Professional Documents
Culture Documents
THE FOUNDATIONS
POLITICS:
AN INTRODUCTION
AND
STUDY
OF
i)
ii)
iii)
iv)
iv)
Political Sociology & Political Culture
v)
International Relations
2.3. Political Thought (Political Philosophy)
2.3.1. What is Political Thought?
i)
ii)
iii)
ii)
iii)
iv)
2.3.3.
problem/questions
of
Political
- Questions concerning :
1) Good/Ideal Society (What, Why, and How)
2) Who gets What, When, How, Why, and How Much
- Questions regarding what and how to develop the best, most
just, equal and legitimate political system
Set of general questions commonly asked/addressed in political
thought: (cf. Sargent 2003: 15-16)
i)
Human Nature
a. What are the basic characteristics of human beings as human
beings?
b. What effect does human nature have on the political system?
ii)
The origin of society and government or the state
a. What is the origin of society? Why does it develop?
TOPIC 3
DEMOCRACY
11
accepted
basic
elements
of
vi)
i)
ii)
16
17
3.6.5.
Equality
19
c) Political influence
- equality in political influence among citizens regardless of race,
religion, gender, economic class, social caste, etc. (not hindered by
formal limitations)
- In reality, not easy to realise although laws are available to
promote such equalities, informal limitations still pervade due to
human nature
3.6.5.2. Equality before the Law
- Considered to be amongst democracys clearest goals (Sargent
2003:61)
- all people should receive fair and similar/equal treatment by the
legal system
- Justice should be colour/race/religion/gender/status blind
3.6.5.3. Equality of Opportunity
- refers to equal ability and mobility of every individual to move up or
down the social ladder (social and economic hierarchy/class within
society), depending on ones capability/ies
- no artificial barrier to prevent one from achieving what one is
capable of, through hard work and efficiency (qf Sargent 2003: 60)
- artificial barriers = race, ethnicity, gender, religion, caste, sexual
orientation, nationality, primordial elements, etc.
- In reality, equality or opportunity = dependent on value accorded
status i.e. material (wealth/money/property) vs. non-material
(aristocracy/religious position/education/etc.)
3.6.5.4. Economic equality
- subjective and highly contested meaning
- narrow terms = every individual should have relatively same
income no one is richer than the other (extreme)
- realistically = should concern equality of economic opportunities,
i.e. employment, business contracts, tender, etc. (not financial
equality)
- According to Sargent (2003), underlying idea = guarantee of a
minimum level of economic security for every individual within
society; security more crucial than equality
20
Social equality
Liberty
v)
vi)
vii)
viii)
ix)
x)
23
3.8.1. Democratisation
- most dominant and widely accepted ideology in contemporary
world
- since the fall of global communism advent of globalization =
spread of democracy = process of democratization, i.e. former
socialist/ communist states, Third World states.
- democratization = process of establishing:i)
democratic institutions
ii)
democratic procedures
iii)
democratic culture (perhaps the most important/fundamental)
- however, democracy in most of these states = fragile, questionable
- Advocates of liberal democracy see these states = not genuinely/
fully democratic
- Democratizing states fall in between the continuum from
authoritarian to democracy =
authoritarian
semiauthoritarian
semi-democracy
democracy
- Critics of liberal democracy = not unambiguously universal, based
on Western political culture, values, experience, and political
context = hence, potentially conflicting with oriental/eastern political
cultures and traditions
- Alternative models of democracy, i.e. Asian-style democracy
debate during 1990s (combination of some universally-accepted
democratic values/principles/institutions/procedures with traditional
cultures/ norms/values
- Question to ponder:
i)
Does the mere existence of democratic institutions and
procedures, i.e. elections, democratic constitution, etc. makes a
country/state truly democratic?
ii)
Are liberal democratic values universal?
iii)
Are liberal democratic values mainly shaped/influenced by
western political cultures/context?
iv)
Are liberal democratic values in conflict with traditional oriental/
eastern political cultures?
v)
Are traditional oriental/eastern political cultures essentially
democratic or otherwise?
