26/12/2014

Aligning overhead crane rails - HOIST magazine

LOGIN or SUBSCRIBE

Enter Keyword
HOME

NEWS

FEATURES

BLOGS

EVENTS

BUYERS GUIDE

SUBMISSIONS

Search

DIGITAL EDITIONS

Latest Features | Features Archive

Aligning overhead crane rails

Share
Share
Share
Share
More 9

17 January 2008
John C Wickhart of Washington DC has applied for international and US
patents for a method and apparatus for performing alignment surveys on
overhead cranes.
Summary
The survey apparatus of the invention is alternately pushed or pulled by the
travelling crane. It consists of a wheeled carriage including survey sighting
targets, such as prisms, that are visible to survey personnel standing on the
ground. Using conventional survey instruments, data is collected for X, Y and Z
coordinates to generate, as required, a rail alignment profile, a rail elevation
profile, a rail span profile and a crane skew profile. These profiles can be used
to determine whether the crane confirms to alignment specifications. The skew
data can also be used to determine whether the crane itself may be misaligned.
Previous art

Fig 4

Fig 1

The apparatus of the invention is designed to work with a typical overhead crane
in which the crane spans a distance between two crane rails (Fig 1 - 1302) with
each rail supported by girder which is, in turn, supported by a series of
columns. The crane contacts each of the crane rails with an end truck with two
or more wheels (1316) at each end. The leading and trailing ends of each end
truck are terminated with a rail sweep (1314).

Fig 1 - Schematic side elevation of a first exemplary rail survey carriage attached
to a crane rail sweep
Typically the crane includes a trolley (Fig 4 - 1318) travelling between the two
end trucks on a pair of bridge rails, each with a bridge girder support. The trolley
will carry hoisting mechanisms and load hooks (1324). Thus, as is usual, the
crane operator can move cargo between any two locations between the crane
rails.
Due to the large scale of typical industrial overhead cranes and heavy loads,
proper alignment of crane rails and crane wheels is crucial to safe and efficient
operation. The invention cites alignment standards outlined in the Crane
Manufacturers Association of America (CMAA)'s specification 70 and AISE
technical report No 13.

Fig 2

Fig 3

Many types of conventional rail surveys involve time-consuming methods

requiring the rail to be locked out (turning off the power to the hot rail), with
survey personnel walking the length of the runway.

Fig 2 - Enlargement of rail survey carriage in Fig 1

As well as alignment other important factors include the positioning of the crane
end-truck wheels parallel to their respective crane rails, and/or assuring that the
drive motor output provided to the respective end-trucks is equivalent.
Imbalances in the drive motor output can cause crane skew even if the rail
alignment is within tolerances. Excess wear and tear on the rail and crane
wheels will result requiring expensive repairs. Thus a safe method for quick
and accurate collection of rail survey data, to find the root cause of
misalignment problems, would be very beneficial.
Previous methods may include use of piano wire for rail straightening, using a
tape measure to check the span between the rails. This method is not very
accurate and is very time consuming. More accurate is the use of setting a
transit on the rail and stopping at various points to take readings by survey

http://www.hoistmagazine.com/features/aligning-overhead-crane-rails/

1/3

26/12/2014

Aligning overhead crane rails - HOIST magazine

personnel, but measuring the span still involves use of a tape measure.
Another instrument is required to check rail elevation.

Fig 3 - Schematic side elevation of a second exemplary rail survey carriage

The inventor cites two earlier patents that are dedicated to the needs of
overhead cranes rather than train tracks. One US Patent (2005/011 1012 by
Steven Waisanen, published May 26 2006) uses a self-levelling, remotely
operated laser survey device as a stationery component, and a mobile
component with a screen and image capture device. The laser emits a beam of
light towards the screen of the mobile part as it travels the length of the crane
rail. The image capture device collects the data of the position of the laser light
beam on the target and transmits to a remote computer. This data is used to
assess the alignment of the crane rail. Wickhart claims that Waisanen does not
provide details of claimed alternate embodiments for crane rail configurations,
but covers a bottom-running crane rail configuration.
US Patent Number 6,415,208 by Romauld Pojda, issued on July 2 2002, also
describes a similar laser-based device but configured to collect data for top-rail
crane configuration.
Waisanan claims that these two patented devices suffer from serious
deficiencies including reliance on complex combinations of electronics,
including mobile operation in harsh environments likely to result in failure and
the need for specialised repairs. He also claims that these devices are not
capable of providing sufficient information quickly and accurately to identify the
cause of misalignment problems (on rail alignment information only in these
cases, with nothing on span alignment and elevation), and are incapable of
giving timely information on crane skew to identify and correct imbalances in the
drive motors.
Total station
A typical total station (ET/EDM) (Fig 8 -1200) is used in conjunction with the rail
survey carriage. It is mounted on a tripod with a calculator attached including a
keypad and display, and is used to determine angles and distances to the
points being surveyed, thus allowing the coordinates of these positions to be
calculated by trigonometry. This data can be downloaded to a computer and
application software used to generate a map of the surveyed area. The total
station may also have a GPS interface.

