Professional Documents
Culture Documents
reports
rep or ts.informationweek.com
O c tob er 2012
$99
Understanding
Software-Defined
Networks
IT organizations we surveyed believe this new approach to
networking can reduce costs and improve network efficiency and
security. So why have only
Maybe because
Previous
Next
CONTENTS
reports
TABLE OF
reports.informationweek.com
3
4
5
6
7
7
10
12
14
15
17
18
20
22
26
Authors Bio
Executive Summary
Research Synopsis
What Is Software-Defined Networking?
A Vision of Control
Impact Assessment
Competing Visions of SDN
Drivers of SDN Deployment
SDN and Security
Be Clear About SDN Objectives
Money Matters
Inhibitors to SDN Deployment
Call to Action
Appendix
Related Reports
Figures
6 Figure 1: Familiarity With Software-Defined
Networking
8 Figure 2: Decoupling of the Control and
Forwarding Planes
9 Figure 3: Familiarity With OpenFlow
10 Figure 4: Attitude Toward OpenFlow
11 Figure 5: Dumbing Down of Switches and Routers
October 2012 2
Previous
Next
Table of Contents
reports
Jim Metzler
InformationWeek Reports
Jim Metzler has a broad background in the IT industry. This includes being a
software engineer, an engineering manager for high-speed data services for a
major network service provider, a product manager for network hardware, a
network manager at two Fortune 500 companies and the principal of a consulting organization. In addition, he has created software tools for designing customer networks for a major network service provider and directed and performed market research at a major industry analyst firm.
Each year Jim publishes two e-books, one on application and service delivery
and the other on cloud networking. He co-authored a book titled Layer 3
Switching, which is part of the Prentice Hall series in computer networking and
distributed systems. He has a Ph.D. in mathematics from Boston University and
is currently an independent industry analyst and consultant.
Want More?
Never Miss
a Report!
Follow
Follow
reports.informationweek.com
Follow
Follow
2012 InformationWeek, Reproduction Prohibited
October 2012 3
Previous
Next
Table of Contents
SUMMARY
reports
EXECUTIVE
reports.informationweek.com
Software-defined networking has the potential to fundamentally change the networking industry. Given that potential and the buzz that surrounds it, you might guess that
SDN is a well-understood concept and has been deployed by a large number of IT organizations. The reality is that only a small percentage of IT organizations claim to be very familiar with SDN. In addition, our InformationWeek 2012 Software-Defined Networking
Survey shows that only 4% of IT organizations have already implemented SDN and only
another 5% of IT organizations are testing it. At present, SDN is only for early adopters.
It will be challenging for SDN to be broadly deployed in the near term in part because
its not a narrowly defined technology like TRILL or SPB. Rather, its an approach to networking that focuses on centralizing control functionality and providing programmatic
interfaces into a wide range of network equipment. It also requires an extensive ecosystem of vendors. The breadth of what is referred to as SDN is partially a result of the varying ways that its possible to centralize control and provide programmatic interfaces into
network elements.
This report aims to bring clarity to the nascent SDN market by outlining the major
approaches to SDN. We dig into how these approaches are similar and where they differ,
and we examine the benefits and drawbacks of each approach. The report also shares the
results from the InformationWeek Software-Defined Networking Survey, which measures
IT pros familiarity with and attitudes toward SDN and OpenFlow, a new protocol closely
associated with SDN. Finally, it provides guidance to help IT organizations develop a
strategy for SDN.
October 2012 4
Previous
Next
Table of Contents
InformationWeek Reports
analysts arm business technology decision-makers with realworld perspective based on
qualitative and quantitative research, business and technology
assessment and planning tools,
and adoption best practices
gleaned from experience.
To contact us, write to managing director Art Wittmann
at awittmann@techweb.com,
content director
Lorna Garey at
lgarey@techweb.com,
editor-at-large Andrew
Conry-Murray
at acmurray@techweb.com, and
research managing editor
Heather Vallis at
hvallis@techweb.com.
