Professional Documents
Culture Documents
LETTERS
$
i~assroomreality
Austin, Tes.
DEARSIRS:I have not read How Children Learn by John
Holt,butChandler
Brossards diatribe [The Childs Style
of Learning, The Nation, Mar. 111 about the degrading
educational experience, especially on theprimary level,
reveals an abysmal lack of acquaintance with pedagogical
reality in this country. As an elementary schoolteacher,
and a teacher of teachers, of forty-three years experience,
in one-room rural schools on through to graduate schools,
here and abroad, I must state that Mr. Brossard is talking
through his hat-and irresponsibly.
Maybe Mr. Holt IS expert enough to be critical I would
want to know his credentials. Mr. Brossard, as a novelist
and author of a forthcoming book on Spain offers not an
iota of qualification for his condemnatlon of elementary
schoolteachers and what goes on in classrooms.
I am tired of upstarts who tell us why Johnny cant read
or, in this case, why the child is systematically disengaged
from his fragile dignity. . . We have empirical evidence
thatJohnny
can and does read, avidly and extensively
Ask the book publishers, or just check the book stores
, .
George I SLi,lchez
andlibraries
the
Mr. Brossard has taught at C. W Post College and Fairleigh Dickinson. His ongoing interest in education has taken
him to the experimental campus of the new StateUnivelsity College,Old Westbury, where he is associate professor
in literatwe and
science.
social
Editols
Seattle, Wash.
DEARSIRS:As an otherwise appreciative reader, I wish to
correct the impression you seem to have of the Boeing
Company as a war profiteer (an opinion I have noticed
two or three times in recent issues).
The Boeing Company does the least defense work of all
aerospace firms, that is, about 40 per cent of its sales for
the past four years have been for the government.
Most of this 40 per cent is unconnected with the Vietnamese War. It includes such work as the Minuteman missile, the Saturn and the SRAM. The only work the Boeing
Company does that is connected with the war is the Chinook
helicopter, which is built by Vertol in Pennsylvania. The
Chinook was conceived as a civilian helicopter, and was
contracted for well before the Vietnamese build-up began.
As you see, the unfortunate opinions of Senators Jacksoy
and Magnuson cannot be attributed to the location of the
Boemg Company. Besides, Rep. Brock Adams, who comes
from a district that iswell described as all Boeing, is not
exactly a flaming hawk.
C. 1. Crawford
abortion law
430
Boeing
.
1
Mi. Johnson made the decision we had repeatedly predicted he would make, and for the reason we had advanced
-the logic of politics left him no alternative. The necessity was twofold: the war in Vietnam, for which he was
primarily responsible in its phase of intervention with U.S.
troops; 'and,asTed
Lewis pointed out in these pages
(January 29), the fact that the Johnson personality itself
had become a factor dividing the country and militating
against his re-election. The news from Texas, as reported
in the Dallas Morning News, that the war and his conduct
of it had lost majority backing even in that most hawkish
of states, must have been the iron that pierced Mr. Johnson's soul.
As for the President's personal make-up, it was hardly
something that he could change, yet he could not but be
aware that it had alienated a very large number-by
all
indications a majority"-of his fellow citizens. Ironically,
even after those traumatic moments when he suddenly
announced his intention not to seek re-election, widespread
skepticism persisted, and many people still are not wholly
assured that he meant' what he said. One of these, for
example, is General Gavin, a soldier of distinguished
achievement who has become wise in the ways of politics
and business after his retirement from the Army. Rep.
Wright Patman, a Johnson supporter, came on the air immediately after the speech to argue that the Democratic
Party would never accept anyone but Mr. Johnson as its
candidate. The President was not responsible for Mr. Patman's reaction, but it is worth noting that Mr. Patman did
not take Mr. Johnson's solemn word as binding.
We do not read the statement that way; we take it at face
value. The question that does trouble us is the validity of
the policy change which the President coupled with his
withdrawal. Had he not announced the latter, the former
would have been of little consequence. One can see it in
perspective by dismissing 'from one's mind the broadcast
presentation and instead reading the text as it appeared in
the early editions of the morning papers. This was the
version the White House released ' to the press before the
President went on the air, and it does not Contain the withdrawal announcement. Without it, the gesture of deescalaaion amounts to no more than a restriction of geographical
area, which for the moment exempts most of the North
Vietnamese population from bombing and in effect makes
Hanoi and Haiphong open cities as long-'and only as long
-as that is the President's pleasure.
In every other respect the Administration's interpretation of history is reiterated without an iota of change:
South Vietnam was invadedbyNorth Vietnam, a total
aggressor: the 'United States intervened, not in a civil war
all Asia from the Red Chinese tyranny
buttoprotect
hovering over the continent; the Vietcong and the North
Vietnamese are solely responsible for
the
devastation
wrought by the Tet offensive, which was-a failure for the
enemy except that(one small concession) it did draw
some ARVN forces back fromthe countryside intothe
cities. The lawfully elected government of South Vietnam
was going to try harder, we' would supply its forces with
better weapons, and stiU another 13,500 American troops
3Ire
rYATIt)N/April15.1968
. +
EDITORIAL
490
ARTICLES
I
Ted Lewis
Theodore Roszak
Michael T . Klaie
Howard Junker
506 Harry Golden
507Caucus for Reality:
The Asian Experts Discover Vietnam
"
D . F . Fleming
David Ray
Paul Rmzen
Lzam Lenfhan
Benjamin Boretz
Stanley Cooperman
Harold Clurman
Robert Hatch
Frank W.Lewis
Publisher
JAMES J STORROW JR.
Associate Publisher
GIFFORD PEIhIP6
Editor
CAREY McWILLIAMS
AssoGIate Editor
Literary
Editor
Executive
ROBERT- HATCE
PHIL K E R n
Editor
HELEN YGLE3X.M
Volltme 206
No. 16
491
What New?
The first duty of contenders for the Presidency-those
now in the race and those who may enter-is to keep the
Administration under constant pressure to seek a peaceful
settlement of the war. The fact that thePresident has
withdrawn from the race creates for him an opportunity to
negotiate that is free of the suspicion that hemight be
using the negotiations for personal political advantage.
This is a net gain. But it would be a mistake to grant
him carte blapche in the conduct of the war and the hanHe is
dling of whatevernegotiationsfinallyshapeup.
entitledtothe
national unitywhichheassertsashis
paramount aim only if he seeks to unite the nation in pursuit of a peaceful settlement at the earliest possible date.
That is what a clear majority clearly wants. If the President moves in this direction, he will need- all the support
he can get. If it comes to negotiations withthe North Vietnamese and the National Liberation Front, the hawks will
be standing invisibly behindour negotiations and making a
r n NATION/
~
Aphl IS, 1968
, ,
493