Professional Documents
Culture Documents
54
the end. He led by example and was always in the forefront of the battle,
which earned him the admiration, respect, and devotion of his men [35].
55
56
was killed. After this episode, Alexander began to lose condence in himself.
He became obsessed by fears of the supernatural and interpreted any
unusual or trivial event as a bad omen. Strange things continued to happen
to him. Apparently, a docile donkey in the kings menagerie attacked and
kicked to death the most powerful of the royal lions. With so many signs of
impending misfortune and evil omens, Alexander feared for life and felt that
the gods had deserted him [3,5,68].
57
Table 1
Last days of Alexander
Dates (Macedonian
calendar)
June 23, 323 BC
(Daisios 17th18th)
June 4, 323 BC
(Daisios 18th)
June 5, 323 BC
(Daisios 19th)
June 6, 323 BC
(Daisios 20th)
Fever noted
PM:
No comments
Summoned his generals to bedside to
plan Arabia expedition
PM:
Fever noted
Fevers continued
(in bed sick at
Royal Palace)
No comments
AM:
PM:
Fevers continued
No comments
AM:
AM:
PM:
June 7, 323 BC
(Daisios 21st)
AM:
June 9, 323 BC
(Daisios 23rd)
June 10, 323 BC
(Daisios 24th)
No comments
Fever continued
AM:
No comments
Very ill
PM:
No comments
PM:
June 8, 323 BC
(Daisios 22nd)
Continued to
deteriorate
PM: Fevers continued
AM: Continued to get worse
AM:
No comments
Deteriorated further.
Unable to speak, but
able to recognize his
generals
PM: Fever intensied
AM: Fevers continued
to intensify
PM:
AM:
PM:
No comments
Recognized
companions, but only
able to nod his head in
response
PM: No comments
AM: Remained very ill
AM:
PM:
a
Comments
Alexander died
No comments
No audiences with his Macedonian
troops. Rumors spread that
he was dead.
Troops led past Alexander in his sick
bed
Six friends went to Marduka
Temple to sleep and ask if Alexander
should be bought to the temple
No comments
Oracle adviced that Alexander should
not be bought to the temple and
should stay at the Court Palace
58
59
not medical, terms. Even when ancient writers describe diseases in medical
terms, they use the terminology of the time. The medical meaning of words is
subject to great variations in interpretation and meaning. The description of
fever is critical in describing the cause of Alexanders death, yet the word for
fever in Greek is applied dierently by Hippocrates, Arrian, and Plutarch and
varies from feverish to fever to high fever. Each of these descriptions has
dierent diagnostic implications. Investigators are left with incomplete
accounts that are written by nonphysicians in lay terms for maladies and are
subject to interpretational variation by translators (eg, classic scholars who
are not physicians). It is worthwhile to investigate the probable cause of
Alexanders death, because he is so important in the history of Western
civilization [2,13,14].
Noninfectious explanations of Alexanders death
Alexander was a heavy drinker, and it has been suggested that he died of
advanced alcoholic cirrhosis terminally complicated by delirium tremens.
The description of Alexanders demise does not resemble delirium tremens.
The characteristic high fever and the tremulousness or hypermetabolic state
of delirium tremens are not included in the descriptions of Alexanders death.
Much has been made about Alexanders prodigious consumption of
wine. Although Alexander was a heavy drinker, he was healthy and able to
remain mentally clear and in control. During his last few days, he frequently
was thirsty and resorted to quenching his thirst by drinking wine. From the
descriptions of Arrian and Plutarch, it seems that Alexander drank wine to
quench his thirst. The consumption of wine, even if excessive, does not t
the description of his death.
Other researchers have suggested that Alexander was poisoned by someone for a variety of reasons. Strychnine poisoning has been mentioned as the
most likely possibility in the category. Strychnine was available in the ancient
world, and its lethal eects recognized. Its peculiar taste could be hidden
by wine, which would be a perfect vehicle to use to poison the wine-loving
Alexander. Strychnine poisoning, however, is characterized by a rigidity of the
muscles and convulsions, characteristics that are incompatible with the descriptions of his nal days. Fever, delirium, and semicomatose state were not
the cardinal features noted in accounts that survived. It is unlikely that
Alexanders nal exodus was caused by a ruptured amebic liver abscess,
chronic alcoholism with superimposed delirium tremens, or strychnine
poisoning [2,5,7,13].
