Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Introduction
Higher order thinking skills include critical, logical, reflective, metacognitive, and creative
thinking. They are activated when individuals encounter unfamiliar problems, uncertainties,
questions, or dilemmas. Successful applications of the skills result in explanations,
decisions, performances, and products that are valid within the context of available
knowledge and experience and that promote continued growth in these and other
intellectual skills. Higher order thinking skills are grounded in lower order skills such as
discriminations, simple application and analysis, and cognitive strategies and are linked to
prior knowledge of subject matter content. Appropriate teaching strategies and learning
environments facilitate their growth as do student persistence, self-monitoring, and openminded, flexible attitudes. An important but challenging part of mathematics teaching is
providing students with opportunities to engage in Higher Order Thinking. These include
students asking thoughtful questions, participating in student-student and student-teacher
substantiate conversations, applying existing knowledge, understanding and skills to
closed and open problems or investigations and learning activities that deepen
understanding of concepts.
HOTS REPORT
BLOOMS TAXONOMY
One of the most important aspects of setting tasks and asking questions is to know what
level of thinking you are requiring from your students.
In 1958, Benjamin Bloom created his thinking taxonomy for categorizing the level of
abstraction of questions that commonly occur in the classroom.
Remember
Understand
Apply
Analyze
Evaluate
Design
HOTS REPORT
HOTS REPORT
HOTS REPORT
future use. Today information grows exponentially and therefore individuals need to learn
to navigate all this information. Many educators believe that detailed knowledge will not
be as significant to tomorrow's workers and citizens as the ability to learn and make sense
of new information. According to Resnick (1987) all individuals, not just the elite, have
the ability to become adept at thinking.
Education Reform
It is a notion that students must master the lower level skills before they can engage in
higher order thinking. However, the National Research Council objected to this line of
reasoning, saying that cognitive research challenges that assumption, and that higher order
thinking is important even in elementary school. Including higher order thinking skills in
learning outcomes is a very common feature of standards based education reform.
Many forms of education reform, such as inquiry-based science, reform mathematics and
whole language emphasize HOTS to solve problems and learn, sometimes deliberately
omitting direct instruction of traditional methods, facts, or knowledge. HOTS assumes
standards based assessments that use open-response items instead of multiple choice
questions, and hence require higher order analysis and writing. Critics of standards based
assessments point out that this style of testing is even more difficult for students who are
behind academically. The Texas Republican Party expressed their opposition to the
teaching of certain HOTS by including the following item in their 2012 Party Platform:
"Knowledge-Based Education We oppose the teaching of Higher Order Thinking Skills
(HOTS) (values clarification), critical thinking skills and similar programs that are simply
a relabeling of Outcome-Based Education (OBE) (mastery learning) which focus on
behavior modification and have the purpose of challenging the students fixed beliefs and
undermining parental authority."
HOTS REPORT
Definition of Thinking
The second edition of the dictionary hall states think is working with brain to make a
decision. According to the fourth edition of the dictionary hall, thinking is to use common
sense to solve something. According to Fraenkel, JR, 1980, however, states that thinking
is the formation of ideas, remodeling experience and organizing information in a particular
form. According to Nickerson, Perkins and Smith, 1985, think is a collection of skills or
mental operations used by an individual. According to Beyer, BK, 1991 defines thinking
as the human ability to form concepts, to reason, or to make the determination.
Different Types of Thinking
Critical thinking is the term that most people associate with higher-order thinking skills
and is characterized by careful analysis and judgment. According to the National Council
for Excellence in Critical Thinking (Scriven and Paul 1987), Critical thinking is selfguided, self-disciplined thinking which attempts to reason at the highest level of quality in
a fair-minded way. People who think critically consistently attempt to live rationally,
reasonably, empathically. In other words, when a critical thinker is posed with a problem,
his or her learning is prompted. The thinker is committed to thinking logically about a topic
and refuse to jump a conclusions. He or she struggles to put away the biases that come so
naturally and endeavors to look at a situation in a new way so that it can be analyzed and
evaluated in a logical manner. And, the thinker reflects on what he or she learned. John
Dewey (1916) described reflective thinking as an active, persistent, and careful review of
something that is believed. The active learner does not just accept information passively;
he or she looks for evidence to support the information. If no evidence is found, the piece
of information cannot be believed. Instead of being told what to think, a person must think
for himself or herself and give good cause for the conclusions that are reached. Reflective
thinking is critical thinking. It is taking control of learning and being continually conscious
and committed to asking why.
