Professional Documents
Culture Documents
- It is estimated about 11.5 person-months of national consultant inputs and 0.8 person-months of international
consultant inputs will be required for stage I and 21.5 person-months of national consultant inputs and 1.2 personmonths of international consultant inputs for stage II;
Selection Method for Firms: Consultants' Qualifications Selection under ADB Guidelines.
Type of Proposal Requested from Firms: Biodata Technical Proposal.
Term of Payment: Output Based.
The procurement committee of Bappenas, invites eligible qualified Consultant Firms to provide the services of:
Transaction Advisory Services for Maros Water Supply Project
The Consultant Firms who has qualified for the projects should submit their EOI separately provided in hardcopy one
original EOI and two copies. The EOI should indicate their qualification to perform the services such as relevant
experience in last 5 years, qualification and competency of key personnel, company profile, legal document, etc, using
standard format. The format template for the EOI and the Term of Reference is available online at website:
www.irsdp.org.
The EOIs submitted will be evaluated on the following criteria: Eligibility of the consulting entity; Management
competence (weighting point: 30%); Technical Competence (weighting point: 60%); and Geographic competence
(weighting point: 10%).
Expression of Interest must be delivered to the address below by Monday 3 January 2011, at 16:00 hours.
Ir. Hari Kristijo, MSc. (Chairman of Procurement Committee for PHLN Projects, Bappenas)
Gedung Madiun Lt.Basement, Jl Taman Suropati No. 2, Telp : (62 - 21) 31931392
Jakarta 10310, INDONESIA.
Project Name
Project Country
I.
Eligibility
Declaration
We2 hereby declare that:
(i)
(ii)
(iii)
We further confirm that, if any of one or more of our experts is engaged to prepare TOR
for any ensuing assignment as part of our work product under the assignment to which
this advertisement relates, our firm and any such expert(s) will be disqualified from
short-listing and/or participation in such follow-on assignment.
CMS Registration Number:3
Lead Firm
Signed by:
Position :
Associate/Partner 1
Signed by:
Position :
Associate/Partner 2
Signed by:
Position4 :
3
4
This EOI template is applicable for ADB-TA, and serves as a strongly recommended guide for Executing
Agencies (EAs) for loan projects. For Consultants Qualification Selection (CQS) and Indefinite Delivery
Contracts (IDCs), where selection and pre-qualification respectively are based on an evaluation of an EOI, the
template may be amplified to reflect any requirement for additional information.
EOIs may be submitted by a firm, association, or a joint venture. For short-listing purposes, the combined
experience of an association or a joint venture will be evaluated although the qualifications of the lead firm will
be given a greater weight. Whereas the firm, association, or joint venture is free to submit additional
information, in hard or soft copy, short-listing will be based primarily on an evaluation of information included in
the EOI template.
CMS registration is not mandatory for the associated firms
Unless otherwise specified, an international firm, as a lead firm, associate or partner can only be nominated in
one EOI. A national firm as a lead firm can only be nominated in one EOI. A national firm as an associate or
partner can be nominated in more than one EOI. To avoid confusion and possible elimination after short-listing,
lead firms of associations or joint ventures are strongly advised to confirm relationships (exclusive or nonexclusive) with selected associates or partners prior to expressing interest.
InfrastructureReformSectorDevelopmentProjectLoanADBNo.2264INO(SF)
II.
Management Competence (Please answer each question in no more
than 10 sentences)
a.
Provide the name, qualifications and relevant experience of the lead firms
director or manager who will assume overall responsibility for the firms,
associations or joint ventures team coordination, management and output.
b.
If you are proposing an association or a joint venture, outline the rationale
for, and benefits to the assignment of, the arrangement.
c.
If you are proposing an association, or a joint venture, outline proposed
management coordination of the arrangement, including the role of each firm.
d.
Does your firm/association/joint venture have standard policies,
procedures or practices in place that promote quality in: the workplace, your
interaction with clients, and the outputs you produce? If yes, describe briefly.
e.
How will you ensure the quality of your firms/associations/join ventures
performance over the life of this assignment?
InfrastructureReformSectorDevelopmentProjectLoanADBNo.2264INO(SF)
f.
How will your firm/association/joint venture deal with any complaints
concerning the performance of the staff or the quality of the reports submitted for
this consulting assignment? What internal controls are in place to address and
resolve complaints?
g.
InfrastructureReformSectorDevelopmentProjectLoanADBNo.2264INO(SF)
III.
