Professional Documents
Culture Documents
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comparison_of_web_conferencing_software
GOOGLE CHROMEBOX
Chromebox for meetings uses Google+ Hangouts for videoconferencing, allowing any Gmail user to
join a meeting from the device of their choice; and the service syncs with Google Calendar. Meetings
can include up to 15 participants. Third party tools are available to help you connect to traditional
video conferencing systems or with participants using phones rather than Google+ Hangouts. The
system also includes a web-based management console.
What makes this solution different than simply running Google Hangouts on your computer is that
the Chromebox for meetings unit includes a customized version of the ChromeOS specifically
designed to run Hangouts in conference room settings. The dedicated software allows you to easily
start Hangouts, pull calendar invites onto the main screen and join meetings with a single click. In
the admin console you can add calendar resources, like meeting rooms, directly to the device,
manage multiple devices and monitor usage. So while it doesnt necessarily take a dedicated
Chrome machine to power Google Hangouts (you can easily bake your own solution on a spare PC,
not to mention a Logitech HD webcam and Jabra speakerphone, or the equivalents), Google's
solution makes it foolproof, which might make Chromebox for meetings appealing to small and
medium-sized businesses.
Google's biggest selling point for its new videoconferencing system is ease of use. "No more
complex dial-in codes, passcodes or leader PINs," writes Caesar Sengupta, a Google VP working
with Chromebox for meetings in a blog post, adding that you can "walk into the room, click the
2 | Page
remote once and you're instantly in the meeting." Regarding the powerful Core i7 processor,
Sengupta says it is necessary to process and locally encrypt multiple simultaneous streams, adding
that because of this, normal Chromeboxes (or lesser powered PCs) won't be able to host this
service. The $250 annual maintenance fee covers 24/7 support.
First there was the Chromebook, then the Chromebox. Now, Google has added a $999 videoconferencing package
that combines a Chromebox and a video camera to enable inexpensive videoconferencing for businesses.
3 | Page
At this point, Google is just calling the system "Chromebox for meetings." Caesar Sengupta, vice president of
product management for Google, said that the system was designed and is used internally at Google. "We've found
that this works quite well for Google, and we're happy to bring this to other companies," he said.
Gilt Group, Eventbrite, and Woolworths UK have all trialed Chromebox for meetings, Google said.
The system includes four components: a new, more powerful Chromebox, based on the Intel Core i7; a 1080p HD
camera module; a combination microphone/speaker; and an RF remote control. Samsung's existing Chromebox uses
a Core i5 chip; the new Chromeboxes, from Asus and Hewlett-Packard, were necessary to permit the multiple,
simultaneous HD streams that the new system enables--up to 15.
Essentially, Google has taken the low-cost, minimalistic approach of Chromebook hardware and applied it to the
market for unified communications. Although low-cost, face-to-face videoconferencing options are available-Google's Hangouts, Microsoft's Skype, and Apple's FaceTime among them--stepping up to a unified
videoconferencing system can run into the thousands of dollars, depending on how much a business is willing to
pay.
Naturally, the new system is designed to work with Google apps and services, including Hangouts, Google Calendar,
Gmail, and others. (Google is also working on a simple extension for Exchange, Sengupta said.) Users who walk
into the conference room can click the remote once to be joined to the conference, without needing to enter a
username or password. Within the interface, users can type in the name of the conference they wish to join, using
some sort of identifying name. The initial screen also displays a subset of the user's calendar, as well as recent
Hangouts. Google+ is prominently displayed in the upper left.
Once joined to the conference, participants will see a Hangouts-style interface, according to a demonstration by a
Google representative. Users will also be able to type in a special URL, g.co/present, which will allow participants
to "volunteer" to share their screen. The participant will then be able to open a Google app in a separate tab and
launch a presentation, for example.
A Google representative said that each Google system (what Google refers to as a "meeting room" will include its
own management account, that users will be able to connect to and "schedule" a meeting on their own calendars.
