Professional Documents
Culture Documents
VS.
FACTORAN
FACTS:
1. The
plaintiffs
in
this
case
are
all
minors
duly
represented
by
their
parents.
2. The
complaint
was
filed
as
a
taxpayers
class
suit
against
the
Secretary
of
the
Department
of
Environment
and
Natural
Resources
(DENR)
3. Plaintiffs
alleged
that
they
are
entitled
to
the
natural
resources
treasure
that
is
the
countrys
virgin
tropical
forests
4. They
further
asseverate
that
they
represent
the
generation
as
well
as
the
generations
yet
unborn.
5. And
that
such
continuation
would
result
in
environmental
tragedies.
6. Plaintiffs
prayed
that
judgment
be
rendered
ordering
the
respondent,
his
agents,
representatives,
and
other
persons
acting
in
his
behalf
to
cancel
all
existing
Timber
License
Agreement
(TLA)
in
the
country
and
to
cease
and
desist
from
receiving
or
approving
new
TLAs.
7. Defendant
filed
a
motion
to
dismiss
on
the
ground
that
the
complaint
had
no
cause
of
action
against
him.
8. The
RTC
Judge
sustained
the
motion
to
dismiss.
9. Plaintiff
thus
filed
a
special
civil
action
for
certiorari.
ISSUE:
Whether
or
not
the
plaintiffs
have
a
cause
of
action
RULING:
1. The
complaint
focuses
on
one
fundamental
legal
right-
the
right
to
a
balance
and
healthful
ecology
which
is
incorporated
in
Section
16
Article
II
of
the
Constitution.
2. The
said
right
carries
with
it
the
duty
to
refrain
from
impairing
the
environment