Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Introduction:
Every major religion has their own passionate controversies and opinions regarding its origin
and associated mythology. The author want to emphasize the intent of this article is not to
offend any beliefs in the ultimate creator that created us and the cosmos. Any religion that
produces peaceful coexistence and message of universal brotherhood should enjoy equality
and respect of the mankind. The subject of this article is discussed by many scholars for
several decades and it may continue but from the historical point of view, the people should
know the evolution of primitive thoughts of worship to the current state of worlds religions.
appreciated the suns regular appearance everyday that injects the energy and life on every
living beings in rather dark and frigid cold planet of the night and without his presence the
life comes to a screeching halt. The worship of appeasement to these natural forces begun
since pre-historic time and then became the regular rituals of worship for the early humans.
During the early Rig-Vedic time, when the ancestors of the Indo-Iranians were still united as a
group, they were already worshippers of the Sun-God Mitra (Mithra). The hymns of the
Vedas celebrated thy name, as did those of the Avestan, and despite their differences
between their theological systems, the Vedic Mitra and the Iranian Mithra have preserved so
many traits of resemblance that it establishes the certainty of its origin without any doubt.
The land of Indian landscape is still houses the number of Sun Temples dedicated to Mitra.
The Islam destroyed Mithras heritage in India and Persia but Zoroaster ruins in Iran and
central Asia still attest the presence of Mithras with their associated ritual and practice. The
Mithras appeared in different forms in many central Asian traditions and their archeological
evidence is still preserved. Helios for Greeks, Elagabalus for Syrians, were all sun God Mithra.
Sun-God Mithra occupied a prominent position in all forms of Paganism in Egypt and ancient
Rome.
Indian Mithras
Varuna-Mithra combined-India
The etymologists have determined that the word Mithra actually derived from Proto-IndoEuropean word Mitra that is well preserved in Sanskrit. Elamite tablets of the time of
Darius, the offerings are recorded five times for Mica-Baga where Mica was Old Persian for
Mithras and Baga meant Bhagwan in Indian and God in English. Yazata, the divinity
of Zaruashtras represents collective good powers of Mithra and Ahar Mazda all rolled into
one. The word Yazata has common root with the Sanskrit word Yajati. This also meant
worship and ritual of Yojna, Yogna or Yoga in Indian languages. But, the Yazata for
Persian was not meant for Deva. The Vedic people took it as a reverse of that and Yojna or
Yogna for Indians meant for Devas that are considered as good Gods.
According to some recent discoveries in Mesopotamia, this Mitra god, with whom the
peoples of Europe were unacquainted with, were worshiper of other Pagan Pantheon from
neighboring people of Acadian or Khemit Empire and ancient Mesopotamia. Mitra-Varuna,
and the five other Aditya celebrated by the Vedas and Mithra-Ahura and the Amshaspands
celebrated by ancient Avestan (Persian) texts defines the Creator of the universe as the sun,
the moon, and the planets, and other celestial objects that are seen in our sky and governs all
life in this planet, collectively called cosmos. The worship of the cosmos was adopted by the
Indo-Europeans and others since primitive times and it continued until the peoples
conversion to reformist religion of the world like Buddhism, Jainism, Islam and modern
Christianity. Indian astrology still uses this concept in charting ones horoscope based on our
cosmos. In the Avesta, Mithras is the genius of the celestial light. He appears before sunrise
on the rocky summits of the mountains; during the day he traverses the wide firmament in
his chariot drawn by four white horses. The Vedic religion displays him as a god of light,
invoked together with the heaven, bearing in the one case the name of Indian Varuna and
in the other that of Ahura. Mithra was the protector of truth, the enemy of falsehood and
error. The sacred Veda of India has preserved him. A single fragment, and even that partially
effaced, is all that has been especially dedicated to him in Veda. He appears mainly in
incidental quotes or sentences, but remains the silent witnesses of his ancient grandeur
status by way of rituals, worships and practice. Over 1000 years ago, the day in India began
with the prayers to Mithra with folded hand when the royals, nobles and commoners faced
the rising sun in the east at Chittore Grah and Fort of Jalore called Sonar Killah.
Maitreya refers to a time when the Dharma will have been forgotten by most on this world.
This sounds so similar to Jewish and Christian bible prophesies. One has to wonder about the
power of Mithras reach.
rd
Future Buddha-Maitreya 3 Century BC Mathura and Bactrian coins depicting Mithra below.
Mitanni Aryans were the first to introduce Mithra to Egyptian Pharaohs that allowed them to
incorporate into their earlier pagan worship of Osiris and Amun. The Ra or Re was the
designated ancient Egyptian solar deity. By the Fifth Dynasty, Mitra or Mithra had emerged as
a major god in ancient Egyptian religion, identified primarily with the midday sun. The
meaning of the name Ra may be uncertain, but it is thought that it is a variant of or linked
to Persian words like Rau, a 'creative power' and 'creator' of the earth, that is sun, the star
of our planetary system. The major cult centre of Ra was located at ancient Heliopolis of
Egypt or land of Khemit where he was labeled as the local sun-god Atum or Atum-Ra. In
later Egyptian dynastic times, Ra was merged with the god Horus, as Re-Horakhty and even
Osiris.
and Anatolia that Romans had conquered from Greeks where already practitioner of Judaism,
Mithraism or Zoroasters religion (similar to Mithra). The Romans had their own pagan
worships that included the worship of Roman emperors, so were early Greeks. The Roman
learned that Anatolians were worshippers of Mithra along with other cults of Greece and
Egypt. The cross cultural exchange introduced Indian-Iranian Mithra to the Ionian, the Lydian,
the Phrygian, the Thracian, and the Celtic-Gaul of Anatolia who incorporated them with their
chosen pagan gods.
Although Christianity only took hold as an official religion under Emperor Constantine,
Constantine himself was a follower of Mithraism and remains so and by some account
through his life until he was baptized as Christian at his death bed. The Yazata of Persian was
interpreted as angels in Christianity. According to Martin Haug, the Amesha Spentas of
Zaruashtras became the arch-angel Gabriel of Christianity. The Mithraic Mystery thus
became the deviant form of religion practiced in Central Asian states due to previous
dominance of the Achemenians Persians and then followed by Indo-Greeks Seleucid rulers of
Bactria.
The Mithraism was introduced to European Roman world through Roman soldiers who had
intermarried with locals Anatolians and Asian Semite and Jews. This was further facilitated by
prolonged absence of soldiers from home so they took local mistress. Simultaneously, they
sent slaves and trader-visitors from conquered territories of Asia to Rome. The trade link with
Persia and India also helped introduce the tradition and rituals of Mithra. The expansion of
Roman Empire all the way to Anatolia, Greece and Egypt brought these new cultural
dimensions to ancient Rome.