Technical Competence
Narrative Descriptions
With reference to the attached project sheets, and in the context of the assignments
TORs, summarize the relevant technical qualifications of your firm/association/joint
venture (maximum of 2 pages).
InfrastructureReformSectorDevelopmentProjectLoanADBNo.2264INO(SF)
IV.
Geographical Competence
InfrastructureReformSectorDevelopmentProjectLoanADBNo.2264INO(SF)
Appendix 1
Project Sheets
Indicate up to 10 reference projects from the past 5 years that the firm/association/joint
venture feels are relevant. You may refer to your Consultant Management System (CMS)
registration projects sheets for additional information.4
Project 1 of __
Project Name
Name of Client
Country
Participation
Value of Services
Source of Financing
Consultancy Services
(i) No. of staff
(ii) No. of person months
Length of Consultancy Assignment
Start Date
Completion Date
Name of Associate Firms (if any)
(dd/mm/yyyy)
(dd/mm/yyyy)
Applicable to TA only.
InfrastructureReformSectorDevelopmentProjectLoanADBNo.2264INO(SF)
Appendix 2
Additional Information
InfrastructureReformSectorDevelopmentProjectLoanADBNo.2264INO(SF)
REPUBLIC OF INDONESIA
TERMS OF REFERENCE
NOVEMBER 2010
TERMS OF REFERENCE
TRANSACTION ADVISORY SERVICES FOR
MAROS WATER SUPPLY PROJECT
TABLE OF CONTENTS
1
1.2
1.3
BACKGROUND .................................................................................................................... 7
1.4
1.5
1.6
1.7
1.8
BUDGET ................................................................................................................................ 26
ASSIGNMENT SCHEDULE................................................................................................... 27
TABLES
Table 1: Pre-Conditions to be satisfied prior to commencing Stage 2: Bid Implementation ........... 9
Table 2: Deliverable Items and Terms of Payment ....................................................................... 23
Table 3: Qualifications of Staff ...................................................................................................... 24
Table 4: Illustrative Staff Inputs ..................................................................................................... 25
Table 5: Budget Estimate for Services (US$) ............................................................................... 27
Term
Meaning
ADB
Bappeda
Bappenas
BKPM
BPPSPAM
BOT
CA
Cooperation Agreement
DGHS
ECA
EIRR
EOI
Expression of Interest
Facility
The Facility will comprise the intake, raw water transmission pumping station and
rising main, water treatment plant, service reservoir, trunk water mains, and
associated appurtenances
FBC
FIRR
GCA
GoI
Government of Indonesia
The term Final Business Case refers to the document which is defined and prepared as a deliverable
under Stage 1 of these Terms of Reference. The FBC document contains all information and
assessments which are required under the term Prastudi Kelayakan as defined in PerMen PPN/Head of
Bappenas 4/2010.
IDR
Indonesia Rupiah
IIGF
IIFF
IM
Information Memorandum
IRSDP
JICA
KKPPI
KPS
MLA
MoF
Ministry of Finance
NRW
Non-Revenue Water
OBC
P3CU
PDAM
PemKab
PII (PT)
PJPK
PPC
Project Preparation Consultant (PT Waseco Tirta and PT Multi Area Desentralisasi
Pembangunan)
PPP
Project
PSO
RFP
ROE
Return on Equity
RMU
SPAM
SMI (PT)
SPV
SOE
TAS
1
1.1
1. Bappenas, through the Project Development Facility (PDF) Steering Committee, has approved the
use of the PDF to fund the preparation for the Development of the Maros Water Supply Project under the
terms of this TOR. The PDF is part of the Infrastructure Reform Sector Development Project (IRSDP).
The Project Management Unit (PMU) responsible for the implementation of the IRSDP is seeking to
appoint consultants (henceforth the Consultant) to conduct the proposed further study and assist with the
subsequent bid implementation (henceforth the Transaction) in accordance with Perpres 67/2005 and
13/2010 and Bappenas Ministerial Regulation 3/2009. The project is categorized as a potential project.
2. The Government Contracting Authority (GCA) for the proposed Public Private Partnership (PPP)
project is the local government of Kabupaten Maros. The PemKab Maros will be responsible for
supervising and monitoring the performance of the Consultant through a technical team functioning as
the PPP Project Implementation Unit. The PMU-IRSDP will assist in the overall supervision and
monitoring on technical matters via TAS (Technical Advisory Services), which is under the PMU.
