Scribd Logo
Upload

Welcome to Scribd!

  • 1st Exam Conflict Case Outline

    Uploaded by

    posh cb
    33 views3 pages
    preliminaries conflicts of law

    Copyright

    © © All Rights Reserved

    Available Formats

    DOC, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd

    Did you find this document useful?

    Is this content inappropriate?

    Report this Document
    preliminaries conflicts of law

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as DOC, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Flag for inappropriate content
    33 views3 pages

    1st Exam Conflict Case Outline

    Uploaded by

    posh cb
    preliminaries conflicts of law

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as DOC, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Flag for inappropriate content
    of 3

    CONFLICT OF LAWS

    1st Exam Case Outline


    Atty. Melissa Romana P. Suarez
    I. Basic Principles
    Topic
    In General

    Case Title
    Saudi Arabian Airlines v. CA

    Citation
    297 SCRA 469

    GR
    122191

    Date
    8 Oct 1998

    Citation
    297 SCRA 469

    GR
    122191
    149177

    Date
    8 Oct 1998
    Nov 23, 2007

    297 SCRA 469


    241 SCRA 192
    252 SCRA 92
    296 SCRA 539
    333 SCRA 545
    401 SCRA 762
    425 SCRA 98

    122191
    112573
    108538
    128803
    121576
    150656
    127692
    140288
    156848
    168747

    8 Oct 1998
    9 Feb 1995
    22 Jan 1996
    25 Sep 1998
    16 Jun 2000
    29 Apr 2003
    10 Mar 2004
    23 Oct 2006
    Oct 11, 2007
    Oct 19, 2007

    380 SCRA
    266 SCRA 554
    435 SCRA 246
    427 SCRA 593

    138104
    113074
    159586
    154618
    156848

    11 Apr 2002
    23 Jan 1997
    26 Jul 2004
    14 Apr 2004
    Oct 11, 2007

    133876

    29 Dec 1999

    120077
    141536
    156848
    162894
    149177

    13 Oct 2000
    26 Feb 2001
    Oct 11, 2007
    26 Feb 2008
    23 Nov 2007
    11 Oct 2007
    2003
    1997

    II. Jurisdiction
    Topic

    Case Title

    In General

    Saudi Arabian Airlines v. CA


    Hasegawa v. Kitamura

    How
    jurisdiction
    acquired

    Saudi Arabian Airlines v. CA


    Northwest Orient v. CA
    Valmonte v. CA
    Asiavest v. CA
    Banco du Brazil v. CA
    Romualdes v. Licaros
    Gomez v. CA
    St. Aviation v. Grand Air
    Pioneer v. Guadiz
    Regner v. Logarta

    MR Holdings v. Bajar
    Foreign
    corporations Hahn v. CA and BMW

    European v. Ingenieuburo Birkhan


    Agilent v. Integrated Silicon
    Pioneer v. Guadiz

    Exceptions
    to Comity

    Cadalin v. POEA
    Pakistani Airlines v. Ople
    Bank of America v. American Realty

    238 SCRA 721


    190 SCRA 90
    321 SCRA 659

    Forum Non- Manila Hotel v. NLRC


    Conveniens Puyat v. Zabarte

    Pioneer v. Guadiz
    Raytheon v. Rouzie
    Hasegawa v. Kitamura
    Pioneer Concrete v. Judge Guadiz
    Bank of America v. CA
    Philsec Investment v. CA

    524 SCRA 153


    400 SCRA 156
    274 SCRA 102

    III. Choice of Law


    Topic
    Choice of
    Law

    Proof of
    foreign law

    Case Title
    Saudi Arabian Airlines v. CA
    Philippine Export v. Eusebio
    Crescent v. M/V Lok Maheswari
    LWV Construction v. Dupo
    Deutsche v. CA
    ATCI v. Echin

    Williamette v. Muzzal
    CIR v. Fisher
    PCIB v. Escolin
    Laureano v. CA
    Yao Kee v. Sy-Gonzales
    Wildvalley v. CA
    In re Estate of Suntay
    Dumez Company v. NLRC
    Asiavest v. CA
    Benedicto v. CA
    Manufacturers Hanover v. Guerrero
    ATCI v. Echin

    Northwest Airlines v. CA
    Processual
    Presumption Laureano v. CA

    Citation
    297 SCRA 469
    474 SCRA 623
    585 SCRA 150

    Cadalin v. POEA
    Pakistani Airlines v. Ople
    Bank of America v. American Realty

    Date
    8 Oct 1998
    13 Jul 2004
    11 Nov 2005
    13 Jul 2009
    2009
    11 Oct 2010

    61 PHIL 471
    Jan 28, 1961
    56 SCRA 265
    324 SCRA 414
    167 SCRA 736
    342 SCRA 213
    258 SCRA 564
    296 SCRA 539
    364 SCRA 334
    397 SCRA 709

    74495
    128803
    125359
    136804
    178551

    31 Jul 1952
    11 Jul 1996
    25 Sep 1998
    4 Sep 2001
    19 Feb 2003
    11 Oct 2010

    241 SCRA 192


    324 SCRA 414

    112573

    9 Feb 1995

    140047
    145587

    13 Jul 2004
    26 Oct 2007

    104776

    5 Dec 1994

    133876

    29 Dec 1999

    Philippine Export v. Eusebio


    EDI-Staffbuilders v. NLRC

    Exceptions
    to Comity

    GR
    122191
    140047
    155014
    172342
    178551

    238 SCRA 721


    190 SCRA 90
    321 SCRA 659

    IV. Recognition and Enforcement of Foreign Judgments


    Topic
    W/N to
    enforce or
    recognize
    foreign
    judgment

    Case Title
    Nagarmull v. Binalbagan
    Northwest Airlines v. CA
    Philsec Investment v. CA
    Asiavest v. CA
    Philippine Aluminum v. FASGI
    Manufacturers Hanover v. Guerrero
    St. Aviation v. Grand Air
    Korea Technologies v. Lerma
    Corpus v. Sto. Tomas
    Landoil v. Al Rabiah

    Citation
    33 SCRA 41
    241 SCRA 192
    274 SCRA 102
    296 SCRA 539
    342 SCRA 722
    397 SCRA 709
    542 SCRA 1

    GR
    L-22470
    112573
    103493
    128803
    114323
    136804
    140288
    143581
    186571
    174720

    Date
    28 May 1970
    9 Feb 1995
    19 Jun 1997
    25 Sep 1998
    12 Oct 2000
    19 Feb 2003
    23 Oct 2006
    07 Jan 2008
    11 Aug 2010
    11 Sep 2011

    Procedure

    Philippines International v. CA
    Oil & Natural Gas v. CA
    Puyat v. Zabarte
    Mijares v. Ranada
    Dacasin v. Dacasin
    Corpus v. Sto. Tomas

    172 SCRA 810


    293 SCRA 96
    352 SCRA 738
    455 SCRA 397

    141536
    139325
    168785
    186571

    26 Feb 2001
    12 Apr 2005
    05 Feb 2010
    11 Aug 2010

    V. Nature and Characterization of Conflicts Rules


    Topic

    Case Title
    Gibbs v. Government
    Cadalin v. POEA
    Saudi Arabian Airlines v. CA

    Citation
    59 PHIL 293
    238 SCRA 721
    297 SCRA 469

    GR
    104776
    122191

    Date
    5 Dec 1994
    8 Oct 1998

    You might also like