Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Abstract
Ecological plasticity, i.e., inter-population differentiation of the species Teucrium flavum was analyzed on the basis
of morpho-anatomical variability of its five populations from the maquis (Cisto-Ericetea and Cisto-Micromerietea),
rocky grounds (Festuco-Brometea) and rocky crevices (Asplenietea rupestris) in the Eumediterranean and sub-
Mediterranean region. Univariate statistic analysis included 22 quantitative characters related to the leaf and stem
anatomy and morphology. In order to establish the variability and significance of morpho-anatomical differentiation,
principal component analyses (PCA), multivariate analyses of variances (MANOVA), discriminant components
analysis (DCA) and clustering, according to the UPMGA method based on Mahalanobius’ distances, have been done.
The morpho-anatomical analysis of plants from the five distant populations confirmed that the species T. flavum
belongs to malacophyllous xeromorphic species. It was established that the plants from all the five populations
analyzed are distinguished by stable conservative xeromorphic characteristics. There is a difference between the
pronounced xeromorphic plants belonging to Eumediterranean populations and the subxeromorphic sub-
Mediterranean ones.
r 2005 Elsevier GmbH. All rights reserved.
0367-2530/$ - see front matter r 2005 Elsevier GmbH. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.flora.2005.05.001
ARTICLE IN PRESS
B. Lakušić et al. / Flora 201 (2006) 108–119 109
Biogeography Adriatic province Adriatic province Aegean province of Adriatic province Adriatic province
of Eumediterranean of Eumediterranean Eumediterranean of of
region region region Submediterranean Submediterranean
region region
Vegetation Rocky crevices Maquis (Cisto- Maquis (Cisto- Rocky grounds Rocky grounds
(Asplenietea Ericetea) Micromerietea) (Festuco-Brometea) (Festuco-Brometea)
rupestris)
Substratum Limestone Limestone Limestone Limestone Limestone
Altitude 40 m 80 m 80 m 200 m
Average annual 15–16 1C 15–16 1C 17–18.5 1C 10–16 1C 10–16 1C
temperature
Average January 7–8 1C 7–8 1C 8.5–10.5 1C 1–5 1C 1–5 1C
temperature
Annual 1300–2300 mm 1300–2300 mm 350–600 mm 1500–3100 mm 1500–3100 mm
precipitation
Chamaedrys which might indicate the relict character of tions analyzed here developed under conditions of the
the species and its belonging to the ancient Mediterra- Eumediterranean climate, on the coasts of the Adriatic
nean flora (Tutin and Wood, 1972). On the basis of and Aegean Sea. Another two populations inhabit sub-
investigation of flowers and inflorescenses of the genus Mediterranean locations (the Montenegro hinterland, in
Teucrium, Kästner (1978) introduced a new classifica- the canyons of Cijevna and Morača rivers), character-
tion of the genus, in which the species T. flavum is ized by the perhumid-sub-Mediterranean Adriatic cli-
included in Sect. Pollium Schreber. mate (Table 1).
In the Balkan Peninsula T. flavum is a strictly
calciphilous plant that inhabits limestone and dolomite,
at altitudes between 0 and 200 m. It is an important
element of maquis and garrigue vegetation as well as of Material and methods
their degradation forms in the Mediterranean and sub-
Mediterranean floristic region (Lakušić, 2000). Plant material and morpho-anatomical analysis
The aim of the present study was to establish whether
there exists a morpho-anatomical differentiation be- A morpho-anatomical analysis was done on plant
tween Eumediterranean and sub-Mediterranean popula- samples from five populations of the species T. flavum
tions of the xeromorphic species T. flavum, bearing in growing in the Adriatic (Montenegro) and Aegean
mind the environmental, particularly climatic differ- (Greece) part of the Mediterranean Basin. The collected
ences between their habitats. Three out of five popula- plant material was either placed in a herbarium or fixed
ARTICLE IN PRESS
110 B. Lakušić et al. / Flora 201 (2006) 108–119
in 50% alcohol and deposited, respectively in the I. Leaf anatomy characters: (1) Height of adaxial
Herbarium of the Institute of Botany and Botanical epidermal cells; (2) thickness of palisade tissue; (3)
Garden ‘‘Jevremovac’’, Faculty of Biology, University thickness of spongy tissue; (4) height of abaxial
of Belgrade (BEOU) and Herbarium of the Institute of epidermal cells; (5) number of palisade layers; (6)
Botany, Faculty of Pharmacy, University of Belgrade surface area of adaxial epidermal cells; (7) surface
(HFF). area of abaxial epidermal cells; (8) surface area of
Voucher specimens: abaxial stomata; (9) number of abaxial stomata;
(10) number of adaxial glandular hairs; (11)
1. Budva (Montenegro – Eumediterranean): rocky number of abaxial glandular hairs; (12) number of
vegetation (class. Asplenietea rupestris), at the alti- adaxial non-glandular hairs; (13) number of abaxial
tude of 40 m (Lakušić, D., 25 May 1995, HFF – non-glandular hair.
