Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Abstract The purpose of this study was to collect and report the current quantity and content of dermatology
taught in the nonclinical and clinical curricula of North American veterinary colleges. This is the first published
record of this information and was gathered from 29/30 colleges. Half of the respondents of the questionnaire
thought that veterinary students currently receive sufficient didactic dermatology course work. A separate didactic dermatology course is required at 16/29 colleges, which provides a mean of 31.31 instructional units. Twentyfour of 29 veterinary colleges offer a separate clinical dermatology rotation. Thirteen schools report that students
who desire a clinical rotation through dermatology usually attain it. However, it is only required for graduation
in seven colleges. This report serves as a tool for veterinary schools assessing their existing curriculum and allows
them to compare the education they provide in this specialty with that of other colleges.
Keywords: colleges of veterinary medicine, education, North America, survey, veterinary dermatology
INTRODUCTION
Dermatological disease is an important and common
presenting complaint of owners concerning their pets.1
It represents a substantial number of outpatient problems, more so in some areas of the country than in others. Recent graduate veterinary practitioners need to
be adequately prepared to diagnose and treat dermatological conditions.
Roundtable discussions focusing on education in
dermatology have occurred in the USA at past meetings of the American Academy of Veterinary Dermatology (AAVD) and American College of Veterinary
Dermatology (ACVD). These workshop notes have
been outlined in newsletters,2,3 but not published elsewhere. For a 1998 roundtable, a survey was conducted
prior to the workshop and shared with the participants.2
Many colleges of veterinary medicine have recently
made changes in their curricula, some to introduce
problem-based or case-based learning. Current trends
have been to reduce didactic teaching down to core or
material deemed essential by instructors or curriculum
revision committees, and then to allow students to
track in specific areas such as small animal, equine or
food animal. Some programmes have replaced heavy
course hour requirements with more electives.
The objective of this study was to survey the colleges
of veterinary medicine in North America to gather
76
RESULTS
Questionnaires were returned from 29 of 30 colleges of
veterinary medicine. All surveys were completed by
either course coordinators or instructors in the dermatology course(s). Twenty-three of the 29 responders
indicated ACVD diplomates teach dermatology. Of
those that reported ACVD diplomates teaching in
clinics, didactic lectures or both, eight schools reported
having one diplomate, twelve schools reported two,
two schools have three, and one school has four diplomates. Twenty-eight colleges had instructors with specific postgraduate training in dermatology. Those who
answered yes to specific postgraduate dermatology
training were asked to reply to five specific questions
(Table 1). Seven colleges reported that they had
Question
Regarding the instruction of didactic and clinical dermatology to students at
your College of Veterinary Medicine, do(es) the educator(s) have specific
postgraduate training in dermatology?
If yes, please answer the following:
If you have non-ACVD educators with training in dermatology teaching students,
have they completed a residency in dermatology?
Do you have dermatology teachers that are board certified in
other specialties (e.g. ACVIM or ABVP)?
Do you have any diplomates of the American College of
Veterinary Dermatology (ACVD) teaching students?
Do you have adjunct or occasional lecturers in dermatology that
come from other locations?
N/A = not applicable or no answer.
2003 European Society of Veterinary Dermatology, Veterinary Dermatology, 14, 75 81
YES
NO
28
1
YES
NO
N/A
YES
NO
N/A
YES
NO
N/A
YES
NO
N/A
7
11
11
17
10
2
23
5
1
3
24
2
School
No. of
ACVD
diplomates
Total no.
of dermatology
IUs required*
Is a dermatology
clinic rotation
required?
Canada
1
2
3
4
2
1
0
0
47
12
10
11
no
no
no
no
Midwestern USA
1
2
2
0
3
1
4
2
5
2
6
0
7
3
8
1
9
1
10
2
12
12
33
26
30
12
50
18
11
15
no
no
no
no
small & other
no
all
no
no
small & other
North-eastern USA
1
2
2
3
3
1
32
21
41
all
small & other
no
South-eastern USA
1
2
2
4
3
1
4
2
5
0
6
2
7
2
8
2
9
1
38
21
30
32
17
10
42
20
47
all
all
all
small & other
all
no
all
no
all
Western USA
1
2
2
1
3
0
34
13
15
small
no
no
*Total required IUs gathered from supplied answers and course syllabi.
If clinics are required for graduation, are they required for all students
(all), small animal tracking students (small) and / or students in other
tracks (other)?
77
Yes
No
N/A
Pyoderma
Dermatophytosis
Yeast dermatoses
Systemic fungal diseases
Ectoparasites
Allergies affecting the skin
Feline skin diseases
Nodules
Antimicrobial therapy for the skin
Parasiticide therapy for the skin
Steroid therapy
Cutaneous neoplasias
28
28
29
23
29
29
29
21
27
29
29
24
1
1
6
2
N/A = no answer.
