Professional Documents
Culture Documents
May 2008
METALS
FEVER
US $6.95 CAN $8.95
f
Reproduction or use of the text or pictorial content in any manner without written permission is prohibited.
Copyright 2008 by Futures Magazine Group, 222 S. Riverside Plaza, Suite 620, Chicago, IL 60606
CH
OF ICAG
TH O
pa E W ON
ge
60 OR TOP
LD
?
PAGE 26
Contents
MAY 2008 VOLUME XXXVII NUMBER 5
26
cover story
Metals: Precious
little supply
By Steve Zwick
ILLUSTRATION BY:
TRADING TECHNIQUES
By James A. Hyerczyk
By Valerii Salov
By Bill Biedermann
Reproduction or use of the text or pictorial content in any manner without written permission is prohibited.
Copyright 2008 by Futures Magazine Group, 222 S. Riverside Plaza, Suite 620, Chicago, IL 60606
Contents continued
group publisher / editorial director
Ginger Szala
D E PA R T M E N T S
10 Editors Note Second to none
contributing editors
James T. Holter
Murray A. Ruggiero Jr.,
art director Carl Walanski
spread
advertising coordinator Dan Hengehold
Chartview
conditions
68 Ad Index
74 Trader Profile Tom James: A matter
of degrees
F E AT U R E S
FUTURES 101
TRADE TRENDS
By Christine Birkner
MANAGED MONEY
56 Alternatives for retail
By Daniel P. Collins
While the universe of alternative
investments is often out of reach for
retail investors, here are a few options.
page 36
A UNIT OF
chairman and ceo William F. Reilly
president and ceo Andrew L. Goodenough
chief financial officer Thomas M. Flynn
executive VP & group publisher Thomas A. Fowler
Reproduction or use of the text or pictorial content in any manner without written permission is prohibited.
Copyright 2008 by Futures Magazine Group, 222 S. Riverside Plaza, Suite 620, Chicago, IL 60606
Second to none
EDITORS NOTE
C U S T O M E R
E-mail me at gszala@futuresmag.com
S E R V I C E
10
from the DoJ recently that, in essence, said a single silo clearing structure was detrimental to competition. This caused the CME Groups
(and most other exchanges) share price to swoon and it still hasnt
regained its previous levels. Further, the main detractors of the single
silo clearing mechanism are the investment banks of the world, who
believe the huge exchange, by owning its clearing house, will arbitrarily hike fees. This has concerned them for years, but now they
launched the Electronic Liquidity Exchange (ELX), which will use
the eSpeed platform, to fight back.
The real problem may be the investment banks shortsightedness.
As every exchange representative on that Florida panel agreed, the
single silo method was the best, mainly because of new product development. Richard Sandor, chairman of the Chicago Climate
Exchange and developer of a few important futures products, such as
interest rates, noted that separating the clearing house from the
exchange can stop you from innovating. He said, I used to believe
we could outsource (clearing)...but how naive to assume that the
provider wont become a competitor. Thats a key reason Liffe is
restructuring its clearing arrangement with the London Clearing
House so it would have more control over launching new products. Nymexs Jim Newsome said, The clearing house helps with new
product formation because it can be faster to bring the product to
market. Andreus Preuss of Eurex added that the key of having a
clearing house is not the cost of clearing but the lost opportunity cost
by [products] taking too long to get to market.
So heres the thing: for the CME Group to continue to thrive, it
must stay relevant in an ever-changing world, as do all global
exchanges. That means feeding the roots that made it great in the
first place: new and useful products. They have to be brought to market regularly and fast.
C E N T E R
Reproduction or use of the text or pictorial content in any manner without written permission is prohibited.
Copyright 2008 by Futures Magazine Group, 222 S. Riverside Plaza, Suite 620, Chicago, IL 60606
Trendlines
12
Reproduction or use of the text or pictorial content in any manner without written permission is prohibited.
Copyright 2008 by Futures Magazine Group, 222 S. Riverside Plaza, Suite 620, Chicago, IL 60606
MF!
Reproduction or use of the text or pictorial content in any manner without written permission is prohibited.
Copyright 2008 by Futures Magazine Group, 222 S. Riverside Plaza, Suite 620, Chicago, IL 60606
13
Trendlines continued
is via computer, that Nymex members
will receive 10% of the revenues or
100% of special fees.
Thats really the value in the seat.
The value in the seat is not being able
to have access to the trading floor anymore, because there is no derivative
value, says Nymex member
Eric Bolling.
I dont believe thats going to hold
this up, says John Vassallo, president
of Coquest Inc. and a Nymex member.
He says that if you compare the equity
and trading rights that Nymex members received through the demutualization and initial public offering, the
trading right is worth about $600,000,
and if members havent sold, their
equity is worth about $9 million. So
the $600,000 is not going to hold up
the $9 million, he says.
Despite member protestations, the
CME offer is still at a premium to
Nymex stock and without a higher
competing bid, there is not much
chance it will change.
The deal also would be subject to
regulatory approval, including the
CFTC and the U.S. Department of
Justice (DoJ), which approved the
CME/CBOT merger, but also recently
made known its objections to vertically integrated clearing of financial
futures. In that same comment letter to
the Treasury, DoJ also said energy markets should be exempt from
such changes.
By Chris McMahon
LONG VERTICAL JUMP
14
taken place.
NYSE Euronext is launching a new
clearinghouse for its Liffe futures subsidiary and other futures exchanges are
talking of doing the same. Meanwhile,
on the equities front and in line with
the European Union Commissions
call for centralized clearing a start-up
called EuroCCP says it wants to
become the counterparty for equities
trades across the continent, just as the
Depository Trust & Clearing
Corporation (DTCC) does in the
United States.
And no wonder London-based
EuroCCP is a subsidiary of the DTCC,
and was set up specifically to clear
trades from pan-European multilateral
trading facility Project Turquoise. Both
DTCC and Turquoise are consortium
owned by the major banks that use
the services.
LiffeClear, on the other hand, will
provide clearing for derivatives traded
on Euronext.Liffe, but will outsource
the actual guaranteeing and banking
arrangements to LCH.Clearnet,
through which Euronext.Liffe currently clears its business.
So, why bother making the change?
The answer, in part, is control
for the way things stand now, its not
really clear in Europe who controls the
liquidity an exchange runs through a
clearinghouse. This means customers
could decide to leave their liquidity
with the clearinghouse should an
exchange switch to another clearinghouse, as ICE is doing as it switches
from LCH.Clearnet to ICEClear.
That scenario led to a pre-emptive
tug-of-war over ICEs liquidity on
LCH.Clearnet last year, delaying the
European Climate Exchanges (ECX)
Certified Emission Reduction (CER)
futures last year. If Euronext.Liffe owns
its own clearinghouse, such disputes
wouldnt happen, even if the guaranteeing and banking functions are outsourced to LCH.Clearnet.
And the idea is catching. ECXs
parent company, Climate Exchange
PLC, could form its own clearing
house for energy and emissions products and it isnt even a real
exchange yet, dependent as it is on
ICEs platform.
LCH.Clearnet doesnt appear to be
entering the Euronext.Liffe deal willingly, and its possible LiffeClear
wouldnt have been proposed if
LCH.Clearnet werent in talks with
Project Rainbow. Now speculation
abounds in London over how Rainbow
will respond to LiffeClears outsourcing
deal after all, without the ability to
outsource, Euronext.Liffe would need a
year at least to set up its own clearinghouse. Rainbow has a first-rate legal
team, and you can bet they will find
some grounds to challenge the
LiffeClear arrangement with regulators, who have long had their sights on
vertical clearinghouses, albeit mostly
in the equities sector.
Deutsche Brse so far has taken the
brunt of that regulatory pressure, with
a vertically integrated clearing and settlement apparatus that can margin
equities against derivatives in two separate clearinghouses under the same
ownership. As a result of vertical structures in equities, cross-border clearing
of equities transactions remains much
more expensive than in the
United States.
The European Commission is set to
release new guidelines for breaking
down these barriers at the beginning of
2009. The Commission has a longstanding threat to mandate consolidation unless clearinghouses can either
merge on their own or blend into some
sort of interoperability model to enable
cross-border trades, but so far the only
link of that sort in the works is a link
between Switzerlands SIS x-clear and
LCH.Clearnet.
ICE, for its part, says it formed
ICEClear because current clearinghouses just arent up to the task of
clearing their over-the-counter (OTC)
and exchange-traded products raising the other cherry on the clearing
sundae: OTC business.
By Steve Zwick
Reproduction or use of the text or pictorial content in any manner without written permission is prohibited.
Copyright 2008 by Futures Magazine Group, 222 S. Riverside Plaza, Suite 620, Chicago, IL 60606
Trading Places
BY CHRISTINE BIRKNER
16
E-mail: cbirkner@futuresmag.com
Reproduction or use of the text or pictorial content in any manner without written permission is prohibited.
Copyright 2008 by Futures Magazine Group, 222 S. Riverside Plaza, Suite 620, Chicago, IL 60606
Market Strategy
BY ANTHONY DRAGER
old, gold, gold thats all you hear about these days.
With the volatility in metals, and all commodities for
that matter, everyones a gold trader or wants to be.