Mythology of Mithra in Roman world and its similarities with Jesuss story:
The name of the Persian god Mithra (proto-Indo-Iranian Mitra), adapted by the Greek as
Helios and Attis, assumed a new and distinctive imagery on Greek model in the Roman world.
The Writers of the Roman Empire world referred to this as a mystery religion by phrases
which can be anglicized as Mysteries of Mithras or Mysteries of the Persians or
Mysteries of Magi, The high priest of Persian Mithra introduced the magic of healing
through ancient knowledge known from India, Persia and east. The name of this commingled
religion in an altered form was dubbed as Roman Mithraism due to its practice, rituals and
presence in Rome proper. We see various depiction of Buddha in Caucasian form as well as
Mongolian form.
It is a natural conclusion that these mysteries were popular in the Roman military as they
spent considerable time in Asian territories. The Mithra (Avestan), the Mitra (Vedic) and
Zoroastrian (yazata) divinity was born from virgin according to the legend of Mithra.
Mahabharata, similarly attest that one man superior to the hero Arjuna was invincible
Karna conceived by the Sun God Mitra to virgin Kunti, the mother of Pandavas. Kuntis
personal pleading to Karna may have saved Arjunas life according to Mahabharata. Jesus
Christ was born of Virgin Mary and he was regarded as the son of God. The virgin birth belief
of Mithras comes along with many other virgin births of Indo-European Gods. The Roman
version of Mithras introduces some additional features from Syria. These features were
picked up through incorporating various central Asian local cults and religious traditions from
the days of Mesopotamia.
of Christianity was ever altered when formulating canonical texts that came into existence
several centuries later after Jesus death, but we should not be surprised, if it did. Although
some atheists argue about the historicity of Jesus but this is not a new phenomenon. Every
God like figures like Buddha, Mahavira, Krishna and Shiva and others were and are similarly
questioned by atheists. Jesus teachings as recorded in New Testament were good moral
judgments for humanity to follow. The messages from the other teachers are very similar.
The following of these paths laid down by those early teachers makes us more human. So, it
makes little difference as to how early Christianity may have been evolved. The historians
always like to explore the historicity of these great teachers and prophets regardless of what
teachings they introduced through various canonical texts and those schisms have continued
in all the religions of the world, and the Christianity is no exception.
12. Both were Celebrated on Sunday as His sacred day (also known as the Lords Day or
Suns day).
13. Both were celebrated as Eucharist or Lords Supper. (Buddha had a last supper)
It appears from the above that the Jesus life story is nearly the same as Mithra and may have
similarities, either divinely duplicated by God during Jesus birth or copied by a scribe while
recording the new testaments and various gospels from earlier stories. We will let the readers
decide.
Roman Mithraism became a popular religion in the Roman Empire after the end of JulioClaudian dynasty coincidental with the rise of Flavius and Severus dynasty. Both of these new
dynasties became patron of Mithraism that Julio-Claudian dynasty will not permit. JulioClaudian dynasty ended with the death of last emperor Nero. It is worth mentioning what
Tacitus wrote about Julio-Claudian Emperors and their history:
But the successes and reverses of the old Roman people have been recorded by famous
historians; and fine intellects did not want to describe the times of Augustus, till growing
sycophancy scared them away. The histories of Tiberius, Caius, Claudius, and Nero, while they
were in power, were falsified through terror, and after their death were written under the
irritation of a recent hatred.
Early Jesus and Christianitys history therefore may have been twisted, doctored or changed.
This is not the first instance in the world history, this type of tempering have occurred before.
We find these alterations in all the worlds religions and they all have some mythical
component added in later ages during their spread and expansion.
Although, the early form of Western and eastern Mithraism is now nearly extinct and not
practiced widely in its early form; it is worth reviewing from historical stand point, the
influence and evolution of this popular religion and how it may still exist in its rebranded
form practiced by Parsee of India and Christians of the world.
There are a number of atheists of western world who are now assembling in London to argue
that Christianity is simply a resurgent model of previously existing faith of Mithraism of
Roman World and it was a modified form of Proto-Indo-Iranian Mithraism. Their main
argument is that Jesus story was probably copied from the mythology of Mithra. They argue
that no one knows who the real Jesus was; perhaps the fictional creator of Jesus was
Josephus Flavius who was being used by Flavius emperors to counter the rebellious
provinces. Josephus was an authoritarian figure connected with early rebellious movements
fueled by religious bigotry to fight the Imperial Rome. Josephus may have known a rebel
name Jesus who threw the coins at the coin changers in anger. Josephus may have
constructed his life imitating Mithra to neutralize the Jewish rebellion under the Flavius
Project designed to subdue the rebellious subjects of the empire. Josephus argued that the
rebellion was primarily driven by religious beliefs than Roman rule. The Jewish people were
also tired of Herods reign as well. The Jews have long believed that they are promised by
God who would send Messiah to liberate the Jews from the oppression. Josephus advised
Titus and Vespasian that this was the mainstay of belief that is keeping the rebellion alive. In
a way, we can draw the same parallels between moderate Islam and Wahhabi brand that
fuels the violence.
The scholarly efforts to connect the eastern Mithra to western Mithra have found some
similarities but not all. Other deviant features were picked up along the way at different time
during the centuries of the history incorporating local cults of central Asia. Much of what is
known about Roman Mithras comes from pictures and murals that have NO TITLES, so the
vast majority of scholarly work on this character is a bit speculative interpretation from the
original displays in murals, archeology and numismatic as no textual references are available
except given by Vedic-Avesta-Mitanni texts and Egyptian references of Mitra.
For this article, we will forget the Indo-Persian aspect but rather focus primarily on Roman
world and try to understand what cult of Mithraism as practiced in Roman world meant
and how it could have influenced the Christianity without getting directly involved in the
authenticity and historicity of Jesus that many believe in. We will leave that in the hands of
Biblical and Catholic scholars who have studied this subject through their entire adult life.
Roman environment. If the Sadducees can be eliminated by the Romans that will help
remove one major obstacle in accomplishing his main objective. This is considered a possible
motive why Josephus wanted to cooperate with Romans and recruited the help of fellow
Pharisee Paul (Saul of Tarsa).
Through the contact with Persian during their ancestors captivity in Babylon, The Pharisees
got acquainted with Mithra worship of Persians well as the cult version of Mithra in Anatolia.