1.2
3. The Study is being prepared pursuant to a request from the Local Government of Kabupaten Maros,
hereinafter referred to as the Government Contracting Authority (GCA), as detailed in a letter ref.
600.58/FS.Bappeda.III.2010 of March 12, 2010.
1.3
BACKGROUND
4. Within Kabupaten Maros piped water supply services are provided by PDAM Kabupaten Maros. The
coverage of piped systems in these areas is currently considered by the Local Government to be too low.
5. Problems associated with water supply have received considerable attention, not only from the Local
Governments, but also the Provincial and Central Governments. In recent years considerable
assistance has been provided by the Government of Japan through JICA. Substantial technical
assistance has been provided on a project entitled MAMINASATA Water Supply Project.
1.4
PROJECT RATIONALE
6. The total population of Kabupaten Maros is some 300,000 persons. The current level of the piped
water supply service is 23% of the population. The existing systems have a production capacity of 130
l/sec with NRW at around 40%.
7. The PPC Consultants Demand Survey identified that around 85% of those currently not connected
to the piped water supply systems consider their current supply inadequate. This represents an
unsatisfied demand of around 400 l/sec at present NRW levels. Further, it should be noted that the
PDAM has a formal waiting list of some 17,224 houses. This number represents an immediate
additional market for some 180 l/sec.
8. The PemKab wish to increase the level of service to 71% by 2020. The number of connections
required by 2020 is estimated at 38,938. Assuming an improved NRW level of 25% and a marginal
increase in per capita consumption to 150 liters per day, this number represents an additional production
capacity of around 300 l/sec.
7
9. In accordance with PemKab objectives, the Project therefore proposes to provide additional
production capacity of some 250 l/sec along with some additional trunk mains within the distribution
system.
10. The Project will help support commercial and industrial development in the area and hence generate
economic growth. It will also improve the quality of life and public health for the residents. The
objectives of this PPP include the following:
provision of bulk treated water which will enable increased coverage of piped drinking water
supply systems in strategic areas of Kabupaten Maros;
increased private sector involvement in piped water supply systems leading to:
1.5
reduction of the need for government to invest capital in developing new assets;
reduced costs for the water supply services arising from higher productivity and
economies of scale through expanded coverage; and
11. Two major sources of water have been considered for future supplies to Maros. These are the
Bantimurung River and the Maros River. The former has been assessed as providing a cheaper source
of water; however, the amount of available debit is limited to 250 l/sec.
12. Briefly, the project water supply system components consist of:
Intake: capacity 270 l/s. Intake will be equipped with a pumping system to deliver the
raw water to the WTP.
Raw Water Transmission: transmission main of 8.5 km length and 500 mm diameter;
WTP: conventional plant with full treatment including clarification, filtration and
disinfection producing 250 l/sec of drinking water;
Service reservoir: storage of 4,500 cubic meters capacity and associated pumping
station built in the same location as the WTP; and
Trunk mains: primary distribution mains of 37 km in length, with diameter range from
200 to 600 mm.
1.6
SITE ENABLEMENT
13. The area of the intake requires land acquisition of around 1,000 square meters and the WTP and
Service Reservoir requires some 7,500 square meters.
The PDAM reports in its letter
Ref.:54/PDAM/MR/X/2010 dated October 28, 2010, that the land for the intake has been acquired,
however the land for the WTP and Service Reservoir has yet to be acquired.
14. The considerable lengths of transmission main are expected be constructed on public land.
15. The project is classified as Category A: Requiring an Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA),
Environmental Management Plan and Public Consultation. Initial environmental investigations have
indicated that the project should not face any significant problems from an environmental viewpoint.
1.7
16. The following table represents a summary of the current status of fundamental items which should
be secured before the project preparation proceeds to the bid implementation stage.
Table 1: Pre-Conditions to be satisfied prior to commencing Stage 2: Bid Implementation
Item
1
Description
Approval for abstraction of raw
water (SIPA) from
Bantimurung River in the
proposed quantity and rate.
Responsible
SDA - Dinas PU
Province Sulawesi
Selatan
PemKab Maros
Confirmation-in-principle from
PemKab Maros that it is
prepared to enter into a take
or pay agreement.
The level of contingent
Government Support for the
take or pay agreement with
the PemKab.
PemKab Maros
1.8
DG Water
Resources
IIGF
Remarks
Preliminary approval for the proposed
abstraction has been obtained. A SIPA has
been issued by the PemKab, however this
requires confirmation from the Provincial
Government Agency.