78
DISCUSSION
The purpose of this study was to collect and record current data on the quantity, subject matter and type (clinical or didactic) of dermatology taught to veterinary
students throughout schools in North America.
Although education studies have been published for
other specialties in colleges of veterinary medicine,510
this is the first such publication regarding veterinary
dermatology. The information reported herein should
be useful for those schools undergoing curriculum revision and for colleges to view how the dermatology education their students receive compares with those
throughout North America.
The use of e-mail allowed the questionnaire to be
sent, completed and returned in a timely manner and
likely resulted in the very high response rate. All veterinary colleges but one completed and returned the
questionnaire. This is an excellent compliance rate and
makes the data more meaningful.
There is some inherent error in gathering data in this
manner. The individual completing the survey may not
be aware of the complete curriculum or whether students are receiving dermatology topics in large animal
courses or within pathology, parasitology, microbiology or other areas. One might wonder if completing an
on-line questionnaire might also allow for more first
thought responses. However, most responders to this
survey also sent copies of the dermatology course syllabus, so responses could be compared and laboratory
IUs calculated. Not surprisingly, half of the respondents indicated that they did not think the number of
IUs available for dermatology lectures in their college
was adequate to cover basic dermatology. This is definitely a subjective opinion question but course coordinators, in general, answered the questionnaire. It is
possible that other instructors at the same college
79
80
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
The authors would like to thank all of the survey
responders for replying so promptly to the survey and
providing a syllabus of course material.
REFERENCES
1. Mason, I. Approach to the animal with skin disease. In:
Moriello, K., Mason, I. eds. Handbook of Small Animal
Dermatology. Oxford: Elsevier Science, 1995: 11.
Rsum Le but de cette tude tait de collecter et de rapporter la quantit et la qualit de lenseignement dermatologique dans les Ecoles Vtrinaires en Amrique du Nord. Il sagit de la premire tude de ce type, obtenue
grce la collaboration de 29/30 coles. La moiti des rponses suggrent que les tudiants vtrinaires reoivent
lheure actuelle suffisamment desneignement dermatologique didactique. Un enseignement spar de la
dermatologie est ncessaire pour 16/29 coles. 24 des 29 coles offrent une rotation clinique dermatologique
spare. 13 coles ont rpondu que les tudiants souhaitant une rotation clinique en dermatologie leffectuent
gnralement. Cependant, cette tape nest ncessaire que dans 7 coles. Ce rapport servira comme lment
permettant aux coles vtrinaires dvaluer leur curriculum et permettra de comparer le systme propos par
rapport aux autres coles.
Resumen El objetivo de este estudio fue recoger y documentar la cantidad y el contenido de dermatologa en
la enseanza acadmica no-clnica y clnica en los colegios (facultades) de veterinaria de Norte Amrica. Esta
es la primera publicacin sobre este tipo de informacin y fue recogida de 29/30 colegios. La mitad de los que
contestaron al cuestionario pensaban que actualmente los estudiantes de veterinaria reciben una cantidad didctica en dermatologa suficiente. En 16/29 colegios se requiere un curso didctico separado en dermatologa, lo
cual proporciona una media de 31.31 unidades de enseanza. Veinticuatro de 29 colegios de veterinaria ofrecen
una rotacin clnica separada de dermatologa. Trece colegios informaron que estudiantes que desean una
rotacin clnica en dermatologa normalmente la obtienen. Sin embargo, esto slo es requerido para la graduacin en siete colegios. Este documento servir de herramienta para los colegios veterinarios que estn evaluando su currculum actual y les permitir comparar la educacin que ellos proporcionan en esta especialidad
con otros colegios.
81
Zusammenfassung Das Ziel dieser Studie war, momentane Quantitt und Inhalte der Dermatologie im Lehrplan von nordamerikanischen tiermedizinischen Hochschulen zu erfassen und zu berichten. Diese Information
wurde zum ersten Mal verffentlicht, 29/30 Fakultten trugen dazu bei. Die Hlfte der Antwortenden waren
der Meinung, dass Tiermedizinstudenten momentan ausreichende didaktische Dermatologiekurse erhalten. Ein
eigenstndiger didaktischer Dermatologiekurs wird von 16/29 tiermedizinischen Hochschulen vorgeschrieben,
und enthlt im Durchschnitt 31.31 Lehreinheiten. Vierundzwanzig der 29 tiermedizinischen Hochschulen bieten
eine separate klinische Dermatologierotation an. Dreizehn Schulen berichten, dass Studenten, die eine klinische
Dermatologierotation wnschen, diese blicherweise auch erhalten. Allerdings wird eine solche Rotation nur in
sieben Hochschulen zum erfolgreichen Abschluss des Studiums vorausgesetzt. Dieser Bericht wird den tiermedizinischen Hochschulen dazu dienen, ihren existierenden Lehrplan zu berprfen und ihnen erlauben, die
in diesem Fachgebiet von ihnen angebotene Ausbildung mit der anderer Fakultten zu vergleichen.