You are on page 1of 32

Vol 3 - Issue 11 | February 2010 | Rs.3.

50

‘Lost decades’ for developed nations, but...


Across the developed world, all markets These are all economies from where
(except gold) have been dominated by funds have sought out emerging markets
government and central bank measures for in the past. This trend of flows to
more than two years now. Even bond markets emerging markets may not get
have been weighed by these two principal hampered (at least as long as China
drivers. This is important because the charts keeps humming). The ebb and flow in
for key bond indices now show a life of two the flows will, however, lead to volatility
parts. and corrective phases. Investors in equity
Pre-Sep 2007, the charts exhibit private and in India must be prepared for such
phases.
market determined trends. In the aftermath of
the crisis officially unfolding in August 2007, In the developed world, it made sense to
the charts developed a different life in which stay out of equity in the past decade
the influence of government and central bank (and in Japan, for the past two decades).
had increased in a pronounced manner to This is one reason why gold has been a
temporarily trample risk. favoured asset class.
As a result, the signalling effects are Even allowing for volatility and corrective
reduction and interest rates starting to rise in Investors in India cannot be blind to this phases linked to global trends, such an
completely different now. We may be
the developed world, one cannot help think trend of Japan-like situation taking deeper approach may not be appropriate in
effectively looking at apples and oranges.
this may just be talk and governments and roots in more parts of the world.This will not emerging markets, including India.
This attribute of government and central bank centrals banks will not walk the talk. At best, hamper economic growth by much in What will be important is for a longer-
support is also true to an extent for what may happen is a winding down of a few countries such as India, which have domestic term approach to equity than what
economies in the emerging world and their of the extraordinary measures by central triggers and Brazil, which has strengths in investors have gotten used to in the past
equity markets; their economies have banks. resources and a macro-economy that is in decade.
responded by showing robust growth, which
Not much more is likely to be done for the good shape.Trends in the past decade are a Also important will be the ability to
is likely to be of a sustainable nature. The
fear of avoiding deflation will dominate policy. good pointer. ‘invest when times are bad and harvest
policy measures have not gone to a stage
Just take the example of Japan, which is now Indeed, even as the developed world spent when times are good’ as suggested by
where they have taken signalling effects out
and this is a notable credit in the present its third decade of fighting the after-effects of the first lost decade and Japan its second, our Head of Equity in a Q & A on
context of the global economic trends. a bubble in the late 1980s. Its nominal GDP is India and other emerging markets had robust lessons from the meltdown and
still close to levels that prevailed at the peak, growth rates and equity markets that recovery of 2008 & 2009.
In contrast, economies in the developed
its equity markets are about 25% of the peak delivered double-digit returns over the past To be informed is important in such an
world have just about managed to avert the
level. decade; the notable exception was China, environment and to help this process,
downward trend with all the support.
Just in the past three months, we have which trailed most of its peers on equity The Wise Investor will continue to
Whatever nominal growth has been reported
witnessed two waves of political pressure on returns despite reported GDP growth of provide a range of views from in-house
is almost entirely driven by the effects of
the Japanese central bank to fight deflation as about 10%. and independent experts.
government stimulus and favourable central
bank policy. This is, therefore, not of a well as more stimulus by the government. Check out tables between pages 22 and 26 The focus of The Wise Investor will not
sustainable nature unless governments go far These measures by the Japanese government for a clear idea of how developed and be to provide only content that is dumb-
in stretching support for extended periods. emerging markets have panned out in the down in nature, which we believe will be
and the central bank there have such a
past ten years. an insult to our readers and also useless
There is not much headroom for additional familiar ring, and one cannot help wonder if
in investing for the long term in a
support, especially in terms of monetary the effects will also be as disappointing as in What the subdued trends in the developed meaningful manner. In this respect, The
policy too, except to keep rates low for the past. It is likely they will be. world will, however, do is to contribute to Wise Investor will seek to avoid the
extended periods, which the Federal Reserve This is a world into which much of the bouts of high volatility in equity markets. We beaten track.
has clearly stated is its intent. It is in this developed world has stepped into. The Dow have a Japan-like situation developed in
backdrop that we need to examine the is threatening to cross 10,000 on the economies that are collectively significantly
effects of life beyond government support in T.P.Raman
downside – 10000 was a level first reached in larger in size (for just the U.S, you can apply
different parts of the world. 1999. So the U.S has already had its first lost a multiple of 3.5 times and if you add Europe, Managing Director
When there is talk of focussing on deficit decade. Story Japan is playing out in full force. you almost double that number). Sundaram BNP Paribas Asset Management
Sundaram BNP
Sundaram BNPParibas Asset Asset
Paribas Management: Investment Manager for Sundaram BNP Paribas Mutual Fund / Portfolio Management Services: Sundaram BNP Paribas Portfolio Managers
Management
Chart of the Month
The Herengracht Index: Four Centuries of Location Value in most cases, at least over the long run.
We have been unable to change the notation in the graph to English, but the message Virtually all of the net growth in real location value on the Herengracht over the
is loud & clear. 346-year period can be attributed to a couple of decades in the 17th century and
a couple of decades in the latter half of the 20th century, both of which were rather
The Herengracht Index shows the CPI-deflated value of housing along a wealthy exceptional periods in history.
canal in Amsterdam.Take note of the spurt in the last ten years, which has left the
index at a record level for 400 years despite the decline in 1980s.This is considered In the former period the Herengracht was at the periphery of the expanding
to be longest available time series of price information for real estate anywhere in residential area of the city. In the latter period the Herengracht was at the
the world. periphery of the expanding commercial core of the city. In both cases a conversion
Amsterdam is in some respects a useful "laboratory" for this type of analysis. in the highest and best use of the land (from agricultural to urban residential, and
Holland is the densest and most intensively farmed country in the Western World. then from residential to commercial) underpinned the jump in real location value.
This, and the country's age-old struggle against flood, may account for the This index shows how important the starting date can be in working out whether
Netherlands having some of the earliest and strictest land use planning and housing is “expensive” or “cheap” at any point in time.
controls in the world. Source: Four Centuries of Location Value: Implications for Real Estate Capital Gain
The 0.56 percent average annual real growth rate in the Herengracht's location in Central Places by Piet M.A. Eichholtz & David M. Geltner
value over the 346-year history presented here may be viewed as rather low. It (http://web.mit.edu/cre/research/papers/wp86eichholtz.pdf) and Steve Keen’s
suggests that real capital gains for unlevered real estate investments will be negative DebtWatch (http://www.debtdeflation.com/blogs/)
Value of housing, over 400 years, along a wealthy canal in Amsterdam

http://www.huizenmarkt-zeepbel.nl/images/huizenprijzen_300jaar.jpg
Global Market Snapshot
Market Cap of Global Markets - A comparision in 2007 (close to peak), 2008 (close to bottom) & the present

Market Cap ( $ Billion) Share in World Marke Cap (%) Returns (%) Distance
Region/Country from Peak
End Jan 2009 2008 2007 End Jan 2009 2008 2007 2010 2009 2008
TYD (%)

World 47830 49722 31901 60880 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 -3.8 55.9 -47.6 -21.4
United States 13135 13748 10455 17660 27.5 27.7 32.8 29.0 -4.5 31.5 -40.8 -25.6
Canada 1517 1609 992 1749 3.2 3.2 3.1 2.9 -5.7 62.2 -43.3 -13.3
Brazil 1242 1326 565 1273 2.6 2.7 1.8 2.1 -6.3 134.7 -55.6 -2.4
Mexico 347 363 247 398 0.7 0.7 0.8 0.7 -4.3 46.8 -37.9 -12.8
Chile 232 229 130 208 0.5 0.5 0.4 0.3 1.4 76.0 -37.5 11.5
United Kingdom 2850 2975 1981 4051 6.0 6.0 6.2 6.7 -4.2 50.2 -51.1 -29.6
France 1774 1900 1480 2736 3.7 3.8 4.6 4.5 -6.6 28.4 -45.9 -35.2
Germany 1270 1371 1075 2208 2.7 2.8 3.4 3.6 -7.4 27.5 -51.3 -42.5
Switzerland 1041 1076 848 1217 2.2 2.2 2.7 2.0 -3.2 26.8 -30.3 -14.5
Japan 3558 3488 3268 4545 7.4 7.0 10.2 7.5 2.0 6.7 -28.1 -21.7
Honk Kong 2148 2268 1312 2655 4.5 4.6 4.1 4.4 -5.3 72.9 -50.6 -19.1
India 1280 1294 640 1813 2.7 2.6 2.0 3.0 -1.1 102.3 -64.7 -29.4
Australia 1162 1253 652 1415 2.4 2.5 2.0 2.3 -7.2 92.1 -53.9 -17.9
China + Others 16274 16823 8256 18952 34.0 33.8 25.9 31.1 -3.3 103.8 -56.4 -14.1
Data Source: Bloomberg;The last available figures for each year have been taken; Analysis: Sundaram BNP Paribas Asset Management
End December 2007 figures have been reckoned as the peak as different countries reached the point on different dates
Sundaram BNP Paribas Asset Management 2 The Wise Investor February 2010
India View Equity

Looking ahead by looking back on 2008 & 2009


Depression were drawn, indeed many experts and others clouded our
thought process.
We began to view the Great Depression as the Great Regression, where all
of us would move back in living standards considerably. Once that thought
process sets in, then all fundamentals that markets rest on can be challenged.
For instance – Will people have jobs in the first place to buy the goods and
services that companies provide, if so at what price will they buy? We need
to settle down more before we can think of the next sustainable rise in
markets.
So we had to cope with the “reflexivity” of markets and ability of markets
to over react on both sides and our ability to cope with them.
During the last quarter of 2008, anything that we sold was a wise decision,
and in the first quarter of 2009, anything that we bought was a wise decision.
Satish Ramanathan We had to be extremely nimble to survive this volatility.
Head-Equity What are your thoughts on the breadth and depth in the Indian equity market
Sundaram BNP Paribas Asset Management after the meltdown and recovery?
Indian markets are still emerging in depth and volatility. I would like to
highlight that perhaps markets are mature, but its participants are not!
When all the investors decide to dump Indian equities, no market can
2008 and 2009 have been tumultuous in different respects.We present a Q provide a simultaneous exit at a uniform price.
& A with Satish Ramanathan, Head – Equity on the import of these two Take the instance of Satyam Computers, when it reached a low of Rs6.30
years from the perspective of economy, markets and investors. and when almost all investors wanted to exit! There are also regulatory
What have been the most important takeaways as a long-only fund manager aspects, which need to ensure that large trades are confidential and do not
from the tumult of 2008 & 2009? impact the market.
As a long-only fund manager, focussed on medium to the short-end of the How does the experience of the past two years compare with the tech boom
cycle, we are prone to the market cycles as much as the average market & bust of 1999-2000? What are the key differences? Have we learnt anything?
participant. The main lesson out of this outcome was to believe in While there are many differences between the tech bubble and the 2008 &
valuations and the franchise value of companies rather than get confused by Q1 2009 market fall, the similarities are what we need to be aware of.
the overall macro situation. Extreme confidence on the future was something that did markets in on
Another important lesson from this tumultuous period has been to ration both events, and also complete disregard for valuations fuelled by an
money and allocate it to higher conviction bets rather than hold a small extremely high liquidity environment. These symptoms are what we need
amount in a larger number of stocks. This affords us the comfort to buy to watch.
stocks that have come down due to short-term panic. The confidence in real estate prices in India is what worries me now. Prices
We also learned that market moves may be irrational in the short term of a few of the high -end apartments in Mumbai and Delhi are now
guided by selling pressure or buying moves, but longer-term price comparable to London and New York, without the matching (or even
movements are almost always guided by earnings. adequate) infrastructure in these cities.
What are the implications of taking sizeable cash calls in a mutual fund type Let us look ahead.What would be the events that would most positively surprise
environment (even in a year such as 2008 when it was the right thing to do)? you through 2010 & 2011?
Does the present regulatory structure hinder in this respect? The key developments that may spring a positive surprise are:
Taking cash calls are also aggressive decisions, but it limits downside risks and • A good monsoon and improved crop output can keep the consumption
often comes at a cost of risking complete participation in any sharp up story ticking albeit at a more modest pace. A lot of industrial goods
moves. We generally take cash calls when the environment is extremely such as cement and steel are also consumed on a diverse basis including
unpredictable and investors’ interests are better protected with cash in the rural consumption. Hence an improvement in agriculture will keep
portfolio. consumption ticking.
The current regulatory environment does allow high cash calls on a regular • A sharp improvement in global economic conditions on back of
basis and we believe this is adequate to buffer investors from extreme demand coming back from consumers could surprise markets, which is
shocks. currently factoring a flat recovery in 2011. This could provide a
What has been most challenging aspect in the past two contrasting years? recovery for Indian IT and other exports, creating employment in India
The most challenging aspect has been how fragile markets are and that • Infrastructure growth could be ahead of expectations and this can
most of them have been on trust. When comparisons to the Great create its own virtuous cycle
Sundaram BNP Paribas Asset Management 3 The Wise Investor February 2010
Let us look ahead a bit more. What would be the events that would most
negatively surprise you through 2010 & 2011? Snippet
We have an extremely difficult situation that we need to navigate carefully.
Jeremy Grantham - 15 Lessons
What are the issues we need to be concerned about (these would not be
negative surprises but issues that could have a negative impact):
In his latest quarterly report, Jeremy Grantham of GMO has provided a
• Personal consumption growth has been very strong on the back of snapshot of lessons learnt in The Decade, Just Past.
higher agriculture product prices and benefits of the sixth pay • The Fed wields even more financial influence than we thought.
commission, which resulted in a lot of money in the hands of people • Low rates have a more powerful effect on driving financial assets than on
bidding up property prices again. With India’s high fiscal deficit, we may driving the economy.
need to increase taxes or scale back subsidies, which could impact • The Fed is capable of being extremely out of touch with the real world –
consumption. More importantly, markets have built secular growth into “what housing bubble?” – plus more doctrinaire – “no, the low rates had
consumer stocks when actually there could be a decline in growth rates. no effect on housing” – than anyone could have imagined.
• Another area of concern is the durability of the recovery process. • Congress is nearly dysfunctional, primarily controlled by large corporations,
Globally all governments have infused significant funds across the and hamstrung by the supermajority now routinely required in the Senate.
banking system, or have given its citizens incentives to consume more, • Government administrations can be incompetent for long periods.
leaving all government budgets with a large hole. We think governments • Poor leadership can really damage a country’s hard-won reputation in a
across the world will begin the process of repair of their balance sheets, mere 10 years.
which could result in some higher taxes or lower subsidies. This could • Obama is not a miracle worker!
result in a slower recovery/ growth in 2011. • The leadership of major corporations can be very lacking in insight and
• China has been a black box for many people and we think that should competence on a fairly routine basis.
there be a sharp slowdown there and deflationary fears could reassert • The two time-tested investment tools, value (P/E ratios and P/B ratios) and
themselves again price momentum, are now much more heavily used and not so reliable as
they once were, say from 1977 to 1997.
• Much of the stability in commodity prices, despite lower consumption
has been on account of higher investments into commodities as an • Asset classes really are more inefficiently priced than individual stocks on
average, and therefore offer greater opportunities for adding value and
inflation hedge. With recent initiatives to reduce proprietary trading, we
reducing risk.
think infusion of leveraged capital into commodities could decline. This
along with a sharp slowdown in China could potentially get us back into • Developed countries, including the U.S., are past their prime compared
with developing countries: it is indeed a new world order.
extremely volatile commodity prices and take us back to a 2008
environment. • Education and training are the keys to increasing wealth on a sustainable
basis and the U.S. is in danger of losing its once large edge here.
• We are also concerned about the fact that this slowdown has not been • We all live on an island, which can be overexploited and turned into a
Darwinian. Capacity abounds and utilisation is low; yet inflationary barren Easter Island if we are not careful. Resources are finite and
pressures loom on account of easy liquidity. This anomaly has to be biodiversity is fragile, and both must be protected. Carbon emissions are
resolved, before one can take a directional call. the single greatest threat.
• Another poor monsoon could damage consumption and government • Being a global policeman is expensive, and somewhere between difficult
finances. As of now markets are assuming a low probability of this event. and impossible.
We have to build in some safety in our portfolios for this event taking • The Fed learns no lessons!
place as well. Source: www.gmo.com
Much of the focus is on India and China. What are the major positives and
negatives for the two emerging economies? The outside view
India and China have become the large engines of incremental growth The infrastructure sector, and in particular the progress made on power and
globally. The fear is, however, that should China slowdown then growth roads, will be the key variable for the Indian economy during the five-year term
across the world could be challenged. China’s consumption is increasing but of the recently re-elected Congress-led government. The importance of
may not be adequate to stem the decline in exports and infra spend. infrastructure can already be seen in the behaviour of the banking system in
India’s consumption story could be delayed on weak monsoons or our terms of the far greater pick up in lending to infrastructure than to the
infrastructure build could be delayed due to government indecision. consumer. This is not to say the consumer story is over. It is just not at the
India and China will have large domestic demand stories emerging forefront since banks have backed off in the past two years from previously
regardless of the global environment, and we have to be alert to capture “hot” areas, such as unsecured consumer financing. Still the long-term
them. These could be multi-year themes such as telecom or two wheelers. consumption story remains healthy, demonstrated by the remarkable
The advantage of investing in these themes is their intrinsic defensive cash consistency of HDFC’s performance.
flows and limited infusion of external capital and higher return on equity. Christopher Wood, Managing Director & Strategist of CLSA Asia-
Pacific, an independent research outfit and author of the weekly
What should be the key takeaways for investors from a period such as 2007-
report GREED & Fear.
2009?
China gets all the play, But …It’s really India that has the long-term
Invest when times are bad and harvest when times are good. demographic advantage. This is true in terms of future population trends, as
As investors, it appears increasingly tough in the fixed-income space, though well as the fact that India also has twice as many people that can be classified
rates are not as low in India as in the developed world. EPF, PPF, Small Savings as ‘middle class’ at 300 million strong. Income fundamentals are also far
& FDs appear the most appropriate options. How are you handling this aspect stronger. Still, China grabs all the headlines, and now it’s all about how last
of investing when you invest for different time periods? year’s massive fiscal and credit stimulus has probably worked too well for its
Investors have to maintain a judicious mix of liquidity, growth and risk before own good.The dark side of the country’s resounding 10.7% GDP growth rate
investing. Fixed income options such as PPF and small savings are definitely is that inflation is percolating across a broad front.
very safe but not liquid. Equities are volatile but are a good growth option. David Rosenberg, Chief Economist of Gluskin Sheff & Associates,
Investors will need to diversify and maintain a balanced approach to their a wealth management firm in Canada.
savings.

