Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Spring 2015
List of Experiments
1.
Multi-stage Distillation
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
1) Multi-stage Distillation
A. Background
The separation of mixtures into essentially pure components is of central importance in the
manufacture of chemicals. Much of the equipment in the average chemical plant has the purpose
of purifying raw materials, intermediates, and products by multiphase mass transfer operations.
The laboratory utilizes a 21-stage Oldershaw distillation column that can be operated with
continuous feed or with total reflux.
B. Objectives
To operate a laboratory scale, multi-stage distillation column and to reconcile its performance
with expectations based on the operating variables. You will explore the operating envelope for
the column and to integrate the use of CHEMCAD simulator with the operation of the column in
order to evaluate the performance.
C. Experimental Apparatus
The laboratory utilizes a modified Oldershaw column. It has been equipped with appropriate
sensors and control elements for semi-automatic operation. The column is controlled and data is
acquired using the Camile system.
The reboiler counts as the 1st tray, there are 10 stages between the reboiler and feed, and another
10 stages above the feed for a total of 21 trays. The overall process is as follows: Feed is
pumped at a specified power setting from the blue feed container through an electrical resistance
preheater into the column at stage 11. At the top of the column, the overhead vapor is condensed
in a cooling water condenser. The reflux ratio is set on the Camile, reflux drips directly back
into the column, product drips to a volumetric cylinder for measurement. The reboiler is a 200
mL three necked flask heated by a 470 W electric mantle (note that most of the heat from the
mantle is lost to the atmosphere). The bottoms product can be pumped out of the reboiler
through a water-cooled condenser to the collection point. Liquid samples are analyzed using a
refractometer.
Instrumentation for the column is interfaced with the CAMILE and consists of two pumps (feed
and bottoms), bottoms pressure, several temperature measurements, feed and reboiler heaters,
and reflux ratio.
D. Operation
Starting Out
This initializes the Camile application.
1. Press the <run> button on the menu bar.
2. Press <control key> and the blue <startup> button on the Camile.
3. If you ever have to stop running the column quickly, press <control key> and the red
<emergency shutdown> button on the Camile.
Calibrations
1. Pump Calibration
a. Initially run the pump at 100% power for several minutes to ensure the pump is
properly primed.
b. Calibrate the feed and bottoms pumps by sending the flow to the appropriate
volumetric cylinder.
c. Place a well-labeled copy of your calibration spreadsheet in the Data folder for
use by other groups. Be sure to list units and include plots. Have four equations
listed:
1)
feed power setting given the feed flow rate.
2)
Feed flow rate given the feed power setting.
3)
Bottoms power setting given the bottoms flow rate.
4)
Bottoms flow rate given the bottoms power setting.
d. Check your calibrations by setting a pump output, then comparing your measured
results with the calibration.
e. Use the calibration for estimating flow rates and power settings - during normal
operation you must measure the flow rate used.
2. Temperature Calibration
a. Assume the temperature calibrations are correct.
3. Index of refraction
a. The first group should measure the index of refraction of various mixtures of
methanol and IPA.
1)
Measurements should be made by mass.
2)
Plots must be on a volume% basis. Ideal mixtures are linear only on
a volume% basis.
b. Place a well-labeled copy of your calibration spreadsheet in the Data folder for
use by other groups. Be sure to list units and include plots. Have three equations
listed:
1)
Volume% given the index of refraction.
2)
Mass% given the index of refraction.
3)
Mole% given the index of refraction.
Total Reflux Operation
Once the column is loaded with an appropriate amount of the feed stock, it should not be
necessary to add more stock because all the overhead vapor gets refluxed.
Realize that the relative volatility (VLE information) will govern the compositions of the
distillate and bottoms. Note that during operation, the column will hold roughly 40 mL and the
reboiler will hold roughly 200 mL. If you were to start with 220 mL of IPA and 20 mL of
methanol, the reboiler would likely have no methanol all of which would be in the column.
To the degree that you can depend on the temperatures measurements, you can use these with
Txy data from Chemcad to determine the reboiler and distillate compositions. You can obtain
better accuracy by analyzing samples using the refractometer, but BE WARNED, obtaining
samples during steady-state, total reflux operation will remove a disproportionate amount of the
volatile component and will change the steady state of the system.
exceeds 500 C. If this happens, fix the problem and use the <control><startup> buttons
to restart the experiment.
11. Set the reflux ratio by setting the <diverter on> and <diverter off> to appropriate times
(<diverter on> plus <diverter off> should total roughly 20 seconds).
a. If you used very long times for on and off, the column would cycle between
two steady states.
b. If you use too short of times, the uncertainty in the times would be sufficiently
great as to make the true reflux ratio unknowable.
