Professional Documents
Culture Documents
com
DECEMBER 2009
VOL 1, NO 8
Listed in ULRICHS
Abstract
Development Bank of Pakistan (now called Zarai Tarkiati Bank Ltd.) and their impact on farm
productivity of different types of growers in Sindh province. This research study is conducted
through primary and secondary data. Following the survey method of study, 500 growers viz
small, medium and large are selected randomly from district Khairpur, who had applied for loan
to ADBP but only 220 growers got loan facilities They were interviewed keeping in view the
objectives of hypotheses. Out of 500 growers, 220 got loan facilities amounting of Rs.
1,42,07,000. The small farmers received 20.62%, medium 09.70% and large 69.68% of total
disbursed loan by the ADBP. The pattern of institutional credit seems to be skewed in favour of
large growers. They received more loan facilities as compared to the small and the medium
growers. The survey further described that despite the development of credit institutions in the
country, the growers still relied on the informal credit institutions, which did not assist to
growers in improving their economic conditions.
Keywords: Agriculture , Credit Facilities , ADBP , ZTBL, Effects , Growers,Khairpur
1. Introduction
Economy of the developing countries depends on the income derived from the agricultural
sector. In modern times, capital is considered as the life-blood of all economic activities. It may
be defined as the existing stock of wealth used for the production of goods and services. It
includes all of those which, if acquired to day, aid us in producing tomorrow
(1) Capital supply in agriculture involves provision of real things used for production. The
produce more, a farmer needs to spend more on inputs, land improvement, wages for hired
labour resources, will result increased production as output is resulted from the transformation of
COPY RIGHT 2009 Institute of Interdisciplinary Business Research
168
ijcrb.webs.com
DECEMBER 2009
VOL 1, NO 8
inputs. Therefore, it is imperative to get desirable capital goods into the hands of common
farmers to obtain increased yield of various crops. Credit is the only device by which this could
be done efficiently.
Credit has been defined as the temporary transfer of assets or wealth from man who has, to man
who has not (2) Inclination of farmers towards the use of modern techniques and qualitative
inputs in optimum quantity in the modern agriculture has resulted in the enhancement of demand
for farm credit in almost all the developing countries with no exception of Pakistan, Accordingly,
there have been many encouraging developments in the sector of agriculture financing. It has
yielded sizeable expansion in the volume of institutional credit.
According to Board of Economic Inquiry, Punjab, (1951), the sources of institutional credit were
formal and informal. The formal sources provided 16 percent loan facilities. The informal
sources provided about 84 percent to growers, for short period on exploitative terms. Realizing
the difficulties of growers, the government established Agricultural Finance Corporation in 1952
and Agricultural Bank of Pakistan in 1957 to extend loan facilities to growers. With the
introduction of new technology in the agricultural sector during mid 1960s the cost of input
increased.
In February 1961, the Agricultural Development Bank of Pakistan (now called Zarai Tarkiati
Bank Ltd.) was established by merging ADFC and ABP for providing short, medium and long
term loan facilities to growers. With the introduction new technology in agricultural sector
during 1966, the demand for loan continued to increase for the purchase of the input. The
government allowed the commercial banks in 1973 to provide loan facilities to growers. In this
way, the credit institution extended more credit facilities to growers. But these institutions hardly
met 32 percent of the requirements. This clearly indicates that there is scope for expansion in the
credit supply.
Agriculture assumes greater importance in a developing country like Pakistan for its varied
contributions to the national economy. Even today, it contributes 25% to GDP and 44% of the
total population directly depends on this sector for their livelihood. (3) in making available the
three basic needs for human existence viz. food, shelter and clothing, agriculture leads all the
sectors of economy.
In addition to these, it provides all the fodder that is needed to sustain livestock whose number
runs into several million. Agriculture sustains much of the non-agriculture activities of the
COPY RIGHT 2009 Institute of Interdisciplinary Business Research
169
ijcrb.webs.com
DECEMBER 2009
VOL 1, NO 8
2. Methodology
For this research both primary and secondary data is obtained for the analysis. A detailed
questionnaire was used to collect data systematically. Since most of the respondents do not
understand English, so the questionnaire was translated into Sindhi, the provincial language, and
this form was supplied to every interviewer. However, the answers given in Sindhi were
recorded in English. An attempt was made to keep the questionnaire concise and to the point.
The questionnaire was also discussed with experts working in the area of agriculture extension
services and with the concerned professors working at Sindh Agriculture University, Tando Jam.
It was decided that pre-tests were required to improve the questionnaire. So a pilot survey for
each group of respondents was carried out before the survey was conducted, and questions were
added or deleted as necessary. Changes were also incorporated / suggested by the interviewers.
