Professional Documents
Culture Documents
ARMOUR
82
Single-core cables
A problem arises with single-core cables because in their installation formation the
armour is situated between the conductors and if a magnetic material is used it causes
high induced currents in the armour. These result in high electrical losses. Consequently
if armour is essential it is necessary to use a non-magnetic material such as aluminium.
However, few single-core cables are buried directly in the ground and as the main
application is for short interconnectors armour is not usually essential.
Armour conductance
Technical details of the importance o f armour conductance with particular reference to
wiring cables are discussed in chapter 10, and armour conductance requirements for
colliery cables are detailed in chapter 18.
83
PROTECTIVE FINISHES
Protective finishes are o f particular interest for the protection of metal sheaths,
reinforcement and armour in buried distribution and transmission cables. Whether the
installation is below or above ground, very few cables are supplied without a protective
finish. For the newer designs o f the above categories of cable, an oversheath of extruded
PVC or M D P E has become nearly universal.
When wiring type cables need to be of robust construction, the cable design normally
comprises an extruded oversheath, but one important difference is that this oversheath
can be of a tougher thermoset material such as PCP, CSP or NBR/PVC. These
materials are also used where special properties are required, e.g. for oil resisting and
flame retardant (OFR) finishes and heat and oil resisting and flame retardant ( H O F R )
finishes as discussed in chapter 3. Such materials could have advantages for distribution
and transmission cables but they can rarely be adopted because the high temperature
required by most methods of curing would cause damage to the cable.
84
A special situation arises when the protective finish both has to be flame retardant
and has to emit a minimum of toxic fumes and smoke in a fire. This is covered in
chapter 6.
The U K attitude for distribution cables has always been that after burial the user
expects to forget about fhem for the rest of their life, and with paper insulated cables life
expectancy has steadily been extended to over 40 years. In spite o f the generally good
corrosion resistance of metals like lead and copper they can fail when buried in some
types of ground, and in the U K such metals have rarely been left bare. Much attention
has been paid to corrosion protection, and cable failures due to this cause have been
rare. In the USA the practice has been somewhat different and in the case of cables
having a copper concentric neutral conductor, it is not unusual to install cables without
protection. The literature has reported a substantial level of cable failures and, although
it is relatively easy with a duct system to replace the cable, the economics of savings
against subsequent expenditure would seem to be finely balanced.
The protection of aluminium against corrosion is of particular importance because
aluminium may corrode very quickly when buried, or even when near the surface and
exposed to damp conditions, e.g. where cables descend from cabinets into the ground.
At these positions, it is most important to apply protection over exposed metal right up
to and over the termination.
The corrosion of aluminium usually takes the form o f local pits which may quickly
penetrate a sheath, although general surface attack may be quite small. The mechanism
of pitting is associated with the local breakdown o f the protective oxide film, in
conditions which do not allow its repair, followed by cell action due to differential
conditions o f electrolyte concentrations or o f aeration. The presence of other
underground services containing metals anodic to aluminium, such as lead, steel or
copper, may accelerate the attack. While some soils, such as in made-up ground, are
worse than others, it is always essential to consider that any ground is aggressive and to
ensure that good protection exists. Protection is also necessary for above ground
installation because in damp conditions corrosion can occur in crevices, owing to
differential aeration conditions, and it is difficult to avoid crevice conditions at points of
support or in contact with walls.
It is convenient to review protective finishes in two categories: first, the bitumentextile type used traditionally with lead sheathed paper cables, and second the extruded
thermoplastic oversheaths which were first developed to provide satisfactory corrosion
protection for aluminium sheathed cables and were then adopted for all newer cable
designs as well as for paper/lead cables when improved protection was desirable. For
armoured cables, the protective finish comprises a bedding under the armour and a
layer over the armour, usually termed a serving when textile and an oversheath when it
is extruded.
BITUMINOUS FINISHES
Constructions
The earliest paper/lead cables at the end o f the last century were protected with coal tar
pitch and fibrous textile materials such as cotton and jute in yarn or woven form, i.e.
hessian. The basic design has changed little over the years but the once popular jute
85
yarn roving has largely given way to woven hessian. Replacement of coal tars by
bitumens provided better uniformity and enabled particular grades to be used
according to their function within the construction. The introduction of two
impregnated paper tapes adjacent to the lead sheath was also beneficial. For many
years stray direct currents from tramway systems caused corrosion problems with
underground cables due to electrolytic effects. The combination of impregnated paper
and bitumen improved the consistency of the protective layer.