12. Wait for the column to heat. When distillate starts to form, activate the feed pump for
operation in the 2 10 ml/min range.
13. Set the feed heater power to obtain the desired feed temperature.
14. Keep track of the distillate flow rate. The bottoms flow rate should be set such that
Feed Flow Distillate Flow = Bottoms Flow. Try to keep the liquid in the reboiler at a
constant level. The bottoms flow may require minor adjustments several times during the
experiment. It is preferable to adjust the bottoms flow instead of the feed flow because
changing the bottoms flow does not change the steady state compositions in the column.
15. Record all changes to the flow rates.
16. Once the reboiler level appears to have stabilized (to some extent), monitor the column
temperatures, and liquid composition while approaching steady state. Steady state is
deemed to have been attained when the temperatures and refractometer readings are fairly
steady. Slowly rising temperatures may indicate a leak in the apparatus.
17. Record in the notebook temperatures and refractometer (composition) data during the
approach to steady state. Record every data available in a data file and in the lab
notebook when steady state is deemed to have been attained.
18. If you need help, ask Jon for assistance.
How long does it take to reach steady state?
If you took samples and recorded temperatures at one-minute intervals, you would find their
values to be almost identical but you would not be at steady state. Use the residence time
to guide you in how often to take measurements. The volume of the system is roughly 240
mL. If your flow is 6 mL/min, then the residence time is 240 mL/ (6 ml/min) = 40 minutes.
Therefore, 20 - 40 minutes between measurements would be more appropriate. As a ballpark
estimate, it will take 3-5 residence times to reach steady state (assuming you do nothing to
upset the approach to steady state).
Other notes
1. During start up, the user needs to monitor the system to ensure that it is behaving as
expected. For example:
Is the feed being heated to the set point temperature (Refer to the section control
loop configurations)?
Is the reboiler liquid level held at a reasonable level? This can be achieved by
small manual changes in the bottoms flow rate.
Is the heating mantle functioning flawlessly?
Is the reflux temperature steady at the set point (Refer to the section control loop
configurations)?
Are the feed stage temperature and other temperatures along the column
approaching expected or set values?
2. When ready to change operating conditions, ask Jon if you require assistance. Some
operating parameters that can be changed are feed compositions (the feed pump will have
to be shut down for a few seconds to change the stock), reflux ratio, feed flow rate, and
reboiler duty.
3. When ready to shut down, <control> <emergency shutdown> buttons.
E. Dos and Donts
1. DO NOT LET THE REBOILER RUN DRY. If the reboiler is close to running dry,
turn off the heater and the bottoms pump.
2. Do not leave the feed heater on for long periods when there is no feed flow (there is no
feed flow during calibration and sampling).
3. Pay attention to your operating parameters - determine what you expect to happen.
Except for some safety items, there are no whistles that will alert you that you are
running the apparatus incorrectly or that the apparatus has a "problem." You are the
operating, you determine if there is a problem, then take appropriate action.
F. Safety
1. Wear safety glasses at all times. Wear gloves when taking samples.
2. In this experiment, methanol and isopropanol are used. Both substances are toxic and
flammable. Review the MSDS sheets for these substances located in the CPE-626 folder
on the world drive. If the chemicals get on you, use the eyewash or shower. In case of
fire, use the fire extinguisher.
3. Do not let the reboiler run dry! If the reboiler is close to running dry, turn off the
heater and the bottoms pump.
4. Do not leave the feed heater on for long periods when there is no feed flow (there is no
feed flow during calibration and sampling).
5. Turn on the hood.
6. Guard against falls, burns, cuts, and other physical hazards.
7. Think of safety in any action you take. If not certain, ask a faculty member before you
act.
8. The experiment is protected with ground fault breakers to help prevent electrocution.
Care should always be taken when combining electricity with water.
0 F C dt M
(2.1)
M C0 V
(2.2)
F C dt
1
C0 V
(2.3)
where:
C = salt concentration (g/l) = constant*conductivity
C0= salt concentration that would be achieved at time zero if mixing were ideal (g/l)
F = flow rate (l/min)
t = time (min)
M = mass of salt introduced to tank (g)
V = tank volume (l)
II
ln C/C0
Slope =
C/C0
extrapolate
tF/V
t F/V
III
C/C0
Back calculated
from
extrapolation
t F/V
Figure 2.1: Procedure for integrating elution profile
I: plot of concentration in dimensionless time
II: plot of log concentration in dimensionless time
Extrapolate for longer periods of time
III: plot of concentration using original data plus extrapolated profile
If your value for F/V is correct, then integrating equation 3 should yield a value of 1. If your
value is not 1, then your value for F/V is incorrect. See Jon if there is a problem.
