Professional Documents
Culture Documents
JUNE 2012
viii
ABSTRACT
The current work focus is machining performance of the coated tungsten carbide
cutting tool by sandblasting pre-treatment. The main objective of this thesis is to
investigate the effect of surface pre-treatment using sandblast on tungsten carbide (WC)
cutting tool. The effect of machining performance on tungsten carbide cutting tool using
this pre-treatment in term of wear rate also studied. The scope of work include tungsten
carbide as cutting tool, silicon carbide for sandblast pre-treatment, PVD coating process
and machining by turning operation. Tungsten carbide cutting tool was subjected to
sandblast surface pre-treatment for 30 seconds before it was deposited with PVD
coating process. Next, the cutting tool was test by turning machine in order to determine
the wear resistant and other material characterization also was performed such as
microstructure study, hardness Vickers test and surface roughness test. The current
work result shows a smooth surface of the original tungsten carbide surface. After
sandblasting pre-treatment, a coarse surface was developed onto tungsten carbide
cutting carbide. Besides, the machining test performance shows the coated carbide with
sandblasting surface pre-treatment provided longer tools life compared to original
tungsten carbide and coated tungsten carbide without pre-treatment cutting tools. In
addition, the micro hardness test indicated that average Vickers micro hardness of
original tungsten carbide specimen was 863.433 HV while coated carbide with
sandblasting pre-treatment specimen was 1464.9 HV. In surface roughness test, the
surface roughness of tungsten carbide increase after subjected to pre-treatment but
decrease after undergoes coating process. From the result, the sandblasting surface pretreatment and coating process affect the mechanical properties of tungsten carbide
cutting tool such as microstructure, wear resistance, hardness and surface roughness.
ix
ABSTRAK
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Page
EXAMINERS APPROVAL DOCUMENT
ii
SUPERVISORS DECLARATION
iii
EXAMINERS DECLARATION
iv
STUDENTS DECLARATION
DEDICATION
vi
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
vii
ABSTRACT
viii
ABSTRAK
ix
TABLE OF CONTENTS
LIST OF TABLES
xiii
LIST OF FIGURES
xiv
LIST OF SYMBOLS
xv
LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS
xvi
CHAPTER 1
INTRODUCTION
1.1
Introduction
1.2
Problem Statement
1.3
Objectives
1.4
Scopes
CHAPTER 2
LITERATURE REVIEW
2.1
Introduction
2.2
2.2.1
2.2.2
5
6
2.3
Aluminum Oxide
Tungsten Carbide
Surface Pre-treatment
2.3.1
xi
2.4
Coating
2.4.1
2.4.2
2.4.3
2.4.4
2.4.4
Coating Technique
Chemical Vapor Deposition (CVD)
Physical Vapor Deposition (PVD)
Coating Material
Diamond-like Carbon
7
8
8
11
13
13
CHAPTER 3
METHODOLOGY
3.1
Introduction
14
3.2
14
3.3
Surface Pre-treatment
15
3.4
Microstructure Characterization
16
3.5
17
3.6
Machining
18
3.7
Material Characterization
19
3.7.1
3.7.2
3.7.3
19
19
20
CHAPTER 4
4.1
Introduction
22
4.2
22
4.2.1
22
4.3
24
24
Performance
4.4
Hardness
26
4.5
Surface Roughness
28
4.6
29
xii
CHAPTER 5
5.1
Conclusion
31
5.2
Recommendations
31
REFERENCES
APPENDIX
A
Gantt Chart
xiii
LIST OF TABLES
Table No.
Page
2.1
2.2
10
2.3
12
3.1
14
3.2
Sandblasting parameter
16
3.3
17
3.4
18
4.1
4.2
27
4.3
28
4.4
30
xiv
LIST OF FIGURES
Figure No.
Page
2.1
10
2.2
12
3.1
Methodology flowchart
15
3.2
16
process
3.3
17
3.4
18
3.5
3.6
20
3.7
21
4.1
4.2
4.3
26
4.4
27
4.5
29
xv
LIST OF SYMBOLS
Cutting speed
Tn
Tool life
Constant
VB
Flank wear
Area
Diameter
Force
Pressure load
xvi
LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS
SEM
PVD
CVD
HV
Hardness Vickers
DLC
CHAPTER 1
INTRODUCTION
1.1
INTRODUCTION
2
1.2
PROBLEM STATEMENT
The tool of a turning machine plays a great role in turning process. Poor tool will
tend to wear faster and has shorter time of usage. Changing the tool repeatedly due to
tool wear and short tool life should be prevented manufacturing process as it will affect
productivity of a company. A more severe case is when sudden failures of cutting tools
happens and lead to loss of productivity, rejection of parts and consequential economic
losses. To increase the cutting tools life, improvements need to be done using surface
pre-treatment and coating process. One of surface pre-treatment technique is
sandblasting. Sandblasting pre-treatment is used to remove cobalt layer on cutting tool
to improve coating adhesion. Coating is used to solve short tool life problem. Applying
coating to tungsten carbide cutting tool can increase hardness, increase wear resistant,
and also can increase tools life. Therefore, the current work focused on improving the
wear resistance of tungsten carbide cutting tool in machining with titanium work piece
in turning operation. The main objective of this study is to increase the carbide cutting
tools life.
