Professional Documents
Culture Documents
SUPREME COURT
Manila
SECOND DIVISION
vs.
NARVASA, C.J.:
In this special civil action of certiorari the University of the
Philippines seeks the nullification of the Order dated October 30,
1990 of Director Pura Ferrer-Calleja of the Bureau of Labor
Relations holding that "professors, associate professors and
assistant professors (of the University of the Philippines) are . .
rank-and-file employees . . ;" consequently, they should, together
with the so-called non-academic, non-teaching, and all other
employees of the University, be represented by only one labor
organization. 1 The University is joined in this undertaking by the
Solicitor General who "has taken a position not contrary to that of
petitioner and, in fact, has manifested . . that he is not opposing
the petition . . ." 2
the
Footnotes
1 A subsequent Order, dated November 20, 1990,
denied reconsideration of the Order of October
30, 1990; SEE footnote 11, infra.
2 Rollo, pp. 105 (Manifestation and Motion), and
222 (Compliance)
3 Docketed as BLR No. 3-08-90.
4 Registered in accordance with Executive Order
No. 180 as evidenced by Registration Certificate
No. 038 dated Nov. 10, 1987.
16 Ibid.
17 Section 7, Ibid., p. 218, Rollo, emphasis supplied.
18 Section 11, Ibid., pp. 218-219, Rollo.
19 Section 12, Ibid., p. 219, Rollo.
20 G.R. No. 75039, January 28, 1988, 157 SCRA 416.
21 G.R. No. 18710, March 30, 1963, 7 SCRA 598.
22 G.R. No. L-18938, August 31, 1964, 11 SCRA 766.
23 Rule 1, Section (1) of the Implementing
Guidelines of Executive Order No. 180.
26 Emphasis supplied.
27 p. 18, Memorandum for respondent U.P. Union,
p. 188, Rollo.
SECOND DIVISION
NOCON, J.:
The sole issue presented for resolution in this petition
for certiorari with prayer for preliminary injunction is whether
or not a single petition for certification election or for
recognition as the sole and exclusive bargaining agent can
validly or legally be filed by a labor union in three (3)
corporations each of which has a separate and distinct legal
personality instead of filing three (3) separate petitions.
On April 6, 1989, private respondent labor union, PGA
Brotherhood Association - Union of Filipino Workers (UFW),
hereinafter referred to as "the Union " filed a petition for
Direct Certification/Certification Election among the rank and
file employees of Philippine Scout Veterans Security and
Investigation Agency (PSVSIA), GVM Security and
SO ORDERED. 1
On July 21, 1989, the security agencies appealed the MedArbiter's Order to the Secretary of Labor and Employment
claiming that said Order was issued with grave abuse of
discretion when it ruled that the three security agencies could
be considered as a single bargaining entity for purposes of the
holding of a certification election.
On December 15, 1989, the Labor Secretary Franklin M. Drilon
denied the appeal for lack of merit while at the same time
affirming the Med-Arbiter's Order of July 6, 1989. He also
ordered the immediate conduct of a certification election. The
dispositive portion of which reads as follows:
WHEREFORE, premises considered, the Appeal
of respondents Security agencies is hereby
denied for lack of merit and the Order dated 6
July affirmed.
Let therefore, the pertinent records of this case
be immediately forwarded to the Regional
Office for he immediate conduct of the
certification election.
SO ORDERED. 2
On January 5, 1990, the three security agencies filed a Motion
for Reconsideration arguing that they were denied their rights
to due process and that jurisdiction was not acquired over
them by the labor authorities.
On January 26, 1990, the succeeding Labor Secretary, Ruben D.
Torres, likewise denied the Motion for Reconsideration for lack
of merit and reiterated the directive that a certification
election be conducted without further delay.
On March 14, 1990, the instant petition was filed by the three
security agencies, raising the following grounds:
I