CODE COMPLIANCE and EXECUTION

CEILING STRUCTURE

DCTS
july 2014

SOURCES: BASED ON DETAILED PROJECTS AND NATIONAL AND ONTERNATIONAL REGULATIONS

Earthquake Damage
A survey of 25 damaged commercial buildings following the 1971 San Fernando Earthquake
revealed the following breakdown of property losses:
3

structural damage
electrical and
mechanical

56

34

exterior finishes
interior finishes

A similar survey of 50 damaged high-rise buildings, which were far enough away from the
earthquake fault rupture to experience only mild shaking, showed that none had major structural
damage but major nonstructural damages:
8
drywall or plaster
partitions
elevators

15
43
18

SOURCES: BASED ON FEMA E 74/2011

broken windows
air-conditioning
systems

Distribution of Costs
Within the nonstructural components
category, the interior construction,
to witch the suspended ceilings belong,
represents the largest source
of costs 30%.

100%
90%

18

17

80%

44

70%
60%
50%

62

Structural
70

Non Structural

40%
48

30%

Contents

20%
10%

20

0%
Office

SOURCES: TAGHAVI AND MIRANDA 2003

13

Hotel

Hospital

Impact
-

Economic impact: losses of inventory and business income;

Threat to life safety: injuries and death;
Loss of function.

CODE COMPLIANCE
P100-1/2013 ROMANIAN SEISMIC DESIGN CODE
CODE PRESCRIPTIONS:
The suspended ceilings of IIII importance class buildings situated on ag>0.25g sites need to
respect the following additional rules:
- the panel support grid is to be made of laminated T-shaped steel profiles;
- the closing marginal L-shapes flange is to be of at least 50 mm;
- on each of the 2 orthogonal horizontal directions, one end of the support grid of
the ceiling is to be fastened to the end L-shape and the other end will have at least a 20 mm
free displacement;
- ceilings with the surface >100sqm will have lateral connections to the main
structure;
- ceilings with the surface >250sqm will be divided into surface areas <250sqm by
means of separating joints or by walls on the entire height of the storey; one can discard this
measure if it can by proven by calculation that the fixing system can fully bear the lateral
displacements of the ceiling;
- measures will be taken to allow the free displacement of the ceiling in the
vicinity of sprinklers and/or other pieces that run through the ceiling;
- in case the ceiling has different height levels, the lateral stability of each area is
to be assured by means of a self-locking system of the lateral displacements (bracing);
- pipes, ventilation ducts, electrical wiring and other installation elements will not
be fixed to the suspended ceiling.

SOURCES: P100-1/2013 ROMANIAN SEISMIC DESIGN CODE

CODE COMPLIANCE
P100-1/2013 ROMANIAN SEISMIC DESIGN CODE
CODE PRESCRIPTIONS:
The partition walls fixed at the suspended ceiling level, as well as any other partition walls taller
than 2.00 m, regardless of the material they are made of, are to be laterally fastened to the main structure,
independently of the suspended ceiling fixing system. In case of framed structure buildings, the connections
will not favor the creation of short-wall situations.
The plan layout of lateral fixing elements and their dimensioning is to be done so that the lateral
displacements of the top ends of walls are compatible with the lateral displacements of the suspended ceiling
in that room.

SOURCES: P100-1/2013 ROMANIAN SEISMIC DESIGN CODE

CODE COMPLIANCE
P100-1/2013 ROMANIAN SEISMIC DESIGN CODE
CODE PRESCRIPTIONS:

The equipments connected directly to the ducting system (such as fans, dust blowers,
heat changers, humidifiers) that have an exploitation weight greater than 0.35kN/35kg must be
propped and connected laterally, independently from the pipeline system.
For pipes/ducts connected directly to the equipment, the lateral fixing is not
mandatory if they have the necessary flexibility to undergo relative displacements with respect to
the attachment points.