1.3
OBJECTIVES
There were three main objectives to be fulfilled in this research which had been
listed as follow:
(i)
To evaluate the effect of wear resistance of coated and uncoated tungsten carbide
cutting tools after turning process
(ii)
(iii)
To distinguish the effect of coated and uncoated tungsten carbide cutting tools
onto machining performance by using different cutting speed.
3
1.4
SCOPES
(i)
(ii)
(iii)
(iv)
(v)
Evaluate the wear rate resistant of the cutting tool, hardness and surface
roughness.
CHAPTER 2
LITERATURE REVIEW
2.1
INTRODUCTION
Tool wear of cutting tool has been a problem to the manufacturing industry since
the day they were introduced. Tool wear decreases tools life and increase the force in
cutting causing a lack of consistency in material removal. There are abundance of
factors that contributes to the wear of cutting tool such as cutting tool properties,
properties of work piece, cutting speed during machining, cutting feed, depth of cut and
also machine rigidity. Usually, cutting tools need to undergo certain improvement to
extend tools life. Examples of cutting tool improvement are sandblasting pre-treatment
and addition of coating layers to the cutting tool. During machining, cutting tools are
exposed to high temperature, tool surface, work piece and presence of foreign particles
that can change the shape of the cutting tool. The changes can affect the tribological
properties and increase the risk associated with tribological processes on machine tool
elements. Therefore, the chapter will provide an overview of cutting tool and discuss
wear of cutting tool, pre-treatment and coating material.
2.2
Cutting tools must be made of a material with higher hardness than the material
which is need to be cut, and the tool must be able to withstand the heat generated during
the metal cutting process. According to George (2009), a cutting tool must have a few
characteristics in order to produce good quality and economical parts such as high
hardness that will allow cutting tools strength to be maintained at elevated
5
temperatures, toughness so that tools do not chip or fracture during cutting operations
and wear resistance characteristic which means the attainment of acceptable tool life
before tools need to be replaced.
The alumina has many advantages to be used in high speed cutting. The
following advantages were:
(i)
High melting point- Aluminum oxide has high melting point up to 2072C.
6
(ii)
(iii)
George (2006) stated that tungsten carbide was discovered in 1983 during a
search for method of making artificial diamonds. Charging sugar and tungsten carbide,
tungsten sub-carbide was melted in an arc furnace. The carbonized sugar reduced the
oxide and carburized the tungsten. It was recorded that the tungsten carbide was
extremely hard, approaching the hardness of diamond and exceeding that of sapphire. It
was further recorded that tungsten carbide was more than 16 times as heavy as water,
and the material proved to be extremely brittle and limited its industrial use. Hence,
tungsten carbide still has several advantages which are listed in table 2.1.
Property
Melting point
Hardness (Vickers Hardness)
Electrical Resistivity
Property value
2870C
2242 HV
2107 Ohmm
Source: Pierson (1992)
2.3
SURFACE PRE-TREATMENT
7
2.3.1 Sandblasting as a surface pre-treatment
Totten (2004) further stated that experimental work indicates that the surface
compressive stress is several times greater than the tensile stress in the interior of the
section, so that when working stresses are applied that would ordinarily impose a tensile
stress on the surface layer , the residual compressive stress will counteract them. Fatigue
failures, which cause about 90% of the mechanical catastrophic failures in metal parts
and structures, largely start at surface cracks that grow under tensile stresses; thus shot
peening generally results in considerably greater fatigue strength.
2.4
COATING
Destefani (2002) stated that Coatings have become such an indispensable part
of most cutting tool grades that 70-75% of all carbides tools are now coated, according
to one expert. Coatings improve wear resistance, they increase tool life, and they
broaden the application range of a given grade, and enable use at higher speeds. By
improving performance, coatings are helping cutting tool manufacturers respond to
changing work piece materials and process requirement. Todays machining operations
can involve high-speed machining, dry machining, use of more near-net-shape work
pieces, tighter surface finish and dimensional tolerances, and increased use of untended
machining, which places a premium on edge security and tool reliability.
8
Coated cutting tool give many benefits in machining productivity. By improving
performance of coatings, the cutting tool manufacturers respond to changing work piece
materials and process requirements better. In many cases coatings are applied to
improve surface properties of the coated tool. Some advantages of coated cutting tool
are:
(i)
(ii)
(iii)
(iv)
(v)
(vi)
(vii)
9
and nonferrous cutting applications. Thickness of CVD coatings can range from 5 to 20
m.