The Pharisees are known to everybody from the New Testament in different light. Once we
get past this accusation or the anti-Pharisee polemic of the gospels. They seem to have been
a scholarly group or a group of Jews who were meticulous observers of the ancestral laws and
strategic in their mission against all kind of adversities. The Pharisees always claimed the
knowledge of the Torah of Moses and the observance of the laws. After the destruction of
the Second Temple in 70 CE, Pharisaic beliefs became the liturgical and ritualistic basis for
Rabbinic Judaism, which ultimately produced the current Judaism . The Pharisees earned
some notoriety by their references in the New Testament to the conflicts between
themselves and John the Baptist. Some Gentiles holds them responsible for John and Jesus
death. The Pharisee thought that in order to accomplish their objective, they had to
collaborate with Romans rather than fight, a slight change in their strategy that Josephus
sieged up on at the right time and it seems like it worked.
The book 2 of Maccabees was likely written by a Pharisee. This work includes several
theological innovations that are found in Christian tradition as a propitiatory prayer for the
dead, judgment day, intercession of saints, and merits of the martyrs. Pharisee believed in
the resurrection of dead. Paul claimed himself to be of Pharisee origin. The first evidence
emerging from the canonical text is that Josephus knew Paul and he was probably his friend
or acquaintance. The writer of the new testaments has identified Saul or Paul of Tarsus as a
Herodian with access to the imperial court. This is a strange statement because he was a
Pharisee by Josephuss account.
According to Philippians 4:22, the reference regarding Saul of Tarsus:
All the saints greet you, especially those of Caesar's household.
In a way this is a remarkable statement as to who made it or who they referred to?. Is this
statement is referring to Paul or Josephus? Paul is said to be executed by Nero along with his
supporters. Josephus statement implies that he saved him in the Rome. Did Josephus
introduced this statement or someone else did? Did Paul acquire the influence with Roman
Caesar?
The Pharisees opponents, of course, were the Sadducees, who were no less pious than the
Pharisees, but the Sadducees did not believe in the authoritative nature of the ancestral laws
(Ezra Law). However, the Sadducees apparently had a great deal of following among the wellto-do aristocrats and wealthy priestly class, and seem to have been characterized primarily by
two things. One, they opposed the Pharisees and two; they denied belief in the resurrection
of the dead. They are the most likely to be dubbed as Herodian by Romans and they did
control the temple during Herods time.
This made the Sadducees famous as we see very clearly in the New Testament passages
where Sadducees vehemently denies the belief in the resurrection. So, it appears to us that
why the Essenes rejected both of these other groups who were competing for power and
influence to control the richest Temple of Asia. During Herod reign, the Pharisees were Jewish
intellectuals and scribes involved in prophesy while Sadducees controlled the Temple wealth
and enjoyed the support of Herod, the Great and were elevated to the priestly class. On the
other hand, the other factions Sircarii and Zealots took their religious understanding as they
understood it and allowed themselves to be manipulated by other sects.
The objective of Pharisee is to serve their own political agenda of controlling the treasure
while destroying Roman power and eliminating their sympathizer and collaborators. The
obvious beneficiaries will be the Pharisee who Josephus and Paul belonged to. Under Roman
oppression the slogan of the rebels was we will kill all collaborators, we will have no King
but only God". Since Sadducees were responsible for upkeep, maintenance and collection of
tribute for the temple and they and their friends formed the aristocratic class of Jewish
society but were judged by rebels and other common Jews as corrupt and collaborator with
Romans. The Sadducees never joined the Jewish rebels.
The Pharisees finally changed themselves to rabbinic form of (modern) Judaism. This brief
history of Jewish history of first century AD is necessary to get comprehensive understanding
of early Christianity and the power politics among various Jewish tribes and how the Judaism
influenced the early history of Christianity.
conversion on the road to Damascus radically changed the course of his life when he became
Christians. This is echoed in Josephuss account and also recorded in Christian canonical texts.
Some Indian historians so easily blame colonial historians that they may have distorted
Indias history. Josephus earned the same distinctive honor by other Jewish historians of
distorting Jewish history. However, it must be said that primary responsibility of keeping the
history of the people lies with the native people themselves.
According to some Jewish historians, they will never kill their own brothers and they do not
take gentiles claim that Jews were responsible for Jesus Crucifixion. The detractor of
Josephus claims that after all he was writing the history of Jews under the sponsorship of
Romans. The question and origination of Christianity gives some credence to the Jewish
arguments and question the authenticity of both Josephus and Pauls account.
Josephus joined the rebellion with Sircalli against Romans and fought alongside with the
rebels during the First JewishRoman War. As as a head of Jewish forces in Galilee he was
captured, when his forces were defeated by Roman General Vespasian and his Tribune son
Titus. The Roman forces captured him and took him to Vespasian. He had learned to
prophesized as a scholar coming from long line of scholarly class. Josephus predicted that
Vespasian will be chosen as the next Roman emperor. At that time, we do not know if
Vespasian took this as a flattery or believed in his power of his prophesy but decided to save
his life and used him as an interpreter and a negotiator. Josephus provided crucial
intelligence that guaranteed the failure of Jewish insurgency against Roman that he admitted
in his own biography.
During the earlier stage of the rebellion, Josephus himself may have proclaimed the Jewish
Messianic prophecies that probably ignited the First Roman-Jewish War. He does not make a
claim in his biography but some of his statements lead us to that conclusion. Josephus kept
promising rebellious Jewish followers that their God had communicated through him that the
next Messiah would come and free the Jewish people from Roman bondage like he did during
first exodus out of Egypt and freedom from Babylonian captivity. This kind of rhetoric may
have contributed to the high morals of Jewish fighters but they had no chance to win
militarily against the Roman. During the Roman seize of Masada, they were forced to commit
the mass suicide when they ran out of food and water. They did not want to bear the
consequences of surrender to Romans for slavery or crucifixion. Those who survived the
revolt ended up in bondage, slavery and subjugation with deep psychological scars that
lingered on for many centuries. This traumatic history of Jewish nation started with the
captivity and exodus from Egypt, followed by Assyrian captivity in Babylon and the first
Roman-Jewish war with Roman occupation of Judah, seventh century AD Muslim aggression
against Jerusalem and rejection in Europe with 20th century of Nazi persecution. This type of
singular experience of persecution is unparalleled in the entire human history. India was the
only country in the world that protected and sheltered the early Jewish immigrants. Their
synagogue and street named after the famous Jewish personality like Prophet Ezra serves as
testimonial to Indias tolerance, love and hospitable nature of Hindu people. To this date,
India can claim that distinction in spite of the Chinese and Islamic hostilities. India remains
the home of venerable holy Dalai Lama of Tibet.
assignments in Judah and Anatolia. When Titus led the Siege of Jerusalem, Josephus was
there and became an eye witness. Titus led assault on Jerusalem led to the city's total
destruction and the looting of Second Temple. Josephus recorded this important phase of
Jewish history, with special emphasis on the first century AD that describes the War with
Roman and the fall of Masada. Due to the imperial sponsorship of his work, it is characterized
as pro-Roman propaganda by some historians.