For armoured cables, the most common construction today is for the bedding to
consist of two bituminised paper tapes plus two bituminised cotton or hessian tapes
with a serving of two bituminised hessian tapes. A suitable grade of bitumen is applied
over each layer and a coating of limewash is given overall to stop rings sticking together
on the drum.
Bitumen
A thick layer of bitumen would give excellent corrosion protection, as it does o n rigid
steel underground pipes, but no method has been found of producing such a layer to
withstand the bending and other conditions necessary with cable. Many grades of
bitumen are available, with a wide range of viscosities and pliability. Careful selection
has to be made to suit the requirement for impregnating the textiles of the particular
layer in the cable and to suit the subsequent service conditions, bearing in mind that
some cables have to operate in the tropics whilst others may be in polar regions. On the
whole the bitumen should be as hard and rubbery as possible, but must not crack when
bent at low temperatures. If the viscosity is too low, troublesome 'bleeding' may ensue
at high ambient temperatures.
EXTRUDED T H E R M O P L A S T I C FINISHES
PVC oversheaths
Following many years' successful use on wiring cables, PVC was established as an
oversheath for power distribution and transmission cables in the mid-1950s and since
then PVC sheaths have become the most commonly used type of protective finish for
power cables.
86
Grade of material
F o r wiring cables, flexibility and easy sheath removal are important and the grade o f
PVC used for sheathing is softer than that used for insulation. However, for the heavier
power cables different criteria apply. Toughness and resistance to deformation both
during and after installation are of greater significance and it is usual to use a similar
grade of material to that used for insulation. F o r most purposes oversheaths are black,
in order to give good resistance to sunlight, but where this is not important colours may
be adopted as a means of cable identification. When red sheaths were first used for
buried cables some darkening o f colour occurred due to sulphides in the ground and
special compositions were found to be necessary.
Whilst the amount of plasticiser in the PVC may theoretically be varied to suit a wide
range o f high and low ambient temperature conditions, the practical advantages are
limited because o f other aspects such as the resistance to deformation previously
mentioned. This is of particular significance when low temperatures are encountered
because at around 0C PVC becomes somewhat brittle and may crack either by a
sudden blow or by rapid bending during handling operations. F o r this reason it is
important not to install cables at low temperatures.
Construction
When applied over any type of cable, extruded PVC provides a clean finish which is
attractive and contributes to ease of handling. Whilst the external profile is smooth if
the application is over a normal metal sheath or wire armour, this is not the case with
corrugated aluminium sheaths or steel tape armour. Extrusion is by the 'tubing-on
technique' (chapter 24) and the external profile follows the contour of the underlying
surface, thus creating small steps over steel tape armour. In the case o f corrugated
sheaths the oversheath tends to be slightly thicker in the troughs.
Initially, when PVC oversheaths were first applied over steel wire armour, no change
was made in the use of bitumen, i.e. the oversheath was extruded directly over armour
which was flooded with bitumen. Such cables are frequently installed vertically in
factories. When bitumen is in contact with PVC it absorbs some plasticiser from the
PVC. Whilst the amount of loss is insufficient to have much effect on the properties of
the PVC, it is enough to cause considerable reduction in the viscosity of the bitumen. In
fact, the bitumen may become so fluid that it can run out o f the cable at terminations
situated below the cable run. Subsequent practice has therefore been to omit bitumen
between wire armour and PVC unless a preference for inclusion is expressed by the user.
A particular example is the use of bitumen in the single or double wire armoured PVC
insulated cables used underground in coal mines. The cables are usually installed
horizontally and as the oversheaths may be damaged it is useful to have the benefit of
bitumen as secondary protection. Similarly, in the UK, bitumen is normally applied
over steel tape armoured cables, as these are invariably buried. It is not so necessary
and normally not used over galvanised steel tape.