Fix.no. Bu 01-02). II. Leaf shape characters: (14) Leaf length; (15)
2. Luštica – Stari Krašići (Montenegro – Eumediterra- distance between the largest leaf width point and
nean): maquis (class. Cisto-Ericetea), limestone, at the leaf top; (16) the largest width of the leaf; (17)
the altitude of 80 m (Lakušić, D. & B. 2225/96, 27 leaf surface area.
July 1996, BEOU, HFF – Fix.no. TFS). III. Stem anatomy characters: (18) Stem diameter; (19)
3. Peloponnesus (Greece, Peloponnesus – Eumeditera- stem diagonal; (20) stem cortex thickness; (21)
nean: maquis (Stevanović, V., May 1995, BEOU – thickness of the stem vascular cylinder; (22) stem
Fix.no. TF). pith diameter.
4. Canyon Cijevna, village Dinoša (Montenegro – sub-
Mediterranean): rocky vegetation (class. Festuco-
Brometea), limestone (Lakušić, B., Jančić, R., Slav-
kovska, V., 09 July 1997, HFF – Fix.no. 11). Statistical analysis
5. Canyon of Morača, Dromir (Montenegro – sub-
Mediterranean): rocks above the river Morača (class. For each of the quantitative characters a univariate
Festuco-Brometea) (Lakušić, B., Slavkovska, V., statistic analysis was done on the basis of the following
Jančić, R. 12 July 1997, HFF – Fix.no. 67). parameters: average value, minimum, maximum, stan-
dard deviation and standard error. The significance of
differences between the populations studied was estab-
Anatomical analyses of leaves and stems were done
lished by multivariate analyses of variances (MANO-
on permanent slides, prepared by the standard method
VA). The general structure of the sample variability
for light microscopy. Cross-sections of the leaves (150
were established by Principal Component Analysis
samples) and stems (50 samples) were cut on a Reichert
(PCA). For checking the hypothesis that the analyzed
sliding microtome (up to 10 mm thick). The sections were
sample was composed of discrete groups, which are
cleared in Parazone and thoroughly washed before
morphologically differentiated one from the other, a
staining in safranin (1% w/v in 50% ethanol) and alcian
Discriminant Component Analysis (DCA) was done.
blue (1% w/v, aqueous).
Overall differences between the compared groups are
Epidermal peels (150 samples), for surface structures
presented by Mahalanobius’ distances, which are used
and stomata analyses, were prepared using Jeffrey’s
for clustering on the basis of UPGMA method.
solution (10% nitric acid and 10% chromic acid, 1: 1)
and stained in safranin and alcian blue. All slides were
mounted in Canada balsam after dehydration.
Density and type of the leaf and stem hairs, as well as Results
the paradermal aspect of epidermal cells, were also
studied with SEM (JOEL JSM-6460), for which the Leaf shape and anatomy
samples were covered by gold.