The Flavian dynasty responded to the threat of Aristocratic Judaism of Sadducees by
promoting more peaceful versions advocated by Josephus that was the combination of:
1. New Rabbinic Judaism within Palestine headed by Pharisee group of priests related to him.
2. The resurgence of the Proto-Christianity of Philo of Alexandria and Anatolia that was the
Sol Invictus (invisible Sun) of revised form of Persian Mithras.
Titus Flavius blessed this strategy and probably sponsored it under the leadership of
Josephus. His brother Domitian continued it as it was becoming more successful and popular
among Romans as well. The Romanized groups of high priest of Pharisees were recruited by
Josephus and were reoriented towards Josephuss strategy. We do not have any definite
evidence of their social gathering or activities. We do have some clues from Josephuss
writing:
It was God's will, Josephus claims. While exonerating his role in the destruction of the
temple, he calls the second temple a material temple that was destroyed by Titus. He exalts
the Jews to build a Spiritual Temple, instead of the material one.
These words certainly can be construed to aim at Roman Jewish Christian ears, not the Jews
of Jerusalem.
There are two additional manuscripts by Josephus wrote that are preserved; Against Apian
way that he finished in 97 AD and his own autobiography- Josephus life, completed two
years later and he died sometime around 102 AD.
The Roman historian Suetonius (69 122 AD) makes reference to those early Christians of first
century AD in his work on Divus Claudius -25 and describes the agitation and revolt by
Roman Jewish community that resulted in expulsion of Jews by Claudius in 49 AD. The
Maniac and Nutty Emperor Nero issued series of edicts and one of that involved the
punishment of Christians around 65 AD. Suetonius describes the Christianity as a heretic and
superstitious. Tacitus and Pliny repeat the same in their history narratives.
Historians debate whether or not the Roman government correctly distinguished between
Christians Jew and Rebellious Jews prior to Nerva's modification of the Fiscus Judaicus in 96
AD. From this point forward, those Roman Jews practicing Judaism paid the tax, while the
Roman Christian Jews did not. This shows a clear distinction between who were pro Romans
Vs. those who were against it. This in turn can be understood as those who worshipped solInvictus vs. Pure Messianic Judaism.
But out of these religious and political conflicts of first century AD, the most important thing
for Roman was the treasure trove of the second temple that can be used to build the Roman
monuments in Rome and that always increased the Roman Emperors power and prestige.
had been the vehicle through which Jewish God had manifested his wrath against his own
chosen people for their deviations of old rules of Abrahams. This also avoids the guessing
game of his potential competitors in Rome who may have ambition to succeed his father
some day.
Construction of coliseum and arc of Titus that were funded from the treasures looted from Jewish Temple.
Consequently, to get rid of the report, Nero fastened the guilt and inflicted the most
exquisite tortures on a class hated for their abominations, called Chrestiani (Some say
Christianity). Chrestus, from whom the name had its origin, suffered the extreme penalty
during the reign of Tiberius at the hands of one of our procurators, Pontius Pilatus, and a
most mischievous superstition, thus checked for the moment, again broke out not only in
Judea, the first source of the evil, but even in Rome, where all things hideous and shameful
from every part of the world find their centre and become popular. Accordingly, an arrest
was first made of all who pleaded guilty; then, upon their information, an immense multitude
was convicted, not so much of the crime of firing the city, as of hatred against mankind".
Here the key words are their centers and hideout probably refers to Mithraism and
Chrestus probably a personal name of rebel who is following this movement. Tacitus must be
in terror of writing any truth that will go against Nero. Tacitus then adds that the most
Romans suspected that Emperor Nero had started the fire himself. To divert attention from
himself, Nero accused the Christians of starting the fire and persecuted them. Tacitus did
suggest that Nero used the Christians as scapegoats. Flavius Clemens got similarly accused as
Christian when Vitellius , Neros henchman learned that his brother Vespasian was
marching towards Rome from Asia to face Vitellius, a Neros agent who was responsible for
setting fire to the Rome. The murdered Clemens was the uncle of future emperor of Titus and
Domitian and brother of Vespasian and follower of Mithra. How this event may have played a
role in advancing sol Invictus as a stepping stone for introduction of the modern Christianity
now becomes obvious. Tituss repel of the Law of Majesta up on assumption of the power
was driven by his uncles killing that was used by Neros henchman.
No original copies of the Tacitus Annals exist and the surviving copies of Tacitus' works derive
from two principal manuscripts, known as the Medicean manuscripts, written in Latin, which
are held in the Laurentian Library in Florence, Italy. It is the second Medicean manuscript
dated to 11th century AD.
The oldest references of Jesus that are found in Josephuss work are called Testimonium
Flavianum.
# 1 reference (Book-18):
At this time there appeared Jesus, a wise man, if indeed one should call him a man. For he
was a doer of startling deeds, a teacher of people who received the truth with pleasure. And
he gained a following both among many Jews and among many of Greek origin. He was the
Messiah. And when Pilate, because of an accusation made by the leading men among us,
condemned him to the cross, those who had loved him previously did not cease to do so. For
he appeared to them on the third day, living again, just as the divine prophets had spoken of
these and countless other wondrous things about him. And up until this very day the tribe of
Christians, named after him, has not died out. (Josephus Flavius, Antiquities of the Jews,
18:63-64).
# 2 references (Book-20):
In book 20, which is the last book, in the form of a subordinate clause concerning the
execution of the brother of Jesus called Christ, whose name was James. So, who was
executed? Jesus or his brother James and Jesus indeed survived ?. This remains the mystery.
The black text in the above looks like the insertion by Christian scribes at a later time working
for Eusebius. The highlighted text in Red appears to be more original text of Josephus as per
some scholars. The argument for and against lies as follows:
A. Did the Josephus himself wrote this in Aramaic Text or it was changed during translation
into Greek and Syrian text when the text was rewritten in the 3rd through 4th century AD ?