Find all of our reports at
reports.informationweek.com.
reports.informationweek.com
SYNOPSIS
ABOUT US
reports
RESEARCH
October 2012 5
Previous
Next
Table of Contents
reports
17%
Somewhat familiar; I have a
general idea of what its about
48%
35%
Familiar; I understand the basics
Data: InformationWeek 2012 Software-Defined Networking Survey of 250 business technology professionals, July 2012
R5451012/1
October 2012 6
Previous
Next
Table of Contents
FAST FACT
33%
of respondents to our
Software-Defined
Networking Survey say
they are familiar or very
familiar with the
OpenFlow protocol.
reports.informationweek.com
reports
Business Organization
Business Competitiveness
Benefit
Risk
issues, those could negatively impact the companys competitiveness. However, few IT organizations will risk running a business-critical application in the short term on an
embryonic set of technologies and products, so significant
disruption is unlikely.
products and standards and only rudimentary interoperability. There is also a lack of applications that take advantage of SDN and gapping holes around how an SDN will
be managed.
Bottom Line:
SDN promises to replace human interfaces into network elements with automated interfaces, which should streamline management and provide granular
visibility and control. SDN also has the potential to open up networking to new applications that will further extend the value of the network infrastructure.
A Vision of Control
There are three general approaches to SDN.
The approach thats probably most well known
separates the forwarding and control planes
that typically reside in a switch and moves the
control plane to a separate device. This device,
Register
Previous
Next
Table of Contents
reports
Previous
Next
Previous
Next
Download
Subscribe
Strategy:
Inside OpenFlow
New software-defined networking technologies in general and
OpenFlow in particular are poised
to disrupt the way we manage
Register
load in
highly virtualized
data
Previous
Next
centers. In a world where for
decades weve relied on Ethernet
Next
Previous
and TCP/IP
standardsand
wherePrevious
big vendors like
Next Cisco and
Juniper have made their fortunes
based on
intelligenceNext
in
Previous
switchesthats a big deal.
Download
reports.informationweek.com
Subscribe
Figure 2
Application
Application
Application
Application
Northbound API
Previous
Next
Southbound API
Switch
Switch
ence Protocol, the Network Configuration Protocol and OpenStack from Rackspace and
R5450912_SDN_chart1
NASA.
However, as our survey shows, OpenFlow is closely associated with SDN (Figure 4).
One of the implications of the ONF approach is the likelihood that switches and
Switch
Switch
R5450912/1
Register
Previous
Next
Table of Contents
reports
Previous
Next
Previous
Next
Figure 3
10%
Not familiar
29%
Familiar; I understand the basics
23%
Somewhat familiar;
I have a general idea of what it's about
38%
Data: InformationWeek 2012 Software-Defined Networking Survey of 250 business technology professionals, July 2012
R5451012/14
Register
Previous
Next
Table of Contents
reports
Previous
Next
Previous
Next
Previous
Download
Subscribe
reports.informationweek.com
Next
Figure 4
13%
15%
32%
40%
R5451012_SDN_Chart15
R5451012/15
Register
Previous
Next
Table of Contents
reports
Previous
Next
Previous
Next
Next
Previous
Download
Previous
Next
RateSubscribe
It!
Something we could do
better? Let us know.
Rate
reports.informationweek.com
Figure 5
Yes
Dont know
29%
34%
37%
No
Data: InformationWeek 2012 Software-Defined Networking Survey of 250 business technology professionals, July 2012
R5451012/12
can be associated with a controller-based architecture (that is, if the controller dies, so
does the ability to move traffic through the
network).