SOURCES: P100-1/2013 ROMANIAN SEISMIC DESIGN CODE

1

EXPERIMENTAL RESEARCH
The research was carried out by building an indoor model with the in plane dimensions of 8.2x4.95 m
(approx. 40 sq.m) and the height of 3.40 m, in which ceilings were fitted having 60cm suspension wires.
Four types of ceilings were tested using combinations of the 3 ordinary means of suspension
recommended by the US regulations:
1 fastening the beams to the edge elements;
2 suspension wires at the end of the beams;
3 inclined wires and rigid columns.

SOURCES: P100-1/2013 ROMANIAN SEISMIC DESIGN CODE

1

EXPERIMENTAL RESEARCH

SOURCES: ARMSTRONG SEISMIC CEILING DESIGN

CEILING ON SITE

10

EXPERIMENTAL RESEARCH

SOURCES: ARMSTRONG SEISMIC CEILING DESIGN

11

RESEARCH RESULTS
Ceiling type

Failure
acceleration

Fasteners
1

Yes

Yes

Yes

Failure mode

>1.5g

Virtually no failure.

Yes

Yes

No

1.5g

The beams were separated from the edge elements;

several cracked panels and a few beam ends deformed
due to contact with the end wall.

Yes

No

No

0.8g

The beams began to rupture and fall. Most panels

cracked at 0.8g. At 1.5g the ceiling collapse occurred.

No

No

No

0.25g

The beams were separated from the edge elements;

the end beams began to rupture and fall at 0.4g.

The A-type composition corresponds to the ASTM E580-96 US regulations and the D-type to
the common practice in non seismic areas.

SOURCES: P100-1/2013 ROMANIAN SEISMIC DESIGN CODE

12

WORLD PLATE TECTONICS

13

WHY FOREIGN NORMS and REGULATION

FIRS ROMANIAN SEISMIC DESIGN CODE FOR STRUCTURES WAS IMPLEMENTED IN 1963 P13-63.
IN 1973 United States of America HAD A SPECIFIC REGULATION SUSPENDED CEILINGS UBC 1973.
AFTER THE EARTHQUAKE OF LAQUILA IN 2009 ITALY STARTED PAYING ATTENTION TO THE NON STRUCTURAL
ELEMENTS AS THE ECONOMIC LOSSES WHERE SIGNIFICANT.
IN 2014 NEW ZEELAND PROPOSED REVISION OF THE SEISMIC DESIGN CODE FOR SUSPENDED CEILINGS DUE TO
ECONOMICAL LOSSES PRODUCED BY THE CANTERBURY EARTHQUAKE FROM 2010. THEY PERFORMED
ADDITIONAL RESEARCH EXPERIMENTS AND THEY DISCOVERED THAT BOTH CODE AND EXPERIMENTAL
RESEARCH WHERE CORESPONDING AND THE DAMAGES OCCURRED DUE TO EXECUTION AND DESIGN LEVEL OF
PERFORMANCE.

SOURCES: A.POURALI, R.P.DHAKAL & G.A.MACRAE Seismic performance of suspended ceilings:

Critical review of current design practice
14

CEILING LEVEL OF DUCTILITY

The point where the system loses its originally intended operation SLS and the
point where it loses integrity and undergoes collapse, thereby endagering occupants
ULS are rather close.

SOURCES: A.POURALI, R.P.DHAKAL & G.A.MACRAE Seismic performance of suspended ceilings:

Critical review of current design practice
15

LEVELS OF PERFORMANCE
P100-1/2013 ROMANIAN SEISMIC DESIGN CODE
CODE PRESCRIPTIONS:

