Professional Documents
Culture Documents
ISBN 98603685 7- 0
9 789860 36857 4
GPN 1010200967
160
101 IOSH101-S322
IOSH101-S322
IOSH101-S322
101 6 101 12
102 4
181
94% API 570
93% API 510
62% API API
570 93% API 510
API 510 API 570
API
1
5
Abstract
Many incidents of fire and explosion in petrochemical and chemical plants in Taiwan
have occurred in recent years. With the aim of effectively reducing such industrial accidents,
this study focused on mechanical equipment integrity and process hazard analysis in process
safety management, created professional training materials, and implemented checklists for
labor inspectors to use in training or self-study. The goal was to enhance the professional
skills of labor inspectors and to effectively help enterprises improve their safety of health
facilities and provide its reference use.
We investigated labor inspectors' needs for the inspection of chemical and
petrochemical plants and surveyed 181 labor inspectors, professionals, and experts. We
found that 94% of the survey respondents thought that API 570 piping inspection knowledge
was required and 93% thought that API 510 pressure vessel inspection knowledge was
necessary for the performance of labor inspections; 62% thought that an API 570 piping
inspection certificate should be required. These results show that the majority of those
surveyed believed that API 510 and API 570 specifications should be among the basic
knowledge required of those implementing chemical plant inspections. Opinions regarding
API certification were inconsistent.
We completed training materials for mechanical integrity and process hazard analysis
for inspector training. Five different checklists were established for mechanical integrity and
process hazard analysis. The results can strengthen the performance of labor inspection and
help petrochemical and chemical industries to improve occupational safety, prevent safety
incidents from happening, and secure workers' welfare.
Key Words: Process safety management, mechanical integrity, process hazard
ii
....................................................................................................................................... i
Abstract .................................................................................................................................... ii
......................................................................................................................................... iii
...................................................................................................................................... v
.................................................................................................................... 1
........................................................................................................................ 1
........................................................................................................................ 1
................................................................................................................ 2
.................................................................................................................... 3
.................................................................................................... 5
........................................................................................................ 6
API ..................................................................................................... 7
.............................................................................. 10
.................................................................................................. 10
.............................................................. 11
...................................................................... 13
...................................................................................... 13
.......................................................................................... 14
...................................................................................................... 19
...................................................................................... 22
.............................................................................................................. 23
...................................................................................................................... 23
...................................................................................................................... 24
........................................................................................................................................ 25
................................................................................................................................ 26
.............................................. 27
iii
.......................................... 28
- .................................................................... 35
- .................................................................... 66
.................................................................. 70
...................................................................................... 75
...................................................................... 85
iv
1 API 510/API 570 ......................................15
2 ...........................................................................17
[2-6]
(Occupational Safety & Health Administration, OSHA)
(American Petroleum Institute, API)
() 2
1.
2.
()
2
() 2
()
[7]
1968 ()
[8]
75
2,500 293.5
66
270,000
(EG)
(VCM)(AN)(SM)(CPL)(PTA)
(PE)(PP)(PVC)(PS)
(PET)(PC)--(ABS)
[9]
[2-6][10-13]
(OSHA)29 CFR 1910.119 (Process Safety
Management, PSM) 14
OSHA 14
[14]OSHA(29 CFR, Part 1910.119)
5
OSHA (Mechanical Integrity, MI)
()
OSHA
OSHA
(What-If)
(Checklist)
/(What-If/Checklist)
(Hazard and Operability Study, HAZOP )
(Failure Mode and Effects Analysis, FMEA)
()(Fault Tree Analysis)
(An Appropriate equivalent methodology)
1 1
API
(American Petroleum Institute, API)
500
2012
2 API
API 570
API 510
150 4 API 50 4
100 107
110 API
API
25
15,000 API 570 API 510
12
7,500
API
2010 10
40 API 140 170 API
API
1 1 API
API API
(OSHA)(API)
(American Society of Mechanical Engineers, ASME)
10
2012
OSHA-Notice-Site Specific Targeting 2011. OSHA - 2011
(API)(ASME)
API 510-Pressure Vessels Inspection Code-2006(70 )
API 570-Piping Inspection Code-2009(78 )
API 571-Damage Mechanism Affecting Fixed
Equipment in the Refinery Industry -2003(49 )
API 572-Inspection Practice of Pressure Vessels-2009(148 )
API 574-Inspection Practice for Piping System
Components-2009(100 ).
