Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Clinical Rehabilitation
25(9) 788799
! The Author(s) 2011
Reprints and permissions:
sagepub.co.uk/journalsPermissions.nav
DOI: 10.1177/0269215511400639
cre.sagepub.com
Abstract
Objective: To review the literature to identify and synthesize the evidence on risk factors for patient falls
in geriatric rehabilitation hospital settings.
Data sources: Eligible studies were systematically searched on 16 databases from inception to
December 2010.
Review methods: The search strategies used a combination of terms for rehabilitation hospital patients,
falls, risk factors and older adults. Cross-sectional, cohort, case-control studies and randomized clinical
trials (RCTs) published in English that investigated risks for falls among patients 65 years of age in
rehabilitation hospital settings were included. Studies that investigated fall risk assessment tools, but did
not investigate risk factors themselves or did not report a measure of risk (e.g. odds ratio, relative risk)
were excluded.
Results: A total of 2,824 references were identified; only eight articles concerning six studies met
the inclusion criteria. In these, 1,924 geriatric rehabilitation patients were followed. The average age
of the patients ranged from 77 to 83 years, the percentage of women ranged from 56% to 81%,
and the percentage of fallers ranged from 15% to 54%. Two were case-control studies, two were
RCTs and four were prospective cohort studies. Several intrinsic and extrinsic risk factors for falls
were identified.
Conclusion: Carpet flooring, vertigo, being an amputee, confusion, cognitive impairment, stroke, sleep
disturbance, anticonvulsants, tranquilizers and antihypertensive medications, age between 71 and 80,
previous falls, and need for transfer assistance are risk factors for geriatric patient falls in rehabilitation
hospital settings.
Keywords
Falls, elderly, rehabilitation, safety, predictors
Received: 30 August 2010; accepted: 23 January 2011
Introduction
Patient falls are the predominant patient safety
issue in hospitals, accounting for up to 32% of
1
Department of Physical Therapy, Florida International
University, Miami, FL, US
2
Glenrose Rehabilitation Hospital, Edmonton, Alberta, Canada
3
Division of Clinical Epidemiology and Biostatistics, Institute of
Social and Preventive Medicine, University of Bern,
Finkenhubelweg, Bern, Switzerland
Corresponding author:
Bruno R da Costa, Division of Clinical Epidemiology and
Biostatistics, Institute of Social and Preventive Medicine,
University of Bern, Finkenhubelweg 11, 3012 Bern, Switzerland
Email: bdacosta@ispm.unibe.ch
Vieira et al.
789
Methods
To identify eligible trials we undertook a systematic search of the following databases:
MEDLINE, EMBASE, CINAHL, SCOPUS,
Web of Science, Rehab data, and CIRRIE
Database of International Rehabilitation
Research from inception to December 2010.
The search strategy included a combination of
terms for rehabilitation hospital patients, falls,
risk factors and older adults (Appendix 1). The
terms included text words, keywords and subject
headings specic to each database. Similar strategies were used to identify previously published
systematic reviews in the following databases:
Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews,
OTseeker, and PEDro from inception to
December 2010. In addition, we searched
ProQuest Dissertations for unpublished studies
(inception to December 2010), searched conference proceedings on OCLC ProceedingsFirst
(inception to December 2010), screened reference lists of all included papers and contacted
authors and experts in the eld. Finally, we
searched four clinical trial registers to identify
ongoing trials: Current Controlled Trials
(www.controlled-trials.com); ClinicalTrials.gov
(www.clinicaltrials.gov);
Australian
New
Zealand Clinical Trials Register (www.actr.
org.au), and UK Clinical Research Network
Study Portfolio (http://public.ukcrn.org.uk/
search/) Our search strategies were derived
from review of a relevant Cochrane systematic
review,15 guidelines for eective searching15,16
and consultation with a medical rehabilitation
librarian.
We included observational studies that 1)
investigated risks for falls among patients
790
Results
We identied 2,824 references in our literature
search and considered 2,309 to be potentially
eligible (Figure 1). After full text screening,
eight articles concerning six studies met our
inclusion criteria.1724 Most of the studies
excluded during full-text screening, were
excluded either because the studies were not conducted in a rehabilitation setting or because
patients were not exclusively 65 years of age or
older. The median year of publication was 2005
(range: 1999 to 2009).
Overall, 1,924 geriatric patients in rehabilitation hospital settings were followed for the
investigation of fall risk factors (Table 1).
In general, patients were going through rehabilitation for neurological or orthopaedic conditions. Only three studies did not report to
which medical subspecialty patients were treated
under. The average age of the patients ranged
from 77 to 83 years, the percentage of women
ranged from 56% to 81%, and the percentage of
fallers ranged from 15% to 54%. All included
studies were longitudinal; two were case-control
studies,17,18 two were RCTs19,20 and four were
prospective cohort studies.2124
All studies presented potential biases
(Table 2). Five had prospective designs, four
enrolled patients consecutively or adjusted their
results for potential confounders, and all studies
provided clear fall event denitions. On the
other hand, only in two studies were the investigators blinded regarding the studies objectives.
Potential biases could not be assessed for some
items in all studies due to incomplete reporting of
the methods employed.
The factors identied as signicant risks for
falls (eect ratios and lower boundary of condence intervals higher than 1) were: carpet ooring (as opposed to vinyl ooring), vertigo, being
an amputee, confusion (three studies), cognitive
impairment, stroke, sleep disturbance, some
medications (i.e. anticonvulsants, tranquilizers
and
antihypertensive
in
two
studies),
age (7180), previous falls, and need for
Vieira et al.
791
12 articles
could not be
retrieved
Figure 1. Stages of this systematic review of studies investigating risk factors for geriatric patient falls in rehabilitation hospital settings.