B. In addition to that, we have various gospels that are written later and modified several
centuries later by many unknown authors that create the historical sketch of Jesus and his 12
apostles and the birth of Christianity in New Testament. Christianity, as we know it, by
universal recognition is a the creation of St Paul, the Pharisee Jew who was sent to Rome
around 61 AD, where he founded the first Christian community at Rome. The Pauls church is
still there in Rome, Italy. The religion imposed by Paul in Rome was quite different from that
was preached by Jesus in Palestine and put into practice by James the Just, who was
subsequently the leader of the Christian community of Jerusalem by some account. Some say
that was James who was crucified and Jesus escaped. The earlier Christian preaching was in
line with the way of living and thinking of the sect known as the Essenes as described above.
The doctrinal contents of Christianity as shaped at the end of the 1st century AD was
extraordinarily close to those of the sect of the Pharisees, to which Paul and Josephus both
belonged. This suggests the close collaboration between Josephus and Paul. Josephus
realized that only way to spread his version of his version of religion in Rome was to involve
another Pagan cult that was permissible to serve as subterfuge to attach to the principles of
early Christianity. The cult of Mithraism became that vehicle and also was known as solInvictus.
According to the official version, Paul was executed probably in 67 AD by Nero, together with
most of his followers. Josephuss account suggests a different version. Initially, Paul was sent
to Jerusalem so he can be judged by the temple priests. At that time, Josephus was in
Jerusalem trying to free Paul from the temple priests. The head priest Sanhedrin while
judging Pauls preaching accusing him of seditious in nature and against the law. Paul said:
"Brethren, I am a Pharisee, the son of a Pharisee: of the hope and resurrection of the dead I
am called in question". This created a dissension among the judges and at that time,
Josephus or someone working for Josephus who was a high ranking priest and trusted by
Romans rose and said:
"We find no evil in this man: but if a spirit or an angel hath spoken to him, let us not fight
against God.
He ordered the Roman soldiers to set him free and take him away. The apostle Paul was then
handed over to the Roman governor, Felix in Jerusalem, who kept him under arrest for some
time, until he was sent to Rome, together with some other prisoners (Acts 27:1), to be judged
by the emperor Nero, to whom, as a Roman citizen, Paul had appealed. In Rome, he spent
two years in prison (Acts 28:39) before being set free in AD 63 or 64 AD.
Another record of Josephus suggests that after saving him in Jerusalem, he was also able to
save Paul, but not all the followers that included many friends and relatives of his Pharisee
group. In his autobiography (Life, 3.13), Josephus says:
"Between the age of twenty-six and twenty-seven I embarked on a journey to Rome, for the
following reason. During the period when Felix was a governor of Judaea, Felix had sent some
priests to Rome to justify themselves before the emperor (Nero); I knew them to be excellent
people, who had been arrested on insignificant charges. As I desired to devise a plan to save
them, I journeyed to Rome." Somehow, Josephus succeeded in reaching Rome in time, where
he made friends with Aliturus, a Jewish mime that was well appreciated by Nero. Thanks to
Aliturus, he was introduced to Poppaea, the wife of the emperor, and through her influence,
he succeeded in freeing the priests (Life, 3.16). The saved priest was probably Paul. It is
therefore easy to conclude that Josephus went to Rome, at his own personal risk and
expense, specifically to free Paul and his companions, and that it was due to his intervention
that the apostle was released.
Paul and Josephus considered a joint priority to save the Jews from the narrowness of
Judaism of Essence that was advocated by Jesus. Josephus thought by amending that will
make revised version appeal to many and will allow it to make it as a universal religion. This
will link all nations across the entire Roman Empire. They were also in agreement on other
significant points; Their belief in the doctrines of the Pharisees, which were those that were
wholly received by the Roman church, in the Acts of the Apostles, (Acts 22.30).
D. J. Love a Christian Minister, TSN, SBC has this to say on connection between Christianity
and Mithraism:
"The Roman Empire began their official recognition of sun worshipping during the time of
Marcus Aurelian when he instituted the cult of "Sol Invictus". There is virtually no difference
between the cult of Sol Invictus and that of Mithraism or for that matter Catholicism. In the
year 307 AD, Emperor Diocletian, a Sun Worshipper, was involved in the dedication of a
temple to Mithra, and was responsible for the burning of Holy Scripture (which made it
possible for later emperors to formulate Christianity, and thus began the Roman version of
the "Universal Christo-pagan Mystery Religion.". After the rein of Diocletian, the Roman
Emperor Constantine, who was an early Christo-pagan emperor maintained the title
"Pontifus Maximus" the high priest of paganism, and remained a worshipper of Mithra. His
coins were inscribed: "SOL INVICTO COMITI", which is interpreted as "Committed to the
Invincible Sun". During his reign, pagan Sun worship was blended with the worship of the
True Creator (syncretism), and officially titled "Christianity" by the (less than holy) Roman
Empire and its' official church the (less than holy) catholic (universal) church.
the city-state status and full control of Catholic Diocese like a corporation. The Powerful
popes in early history sanctioned the crusades against the Moslems invaders of holy places
and also made a trip to convince Attila, the Hun to spare Rome and return to his own
territory. This power equation can be compared in the same way with Islam, where it is hard
to separate political components of Islam from religious core.
It appears through various analyses and historical accounts that Josephus and Paul played a
significant role in formulating early phase of Christianity.
American bible scholar Joseph Atwill believes that Romans used Christ as propaganda to
pacify the rebellious subjects. He claims that many parallels exist between the story of Titus
Flavius and Jesus Christs missions, meaning both happen to be in same place at same time
probably with Josephus as an eye witness. He also claims that various gospel is the
combination of one continuous story of Jesus. He uses the parallel mythology of Jesus with
sun god Mithra as a borrowed from ancient stories. The common elements in that entire
story of Jesus are Josephus, Paul, Mithra, Jesus and Titus Flavius.
The Indians can compare this to the myth of embryo transfer theory of Jaina Mahavira and
dream theory of Buddha, or birth story of Karna or Krishna of Mahabharata. If Atwills theory
is right, the Christianity did not start out as a religion but more like a pagan cult of Mithra
that was practiced in Asian territories of Imperial Rome. It is hypothesized that when Mithra
cult moved to Rome, it came in Pagan form. The idol of Asian Mithra was replaced with
Apollo of the Greek that was converted to Modern Jesus on the Cross. However, the
Mithraum or temple of worship that was built became an early church where Paul and other
preachers spoke the Jesus life, spread the messages and discuss miracles. The church
activities were centrally controlled by Romans and propagated against rebellious opposition
in occupied territories. The probable sketch of the Flavius Project was based on high
acceptability of son of God- Mithra in Asia Minor and Judah. If the rebellion can be ended in
Asia, then the Northern Germanic Tribes revolts can be dealt with militarily.
