You are on page 1of 47

Master in Information Technology (MIT) Graduate Program

Project Management

Pre-Project and
Project Initiation
Phase
J.S.Javier October 2014. All Rights Reserved.

Project Beginnings
Business Case
Definition
Justification

Initiating Process Group


Project Charter
Project Organization
Stakeholder Analysis

J.S.Javier October 2014. All Rights Reserved.

- 2-

Generic Life Cycles


TIme
R. D. Archibalds Generic Project Life Cycle
Concept

Definition

Execution

Closeout

Product Development Life Cycle

Idea

Business
Case

Phase 1

Phase 2

Phase N

System
Development Life
Cycle

Authorization
Pre-Project

Project

Project Development Life Cycle


J.S.Javier October 2014. All Rights Reserved.

- 3-

Definition : Business Case


A business case is an argument, usually
documented, that is intended to convince a
decision maker to approve some kind of action.
At its simplest, a business case could be a spoken
suggestion.
For more complex issues, a business case should be
presented in a carefully constructed document
The document itself is sometimes referred to as a
business case

As a rule, a business case has to articulate a


clear path to an attractive return on investment
(ROI)
J.S.Javier October 2014. All Rights Reserved.

- 4-

Key Elements : Business Case


Description of Problem (or Opportunity)
that exists in the business
Optionally, the impact of doing nothing to
address the problem or exploit the opportunity

Available options to solve the problem (or


exploit the opportunity)
Benefits and costs of each option (typically
include cash flow analysis)
Recommended solution
J.S.Javier October 2014. All Rights Reserved.

- 5-

Benefit and Cost Estimation


Tangible Costs / Benefits
Directly measurable
Typically recorded in Book of Accounts
Example : Hardware Cost, Development Cost,
Savings, Revenues

Intangible Costs / Benefits


Difficult to estimate
Example : Usability, Operational
Improvements, Improvement in Reputational
Asset, Goodwill
J.S.Javier October 2014. All Rights Reserved.

- 6-

Project Evaluation Techniques


Constrained Optimization Methods
aka Decision Models
Examine different criteria used in making decisions regarding
project selection
Algorithmic and highly mathematical approach for solving a
specific problem, such as Linear Programming and Decision
Tree Analysis

Benefit Measurement Methods


aka Calculation Methods
Provide a way to calculate the value of the project which is used
in project selection decision making
Examples : Scoring Models and Cash Flow Analysis Techniques

J.S.Javier October 2014. All Rights Reserved.

- 7-

Cash Flow Analysis Techniques

Net Present Value


Payback Period
Internal Rate of Return
Return on Investments

J.S.Javier October 2014. All Rights Reserved.

- 8-

Net Present Value


A method for calculating the expected net monetary gain
or loss from a project by discounting all expected future
cash inflows (benefits) and outflows (cost or expense) to
the present point in time, less initial investment (if any)
Formula : NPV = [ t=1..n DCF] initial investment
where :
t is year of the cash flow
n is the nth year (or last year) in the cash flow
series
DCF is discounted cash flow (present value of
cash flow)

J.S.Javier October 2014. All Rights Reserved.

- 9-

Time Value of Money


0

F1

F2

Ft
Time Period

PV1 = F1 / (1 + r) 1
PV2 = F2 / (1 + r) 2

PV t = Ft / (1 + r) t

Present
J.S.Javier October 2014. All Rights Reserved.

- 10-

Discounted Cash Flow


A discounted cash flow is the present
value of the cash flow
Formula : DCF = A x [ 1 / (1 + r) t ]
Where :
A is the cash flow (benefit cost or expense)
r is the discount rate (per year)
The discount rate is the minimum acceptable rate of
return on an investment
aka hurdle rate, rate of return, opportunity cost of capital

t is the year of the cash flow

J.S.Javier October 2014. All Rights Reserved.

- 11-

Sample Problem 1
ABC Company is evaluating two IT projects, each with the projected cash
flows as shown below :

Year
1
2
3
4
5

Project 1
14,000
14,000
14,000
14,000
14,000

Project 2
28,000
12,000
10,000
10,000
10,000

Project 1 will require an initial investment of $42,000, while Project 2 requires $45,000.
If the cost of capital to ABC is 10%, which project will they prioritize ? Compare using
the NPV method as a basis for your recommendation.
J.S.Javier October 2014. All Rights Reserved.