Fig 4 - Ground view schematic perspective of an overhead crane equipped with

rail survey carriage and electronic transit (ET)/electronic distance measuring
(EDM) device or 'total station' positioned at dock level
The total station generates angle results as digital read-outs, being more
accurate and less prone to errors due to interpolating between scale marks and
any misrecording. Readouts are also continuous so angles can be reviewed at
any time. The use of reflecting prisms also improves accuracy in the laser EDM.
If a data recorder is used for downloading measurement data and target
location codes it can also reduce the potential for error.
When first switched on the total station may set itself to zero degrees (north), but
a control knob will allow this siting to be reoriented by rotating the whole
instrument. Thus in this way the total station, or ET/EDM, can be used in
conjunction with the rail survey carriage to perform surveys of the crane.
Rail survey carriage
In Fig 1 a form of rail survey carriage (100) is shown in side elevation attached
to a crane rail sweep. Included is an end rail bumper (1310) acting as a
collision damping mechanism in case the crane exceeds its designed
operating zone along the crane rails. This bumper can also be used as support
for a carriage safety harness (1311) to prevent the rail survey carriage from
falling down.
Fig 2 shows an enlargement of Fig 1 showing the rail survey carriage with a
body (102) that rides on the crane rail via survey carriage wheels (104). The
carriage is connected to the rail sweep via a swivel arm (106), or drive arm,
allowing the survey carriage to be moved selectively along the rail. The swivel
am is connected to the survey carriage body via a pivot post (108) extending
from a survey carriage hinge (110) and connected to the body by a hinge pin
(111). A force applied from the crane rail sweep to the survey carriage pivot post
is dampened by a survey carriage hinge spring (112). At the other end the
swivel arm is attached to the rail sweep via a bracket (120) above the crane rail.
The rail survey carriage includes a prism arm (126), extending in a direction
generally perpendicular to the crane rail, towards the opposite crane rail. At
least one prism (122) is attached via a bracket (124) to the of the prism arm.
Additional prisms can be attached to facilitate sighting of at least one of the

http://www.hoistmagazine.com/features/aligning-overhead-crane-rails/

2/3

26/12/2014

Aligning overhead crane rails - HOIST magazine

prisms by the total station.

The prism arm may also include prism arm counterweights on the opposite
end of the prism arm to where the prisms are mounted. Connections may be
bolted. The counterweights are selected to counterbalance the combined
weight of the prisms and prism arm. The combined weight of the assembly is
therefore centred over the centreline of the survey carriage body extending in a
direction parallel to the length of the crane rail.
The sighting target on the prism arm is mounted at a known offset relative to the
centreline of the survey carriage body.
The patent includes a detailed description of the components of the first
example of a rail survey carriage and an exploded diagram of these
components. Component features include outer circumferential flanges (105)
on the survey carriage wheels. The wheels may be tapered to aid centring of
each survey carriage wheel pair, and hence the carriage body, on the crane rail.
Fig 3 shows a second example of a rail survey carriage in schematic side
elevation with several modifications. These include single survey carriage
wheels positioned at each end of the carriage body attached by a single axle.
The wheel rides directly on top of the crane rail. To ensure that the carriage
remains aligned with the centreline of the crane rail, the survey carriage
includes carriage stabilising side-arms each with a stabilising wheel.
Suggested wheel material is polyurethane with a Shore Scale 9OA. The
stabilising wheels make tight contact with the side faces of the crane rail to
ensure centring. Each rotates about an axis to reduce friction and wear.
Another modification is the construction of the survey carriage swivel arm or
drive arm. It includes several rigid members connected together at one of more
adjustable joints allowing adjustment of the angles at the time of installation, for
example sections 206A, B and C in the diagram. The adjustable joints are
formed about a central hole (243) with several circumferential holes (245) in
one member being connected and circumferential slots (247) formed in the
rigid plates of the other member being connected. With bolt connection this
allows the members to be rotated relative to each other to achieve the desired
angle.

About us
RSS feeds
Links

Advertise with us
Terms and conditions
Site Map

Contact us
Privacy
Cookie Policy

Newsletter sign up
Online magazine sign up

www.hoistmagazine.com is a product of World Market Intelligence. Copyright 2014 World Market Intelligence Ltd. All rights reserved.

http://www.hoistmagazine.com/features/aligning-overhead-crane-rails/

3/3