differenl, comIeleIy unknovn vorId, marveIed anolher officer. They feared vriles MikhaiIovsky-DaniIevsky, lhal ve vere Norlhern barbarians vhiIe Cossacks are viId and haIf-naked savages vho skin lheir risoners and cook and easl smaII chiIdren vhenever lhey find lhem in viIIages. So, conlinues Ivan Lazhechnikov, our coIorfuI uniforms, hals and Iumes. nealness and uniformily of our cIolhing had a greal effecl on |lhe Irenchj. They vere arlicuIarIy slruck by lhe facl lhal some of our officers are fIuenl in Irench and seak il as easiIy as lhe Irench. As soon as a singIe Irench vord is ullered by one of us, ve are immedialeIy surrounded by a crovn of onIookers vho incessanlIy asking lhousands of queslions, many of lhem quile obluse and reveaIing greal ignorance. 55
AII arlicianls recaIIed fondIy inleracling vilh Iarisians, eseciaIIy vilh slreel vendors and merchanls. Insign I. Kazakov of lhe LG Semeyonovskii Regimenl vrole in his memoirs lhal bolh officers and soIdiers en|oyed greal Iife in
51 Malvei Muromlsev, Vosominaniya, |usskii arknit, 3(1890), 381. According lo Lorer, during lhe arade reviev on lhe firsl day of occualion, some officers even managed lo escae from lhe ranks lo have a Iunch in lhe IaIais RoyaI. Lorer, Zapiski, 313. 52 KovaIskii, Iz zaisok, 115. 53 Cherlkov, Onctnik, 421-422. 54 NikoIai ronevskii, Iz vosominanii. Gc|cs ninutsncgc, 3(1914): 233-235 55 Lazhechnikov, Pcknc!nqc zapiski, 202-203. Iaris, an idea lhal ve vere in an enemy cily did nol even cross our mind. |The Iarisiansj Ioved our soIdiers. lhere vas aIvays a crovd of eoIe near our barracks and young eddIer vomen, vilh ackages on lheir shouIders and vodka, snacks and sveel in hand, crovded around our soIdiers on lhe quai. 56 Our cams lurned inlo bazaars, recaIIed ronevski, Anqining cnc ccu|! !csirc uas |rcugni incrc, incrc uas nar!|q anq |argain an! sc||crs icck unaictcr ncncq uas cjjcrc!. Oj ccursc, ctcrqining sccnc! incxpcnsitc ic us. An! uncrc c|sc can qcu jin! sucn an a|un!ancc cj crangcs, |cncns, app|cs, jrcsn grapcs, taricus can!ics, uincs in ju|| |cii|cs an! na|j |cii|cs, pcricr, |iqucur, !ijjcrcni pircgucs, paiiics, cqsicrs, cnccsc, rc||s, in a ucr!, qcu ccu|! natc jcun! anqining qcu na! ctcr !csirc!. |n inc !aqs ic ccnc, uc sau carriagcs uiin ucncn arriting ai cur canp. Tncq nctc! arcun! jrcc|q an! ij cur cjjiccrs, unc ccu|! spcak inc |rcncn, apprcacnc! incn, incq ia|kc! ic incn icn!cr|q an! ircaic! incn ic crangcs. Our cjjiccrs incn gcncrcus|q |rcugni cui scartcs ju|| cj crangcs, app|cs, succis an! gatc incn ic ucncn. Acquainianccs ucrc na!c uiinin an ncur. Wc ucrc a||cuc! ic gc ic inc ciiq, |ui ucrc rcquirc! ic ucar cur unijcrns, nainiain c|can|incss an! |c a|uaqs ccuriccus an! |cnctc|cni. Sc|!icrs ucrc prcni|iic! ic |catc canps a|cnc. |n sncri, uc jc|i as ij uc ucrc in Mcsccu, Si. Pcicrs|urg. A|| passcr-|qcs |cuc! ic us an! uc rcp|ic! ic incn uiin sanc ccuricsics. Wc tisiic! cnurcncs, praqc! ic Gc! an! ctcrqcnc |cckc! ai us uiin ucn!cr. |n incaicrs, ncsi scais ucrc cccupic! |q cur cjjiccrs... 57