API 576-Inspection for Pressure-Relieving Devices-2009(78 )
API 577-Welding Inspection & Metallurgy-2009(112 )
API 578-Material Verification Program for
New and Existing Alloy Piping System-2010(24 )
ASME B16.5-Pipe Flanges and Flanged Fittings-2003(236
)
ASME B31.3-Process Piping-2008(388 )
2007 API 510 ASME Sec. V-Nondestructive
Examination-for API 510-2007(96 )
2007 API 570 ASME Sec. V-Nondestructive
Examination-for API 570-2007(160 )
2009 API 510 ASME Sec. V-Nondestructive
Examination-for API 510-2009 Addenda(40 )
11
12
API
13
30
(Shell)(BP)
//////
/ 30
10
181 61 78
42
API API
API 510 API 570
API API
1
(99%) API API
14
85% API
87% API
API
1 API 510/API 570
API 510
61
0.85
78
0.99
42
0.95
181
0.93
API 510
61
0.42
78
0.68
42
0.74
181
0.60
API 570
61
0.87
78
0.99
42
0.95
181
0.94
API 570
61
0.42
78
0.71
42
0.74
181
0.62
API API
2/3 API 510
API 570 42%
API
15
API
API 570 API 510 74%
OSHA 14 1.2.3.
4.5.6.7.8.
9.10.11.12.13.
14.
2 1.
2.3.4.5.6.7.
8.9.10.11.12.
13.14.
14
12
6 10
11 14
4
16
61
6.05
78
5.17
42
5.60
181
5.56
61
4.58
78
4.08
42
4.83
181
4.42
61
3.52
78
3.95
42
3.55
181
3.71
61
4.70
78
4.81
42
5.74
181
4.99
61
5.49
78
5.06
42
6.05
181
5.44
61
8.31
78
7.96
42
5.93
181
7.60
61
6.70
78
6.76
42
6.07
181
6.74
61
6.93
78
6.41
42
5.74
181
6.42
61
8.43
10
78
7.96
42
8.33
10
181
8.21
10
10
61
7.03
78
8.10
10
42
7.76
181
7.66
11
61
10.9
13
78
11.3
13
42
10.9
13
181
11.1
13
12
61
8.65
11
78
9.36
11
42
9.24
11
181
9.09
11
13
61
10.0
12
78
10.5
12
42
10.6
12
181
10.3
12
14
61
13.1
14
78
13.6
14
42
13.7
14
181
13.5
14
17
PSM
PSM 14
()
()
()
()
()
()
() API
() 6
3
()
()
()
() ASME(NDT)
()
()
18
OSHA (CFR 1910.119 Appendix C Compliance
Guidelines and Recommendations for Process Safety Management)(API)
(ASME)(AIChE)
() /(Construction/Installation)
() (Inspection and Testing)
() (Contractor Management)
() (Material Acquisition, Stores, and Issue)
() (Engineering Design)
() (Fabrication)
() (Repair)
()
() (,)
() ()
()
19
()
()
() (ASME B31.3)
() (ASME VIII)
() (ASME sec.XIAPI 577)
() -
(RBI)
() -
1.(API 570)
2.(API 510)
() -
1.(API 570)
2.(API 510)
() -
(API 578)
()
1.
2.
3.
(1)/
(2)
(3)
20
(4)
4.
(1)
(2)
(3)
5.
(1)
(2)
(3)
()
1. -
2. (Checklist)
3. (What-if)
4. (Hazard and Operability Study, HazOp)
5. (Failure Mode & Effect Analysis, FMEA)
6. ()(Fault Tree Analysis,FTA)
7. ALOHA
8.
2 1 2 2
2 1
10
21
22
API
API
API
API
61 78
42
1 2012 10 API
510 API
API
API API
API
API
()
()
() API
() 6
3
23
()
()
()
() ASMENDT
()
()
6
3
API
24
25
[1] US Chemical Safety Board;
http://www.csb.gov/investigations/detail.aspx?SID=20&Type=2&pg=1&F_Investigatio
nId=20.
[2] Drogaris G. Learning from Major Accidents Involving Dangerous Substances. Safety
Science 1993; 16: 89-113.
