Professional Documents
Culture Documents
161978/2014
Plaintiff,
V.
~ummons
N ewskann.com
2100 Linwood Ave, 4B
Fort Lee, NJ 07024
2.
Minho Lee
2100 Linwood Ave, 4B
Fort Lee, NJ 07024
3.
Joy Lee
2100 Linwood Ave, 4B
Fort Lee, NJ 07024
Index No.
Date Purchased:
Plaintiff,
v.
NEWSKANN.COM, MINHO LEE, JOY LEE,
ABC COMPANY 1, ABC COMPANIES 2
THROUGH 5, and JOHN DOES 1-5,
Defendants.
Plaintiff H Mart, Inc., brings this complaint for defamation and other claims against
the above-named defendants and alleges:
THE PARTIES
1. At all relevant times, H Mart, Inc. (HMI), is a business entity organized under
Delaware law and operates a supermarket chain at 44 locations throughout the United States
including various locations in New York and New Jersey. Operating under the brand name
H Mart, HMI sells a full array of American products and Asian products which number in
tens of thousands of actual products among thousands of product categories.
2. At all relevant times, defendant Newskann.com holds itself out to be a business
entity organized under New Jersey law and states that the principal place of business is
located at 2100 Linwood Ave, 4B, Fort Lee, New Jersey.
3. At all relevant times, upon information and belief, defendant Minho Lee, whose
residential address is unknown but may be served at his business address at 2100 Linwood
Ave, 4B, Fort Lee, New Jersey, holds himself out to be an editor-in-chief of defendant
Newskann.
4. At all relevant times, upon information and belief, defendant Joy Lee, whose
residential address is unknown but may be served at her business address at 2100 Linwood
Ave, 4B, Fort Lee, New Jersey, holds herself out to be a publisher of defendant Newskann.
5. At all relevant times defendant ABC Company 1 is the actual legal entity operating
the Newskann.com website at 2100 Linwood Ave, 4B, Fort Lee, New Jersey, but plaintiff
is presently without knowledge as to the true and accurate corporate status of this entity and
therefore this entity is identified here as ABC Company doing business as newskann.com.
6. Defendants ABC Companies 2 through 5 are unknown possible business entities
who are acting in concert or participation with the named defendants who are believed to
exist but whose identities are not known to plaintiff at this time. Upon information and
belief, defendants ABC Companies 2 through 5 are believed to have participated with the
named defendants in the manufacture of false facts or articles that are implicated in this
action in concert and participation with the named defendants and therefore may be liable
jointly and severally to plaintiff.
7. Defendants John Does 1 through 3 are individuals who are believed to exist but
whose identities are not known to plaintiff at this time. Upon information and belief,
defendant John Does 1-3 are believed to have participated with defendants in the
manufacture of false facts or articles that are implicated in this action in concert and
participation with the defendants and therefore may be liable jointly and severally to plaintiff.
2
COMMON ALLEGATIONS
8. Newskann.com holds itself out to be an online newspaper serving the Korean
community of New York and New Jersey. At the bottom of its masthead, and at the bottom
of every page of its website, the following notation is displayed:
Call for Information: 201-674-5161 Korean-American
Newspaper NEWSKANN is New Jersey registered media. If
news and contents are used without permission there will be
punishment under copyright laws and other related laws.
Copyright 2010 newskann.com All rights reserved.
9. Newskann.com holds itself out as serving the New York/New Jersey region; it
appears to be accessible from the entire United States and the rest of the world and it invites
membership from anyone, anywhere, without geographic limitation.
10. The two named individual defendants, Joy Lee and Minho Lee, appear to be the
only employees of newkann.com. In the Company, section of its website, newskann.com
identifies defendant Joy Lee as both the President and Lead Reporter; and defendant
Minho Lee as the Editor in Chief.
11. Apart from these two individuals, a review of the entire website, and numerous
articles posted on the website reveals no other employee, reporter, editor, fact checker,
research staff, interviewer, producer, or other staff is identified. There exists no masthead
as such showing various editorial staff or personnel in the operation of the internet
newspaper. Thus, plaintiff believes that newskann.com is operated by only the two
individuals named in its website and these individuals generally do not perform independent
fact checks and did not engage in any fact-checking before posting alleged news articles
3
about plaintiff.
DEFENDANTS ARE NOT BONA FIDE INTERNET NEWSPAPER
BUT RATHER PLAGIARISM WEBSITE
12. It appears that defendants believe they can simply organize an internet website,
call it a newspaper, and function as a newspaper. In reality it appears that many of
defendants website contents of so-called news articles and news photographs appear to
have been wholesale copied from third-party sources. Upon information and belief,
defendants are taking wholesale copies of news articles and photographs from third-parties,
principally from real news organizations such as the Bergen Record (NorthJersey.com),
Associated Press, New York Times, and others, and filling their own website with such thirdparty materials and those third-parties intellectual property rights including copyrights and
moral rights of writers, photographers, and news organizations. Such conduct would be in
violation of the Copyright Act of 1976 and the Digital Millennium Copyright Act.
13. The newskann.com websites landing page shows a header bar stating, in Korean,
NEWS, PLANNING DESK, LIFE, TASTING, TRAVELING, FEATURED
SPECIALS, SHARING, and COMMUNITY.
subdivided into these categories, All, Society, Politics, Economy, Culture, Video
News, Photo News, and English [News]; and under the LIFE tab which reveals
Sports and Entertainment, substantially all materials are, upon information and belief,
plagiarized from third-party sources and third-party owners of copyright. Countless photo
and video images are displayed with large NEWSKANN.COM superimposed in large
characters inside in the images; some images are shown with other source identification
marks but wholesale used in defendants website. News and other stories, too, are either
wholesale copied and posted in defendants website, such as an Associated Press story about
the two Americans released from North Koreas prisons:
14. As is readily apparent from the face of the alleged lead sentence, the source of the
article is Associated Press (AP) yet it appears that defendants superimposed their
NEWSKANN.COM mark on the photo and presented the article as their own so that their
readership would think the article was, in fact, their work in whole and in part. Upon
5
information and belief, defendants never visited the two prisoners inside North Korea; did
not take the photograph; but rather plagiarized from the confines of their office.
15.
The following news from defendants Society page shows the Philae, a
European stellar vehicle landing on the moving comet, making history on November 12,
2014. Here too the photo inset is identified as NEWSKANN.COM when in fact, upon
information and belief, defendants were not physically or otherwise within photographic
access of the Philae vehicle or imagery. Indeed, the entire article was essentially copied
in whole or material part from other, legitimate news sources, despite the lead identification
of the byline as [Newskann=Joy Lee Reporter] in the opening line.
16.
recklessly and far beyond negligently plagiarize third-party materials and engage in
wholesale copying of third-party copyrights and moral rights to create, operate, and maintain
their website newskann.com so as to generate revenue from their advertisers who are led to
6
18. Based upon the foregoing examples and extensive others found in defendants
7
website, it appears defendants are not operating a newspaper but rather a website which
is self-proclaimed to be a newspaper but which presents plagiarized stories and uses
intellectual properties of third-parties.
19. Such wholesale copyright infringement acts have been the focus of precedential
decisions of federal courts having exclusive jurisdiction over disputes involving copyrights
under the U.S. Copyright Act of 1976, as amended, 17 U.S.C. 101 et seq, as well as the
Digital Millennium Copyright Act of 1998, 17 U.S.C. 512, 12011205, 13011332; 28
U.S.C. 4001, which implemented the copyright treaties executed under the auspices of the
World Intellectual Property Organization.
20. In the precedential decision of Associated Press v. Meltwater U.S. Holdings, Inc.,
931 F. Supp.2d 537 (S.D.N.Y. 2013), the facts were virtually identical to the business model
of the defendants here, where that defendant operated an online news clipping service which
copied third-parties news and photos wholesale and re-posted those materials which were
then claimed to be their news stories. This appears to be the very business model of the
defendants in this action, as they claim to be the originators of much of the writing and
photos that are found on their website newskann.com. Presumably they claim their conduct
constitutes fair use of third-parties intellectual properties for news purposes. In
Associated Press, at 561, the Court held however:
Examining the four factors individually, and considering
them as a whole in light of the purposes of the Copyright Act
and the fair use defense, Meltwater has failed to raise a material
question of fact to support its fair use defense. Meltwater's
business model relies on the systematic copying of protected
8
11
rejected in Korea, to be sold at its locations in New York, New Jersey, Virginia and
elsewhere; and
e) Contrary to the article, H Mart has never acquired product distribution rights to
fishery products that cannot be sold to the consumers of Korea, among other allegations.
24. The article was presented with a lead-in photograph which had nothing to do
with it. This fact is revealed at the bottom of the article, where it state, Photograph is
unrelated to the story; but this fact is not even disclosed in the photo inset, where it was used
to grab the readers attention but used as a bait and switch tactic.
manufactured a story rather than reporting one.
12
Defendants
25. This photograph too appears to have been taken by someone other than
defendants. Defendants intentionally used an unrelated photograph knowing it is unrelated
simply as a marketing tool to induce readers attention rather than reporting some related
facts. Both specific parts of the article and its overall tenor is one of contempt and ridicule
by falsely stating that H Mart sold contaminated, radioactive products borne of the
Fukushima disaster which were acquired overseas because of over-supply stemming from
the locals rejection of contaminated products, which were then purchased dirt cheap
through an unseemly secret contract then fraudulently imported into the United States and
sold as premium fishery products to unknowing consumers in the United States. Such
statements were not matters of opinion or puffery but statements of fact intended to place
plaintiff in a hostile light, especially in relation to the customers of H Mart, and they
immediately had the intended effect, to damage plaintiffs business activity.
26. Material portions of the foregoing phony "article" were demonstrably false;
defendants were totally indifferent to the truth and they published the phony story so as to
cause alarm and panic.
27. Defendants engaged in their acts of malice, without justification, so as to cast
plaintiff in a bad light publicly and to ruin plaintiffs business standing everywhere they are
known. As a result of defendants actions, plaintiff has suffered damage to its good name
and reputation, to its prospective income and advantage, and to the value of its trade name
and standing for which plaintiff have been working hard and diligently for decades.
13
14
15
is known, which is essentially across much of the United States. As a result of defendants
actions, plaintiff has suffered damage to its good name and reputation, to its prospective
income and advantage, and to the value of its trade name and standing for which plaintiff
have been working hard and diligently for decades.
THE FALSE AND INACCURATE OCTOBER 24, 2014, ARTICLE
31. October 24, 2014, Newskann reported, in its Society section, an article
entitled, Jeju Fishery Products Additional $10 Million Shipment Reported, annexed hereto
as Exhibit 3, purporting to confirm its previous article of October 16, 2014 concerning H
Marts sale of fish contaminated from the Fukushima, Japan, nuclear plant accident of June
2, 2011, which states as follows:
According
to
the
Fishery
Newspaper
(webmaster@isusanin.com) last May 30, [2014] as the Jeju
Fishery Products Association and Jeju Agricultural and Fishery
Foods clarified that they have shipped the products to U.S.
based H Mart for a cooperative export, and NEWSKANNs
(10/16) report has been confirmed as a fact.
This round of exported products are $200,000.00 worth of fluke,
belt fish, red tilefish, samdasoo, bracken, tot and citrus cookies
among 34 kinds that will be sold at the opening exhibition of
Jeju speciality products at the 4 different branches of H Mart
stores in the Central United States such as in Texas in the
middle of July.
Jeju Fishery Products Association is seeking to utilize H Mart's
entry in the central-U.S. region as an opportunity to set Jeju's
agricultural and fishery products foods $10 million in exports
and planned to ship significantly more products in the second
half of the year, as reported by the Fishery Newspaper.
<Photo=mirror.enha.kr>
16
(Emphasis added.)
32. The article was told with a lead-in photograph which had nothing to do with
the story. This fact is revealed at the bottom of the article, where it is stated, Photograph
is unrelated to the story and is not disclosed in the photo inset as would be expected.
33. Material portions of the foregoing phony "article" were demonstrably false;
defendants were totally indifferent to the truth and they published the phony story so as to
cause alarm and panic.
34. Defendants engaged in their acts of malice, without justification, so as to cast
plaintiff in a bad light publicly and to ruin plaintiffs business standing everywhere they are
known. As a result of defendants actions, plaintiff has suffered damage to its good name
and reputation, to its prospective income and advantage, and to the value of its trade name
and standing for which plaintiff has been working hard and diligently for decades.
THE FALSE AND INACCURATE OCTOBER 26, 2014, ARTICLE
35. On October 26, 2014, Newskann reported, in its Society section, an article
entitled, Fishery Products Suspected of Radiation Poisoning Served at Korean-American
Tables, annexed hereto as Exhibit 4, purporting to confirm its previous article of October
16, 2014 concerning H Marts sale of fish contaminated from the Fukushima, Japan, nuclear
plant accident of June 2, 2011, which states as follows:
NEWKANN
Korean American New York New Jersey
[Society] Refutation by Korean-American Association of Jeju
Citizens Unseemly
17
21
readers to believe it was a recent event. Worse, the article as a whole implicitly tells the
reader that it was H Mart who used Made in Korea labeling to cover the Made in Japan
original labeling. Even though defendants knew or should have known that real news
gathering and reporting would have enabled them to know, and H Mart certainly would have
provided facts, that a company called Haitai America, wholly owned by Haitai Korea, was
the importer and that H Mart was nowhere in the zone of knowing about, much less having
control over, the labeling process, defendants intentionally equated H Mart with alleged
notoriously fraudulent substitution of country-of-origin practices that are simply unknown
to H Mart.
40. Material portions of the foregoing phony "article" were demonstrably false;
defendants were totally indifferent to the truth and they published the phony story so as to
cause alarm and panic.
41. Defendants engaged in their acts of malice, without justification, so as to cast
plaintiff in a bad light publicly and to ruin plaintiffs business standing everywhere they are
known. As a result of defendants actions, plaintiff has suffered damage to its good name
and reputation, to its prospective income and advantage, and to the value of its trade name
and standing for which plaintiff has been working hard and diligently for decades.
DEFENDANTS VIOLATIONS OF LONG-ESTABLISHED
JOURNALISTIC STANDARDS 101
42. Defendants website newskann.com provides no disclosure as to the standards
that are applied to fact-gathering, fact-checking, and reporting or filing news articles, and
22
certainly no standard for verifying or checking facts with the targets of the articles. In fact,
defendants clearly are not interested in presenting a factually accurate story; when H Marts
corporate counsel wrote to advise them of their inaccuracy, they mocked the corporate
counsels correction/retraction request by stating that they will be filing a complaint with the
Office of Attorney Ethics for interfering with a member of the press.
43. While the news industry, as such, is not regulated by law, there exist known and
long-adhered standards for journalism, journalists, newspapers, and operators of such
businesses that are set and promulgated by various organizations. The principles of
truthfulness, accuracy, objectivity, impartiality, fairness and public accountability are
common to many such journalism standards and are practically self-evident necessities for
a fair and balanced reporting of stories.
44.
The
American
Society
of
Newspaper
Editors
23
(ASNE)
24
***
46. Minimal journalistic standards were not applied through defendants abject failure
to interview anyone from H Mart, from governmental authorities that have safety and
regulatory authority over fishery imports, including the U.S. Food and Drug Administration
and the U.S. Department of Agriculture, both of which are easily accessible from the Internet
and the phones, before defendants disseminated the purported articles using passionate
headers and lead lines; and they used conjecture and supposition to fill fact-gaps of
significant proportions in their reckless abandonment of journalistic integrity and societal
responsibility. These are not the proper actions of a bona fide newspaper or news media
but rather rogue individuals scandalizing an unfortunate accident to cause havoc among
consumers so as to enhance their own sense of prestige.