The reasons for these changes were that the farmers initially thought that the survey was an
COPY RIGHT 2009 Institute of Interdisciplinary Business Research
170
ijcrb.webs.com
DECEMBER 2009
VOL 1, NO 8
attempt to get information which might get them into trouble with the authorities. Farmers were
therefore reluctant to point out problems such as shortage of credit, sharing inputs with landlords
and the role of bank and revenue authorities in the distribution of credit. Therefore, it was
decided that the farmers must clearly be informed, before questions were asked, that the
information was strictly confidential and would be used for academic purposes only. This
encouraged the farmers and they gave the requisite information quite willingly.
wise
in
Loan
350
140
Medium 05-10
60
30
90
50
Total
500
220
Hectares
3. Literature Review
Idress Muhammad and Ibrahim Muhammad (1993) have examined the results of the study and
have given a clear picture of the relation between agricultural credit and agricultural
development. The results showed a great diversity in money saving behavior based on education.
It is found that out of the total 120 sampled farmers, 58% do not save money. The farmers also
save money, 50% of this, have education above middle and 36 have education up to middle
level. Study reveals the most of the improved practices that the farmers are adopting, are
171
ijcrb.webs.com
DECEMBER 2009
VOL 1, NO 8
improved seed, improved implements, farm manure and commercial fertilizers after getting
agricultural credit. Khan, Rao, Abdul Rauf, (1994) has discussed the emerging trend of focusing
on more and more attention on improving the production and productivity of farming in
Pakistan. In this regard, the bankers have promoted to evolve better schemes to improve the
income generation capacity of the farming community and help them to repay the borrowed
funds in time. Ahmed Himayat Ullah (1995) has pointed out that the institutional credit in real
term has expanded at a highly rate over the last forty years. But the contribution of institutional
loan to agricultural development has been found weak and below their expectations. Iyare
Osaretin, (1995) has discussed the issue of Agricultural Financing in Nigeria. He has analyzed
the reasons why credit policies have been unsuccessful. He further suggests that the problems of
agriculture and the financial institutions lending to farmers would be worse in the future if the
greater effort is not made to integrate rural financial market into national money markets as well
as controlling the volatility of interest rates. Khan Rao Abdul Rauf (1995) has described that in
any anti-poverty programs as well as in long-term development strategies, supply of credit by
specialized institutions takes a very important place. Qureshi, Sarfraz, Khan (1995) has analysed
that over the last thirty years, Pakistans subsidized supply led approach to increasing rural credit
for the poor has had limited success. Irfan Muhammad Arif, et al have (1999) examined the
structure of informal credit market in Pakistan by combining two approaches; a field survey
administering semi-structure questionnaire to more than 1000 informal lenders supplemented by
case studies. According to the survey, a good deal of inter-linkages exists between formal and
informal credit institutions. Mukhtiar, Kazi, (1999), has examined that the transformations from
conventional to modern farming methods demanded a change in agronomic practices to enhance
productivity per unit area of cultivation. Malik, Sohail, et al (1989) have examined that the farm
sector has increased relative importance of institutional source of credit, specially the ADBP,
Commercial Banks and Cooperatives. Anka, Alhaje, Mohammad Lawal (1992), have reviewed
the concept of supervised agricultural credit its historical perspective, appraisal of credit policies,
lending issues and factors affecting repayment by the clienteles. Khan, M. Hassan (1981)
presented a detailed analysis of financing small-scale farmers and its problems. Kamdar and
Tatri (1992) have examined the relationship between informal rural credit and selected
characteristics of farmers, such as family size and size of holding. They concluded that the size
of holding and acreage under rice and wheat increases the demand for borrowing increases.
COPY RIGHT 2009 Institute of Interdisciplinary Business Research
172
ijcrb.webs.com
DECEMBER 2009
VOL 1, NO 8
Mellor (1995) concluded that greater access of credit to small farmers would allow for high
volume and high branch density.
173
ijcrb.webs.com
DECEMBER 2009
VOL 1, NO 8
transportation hire charges, packing material etc. the long-term needs of these sectors are for
construction of go downs, bins and silos, purchase of trucks, bullock-carts, transport machinery,
country-boats, fork lifts etc. and purchase of processing machinery for use at the farm.