But even a gold bull could have experienced serious losses
in recent years despite its huge run up because of the huge
volatility and tendency to produce stop-shattering corrections amid a strong bullish trend.
Unless you have unlimited capital or have the uncanny
ability to pick tops and bottoms, the gold market has been
too volatile to simply play it from the long side, even when
you are right on the direction. Gold futures dropped more
than $150 from March 17 to April 1 and the market didnt
even approach its 200-day moving average or change the
long-term trend.
Gold has traded substantial volumes electronically since
2006, which has increased its access and improved its liquidity. This has allowed traders to use many short-term strategies
in gold that were previously only appropriate for liquid finan-
9820
9800
10:00
Source: eSignal
11:00
12:00
13:00
Reproduction or use of the text or pictorial content in any manner without written permission is prohibited.
Copyright 2008 by Futures Magazine Group, 222 S. Riverside Plaza, Suite 620, Chicago, IL 60606
17
relations go to 1.0. He says it is a problem of contagion, which causes otherwise non-correlated asset classes to correlate and leads to huge losses. What
he was looking for was a way to, hedge
these events regardless of asset class.
The program has produced strong
pro forma results. Applied to one fund
of funds last August, the strategy would
have improved the funds performance
from -0.26% to 1.6%, says Abernathy.
Abernathy recommends an allocation of 3% of a fund of funds assets to
the program that works as a risk overlay. The strategy uses a number of measures of risk to determine when an allocation should be made, but the majority of the time that allocation will
remain in cash.
February
-3.25%
+0.48%
+1.27%
+7.06%
YTD
-9.05%
+3.12%
-8.13%
+9.14%
18
YTD
. . .+7.47%
. . .+4.68%
. . .+0.69%
. .+15.06%
. . .+3.51%
. . .+7.51%
. . .+9.28%
. .+72.90%
. .+50.78%
. .+44.60%
. .+44.29%
. .+51.04%
. . .-50.46%
. .+31.96%
. . .-45.81%
. .+33.06%
. . . .-6.92%
Down: 29
Unchanged: 0
Mar. Return
YTD
. . . . . .14.84%
. . . . . . .8.47%
. . . . . . .7.83%
. . . . . .14.15%
. . . . . . .8.96%
2008 results
(through Mar 31)
Trading advisor(s)
. . . . . .14.67%
. . . . . . .5.26%
. . . . . . .6.42%
. . . . . . .3.61%
. . . . . . .5.99%
Number reporting: 48
Average performance for the year: +8.20%
Funds up: 43
Down: 5
Unchanged: 0
Mar. Return
YTD
. . . . . .31.88%
. . . . . .23.50%
. . . . . .17.95%
. . . . . .17.80%
. . . . . .17.74%
Trading advisor(s)
* Offshore fund.
Reproduction or use of the text or pictorial content in any manner without written permission is prohibited.
Copyright 2008 by Futures Magazine Group, 222 S. Riverside Plaza, Suite 620, Chicago, IL 60606
TEAMING UP
With the worlds regulators talking
about greater cooperation, it only
makes sense for professional groups representing hedge funds to work together
as well. And in April, the Managed
Funds Association (MFA) and
Alternative Investment Management
Association (AIMA) announced that
they were entering an alliance to work
more closely together and collaborate
on key initiatives. Richard H. Baker,
MFA president and CEO, says the two
groups have already worked together
and have a common goal of supporting
principles-based regulation. The market is a composite of investors and
firms in the global markets, so the standards of AIMA and MFA should be
consistent, Baker says.
Hedge Funds
Hedge Fund Returns
Feb. return
12 Mo. return
5.96%
-2.01%
19.43%
15.21%
9.03%
-2.81%
3.86%
4.69%
3.44%
5.07%
3.93%
-1.95%
0.51%
15.55%
3.22%
10.08%
-4.9%
10.76%
4.06%
0.48%
0.42%
-0.2%
-0.97%
-1.24%
-1.57%
-2.02%
-2.04%
-3.14%
-4.44%
-4.5%
-4.62%
-4.88%
Reproduction or use of the text or pictorial content in any manner without written permission is prohibited.
Copyright 2008 by Futures Magazine Group, 222 S. Riverside Plaza, Suite 620, Chicago, IL 60606
19
Hot Commodities
B Y C H R I S M CM A H O N
Gassed
No European vacation
With crude oil trading above $110 per barrel and Memorial Day on the horizon,
gasoline futures should be poised for take off. But with inventory at a 17-year high
and demand dropping for the first time in 17 years, gasoline has failed to keep pace
with crude.
The market is not moving around very much, says Joe Marshall, analyst for
PitGuru. We are in a trading range, and we are in a very high trading range. So not
only is it expensive to trade, you are
$ per gal
Unleaded Gas (June '08) daily
not getting a bang for your dollar. In
2.850
2.800
May he says the low is $2.65 per gal2.750
2.700
lon and could go higher than $3.
2.650
2.600
2.550
The backwardation in the futures
2.500
2.450
spreads are not strengthening,
2.400
2.350
observes Darin Newsom, analyst for
2.300
2.250
DTN, meaning commercial buying
2.200
has yet to step in. He says support is
15 22 29 5 12 19 26 3 10 17 24 31 7 14 22 28 4 11 19 25 3 10 17 24 31 7
Nov
Dec
2008
Feb
Mar
Apr
at $2.4875 and resistance is at $3.05.
Source: eSignal
In a major economic downturn,
gas futures could drop to $2.40, says Darren Dohme, trader at Powerline Petroleum.
But he says Fed actions and global demand will keep crude demand up, and gasoline
prices will firm. Support is $2.60, resistance is $3. Crude might run as high as $125,
plus a $10 crack spread is $135, divided by 42 gallons per barrel, and that would give
you $3.20 unleaded gasoline futures. Thats my maximum high-side target, he says.
Beans on a tear
After trading near $16 per bushel in early March, May soybeans dipped to below
$11.50. Victor Lespinasse, analyst for Grainanalyst.com., attributes the sell-off to
profit taking but adds, tight end$ per bu
Soybeans (May '08) daily
ing stocks and a long growing
16.00
season will keep weather premi15.50
15.00
ums high. So hes looking at the
14.50
14.00
spreads. November beans price
13.50
vs. December corn price, the
13.00
12.50
ratio is two to one. That strong12.00
ly favors planting corn. The
11.50
11.00
normal ratio would be 2.25 or
10.50
2.4 to one, Lespinasse says. A
5 12 19 26 3 10 17 24 31 7 14 22 28 4 11 19 25 3 10 17 24 31 7
Dec
2008
Feb
Mar
Apr
lot of people think that is whats
Source: eSignal
going to happen; never mind
the planting intentions report.
Thats written in sand.
He adds that cold wet weather could push beans down but dry weather could
draw acres to corn, pushing prices near the $15 high.
All the acres are going to go into beans at the expense of corn. Its the opposite
of last year, says Stephen Davis, broker for RJO Futures. We are going to back
and fill and the only thing that would stop us is Mother Nature. For May, he says
support is $12 per bushel and resistance is $13.
Tom McKenna, merchandiser at Scoular Grain, says U.S. bean prices have been
supported by the Argentinean farmers strike. They have shut in crops, protesting a
new tax on export goods. Farmers are good at responding to what the market
does, he says, and ultimately beans will be dependent on corn and weather.
20
1.5800
1.5600
1.5400
1.5200
1.5000
1.4800
1.4600
1.4400
31 7 14 21 28 4 11 18 25 3 10 17 24 31 7
2008
Feb
Mar
Apr
Source: eSignal
Reproduction or use of the text or pictorial content in any manner without written permission is prohibited.
Copyright 2008 by Futures Magazine Group, 222 S. Riverside Plaza, Suite 620, Chicago, IL 60606
Options Strategy
BY HOWARD TYLLAS
be expensive and not worth the risk of ownership. But if soybeans were trading at $16, the $12 call is protected by one of
your $13 calls, so that would be $1 against you and the other
$13 call is worth $3:
$3-$1=$2 - 72.5 = $1.275 profit.
If you held the spread until expiration, you would lose the
entire 72.5 if the market settles below $12. If at $13 you
would also lose the $1 differential on the vertical. This would
Howard Tyllas is registered with the CFTC as a floor broker and CTA. Hes
a member of NFA and a veteran trader of 31 years. He has traded options
on futures since their inception. www.howardtyllas.com.
22
Reproduction or use of the text or pictorial content in any manner without written permission is prohibited.
Copyright 2008 by Futures Magazine Group, 222 S. Riverside Plaza, Suite 620, Chicago, IL 60606
Forex Trader
BY ABE COFNAS
24
Reproduction or use of the text or pictorial content in any manner without written permission is prohibited.
Copyright 2008 by Futures Magazine Group, 222 S. Riverside Plaza, Suite 620, Chicago, IL 60606
MARKETS
The price of gold has surged more than 50% in the past year, even with the
recent correction figured in, bringing platinum and palladium with it. So, is
this the end of fiat currency as we know it, as gold bugs have claimed? Or
were commodities in a bubble that has burst and is gold on the way
back down? What are the forces jostling the global metals markets?
METALS:
PRECIOUS
LITTLE
SUPPLY
BY STEVE ZWICK
26
Reproduction or use of the text or pictorial content in any manner without written permission is prohibited.