DEFENDANTS VIOLATION OF THE LAW OF LIBEL DEFAMATION
47. Defendants purport to have reported events uncovered by them from U.S.
Customs records out of the JFK Airport facilities where plaintiff Captain Blue allegedly
imported nuclear contaminated products. The allegations involve New York events and were
made from defendants offices in New Jersey, and thus both the laws of New York and New
Jersey are potentially implicated.
48. Under New York law a plaintiff must establish five elements to recover in libel
or written defamation: (1) a written statement of fact (not opinion) concerning the plaintiff
which is claimed to be defamatory; (2) publication or dissemination to a third party; (3) fault
(either negligence or actual malice depending on the status of the claimed injured party); (4)
25
falsity of the statement; and (5) special damages or per se basis of action (facially
defamatory). Celle v. Filipino Reporter Enterprises Inc., 209 F.3d 163, 176 (2d Cir. 2000)
(summarizing New York law). [A] writing which tends to disparage a person in the way
of his office, profession or trade is defamatory per se and does not require proof of special
damages. Id. (internal quotation marks and citations omitted).
49. As the New York Court of Appeals stated in, a complaint states a valid cause of
action for libel per se under these circumstances:
The common law of libel in New York makes any libelous written words
published or concerning another which are false and tend to injure another's
reputation and discredit that person in the estimation of the public. To make
an article libelous per se the charge must impeach the honesty, virtue or
character of the complaining party or expose that person to public hatred,
contempt, ridicule or obloquy or injure the person in his business or occupation
(1 Seelman, Law of Libel and Slander in State of NY, par 11, pp 10-11).
Rupert v. Sellers, 65 A.D.2d 473, 481 (4th Dept. 1978).
50. New Jersey law is essentially identical in that the same five elements are required
to prove defamation. See e.g., Monroe v. Host Marriot Services Corp., 999 F.Supp. 599, 603
(D.N.J. 1998) (five elements of defamation); Feggans v. Billington, 291 N.J. Super. 382,
391, 677 A.2d 771 (1996) (five elements of defamation):
In order to state a claim for defamation, a plaintiff must satisfy
five elements: (1) a defamatory statement of fact, (2) concerning
the plaintiff, (3) which was false (4) communicated to a person
or persons other than the plaintiff, and (5) damages.
Petersen v. Meggitt, 407 N.J. Super. 63, 74 (App. Div. 2009) (internal quotations omitted).
51. Under New Jersey law, defamation per se arises, similarly, when the defamatory
26
statement (1) accuses another of having committed a criminal offense; (2) attributes another
of having a loathsome disease; (3) accuses another of engaging in conduct, or having a
condition or trait, incompatible with his or her business; and (4) accuses another of having
engaged in serious sexual misconduct. Ricciardi v. Weber, 350 N.J. Super. 453, 475-76
(App. Div. 2002); Biondi v. Nassimos, 300 N.J. Super.148, 154-57 (App. Div. 1997).
Defendants actions implicate the third defamation per se standard, as defendants have
attacked plaintiffs business practices as being dishonest; as posing consumer safety concerns
from nuclear contaminated products, as their articles have asserted.
52. Defendants actions constitute defamation per se because their actions subject
plaintiff to ridicule, hatred, or contempt or which clearly sound to the disreputation of an
individual are defamatory on their face Id. at 459, meaning they are libel per se, and
actionable without further proof. See also Hoagburg v. Harrahs Marina Hotel Casino, 585
F. Supp. 1167 (D.N.J. 1984); Dijkstra v. Westerink, 168 N.J. Super. 128 (App.Div. 1979),
certif. den. 81 N.J. 329 (1979).
53. Defamation arises from falsity of facts; only facts are capable of being proven
false, it follows that only statements alleging facts can properly be the subject of a
defamation action. Gross v. New York Times Co., 82 N.Y.2d 146, 152-153 (1993). In
distinguishing between facts and opinion, the following factors guide the conclusion (1)
whether the specific language has a precise meaning that is readily understood, (2) whether
the statements are capable of being proven true or false, and (3) whether the context in which
the statement appears signals to readers that the statement is likely to be opinion, not fact.
27
See Mann v. Abel, 10 N.Y.3d 271, 276 (2008), cert denied 555 U.S. 1170 (2009); Steinhilber
v. Alphonse, 68 N.Y.2d 283, 292 (1986). The dispositive inquiry . . . is whether a reasonable
reader could have concluded that the [statements were] conveying facts about the plaintiff.
Gross v. New York Times Co., 82 N.Y.2d at 152; Millus v. Newsday, Inc., 89 N.Y.2d 840,
842 (1996), cert denied 520 U.S. 1144 (1997). Defendants have repeatedly asserted that they
reported only facts in relation to plaintiff.
54. The Restatement (Second) of Torts, 568 (1977), although not law, as such,
is applied as authoritative and effectively into common law decisions. The Restatement
(Second) of Torts, Section 568 distinguishes between slander (verbal defamation) and libel
(written defamation) as follows:
(1) Libel consists of the publication of defamatory matter by written or
printed words, by its embodiment in physical form or by any other form of
communication that has the potentially harmful qualities characteristic of
written or printed words.
(2) Slander consists of the publication of defamatory matter by spoken
words, transitory gestures or by any form of communication other than those
stated in Subsection (1).
DEFENDANTS NEWS MEDIA STATUS DOES NOT
CONFER ANY LICENSE TO REPORT FALSE FACTS
55. Defendants are of the view that the mere fact that they are self-proclaimed
members of the news media somehow confer upon themselves some license to present
demonstrably false facts as news in their online facility. Because of the importance of
speech and free speech and indeed it is the very first amendment among the set of
Constitutional principles known as the Bill of Rights, there is no question that the United
28
States is a nation of freedom of expression and ideas. This basic reality does not displace the
concomitant legal and constitutional principle that false facts that result in harm cannot be
shielded by the first amendment freedoms. Indeed, almost a hundred years ago, the United
States Supreme Court provide the example repeated countless times that someone who yells
inside a crowded movie theater, fire!, when in fact there is no fire, has no protection under
the first amendment to create havoc in the society, stating:
The most stringent protection of free speech would not protect
a man in falsely shouting fire in a theater and causing a panic. .
Schenck v. United States, 249 U.S. 47,52 (1919).
56. As the U.S. Supreme Court has also observed time and time again, false facts are
simply not protected regardless of who utters them:
the press has an obvious interest in avoiding the infliction of
harm by the publication of false information, and it is not
unreasonable to expect the media to invoke whatever procedures
may be practicable and useful to that end. Moreover, given
exposure to liability when there is knowing or reckless error,
there is even more reason to resort to prepublication precautions,
such as a frank interchange of fact and opinion.
Herbert v. Lando, 441 U. S. 153,174 (1979).
57. The Supreme Court has repeatedly validated lawsuits against members of the
news media, even well known media that follow established journalistic principles as those
discussed above, where they have gone astray in their reporting of false information as
facts resulting in injury to the object of scorn, ridicule, or denigration in their articles:
But there is also another side to the equation; we have regularly
acknowledged the important social values which underlie the
29
30
58. Indeed, even real news media defendants face liability when their articles cause
reputational injury when false information is reported as facts or news. See e.g.,
http://www.boston.com/news/local/massachusetts/2014/09/30/new-york-post-reaches-sett
lement-boston-marathon-libel-case-and-never-know-who-won/s2oKBTnWCD7U0A7TV
TQkWO/story.html; Sprague v. Philadelphia Newspapers, Inc.: $34 million libel verdict in
Pennsylvania; and countless others.
59. Regardless of whether defendants are news media members or not, they are not
above the law, and they have no automatic refuge from this libel action merely because they
hold themselves out as members of the news media. Because they are held to the basic
Constitutional standard that false facts cannot be deployed to harm the reputation of other
persons and business entities, they should be required to account for their acts.
DEFENDANTS SCIENTIFIC ASSERTIONS
WITHOUT SCIENTIFIC EVIDENCE OR SUPPORT
60. A central factual thesis in defendants numerous articles about the products
being sold by plaintiff, imported from Korea, not Japan, is the raw passionate linkage they
instigate, with no real scientific support, that the Fukushima, Japans nuclear spill accident
of 2011 is actively contaminating the fishery products of Jeju Province, Korea. Jeju is the
southern-tip island provincial territory of South Korea (see map, infra) which is due south,
west of Japan and significantly due south, west of Fukushima (see map, infra). Fukushima,
having a compass point of 37.4231 N, 141.0331 E, is decidedly due north-west of Jeju
islands, located at 33.3667 N, 126.5333, decidedly south-west of Fukushima.
31
NOAAs products and services support economic vitality and affect more than one-third of
Americas gross domestic product. NOAAs dedicated scientists use cutting-edge research
and high-tech instrumentation to provide citizens, planners, emergency managers and other
decision makers with reliable information they need when they need it.
http://www.noaa.gov/about-noaa.html. NOAAs maps of oceanic currents include the
following currents-map of the Asian-Pacific rim:
62. The currents flow from Japan to the U.S.A. passing through the Hawaiian
archipelago, and do not flow south-westerly to Jeju Islands, pushed due north-west by the recirculation gyre.
63. More than two years after the Fukushima incident, in a September 16, 2013,
33
article, Korea and World Fear Fukushimas Radiation: Early Protections Have Led to
Tighter Rules after Leaks Continued, Korea Joonang Daily reported of the fears of
contaminated fishery products, among neighboring Asian countries, in part:
Despite being the nation nearest to Japan, Korea remained
relatively calm after the March 2011 disaster at the Fukushima
Daiichi nuclear plant.
But more than two years after the nuclear plants meltdown, the
fear of radiation has increased in Korea after a series of
revelations about contaminated water flowing into the Pacific.
The Korean government is trying to say that consumer anxiety
over the safety of Japanese products in particular is being
whipped up by irresponsible postings on the Internet and
through social network services.
Prime Minister Chung Hong-won even said he would direct
severe punishment at people who spread unfounded,
radiation-related rumors.
But fear continued to rise and fish consumption fell regardless
of where the fish came from, affecting local fishermen and fish
retailers. As a result, the Korean government decided on Sept.
6 to ban fish imports from eight prefectures surrounding the
crippled Fukushima Daiichi nuclear complex to calm people
down.
Korea had banned 26 agricultural products from 13 prefectures,
but the import of fish products was relatively unaffected,
according to the Ministry of Food and Drug Safety.
Exhibit 6.
64. The article discussed western fears including voices of fears in the United States
and European Union, which resulted in import bans of Japanese fishery products. The
Korean government has never identified any nuclear fallout concern within the waters of the
34
South Korean peninsula that justifies the kind of fear-mongering being instigated by
defendants under the facade of their news media status.
65. The Center for Research on Globalization (CRG) is an independent research
organization that presents highly aggressive views, even controversial, concerning nuclear
fallout and contamination and general environmental issues.
numerous research articles and scientific data presented from its viewpoint. Even CRG,
with its anti-nuclear advocacy platform, has virtually no substantive adverse commentary on
the fishery of South Korea in the aftermath of the Fukushima, Japan accident. Indeed, in a
nuclear fallout computer imagery, CRG posits that nuclear fallout spread east to west
(following the ocean current pattern) from eastern Japan to North America:
35
73. As a direct and proximate result of defendants conduct, plaintiff suffered damage
to its good name and reputation, and plaintiff is entitled to damages.
74. The October 22, 2014 publication was a separate publication within the meaning
of Rinaldi v Viking Penguin, 52 NY2d 422, 433-435 (1991), as defendants consciously and
deliberately incorporated the October 16, 2014, initial article by referencing it in this
subsequent, separate article in which it referred to its previous article which was
defamatory.
Count Three Libel Per Se October 24, 2014
75. Plaintiff incorporates the preceding paragraphs by reference.
76. As stated above, defendants and each of them committed libel per se by writing
and publishing an article containing defamatory statements of fact, concerning the plaintiff,
which was false, which was communicated to a many individuals other than plaintiff, and
which caused damage.
77. Defendants and each of them targeted plaintiff concerning its business practices
which defendants intended to defame and therefore defendants and each of them committed
libel per se.
78. As a direct and proximate result of defendants conduct, plaintiff suffered damage
to its good name and reputation, and plaintiff is entitled to damages.
79. The October 22 publication was a separate publication within the meaning of
Rinaldi v Viking Penguin, 52 NY2d 422, 433-435 (1991), as defendants consciously and
deliberately incorporated the October 16, 2014, initial article by referencing it in this
37
subsequent, separate article in which it referred to its previous article which was
defamatory.
Count Four Libel Per Se November 3, 2014
80. Plaintiff incorporates the preceding paragraphs by reference.
81. As stated above, defendants and each of them committed libel per se by writing
and publishing an article containing defamatory statements of fact, concerning the plaintiff,
which was false, which was communicated to many individuals other than plaintiff, and
which caused damage.
82. Defendants and each of them targeted plaintiff concerning its business practices
which defendants intended to defame and therefore defendants and each of them committed
libel per se.
83. As a direct and proximate result of defendants conduct, plaintiff suffered damage
to its good name and reputation, and plaintiff is entitled to damages.
84. The November 3, 2014 publication was a separate publication within the meaning
of Rinaldi v Viking Penguin, 52 NY2d 422, 433-435 (1991), as defendants consciously and
deliberately incorporated the October 16, 2014, initial article by referencing it in this
subsequent, separate article in which it referred to its previous article which was
defamatory.
Count Five Libel Per Se MissyUSA.com October 16, 2014, Posting
85. Plaintiff incorporates the preceding paragraphs by reference.
86. Upon information and belief, defendants made and posted or caused to be posted
38
a wholesale copy of their defamatory article dated October 16, 2014, and re-posted it or
caused to be reposted on a website used by Korean-American housewives and others,
which is significantly more popular, with a significantly higher audience, than their
newskann.com website. Exhibit 7. They did so in order to indirectly use the missyusa.com
portals more-popular blog forum to cause readers to pay attention to their newspaper
substantially as a marketing artifice. Defendants intentions yielded fruit as numerous
individuals read the posting and engaged in comments that were decidedly adverse to the
plaintiff.
87. Defendants and each of them targeted plaintiff concerning its business practices
which defendants intended to defame and therefore defendants and each of them committed
libel per se.
88. As a direct and proximate result of defendants conduct, plaintiff suffered damage
to its good name and reputation, and plaintiff is entitled to damages.
89. The October 16, 2014 publication was a separate publication within the meaning
of Rinaldi v Viking Penguin, 52 NY2d 422, 433-435 (1991), as defendants consciously and
deliberately incorporated the October 16, 2014, initial article by referencing it in this
subsequent, separate article in which it referred to its previous article which was
defamatory.
Count Six Libel Per Se MissyUSA.com October 17, 2014, Posting
90. Plaintiff incorporates the preceding paragraphs by reference.
91. Upon information and belief, defendants made and posted or caused to be posted
39
a wholesale copy of their defamatory article dated October 16, 2014, and re-posted it or
caused to be reposted on a website used by Korean-American housewives and others,
which is significantly more popular, with a significantly higher audience, than their
newskann.com website. Exhibit 8. They did so in order to indirectly use the missyusa.com
portals more-popular blog forum to cause readers to pay attention to their newspaper
substantially as a marketing artifice. Defendants intentions yielded fruit as numerous
individuals read the posting and engaged in comments that were decidedly adverse to the
plaintiff.
92. Defendants and each of them targeted plaintiff concerning its business practices
which defendants intended to defame and therefore defendants and each of them committed
libel per se.