Participants who are working from home, or don't use the system, can be connected to the meeting via Gmail, using
Hangouts from a PC, Chromebook, Android phone, or another device that supports Hangouts. Vidyo will also
provide a special tool to connect to its videoconferencing systems, and users can also join via a number from
UberConference.
4 | Page
There's a bit of a catch: Each system will also come with a $250/year management fee. The first year is included,
Sengupta said. In return, Google will provide an undisclosed level of SLA guarantees, continue to provide software
upgrades, and other improvements, Sengupta said. "Over time, you'll see more and more management features
baked into this," he said.
Google's Chromebooks have quietly emerged as a force in the low-end computing market. Will this
videoconferencing capability be what the Chromebox needs to make the same inroads into the business market?
Microsoft and its partners will be guarding their territory jealously.
Updated at 11:28 AM with additional details.
5 | Page
Overall Score
TeamViewer
(9.26)
AnyMeeting
(8.58)
(8.49)
Google+ Hangout
(8.17)
Skype Free
(8.14)
Spreed Meeting
(8.07)
Mikogo Free
(8.07)
GoToMeeting Free
(7.71)
Vyew
(7.60)
join.me
(7.53)
MeetingBurner
(7.33)
6 | Page
Review of TeamViewer
Criterium
Rating
functions
Software Installation
Cost Transparency
Security
initiated ad-hoc.
Easy installation
Overall Score
7 | Page
9.26 / 10
Review of AnyMeeting
Criterium
Rating
Usability
easy-to-use
Browser-based, no installation
Software Installation
Cost Transparency
Security
free-of-charge
Overall Score
8 | Page
8.58 / 10
Rating
Software Installation
Cost Transparency
Security
initiated ad-hoc.
No installation necessary
free-of-charge
Overall Score
9 | Page
8.49 / 10
10 | P a g e
Rating
Usability
be extended by apps
easy-to-use
Software Installation
Cost Transparency
Security
free-of-charge
Overall Score
11 | P a g e
8.17 / 10
Functionality
Usability
Rating
easy-to-use solution
Software Installation
Cost Transparency
Security
easy installation
free-of-charge
Overall Score
12 | P a g e
8.14 / 10
Our Reviews
Review
Overall Score[1]
9.60
9.42
9.38
ClickMeeting
9.35
Mikogo 5 (BeamYourScreen)
9.32
TeamViewer 9
9.28
9.24
8.97
13 | P a g e
Compare
Tools
Review
Overall Score[1]
PGi GlobalMeet
8.84
join.me pro
8.84
Spreed Meeting
8.83
8.73
Saba Meeting 8
8.71
AnyMeeting Pro
8.67
8.64
Brother OmniJoin
8.48
GatherPlace
8.26
Fuze Meeting
8.24
8.19
InstantPresenter
8.09
8.04
14 | P a g e
Compare
Tools
Review
Overall Score[1]
Skype Premium
8.03
7.98
MegaMeeting
7.97
7.95
7.91
7.86
iVocalize
7.81
Vyew
7.71
7.54
Voxwire
7.52
Glance 2.8
7.27
7.14
Blackboard Collaborate
6.68
15 | P a g e
Compare
Tools
Review
Overall Score[1]
Microsoft NetMeeting*
16 | P a g e
5.91
Compare
Tools
Platform Support
Runs on Windows 2003 Server or later, runs on Mac OS X 10.6 or higher (annotation and drawing tools
are not available for Mac), HDFaces video are not recorded
Pricing
Flatrate: USD 49 per month and host for up to 25 participants; Annual subscription (pre-paid): USD 468
per year
License options
Single user license for unlimited meetings with up to 25 participants
17 | P a g e
Criterium
Functionality
Usability
Rating
Software Installation
Security
Overall Score
18 | P a g e
9.60 / 10
19 | P a g e
Platform Support
Native Windows (ME or higher) and Mac OS X (10.6 or higher) client for hosting and
participating meetings; for attendees additional browser-based Flash client; Mobile Device
Support: iOS and Android Runs on Windows ME or later
Pricing
Monthly single-user subscription for one online room: 38 EUR per month (minimum contract
duration: 12 months)
Single user license for purchase: 979,00 EUR plus maintenance contract for one online meeting
room
Prepaid: 90 EUR for 600 minutes runtime, any number of concurrent sessions possible
License options
Single user license for annual subscription or purchase
20 | P a g e
Functionality
Usability
Rating
easy-to-use
Software Installation
Security
Overall Score
21 | P a g e
9.42 / 10
ClickMeeting Review
ClickMeeting is a browser-based web conferencing software. The host can use the online portal to
either schedule meetings in advance, or to start ad hoc web meetings. The user interface of the
service is very well structured and intuitive to use. During an online meeting the host can show
presentations, YouTube videos or simply use the screen sharing function. ClickMeeting also allows
virtual collaboration among the attendees. In the latest version the moderator can create surveys and
tests during the meeting with results immediately following after the survey or test has ended.