On the downside, this approach is vendorspecific. In a multivendor network environment, it would result in islands of control
whereby the operator would have differing
October 2012 11
Register
Previous
Next
Table of Contents
reports
Previous
Next
Previous
Next
Download
Subscribe
reports.informationweek.com
Next
Figure 6
Slightly willing
Completely willing
12%
11%
Very willing
29%
Moderately willing
48%
R5451012/5
Register
Previous
Next
reports
Download
reports.informationweek.com
Subscribe
R5451012_SDN_Chart6
impacts
revenue in a way that is very direct
and measurable. Value proposition 3 should
appeal to all types of organizations.
In addition to reducing costs and automat-
1%
Other
1%
4%
8%
10%
12%
Increase scalability
20%
23%
25%
Get more visibility into applications that are using the network
29%
31%
Reduce cost
32%
Download
Improve security
Next
Figure 7
35%
Previous
Next
42%
Previous
Previous
Next
Reduce complexity
Table of Contents
R5451012/6
Register
Previous
Next
Table of Contents
reports
Previous
Next
Previous
Next
Previous
Download
Subscribe
reports.informationweek.com
Next
Figure 8
10%
Dont know
31%
32%
Networks will be much less secure
1%
11%
15%
It will have no impact on network security
Data: InformationWeek 2012 Software-Defined Networking Survey of 250 business technology professionals, July 2012
R5451012/9
Register
Previous
Next
Table of Contents
reports
Previous
Next
Previous
Next
Previous
Download
Subscribe
Next
technologies, are to be expected when implementing any new technology (Figure 9).
Some other challenges, such as the concerns
over the vulnerability of the controller, are
unique to SDN. For instance, if hackers were to
gain access to the SDN controller, they would
have the power to inflict significant harm. The
counterargument is that its often easier to protect one central device than it is to protect hundreds or thousands of decentralized devices.
Survey respondents do see the potential
for SDN to benefit network security. The
most anticipated benefit is that SDN will
make it easier to apply a unified security policy (Figure 10). The bottom line is that any IT
organization that is evaluating SDN needs to
address security issues from the outset.
Be Clear About SDN Objectives
When discussing SDN, its common for the
trade press and industry analysts to talk about
its ability to better support the adoption of
private and/or hybrid cloud computing. However, as Figure 7 shows, that capability isnt a
strong driver of enterprise adoption of SDN.
reports.informationweek.com
Figure 9
44%
The controller scares meif an attacker owns that, it's game over
40%
More complexity, which always means less security
38%
Functionality leveraging controller intelligence opens new attack surfaces
38%
Inability to inspect every packet
20%
It will hinder performance to such a degree that public cloud/SaaS use will increase
10%
Other
2%
None; it will help security
9%
Note: Multiple responses allowed
Data: InformationWeek 2012 Software-Defined Networking Survey of 250 business technology professionals, July 2012
R5451012_SDN_Chart11
R5451012/11
Register
Previous
Next
Table of Contents
reports
Previous
Next
Previous
Next
Previous
Download
FAST FACT
Subscribe
12%
of respondents think
implementing SDN will
make networks less
secure; 31% say they just
dont know.
reports.informationweek.com
Next
Figure 10
44%
Data security via transport encryption
32%
Integrated and more granular access control
29%
Additional points where security controls can be placed to address software/application security issues
28%
Intra-hypervisor (VM-VM) packet inspection and firewall
22%
Malware filtering
22%
More situation- or application-aware security event logging details
22%
Improved security appliance performance/throughput
17%
DoS mitigation
17%
Other
4%
None; it will hurt security
12%
Note: Multiple responses allowed
Data: InformationWeek 2012 Software-Defined Networking Survey of 250 business technology professionals, July 2012
R5451012_SDN_Chart10
R5451012/10
October 2012 16
Register
Previous
Next
Table of Contents
reports
Previous
Next
Previous
Next
Previous
Next
about the benefits of SDN, how those benefits might evolve over time, and how SDN
will complement or support other major IT
projects and goals.
