Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Discuss how successful the firm has been at delivering value to its shareholders
over the past 5 years.
Explain how and why the value of equity has changed over the past 12 months.
Undertake a current valuation of the equity in this firm, using the following
methods:
-
Attempt to reconcile any differences in value that you obtain by using these different
methods and state (with reasons) what value you think is correct for the firm.
Note:
For the purpose of my assignment, I have selected the Emirates Bank International of
United Arab Emirates, which is listed on the Dubai Financial Market.
Table of Contents
Page no.
Emirates Bank International: Valuation Report
Introduction
Limitations of the Report
6
6
6
Executive Summary
9
9
10
11
11
11
11
12
12
12
13
14
14
14
14
15
15
16
16
16
17
17
17
18
18
18
18
19
19
______________________________________________________________________________________
Page 2 of 24
Calculation Value
19
21
21
Conclusions
21
Bibliography
23
Acronyms
24
Appendices
26
I
II
III
IV
V
VI
VII
______________________________________________________________________________________
Page 3 of 24
______________________________________________________________________________________
Page 4 of 24
Executive Summary:
The EBI is a well-reputed local bank, which was established in 1977, and it is
owned upto 77% by the Government of Dubai 1. EBI is listed on the Dubai
Financial Market (DFM) and has been making rapid progress since its
establishment.
The UAE economy is experiencing boom conditions because of the rise in oil
prices. Moreover, the overall environment of UAE is very investment friendly,
which is providing ample opportunities to investors. After the 9/11 incidents, the
repatriation of AGCC investments from USA and Europe have played a major
role in increase of FDI in UAE, while the recent political uncertainties in
neighboring countries like Saudi Arabia, Iran, Iraq etc. have also contributed in
transfer of investment from these countries to UAE. The sale of freehold property
by the Dubai Government has also attracted cash-flow from abroad. All these
factors have given sharp rise to the banking industry and EBI has benefited in
particular, having the backing of Dubai Government.
A detailed macro and micro analysis was undertaken using PEST, Porter's Five
Forces, and SWOT models which all show a very favorable future potential for
the EBI.
The main aim of this report was to assess the value of EBI, which was done by
using three different methods, Net Assets Value (NAV), Price Earning Ratio (PE)
and the Discounted Cash-Flow (DCF). The results are as under:
No.
Valuation Methods
1
2
3
Different methods have yielded different values because of various reasons. The
NAV method provides the lowest limit because it indicates only the book value of
the tangible assets as at 31-12-2004. It ignores the profit generating ability of the
assets as well as the intangible assets. PE ratio gives the highest value because
it is influenced by the inefficiency of the DFM and the overoptimistic expectation
of the public (both the existing and potential investors). DCF method provides a
moderate value because it takes into consideration the Free Cash-Flow, and not
the accounting profit. So it is not influenced by manipulations of non-cash
expenditure like depreciation.
1
www.emiratesbank.ae
______________________________________________________________________________________
Page 5 of 24
Under the above mentioned circumstances, the valuation provided by the DCS
method seems to be more reasonable and reliable.
It is to be noted that all the calculations are based on the published accounts for
the year ended 31-12-2004. The accounting results for the first quarter of 2005
are not incorporated because the accounts are not yet audited.
______________________________________________________________________________________
Page 6 of 24
www.emiratesbank.ae
______________________________________________________________________________________
Page 7 of 24
Share Capital
Cash Dividend
Earning Per Share
Markt. Price/ Share
Year 2000
734.7 M
20 %
1.43
16.07
Year 2001
918.4 M
20 %
1.44
17.85
Year 2002
918.4 M
20 %
1.22
20.00
Year 2003
1148.0 M
20 %
1.33
21.10
Year 2004
1485.0 M
20 %
1.69
50.85
Notes:
- The face value of each share is AED: 2.50
- The increase in share capital is due to bonus issue. One bonus share was
issued for every four shares held.