174
ijcrb.webs.com
DECEMBER 2009
VOL 1, NO 8
No. of
Cases
Medium-Term
Amount
No. of
Cases
Long-Term
Amount
No. of
Cases
Total
Amount
No. of Cases
Amount
1986-87
201
589.95
39.3
64
229.26
15.3
44
683.12
45.4
309
1502.33
1987-88
201
776.64
40.2
122
375.46
19.5
48
778.84
40.3
371
1930.94
1988-89
206
819.87
41.3
99
356.46
17.9
42
811.71
40.8
347
19.88.04
1989-90
182
829.26
43.5
65
301.04
15.8
34
773.91
40.6
281
1904.22
1990-91
155
814.87
48.5
49
307.51
18.3
22
556.63
33.2
226
1679.01
1991-92
146
867.88
60.1
45
261.59
18.1
13
314.52
21.8
204
1443.99
1992-93
530
817.89
50.2
40
270.93
16.6
16
541.01
33.2
586
1629.83
1993-94
163
694.76
35.4
70
649.7
33.1
23
620.16
31.6
256
1964.62
1994-95
389
1665.27
54.6
53
454.36
14.9
40
929.05
30.5
482
3048.68
1995-96
207
1042.09
72.4
10
92.82
6.4
18
304.40
21.2
235
1439.31
1996-97
245
1330.33
63.1
32
517.13
24.5
261.79
12.4
286
2109.25
1997-98
390
2521.38
69.6
70
554.66
15.3
13
548.86
15.1
473
3624.90
1998-99
537
3910.74
78.5
43
406.87
8.2
19
663.72
13.3
599
4981.33
1999-00
491
3998.82
83.5
43
411.27
8.6
15
380.70
7.9
549
4790.79
175
ijcrb.webs.com
DECEMBER 2009
VOL 1, NO 8
Chart No.1
Series1
1
9
9
9
-0
0
1
9
9
8
-9
9
1
9
9
7
-9
8
1
9
9
6
-9
7
1
9
9
5
-9
6
1
9
9
4
-9
5
1
9
9
3
-9
4
1
9
9
2
-9
3
1
9
9
0
-9
1
1
9
8
9
-9
0
1
9
8
8
-8
9
1
9
9
1
-9
2
Series2
1
9
8
7
-8
8
4500
4000
3500
3000
2500
2000
1500
1000
500
0
1
9
8
6
-8
7
A
m
o
u
n
t
Ye a rs
Chart No.2
A
m
o
u
n
t
Series1
300
200
100
0
Series2
19
8687
19
8788
19
8889
19
8990
19
9091
19
9192
19
9293
19
9394
19
9495
19
9596
19
9697
19
9798
19
9899
19
9900
Ye a rs
Chart No.3
Am
ount
Series1
Series2
19
8687
19
8788
19
8889
19
8990
19
9091
19
9192
19
9293
19
9394
19
9495
19
9596
19
9697
19
9798
19
9899
19
9900
Years
176
ijcrb.webs.com
DECEMBER 2009
VOL 1, NO 8
of Sindh province is analyzed by two methods. Firstly, it is described by the traditional methods
of cultivation and secondly in the light of new technology that was introduced in the year 1966
and brought changes in the rural economy (Saeed 2003).
Year
Decrease
1990/91
155.23
+08.25
1991/92
177.35
+14.25
1992/93
193.52
+09.12
1993/94
215.40
+11.31
1994/95
248.17
+15.21
Increase
or
177
ijcrb.webs.com
DECEMBER 2009
156.42
-37.00
1996/97
202.23
+29.29
1997/98
350.88
+73.50
1998/99
546.15
+55.65
1999/2000
593.39
+08.64
Total
2838.74
188.22
Average
283.874
+18.82
VOL 1, NO 8
Chart No.4
700
600
500
400
300
200
100
0
19
99
/2
00
0
19
98
/9
9
19
97
/9
8
19
96
/9
7
19
95
/9
6
19
94
/9
5
19
93
/9
4
19
92
/9
3
Series1
19
91
/9
2
19
90
/9
1
Amount
Years
It is evident from the Table that the loan facility was increased from Rs. 155.23 million to Rs.
593.39 million during the period 1990-91 to 199-2000. This shows an increase of more than
three times. The average loan facility stood Rs. 283.874 million with the average growth rate
18.82 percent. Such increasing investment has not yet removed the poverty from the rural area of
the district.
178
ijcrb.webs.com
DECEMBER 2009
VOL 1, NO 8
Size of
Sampled
No. of
No. of
Farms
Growers
Growers
Category
Applied for
Received
Wise in
Loan
Loan
Cultivated
Total Loan
Area of
Received in
Sampled
Rs.
Farms in
Hectares
Hectares
Small below
0-5
Medium
05-10
Large 10-20
& above
Total
Average
Loan Per
Hectare in
Rs.