All morpho-anatomical measurements were done The leaves of T. flavum are elliptically oval, being the
with the Image Analyzer System Ozaria 2001 and the widest at the basal part, and rounded at the tip. The leaf
data processed in the statistical package Statistica 4.5 margin is obtusely dentate. The leaf stalk is long. It
for Windows. For each of the quantitative characters, 30 should be pointed out that the leaf shape was always the
leaf samples and 10 stem samples were obtained from same in all the populations studied.
different individuals belonging to each of the five In general, in all the populations studied the leaf
populations analyzed. length was between 12 and 27 mm, whereas the leaf
Twenty-two quantitative characters of the statistical width ranged between 11 and 21 mm. The leaf surface
analysis were grouped in three categories: I, Leaf area varied between 80 and 370 mm2.
anatomy characters (13); II, Leaf shape characters (4) The leaf indumentum of all the plants studied
and III, Stem anatomy characters (5). was composed of glandular and non-glandular hairs
ARTICLE IN PRESS
B. Lakušić et al. / Flora 201 (2006) 108–119 111
established. It should be pointed out that the most axes, the populations from Peloponnesus and Budva
important characters in structural differentiation are stand completely separated from the sub-Mediterranean
those related to leaf shape, stem anatomy, indumentum, populations. The population from Krašići shows
and leaf anatomy features in this order of significance (Fig. 12) transitional characteristics between the
(Table 2). Peloponnesus and Montenegro sub-Mediterranean
DCA of the populations studied of T. flavum populations, as it was the case also in the PCA analysis.
has shown that the Eumediterranean (Peloponnesus, Morpho-anatomical separation between Mediterranean
Krašići, Budva) and sub-Mediterranean (Morača, and sub-Mediterranean populations is clearly observed
Cijevna) populations represent two morphologically also on the basis of overall Mahalanobious’ distances
almost completely separate groups. On the first two (Fig. 13).
ARTICLE IN PRESS
114 B. Lakušić et al. / Flora 201 (2006) 108–119
Discussion
The analyzed populations of the species T. flavum
inhabit the Mediterranean area on ‘‘terra-rossa’’ (red
soil) substrate, which develops on porous limestone. The
species grows within the maquis-garrigue vegetation of
different stages of progression and regression, under
various Mediterranean bio-climate conditions – perhu-
mid Mediterranean Adriatic, arid Mediterranean Ae-
gean and perhumid sub-Mediterranean Adriatic climate.
The resemblance of plants from different populations is
obvious, even at first sight, due to the similar general
habit, i.e., of quite a similar external morphology of the
stem and evergreen leaves. It is rather important to
Fig. 6. Teucrium flavum paradermal view A, undulate anticli- stress this uniformity of the species T. flavum that
nal walls of the upper epidermal cells of plants from Morača.
contrastes to the extreme morphological heterogeneity
B, straight anticlinal walls of the upper epidermal cells of
plants from Budva.
that is present within the whole genus Teucrium. A
detailed growthform analysis of Teucrium have shown
significant morphological differences between shrubs,
semi-shrubs and perennial and annual herbs, especially
in regard to the extension and volume of lignification, as
well as with respect to the existence or the lack of
sclerenchyma elements in the cortex. Some of these
features can be used taxonomically on the level of
sections and species groups (Kästner, 1978, 1979,
1981, 1986).
The macromorphological similarity of the stems and
evergreen leaves of T. flavum populations might be
assumed as a strong indication of structural stability and
some kind of morpho-anatomical conservatism of this
ancient Mediterranean xerophyte. However, this phy-
siognomic uniformity obviously is combined with eco-
anatomical differentiations of leaves and stems of T.
flavum populations which thrive both in sites with
summers not particularly dry, and in those with a
pronounced summer drought.
In general, the evergreen leaves of T. flavum are
xeromorphic, moderately to significantly thick, tough
but not flabby neither rigid nor hard. In the Mediterra-
nean vegetation there is a large number of xerophytes
with such leaves, commonly known as malakophyllous,
notably within the genera of Cistus, Rosmarinus,
Thymus, etc. (Breckle, 2002; Kummerow, 1973).