The Ionian Geeks also had their own sun god named Attis or Hellos who was the consort
of Phrygian Goddess Cybil (equated as Goddess earth). Flavio Barbiero suggests that
Mithra and Jesus were two sides of the same coin. Flavio Barbiero is a retired admiral in the
Italian Navy and author of the three books. He believes that after the killing of priestly class
of all Sadducees and the sack of second Temple by Titus, the Pharisees got the upper hand
and seized the religious authority over Jews.
In his book Antiquities of Jew, Josephus creates an impression by conceding two basic
The most significant proof of the existence of Mithraism is the coin of first Christian king
Emperor Constantine the Great. He was an affiliate of Sol Invictus Mithras and never
disowned it, not even when he openly embraced Christianity and declared himself to be
"God's servant" and a sort of "Universal Bishop" or Pontifex Maximus.
The biographer Eusebius equated him as the "New Moses", but Constantine was baptized
only on his death bed, and he never stopped minting coins with Mithraic symbols on one side
and Christian on the opposite side (see above). He even erected in Constantinople a colossal
statue of himself wrapped up in Mithraic symbols.
The emperor Constantine believed that Jesus Christ and Sol Invictus Mithras were both
aspects of the same Superior Divinity. He was certainly not the only one to have this
conviction. Tertullian writes that the pagans believe that the Christian God is the Sun,
because it is a well-known fact that we pray turning towards the rising Sun, and that on the
Sun's day we give ourselves to jubilation." (Tertullian, Ad Nationes 1, 13). Tertullian attempts
to justify this substantial commonality between Christianity and Mithraism in the eyes of the
faithful Christian.
If Atwills discovery and Barbieros analysis is correct then the Romans invented the whole
story with Josephuss assistance with commonality of mutual interest. It is always a
possibility that after Roman received the limited cooperation from Josephus and Paul, the
Roman scribes may have altered the Josephuss early text. Atwill, a biblical scholar is
expected to present his finding at the next conference in London in October 2013 but he is
going to do it in a way that does not hurt Christians belief and values. He likes to draw a
parallel that why the government does the things that alters the truth hoping that it will
result in common good but sometimes gets unintended outcomes.
Atwill claims that he found many striking similarities between Titus Flavius military campaign
stops and Jesus Christs appearance at various places of his mission in gospels that led him to
the conclusion that this is no coincidence of occurrences. He made this discovery while
studying the ancient text of first century AD historian Josephuss work along with various
gospels
.
The Phrygian Goddess Cybele is described as Kubeleyan Mother and equated as the earth
Goddess. In India, Laxmi Kubera is also described as earth Goddess along with Ram-Sita and
Rama of Ramayana came from solar race and was an incarnation of Sun-God. These
similarities in belief system are still present among all Indo-European people in one form or
another.
On some coins of the fourth century AD, the Christian banner at the top reads "Sol Invictus."
A large part of the Roman population believed that Christianity and the worship of the sun
were closely connected, if not necessarily the same.
Jesus was often called by the name Sol Justitiae, (Sun of Justice) and was represented by
statues that were similar to the young Apollo. This way it became the bridge between
Mithraism and Christianity in their own iconic depiction.
Once Christianity was legitimized by Great Constantine in the Roman Empire, the Romans
(both Jews and Gentiles) kept on worshipping both the Sun and Christ. Pope Innocentius
authorized the resumption of ceremonies in honor of the Sun in 410 AD, hoping that it will
save Rome from the sacks from the Visigoths. Pope Leo the Great similarly wrote in 460 AD
that the most Christians, when entering St Peters church must first turn towards the sun and
bow in its honor. The bishop of Troy openly continued to profess his worship of the sun even
during his episcopate.
Atwill believes when Romans exhausted all their efforts to suppress the rebellious province
of Judah, they created Jesus through Josephuss work followed by various gospels by Paul, a
collaborator. Since Jews were led to believe that the savior or Messiah is about to arrive to
free them of the bondage from Roman. This judgmental advice was probably rendered to
Roman by the Josephus. Romans concluded that best way to counter this is through a reverse
program of sol Invictus. Their hope was to counter zealous missionary activities of rebels by
introducing peaceful missionary activities with Proto-Christianity. Atwill concludes as many
other scholars have observed in the past this missing link of Josephus and Apostle Paul to
Christianity. Atwill have now matched the dates and sequence of events surrounding Jesus
with Josephus and Titus.
Beth Alpha synagogue, with the sun in the centre, surrounded by the twelve zodiac constellations and
with the four seasons-located at Gilboa Mountains near Beit She'an, Israel.
Roman Imperial-3rd cent. Christian Emperor Constantine with Mitra Mosaic of Christ as Sol Invictus
rd
Under necropolis at St.peters Basilica
Sol Invictus Pessinus
3 century AD- Sol Invictus
Two important places of reference: Emesa (Syria) for Aurelian emperors. Edessa in Armenia-St. Thomas of India
His younger daughter Julia Domna was not married. Severus and Domna, married thereafter.
Domna bore Severus two sons. Lucius Septimius Bassianus (Caracalla- 188- 217AD) and
Publius Septimius Geta (189- 211 AD). Caracalla and Geta would become future Roman
Emperors and heirs to their father. These lines of emperors made Sol Invictus invisible sun
more visible and official by including them in their coinage. This was one of the official
introductions of sol Invictus or Mithra to the Roman that was practiced behind closed door.
The wives and Children of cross cultural marriage play an important role in this religious
introduction and diversification especially with the help of sympathetic emperors.
Caracalla was of mixed Berber and Syrian descent and was called Marcus Aurelius Severus.
Geta emerged as Publius Septimius but involved in assassinating his brother at Emesa.
Elagabalus who followed was also a Berber-Syrian and was known in Roman history as
Marcus Aurelius Antonius. This Marcus was the cousin of the first Marcus Aurelius who was
assassinated. After defeating the usurper Publius, he decreed and made Sol Invictus
(Elagabalus) of Emesa, the major Roman religion. He himself assumed the title of Pontifex
Maximus and presided over the ceremony. In spite of his effort, his downfall is attributed to
his eccentricity and sexual scandals.
http://www.livius.org/jo-jz/julia/julia_maesa.html
Julia Maesa was born on 7 May of an unknown year. Because her first daughter was born
in 180 AD, and Roman girls typically married at the age of fifteen, she may have been born in
165 AD or a few years earlier. Her father was Julius Bassianus, the high priest of the sun god
Elagabalus of Emesa, a holy city in Syria. Maesa married to a Roman knight named Gaius
Julius Avitus Alexianus. The couple had two daughters, Julia Soaemias (born180 AD) and Julia
Mamaea, who was a bit younger. The Roman emperor Aurelius (Caracalla) was the first
Roman emperor a statesman and intelligent, scholarly wise man and worshipped the cult of
Mithra due to his familys affiliation. This cult was already popular in Syria and known as the
cult of Elagabalus. The Elagabalus meant Sun God of the mountain and the statue was
brought to Rome and combined to gather that became sol invective (invisible Sun) of the
Roman Empire.