93. As a direct and proximate result of defendants conduct, plaintiff suffered damage
to its good name and reputation, and plaintiff is entitled to damages.
94. The October 17, 2014 publication was a separate publication within the meaning
of Rinaldi v Viking Penguin, 52 NY2d 422, 433-435 (1991), as defendants consciously and
deliberately incorporated the October 16, 2014, initial article by referencing it in this
subsequent, separate article in which it referred to its previous article which was
defamatory.
Count Seven Libel Per Se MissyUSA.com October 18, 2014, Posting
95. Plaintiff incorporates the preceding paragraphs by reference.
96. Upon information and belief, defendants made and posted or caused to be posted
40
a wholesale copy of their defamatory article dated October 16, 2014, and re-posted it or
caused to be reposted on a website used by Korean-American housewives and others,
which is significantly more popular, with a significantly higher audience, than their
newskann.com website. Exhibit 9. They did so in order to indirectly use the missyusa.com
portals more-popular blog forum to cause readers to pay attention to their newspaper
substantially as a marketing artifice. Defendants intentions yielded fruit as numerous
individuals read the posting and engaged in comments that were decidedly adverse to the
plaintiff.
97. Defendants and each of them targeted plaintiff concerning its business practices
which defendants intended to defame and therefore defendants and each of them committed
libel per se.
98. As a direct and proximate result of defendants conduct, plaintiff suffered damage
to its good name and reputation, and plaintiff is entitled to damages.
99. The October 18, 2014 publication was a separate publication within the meaning
of Rinaldi v Viking Penguin, 52 NY2d 422, 433-435 (1991), as defendants consciously and
deliberately incorporated the October 16, 2014, initial article by referencing it in this
subsequent, separate article in which it referred to its previous article which was
defamatory.
Count Eight Libel Per Se MissyUSA.com October 19, 2014, Posting
100. Plaintiff incorporates the preceding paragraphs by reference.
101. Upon information and belief, defendants made and posted or caused to be
41
reposted a wholesale copy of their defamatory article dated October 16, 2014, and reposted it or caused to be reposted on a website used by Korean-American housewives and
others, which is significantly more popular, with a significantly higher audience, than their
newskann.com website. Exhibit 10. They did so in order to indirectly use the missyusa.com
portals more-popular blog forum to cause readers to pay attention to their newspaper
substantially as a marketing artifice. Defendants intentions yielded fruit as numerous
individuals read the posting and engaged in comments that were decidedly adverse to the
plaintiff.
102. Defendants and each of them targeted plaintiff concerning its business practices
which defendants intended to defame and therefore defendants and each of them committed
libel per se.
103. As a direct and proximate result of defendants conduct, plaintiff suffered
damage to its good name and reputation, and plaintiff is entitled to damages.
104. The October 19, 2014 publication was a separate publication within the meaning
of Rinaldi v Viking Penguin, 52 NY2d 422, 433-435 (1991), as defendants consciously and
deliberately incorporated the October 16, 2014, initial article by referencing it in this
subsequent, separate article in which it referred to its previous article which was
defamatory.
Count Nine Libel Per Se MissyUSA.com October 26, 2014, Posting
105. Plaintiff incorporates the preceding paragraphs by reference.
106. Upon information and belief, defendants made and posted or caused to be posted
42
a wholesale copy of their defamatory article dated October 16, 2014, and re-posted it or
caused to be reposted on a website used by Korean-American housewives and others,
which is significantly more popular, with a significantly higher audience, than their
newskann.com website. Exhibit 11. They did so in order to indirectly use the missyusa.com
portals more-popular blog forum to cause readers to pay attention to their newspaper
substantially as a marketing artifice. Defendants intentions yielded fruit as numerous
individuals read the posting and engaged in comments that were decidedly adverse to the
plaintiff.
107. Defendants and each of them targeted plaintiff concerning its business practices
which defendants intended to defame and therefore defendants and each of them committed
libel per se.
108. As a direct and proximate result of defendants conduct, plaintiff suffered
damage to its good name and reputation, and plaintiff is entitled to damages.
109. The October 26 publication was a separate publication within the meaning of
Rinaldi v Viking Penguin, 52 NY2d 422, 433-435 (1991), as defendants consciously and
deliberately incorporated the October 26, 2014 initial article by referencing it in this
subsequent, separate article in which it referred to its previous article which was
defamatory.
Count Ten Libel Per Se MissyUSA.com November 1, 2014, Posting
110. Plaintiff incorporates the preceding paragraphs by reference.
111. Upon information and belief, defendants made and posted or caused to be posted
43
a wholesale copy of their defamatory article dated October 22, 2014, and re-posted it or
caused to be reposted on a website used by Korean-American housewives and others,
which is significantly more popular, with a significantly higher audience, than their
newskann.com website. Exhibit 12. They did so in order to indirectly use the missyusa.com
portals more-popular blog forum to cause readers to pay attention to their newspaper
substantially as a marketing artifice. Defendants intentions yielded fruit as numerous
individuals read the posting and engaged in comments that were decidedly adverse to the
plaintiff.
112. Defendants and each of them targeted plaintiff concerning its business practices
which defendants intended to defame and therefore defendants and each of them committed
libel per se.
113. As a direct and proximate result of defendants conduct, plaintiff suffered
damage to its good name and reputation, and plaintiff is entitled to damages.
114. The November 1, 2014 publication was a separate publication within the
meaning of Rinaldi v Viking Penguin, 52 NY2d 422, 433-435 (1991), as defendants
consciously and deliberately incorporated the October 22, 2014, and October 26, 2014 initial
articles by referencing them in this subsequent, separate article in which it referred to
its previous articles which was defamatory.
Count Eleven Tortious Interference with Prospective Economic Advantage
115. Plaintiff incorporates the preceding paragraphs by reference.
116. By spreading false and defamatory public attacks against plaintiffs lawful
44
business activity, defendants have repeatedly interfered with each plaintiffs relationship with
its customers at large and with suppliers, domestic and overseas, and with each other, by
association with the severely adverse social stigma of selling supposed nuclear
contaminated fishery products.
117. Defendants are well aware that the consumers at large, plaintiffs suppliers, and
all persons engaged in business relations with plaintiff are influenced by news reports, and
they deliberately launched attacks presented as news reports to wage a campaign adverse
to plaintiff to create hysteria and thereby attract new readers and enhance their self-prestige
and cause havoc in plaintiffs relationships with suppliers and customers.
118. In 2008, it was widely reported all over the world that when American beef
products were to be permitted to be imported into South Korea, mass hysteria over concerns
of mad cow diseases resulted in mass rioting and even suicide by Koreans who were
antagonized by anti-import forces. See Exhibit13 (NY Times, Beef Protest Turns Violent
in South Korea, 6-30-08); such provocation of mass hysteria, then as now, is far worse than
shouting fire inside a crowded theater, as exponentially large numbers of persons are
harmed from the mass hysteria created by false facts. With years having passed since
American beef was permitted importing into Korea, with no mad cow diseases evident, only
those who perished or were injured from the mass hysteria are victims who suffered
irretrievable losses. Defendants in this case are using the severely negative stigma of the
Fukushima nuclear disaster stemming from the Tsunami of 2011 to create pure hysteria
rather than reporting the facts. They are creating hysteria so as to enhance their own prestige
45
in the Korean-American community and the fact that they are interfering with the prospective
and pending economic advantage of plaintiff is their means of achieving their end. By reason
of those facts, defendants and each of them committed tortious interference with prospective
economic advantage against plaintiff.
119. As a direct and proximate result of defendants malicious acts, plaintiff suffered
injury.
Count Twelve Declaratory Judgment
120. Plaintiff incorporates the preceding paragraphs by reference.
121. Plaintiff requests declaratory judgment that defendants website newskann.com
is not a bona fide newspaper as is self-claimed in defendants website. Defendants claim
that their website is a newspaper; media and that they engaged in fair news-gathering
and dissemination services and plaintiff maintains they are not a newspaper and they did not
report the facts fairly and accurately. There is therefore a dispute as to this issue and
declaratory judgment is appropriate.
Count Thirteen Declaratory Judgment
122. Plaintiff requests declaratory judgment that defendants website newskann.com
holds no copyright to third-party works of authorship which themselves constitute
wholesale copyright infringement of third-parties intellectual property rights. Defendants
claim that their website owns all copyright as of 2010 and plaintiff maintains defendants
claim of copyright is false and unlawful. There is therefore a dispute as to this issue and
declaratory judgment is appropriate.
46
By: __________-H__
MichaelS. Kimm, E . (Admitted in NY)
Thomas W. Park, Esq. (Admitted in NY)
Sung H. Jang, Esq. (PHV)
Attorneys for Plaintiff H Mart, Inc.
_ L _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ __
48
49
EXHIBIT 1
Page 1 of2
Ill
NEWSKANN
HOME
I :Je! I J!I@Jig)
2!Aie!LH
.,._
'-A
PRE\IOUS
LIST
[M.2:1]
NEXT
e!"e.! 61
5:/"011
\ill-: 14-1016 12:17
English News
-~~~'*~
( Coslume lnslitu]
H-\T~
Exhibition Dates:
~Of-'n-~
"
Skin Ca ...
[ BCPD Announces )
An arrest of two
men for ...
-Fe ...
.ft~t:!%r.6
HDf ~.S.:O, 2gj01 21~8 .Aii~H ~~' oH~, g)Jll, ~01 CH~ -'?gj
~
fl
iT~~.!f!-.2.~,
~2.16~~ 5~ .;:t~SUii.R
ate
HDI.e J:ii"?H *H~'2! ~~Jlf C:!"'!, OHg, 'illJII. &1, H !;l-::1:1, >iltOi 121 C:!~~
-*gjofJI.SO Aii"?*H~'iH\:ll:'f~(Jfog)Jll- JliQf~ .Xll~oi::L! lSgj 2-"i< 'IT& 711LiiCI ~
~011 *H~OI ~ 50~(2.,' 5~ Iif!.E~ l:f:~)!1 ~eJ-gj::J:f~ OI~CI.
HOf..e 16gj 'rr&Jll- 'rrXiXI, tllXILIOI{~J:H fE\5) ~ 01"? OH~OII if!~oH ~OHOII
~OiJIXf ml:! .>'f<=iiAIOI ~AI~ Af::L! 01 E!XH J:il"?tlfQ~ !i!IAioH ~OH, 'el'oH g)J
tlfQ21 ~Af{!l 2gj Jf~{!JOI JtiX~ ~~ AIE!'OI 2.1eiof.:U ~!:lXI Pie *H~~ 01"?
~011Jll if!~~ Xi21Jf 212lJrn HOI. ~OHfE~OII ~OiJfAH:: ~2.1Jf ~Af1
IiiAI.:U 1 Q.
:qL=f.ii!-&
1:l Xll4'"f
gt.=a . .2~~o~
[8 >') ~Af
2f?:!
...
..
HI<>.LI!>
,__ ......
e!~ ~~
?J!l/
~21 OI~C!i!!
1'011;! 90ml601!!1
JI2H~ !60Sici,
!?~tste! -ru~ou
~S[fi~~=
~
~2~ ~~!!- e!~ ~J-21 'UI~OII
ill~ ~2101' @!~~21 .!;!~::
:i:il!l2 Ol~!i!:li!!O!IJII t:HI M
;:!;0101 JIAI]
!;!63l!;ll::! 7! ...
~AI~
2g
OHH~~
QlJllle!
5~
~~01
AI<St!1
!::c.i~le ~
~~~
gt,
gj~g,<,
2-t gtOII
Ii!ll::!i!ICi
.;;2121~
ciXI!!l ...
~~~ OP~!H:!H~~~2!=?:1::
32t:l
SJI...
AIE!'OI 2.1e!oH ~OHJI !XI PlXf gJMfJll ~~~ ll:tOI ~i'UOII AlA~ 01"?
J:!Jf21 Jf~OII ~OHofe 3:!g 01"? ~~ ~Jll Oft: g)Oirn HDI.Jf ~
~ztg ~.2..S: ofXI Pi.:U ~21"?.50~ ~Af~21 tll~~~ ~2.H:!l ~~~~.AI
1Jf -TtE:!oHOt 8Cf.
HOI.e
~~
~011Jll
C:!l'EJfOII
'2!oH
EJIJ!'lgj'~
g31e
~2-t{!l~
< ...
[-- 1fAI
~~)
'21...
XI
?;j~CI.
http://www.newskann.com/bbs/board.php?bo_table=news&wr_id=4838&page=4
2014-11-07
Page 2 of2
2et ~g g;i:!Jf 01.!::: :011,\-J ~~et 3;!!XI 2~XJ8,
.!fl QIOIAf~ ~oH ~*8 ~ 18 km~ Olet 3:!01Cf.
~~AJDf ~,\f)3~~01 ~
-R-~011 Afe et1 ~ 2Mie "Clt.!fiOII ~2.f2! {!lCl ilf:1 eJ~etJf'~~ El~of:i1 "HDf
~{!12.1" ofeXJ, gj:i1 !<!Olot of.!:::U"Jf -E:!2:!0I2.f:i1 ~~~a.
e i!f'2'!
E1 C!~JfJf LH~g ~i:fiAIDf ~C! ALJl 01~ AI~C!IOIC!OIIe ofLf ~l!>l ~xjJ~ ~
2.1LH:i1 ~:i1.2e 2022~0111= 2.1AIOf 21" t:lfQJJfXI ~Afl3011 .2gj ~~ ~IIAI~
O.<Af~g JJAff -E:!JlJJf &t. grilsheloved tistory>
LIST
PREIJOUS
;E!E:!
<?~>;<
NEXT
~~ :QIXH~ ~Jll
!JUQ.
http://www.newskann.com/bbs/board.php?bo_table=news&wr_id=4838&page=4
2014-11-07
EXHIBIT 2
Page 1 of2
IIIII
NEWSKANN
HOME
JAie!Ul/
~:Je!
J!E!Jigj
0 -rr'-A
UST'
[N1] e:!g
~
t!l-OH
English News
S~{t*~
.!!~
l!!Ofu.h.
Skin Ca ...
{SCPO Announces 1
An arrest of two
men for ...
. ..
9~~~.~er 20,
2014
c ... I
-t!~~-\T.:!>
[I ~Q{2j ~Af-- -9-~ 51Q:U
oH::!;II
:tlll:liCI
gj*
~JHOU~
0] Af~"iEj?/;<lf\:! '&all~ 1} .. .
HDf:
~Xf, .:J:!I:tl~
oriHl
'<!~?il'U!~
E.!~~~~~ a~ m~CJ~
~~~ 90ml60"'!
Jl24 160S/2i,
~~BJE! ~~011
.kJ ~S[!n-:6:~=
Xi!'?
'"'0101 JIXI] S
'
HDf:l:: CHgJ e!-e.!Df:~ 01~~ OfAie.t 6.(g Xile.!~ Jf~Cil ~CH 712~ ~~g,f~
i?d"i!i"Jl 2-lCI-. !n-~, !n-XiXI, ~2.1.:LIOf 13JH -'?011 41JH om~ ~~of:il e!DH~
g 12Ql ft2.1 011 ftero.
OlJ:I~ 9-~e!- 3:!~
.. .
~\d:..:-;.
!<!~
~ll5.Lil>
?HI<ei 'Ull!lOll
!::!.63EJc:! 7L.
IDIC!2.1C~ ~ ~2l~~ 2IXI~S
...
012li;!~J:I ~~
Cl!!! e!JI!iiOI
~'i'!~ Ol'l!l{l!2Ji)ill'2!'?~ i;iJL ..
32~ ~AJ.2J ~6~aJ
aeJ
Et~L.
Al;sr
<...
