Professional Documents
Culture Documents
of
Advertising
Affecting
Consumers Behavior
Ali Ammad
Tahseen Hasan
Zahore Abbasi
(1335105)
(1335132)
(1335121)
TECHNOLOGY,
Dec 2014
Characteristics
of
Advertising
Affecting
Consumers Behavior
Ali Ammad
1335105
Tahseen Hasan
1335132
Zahore Abbasi
1335121
June 2014
________________________
Supervisor Name & Signature
____________________________
Program Manager Name & Signature
Date________________
Date_________________
___________________________
1335132 Tahseen Hasan
___________________________
1335121 Zahore Abbasi
_______________________
Supervisor
Name & Signature
___________________________
___________________________
___________________________
1335121 Zahore Abbasi
_____________________
Supervisor Name & Signature
Abstract:
Advertisement has high sensory ad appeal hence it attracts more customers
toward the brand because people can easily pass on themselves toward the brand
due to which the positive affect creates in consumers minds which influence the
brand attitude. Purpose of the study is to identify various reasons that contribute
toward brand attitude in Pakistan some of them are sensory appeal, self-reference
and positive affect (which are core part of the advertisement) and the preventive
strategies that can be taken to overcome this issue. The scope of study is twin cities
(Islamabad and Rawalpindi) and the data is collected from different segments of
society which includes professionals, teachers, housewives and students. So
keeping in view the importance of the core part of the advertisement the study is
conducted to The effect of Sensory Ad Appeal, Self-Referencing and Positive Affect
on Brand Attitude, Brand Image affect as a mediator. For this purpose Questionnaire
method is used. It is examined that Sensory Ad Appeal, Self-Referencing and
Positive Affect are important factor which have positive relationship with the brand
image and brand image has positive relation with the attitude of the brand.
Table of Contents
Contents
Characteristics of Advertising Affecting Consumers Behaviour.................................1
Characteristics of Advertising Affecting Consumers Behaviour.................................2
Abstract:..................................................................................................................... 7
Acknowledgements.................................................................................................. 13
Dedication................................................................................................................ 14
Chapter 1:................................................................................................................ 15
Introduction.............................................................................................................. 15
Background of the problem...................................................................................15
Identification of research gap...............................................................................16
Problem statement................................................................................................ 17
Significance of research........................................................................................ 17
Delimitations......................................................................................................... 17
Chapter 2 :............................................................................................................... 18
Industry Profile:........................................................................................................ 18
Analysis:.............................................................................................................. 18
Progression in Industry:......................................................................................... 19
Major Competitors................................................................................................. 20
Competition of Washing Powder Brands in Pakistan..............................................20
Surf Excel........................................................................................................... 20
Ariel :................................................................................................................. 21
Bonus :.............................................................................................................. 22
Brite :................................................................................................................. 22
Market Share of different washing powder Brands in Pakistan.................22
Chapter 3 :............................................................................................................... 23
Literature Review..................................................................................................... 23
Brand Attitude:...................................................................................................... 23
Positive Affect:...................................................................................................... 27
Self-reference:....................................................................................................... 28
Sensory Appeal..................................................................................................... 31
Brand Image :....................................................................................................... 32
Chapter 4 :.............................................................................................................. 35
Theoretical framework.............................................................................................. 35
Relationship Diagram:........................................................................................... 35
Acknowledgements
We pay special thanks to ALLAH Almighty who bestowed us the opportunity,
courage and confidence to obtain more knowledge to complete our thesis project,
which will facilitate us greatly in my intellectual development and skills
capitalization.
We like to submit our deepest gratitude to our supervisor Mr. Usman Kamal,
who really guided us in a very nice and supportive manner whenever we asked him
for his worthy guidance. His behavior was very supportive during this whole journey.
We remain thankful to all other faculty members and staff of SZABIST for
providing necessary support.
Dedication
This report is dedicated to our loving parents. Without their knowledge,
wisdom, and guidance, we would not have the goals we have to strive and be the
best to reach our dreams!
Chapter 1:
Introduction
Background of the problem
Human sense is a physiological capacity of organisms that gives data for
perception. Humans have senses of Smell, Hearing, Taste and touch are the
marvelous system of collecting information., Through these senses we
recreate/create ambient images of circumstances and, on this information, we
instinctively and immediately process sensory material to create about to happen
decisions. Recently promising communicative managers have begun thinking about
the gap for sensory marketing, which strains the sensory impersonation that
generally escort most favorable expressive responses to check changing in brand
attitude.
Brand attitude is most important thing for every organization because on the bases
of that the sales increase and decrease. Beliefs of consumers towards a brand
resolute through market research. The brand attitude tell what customers think
about a product or service, whether the product answer a consumer requirement,
and just how much product is needed by the consumer. Knowledge of brand
attitude is much helpful in planning an advertising promotion. Brand attitude is the
main thing on which organizations emphasizes a lot during the promotion strategy.
Whereas, they also focus on how the activities could inspire or motivate the target
audience.
Positive affect plays an important role in advertisement and decision making
process. While this is the main part through which the brand attitude create in
customers mind. If the ad is not creating a good effect on customers or audiences
mind then customer would be little confused in order to buy that product. Whereas
companies always trying to generate a good imprint on consumers through
advertisement and try to develop a positive attitude toward its brand. Sometimes
companies try to excite the customers in order to attract them toward the brand.
