Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Morales 2
Jeffrey Morales
Dr. Hall
English 112-66
10/22/2013
Rogerian Paper
Morales 3
less solutions. In addition to that, there have been recorded deaths regarding gene therapy.
There have been several deaths in gene therapy trials, most famously that of Jesse Gelsinger in
1999. (Arnold).
The second reason is because mutations can occur and cause problems later on. With
solving the problem of one disease, or genetically modifying a gene for some reason, a mutation
with a detrimental effect can fill its void. Most scientists say that what is preventing them from
embarking on HGE [Human Genetic Engineering] is the risk that the process will itself generate
new mutations, which will be passed on to future generations (King). This causes an unforeseen
threat that will sooner or later materialize and become a massive problem. The mutations that
occur cannot be controlled because they happen at a molecular level within our body, and
changes in our body do not always have answers along with them. Mutations that occur in the
human body cannot always be predicted or controlled by humans working inside a lab.
The third reason is that genetic alteration could be exploited to benefit the act of
terrorism. When it comes to terrorist, new technology could lead to new tactics they can use.
Terrorist groups or armies could develop more powerful biological weaponry. These weapons
could be resistant to medicines, or even targeted at people who carry certain genes
(McPhersson). With war always being around, the enemy will always find a way to hurt their
enemy using brutal tactics.
When it comes to genetically enhancing humans, we should only do it to people in
dire need of gene therapy, to help eliminate inherited diseases, and to use it purely for
medical purposes. If people are going to die because of something wrong in their genes, it is
most appropriate for them to use gene therapy as a last resort. Since they were going to die
anyways, it only makes sense to use gene therapy to see if that option can save them. Also,
Morales 4
diseases like cancer could be avoided in the future if we can use human engineering to tweak our
DNA. genetic mutations can make our bodies more susceptible to attack from viruses or our
own immune system. If the full benefits of gene therapy are ever realised we can replace the dud
genes with correctly functioning copies (Arnold).
Overall, using human engineering when someone is in dire need of gene therapy, for
eliminating deadly diseases, and using gene therapy for only medical reasons can be very
important in our society today. As long as the scientists do not try and perfect the human
genome, we can use human genetic engineering to benefit the lives of future Americans.
Morales 5
Works Cited
Arnold, Paul. "Pros and Cons of Genetic Engineering in Humans." Bright Hub. Bright Hub, 28
Feb. 2012. Web. 14 Oct. 2013.
Canano, C., N. Schichor, and J. Simonet. "Should We Allow Genetic Engineering? A Public
Policy Analysis of Germline Enhancement." Developmental Biology 10e Online:. N.p.,
June 2012. Web. 14 Oct. 2013.
King, David. "Human Genetics Alert - The Threat of Human Genetic Engineering." Human
Genetics Alert - The Threat of Human Genetic Engineering. Human Genetics Alert, n.d.
Web. 14 Oct. 2013.
McPhersson, Jerry. "Effects of Genetic Engineering." Effects of Genetic Engineering. N.p., 24
Aug. 2008. Web. 14 Oct. 2013.