Sundaram BNP Paribas Asset Management 4 The Wise Investor February 2010
IndiaView Bonds

CRR hike in homestretch to rate hikes


government borrowings next year. Last year’s borrowing Stance of Monetary Policy
programme had sailed through largely due to the liquidity • Anchor inflation expectations and keep a vigil on the
enhancement measures adopted by RBI. trends in inflation and be prepared to respond swiftly
The RBI may thus wait for trends to pan out better on the and effectively through policy adjustments as warranted.
growth front and for more clarity on the fiscal situation before • Actively manage liquidity to ensure that credit demands
moving on rates, possibly in April 2010. In the meanwhile, of productive sectors are adequately met consistent
surges in excess liquidity may get drawn out through CRR with price stability.
hikes, even on an inter-meeting basis, so that the eventual hikes • Maintain an interest rate environment consistent with
in policy rate are more effective. price stability and financial stability, and in support of the
With the much anticipated negative event past for now, the growth process.
market will look forward to inflation and growth data for Expected outcomes:
direction. The budget for the next year due in February and • Reduction in excess liquidity will help anchor
will be the event the bond markets will look forward to with inflationary expectations.
more nervousness for a direction on likely level of government • The recovery process will be supported without
borrowings and contours of other fiscal policy moves. compromising price stability.
• The calibrated exit will align policy instruments with the
The RBI View on Key Macro-Economic Parameters current and evolving state of the economy.
K Ramkumar
Growth:…Growth during Q2 of 2009-10, at 7.9 per cent, Key Numbers
Head – Fixed Income reveals a degree of resilience that surprised many. Subsequent • CRR raised by 75 basis points to 5.75% to be
Sundaram BNP Paribas Asset Management data releases, whether on industrial production, infrastructure implemented in two phases and would remove Rs
or exports, confirm the assessment that the economy is 36,000 crore from the system by 27th Feb 2010.
steadily gaining momentum. • Reverse Repo rate held unchanged at 3.25%.
Based on this better-than-expected performance, growth • Repo Rate held at 4.75%.
forecasts for 2009-10 have generally been revised upwards. • Bank Rate kept unchanged at 6%.
The Reserve Bank of India announced the Third Quarter • Statutory Liquidity Ratio (SLR) maintained at 25%.
Review of the Annual Policy Statement for fiscal year 2009-10 As reassuring as this recovery is, it is still unbalanced. Public • GDP estimate for FY10 revised to 7.5%.
on January 29, 2010.The key measures and numbers from the expenditure continues to play a dominant role and • Inflation estimate for end fiscal revised up from 6.5% to
RBI Statement are presented in the accompanying panel. performance across sectors is uneven, suggesting that 8.5%
Comment: The quantum of hike in the Cash Reserve Ration recovery is yet to become sufficiently broad-based. • Non-food credit growth estimate for FY10 revised
(CRR) is higher than what was expected by the market. This …A consolidating recovery should encourage us to clearly down to 16.5% from 18%.
was perhaps attributable to the need to cover ground due to and explicitly shift our stance from 'managing the crisis' to • Projected M3 growth revised down to 16.5% from 17%.
a delayed action. Lower bank credit growth has also created 'managing the recovery'. We articulated this change in our
more surplus in the banking system. Thus the idea behind stance in the October quarterly review, but the growing constraints could potentially reinforce supply-side inflationary
hiking only CRR and not the reverse repo or the repo rates is confidence in the recovery justifies our moving further in pressures.
to suck out the surplus liquidity so as to make any future rate reversing the crisis-driven expansionary stance. …Though the inflationary pressures in the domestic economy
hikes meaningful. Our main policy instruments are all currently at levels that are stem predominantly from the supply side, the consolidating
Given that the markets are still in reveres repo mode, a change more consistent with a crisis situation than with a fast- recovery increases the risks of these pressures spilling over
in the repo and reverse repo rates would have been recovering economy. It is, therefore, necessary to carry into a wider inflationary process.
ineffective. Moreover RBI has stated the transmission of earlier forward the process of exit further. Looking ahead into 2010-11, if the growth momentum turns
cuts to lower lending rates is still ‘in progress’. Government borrowings: …But as the recovery gains out to be as expected, pressures on capacities in an increasing
The long term G-Sec yields were neutral to the policy initially. momentum, it is important that there is co-ordination in the number of sectors are likely to strengthen the transmission of
There was negative reaction later in the day, due to fear of fiscal and monetary exits. The reversal of monetary higher input and wage costs into product prices.
higher anticipated borrowings in the current year, following accommodation cannot be effective unless there is also a roll Growth versus Inflation: …Significantly, prices of important
the cancellation of telecom 3G auctions, which were expected back of government borrowing. food items are also firming up. Going by the Food and
to yield about Rs 25,000 crore.. Even as the government borrowing had increased abruptly Agriculture Organization (FAO) data, the global rates of
Corporate bond yields moved up by 5-10 basis points (a basis during 2008-09 and 2009-10, it could be managed through a increase in the prices of sugar, cereals and edible oils are now
point is 0.01%) across all segments between three and ten host of measures that bolstered liquidity. Those liquidity appreciably higher than domestic rates.
years. The less-than-one-year segment is likely to see yield infusion options will not be available to the same extent next The opportunity to use imports as a way to contain domestic
hardening by about 15-25 basis points over the next one year. food prices is, therefore, quite limited.…More recently, there
month or so. Inflation: …For several months, rapidly rising food inflation has are indications that the sustained increase in food prices is
Predictably enough, the RBI sounds unnerved on inflation, been a cause for concern. More recently, there are indications beginning to spill over into other commodities and services as
especially in the light of the observed upward trend in global that the sustained increase in food prices is beginning to spill well.The increases in the prices of manufactured goods have
commodity prices.The year-end estimate has been revised up, over into other commodities and services as well. The accelerated over the past two months.
but may also be overshot marginally. increases in the prices of manufactured goods have While food products, understandably, contribute significantly
Growth, according to the RBI, is still propped by the stimulus accelerated over the past two months. to this, pressures in other sectors are also visible. … Even
measures, and therefore, worries on the same have not While food products, understandably, contribute significantly amidst concerns about rising inflation, we must remember that
disappeared in the central bank’s view. On the other hand, the to this, pressures in other sectors are also visible. Further, the recovery is yet to fully take hold.
central bank pencils in 7.5% growth in FY2010, based on flat prices of non-administered fuel items have increased Strong anti-inflationary measures, while addressing one
agriculture growth, both of which could be considered significantly in line with rising international prices. problem, may precipitate another by undermining the
optimistic. With growth accelerating in the second half of 2009-10 and recovery, particularly by determining private investment and
Another looming uncertainty is that of the quantum of expected to gain momentum over the next year, capacity consumer spending.
Sundaram BNP Paribas Asset Management 5 The Wise Investor February 2010
Emerging Markets Focus

Turbulence spots in Latin America


tension. President Fernandez fired the central bank Asset Allocation Stance
governor on 7 January. The governor was subsequently
Emerging markets are reasonably valued according to
reinstated by the courts, but the government is appealing
traditional criteria. Most emerging multiples have
the decision, and a political crisis appears to be unfolding.
returned to their historical average and are now
Implications: The repercussions so far have been political
comparable to those of the developed markets.
rather economic, and it’s likely that the congress will
At 13.6% return on equity (vs. 14.8% for the
shortly address the crisis, since a failure to find a political
developed markets but using much more leverage) is
solution would be likely to affect Argentina’s debt
back up to a pre-crisis level thanks to higher profit
restructuring programme and would drive borrowing
margins and asset turnover, while lower debt-to-equity
costs up.
ratios reduce risk. Earnings prospects are still solid and
On 13 January, the Merval equity index was virtually flat should justify a premium. The consensus forecast
compared to its level at the end of 2009. Note that foresees 28% and 20% earnings growth in the
Argentina is not part of the MSCI Latin America index. emerging markets in 2010 and 2011 respectively
Martial Godet The country was downgraded to “frontier” status after
Head of Investment Management-New Markets • We maintain our overweight in Asia and continue
the Fernandez government nationalised the country’s
BNP Paribas Investment Partners to prefer China, although we have reduced our
pension fund assets.
exposure. The Chinese economy's vigour is
Venezuela – devaluation to the rescue causing authorities to tighten monetary policy.
Context: Venezuelan authorities are facing dramatic • Exposure to Korea has been trimmed, in
economic challenges: GDP is likely to contract by 2.9% in expectation of higher policy rates.
Last month, a new political crisis broke out in Argentina,
2009, while the inflation rate is close to 25%. As the
and Venezuela announced a devaluation of its currency. • We have added toTaiwan, given the sharp upward
October legislative elections approach, the government
Below we review the implications of these events revisions in earnings forecasts fuelled by the global
is manoeuvring for greater spending power. Indeed, the
Argentina – new year, new troubles recovery.
primary goal of the devaluation is to increase
Context: Argentina doesn’t have access to international government revenues. President Chavez also requested • We are neutral in India, where earnings revision
capital markets, as it is in the process of restructuring the central bank transfer US$7billion to the Fonden – a momentum is stalling, rising inflation is likely to
US$100 billion of debt on which the country defaulted dedicated fund created a few years ago for the mean tighter monetary policy and valuations are
in 1991. As part of this process, Argentina was preparing redistribution of oil revenue. relatively high.
to launch, later in January, a swap of its defaulted debt for What happened: Last week, President Chavez • We are overweight in Brazil and Russia, which are
US$20 billion with non-litigating investors. announced a devaluation and the introduction of a dual favourably exposed to rising commodity prices.
In 2010, the country is expected to pay investors US$13 exchange rate: • We are underweight in Turkey (economic
billion in total. As recent events have shown, the • The official exchange rate was moved from 2.15 (in prospects have dimmed) and South Africa, where
Argentine government was, however, also tempted to place since 2005) to 2.60 bolivar to the US dollar. the business and earnings cycles and monetary
find a faster, if less orthodox, solution to its debt issue. policy are less favourable relative to other
This exchange rate will be applied to so-called
emerging economies.
What happened?: On 14 December, President Cristina priority sectors, such as food, healthcare products,
Fernandez de Kirchner asked the central bank to transfer science and technology, among others. becomes even stronger, it will erode fiscal gains and the
from its reserves US$6.5 billion into the “Bicentennial • All other transactions will now be conducted at the government will face the same macroeconomic issues
Fund for Stability” to repay some of the country’s debt. so-called oil exchange rate, set at 4.30 bolivar to the again.
But the President of the central bank (which has US$48 US dollar. This exchange rate will be used for In the short term, the measure will provide the
billion of reserves) Martin Redrado refused, challenging transactions in sectors such as autos, retail, telecoms, government with some additional fiscal resources – after
the legality of the decree. chemicals, and metals. the announcement, S&P has even raised its outlook on
His concern was that the use of central bank funds in this In essence, the introduction of the oil exchange rate the country’s debt (with a BB- note) from “negative” to
way would spark claims from holders of defaulted means that oil exports generated by the state oil “stable”.
Argentine bonds, and would cause a freeze of central company PDVSA will now be converted at a higher Conclusion: The impact of the events in Argentina and
bank assets abroad. That appears to have begun to domestic rate generating higher revenues expressed in Venezuela on our equity portfolios is virtually nil, as
happen. A US district court judge has now frozen the domestic currency. neither country is part of our investment universe. The
Argentinian central bank's U.S. accounts at the request of Implications: The new exchange rate is expected to impact on their neighbours such as Brazil or Mexico is
holders of Argentine debt. dramatically increase the domestic price of imported expected to be insignificant, as events in both Argentina
The amount of assets frozen is only US$1.75 billion, but goods – right after the announcement, Venezuelans and Venezuela are “domestic”, and shouldn’t concern
the seizure has further inflamed domestic political rushed to shops to buy consumer goods. If inflation materially neighbouring countries.

Sundaram BNP Paribas Asset Management 6 The Wise Investor February 2010
By Invitation

Need for two kinds of businesses


“The poor do not qualify to take loans from the bank - true at all. In fact, these crises grow from the same
they are not creditworthy.” I argued with him about this root—a fundamental flaw in our theoretical construct of
for several months, but I couldn’t change his mind. So I capitalism.
offered to become a guarantor for loans to the poor. The biggest flaw in our existing theory of capitalism lies
The bank agreed to accept this proposal. in its misrepresentation of human nature. In the present
By the middle of 1976, I started giving out loans to the interpretation of capitalism, human beings engaged in
village poor, taking personal responsibility for their business are protrayed as one-dimensional beings whose
repayment. I came up with some ideas for making it only mission is to maximize profit. This is a much
easier for the poor people to repay the money they had distorted picture of a human being.
borrowed. These ideas worked. People paid back the Human beings are not money-making robots. The
loans on time, every time. essential fact about human beings is that they are multi-
It seemed to me that lending money to the poor was not dimensional beings. Their happiness comes from many
as difficult as it was imagined. But I kept confronting sources, not just from making money.
difficulties in trying to expand the programme through
Professor Muhammad Yunus Yet economic theory has built the whole theory of
the existing banks. Finally, I decided to create a separate
business on the assumption that human beings do
bank for the poor. Finally I succeeded in creating this
nothing in their economic lives other than pursue their
bank in 1983. We called it Grameen Bank.
selfish interests. The theory concludes that the optimal
This idea of small, collateral-free loans for poor women, result for society will occur when each individual's search
known as "microcredit", or "microfinance", has spread for selfish benefit is given free rein.
around the world.
This interpretation of human beings denies any role to
Professor Muhammad Yunus delivered the second Fundamental Flaw & The Financial Crisis: During the other aspects of life - political, social, emotional, spiritual,
Annual Hirendranath Mukerjee Memorial Parliamentary current financial crisis, the falsity of the old assumption environmental, etc.
Lecture at the joint-meeting of the members of Lok (of not lending to the poor) became even more visible.
Sabha and Rajya Sabha of India in Delhi on December 9, No doubt human beings are selfish beings, but they are
While big conventional banks with all their collateral
2009. We present edited extracts: were collapsing, microcredit programmes, which do not selfless beings too. Yet this selfless dimension of human
depend on collateral, continued to be as strong as ever. beings has no role in economics. This distorted view of
In 1974, I found it extremely difficult to teach elegant
human nature is the fatal flaw that makes our economic
theories of economics in the classroom while a terrible Will this demonstration make the mainstream financial
famine was raging outside. Suddenly I felt the emptiness thinking incomplete and inaccurate. Over time, it has
institutions change their minds ? Will they finally open helped to create the multiple crises we face today.
of economic theories in the face of crushing hunger and their doors to the poor?
poverty. I realized that I had to leave the campus and Once we recognize this flaw in our theoretical structure,
I am quite serious about this question. When a crisis is
somehow make myself useful to the distressed people of the solution is obvious. We can easily replace the one-
at its deepest, it can offer a huge opportunity. When
Jobra, the neighboring village. dimensional person in economic theory with a multi-
things fall apart, that creates the opportunity to redesign,
I was shocked to meet a woman who had borrowed just dimensional person - a person who has both selfish and
recast, and rebuild. We should not miss this opportunity
five taka from a money-lender and trader.The condition selfless interests at the same time.
to redesign our financial institutions. Let’s convert them
of the loan: She would have to sell all her products to into inclusive institutions. Our picture of the business world changes immediately.
him at a price he would decide. A five-taka loan Nobody should be refused access to financial services. We now see the need for two kinds of businesses, one
transformed her into a virtual slave. Because these services are so vital for self-realization of for personal gain (profit maximization), another
To understand the scope of this money-lending practice people, I strongly feel that credit should be given the dedicated to helping others. In one kind of business, the
in the village, I made a list of the people who had status of a human right. objective is to maximize economic gains for the owners,
borrowed from the money-lenders. When my list was even if this leaves nothing for others, while in the other
Let me return to the current financial crisis.
complete, it had 42 names. These people had borrowed kind of business, everything is for the benefit of others
Unfortunately, the media coverage gives the impression
a total of 856 taka from the money-lenders. To free that, once we fix this crisis, all our troubles will be over. and nothing is for the owners—except the pleasure of
these 42 people from the clutches of the money lenders, We forget that the financial crisis is only one of several serving humanity.
I gave them the money to repay the loans. crises that are threatening humankind. Let us call this second kind of business, built on the
The excitement that was created in the village by this We are also suffering a global food crisis, an energy crisis, selfless part of human nature, as “social business”.This is
small action touched me deeply. I thought, “If this little an environmental crisis, a health care crisis, and the what our economic theory has been lacking. To read
action makes so many people so happy, why shouldn't I continuing social and economic crisis of poverty. These more, please visit http://bit.ly/62rTMm
do more of this?” crises are as important as the financial crisis, although Source: http://www.muhammadyunus.org
That's what I have been trying to do ever since. they have not received as much attention. Note: By Invitation features articles solicited by The Wise
The first thing I did was to try to persuade the bank Furthermore, the media coverage may give the Investor from experts. It may, on occasions, showcase
located in the university campus to lend money to the impression that these are disconnected crises that are excerpts of exceptional papers/speeches, which are
poor. But the bank manager refused to do that. He said, taking place simultaneously, just by accident. That's not available in the public domain or published with permission.
Sundaram BNP Paribas Asset Management 7 The Wise Investor February 2010
Knowledge Centre