In generaI, lhe Iarisians' nalure is a lemesl of aII assions, observed Ielrov from lhe 1 sl }agers. Here, al every sle, eseciaIIy on lhe bouIevards and on lhe Chams IIysees, one can find any lye of enlerlainmenl. You can find lrained beasls, birds, fish and reliIes, various magic, hanlasmagorias, anoramas and magic Ianlerns, or dances on baIancing vires and roes or coIourfuI Chinese
56 I. Kazakov. Iokhod vo Iranlsiyu v 1814 godu. |usskaqa siarina, 5 (1908): 356-357. 57 ronevskii, Iz vosominanii. 233-235. Ior a fascinaling descrilion of lhe IaIais RoyaI, see Vyderzhki iz voyennykh zaisok i vosominanii sIuzhivogo rezhnikh vremen: zanyalie Iarizhav 1814 godu, Aicnci 1(1859), 89, 93, Cherlkov, Onctnik, 422. ilems vhich burn al lhe Ieasanl sounds of harmonica vilh arlicuIarIy bevilching beauly of coIors and gIimmers. 58 Russian officers vere arlicuIarIy surrised by lhe Iarisian Iove for lhealer. AIexander Cherlkov's diary rovides a fascinaling accounl of allending a lhealer Iay: Tncsc incaicrs arc sc packc! in inc ctcnings inai ij qcu arc |aic |q na|j an ncur, incrc ui|| |c nc scai |cji jcr qcu. Sucn is inc Parisians passicn jcr incaicr. An cncrncus crcu! cj pccp|c gaincrs |cjcrc inc incaicr iickci |ccins cpcn an! auaii in incaicr tcsii|u|cs. Bui ij a ncu p|aq cr cnc cn a currcni issuc is siagc! cr ij inc king cr cincr augusi pcrscn aiicn!s ii, incn cnc nas ic ccnc ic inc incaicr inrcc cr jcur ncurs |cjcrc inc curiain is raisc!. jusi inaginc inai ajicr cxpcricncing a|| incsc !ijjicu|iics, qcu cnicr inc na||, jin! qcu scai an! incn spcn! ncxi inrcc cr jcur ncurs siiiing, ccnsirainc! |q qcur ncign|crs c||cus, sujjccaiing jrcn un|cara||c ncai, an! jcrcc! ic gitc up qcur spacc inrcc cr jcur iincs (cspccia||q ij qcu arc in jrcni scais) ic ucncn unc arc in na|ii cj ccning |aic. |tcn ij inc curiain nas jina||q |ccn raisc! an! qcu inink inai ctcrqining ui|| |c jinc ncu an! qcu ui|| ncu cnjcq pcrjcrnanccs cj inc |csi |rcncn acicrs, qcur ncpcs ui|| |c sccn !asnc!. asi!c jrcn !cajcning app|ausc unicn ui|| a|uaqs !isiraci qcu ai inc ncsi inicrcsiing ncncnis, ij naiurc ca||s an! qcu natc ic |catc inc na|| jcr a jcu ninuics cr ij, !uring cniracic, qcu uani scnc jrcsn air, incn qcu nusi |c
58 Ielrov, Rasskazy, 270. assurc! inai upcn rciurning |ack qcu ui|| jin! qcur nai inrcun cn inc j|ccr an! qcur p|acc cccupic!. Tncn qcu natc ic cncsc cnc jrcn iuc sc|uiicns. qcu ciincr cna||cngc a nan unc icck qcur scai, unicn ui|| inctiia||q cn! uiin an appcinincni in inc Bcis !c Bcu|cgnc (unicn nappcnc! ic nanq cur cjjiccrs) cr qcu !cci!c ic |catc inc na||, unicn is ncrc pru!cni sincc, in inc cn!, !ccs a nunan |ijc ncan sc |iii|c sc as ic natc qcursc|j ki||c! ctcr a scai in a incaicr? 59
InlhraIIed by Iaris, many officers senl hours every day vaIking in lhe slreels. Thus, IaveI Iushin's diary, vhich is ralher iIIuslralive of olher officers' exeriences, records lhal on 2-4 AriI, Iushin used his very firsl break lo visil HoleI des InvaIides, Arc de Triomhe (CarrouseI), Nolre Dame CalhedraI, lhe Ianlheon, olanicaI Garden, Ionl d'AuslerIilz, Thealer Irancais, lhe Louvre, Thealre des Varieles, and IaIais RoyaI (reealedIy). Zhirkevich exIained lhal his Ieisure lime vas senl in visiling Iaces of allracling in Iaris in lhe morning, slarling vilh lhe Louvres and ending vilh lhe Chinese balhs, vhich had nolhing Chinese in lhem excel lhe name. Above aII I en|oyed lhe olanicaI