Some of the recent key indicators are shown with the help of the graphs obtained
from the web-site of DFM (DFM)4, Appendix III.
EBI has been following the policy of uniform dividends @ 20% for the past
several years, however, huge profits have induced the directors to give bonus
shares/ stock dividend. It is normally observed that the market price of shares
decline after a bonus issue but the shares of EBI have shown a steady growth till
2003. In 2004 the shares price has taken a big leap from AED: 21.10 to AED:
50.85. During the first quarter of 2005, the price has gone even higher because
of the soaring profits. EBI's first quarter net profit has increased by 62.39% to
AED: 272.400 Million5, therefore, the market price of shares rose above AED:
60.00 in the month of April 20056.
Page 8 of 24
Reasons for E.B.I's rapid growth during the past twelve months:
The EBI has made a remarkable growth during the past 12 months. The earning
per share has increase tremendously and consequently the market price of the
share has also taken a big leap. During April 2004 the price of the share was
approx. AED: 23.00, while in April 2005 the price has gone to AED: 64.10 7. This
rapid growth can be attributed to several factors, which are briefly analyzed here.
Economic Boom:
The economy of UAE is experiencing robust boost, largely because of the
soaring oil prices in the world market. The oil has gone above US$: 50.00 per
barrel and at times it has crossed even US$: 58.00 per barrel. There is a high
demand for oil because of uncertain and unstable supply of oil from Iraq. So UAE
has been drilling oil at near capacity point. These factors contributed toward a
high level of public revenues and also public expenditures, which benefited the
banking industry in general.
Government Backing:
77% of the EBI is owned by the Government of Dubai. So it enjoys full backing
and support of the Government. The accounts of all the major public sector
corporations are held by the EBI. So the increase in public revenue and
expenditure primarily and particularly benefited this bank. Moreover, the
Government backing has increased the goodwill of the bank, and common public
has shown greater confidence in the EBI. As a result the deposits and advances
of the EBI have grown faster than those of the other banks.
Freehold Property:
The Government of Dubai has started selling freehold properties to expatriates.
These property holders are also given stay permit to the extent of the ownership
of these properties (in some cases upto 99 years). This has proved to be a major
attraction and peoples from allover the world are buying freehold properties in
Dubai. In other words there is a major cash inflow and being the market leader of
the banking industry the EBI has received the lion's share from this inflow.
______________________________________________________________________________________
Page 11 of 24
Fixed assets are stated in the balance sheet under "historical cost concept",
which may differ significantly from the market value.
Valuation of stock is often arbitrary. There are different stock valuation
methods, but the most commonly used is cost or net realizable value, which is
lower. Hence the appreciation in the value of stock is not revealed.
The debtors may include doubtful or even bad-debts.
Intangible assets are difficult to be valued. Firms have intangible assets like
goodwill, patents, intellectuals etc. which are not adequately recorded in the
books. Hence the NAV will be less than the actual value of the company.
______________________________________________________________________________________
Page 12 of 24
38,060,629
32,240,781
NAV
5,819,848
3,400
5,816,448
EPS
= .
PAT
.
No. of Ordinary Shares
______________________________________________________________________________________
Page 13 of 24
PE ratio takes into account the profit earning capacity of the business and not
the mere book value.
PE ratio is readily available as it is published daily in the financial press. The
ratio can also be seen at the web-site of DFM.
The PE ratio can be compared against industry benchmark (also available
readily in the press) and hence this method becomes more reliable.
1,033,653
Nil
1,033,653
30.09
(997,464) X 30.09
______________________________________________________________________________________
Page 14 of 24
AED ('000)
30,013,692
______________________________________________________________________________________
Page 15 of 24
It takes into consideration the stream of benefits generated by assets and not
the static value of assets only.
It allows for future capital investment requirements.
It avoids the effects of manipulation in accounting profits.