Mutual Funds Demystified


• 24 •

market – of course if they had their way the yield borrower anticipates!!
curve would always be normal!
Let me end with a numerical example to illustrate
Herein lies the answer to why the yield curve is this:
sometime flat or downward sloping.
Let the borrowing amount be Rs 100 and the
To explain, suppose there were no borrowers at current one-year rate be 5 per cent per annum
all in the market for long-term money.Then what and the 5 year rate also be 5 per cent per annum
would a lender do? He has an option to spend his - a ‘flat’ yield curve.
money on immediate consumption. But what if he
If the lender lends the money for 1 year he would
has satisfied all his consumption needs? He could
earn Rs 5; If he lends it for five years, he would
lend it in the short term market and hope that earn Rs 25 (Rs 5 x 5-we are ignoring
when the short-term borrowing matures. He compounding effects in order keep the discussion
Sunil Subramaniam could find another borrower to lend to. simple).
Executive Director-Sales & Marketing
Alternatively he might agree to lend it for a longer Suppose the lender is not able to find an
Sundaram BNP Paribas Asset Management
tenor at the same rate as for a shorter tenor! That acceptable borrower for a five-year tenor, he has
would naturally lead to a ‘flat’ yield curve! to adopt the strategy of lending it for one-year
Why would he do this? This is because he expects today and at the end of one year, lending the
We continue on our yield curve journey. To interest rates to decline and hence would like to money for a further period of four years, if there
summarise our discussions so far: ‘lock on’ to the current higher rates!! (Here `high’ is a borrower for such a period then.
The yield curve is obtained by plotting the market is a relative term). Assuming he finds such a lending trail, he will earn
rates of interest for a risk-free borrowing (by the Why would he expect interest rates to fall in the Rs 5 for one year and Rs 20 (Rs 5 x 4) for the
Government) against time. By looking at the curve future? One key reason would be if future inflation remaining 4 years!! Hence his total earnings
one can obtain the rates of interest payable for is expected to be lower. remain Rs 25.
any specified tenor.
To refresh one’s memory of an earlier discussion Suppose he fears that at the end of one year, the
Generally, a yield curve is upwardly sloping. In - Nominal Interest rate = Real Rate + Expected four-year lending rate might be only 4 per cent
simpler terms, interest rates for longer tenors are Inflation. per annum as inflation is going to turn out to be
more than interest rates for shorter tenors. From lower that what market is expecting? Then by
This very factor also leads to a ‘downward sloping’ adopting this strategy, his actual earnings would be
our earlier discussions, this is intuitively easy to
yield curve. much lower – Rs 5 for one year plus Rs 16 (Rs 4
understand as the investor (or lender) should be
compensated for postponing his natural desire to Because the information about lower future x 4) for four years (Rs 21).
consume his money immediately and the more inflation is available to the borrowers also!!! Hence Also, there is the risk that he might not find a
we delay his consumption the greater should be their natural tendency would be to borrow for a suitable borrower at that point in time!!
price that the borrower will have to pay. shorter tenor so that when it matures they hope
that the future borrowing rate would be lower Hence, his approach would be to tempt the ‘good
We will dwell a little more on this aspect today: quality borrower willing to borrow for a five-year
than what prevails now.
Why did we use the term ‘generally’? Should not period today’ with an attractive rate of only 4.75
Thus there is a constant tussle in the market place per cent per annum. Why? In such a case, he
the yield curve be always ‘upwardly sloping’?
between the borrowers and lenders – and at would end up making more money over a five-
The answer is that it is not the case; at times it is times, the lenders become desperate (especially if year period – Rs 4.75 x 5 = Rs 23.75, which is
‘downward sloping’ or sometimes it is ‘flat’. there is a high quality long term borrower) and greater than Rs 21.
are willing to offer lower rates for the long term
Why? Is our intuition wrong? Our intuition is not If the borrower is tempted – we then have a data
in order to tempt the borrower into borrowing!!
wrong – in fact an ‘upwardly sloping’ yield curve is point for our yield curve which would render it
Thus leading to a ‘downward sloping’ yield curve.
referred to as a ‘normal’ yield curve. ‘downward sloping”!!!
Why again? As they believe that interest rates are
Lenders do not, however, always control the going to drop much more sharply than what the I will end on this note today!!
Sundaram BNP Paribas Asset Management 8 The Wise Investor February 2010
Investing Environment

Basics of the fixed-income space


Fixed-Income funds can be broadly classified prevailing market yield plus 20-60 basis points Fixed-Income Concepts
into liquid funds, liquid plus funds, short-term by taking small exposure to riskier (as compared Portfolio Maturity: Every fixed-income
bond funds, long-term bond funds and gilt funds to securities in a liquid fund) bonds with longer instrument or money-market instrument has a pre-
in the ascending order of risk; volatility of returns maturity. As these funds belong to debt funds defined maturity with the exception of a few
perpetual bonds. In case the instruments have
may also vary from less to more in the same category, the dividend distribution tax incidence
embedded options of either call or put or both,
order. In the process of fixed-income investing, on the dividend option is lower and hence more dates on which they can be exercised are deemed to
suitability of the funds shall depend on time attractive as compared to liquid funds. be maturity dates. An average of the maturity of
horizon of investments. This linkage is essential various instruments in the portfolio with duly
Short-Term Bond Funds: Such funds are
for investors to be prepared and overcome assigned weights is termed as the portfolio maturity.
suitable for investors with a more-than-3 month Portfolio maturity, in simple terms, reflects the
frequent bouts of volatility for short periods that
investment horizon.The average maturity of the interest -rate risk associated with the portfolio (but
may be experienced by such funds in the short in reality, it is not so simple).
portfolio may be more than a year, and so entail
term. On relative terms, a portfolio with higher maturity
higher market risk. They generally invest more
Liquid Fund: These are funds that are carries higher interest rate risk and more market risk
than 50 % of the funds in marked-to-market
appropriate for deploying surplus funds available as compared to a portfolio with lower maturity.
securities and hence can be volatile on a daily Using the examples of the types of funds, liquid funds
with investors for short-term parking purposes basis. The fund aims to capture higher accruals have low portfolio maturity and low interest-rate
ahead of usage/investment in other options. The or earnings by investing in securities with risk. They capture prevailing yield. Portfolio maturity
surplus is funds beyond transaction money and is incrementally higher for other types of funds and
maturity of more than a year.
waiting to be invested or used for specific rises as we move liquid plus to long-term bond
Long-Term Bond Funds: Such funds funds.
purposes. The portfolio of such funds is also
represent a classic case of a fund manager’s Duration: Duration of a fixed-income instrument is
guided by regulation, and hence, market risks are
conviction on likely trends in interest rates. The the measure of average time period over which the
contained. The marked-to-market component fixed cash flows associated with that particular
portfolio is usually a mix of Government
is restricted to 10 %. Such funds have average instrument are received. A coupon-paying bond
securities, corporate bonds and other
maturities of less than 90 days so as to mitigate receives interest income at fixed intervals and final
structured instruments and is actively managed. payment of the face value on date of maturity. As a
market risk. They are suitable for investors with
They are appropriate for investors with certain portion of income earned on the bond is
a time horizon of 1 day to 15 days. Such funds
investment horizon of more than six months. received before its date of maturity, the average
also provide high liquidity, quality portfolio and maturity of the bond is less than its tenor (period till
seek to capture prevailing market yield. Investing in such funds may be a superior option
maturity). We can consider two bonds of one-year
when interest rates have peaked and appear to maturity. Bond A maturing on December 30, 2008
Liquid Plus Fund: They carry moderately
be heading for lower levels. When anticipated pays to investor Rs. 50 on June 30 and Rs. 50 on
higher degree of market risk as compared to December 30, vis-à-vis Bond B maturing on
lower rates materialize, bond prices rise and
liquid funds as such products may invest a part December 30 that pays to investor Rs. 100 on
capital appreciation provides a boost to returns.
of the portfolio in securities with longer December 30.
Such funds also have an exit load for investors
maturity.These securities will have to be marked The average time over which Bond A pays the
to deter them from taking short-term view.The investor the due flows is less than one year; hence its
to market based on price movement every day
portfolios of such funds have an average duration or average maturity will be less than one
and this aspect creates the incremental risk.
maturity of between 3 years to 8 years and year. As Bond B pays the investor after one year, its
There is no restriction in respect of marked to duration will be one year.The same concept can be
NAV can be extremely volatile in shorter
market and hence the funds may have exposure applied to instruments of higher maturities, too, to
of higher than 10 % to marked-to-market periods. calculate duration. The duration of a bond increases
Gilt Funds: Such funds invest in securities with its term-to-maturity and is inversely related to
securities. The portfolios of such funds usually
the coupon of the bond. Higher the duration greater
have average maturities of between 90 days and issued by the government of India and exhibit all
the interest-rate risk of the bond, as yield and
180 days. It is suitable for investors with a time qualities of long-term bond funds. They are duration are inversely related. Duration of a portfolio
horizon of 15 days to 3 months. Such funds especially suitable for Provident and Gratuity is an important measure in determining its interest-
provide high liquidity and seek to capture funds with statutory investment guidelines. rate risk.

Sundaram BNP Paribas Asset Management 9 The Wise Investor February 2010
Perspective India

Financial Inclusion, A Thousand Flowers Blooming


the bank, and the credit needed to keep her kids clutches of the usurious money lenders.
in school - a good fortune she herself never had. There is another benefit of financial inclusion which
• And then there is Lakshmi Shellar. Widowed at we have yet to fully appreciate let alone exploit.
17, Lakshmi helped form a local self-help group. Financial inclusion will make it possible for
She spoke up and spoke out at meetings, and governments to make payment such as social
inspired other women in the group to take their security transfers, National Rural Employment
future into their own hands. Meanwhile, she Guarantee Programme (NREGA) wages into the
brought banking services to them. And she bank accounts of beneficiaries through the ‘Electric
provided evening literacy classes. The 177 Benefit Transfer’ (EBT) method.
women of Lakshmi’s self-help group have all This will minimize transaction costs including
borrowed and repaid their loans. leakages. In parts of the country where such EBT has
Aruna and Lakshmi are just two of the millions of already taken off, the results are impressive and the
women across the countries who have experience of both payers and recipients extremely
Duvvuri Subbarao demonstrated what is possible if only rural women satisfying.
Governor can have access to basic financial services.This is what There are enormous benefits at the aggregate level
Reserve Bank of India financial inclusion is all about – giving people an too.
opportunity to build better lives for themselves and • The first and more obvious benefit is financial
their children. inclusion provides an avenue for bringing the
That impulse, if given a chance, can contribute to savings of the poor into the formal financial
Banking on the poor can actually be a rich banking sustained improvements in the quality of life at the intermediation system and channel them into
proposition. Financial inclusion is a win-win community level and foster growth and poverty investment.
opportunity for the poor, for the banks and for the reduction at the national level. • Second, the large number of low cost deposits
nation. Because of growing incomes, and improving There remain tremendous barriers to unleashing this will offer banks an opportunity to reduce their
awareness levels, aspirations of the poor are on the “fortune at the bottom of the pyramid.” Chief among dependence on bulk deposits and help them to
rise. them: financial exclusion. better manage both liquidity risks and asset-
We will not be forgiven if we do not rise up to meet This is a confluence of multiple barriers: lack of liability mismatches.
these aspirations if only because of poverty of access, lack of physical and social infrastructure, lack Financial Exclusion - The Big Picture
imagination. It is for the banks to convert what they of understanding and knowledge, lack of technology; Effort at financial inclusion is not new; both the
see as a dead-weight obligation into an exciting lack of support, lack of confidence, among others. Government and the Reserve Bank have been
opportunity and move on aggressively on financial
Overcoming these barriers is, in a nutshell, the pursuing this goal over the last several decades
inclusion.
challenge of financial inclusion. through building the rural cooperative structure in
Let me begin with a couple of anecdotes. In rural the 1950s, the social contract with banks in the
Why is Financial Inclusion Important?
Maharashtra, where people, like everywhere else in 1960s and the expansion of bank branch networks in
the country, face the daily challenges of water, Why is financial inclusion important? It is important
the 1970s and 1980s.These initiatives have paid off in
sanitation, electricity and transportation, a number of simply because it is a necessary condition for
terms of a network of branches across the country.
women have improved their lives, and the lives of sustaining equitable growth. There are few, if any,
instances of an economy transiting from an agrarian Yet the extent of financial exclusion is staggering. Out
their families, by becoming entrepreneurs, all because
system to a post-industrial modern society without of the 600,000 habitations in the country, only about
they could take a bank loan.
broad-based financial inclusion. As people having 30,000 have a commercial bank branch.
• Take Aruna Gaikwad. Aruna, a farm labourer,
comfortable access to financial services, we all know Just about 40 per cent of the population across the
began selling excess produce at the local market.
from personal experience that economic country have bank accounts, and this ratio is much
An astute observer of the laws of supply and
opportunity is strongly intertwined with financial lower in the north-east of the country. The
demand when it came to pricing fruit and
access. proportion of people having any kind of life
vegetables, she soon saw an uptick in business.
insurance cover is as low as 10 per cent and
To expand, she needed to borrow money so Such access is especially powerful for the poor as it
proportion having non-life insurance is an abysmally
that she could build her own vegetable stand. provides them opportunities to build savings, make
low 0.6 per cent.
The loan helped her establish a thriving investments and avail credit. Importantly, access to
vegetable vending business, allowing her to shift financial services also helps the poor insure People having debit cards comprise only 13 per cent
away from the back-breaking work tending themselves against income shocks and equips them and those having credit cards only a marginal 2 per
other people’s fields. Her former hand-to-mouth to meet emergencies such as illness, death in the cent.
existence had given way to a new reality, one family or loss of employment. Needless to add, The National Sample Survey data reveals that, in
which includes savings and checking accounts at financial inclusion protects the poor from the 2003, out of the 89.3 million farmer households in
Sundaram BNP Paribas Asset Management 10 The Wise Investor February 2010
the country, 51 percent did not seek credit from taking initiative from the supply side. remittances take place across the country today,
either institutional or non-institutional sources of any The big take away from (a recent) workshop, for the predominantly from migrant labour, and over ninety
kind. Reserve Bank as an institution and for me personally, per cent of this happens through non-formal
These statistics, staggering as they are, do not convey was that even as there are problems to extending channels.
the true extent of financial exclusion. Even where financial inclusion, these are not insurmountable. If If banks can capture even half of this into their fold,
bank accounts are claimed to have been opened, the Reserve Bank and the commercial banks put they will not only reduce costs for the labour making
verification has shown that these account are their minds, and more importantly their hearts, remittances but they will also have the advantage of
dormant. together these problems can be resolved. an enormous, permanent float.
Few conduct any banking transactions and even According to what we heard at the workshop, the Third, EBT, the electronic benefit transfer, is another
fewer receive any credit. Millions of people across three big challenges are: (i) cost; (ii) lack of robust big opportunity. I believe banks are inhibited about
the country are thereby denied the opportunity to technology; and (iii) lack of awareness. Some of these pushing this forward because of the fear of the
harness their earning capacity and entrepreneurial challenges are clearly being exaggerated and others unknown: they are not certain that the business can
talent, and are condemned to marginalization and can be easily redressed. be cost-effective. Banks are clearly underestimating
poverty. Cost, of course, is the main consideration. It is the potential.
But there is a brighter side to the story. Remember nobody’s case that each of the over 500,000 villages If indeed, all or even most government payments to
that illustration they give in business strategy courses. in the country can each be covered through a brick rural people are captured through the EBT mode,
A business executive of a shoe company was sent to and mortar branch. That is clearly not a ‘bankable’ this again can give banks a large float and make it an
a large developing country to assess the market proposition. We need to go through the low cost attractive business proposition. So far there has been
potential there. What he saw was millions of people Business Correspondent model and leverage a sharing of the costs between banks and state
going without shoes. He came back and reported to technology to deliver financial services. governments with regard to EBT. As EBT mode
the management that there was no business The Reserve Bank has encouraged banks to use IT- expands and becomes universal, banks will find that
potential there because no one wears shoes. enabled financial inclusion by leveraging on the smart this is a viable business model even without any
A few months later, a strategist of a rival company cards/mobile technology. Business Correspondents service charges.
went and saw the same picture. He came back and of banks are making extensive use of hand held It is also relevant here to acknowledge the potential
reported to his management that there is devices/mobile phones to reach banking services to of the Unique Identification Number (UID) that
tremendous business potential in that country remote villages, and especially for Electronic Benefits Nandan Nilekani and his team are working on. The
because of the number of shoes they can sell. Transfer of NREGA wages and social security UID will be a powerful instrumentality for helping
payments. poor people establish their identity to meet the
Ultimately, it is a question of mindset.
This has been very successful in Andhra Pradesh, and banks’ KYC norms.
Banks must see the picture like the second business
a state-wide project has recently been kicked-off in I believe, this is going to reduce cash and non-cash
strategist, look at the opportunity at the bottom of Orissa. In addition, pilot projects are underway in
the pyramid and move into financial inclusion in a big transaction costs both to the banks and to the
most states of the country. potential customers. The UID is another powerful
way.
As a village-to-village robust electronic remittance illustration of harnessing technology to the benefit of
Financial Inclusion-Challenges & Opportunities system is presently not available in the country, it can the poor.
Let me now turn to challenges to financial inclusion be enabled by building suitable infrastructure to
The Reserve Bank has made a commitment to bank-
and the potential opportunities. The question we connect the systems of various banks which are
led model of financial inclusion and will support
should ask ourselves is this: despite the rural policy- presently involved in Electronic Benefit Transfer
banks in their financial inclusion initiatives by way of
push, why are so many bankable people unbanked? (EBT) through the medium of Business
information dissemination, sharing of best practices
There are barriers to access financial services Correspondents.
and also through regulatory incentives.
emanating from both demand side and supply side A robust switch similar to the National Financial
factors. I want to add that our commitment to a bank led
Switch (NFS) located for the purpose in the National
model is not irrevocable.There are other models of
From the demand side, the big barriers are the lack payments Corporation of India / Institute for
financial inclusion that are being experimented
of awareness about financial services and products, Development Research in Banking Technology may
elsewhere in the world. Should banks fail to come
limited literacy, especially financial literacy of the fulfil a long felt requirement of a nationwide
forward and exploit this opportunity of financial
populace, and social exclusion. Many of the generic remittance system for the country.This will make the
inclusion, the Reserve Bank will not hesitate to
financial products are unsuitable for the poor and remittance system more efficient, and therefore,
explore other models of furthering financial inclusion.
there is not much of an effort to design products more attractive.
suitable to their needs. Last week, I visited Jalanga village in Orissa as part of
I also want to emphasize that there is tremendous
the outreach programme. I was very impressed by
The unfriendly and unempathetic attitude of the opportunity on the way forward for reducing costs
the self-help groups – groups of usually women who
banks to the customers also plays an important role by increasing volumes. Let me elaborate a bit. First,
there is the demographic profile – the labour force get together, pool their savings and give loans to
in undermining the demand for financial services. On
in the 15-64 age group is going to increase. members – and how these groups have empowered
top of that, exorbitant and oftentimes non-
the women by giving them financial independence
transparent fees, combined with burdensome terms As job opportunities grow and these people start
and thereby confidence.
and conditions attached to the financial products, earning, their incomes provide a large and growing
also dampens the demand. source of deposits for banks. Banks that are ahead of More than just hope, these women have the vision
the curve in establishing a presence in the vast to imagine how they can take advantage of the
From the supply side, the main barrier is the
hinterland of the country will have a first mover slightest opportunities and to work hard to make it
transaction costs that the bankers perceive. Because
advantage in exploiting this potentially huge happen.
of current low volumes, banks find that extending
financial services is not cost effective. Furthermore, opportunity. Remarks by Dr. D. Subbarao, Governor, Reserve Bank of
lack of communication, lack of infrastructure, Second, there is the opportunity of capturing India at the Bankers’ Club in Kolkata on December 9,
language barriers and low literacy levels all raise the remittances.Although there are no firm figures, I have 2009.
cost of providing services and inhibit bankers from been told that thousands of crores of rupees of Source: www.rbi.org.in
Sundaram BNP Paribas Asset Management 11 The Wise Investor February 2010
Thoughts From The Frontline