You are now ready to analyze your experimental data. The experimental response curve (for
example Figure 1-II) can be described by
T F/V
ln
C
tF
F
C0
V
V
Case
Perfect mixing
plug flow
dead space
bypassing
error in F/V
system lag
1
>1
>1
<1
<,>
1
1
(2.4)
F/V
0
>0
0
<0
0
0
Where:
effects
NOTE: If you place the wooden meter stick on the flat ring above the drain tube:
V = H*1.6573+1.5775
where:
H = height of water surface (cm)
V = volume (L)
F. Dos and Donts
1. Care should be taken that the initial concentration of salt in the tank (not the
concentration of salt in the solution added to the tank, which will of course be much
higher) does not exceed the level of linearity with conductivity.
2. Do not put salt in the tank without first dissolving it. This will lead to solid salt falling
into the drain, altering the conductivity measurement.
3. The analysis above is just one of many ways of analyzing mixing - find some other ways
from the literature.
4. For the Step Change experiment, the trick will be to make sure that the water level does
not change after the flow is commenced. Think of ways to ensure the water level stays
constant.
G. Safety
1. Wear sturdy shoes suitable for a possibly wet and slippery floor.
2. The experiment is protected with ground fault breakers to help prevent electrocution. Care
should always be taken when combining electricity with water.
H. References:
D. Operation
Operating Guidelines - Calibration
1. Calibrate the flow meter.
a. Remove all outlets to tank A, which will act as the bucket
A
B
b. Place the PID controller for the valve in manual.
c. Set the "valve closed" position to some value.
d. Send flow to the top of tank A (sending to the top of the tank instead of the
bottom, provides a steady flow).
e. Measure the flow by noting the rate at which the tank fills.
f. Measure a variety of flows to create a trend line.
g. The maximum "valve open" position is 60%, after which the flow is nonlinear.
2. Calibrate the pressure transducer tank levels.
a. Use the outlet valves in conjunction with the pump to fill the tanks to a variety of
levels. Note the strategically located sight glasses.
3. Now it is time to have fun!!!
C
Operating Guidelines - Tuning
From your control book, you will find a variety of tuning methods. One method is described on
p. 8-18 of Perrys:
1. Set the PID controller for the valve to manual.
2. Set the "valve closed" position to some value.
a. Obtain a steady state level.
b. Note that it can take an inordinate amount of time for the level to steady. Open or
Control
close the valve leading
to theValve
pressure transducer to speed the process.
3. When the level is steady, start logging to obtain a two-minute baseline. Use a 20 s
logging interval.
4. Change the "valve closed" positionFlow
and wait for the new steady state.
meter
5. For estimating the various time constants, you will need to know the time at which the 2nd
derivative of height with respect to time is zero the inflection point. You could plot
height with time and eyeball the time of the inflection point - this is not sufficiently
accurate. Instead, plot d(height)/d(time) or [height(t=i+1) height(t=i-1)]/(2t) vs.
time. The time of the inflection point will be at the peak of this plot. The maximum of
the plot is the slope of the tangent at the inflection point.
6. Make a plot of the level vs. time. Include the tangent at the inflection point (from step 5).
7. Mathematically calculate the intercept of the tangent to the baseline. This is .
8. Mathematically calculate the time for the tuning curve to reach a 0.63 change in the level.
This is .
Figure 3.1: Liquid Level Control Apparatus
9.
Ensure
that the
plot site
fromgauges,
step 6 jibes
with the values
not shown are
secondary
drains,
and overflow
lines. obtained mathematically in steps 7
andshows
8.
This schematic
the physical tank locations relative to each other.
10.
Calculate
P, i, andthat
d from
8-3 ofofPerrys.
For your report, it is suggested
you table
omit parts
the above diagram not used
Operating Guidelines - Changing Set points
1. Set the PID controller to automatic.
2. Set the set point to the initial value of the level used during the tuning procedure.
3. Let the level steady.
4. Log using 10 - 20 s intervals. Obtain a baseline.
5.
6.
7.
8.
F. References
1. Ogunnaike, B. A. and W. H. Ray, Process Dynamics, Modeling and Control, Oxford
University Press, 1994.
2. Perry, J.H., Editor, Chemical Engineers Handbook, 8th Edition, McGraw Hill Book
Company, pp. 8: 18-19 (2008).
A. Background
The non-steady-state heating and cooling of process tanks is an important task in many areas of
chemical engineering. The experimental apparatus permits the cooling of a hot water tank using
a jacket or a coil through which cooling water flows.