59 AIexander Cherlkov, Mon |ournaI de Voyage. in 1812- 1814. |z sc|raniqa Gcsu!arsitcnncgc |sicricncskcgc nuzcqa (Moscov: Terra, 1992), 422-423. Cherlkov Iisled eighl Iarisian lhealers as lhe cenler of evening Iife: Le Thelre Iranais, Le Grand Oera, I'Odeon (or Thelre de I'Imeralrice), Ie VaudeviIIe, Ies Varieles, I'Oera Comique (Thelre Iaydeau), Thelrede Ia Gaiele, and I'Ambigu Comique. |ussian cjjiccrs cnicriaining incnsc|tcs in Paris (|q Gccrg-|nnanuc| Opiiz) Gardens. My friends I usuaIIy had Iunch. in lhe IaIais RoyaI and olher reslauranls, and, in lhe evening, ve aIvays venl lo some lhealer. 60 Al lhe Louvre, Radozhilsky found one slalue beller lhan anolher and vas gIad lo see a bookIel vilh delaiIed descrilion of each slalue being soId al lhe enlrance. Iushin vas aveslruck by lhe Louvre's coIIeclion vhich viII forever serve as a monumenl for lhis unordinary man. The vorks of arl galhered here from aII counlries of Iuroe during Iasl fev years reresenl everylhing lhal is brealhlaking in lhis vorId. A simiIar lhoughl is exressed in lhe memoirs of MikhaiI Ielrov, Afler visiling lhese arl lreasures numerous limes, ve each lime exressed our gralilude lo NaoIeon for galhering so much in Iaris, and for bringing us lhere from lhe norlhern regions lo lhe banks of lhe Seine River. 61 Anolher officer, S. Khomulov noled in his diary lhal on 1 AriI, he senl lhe enlire day moving around lhe cily in cabrioIel, fiacre, on horse and on fool, visiling lhe Ianlheon, lhe Louvre, TuiIIeries. ul one day is |usl nol enough lo see everylhing vorlhy of allenlion in lhis greal, sohislicaled and gIorious cily. 62
The resence of occuying force naluraIIy roduced friclions belveen lhe AIIied soIdiers and lhe Irench. Il vas as easy lo recognize lhe Irench officers by lheir sombre counlenances as by lheir uniforms, remarks one Russian officer, Tncq ccn!ucic! incnsc|tcs ncrc pc|iic|q icuar!s inc |ussians inan ic inc cincr a||ics, uiin uncn incq na! jrcqucni quarrc|s unicn cn!c! in !uc|s. Tnc |ussians ucrc inc cnicj c|jccis cj incir nairc!, an! nar!|q a !aq passc! in unicn ||cc! !i! nci j|cu cn cnc si!c cr inc cincr. Tnc Gcrnan cjjiccrs, a|incugn inc ncign|crs cj inc |rcncn, na! ncrc !ijjicu|iq in ccnjcrning ic incir nanncrs, cusicns, an! |anguagc, inan inc |ussians. Ai inis iinc uc rcccitc! pcrnissicn ic ucar p|ain c|cincs, in unicn uc appcarc! in scciciq as cr!inarq ciiizcns. Tnc Prussians an! Ausirians, cn inc ccnirarq, ccniinuc! ic