When the Fed Stops the Music


the G-7 countries want to issue? Who is Who Wants the Old Maid?
going to buy another $1 trillion here in just Why, therefore, would anyone want to be
the US? That is 7% of GDP. That means that long the dollar or treasuries? The dollar may
consumers and businesses will have to save be the worst currency in the world, except
an additional 7% of GDP just to finance for all the others.What's an emerging-market
government debt at the federal level, not
central banker to do? Where do you put your
counting state and local debt. As Bill Gross
reserves?
concludes in his recent column
(www.pimco.com): The dollar? With large fiscal deficits and low
interest rates? "What are my other choices?"
"The fact is that investors, much like national
they must be asking themselves. The euro?
citizens, need to be vigilant, and there has been
Really? The euro is not a currency, it is an
a decided lack of vigilance in recent years from
experiment.
John Mauldin both camps in the U.S.While we may not have
much of a vote between political parties, in the Everyone knows the problems of Greece.
Best-Selling Author, Recognized Financial Expert
and Editor of Thoughts From The Frontline investment world we do have a choice of There is no political will in the country (so
airlines and some of those national planes may far) to do what Ireland has done, and really
have elevated their bond and other asset cut their budget. I think Spain is an even
markets on the wings of central bank check bigger nightmare for the EU when compared
writing over the past 12 months. to relatively small Greece. Italy? Belgium?
The Federal Reserve has been very clear
Downdrafts and discipline lie ahead for Portugal?
about the fact that they intend to stop the
quantitative easing program at the end of governments and investor portfolios alike. All those countries (and their voters) will be
March. What that means in practice is that While my own Pollyannish advocacy of watching to see how the EU deals with
they are going to stop buying mortgage 'check-free' elections may be quixotic, the Greece.The potential for volatility in the euro
securities.That does two things. shifting of private investment dollars to more is just huge. I hope the euro survives. The
fiscally responsible government bond markets world is better off with the euro. But there
As Bill Gross so aptly points out, those
may make for a very real outcome in 2010 are very large pressures facing the Eurozone.
mortgage purchases helped keep mortgage
and beyond.
rates low. But they also financed the US And what about the British pound? Already
Additionally, if exit strategies proceed as down 20% (a little relief for my London trip
government fiscal deficit, albeit indirectly. It
planned, all U.S. and U.K. asset markets may next week!), and their problems are every bit
seems that funds and banks that sold the
suffer from the absence of the near $2 trillion as large as those in the US. What about the
mortgage securities turned around and
of government checks written in 2009. It yen?The government has let it be known they
bought US government debt or put the cash
seems no coincidence that stocks, high yield are not happy with the rise in the yen, and
right back at the Fed.
bonds, and other risk assets have thrived seem ready to actually do something about it.
Foreigners bought about $300 billion of the since early March, just as this 'juice' was being
$1.5 trillion in new government debt.The rest What about the Renminbi? Oh, wait, you
squeezed into financial markets.
came from the US, courtesy of the Fed can't get enough of them, and the Chinese
If so, then most 'carry' trades in credit,
buying mortgages. But that program stops manipulate their currency. Same for most
duration, and currency space may be at risk in
(theoretically) at the end of March. The other Asian currencies.
the first half of 2010 as the markets readjust
government still plans to run yet another The dollar may rise against the major
to the absence of their 'sugar daddy.'"
$1.4-trillion-dollar deficit (give or take a few currencies during the first part of the year. As
This is yet another uncertainty. We simply
hundred billion). I wrote weeks ago, world trade is slowly
have no idea, no relevant marker, for what
The question is, who will buy the debt? picking up. While that growth has not been
happens when a country goes so cold turkey,
Foreigners will kick in another $300 billion, very visible in the US, it is becoming evident
coming off a central bank bond-buying binge.
unless they decide to stop selling us stuff, or And this in the midst of a massive among the emerging-market countries that
buy other less liquid or physical assets. So far deleveraging and with stock market were not overly leveraged when the crisis
there is no sign of that. valuations basically where they were in 1987 began. And trade is still in dollars.
But as I asked last year, who is going to buy - except there was at least large earnings Businesses sold their dollars during the crisis,
the multiple trillions in government debt that growth then. as they did not need them for trade. But now,
Sundaram BNP Paribas Asset Management 12 The Wise Investor February 2010
with trade picking up, they once again have to • Deleveraging episodes are painful, lasting That worked for Japan for 20 years, as their
buy dollars.That is one reason for the recent six to seven years on average and domestic markets bought their debt. But that
bull market in dollars. The other is that the reducing the ratio of debt to GDP by 25 process is coming to an end.
markets are massively short the dollar. percent. GDP typically contracts during James Carville once famously remarked that
When everyone is on the same side of a the first several years and then recovers. when he died he wanted to come back as the
trade, that trade may have run its course, at • If history is a guide, many years of debt bond market, because that is where the real
least for a while. And that seems to be the reduction are expected in specific sectors power is. And I think we will find out all too
case recently for the dollar. of some of the world's largest soon what the bond vigilantes have to say.
So, where are the strong currencies going economies, and this process will exert a And so we have uncertainty all around us.
forward? The Canadian dollar is on its way to significant drag on GDP growth. What will our taxes look like in the US in just
parity. I would want to own the Aussie, if I was • Coping with pockets of deleveraging is 12 months? Health care? Who will finance the
a trader. Maybe the Swiss franc, although it is also a challenge for business executives. bonds, without a credible plan to reduce the
so high on a parity-value basis right now. The process portends a prolonged deficit? And any plan that has Nancy Pelosi as
But the currency I want the most if I am a period in which credit is less available and its guarantor is by definition not credible.
central banker is that barbaric yellow relic, more costly, altering the viability of some There is just so much that is uncertain, and all
gold. Just as India has recently bought 200 of business models and changing the
we can do is wait to see how it unfolds. My
tons of gold, I think central banks in other attractiveness of different types of
best guess is that we see a solid GDP number
emerging nations will want to buy more, too. investments. In historic episodes, private
posted for the 4th quarter (which will get
They all have relatively little gold as a investment was often quite low for the
revised down over time), due mostly to
percentage of their reserves. Look for that to duration of deleveraging. Today, the
stimulus and inventory rebuilding.
change. household sectors of several countries
have a high likelihood of deleveraging. If By the middle of the year the stimulus will be
I also like gold in terms of the euro, the far less. And while inventories are rebuilding
this happens, consumption growth will
pound, and the yen - more than I like it in and that is good for the GDP numbers, the
likely be slower than the pre-crisis trend,
terms of the US dollar, but even there I like sales-to-inventories number has not risen.
and spending patterns will shift.
gold long-term, at least until we get some And final demand is what drives inventory
Consumer-facing businesses have already
fiscal sanity. rebuilding.
seen a shift in spending toward value-
It's the Deleveraging, Stupid! oriented goods and away from luxury The latter half of the year looks to be weaker,
The reason this recession is different is that it goods, and this new pattern may persist and then we hit what right now looks like the
is a deleveraging recession.We borrowed too while households repair their balance largest tax increase in history, much of it on
much (all over the developed world) and sheets. Business leaders will need the small businesses that are the drivers of
now are having to repair our balance sheets flexibility to respond to such shifts. job creation. The National Federation of
as the assets we bought have fallen in value You can read the whole report at their web Independent Businesses just released their
(housing, bonds, securities, etc.). site. The ten-page summary is also there. latest survey. It was brutal. There is little
A new and very interesting (if somewhat http://www.mckinsey.com/mgi/publications/d optimism in it.
long) study by the McKinsey Global Institute ebt_and_deleveraging/index.asp The Fed is going to stop the music in March.
found that periods of overleveraging are The Lex column in the Financial Times There will be a scramble for the chairs.This is
often followed by 6-7 years of slow growth as observes, concerning the report: a huge experiment with no precedent. The
the deleveraging process plays out. No quick entire developed world is the test subject.
"It may be economically and politically
fixes. Risk assets will be subject to uncertainty. And
sensible for governments to spend money on
Let's look at some of their main conclusions markets hate uncertainty.
making life more palatable at the height of the
(and they have a solid ten-page executive crisis. But the longer countries go on before Hopefully, we can Muddle Through this year
summary, worth reading.) This analysis adds paying down their debt, the more painful and before a relapse into recession in 2011
new details to the picture of how leverage drawn-out the process is likely to be. Unless, (because of the tax increase). I wish I could
grew around the world before the crisis and of course, government bond investors revolt see it like Larry Kudlow (of CNBC), but I
how the process of reducing it could unfold. and expedite the whole shebang." don't. I would be very cautious about being
MGI finds that: long the stock market. It is now a trader's
And that is the crux of the matter. We have
• Leverage levels are still very high in some to raise $1 trillion-plus in the US from market. I would not be buying long-duration
sectors of several countries - and this is a domestic sources. Great Britain has the GDP- bonds. It is still an absolute-return world.
global problem, not just a US one. equivalent task. So does much of Europe. Copyright 2009 John Mauldin. All Rights
• To assess the sustainability of leverage, Japan is simply off the radar. Japan, as I have Reserved.
one must take a granular view using noted, is a bug in search of a windshield. John Mauldin, Best-Selling author and
multiple sector-specific metrics. The Some time in the coming few years the bond recognized financial expert, is also editor of
analysis has identified ten sectors within markets of the world will be tested. Normally the free Thoughts From the Frontline that
five economies that have a high likelihood a deleveraging cycle would be deflationary goes to over 1 million readers each week. For
of deleveraging. and lower interest rates would be the more information on John or his FREE weekly
• Empirically, a long period of deleveraging outcome. But in the face of such large deficits, economic letter go to:
nearly always follows a major financial crisis. with no home-grown source to meet them? http://www.frontlinethoughts.com/learnmore
Sundaram BNP Paribas Asset Management 13 The Wise Investor February 2010
Economic Crisis Effects

Life in the time of Great Recession


The title is not original. It is a take off from Love in the Time of Cholera by Gabriel Garcia Marquez, Nobel Prize
winning author from Columbia, who was also recently selected as the most influential writer of the past 25 years for this
book. Pardon that indulgence on our part, but we felt this best captures what you are about to read.

Even as equity markets led by Wall Street have charted a major rally on the back of liquidity since March 2009, the
ground reality on Main Street is different. Read this eighth part of how the Great Recession is touching lives in many-a-
different way.
Number of start-ups tumble: The number of people with no home or relatives. structural unemployment.” Entire industries have
new businesses being set up around the world has But in 2009, Gunson says, an unprecedented been hobbled, such as construction, some elements
declined in the face of the global recession, a number of bodies went unclaimed — some for a of financial services, and the auto industry.
report has found. month or more — not because family couldn't be Staying late, millions are working for nothing: If
New start-ups were down 10% last year in 20 of found, but because the economy has left families you spent yesterday playing in the snow with the
the world's richest nations, said the latest edition of unable to pay for even the most basic $500 kids, there is no need to feel guilty. If you were one
the annual Global Entrepreneurship Monitor cremation. of the five million people who regularly work
(GEM). It found that the decline was the most The trend is elusive to track. In Oregon, demand on unpaid overtime, you were merely redressing the
severe in the US, where it fell 24%. By contrast, the the indigent burial fund was so high last year, the balance, at least for a day.
UK only saw a 6% dip. Legislature had to nearly triple fees on death The TUC said yesterday that UK workers were
The United Arab Emirates saw the most start-up certificates to keep the fund solvent. giving away £27.4 billion of unpaid overtime,
activity in 2009, up 38%. Now in its 11th year, the Highest Number of Long-Term Unemployed In 62 despite a prolonged recession that has seen many
2009 GEM report was based on a study of 54 years: Forty percent of all unemployed Americans, companies cut working hours and drastically scale
countries, and more than 180,00 interviews. The at least 6 million, have been out of work more than back paid overtime.
study was established by London Business School six months. Many are so discouraged they have lost According to the TUC’s latest research, the five
and Babson College in the US. hope that a job exists for them.It is a national million people who regularly work unpaid overtime
"Throughout the world, would-be entrepreneurs challenge: reduce the number of people who have are working on average 57 days a year for nothing.
reported greater difficulty in obtaining financial been out of work for a long time. The figure represents the highest number of unpaid
backing for their start-up activities, especially from In the December unemployment report, the extra hours worked since the late 1990s.
informal investors - families, friends, and strangers," Bureau of Labor Statistics said the number of On the positive side, there has been a small
said Professor Bill Bygrave of Babson College, one people out of work for 27 weeks or more hit 6.1 decrease in employees who regularly work unpaid
of the founders of GEM. million Americans, or 40 percent of all 15.3 million overtime. Since 2008, when the TUC last analysed
"What is needed is for entrepreneurs to feel jobless. official statistics, 168,000 fewer people have said
comfortable venturing out again, because they are This is the most since 1948, when the data was first that they regularly work extra hours for no pay.
the real engine for creating new jobs. Unfortunately, recorded, according to the Department of Labor. Warring couples forced to live together:
there is not a silver bullet for entrepreneurs,” said On average, it now takes 20.5 weeks to find a new More than a quarter of cohabiting couples that
Kristie Seawright, executive director of GEM. job – double the amount of time in the 1982-83 break up are forced to continue living together
More Unclaimed Bodies: To step into the recession. because of the effects of the recession, research
morgue at the Oregon medical examiner's office is “It’s a real risk to the workplace,” says John has found.
to confront destitution at its most final. Challenger of Challenger, Gray & Christmas, the Two-thirds of people who continue to share a
In this frigid, dark locker, the dead lie draped in outplacement firm in Chicago.“We may be creating property with a former partner said they cannot
plastic sheeting on steel tables.These aren't people a permanent group of people who think there are afford to move, while one in forty couples are
who died watched over by family. Dr. Karen no jobs out there, who feel they are shut out of the unable to sell their homes because of negative
Gunson's morgue is the first stop for people who system.” equity, according to the survey by
were killed in car accidents or shootings, or who Part of the reason the nation has such a large Easyroommate.co.uk .
simply died at home, by themselves. number of long-term unemployed is related to the Jonathan Moore, of the house and flat-share
Gunson says these people died unexpectedly, and nature of the downturn, says economist Richard website, said: “The recession is preventing even
their families — if they had families — weren't DeKaser of Woodley Park Research in Washington. more couples from making a clean break when
prepared.Oregon is one of several states that “This is not your typical cyclical downturn where they split up. Unfortunately, those same financial
provides funding for so-called indigent burials. hiring is just postponed until business improves,” stresses that make the break-up process so difficult
Historically, this money pays for a final service for says Mr. DeKaser. “This is really more about are often a key reason for the break up. And

Sundaram BNP Paribas Asset Management 14 The Wise Investor February 2010
although people are aware of the negative equity • Americans will buy more wine at the $10-and- even feel bad I guess asking for a lot.”
trap that many divorcing couples face- few realise under level. The best bet for an expanding Teenagers’ growing mindfulness about money is
the heartache this is causing cohabiting couples market is China, which is thirsty for good, influenced, of course, by the way their parents are
who have split up.” inexpensive wine. cutting back, and by a record-high teenage
Research by Shelter, the housing charity, also Lowest-ever level of job satisfaction: Even unemployment rate. But the biggest factor,
indicates that a quarter of Britons are sharing with Americans who are lucky enough to have work in according to the teenagers themselves, is that they
an ex-partner or know someone who is, because this economy are becoming more unhappy with have come to understand the social moment. “As
they cannot afford to live alone. The charity said their jobs, according to a new survey that found me and my brothers get older and we realize the
that the high cost of housing and the shortage of only 45 percent of Americans are satisfied with implications of the recession,” said Sarah Berger, 16,
affordable homes was forcing an increasing number their work.That was the lowest level ever recorded “we just kind of value presents and gifts less.”
of couples to share a property when they might by the Conference Board research group in more Seismic shift in consumer culture: As crazy
not under different circumstances, putting strain on than 22 years of studying the issue. In 2008, 49 as it sounds, losing a $70,000-a-year job has been
otherwise happy relationships. percent of those surveyed reported satisfaction good for Marty Morua's finances. The former Wall
with their Street stockbroker says the setback forced him to
"New York Runs Like a Payday Loan
Operation" : In a strikingly blunt State of the Workers have grown steadily more unhappy for a scrutinize his family budget and snip away at
State address, Gov. David A. Paterson chastised the variety of reasons: expenses. And soon, even with less income, their
lawmakers seated before him saying they had • Fewer workers consider their jobs to be savings grew.
spent the state into near-ruin and stood by as a interesting. First, he and his wife decided to live on her salary
plague of political corruption destroyed New • Incomes have not kept up with inflation. so he could be home with their 5-year-old
Yorkers’ trust in their government. daughter after school. Without a nanny, they saved
• The soaring cost of health insurance has eaten
The public scolding drew a cold response from into workers' take-home pay. $12,000 a year. He dropped services he didn't use
lawmakers. Some sat stony-faced during the on his cellphone -- texting and video games -- to
If the job satisfaction trend is not reversed,
speech, while others fidgeted with BlackBerrys. pocket $250 a year.
economists say, it could stifle innovation and hurt
Lawmakers, Mr. Paterson charged, had too often America's competitiveness and productivity. And it He took a defensive-driving course for a 10
bowed to the wishes of powerful special interests, could make unhappy older workers less inclined to percent discount on his auto insurance and
feeding an “addiction to spending, power and take the time to share their knowledge and skills dropped car-rental and roadside-assistance
approval” and plunging the state into economic with younger workers. coverage, for an extra $150 a year. For holiday gifts,
catastrophe. “No longer are we going to run New he turned to thrift stores and gave home-baked
College costs rise, loans harder to get:
York like a payday loan operation,” the governor cookies.
When Daniel Ottalini entered the University of
vowed. Maryland in 2004, his family had an array of choices "When I was working, I didn't look at the price tag,"
Referring to industry and labor lobbyists in the to cover the cost -- cheap student loans, a second he said. "In a strange way," he added, losing the job
chamber, he declared, “The moneyed interests — mortgage at low rates, credit cards with high limits "has been a blessing to teach me how to become
many are here today as guests — have got to and their own soaring investments. aggressive and wise about saving and ways to save
understand that their days of influence in this town -- areas I never would have thought about."
By the time his younger brother, Russell, started at
are numbered.” the University of Pittsburgh this fall, the financial The recession has caused a seismic shift in the
Challenging times for wine & champagne: crisis had left the family with fewer options. Russell consumer culture, converting die-hard spenders
What a difference a decade makes. With high has had to juggle several jobs in school, and the into savers. A growing number of people, either
unemployment, pared-down expense accounts and money he could borrow came with a much higher smarting from a job loss or spooked by the financial
a glut of wine, it’s the consumer’s turn to make interest rate that could climb even further over crises of others, are scrambling to get out of debt,
merry, with lower prices, more choice and less time. establish emergency funds, and add to their
pretension.Those 99-point ratings don’t seem quite retirement and savings accounts.
To pay for higher education, most Americans had
so requisite any more to buying good wine. So come to rely on a range of financial products born Youth Depression hard on retailers: People under
what do I see happening in 2010? of the Wall Street boom. Nearly all of these shrank 30 have been pounded by this recession and its job
• Prices will continue to drop across the board, or disappeared in the storm that engulfed the stock losses and the implications for some retailers are
from the priciest of Bordeaux and Burgundy to and debt markets. proving to be dire this holiday season. Andrew Sum,
cult California wines that were once available a labor economist at Northeastern University in
Lenders have raised rates and tightened standards,
only by subscription. Boston, reckons about 50 percent of the 7.7 million
dramatically limiting the availability of home-equity
jobs lost over the past two years have been
• More people will buy online. Wine stores will loans and private student loans. College savings
absorbed by those under 30.
stock more inexpensive wines, which account accounts, known as 529 plans, had acute losses in
for most of their profits. the downturn. And a new law, set to take effect Feb. Within that group, about 62 percent of these job
22, will bar students younger than 21 from getting losses have been incurred by young men Those
• The tsunami of new wines from South aged 16 to 19 have seen a 23 percent decline in
credit cards on their own.
America and Eastern Europe will ebb as the jobs -- by far the sharpest decline of any age
market overflows. Teenagers cutting back: After a year of
observing their parents pinch pennies and fret category.This may explain why mall-based retailers
• Champagne will be in serious trouble. catering to male and female teens are resorting to
about the economy, the nation’s teenagers may be
• Fine-dining restaurants will buy nominal coming to grips with reality. Sales are down sharply steep promotions.
numbers of expensive wines after trimmed in recent months at nearly every major retail chain The young tend to spend what they earn so their
expense accounts caused them to sit on their catering to teenagers, and interviews with job woes are bad news for retailers. And in this
previous big capital purchases.They’ll wait until teenagers suggest that the reasons go beyond their downturn, they can't rely on making up the
guests are telling sommeliers, “Money is no own difficulty finding part-time jobs. difference through from parents' wallets, which
object.” Good luck with that. “I think my sister and I, throughout this year we’ve already are stretched thin.
• Fewer top-end restaurants will even open, and kind of lost an interest in getting gifts and things like Sources: BBC, NPR, Christian Science Monitor, Times
more modest new eateries will build wine lists that,” said Morgan Porpora, 16, who in the past had Online, Mish Global Economic Analysis, Bloomberg,
with interesting, small labels from around the a list of things she wanted for Christmas. “I guess Washington Post, New York Times. Reuters, Financial
world and sell them at reasonable mark-ups. we’ve noticed the economy and we just kind of Armageddon, Reuters