~JlJliAH), !n-~~
~.fi<AH@Jll JIAf
>t=<l "'!'I)
~!! ...
[!ji
04/1112014
0Pfl OH.S::ef
HDf~e 5~1
HJH::L! 2
LIST
l!t~.2
PRE\lOUS
NEXT
gJL/CL
http://www.newskann.com/bbs/board.php?bo_table=news&wr_id=4852&page=4
2014-11-07
EXHIBIT 3
Page I of2
liiNEWSKANN
01
*~
PRE\IOUS
UST
[ N 1 ] Xi I~ H Ol-f
NEXf
~ ~ e.!" ~ 2.-J ~ J ~ ~ ~
~.s::
';;!"!-: 14-10.24 07:19
English Naws
A~~~*~
I Costume
R.W.~
lnslilu)
Exhibition Dales:
May 7&# ...
ISouth Korea
Exp .. l
Skin Ca ...
I BCPD Announces l
An arrest of two
men for ...
{Cubism: The Leo J
g~
[1 fi~~..!J!.~.
XfL11il-&
~~
El-9-CI~~:::::: ~~ .:jl-~2.tll2.
Xii'?OJ~g;<'>J'i'~g OJ~ 01~ lf!XIQl H-Df. ~~~ Jl1 l.oH Ail'?t! ~*~
'i't.t<'>Jil 'i'~i.H~ 1000e!'&ci A11:e/2{):j oH~!JIOIIe C-1 Btg ~OJ ~Jf tl~
~ OU~OIO.:Ll -*He.! tJ~OI ':i'.S::~Cf.<Af~=mirror.enha.kr>
E~~
%12-tAf
~~ 40~';:1
7l'zSCH
HIZi'-1~
f..... , ....
:
LIST
PRE\IOUS
!lit~
90ml60!!!i
J~~g 160Et2.i,
-'?@OH?:! ~~011
Ai ~$[-'iT~~;;:;
NEXf
~0101 JIX!] ~
~~~ ~~!! ~~ ~.2t.2/'UIOII
~~ ~~01' @~~~ ~~~.~
:<125'. Ol"l~.!l~OIIJII ~~ A1
=:!::::::3iS~ 3i ...
Iill~CICi ~ ~21~~ CI.XI~S
...
32\::!
< ...
(Sf-
]p:.j ~~]
~-
~j
liB
http://www.newskann.com/bbs/board.php?bo_table=news&wr_id=4859&page=3
2014-11-07
EXHIBIT 4
Page 1 of2
IIINEWSKANN
0~
LIST
PRE\.IDUS
NEXT
-~~*~
Ei.%J.~
(Costume lnstitu)
Exhibition Dates:
May 7&# ...
:I
:
Skin Ca ...
( BCPD Announces ]
An arrest of two
men for ...
[Cubism: The Leo .. )
-Fe ...
~{Jt!%r.C:
ill g~ '8!<H
D
Dl;i;<H~
if:<i
*~~.!:f.2.tl, A}L1.ill:&
!f4
(J .?jS-2.)~~~ S1 ;:z.~2Ail2
rJ
Jll~of
Ql,;;s ~Ql !SOl t!!Ei~ ~~OHxll -\T~~ ~t!Afe ~~Ai.S:. @t ~2;J~.J:! ~ ~ Cfof
E eJeOICf. *ste ~g ~~Ail OIOiXi OJ;;;s.31 !:4*~ ~.J:!~ct. :lciW
AHDIAII~.S:.E.!~e ~~!:C.S:.2f Af~!:C.S:.~ E.! XI ~of.J:! ~Afi~ Olt:!e! ~ XiAfl=
!F.:ilfF.J:! l::liEt~~ 3:!0icf.J:! ~XiXI!!/4l:!fOII Ji~ofe ~ 2(45)!AIJf ~~Cf.
Xis ~~g gj~l!tAf~ Oiiif [[JlOII AII9.S:. H~ l::ll~oH 6.lfOIIA~ oW~OI AfcfXI
.Jl 1e!~ofe *~2:1~ JIAfJf gjl.fXIOII ~2.1.Jl ~e ~~010. All~*&~ Jf2:101
~S',ff:lll~ Ef ~Afi01 '2l%!Jf2l(~iU)OII AfA~ Ol;;;s ~.~0liJlll::li!AfJll life 3:!~
~!:'1 3:!01Cf.
l!tAf~ Oliii- Xii~*H~g ~Oi?SI::li.S:. ~ 2:JXI.Jl @&Xf8Xile \illcte 01~01 st
Cf. 2fF f:llgeJ- '*'l.L! ~lgjx11 EtOH~Ei.S:. J!lj~OICf.XI\::! 96l0l""l.S:. lO~e!Oll ~
~ct.
t...Hj
[~~ZJ=OI!!
Et~cg~ -~PI~~Oil
tJ ::SJQ.l-21
tgAJ~ .!:r~
mT:!~AJ
:&Zj
S':::!V ...
40~12! 7~~QI
Ul2'-l~
; ..-.:,.:
~~ ~~~-*a~ m~C!~
1';1"' 90ml60!!!i
Jl~g
160st2i,
=?~OH~! ~~011
Ai
~a[ff~ZJ:::
. ~0101 JIXI] ~
~2. ~~~ ~~ ~f2.1'UISOII
~~~~OJ' ~~~g ~!!e
;tHs2. Ol~.!ll!iOIIJIIlUt Ai
!=!~3~C! 71 ...
liHc:!21C1
a ~2.1~~
m2.1~~.:tl ~~ ~!"
21XI~S
...
2JJIOI
3JI...
~21 ~~ ...
6~6: Ql~g~~~!=?.1!
32\::1
~Af1 ~~~~
{~ 7~.X.J ~~]
Ill ...
2014-11-07
OI~Jll
S:.E.!.2le tJf
3:!8
3:!01 OfLI2.f
e!AI~~
tJf
~e
Jl
.
<,
li!;'Cf Hg>
LIST
PRE\IOUS
NEXT
gJLICI.
2014-11-07
EXHIBIT 5
Page 1 of2
~NEWSKANN
01
*"
UST
PRE\IOUS
[N1] HmE
f9-0H
NEXT
English News
-a~~*~
(Costume lnstitu 1
Hff~
Exhibition Dates:
May 7&# ...
An arrest of two
men for ...
-Fe ...
=!~~*~
[I g~
=2-Z:!CJJ
Ti-Ai
OJ~[.~~~
OJE!Oil'PHi ';1;E.I2f
~ .. .
~-~t!
.. .
D Xil4*t
;;t~AI~ \'!'?-~1
>H;!;I
f'l t:JQ./"21
~A~~~~ S~{J
ff~ @Z{A~
;g{:!
409-li:! 7)\:3r{l
JIAf
~ Af~
['n-~~=01'2.!:2
~JI
31XIe
~J.I X11~
l'ill!l!90ml60<!!!
~e
n~g 16o~2.-1,
. <:?~Ot~ et~Oll
: M ~S[fi~l.l'=
,0101 JIXI] i1l
EC~ ~~~eeL
3\il.! 01;;011 Ale Ol-2!~01 ~ Olole OIIAIUSA Oll '~J.I \il.!!H et;;&~
~'OI2H:: X11~~ :~ ~J.I X11~ Af~OI JIIJ:H~CI.
AI~ 018~ ~e:J 'PRODUCT OF KOREA(et:;;;OJIJ..-l ~W)'ci.::L! fDI ~EI31
Ol2ll 'PRODUCTOFJAPAN(\il.!!OliJ..-l ~!J&)'OI 'r.eJCI. ~8 l::f!~Oll ~EI31
Jl ~OI~.::L! et~ '~J.I(~&XI:et;;, Xle:J&)'OI2-I.::L! Dm ~Cf. ~ ~!&
~ et:;;;&~ ~AI~ {g!OICI.
JIIAI~~ ~-2Jet liiEiee AI~J2f grJJII "OI;;Oll ~e H martOliJ..-l ~gJeJ- ~W
ciOl "~EI31JI ~Ol~Ol :::r~ [JI'r.LI \il.!!OIIJ..-1 Q!l& J:ii~Oici.::L! ~01 ~C-l
cl"e:JJ..-l "~!O!IJ..-l gg ~J.I2-I.::L! ole! ~Ails [H~Oll ~ciXI .'~ ~ ~01 et
~H012.1.::L! ~Ole
3:!
OILI~~Lt".:il ~CI.
http://www.newskann.com/bbs/board.php?bo_table=news&wr_id=4886&page=1
'UIOII
llflt!2.1C1@
~l2!~ 21AI~~
m2.1&~J:J 5~ ~E!
..
e!JI20t
*e.!
iY~ ...
< ...
nx1
~ ...
[.!f
~~J
2014-11-07
Page 2 of2
~~~
'?i
~LH.i-i.'i: ~Jf
~eJ~~ *H~Oil
(]e!-
LfJ,-J
BE:! ~lf!E 3~Ei 5:! ~'2.!- 9&~ ~-&XI H.i-1011 CHek ~~ 8~~ ~AI
ofJI ~Cf. 8~ CH~g ~!E-& 9-&~~ .~oH e ::l::JJ'i!'!EJl~Ol ~ 'i!'!~
Xil-*~ 9-&~Jl.f 'ili1:X:Ii'iHJI J.il.s ~ t!~~ 9-&~0ICf. <AIQ!==;e.t~!i!>
LIST
PAE\.IOUS
. ~
iiiiiiBL.
NEXT
Copyright
2014-11-07
EXHIBIT 6
12/3/2014
}j
Si
Industry
IT/Science
Stock Market
! URL j;[OI/1
.'
~.
"".
Special series
[:;:;\{;;~]
I [@:ii dictionary
(8)
t!J
Sept 16,2013
2014-12-04
Market Data
K05DAQ
549.23
KOSPI
1,982.00
09:3171~
Exchange Rate
1,115.00
Bilingual Column
rmro
Despite being the nation nearest to Japan, Korea remained relatively calm after the March
2011 disaster at the Fukushima Daiichi nuclear plant.
But more than two years after the nuclear plant's meltdown, the fear of radiation has
increased in Korea after a series of revelations about contaminated water flowing into the
Pacific.
JH!1~Xf.Cll~e!'"C"!IQI 4000!~"JJfXI!!
The Korean government is trying to say that consumer anxiety over the safety of Japanese
products in particular is being whipped up by irresponsible postings on the Internet and
through social network services.
Prime Minister Chung Hong-won even said he would direct severe punishment at people
who spread unfounded, radiation-related rumors.
<Stg31. 6-151-jl
"'?-~" ~QI
2.1XI 011-jiR
But fear continued to rise and fish consumption fell regardless of where the fish came from,
affecting local fishermen and fish retailers. As a result, the Korean government decided on
Sept. 6 to ban fish imports from eight prefectures surrounding the crippled Fukushima
Daiichi nuclear complex to calm people down.
Korea had banned 26 agricultural products from 13 prefectures, but the import of fish
products was relatively unaffected, according to the Ministry of Food and Drug Safety.
Editorials
Grimy appointments
1/6
12/3/2014
JlJ1:::711!1liW>!I tJ3f.liiE.!
INSIDE K-Wave
2014's top pitchwoman is
Jun Ji-hyun
The most popular TV model of the
year is actress Jun Ji-hyun...
My App Series
1200+ Financial Terms HD
This elaborate glossary is useful
for people ...
=
r~..
~
Opinet'
..
'
Business
Opinion
Culture
216
12/3/2014
China, Taiwan, Russia, Hong Kong, the U.S. and the EU immediately took actions such as
banning imports of food from Japan after the disaster and conducting radiation tests.
Korean consumers also distrusted local fish retailers, thinking they may lie about the origin
of their products.
The government came up with measures to punish retailers who lied about the origin of
their products with up to seven years in prison and fines of up to 100 million won.
Delayed measures
But the measures came out nearly two-and-a-half years after the radiation leak began in
2011.
"As the tainted water is spread over the ocean, we cannot rule out radioactive materials in
fish from outside the eight prefectures, especially those from Hokkaido and Tokyo/' said
Kim Ik-joong, a microbiology professor at Dongguk University.
China imposed an import ban on May 25, 2011. Taiwan imposed an import ban on
Japanese food products on April 28, 2011.
"The allegations of highly toxic radioactive water leaking into the ocean were raised long
ago/' said a spokesperson for local discount chain Lotte Mart. "The slump in demand for
fish products is not improving. The idea that Japanese fish products are dangerous to eat is
too entrenched."
3/6
12/3/2014
In the U.S., some nuclear experts say radiation tests on all seafood from the Pacific must
be conducted, as contaminated air, rainfall and even radioactive debris from Japan have
been drifting toward the U.S. West Coast since the March 2011 disaster.
MSN News quoted Atjun Makhijani, president of the Institute for Energy and Environmental
Research, as saying, "We still don't know how contaminated the water is, and some
sampling of U.S. West Coast waters would be useful, as well as making the sampling of
some fish public. I definitely would recommend that the FDA and EPA increase their
vigilance in terms of the monitoring of food."
Ken Buesseler, a senior scientist at the Woods Hole Oceanographic Institute near Boston,
Massachusetts told ABC Radio Australia that a nuclear material from Fukushima will
continue to reach the U.S. West Coast for years as radioactive water never stopped flowing
into the ocean.
The U.S. Food and Drug Administration in 2011 banned imports of Japanese dairy products,
vegetables and fruits due to concerns over radioactive contamination.
In February, it said it would halt imports of dairy products and produce from the affected
areas of Japan.
Broccoli was added to a list of contaminated vegetables and seafood was to be screened
for radiation.
"China is banning imports of Japanese food products from 10 prefectures," said a
spokesman for Korea's Ministry of Food and Drug Safety, "and Hong Kong and Taiwan are
banning food imports produced in five prefectures. Russia is banning imports from 242
fishery processing companies in eight prefectures of Japan."
According to Hong Kong's South China Morning Post, about 600 Japanese restaurants in
Hong Kong saw sales plunge and many hotels and upscale restaurants have stopped
serving raw fish.
Singapore has banned imports of fish products from Fukushima while requiring certification
by the Japanese government that no radioactive materials were found in fish products
caught in areas around Tochigi, Gunma, Ibaraki, Kanagawa, Chiba and Saitama
prefectures.
India decided in 2011 it would ban imports of Japanese food until there was reliable data
on the level of radiation, according to the Korean government-run Food Safety Information
Service under the Ministry of Agriculture and Food and Rural Affairs. The Indian Food
Safety and Standards Authority reviewed radiation tests every week since 2011. In April
2013 it loosened some import bans.
In 2011, the executive board of the European Union advised its 27 member countries to
test all Japanese food products for radiation.
The EU has conducted tests on food and animal feed imported from Japan since the
disaster. Italy was the first country in the EU to suspend imports of Japanese food.
The EU is now banning all food products from Fukushima and is requiring radiation
inspection certificates for food products from areas near Fukushima. Like Korea and the
U.S., it is banning imports of fish from eight prefectures. Its radiation limit is 100
becquerels per kilogram.
http://koreajoongangdaily.joins.com/news/article/article.aspx?aid=2977639
4/6
12/3/2014
A study by one of the wend's leading institutes in the field of marine sciences, the GEOMAR Helmholtz Centre
for Ocean Research based in Germany, shows the spread of contaminated Fukushima waters. The first picture
shows the spread of contaminated waters 16 months after the accident at the nuclear plant, the second shows
30 months after the accident and the last illustrates 80 months after. As a result of the Fukushima catastrophe,
scientists suggest that Fukushima radiation could reach the U.S. West Coast in five years. Provided by GEOMAR
Helmholtz Centre for Ocean Research Kiel
No precise countermeasures
The Japanese government announced a comprehensive plan to create frozen barrier walls
around the Fukushima nuclear plant by investing 47 billion yen on September 4.