- 12-

NPV Selection Criteria


If the NPV of a cash flow is greater than or
equal to zero, a firm will earn a return
greater than or equal to its cost of capital
If NPV >= 0, accept the project
If NPV < 0, reject the project

In selecting from a list of projects, always


select that project with the highest positive
NPV as it gives the highest return relative
to the other projects
J.S.Javier October 2014. All Rights Reserved.

- 15-

Payback Period
The exact amount of time required for the project
to recover its initial investment as calculated
from the cash inflows
For annuity cases, this can be found by
dividing the initial investment by the annual
cash inflow
For mixed stream, the yearly cash inflows
must be accumulated until the initial
investment is recovered
The elapsed time required for accrued benefits
to overtake accrued and continuing costs
J.S.Javier October 2014. All Rights Reserved.

- 16-

Payback Period Criteria


Accept projects if the payback period is less than
or equal to the maximum acceptable payback
period
In selecting among projects, select that project
that has the shortest payback period
Typically used as a measure of risk exposure
The shorter payback period the less
exposure, and vice versa

J.S.Javier October 2014. All Rights Reserved.

- 19-

Initiating Process Group


Processes performed
to define a new project
or a new phase of an
existing project by
obtaining authorization
to start the project or
phase

Defining initial scope of project


Securing commitment to initial
financial resources
Identifying project stakeholders
Identifying the Project Manager

PMBOK Guide, 5th Ed. 2013, p.54


J.S.Javier October 2014. All Rights Reserved.

- 20-

The Project Charter


A document issued by the
project initiator or sponsor
that formally authorizes the
existence of a project

Project Charter

It provides the project manager


with the authority to apply
organizational resources to
project activities
Chartering a project links the
project to the strategy and
ongoing work of the organization
PMBOK Guide, 5th Ed. 2013, p.67
J.S.Javier October 2014. All Rights Reserved.

- 21-

Key Contents : Project Charter


Project purpose or justification
Measurable project objectives and related
success criteria
High level requirements
High level project description
High level risks
Summary milestone schedule
Summary budget
Project approval requirements

Project Charter

What constitutes project success


Who decides the project is successful
Who signs off on the project

Assigned project manager, responsibility,


and authority level
Name and authority of the sponsor or other
person(s) authorizing the project charter
J.S.Javier October 2014. All Rights Reserved.

PMBOK Guide, 4th Ed., 2008

- 22-

Why a Project Charter ?


Describes problems to be solved
Provides a vision of how the business
need will be resolved
Describes the elements of the solution
expected by the sponsor from the delivery
organization (i.e. the Project Team)
Identifies the main stakeholders in the
various organizations involved in the
project.
J.S.Javier October 2014. All Rights Reserved.

- 23-

Risks Without a Project Charter


Unclear need that is likely to give unstable
direction to the project
Possible ambiguity about the project
objectives and scope
Possible ambiguity concerning the solution
Possible lack of identifying an important
stakeholder for the project.
* May also be due to Poorly-Written Project Charter

J.S.Javier October 2014. All Rights Reserved.

- 24-

Project Charter : Aliases

Project Definition Document


Project Datasheet
Proposal
Reference Specification
Statement of Work
Plan of Record
Letter of Agreement
Work Contract
Reference : The Project Management Toolkit by Tom
Kendrick. 2010. AMACOM Books
J.S.Javier October 2014. All Rights Reserved.

- 25-

Project Boundaries

PMBOK Guide, 5th Ed. 2013, p.54

J.S.Javier October 2014. All Rights Reserved.

- 26-

Organizational Structures
Describes the set-up of project units in an
organization and establishes the authority
of the project manager
It constrains the availability or terms under
which resources become available to the
project

Classifications of Organizational Structure


Functional
Project
Matrix (Weak, Balanced, Strong)
J.S.Javier October 2014. All Rights Reserved.

- 27-

Functional Organizational Structure


Chief Executive

Functional Manager

Functional Manager

Project Coordination

Functional Manager

Staff

Staff

Staff

Staff *

Staff *

Staff

Staff

Staff *

Staff *

* Staff engaged in project activities

Characteristics :
Each unit is responsible for carrying out a
specific, similar set of activities

Reporting is hierarchical each


individual reporting to a single manager

Multiple people perform each type of activity

Project Manager s authority is low,


relative to functional manager s
authority

J.S.Javier October 2014. All Rights Reserved.