Sundaram BNP Paribas Asset Management 15 The Wise Investor February 2010
EcoWeek

Unsynchronised recoveries
The Chinese economy hit an air pocket in late
Greece in the limelight
2008/early 2009, but the government managed to
stimulate infrastructure investment via very aggressive Greece remains in the headlines after its credit
budget measures and an extremely accommodating rating was downgraded by the three big rating
monetary policy (loans outstanding were up 34% at agencies in December and January: it now has a
mid year). Retail sales also accelerated rapidly. BBB+ rating with Fitch and Standard & Poor’s, and
Buoyant domestic demand offset mild exports and an A2 rating from Moody’s.
the negative contribution of foreign trade to GDP After a visit from experts from the European
growth. Growth surged from 6.1% in the first quarter Commission and the ECB to examine its public
to 8.9% in the third quarter. The government could finances, the Commission has just released a very
even reach its 2009 target of 8% growth. Yet these critical report on the quality of Greek statistical data
policies are also risky and threaten to create surplus (see “Report on Greek government deficit and
capacity, asset bubbles, to name a few. debt statistics”, European Commission, January
Widespread wage moderation combined with the 2010).
cyclical rebound in productivity gains, especially in the The Commission fears that the estimates published
Philippe d'Arvisenet US, has put downward pressure on unit wage costs. last October could be much too optimistic. The
Chief Economist Consequently, we can rule out the idea of inflationary public deficit could reach about 12% of GDP in
BNP Paribas - Economic Research pressures in terms of costs. 2010, after nearly 13% in 2009, with the public debt
The abundance of unused production capacity and accounting for about 125% of GDP in 2010, the
the negative output gap will persist throughout 2010 highest in the Eurozone.
as well as 2011, given the feeble strength of growth Moreover, at the government’s request, an IMF
expectations, eliminating all pricing pressures in terms mission was sent to Greece this week “to examine
History will remember 2009 as the year of the
of demand. the possibility of providing technical assistance on
deepest and longest recession since the Second
On the whole, although the impact of higher oil reforming pensions, fiscal policy, tax administration
World War. Economic activity contracted dramatically
prices and the elimination of base effects due to the and budget management.”
under the combined impact of housing market crises,
especially in the US, the UK, Spain and Ireland; the past drop in energy prices is in the process of lifting The Greek prime minister has presented the broad
inflation into positive territory, the downward outlines of his stabilisation and growth plan (the
collapse of exports, notably in Germany and Japan;
pressure on core inflation guarantees that inflation document was sent to the European Commission
the drop-off in asset prices and in general, the impact
will be very mild in 2010. on Friday, 15 January), which is designed to reduce
of the downturn in job markets on revenues and
Yet the consequences of the crisis are far from over the public deficit to less than 3% by 2012.
confidence.
and will continue to strain growth in 2010, preventing Yet the financial markets do not seem very willing
Both the UK and Spain were still mired in recession GDP from rising above or even matching its long- to be convinced
in the third quarter, and the Spanish economy is term potential: there will not be a catching up effect
expected to contract slightly further in 2010. for GDP lost during the crisis. With the deterioration of public finances, the credit
US GDP contracted over four consecutive quarters First, in countries with very high debt ratios where agencies have downgraded their ratings for
before swinging back into mild growth in third the negative wealth effect continues to play, several countries, some with a negative credit watch.
quarter 2009, bolstered by the slowdown in household will mainly be concerned about repairing All of this tended to exacerbate fears, resulting in
destocking, the rebound in the housing market, thanks their balance sheets. The deterioration in the job wider sovereign debt spreads.
to past price cuts and fiscal incentives for first-time markets is not over yet.
Although it might seem judicious to move cautiously
homeowners, and a surge in household consumption, Employment is a lagging variable in the business cycle, down the path towards budget consolidation at a
fuelled largely by the cash for clunkers programme. and the jobless rate has yet to peak (unemployment time when the economic recovery is so fragile, it is
Temporary technical factors and economic stimulus was over 10% in the US and nearly as high in the
crucial to demonstrate credible programmes to clean
measures were key drivers behind this rebound, Eurozone in December 2009). This strains the
up public finances.
which explains the persistent uncertainty concerning formation of revenues and creates incentives for
precautionary savings. To halt current budget overruns, it is important to
the solidity of the recovery. All in all, US GDP restore budget manoeuvring room and prevent
contracted roughly 2.5% in 2009. Moreover, the recession triggered a very sharp
uncertainty from further encouraging private savings
decline in fiscal revenues coupled with a series of
In the Eurozone, economic activity contracted much in anticipation of higher fiscal pressures, which would
economic support measures, without speaking about
more abruptly over a period of five quarters (-3.8% efforts to rescue financial institutions. only hamper the recovery.
in 2009), despite similar efforts to adopt extremely Under this cyclical environment and in the absence
accommodating policies. It is worth noting the sharp Public deficits have soared to 10 points of GDP in the
US, over 13.5 points in the UK and 6.5 points in the any inflationary threats, key central bank rates are
disparities: GDP contracted by nearly 5% in Germany likely to be held at currently low levels throughout
Eurozone. Public debts have swollen dramatically, and
and Italy, over 3.5% in Spain and nearly 2.5% in France. 2010. Priority will be given to the gradual elimination
recent trends cannot be sustained. The impact on
Japan was hard hit by the full impact of the crisis on interest charges has not been very significant given of non-conventional measures.
exports and investment, and sunk back into deflation. the decline in interest rates, but naturally this effect Source: BNP Paribas EcoWeek, a publication of the BNP
GDP is expected to contract by nearly 5.5% in 2009. cannot be replicated. Paribas group www.bnpparibas.com
Sundaram BNP Paribas Asset Management 16 The Wise Investor February 2010
Insight

Making room for China in the world economy


does, the Chinese position has more force than critics explicit industrial policies that the country had been
give it credit. The conventional fix for China’s current relying on. Prior to the late 1990s, China’s
account surplus, consisting of a combination of manufacturing industries were promoted by a wide
expenditure expansion and currency appreciation, will variety of inducements, including high tariff barriers,
shift the structure of the economy away from tradables investment incentives, export subsidies, and domestic
and towards non-tradables. content requirements on foreign firms.
This may be good for macroeconomic balance in China As a condition of membership, China had to phase out
and elsewhere, but it will almost certainly have adverse these policies. From levels that were among the highest
effects on China’s growth – perhaps large enough to in the world as late as the early 1990s China’s import
even endanger the country’s social and political stability. tariffs fell to single-digit levels by the end of the decade.
Tradables as the engine of growth Local content requirements and export subsidies were
What is common in the experiences of Japan, South eliminated. Currency undervaluation, or protection
Korea, China, and all other growth superstars? They all through the exchange rate, became the de facto
based their growth strategies on developing industrial substitute.
Dani Rodrik capabilities rather than on specialising according to their What if China stopped growing?: If undervaluation has
Rafiq Hariri Professor of International Political prevailing comparative advantages. They each became supported China’s recent growth, what kind of growth
Economy manufacturing superpowers in short order – and much penalty would the economy suffer if China were to let
John F. Kennedy School of Government. more rapidly than one would have expected based on its currency appreciate (in the absence of compensating
their resource endowments. changes in industrial policies)?
China’s export bundle was built up using strategic By many accounts, including my own estimates, China’s
public investments and industrial policies that forced currency is undervalued by around 25%. Correcting this
Policymakers blame the undervalued renmimbi for the foreign companies to transfer technology; today, the undervaluation would result in a reduction in Chinese
global imbalances. Here one of the world’s leading country’s export bundle resembles what one would growth of 2.15 percentage points per annum. This is a
development economists argues that the undervalued expect for a country that is three or four times richer sizable effect, even by the standards of China’s
currency boosts China’s growth, and this, in turn, is good than China. superlative growth record.
for the world’s recovery and the alleviation of poverty. High-growth countries are those that are able to Most importantly, a slowdown of this magnitude would
China could maintain its growth without trade undertake rapid structural transformation from low- put China below the 8% growth threshold its
imbalances if it could introduce industrial subsidies to productivity (“traditional”) to high-productivity leadership apparently believes is necessary to maintain
offset a rising yuan. It is better to subsidise tradables (“modern”) activities. These modern activities are social peace and avert social strife.
directly than to subsidise them indirectly through the largely tradable products, and within tradables, they are No-one knows where the 8% figure really comes from;
exchange rate. This may run afoul of WTO rules, but mostly industrial ones (although tradable services are it clearly does not have a scientific basis. Many China
that doesn’t diminish the economic case for the policy. clearly becoming important as well). experts think the Chinese society and polity are
As it comes out of the crisis, the world economy faces The reason that undervaluation of the currency works capable of handling growth much lower than that.
two apparently conflicting demands. On the one hand, as a powerful force for economic growth is that it acts Nevertheless, even if the political implications can be
achieving global macroeconomic stability and as a kind of industrial policy. By raising the domestic put aside, it would be hardly a desirable outcome if the
preventing a protectionist backlash will require that we relative price of tradable economic activities, it increases most potent poverty-reduction engine the world has
avoid large current account imbalances of the type that the profitability of such activities, and spurs capacity and ever known were to experience a noticeable slow
the world economy experienced in the run-up to the employment generation in the modern industrial down.
crisis. On the other hand, returning to rapid growth in sectors that are key to growth.
It is true that other countries that relied on exports to
the developing nations will require that they resume As discussed in detail in Rodrik (2008), the association grow rapidly – such as Germany, Japan, and South Korea
their conquest of global market share in tradable goods. between undervalued currencies and high growth is a – eventually had to let their currencies appreciate. But
The challenge of meeting both demands is epitomised very robust feature of the post-war data, particularly for China is still a very poor country, at barely above one-
by the contentious US-China bilateral relationship. lower-income countries. tenth the income level of the US.
American (and European) policy makers blame China China’s currency undervaluation: China has not always It has a huge reservoir of surplus labour in the
for an undervalued renminbi, which they argue is the had a large external imbalance, or an undervalued countryside. In addition, it has to live with restrictions
root cause of China’s huge trade surplus. currency. In fact, prior to the present decade it never on its industrial policies that none of these other
Chinese leaders resist the pressure, fearing that had a current account surplus exceeding 4% of GDP. countries, in pre-WTO days, had to abide by.
appreciation will undercut the competitiveness of From 2001 on, China’s surplus began its inexorable rise
Dani Rodrik is the Rafiq Hariri Professor of International
Chinese goods in world markets, hurt exports, and to more than 10% by 2007.
Political Economy at the John F. Kennedy School of
damage growth. China’s arguments are typically Interestingly, 2001 also saw China joining the WTO, Government.
dismissed by Western commentators, who argue that it after years of negotiation. It may not be a coincidence Hyperlink to this article:
is time the country turned away from exports and gave that China’s current account imbalance began to widen http://www.voxeu.org/index.php?q=node/4399
a boost to its service industries. and its currency undervaluation started to rise just as Source: www.voxeu.com (VoxEU.org is a policy portal
But if growth depends primarily on the supply of the country became a member of the trade body. set up by the Centre for Economic Policy Research
modern manufactured products and other tradables as WTO membership made it difficult, if not impossible, (www.CEPR.org) in conjunction with a consortium of
opposed to services and non-tradables, as I think it for China to promote its industries with the type of national sites)
Sundaram BNP Paribas Asset Management 17 The Wise Investor February 2010
Blog Picks

Short memory, $ positives & If I were Ben


The decade of short memory: Ingrid Bergman quick to adopt a pre-emptive-strike Dollar Positives
once said that “happiness is good health and a doctrine, invade Iraq, seal our windows with Kyle Bass, founder of Hayman Capital, says the
bad memory”. I beg to differ. duct tape and, lately, prohibit airline US has 10-12 years to right the ship; I think 5-
At the risk of challenging the philosophical and passengers from covering themselves with a 10 years (but closer to 5 than 10). Even if it's
emotional authority of a Hollywood celeb, I’d blanket *one hour* before a plane’s landing! only three years, it's not today's worry. In the
argue that forgetting, say, the name of a senior • Economic policymakers are barely faring meantime, the pending collapse of Japanese
manager at your company’s Christmas party, or better: Short memory against the backdrop government bonds will not be good for the
driving off with someone else’s sports car after carry trade, but should benefit the US dollar.
of the stunning “failure of capitalism” has
the parking valet (and you!) confused it for your In fact, there are many things good for the US
brought (some of) us back to Keynes’ arms, dollar here.
own rental, are not exactly “happy moments” has triggered calls to reinstate the Glass-
once you account for the consequences. • Japan demographics as noted above
Steagall Act and has even led to doubts
• Greece bailout
But worse than a bad memory is a short about the Fed’s independence. • Spain property bubble
memory. And in the spirit of the general • Short memory even discouraged some • Baltic state currency collapse
pontification on the decade that is about to go traumatized investors from getting back into • Savings rate in US headed north
by, let me say that this was the decade of short the stock market earlier this year, costing • Extreme bearish US dollar sentiment
memory par excellence. them the opportunity of a +68% • Pending implosion in the UK
• Take national security: Short memory in turnaround. • Canadian property bubble bursting
• Australian property bubble bursting
the context of a few years of “terror-free Problem is, a complete self-imposed disbelief in • Hard landing in China, collapse of the RMB
calm” on US soil is in part to blame for the your own memory is very hard to achieve, both
spectacular blunder that allowed a guy with Most would argue against a hard landing in
at an individual level, let alone by an entire China, but I actually think that is the best
explosives wrapped around his body to Congress. Coming to think of it, maybe Ingrid China can look forward to after its rampant
board on a US-bound airplane. Bergman’s plea was right after all… happiness expansion of credit. All of the above are
• Short memory (or shall we say ignorance of may indeed rest on a truly bad memory… accidents in progress or accidents that will
history?) was also behind the failure of US provided that we’re aware of it! happen soon enough. The US dollar should
intelligence to grasp the threat to national benefit when they do.
Models & Agents http://bit.ly/83BFgB
security from Afghanistan’s internal Moreover, I would like to point out that the
instability and socio-ethnic fragmentation If I were Federal Reserve Chairman: If I were Massachusetts special election is likely to be
back in 2001. Federal Reserve Chairman, I would figure out US dollar positive. After the special election
why: Democrat massacre, there will be little
• Basically, short memory drove us away from
• The value of the dollar has declined more sentiment for more bailouts but there will be
the big picture, compromised our forward- increasing calls for more fiscal prudence and
looking vision, compartmentalized our focus than 95 percent since the Federal Reserve
was created in 1913, given that one of the less government spending. It will be much
and prevented us from connecting the dots tougher to pass stimulus bills, or bills of any
at critical moments. Compartmentalized Fed’s two mandates is to promote “long-
kind.
focus… failure to connect the dots… Tell term price stability” (the other is “full
employment”); Health care may not even pass now, although
me you see the parallel with our blunders in it's likely the Obama administration will
the sphere of finance! • Many banks were allowed to loosen or manage to slam it through in one last hurrah,
• As it happened, short memory led investors abandon traditional lending standards, ramp possibly by the simple manoeuvre of the
to flout growing signs of asset bubbles and up leverage, concentrate their credit House accepting the Senate version straight
flock into investments that, in retrospect, exposure in risky sectors (e.g., commercial up.
seemed absurd. real estate), and skirt rules designed to However, if the healthcare bill does not pass,
protect the financial system, given that the that too would likely be US$ positive.
• Short memory drove traditional “financial
Fed is charged with regulating and Finally, many US states are in deep, deep
fire brigades” like the IMF to near extinction,
after a few crisis-free years bred a belief in supervising the sector; and, trouble. California and Illinois lead the list.The
• Monetary policies ostensibly aimed at change in the senate is a huge message that
countries’ economic impregnability.
smoothing the peaks and troughs of the states are going to have to go it alone and not
• Short memory even afflicted such rely on Washington for bailouts.
intellectual masters as Ben Bernanke, who business cycle and ensuring that the U.S.
economy remained on an even keel Add it all up and most of the possible
coined the term “Great Moderation” in surprises are likely to be US$ supportive.
describing our new era or “stability” and spawned numerous asset and credit bubbles
Thus, dollar bears should consider hibernating
“prosperity”. and laid the groundwork for the biggest for a while.The stars are aligned for at least a
financial crisis this century. modest dollar rally, and perhaps a lot more
• Now, failing to prevent major blunders is
one (bad) thing… Allowing our short After that, I would take Jim Rogers’ advice and than that.
memory to define our (knee-jerk) response call it a day. Mish Global Economic Analysis:
is still another.Yet, in this very spirit we were Financial Armageddon http://bit.ly/daYYFM http://bit.ly/4Y3jTG

