Professional Documents
Culture Documents
redefining
employability
BY ARVA SHIKARI
28
November 2011
www.humancapitalonline.com
H R R O U N D TA B L E
PROF. INDIRA PARIKH has done her M.Ed. (Rochester), and Ph.D. (Gujarat)
and is a retired IIMA Dean. Currently, she is the Founder President of Foundation
for Liberal And Management Education, Pune. She is the Founder Member of
Sumedhas: The Academy for Human Context. She is
on the Board of Indian Oil Corporation Limited and K. A. NARAYAN has done his post-graduation in Commerce, Law
several other organizational and academic boards.
and Personnel Management. He is an alumnus of Harvard
The current focus of work is on transformation of
Business School. He has over 27 years of experience in the field
organizations and corporate boards. Prof. Parikh has
of human resources. He is presently the President - Human
been a recipient of many awards.
Resources for Raymond Group. Prior to Raymond, he worked
with Wockhardt, Lupin Laboratories, Garware Group and the
Mafatlal Group. He has been a recipient of
several industry awards for outstanding
PRABIR JHA is presently the Senior Vice President and Head-HR at Tata
work in HR.
Motors. After almost 10 years in the Indian Civil Services handling the entire
gamut of HR & IR issues, on his switch to the corporate world, he has worked
in senior management positions for organizations like Thermax, TechMahindra,
and Dr. Reddy's. He has handled all areas in HR with special
interest in change management, OD interventions, global HR
MADHAVI LALL is currently the Regional Head Human
strategy, employer branding and leadership capability
Resources, India and South Asia, Standard Chartered Bank.
development. Prabir has consistently been featured in the "List
In her current role, Madhavi is responsible for developing and
of Most Powerful HR Professionals in India" and won several
executing people strategy for the bank. She leads the people
professional recognitions.
agenda within the region and ensures the delivery of strategy,
V. KRISHNAN is the Executive Vice President of Human
Resources at Dabur. He is a part of the team that leads Dabur's global human
resources with the responsibility for driving organizational development strategies that
support the company's global growth, talent management and total rewards for more
than 5,000 employees worldwide. He is currently responsible for the human resource
activities for sales and marketing of all domestic businesses i.e. FMCG, retail and
pharma, apart from anchoring key corporate HR initiatives, with the primary mandate
of talent acquisition, development and retention.
www.humancapitalonline.com
November 2011
29
H R R O U N D TA B L E
that point of time organizations
corporate tone. Franchisee
needed that kind of managers,
comfort in dealing with the
and that kind of b-school
candidate will eventually lead
graduates and management
him/her to interesting
education provided that. Today,
customer and trade insights.
the
whole
nature
of
After all, it's the customer and
organizations have changed
the trade that drives business
and also the environment.
planning.
Therefore, organizations are
PRABIR JHA: Creativity,
looking for b-school graduates
willingness to manage
who can take on the
ambiguity, excellent peer
responsibility immediately and
relationships, networking skills
not spend too much time in
and the ability to have a high
preparing them for induction
result bias are things that
into the world of work.
recruiters typically look for in
K. A. NARAYAN: Business
a fresh b-school graduate
schools are focussing on
these days. It is assumed that
building a powerhouse of
having survived two years at
managers who are equipped
a b-school would have
with functional knowledge.
imparted a base level of
While
knowledge
and
fundamental skills.
intellectual acumen have been
MADHAVI
LALL:
The
environment today in which
the single most important
the Indian business schools
criteria for ascertaining
operate in is in a state of flux.
employability of management
Dynamic changes brought
school candidates until the
PROF. INDIRA PARIKH
about
by
economic
recent past, the scenario today
30
November 2011
www.humancapitalonline.com
H R R O U N D TA B L E
the b-school graduates should be
able to develop a balance between
task and relationship at the
workplace. In a nutshell, they should
have a good balance between the
left and right brain.
32
November 2011
www.humancapitalonline.com
H R R O U N D TA B L E
etc., but, a lot more still needs to be
are realizing that values and attitude
MADHAVI LALL: Top b-schools are
done.
are integral to the management
more equipped in bridging the
learning process. However, they have
employability gap in the Indian
Do you see any skills gap that can
a long way to make it a key
scenario because of their strong
be taught / coached to improve
component of their syllabus.
industry-interface which ensures
employability levels of b-school
Premier business schools have a
their students get the right
grads? How?
brand premium, based on the
orientation to prepare them for the
PROF. INDIRA PARIKH: The most
learning model and content they
corporate world; the same cannot
important aspect is the attitude. If
have created over the years. This is
be said about most other b-schools
the attitudes are appropriate, then
a model tested for success in the
in India. Unfortunately, the lack of
the skills can be learnt very quickly.
industry interaction to groom future
past. There are other management
Basically, the business schools need
managers in b-schools has resulted
schools that have deviated from the
to prepare students for the realities
in candidates whose capabilities do
set model to incorporate some of
of work life and equip them with
not match the desirable capability
the factors deciding employability.
understanding of ways of relating and
level of a prospective employer. The
However, they are yet to show
working anchored in values of life
positive side to this is that there is an
results.
and work.
increasing level of awareness and bWhile business schools see an
K. A. NARAYAN: B-schools can
schools are now taking various steps
element of risk in imbibing this
in mitigating the employment gap.