The high process temperature used in CVD ensures good bonding between the
substrate and the coating material. It also can cause embrittlement and other
microstructural changes in the substrate material, reducing tool life and increasing the
potential for catastrophic failure. In response to this, the medium-temperature CVD
(MTCVD) process was developed in the 1980 to allow coating deposition at
temperatures from 700 to 900C (1300 - 1650F). The reduced processing temperature
and faster deposition of MTCVD work to maintain toughness of the substrate material,
and reduce thermally induced cracking in the coating.
Coatings produced using MTCVD processes are tougher than traditional CVD
coatings. This increased toughness results in minimal chipping and improved surface
finishes when machining stainless steels and other materials that are prone to causing
built-up edge on the cutting tool. Cutting tools with MTCVD coatings originally were
applied for interrupted cuts. More recently, MTCVD-coated tools are being used in
turning and other continuous cutting operations. The schematic diagram of CVD
process is as shown in figure 2.1.
10
Advantage
Disadvantage
i.
Uniform distribution over large
i. Mostly involve safety and
areas
contamination
ii.
No compositional gradients over
ii.
Hydrates and carbonyls are
substrates
poisonous (especially arsene)
iii. No need to break vacuum for
iii. Metal organics are pyrophoric
source changes
(ignite in contact with air)
iv.
More selective area deposition
iv.
High cost for compound with
because of higher activation energy
sufficient purity
for reaction with foreign
substances
Source: Destefani (2002)
11
2.4.3 Physical Vapor Deposition (PVD)
Destefani (2002) stated that PVD is the other major process used to produce
cutting tool coatings. PVD emerged in 1980 as a viable process for applying hard
coatings to cemented carbide tools.
In PVD, the coating is deposited in a vacuum. The metal species of the coating,
obtained via evaporation or sputtering, reacts with a gaseous species (nitrogen or
ammonia, for example) in the chamber and is deposited onto the substrate. Because
PVD is a low-pressure process, the coating atoms and molecules undergo relatively few
collisions on their way to the substrate. PVD is therefore a line-of-sight process that
requires moving fixtures to ensure uniform coating thickness.
The chief difference between PVD and CVD is the former's relatively low
processing temperature of PVD which is 500C (930F). This lower processing
temperature resulted in multiple benefits for PVD coatings. For example, the grain
structure of the coating is very fine. The result is a very smooth, bright coating with a
low coefficient of friction. In addition, PVD coatings are essentially free of the thermal
cracks that are common in CVD coatings.
Another advantage of the PVD process is the ability to coat tools with sharp
edges and complex chip breaker geometries. CVD-coated tools require a hone, because
the high-temperature process results in formation of eta phase in the carbide substrate.
Eta-phase formation is especially prevalent on sharp edges. In PVD, processing
temperatures are low enough that eta-phase formation is eliminated, allowing deposition
of PVD coatings on sharp edges. Ability to coat sharp edges is also enhanced by PVD
coatings' relative thinness versus CVD.
12
important in, for example, untended machining operations. Figure 2.2 shows the
schematic diagram of PVD process.
Advantages
i.
Fine grain structure of coating
ii.
Low coefficient of friction
iii. Free of thermal cracks
iv.
Ability to coat tools with sharp
edges and complex chipbreaker
geometry
v.
High built-in compressive stresses
that help in resist crack initiation
and propagation.
vi.
Prevents premature tool failure
vii.
Improve tool edge security
Disadvantages
i.
Lower adhesion compared to CVD
coatings
ii.
It is a line of sight technique
meaning that it is extremely
difficult to coat undercuts and
similar surface features
iii. High capital cost
iv.
Some processes operate at high
vacuums and temperatures
requiring skilled operators
v.
Processes requiring large amounts
of heat require appropriate cooling
systems
vi.
The rate of coating deposition is
usually quite slow
13
2.4.4 Coating material
Scott (2005) stated that the correct surface treatment on small round tools can
increase overall tool life, decrease cycle time and help better surface finishes.
Unfortunately, choosing the correct coating for production application can be a
confusing task. Each coating has advantages and disadvantages in the machining
process. Choosing the wrong coating can lead to less tool life than an uncoated tool and
sometimes result in more problems than solutions.
(i)
(ii)
Low friction
(iii)
High hardness
(iv)
Anti-reflective
(v)
Corrosion resistance
CHAPTER 3
METHODOLOGY
3.1
INTRODUCTION
3.2
In this research, the material selected for the cutting tool is tungsten carbide
(WC) or carbide. The raw materials were provided by CERATIZIT model TCGT
16T304FN-27 H10T tungsten carbide turning cutting tools. The details of the cutting
tool were described in Table 3.1 while figure 3.1 shows a methodology flow chart used
for the current work.
Detail
Standard designation of insert
Basic shape
Cutting edge length
Description
TCGT 16T304FN-27
Triangle
16.5