Copyright 2008 by Futures Magazine Group, 222 S. Riverside Plaza, Suite 620, Chicago, IL 60606
ELECTRIC GRIDLOCK
Most coverage of golds rise focuses on two
factors: the plunge in the U.S. dollar and a
general fear of exposure to paper assets. Less
attention has focused on the supply side of
gold and silver, but more of platinum, palladium and plain old copper.
In South Africa, the main power supplier, Eskom, has run out of reserve capacity,
and this has caused rolling power cuts,
Trickey says. Many platinum and palladium
mines had to close temporarily at the end of
Reproduction or use of the text or pictorial content in any manner without written permission is prohibited.
Copyright 2008 by Futures Magazine Group, 222 S. Riverside Plaza, Suite 620, Chicago, IL 60606
27
Markets continued
January, since power could not be guaranteed, and this posed a safety risk,
especially for the underground mines.
As a result, mines are operating at
just 95% capacity, at a time when
industrial demand, primarily in
China, remains at full throttle.
Theyre able to operate on that, but
companies are looking at ways to find
individual power sources of their
own, she says.
Palladium, thanks to these and
other factors, rose from less than $200
per ounce in March 2003, to nearly
$580 in February this year (after a
one-month surge of about 40%),
before settling down to its current
mid-$400 range.
COPPER BOTTLENECK
Supply concerns also are dominating the
copper market. The supply side seems
to perennially shoot itself in the foot,
and so far in 2008 it seems to have shot
itself in both feet, says Trickeys colleague, Allan Trench, who is CRUs
research manager for copper. He says
many of the bullets hitting those feet left
their chambers in the 1990s.
You had a lack of investment then
due to low prices. But when that
changed, you had all the usual quick
fixes being implemented, like expanding leach tanks and debottlenecking
the crushing circuit, or putting an extra
shovel in the pit in cases where an
operation was pit-constrained,
PRECIOUS INDUSTRIALS
While platinum and palladium have many industrial uses, theyre quite pricey and can
be substituted for each other.
$ per oz
700
650
600
550
500
450
400
350
300
250
200
150
$ per oz
2,250
Platinum
2,025
Palladium
Palladium
Platinum
1,750
1,500
1,250
1,000
750
500
2003
2004
2005
2006
2007
2008
Source: eSignal
GOLDEN OPPORTUNITY
Many people saw the bull market in gold when it was caught in a 20-year bear market
at the beginning of this century. It has quite a ways to go lower to indicate a reversal of
the trend started from below $300.
11000
10000
9000
8000
7000
6000
5000
4000
3000
2002
2003
Source: eSignal
28
2004
2005
2006
2007
2008
Trench says.
What didnt happen was significant
re-tooling. As a result, everyone is
doing the same thing at the same time,
meaning major expansions and new
projects and suppliers are swamped.
He cites a litany of statistics: tires
that could have been delivered in four
months three years ago now sometimes
need almost two years to arrive.
Trucks that would show up in three
months now need two years.
You know how theyre dealing with
this? he asks. Theyre driving slower
to maintain tire life.
P-PROGNOSIS
Analysts seem at odds over the shortterm prognosis for platinum, which
recently traded up to $2,276 per ounce
before settling down to its current range
just below $2,000.
The consensus on its poor cousin,
palladium, however, is strong largely because of the paradox that, as with
platinum, most of the factors that can
make demand for the metal go down
actually make it go up. In other words,
the factors that hurt demand for palladium as an industrial metal actually
help it as a precious metal, and vice
versa at least, thats the perception.
A global deflationary trend would, in
reality, drag down the price of both
precious and industrial metals.
But in reality, South Africas electricity problems and strong industrial
demand are only half of the palladium
story. The other half is gold and platinum. Economic news from the USA
seems to be pushing gold around, and
thats also having an effect on platinum on a day-to-day basis, Trickey
says. Given platinums stellar performance so far this year and the risk to
the supply side, this should continue to
be supportive for palladium.
This quarter, she sees platinum averaging between $2,000 and $1,900, with
palladium remaining in the mid-$400s.
In the second half of the year, she sees
prices dipping for both.
Im expecting platinum to be
around $1,800 in the second half of the
Reproduction or use of the text or pictorial content in any manner without written permission is prohibited.
Copyright 2008 by Futures Magazine Group, 222 S. Riverside Plaza, Suite 620, Chicago, IL 60606
Reproduction or use of the text or pictorial content in any manner without written permission is prohibited.
Copyright 2008 by Futures Magazine Group, 222 S. Riverside Plaza, Suite 620, Chicago, IL 60606
29
Markets continued
COPPER DOLLAR
Copper has rallied by a greater multiple than gold this century, moving from below 60
to more than $4 per lb.
42500
40000
37500
35000
32500
30000
27500
25000
22500
Feb Mar Apr Jun Jul Sep Oct Dec Jan Feb Mar Apr Jun Jul Aug Oct Nov Jan Feb Mar Apr
2007
2008
Source: eSignal
hough one of the least sophisticated technical indicators, the simple-moving average (SMA) has become a
useful tool for trading precious metals, particularly gold.
Smoother and slower moving than the more complex exponential-moving average (EMA), the SMA flattens short-term
volatility to help traders gauge trends and judge support
and resistance levels over intermediate time frames.
The chart shows weekly gold futures overlaid with fiveand 50-week simple moving averages. The sensitivity of the
five-week moving average makes it track actual prices closely, but more importantly, the chart reveals the five-week
moving average works as a key support level in periods of
increasing price, and that resistance there indicates further
price declines. Understanding the markets response at the
five-week moving average not only clarifies the direction of
the underlying trend, it also directs traders to where to
place buy, sell and stop orders to take advantage of both
the dips and the rips.
Nov Jan Mar May Jul Aug Oct Dec Feb Apr Jun Aug Oct Dec Feb Apr Jun Aug Oct Dec Feb Apr
2005
2006
2007
2008
Source: eSignal
Similarly, the 50-week moving average can be interpreted as a proxy for the bull market in gold, which is useful for
understanding price action and planning trades. Notice the
50-week SMA has been strong support for gold during the
bleakest periods of its recent history. Even after the sell-off
in May 2006 and the ambiguous price action of early 2007,
support at the 50-week moving average has been the base
on which subsequent advances were built. Though losing
the 50-week moving average could create serious doubts
about the bull market in gold, even the steepest declines are
merely corrective with price remaining above it.
30
Reproduction or use of the text or pictorial content in any manner without written permission is prohibited.
Copyright 2008 by Futures Magazine Group, 222 S. Riverside Plaza, Suite 620, Chicago, IL 60606
Reproduction or use of the text or pictorial content in any manner without written permission is prohibited.
Copyright 2008 by Futures Magazine Group, 222 S. Riverside Plaza, Suite 620, Chicago, IL 60606
31
32
Reproduction or use of the text or pictorial content in any manner without written permission is prohibited.
Copyright 2008 by Futures Magazine Group, 222 S. Riverside Plaza, Suite 620, Chicago, IL 60606
THATS A TOP
Following the swing top formation on the monthly chart in September 2005, we can say
the housing index made a technical top. However, this does not necessarily mean it has
established a new downtrend.
1039.06
$DJUSHB MONTHLY
GANN ANGLE TRENDING ACTION
1,100.00
1,000.00
900.00
790.31
800.00
807.15
700.00
600.00
545.75
500.00
245.76
1x2
02
Jul
03
Jul
04
Jul
05
Jul
06
Jul
07
Jul
08
Jul
09
1x1
400.00
1x1
300.00
Jul
Source: Tradestation
BREAKING ANGLES
KBH topped in much the same manner as the housing index itself. From the chart, we can
see that the downtrend is currently being controlled by both the series of lower tops and
lower bottoms, along with down-trending Gann angles.
81.99
85.45
KB HOMES MONTHLY
GANN ANGLE TREND
80.00
70.00
60.00
56.08
60.82
50.00
2x1 40.00
37.89
30.14
02
Jul
03
Jul
04
2x1
15.76
Jul
05
Jul
06
Jul
07
Jul
20.00
1x1 1x1
08
Jul
30.00
09
Jul
Source: Tradestation
Reproduction or use of the text or pictorial content in any manner without written permission is prohibited.
Copyright 2008 by Futures Magazine Group, 222 S. Riverside Plaza, Suite 620, Chicago, IL 60606
33
UPTREND IN MAKING?
If the housing index can hold the January bottom through April, and particularly through
August, we can declare a new technical bottom fully formed. A savvy trader would look for this
price action in both the index and component stocks, such as KBH (below).
1x1
81.99
85.45
KB HOMES MONTHLY
TOPPING ACTION
80.00
70.00
60.00
56.08
60.82
50.00
2x1 40.00
37.89
30.00
30.14
02
Jul
03
Jul
04
15.76
Jul
05
Jul
1039.06
06
Jul
07
Jul
20.00
08
1x1
Jul
09
Jul
1,100.00
1,000.00
900.00
790.31
800.00
807.15
1x1
600.00
50.00% (518.04)
545.75
500.00
1x1
1x1
245.76
02
Jul
03
Jul
04
Source: Tradestation
34
Jul
05
700.00
Jul
06
Jul
300.00
1x2
07
Jul
08
400.00
Jul
09
Jul
Reproduction or use of the text or pictorial content in any manner without written permission is prohibited.