Total Loan
Received by
Each
Category
Sampled
Growers
350
140
29,29,500
630
4650
20.62
60
30
13,77,500
290
4750
09.70
90
50
99,00,000
2000
4950
69.68
500
220
1,42,07,000
2920
100.00
4865.41
Average per
Hectare
Loan
179
ijcrb.webs.com
DECEMBER 2009
VOL 1, NO 8
Size of Sampled
Farms Category
Wise in Hectares
No. of
Growers
Applied
for Loan
Difference
Total Loan
Total
Between
Received in
Requirements
Demand and
Rs.
of Loan in Rs
Supply in
Rs.
Percentage
of Total
Disburseme
nt by Each
Category of
Grower
350
140
29,59,500
69,30,000
20.62
Medium 05-10
60
30
13,77,500
30,56,600
09.70
90
50
99,00,000
2,01,20,000
69.68
500
220
1,42,07,000
3,01,06,00
100
32.06
of
Requirement
Source: Survey Data
Table 5 analyses the loan facility extended by the ADBP in district Khairpur. It is pointed out
that the large growers have got 69.68% loan facility, medium growers 09.70% and the small
growers 20.62%. The overall credit facility met the requirements 32.06% of the growers. This
proves that major portion of credit is arranged by the growers from the non-institutional sources
of credit. The inconvenience in loan disbursement occurs due to ineffective policies of the policy
makers in the country.
180
ijcrb.webs.com
DECEMBER 2009
VOL 1, NO 8
mills as raw material for the production of sugar. With the encouraging output of sugarcane two
sugar mills were set up in district Khairpur and provided every year two thousand job
opportunities to the people of this district. Besides, the infrastructure around the district
improved which provided marketing facilities to the growers. In this way, the revenue of the
growers increased and had brought changes in their living standards. Cotton is also the cash crop
of district Khairpur. The cultivated area of cotton increased from 69,750 hectares to 77,928
output hectares from 1,36,231 ton to 2,85,765 tons yield per hectare rose from 356 kgs to 576
kgs which shows an average increase of 4 percent in the cultivated area, 11.27% in output and
yield per hectare 8.59%. This increasing trend encouraged private sector for the establishment of
ginning factories and currently 16 ginning factories are functioning in this district. Thus, this
crop extended job opportunities in the district and change the socio-economic conditions of the
rural people.
4. Findings of the Study
a. 500 different respondents were interviewed viz small, medium and large growers who applied
for loan to ADBP. All growers adopted new methods of cultivation.
b. Out of 500 growers, 220 got loan facilities from the ADBP amount of Rs. 1,42,07,000.
The classification of growers who received loan is as under
Table 6: Classification of Growers
Size
of Number
of
Growers
Growers
in Rs.
Each Category
Small
140
29,29,500
20,62
Medium
30
13,77,500
09,70
Large
50
99,00,000
69,68
Total
220
1,42,07,000
100
The study analyzed that the average per hectare cost of production of small grower stood
Rs. 15,650 and against it he got loan facility of Rs. 4,620 per hectare, the medium
181
ijcrb.webs.com
DECEMBER 2009
VOL 1, NO 8
growers cost was Rs. 15,290 and against it he received Rs. 4750 per hectare and the
large growers cost became Rs. 15,010 and against it he sanctioned Rs. 4950 per hectare
which was low amount.
ii.
The net revenue of small grower stood Rs. 6,450 per hectare, the medium growers net
revenue comprised Rs. 7,310 and the large grower earned Rs. 7,890 net revenue per
hectare.
iii.
The research proved that growers did not receive loan facilities according to their
requirements.
iv.
The survey further describes that despite of development of credit institutions, the
growers still rely on the informal credit institutions which did not improve their income
due to high rate of interest and pre-conditions put by the agents.
v.
Reasons for inadequate supply of credit. While conducting interviews from the growers,
they described the following main problems during getting the loan.
a. Inadequate supply of credit by the formal institutions.
b. Bribe for sanctioning of loans
c. Delay in sanctioning and payment of loans
d. Lengthy and completed procedure
e. Political interference
f. Mismanagement in the system
g. These problems bring adverse effects on the production.
5. Conclusion
182
ijcrb.webs.com
DECEMBER 2009
VOL 1, NO 8
References
Ahmed Mahmood and Roy, Mihir, Kumar (1995), Bank Finance in Agricultural Experiences of
Islamic Bank Bangladesh Limited, Peshawar, Journal of Rural Development and
Administration, Summer, Vol: XXVII: 3
Andrus and Muhammad, (1966), Trade, Finance and Development in Pakistan, Oxford
University Press.