B. Objectives
To determine the functionality of coolant flow rate, stirrer speed, and baffles on transient heat
transfer coefficients.
C. Experimental Apparatus
The apparatus consists of a stirred tank fitted with a cooling jacket and with internal cooling
coils. Measured variables include coolant water flow rate, tank temperature, and inlet and outlet
coolant temperatures. A baffle is also available.
D. Operation
Operating Guidelines - Calibration
1.
The flow has been calibrated previously; however, perform a check of the flow
calibration. Be sure to record the check in your notebook and in your report.
2.
Calibrate the stirrer speed using the manual tachometer.
a. Create a spreadsheet to calculate rpm given dial indication and vice versa
b. Place a well-labeled copy of this spreadsheet in the Data folder for use by other
groups.
Operating Guidelines - Experiments
1. Fill a beaker with roughly 1.8 L of hot water from the tap. Further heat the water in the
microwave oven to about 70 - 80C.
2. While the water for the tank is heating, have cooling water flowing to the jacket or coil
heat exchanger.
a. This is to prevent cooling of the inlet during the experiment.
3. Begin logging using 20 s intervals.
4. Momentarily stop cooling water flow.
a. This is to keep the tank water as hot as possible until the apparatus is completely
prepared.
5. Weigh the hot water, then add to the tank.
6. Install the tank cover
7. Position the tank thermister about 1 cm above the bottom of the tank.
8. Set the stirrer at the desired rotational speed.
9. Restart the cooling water flow.
10. Start heating the next beaker of hot water.
11. Stop the experiment when the difference between the inlet and outlet temperatures is
around 2 - 3 C.
12. Analyze your data immediately.
The refractometer should already have been on for 30 minutes with a setpoint
temperature of 20C
If the refractometer is not already on, turn the instrument using the power switch on
the back. Wait for 30 minutes before proceeding to the next step
If the temperature is other than 20C, press <SETUP> and scroll the temperature
setpoint to 20C
c. From the index of refraction, obtain the volume%, mass%, and mol%.
7. Determine the moles of each component in the arm, then by subtracting this from the
total moles, determine the moles of each component in the still.
8. Subtract out the sample removed from the amount of each component in the entire
inventory.
9. Add enough of the second component to the still to increase its percentage by about 10%,
update the inventory, and continue with steps 3 - 9.
10. Stop when you have roughly a 50% mixture. Drain the still and start from the other side
of the Txy diagram.
11. Important note: Any errors you make to the inventory will be additive to previous errors.
Waste Materials: At the end of the experiment you will have a fair amount of waste. Pour these
into the steel safety can provided.
E. Safety
1. You must always use safety gloves when handling any liquid samples.
2. Breakage be careful. Do not try to pick up the still. Dont move heavy hard objects
near it.
3. Do not let the still run dry.
4. Do not plug in the heater until fluid covers the coils. If you do, the coils will
instantaneously turn red hot and melt.
5. Make sure you know where the fire extinguisher is and how to use it.
6. Note the location of the safety shower.
7. Avoid breathing the vapors of solvents.
8. Review the MSDS sheets for the substances used see Jon if you cannot find this
information
9. The experiment is protected with ground fault breakers to help prevent electrocution.
Care should always be taken when combining electricity with water.
VLE data for combinations of chemicals: It is interesting to vary the ending group of one of
the chemicals used to see the effect on your Txy diagram. For example
Water - methanol
Water - ethanol
Water - 1-propanol
Or
Methanol 1-propanol
Methanol 2-propanol
Etc.
Figure that you have time to do a maximum of two to three sets of chemicals. You can also
coordinate with groups in other lab sections to get more sets of chemicals
On the following pages you can see some possibilities. Note that not all chemicals form
solutions (for example, you wouldnt want to use butanol-water as one of your combinations)
Methanol
BP = 65 C
IR = 1.3314
ethanol
BP = 78 C
IR=1.3616
1-propanol
BP = 97 C
IR=1.387
1-butanol
BP = 118 C
IR=1.3993
1-butanol
BP = 97 C
IR=1.387
2-butanol
BP = 118 C
IR=1.3993
1-propanol
BP = 97 C
IR=1.387
2-propanol
BP = 82 C
IR=1.3776
methyl acetate
BP = 57 C
IR=1.361
Ethyl acetate
BP = 77 C
IR=1.372
n-propyl acetate
BP = 102 C
IR=1.384
n-butyl acetate
BP = 127
IR=1.3941
methyl acetate
BP = 57 C
IR=1.361
2-butanone
BP = 80 C
IR=1.3788
2-butanol
BP = 118 C
IR=1.3993
acetone
BP = 57 C
IR=1.359
2-butanone
BP = 80 C
IR=1.3788
acetone
BP = 57 C
IR=1.359
2-propanol
BP = 82 C
IR=1.3776
water
BP = 100 C
IR=1.333
H2O
Note: There is frequently a bottleneck caused by inattention to the GC. Do not less the GC
rest.