Sundaram BNP Paribas Asset Management 18 The Wise Investor February 2010
The Book of Choice

Survival +
other words: "what happens in month seven"? Elite (the Plutocracy) or to its high-caste technocratic
Viewing ourselves in isolation is ultimately misleading.That is workforce.
why I subtitled this book "Structuring Prosperity for Yourself These are troubling assertions, and they require careful
and the Nation." To believe that we can prosper individually analysis.
without regard for the actions of our fellow citizens and the It is my contention that the global meltdown has exposed the
State (government) is simply not practical. This, then, is a Plutocracy's over-reach via ever-larger bets, ever-riskier
practical book for the rest of us. leverage and ever-larger redistributions of national income to
The status quo "Powers That Be" and its mainstream media its own coffers.To protect its interests and dominance, it must
repeatedly insist that: defend at all costs the intellectual framework that enables its
• We have abundant cheap energy for a long time to dominance.
come; shortages or permanently costly energy is Thus there is a whiff of desperation in its campaign to
decades away.We have plenty of time for technological convince the world that this is not at heart a global crisis
wonders to arise and replace petroleum. which threatens to bring down the entire structure but a
• The Social Security and Medicare entitlements "normal" if slightly deeper recession which has already been
promised to all Americans, though totaling some $50 repaired by the usual "fix" of State manipulation of interest
trillion in excess of projected tax revenues, will be paid; rates and money supply.
all that is needed are modest policy adjustments. We must be alert to the concentrated ownership/control of
• The current financial meltdown was unexpected and the mass media, and to the overwhelming need of the global
could not have been foreseen; it is a temporary "bad Elites to reassure their restive, anxious populaces that the
patch" which has already been fixed by government structure of Elite dominance and wealth is robust, secure, and
intervention and modest policy/regulatory adjustments. in the populace's self-interest.
• Public and private credit and debt can continue Conflicts between various segments of the Elite does not
Of Two Minds is a blog that has articulated on the global
expanding three times faster than GDP indefinitely; mean there is no Plutocracy--it only means that greed and
economic and financial crisis from an early stage. Charles
rising credit and debt are the essential lifeblood of over-reach naturally set up some shuffling and pushing to
Hugh Smith has put together his thoughts on the crisis and
permanent growth. head the line.
the challenges it poses in a simple, cogently argued and
comprehensive book, Survival +. We have had the • Environmental issues such as the stripping of the world's Lastly, the status quo understanding of the world is that any
opportunity to read the compressed e-book version. It is a fisheries, dead zones in the Chesapeake Bay, dwindling problem is inherently "fixable" with minor policy adjustments.
must read to understand the processes at work, as the effects fresh water aquifers, etc. can all be fixed with modest Thus even as the global financial pyramid of highly leveraged
could last several years (Japan has stepped into its third policy adjustments. bets and debts unravels, the status quo response is
decade of woe).A complete review will follow when we have • The consumerist culture that has evolved over the past bureaucratic shuffling of oversight duties, minor tweaking of
read the full book. 60 years is a natural and highly successful perfection of regulatory rules trumpeted as "major fixes" and behind the
We present edited extracts from the book. capitalism, prosperity and American values; Americans scenes, trillion-dollar bailouts of the Plutocracy funded by the
are the happiest, most prosperous people on the planet. non-Elite taxpayers.
Since launching my blog www.oftwominds.com in May 2005,
nothing seemed more important than warning readers that • The fast-growing epidemic of obesity and related When the non-Elite citizen comes to understand this, a new
the unsustainably leveraged credit-mad global financial system chronic diseases in the U.S. are puzzling and worrisome, mechanism takes hold that I call when belief in the system
was poised to break down. but we have the finest healthcare system in the world. fades.
Once the system finally crashed in late 2008, my goal Yet all of the above is demonstrably false. This is how empires fall: complacency joins hands with self-
switched to writing a practical guide for not just surviving the If all the fundamental contentions of the Powers That Be are aggrandizement.
coming Great Transformation but prospering: a concept I demonstrably false, we are forced to ask why they press them As the wheels fall off the U.S. economy and the bubbles
called Survival+ (Plus).This requires liberating ourselves from so mightily and persuasively on us. cannot be re-inflated, fruitless attempts at holding back the
failed models of credit expansion, resource depletion, financial The answer to this critical question can be found by asking cui tide with incantations (stop, tide, I speak for the U.S.Treasury!)
looting and a counterfeit prosperity built entirely on debt. bono: to whose benefit? and loopy sand castles (the bottom is in, buy now!) abound.
I immediately ran into several great difficulties. Many others Although we are constantly told the system benefits all of us, Unresponsive to propaganda, the real world grinds down into
had foreseen the same calamity, and their focus narrowed on that it is the very perfection of prosperity, free market a global Depression without visible end. If we do nothing, we
individual survival: relocating to a remote/sustainable spot and capitalism and thus of happiness itself, this is also will be swept along in the Great Descent. Alternatively, if we
preparing for societal collapse by stockpiling self-defense and demonstrably false. want to prosper, then we must first gain an integrated
food. This leads to the conclusion that the entire intellectual understanding of all the interlocking crises we face.
While prudent and practical on a short-term timeline, this structure which supports and enables the U.S. economy, Book: Survival + "Structuring Prosperity for Yourself and the
response struck me as incomplete on several levels. Most government and culture is nonsense, and those pushing it so Nation." by Charles Hugh Smith (396 pages).A truncated version
importantly, stockpiling six months' supplies would not sustain mightily and perseveringly are doing so out of a highly refined Survival + The Primer (134 pages) is also available. If you are
anyone through a 20-year Crisis and Transformation; their self-interest--a self-interest which does not magically better interested in buying either of the two versions, check out
own Crisis was simply being delayed a relatively short time. In the nation or those not fortunate enough to belong to the http://www.oftwominds.com/survivalplus.html
Sundaram BNP Paribas Asset Management 19 The Wise Investor February 2010
Taking note of

Paul Volcker, In the limelight


Paul Volcker, the legendary former Chairman of the U.S Federal Reserve, has long maintained that the only useful financial innovation
in decades has been the ATM. He was one of Obama’s key advisors in the run-up to the Presidential elections. Post the election, he
appeared to have been shunted in favour of persons more favourably inclined to the big banks and Wall Street.
Volcker had remarked in October 2009 that it was wrong to even assume he had influence in the first place. This view was from a
man of formidable reputation and credibility and a person who is chairman of the President’s Economic Recovery Advisory Board
indicated the extent to which the reform process appeared off track.
He had laid the road map for reforming the financial sector in the G30 Report (http://www.group30.org/pubs/reformreport.pdf)
Just when it was taken for granted that Volcker would not have his way, he has moved centre stage. In what became known as the
Volcker World Tour, he outlined his views in the public domain. (We had presented a selection of quotes in Voices Page of The Wise
Investor January 2010. (http://www.sundarambnpparibas.in/wiseinvestor_pdfs/The_Wise_Investor_January2010.pdf)
In the course of an interview in December 2009, he remarked `I am not alone in this (proper and needed reforms), and in fact I think that I am probably going
to win in the end. (This view was in December 2009 was in sharp contrast, after his October statement: `I did not have influence to start with’.)
The Volcker Rule: On January 24, in an address, President Obama acted on a part of the Paul Volcker thought process. Deposit-taking banks will not be able to
engage in proprietary trading or owning, investing in or sponsoring hedge funds or private equity funds
Volcker has stepped up the pressure by an excellent summary of his thought process in an Op-Ed article in The New York Times on January 30, 2010.
(http://www.nytimes.com/2010/01/31/opinion/31volcker.html)
This has to go through U S Congress. A right step has unfortunately been labelled as populist – mainly because of the fact that what should have been done in
the first place is now getting started and an election loss has provided a perfect way to spin the step as populist. Of course, Wall Street banks are not pleased.

Here are a few independent views on the move:

The Washington Post went with the headline “Volcker Rule Shifts Power from Geithner.” Secretary Geithner is perceived as more of a New Era Wall Street-
type – a tenuous position to find oneself these days. Paul Volcker is the consummate tough, no nonsense Old School financial regulator. Mr. Volcker is an
anachronism from a different era – or so the markets had thought until yesterday.
The general perception was that he had lost touch – and was basically out of touch with the White House. Yet the great American statesman has made a
dramatic return to the center stage. (http://www.prudentbear.com/index.php/creditbubblebulletinview?art_id=10335)
Doug Noland, Credit Bubble Bulletin

Still for GREED & fear the real point is less the details than the new political reality.This is that a fundamental increase in regulation over finance in the West is
coming despite the obvious power and wealth of the finance lobby. If so, it will undermine the assumptions of the consensus which had been assuming until
yesterday that the 83-year-old Paul Volcker was too old and anachronistic a figure to influence the debate. In this respect Obama has smartly, albeit, belatedly,
sought out the advice of his one economic adviser with total credibility as a public servant. Meanwhile, if the President wants to maintain the political momentum
he should now change the rest of his economic team, all of whom are viewed as far too close to Wall Street
Christopher Wood, Managing Director & Strategist, CLSA Asia-Pacific Markets

The unintended message of Volcker’s op-ed (in The New York Times) may be that even someone as tough-minded as he is may not recognize the magnitude
of structural change needed to limit the extent of government guarantees to the financial sector and contain officially-backstopped risk-taking. And while Volcker
does speak of the need for structural reform, which is absolutely necessary, his outline does not go anywhere near far enough to start defusing the bomb that
financial services deregulation managed to create. I believe this problem is solvable, but it requires even more intrusive measures than Volcker contemplates. It
would be better if I were wrong, but we may need yet another crisis to produce the needed political will.
Naked Capitalism blog

There are three problems with the current setup on Wall Street: systemic risk, rent seeking and conflicts of interest.The Volcker proposal addresses the systemic
risk problem to a great extent, but does not do much about the other two. For a complete solution, we thus need to go further. Let us atomize Wall Street.
Martin Hutchinson,The Bear's Lair

Sundaram BNP Paribas Asset Management 20 The Wise Investor February 2010
Voices
David Rosenberg is the Chief Economist of Gluskin Sheff & Associates, a wealth management firm in Canada. He was earlier Chief
Economist at Merrill Lynch. He is one of many who saw the financial and economic crisis coming well in advance. His views are always a
must read. Rosenberg publishes a daily report Breakfast With Dave, which should be a good addition to reading for those interested in
economy and markets. Here is a selection of quotes reflecting his thought process:.

Mainstream economists called this downturn “The Great Recession”. But this is truly a gentle way of saying
1
“Depression”.

The emerging consensus is that everything is just going to be fine and that we should expect nothing more than
2 a second-half economic slowdown, and that if there is a sharper turndown the monetary and fiscal spigots will
be turned on even harder.

I do not view the economic events of the last two years as a classic recession/recovery phase. They only exist
3
in the context of secular credit expansions.

Having read various Year-Ahead Reports, it sure seems like there is a remarkable level of agreement for 2010.
4 We are with a glorious opportunity to reintroduce Bob Farrell’s Rule 8: “When all forecasts and experts agree,
something else is going to happen.”

You’d be surprised how a blend of intuition and experience can make a difference in a cycle like the one we are
5
in that has nothing in common with the other recessions of post-WWII era.

If the new normal coming out of recession is a penny a share of profit for a global company like Alcoa, then we
6 can be assured that we are in anything but a normal economic environment; despite all the efforts to put on a
brave face and appear optimistic.

It is extremely difficult to handicap “double dip” odds at this time but the history of post-bubble credit collapses
7
is such the economy remains extremely vulnerable to adverse shocks for years

The ratio of household debt to disposable income is up from a 30% ratio in 1950s to 125% today (down from
8 139% at 2007 peak). Mean reverting closer to 60% means deleveraging will be a multi-year event and more than
$7 trillion in additional household credit will have to be extinguished.

We must refrain from over-reacting to every piece of minutia in the economic data; know the fundamental
9
trends and ignore the noise around the trend.

Tape and Glue: That is what is holding the global economy and capital markets together – not just dramatic
10 monetary easing but the fact that G20 governments have managed to spend $2.2 trillion to restore growth. But
this is clearly unsustainable.

While much is made of the federal funding earmarked for infrastructure, something tells us these monies will
11
find their way towards plugging record fiscal gaps in state & local government

We look forward to the day, especially with regard to the equity market when either the price catches down
12 to the fundamentals or the fundamentals play catch up to the price. Even after a whopper of a 70% bear market
rally in the S&P 500, patience will win out.
Source: www.gluskinsheff.com

Sundaram BNP Paribas Asset Management 21 The Wise Investor February 2010
Best & Worst Performers Global
Month/Year/Category MSCI MSCI 2009 1 3 6 1 3 5
Emerging Market World Month Months Months Year Years Years
Jan-10 Best 934 1119 Russia Turkey Turkey Russia Indonesia Gold Brazil
Worst Brazil Brazil Honk Kong Honk Kong Gold Nikkei 225 Nikkei 225
Dec / 09 Best 989 1168 Brazil Turkey Crude Indonesia Brazil Gold Brazil
Worst U.S (Dow) Gold Korea Japan U.S (Dow) Japan U.S (S&P 500)
Nov / 09 Best 953 1149 Brazil Gold Brazil Indonesia Indonesia Gold Brazil
Worst Japan Japan Japan Japan Japan Japan Japan
Oct / 09 Best 914 1106 Indonesia Crude Russia Indonesia Indonesia Gold Brazil
Worst U.S (Dow) Korea Japan Japan U.S (Dow) Japan U.S (Nasdaq)
Sep / 09 Best 914 1127 Indonesia Brazil Russia Indonesia Indonesia Brazil Brazil
Worst Gold Japan Crude Crude Commodity UK U.S (Dow)
Aug / 09 Best 839 1086 Indonesia Turkey Turkey Indonesia Gold Brazil Brazil
Worst U.S (Dow) Hong Kong Russia Gold Russia Russia U.S (S&P 500)
Jul / 09 Best 844 1045 Indonesia Indonesia India Indonesia Gold China Brazil
Worst UK Commodity Gold Gold Russia Russia U.S (Nasdaq)
Jun / 09 Best 761 964 Crude Indonesia India Crude Turkey China Brazil
Worst UK Russia Gold UK Russia Russia UK
May / 09 Best 773 970 Russia India Russia Indonesia Gold Brazil Brazil
Worst U.S (Dow) U.S (Nasdaq) Gold U.S (Dow) Russia Japan Japan
Apr / 09 Best 663 893 Brazil Russia Russia Indonesia Gold Gold Brazil
Worst U.S (Dow) Gold Gold Crude Russia Russia Japan
Mar / 09 Best 570 805 Crude Korea Crude Gold Gold Gold Brazil
Worst Dax Gold Dax Crude Russia Russia Taiwan
Feb / 09 Best 499 751 Gold Taiwan Gold Gold Gold Gold Gold
Worst Mexico Korea Mexico Russia Russia Russia Taiwan
Jan / 09 Best 530 839 Crude Crude Gold Gold Gold Gold Gold
Worst South Africa South Africa Russia Russia Russia Russia Taiwan
Dec / 08 Best 567 920 Gold Indonesia Gold Gold Gold Gold Gold
Worst Russia Crude Crude Russia Russia Russia Taiwan
Nov / 08 Best 527 893 Gold Gold Gold Gold Gold Gold Brazil
Worst Russia Crude Russia Russia Russia Russia Taiwan
Oct / 08 Best 571 957 Gold UK U.S (Dow) Gold Gold Gold Brazil
Worst Russia Indonesia Russia Russia China Japan Taiwan
Sep / 08 Best 787 1182 Gold Gold U.S (Dow) Crude Crude Gold Brazil
Worst India Russia Russia Russia China Japan Taiwan
Aug / 08 Best 956 1345 Crude Turkey Crude Crude Crude Brazil Brazil
Worst India Russia India India Europe Europe U.S (Dow)
Jul / 08 Best 1042 1367 Crude Turkey Crude Crude Crude Brazil Brazil
Worst India Russia India India Europe Europe U.S (Dow)
Jun / 08 Best 1087 1402 Crude Gold Crude Crude Crude Brazil Brazil
Worst India India India India Europe Europe U.S (Dow)
Dec / 07 Best 1246 1589 Brazil India India India Brazil Brazil Brazil
Worst Japan China Japan Japan Japan U.S (S&P 500) U.S (Dow)
Europe: MSCI Europe; Commodity: S&P GSCI Index; Rank based on returns in $ terms. Data Source: Bloomberg; Analysis: Sundaram BNP Paribas Asset Management Analysis: A Preetha
Sundaram BNP Paribas Asset Management 22 The Wise Investor February 2010
Best & Worst Performers India
Month/Year/Category S&P S&P 2009 1 3 6 1 3 5
CNX Nifty CNX 500 Month Months Months Year Years Years
Jan-10 Best 4882 4156 Consumer Durables Consumer Durables Small-Cap Small-Cap Metals Metals Capital Goods
Worst Realty Realty Realty Realty FMCG IT Healthcare
Dec / 09 Best 5201 4329 Metals Small-Cap Metals Auto Metals Metals Capital Goods
Worst FMCG FMCG Realty Capital Goods FMCG IT Healthcare
Nov / 09 Best 5033 4145 Metals Metals Metals IT Metals Metals Capital Goods
Worst FMCG Reality Reality Reality FMCG IT Healthcare
Oct / 09 Best 4712 3853 Metals FMCG Healthcare Metals Metals Oil & Gas Capital Goods
Worst FMCG Realty Realty Oil & Gas Oil & Gas IT Healthcare
Sep / 09 Best 5084 4119 Auto Banks Small Cap Realty Auto Oil & Gas Capital Goods
Worst FMCG FMCG FMCG FMCG Oil & Gas IT Healthcare
Aug / 09 Best 4662 3840 Auto Realty IT Realty Auto Oil & Gas Banks
Worst Healthcare FMCG Oil & Gas FMCG Capital Goods IT Healthcare
Jul / 09 Best 4636 3764 Metals Auto Realty Metals Auto Oil & Gas Capital Goods
Worst Healthcare Capital Goods Oil & Gas FMCG Realty IT Healthcare
Jun / 09 Best 4291 3470 Metals IT Realty Metals Public Sector Banks Capital Goods
Worst FMCG Realty FMCG FMCG Realty IT Healthcare
May / 09 Best 4449 3580 Auto Realty Auto Power FMCG Oil & Gas Capital Goods
Worst Consumer Durables FMCG Consumer Durables Consumer Durables Realty Consumer Durables Healthcare
Apr / 09 Best 3474 2663 Auto Realty Auto Power FMCG Oil & Gas Capital Goods
Worst Consumer Durables FMCG Consumer Durables Consumer Durables Realty Consumer Durables Healthcare
Mar / 09 Best 3021 2295 Auto Metals Auto FMCG FMCG Oil & Gas Capital Goods
Worst Realty FMCG Realty Realty Realty Small-Cap Auto
Feb / 09 Best 2764 2113 Auto Auto Auto FMCG FMCG Oil & Gas Capital Goods
Worst Realty Realty IT Realty Realty Consumer Durables Metals
Jan / 09 Best 2875 2209 Oil & Gas Oil & Gas Power FMCG FMCG Oil & Gas Capital Goods
Worst Realty Realty IT Realty Realty Small-Cap Auto
Dec / 08 Best 2959 2296 FMCG Realty FMCG FMCG FMCG Oil & Gas Capital Goods
Worst Realty IT Metals Metals Realty Auto Metals
Nov / 08 Best 2755 2093 FMCG FMCG FMCG FMCG FMCG Oil & Gas Capital Goods
Worst Realty Realty Realty Realty Realty Auto Metals
Oct / 08 Best 2886 2226 FMCG IT FMCG FMCG FMCG Oil & Gas Capital Goods
Worst Realty Realty Realty Realty Realty Small-Cap Metals
Sep / 08 Best 3921 3059 FMCG FMCG Public Sector Healthcare FMCG Oil & Gas Capital Goods
Worst Realty Realty Metals Realty Realty Small-Cap Healthcare
Aug / 08 Best 4360 3489 Healthcare Banks Healthcare Healthcare Healthcare Oil & Gas Capital Goods
Worst Realty Small-Cap Realty Realty Realty Small-Cap Healthcare
Jul / 08 Best 4333 3457 Healthcare Public Sector Healthcare Healthcare Oil & Gas Capital Goods Capital Goods
Worst Realty IT Realty Realty Realty Auto FMCG
Jun / 08 Best 4041 3203 Healthcare Capital Goods Healthcare Healthcare Oil & Gas Capital Goods Capital Goods
Worst Realty Realty Realty Realty Realty Auto FMCG
Dec / 07 Best 6139 5355 Power Consumer Durables Small-Cap Metal Power Capital Goods Capital Goods
Worst IT Capital Goods IT IT IT Healthcare IT
Rank based on returns in INR terms. Sector Information is based on BSE Indices; Data Source: Bloomberg; Analysis: Sundaram BNP Paribas Asset Management Analysis: A Preetha
Sundaram BNP Paribas Asset Management 23 The Wise Investor February 2010
Periodic Table & Quartile India
The Periodic Table compares returns of different asset classes over each of the past 11 years as well as for the 10-year period between 2000
and 2009; This period includes deep bullish and bearish phases. The table illustrates the experiences of investing in different asset classes,
investment style and market capitalisation across market phases.
Annual Returns for Key Asset Classes (1999 - 2009 YTD) Ranked in Order of Performance
1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 Dec 1999-Dec 2009
Nifty Junior I-SEC Bond I-SEC Bond Gold Nifty Junior Nifty Junior Diversified Sensex CNX Mid Cap I-SEC Bond Nifty Junior CNX Mid Cap
Fund
162.3 12.6 25.3 24.7 141.0 30.8 46.7 46.7 76.9 27.1 127.9 20.6