- 28-

Project Organization
Project Manager

Chief Executive

Project Coordination

Project Manager

Project Manager

Staff

Staff

Staff

Staff

Staff

Staff

Staff

Staff

Staff

Characteristics :
Each unit operates to complete a different project
Some organizations have separate support units and systems
per project unit (e.g. HR and Purchasing), while others have
common support units and systems
J.S.Javier October 2014. All Rights Reserved.

- 29-

Matrix Organization (Weak)


Chief Executive

Functional Manager

Project Coordination

Functional Manager

Functional Manager

Staff *

Staff

Staff

Staff

Staff *

Staff

Staff *

Staff *

Staff *

* Staff engaged in project activities

Characteristics :
Project team composition comes from different functional units
Maintains many of the characteristics of a functional organization
Project Manager role is more of a coordinator or expediter than that of a
manager
J.S.Javier October 2014. All Rights Reserved.

- 30-

Matrix Organization (Balanced)


Chief Executive

Functional Manager

Project Coordination

Functional Manager

Functional Manager

Staff *

Staff

Staff

Staff

Staff *

Staff

Project
Manager

Staff *

Staff *

* Staff engaged in project activities

Characteristics :
Project team composition comes from different functional units
A member under a functional unit has an official management position with
low to moderate authority as a project manager
J.S.Javier October 2014. All Rights Reserved.

- 31-

Matrix Organization (Strong)


Chief Executive

Manager of Project
Managers

Functional Manager

Functional Manager

Functional Manager

Project
Manager

Staff *

Staff

Staff

Project
Manager

Staff

Staff *

Staff

Project
Manager

Staff *

Staff *

Staff *

Project Coordination

* Staff engaged in project activities

Characteristics :
Project team composition comes from different functional units
Maintains many of the characteristics of a project organization
A member under a functional unit has a project management position with
moderate to high authority for a project manager
J.S.Javier October 2014. All Rights Reserved.

- 32-

Org Structure Influences on Project

Management of IT Projects, Kathy Schwalbe, 2011


J.S.Javier October 2014. All Rights Reserved.

- 33-

Relative Authority of PM

J.S.Javier October 2014. All Rights Reserved.

- 34-

IT Project Org Chart Sample


Project Committee

IT Manager

Project Manager

QA Team

Counterpart IT Staff

Systems Analysts

System Owner

Support Team

Counterpart SubjectMatter Staff

Project Team Units

Programmers

Technology Group

J.S.Javier October 2014. All Rights Reserved.

- 35-

Who are the Project Stakeholders ?


Persons and Organizations
that are actively involved in
the project
Those whose interests may
be positively or negatively
affected by the execution or
completion of the project
Examples :
Customers
Sponsors,
Performing organization
General Public
J.S.Javier October 2014. All Rights Reserved.

PMBOK Guide, 4th Ed., 2008


- 36-

Key Project Stakeholders - 1


Executive Sponsor
A member of senior management
who is committed to the project
With enough clout to fill his / her
primary role
Is not involved in the details of the
project (may even be invisible to
the project team)
Authority to ensure compliance by
organization, if not cooperation
J.S.Javier October 2014. All Rights Reserved.

- 37-

Key Project Stakeholders - 2


Project Steering Committee
Consists of senior client
management
Job is to enforce, from
client s perspective, the
project s term of reference
Approve or deny requests for
additional resources or
changes to scope or
schedule
J.S.Javier October 2014. All Rights Reserved.

- 38-

Key Project Stakeholders - 3


User Group
Set of people who will be
responsible for the day-today details and decisions in
the project

Client Project Manager


A senior member of the
client s user group and is the
primary contact between PM
and client organization
J.S.Javier October 2014. All Rights Reserved.

- 39-

Characteristics of Stakeholders 1 of 2
May exert influence over the
project, its deliverables, and
the project team members
May be internal or external
to the project
May have varying levels of
responsibility and authority
when participating on a
project and these can
change over project lifetime
May have adverse impact
on the project objectives
J.S.Javier October 2014. All Rights Reserved.