[3] Kjellen U. Prevention of Accidents through Experience Feedback. Taylor and Francis;
London; 2000.
[4] Balasubramanian SG, Louvar JF. Study of Major Accidents and Lessons Learned.
Process Safety Progress 2002; 21: 237-244.
[5] Dien Y, Llory M, Montmayeul R. Organisational Accidents Investigation Methodology
and Lessons Learned. Journal of Hazardous Materials 2004; 111: 147-153.
[6] Le Coze JC. Disasters and Organizations: from Lessons Learnt to Theorizing. Safety
Science 2008; 46: 132-149.
[7]
http://iht.nstm.gov.tw/form/index-1.asp?m=2&m1=3&m2=76&gp=21&id=6
[8]
200210
[9] ()
2008
[10] Johnson C. Software Tools to Support Incident Reporting in Safety-Critical Systems.
Safety Science 2002; 40: 765-780.
[11] Johnson C, Holloway CM. A Survey of Logic Formalisms to Support Mishap Analysis.
Reliability Engineering and System Safety 2003; 80: 271-291.
[12] Katsakiori P, Sakellaropoulos G, Manatakis E. Towards and Evaluation of Accident
Investigation Methods in Terms of Their Alignment with Accident Causation Models.
Safety Science 2009; 47: 1007-1015.
[13] Sklet S. Comparison of Some Selected Methods for Accident Investigation. Journal of
Hazardous Materials 2004; 111: 29-37.
[14] 199481-4
26
__________________________
________________
1
(API 570)?
_____
API 570 ?
_____
2
(API 510)?
_____
API 510 ?
_____
3? 1
14 1
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
14.
1.
27
1 API 510/API 570
0.93
0.250
180
0.60
0.491
API 570
180
0.94
0.240
API 570
180
0.62
0.488
API 510
180
API 510
180
5.56
4.27
180
4.42
3.33
180
3.71
2.74
180
4.99
2.74
180
5.44
3.08
180
7.60
2.93
180
6.74
2.82
180
6.42
3.25
180
8.21
2.91
10
10
180
7.66
3.05
11
180
11.1
2.82
13
12
180
9.09
2.94
11
13
180
10.3
3.04
12
14
180
13.5
1.96
14
28
15
8.3
8.3
8.3
16
8.8
8.8
17.1
30
16.6
16.6
33.7
2.8
2.8
36.5
2.8
2.8
39.2
43
23.8
23.8
63.0
33
18.2
18.2
81.2
1.1
1.1
82.3
29
16.0
16.0
98.3
1.7
1.7
100.0
181
100.0
100.0
///
//
////
2.8
2.8
3.1
13
7.2
7.2
9.9
///
10
5.5
5.5
15.5
//
//
11
6.1
6.1
21.5
41
22.7
22.7
44.2
////
/
//
4.4
4.4
48.6
61
33.7
33.7
82.3
25
13.8
13.8
96.1
3.8
3.8
96.7
181
100.0
100.0
29
0.85
360
60
0.42
497
API 570
60
0.87
343
API 570
60
0.42
497
API 510
60
API 510
60
6.05
4.296
60
4.58
3.679
60
3.52
2.639
60
4.70
2.586
61
5.49
2.998
59
8.31
3.001
60
6.70
2.872
59
6.93
3.473
60
8.43
2.683
10
61
7.03
3.016
10
11
60
10.87
2.983
13
12
60
8.65
3.328
11
13
60
10.00
3.324
12
14
60
13.12
2.558
14
30
///
//
11.5
11.5
13.1
//
53
86.9
86.9
100.0
61
100.0
100.0
0.99
0.216
78
0.68
0.457
API 570
78
0.99
0.216
API 570
78
0.71
0.445
API 510
78
API 510
78
5.17
4.160
78
4.08
3.116
78
3.95
2.819
78
4.81
2.487
78
5.06
3.217
78
7.96
2.789
78
6.76
2.924
78
6.41
3.106
78
7.96
3.221
31
10
78
8.10
2.944
10
11
78
11.31
2.655
12
12
78
9.36
2.623
11
13
78
10.45
2.762
13
14
78
13.55
1.255
14
10
1.3
1.3
1.3
2.6
2.6
3.8
11
3.8
3.8
7.7
12
1.3
1.3
9.0
13
9.0
9.0
17.9
14
64
82.1
82.1
100.0
78
100.0
100.0
78
100.0
11
43
55.1
55.1
55.1
33
42.3
42.3
97.4
2.6
2.6
100.0
78
100.0
100.0
32
12
//
///
5.1
5.1
5.1
///
/
13
16.7
16.7
21.8
///
11.5
11.5
33.3
/
/
11
14.1
14.1
47.4
//
41
52.6
52.6
100.0
78
100.0
100.0
0.95
0.216
42
0.71
0.457
API 570
42
0.95
0.216
API 570
42
0.74
0.445
API 510
42
API 510
33
14
42
5.60
4.277
42
4.83
3.689
42
3.55
2.643
42
5.74
3.306
42
6.05
3.471
42
5.93
3.219
42
6.79
2.772
42
5.74
3.306
42
8.33
2.238
10
42
7.76
3.341
10
11
42
10.93
2.541
11
12
42
9.24
2.703
12
13
42
10.55
2.957
13
14
42
13.74
1.547
14
34
-
1
35
1.