Diversified Gold Gold CNX Mid Cap CNX Mid Cap Diversified MSCI India Nifty Junior Gold CNX Mid Cap Diversified
Sensex
Fund Fund Fund
127.8 -5.5 2.5 24.2 138.3 26.0 42.3 46.5 75.7 5.1 99.0
17.3

BSE 100 Diversified CNX Mid Cap BSE 100 CNX 500 MSCI EM MSCI India
Nifty MSCI EM I-SEC Bond MSCI India Gold
Fund
93.1 -14.7 -1.7 23.0 107.6 25.0 40.2 41.0 62.5 -43.8 91.5 14.3

MSCI India MSCI India Nifty Diversified CNX 500 CNX 500 BSE 100 Nifty BSE 200 Nifty CNX 500 BSE 200
Fund
89.1 -17.2 -16.2 98.1 17.9 38.3 39.8 60.4 -51.8 88.6 13.9
17.6

BSE 200 Sensex Sensex MSCI EM BSE 200 Diversified Sensex BSE 200
BSE 200 BSE 200 Nifty CNX 500
Fund
88.7 -20.6 -17.9 15.5 94.5 16.6 36.3 39.6 59.7 -52.4 88.5 13.6

CNX Mid Cap BSE 100 MSCI India BSE 100 Diversified BSE 100 BSE 100
CNX 500 BSE 100 CNX 500 BSE 100 Nifty
Fund
68.7 -22.6 -18.6 10.3 84.7 16.4 36.3 34.9 59.7 -55.3 85.0 13.4

MSCI EM CNX 500 Diversified BSE 200 Diversified Diversified


Nifty Junior Sensex MSCI EM CNX 500 Nifty Sensex
Fund Fund Fund
67.8 -24.2 -20.3 8.8 72.9 15.7 35.1 34.0 54.8 -55.3 84.5 13.3

Nifty Diversified Sensex


BSE 200 BSE 100 Nifty CNX Mid Cap CNX Mid Cap MSCI India BSE 200 Sensex BSE 100
Fund
67.4 -21.9 6.9 71.9 13.1 35.0 29.0 52.5 -56.5 81.0 13.4
-24.5

Sensex CNX Mid Cap CNX 500 MSCI India MSCI India MSCI India BSE 200 Nifty Junior Sensex MSCI India Nifty MSCI India
63.8 -25.0 -23.3 5.3 65.5 11.0 33.8 28.2 47.1 -56.8 75.8 12.9

CNX 500 BSE 200 BSE 100 Sensex MSCI EM Nifty Nifty Junior MSCI EM Gold CNX 500 MSCI EM I-SEC Bond
53.1 -26.2 -23.4 3.5 44.2 10.7 24.4 26.9 31.0 -57.1 66.8 10.6

I-SEC Bond MSCI EM CNX Mid Cap Nifty Gold Gold Gold Gold MSCI EM CNX Mid Cap Gold Nifty Junior
16.4 -26.9 -27.6 3.3 19.3 5.5 18.0 23.0 21.5 -59.4 25.5 10.0

Gold Nifty Junior Nifty Junior MSCI EM I-SEC Bond I-SEC Bond I-SEC Bond I-SEC Bond I-SEC Bond Nifty Junior I-SEC Bond MSCI EM
0.1 -39.1 -46.5 -8.5 12.4 -1.4 6.3 6.0 6.9 -63.5 -6.8 8.0

Asset classes in Quartile 1 & 2 should do a good job of wealth creation


Number of years in each quartile
Asset Class Q1+Q2 Q3+Q4
1 2 3 4
Diversified Funds 5 2 4 0 7 4
BSE 100 2 7 1 1 9 2
S&P CNX Nifty 1 4 4 2 5 6
CNX Mid Cap 5 1 3 2 6 5
S&P CNX 500 1 5 3 2 6 5
Sensex 2 3 5 1 5 6
BSE 200 0 6 4 1 6 5
MSCI India 3 3 5 0 6 5
CNX Nifty Junior 5 0 2 4 5 6
Gold 4 0 0 7 4 7
I-SEC Bond 3 1 0 7 4 7
MSCI Emerging Markets 2 1 2 6 3 8
Average Returns 52.2 30.8 22.8 1.2 41.5 12.0
Data Source: Bloomberg; Analysis: Sundaram BNP Paribas Asset Management; Returns for diversified fund is sourced from Value Research
For every 100, Q1: ranks 1-25, Q2: ranks 26-50, Q3: ranks 51-75 and Q4: ranks 76-100 Analysis: S Vidhya
Sundaram BNP Paribas Asset Management 24 The Wise Investor February 2010
Periodic Table Global
Annual Returns for Key Asset Classes (1999 - 2009 YTD) Ranked in Order of Performance
1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 Dec 1999-Dec 2009
Russia Commodities Russia Crude Brazil Indonesia Russia China Brazil US Treasury Brazil Brazil
246.2 26.9 53.2 55.4 102.9 44.5 69.5 78.1 75.3 14.9 121.3 15.1

Crude EM Bond Korea Commodities BRIC Real Estate Korea Indonesia India USD (DXY) Indonesia Gold
135.5 14.4 46.0 39.0 84.2 38.0 54.3 69.6 71.2 6.0 120.8 14.3

Singapore Real Estate Taiwan Indonesia China Latam Brazil Russia China Gold India Latam
97.1 13.8 8.8 38.1 81.1 34.8 50 53.7 63.1 5.1 100.5 13.9

Indonesia US Treasury US Treasury Gold Chile Europe EM Europe BRIC Crude EM Bonds Russia Russia
92 13.3 6.9 24.7 79.7 33.4 47.2 52.9 56.1 -10.9 100.3 13.5

Korea Agriculture USD (DXY) Agriculture India Crude Crude India BRIC Singapore India
Latam 98.1
90.2 12.1 6.6 19.1 73.9 32.0 46.3 49 56.1 -18.2 12.2

U.S (Nasdaq) USD (DXY) Asia Russia Russia Brazil Latam Real Estate Indonesia Agriculture BRIC Crude
85.6 7.5 4.2 13.9 70.3 30.5 44.9 42.4 50.8 -19.7 88.8 12.0

India Gold Gold Indonesia Chile BRIC Singapore Latam Japan Crude Indonesia
EM Bond 13.1
84.7 -5.5 2.5 70.0 24.6 39.8 41.9 46.9 -27.7 84.9 11.7

EM Europe U.S (Dow) EM Bonds US Treasury Latam MSCI EM Commodities Brazil Agriculture U.S (Dow) Chile BRIC
81.3 -6.2 1.4 11.5 67.1 22.4 39.1 40.5 41.2 -33.8 81.4 11.0

BRIC Crude Real Estate Korea EM Europe Honk Kong India Latam Commodities Chile EM Europe Chile
78.2 -9.4 -3.8 7.4 65.5 20.8 35.4 39.3 40.7 -37.3 81.1 10.9

Asia MSCI Europe Latam India Germany Korea MSCI EM Germany Asia U.S (S&P 500) Taiwan EM Bond
67.7 -9.9 -4.3 5.9 64.0 20.0 30.3 36.0 38.3 -38.5 75.1 10.5

MSCI EM U.S (S&P 500) MSCI EM EM Europe MSCI EM Commodities Asia EM Europe Honk Kong U.S (Nasdaq) MSCI EM Commodities
63.7 -10.1 -4.9 2.9 51.6 19.2 23.5 33.5 37.5 -40.5 74.5 10.4

Asia ex-Japan Germany Asia ex-Japan Real Estate U.S (Nasdaq) Singapore Japan Asia ex-Japan Asia ex-Japan MSCI World Asia Real Estate
61.9 -13.5 -5.9 2.8 50.0 18.8 22.5 30.1 37.1 -42.1 70.3 9.2

Brazil MSCI World Chile Asia Asia MSCI Europe Asia ex-Japan MSCI Europe MSCI EM Germany Korea Agriculture
61.6 -14.1 -6 -6.2 47.1 18.0 19.3 29.8 36.5 -42.8 69.4 8.1

Latam Brazil U.S (Dow) MSCI EM Asia ex-Japan Germany Chile Asia Germany Commodities Asia ex-Japan Korea
55.5 -14.2 -7.1 -8 42.7 16.8 18.4 29.8 36.4 -42.8 68.3 7.5

Honk Kong FTSE 100 EM Europe Japan Real Estate India Gold Agriculture Gold Real Estate Singapore MSCI EM
54.8 -16.9 -10.5 -9.9 40.7 16.5 18 29.6 31.0 -47.7 68.2 7.3

Japan Chile Indonesia Asia ex-Japan Taiwan FTSE 100 Agriculture MSCI EM Korea MSCI Europe China China
53.3 -17 -10.9 -10.2 40.0 15.5 16.4 29.2 30.0 -47.9 58.8 6.9

Taiwan Honk Kong U.S (S&P 500) USD (DXY) Japan Asia ex-Japan China Chile EM Europe Taiwan Honk Kong Europe
51.5 -17.0 -13 -12.8 37.7 14.4 15.9 26.4 27.8 -48.7 55.2 6.5

Commodities Latam Agriculture Singapore Singapore BRIC Real Estate Honk Kong Singapore FTSE 100 Commodities US Treasury
46.2 -18.4 -14.1 -13.1 34.2 13.6 15.4 26.2 23.9 -49.5 50.3 6.1

Chile BRIC Crude BRIC MSCI Europe MSCI World USD (DXY) FTSE 100 Russia China U.S (Nasdaq) Asia
36.5 -22.8 -14.4 -15.2 34.1 12.8 12.8 26.1 22.9 -51.9 43.9 4.9

U.S (Dow) India BRIC China Korea Asia Indonesia Gold Chile Latam Real Estate Asia ex-Japan
25.2 -22.8 -17 -16.2 32.6 12.2 12.6 23.0 20.8 -52.8 38.3 3.8

EM Bond Singapore MSCI World FTSE 100 Honk Kong Japan Singapore MSCI World MSCI Europe Honk Kong U.K Singapore
24.2 -28.6 -17.8 -16.4 32.5 11.8 10.8 18.0 10.6 -52.9 35.2 3.1

MSCI World Russia FTSE 100 U.S (Dow) MSCI World EM Bond Taiwan U.S (Nasdaq) Asia ex-Japan MSCI Europe Germany
EM Bond 11.7
23.6 -30.4 -18.4 -16.8 30.8 10.7 16.3 9.8 -53.6 30.6 2.0

Germany MSCI EM U.S (Nasdaq) MSCI Europe U.S (S&P 500) U.S (S&P 500) Germany U.S (Dow) US Treasury Asia EM Bond Honk Kong
20.1 -31.8 -21.1 -20 26.4 9.0 10.3 16.3 9.0 -54.1 28.2 1.0

U.S (S&P 500) China India Honk Kong FTSE 100 U.S (Nasdaq) MSCI World U.S (S&P 500) MSCI World MSCI EM MSCI World MSCI Europe
19.5 -32.2 -21.2 -20.6 25.8 8.6 7.6 13.6 7.1 -54.5 27.0 -0.6

MSCI Europe Japan Honk Kong MSCI World EM Bond Taiwan MSCI Europe Korea U.S (Dow) Crude Germany U.S (Dow)
15.3 -34.9 -21.2 -21.1 25.7 6.5 7.2 11.2 6.4 -55.5 25.8 -1.0

FTSE 100 EM Europe MSCI Europe Chile U.S (Dow) Gold Honk Kong EM Bonds EM Bonds Korea Gold MSCI World
14.5 -35.3 -21.3 -21.7 25.3 5.5 4.8 9.9 6.3 -55.9 25.5 -1.9

China Asia ex-Japan Brazil U.S (S&P 500) Gold Russia FTSE 100 U.S (Nasdaq) Taiwan Indonesia U.S (S&P 500) U.K
9.9 -36.3 -21.8 -23.4 19.3 4.1 4.7 9.5 5.4 -57.6 23.5 -2.4

Real Estate U.S (Nasdaq) Germany - Latam Agriculture US Treasury Taiwan Japan FTSE 100 Brazil U.S (Dow) USD (DXY)
8.9 -39.3 24.6 -24.8 12 3.5 3.3 5.9 5.2 -57.6 18.8 -2.6

USD (DXY) Asia Singapore Taiwan Commodities U.S (Dow) U.S (S&P 500) US Treasury U.S (S&P 500) BRIC Japan U.S (S&P 500)
8.2 -42.5 -25 -25.4 10.8 3.1 3.0 3.1 3.5 -60.3 16.4 -2.7

Gold Taiwan China U.S (Nasdaq) US Treasury China US Treasury Crude Japan India Agriculture Taiwan
0.1 -45.3 -26 -31.5 2.3 -0.8 2.8 2.1 -6.2 -65.1 14.7 -2.8

Agriculture Korea Commodities Germany Crude USD (DXY) U.S (Nasdaq) Commodities Real Estate EM Europe USD (DXY) - Japan
-10.4 -50.3 -31.5 -33.5 1.6 -7 1.4 0.4 -7.0 -68.6 4.2 -4.7

Indonesia Japan Brazil USD (DXY) Agriculture U.S (Dow) USD (DXY) USD (DXY) - Russia US Treasury U.S (Nasdaq)
-63.0 -33.2 -33.8 -14.7 -14.0 -0.6 -8.2 8.3 -74.2 -4.3 -5.7

Sundaram BNP Paribas Asset Management 25 The Wise Investor February 2010
Quartile based on Periodic Table Global
No need to chase the top performer; asset classes in Quartile 1 & 2 should do the job
Number of years in each quartile
Asset Class 1 2 3 4 Q1+Q2 Q3+Q4

F MSCI EM 1 8 2 0 9 2
I
R Indonesia 7 1 1 2 8 3
S
T India 5 3 2 1 8 3
Q EM Europe 2 6 1 2 8 3
U
A Asia 1 7 2 1 8 3
R
T Asia ex-Japan 0 8 2 1 8 3
I
L Brazil 6 2 0 3 8 3
E
Latin America 5 3 2 1 8 3
S Russia 7 0 2 2 7 4
E
C Crude 6 1 1 3 7 4
O
N Korea 3 4 1 3 7 4
D
Chile 3 4 3 1 7 4
Q
U Real Estate 3 4 2 2 7 4
A
R BRIC 5 1 4 1 6 5
T
I Commodities 3 3 2 3 6 5
L
E Germany 0 6 2 3 6 5
T Gold 4 2 1 4 6 5
H
I Agriculture 4 2 1 4 6 5
R
D Singapore 3 2 5 1 5 6
Q Emerging Market Bonds 4 0 4 3 4 7
U
A
MSCI Europe 0 4 4 3 4 7
R
T
China 3 1 4 3 4 7
I
L
U.S Treasury 4 0 1 5 4 6
E
U.S (Nasdaq) 1 2 4 4 3 8
F Honk Kong 0 3 6 2 3 8
O
U Japan 1 2 3 5 3 8
R
T Taiwan 1 2 3 5 3 8
H
U.S (Dow) 2 1 3 5 3 8
Q
U USD 3 0 2 6 3 8
A
R MSCI World 0 2 8 1 2 9
T
I U.S (S&P 500) 0 2 4 5 2 9
L
E U.K 0 2 6 3 2 9
For every 100, Q1: ranks 1-25, Q2: ranks 26-50, Q3: ranks 51-75 and Q4: ranks 76-100
Analysis: S Vidhya
Data Source: Bloomberg; Analysis: Sundaram BNP Paribas Asset Management; Methodology: www.sundarambnpparibas.in

