Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Use trend and moving average tools to calculate technical analysis. Write down the
Interpretation implication and limitation of the result. Do intrinsic value calculation and
technical analysis gives the same result? Why? Why not?
A. NTC
We have taken NTC from Nepali stock market in order to do the technical analysis through the
trend analysis and moving average from three methods as they are simple moving average,
weighted moving average, exponential moving average and the result obtained are illustrated in
the table below and they are shown through the graph as below.
Close
Date
Price
SMA(3)
SMA(5) EMA(3)
10/26/2014
618
10/27/2014
620
10/28/2014
616
618
618
10/30/2014
619 618.3333
617.5
11/2/2014
616
617
617.8
617.5
11/3/2014
607
614
615.6
611.5
11/4/2014
609 610.6667
613.4
608
11/5/2014
610 608.6667
612.2
609.5
11/6/2014
612 610.3333
610.8
611
11/9/2014
610 610.6667
609.6
611
11/10/2014
600 607.3333
608.2
605
11/11/2014
610 606.6667
608.4
605
11/12/2014
600 603.3333
606.4
605
11/13/2014
601 603.6667
604.2
600.5
11/16/2014
600 600.3333
602.2
600.5
11/17/2014
591 597.3333
600.4
595.5
11/18/2014
600
597
598.4
595.5
11/19/2014
600
597
598.4
600
11/20/2014
600
600
598.2
600
11/23/2014
607 602.3333
599.6
603.5
11/24/2014
600 602.3333
601.4
603.5
11/25/2014
600 602.3333
601.4
600
11/30/2014
597
599
600.8
598.5
12/1/2014
600
599
600.8
598.5
12/2/2014
600
599
599.4
600
12/3/2014
599 599.6667
599.2
599.5
W1=0.2
W1= 0.1
EMA (5)
618
614.3333333
612.5555556
612.5555556
612.3703704
612.3703704
608.2469136
608.8312757
605.8875171
604.2583448
602.8388965
598.8925977
599.2617318
599.5078212
599.6718808
602.1145872
601.4097248
600.9398165
599.6265444
599.7510296
599.8340197
599.5560131
WMA(3) WMA(5)
617.6
618.3
616.9
612.1
609.8
609.1
610.8
610.6
605.4
607
603
602.5
600.3
595.7
597.3
598.2
600
603.5
602.1
601.4
598.5
599.1
599.4
599.5
W4=0.2
Submitted By: Usha Panth (13123), Surendra Pandey (13121) and Rabin Regmi (13127)
617.6
614.3
612.7
611.3
610.4
609.9
607.3
608.4
605.2
603.3
602.2
598.5
598.4
598.3
598.2
601.2
601.4
601.4
600.5
600.1
599.4
599.1
12/3/2014
12/1/2014
11/29/2014
11/27/2014
11/25/2014
11/23/2014
11/21/2014
590
580
12/3/2014
12/1/2014
11/29/2014
11/27/2014
11/25/2014
11/23/2014
11/21/2014
11/19/2014
W3= 0.2
11/19/2014
W3=0.5
11/17/2014
W2= 0.2
11/17/2014
11/15/2014
11/13/2014
11/11/2014
11/9/2014
11/7/2014
11/5/2014
11/3/2014
11/1/2014
10/30/2014
10/28/2014
10/26/2014
W2=0.3
11/15/2014
11/13/2014
11/11/2014
11/9/2014
11/7/2014
11/5/2014
11/3/2014
11/1/2014
10/30/2014
10/28/2014
10/26/2014
K=2/ (N+1)
a. Trend analysis:
Close Price
630
620
610
600
Close Price
570
620
615
610
605
600
595
SMA(3)
SMA(5)
590
585
Submitted By: Usha Panth (13123), Surendra Pandey (13121) and Rabin Regmi (13127)
620
615
610
605
600
595
WMA(3)
590
WMA(5)
585
12/3/2014
12/1/2014
11/29/2014
11/27/2014
11/25/2014
11/23/2014
11/21/2014
11/19/2014
11/17/2014
11/15/2014
11/13/2014
11/11/2014
11/9/2014
11/7/2014
11/5/2014
11/3/2014
11/1/2014
10/30/2014
10/28/2014
10/26/2014
580
EMA(3)
590
EMA (5)
585
12/3/2014
12/1/2014
11/29/2014
11/27/2014
11/25/2014
11/23/2014
11/21/2014
11/19/2014
11/17/2014
11/15/2014
11/13/2014
11/11/2014
11/9/2014
11/7/2014
11/5/2014
11/3/2014
11/1/2014
10/30/2014
10/28/2014
10/26/2014
580