Figure 11
66%
Download
Subscribe
reports.informationweek.com
Money Matters
Given that IT believes the primary benefits
of SDN relative to the data center are reducing cost and automating management and
security policy enforcement, its not surprising
that those tend to be the selling points used
by IT organizations that have implemented
SDN or intend to implement it (Figure 11).
However, its not clear that the expected cost
savings anticipated with a controller-based
SDN model will appear. IT anticipates those
savings in large part because dumbed-down
switches will be cheaper than conventional
switches. But given the current state of the
market, the deployment of SDN wont result in
any dumbing down of switches and routers
for at least the next two years. That follows in
part because it will take a new generation of
merchant silicon to build fully functional,
highly scalable OpenFlow-enabled devices.
50%
Ability to apply QoS via traffic awareness
36%
Ability to test new routing protocols
17%
Other
3%
We wont even try; benefits are on the networking side
4%
Note: Multiple responses allowed
Base: 116 respondents at organizations with, or planning to have, SDN in production
Data: InformationWeek 2012 Software-Defined Networking Survey of 250 business technology professionals, July 2012
And even if fully functional OpenFlow devices were available, the vast majority of IT
organizations would adopt them over time
R5451012_SDN_Chart7
and
most likely would implement them only
in part of their infrastructure. Thats because
IT organizations seldom swap out one infrastructure for another in a single move, par-
R5451012/7
Register
Previous
Next
Table of Contents
reports
Previous
Next
Previous
Next
Previous
Download
Subscribe
Next
18%, was that costs would simply shift to controllers and software (Figure 12).
In addition, some IT organizations are likely
to adopt SDN in a hybrid model, in which
some control plane functionality is centralized
and the remaining functionality remains distributed within switches. Depending on how
much control functionality is centralized, this
scenario may not result in switches with significantly less functionality; in fact, this scenario may result in switches that require additional functionality.
The bottom line is that any cost savings that
might result from adopting low-cost OpenFlow-enabled devices will take place over a
number of years, if at all.
Figure 12
Somewhat lower prices, less hardware differentiation, but same main players
22%
The cost will just shift to controllers and software
18%
Fewer proprietary features, emphasis on standards
16%
Will reshuffle market leadership
11%
Switches and routers will be a commodity; pricing landscape will be totally different
7%
Switches and routers will be a commodity; vendor landscape will be totally different
7%
Other
1%
No impact; Cisco will figure out how to maintain its margins
18%
Data: InformationWeek 2012 Software-Defined Networking Survey of 250 business technology professionals, July 2012
R5451012_SDN_Chart13
R5451012/13
Register
Previous
Next
reports
LikeFollow
This Report?
Share it!
Like
Tweet
Like
Next
Share
Tweet
reports.informationweek.com
Follow
Next
2%
4%
2%
Other
11%
13%
14%
18%
18%
22%
23%
24%
25%
Follow
Follow
Follow
Share
Share
Which of the following are the top inhibitors to your company adopting SDN in the next two years?
Subscribe
Download
Figure 13
32%
Next
Previous
Next
41%
Previous
Previous
Next
Table of Contents
R5451012/8
Register
Previous
Next
Table of Contents
reports
Previous
Next
Previous
Next
Previous
Download
Next
Call to Action
There are relatively few players in the IT industry making the argument that SDN is
ready for broad deployment in production
Subscribe
networks. As such, SDN
is not encumbered by
As is typical of any early-adopter
too much hyperbole.
market, the development and
However, given the
market research preimplementation of SDN is marked
sented in this report, it
by immaturity and confusion.
is clear that SDN is
shrouded in confusion.
IT organizations need to disperse this confusion to better understand SDN and to establish
a strategyeven if that strategy is to do nothing relative to SDN for the foreseeable future.
We offer a set of considerations to help guide
you in creating that strategy.
reports.informationweek.com
Register
Previous
Next
Table of Contents
reports
Previous
Next
Previous
Next
Previous
Download
Subscribe
reports.informationweek.com
Next
tion will minimize and mitigate the risks associated with implementing SDN.