Infectious diseases in ancient Babylon
In the time of Alexander the Great, a variety of infectious diseases
periodically ravaged the ancient world. Endemic infectious diseases were
responsible for much of the mortality and morbidity that controlled
population growth in ancient populations. Infectious diarrhea and dysentery
60
61
Table 2
Time course of malaria
Time course
Incubation period
First week
Second week
Third week
a
Except for Plasmodium falciparum-related malaria, individuals with malaria caused by
P ovale, P vivax, or P malariae resolves without treatment unless there are complications (eg,
splenic rupture). P falciparum may be complicated by cerebral malaria, ARDS, hypoglycemia,
or kidney failure.
Survivors of malaria remain febrile into the third week and gradually recover.
Except for fever, per se, there is little in the descriptions of Alexanders illness
to support malaria. Typhoid fever is the best possibility, even though some
features of typhoid fever are not described. The cardinal features of typhoid
fever are present, particularly the gradual step-wise increase in fever without
signicant rigors or sweating. The continuous fever of typhoid fever ts well
with Arrians and Plutarchs descriptions. Patients with typhoid fever initially
present with constipation and later may develop diarrhea, but these details
have been left out of the existing records. The demise of patients with typhoid
Table 3
Time course of typhoid fever
Time course
Incubation period
First week
None
Initial chill
Fever begins
Malaise
Anorexia
Headache
Dry cough
Constipation
Gradual stepwise increase in fever
Continuous fever (temperature gradually increasing)
Apathetic aect
Skin dry or hot
Sweating but no drenching sweats
Continuous fevers peak
Delirium or stupor
Intestinal hemorrhage
Intestinal perforation or peritonitis
Second week
Third week
62
Typhoid fever
Malaria
Salmonella typhi
+
714 d
Insidious
Plasmodia species
+
714 d
Acute
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
a
63
References
[1] Fox RL. Alexander the Great. London: Penguin Books; 1973. p. 3569.
[2] Plutarch. Plutarchs lives of noble Grecians and Romans, vol II. New York: Modern
Library; 1992. p. 13999.
[3] Savill A. Alexander the Great and his time. New York: Barnes & Nobles Books; 1993.
p. 13854.
[4] Arrian. Anabasis of Alexander, vol II. Boston: Harvard University Press; 1983.
[5] Green P. How many miles to Babylon? In: Alexander of Macedon. Berkeley (CA):
University of California Press; 1991. p. 4718.
[6] Wilcken U. Return and end. In: Alexander the Great. New York: W. W. Norton &
Company; 1967. p. 22938.
[7] OBrien JM. Death in Babylon. In: Alexander the Great: the invisible enemy. London:
Routeledge Taylor & Francis Group; 1992. p. 21728, 3189.
[8] Wood M. Well say our goodbyes in Babylon. In: In the footsteps of Alexander the Great.
Berkeley (CA): University of California Press; 1997. p. 22332.
[9] Osler W. The diagnosis of malarial fever. Med News 1897;70:28992.
[10] Rubin RH, Weinstein L. Salmonellosis: microbiologic, pathologic, and clinical features.
New York: Stratton Intercontinental Medical Book Corporation; 1977. p. 4658.
[11] Jones WHS. The prevalence of malaria in Ancient Greece. In: Brothwell D, Sandison AT.
Diseases in antiquity. Springeld (IL): Charles C. Thomas; 1967. p. 1706.
[12] Patrick A. Diseases in antiquity: Ancient Greece and Rome. Springeld (IL): Charles C
Thomas; 1967. p. 23846.
[13] Engels DW. A note on Alexanders death. Classical Philosophy 1978;73:2248.
[14] Samuel AE. Alexanders royal journals. Historia (Argentina) 1965;14:112.
[15] Borza EN. Malaria in Alexanders army. Ancient History Bulletin 1987;1:368.
[16] Willis T. Typhoid fever. In: Major RH, editor. Classic descriptions of disease. Springeld
(IL): Charles C Thomas; 1967. p. 17986.
[17] Osler W. Malarial fever. In: The principles and practices of medicine. New York: Appleton
and Company; 1892. p. 14056.
[18] Osler W. Typhoid fever. In: The principles and practices of medicine. New York: Appleton
and Company; 1892. p. 239.
[19] Verghese A. The typhoid state revisited. Am J Med 1985;79:3702.
[20] Wernsdorfer WH, McGregor SI. Malaria: principles and practice of malariology.
Edinburgh: Churchill Livingstone; 1988.
[21] Hak R. The complications of typhoid fever. J Trop Med Hyg 1961;64:14352.