PMBOK Guide, 4th Ed., 2008

- 40-

Characteristics of Stakeholders 2 of 2
Stands to gain or lose through
the success or failure of the
project
Provides funding for the project
Has invested resources in the
project
Participates in (works on) the
project
Is affected by the outputs or
outcomes of the project
Is in the chain of accountability

Project Management Briefcase (p.186). by


Gary R. Heerkens, PMP, McGraw-Hll. 2002.

J.S.Javier October 2014. All Rights Reserved.

- 41-

Chain of Accountability
A hierarchy of people who signs
off to approve the project in some
ways and are viewed as taking on
some accountability for the project.
As such, they may see themselves as
stakeholdersand feel that they have
the right to exert influence on the
project, if they sense the need.

Often found in Bureaucratic


Organization
Politically astute project managers
will pay close attention to who
Project Management Briefcase (p.186). by
these people are.
Gary R. Heerkens, PMP, McGraw-Hll. 2002.
J.S.Javier October 2014. All Rights Reserved.

- 42-

Relationship : Project & Stakeholders

PMBOK Guide, 4th Ed., 2008


J.S.Javier October 2014. All Rights Reserved.

- 43-

Project Team Responsibilities


Expectations Management
Identify both internal and external
stakeholders in order to determine
the project requirements and
expectations of all parties involved

Balance conflicting interests


Manage the influence of the various
stakeholders in relation to the
project requirements to ensure a
successful outcome

Interact with stakeholders in a


professional and cooperative
manner
J.S.Javier October 2014. All Rights Reserved.

PMBOK Guide, 4th Ed., 2008


Section 2.3, p. 23
- 45-

Technique : Stakeholder Analysis


A technique of systematically
gathering and analyzing
quantitative and qualitative
information to determine whose
interests must be taken into
account throughout the project
Identifies interests, expectations, and
influence of the stakeholders and
relates them to the purpose of the
project
Identify stakeholder relationships
that can be leveraged to build
coalitions and potential partnerships
to enhance the project s chance of
success
PMBOK Guide, 4th Ed., 2008, Sec. 10.1.2, p. 248
J.S.Javier October 2014. All Rights Reserved.

- 46-

Stakeholder Analysis : Step 1


Identify all potential
stakeholders and relevant
information
roles, departments, interests,
knowledge levels,
expectations, influence levels
Include anyone in a decisionmaking or management role
who is impacted by the
project outcome
Usually done by interviewing
identified stakeholders and
expanding the list until all
potential stakeholders are
included
PMBOK Guide, 4th Ed., 2008, Sec. 10.1.2, p. 248
J.S.Javier October 2014. All Rights Reserved.

- 47-

Stakeholder Analysis : Step 2


Identify the potential
impact or support
each stakeholder
could generate
Classify them so as to
define an approach
strategy
Multiple classification
models available

PMBOK Guide, 4th Ed., 2008, Sec. 10.1.2, p. 249


J.S.Javier October 2014. All Rights Reserved.

- 48-

Stakeholder Analysis : Step 3


Assess how key stakeholders
are likely to react or respond
in various situations
Plan how to influence them to
enhance their support and
mitigate potential negative
impacts

PMBOK Guide, 4th Ed., 2008, Sec. 10.1.2, p. 250


J.S.Javier October 2014. All Rights Reserved.

- 49-

Output : Stakeholder Registry


Contains all details related to the identified
stakeholders
Includes (but not limited to) :
Identification Information
Name, Organizational Position, Location, Role in
Project, Contact Information

Assessment Information
Major Requirements, Main Expectations, Potential
Influence in the project, Phase with most interest

Stakeholder Classification
Internal / External, Supported / Neutral / Resistor,
etc.
PMBOK Guide, 4 Ed., 2008, Sec. 10.1.2, p. 250
th

J.S.Javier October 2014. All Rights Reserved.

- 50-

Output : Stakeholder Strategy


Defines an approach to increase the support and
minimize negative impacts of stakeholders
throughout the entire project life cycle
Some of the information related to certain
stakeholder management strategies could be too
sensitive to be included in a shared document
Exercise judgment as to information to be included

Common way to represent is through the use of


a Stakeholder Analysis Matrix (SAM)

PMBOK Guide, 4th Ed., 2008, Sec. 10.1.2, p. 251


J.S.Javier October 2014. All Rights Reserved.

- 51-

Strategic Analysis Matrix Sample

J.S.Javier October 2014. All Rights Reserved.

- 52-

You might also like