Whether the plan will work is not known.
"It is true that about 70 percent of Japan's territory is polluted," said Kim Ik-joong,
microbiology professor at Dongguk University. "According to PNAS, a scientific journal
published by Japanese scholars, about 20 percent of Japanese land, including Tokyo, is
contaminated with highly toxic radiation. It is obvious that agricultural products are also
contaminated as the land is polluted with radioactive materials. The contamination on land
will last approximately 300 years."
BY KIM JUNG-YOON [kjy@joongang.co.kr]
J-Hot Click
Blue House reels over aide charge
Pyongyang purges more Jang Song-thaek loyalists
Business hotels are becoming more refined
Seoul calls off human rights charter
SK Internet down after cyberattack
http://koreajoongangdai ly .joi ns.com/news/article/articl e.aspx?aid= 2977639
5/6
12/3/2014
................. ,,.....
Tweet~~ 34
Rer.omnsend <
~dictionary
URL ~OJ71
(2J
t!J
Contact Us
Advertising
Terms of Use
FAQ
Q&A
Copyright Policy
Privacy Policy
All materials contained on this site are protected by Korean copyright law and may not be reproduced,
distributed, transmitted, displayed, published or broadcast without the prior consent of Joins.com
[Policy on the use of contents)
6/6
EXHIBIT 7
4r~OI
~01.,/Af~/~;i:l
173.-.48.107
Aii->!:2:~Af ~5!./0H.!i:
HDf~
9-.S::,
9- cJ1'8(1'2.!-
Heartwarming
%[-\T~t:l=OI\'.!:2:
?B
71Xf] <8~>
2:2:1 ~.S:. oij
"'il-'i'-tr 4-tr~~
~~~~~(7~.::il)-?-
s~e Ojl~).-"'
:itililof:il15~
2.'
.fr~
AI,
t:i-jA[l-JoH~AH
.!r_~{l. A~i{
7f~';;j
~Oj
.C.
)i;:Y\!J.S>.I
'2PII.
OIOPI
'S TIIoH7f ~Zfafoj B~~"l \!,'Af~ 2.'EJ7f~{;JOII .'I:~~ B~tf Htr~~ Af>OI.S:: ~cH "1"1
9-1-ll- Et-'i'~Cf. HDf"'e B~ Afllol .s>.lf"!"ll ~'H7f -"JXI p,txf 'lli"'flil t'!i'!~ ~!of ~;;.tOll AfAi ol
-'/' %~0117il :il7f1 7f2!0il flDijofE ?;!~ Dl-'/' 'S-li- 'i'Ei7il ofe ~OIDj HDf~7f 'S~Zf~ ~:2:.5:: of
Oil
.'I:~-"1-i=
~xfoj
A[ Pl.:i!
31,:1
Ol'011-\= ~.g:i!f 7f'& 7f}}f~ B~~fcf(%aH, AiOH, 'EtoH)S'.'EJ:i!f ~B O<l"i}}fXI ;tCJISOIJ2 2-IAiof ~J;i:f7f ~
.S::}}fO<I.IijAie ?;!OI \!,'Af~ S'.'El1 'i'Ai~ ~~OICf. B ~~7f0il lLfE.f"! 10\1 ' ~g >gAf~ 'r~!Ec ~oij
H'1~~ ~71-\= ~Zf{;J~ XI"J~Cf. "'!cOil '!!!~1'-lof Xl"iOIIAi ''i'Aiof \!fAf~OII S'.'El~ 'i'Li7f ~""'~
~~Aij.7~ ~.2o~ %2B gc ~~~.7~ Oi.=:. ~OIIA1 ~~IB ~<rjX] .E.X[~. ~-A[o~ ~A~.g~~O] ~!fl Q:jOJ
A~~- ~%H ~T~ ~ 1 eJ- km~ 0/~8 ~o]q_ iT~OII A~~ B~ ~ A'-I~ "~:,1-!fiDll ~2-R! {11{::! :1!~21
~OJI
~~~.7~"-!- ]~0~.:1! "Ho~.C :!!~~ ~~~zt-6- o~~AI. ~.:1! 9::10iO~ o~.::.q".7~ ~_I<(::!OJ2.~2 ~~~cL
'Sports
~g7f7f cH!J;~
-\= cjAIOf
''i'Aiof
~~
~~ ~:itilii-
tis tory>
1 !!:~
2014-10-16 pm 7:55:00
108.~~.126.233
'--~>
:::l~.S::
~IAfOIIAi
life '21%
ez!
A~~Jll ~goj~. ..
~{j~ i'!!i'J~7-B!11i.?
*** !UH,'@
2014-10-16 pm 8:39:00
104.~-.160.90
'-t-
69.--.2.19
@of@\:JAI.s>.l 'cf!j'{!l~
@ Love and the City
2 ***I])@])
2014-10-16 pm 7:56:00
172.--.121.178
Hello, Stranger!
~~~1 t1e!
!!:~
2014-10-16 pm 8:01:00
173.--.135.92
@.'I:.~\!1 4-~H2f:<H:I
@~Of.S>.I
!!:~
2014-10-16 pm 7:56:00
108.--.126.233
i'tfi.
Oil'i' .. ::I"i'-lnf
Af*Cfi'lof.
91l=Cfe oloPI'i:!Cil.
:::1
Pt~
S'.'El1"1
OIOPI
*** (1!1@])
0 Rainsonata Diary
0 Gratitude Living
2014-10-16 pm 8:01:00
96.--.216.53
@7ful.s>.f<:'l~
0\lJ-'=.OIIC!I~'T-Cf
@@])
..,
'g~AI.S:.
~~{:!.7~?
--i5H
o~:&.7~;q~.(j.J~?
.g-f.j
'rJ"?!!,!A[I2.!-.TT
q 5HA-i.
@])
***liiH}]
.:i!Oi.C ~~i5H.7~ oH:.! ZS~[Oit:l- OI~J!IL9. ~e!Cil ~AI~ ~lf-~ Oi~T ~01 ~.CC-tl
~~~'-ICf. ~"51.
XIE\' cjJg
*** Wl@])
108.--.126.233
'iT~
'bl.
?:1011 oH!i!.'-1. \!{Af~ ?JAfl= Cf
*** Wl G)
2014-10-16 pm 8:-16:00
50.--.147.51
***WiG
"5fL..f~f2.(~ofL..f
.g-c5j.C
Photos
~Home Decor
~Yummy Photo
~Silly Pets
~Art & Craft
!& Travel Gallery
AijCij.
2014-ID-16 pm 8:33:00
~Kids Photo
::E[.:-i5H.~
2014HH6 pm 8:0<:00
108.--.126.233
2014-10-16 pm 8:25:00
108r.48.132
IIJ~O\I~.s>.l ~71
~My Garden
A~.S:. ~Ei5H.2..
2014-ID-16 pm 8:06:00
100.--.102.116
0~.::;'=.2.1 ~~X.
2tt!El,
Ail?t!- BHtl~OI 2~S!q.::t:!. 1~0[ :vqe1, A15H ~ ~12.1Ole! A~e! ~z.t"O[ ~Ci-2'. B~ A~~~-- Oi't!~ Q:jAI?
2-!Aiof '<J'2.J-OI
~f
~Oi ~--
f:l A~~
''i'A1Df!Ec
iY-.C
O~.CX ..
~2.f7fl= ~~
~~o~q.:il
O[e!:z:!
O~O!I ~2.[AI.S:.
at.::il,
5l.
~'S
\'J?:/01 3.J22.. Aj
run.
A~Ef~-- ~?!!,!A[I2}
2014-ID-16 pm 9:0<:00
99.--.244.105
OI~~OI
7i1
~oj 2!1lt~l'-lnf
{:!!7[.C/-f.fi.
SO'EI
Al
***I])@])
20H-1G-16 pm 9:22:00
108.--.126.233
O<lil< :::1~ 'EJcjii- :'JOI "5fAI-\=Cil Ojlii- ~Oj JOjft~ ?:!'i'Oile 2.~ ~l'i'lofl= Oj%.2.Ai Xf71
7f EijOje :JC2.!Ec tf~ofci %'-ICf. :::l~Aj 'i'~IL..f2f '<JOje cjAiof Af~EJ O<l'i'-li- 7itjAj ~
Eijj!j~ llll~"ll-li- 7itj CfAI 'i'2IL..f2f ~012.71 ITII~Oil ~g '1'\'1~ 7ii;J 'EJ2.Pf 'ili:il2.. :F.
XI~ 9~0l~ C:.C 9l'ii"9AI P.J-~I....l7H? .::.91;:!;"9~ 7.-.P:;:: Q.}?.UA::;r~ NOI2~F7~ t..,-2$JIOI NOI71
<J.iEL-!q_
ot
~~~E
.2..5:. gJ,Et-ICL
2.'512~ ~~-e- ~A~.SOII CH~ ~z.t-~Oili-O~A-j ~NE ~A~ q OH. (~-E 0~~ qA-j ~EI-~
~.ttoJ ~.Eo~-c-AI gJ-@- =? ~=-q-cq~~.x-u TT) cc-11 oJ~~ tgA~EOJI CHoH ~-i>:l o~
*** Ul
2014-10-16 pm 10:03:00
70.-.212.205
-'?-
~ztoJ
2~
\lifilof.
3 ***(ill 1\B
2014-10..16 pm 7:56:00
66.--.19.53
4 ***(ill)
2014-lQ-16 pm 7:57:00
98.--.154.181
***(ill)
201410-16 pm 7:58:00
178r.124,9
*** 1\B
2014-10-16 pm 8:10:00
61.-.219.99
.'Pil-E
Sl".fl.
(ill
2014-10-16 pm 8:47:00
so.-.147 .s1
2014-HHG pm 9:56:00
76.-.13.216
5 ***
2014-IQ-16 pm 8:00:00
108.--.126.233
U:f-2
~Af711
1C1
2f-T.
~71[ ~tj 0[~71
Cf
.:;>:_~oHAi
"*ill) !\B
2014-10-16 pm 8:02:00
82.--.235.206
6 (ill@
2014-10-16 pm 8:02:00
68.--.189.150
*** illl!\B
2014-10-16 pm 8:08:00
so.-.194.50
***
2014-10-16 pm 8:11:00
108.--.126.233
2014-10-16 pm 8:34:00
67.-.134.227
{!! ::::>!7[-2
2-Cil .:J.~~j:;~
;<j.S: OJ 'OJ -l'
~o~~~
lEA[
oH~:i!
Jl!:C12f'j'-
*gJ~Oi
~:1.!0i.
7 ***
2014-10-16 pm 8:04:00
173.-.61.42
c.,
*** fm 6]
2014-HH6 pm 9:46:00
23.-.128.117
8 ***(ill)
2014-10-16 pm 8:09:00
7Sr.236.9
9 *** @)
2014-1016 pm 8:09:00
100.--.128.129
~fef-10-
Cf
2.'i"[A[7j~:i! .. O[EJCj
2JI
~Xi[Af:lt[OIJAi
~~~C-jl_
10 ***(ill@
2014-10-16 pm 8:11:00
108.--.91,81
c.,
Q:jXf
*~ ~?:.!~
*** ffil
2014-lCHGprn 8:42:00
76.-.252.127
AfJ!f
Mf~2.11Afef7f
4;'~
'!lief
'2!7i Afcf7f
Cf"i:l:lOi
'"IS:
~2f~I~OiC[:i!
1-c-
'--[AH1J[~Oil711
~~ePI-501 ~q ~t-Jq,
X~'!
Cf\'J~Pi
11 * * * ffil ll
2014-10-16 pm 8:12:00
67 r.222.152
12 *** ffil@J
2014-!Q-16 pm 8:14:00
69.--.29.230
\,}-
*** @)
2014-10-16 pm 8:17:00
108.--.126.233
*** (6)1)
2014-1Q-16 pm 8:20:00
173.~.163.53
***(ill 1\B
2014-10..16 pm 8:58:00
99.-.244.105
13
!111@1
201+10..16 pm 8:15:00
71..216.58
2H
%\:101"-f:i! ofCi"-f-T.
-'f-:gj:il
~:i! :::1~711
-T;';'-
2014-10.16 pm 8:20:00
106.--.69.42
***
mJ G
2014-10-16 pm 8:23:00
173.--.165.156
***@13
2014-10.16 pm 9:08:00
24..-.23.226
***
W!aJ
2014-10.16 pm 9:33:00
108.--.252.73
22222222
333333333333333333333333
4444444444
Xi]/~ -@7Je
*** @(l}
2014-IQ-16 pm 9:34:00
108.--.252.73
***Gil~
2014-10.16 pm 9:57:00
73.-.214.188
W!f:l
2014-1().16 pm 10:15:00
76.-.7.86
c.,
::IEJ
***('ill(
2014-10-16 pm 10:33:00
107.--.138.33
q
***
2014-10.16 pm 10:44:00
68.-.10.17
14 ***
W!f:l
2014-1(}.16 pm 8:15:00
24.--.20.68
15
~~OJ ~04~1C!JCiJ..
mJGj
W!f:l
2014-lD-16 pm 8:17:00
98.--.60.253
777
0]~~0] ~.PJ:~
!!!!!
~~rrHo~q ~.g~tHS?..
***~~
2014-1D-16 pm 8:29:00
71.--.160.199
;>;j.11. ...
-6H~~ ~o~o~~c.i] ~AI ~<5"~.:il .... Z:!?~~ ~.g
Ill) IZ2
2014-10-16 pm 9:09:00
74.--.66.150
16 ***
2222222222222222
mli!B
2014-10.16 pm 8:18:00
98.--.113.108
** WI lGl
2014-10-16 pm 8:23:00
173.--.165.156
2222222222222222222222222
:J.~
17 *** @@
2014-1Q-16 pm 8:22:00
173.-.146.154
18 @J!l!)
2014-1D-16 pm 8:23:00
173.--.32.47
19 @J!l!)
2014-10.16 pm 8:23:00
~A~
23.--.178.110
20
i:::j-XI
~71~ ~C/l
W!@J
2014-10.16 pm 8:24:00
71.--.221.196
2014-10.16 pm 9:23:00
2222222222222222
216.--.81.59
21 ***@G)
2014-10-16 pm 8:25:00
74.--.165.6
22
*** @@
2014-1(}.16 pm 8:26:00
24.--.170.51
OIIOI:<iof.OIIA1 \!] Oj<!j\!.J Afj!{~cjj g,f~ Cf ~oj~ojoj 8"8\!.l.S:: 8 t<fi..f.<>.l\!1.5': 'W~B711 \lJCj2.f"j'-h
)}f!lt..j))f Of gli!L.f!i ; Cf }}fOj/foj \!J)}f!l\"J 4<~ ~ojAj Aj7j'l;!2 - - A ::liTH~ {f;Oj ~%ofAj :::1'1!~
AjOt.:il E:f. A~IC:! gl-~ ~(}j~<.?f- Oi~7JJ :J.~~ ~tg!.JllltCXJ .... ~O{Ai l::lt.Jfl-2-f/~Aj ~Ot.:il
2014-10-16 pm 8:57:00
70.--.72.53
23
222222222222
'**@
24 *** @@
2014-lD-16 pm 8:29:00
98.--.156.25
*** @@j
2014-10.16 pm 8:51:00
108.--.14.177
26 '**@@
2014-1(}.16 pm 8:35:00
180.-.174.211
27 *** @@j
222
~2.1~ tHt!-~~
gx-JJ~
:o:j~ &'--1.2.~ ~712.1Lil2. ~ tJoH :>171 ~7fXI\!J 7fAj AfAI~ j!!l~j!!l 3'0-2) "5fAjo~ ~Oi2.