When PVC is applied directly over aluminium sheaths it is particularly desirable to
have a uniform coating of bitumen on the aluminium to provide an interface seal and
mitigate against spread of corrosion resulting from damage to the PVC. At one time it
was a practice to include a small amount o f a sparingly soluble chromate in the bitumen
to serve as a corrosion inhibitor but, whilst this was undoubtedly beneficial, it is no
longer used because of possible toxic effects. With corrugated sheaths the tendency is
for an excess of bitumen to remain in the troughs and the corrugation effect is less
87
visually apparent on the finished cable. Some German manufacturers aim at complete
filling of the troughs on such cables and also apply a layer of a thin plastic tape to assist
in maintaining a thick bitumen layer.
Characteristics of P VC
In combination with a good measure of flame retardance, and resistance to oils and
chemicals, PVC contributes much to robustness and ease of handling. Very few
chemicals normally found in the ground on cable routes have significant effect on PVC.
Investigations have been carried out to determine whether any substances found in
chemical factories and oil refineries are particularly aggressive to PVC. It was found
that the only chemicals which caused attack were high concentrations of chlorinated
solvents, esters, ketones, phenols, nitro compounds, cyclic ethers, aromatic amino
compounds, pyridine, acetic anhydride and acetic acid. Except for perhaps occasional
splashes, it is unlikely that such materials will be in contact with cables. Prolonged
immersion in oils and creosote may cause swelling and softening but there is usually
considerable recovery when the source is removed.
Loss of plasticiser from PVC to other materials in contact with cables may cause
some problems with wiring type cables. One example of this relates to cables in roof
spaces where polystyrene granules have been used for thermal insulation over ceilings.
The granules in contact with the oversheath may become soft and tacky due to leaching
of plasticiser from the PVC, which itself will lose some flexibility. Direct contact
between the granules and cables should be avoided. Similar remarks apply to some
fittings which are in contact with cables. In addition to polystyrene and expanded
polystyrene, acrylonitrile-butadiene-styrene (ABS), polyphenol oxide and polycarbonate are also affected. Nylon, polyester, polyethylene, polypropylene, rigid PVC and
most thermosetting plastics are little affected.
With the greater thickness of oversheath on distribution and transmission cables the
rate of loss of plasticiser from the body of the oversheath is much slower and in any
case subsequent disturbance by bending is unlikely. Although the PVC becomes
somewhat harder as plasticiser is removed, the properties of permeability to moisture
and protection against corrosion are not impaired.
A special situation arises when PVC oversheathed cables are in ground which may
contain hydrocarbons such as petrol. This can happen in oil refineries as a result of
spillage. Although only a small amount of hydrocarbon is absorbed by the PVC, such
materials can diffuse through the sheath and be taken up by materials inside, or
condense in any air spaces available. The PVC itself is unaffected, except for some loss
of plasticiser. However, the petrol may then flow along the cable and run out of joints
and terminations. For such conditions it is general practice, therefore, for cables to have
a lead sheath, even if the insulation is of PVC. By sealing the lead sheath to the
equipment, no hydrocarbon will flow into the equipment. Flow will still take place
along the armour, and if it is important that no leakage should occur at the armour
termination this may also need to be specially sealed.
Polyethylene oversheaths
Although from the outset PVC became the established material in the U K for power
cables, polyethylene has tended to be preferred in the USA and also throughout the
88
world for telephone cables. Most of what has been stated for PVC applies equally to
polyethylene but, whereas PVC has to be compounded with plasticisers and fillers etc.,
the only additions normally made to polyethylene are antioxidant and carbon black.
Problems due to such aspects as loss of plasticiser do not arise. Furthermore,
polyethylene does not suffer from effects of brittleness at low temperatures and so has a
particular advantage for installation in countries where sub-zero temperatures exist for
long periods. Polyethylene sheaths have to contain carbon black and this prevents their
use when coloured sheaths are required.
On balance the overall advantages and disadvantages of the two materials are
marginal and it is more economic for manufacturers to standardise on one material.
Polyethylene is flammable and this is one o f the main reasons for the preference for
PVC. Another is that resistance to thermal deformation is an important characteristic
for distribution cables. Whilst polyethylene may be marginally better for temperatures
within the normal continuous operating range, it softens more than PVC above 80C,
and at 130C it flows readily under mechanical load.
Many grades of polyethylene are available and for oversheaths it is necessary to select
one which has good resistance to environmental stress cracking.