Operating Guidelines - Experiments
1. Load the reactor from the top with between 0.5 and 2.0 grams of catalyst. The catalyst is
held in place within the reactor by a screen fixed approximately 3 from the bottom.
2. Set the temperature of the coolant bath between -10 and 15 C. Temperatures at the low
end can require an hour of waiting - contact the laboratory supervisor prior to the lab to
have the coolant bath ready for you at the lower temperatures.
a. Do not use bath temperatures higher than 15C because the Gas Chromatograph
response is not linear at higher concentrations.
9. During an experiment, flow can be set between roughly 20-120 sccm and temperature can
be set between 25 and the upper temperature determined during the blank run, in roughly
25C increments.
10. Once steady temperature has been achieved (in roughly 10-30 minutes following each
setting), the exit stream from the reactor is fed into a gas chromatograph.
11. Each sampling takes 10 minutes to be analyzed by the GC.
12. Run the GC repeatedly until you have three consecutive chromatograms with peak areas
that are within 1% of each other.
Table 6.1 provides the GC settings and sample elution times.
Table 6.1: HP 5890 Series 2 Gas Chromatograph Settings
Injector
Temperature 160 C
Column
Temperature 160 C
Detector
Temperature 160 C
Column
Pressure
40 psig
Theory
The reaction of Isopropanol follows two possible routes:
C3H7OH
C3H6O + H2
C3H7OH
C3H6
+ H2O
(6.1)
(6.2)
Follow the development of the plug flow reactor in Example 4-4 of Fogler (1986). Similar to the
example, for each of the above reactions we have two products:
A B+C
(6.3)
Initially, we will consider the two reactions (6.1 and 6.2) to be a single reaction. Our design
equation is:
x dx
V F A0
0 r
A
(6.4)
Note that V is the volume of the catalyst. For our purposes, V is calculated independently:
bulk
(6.5)
where m is the mass of the catalyst and bulk is the bulk density - the density based on both the
catalyst and the void space. You need to measure both these values prior to the experiment.
The rate law is given as:
rA k C A
(6.6)
(6.7)
Isopropanol is assumed to reach saturation in the bubbler prior to the reactor. Use Perrys (Page
2-59, Table 2.8, Entry No. 282) to create a correlation for isopropanol vapor pressure in psia
between -10 and 15C.
You will need to check your results to verify that the expected mole fraction of IPA is the actual
mole fraction. Remember that Camile reports Preact in psig.
y IPA, 0
where:
xtotal
y acet y prop
xtotal (1 y acet y prop )
(6.8)
y acet y prop
y acet y prop y IPA
(6.9)
note that:
x acet
x acet
y acet
y acet
y prop y IPA
(6.10)
y prop
y acet y prop y IPA
(6.11)
FA0
1
xtotal
(1 ) ln
V C A0
1 xtotal
(6.12)
It is noted that the volumetric flow rate, v0 is at reactor temperature and pressure, but the flow is
actually measured upstream of the reactor at STP (1 atm, 0C) before the addition of IPA. Any
complexity is due to the density and therefore the concentration and volumetric flow rate varying
with temperature and pressure till the IPA reaches the reactor.
FIPA, 0
Treact
1atm
v0 v measured (1 y IPA,0 )
C IPA,0
298.15K ( Preact Pamb)
(6.13)
Finally, we end up with:
k total v 0
bulk
1
y A0 xtotal
(1 y A0 ) ln
m
1 xtotal
(6.14)
Using the GC peak areas obtained for each compound, the IPA conversion can be
calculated at each temperature setting. The recorder provides peak areas based on the thermal
conductivities of the gases flowing by the gas chromatograph thermal conductivity conductor. A
given mole fraction of some gas has its own conductivity. Thus, the peak areas must be divided
by a thermal response factor.
Areacorr = Arearecorder/thermal response factor
yield acet
yield prop
(6.15)
y acet
y acet y prop
(6.16)
y prop
y acet y prop
(6.17)
(6.18)
(6.19)
G. Safety
1. In this experiment, compressed air and helium are used. If the tubing is improperly
connected, the pressure will cause the tubing to disconnect from its fitting. The primary
danger is from being hit in the eye with this tubing. It is essential that safety glasses be
worn to prevent this danger.