The prominent xeromorphic features of the T. flavum
leaves are: simple form and relatively small size, dense
indumentum, especially on the lower side where a high
number of stomata are also located. The smallest leaves,
having a reduced external surface and mesophyll
thickness, are found in plants from the Eumediterra-
nean, Peloponnesian locality. In contrast, the thickest
leaves with the largest lamina surface area have the
Fig. 7. Teucrium flavum A, anomocytic (a) and diacytic (d) plants from the sub-Mediterranean locality in the
stomata. B, stomata encircling by the glandular hairs or canyon of Cijevna.
glandular hairs encircling stomata. (SEM). C, highly raised A dense and complex indumentum, composed of
stomata and cuticular striae. (SEM). D, peltate hair around glandular and non-glandular hairs, covers the lower
the stomata (SEM). leaf side, shielding stomata and thus advantageously
ARTICLE IN PRESS
B. Lakušić et al. / Flora 201 (2006) 108–119 115
reducing transpiration loss. Stomata and glandular resistance to gas diffusion. Regardless of the small
hairs are very closely related, meaning that the stomata quantity of essential oils (0.1–0.2%), which characterizes
are surrounded by glandular hairs or glandular hairs the specimens of T. flavum, even their minimal presence
are surrounded by stomata. In any case, stomata are in the external secretory structures may be efficient in
partially or totally flanged by the large subcuticular reducing both transpiration and overheating (Ćorović et
swellings of peltate hairs and/or secretory cells of the al., 1969; Todorović and Stevanović, 1994). Otherwise,
capitate hairs. Since the protrusions of capitate secretory it is well known that all species of the genus Teucrium
cells have only a small storing space, there is a are distinguished by only a low quantity of essential oils
continuous evaporation of essential oils (Werker et al., (Kovačević et al., 2001; Petričić et al., 1993).
1985a, b). This renders the air near the leaf surface more Beside essential oils, some other terpenoids, as well
condensed thus providing a higher boundary layer as flavonoids and/or phenylcarbonic acids might be
ARTICLE IN PRESS
116 B. Lakušić et al. / Flora 201 (2006) 108–119
Fig. 10. Cross section of the leaf: A, from Krašići. B, from Peloponnesus.
Fig. 11. Cross section of the stem: A, square-shaped stem. B, rounded stem.
produced by these glandular hairs (Wollenweber, 1984). (Kelsey et al., 1984; Wollenweber, 1984). It has been
Terpene exudates are the resins that cover the surface of reported previously that the resin content in T. flavum
the plant above-ground parts, while the flavonoids are leaves is about 1.03%, consisting of terpenes, another
incorporated either into the resins or into the coating the phenolic compounds, and free flavonoids (Kovačević et
leaf surfaces of many plants from the semi-arid regions al., 1998). All these mostly aromatic volatile compounds
ARTICLE IN PRESS
B. Lakušić et al. / Flora 201 (2006) 108–119 117
Dependent variable Mean sq. effect Mean sq. error F(df1,2) 4,45 p-level
on the upper leaf side consisting of short and protruding of the stem cortex to stem diameter ranges from 0.226 to
non-glandular hairs and of all the types of glandular 0.343, which is within the usual values found in
hairs mentioned, especially in plants from the Eumedi- xeromorphic stems (Fahn and Cutler, 1992).
terranean populations, also have an important influence All the data obtained, particularly those subjected to
on the spectral features of the leaves. Such structural a comparative multivariant analysis of morpho-anato-
adaptations increase leaf reflectance, thus reducing solar mical characteristics of the five populations from three
inception, heat load and therefore water deficit. This has different climate variants, have shown that the species
been reported for leaves of Mediterranean species from T. flavum has maintained quite a stable, conservative
the genus Cistus (Gausman and Quisenberry, 1990). morpho-anatomical structure. Such a substantial simi-
It is worth mentioning that the more dense indumen- larity between different populations is also characteristic
tum of leaves from the Peloponnesian population must of other ancient Mediterranean plants since their
be regarded as a favorable adaptive modification which adaptive structures evolved, in the first place, as the
helps in protecting the mesophyll from excessive water consequence of severe summer drought and high
loss and intense radiation in this particular hostile, temperatures (Margaris, 1981). In all the localities, both
perarid Mediterranean environment. eu- and sub-Mediterranean ones (arid-Mediterranean
More or less conspicuous xeromorphic characteristics and perhumid-sub-Mediteranean), the plant popula-
of T. flavum, from different populations, are represented tions of which have been studied, more or less
by a relatively high number of stomata, ranging from pronounced, longer or shorter intervals of summer
129 to 257 per mm2 in the plants from the sub- drought stress prevail. Inter-population differences refer
Mediterranean sites to 143–300 per mm2 in those from to small variations in leaf size, indumentum density,
the Adriatic coast and the Peloponnesus. A similar high number of stomata, thickness of cuticle and outer
number of stomata was established also in the Apennine epidermal cell walls, as well as to the number of the
populations of T. flavum, in which the number of mesophyll tissues layers. While all these anatomical
stomata varies from 168 to 258 per mm2 (Kästner, 1979). features are of the same pattern, they are clearly more
It is also a typical xeromorphism that the dense, expressed in the Eumediterranean than in the sub-
complex indumentum on the lower leaf side protects Mediterranean populations.