Creative thinking is also a higher-order thinking skill and is equally as important as critical
thinking. In the book Curriculum 21: Essential Education for a Changing World, Heidi
Hayes Jacobs (2010) says that curriculum should go beyond giving tools for reasonable
and logical thinking. Curriculum should also nurture creativity in all learners. Inventing
HOTS REPORT
and synthesizing characterize creative thinking. Create means to bring something valuable
into existence that was not there previously. It is the process or bringing about a new idea.
Michael Michalko (2006), author of Thinker toys: A Handbook of creative-Thinking
Techniques, says, Creativity is not an accident, not something that is genetically
determined. It is not a result of some easily learned magic trick or secret, but a consequence
of your intention to be creative and your determination to learn and use creative-thinking
strategies (Introduction XVII). Creative thinking is active work.
Convergent/Analytical thinking involves bringing facts and data together from various
sources and then applying logic and knowledge to solve problems or to make informed
decisions. Convergent thinking involves putting a number of different pieces or
perspectives of a topic back together in some organized, logical manner to find a single
answer. The deductive reasoning that the Sherlock Homes used in solving mysteries is a
good example of convergent thinking. By gathering various bits of information, he was
able to put the pieces of a puzzle together and come up with a logical answer to the question
of Who done it?
Fact
Fact
Fact
Answer
Fact
Fact
Fact
HOTS REPORT
Divergent / Creative thinking, on the other hand, involves breaking a topic apart to explore
its various component parts and then generating new ideas and solutions. Divergent
Thinking is thinking outwards instead of inward. It is a creative process of developing
original and unique ideas and then coming up with a new idea or a solution to a problem.
Inductive thinking is the process of reasoning from parts to the whole, from examples to
generalizations. This type of thinking is something we are rather good at, especially as it is
our main mechanism for learning about the world. According to S. Ian Robertson (2013)
Inductive thinking refers to the extent to which we can make reasonable generalizations
from our specific experiences. This thinking is an extremely powerful thinking mechanism
since it underpins almost all learning. It allows you to learn fairly quickly to make new
types of inference that you have never made before.
Deductive thinking is the type of reasoning moves from the whole to its parts, from
generalizations to underlying concepts to examples. It is the process of reasoning from one
or more general statements regarding what is known to teach a logically certain conclusion
(Johnson-Laird, 2000). It often involves reasoning from one or more general statements
regarding what is known to a specific application of the general statement. This type of
thinking is based on logical propositions which is basically known as an assertion, which
may be either true or false. It is very useful because it helps people connect various
propositions to draw conclusion.
Closed questions are questions asked by teachers that have predictable responses. Closed
questions almost always require factual recall rather than higher levels of thinking. It is
involved a statement or question that followed by a rating scale. Robert D. Reid (2009)
said, closed questions provide a "don't know" or "no opinion" response where appropriate.
Closed question provides the respondent with options from which to select a response. It
is much easier to collect and analyze information in this type of question.
Open questions are questions that do not have predictable answers. Open questions almost
always require higher order thinking. Which is David C. Bojanic (2009) said, open question
does not provide the respondent with any options, categories, or scales to use in answering
this question. These questions ae valuable fo obtaining information for exploratory
research, o in instances when the researcher is not sure what the response might be. This
HOTS REPORT
type of questions are used to build a rapport and obtain information that is easy for the
respondent to provide.
Lateral Thinking Technique
A set of techniques used to stimulate creative or "out of the box" thinking. Applying lateral
thinking techniques is a deliberate strategy to interrupt normal, linear thought patterns, to
facilitate the transition between patterns, and to widen the range of possibilities.
Base on Edward DeBonos concepts of lateral thinking include the following
characteristics:
The
results
of
lateral
thinking
are
unpredictable
and/or
probabilistic.
Other techniques are available to stimulate creative or lateral thinking. These include
checklists, attribute analyses, games or exercises and metaphors and analogies.