Submitted By: Usha Panth (13123), Surendra Pandey (13121) and Rabin Regmi (13127)
Submitted By: Usha Panth (13123), Surendra Pandey (13121) and Rabin Regmi (13127)
Submitted By: Usha Panth (13123), Surendra Pandey (13121) and Rabin Regmi (13127)
500
400
300
Close Price
200
100
0
5-Aug-14
5-Sep-14
5-Oct-14
5-Nov-14
5-Dec-14
Submitted By: Usha Panth (13123), Surendra Pandey (13121) and Rabin Regmi (13127)
No.of Shares
1500000
1000000
500000
No.of Shares
Submitted By: Usha Panth (13123), Surendra Pandey (13121) and Rabin Regmi (13127)
5-Sep-14
5-Oct-14
5-Nov-14
5-Dec-14
Submitted By: Usha Panth (13123), Surendra Pandey (13121) and Rabin Regmi (13127)
600
500
400
300
Close Price
200
100
0
Submitted By: Usha Panth (13123), Surendra Pandey (13121) and Rabin Regmi (13127)
500
400
Open Price
High Price
300
Low Price
Close Price
200
100
0
5-Aug-14
5-Sep-14
5-Oct-14
5-Nov-14
5-Dec-14
Submitted By: Usha Panth (13123), Surendra Pandey (13121) and Rabin Regmi (13127)
Close Price
200
Simple Moving
Average
100
0
Close Price
200
Exponential Moving
Average
100
0
Submitted By: Usha Panth (13123), Surendra Pandey (13121) and Rabin Regmi (13127)
Close Price
200
Weighted Moving
Average
100
0
There is some optimism in the market and the price of this stock is in upward trend,
therefore we can expect that the price may go up. Therefore it is a good choice for
investor.
As far as timing is concerned, it is advised to wait for few days before making the choice
of investment, which may be for 5 days or so.
Limitations:
Following are the limitations of technical analysis.
These results are completely based on the historical data and the trend of the stock price,
so it does not take fundamental analysis of the stock selection into consideration.
Submitted By: Usha Panth (13123), Surendra Pandey (13121) and Rabin Regmi (13127)
This sort of analysis will be suited for the short time period and company financial
strength comes into account while doing analysis of the stock investment for long period
time.
Moreover, it does not tell the exact price of the stock, rather indicates us about the timing
of the investment decision.
Fundamental analysis and technical are two different methods used for analysis and they
have no correlation at all when it comes to how the stock is analyzed.
Technical analysis base the decision based only on historical figures and trends followed
and is subject to vary due to subjective evaluation of it by the investors. On the other
hand, fundamental analysis is not driven so much by the subjective evaluation. Therefore
there are certainly some differences in the investment decision.
Furthermore, fundamental analysis is largely employed for long term decision while
technical analysis is a tool for the short term investors in the stock market. Therefore
there is some difference in their objectivity as well. This may be another reason behind
the different decision coming for the investment decision.
Works Cited
Axis Bank. (2014, Dec). Axis Bank. Retrieved Dec 7, 2014, from Axis Bank Website:
www.axisbank.com
Bombay Stock Exchange. (2014, July 28). Bombay Stock Exchange. Retrieved December 7,
2014, from Bombay Stock Exchange Web Site: http://www.bseindia.com/stock-share-price/axisbank-ltd/axisbank/532215/#
Submitted By: Usha Panth (13123), Surendra Pandey (13121) and Rabin Regmi (13127)