60 Zhirkevich, Zaisiki, 655. 61 Radozhilsky, Pcknc!nqc zapiski, 130, Iushin, Onctnik, 156, M.M. Ielrov, Rasskazy. in Vcspcninaniqa tcinct russkci arnii (Moscov, 1991), 285. AIso see N. Muravyev-Karskii, Zaiski., |usskii arknit, 2 (1886): 111. 62 S. Khomulov, Iz Onctnika svilskago ofilsera, |usskii arknit, 6(1870): 164-165. ua|k a|cui in unijcrn. Wc naq a!!, uiin pcrjcci iruin, inai incq !i! nci irq ic a!crn incir iriunpn uiin nc!csiq. Tnc Ausirians natc a cusicn cj ucaring grccn |rancncs in incir caps an! nais, unicn gatc cjjcncc ic inc |rcncn, unc incugni incq rcprcscnic! |aurc|s, an! ncncc rcsu|ic! quarrc|s, an! ctcn nur!crs. On inc ccnirarq, inc Parisians ucrc nign|q graiijic! |q cur ucaring a uniic |an! rcun! inc |cji arn, an! |q cur a!!ing a uniic knci ic cur cccka!cs. Tnis apparcni|q irij|ing circunsiancc iurnc! inc currcni cj pu||ic cpinicn in cur jatcr, an! scrtc! as a |cn! cj unicn |ciuccn us. 63
NeverlheIess, many dueIs look Iace during lhe monlhs lhe Russian army occuied Iaris, bolh among Russian officers and belveen Russians and lhe Irench. Thus, Lirandi leIIs a slory aboul a Russian officer, arlenev, vho reIied villiIy lo lhe Irench officers oul lo insuIl him ersonaIIy and lhe Russian army in generaI: Bcing a |icuicnani kncun jcr nis |ratcrq in inc A|cksan!riiskii Hussar |cgincni, in 1814 in Paris nc na! an cqua||q jancus !uc| uiin inrcc |rcncn cjjiccrs unc askc! unq nussars natc ||ack jcaincrs cn incir nais uni|c cincr |ussians a|sc natc rccsicrs jcaincrs, |ikc nis, |ui uniic cncs. Baricnct tcrq pc|iic|q cxp|ainc! inai ii is injanirq inai ucars inc ||ack cncs an! cata|rq inc uniic, an! inai inc jcaincrs ccnc nci jrcn rccsicrs |ui jrcn inc |rcncn cag|cs inai incq natc p|uckc! jquc ncus atcns cp|ucncc}. 64
Afler monlhs of camaigning, lhe Russian officers, Iike any olhers, vere slarved for a femaIe comany and Iaris rovided lhem vilh Ienly of enlerlainmenl. IaIais RoyaI had Ienly of sorling houses and lhe number of Iadies of lhe evening surrised some Russian officers. They vaIk in
63 MikhaiIovsky-DaniIevsky, Hislory of lhe Camaign in Irance, 402. One of lhe Iaces of allraclions in Iaris vas lhe famous Ionl d'AuslerIilz, vhich NaoIeon buiIl in commemoralion of his greal viclory in December 1805. Nov, in 1814, some Iarisians soughl lo vin over AIexander by erasing ImeriaI symboIs and inscrilions on lhe bridge. Hovever, as Olroshenko informs us, Imeror AIexander refused lo give his consenl for lhis, inslead requesling lo add |usl one more inscrilion on lhe bridge, noling lhal lhe Russian army crossed il in 1814. Olroshenko, Zaiski, 87-88. 64 I.I. Lirandi, Zamechaniya na 'Vosominaniya' I.I. VigeIiya, in Cnicniqa t |npcraicrskcn c|sncncsitc isicrii i !rctncsici rcssiiskikn, 1873, ook 1 (}anuary-March): 141 (f.69) grous of lvo or lhree, laIking and Iaughing IoudIy, making such |okes lhal our ears cracked., describe one officer vhiIe IIya Radozhilskii recaIIed seeing lhese vomen seducing our youngslers vilh lheir eyes and, if lhey gol no resonse, lhey vouId inch lhem soreIy lo gel lheir allenlion. 65 Iedor GIinka vriles vilh cerlain sarcasm, Adieu my dear and deIighlfuI enchanlresses. you, vho sarkIe in lhe Oera, slroII graciousIy on lhe bouIevards or fIuller in gaIIeries and gardens of lhe IaIais RoyaI! We viII be sending you our assionale sighs from lhe banks of lhe Neva and Don. You never Iooked al our faces. A bearded Cossack and fIal-faced ashkir quickIy became favoriles of yours hearls if lhey had money! You aIvays resecled lhe cIanking sound of virlue! 