2. 300
3. 1
2
()
1.
2.
3.(
)
17
4.
18
()
(
)
(
)
(
) (
)
5.
()
()
()
()
(______)
36
()
( )
()
( )
( )
()
()
( )
(kg/)
(kg)
() ()
()
()
()
()
EEP
()
()
37
4 1
1
1 ()
14
2 ()
()
15
()
17
()
18
()
23
1 ()
25
1 ()
15 1
15 2
17
()
30
()
31
33
35
38
()
2
()
38
39
40
41
50 1
61
72
79
()
3 ()
80 ()()()()
()
()
9 ()
11 ()
3
1 3
12 ()
3
20
39
()
13 ()
14 1 ()
16 12
()
1 3 (
)
70
) 3
17 12
()
21 ()
21 1 1 ()
()
21 2()
22 ()
40
()
27 ()
80 2
31 ()
34 ()
35 ()
()
75
36 47 () 30
6 9
2
() 6
37 8 ()
()
40 ()
29 1 1 ()
29 2()
29 3()
29 4()
29 5 1 ()
29 6 1 ()
1
152 ()
153 ()
154 ()
41
()
155 1()
161 ()
165 ()
167 ()
106 ( 1 4 )
107 ()
108 ()
1.5
2.5
()
()()
()
()
100
40
40
109
110 ()
111 ()
42
()
169
3m
170
171 ( 1 )
173 ()
175 ()
177 1 ( 12
)
177 2()
178
180 ()
181 ()
182 ()
183 ()
43
()
184 ()
185
()
185 1()
186 ( 4 )
1.2.
188 1 ()
194
196 ( 1 )
197
198 ()
44
()
299
224 ()
225 ()
30
227 ()
1.5
228 ()
30
229 ()
75
230 ()
232 ()
234 ()
238 ()
241 ()
243 1 ()
(
)
()
150
245 ()
246 ()
249 ()
24
45
()
250 ()
252 ()
253 ()
254 1 ( 1 )
256 ()
257 ()
258 ()
60
259 ()
261 ()
262 ()
263 ()
46
()
(600 ) 50
( 600 22800 )
264 ()
( 22800 )
265 ()
6
272 ()
275 ()
()
276 ( 2 )
279 ()
280 ()
280 1()
281 1 ()
284 ()
285 ()
288 ()
290 ()
47
()
295 ()
90
8
140 115
8 85
300 ( 1 )
90
310 ()
13 ()
)
14 ()
15 ()
16 1 ()
17 ()
18 ()
19 ()
()
20 ()
21 ()
48
()
100 (
1 2 )
23 ()
25 ()
26 ()
100
27 ()
28 ()
29 ()
30 ()
32 ()
33 ()
34 ()
36 ()
100
37 ()
49
()
39 ()
40 ()
43 ()
47 ()
(
)
50 ()
6 ()
7 ()
12 ()
15 1 ()
16 ()
19 ()
50
()
18
20 ()
21 ()
22 1 ()
24 ()
26 ()
6
()
7
()
10
()
15
()
()
2 ()
()
()
4
()
16
19
20
21
(
)
()
1 ()
8
()
51
()
10
12
()
16
1 ()
17
()
18
()
20
()
21
()
()
()
()
()
25
26
27
28
5 10 (
5 )
()
()()()()
()
100
8
12 ()
13 1
3
15
52
()
17 1 (
3 )
()
31 154
()
()
33 ()
(
) (
) 5
34 ()
() 10
300 3000
1
35 119
36
1000
10000
37 119
10
()
38
() 1.5
41