stomata which, on the other side are somewhat raised
above the level of the epidermal cells.
Smaller and thick-walled epidermal cells on the upper Acknowledgements
leaf side are a pronounced xeromorphic feature of the
Eumediterranean populations of the taxon, compared The authors are grateful to Prof. Dr. Vladimir
with the two sub-Mediterranean ones. The anticlinal Stevanović, Institute of Botany and Botanical garden
walls of both adaxial and abaxial epidermal cells of ‘‘Jevremovac’’ University of Belgrade for useful advice
plant leaves from all populations studied are straight to and valuable comments and to the Ministry for Science,
wavy, which is described as an other xeromorphic Technology and Development of Serbia (Project Nos.
feature (Fahn and Cutler, 1992). 1568 and 1505) for financial support.
A ratio between 1.4:1 and 2:1 of 2–4 layered palisade
parenchyma to 2–3 layered spongy parenchyma is
characteristic for plants from all the five populations.
References
The number of palisade layers is increased in the plants
from Eumediterranean populations, particularly in Breckle, S.W., 2002. Walter’s Vegetation of the Earth.
those from the localities near Budva and Krašići, but Springer, Berlin.
also in those from Peloponnesus. Moreover, the palisade Ćorović, M., Stejepanović, L., Nikolić, R., Pavlović, S.,
cells of these plants are narrower and more compact. In Živanović, P., 1969. Comparative investigation of the
addition, in leaves of these groups of plants of spongy level of osmotic values, transpiration and quantity of
cells can be found, which elongate in such a way that essential oil in some species of Labiatae family. Glasnik
they resemble palisade cells. A partial differentiation Botaničkog zavoda i bašte Univerziteta u Beogradu 4,
into an isolateral mesophyll is asumed to be a strongly 19–27.
xeromorphic character. Again, similar characteristics of Fahn, A., Cutler, F.D., 1992. Xerophytes. Encyclopedia of
Plant Anatomy. Borntraeger, Berlin.
the palisade and spongy tissues were established also in
Gausman, H.W., Quisenberry, J.E., 1990. Spectrophotometric
the Apennine populations of T. flavum (Kästner, 1979).
detection of plant leaf stress. In: Katterman, F. (Ed.),
The stems of the studied T. flavum populations are Environmental Injury to Plants. Academic Press, San
also protected by a thick cuticle with waxy layers and Diego, pp. 257–280.
with a dense indumentum of the same structural pattern Kästner, A., 1978. Beiträge zur Wuchsformenanalyse
as that of the leaves. The stem hairs are more protruding und systematischen Gliederung von Teucrium L. I. Die
and less intertwined than those on the leaves. The ratio Infloreszenzen und Blüten. Flora 167, 485–514.
ARTICLE IN PRESS
B. Lakušić et al. / Flora 201 (2006) 108–119 119
Kästner, A., 1979. Beiträge zur Wuchsformenanalyse und subspecies of Teucrium flavum L. (Labiatae) from the
systematischen Gliederung von Teucrium L. II. Anatomie Italian flora. Flora 190, 237–242.
der Sprosse und Blätter. Flora 168, 431–467. Margaris, N.S., 1981. Adaptive strategies in plants dominating
Kästner, A., 1981. Beiträge zur Wuchsformenanalyse und Mediterranean-type ecosystems. In: Di Castri, F., Goodall,
systematischen Gliederung von Teucrium L. III. Wuchsfor- D.W., Specht, L.R. (Eds.), Mediterranean-type Shrublands.
men und Verbreitung von Arten der Sektionen Teucropis Elsevier, Amsterdam, pp. 309–315.
und Teucrium. Flora 171, 466–519. Meusel, H., Jäger, E., Rauschert, S., Weinert, E., 1978.