B.;:,tOliA-l 2.i
1~
1Ai <2!
25 *** @@
2014-1(}.16 pm 8:32:00
173.-.144.124
28 ***@ilB
20141016 pm 8:38:00
142.--.52.218
o1o1 >OI8
l{l!- o[o[
Cjl.\l..
7~01115'"'~ '@oHJII~Xief\'0
71}-f]f it: '>:lOll :'IJL11R. '"'EI hDf:OIIAi "!'\':! ~01 of'--12-f\'!1 ';';:1
01 - ~XJI~:r{ ~L-l!. o[M[.7~ hD~. .:1:~. ~.:il ~.C
29 *** (llj@)
201410-16 pm 8:'12:00
71.--.1.152
-~
*** (llj@)
2014-lD-16 pm 8:43:00
180.--.174.211
30 *** (ij)@}
XtS:. HD~.. ~lt riOiO~~Oi!! A~.C ~E-~ c~ ?j.:il ~2 1f1T -~~01 ~o~q o[~E}A[
201+1D-16 pm 8:44:00
72.--.80.36
Ci\:;JJII
-l:!.
:i!~~
~~2 ...
31 *** Gil
2014-lQ-16 pm 8:48:00
162.--.186.177
32 *** Gij@j
2014-!D-16 pm 9:02:00
162.-.196.210
efo~a .:L!TD~ <!~t!-.
33 *** Gil
201+1D-16 pm 9:05:00
67.-.37.222
34 ***Gil@
2014-10-16 pm 9:17:00
69.--.10.205
"1.\l.. cCil
35 ***Gil
2014-1017 am 6:52:00
68.--.174.211
36 ***Gil
2014-10-17 pm 7:25:00
24.--.121.229
OiUII??
'l:l~l't!OII AfAiQ:j~OjSl.
37 ***G\lfi!J
20141017 pm 7:28:00
24.--.121.229
L-ij@-:C~
lEJ"eJ-
A~~OIOll,.
38 ***@1
2014-10-18 pm 1:20:00
64.--.64.192
fi'l:l\'OCil &-ff,
DIE\ ~t!-~
*f'2jL-f?
s>.I~\:!~Oil:>il
f;!2jot X11
~t!
{!!~
'f-jj-}}fXI
o~ctL-1
Ol~7i
1-t=cil),
5!.2
~01 ~ ...
(1-80 I 80)
[ofXI"-f
~E.!- .fd~ ..
...
9!~~L-ief.]
ADD
..
~w: HO~E
WAt.
21fl~-:-i f~i;lOII
roH5H
o!TW~on
t:!JMP-11
wq
EXHIBIT 8
'~OI"if/Af~l/~ :<1
72.-.237.72
Aii-!.2:~Af ~.5!./0HS:.
http://www.newskann.com/bbs/board.php?bo_table=news&wr_id=4838
HD~~ 9-, .2.~01
gJ{J.S A-119-fl
Cfi'S
?~ %(-IT~t.J-;;0]~.:2: /[A~]
<8&>
Heartwarming
B~OIIAi.S:.
ej>:l :"Ji=
'i"ti~~OI
"'2j~
HDf.(t)of
gfi'f~(7fJl)
'1' 2:2:1
~5:. oij
'1' Cfl'8(1\15t:i{'i;
~1~).2. -?~%H
AI/::0~/0{IAiiOI
-EJ-oijoll
~!.l~I~X~1 ~~7~~ ~g
tt
711Li]CI
f>.J'.C
'2jojl
~.!f.~fCf9.1
'i1J"Af{;J
i= ~:::0"-171 %-'lAf:O:Ilfi>:IJl
~c~.
tgA~~
27
tiijt}~E ~]j[1121
5tJ .qr_
2{0~0~ E!-,!~1
Ap::[
~Cll
Q:tAI
Humor/Game
%~~2{~ ~~ C>~;;q
f>.t:il -*2PJSB
::0~
ojf'
%:>!:~
-'f-Ei:>il of-<=
7f]Jf-11:
B~~fCf(%oH,
~B
AioH, hloH)2.'1lJ!f
>:IQ17Jf>:l
~Cfi1Jl
Missy WYiter
Lf~o~ 1 .SMI
ofgof
<zJtH
of
>:i"1011Ai ''1'-AIDf 'i1)-Af~OII 2.'13@ .!j'Li7f ~'" :2:fXil7f 'B!.'?.Dj %.<?.B ~~ H*l7f oj!::. ;;;tOIIAi ~<j;IB '3;!
\'J>:I 2...>:1'2}, .!j''!'AIDf
fD Hello, Stranger!
0%;g~1 ~iC!"
i=r-&011
@.'r.~~ ?xH~f:>:i~
A~~
B<zJ {;!
4- 1 '2.!-
'E:!:il
@<aof1 OIOPI
B 1:Jl?7f7f cH~~
''1'-AIDf ~{;j Af]l Ol.!j' Algo1IOI{'!OIIE ofl..f
}}f>:l 'i1J"Af~OII 2.'13@
OJ Rainsonata Diary
@Gratitude Living
I] 7j lil2f 'i'l ~
S:.2jcij]l
~]l
~fCf
@ Jane1
~~ ~>11~
@7fi!ll .\'IDIO!I..
@j;12.lof1 a~~ Dl"'~
@gc.lj6J21 ~PI
1 *** !JlHiiJ
2014-1D-16 pm 11:06:00
70.--.38.109
.!fJOll
Al ~~Ell~-2- EO{~L-I ... IQ'O~L-j ~t!-XIJ~ ... AHJt!! .... tj~ !f~tg!51;'1'2! .... q-t:J ~A~2.
2014-!Q-16 pm lUSoOO
12.--.113.38
Photos
My Garden
Kids Photo
Home Decor
2014-1D-16 pm 11:27:00
108.--.32.23
$Yummy Photo
silly Pets
Art & Craft
!&Travel Gallery
Ul
=M.:L!
A~l?t!
oi~~~Ai of9j~7il
.:gt-0{.
~<5HA1
O{hliq
:O:I2f. .. lTlT
2014-1D-17 am 1:05:00
99.-.164.80
5 *** @fl]
2014-HJ-16 pm 11:45:00
180.--.134.163
of\:J7f ~2f.
o *** WH3
2014-10-16 pm 11:46:00
69.--.130.241
7 @@
2014-10-16 pm 11:47:00
174.-.198.3
OIIAi.S: Xii-';'.S:JfAj
i:'Cil Ol 71Af
"Xil'l'~fCf~
Ol~-o-f;<ol
tlfL.f?
hl<H
8 *** @@
2014-10-16 pm 11:48:00
23.--.94.211
~011.
-\'IAIOI/
'i!l
@(9
2014-10-17 am 5:16:00
74.--.165.6
2222222222
*** f.W~
2014-10-17 am 5:28:00
184.--.50.202
444444
t_l- 5E cgJ~t.J-~
*** @(9
2014-10-17 am 5:53:00
115.--.122.79
~ ~21'LJIR .
<...
*** @8
201'1-10-17 am 7:29:00
55555555555555
73.--.214.188
.gm
*** (ttlllt]
2014-10-17 am 7:41:00
69.--.130.241
***@ Wl
2014-10-17 am 8:0<1:00
67.--.104.11
Xil-';'tl-OI"-f e_f~-o-fcf~{:j
~7f"-l:i! ofOili.
~fefOII El ::tOj'J;:i! ef'i!!l :<fOIC.f.S: Xil-'1'~011 7f}}f~
~OIIAi ~~]{:!
Xil'l'tJ-,
~l;'~OIIAi
7f@lll
i')~{:! ~J;<tfOIL-IlJf.
6666666666666666666666666
71Af7f j!j Ol~i<fli? HOf~ iiHtJ-~OIIAi \lJ"Af~OI fj1i!;~Cf .. 'i'< OlE! <;!.S: ofL-1:<! ... ::t\3' Xil-';'
\'.!i:'OIIAi i')~ oHtJ-~~ 9\1J;.>ief~ lJCll. ::t!l!lll rtfXI:<f\:1 oHtJ-~ :<If~ .2.- of~7f Cf ~Xil
~~
7-fn..
9 *** @8
2014-10-16 pm 11:52:00
104.--.202.136
..
*** @ll1!
2014-10-17 am 12:55:00
50.--.252.191
***
t:rom
2014-10-17 am 3:21:00
72.--.220.67
222222222222222 g!OI
33333333333
~ :<!71 ~C!I
lli~Oi.
e_f~.
10 *** @@
2014-10-16 pm 11:56:00
66.--.173.72
11 *** @l!il
2014-10-17 am 12:06:00
76.--.11.112
OiCIAl
12 @l!il
2014-10-17 am 12:41:00
.:J.2.[.:il OfXif hD~..Oll tgA~-6- =f:Xj Xi[~ 717:117~ ~DiAl .}-{JO~.:il A~~.2.2~.:il Jkj~e:!C~I .:J.E;l .:J.(:! ~7~.2.?
24.--.213.24
c~.::::
*** @fl'j
2014-10-17 am
3:14:00
108.--.186.169
*** tUHLl
2014-1017 am 4:44:00
72.--.220.67
*** @ll1!
2014-10-17 am 7:52:00
50.--.164.251
13 ...
2014-10-17 am 2:51:00
96.--.119.196
14
!IDGJ
2014-10-17 am 3:53:00
96.--.146.176
15@el
2014-10-17 am 4:36:00
173.--.211.197
16 liD
2014-10-17 am 4:41:00
70.--.129.54
H mart e!
Wl
201410-17 am 5:20:00
98.--.119.150
::t!j!~Oj?
17
201410-17 am 5:37:00
99.--.100.138
\li~
."''-'1!!.=.7f
~Oj2f~:i!.
~OH.S:.
1s ...
2014~1G-17
uHa
am
7:08:00
184.--.208.150
TiC! H
"W
.'c2.IE7j'i'-L.f
LiLji~OI..2\'!J 'f-~?:!
19 (i!)@
2014-lD-17 am 7:23:00
172.--.104.31
o<H
20 (i!)@
66.--.65.72
21 (i!) I);)
2014-lQ-17 am 9:12:00
66.--.65.72
~
~cH
f::OH.!J!r otL-J
~8~.
.?.~ ~ztotr
-T-7~ q
2[q1 \itr
9:1rc~.:L!.
't.Fl.!~OI
.!:f.
2 BUY 1 GET 1 FREE?~~ -cl:P~l. . .AILi]Jt ~~B~'f.:il E:E 0[-.0t-c-l:!xf. ~ot ~~BUY 1 G
ET 1FREE? Otj! ot~-fE-~ITH U"?~ ~qJt .:J.'cJ= ~.f:!Oll qe7-! AtAt Ot.:il ~'tiqJt q ..!:f..:il }0J .. ot ..
Ol~
2014-!Q-17 am 9:04:00
ot<2J 8-lJ-
... ::r~
l:!
8{.)~
-0
2,';<j2.l 8Cil.
o~q~~ gt~2~ ~~
E;.;g:<IOII
Hf2SE 'ij{;'f:!OI!llOJ..
!EJ
2014-lD-17 am 11:04:00
76.--.8.30
22
IEJ
2014-10-17 pm 7:03:00
100.-.156.144
23 (i!) I);)
2014-10-18 am 7:43:00
108.--.123.18
7fA~~ A~AiJOJ ~e:f Oj~~ .E~~Oj ~LiJ.2.. ~A~.gOl[ .2.~S!q.C .!rl~~'2} ~E~ ~Of .:J.~q-c OH7J
~Oi.. 271.7~ g;t.2,t...J g{..!f. ~A] ~f!~. %1 t::!~qoJI ~A~-5 2~ 7~-5~01 .i1fAIC7-/] ~AI ... H
oJe.
Ej
'fJIE
~~~j!. 1::1~.52~ ~O~Ai II~C ~~OJOiJ. ~OJ AiEl ~tJ-ff. ... I!.~<l.ff ... .::i27[-ff ... o~~~O] Oj
it~
~~~-
Xl'bf
'e~OJ"-18
..
~~- o1~21
2-E
B8of'OJ!~~
Cf
~f[~ ~
ADD
(Ift)Ho~E
.&
,-:
,.
of2~jl:
T .2.?30!
HOf" 'bfAfE
<'!J: MissyUSA
9-I{:H~I
AiPTN
f-15
<5H~
9;Pll
&Oi
91'6 T%J ?f
"IHf;'il Wef
EXHIBIT 9
B!og
Gale
4r~O/
'~OI~/Af~/~:>:1
Ail-'g!:2:~Af
{!!')!! ~el
24.--.160.171
~!i'./Oij5'_
.!:t:;<3f-'f
[ -\T~'l}=OI\:1:2: 71Xf]
<8~> ~~OIIAi
QjXI
:'.1:-l::
HDf..(tit;f
><~i{!
'IJJE!
~-';')7f '1'~
~:lief.
HD~~.C
AiJ?tl
-6HM.
'frXiXI.
~iXI'-IofWAII
32[ tj'2r-E
9~"5t7]. Aif?9tl~
(i;'!!i2.1~1
~~
TI[LiJCJ
5t:!
nt~. ~~)11
of?;;!Cf.
16~ -\T~1!f
HDf..-l::
'"!"'~~::q] ~~7~~ ~g
ilft}tgj
"f'tf~~oj
~~;:f~(7f:il.)iEc '1' 2'"=1 ~ Dij'f' Cij~(1'2.!- 5t!~ Oil~) 9%l~H ~HOII ~OPfXf ~\:1"1{011 ~~~Oj
Heartwarming
=T=tl@--ar oJ-?
~..!:f.1::1~q2[ ~A~~
Ef%H
.2i
.. OPfXf 2\1't!
~'iiAI
7~-g.~o[Jti.:q B~ A~'Ef
&
~Cf.
ogj-Af~ .2.~ ~Htl~~ "llll1\"! 5\1 ~ 'O['i;!Oj Al~.%11 ~~~ gf, ~'!igj-, Zf% g)-011 .!:t::~1-l::% JII~!Pf ~
ZfCi}O:j e.!-~~21 ~At.g. .2.iJ~.g~OII z~. B~t!- aHt:t~- A~Af ~Cll ~AI ~A~o~ -?-21~ g-J:F.~q.
''2jOjl
HDf.-l::
Sports
4;'.<>1
~~~gt~
Sci\:!!
.5F&JlJ
~~gt~
~'.':!~~Of ~~Oil
7f~
%:Af;O:j7f
T]-~oijo~ ~Cf.
ogj-Af~Oj 'r~10i 3\1 Oj~OIIe ~g1!f 7f~ 7f]Jf.g ~~~fcf(%iiH. AiiiH. ~iiij).2.~1!f "'}~ Xl"i>lfXI ~Cij
j:il.
~jAjof ~:<f7f
\!.f]]fXIli!XI-l:: '3;!0j
'1!{Af~
.2.'i!J1
.!j'-Aj~ ~~O!Cf.
Music
Humor/Game
"'-12011
~2.1.!>!:'-IOf
.=. :3:-0JIAi
Xj"iOIIAi
~-?]~ ~<2JAJ
2..5.A]'2_1-,
'f-Lj7f
1~
;O:f>:ij7f !B(."'1
%~ g~ ~:>l7f
*T@
1.1-
Oi
km~ Oj~
~'3;!01Cf.
fr~0/1 A~-c- B~ .fj M[~
"6.J!"10ll
Missy Writer
~ 'tj.g7f7f Lij'~ ~'!iAiof ~'tj Af:il. Ol~ Alg2liOl{:JOII-l:: 'O'fl..f ~!tj ~ill~ E.~iLH:il. ~:il. .2.-l:: 2022
\1011-l:: ~iAiof '?[ ~fCf]]fXj ogj-Af~OII .2.~~ ~~ XiiAI;)!cf
@Df'Et""/AI1 \3"-'f-')!1~
@Love and the City
@Hello. Stranger!