Copyright 2008 by Futures Magazine Group, 222 S. Riverside Plaza, Suite 620, Chicago, IL 60606
rally would have to be shorter in duration and priced to indicate a top. The
next up move fell short of the objective at a down-trending Gann angle
and retracement zone. Following this
secondary lower top, the housing index
turned the trend down and broke considerably until its most recent bottom
on Jan. 9, 2008, at 245.76.
In addition to the swing analysis,
the down move was confirmed when
the market broke through up-trending
Gann angles drawn from the last
swing bottom before the top. Downtrending Gann angles from the top
and subsequent lower tops are controlling the trend at this time, along
with the lower tops and lower bottoms
from the swing chart.
A similar pattern developed in KBH.
The first leg down from the 85.45 top
on July 20, 2005, was 24.63 in three
months. This was considerably greater
than the previous monthly downswing
from 40.95 on March 31, 2004, to
30.14 on May 12, 2004. This first clue
was confirmed when the subsequent
rally failed to exceed the previous
swing rally. In addition, the market
found Gann-angle and retracement zone resistance before changing trend
and trading down to 15.76 on Jan. 9,
2008 (see Breaking angles, page 33).
Because we have substantial evidence regarding how the housing market stocks topped, we can use the same
tools to forecast how the market will
bottom. Even if a major change in
trend does not occur during the period
that our analysis takes place, the trend
trader may be able to use this information to manage trailing stop points.
CAN WE SEE THE BOTTOM?
The two-month higher-high, higherlow pattern from Jan. 9, 2008, makes
245.76 a main bottom. Since the
main top in 2005, the housing index
has only formed two main bottoms.
The first was 807.15 to 1039.06, or
231.91 points, in three months. The
second was 545.75 to 790.31, or
244.56 points, in seven months.
Based on the new main bottom at
Reproduction or use of the text or pictorial content in any manner without written permission is prohibited.
Copyright 2008 by Futures Magazine Group, 222 S. Riverside Plaza, Suite 620, Chicago, IL 60606
35
TRADING TECHNIQUES
Curve fitting is the bane of system developers, but by embracing the hindsight
provided by market prices we can calibrate systems and time frames within
them to improve overall returns.
Idealized models
for real profits
BY VALERII SALOV
36
Reproduction or use of the text or pictorial content in any manner without written permission is prohibited.
Copyright 2008 by Futures Magazine Group, 222 S. Riverside Plaza, Suite 620, Chicago, IL 60606
in the top oscillator uses a per-transaction cost of $12 and the one depicted
in the bottom oscillator uses a pertransaction cost of $500. (Keep in
mind that these transaction costs are
not intended to reflect realistic commission and slippage values, but are
being employed here simply as part of
the analytical process.)
As a reminder, there is no magic
about these trading strategies. They
simply use the benefit of hindsight to
determine the most profitable entry
and exit prices given the two pertransaction costs. Over the period
shown, the maximum profit returned
by the $12-cost system is $69,015.
The maximum profit returned by the
$500-cost system is $22,800.
Clearly, the number of optimal
transactions decreases as per-transaction costs increase. For unlimited
trading costs the best strategy is do
nothing. If the costs equal zero, then
each nonzero price change would
result in a profit.
NEW MARKET PROPERTY
A maximum profit strategy does not
describe the strategy of an individual
trader. Its determined by prices, transaction costs and the market access processes in use by the industry. As such, what
it tells us about the market relates to
other market properties, such as trend
and volatility.
The maximum profit, a strategy
returning it and time distribution of
successful transactions is another form
of studying markets and their repetitive
statistical behavior. These studies add
to the information conveyed by traditional studies because they combine
price information, variable transaction
costs and trading rules to express
results in the most interesting view:
trading profits.
Because maximum profit strategies
can be expressed as a general market
property, they can be used like any
other indicator. Consider moving
averages. They are calculated on past
prices with the benefit of hindsight.
They are then shifted forward, as new
MOVING FORWARD
When a new price arrives, we rebuild
the maximum profit strategy using
this larger time interval. As we add a
new price, we may see a change in the
two most recent transactions.
Remember, we are using a simple,
always-in system. The last transaction
will close a position and extract
marked-to-market profit. The ideal
ALWAYS IN
The oscillators below the price chart of July 2007 corn demonstrate the buy and sell
signals of two perfect trading systems. The only difference is one has a per-transaction
cost of $12, and the other has a per-transaction cost of $500.
470
450
430
410
390
370
350
330
310
290
270
250
5/8/06 6/17/06 7/27/06 9/5/06 10/15/06 11/24/06 1/3/07 2/12/07 3/24/07 5/3/07 6/12/07
Data: www.cbot.com
COST COLLECTION
Heres a visual representation of how various system combinations performed. Each line
represents a different low-cost value, while the accompanying high-cost value is the point
along the horizontal axis.
8000
7000
6000
5000
4000
3000
2000
1000
0
-1000
-2000
-3000
-4000
-5000
-6000
-7000
-8000
25
50
75
100
125
150
175
200
50
100
150
200
Reproduction or use of the text or pictorial content in any manner without written permission is prohibited.
Copyright 2008 by Futures Magazine Group, 222 S. Riverside Plaza, Suite 620, Chicago, IL 60606
250
300
350
400
450
37
PERFORMANCE MATRIX
Here are the evaluation reports for a number of low-cost/high-cost system combinations.
As you can see, combinations using $50 for the low-cost system did well across a range of
higher-cost values.
Large Cost/Small Cost
200/25 150/50
200/75
225/100 225/175
Total P&L
$5,934 $6,123
$6,647
$4,825 $7,263
Gross profit
$17,783 $15,272 $16,413 $13,919 $11,932
Gross loss
$11,849 $9,149
$9,766
$9,095 $4,669
Total number of trades
84
48
47
37
13
Number of winning trades
33
22
25
19
7
Number of losing trades
51
26
22
18
6
Average profit
$539
$694
$657
$733
$1,705
Average loss
$232
$352
$444
$505
$778
Largest winning trade
$3,114 $2,339
$3,114
$2,089 $3,614
Largest losing trade
$1,749 $2,124
$2,124
$4,724 $1,824
Max number of consecutive wins
5
3
3
3
3
Max number of consecutive losses
5
4
4
3
2
Maximum consecutive profit
$4,003 $2,790
$4,453
$2,427 $5,878
Maximum consecutive loss
$1,749 $2,124
$2,124
$4,724 $1,936
Maximum account value
$16,520 $16,284 $16,784 $15,912 $21,150
Minimum account value
$8,797 $8,421
$7,667
$8,094 $9,005
Largest drawdown
$3,358 $4,284
$3,950
$5,299 $4,950
Average drawdown
$377
$429
$304
$264
$279
38
Reproduction or use of the text or pictorial content in any manner without written permission is prohibited.
Copyright 2008 by Futures Magazine Group, 222 S. Riverside Plaza, Suite 620, Chicago, IL 60606
Reproduction or use of the text or pictorial content in any manner without written permission is prohibited.
Copyright 2008 by Futures Magazine Group, 222 S. Riverside Plaza, Suite 620, Chicago, IL 60606
39
TRADING TECHNIQUES
Trading E-mini futures profitably is difficult and can become nearly impossible
when relying on too many time frames and indicators. Here is a relatively
simple approach that involves price action and a basic five-minute E-mini chart.
Five minutes to
fame in the E-mini
BY AL BROOKS
rading does not have to be
complicated. For most traders, if
they take time to look carefully
at candle or bar charts, they will
quickly discover that price action alone
is all you need to observe to be successful. As a bar develops, consider the tone
of the market, whether the bulls or
bears are in control, and more importantly, who is trapped and who will
have to get out. It can be that simple.
While this approach works with all
time frames and all markets, it is efficient on five-minute charts of the Emini S&P 500. Typically, there are
from 10 to 20 set ups per day on the
five-minute time frame, which is far
more than needed to do well. If you
trade enough contracts, you only need
to net one or two points a day
to succeed.
Its typical (right) is a five-minute
chart depicting a normal day in the Emini S&P 500, while First shift (page
42) is a closer look at the first four
hours of trading. For example, 37 is the
37th bar of the day. By reviewing the
price action as this day unfolds, we can
point out several opportunities as they
occur. Along the way, we might refer
to various formations, but general price
40
Reproduction or use of the text or pictorial content in any manner without written permission is prohibited.
Copyright 2008 by Futures Magazine Group, 222 S. Riverside Plaza, Suite 620, Chicago, IL 60606
ITS TYPICAL
This chart shows a typical day in the E-mini S&P 500. Theres sideways action, big trend
moves and numerous opportunities for profit.
1,449.00
1,447.00
1,445.00
1,443.00
1,441.00
1,439.00
1,437.00
1,435.00
1,433.00
1,431.00
1,429.00
1,427.00
1,425.00
1,423.00
1,421.00
1,419.00
1,417.00
1,415.00
12:30 11/21 7:00 7:30 8:00 8:30 9:00 9:30 10:00 10:30 11:00 11:30 12:00 12:30 11/22
@ ES.D 5-min CME L=1417.75 -28.25 -1.95% MAX (20) 1425.87
Source: Tradestation
Reproduction or use of the text or pictorial content in any manner without written permission is prohibited.
