Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Teresa A. Marshall
J Am Dent Assoc 2009;140;670-674
2011 American Dental Association. The sponsor and its products are not endorsed by the ADA.
CLINICAL PRACTICE
N U T R I T I O N
http://jada.ada.org
ABSTRACT
Background. A dietary habit assessment should be
an integral component of oral health care. The author
outlines strategies that oral health care professionals
can use to assess dietary habits associated with caries
risk and to develop dietary recommendations.
Conclusion. A caries risk assessment tool can be
used to identify dietary habits that may contribute to
caries risk.
Practical Implications. The caries risk assessment tool can provide structure for evaluating patients
dietary habits and food choices and helping oral care
health professionals provide preventive dietary
recommendations.
Key Words. Caries; diet.
JADA 2009;140(6):670-674.
Dr. Marshall is an assistant professor, Department of Preventive and Community Dentistry, College of Dentistry, N-335 Dental Science Building, University of Iowa, Iowa City,
Iowa. 52242-1010, e-mail teresa-marshall@uiowa.edu. Address reprint requests to
Dr. Marshall.
June 2009
Copyright 2009 American Dental Association. All rights reserved. Reprinted by permission.
CLINICAL PRACTICE
N U T R I T I O N
ANTICIPATORY GUIDANCE
http://jada.ada.org
Copyright 2009 American Dental Association. All rights reserved. Reprinted by permission.
June 2009
671
TABLE 1
oral health care practitioners to begin conversaDiet assessment of caries risk.
tions regarding dietary
KEY AREA
PROBABLE
RELATIVE RISK
DESIRED BEHAVIOR
habits with patients.
RESPONSE
GUIDELINES*
Having knowledge about
Number of
< 6/day
Low
3-6/day
patients dietary behaviors
Meals/Snacks
> 6/day
Moderate
that are associated with
Meal/Snack Structure Structured
Low
Structured meal
caries risk is essential
pattern
Unstructured/grazing
Moderate
when providing specific,
Sugared Beverages
individualized recommenQuantity
< 12 ounces/day
Low
6-8 ounces of 100 percent
dations that may decrease
juice or other sugared
12-20 ounces/day
Moderate
caries risk. The caries
beverage/day; < 12 ounces
of sugared soda pop/day
process depends on the
> 20 ounces/day
High
presence of host and enviTiming
With meals
Low
With meals
ronmental factors,
With snacks
Moderate
including exposure to ferBetween meals/snacks
High
mentable carbohydrates.
Frequency
1 exposure/day
Low
1 exposure/day
The structure of meals and
2-3 exposures/day
Moderate
snacks influences the
4 exposures/day High High
quantity and frequency of
Length of exposure
< 15 minutes
Low
< 15 minutes
patients exposure to fer15-30 minutes
Moderate
mentable carbohydrates
and, subsequently, caries
> 30 minutes
High
risk.8-11 Key areas to
Drinking style
Straw
Low
Straw
include in a dietary assessOpen container
Moderate
ment of caries risk are the
Swishing within mouth High
number of dietary expo* The desired behavior guidelines are based on dietary guidelines and current practice and are presented
sures (meals and snacks),
for adolescents and adults. Sources: U.S. Department of Agriculture6 and U.S. Department of Health
and Human Services and U.S. Department of Agriculture.7
the structure of meals and
Sugared beverages include 100 percent juice, juice drinks, soda pop, sports drinks, energy drinks, and
snacks and the manner of
sugared coffee and tea.
sugared beverage intake.
BOX 1
(Sugared beverages include 100 percent juice,
juice drinks, soda pop, sports drinks, energy
Definitions of terms.
drinks, and sugared coffee and tea.) These key
ANTICIPATORY GUIDANCE
areas, as well as the potential caries risk assoHealth promotion guidelines designed to promote health
ciated with probable responses and desired
and prevent disease.
behaviors, are outlined in Table 1. The desired
24-HOUR RECALL
behavior guidelines, which are based on dietary
A 24-hour recall is an interviewer-administered dietary
assessment tool designed to gather information about food
guidelines and current practice, are for adolesand beverage intakes and meal patterns. Open-ended
cents and adults6,7; guidelines for young children
prodding questions are asked to facilitate recall of foods
and beverages consumed. The 24-hour recall also can be
and elderly people differ.
CLINICAL PRACTICE
N U T R I T I O N
BOX 2
http://jada.ada.org
COUNSELING STRATEGIES
Although oral health care professionals can identify patients food or beverage selections and
dietary habits that increase their risk of developing caries, patients are responsible for
changing their behaviors. Oral health care professionals can only provide recommendations; however, the manner in which those recommendations are provided will improve the patients
receptivity.12,13 Knowledge of patients understanding of diet-disease relationships and motivation to change will help oral health care practitioners tailor recommendations to each patient.
Providing how-to adviceincluding different
strategies to use to achieve the desired outcome
June 2009
Copyright 2009 American Dental Association. All rights reserved. Reprinted by permission.
CLINICAL PRACTICE
N U T R I T I O N
TABLE 2
CARIES RISK
Food Item
Quantity
MODIFIED DIET
Where Consumed
One
McDonalds
Low
12 servings,
consumed
throughout day
beginning with
breakfast
McDonalds
High
Coffee
Ham sandwich:
bread, ham
Two
Work
Low
Mountain Dew
See note in
Breakfast row
Work
High
Mountain Dew
Defined snack
Powerade
(The Coca-Cola
Company, Atlanta)
20 ounces
During commute
High
Propel (PepsiCo)
Dinner
Subway (Milford,
Conn.) meatball
sandwich
One 12-inch
sandwich
Take out
Low
Subway meatball
sandwich
Salad
Mountain Dew
See note in
Breakfast row
Home
High
Mountain Dew
See note in
Breakfast row
Work, home
High
Lunch
Between meals
Notes:
1. Patient likes fruits and vegetables and is willing to drink milk on cereal.
2. Patient quantified his Mountain Dew intake as about a 12-pack per day.
3. Patient reported swishing, but not holding, Mountain Dew in his mouth.
4. Although the patient accepted diet Mountain Dew, he was unwilling to give up all of his Mountain Dew at this time. We negotiated limiting Mountain Dew to lunch only with a water rinse after consumption.
5. Patient denied regular intake of candy, baked goods and snack foods.
* The patient was a 25-year-old man who was 5 feet, 10 inches tall and weighed 276 pounds. Reported alcohol intake included three to four
drinks once a week.
The questions asked to assess the topics outlined in the Diet Assessment of Caries Risk tool
should be tailored to the age and culture of the
patient and to the oral health care professionals
style. However, all questions should be openended and nonjudgmental so as to minimize the
patients guilt and encourage honest responses.
Receiving accurate information from the patient
is essential for negotiating dietary changes that
support oral and systemic health.
CONCLUSIONS
http://jada.ada.org
Copyright 2009 American Dental Association. All rights reserved. Reprinted by permission.
June 2009
673
McDonalds
(Oak Brook, Ill.)
bacon, egg and
cheese biscuit
CLINICAL PRACTICE
N U T R I T I O N
dietary habits is an essential component of preventive oral health care and targeting specific
high-risk behaviors will help oral health care
practitioners provide preventive dietary recommendations to patients.
Disclosure. Dr. Marshall did not report any disclosures.
Nutrition is published in collaboration with the Nutrition Research
Group of the International Association for Dental Research.
674
http://jada.ada.org
Copyright 2009 American Dental Association. All rights reserved. Reprinted by permission.
June 2009