The Local Government of Kabupaten Maros
has to acquire the necessary land for
construction of the intake, WTP, service
reservoir and associated facilities.
Confirm the technical feasibility and attractiveness of the project for private investment.
SCOPE OF WORK
2.1
Ensure the PPP Concept is approved by the PemKab Maros and other stakeholders;
Confirm the readiness of the PemKab to bear the "take or pay" risk on the payments to
be made to the investor for the treated bulk water supply;
Assist PemKab Maros with submission of requests for Government Support from the
relevant Ministries and for a Government Guarantee from the Ministry of Finance given
the Outline Business Case indicates the need for Government Support and Government
Guarantee ;
Ensure the site preparation programs (with land acquisition) and resettlement programs
are being implemented, including budget and schedule approved by the DPRD, and
Ensure the plan and timetable of environmental compliance programs and steps to
resolve various legal issues have been executed.
19. PPP Project Readiness Report consists of information on all institutional readiness assessments,
preparation of sites, environmental compliance, land acquisition and resettlement as well as the
readiness reviews of the legal aspects and all supporting documents.
Assist the GCA to establish the Project Management Team members who will be
involved in managing the Final Business Case preparation and the Bidding process.
Assess the capacity of the Team members to perform the required tasks and identify
areas where special capacity building on-the-job assistance will need to be provided by
the Consultant during the period of the PPP Transaction Advisory.
10
Provide the basis for the development of the project, including validation of how the
project will not only service an unsatisfied demand for drinking water but also support
both Central and Local Government infrastructure expansion plans and objectives.
Confirm the validity of the proposed water abstraction permit (SIPA) for the project.
Review the performance of the PDAMs with regard to the current plan which were
previously prepared with the assistance from JICA.
Assist the PDAM to prepare a feasible and realistic Business Plan for the period 20122016 with the objective of expanding distribution systems in the service areas to a level
and at a rate which will support private investor development of the Bantimuring water
source.
Provide CAPEX financing plans which are achievable and realistic for development of
secondary supply systems.
Include in the Business Plans Customer Relations Programs which will ensure that new
connections are added to the system at the maximum rate once the new supplies
become available.
Confirm with the PemKab Maros and other stakeholders, the project priority, institutional
capacity, views on providing PPP project support, and available budget.
Review, validate and update institutional, market, technical, social, environmental and
legal analyses; assess potential for optimism bias.
Review the technical design and the estimated costs of the project, including CAPEX
and OPEX. Including:
Confirmation with relevant Central and Local Government agencies of the scope
of work to be offered to the private sector.
Review and adjustment where necessary of the budget estimates of cost for the
construction and operation of the proposed works.
Confirm that the project is financially viable and that any changes in project scope and
costs since the preparation of the Outline Business Case have not materially affected its
viability.
11
Update the Project plan setting out key milestones for components, including approvals,
design, construction, commissioning and operation.
Evaluate the legal/regulatory framework for the special purpose vehicle which will be
established by the private sector and identify any impediments to mobilizing finance in
areas such as taxation.
Assess potential restrictions on local and foreign sponsors and potential lenders in areas
such as competition, tax, labor, use of financial instruments, and foreign exchange.
Identify the mechanism for arbitrating disputes between the SPV and the PemKab
Maros.
Determine the extent to which the PemKab Maros can contract with the private sector
establish an escrow account, and provide forms of credit enhancement to support the
project.
Clarify legal requirements with regard to bid documents, bid evaluation procedures and
criteria which the PemKab Maros must comply with to tender a PPP contract.
Define the key service relationships and the interaction of the critical elements of service
delivery including the scope of the concession contract, the obligations of both the
concessionaire and the PemKab Maros.
Prepare a detailed list of assumptions with regard to the formulation of the Business
Case including those relating to the technical design as well as those used in the
financial analysis.
Prepare indicative schedules for design and construction of civil works and supply and
installation of equipment.
Define all sites to be utilized by the Project and any limitations on construction at each
particular site.
12
Define key performance indicators (KPIs) for outputs and minimum required levels that
need to be achieved (price, service levels, quality, availability, minimum regulatory
standards, etc)
Outline monitoring arrangements for both the construction and operations phases of the
Project.
Define sovereign risks including currency/exchange rate controls, economic growth rates
and political stability as they relate to the Project.
Define project revenues, O&M, capital, project preparation and management costs under
alternative development scenarios.
Assess threshold return on equity (ROE) for prospective sponsors and investors.