In addition to task-oriented cooperation participants can also communicate via video conference. The
placement of the webcams within the browser is flexible and can be altered to a number of predefined
settings with a single click.
Bottom line: ClickMeeting is well suited for planned and unplanned web meetings where content needs
to be presented and edited in various formats.
Platform Support
Browser based running on Windows, Mac, and Linux with Flash Player, mobile device support: iOS,
Android, Blackberry apps available
Pricing
CM25: USD 30 per month for meetings with up to 25 participants (annual subscription: USD 22.50 per
month paid in advance)
CM50: USD 40 per month for meetings with up to 50 participants (annual subscription: USD 30 per
month paid in advance)
CM100: USD 79 per month for meetings with up to 100 participants (annual subscription: USD 59.25
per month paid in advance)
CM500: USD 160 per month for meetings with up to 500 participants (annual subscription: USD 120
per month paid in advance)
22 | P a g e
CM1000: USD 280 per month for meetings with up to 1000 participants (annual subscription: USD 210
per month paid in advance)
License options
Single user license for meetings with up to 1000 participants
Criterium
23 | P a g e
Rating
Functionality
intuitive usage
Browser-based, no installation
Software Installation
Security
Overall Score
9.35 / 10
TeamViewer 9 Review
TeamViewer is a web conferencing program that can be used for scheduled and ad hoc online
meetings.
Since version 8, the moderator can plan web conferences and invite participants in advance using the
integrated scheduling functionality in Outlook. In addition, all essential functions can be easily
accessed in the locally installed web console by the moderator while running the web meeting.
24 | P a g e
Moreover, users can switch to video conferencing mode. Unfortunately, the picture quality is not HD.
Beyond the missing HD quality we noticed performance issues with VoIP while conducting online
presentations.
Bottom line: TeamViewer 9 is well-suited for planned and ad hoc web meetings.
Platform Support
Runs on Windows ME or later, runs on Mac OS X 10.5 or higher, participation is browser based
requiring Flash Player
Pricing
"Business" edition: $749 for a lifetime single user license; maximum number of meeting participants:
15;
"Premium" edition: $1,499 for a lifetime single user license; maximum number of meeting participants:
25;
"Corporate" edition: $2,839 for a lifetime multi user license allowing up to 3 online meetings with up to
25 participants at the same time;
Free of charge for non-commercial usage
License options
Single and multi user licenses (one time fee)
Criterium
25 | P a g e
Rating
Functionality
Software Installation
initiated ad-hoc.
Easy installation
Security
Overall Score
External resources
26 | P a g e
9.28 / 10
Pros
Onstream Meetings Web
screen.
Cons
This service does not
The Verdict:
9.75/10
Onstream Meetings offers the best web conferencing tools with an easy-to-use format that's well suited for small and
medium businesses.
27 | P a g e