Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Group 10
Kanika Virmani, 13P146
Shashank Shukla,13P166
Table of Contents
Contents
Executive Summary __________________________________________________________ 1
Purpose ____________________________________________________________________ 3
Justification _________________________________________________________________ 4
Introduction _________________________________________________________________ 5
Brief History _________________________________________________________________ 6
SWOT Analysis ______________________________________________________________ 8
PEST Analysis ______________________________________________________________ 10
Porters Five Forces _________________________________________________________ 11
Survey Results _____________________________________________________________ 15
Product Offerings &Marketing Strategy __________________________________________ 22
Market Share _______________________________________________________________ 23
Future Growth Strategy _______________________________________________________ 24
Segmentation ______________________________________________________________ 25
Positioning _________________________________________________________________ 27
Exhibits ___________________________________________________________________ 29
References ________________________________________________________________ 32
Executive Summary
Pg. 01
Executive Summary
Amul is a product that has a great reach in the market with its packaged milk, butter
and cheese, especially in western and northern markets. It has been able to run a
profitable business despite following co-operative business model. The focus has
always been on providing fair price to the farmers and not on profit maximization.
Moreover, the expenditure on advertising and marketing was around 1% of its
revenues which is very less than what other FMCG companies spent.
Amul is seen as a brand that people can trust and connect as a brand associated with
purity and benevolence. Other than that it also has a strong distribution network which
allows it to improve the milk collection facilities and distribution. Its presence in rural
markets is very prominent. Despite that, there are segments where Amul is not doing
very well.
Amul chocolates are nowhere close to the market leaders Nestle and Cadburys. They
have not been able to leverage their experience in dairy industry to capitalize in this
segment. Our research indicated that almost 48% of current chocolate users are
willing to try a new product from Amul and 56% of those would prefer that it be in a
range of 10-15. Amul can re-launch their chocolates and position them in a way that
they are closer to the parent brand. It might not be able to use the Amul Girl for the
chocolate campaign as it might not be able to return equity to the parent brand, but
packaging can be changed to resemble the brand values of benevolence and purity,
for the current packaging is not close to it.
The Amul ice-cream is made of milk fat instead of vegetable fat which improves its
quality. But market penetration of Amul in ice-creams is only in family packs. Amul
needs to capture this market as well and try to enhance its reputation in the dairy
industry. Our market research concluded that majority of Amul Loyalist (Those who
prefer Amul ice creams not only in Family packs but other forms as well) stuck with the
brand for its superior taste. This approach to brand positioning will help Amul to
capture this market as well.
Executive Summary
Pg. 02
There is not much presence of Amul in Fast Food segment and visibility is limited to
western region only. But company is not concentrating in this area. For Amul, this is
only to complement its current range of products. Moreover, fast food segment is
capital intensive and there is stiff competition from other national and international
brands.
In the future, the company wants to increase its share of organized milk production in
India, which is currently only 3%. For that, it will have to concentrate in southern and
eastern regions where its presence is limited and fight against the strong regional
players there. To gain market share in the new product categories that it is entering
(ice-cream, beverages, paneer, milk (in tetra packs), and dahi and fresh-fruit lassi)
they will have to increase their advertising expenditure. It has strong visibility across
the segments but is not able to give the consumers a compelling reason to buy. For
that to happen, brand equity will have to flow from parent brand to these new
products, but care needs to be taken to make sure that such steps do not dilute the
brand equity of the parent brand.
Purpose
Pg. 03
Purpose
The main purpose of this case study is to understand the underpinnings of Amul. Amul
is the biggest milk aggregator of India, the oldest and most successful co-operative
unit in India and the biggest milk supplier as well. It has become the most far-reaching,
flexible distribution network that allows it to supply milk to consumers after collecting it
from farmers.
Moreover, despite spending only a fraction of its revenues on advertising, it has a high
brand recollection value and has been able to leverage it to increase its reach to the
customers.
Also, there is a scope to replicate the success of co-operative model of Amul to
various other segments where the suppliers are very week and fragmented. One of
the examples can be vegetable vendors.
But despite having so many strengths, Amul happens to lag behind in many
categories where it has positioned itself. Primary among those categories being
Desserts category. Through this Case study, we will try to understand the dairy
segment, its drivers, the customer perception of the same and product branding by
Amul.