Political violence
Breach of contract
Prepare indicative risk allocation matrices for various outputs, technical solutions,
financial structures and Government support scenarios.
Identify costs of mitigation strategies and ensure estimated project costs and benefits
reflect these risks.
Identify residual risks which will be borne by the PemKab Maros/ other Government
agencies and the private sector under each scenario.
Financial viability/sustainability
Balance sheet
Financial indicators
Evaluate defined scenarios and risk allocation structures in relation to the following
indicators:
o
Tariffs
FIRR
FNPV
Conduct a sensitivity analysis and identify the impact on the ROE and other financial
indicators.
Assess the probability and impact of major risks and propose adequate risk mitigation
measures.
Assess if there are any significant changes to the project EIRR under the various
scenarios.
Interview potential local and international investors and assess their attitude to project
risks and likely minimum levels of Government support which are proposed.
Interview local financial institutions to determine if credit is available on the local market
and on what terms.
Evaluate the extent the GCA is willing to support the project in terms of providing:
o
Liaise with RMU and IIGF to confirm the extent to which they are willing to support the
project in terms of providing:
14
Assess the likely market interest in developing and financing the project under various
forms of Government support
Assess the extent that project viability can be improved by mechanisms such as:
o
Evaluate options in terms of value for money, bankability, government support and
affordability to the GCA.
Review tariff setting policy, adjustment mechanism, benchmark indices for making
adjustments to parameters such as inflation and exchange rate movements.
Specify tariff structure, adjustment, and output payment/penalty mechanism for the
Concessionaire.
Determine procedures and responsibilities for reviewing and adjusting the tariff over the
life of the PPP concession.
Define the structure of the political risk and payment guarantees, and revenue support
provided by the PemKab Maros.
Define the lease rental structure in terms of fixed and variable payments linked to
availability and usage of outputs.
Define the structure of the performance guarantee from the private sector supplier
(performance bond) covering failure to achieve financial close, and construction (e.g. a
percentage of project cost, which will be released at the time of construction completion)
Define term of the contract and income sharing arrangements between the project
company and the PemKab Maros in circumstances where:
o
Cost over-run
15
Assess the need to ring fence tariff revenues, identify requirements for establishing an
escrow account and trust bank, define cash flow priorities, billing procedures, accounting
and reporting requirements, and management information system needs.
Assess other likely forms of arrangements that will be needed by financiers in terms of
securing cash flows, and managing risks in the event of a change in ownership or
insolvency (eg direct agreement with the PemKab Maros defining step in rights), or force
majeure (natural disaster or political turmoil).
Define pre-conditions for concessionaire to meet service obligations, default and risks
clauses, step-in rights for the lenders etc.
Draft a Performance Based Contract Agreement between the PemKot and the PDAM
which defines, at a minimum, the following:
o
Payment terms to PemKab for bulk water supplied by the SPV to the PDAM
Continuity of service
Prepare the draft term sheet for the Project Agreement including:
o
Conditions precedent
17
Prepare the bid implementation plan, management responsibilities timeline for bid
process and resource needs.
Prepare a Final Business Case that consolidates the findings of the Outline Business
Case and the above listed tasks.
On completion of the Final Business Case, the PemKab Maros with assistance from the
Consultant is to present the Project to BAPPENAS and Ministry of Finance.
Once concurrence of all parties is received to the proposal, the Consultant is to proceed
with the Bid Implementation phase of the Project.
2.2
The draft Project Agreement should contain at least the following provisions:
o
Transfer of assets
Implementation schedule
Step-in rights for the Government, allowing it to take over service provision if the
supplier gets into difficulties
18
Step-in rights for the lenders, allowing them to substitute another service
provider if the supplier defaults
Termination payment (eg 100% debt, plus equity in accordance with costs
incurred on project implementation costs defined in the bid documents)
Role and scope of work of the Independent Consultant who will monitor project
implementation on behalf of the Government
The land lease and raw water supply agreements, defining factors such as
scope, availability provisions and payment terms
Prepare guidelines for the Government to run the tender, providing information on:
o
General overview of how the tender should be set up, organized, and run
Who should run the tender and the probity procedures that should be followed
Define two stage bidding process with prequalification required and pre-bid
conference required
The criteria which should be used to evaluate the PPP bids and the scoring
mechanism to be applied:
-
19
Confidentiality Statement
Market analysis
20
Work with the Procurement Committee established within the Project Management
Team to review, refine and approve proposed financial structure, bid strategy, bid
evaluation criteria etc. Update bid implementation program identifying major milestones,
decision points, responsibilities etc.
