Clyde Bennett II, the attorney for Judge Tracie Hunter in her criminal trials, has
subpoenaed 29 potential witnesses for Hunters June 1 trial.
The problem with the Bennetts subpoenas is they are made out for the potential witness to report to Judge Norbert Nadel in Room 560. Nadel was the judge for the first trial but retired at the end of 2014. The judge for the second trial is Patrick Dinkelacker. His courtroom will be 360. Most of those subpoenaed already testified at Hunters first trial last fall where she was convicted of using her position as a judge to get information on a teen inmate who was punched in the face by the judges brother a Juvenile Court worker fired for punching the teen inmate. Her brother, Steven Hunter, later used documents during a disciplinary hearing. Legally, he wasnt entitled to have some of the documents. That was information provided to Tracie Hunter in her capacity as a judge. Eight other charges against the judge forgery, tampering with evidence, theft in office and helping her brother get overtime were declared a mistrial and are scheduled to be retried at the June 1 trial. Subpoenaed were Hamilton County Prosecutor Joe Deters and Prosecutor employees Bill Breyer, Bill Ranaghan, Gwen Bender, Ron Springman, Katie Pridemore and James Harper; Juvenile Court Judge John Williams; Now-Judge Curt Kissinger (who was Juvenile Court Administrator at the time of the allegations and during Hunters first trial); her brother, Steven Hunter; her bailiff Avery Corbin (who didnt do well on the stand in the first trial); Public Defender Ray Faller; Juvenile Court workers Steve Rokich, Lisa Miller, Karen Oakley (Hunters staff lawyer when she was a judge but not currently a Juvenile Court worker), Wayne McFarland; Ray Beneker, Dwayne Bowman, Connie Murdock, Carla Guenthner and Brian Wolfe; and others -- Rachel Curran; Justin Kudela; Juliette Dame; Don Flischel from the company that provides software to Juvenile Court; Firooz Namei (one of Hunters court-appointed attorney in non-criminal issues as a judge); defense attorney Jay Clark, and; Harry Poltnick. Not subpoenaed was Janaya Trotter Bratton, a Hunter witness who testified in the first trial. She also was the attorney for Steven Hunter -- who handed the documents that resulted in Judge Hunters conviction to Bratton. She refused them, testifying during the trial it would have been "unethical" as an attorney to take them. Hunters conviction led to a six-month jail sentence. Because she appealed the sentence, the Ohio Supreme Court ruled Hunter didnt have to serve her sentence until the appeal is resolved.
United States v. Criden, Howard L., Jannotti, Harry P., Johanson, Louis C., Schwartz, George X., Jan Schaffer, A Witness in The Above-Referenced Proceeding, 633 F.2d 346, 3rd Cir. (1981)
United States Ex Rel. Charles Glinton, Relator-Appellant v. Wilfred L. Denno, Warden of Sing Sing Prison, and The People of The State of New York, 291 F.2d 541, 2d Cir. (1961)
Wesley Irven Jones, Jr. v. Jerry E. Richards, Sheriff of Burke County, N.C. Rufus L. Edmisten, Attorney General, State of North Carolina, 776 F.2d 1244, 4th Cir. (1985)
United States v. Mutulu Shakur, A/K/A "Doc", A/K/A "Jerel Wayne Williams", and Marilyn Jean Buck, A/K/A "Carol Durant", A/K/A "Nina Lewis", A/K/A "Diana Campbell", A/K/A "Norma Miller", 888 F.2d 234, 2d Cir. (1989)
Lisa Michelle Lambert v. Charlotte Blackwell (Administrator of The Edna Mahan Correctional Facility For Women) The Attorney General of The State of Pennsylvania, 387 F.3d 210, 3rd Cir. (2004)
United States of America Ex Rel. William Petersen, Relator-Appellant v. J. Edwin La Vallee, Warden, Clinton Prison, Dannemora, New York, 279 F.2d 396, 2d Cir. (1960)
Clayton Thomas v. Ben Varner The District Attorney of The County of Philadelphia The Attorney General of The State of Pennsylvania, 428 F.3d 491, 3rd Cir. (2005)