Copyright 2008 by Futures Magazine Group, 222 S. Riverside Plaza, Suite 620, Chicago, IL 60606
41
1,450.00
1,448.00
1,446.00
1,444.00
1,442.00
1,440.00
1,438.00
1,436.00
1,434.00
1,432.00
1,430.00
1,428.00
1,426.00
1,424.00
1,422.00
1,420.00
1,418.00
1,416.00
43
6
10
31
16
28
22
3
41
8
37
13
20
12:30
13:00
11/21
7:00
7:30
8:00
8:30
9:00
9:30
10:00
Source: Tradestation
42
BIGGER SWINGS
The sell off down to Bar 37 also breaks
the bull trendline from Bar 20 to 31.
The bear trap is set and the new bears
are worried by their inability to move
the market down forcefully. Also, bulls
are eagerly looking for any sign of
strength to add to their longs near the
EMA. Bars 35 and 37 have down closes,
and they are two attempts by the bears
to gain control and both fail. Bulls go
long and bears exit at one tick above
Bar 37. This results in a significant
higher low. Bar 38 is a strong bull trend
bar that broke above the EMA and
broke above the bear trendline from Bar
32 to Bar 34.
Now, you should expect at least two
legs up, which the market gives you:
one ending at Bar 41, and the other at
Bar 45. Bar 43 is a new high for the day
and a huge second leg up (Bar 20 to Bar
31 was the first). This second leg up also
had two legs (Bar 37 to Bar 39 and Bar
41 to Bar 43).When the day is not a
clear and strong trend day, you should
always be looking for set ups that allow
you to fade new swing moves and new
highs and lows for the day. Bar 43 gives
you several and you would sell, expecting at least a scalpers profit and likely
two legs down.
This approach is difficult to quantify
and requires practice to develop a feel
for the market; however, once learned,
it works consistently. For most of us, the
five-minute chart is the best time frame,
providing enough time to spot most set
ups and enter the market. The fiveminute chart offers an incredible opportunity to a day-trader if you remain
patient, trade within your means and
take time to understand what the price
action is telling you.
FM
Al Brooks, M.D., stopped practicing medicine 20
years ago to raise his kids. He has been day
trading for his personal account ever since. He
can be reached at Albrooks223@gmail.com.
Reproduction or use of the text or pictorial content in any manner without written permission is prohibited.
Copyright 2008 by Futures Magazine Group, 222 S. Riverside Plaza, Suite 620, Chicago, IL 60606
TRADING TECHNIQUES
The metals markets have been booming and are showing no signs of slowing
down in 2008. Some of the better opportunities have been in silver, the industrial
and precious qualities of which make its story one of the most compelling.
44
and examine some techniques for guiding your entries into the market.
MONEY METALS
Gold and silver have been recognized
as stores of value for thousands of
years. Gold has certainly done its job,
preserving wealth for those who have
invested in the yellow metal. But
despite its exceptional performance of
late, gold hasnt always offered the
best returns. In 2004, silver outperformed gold. While the price of gold
increased approximately 6% from the
last day of 2003 until the last day of
2004, the price of silver increased
more than 15% during the same period. Silver also outperformed gold in
2005 and 2006; however, gold
returned to the lead in 2007.
Going forward, there are several
reasons silver likely will continue its
position of strength. One of the most
bullish factors is simply that demand
outstripped supply for 16 straight
years. That means that from 1990
through 2005, the world used more
silver each year than what mines took
out of the ground. Because of that, the
above-ground stockpile of roughly two
Reproduction or use of the text or pictorial content in any manner without written permission is prohibited.
Copyright 2008 by Futures Magazine Group, 222 S. Riverside Plaza, Suite 620, Chicago, IL 60606
PRICE-INELASTIC
The largest use of silver comes from
industrial demand, jewelry/silverware
and photography, in that order (see
Uses for silver, below). Industrial
demand for silver makes up 51% of total
demand, and this area is also the fastest
growing area of silver demand. The
industrial portion of the market is growing at about 2% per year. It is important
to understand that in almost all
instances, the amount of silver used in a
cell phone, laptop computer or
microwave oven is so small that it cannot be recovered. For all practical purposes, the silver used in these applications is lost and unrecoverable.
Economists describe the industrial
demand for silver as price-inelastic.
Price inelasticity means that demand
for the product does not move much
relative to changes in price. One reason might be that because a small
amount of silver is used in each application its an insignificant factor in the
price of the product.
The amount of silver used in the
manufacture of a battery, an automobile, a computer or cell phone is
insignificant when compared to the
1990
1990
2007
2,000
Million ounces
1,500
1,000
2007
500
0
Gold
Silver
Electroplating
Jewelry and Silverware
Medical Applications
Mirrors and Coatings
Photography
Solar Energy
Water Purification
Reproduction or use of the text or pictorial content in any manner without written permission is prohibited.
Copyright 2008 by Futures Magazine Group, 222 S. Riverside Plaza, Suite 620, Chicago, IL 60606
45
SPIKED!
Capturing big moves in silver requires lots of patience. However, it can pay off. Notice
how quickly the spike low follows the spike high.
SILVER - CONTINUOUS CONTRACT (EOD)) INDX 28-FEB-2008
Open 16.94 High19.97 Low 16.23 Close 19.71 Chg +2.71 (+15.98%)
20
Spike high?
19
18
Spike high
17
16
15
14
Spike low 13
Spike low
12
Spike high
11
10
9
8
Spike low
7
6
5
4
00 A J O 01 A J O 02 A J O 03 A J O 04 A J O 05 A J O 06 A J O 07 A J O 08
$Silver (Monthly) 19.71
MA (50) 10.27
MA (200) 6.18
Volume undef
Source: StockCharts.com
46
Reproduction or use of the text or pictorial content in any manner without written permission is prohibited.
Copyright 2008 by Futures Magazine Group, 222 S. Riverside Plaza, Suite 620, Chicago, IL 60606
TRADING TECHNIQUES
The current acreage dilemma for the United States makes grain fundamentals
even more critical and ensures a prolonged bull market unless powerful
forces intervene.
Grain bears:
Waiting for a miracle
BY BILL BIEDERMANN
MARKET SUSTAINABILITY
Investment money is historically
involved with non-essential markets or
third-party investment vehicles. Thus,
the influx directly into commodities is
not only new for the investor but also
48
wheat acreage.
As a result of flat acreage, corn-ending stocks will fall from 1.9 billion
bushels in 2005 to a projection of only
650 million bushels in 2008. This barely meets pipeline supplies and assumes
a trendline yield. Any adverse weather
would immediately result in a shortage.
About the only way to avoid a tight
stocks situation would be an act of God
or, more to the point, a gift from
God in the form of great weather and
record yields.
Although the Secretary of
Agriculture has authority to release
acres into production, if potential
stocks dictate the need, the U.S. government currently seems content betting on weather and scientific plant
genetics rather than releasing more
acres into production. This can
change and any change in policy
would have a huge impact on prices.
If theres no acreage release and bad
weather reduces yields, then corn could
rally beyond $8 per bushel and soybeans could climb above $20. It sounds
almost fantastical, but Minneapolis
wheat hit $25 in February, and soybeans traditionally have traded higher
Reproduction or use of the text or pictorial content in any manner without written permission is prohibited.
Copyright 2008 by Futures Magazine Group, 222 S. Riverside Plaza, Suite 620, Chicago, IL 60606
Possibilities include:
Allowing foreign ethanol to enter
the United States without tariff
Releasing some acres from the setaside program
Temporarily mandating all or a portion of U.S. ethanol plants to close
for a period of time to free up supplies; U.S. plants would continue to
receive their scheduled subsidy to
maintain financial stability
Ban exports of U.S. grain (this one is
highly unlikely but has been implemented overseas)
Obviously, if any of these options
were enforced, it would have a dramatically negative impact on prices and
liquidity would be questionable.
300
250
200
150
Plants
18000
100
4000
50
2000
2010e
0
2009e
2008
2007
Total Plants
2006
2005
2004
Production
2003
2002
2000
2001
Total Capacity
0
1999
OUTSIDE INTERVENTION
Of course, this type of price explosion
could cause some serious potential
issues that investors would have to
monitor. Food processors are already
under intense pressure to raise retail
prices or operate in the red. This
income squeeze has become so heightened that the first protest since World
War II against high food costs took
place in Washington on March 12.
The march, organized by the
American Bakers Association, lobbied
officials to change agricultural policy to
get markets under control. The organization actually has cooked up a good
argument based on the law that
requires the U.S. Secretary of
Agriculture to maintain a reliable and
affordable supply of food.
If lobby efforts are successful, or if
poor weather develops and reduces
stocks even more, the USDA likely
will be forced to make some decisions
that would destroy the bull market
with the stroke of a pen. Getting
involved, right, shows what has happened during past periods of government intervention.