Prepare a plan for management and administration of the PPP Agreement during the
post-transaction period - Phase IV: Contract Management. Provide an outline of the
structure, responsibilities and reporting requirements of all parties involved in this Phase.
Identify any specific concerns that may need to be addressed in the bid documents and
revise draft RFQ, and other bid documents.
Definition of the type of outputs, payment structure and the scope of the project
Details of existing facilities and how they might be used in the project
Deliverables expected from the private investor, KPIs, and control arrangements
Following Application Due Date review RFQ submissions, verify submissions and
evaluate in accordance with minimum standards of technical and financial capability
Identify and pre-qualify short list of prospective bidders based on qualifications (technical
and financial capacity) of bidders
Finalize Request for Proposal (RFP) describing the project, defining the PPP output
specification, payment structure, performance standards, draft contract and support
agreements, information required from potential bidders to assess technical and financial
capacity, criteria for awarding the concession, and submission requirements (including
an electronic copy of the financial model of their proposal).
Finalize the procedure for dealing with requests for information, providing information to
bidders and scope for negotiation.
Assist with clarification/negotiation of the final terms of the PPP Agreement including
requirements for Government support, conditions precedent, and term of the PPP
Agreement before it expires due to failure to achieve financial close.
Review proposed terms in the light of the assumptions in the Final Business Case to
confirm that they offer value for money and are affordable.
Obtain approval from Government/MOF that the bid is affordable and feasible, and
finalize the level and form of Government Support which will be provided.
Award the PPP Concession Agreement and issue Letter of Acceptance specifying:
o
Conditions precedent
In collaboration with the GCA, prepare a Final Project Report documenting the complete
Stage 1 and 2 works and focusing on Lessons Learned in the execution of the
assignment.
The GCA with assistance from the Consultant is to present the Final Project Report to
BAPPENAS, Ministry of Finance and the ADB.
CONSULTANT DELIVERABLES
20. The contract is to be output based with lump sum payments made based on deliverable items. The
following table provides details of deliverables, due dates and portions of the contract sum which may be
claimed on successful completion, delivery and acceptance of each item.
Deliverable/Milestone
Mobilization
Inception Report
Project Preparation Report
Draft Final Business Case
Final Business Case
Total Stage 1
Bid Documents
Bidding Commenced
Bids Received
Preferred Bidders Selected
Contract Award
Final Report
Total Stage 2
a.
b.
c.
d.
e.
f.
Due Date
End of week 2
End of week 3
End of week 7
End of week 9
End of week 12
End of week 19
End of week 32
End of week 35
End of week 38
End of week 40
23
Terms of Payment
10%
10%
10%
50%
20%
100%
20%
15%
10%
15%
20%
20%
100%
21. All deliverables must be approved by Bappenas and endorsed by the ADB before submission of
invoices for payment.
22. The Transaction Advisory services are expected to be provided over a period of approximately
twelve months. Stage I is expected to take two months including a period for discussion and adoption of
the Final Business Case Report. The timing requirements for Stage II will be confirmed at the end of
Stage I. A preliminary estimate of the durations and sequencing of tasks is included in the attached
Schedule for Transaction Advisory.
23. The Consultant is responsible for the provision of all professional and supporting staff necessary for
the satisfactory completion of the Services.
24. Minimum experts required for the implementation of assignment in terms of expertise, nationality and
qualifications are presented in Table 3: Qualifications of Staff. The precise experts required will be
identified in the specific terms of reference of IDCA.
Table 3: Qualifications of Staff
Consultant
Nationality
National
Minimum
Qualification
S1
Years
Experience
10
Team Leader/ WS
Engineer
Transaction
Specialist
International
S2
10
Legal Specialist
National
10
Financial
Specialist
National
S2 (plus Izin
Advocat)
S2
10
Social and
Environmental
Specialist
National
S2
Comments
Must have experience in PPP within
water supply sector and the preparation
and design of infrastructure projects.
Must have international experience in
finance for, and deal structuring of, PPP
infrastructure projects
Experience in commercial law, preparing
lease agreements, infrastructure projects
Experienced in preparing financial and
economic models for water supply
projects.