There are many objectives through which we are trying to look at Amul:
Current market and brand positioning of Amul and entire portfolio of products
Future opportunities due to the changing market dynamics and leveraging the
current market strengths
An onslaught of foreign players and diversification of the current market players
might pose an imminent threat to the current market position of Amul
To understand how despite limited spending Amul has had success in positioning
its product well
Justification
Pg. 04
Justification
Despite having successful products, Amul still has a list of under-performing product
range. This might pull the company down, if the product which are now Amuls forte
start to under-perform.
Taking another look at it product portfolio and utilizing its existing strengths will allow
Amul to maintain the industry leader that it has been over the years. Also, it is the right
time for Amul to restructure, as other competitors are planning to enter the market, but
as of yet do not have a foot hold in the market
Also given the changing scenario of the global milk market, it is only natural that Amul
introspects into its current strengths and positioning.
Introduction
Pg. 05
What you need is
good
management with
farmer power.
Good
management
gives this power
the right direction
and thrust.
Nothing can stop
the farmers then.
Least of all the
MNCs.
V.Kurien
Introduction
Amul - Anand Milk Union Limited, is the Indian dairy cooperative, based at
Anand in Gujarat, India, which made India worlds largest producer of milk and milk
products. In 1946, beginning with two village cooperatives and 250 liters of milk per
day, nothing but a trickle compared to the flood it has become today, Amul, a product
of Dr. Verghese Kuriens brainchild movement, White Revolution, has risen to become
the largest food brand in India with equal stand overseas.
A cooperative movement which began in 1946, got full integration and
organization after GCMMF - Gujarat Cooperative Milk Marketing Federation Ltd, the
apex marketing body of these district cooperatives was set up in 1973. Thereafter
GCMMF went on to become the largest food products marketing organization of India.
Over the last five and a half decades, Dairy Cooperatives in Gujarat have created an
economic network that links more than 3.1 million village milk producers with millions
of consumers in India. Few of the achievements of Amul are:
Brief History
Pg. 06
Who told you
there is one
Amul? There are
more than 175
Amuls across
various districts
(in Gujarat)
V.Kurien
Brief History
The revolution started as an awareness program among the farmers who had
grown and matured into a protest movement against the exploitation of marginal milk
producers by traders or agents of the only existing dairy, the Polson (brand) dairy, in
the small town of Anand (in Kaira District of Gujarat). As milk is perishable, farmers
were compelled to sell it for whatever they were offered. Often, they had to sell cream
and ghee at throwaway prices. In this situation, the one who gained was the private
trader. This situation is what led to the establishment of the Kaira District Cooperative
Milk Producers' Union Limited (popularly known as Amul) which was formally
registered on December 14, 1946.
The Kaira Union began pasteurization and marketing for dairy needs of
Bombay Milk scheme in full force from June 1948. Being an assured market rendering
inherent incentives, by the end of 1948, more than 400 farmers joined in more village
societies, and the quantity of milk handled by one Union increased from 250 to 5000
liters a day.
The cooperative was further developed and managed by Dr. Varghese Kurien
along with H.M. Dalaya, whose innovation of making skim milk powder from buffalo
milk for the first time anywhere in the world and a little later, along with Kurien's help,
making it on a commercial scale led to the first modern dairy of the cooperative at
Anand, which would compete against established players in the market. The success
of the dairy co-operative movement spread rapidly in Gujarat. Within a short span five
other district unions Mehsana, Banaskantha, Baroda, Sabarkantha and Surat were
organized.
In order to combine forces and expand the market while saving on advertising
and avoid competing against each other, the GCMMF, an apex marketing body of
these district cooperatives was set up in 1973. The Kaira Union which had the brand
name of Amul with it since 1955, transferred it to GCMMF.
Amul has a three tier organizational structure:
Daily Cooperative
Society
(Village Level)
Milk Union
(District Level)
Milk Federation
(State Level)
Pg. 07
Brief History
This structure evolved at Amul in Gujarat later on went on to be replicated all
over the country under the Operation Flood Programme. The effect of this operation is
clear in the evaluation of World Bank which states
It has been proved that an investment of Rs. 20 billion over
20 years under Operation Flood Programme in 70s & 80s has
contributed an increase of Indias milk production by 40 Million
Metric Tonne (MMT) i.e. from about 20 MMT in pre- Operation Flood
period to more than 60 MMT at the end of Operation flood
Programme.