Sundaram BNP Paribas Asset Management 26 The Wise Investor February 2010
Performance Tracker Global
Index Year-To-Date One Month Three Months Six Months One Year Three Years Five Years
Return Rank Return Rank Return Rank Return Rank Return Rank Return Rank Return Rank
S&P 500 -3.7 8 -3.7 8 3.6 13 8.7 15 30.0 19 -25.3 21 -9.1 24
Dow Jones -3.5 7 -3.5 7 3.7 12 9.8 12 25.8 23 -20.2 20 -4.0 22
Nasdaq Composite -5.4 13 -5.4 13 5.0 7 8.5 16 45.4 15 -12.8 15 4.1 20
Nikkei 225 -3.3 6 -3.3 6 1.6 17 -1.5 23 27.6 22 -41.3 -10.4 25
Dax -5.9 15 -5.9 15 3.6 14 5.2 19 29.3 20 -17.4 19 31.8 15
FTSE 100 -4.1 9 -4.1 9 2.9 16 12.6 6 25.0 24 -16.4 18 6.9 19
S&P GSCI Index Spot -7.3 21 -7.3 21 -2.1 21 6.3 18 44.6 16 13.8 7 46.7 14
MSCI World -4.2 10 -4.2 10 1.2 18 7.2 17 33.5 18 -25.4 22 -2.0 21
MSCI Europe -2.9 5 -2.9 5 3.9 9 9.4 14 28.1 21 -34.0 24 -5.9 23
MSCI Asia ex-Japan -6.1 17 -6.1 17 0.5 19 4.7 20 67.4 9 1.7 10 55.2 10
Crude -8.7 24 -8.7 24 -5.3 23 -0.6 22 56.8 13 23.2 4 53.6 12
Gold -1.5 4 -1.5 4 3.4 15 13.3 5 16.5 25 65.5 1 155.8 3

Emerging Markets (MSCI Indices)

BRIC -7.5 22 -7.5 22 -1.2 20 9.6 13 81.9 7 10.6 9 135.2 5


Brazil -11.0 25 -11.0 25 -2.5 22 16.6 4 88.5 5 45.3 3 216.8 1
Russia 2.4 1 2.4 2 8.2 3 33.2 1 132.1 2 -31.3 23 64.7 9
India -5.3 12 -5.3 12 6.2 4 11.5 8 94.0 4 10.8 8 133.1 6
China -8.6 23 -8.6 23 -6.0 24 -3.1 24 58.2 12 18.8 6 140.1 4
Korea -4.9 11 -4.9 11 3.9 10 10.4 10 69.3 8 -2.5 12 49.3 13
Taiwan -6.5 20 -6.5 20 5.4 5 9.8 11 82.1 6 -8.9 14 9.8 18
Singapore -6.1 16 -6.1 16 3.7 11 1.9 21 54.9 14 -13.6 16 30.2 16
Honk Kong -6.4 19 -6.4 19 -6.0 25 -3.7 25 44.5 17 -8.1 13 29.1 17
Indonesia 2.0 2 2.0 3 11.1 2 18.5 3 145.1 1 51.3 2 160.3 2
Mexico -6.2 18 -6.2 18 5.1 6 12.6 7 64.4 11 -14.3 17 77.2 7
South Africa -5.4 14 -5.4 14 4.6 8 11.4 9 66.3 10 -0.2 11 54.4 11

Turkey 1.6 3 19.2 1 13.6 1 22.9 2 96.8 3 20.2 5 72.3 8

Top Performer Russia Turkey Turkey Russia Indonesia Gold Brazil


Worstt Performer Brazil Brazil Honk Kong Honk Kong Gold Nikkei 225 Nikkei 225

Source: Bloomberg; P/E: Price-to-Earnings ratio; P/B: Price-to-Book ratio; 12-M: 12 Months; Returns is in percentage and in U.S. Dollar terms for each period and not on an annualised basis. Analysis: A Preetha
Sundaram BNP Paribas Asset Management 27 The Wise Investor February 2010
Performance Tracker India
Index Trailing Year-To-Date One Month Three Months Six Months One Year Three Years Five Years
12m P/E Return Rank Return Rank Return Rank Return Rank Return Rank Return Rank Return Rank
Cap-Curve Indices
BSE Sensitive Index (Sensex) 24.5 -6.3 19 -6.3 19 2.9 20 4.4 19 73.6 19 16.1 18 149.5 7
S & P CNX Nifty 24.1 -6.1 18 -6.1 18 3.6 18 5.3 17 69.8 21 19.6 17 137.3 14
Nifty Junior 20.5 -3.8 8 -3.8 8 9.0 8 17.8 8 136.1 4 37.4 7 135.1 15
Nifty 100 23.5 -5.8 17 -5.8 17 4.5 17 7.1 15 78.3 17 22.1 13 — —
CNX Mid-Cap 17.9 -3.1 6 -3.1 6 9.5 7 21.0 7 114.5 7 36.4 8 151.4 6
BSE Mid-Cap 18.4 -3.1 5 -3.1 5 8.2 10 16.9 9 121.3 6 7.7 20 118.7 18
BSE Small-Cap 15.7 -1.5 3 -1.5 3 16.6 1 32.7 1 146.6 3 9.7 19 140.5 11
BSE 100 24.4 -5.7 16 -5.7 16 4.5 16 6.5 16 81.8 16 21.9 15 147.3 9
BSE 200 23.2 -5.3 15 -5.3 15 5.2 14 8.1 14 86.5 14 22.1 14 137.7 13
BSE 500 22.6 -4.9 12 -4.9 12 6.0 12 9.6 13 90.0 12 20.4 16 138.8 12

S & P CNX 500 21.2 -4.0 10 -4.0 10 7.9 11 10.4 12 88.1 13 22.5 12 135.0 16

Sector Indices

BSE Auto 49.9 -6.5 20 -6.5 20 10.2 6 21.7 6 178.1 2 26.1 10 147.9 8
BSE Banks 14.8 -3.8 7 -3.8 7 3.4 19 14.0 10 97.0 11 33.0 9 163.0 3
BSE Capital Goods 32.4 -7.0 21 -7.0 21 2.0 21 4.2 20 109.8 10 38.4 6 339.6 1
BSE Consumer Durables 12.6 0.4 1 0.4 1 13.5 3 21.8 5 113.7 8 0.0 21 162.3 4
BSE FMCG 31.2 -2.4 4 -2.4 4 -3.0 22 -0.5 22 34.1 23 43.0 5 142.9 10
BSE Healthcare 47.7 -5.0 13 -5.0 13 8.9 9 25.2 4 75.6 18 25.3 11 76.4 20
BSE IT 22.1 -4.0 11 -4.0 11 12.5 5 25.6 3 122.6 5 -6.0 22 93.7 19
BSE Metal #N/A -8.3 22 -8.3 22 14.5 2 28.8 2 213.0 1 71.9 1 161.5 5
BSE Oil & Gas 18.7 -5.1 14 -5.1 14 5.3 13 4.8 18 59.0 22 49.9 3 224.4 2
BSE Public Sector 18.4 -0.6 2 -0.6 2 12.8 4 13.2 11 85.2 15 50.4 2 122.9 17
BSE Power 31.1 -4.0 9 -4.0 9 5.0 15 3.1 21 70.8 20 45.7 4 — —

BSE Realty 19.1 -9.2 23 -9.2 23 -8.5 23 -10.5 23 109.8 9 — — — —

Top Performer BSE Consumer BSE Consumer BSE Small-Cap BSE Small-Cap BSE Metal BSE Metal BSE Capital Goods
Durables Durables
Worst Performer BSE Realty BSE Realty BSE Realty BSE Realty BSE FMCG BSE IT BSE Healthcare

Source: Bloomberg; P/E: Price-to-Earnings ratio; P/B: Price-to-Book ratio; 12-M: 12 Months; Returns is in percentage for each period and not on an annualised basis. Analysis: A Preetha
Sundaram BNP Paribas Asset Management 28 The Wise Investor February 2010
Equity Chart Book
MSCI World MSCI Emerging Markets

1600
1600
1400
1400 1200

1200 1000

800
1000
600
800
400

600 200
Jan-00

Jan-01

Jan-02

Jan-03

Jan-04

Jan-05

Jan-06

Jan-07

Jan-08

Jan-09

Jan-10

Jan-00

Jan-01

Jan-02

Jan-03

Jan-04

Jan-05

Jan-06

Jan-07

Jan-08

Jan-09

Jan-10
Open 1422 High 1682 Low 689 Close 1120 Open 489 High 1338 Low 246 Close 934

MSCI Brazil MSCI Russia

1600
4300

1100

2300
600

300 100
Jan-00

Jan-01

Jan-02

Jan-03

Jan-04

Jan-05

Jan-06

Jan-07

Jan-08

Jan-09

Jan-10
Jan-00

Jan-01

Jan-02

Jan-03

Jan-04

Jan-05

Jan-06

Jan-07

Jan-08

Jan-09

Jan-10

Open 889 High 4728 Low 279 Close 3226 Open 223 High 1642 Low 139 Close 814

MSCI India MSCI China

780 100

680

580

480
50
380

280

180

80 0
Jan-00

Jan-01

Jan-02

Jan-03

Jan-04

Jan-05

Jan-06

Jan-07

Jan-08

Jan-09

Jan-10

Jan-00

Jan-01

Jan-02

Jan-03

Jan-04

Jan-05

Jan-06

Jan-07

Jan-08

Jan-09

Jan-10

Open 148 High 694 Low 71 Close 444 Open 33 High 104 Low 13 Close 59
Source: Bloomberg

Sundaram BNP Paribas Asset Management 29 The Wise Investor February 2010
%

4
6
8
USD Million

10
12
14

3
5
7
%9
13
15

11
Dec/01 Jan/00
Jul/00

10000
70000
130000
190000
250000
310000
370000
Jun/02
Jan/00
Dec/00
Jul/00 Dec/02

Open 35.1
Open 8.15
Open 11.26
Jun/01
Jan/01 May/03
Jul/01 Dec/01
Nov/03 Jun/02
Jan/02
Jul/02 May/04 Dec/02
Jan/03 Jun/03
Nov/04
Jul/03 Dec/03

High 316.2
High 13.91
May/05

High 11.77
Jan/04
Jun/04
Jul/04 Nov/05
Dec/04
Jan/05
May/06 Jun/05
Jul/05
Nov/06 Dec/05

Sundaram BNP Paribas Asset Management


Jan/06
Jul/06 May/07 May/06

Low 34.7
Low 4.80
Low 4.99
Jan/07 Nov/06
Nov/07
Jul/07
10-Year G-Sec Yield (%)

May/07
Jan/08 May/08
Nov/07
Jul/08 Oct/08

India Forex Reserves ($ billion)


May/08
Jan/09
Apr/09 Nov/08

1-Year AAA Corporate Bond Yield (%)


Jul/09
Oct/09 May/09
Jan/10

Close 6.18
Close 7.59

Nov/09

Close 282.9

30
bp

0
2
4
%6
8

-2
10
12
14
Jan/00

10.0
0

100.0
bp 190.0
280.0
370.0
(100)
100
200
300
400

Jul/00 Dec/01 Jan/00


Jan/01 Jul/00

Open 210
Open 126

Open 2.81
Jun/02
Jul/01 Dec/00
Dec/02
Jan/02 Jun/01
May/03 Dec/01
Jul/02
Jan/03 Nov/03 Jun/02
Jul/03 May/04 Dec/02

Jan/04 Jun/03

High 423
High 341

Nov/04

High 12.82
Dec/03
Jul/04
May/05 Jun/04
Jan/05
Nov/05 Dec/04
Jul/05
May/06 Jun/05
Jan/06
Dec/05
Jul/06 Nov/06

WPI Inflation (%)


May/06
Low -16
Low -64

Jan/07 May/07

Low -1.01
Nov/06
Jul/07 Nov/07 May/07
Jan/08 Nov/07
May/08
Jul/08 May/08
Oct/08
Jan/09 Nov/08
G Sec 1-10 Year Spread (basis points)

Apr/09
Jul/09 May/09
Oct/09 Nov/09
Close 114
Close 299
Fixed-Income Chart Book

Close 7.31

The Wise Investor February 2010


5-Years G Sec AAA Bond Spread (basis points)

Source: Bloomberg
Commodities Chart Book
Crude Oil Gold

170 1200
150
1000
130
110
$/bbl

800
90

$/oz
70 600

50
400
30
10 200

Jan-00

Jan-01

Jan-02

Jan-03

Jan-04

Jan-05

Jan-06

Jan-07

Jan-08

Jan-09

Jan-10
Jan-00

Jan-01

Jan-02

Jan-03

Jan-04

Jan-05

Jan-06

Jan-07

Jan-08

Jan-09

Jan-10
Open 23.9 High 145.7 Low 16.6 Close 70.5 Open 288.0 High 1215.7 Low 255.6 Close 1080.9

Baltic Freight Index LME Metals Index

21700 5000

18700 4500
4000
15700
3500
12700
3000
9700
2500
6700
2000
3700 1500
700 1000
Jan-00

Jan-01

Jan-02

Jan-03

Jan-04

Jan-05

Jan-06

Jan-07

Jan-08

Jan-09

Jan-10

Apr-00

Apr-01

Apr-02

Apr-03

Apr-04

Apr-05

Apr-06

Apr-07

Apr-08

Apr-09
Open 1782.0 High 19687.0 Low 830.0 Close 3494.0 Open 1254.2 High 4556.6 Low 958.3 Close 3125.4

S & P Goldman Sachs Commodity Index CRB Non-Energy Index


1000 700
900
600
800
700 500
600
400
500
400 300
300
200
200
100 100
Jan-00

Jan-01

Jan-02

Jan-03

Jan-04

Jan-05

Jan-06

Jan-07

Jan-08

Jan-09

Jan-10
Jul-00

Jul-01

Jul-02

Jul-03

Jul-04

Jul-05

Jul-06

Jul-07

Jul-08

Jul-09

Jan-00

Jan-01

Jan-02

Jan-03

Jan-04

Jan-05

Jan-06

Jan-07

Jan-08

Jan-09

Jan-10
Jul-00

Jul-01

Jul-02

Jul-03

Jul-04

Jul-05

Jul-06

Jul-07

Jul-08

Jul-09

Open 194.5 High 890.3 Low 162.0 Close 790.5 Open 162.8 High 499.2 Low 149.6 Close 327.8

Source: Bloomberg

Sundaram BNP Paribas Asset Management 31 The Wise Investor February 2010
In a lighter vein
"'I want to see the boss.' 'What do you want to see him about?' 'About a job.' 'I'm sorry, but you can't see him; he's in an unemployment conference.'"

Patient - My nerves are worn to a frazzle. Doctor - Stop thinking about yourself - lose yourself in your work Patient - Gosh! And me a cement mixer!

Interior Sec. Wilbur has a large index on his desk to keep track of progress on the Hoover Dam, one of the largest projects ever undertaken. While showing it

to reporters the other day, he remarked "Yes, everything is fine about the book but its name." And he turned it over to show the cover "Dam Progress

Doctor - Did you put a mirror in front of the patient's face, to see if she is still breathing? Nurse - Yes, and she blushed and asked for her vanity case."

"'That man wants me to lend him some money. Do you know anything about him?' 'Why, I know him as well as I know you. Don't lend him a bean, old man.'"

Source: http://newsfrom1930.blogspot.com/

BackPage Investment Quiz


1 Name the foreign investor who picked up a small stake in Reliance Mutual Fund, a couple of years ago?

Compiled by S.Vaidya Nathan


2 The currency of this Latin American country was devalued by its government steeply last month. Which currency and country are we referring
to?
3 Who is the author of Too Big To Fail? (We had in November 2009 asked for the author of Too Big To Save)
4 What is the maximum fee + expenses that a fixed-income fund can charge according to SEBI regulation?
5 Which fund house was the first in India to launch an exchange-traded fund to track gold? Also which was the first fund launched to track gold-
mining stocks?
P
R Answers must be mailed to iq@sundarambnpparibas.in
I The first 25 responses with correct answers to all questions will receive a prize. Please mention your mailing address in your e-mail. Employees of Sundaram BNP Paribas
Z Asset Management, its Sponsors and Associates & Group Companies of the Sponsors shall not be entitled to prizes even if they participate and mail correct answers.
E

Answers for January 2010 Quiz


1 Who was India’s Finance Minister as we stepped into the last decade (We are looking for the person who held the portfolio in 3 Name the fund house that launched the first fund to invest in overseas securities in India?
January 2000)? Principal Mutual Fund
Yashwant Sinha 4 We all know Reliance Mutual Fund ended the decade as # 1 in terms of assets under management. Which fund house was #
1 at the start of the decade?
2 This is a sitter. Name the only IT stock that has regained the market cap that it enjoyed at the peak of the tech boom that ended Unit Trust of India
after Q1 2000? 5 Who is author of Lords of Finance:The Bankers Who Broke The World?
Infosys Technologies Liaquat Ahamed

Disclaimer
Mutual fund investments are subject to market risks. Please read the Statement of Additional Information of Sundaram BNP Paribas Mutual Fund and
Scheme Information Document of Sundaram BNP Paribas Mutual Fund carefully before taking an investment decision. Risk Factors: All mutual funds and
securities investments are subject to market risks.There can be no assurance or guarantee that a scheme's objective will be achieved. NAV may rise or decline, depending on factors and
forces affecting the securities market.There is risk of capital loss and uncertainty of dividend distribution. General Disclaimer: The Wise Investor, a monthly publication of Sundaram
BNP Paribas Asset Management, is for information purposes only.The Wise Investor is not and should not be construed as a prospectus, scheme information document, offer document,
offer solicitation for an investment and investment advice, to name a few. Information in this document has been obtained from sources that are reliable in the opinion of Sundaram BNP
Paribas Asset Management. Opinions expressed by authors may not necessarily represent that of Sundaram BNP Paribas Asset Management or Sundaram BNP Paribas Trustee Company
Design and layout by Spark Creations: +91 044 45510041

or Sundaram BNP Paribas Mutual Fund. The detailed disclaimer/disclosures/risk factors, including that of BNP Paribas Asset Management, available at www.sundarambnpparibas.in must
also be treated as an integral part of this communication. Statutory: Mutual Fund Sundaram BNP Paribas Mutual Fund is a trust under the Indian Trusts Act, 1882 Sponsors (Collective
liability is limited to Rs 1 lakh): Sundaram Finance Limited & BNP Paribas Asset Management. Investment Manager: Sundaram BNP Paribas Asset Management Company Limited.
Trustee: Sundaram BNP Paribas Trustee Company Limited. Past performance of Sponsors/Asset Management Company/Fund does not indicate or guarantee future performance.
Published by Sunil Subramaniam on behalf of Sundaram BNP Paribas Asset Management Company Limited, from its office at Sundaram Towers, II Floor, 46, Whites Road, Chennai 600 014.
Printed by R.Velayudhan at Paper Craft, No.25, C.P.Mudali Street, Pudupet, Chennai 600 002.
Editor: Sunil Subramaniam.
Toll Free 1800 425 1000 www.sundarambnpparibas.in
SMS SFUND to 56767 E-mail service@sundarambnpparibas.in
Sundaram BNP Paribas Asset Management 32 The Wise Investor February 2010

You might also like