The purpose of using lateral thinking technique is to stimulate creative thinking during
brainstorming, visioning, and reengineering sessions while helping project teams relate to
One another and affiliate. The benefit of using lateral thinking technique is that it stimulates
out of the box thinking in group sessions.
HOTS REPORT
10
HOTS REPORT
11
HOTS REPORT
12
HOTS REPORT
13
HOTS REPORT
Many students with higher order thinking challenges benefit from individual evaluation
and remediation by highly qualified professionals.
Make students your partners
A teacher should let the student with higher order thinking challenges know that they will
work together as partners to achieve increases in the student's skills. With this type of
relationship, often the student will bring very practical and effective strategies to the table
that the teacher may not have otherwise considered.
Examples of Question in HOTS
(a) Function and Decimal
1. How can I use fractions in real life?
2. How can decimals be rounded to the nearest whole number?
3. How can models be used to compute fractions with like and unlike denominators?
4. How can models help us understand the addition and subtraction of decimals?
14
HOTS REPORT
5. How many ways can we use models to determine and compare equivalent fractions?
6. How would you compare and order whole numbers, fractions and decimals through
hundredths?
7. How are common and decimal fractions alike and different?
8. What strategies can be used to solve estimation problems with common and
decimal fractions?
9. How are models used to show how fractional parts are combined or separated?
10. How do I identify and record the fraction of a whole or group?
11. How do I identify the whole?
12. How do I use concrete materials and drawings to understand and show
understanding of fractions (from 1/12ths to 1/2)?
13. How do I explain the meaning of a fraction and its numerator and denominator, and
use my understanding to represent and compare fractions?
14. How do I explain how changing the size of the whole affects the size or amount of
a fraction?
(b) Function and Algebra
1. Are patterns important in the world today?
2. What is the unknown?
3. Why do we use variables?
4. How can a variable transform itself?
5. How would you describe the order of operations?
6. What are the tools needed to solve linear equations and inequalities?
7. Are you able to solve a linear inequality by graphing?
8. When are algebraic and numeric expressions used?
9. How do we create, test and validate a model?
10. Do mathematical models conceal as much as they reveal?
11. What patterns or relationships do we see in each type of mathematics?
12. What are the different ways to represent the patterns or relationships?
13. What different interpretations can be obtained from a particular pattern or
relationship?
15
HOTS REPORT
16
HOTS REPORT
Differences between Higher Order Thinking Skills (HOTS) and Lower Order
Thinking Skills (LOTS)
Higher Order Thinking Skills (HOTS) is the ability to think beyond rote memorization of
facts or knowledge. Rote memory recall is not really thinking. Higher order thinking skills
involve actually doing something with the facts that we learn. When students use their
higher order thinking skills that means they understand, they can find connections between
many facts, they can put them together in new ways and they can manipulate them. Most
importantly they can apply them to find new solutions to problems.
Lower Order Thinking Skills (LOTS) is the foundation of skills required to move into
higher order thinking. These are skills that are taught very well in school systems and
includes activities like reading and writing. In lower order thinking information does not
need to be applied to any real.
There are several differences between HOTS and LOTS which are:
LOTS are used to understand the basic story line or literal meaning of a story ,play
or poem while HOTS are used to interpret a text on more abstract level and
manipulate information and ideas in ways that transform their meaning and
implications
HOTS can make the student to think more creatively and think out of the box while
LOTS , the student only think and just recall back on the topic that they had learnt.
17
HOTS REPORT
What is...?
18
HOTS REPORT
Level 3: Apply Solve problems by applying knowledge, facts, techniques and rules
in a unique way
List of key words:
Apply, Build, Choose, Construct, Demonstrate, Develop, Draw, Experiment with,
Illustrate, Interview, Make use of, Model, Organize, Plan, Select, Solve, Utilize
List of Question Starters:
Illustrate how the belief systems and values of the characters are presented in the
story.
19
HOTS REPORT
Do you believe...?
20
HOTS REPORT
What do you imagine would have been the outcome if... had made a different choice?