Caracalla (nickname) renamed himself as an Emperor Aurelius and Geta (nickname) as Publius Severus, and
Heliogabalus was Elagabalus or second Marcus Aurelius. (Both names are suggestive of sun-Greek-Helios and
Syrian- Elagabalus.
We also know that the many early Roman Emperor starting from Augustus equated them
with the God. The main guiding principle was to establish their authority as ultimate and
unchallengeable by the people they ruled. Unquestionably, Julius Cesar may have learned
that from the Egyptians history on how Pharos ruled and maintained their authority.
i
Roman Aureus depicting Elagabalus. The reverse reads Sanct Deo Soli Elagabal (To the Holy Sun God Elagabal),
and depicts a four-horse, gold chariot carrying the holy stone of the Emesa temple. The silver coin in the right
shows the coin of Coin of Emperor Probus, circa 280, with Sol Invictus riding a quadriga, with legend SOLI
INVICTO, "to the Unconquered Sun": the Emperor (at left) wears a radiated solar crown, worn also by the god.
After Aurelian, the next coin appeared under Christian emperor Constantine who worshipped
Christianity and Mithraism. Some say, Constantine was baptized as Christians at his death
bed. Falvio Barberio claims that the formal introduction of Mithra cult was introduced in
Rome around early third century AD. by Flavius dynasty.
A gold multiple of "Unconquered Constantine" with Sol Invictus, struck in 313. The use of Sol's image appealed
to both the educated citizens of Gaul, who would recognize in it Apollo's patronage of Augustus and the arts;
and to Christians, who found solar monotheism less objectionable than the traditional pagan pantheon. On the
right mural indicate a Dedication made by a priest of Jupiter Dolichenus to Sol Invictus and the Genius of the
military unit equites singulars
The Roman emperors after the end of Julio-Claudian dynasty came from the Roman
equestrian order that means coming from Military order of Plebeian. One important element
of The Roman equestrian order was ("Order of Mounted knights"), similar to the mythical
order of King Arthurs Knights of The round Table.. They constituted equestrian order
ranking below the original patricians (Roman Patricii), a hereditary caste that monopolized
political power during the early era of the republic. The non-patricians (plebeians) also have
become the people of mixed origin due to their long military careers overseas. This can be
easily compared to Indian Vedic Kshatriya and Vrtya Kshatriyas of the later period or
Agnivansh Kshatriyas. A member of the equestrian order was known as an Eques
(equivalent to Sanskrit-Asva) meaning horse mounted they occupied the Praetorian
Guards ranks during Vespasians time and therefore became the second order of roman
aristocrats. Domitilla, the Elder was the wife of the Roman Emperor Vespasian. She was a
daughter of Flavius Liberalis, a humble Roman clerk. Before her marriage, she was a formal
mistress to an African Roman knight of equestrian order. She was the mother of Titus Flavius
Caesar. Titus was a military commander and tactician, serving under his father in Judaea
during the First Jewish-Roman War and associate of Josephus.
The last book of the New Testament is commonly known today as the "Book of Revelation"
or "The Revelation by John". The traditional date for the Book of Revelation is towards the
end of the reign of Domitian Flavius. The Revelation was written against the background of
the administration of the Fiscus Judaicus under Domitian. This will further support the
majority opinion about the date for this book, towards the end of Domitians reign.
The different punishments for Christians that can be found in this apocalyptic book
(imprisonment, banishment and execution) clearly point in the direction of the Fiscus
Judaicus and the distinction it made between Jewish people practicing Judaism and Jewish
Christians who followed sol-Invictus. This distinction is also very present in the letters to the
seven churches in Rev. 2 and 3, and also in the vision in Rev. 7 about the 144 000 and the
innumerable multitude. Both in the seven letters and in the vision, as mentioned above, a
clear distance between Christian communities that included Jewish Christians and
mainstream Judaism can be detected.
There are more words of praise by Aconia Fabia Paulina, the wife of Vettius for 40 years and
one noteworthy comment she makes is very revealing and compatible with Persian Mithra.
There were blood sacrifices consistent with Mithras bull mythology of pagan worship. Julia
confirms through the above inscription that the blood sacrifices such as the Taurobolium
(as portrayed in TV series Spartacus and Rome were all secret and nocturnal rituals within the
church. Within a decade of his death, all places of pagan worship would be closed and
replaced with Christianity. Same parallels are drawn with rituals of Indo-Persian. All Parthian
emperors were crowned by House of Suren with blood Ceremony.( Gonophores (One of the
alleged Magi) belonged to House of Suren). Sisodiya Rana also performed the blood rituals at
the inauguration with same blood rituals that they observed from Guhilot and Maitraka of
Saurashtra.
Archeologically, The Mithraeum of the Seven Spheres seems to have been excavated for the
first time by Petrini, in the years 1802-1804. Four inscriptions were found:
He was the last pagan head of the church of Mithra ritual. Timothy Frake in his article The
Jesus Mysteries writes that at the site of Vatican, there once stood the Temples of Sun God
Attis and Goddess Cybele along with Mithraum where sacrifice to of the bull were made and
a piece of sacrifice along with blood was offered to devotees after the sermon. In the present
catholic church communion, these two symbolic items are replaced as bread of Christ with a
little sip of red wine replacing the ancient offering of bull meat and blood at the ceremony.
"He who will not eat of my body and drink of my blood, so that he will be made one with me
and I with him the same shall not know salvation."
At the heart of these mysteries, there is a good reason to believe the hands of brilliant
Josephus who knew many eastern and Asian cultures where similarities of the beliefs
persisted and it is not too difficult to create a mythology for the Prophet hungry masses
who were waiting for centuries for the arrival of another messiahs.
The satirist Celsus observed that the new religion was nothing more than a pale reflection of
their own ancient teachings of Greeks. Early bishops like Justin Martyr, Tertullian and
Irenaeus, were very disturbed and blamed these similarities were the result of 'diabolical
mimicry'. Other absurd arguments ever advocated was none other than the Devil made us to
do this or in a kinder word of 'plagiarism by anticipation'.