> Develop a program to get management buy-in. This includes getting funding
as well as the buy-in from any other organization that will be directly impacted by the
deployment of SDN.
October 2012 21
Register
Previous
Next
Table of Contents
Previous
Previous
Next
Previous
Download
Subscribe
reports.informationweek.com
Next
APPENDIX
reports
Next
Figure 14
Job Title
Which of the following best describes your job title?
89
Other
7
6
Consultant
7%
8%
7%
Line-of-business management
5%
IT director/manager
IT/IS staff
33%
8%
32%
Data: InformationWeek 2012 Software-Defined Networking Survey of 250 business technology professionals, July 2012
R5451012/24
R5451012_SDN_Chart24
October 2012 22
Register
Previous
Next
Table of Contents
reports
Previous
Next
Previous
Next
Figure 15
Previous
Next
Industry
What is your organizations primary industry?
Construction/engineering
2%
Download
11%
Education
7%
Electronics
2%
Financial services
Subscribe
9%
Government
12%
Healthcare/medical
10%
IT vendors
10%
Manufacturing/industrial, noncomputer
10%
Media/entertainment
2%
Retail/e-commerce
4%
Telecommunications/ISPs
8%
Utilities
2%
Other
11%
Data: InformationWeek 2012 Software-Defined Networking Survey of 250 business technology professionals, July 2012
reports.informationweek.com
R5451012/25
October 2012 23
Register
Previous
Next
Table of Contents
reports
Previous
Next
Previous
Next
Figure 16
Previous
Next
Revenue
Which of the following dollar ranges includes the annual revenue of your entire organization?
14%
10%
Government/nonprofit
8%
7
6
Download
89
17%
2
3
Subscribe
$5 billion or more
12%
7%
11%
13%
$1 billion to $4.9 billion
8%
Data: InformationWeek 2012 Software-Defined Networking Survey of 250 business technology professionals, July 2012
R5451012/26
R5451012_SDN_Chart26
reports.informationweek.com
October 2012 24
Register
Previous
Next
Table of Contents
reports
Previous
Next
Previous
Next
Figure 17
Previous
Next
Company Size
Approximately how many employees are in your organization?
89
Fewer than 50
Download
10,000 or more
8%
20%
7
6
50-99
8%
4
100-499
5,000-9,999
20%
14%
2
3
Subscribe
8%
22%
500-999
1,000-4,999
Data: InformationWeek 2012 Software-Defined Networking Survey of 250 business technology professionals, July 2012
R5451012/27
R5451012_SDN_Chart27
reports.informationweek.com
October 2012 25
Previous
Table of Contents
MORE
reports
LIKE THIS
Newsletter
Want to stay current on all new
InformationWeek Reports?
Subscribe to our weekly
newsletter and never miss
a beat.
Subscribe
reports.informationweek.com
IT Pro Ranking: Data Center Management: Three hundred fifty-seven IT pros weighed in
to rank 10 data center management products. EMCs Unified Infrastructure Manager earned
the highest score for both overall performance and data center management features.
VMware and Cisco both tied for the second spot in overall performance. On the features
front, Cisco, VMware and IBM all earned scores of 77%, just two points behind EMC. Other
vendors evaluated include HP, Microsoft, Oracle and Symantec.
Fundamentals: Understanding Flat Networks: A flat network or fabric provides more
paths through the network and can maximize bandwidth and better support a highly virtualized data center. Well look at standards-based approaches to designing a flat network, including TRILL and SPB, as well as proprietary vendor implementations. Well also discuss the
implications of moving to a flat network, and provide guidance to help you decide whether
this approach is the right one for your data center.
PLUS: Find signature reports, such as the InformationWeek Salary Survey, InformationWeek
500 and the annual State of Security report; full issues; and much more.
October 2012 26