Anka, Alhaje, Mohammad Lawal (1992), Supervised Agricultural Credit, Its Problems,
Prospects, Suggestions for Implementation in Pakistan, Peshawar Journal of Rural
Development and Administration, Vol: XXIV:3
Akhter, S.M, (1986), Economic Problems of Pakistan, Lahore.
Board of Economic Inquiry, Punjab (1951), Report on the Need and Supply of Credit in the
Rural Areas of the Punjab, Lahore, Publication No. 101.
Government of Pakistan (1980), Private Tube Wells and Factors Affecting Current Rate of
Investment, Islamabad, Research Section, Planning and Development Division.
Government of Pakistan (1993), Report of the Prime Minsters Taskforce on Agriculture,
Islamabad.
Government of Pakistan (1980-2005) Economic Surveys, Finance Division, Islamabad.
Government of Pakistan (1985-2005), Agricultural Statistics of Pakistan, Islamabad.
Government of Pakistan (1985-1995) Pakistan Basic Facts, Islamabad.
Government of Pakistan, (1985) Pakistan Statistical Yearbook 1985, Karachi, Statistics Division.
Himayatullah (1995), Agricultural Credit Availability and Requirement in Pakistan: A Detailed
Analysis, Peshawar, Journal of Rural Development and Administration, Vol: XXVII: 4.
Idrees Muhammad and Ibrahim Muhammad (1993), Agricultural Credit Role in the
Development of Agriculture, Peshawar, Journal of Rural Development and
Administration, Vol. XXV: 4.
Irfan, Muhammad Arfi, G.M. Ali, S. Mubshir and Nazil, Hina, (1999), Islamabad, The Structure
of Informal Credit Market in Pakistan, PIDE.
Iyare Osaretine (1995), Agricultural Financing and Credit Policies in Nigeria, Journal of Rural
Development and Administration, summer, Vol. XXVII, No. 3.
Khan, Rao, Abdul Rauf (1992), Role of Credit in Rural Development, Peshawar, Journal of
Rural Development and Administration, Vol: XXIV:1.
COPY RIGHT 2009 Institute of Interdisciplinary Business Research
183
ijcrb.webs.com
DECEMBER 2009
VOL 1, NO 8
Khan, Rao, Abdul Rauf (1995), Why Access of Credit to the Poor? Journal of Rural
Development and Administration Summer, Vol. XXVII: 3.
Khan, Rao, Abdul Rauf (1994), Farm Loans Recovery Problem in Pakistan: Its Possible
Solution, Islamabad, The Pakistan Development Review, Vol: 33:4, Part II.
Kamdar, M.S and G. Tatri, (1992), Borrowing and Lending in Agriculture: A Case Study of Tatri
Village, District Larkana, Peshawar, Journal of Rural Development and Administration.
Khawaja, A. Haleem and Malik, Liaqat (1992) Economic Development of Pakistan Problems
and Policies, Lahore, First Edition.
Khan, M. Hassan (1981), The Under Development and Agrarian Structure in Pakistan, Boulder,
West-View Press.
Khan, Mahmood Hassan, Syed Nawab Haider Naqvi and Ghaffar Chaudhry (1989), Structural
Change in Pakistans Agriculture, PIDE, Islamabad.
Malik, Sohail, J. Mustaq et al (1989), Different Access and the Real Credit Market in Pakistan:
Some Recent Evidence, Islamabad, The Pakistan Development Review, Vol: 28/4.
Malik, Sohial, Safiya, Arab and Nargis Sultana (1994), Pakistans Economic Performance 1947
to 1993: A Descriptive Analysis, Sure Publishers, Lahore.
Mellor (1995), Some Issues International Finance for Agricultural Development: International
Evidence and Implications for Pakistan, Islamabad, The Pakistan Development Review.
Mukhtiar, Kazi, (1999), Agricultural Financing for Production, Development and Marketing
Needs, Pakistans Experience Journal of the Institute of Bankers Pakistan, Karachi.
Nasir, M. Saeed and Hyder, S. Kamal (2002), Economics of Pakistan, Lahore.
Muhammad Aslam (1994), Perspective on Development Planning in Pakistan, Lahore, Third
Edition.
Qureshi Sarfraz Khan (1995), Credit for Rural Poor in Pakistan, Islamabad, The Pakistan
Development Review, Winter, Vol. 34:4 Part II.
Report of the State Bank of Pakistan (1962), Agricultural Credit in Pakistan, Karachi.
State Bank of Pakistan (1999-2004) Annual Reports, Karachi.
184
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.