LIQUIDITY CRUNCH
The volatility and influx of investor
funds have already impacted the liquidity of the market. Cash traders have
pulled away from the market for two
reasons. First, end users do not want to
be stuck owning too much inventory
at current prices because many sectors,
such as the ethanol industry, are not
able to turn a profit on the end product they sell (see Profit profile, page
50). Currently, nearly every ethanol
plant is in the red at todays cost of
corn, even when considering the value
Millions of Gallons
GETTING INVOLVED
One sure way to end a bull market in grain is for the government to get involved. Heres a
look at past, short-lived bull markets in corn.
1973
1977
1994 1996
2002
We have highlighted with a measurement the moves associated with big demand:
Great Grain Robbery in 1973 and 1974 Russia buys
Great Grain Robbery II in 1996 China buys
Great Grain Robbery III in 2006-2007 Ethanol Expansion
4000
3750
3500
3250
3000
2750
2500
2250
2000
1750
1500
1250
1000
1969 1971 1973 1975 1977 1979 1981 1983 1985 1987 1989 1991 1993 1995 1997 1999 2001 2003 2005
Source: Allendale Inc.
Reproduction or use of the text or pictorial content in any manner without written permission is prohibited.
Copyright 2008 by Futures Magazine Group, 222 S. Riverside Plaza, Suite 620, Chicago, IL 60606
49
WHAT TO DO NOW
Buying breaks in commodities will likely
remain the fad of most traders. But with
this surety of success comes the contrarian thinking that one of the two mentioned arrows will pierce the heart of
this bull. A better way to approach this
market, with an eye toward the bearish
risk, is to employ some option positions
designed to provide some precautionary
fiscal health.
Option programs can be employed
against futures positions to help manage the exposure of an adverse move.
For example, we can convert an open-
PROFIT PROFILE
With corn as expensive as it is today, its difficult for ethanol producers to turn a profit.
$7
$6
$5
Per bushel
$4
without subsidy
$3
$2
$1
$0
-$1
-$2
02
03
04
05
06
07
08
Profit / Loss
4200
3600
3000
2400
1800
1200
600
0
-600
-1200
-1800
-2400
-3000
400.00 425.00 450.00 475.00 500.00 525.00 550.00 575.00 600.00 625.00 650.00 675.00 700.00 725.00 750.00
-1,900 -1,981 -2,106 -2.281 -2,519 -1,575 -706 94 819 1,475 2,063 2,581 3,038 3,444 3,800
50
Reproduction or use of the text or pictorial content in any manner without written permission is prohibited.
Copyright 2008 by Futures Magazine Group, 222 S. Riverside Plaza, Suite 620, Chicago, IL 60606
FUTURES 101
Understanding the fundamentals of ag markets is no longer as simple as
following the weather and knowing what USDA reports to watch. Speculative
money flows, non-U.S. demand and energy fundamentals often trump the more
traditional supply and demand measures.
Ag fundamentals:
Old and new
BY CHRISTINE BIRKNER
52
Reproduction or use of the text or pictorial content in any manner without written permission is prohibited.
Copyright 2008 by Futures Magazine Group, 222 S. Riverside Plaza, Suite 620, Chicago, IL 60606
Corn
Soybeans
20%
15%
10%
5%
0%
2004
2005
2006
2007
2008
estimates
Reproduction or use of the text or pictorial content in any manner without written permission is prohibited.
Copyright 2008 by Futures Magazine Group, 222 S. Riverside Plaza, Suite 620, Chicago, IL 60606
53
Corn
Soybeans
Acers in millions
Wheat
2004
2005
2006
2007
2008
estimates
On March 31, the USDA released its Prospective Plantings report for 2008. The most
important figures in the report are the total expected acres for soybeans, corn and wheat.
The chart above shows actual acres for the past four years and the USDAs estimates for
2008. USDA reported corn at the low end of expectations, a bullish figure. Soybeans came
in above expectations, a bearish figure, and wheat was close to expectations.
Source: Allendale Inc.
54
Reproduction or use of the text or pictorial content in any manner without written permission is prohibited.
Copyright 2008 by Futures Magazine Group, 222 S. Riverside Plaza, Suite 620, Chicago, IL 60606
MANAGED MONEY
The amount of money allocated to alternative investments, particularly hedge
funds and managed futures programs, has grown immensely over the last
decade but unfortunately and it is unfortunate most retail sized investors
do not have access to these alternatives.
56
A BETTER ALTERNATIVE
The S&P Diversified Trends Indicator has similar returns to equities with less risk.
S&P DTI
S&P 500
Lehman Bond index
Returns from 1985-2007
11.50%
12.83
8.55%
STD 1985-2007
5.95
14.69
4.29
Sharpe Ratio 1985-2007
1.43
0.67
1.29
Source: Rydex
PORT IN A STORM
Both the S&P DTI and the Barclay CTA index show why managed futures are such a good
diversifier. Here is what they do in the S&P 500s five worst performing months.
10.00%
5.00%
0.00%
-5.00%
-10.00%
S&P 500
-15.00%
S&P DTI
-20.00%
-25.00%
Oct 1987
Aug 1998
Sep 2002
Feb 2001
Aug 1990
57
182
152
122
95
68
2003
2004
2005
2006
Feb 2008
Note: Programs include some public commodity pools and private funds.
Source: Barclay Hedge
58
Gallwas says.
Our goal is to get people into diversified products, Gallwas says. RJO
does this by creating portfolios with a
diversified group of CTAs. But even
this is bringing them to the high end.
Gallwas says that the minimum investment for a group of CTAs would be
$250,000. While not traditional retail,
the vast majority of CTAs have minimums of several hundred thousand, so
he is serving a niche.
Peregrine Financial Group also is
trying to fill that niche and is actively
searching out emerging CTAs with
lower minimums, says Russ Wasendorf
Sr. We are able to take these CTAs
and give them proprietary capital to
develop their track records,
says Wasendorf.
PFG runs contests for emerging
CTAs that reward them with allocations. The goal is to build low barrier
to entry products, Wasendorf says.
The purpose of regulation, especially
on the retail side, is to protect John Q.
Public from unscrupulous players
attempting to take advantage of less
sophisticated investors. While a noble
goal, it is one that has failed. A simple
perusal of CFTC enforcement actions
will indicate that there is no shortage
of bad apples out there. And some may
suggest these onerous rules have served
to protect powerful interests to the
detriment of retail investors, who as a
result have less diversified portfolios.
The good news is that while they are
more difficult to find, there are alternative products that retail investors can
access to diversify their portfolios.
However, those attempting to offer
alternative investment products to retail
have to go through a gauntlet of regulators and retail investors, and ironically
must be much more sophisticated and
industrious to find these products than
the supposedly more sophisticated high
net worth individuals.
FM
Funds Review
Date
started
Trading advisor(s)
U.S. CLOSED
Name of fund
Trading advisor(s)
Date
started
Multiple Advisors
Mar-95
1000 -0.71%
0.48%
Multiple managers
Jan -96
1000
-1.99%
3.17%
Apr-94
1000 -0.22%
0.74%
Multiple managers
Jan -94
1000
-2.52%
6.13%
Marathon FX
Multiple Advisors
Jan-98
1000
0.17%
1.24%
SSARIS
Feb -90
1000
-2.19%
-2.27%
Jan-00
1000 -0.60%
1.39%
Mar-98
1000
1.39%
2.59%
Nov-94
10
-3.81%
3.61%
Multiple managers
Feb-99
1000
-4.20%
6.42%
Multiple Advisors
Apr-98
1000
-1.14%
5.10%
Multiple managers
Jun-99
1000
-1.98%
6.69%
Multiple managers
Jun-00
1000
-0.21%
7.17%
Multiple managers
May-03
1000
-2.46%
6.70%
975
6.31%
8.47%
Mar-04
1000
0.73%
7.67%
May-87
975
8.53%
14.84%
Sep-05
10
4.95%
7.83%
Nov-90
1000
-0.06%
17.62%
Multiple Advisors
Mar-95
1000
-0.74%
7.86%
Feb-91
1000
0.26%
17.74%
Multiple Advisors
Nov-94
10
-2.61%
8.90%
Apr-88
1000
0.20%
17.80%
Nov-94
1000
3.65%
8.96%
Sunrise; Graham
Jan-85
975
2.57%
17.95%
Dec-06
10
-1.68%
9.32%
Mar-99
10
1.08%
10.63%
Multiple Advisors
Aug-91 10
-1.48%
13.22%
Jul-95
1000
-9.98%
14.67%
J.W. Henry
Aug-97
1000
1.26%
31.88%
Oct-99
N/A
-2.99%
10.97%
Karin Kisling
Mar-04
100
-1.86%
-2.65%
Northfield International
Northfield Trading
Mar-91
10
3.65%
4.91%
Apr-05
100
-5.70%
5.26%
13.97%
72.67 -3.36%
17.20%
1000
23.50%
U.S. OPEN
SB Warrington Fund
Multiple managers
Feb-07
1000
1.67%
-3.16%
1000
1.35%
2.49%
Multiple Managers
Mar-02
100
-3.78%
5.99%
CMF Institutional
Multiple managers
Jan-06
1000
-3.22%
8.03%
Multiple Managers
Jun-02
1000
1.17%
9.42%
Multiple managers
Feb-07
1000
-1.39%
9.45%
Multiple Advisors
Dec-06
10
-2.57%
10.58%
1000
3.99%
14.15%
Oct-97
1000
-0.67%
-0.78%
SSARIS
Nov-94
10
-3.60%
-0.77%
MS Charter Campbell
Oct-02
10
-0.36%
0.45%
OFFSHORE
May-02
3.51%
The following fund has the following cash distribution, which should be added to the funds current value to get a true picture of the funds
actual returns since beginning trading.