Experience in resettlement in
infrastructure sector; experience in
preparing IEA and familiar with AMDAL
requirements
25. Team Leader - will have a water supply engineering specialization and experience and knowledge of
PPP. He/she will be responsible for coordinating all inputs of the Assignment, submission of reports to
the Government and Bappenas, facilitation of meetings and stakeholder consultations, as required, and
liaison with the Government and Bappenas as required. The Team Leader will be responsible for
reviewing the Final Business Case to confirm commercial and financial requirements, and ensure
necessary drafts bid implementation plan and term sheets of the concession agreement are in place to
move forward the project to the transaction phase. The Team Leader will take the lead preparing and
finalizing the final business case document. He will assist PemKab Maros on matters related to the
government guarantee (IIGF). He/she will be responsible for managing the implementation of bidding
including collating and editing all documents and administrative management of the team through all
phases of the bidding process. As an engineering specialist he/she will lead the technical validation of
project design and cost estimates by reviewing and updating the draft outline business case, verifying
quantities and rates for major civil works, equipment construction, verifying operating and maintenance
(O&M) costs, and confirming the design on a least cost basis in financial and economic terms. The
24
Specialist will provide inputs into the output specification, the economic and financial model, contract
specification, and support technical aspects of the bid process.
26. Transaction/Financial Specialist - will have a financial specialization. He/she will review and
validate the market studies and prepare a detailed financial model that can be used to evaluate the
project structure under various economic and financial scenarios. The Transaction/Financial Specialist
will take the lead in preparing the PPP structure and the Draft Term Sheets. During bid implementation
the Specialist will perform an over-seeing role in the preparation of the draft agreement and supporting
documents, tender guidelines and bid documents. He will play a leading role in the bid evaluation and
negotiation activities.
27. Legal Specialist - will be responsible for performing the legal review, confirming project assets are
free of encumbrances, ensuring the required permits are in place, participating in stakeholder
consultations, developing bankability measures such as fee payment mechanism, defining pre-conditions
for a private operator to fulfill in meeting service obligations, drafting concession agreement and support
agreements, as well as the bid documents.
28. Social and Environmental Specialist will review the social impact analysis and ensure that it
complies with the requirements of the Government, and is consistent with ADB's social safeguard
policies. Assess adequacy, project capacity and commitment to implement the indigenous peoples,
involuntary resettlement programs identified in the Outline Business Report. Ensure proposed mitigation
measures and impact monitoring procedures are adequate, and that the necessary consultation and
disclosure frameworks are in place to ensure the proposed Indigenous Peoples and Resettlement
programs are implemented effectively. This Specialist will also review the environmental impact analysis
and ensure that it complies with the requirements of the Government, and is consistent with ADB's
environmental safeguard policies. Assess adequacy, project capacity and commitment to implement the
program identified in the Outline Business Report. Ensure proposed mitigation measures and impact
monitoring procedures are adequate, and that the necessary consultation and disclosure frameworks are
in place to ensure the proposed environmental management program is implemented effectively. The
Social and Environmental Specialist will provide inputs into the output specification, the economic and
financial model, contract specification.
29. Sub-Professionals several sub-professionals will be employed as junior staff to assist the key
professionals. These will include a water supply or civil engineer, a legal and a financial specialist. In
addition an IT specialist will be required along with a cost estimator.
30. Estimated number of staff and durations are shown in Table 4: Illustrative Staff Inputs. The Bidder
should present a management chart which identifies through bar charts the expected time that each
consultant will spend on the Project.
Table 4: Illustrative Staff Inputs
Item
Description
Source
1
2
3
4
5
7
National
International
National
National
National
National
25
PreFeasibility
1.5
1.0
1.0
1.5
1.0
8.0
14.0
Bid
Implementation
6.5
1.5
2.0
1.5
0.0
8.0
19.5
Input Months
8.0
2.5
3.0
3.0
1.0
16.0
33.5
MANAGEMENT OF SERVICES
31. Bappenas shall be the Executing Agency (EA) for the Consultancy and will enter into a contract with
the Consultant. The Consultant will have been selected by the PMU (under BAPPENAS).
32. The BAPPENAS PMU-IRSDP will provide strategic direction and advice to the Consultants during
the course of the Assignment. The Consultant will discuss technical issues with TAS-IRSDP including
environmental, social, and resettlement. TAS-IRSDP will provide trainers and training materials for
Capacity Building exercises. During Implementation the Consultant will report to the PemKab Maros,
who is the end user of the Consultancy on technical matters. The PemKab Maros will monitor and
supervise the performance of the Consultant. All technical reports and communications will be submitted
to the PemKab Maros, with copies to BAPPENAS and to TAS-IRSDP.