AED ('000)
Cost %
Shares Capital
Loan (Bonds)
1,435,014
5,564,595
20%
4%
4.10%
3.18%
6,999,609
Weighted Average Cost of Capital (WACC)
7.28 %
Net Profit
AED (' 000)
Discount Factor
(7%)
Present Value
Year 2005
Year 2006
Year 2007
Year 2008
Year 2009
Beyond
1,033,653
1,085,336
1,139,603
1,196,583
1,256,412
1,256,412
0.9346
0.8734
0.8163
0.7629
0.7129
--
966,052
947,932
930,258
912,873
895,696
--
Value of Perpetuity
17,948,743
Present Value
Perpetuity
11,960,005
Note:
of
Since
(Depreciation
(Free Cash Flow
=
=
Capital Expenditure)
Net Profit)
Because
______________________________________________________________________________________
Page 17 of 24
AED ('000)
(Total Present Value
of the Company)
966,052
947,932
930,258
912,873
895,696
11,960,005
16,612,816
______________________________________________________________________________________
Page 18 of 24
Methods
5,819,848
30,013,692
16,612,816
The NAV method shows the minimum level of valuation and only reflects the
net value of existing assets. It does not take into consideration the revenue/
profit generation capacity of the business.
Intangible assets (like brand name, goodwill, etc.) are not recorded although
they have a significant value.
The PE ratio heavily depends on the market price. There are imperfections in
the DFM. At most, it can be taken as semi-efficient. Therefore, the valuation is
influenced by the overoptimistic expectations of the market.
The cost of equity is based on the minimum expectations of the shareholders
to find out WACC, whereas the actual return is higher.
The growth rate of 5% is very modest keeping in view the growth of about
40% in the first quarter of 20059.
Conclusions:
The EBI is an established company which is listed on the DFM. It has shown
remarkable growth during the last five years and there is great potential for the
near future.
The valuation of the company is undertaken using three different methods,
namely NAV, PE Ratio, and DCF. All the methods provided different values but
the figure provided by the DCF method is more reasonable and reliable because
9
Appendix IV
______________________________________________________________________________________
Page 19 of 24
of the distinct advantaged of this method. Therefore, the true value of the EBI is
taken at AED: 16,612,816,000/- (US$: 4,522,955,622.11), at the conversion rate
of US$ 1 = AED: 3.673
______________________________________________________________________________________
Page 20 of 24
Bibliography
Books
Richard Pike and Bill Neale, "Corporate Finance and Investment: Decisions and
Strategies", 4th edition, Prentice Hall, McGraw-Hill, Europe, 2003. (Core book for
SFM module).
Dr. Patrick Barber and Bill Neale, "Study Book", 3 rd edition, Bradford University,
UK, 2003. (Core book for SFM module).
Gary E. Jones and Dirk Van Dyke, "The Business of Business Valuations", 1 st edition,
McGraw Hill Publications, 1998.
Tutorials
Dr. Patrick Barber and Dr. Iain Ward Campbell, Professors/ Lecturers for the Strategic
Financial Management Module, University of Bradford, UK. SFM Notes and worked
examples 2005, Dubai.
Mr. Shawn Akhtar, local tutor for the SFM module, Dubai, UAE.
Internet Sites
http://www.emiratesbank.ae
http://www.emiratesislamicbank.ae
http://www.eiu.com
http://www.economist.com
http://www.gitex.com
http://www.dfm.ae
http://www.investopedia.com
______________________________________________________________________________________
Page 21 of 24
Acronyms Used
AED
AGCC
CAPM
DCF
DC-UAE
DFM
FCF
EBG
EBI
EFS
EPS
Euromoney
GTC
KSA
MEB
NAV
NI
Network International
NGI
______________________________________________________________________________________
Page 22 of 24
PAT
P. E. Ratio
PV
Present Value
UP
Union Properties
US$
UAE
WACC :
______________________________________________________________________________________
Page 23 of 24
Appendices
Appendix I :
Appendix II :
Appendix III :
Appendix IV :
Appendix V :
Appendix VI :
Appendix VII:
______________________________________________________________________________________
Page 24 of 24