Fund: Hutton Investors II
Total: $200
59
TRADE TRENDS
60
that meant utilizing clearing as a revenue stream and allowing users to have
direct electronic access to the markets
on a near 24-hour basis.
SETTING THE STAGE
The Common Clearing Links advantages are vast but can be summarized by
stressing the one word: single, said
CBOT Chairman Charles P. Carey of
the historic clearing link between the
CBOT and CME in his July 10, 2003
Mid-year Chairmans Report. The new
Common Clearing Link helps assure
benefits for CBOT customers, members
and member firms via a simplified clearing system that combines a single point
of collateral management; a single location for positions; a single risk management platform; a single clearing interface; and a single guarantee fund. And
for customers, the CME Group says the
savings have been profound.
We looked at the capital savings of
bringing the two markets together, and
that figure is north of a billion dollars
that we have been able to save our
clients from a capital standpoint, says
Rick Redding, managing director of
products and services for CME Group.
Up and comers
C
61
CBOE: Unbowed
W
team that is dedicated, from our technical support arena, to making sure that
these thousands of user sessions are
properly aligned to garner that performance efficiency.
And so far, the system has remained
stable, even with the increase in trading volumes. There havent been any
significant drop downs to note, says
Boyd Cruel, analyst for Alaron Futures
and Options. There were days the
eCBOT system would go down and
wed have to go straight to the pit.
Integration of the trading floor
also was moved forward, and was
scheduled to begin on April 7 for equity indexes, April 28 for interest rates
and foreign exchange, and May 12 for
commodities.
They have had a half-dozen meetings for our market. And they are
doing it in a very orderly and thought
out way, says Kevin P. Hubbell, a
partner at Bear Brokerage. He says that
traders in the Eurodollar options pit
have visited the new trading floor and
that the few complaints he heard were
related to the physical space and limited to sightlines and angles, nothing
62
corn and soybeans are much more global in nature than CME legacy commodity products, such as cattle and hogs.
And thats very important. Thats very
strategic for us to help globalize our
product base and globalize our market,
he adds. Another example would be an
international client who was buying or
hedging with CBOT U.S. Treasuries
products. That trader could benefit
from having CME interest rate products, such as the Eurodollars, on the
same platform, which could result in
new trading strategies.
The CME Group is aggressively
extending itself through international
projects, like the recent equity swap
with The Brazilian Mercantile &
Futures Exchange, which includes
order routing, offshore collateral management and super-clearing membership. CME Group also has proposed a five-year agreement to list
KOSPI 200 futures contracts on
Globex and has offered a super-clearing membership and access to CME
foreign exchange and interest rate
products to the China Foreign
Exchange Trade System.
COMING SOON
The CME began hosting New York
Mercantile Exchange (Nymex) energy
and Comex metals contracts on
Globex in the second quarter of 2006,
and since then Nymex has had six
consecutive record volume quarters.
If CME Group successfully acquires
Nymex, it would do more than add
the extremely valuable energy and
metals suites to their product mix.
They would pocket all of the transaction fees currently split with Nymex
and capture all of the clearing fees
that had been going to the Nymex
Clearing House. CME Group expects
$60 million annually in expense synergies from the merger, beginning 12
to 18 months from closing the deal.
And the deal is compelling on several
other fronts as well, helping CME
Groups plan to expand its share of
the over-the-counter (OTC) market
and feeding globalization efforts.
The OTC market is huge, and
Nymex is a big player in those markets.
According to the Bank for
International Settlements (BIS), at the
end of June 2007, the notional value of
63
SIZE MATTERS
Volume at the CME Group dwarfs all others, including
cap, which traded 1.9 billion contracts in 2007.
2007
CME Group
2,804,998,291
Korea Exchange
2,709,140,423
Eurex
1,899,861,926
Liffe
949,025,452
Chicago Board Options Exchange
945,608,219
International Securities Exchange
804,347,677
Bolsa de Mercadorias & Futuros
426,363,492
Philadelphia Stock Exchange
407,972,525
National Stock Exchange of India
379,874,850
Bolsa de Valores de So Paulo
367,690,283
New York Mercantile Exchange
353,385,412
NYSE Arca Options
335,838,547
JSE (South Africa)
329,642,403
American Stock Exchange
240,383,466
Mexican Derivatives Exchange
228,972,029
IntercontinentalExchange
195,706,040
Dalian Commodity Exchange
185,614,913
OMX Group
142,510,375
Boston Options Exchange
129,797,339
Australian Securities Exchange
116,090,973
Total
13,952,824,635
% Change
26.97%
9.48%
24.44%
29.95%
40.05%
35.88%
50.36%
49.39%
95.32%
27.88%
27.97%
70.84%
213.80%
21.99%
-16.80%
39.51%
54.23%
15.70%
37.51%
15.43%
28.30%
* Note: Ranking does not include exchanges that do not report their volume to the FIA. Exchanges under common
ownership are grouped together.
Source: Futures Industry Assoc.
64
THE CRITICS
Some traders are cheering at the
prospective efficiencies that would
come to the futures markets, including
presumably lower clearing costs and
cross margining opportunities. But a
group of New York based investment
banks and technology firms have
teamed up and plan to create a competitor: the Electronic Liquidity
Exchange (ELX). The backers of the
ELX are formidable and include
JPMorgan, Merrill Lynch & Co.,
Citadel Investment Group, eSpeed
Inc., Bank of America, Credit Suisse,
Barclays Plc, Citigroup Inc., Deutsche
Bank AG, GETCO LLC, PEAK6 and
Royal Bank of Scotland Group.
Although a headquarters and CEO
have yet to be chosen for the
exchange, it is widely expected that
the first contracts to be listed will be
U.S. Treasury futures.
Another threat may prove to be
Nymex members, who have filed law-
Dateline
SPONSORED BY:
M AY
MONDAY
30
29
28
WEDNESDAY
TUESDAY
FRIDAY
THURSDAY
2
Employment
Crop summary
12
13
UK merchandise trade
19
26
20
14
27
Australia employment,
Germany production index,
merchandise trade
15
Cotton ginnings,
merchandise trade, Canada
employment, France
production index
16
Cattle on feed, France
employment
22
21
23
Canada CPI
28
Crop summary
Livestock slaughter
29
30
C O N T R A C T D AT E S
1 LTD: CME Frozen pork bellies OF, Butter OF, BM&F Alcohol OF
4 LTD: CBOT Ethanol F
6 LTD: ICE Futures US Cotton F
8 LTD: CME Currencies OF, Mexican Peso OF, BM&F Alcohol F, Jun Arabica
coffee OF, Jun Conillon coffee OF
11 LTD: ICE Futures US Orange juice F, Euronext-Liffe Milling wheat F
12 LTD: Nymex Jun Russian Export Blend Crude Oil F
13 LTD: CBOT Corn F, Oats F, Rough Rice F, SA Soybeans F, Soybean Meal
F, Soybean Oil F, Soybeans F, Wheat F, Mini corn F, Mini soybeans F, Mini
wheat F, CME Lean Hogs F, OF, KCBT Wheat F, MGEX Wheat F, Nymex Jun
Brent crude F, DCE No. 1 Soybeans F, No. 2 Soybeans F, Corn F, Soybean
meal F, Soybean Oil F, Euronext-Liffe Cocoa F, WCE Canola F, Feed Wheat
F, Western Barley F
14 LTD: CME Eurozone Index of Consumer Prices F, Diammonium Phosphate
F, Lumber F, Urea F, ICE Futures US Cocoa F, BM&F Corn OF, Feeder cattle OF,
Eurex SMI, SLI O, Italian Single Stock F, O, Euronext-Liffe Jun Corn OF
15 LTD: KCBT Value Line OF, Nymex London Copper Grade A F, London
Primary Aluminium F, London SHG Zinc F, BM&F Gold O, Jun Soybeans OF,
Eurex OMXH 25 O, Stoxx 50 O, Titans O, Single Stock F, O, Euronext-Liffe
American style stock O, Cac 40 F,OF, TGE Soybean meal F, Coffee F
18 LTD: CME Currencies F, Mexican Peso F, Euroyen Libor F, OF, China
Renminbi/Euro F, OF, China Renminbi/Yen F, OF, Chinese Renminbi F, OF,
BM&F Jun Soybeans F
66
19 LTD: CFE Volatility Index F, CME Butter F, ICE Futures US Coffee F, Nymex
Jun Light sweet crude oil F, Jun Gulf Coast Gasoline F, Jun Gulf Coast Ultra
Low Sulfur Diesel F, BM&F Corn F
20 LTD: BM&F Arabica coffee F, JSE White Maize F, Wheat F, Sunflower Seeds F
21 LTD: CME Feeder cattle F,OF
22 LTD: CBOT Jun 30-yr. treasury bond OF, CME Housing Index F, KCBT Jun
Wheat OF, MGEX Jun Wheat OF, Nymex Uranium F, Eurex Bobl OF, Bund OF,
Schatz OF, Buxl OF, CONF OF, Euronext-Liffe Feed Wheat F, Tocom Jun
Gasoline F, Jun Kerosene F
25 LTD: Nymex Jun Singapore Fuel Oil 380 Swap F, Tocom Rubber F
26 LTD: CBOT Jun 100 oz. Gold OF, CME Frozen pork bellies F, Nymex Jun
Natural gas F, TGE Azuki F, Raw Silk F, Vegetable F
27 LTD: CBOT Silver F, Mini Silver F, Nymex Palladium F, Platinum OF, Silver
OF, Copper OF, Gold OF, Aluminum OF
28 LTD: CME Milk F,OF, Class IV Milk F, OF, Mid-size Milk O, Nonfat Dry Milk
F, OF, Cash-settled Butter F, Dry Whey F, Nymex PJM Electricity F
29 LTD: CBOT 30-Day Fed Funds F, OF, Ethanol forward month swap F, CME
Jun Real F,OF, Jun Ethanol F, MGEX HWI/NCI/NSI F,OF, Nymex Jun Heating oil
F, Jun Gasoline F, Jun New York Harbor Ultra Low Sulfur Diesel F, BM&F Jun
Euro F, Jun Gold F, Jun IDI O, Jun US dollar F,O,OF, Jun Ethanol F, Conillon
coffee F, Feeder cattle F, Live cattle F, Live cattle OF, Mini Live cattle F,
Euronext-Liffe Robusta coffee F, Tocom Jun Gold OF
30 LTD: Nymex Jun Propane F
JUNE
MONDAY
WEDNESDAY
TUESDAY
12
13
Employment, Canada
employment, France
merchandise trade, Germany
production index
10
11
17
16
18
23
24
Crop summary
Australia merchandise
trade
Australia employment
19
Canada CPI
25
2
20
Traders Expo Los Angeles, Ontario Convention Center, Ontario, CA, June 18-21.