increase employability levels of their
change, with corporates looking for
V. KRISHNAN: While the premier and
students by focusing on making them
managers who are personalities and
A-category b-schools are aware of
holistic managers. Students need to
not just functional experts, they are
this and have started working on the
be coached with real life scenarios
sure to adopt a learning model which
same, there are many others who
of how knowledge needs the strength
is beyond just imparting knowledge
still have a long way to go. In the
of right attitude and values to tide
soon.
recent past, there has been more
over challenges. This takes students
PRABIR JHA: In a talent-deficit
emphasis on industry interactions,
beyond their textbooks and helps
environment that India is, I honestly
live case studies, interaction with
them think on-ground and as
think employment is not a worry.
senior professionals from the
managers starting their b-school
What is more significant to keep in
industry, leveraging alumni network
days.
mind is whether all such candidates
PRABIR JHA: The ability to
will actually grow and deliver
work in two very different
such that career derailments
contexts - global and the
do not happen. Having seen
rural Indian context - is a
numerous students across
useful skill to help work on
some of the finest b-schools in
for b-school graduates. Both
India, my worry is that not too
have huge possibilities, but,
many leave you impressed as
need a very different
a clear select. Much of the borientation. I also feel that
school curriculum is about the
the ability to pick up more
standard electives, but, does
languages and appreciate
not adequately address on the
cross-cultural nuances is
softer dimensions of work
becoming
increasingly
effectiveness. Soft is always
important. At the same time,
more hard. Given the unusual
there must be a very
skew in our selection process,
conscious effort to teach bstudents with an engineering
school students to think
or quantitative background
more 'pluraly'. There is a fair
clear the current assessment
bit of one-dimensional
norms. Is that indeed reflective
thinking that one sees on
of creativity, customer bias and
campuses these days. Broad
leadership acumen? Can these
basing the composition of
really be taught? And if they
the class is an immediate
can, how much are b-schools
requirement. It is very
bothered about students
important to get more
acquiring these?
diversity of thinking on bThere has been some
school campuses in India.
movement on some campuses,
Real life business and
no doubt. However, this is too
K. A. NARAYAN
leadership is not just about
little and possibly already too
the ability to solve tough
late.
President - Human Resources Raymond Group
34
November 2011
www.humancapitalonline.com
H R R O U N D TA B L E
mathematical
equations!
Communication and presentation
skills are another area that needs to
improve. Many b-school graduates
are very poor at broad based
communication,
informal
influencing and presenting their
ideas. Making a smart PPT is not
winning hearts and minds.
MADHAVI LALL: Apart from the
technical skills, a range of broader
skills and attributes that include
critical thinking, adaptability, ability
to see the trend and predict the
future with reasonable accuracy and
managerial abilities are what many
organisations look for in b-school
grads. Some ways in which these
skills can be developed and honed
are through industry interface,
workshops, industry mentoring
programs and live project
experiences.
A frequent aspiration of graduates
is for them to take on the so called
"higher end" roles such as strategy,
products, etc. Graduates need to
understand the criticality of working
MADHAVI LALL
Regional Head-HR India and South Asia,
Standard Chartered Bank
36
November 2011
www.humancapitalonline.com
H R R O U N D TA B L E
a perspective of the real world and
present a platform to groom future
managers. Workshops conducted by
experienced corporate trainers will
help build the students potential by
providing
a
whole-rounded
experience of thinking and learning.
Industry feedback on what business
requires is crucial for the b-schools
to remain agile and aligned to the
needs of the recruiter.
One other area where the
corporate sector can bring a lot of
value is by helping b-schools identify
the gaps in their present curriculum.
While organizations may not be able
to directly influence curriculum
redesign, they can contribute to
student learning through structured
interactions with students by way of
guest lectures, live project
experiences,
well-structured
internships etc. The increased
involvement
of
recruiting
organizations in b-school activities
can also subsequently impact change
in curriculum to make it more
industry relevant.
These steps will provide a
threshold to initiating the change and
bridging the gap between "what is"
and "what should be".
V. KRISHNAN: I genuinely feel that
a well managed summer internship
program is a good solution to most
of the issues we have discussed so
far. Two months time is good enough
for both the organization and a bschool grad to assess compatibility
and culture fit from all dimensions.
Pre-placement offers (PPOs) ensure
that there are no surprises on either
side, and that the graduate settles
into the organization much faster.
Currently, almost 50% of our
management trainees are through
the PPO route, which we would like
to enhance further.
We, at Dabur, have constantly
focused on getting top talent for our
businesses. We intend to stick to this
approach of creating and sustaining
the talent pipeline to supplement our
growth both in the domestic and
international markets, through our
structured MT programme, YMDP.
Given the fact that both our domestic
and our international business has
been growing at a healthy pace, we
38
November 2011
www.humancapitalonline.com
H R R O U N D TA B L E
this possibly becomes the single
biggest career derailers of otherwise
smart brains. A combination of the
left and the right brain is an
imperative.
MADHAVI LALL: To "manufacture"
talent for the long term, the
government, academia, and the
industry need to work together to
better align education and workforce
training with the needs of the
industry.
40
November 2011
www.humancapitalonline.com
Copyright of Human Capital is the property of HR Information Services and its content may not be copied or
emailed to multiple sites or posted to a listserv without the copyright holder's express written permission.
However, users may print, download, or email articles for individual use.