Kästner, A., 1986. Beiträge zur Wuchsformenanalyse und Vergleichende Chorologie der Zentraleuropäischen Flora,
systematischen Gliederung von Teucrium L. V. Wuchsfor- vol. 2. Fischer, Jena.
men und Verbreitung von Arten der Verwandtschaftskreise Petričić, J., Blažević, N., Plazibat, M., 1993. Essential oil of
von T. marum und T. chamaedrys sect. Chamaedrys. Flora Teucrium flavum L. from Croatia. J. Essential Oil Res. 6,
178, 111–138. 625–627.
Kelsey, R.G., Reynolds, W.G., Rodriguez, E., 1984. The Todorović, B., Stevanović, B., 1994. Adaptive characteristics
chemistry of biologically active constituents secreted and of the endemic species Satureja horvatii Šilić (Lamiaceae) in
stored in plant glandular trichomes. In: Rodriguez, E., Healey, mountain-Mediterranean and Mediterranean habitats. Bot.
L.P., Mehta, I. (Eds.), Biology and Chemistry of Plant J. Linnean Soc. 114, 367–376.
Trichomes. Plenum Press, New York, London, pp. 187–243. Tomas-Barberan, F.A., Wollenweber, E., 1990. Flavonoid
Kovačević, N., Ristić, M., oković, D., Vuković, Z., Lakušić, aglycones from the leaf surfaces of some Labiatae species.
B., 1998. Herb exudates of Teucrium L. species. Arch. Plant Syst. Evol. 173, 109–118.
Pharm. 6, 944–945. Tutin, T.G., Wood, D., 1972. Teucrium L. In: Tutin, T.G.,
Kovačević, N., Lakušić, B., Ristić, M., 2001. Composition of Heywood, V.H., Burges, N.A., Moore, D.M., Valentine,
the essential oils of seven Teucrium species from Serbia and D.H., Walters, S.M., Webb, D.A. (Eds.), Flora
Montenegro. J. Essential Oil Res. 13, 163–165. Europaea, Vol. 3. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge,
Kummerow, J., 1973. Comparative anatomy of sclerophyllus pp. 129–135.
of Mediterranean climatic areas. In: Di Castri, F., Mooney, Werker, E., Ravid, U., Putievsky, E., 1985a. Structure of
A.H. (Eds.), Mediterranean Type Ecosystems – Origine and glandular hairs and indetification of the main components
Strukture. Springer, Berlin, Heidelberg, New York. of their secreted material in some species of the Labiatae.
Lakušić, B., 2000. Morphological variability and ecological Israel J. Bot. 34, 31–45.
differentiation of species of genus Teucrium L. (Lamiaceae) Werker, E., Ravid, U., Putievsky, E., 1985b. Glandular hairs
in Yugoslavia. Unpublished D. Phil. Thesis, Fac. Biol., and their secretions in the vegetative and reproductive
University in Belgrade. organs of Salvia sclarea and S. dominica. Israel J. Bot. 34,
Maleci, L.B., Servettaz, O., 1991. Morphology and distribu- 239–252.
tion of trichomes in Italian species of Teucrium sect. Wollenweber, E., 1984. The systematic implication of
Chamaedrys (Labiatae) – a taxonomical evaluation. Plant flavonoids secreted by plants. In: Rodriguez, E., Healey,
Syst. Evol. 174, 83–91. L.P., Mehta, I. (Eds.), Biology and Chemistry of
Maleci, L.B., Pinetti, A., Servettaz, O., 1995. Micromorpho- Plant Trichomes. Plenum Press, New York, London,
logical and phytochemical characteristics of the two pp. 53–69.