Due to this movement, the growth movement rendered the milk
production triple between the years 1971 to 1996. As a result, expanding its
business overseas, in June 2013, Amul signed a tripartite agreement to start a
dairy plant in Waterloo Village in upstate New York. Under the agreement
Amul will be able to supply to US as well as Canada, and export to Europe. In
a way beginning a new era for Indias dairy giant.
SWOT Analysis
Pg. 08
SWOT Analysis
Strengths
Amul has the largest distribution network for any FMCG company. Amul
products are available in over 500,000 retail outlets across India through its
network of over 3,500 distributors. This makes it very successful in rural market
penetration, an area now being explored by FMCG due to market saturation in
urban markets
This distribution network is supported by the largest cold chain network in the
country
Amul is the largest exporter of dairy products in the country and has a foot print
in over 40 countries around the world. It can be called the Global face of Indian
Dairy Industry and Indian Co-operative model as well
Amul's uses superior quality in its ice creams as well. Ice creams by Amul are
made from milk fat and thus are ice creams in real sense of the word, while
many brands in India sell frozen desserts made from vegetable fat
To ensure that the customers get better Value-for-Money, Amul has never
spent more than 1% of its revenues on brand building, as against other
FMCGs who spend close to 6-7%. This allows them to cater to the price
sensitive market as well
With such presence, it hardly comes as a surprise that Amul was named the
Most Trusted brand in the Food and Beverages sector in The Brand Trust
Report
SWOT Analysis
Pg. 09
Weaknesses
The highly complex supply chain, which gives effective results to Amul is also a
liability, given the fact that it has now become very complex to handle. This is
partly due to its strong dependency on weak infrastructure.
3rd party alliances with firms that do not belong to the organized sector can
make it vulnerable
Opportunities
Threats
PEST Analysis
Pg. 10
PEST Analysis
Political
Since Dr. Verghese Kurien was forced to quit a power struggle has ensued
Will have to engage and negotiate with political interests for smooth functioning.
Since the budget range is decontrolled, no political effects are seen on that front
Economic
Social
Per capita consumption of the dairy products is expected to increase in the future
Health conscious appeal to the society by providing lower cholesterol in its
products than Mithais (sweet meat)
Increasing gifts and incentives culture in the society is now shifting to desserts
So there is an incentive to increase Dessert portfolio
Payout to the farmers has also been registered amounting to 23%CAGR in the
preceding few years, which has resulted in social upliftment and raising standard
of living for the rural India
Technological
Pg. 11
With regard to GCMMF the porters five forces can be explained as follows:
Threat of entry of new competition LOW
o Capital Investment
Investment requirement of this business - substantially large (including the
processing and marketing costs)
With established cooperatives like Amul, it becomes very difficult to step into
the highly dominated market.
Brand Loyalty
GCMMFs long established benevolent image
Major challenge to mold the preference of its customers.
Resource Advantage
GCMMF, having a very good reputation both in India and the international
market
Procurement of raw materials becomes a challenge for new entrants with
Amul in picture.
Distribution Channels
Effective channels for procurement and supply essential for maximizing
productivity and profitability.
Amul already holding and maintaining well its procurement and supply
channels
Difficult for new organizations to tap onto the same.
HIGH
Pg. 12
Economies of Scale:
GCMMF enjoys high economy of scale especially in the dairy
product market
An aegis under which Amul has not yet faced any major
competitive threat.
Pg. 13
o
Also the increasing number of buyers makes it difficult for Amul to manage its brand
loyalty.
The above mentioned forces keep interacting with one another in order
to change the dynamics of the market. But seeing the previous performances it
can be concluded that Amul has outperformed most of its competition.