I-Think
I-Think is an education program that created by Malaysian Ministry of Education
together with Agensi Inovasi Malaysia (AIM). The aim of this program is to equip
Malaysias next generation of innovators to think critically and be adaptable in preparation
for the future. Besides, Thinking School International (TSI) team works together with
Malaysian government in I-Think project. TSI is a team established in 2010 and focused
on students thinking skills across the globe that are committed to develop 21st century
learning.
According to Richard Cummins (CEO of TSI) and Nick Symes (Global Trainer of
TSI), i-Think program has three main objectives:
Nurture and develop innovative human capital
Increase thinking skill amongst children
Equip future generations with Higher Order Thinking Skills
I-Think program is conducting in schools based on these objectives. I-Think program have
eight types of thinking maps. They are:
1. Circle Map
Thinking Process
: Defining in context
Aim
Key Question
21
HOTS REPORT
Design
Example
Journal
Algebra
Integration
Multiplication
Calculus
Topics in
Maths
Factorization
Statistics
Probability
Matrix
Percentage
Whole Number
Form 5 Text Book
22
KPM Website
HOTS REPORT
2. Bubble Map
Thinking Process
Aim
Key Question
Design
Example
Loving
Patience
Discipline
Clever
Maths
Teacher
Knowledgeable
Confident
Strict
23
Hardworking
HOTS REPORT
Aim
Key Question
Design
: In the center circle are the words for the two things
being compared and contrasted. In the middle bubbles,
use terms to show similarities. In the outside bubbles,
describe the differences. If there are too many
similarities or differences, student should prioritize and
keep only he most important.
Example
4 equal
side
2 sets of
parallel
side
All vertices
from right
and left
angle
24
No
right
angles
Sides
(4)
Square
Shapes
Vertices
(4)
Trapezoid
No
equal
sides
Only top
& bottom
sides
parallel
HOTS REPORT
4. Tree Map
Thinking Process
: Classifying
Aim
Key Question
Design
Example
1 = ( 2 )
1
2 1
=
1
2 1
+
=1
Equation in the
gradient form:
= +
25
Equation in general
form:
+ + = 0
HOTS REPORT
5. Brace Map
Thinking Process
Aim
Key Question
Design
Example
: Decomposing of RM 1.00
RM 0.05
RM 0.25
RM 0.10
RM 0.25
RM 1.00
RM 0.05
RM 0.25
RM 0.25
26
RM 0.10
RM 0.05
HOTS REPORT
6. Flow Map
Thinking Process
: Sequencing
Aim
Key Question
Design
Example
Identify the
number to be
rounded
Go to the right if
the number
If the number is
5 or greater,
increase the
number to be
rounded
If the number is
4 or less, do not
change the
number to be
rounded
27
HOTS REPORT
7. Multi-Flow Maps
Thinking Process
Aim
Key Question
Design
Example
Practice more
exercises
Create a study
group
28
Good Grades in
Mathematics
Award
HOTS REPORT
8. Bridge Map
Thinking Process
: Seeing analogies
Aim
Key Question
Design
: On the far left line, write the relating factor. On the top
and bottom of the bridge, write in the first pair of things
that have this relationship. On the right side of the
bridge, write the second pair with the same
relationship. The line of the bridge represents the
relating factor between the pair of things.
Example
: Coordinate plan
as
(+,+)
Quadrant III
Quadrant II
Quadrant I
as
(-,+)
Quadrant IV
as
(-,-)
(+,-)
Relating Factor: Any points located in _____________ will always have ________
coordinates.
29
HOTS REPORT
Conclusion
Thinking is the heart of all learning. Thinking makes things that have yet to be perceived
possible, thinking facilities and enhances our ability to perform and produce and pass on
such vital information to others who would then do the same. There many types of thinking,
students should choose the best method to solve their problem. Students need to make
significant academic gains only to catch up with other students and have more life
opportunities. One way to help students is to provide the opportunity to lead, engage, and
motivate students toward higher-order thinking. Malaysian Education System helps
students gain knowledge, but now we need a transformation create thinking generation.
With i-Think program, students will become lifelong learners, equipped with the right skill
sets to take on the challenges of the 21st century. As a conclusion, HOTS is an alternative
that can improve the Malaysia education quality and all parties must take part in order to
gain the best outcome of this program.
30