33. Within 15 working days of the signing of the contract, the Consultant shall submit an Inception
Report giving a detailed workplan and assignments for each individual in the team.
34. The Consultant shall submit concise interim reports each month describing progress of work,
updated work schedule, and any key constraints encountered by the Consultant in the performance of
his activities. The Monthly Reports are to be issued within three working days of the end of the month.
Monthly Coordination Meetings will be held between the Consultant, GCA, PMU, TAS and other
agencies as appropriate within five working days of issue of the Monthly Reports. Meeting notes from
Monthly Meetings will be prepared by TAS and issued within three working days of the meeting. The
notes will include an Action List stating specific tasks which are to be addressed during the month and
responsibilities for these tasks.
Data and Information: PDAM and related agencies will provide the Consultant with
relevant existing data and information including appropriate maps, plans, charts, satellite
imagery, previous surveys, and reports necessary to adequately perform the required
Services.
Counterpart Assistance: Province/Local Governments and the PDAM will assign full time
staff to work with the Consultant as counterparts. The counterparts will facilitate access
to parties and documents necessary for the execution of this Consultancy.
Support Facilities: The Provincial Government will provide an office with desks, chairs,
file cabinets, and bookcases for the Consultant in Denpasar during the period of the
Consultancy.
BUDGET
36. The estimated budget for the Technical Assistance for Stage I: Final Business Case is
approximately US$ 104,000. Total Budget is around US$ 234,297. The source of funds for this
Consultancy is from the Infrastructure Reform Sector Development Project (IRSDP) under the provision
of the ADB Loan No. 2264-INO (SF).
26
ID
1
2
Task Name
STAGE 1: FINAL BUSINESS CASE
Deliverable 1: Project Preparation Report
Duration
43 days
Start
3 Jan '11
Finish
Dec
2 Mar '11
10 days
3 Jan '11
14 Jan '11
10 days
3 Jan '11
14 Jan '11
5 days
10 Jan '11
14 Jan '11
25 days
17 Jan '11
18 Feb '11
1 day
17 Jan '11
17 Jan '11
5 days
18 Jan '11
24 Jan '11
Project Rationale
10
11
12
13
14
15
5 days
18 Jan '11
24 Jan '11
10 days
18 Jan '11
31 Jan '11
5 days
18 Jan '11
24 Jan '11
3 days
1 Feb '11
3 Feb '11
3 days
4 Feb '11
8 Feb '11
10 days
1 Feb '11
14 Feb '11
5 days
1 Feb '11
7 Feb '11
5 days
1 Feb '11
7 Feb '11
16
3 days
3 Feb '11
7 Feb '11
17
3 days
8 Feb '11
10 Feb '11
18
3 days
11 Feb '11
15 Feb '11
19
3 days
16 Feb '11
18 Feb '11
20
21
22
8 days
21 Feb '11
2 Mar '11
216 days
3 Mar '11
29 Dec '11
16 days
3 Mar '11
24 Mar '11
23
5 days
3 Mar '11
9 Mar '11
24
3 days
10 Mar '11
14 Mar '11
25
5 days
10 Mar '11
16 Mar '11
26
2 days
15 Mar '11
16 Mar '11
27
3 days
17 Mar '11
21 Mar '11
28
3 days
22 Mar '11
24 Mar '11
1st Quarter
2nd Quarter
3rd Quarter
4th Quarter
1st Q
Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec Jan
Task
Rolled Up Task
External Tasks
Critical Task
Project Summary
Progress
Rolled Up Milestone
Group By Summary
Milestone
Rolled Up Progress
Summary
Split
Page 1
ID
29
Task Name
Deliverable 2: Assistance with Bid Process
30
31
Pre-Qualification
32
33
Duration
195 days
Start
25 Mar '11
Finish
Dec
22 Dec '11
5 days
25 Mar '11
31 Mar '11
25 days
1 Apr '11
5 May '11
5 days
6 May '11
12 May '11
65 days
13 May '11
11 Aug '11
34
30 days
12 Aug '11
22 Sep '11
35
20 days
23 Sep '11
20 Oct '11
65 days
23 Sep '11
22 Dec '11
5 days
23 Dec '11
29 Dec '11
36
37
1st Quarter
2nd Quarter
3rd Quarter
4th Quarter
1st Q
Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec Jan
Task
Rolled Up Task
External Tasks
Critical Task
Project Summary
Progress
Rolled Up Milestone
Group By Summary
Milestone
Rolled Up Progress
Summary
Split
Page 2