Eusebius of Caesarea & Pamphili was a Roman historian and Christian scholars. He was
appointed as the Bishop of Caesarea in Palestine during 314 AD. He wrote early several
Christian works. The suspicion of alteration of the Josephus text falls on the shoulder of
Eusebius. A copy of the original Hebrew Version of the Gospel of Matityahu (Josephus), and
many of Origen's own writings, the marginal comments in extant manuscripts note that
Eusebius, Pamphilus and his friends and pupils corrected and revised much of the biblical text
in their library that has become the source of current canonical texts. Eusebius was the
person who baptized the Great Constantine at his death bed and became the favored christen
Bishop of the Constantine, the Great.
There are many dissenters and atheists who question the subject of the relationship of Jesus
and Mithra cites several examples of those who offered proof were viciously refuted or
murdered as an anti-Christ pagans.
Acharya S/D.M. Murdock in their articles on The origin of Christianity and mysteries of
Jesus present some historical evidence that:
the various Christians themselves have disclosed the myth founded upon more ancient
deities located throughout the known ancient world. Some of the "great" Church fathers,
such as historian Eusebius (c. 263-339), were determined by their own peers to be
unbelievable liars committing Pious fraud ,who regularly wrote their own fictions of what
"the Lord" said and did during his alleged sojourn upon the earth. According to renowned
historian Edward Gibbon, in one of his works, Evangelical Preparation. Eusebius provides a
handy chapter entitled, "How it may be lawful and fitting to use falsehood as a medicine, and
for the benefit of those who want to be deceived. Wheless calls Church fathers Justin Martyr
(c. 100-c. 165), Eusebius and Tertullian (c. 160c. 220) "three luminous liars, while Bronson
Keeler concludes that the early Christian fathers were extremely ignorant and superstitious;
and they were singularly incompetent to deal with the supernatural myths. In addition, of
the dozens of gospels, those once considered canonical or genuine were later rejected as
"apocryphal" or spurious, and vice versa. Illustrating this contention, in his play from 1564
AD, Bishop of Ossory, appears to be suggesting that Pope Leo X (1475-1521AD) was privy to
the truth based on his high rank, when the bishop recounts an alleged exchange between
Cardinal and Pope regarding the false hood.
The son of God or reincarnation of God existed in many ancient religions and this should not
be any surprise. Acharya S/D.M. Murdock finds similarity in myths, biographies , stories and
tradition that parallel Christianity.
1. Adad of Assyria
2. Adonis, Apollo and Zeus of Greece Agni of India
3. Alcides/Hercules of Thebes Attis of Phrygia
4. Baal of Phoenicia Bali of Afghanistan33
5. Buddha/Beddhu of India, China and Japan
6. Deva Tat (Buddha) of Siam34 Hesus of the Druids
7. Horus, Osiris, and Serapis of Egypt35 Indra of Tibet/India
8. Jao/Iao of Nepal Krishna of India
9. The Mikado of the Shintos Mithra of Persia
10, Odin of the Scandinavians Prometheus of Caucasus/Greece
11. Quetzalcoatl of Mexico Salivahana of Burma 36
12. Tammuz of Syria or Elagobalus
14. Thor of the Gauls
15. Universal Monarch of the Sibyls Wittoba of the Bilingonese
16. Xamolxis/Zamolxis of Thrace Zarathustra/Zoroaster of Persia
17. Mahavira and other Jaina Tirthankaras
References:
1. Peterson, Joseph H. (June 4, 2003), Angels in Zoroastrianism, Herndon: avesta.org
2. Boyce, Mary (1983), "Ama Spnta", Encyclopedia Iranica 1, New York: Rutledge & Kegan
Paul.
3. Boyce, Mary (1969), "On Mithrass Part in Zoroastrianism", Bulletin of the School of
Oriental and African Studies
22. Anonymous. The Existence of Christ Disproved. Private Printing by "A German Jew," 1840.
23. Badiozamani, Badi. Iran and America: Rekindling a Lost Love. California: East-West
Understanding Press, 2005.
24. Beck, Roger. Beck on Mithraism. England/Vermont: Ashgate Pub., 2004.
25. Berry, Gerald. Religions of the World. New York: Barnes & Noble, 1955.
26. Bleeker, Claas J. The Sacred Bridge: Researches into the Nature and Structure of Religion.
Leiden: E.J. Brill, 1963.
27. Boyce, Mary. "Mithraism: Mithra Khsathrapati and his brother Ahura."
28. www.iranchamber.com/religions/articles/mithra_khsathrapati_ahura.php
A History of Zoroastrianism, II. Leiden/Kln: E.J. Brill, 1982.
29. Campbell, LeRoy A. Mithraic Iconography and Ideology. Leiden: E.J. Brill, 1968.
de Jong, Albert. Traditions of the Magi: Zoroastrianism in Greek and Latin Literature.
30. Frazer, James G. The Worship of Nature, I. London: Macmillan, 1926.
31. Gordon, Richard L. "FAQ." Electronic Journal of Mithraic Studies,
www.hums.canterbury.ac.nz/clas/ejms/faq.htm
32. Molnar, Michael R. The Star of Bethlehem: The Legacy of the Magi. New Jersey: Rutgers
University Press, 1999.
32. Plutarch. "Life of Pompey." The Parallel Lives by Plutarch, V. Loeb, 1917;
33. Prajnanananda, Swami. Christ the Savior and Christ Myth. Calcutta: Ramakrishna
Vedanta Math, 1984.
34. Robert, Alexander, and James Donaldson, eds. Ante-Nicene Christian Library, XVIII: The
Clementine Homilies. Edinburgh: T&T Clark, 1870.
35. Weigall, Arthur, The Paganism in Our Christianity. London: Thames & Hudson, 1923.
36. http://www.york-united-kingdom.co.uk/constantine/
37. http://natzrim.blogspot.com/2010_08_01_archive.html
38. http://skookumpete.com/Praetextatus.htm
39. http://www.tertullian.org/rpearse/mithras/display.php?page=cimrm420
40. Cameron, Alan. The Last Pagans of Rome. Oxford University Press, 2011, ISBN 978-0-19974727-6.
41. Jesus Mysteries by Timothy Freke : www.jesusmysteries.demon.co.uk
42. The Origins of Christianity and the Quest for the Historical Jesus Christ,
By Acharya S/D.M. Murdock: stellarhousepublishing