() 2
43
100 1 (
45
)
(
5 ) ( 300
3 ) ( 5
46 ()
) ( 5000 )
47 ()
()
()
52 ()
2
53
()
5000
(
)
53 ()
()
54 ()
55
58 ()
12
100
12
59 ()
60 167 ()
()
61
62
63 ()
64 ()
65 ()
66 166 ( 66
)
68
()
()
69 172 ( 69
54
()
1
100
()(
70
)()
()
()(
)
()(
)
5000
71 ( 7 )
15
74 ()
75 145 ()
76
77 ()
79 123468
()
85
()
()
100 1
()
2
9
55
()
87
89
()
90
92 ( 1 )
5000
1000
93
5000
94
106
111
113
100 1
56
()
60
116
300 3000
()
118
120
154
155
(
1000 3000
) 1.5
158
()
160
166
167
5 ()
172
169 192
()
()(
) 8
176
178
()
186
205
1.5
206
211
57
218
219
()
220
221
100 (
200
)
225
100 ( 200 )
227
35 1
( 10 1 )
160
228 ()
229 ()
238
239
240
()
()
4 ()
1
50 ()
58
()
53 ()
55 ()
60 ()
64 ()
65 ()
20
65
76 ()
77 ()
78 ()
2
4 4
79 ()
16
90
1.8
80
124 ()
96 104
95 ()
105 ()
43 1 ()
45 ()
47 ()
48 ()
2
49 1 ()
50 ()
54 ()
59
()
55 ()
56 ()
57 13 ( 1
58 ()
()
61 ()
62 1 ()
1
3
63 ()
()
64 ()
71 ()
73 1 ()
74 ()
90
76 1 ()
78 ()
79 ()
()
82 ( 1 )
83 ()
88
64 ()
60
()
89
183446
()
90 ()
0.25
91 ()
0.05
92 1
213948
()
93 ()
94 ()
95 ()
7.5
96 ()
98
69 ()
99
68 ()
100
70 ()
102
72 ()
19 1 ()
22 5 ()
61
29 ()
32 ()
35 1 ()
38 1 1 ()
41 1 ()
62 ()
63 24678
()
()
(
)
3
6
65 1 ()
77 ()
78 ()
62
()
79 ()
95 ()
96 ()
99 ()
100 ()
102 ()
103 ()
115 ()
()
116 23469
101112 ()
()
()
118 ()
128 1 1256
7 ()
30
143 ()
2
10 ()
10
15
12 ()
1.2
2
13 ()
63
()
500
50
15 ()
500
50
16 1 124
568 2 ()
18 235 ()
27 1 ()
28 12347
()
31 ()
5 ()
7 ()
6
1
9 13 ( 3 85
6 1
)
6 1
6 1
10 2346 6
7 ( 2346 ) 1
1
64
()
()
15 ( 1 )
100
15
3
30
16 ( 12 ) 10
26
81216
5
1.
2.
65
-
1
66
1.
2. 300
3. 1
()
1.
2.
3.(
)
17
4.
18
()
(
)
(
)
(
)
(
)
5.
()
()
()
()
(______)
67
3 1
1
1 ()
14
2 ()
()
15
()
()
30
()
31
33
35
2
()
38
39
61
50 56 58 77
78
()
79
()
3 ()
80 ()()()()
()
()
9 ()
13 ()
68
()
16 12
()
()
) 3
22 ()
() 1.5
41
() 2
43
100 1 (
45
)
(
5 )( 300
3 )( 5 )
46 ()
( 5000 )
100 1
76
77 ()
106
218
1.
2.