Pg. 14
Threat of new
entrants - LOW due to
established
players and
brand loyalty
Bargaining
power of
Suppliers - LOW
- cooperative
society with most
suppliers rural
farmers
Rivalry among
competitors HIGH - due to
presence of other
brands and local
vendors
Threat from
substitutes LOW - since
most products
are necessities
Bargaining
power of buyers
- HIGH - due to
lot of options
available
Survey Results
Pg. 15
Survey Results
Average Weekly expenditure
350
300
250
200
311
150
252.16
228.12
100
50
0
North
West
Rest of India
Pg. 16
Survey Results
Pg. 17
Survey Results
Survey Results
Pg. 18
Factors in buying Amul Brand of Milk
Purity
Availability
Pricing
Others
72
54
10
5
West
Reason
Number
Amul Loyalist
Taste
Availability
58
28
25
19
Variety
Discount Offer
27
8
16
5
Survey Results
Pg. 19
North
Reason
Taste
Availability
Variety
Discount Offer
Number
70
29
20
2
Amul Loyalist
20
10
13
2
Rest of India
Reason
Taste
Availability
Variety
Number
21
7
8
Willingness to change
94
Willing to Change
88
Amul Loyalist
8
4
4
Survey Results
Pg. 20
10
20
30
40
Column3
50
60
70
80
Survey Results
Pg. 21
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
Column3
10
Column3
12
14
16
18
20
Pg. 22
Market Share
Pg. 23
Market Share
Gujarat Co-operative Milk Marketing Federation (GCMMF), owners of Amul brand of
milk and dairy products, posted sales of Rs11,670 crore for the year ended March
2012, almost 55% more than Nestle Indias Rs7,541 crore sales.
Following are the market share figures for various Amul products:
With expected growth rate of 20 percent, 12% growth rate can be attributed to price
rise and another 8 percent to rise in demand for dairy products.
Pg. 24
Segmentation
Pg. 25
Segmentation
AMUL
CHOCOLATES
DAIRY PRODUCTS
Primary dairy products such as milk, butter, cheese are well segmented and
dairy products being necessity by each category in every part of the country.
They can target higher earning class for some of the products with better
packaging such as adding an extra layer of protection which would again
emphasize on Amul focusing on purity and goodness of a product.
Segmentation
Pg. 26
ICE-CREAMS
Amul should continue to target families with their family packs and continuously
come up with newer flavors to keep the customers engaged as Amul has a
strong hold on family packs segment.
Amul will have a difficult time to fight with retail ice cream parlors because
there are already a good number of players present such as Baskin Robbins,
Vadilal, Top n Town, Kwality walls etc. with good brand loyalty. Amul has come
up with their own chain of retail parlors which is a good idea and should
enhance their penetration of smaller packs of ice cream along with other
products as these parlors contain other products such as milk, cheese, butter
etc.
Positioning
Pg. 27
Positioning
Ice Creams
Amul's ice creams are made from milk fat and thus are ice creams in real sense of the
word, while many brands in India sell frozen desserts made from vegetable fat.
The two main factors for Ice Cream purchaser is taste and availability. Amul Ice
creams are made of milk cream and available everywhere in the market because
of their market penetration
They should now try to concentrate variety factor and try and introduce new
flavors. This will also allow them to reach to new customers
Chocolates
Amul should take proper action in order to improve service, because although
being on a top slot in Butter and milk supplies it does not get the sales in
chocolate, which it should get
Amul should use brand ambassador which attracts each age segment
It should make use of its strong distribution structure to increase the width and
penetration of its chocolates in the urban as well as rural markets. It should
increase its visibility at retail points
It should launch chocolate in new attractive packing to change image of Amul
chocolate in consumers mind. The current packing is not in line with its
competitors. Instead it is very dull and obsolete. This is a major area on which it
can work and increase the visibility of the product
Positioning
Pg. 28
It should introduce sales promotion schemes like free weight, pranky, tattoo,
contest, free gifts etc.
It should increase its R&D spending to improve the quality & taste of its chocolates
as compared to its competitors
Once the above have been done, it should look at new avenues such as marketing
alliances with various portals for festive occasions and celebrations to offer
products, coming up with its own chocolate boutiques and other ways of
rejuvenating its brand
Amul has come up with a campaign Eat milk with every meal. This campaign is
a part of Amuls efforts to re-position milk and make the entire range of Amul dairy
products trendy and appealing to all
Milk was earlier positioned as the Worlds original energy drink in earlier
campaigns. This campaign provides Amul with a unique opportunity to showcase
the goodness of the entire range of Amul products and make milk, in its various
forms, an integral part of every meal
Exhibits
Pg. 29
Exhibits
Exhibit 1
Exhibit 2
Exhibits
Pg. 30
Exhibit 3
Exhibit 4
Exhibits
Pg. 31
Exhibit 5
Exhibit 6
References
Pg. 32
References
http://www.economictimes.com
http://www.rediffnews.com
http://www.ukessays.com
http://www.wikipedia.org
http://www.academia.edu
http://www.business-standard.com
Marketing Management Philip Kotler