The general behavior description of the CNS subassembly, for each of the four levels of seismic performance (NPS) of
the building, was made as following:
I.Completely functional/operational: Only minor damage is produced to CNS, that keeps on functioning and the
building is available for normal use. (Refitting, locally and isolated, if necessary, can be done at the beneficiarys will.
Meeting this level depends also on the equipment characteristics seismic qualification and on the execution
quality. Sometimes the existence of backup electrical supply is necessary.)
II.Functional: CNS is safe and, if the power supplies are available, most of them can function. Vital systems (Life
Safety Systems) are operational. (Minor damage to some CNS is produced, some windows are smashed and some
equipment may fail. Access paths and life safety equipment are generally available and functional if the power
supply exists. Refitting, at times more numerous, can be done at the beneficiarys will. The risk of injuring/life loss
due to CNS damage is very low. If the structure does not present major damage, the occupants can remain safely in
the building but, sometimes, under reduced comfort conditions.
III.Life protection: Significant damage to the CNS is produced. These are safe from the stability and strength point of
view but there is a possibility, in most cases, for the installation and equipment to stop working. (Extended and costly
damage to the CNS are produced, that require a long period of time to repair, but no dislocation or systematic
failures are produced. Access paths can be partially blocked by rubble or by fallen construction elements. Significant
degradation of the building. People can be wounded by falling of CNS but the risk of life loss is, generally, very low,
both inside and outside of the building.
IV.Pre collapse: It is possible that several CNS to be displaced or to present damaged/ruptured connections and for
this reason to represent a major risk of collapse and, hence, danger for life safety. (In the correctly designed
buildings, the heavy/massive elements that represent major danger in case of collapse are assured and do not fall in
areas of possible people congestions. For this damage level one cannot assure the protection of access routes,
neither the equipment that to assure life safety ( fire extinguish installation, for example.)

SOURCES: P100-1/2013 ROMANIAN SEISMIC DESIGN CODE

16

PROPER EXECUTION

SOURCES: ARMSTRONG SEISMIC CEILING DESIGN

17

PROPER EXECUTION

SOURCES: ARMSTRONG SEISMIC CEILING DESIGN

18

PROPER EXECUTION

SOURCES: ARMSTRONG SEISMIC CEILING DESIGN

19

PROPER EXECUTION

SOURCES: ARMSTRONG SEISMIC CEILING DESIGN

20

PROPER EXECUTION

SOURCES: ARMSTRONG SEISMIC CEILING DESIGN

21

IMPROPER EXECUTION

SOURCES: BASED ON DETAILED PROJECTS AND AS BUILT DOCUMENTATION

22

IMPROPER EXECUTION

SOURCES: BASED ON DETAILED PROJECTS AND AS BUILT DOCUMENTATION

23

IMPROPER EXECUTION
SEISMIC JOINTS IN EXISTING STRUCTURE SEISMIC JOINT IN CEILING STRUCTURE

SOURCES: BASED ON DETAILED PROJECTS AND AS BUILT DOCUMENTATION

24

IMPROPER EXECUTION
CEILING BRACEINGS

SOURCES: BASED ON DETAILED PROJECTS AND AS BUILT DOCUMENTATION

25

SEISMIC KNAUF
RIGID SUSPENSION

SOURCES: KNAUF SEISMIC DESIGN Edition 08/2004 New Zeeland

26

STELL STRUCTURE OVERVIEW

SOURCES: BASED ON DETAILED PROJECTS AND AS BUILT DOCUMENTATION

27

STELL STRUCTURE OVERVIEW

SOURCES: BASED ON DETAILED PROJECTS AND AS BUILT DOCUMENTATION

28

CEILING CRASHES IN ROMANIA

City Park Mall Constanta: Adidas - 2013, B&B Collection - 2008
Galleria Arad - 2012
Cora Lujerului - 2014
Mall Vitan 2010
Comercial Centrum Vitantis - 2010
Ploiesti Shoping City - 2013
AFI Palace Cotroceni - 2013
Financial Administration 5th District - 2014
Restaurant Targoviste - 2011
Underground Unirea 2 2011
Iulius Mall Cluj, Timisoara - ploi

SOURCES: adevarul.ro stirileprotv.ro a1.ro zf.ro realitatea.net

29

FOR FURTHER INFORMATION PLEASE CONTACT ANA-MARIA POPA AT:

anamaria.popa@dcts.ro

+40 721 308 407

www.dcts.ro

30