89
The use of metal barriers has been shown historically to be effective provided no gaps
exist. However additional metallic layers add expense, complexity, increased heat
losses, and the need to electrically bond metallic layers to the cable. It may not be
possible to prevent corrosion of the metallic layer because of termite attack to the
polymeric oversheath.
High- or medium-density polyethylenes with a Shore D Hardness of 60 provide
adequate resistance to attack by some termites, 3 however, the surface of the oversheath
must be smooth to prevent termites from initiating their attack. Softer materials such as
PVC provide little protection against the more aggressive species of termites. Harder
materials such as nylon, which have hardness in excess of 65 show absence of termite
attack} Due to its high cost nylon is usually applied as an additional thin layer over the
normal cable oversheath, then to prevent abrasion damage or wrinkling of this layer
during installation, a further protective oversheath is necessary.4 This solution has
tended to be used for small diameter cables.
The chemical treatment of trench backfills to deter termites is, at first sight, a simple
solution and has been widely used to provide protection to timber buildings. However,
treating the quantity of backfill required to protect a cable route is expensive and the
introduction of quantities of chemicals into the ground is undesirable. Three
insecticides which have been successfully used in the past, i.e. aldrin, dieldrin and
90
BRAIDED FINISHES
Braided finishes used to be popular before extruded finishes came into general use.
Because of the slow manufacturing process, however, they were expensive and could
only be justified when there was a need for improved abrasion resistance. For power
cables, hessian, cotton and asbestos braids were superseded by extruded PVC and the
special formulations for flame retardance discussed in chapter 6. Health and safety
problems also arose with asbestos.
For flexible cables, braided finishes have continued to find fairly standard application
for domestic appliances where there is a possibility of the cable coming into contact
with hot metal and an extruded finish might be damaged, e.g. for electric irons and
toasters etc. Continuous filament of the regenerated cellulose type is now the most
common material for such braids. When there is justification for a more robust finish,
as for aircraft cables, nylon is used.
91
When the requirements are onerous it is usual to check that no damage has occurred
during laying and often subsequently during the life of the cable. This is done by a
voltage test and for the purpose a conducting layer of graphite type varnish is applied
on the outer surface of the oversheath at the time of cable manufacture. The routine test
in the factory is at a voltage (2.5t + 5)kV, applied for 1 min, where t is the minimum
average thickness of the oversheath.
Test for protection of aluminium
In the event of local damage to the oversheath, it is important that soil water should not
penetrate beyond the exposed area and reference has been made to the application of
bitumen to provide such secondary protection. The test for this purpose is carried out on
a length of cable previously submitted to a bend test. Four circular pieces of oversheath
10 mm in diameter are cut out with a cork borer and the exposed aluminium is cleaned.
The sample is placed in 1% sodium sulphate solution with the ends protruding and 100 V
d.c. is applied between the aluminium sheath and the bath, a resistor being used so that
the current is 100mA. After 100 hours the oversheath is removed and no signs of
corrosion should be visible beyond 10 mm from the initial holes.
Abrasion and penetration tests
Tests are included in IEC 229 to demonstrate that the finish has adequate resistance to
abrasion and to penetration by sharp objects. They are described in chapter 39. These
tests were originally developed to create a standard at the time when finishes included
layers of unvulcanised or vulcanised rubber together with outer layers of hessian. They
are of less significance with modern extruded oversheaths.
References
(1) Field, A. W. and Philbrick, S. E. (1991) 'Protecting Cables from Insect Attack'.
JiCable Conference Proceedings, 447-452.
(2) Report of CIGRE WG21-07, 'Prevention of Termite Attack on HV Power Cables'.
Electra, No. 157, December 1994.
(3) Bell, A. (1985) 'Plastics that Termites Can't Chew'. Plastics News, July 1985.
(4) Nakamura, T. et al. (1934) 'The Practical Application of Nylon Jacketed Termite
Resistant Power Cables'. Sumitomo Electrical Technical Review, No. 124, 1984.
(5) Blackwell, N., Gregory, B., Head, J. G., Mohan, N. C., Porro, R. and Rosevear,
R. D. (1996) Termite Protection of Underground Distribution and Transmission
Cables. Electropic 96 Conference, 1996.
(6) Process for Making Termite Resistant Cable Sheaths. UK Patent No. 2276171B.
(7) PANGOLIN registered product of BICC Cables Limited.