69
Applications
(
)
(
)
(
)
(
)
RBI
LOPA
(
)
RCM
(FMEAFTA)
70
MI
(QA)
(PMI)
Written
Procedures
(ITPM)
RAGAGEPS:
Recognized
And Generally
Accepted Good
Engineering
Practices
( Lockout/Tagout
(RAGAGEPS)
MOC
71
Training for
Process
Maintenance
Activities
Inspection and
Testing
ITPM:
Inspection and
Testing
Preventive
Maintenance
API 653
API 510
API 570
NACE (
)
ASNT (Level I, II, III)
AWS CWI
(RAGAGEPs)
(OEM) Licensor
72
Inspection and
Testing
ITPM:
Inspection and
Testing
Preventive
Maintenance
(CML)
(CUI)
(Internal)
(On-stream)
()
Equipment
Deficiencies
(
,
()
()
()
(
)
()
,
MOC
73
Quality
Assurance
/
/
//
(PMI)
74
75
1.
2. 300
3. 1
2
()
1.
2.
3.(
)
17
4.
18
()
(
)
(
)
(
)
(
)
5.
() ()
()
()
(______)
76
3
()
( )( )( )
()
()
()
( )
(kg/)
(kg)
() ()
()
()
()
()
EEP
()
()
77
4 1
1
()
18
()
12
1 1 ()
300
12 (1)(2)(3)
2
(4)(5)
3
300
12
3
3
300
12
39
29 1 1 ()
29 2()
29 6 1 ()
1
154 ()
78
155 1()
1.5
2.5
()
161 ()
()()
()
()
173 ()
175 ()
177 1 ( 12
)
184 ()
186 ( 4 )
1.2.
188 1 ()
194
79
()
196 ( 1 )
197
198 ()
30
229 ()
234 ()
238 ()
241 ()
246 ()
249 ()
250 ()
(
)
()
24
252 ()
279 ()
280 ()
80
()
280 1()
281 1 ()
284 ()
288 ()
50 ()
23 1 ()
26 ()
20
()
26
()
60 167 ()
63 ()
100 1
113
167
81
()
218
229 ()
64 ()
65 ()
80
124 ()
105 ()
43 1 ()
54 ()
56 ()
57 13 ( 1
58 ()
()
63 ()
90
76 1 ()
78 ()
83 ()
82
()
29 ()
()
116 23469
101112 ()
()
128 1 1256
7 ()
31 ()
83
()
14
134 ()
()
1.
2.
84
1.
//
()
12
()
Critical Task
(1)
Analysis and
?(
Procedures
_______)
(2)
1.
2. ?
85
3.
?( a))
4.
/?
()
;
)
(1)()
(2)()
Critical Task
Analysis and
(3)/?(
Procedures
(4)()
(5)/()
(6)
()
(7)()
(8)
86
1.
?
(
?)
2. ?
Critical Task
()
Analysis and
Procedures
3.
?()
4. ?
(
)
(1)?
(2)?
87
5. ?
(
)
6.
?
Critical Task
Analysis and
Procedures
(
)
7.
?
(
)
(1)
?
88
37/
15
System
Evaluation
1.
?()
2.
?()
3. ?(
4.
/
?
(
)
89
5.
?
(
???)
System
Evaluation
6.
7.
8.
(1)?
(2)
90
System
Evaluation
1.
(1)
(2)
(3)/
(4)
(5)
(6)
(7)
(8)/
(9)/
(10)
(11)
91
System
Evaluation
(12)
(13)
(14)
(15)
(16)
(17)
(18)
(19)
(20)
(21)
1.
2.
92
System
Evaluation
3.
(1)
(2)
(3)
(4)
(5)/
(6)
(7)
(8)
(9)/
(10)
(11)()
(12)
93
System
Evaluation
(13)
(14)
(15)
(16)
(17)
(18)
(19)
(20)
4.
5.
6. ?
94
1.
?
(1)
(2)
(3)
Hazard
Identification
and Risk
Assessment
(4)
(5)
(6)
(7)
(8)
(9)
95
(10)
(11)
(12)
Hazard
Identification
and Risk
2.
Assessment
(1)?
(2)?
(3)
?
3.
96
(CIP)
/
, . -- 1 . -- :
, 102.04
;
ISBN 978-986-03-6857-4()
1. 2.
556.83
102008996
()
22143 407 99
02-26607600
http//www.iosh.gov.tw/
102 4
()1 1
160
6
04-22260330
209 1
02-25180207
http
//www.iosh.gov.tw/Book/Report_Publish.aspx
ISBN 978-986-03-6857-4
GPN1010200967
97