Canada PPI, France PPI,
Japan production index,
employment, CPI, UK
balance of payments
NIBA 2008 Conference,
Chicago, June 28.
26
27
Managed Funds Association Forum 2008, The Fairmont Chicago, June 23-25.
30
FRIDAY
THURSDAY
ABOUT THE CALENDAR Dates are believed to be correct but sometimes do change. Holidays may affect government offices or banks
but not trading. Check with your broker or the exchange. Reports are U.S. reports unless indicated otherwise. Contracts traded are for
current month unless indicated. Abbreviations used with contracts: F futures. OF options on futures. O options. LTD last trading day. FND first notice day. LND last notice day.
CBOT
T-bonds/10-yr.
T-notes/inflation-indexed
Treasuries F..........................-........6/18
T-bonds/5-,2-yr.
T-notes/inflation-indexed
Treasuries F..........................-........6/29
Rough Rice F ..................5/13 ............SA Soybeans F ................5/13 ............Soybean Meal F ..............5/13 ............Soybean Oil F ..................5/13 ............-
CFE
Volatility Index F..............5/19........6/16
Variance F ............................-........6/18
CME
Currencies F....................5/18........6/15
Ethanol F............................5/4..........6/3
Currencies OF ..................5/8..........6/5
Ethanol forward
month swap F ................5/29........6/29
ICE Futures US
Gasoline F ............................-........5/29
KCBT
Wheat OF ..............................-........5/22
Palladium F ....................5/27........6/25
Platinum OF ....................5/27........6/25
MGEX
Propane F ............................-........5/30
Silver OF ..........................5/27........6/25
Wheat OF ..............................-........5/22
Copper OF........................5/27........6/25
HWI/NCI/NSI F,OF............5/29........6/29
Gold OF ............................5/27........6/25
Aluminum OF ..................5/27........6/25
Uranium F........................5/22........6/29
Nymex
Brent crude F........................-........5/13
Light sweet crude oil F........-........5/19
67
Dateline continued
Grain outlook
AD INDEX
ADVERTISER
PAGE
ADVERTISER
PAGE
Alaron . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .c3
Alpari . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .16
Buytherumorsellthefact.com . . . . . . .19, 65
Interactive Brokers . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .9
CBOE . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .23
KRX . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .c2
Lind Waldock . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .3
Market Technologies . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .15
Nymex . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .21
ODL . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .47
PFGBest.com . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .51
Puretick . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .39
Gain . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .43
TradeStation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .4-5
SEE CLASSIFIED ADVERTISING ON PAGES 7073
EVENTS COMING UP
Visit the Web sites listed for more information. For other seminars, see the classifieds on pages 70-73.
Futures I-Trade Show. MAY 6-7, 2008. Online
and free. Visit www.futuresmag.com to register.
Beyond Black-Scholes:
Option pricing models
Well take a fresh look at option
pricing models, and show what
futures traders can learn from
options on those contracts.
Capturing short-term
swings in Nasdaq futures
We will discuss how and when
setups for short-term price swings in
the E-mini Nasdaq can be used for
greatest profit.
Soybeans OF ........................-........5/15
Bund F ..................................-..........6/5
Schatz F ................................-..........6/5
Equities O..............................-........6/19
BM&F
Buxl F ....................................-..........6/5
Ibovespa F ............................-........6/17
CONF F ..................................-..........6/5
Mini-Ibovespa F ..................-........6/17
Dax F ....................................-........6/19
TGE
IBrX-50 F ..............................-..........6/1
OMXH 25 F ............................-........6/19
Azuki F ............................5/26........6/24
Stoxx 50 F ............................-........6/19
Euro F....................................-........5/29
Titans F..................................-........6/19
Soybeans F ..........................-........6/12
OMXH 25 O ......................5/15........6/19
IDI O ......................................-........5/29
Stoxx 50 O........................5/15........6/19
Cac 40 F,OF......................5/15........6/19
Titans O............................5/15........6/19
EuroMTS Eurozone
Sugar OF ..............................-........6/12
Vegetable F......................5/26........6/24
Alcohol F............................5/8..........6/8
MTS Deutschland
Tocom
Rubber F..........................5/25........6/23
Eurex
Alcohol OF..........................5/1..........6/1
Bobl OF ............................5/22........6/22
Euronext-Liffe
Bund OF ..........................5/22........6/22
Schatz OF ........................5/22........6/22
JSE
Alumunum F ........................-........6/24
Buxl OF ............................5/22........6/22
Gasoline F ............................-........5/22
Corn OF............................5/14........6/12
CONF OF ..........................5/22........6/22
Corn F....................................-..........6/4
Kerosene F ..........................-........5/22
Soybeans F ..........................-........5/18
Bobl F....................................-..........6/5
Corn OF ................................-........5/14
DCE
68
WCE
Feed Wheat F ..................5/13 ............-
Gold F....................................-........5/29
Ethanol F ..............................-........5/29
212-660-6128
ibpartners@gfsforex.com
www.GFSforex.com
GFS Forex & Futures, Inc. is a Registered Futures
Commission Merchant (FCM) with the Commodity
Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) and is a
member of the National Futures Association (NFA).
Forex trading involves high risks, with the
potential for substantial losses and is not
suitable for all investors.
FCMs! For advertising details contact: Jean Berger 312-846-4626 or email: jberger@futuresmag.com
70
Classifieds
INTRODUCING BROKER
DIRECTORY
Are you looking for a new broker?
Look no further, our new IB
directory will help you find the
right broker to meet your needs.
For more information on how to be
listed in our new IB directory
contact Jean Berger at
312-846-4626 or
email: jberger@futuresmag.com
Advisory Services
Trade with todays most
accurate S&P daytrader.
Our Seventh Year!
Free trial and Nightly Report. 888-231-4702
P a g e Tr a d e r. c o m
www.futuresmag.com | May 2008
71
Classifieds
Advisory Services
Brokerage Services
Discount Brokerage
Trade ALL Futures Online!
www.ExpressFutures.com
Low Discount Rates!
Educational Services
Charting Services
Database Services
www.scalptrader.net
Brokerage Services
Attention Option Traders!
Commission Rates as low as $9!
Trade Confidently with former CME
Options Specialist
Trade Electronically or Direct to the Floor
No Monthly Quota
At Lakefront, our brokers understand your
option strategies no matter how complex.
Call us today at 888-748-8122 or visit us at
www.lakefrontfutures.com.
Futures trading is not suitable for all investors
Daytrading
Our 6th Year of Daytrading Profits!
RJ will teach you to follow the smart money.
Learn a simple, exact S&P e-mini signal.
RobertJacksEmini.com
Discount Brokerage
Trade Futures & Options Online
with Field Financial Group
72
Educational Services
Trading Systems
Hosting Services
SP500guru.com
http://hosting.fptrade.com
www.DayTradingCourse.com
Precise, Simple, & Profitable Trading System
KeyTurningDates.com
New Release "The Trading Method That
Can Make You Rich" by Roy Kelly
www.trendpro.com
Professional Services
ATTORNEY
Commodities Litigation / Appeals & More
866-543-2818 thmpson@pacbell.net
Real Estate
Want to purchase minerals and other
oil/gas interests. Send details to:
P.O. Box 13557, Denver, CO. 80201
www.SystemRank.com
Software
Trading Seminars
www.LibertyOption.com
(futures trading involves risk of loss)
73
Trader Profile
BY STEVE ZWICK
74