24
25
- i.e. individual preference for one law, but having to obey contrary
law chosen by majority; voting for losing party but having to obey
laws passed by successful rival party (Goodwin 2007: 302)
- i.e. contradictory moral beliefs of a smoker - banning smoking is
wrong; banning smoking is right if the majority thinks it right =
hence moral dilemma of the policy banning smoking = both
simultaneously right and wrong
ii) the related problem of minority
- involves the dilemma of contradiction between the basic
democratic principle of the will of the majority rules with the likes
of justice, and equality
- i.e. minority unlikely to agree that majority opinion is right ; neither
laws of the majority are just and equal towards minority hence,
minority may question validity and value of democracy itself
- Solution = institutionalize position of minority
- However, according to Goodwin, to institutionalize the position of
minorities goes against democratic equality, while to leave their
cause to the good nature of the majority will in many cases mean
that they may suffer injustice or even oppression (Goodwin 2007:
305)
26
TOPIC 4
4.1. Introduction
- Capitalism and Socialism = two distinct types of economic system
that have strong relationship with idea of democracy
- To some, Capitalism closely related to Democracy, while to others,
Socialism and democracy = ideal partnership
- Both capitalists and socialists claim to be the most democratic in
the economic sense i.e. genuine/true democrats
- These different groups/societies, see either capitalism, or
socialism/ socialist = negative connotation/taboo word
- Simply put = major disagreement and misunderstanding on both
types of economic systems
- These economic systems can combine with both democratic and
authoritarian political systems in fairly robust manner, i.e. socialist
democracies, totalitarian states, capitalist democracies.
4.2. Capitalism (Democratic Capitalism)
4.2.1. Introductory remarks
- Closely related and like liberal democracy - seen today as the
dominant economic system, following the fall of authoritarian
socialism/communism that marked the end of the Cold War ; what
scholars term as the liberal hour (Balaam & Veseth 2005) and
end of history (Fukuyama)
- Spread of global capitalism and the advent of a capitalist global
economy - even socialist/communist states like PRC, Russia, and
Vietnam have embraced pro-market reforms and marketisation
policies, while former Eastern bloc joining EUs single market
4.2.2. General Ideas, Assumptions, and Characteristics
- Keyword = Capital (wealth/income/money/profit)
27
29
30
31
- By end of 1990s = arrival of the liberal hour capitalism and neoliberalism = dominant theory following obsolescence of
communism, failure of socialism and Japanese-style mercantilism;
Advocates
see
Free-market
Capitalism
or
market
fundamentalism = only workable ideology in contemporary
international political economy
- International economic institutions like World Bank, International
Monetary Fund (IMF), World Trade Organisation (WTO) guided by
free market capitalism
- Washington Consensus effort by IMF, WB, and US Treasury to
cultivate neoliberal/capitalist policies in less developed and
emerging market economies like the four little dragons and tiger
economies of Asia
- Policy prescription = smaller govt, larger market links the success
of free-market capitalism/econ. liberalism to the need for political
reforms
- Michael Mandelbaums Golden Triangle hypothesis:
PEACE
FREE MARKET
DEMOCRACY
32
33
iii)
iv)
v)
i)
ii)
36
CORE
(A)
A = Core
B = Semi-Periphery
C = Periphery
Bilateral econ.
relationship (trade and
investment)
37
TOPIC 5
FEMINISM
5.1. INTRODUCTION
- An ideology with core positions and variants
- Also an international movement that transcends traditional social,
political & economic barriers i.e. national, class, racial, gender, etc.
- Main concern = about the oppression of women by men; and the
need to replace what has been commonly perceived to be a
system of male dominance = patriarchy found to affect all social
institutions
- Ultimate goal = to promote gender equality = to create awareness
in both men and women regarding the need to recognise related
social restrictions (on women), and act to reduce and most
crucially, eliminate such restrictions
- Also a form of identity politics, i.e. self vs. other ; to create
awareness regarding the marginalization/exploitation of the other;
and the need to re-embrace the marginalized
- Other = not exclusively womenfolk but all marginalized groups
within mainstream society i.e. children, disabled person, old folks,
LBGTIQ
[lesbian,
bisexual,
gay,
transgender, intersex
(androgyny/hermaphrodite), questioning] community, etc.