Discussion
This systematic review identied eight articles
concerning six studies investigating falls risk
factors for geriatric patients in rehabilitation
hospital settings. Studies identied in this
review indicate that the following are signicant
risk factors: carpet ooring, vertigo, being an
amputee, confusion, cognitive impairment,
stroke, sleep disturbance, anticonvulsants,
17
Barr 199918
Aizen 2007
Ref.
Design
n*
Medical condition
77
71
56
Mean %
Age ,
Medical records
and incident
reports.
Interview; medical
records; functional tests.
Measurement of
exposure, patient
characteristics,
and falls
100
# falls
Table 1. Overview of included studies showing studies characteristics and summary of findings
Unclear
84 (54)
Main findingsy
Unclear
Amputee: OR
5.15 (2.15
12.45)
Stroke: OR 2.71
(1.734.24)
Patients requiring assistance
with transfers:
OR 1.74 (1.21
2.5)
Confused: OR
5.18 (2.839.49)
Antipsychotics:
OR 0.35 (0.16
0.79)
Vertigo:
OR 5.25
(1.0725.9)
Antihypertensive: OR 2.4
(1.135.1)
Fall
incidence rate,
length of
# fallers (%) follow-upz
792
Clinical Rehabilitation 25(9)
Haines
200620
Izumi 200221
Donald
200019
277
226
54
83
83
58
67
81
11
Standardized risk
assessment tool;
fall incident
report.
Medical records
Unclear
Unclear
39 (17)
8 (15)
13 months
follow-up
Anticonvulsants:
OR 2.22 (1.08
4.58)
Previous falls:
OR 1.75 (1.19
2.56)
Sleep disturbance: OR 2.39
(1.653.48)
Carpet floor vs.
vinyl floor: RR
8.3 (0.9573)
(favoring vinyl
floor)
Poor patient
and therapist
communication:
RR 1.21 (0.68
2.14)
(continued)
Use of a walker:
OR 0.22 (0.05
1.01)
Use of a wheelchair: OR 1.22
(0.403.70)
Vieira et al.
793
Vassallo
2004**22
Design
Medical condition
Ref.
Table 1. Continued
599
n*
82
136 (23)
Mean %
Age ,
Measurement of
exposure, patient
characteristics,
and falls
Unclear
Previous fall:
OR 2.05 (1.22
3.44)
Visual impairment: OR 1.18
(0.721.93)
Hearing impairment: OR 1.39
(0.922.10)
Lower limb
abnormality: OR
1.07 (0.701.65)
Confusion: OR
3.77 (3.525.65)
Use of diuretics: OR 0.85
(0.571.24)
Antidepressants: OR 1.22
(0.702.12)
Antihypertensive: OR 1.31
(0.881.96)
Antiparkinsonian: OR 1.69
(0.823.47)
Tranquilizers:
OR 1.52 (0.99
2.34)
Fall
incidence rate,
length of
follow-upz
Main findingsy
794
Clinical Rehabilitation 25(9)
Vassallo
2009**24
825
1,025
83
82
173 (17)
25.6 days
16.8 days
Cognitive
impairment: OR
3.75 (2.585.45)
Non-confused
patients: OR
0.38 (0.290.49)
Patients not on
tranquilizers: OR
0.63 (0.490.82)
*N of interest to our review. **Study population of Vassallo et al.2224 derived from the same patient cohort (confirmed through contact with the author).
y Effect measures based on faller or non-faller classification. Unclear whether fall occurrence in Izumi21 was considered >1/per patient.
z When available. Fall rate standardized to 100 patient-years to facilitate interpretability.
Vassallo
2006**23
Vieira et al.
795
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
Yes
No
Aizen 200717
Barr 199918
Donald 200019
Haines 200620
Izumi 200221
Vassalo 200422
Vassalo 200623
Vassalo 200924
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Unclear
Yes
Unclear
Unclear
Unclear
Unclear
Yes
Unclear
No
Unclear
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Study
Yes
Unclear
Yes
Unclear
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Clear definition
of fall provided
Completeness
of data analysis
Adjustment
for confounders
Blinding of
investigator
Consecutive
enrolment
Prospective
design
Table 2. Findings of the assessment of the included studies in relation to risk of bias
Unclear
Unclear
Not applicable
Unclear
Unclear
Unclear
Unclear
Unclear
Selection
of threshold
a priori y
796
Vieira et al.
797
798
Clinical messages
. Falls in geriatric rehabilitation settings are
common; from 15% to 54% of these
patients fall during hospitalization.
. Carpet ooring, vertigo, being an amputee, confusion, cognitive impairment,
stroke, sleep disturbance, anticonvulsants,
tranquilizers and antihypertensive medications, age between 71 and 80, previous
falls, and need for transfer assistance are
risk factors for geriatric patient falls in
rehabilitation hospital settings.
. There seems to be no unique features
among geriatric rehabilitation hospital
patients. Thus, the higher rates of falls in
this setting may be related to a higher
prevalence of known risk factors for falls
among these patients.
Acknowledgements
The authors would like to acknowledge the Glenrose
Rehabilitation Hospital Research and Nursing oces
for their support. We would like to thank Daniel Holt
for his help formatting this paper, and we would like
to thank and to acknowledge the other members of
the Glenrose fall reduction group (Colleen Berean,
Debra Paches, Penny Caveny, Doris Yuen and
Lauralee Ballash) for their input and suggestions on
early drafts of this paper.
Funding
This work was supported by the Alberta Health
Services.
Competing interests
None declared.
Refererences
1. Healey F, Scobie S, Oliver D, et al. Falls in english
and welsh hospitals: a national observational study
based on retrospective analysis of 12 months of patient
safety incident reports. Qual Saf Health Care 2008; 17:
424430.
Vieira et al.
799
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.