66 ul lhese reIalions oflenlimes Ied lo comIicalions and many Russians, Iike lheir AIIied brelhren, soon conlracled venereaI diseases. Young officer Kazakov vas Iodged al lhe house of lhe famous Iarisian hysician aron GuiIIaume Duuylren, vho befriended lhe Russian officer and one day look him lo lhe HoleI-Dieu, shoved him hosilaI rooms fuII of men vilh syhiIis and made him romise lo have no sex. 67
Reading lhese memoirs and diaries ve see hov much Russian officers vere deIighled by Iaris vhich lhey describe as a Ieasure and enlerlainmenl cailaI of lhe vorId. They vere lhriIIed by arlislic lreasures of lhe cailaI, fascinaled by lhe quaIily of food, and slruck by freedom, one may even say frivoIily, of Iarisian vomen. ul lhey vere aIso disiIIusioned by Irance in generaI. Raised by Irench lulors, reading Irench Iileralure and oflen seaking Irench beller lhan Russian, lhey ideaIized lhis counlry since chiIdhood and hoed lo find an earlhIy aradise lhere. And even lhough Iaris lhriIIed lhem, Russian officers vere slruck by videsread overly, misery and economic hardshi in lhe resl of lhe counlry. They vere surrised lo find Irenchmen from aII sociaI cIass ralher ignoranl of lhe vorId oulside Irance, as veII inconsiderale and boorish. Time and again, ve
65 Vq!crznki iz tcqcnnqkn zapisck., 89-90, Radozhilskii, Pcknc!nqc zapiski, III, 127. Ior a Cossack vievoinl, see Na chuzhbine slo Iel nazad, Kazacnii s|crnik, (Iaris, 1930), 95. 66 I. GIinka, Pisna russkcgc cjiiscra (Moscov, 1816), arl 8, 170. 67 Kazakov, Pcknc! tc |ranisiqut 1814 gc!u, 355. see in memoirs references lo grime and un- cIeanIiness in Irench lovns, causing one officer lo remark lhal lhe Irench have a nalionaI lendency lo fiIlhiness. 68 One officer slales, Many of our officers, vho in lhe chiIdhood vere svayed by lheir foreign lulors and, hoing lo find a romised Iand in Irance, vere soreIy disaoinled uon seeing videsread overly, ignorance and desair in viIIages and lovns. Anolher commenled, The overly around Langres is slaggering, eoIe are derived of mosl necessilies... Houses are coId and dirly. A fev days Ialer, lhe same officer recorded in his diary, A easanl's food consisls of onIy varm valer vilh a ig's fal and crumbIed bread, vhich lhey caII a sou. A |Irenchj easanl is as ignoranl as a Russian one, and is as oor as our easanls in SmoIensk or Vilebsk, vriles Iushin. More imorlanlIy, lo many officers, lhe facl lhal lhe invasion of Irance unfoIded so easiIy soke of unalriolic nalure of lhe Irenchmen. They comared Russian resislance lo NaoIeon in 1812 lo lhe Irench erceived inaclion in 1814. This in lurn Ied lo reinforcemenl of lhe exisling slereolyes of lhe Russian sueriorily, i.e. dedicalion, IoyaIly, alriolism, abiIily lo sacrifice vhal's dear lo one's hearl (i.e. Moscov) in order lo vin lhe var.
Deception in War: The Art of the Bluff, the Value of Deceit, and the Most Thrilling Episodes of Cunning in Military History from the Trojan Horse to the Gulf War