- Main constraint = women themselves often unaware or recognise
restrictions
due
to
entrenched
socio-cultural/religious
norms/values/customs/laws; hence, the need to promote
consciousness amongst womenfolk before targeting their
opposite sex
5.2. Background and Development of Feminism
- Debate since Biblical age, i.e. Biblical tale of Garden of Eden,
Adam and Eve, and the Fall of Man womenfolk viewed with
suspicion by men in Judeo-Christian world (Goodwin 2007:200) =
the idea of women as temptresses, weaker, more irrational and
less law-abiding than men pervaded in many cultures both East
and West
- radical Demonisation of women = women susceptible to lure of
the Evil side = witchhunt during middle ages
38
39
i)
ii)
iii)
iv)
v)
vi)
40
i)
ii)
iii)
42
Questions to ponder
1) Is feminism universal in its values and ideas?
2) Should rights for abortion be legalized?
3) Should birth control be denounced?
4) Is gender equality possible in the military / sporting arenas?
5) Do you think making marital rape unlawful is reasonable?
6) What about the problems of cry-wolf, and date rape?
7) Does a wife have the right to refuse sex from her husband?
8) Should provisions made for the emancipation of women be granted
to homosexuals/gays?
9) Should married women with family (specifically home-makers) be
paid to do house chores?
TOPIC 6
ANARCHISM
43
6.1. Introduction
- roots of Anarchism in classical Greece; came from Greek
term
an
and
arkhe
(meaning
absence
of
ruler/government); idea found in classical Chinese texts on
Taoism, i.e. Tao te Ching
- emerged as a modern ideology sometime during the same
period of Marxism
- keyword = anarchy = rule by no one, no overarching
authority; seen negatively in contemporary era as chaos,
disorder etc.
- Central conviction = government/state, the law, private
property = absolute evils; man = naturally good but
society is bad; anti-capitalism, anti-law and order
- Today = forms of anarchism exists in extreme left, or right
movement, i.e. anarcho-capitalism (rightwing); another
offshoot = libertarianism, or minimalism (Sargent
2003:164)
6.2. Principles of Anarchism
- Anarchism exists in a variety of forms, and different ideas
- Most interpretation based on ideas of a group of thinkers,
i.e. Prince Pyotr Kropotkin (1842-1921), Pierre-Joseph
Proudhon (1809-1865),
Mikhail Bakunin (1814-1876),
Count Leo Tolstoy (1828 1910), William Godwin (17561836), Emma Goldman (1869-1940), etc.
- Kropotkin defines Anarchism as
...a principle or theory of life and conduct under
which society is conceived without government
harmony in such a society being obtained, not by
submission to law or by obedience to any authority,
but by free agreements concluded between the
various groups, territorial, and professional, freely
constituted for the sake of production and
consumption, as also for the satisfaction of the
44
45
46
Libertarianism
(or
sometimes
known
as
minimalism)
- Closely related to anarcho-capitalism
- Among the best known libertarian = Robert Nozick
(Anarchy, State, and Utopia)
47
48
TOPIC 7
NATIONALISM
7.1. Introduction
49
51
v) Intellectually coherent
vi) Critical of official nationalism
7.4 Nationalism in Reality: Issues and evaluation
a) Idea of nation-state = more myth than reality
Five basic patterns of fitting between nation and states
i) One state, One nation
ii) One state, Multiple Nations
iii) One nation, Multiple state
iv) One nation, no state
v) Multiple nations, multiple states, i.e. Afghanistan
Pashtun, Tajiks, Uzbeks, Turkmens
b) Nationalism as both Builders and Destroyers
Janus-faced nature
Beneficent face :
i) nationalism promotes democracy (popular sovereignty)
ii) discourages imperialism
iii) allows for economic development
iv) allows diversity and experimentation
Troubled Face of Nationalism
i) Lack of concern for others (ethnocentrism)
ii) Xenophobia (fear and suspicion towards foreigners)
iii) Oppression and aggression
7.5. Countervailing Tendencies
a) Regionalism i.e. EU (1993) (from ECSC, to EEC, to EC) EU
has Parliament; European Court of Justice, and EU bureaucracy;
single market and currency Euro
b) Cosmopolitanism
c) Globalisation
CURRENT TRENDS
i)
Secession ii) Nationalist conflicts iii) Irredentism iv)
postcolonialism
ii)
Ethno-religious nationalism
53
54