~~~.2.] ~ret
@X.~~
.:T:XHP::iiE:!
@'2jof1 OIOPI
@ Rainsonata Diary
@Gratitude Living
@7iill2f ;;;~:;;;:
201+10-17 pm 7:22:00
173.--.125.67
Ull~
Cl
@~.'=.Oil C!IE!-"i"Cf
201+HH7 pm 7:25:00
24.-.25.42
..
~.:f=-21 {;~X..
"-+
***lm@
2014-10-17 pm 10:07:00
138.--.202.210
@7fitll :<floiOII..
@~011611 ~PI
Cl
2014-lD-17 pm 7:51:00
98.--.16.11
@ Ol-'f-~1 <;ijill'21! \3
***
2222
3333333333333
2 ~
2014-10-17 pm 7:25:00
162.-.254.32
Ull~
201+10-17 pm 7:25:00
99.--.201.145
iJ My Garden
.....
***
Ullli'!JI
201+1D-17 pm 7:27:00
71.-.190.88
&Kids Photo
&Home Decor
& Yummy Photo
Gsilly Pets
GArt & Craft
& Travel Gallery
***~
2014-10-17 pm 7:26:00
100.-.18.250
4
***~
2014-10-17 pm 9:00:00
104.--.160.90
5 ***Ullli'ill
1f1f1f
6 *'*Uil0
20141017 pm 7:28:00
76.--.36.11
7 Ui!O
2014-lD-17 pm 7:29:00
12.--.113.38
8 ***8
9 ***IillO
2014-1017 pm 7:31:00
166.-.246.89
~~~
*** t'ia~
10 *** il!lt:n
2014-10-17 pm 7:34:00
~~-ofcil-J ...
2014-lQ-17 pm 7:39:00
75.-.194.2
98.--.50.107
~'e!
.2.2.11~ ~ ~2
::::t>!Cil-J '14
~.2.-ofoj
oil:! .::1'3 x119 ~ er~t:t ?t:t-e- ::r:~erq~ 7JA~~c-tJ. . .:1~ xi(9t:t ?tt-e-~ B~Dll{::l ~~2 ~~2~
Ai EtofL-J ai~Ai 'l'gj~cfe {:!XI l"! op1~ O"f:i!Xf -ofe<:!xl %! OI"OIPf !7fLil.
HD~..~
XiJ-?tl-
!l!l8
11
~-txl.
iT& TI]L-{]C]
2014-lD-17 pm 7:48:00
75.--.182.59
tt
-NOi -52-1
~~~ ?~c5PJ~
E~<>ll ?0~01 ~ ~
~Xi]~
.:c!
Ail??
....... .
'6i0i.!i!OJ~C-jJ.
:1'3
::::t2.11Ai
{!J~OI
~~0
oP-1'2:1
E/of-E:of
-9-t:t~
"'~:<ll7f
\3"&01 E]-7fLil.
~i:.t~fi Af~Cfl':-
:J.Jl]
rn
.7~-g.~ol
20H-HH7 pm 7:53:00
74.-.238.176
o~L-19Je:!l:!7~.2.?
{:!Cil ...
Ef-"iiH
B~ A~WOI 11210~2 ~2.pq ?J-~ -9-t:t~~ oJ9 ~~OliJll E~B Xi17~ 2-1~
~oH~-E:Oil ~Oj7fXf1':- &:0::2.171 %.:ll:.Af:1ltJXI:il ~Cf.
Jtj:;q
ioj HDf..
op;s.
***wE)
'-t
2014-lQ-18 pm 12:05:00
23.--.94.211
12 IJ.ill\'il
2014-10-17 pm 7:48:00
72.--.229.60
13 ***
B~OIIAi Xil9-tf ruOiAi 'l';~Oi ... \1J"Af'5?:J~ofAI1':- 1"'~~ oHtf~ ofOjl E}E.AI1':-71'i' ... Xii'T' 7f\'i ~1':-71 Cf Xii'T' tfOI2 .2:>!!7fl-J Cf ~cHtf "OHtf~ %!'2.! ~'2!Cfl ... Xii'T'
~t!- 9-~~C~.:il ~2:t~~OJ2.~~ OliiH7~
<2}ll;JI.2. ...
~1
{!J7j
7l~ol1':-i!i .. ~\10I
XIL.-f
i;i~ ~E ~~
!lll ilJj
201410-17 pm 7:51:00
108.--.105.23
._
*** fm@
2014-lD-17 prn 7:55:00
108.--.31.5
......
*** ~
2014-10-17 pm 7:58:00
69.--.10.205
***@l
'--t
2014-lD-17 pm 8:13:00
73.-.88.116
::I.I3
5::::t0i
~OJ
~.2.119??
E:.Ai].2.--
*** t:n
2014-1()..17 pm 8:52:00
66.--.99.174
***liN
20lHCH7 pm 10:18:00
69.-.251.98
14
l!il
2014-lD-17 pm 7:56:00
182.--.58.92
15 *** ffillffi}
2014-!D-17 pm 7:57:00
182.--.58.92
B~0/1~ .:J.~ iiH0~ %~ ~Oll ~N.g.21i ~A~~ o~q.? ~:i!~1XI ~B~-~ i1117IO~XI?J.:i2 oJ~.2.
. 7fJ:j :cJCfl':-:c! XI ..
B~OiiAi
*** WH!l
'
2014-10-17 pm 8:24:00
108.--.126.233
16
2014-10-17 pm 8:06:00
71.--.92.41
17 ***
!llll!il
2014-HH? pm 8:07:00
69.--.170.86
<...
***~ill
2014~10-17 pm 8:23:00
75r.182.59
18 ***
qe
~'2.!- ~Xij~L~? ~
:In?
.:J.l:!Cil
Ail?
.:J.2.I.:i2
~OtJll ~Oi.
l!il
2014-10-17 pm 8:08:00
70.--.170.187
oj~.Q.~ .go~ ~~~~01 9-~~2~~
19
2014-!D-17 pm 8:14:00
71.--.234.29
~.q-t=-~- ~~ ~0:1
Ai 'EJAfoHAi m2'1B
B~E~ oJ~.2.EE
W.S:.
'l''.it't!DII
'EJAf~
mL-JCf.
~<:!EJ- Dl~.2. ~97f ~1':-Cil -hlof~e >Htf~~ ::::t~ 'l';~OjAj ~~OIIAi iill71
7t:;q~q.:il 7JA~~ ~~-A~ 7]Xt 4:01 ]-2:j~~EL-!q, :XiJ7t B~~
9-cg,JiiHA-i
-fjyq
'
GJ
'
eJ Ole!
***ill
~of%011Ai
OJ71Af2Af'if
201+10-17 pm 8:19:00
166.--.242.35
20
7]At7t t_hS:HOtqt-]JJt..
2014-10-17 pm 8:16:00
70.--.170.187
'f'tijo~g,f~Xil
Li.!:f-
liot.S:. .:Ct17-l
liB
2014-10-17 pm 8:29:00
24.--.17.28
~~ot.Jt e1~t[ Xi]?~
21 @!IT)
ct-E
2014-HH7 pm 8:39:00
72.--.220.193
Bef~C!>:J...?
....
*** (W@
2222222
201+HH7 pm 8:49:00
166.--.252.47
*** GD~
~71
Xii~Cf~/fl
'M
201<1-10-17 pm 9:32:00
71.-.240.212
fr&Oll
~e:!Cil. ..
B~o~...I.
II
if.~
AH-?t!-
HDt.I2J-
9-t!-~
~.Xi]Jt
jq.?
.r
'!OI E!11.>. ..
~i01.5".Ail.>..
::I!Cf~7fl
HDf.\:1
22 @!IT)
23
'**\lliili!l
2014-lD-17 pm 9:04:00
50.--.164.251
~.
Xil-';'tfOI
-l:!-01/..
.aj-~t"fefei
OIIOI"iDf.:>j
tfOI 2'EJE!1XI
***GJ
2014-10-18 am 10:37:00
172.--.31.57
~JSO':<I\:1 ~i",t!-Oit..f
OjEf
product of
~~t!-.5':
>l-1'5!01
~012~
~2.f~;>ftf.5!.Cf ~
Ail-?-
t..fof.>. ..
LiJ- ~OjAij~----
24@1!B
201<H0-17 pm 10:52:00
24.--.39.70
251!B
2014-10-17 pm 11:45:00
23.--.46.130
26 QJ
2014-10-20 am 5:36:00
211.-.128.137
q~ a~~7~~ ~5t~m.a
\:Iilii ~""
lTlT
\':!Xi
\\f{.j1~01.>.
H of.OIXI\:1. DI~LH of.OI71 ITII~OII '\"21 oi>AI~OI ol~ 'i'lE!OIIAi :g-o1~ ~~~7i2.f "f'i'J"tl {!j:z{t"f
~ ?;i.!f-Jf ~171 ITII~Oil OlE! 71Af7f ~Rilfef:V. ~<1~<-lef. HDf. ~OIIAi ~tfXI ~~<>I lEAl X!.'?.\!! %
27 ... @QJ
2014-lD-21
am 9:53:00
108.--.230.13
~EJL-jq,
OIJ!:f<-Jef.
.::ilot t:J8AI~ .X..E.~101 tfOj2.~ "5ij*.:iJ., Q{~ 7~~e1 @{:!-Aj _EA] ~10i ~~~.!f. '['.j
<!;~ 71~~2 ~~oHAi ~~OI2.f.'i:
~ei 1~
:>lit.
ADD
EXHIBIT 10
4i~OI
'~Oifl-/Af~lm=<l
Aii~.2:~Af ~.'i'./OH.S:
72.--.5.18
http://www. newskann. co m/bbs/board. php ?bo_table=news &wUd=4838 &sca=%8 8%E7%C8 %88
S Li.!f-'E.!-q.:il
Heartwarming
(Af:1] 'i!,!-Af~ 2~21~ ~~ ol~ E!'Oi ~{Oil
\t>!f: 14-10-1612:17
J: Oj~A~I:tfA~.9.j
,~; ~
2.1 ;g.1
~~7~~
ll~tf'g;j ~~
~~f~Vf:i!J-"'-
Q:lAJ
f4
5'1,q,
HD~.~
Entertainment
9- 2!l.l
Ail-9-tt
H \;{AI,
7-fiLiJCI
~Oi
-5-1
~'5~
TgJOPI
Aii-9-Ttt~
.g'5)fl
~~~j;:~~ D~~q.
'2JOjl
Life & Culture
HD~..-c-
16'lJ
fr-~1!~
fTA1Al,
1:11XJL-IoH~AI/ ~.%)--
oJ-?
oH~Oll ~~~H
-E!"oHOJI
o~ ~A~g A~.:il Oj~ ~AH A-jj2j5-I:I~C~~ ~IJ.. IOH ~~H. hl~H ~.!f.t:l~qEJ t;bi'At~ .2~ /~~{:;OJ ItJA1 "!"~ A~~
'Sports
OJ
2j'2j<5~.:il
~2.17~ ~..At:1
Music
\:!:tl-ll1121 51;:1 ~ ~~0] Al~11 .u~~ 'gf, ~!f.gf, z.t~ 'E!"Oll .J=.~1~ lLJ~H7t ~
AtAI5: ~CH Q:lXJ ~Ato~ 9-21~ a!".!f.~q.
Humor/Game
HDf.l:; E}~ Af'iIOJ 21\!J~ij ~OHJf SOJXJ pJXf :gjMf:>il ~'i:J~ 'E)-of ~i:(DJJ AfAj DJ"i' ~_:;t_DJJ:>il :i!Jfs>.J Jf;<j
OlJ -EJ-oH'O~~ ~-e. DJ9- %..~ !f.@J!I ot~ ~OJD1 HDt..7t ~..-g!Z{-e- ~.: <5~AJ ?J.:il -@219-.I~ ~At
~EI t:1j~8[~ E.2H:!! ~~gf~ ~.At:/7t Tt!E!~Ho~ ~ct.
\!J-Af~oJ 'r~XIOi 3\:'l oJ~OIIl:; ~g:cf Jf~ JfJJf~ B~"fef(~oH. Ai~H. 'cf~H)2~:Cf ~B XJ"iJJfXI
~7JfXJ
frjXJl:; ""OJ
:&J-C/1
Missy Writer
,;li::.'OIJ '!1!2.l_:;t_L-Iof XJ"iDiJAj ~9-AJDf \!J-Af~DIJ 2~~ 'f-LjJf ~~ :O:f<iJJf 'B(.2.Dj %RE! ~g '>f:i:IJf Oj
JE}O~E{G:j.Aj.QI 'i=J".gj~
=.
B""OJcf.
CD Hello,
3:0llA1
4--T-Afot
4 1 '2.!-
km~ Of~
Stranger!
@--~--.9-j ~~
IT~Oll At~ B~
@.'!:.~\>! 9-jH~f:<i'EJ
o~-c-xJ,
gJ.:il
.fd
MJ~
Q:lOjo~ <5~.=,q".7t
-e!':c!OJ2.t.:il
b"~%!c.t.
@'2jof1 OIOf71
B ~Hi'JfJf cij'Fg ~9-AIOf ~~ Af:il OJ~ AJg2lJOli:JDill:; "OfL-f ~~ ~;<JJ~ S21cH2 ~:il 21:; 2022
@ Rainsonata Diary
\10111:; 2-jAJof '1 "fefJJf>:J \!J-Af~Dil 2~~ ~'&~ <iJAmef.<Af~g JJAff tf:>jJJf ~i. grilsheloved
@Gratitude Living
tis tory>
@7jUis>.f -'?IR:
@~E.OII
Cjje:J-9-Cf
@Jane1
tJ'bf
fill L.f~
OiiAiiOI
~of7f-E oj'@
@OI.!f-e!1 aHUI\'!I'a
@)~~.Qj ~~~._
fill Of7f';J.'1
;;j-- Aj;<H
@:>filii 'i'IOIOII~
@~2-lof1
t]:gje:J-
!Il~C/I~1llPI
Photos
~My Garden
~Kids Photo
!& Home Decor
!&Yummy Photo
~Silly Pets
~Art &Craft
1$ Travel
Gallery
ol~~
1 (ill Gl
2014~10...18
pm 9:22:00
24.--.36.199
2 UilGl
2014-lG-18 pm 9:27:00
71.--.240.212
{l.j) Gl
2222222222
3333333333333
4444444444444
3 {l.j)@
2014-lQ-18 pm 9:29:00
96.-.33.223
tl:l
2222222222222222
2014-lD-18 pm 9:38:00
24.-.39.70
*'*@
2014-lQ-18 pm 9:48:00
208.-.170.36
;:>cjl Ol~<'>f:>il
;:r~:!7i ~:<i<'>l
:::Ol:JXI..
5 (ill tl:l
2014-lQ-18 pm 9:57:00
98.--.157.206
~ ~i!ll7lf:t~ op!oft!Jf1..
~. ~A~.S~Ai].C ~_g~ -?t!~ E:E.C ~2.~~7~'-~ oj~Ai.!f-ef t}1 {;JZ{~. ~1.7~
~~~l-j}}L O]:z:! q~ ~~~X4]~1 ~ot~~ ~EH~~Ci[.
OliO!<:!
6 *** Gl
2014-lD-18 pm 10:09:00
76.--.200.151
-?-t.2..
7 (ill Gl
2014-1018 pm 10:29:00
73.--.240.82
ol~oH1.. 27i.S: \li:i!, <il9-t! oHtf~~ q <gAf'50il ~~ ilPI~OI2f-E?:!7f. of'S Bof~OIIAi
B~OIIAi <gAf'54'*1 ~J!f~<'>f-Efi Bof~OiiAi Mf:>il ~ojfAi ii!.:'l~B'"I t:!-Cf-E<:!Jf .. <gAf'52.~s>.l~
01 71Af
8 {l.j)@]
2014-10-18 pm 11:43:00
70.--.170.187
9 (ill tl:l
201H0..19 am 4:15:00
96r.165.243
10
***
.:J.E:I
o]~ c~A]o~
riOi~n
i:'C11 2
l-'llt2.1'--l]]f ;:I'OJ<:!
~.CC~I, ...
(i!jl)]l
11
@]
2014-10.20 am 8:30:00
107.--.174.33
12
***Ell
2014-lD-21 pm 8:47:00
107.--.26.106
ADD
.A.'\!!;:/: ofE
"'of2J!;:1:
~{j
{)l{j ADf"EIOI"':i!~-ECil
MissyUSA
EXHIBIT 11
xoi-R/Af~m:i:l
72.--.210.10
1ot1912o14 <2o:17:59l!i:llrn
Ailil.g.Af ~.'Z./OHS::
Heartwarming
-"I~~
Xil'i'-ti
~"* ~~
'21711
i!!Oi
[ij\'} ?~%(71Af;;<:~)
-.!FOJJ
http:/ /www.newskann.com/bbs/board.php?bo_table=news&wr_id=4838
liD
rn
2014-lQ-19 pm 9:10:00
76.--.122.239
7]A~.7~
Q{Ej~O]Lfl. ...
B~OliA-ii
e:p;:Jfi.C Xil?tt
Oii.:t:!. :12llt:i-12.112:\
Oi:.P~~-c (:!AI. ..
2 ~IDrn
2014-1019 pm 11:36:00
96.--.254.106
Life & Culture
Sports
ADD
'Music
"" >...................................,
Humor/Game
l~. . !ilill
.4 ~i: t:lj2~0!~0l1Ai AH-O. 1::1~.:t:!. .u.~ Ao~efi!.N
.... 0~2J!": ~~ AQ~E~
Missy Writer
@ '210f.9.1 OIOPI
@ Rainsonata Diary
@ Gratitude Living
@31fiii.9.f '?I:
@~E.OII CIIE.f?cf
0Jane.9.1 ~y OIIAiiOI
@ L-f~ ~Of7f-i= Of@
@OI!HJ.9.1 ~"'1'2i!'a
~91 ~~z~
@ Df7f';!!.9.1 ~- AjJ;H
@?flill lfloiO!I..
@g2.lof.9.1 B~"E.f ol~tf
I~Hr211~.9.1 ~PI
~My Garden
~Kids Photo
~Home Decor
~Yummy Photo
~Silly Pets
~Art & Craft
~Travel Gallery
T2.1
ship
o~::c-!1. ..
EXHIBIT 12
~oll'l-/Af~mxl
Ajl-"l.2:NAf
{!! {!! ~ ll
142.-.38.103
~5'./0H.'r.
http://www .newskann.com/bbs/board.php?
bo_table=news&wr_id=4879&page=O&sca=&sfl=&stx=&sst=&sod=&spt=O&page=O
x:W'i'-
Heartwarming
Missy Writer
@L-f""'o~ 1 .5Ajl of of
@Oiijl~!<l Dl~oJI ~'"!
@of@'=JAI21
\3--'j'-{!j~
@Hello, Stranger!
-E~~Q]
\ti-iC!
@.'r.~\!1 ?~H~fxi'<:l
@?1lil2f
?I~
@~~Oil Cll~?cf
@L-f~ ~Of7f""'
@ol-'j'-~21'0Hlil'/!!'i1
0~99.1 ~~.I.
.:::I.2.12-i=
@>[211~21 -~171
J?..
X{@-11 ?gJB~
'atqCil-Je! OjXiJ.C
t:J.i-3!0/
~2 ~2.].Jl
13
~~~~ 7~W(?)Ail-?tfOJ)1L~
~My Garden
!&Kids Photo
~Home Decor
~Yummy Photo
~Silly Pets
~Art & Craft
a Travel Gallery
[-\T~Lf=OI'2J.. 7IA:f] -\T&OJIA-J 't-cJ-i5f-'c- .2. ~'2.] ~L-Jit.)~_g '-'?t.)-~ ~Af~ .2.
\?31~' .':I!..S:. \!.!-!;;!{~ 'fi~H t.:il-?.5:.~-'i~:PU ~7Ff ];;}:7-j ~ol~ LH%~ ~~cf. ~
7-j ~DI2.f-'c- ~_g ~if-~ ~l.::il -'?.'2.]Af7f g ~~ ~Zf1 ~~<S:j'2.] %f.::il 71Afcf.
~KJ~ru
K:o 0\i<J
Kl- UH:<"
~:;:ru"k
w1 ~oJ
oOI ~o
0-j r::< :<
-J
OIJ OjJ ~o
orJ6
-:;:-J u1ru oK
0'\'6'-=<"
IOI- i\0
Lf~<I:
~ 0 0
lol R'< LL
~..,.-~
o"-"'
oJIJ~
~u~~
oO 0~ Dim
KO~~J
li:l_rtr
JIJ E..:<
.,...,o_
Oil:( f'\
o _ OfJ
rulo oJ ru
o!f=1
f<~lll-
~~~ KJ ~IJ
5' 5J ~~
;jOt Olru ulu
oJDir ~J
U-j '6' ~ru
KI-KI-_
Wr-1 ol
o~o~~
R' OIJ !1..
Of Ulru-<
1lf<K0
j" O-j Kl-
Jlill~'R'
~oo
~~~
2l '6' ilio
K:ru ~o :< Lf
R'J 110 U-j 0~
JIJ Oir Kl- ~
Ef :OJ JIJ
nr u1ru u1ru
u-JJI=w~
])-j~
"'
K wJR'
rnlr:rwJ
K'f<UF
~5'U-j
~B'])-j
Wo-J3.ru .
Olilli'iJOKliJ
lll!J OF tr 15~
:DJ OIJ :< W1
wJDfJ~~O
tH lll!J Oi r-1
r::< orJ
OjJ~
'6' lll-
i\O
IiJ
z :jQJ i1r
-;rulru:<
tJ
I-:<"i\0
- i\Dj"
Ujo
Ojr ~
0\ ~J-
II
Jl: .J
~
r-1 iil~
u1ru '10 o
iiJDK'oJ
:< ~ru <lo......:
U-j '6' ( .it
~Diru
0~
Olillf<
i\1 OJ
;Kr i1r
"'
KI-WLL~
w.
~j"
RJU JIJ
iQ~o~--0
rn1~"' il:;J
DfJU
Oi~
;jl)=
i<J~
:::rulru
0=
:( ilu
R' loj
U!r ])-j
1-jO IIIII
lD U-j
~~;
OiiO
~ruu
~olru......:
-< Ciru ,;f
U-j
lo~
KI-~Ciru
l'for-J
' lll!J i1r
JIJoJ 0
_I DIJ :fl
~ rrr 10\
Gjp~
-a"""' ol
1'\ ,"' 'QJ
r=H urrr
UjOi\WwJ
-<-o
"'rl::J
WI <I
0 Jl:
0-j OIJ
R'J u1ru
iii [:j-j
~ Ujo
K-j OIJ
*'~
'6' <IOJ LiJ
;JJ =<~
golru
W10J:!J:'~ru
......:~r-1 <I
010~0
"0 LL \OJ nI
zJJIJLiJ~
r-1 ~
JIJ ~ 15~-<
~r.JOnn c?.
LJ lll!J-o
;;;:J~jKI- o
_ l l o1ru~
K ~J
.,..
o1ru,';'. ~"'
~,K:J ol W
uJ =J-tJ
:(1
.J 0\
r:j-j 'eS'oJ ~
Ujo DfJ "k-<
OIJ":("J'!;!~~
rl::J:(rua~J
<lrirR 0 ru
Jl: "k i\< JIJ
UIO
;jQ mru
~;jOt
or
j"
1-<~
ofJ JIJ
lll!J -<
0<
~O:jQJ
.::.= <1-
7\0 <-J
!::c."
()0~
~l()jru
~~
i";'i'J'
oHiJ
RKwJ
rul :(
ni-Lr
o1ru '6'
i]ruolr
r-1 Jl:
(ill :(ill
:(1:<
co r-J
6 ~~
~0 0
Kl-~
w.:.
*'<' (fj
-.J
E'W
'i:J-<[
w~<
'OJ~
~~~0
era t::t
"' LJ
co~
Kl-~
(')-~
W"Joo
~-j OF i\<
tr
-<
0<
o1ru '10
Di<
k
!SJ
OC'?
U-j
*<
0
U-j......:
D
:(1
w~
r-1
0~~
u1ru~
Oj
<I-
6olru
~00\
U-j~
Kl- .J
Ol
KI-Oi
WKJ
iQOVJ
WlrnjJ
tioru
_LJ
Oj :,=
<I- U-j
6])-j
:<'6'
r.ro {)0
:KO ;jO
iDi=i{O
~OjO
-01
0 -J
0\~
II
~OLf
(ill DfJ
:(1 Kiru
co OF
6<1-
~~
W;rt>J
'6' U-j
;Ko ])-j
oolru
.15~
U-j
:tl]]-j
~
OIJ _r:j
7\l_r:l_
~o
"'K:O
6:(ill
~O OfJ
U-j i'i'i'
Kl-6
Wu-J
==
K CJ
:jB"J ~J
~~~-~
r-r~
JIO~
~Dim!
.'6'
it
~-j C<O
~_r:J_u
0
Ol KIO '6'
i':< ~Oi<J
~..:x:
"' 0
~o
oim;
mru~~
nn~
"-~-<
~Kiru
~<1-
<-J 0\W
:<"J~
<I- \0
=
=IO
~6llil
iir.ro;jO\
~::!:!
LJ"J(~
o'6'~
lol-:::_
oiO
R'Jo-J
ii!Oilr~
Dim~......:
-u
~ 0.15~
WLrDI<
OfJ~k
KiiUKim~
:<"K
OF~~
i]O OIJ
<1-01 Kiru
wrc:-<
*<< JIJ
~0~
OF:r-1
oRFti
JIJ o1ru~
WOI!If\
OJ iiJ Dim
~6w
E'~lll~J~W
IiJ
~~~~
i\O~
{)OI~Ig
O-j njJW
i<J :( olru
Of'J c;r nro
])jJ I1 Oiru
(jill <-J iifJ
rulo ~o
o 001
oo
oimw <-J
=;= (5J 6
f< 111=
i<l u~o
KIOi'UJ u~
~r.rJ])-j
lijfu~
~:(I Ol
J -~,
f<OI
K
3ru KIO
OIJ iR' i<ll
ulru C<O rulru......:
Kl-i'fJ-.'t~
"'TO
KO\
~0 ~ ofJru
~~ ~o KIO Dim
cololorulru
6:F U-j t-\
~r-10'6'
~oolll-rzru
f<co~
jJ :(1 K-jJ
~I\
"'
LJ
\0
Q)
~c
o1ru 25
liD~
i]ru:;;:
r-1~
~K
u~
0~ -<.
-o~u
k15~
O-j~
6-<
u1ru ~
-01
0 -r<
Dim I'\
-;(J OjJ
<1-6
~ Ulill
Ol ~
~o ol
1-jO :j(;O
;::r 110
~j}"
~~
JIJ if
WI C<
o'6'
0-j DfJ
v lll!J
2014-11-01 pm 6:25:00
72.--.147.158
2 ** !lil ffi
2014-11-02 pm 12:52:00
98.--.66.217
3 ***
tll)GJ
2014-11..02 pm 2:30:00
100.-.59.119
4 ***!lilG:l
5 ***!lilGl
2014-11-02 pm 8:01:00
115.-.132.18
6 *** 1'.\ilGJ
2014-11-o:t am 5:51:00
D[gDII -"!.:>!:~~ *~of-<:; H mart~oH le%D[2-f.'C ... Xf2.fL.f-i:; ofo[~Dil:>il {;l~Ojof~x[ :i!\'.]D[Li[
~;
67..156.59
(1-6 I 6)
[DfXI"f :J!'~L-[Cf.ll~i
ADD
~-~- ~~
..&. ~I:
5' 0 %!
%!F~ 12..H-P,ilo
"": MissyUSA
EXHIBIT 13
12/3/2014
Asia Pacific
WORLD
AFRICA
HEALTH
U.S.
AMERICAS
ASIA PACIFIC
EUROPE
SPORTS
OPINION
MIDDLE EAST
MOST POPULAR
TWITTER
SEOUL, South Korea -The government of President Lee Myungbak sealed off major rallying points in central Seoul on Sunday after
hundreds of citizens and police officers were injured during a protest
against United States beef imports.
Police buses cordoned off plazas and intersections where large
crowds have gathered almost daily since early May to demand that
the government renegotiate the deal. Police officers blocked subway
entrances and alleys leading to those rallying points.
LINKEDIN
SIGN INTO EMAIL OR SAVE
THIS
PRINT
2.
REPRINTS
SHARE
Still, protesters broke into several groups of hundreds and marched Sunday evening,
engaging in sporadic shoving matches with the police.
Justice Minister Kim Kyung-han said in a statement on Sunday, "W.e will chase those
who instigate violent protests and those who use violence to the end and bring them to
justice."
Mr. Kim warned that the police would use liquid tear gas, which they have refrained from
using in the past decade. They commonly used liquid tear gas against antigovernment
demonstrators during the military dictatorships of the 1970s and '8os and against labor
activists of the 1990s.
The Korean Metal Workers' Union, which represents workers at 240 companies,
including the country's four major automakers, said 76 percent of its voting members
had agreed to a two-hour work stoppage on Wednesday to demand a new beef deal and
better working conditions.
TI1e Catholic Priests' Association for Justice, an influential religious group known for its
struggle against the dictatorships, said it would lead an outdoor Mass on Monday to lend
its moral support to the protesters.
A protest that began Saturday evening and continued until Sunday morning attracted
more than 18,ooo people, the largest crowd since a rally on June 10 brought together at
least wo,ooo people.
Police officials reported that 112 officers had been injured and 35 police vehicles had been
damaged. About so protesters were detained on charges of assaulting police officers, they
said.
Organizers of the protest said that 300 to 400 people had been hurt "because of police
brutality."
In April, South Korea agreed to lift the ban on American beef, first imposed in 2003 after
a case of mad cow disease was detected in the United States. Officials in Seoul persuaded
the United States this month to revise the terms of the April deal to placate the protesters.
But the protests continued, dashing Mr. Lee's hopes for an early end to what has become
the biggest political crisis of his four-month-old government.
More Articles in World
1/2
12/3/2014
Past Coverage
South Korea
Demonstrations and Riots
Mad Cow Disease (Bovine Spongiform
Encephalopathy)
Meat
Home
World
U.S.
N.Y. i Region
Add Alert
Add Alert
Add Alert
Add Alert
fulsiness
http://www.nytimes.com/2008/06/30/world/asia/30korea.html?fta=y
Sports
CorrectkJns
Opinion
RSS
Arts
1yJg
First Look
Travel
!:!Q!Q
Jobs
Contact Us
Work for Us
Back to Top
Site Map
212