Whereas the Self reference is also important in order to attract the customer toward
the brand. Self-reference works when you put the same characteristics which really
exists in your target audience otherwise it is very difficult or near to impossible for
the customers to think their selves at that position. For example in Surf Excels ad
they try to attract the mothers by showing the relationship of mother and children.
Our based research is do sensory ad appeal influence brand attitude? by Yoon and
Park (2012). In which they try to check the relationship of sensory appeal, selfreference and positive affect on brand attitude. For this they choose the coffee
brand to interpret the results while they also recommend that the further research
on it could be done by choosing the different brands of same category and try to do
the comparison between them in order to check the impact of variables
Problem statement
Before the emergence of media channels there is only print media where brands
advertise themselves. Now there are so many media channels and through these
media channels now companies can target masses and customers also have access
to gather information about brands.
Significance of research
Our study will explore impact of sensory ad appeal on the brand attitude in
Pakistan. Compared to the base study by Yoon & Park (2012) we have chosen
Washing Powder Brands. Whereas, the main objective of this research is to study
the effect of Sensory Ad Appeal, Self-Referencing and Positive effect on Brand
Attitude, Brand Image affect as a mediator.
Delimitations
There will be two big limitations in this research. First, the time constrain, the time is
very short in order to do the research. This research could show better result if the
more time is available by giving more detailed analysis and try to figure out any
other factors. If the more time is available then we go to the females which are
married and housewives and try to calculate the results according to their behavior.
Chapter 2 :
Industry Profile:
Analysis:
The washing powder market shows continue growth with time. These intensive
growth rates have commanded to strong rivalry between competitor producers and
steady increase in customer choice. Market presently faces strategic challenges as
there are consumer needs and wants are changing as consumer preferences also
changes over time as well as any future escalation in outsource and use of multipurpose washing powders and up-and-coming technologies in washing.
Cooking and food are the majority communal causes of staining customs and aroma
tainting for many users. UK users frequently use washing machines every time they
feel need of washing though in Pakistan peoples wash wears more regularly with a
blend of hand and with the machine.
For many eras, soapsuds were the mainly used for washing. Though, washing
powder replace soap as they are performing well over a vast variety of levels of
water solidity.
Washing Powders and washing detergents are now an essential part of every
consumers routine. In bazaar there are a lot of washing detergents, each washing
powder company is claiming to give bet wash and the sparkling wash at competitive
and reasonable price to buyers. Washing powders, however exercise a unseen but
dangerous effect on the customer health and on environment due to the ingredients
that are harmful. Mainly Phosphates is used in almost all current washing powders
and its also pollute water and cause its hardness
Progression in Industry:
Washing care in Pakistan noted present value growth of 16% in 2013. Washing care
value sales touched PKR58.3 billion, with washing detergents secretarial for a 95%
value share of the type. Growth was due to regular brands introduced in past years
and strong advertising and marketing efforts by Unilever Pakistan, ColgatePalmolive (Pakistan) and many other top producers.
Intense rivalry in product groups has led to rise in the diversity of products. In many
others, it has directed to the aiming of a greater base of customers through growing
responsiveness of definite products product utility and leading brand consciousness
campaigns. Generally, competitive force rising from price hike and the effects of the
downward economic spiral directed to some big companies taking realistic actions
during 2010 in order to increase market share by increasing into certain vacant
grouping of home care and looking for distinguish their brands among customers..
Few multinationals rule worth sale in many products of regularly use. These washing
powder symbolize availability &quality and have a strong brand image. Local brands
give a low quality and act as a cheapest alternate. International companies use their
Major Competitors
There are many competitors in Washing Powder Market in Pakistan. Some Top
Brands are
Ariel
Surf Excel
Brite
Bonus
Sunlight
It is the countrys leading washing powder; it prides in removal of the toughest dirt
markings and causes no damage to the cloth. Unilever Company has a Rigorous
dealership system of 530 distributors in Pakistan.
Advertisement plan of the company is on yearly form which is tailored made on the
basis of previous records.
Advertisement budget is divides into two parts, subject matter advertisement
budget and other attentive on advertising activities. As a top brand Surf Excel
rudiments to have large bombardment of promotions via TV and Other media
channels are also used keeping in view of the target market. TV is the most
prominent mainstream media thats why major chunk of advertisement goes to
mainstream channels. For promotion purpose trading offers, sales force and
consumer promotion are used
Ariel :
Company P&G market nearly 350 different brands which include Tide, Ariel,
Pampers, Whisper, always, Bounty, Pantene. In late 1990, company launched Ariel
Proctor and Gamble have make segments of their consumers in three different
classes. These are Price and Quality consciousness.
Bonus :
It is a cheap washing alternative offered by of Colgate Palmolive - backed by
Lackson Group of Industries, and is a some of the primogenital washing cleaners in
the country and are enjoying good amount of market share in washing powders
marketplace. Since Bonus have low price which attract significant market share
segment of the market but due to low-grade quality and less scent, Bonus didnt get
main share from the market.
Brite :
It is a product of Colgate Palmolive backed by Lackson Group of Industries which
entered into the washing industry by introducing a product with a name Brite in
early 1980s. Though Brite wasnt successful in gaining major share from Surf Excel,
but it is a main competitor.
Chapter 3 :
Literature Review
Brand Attitude:
Our research is to examine how the sensory ad appeals impact the Brand Attitude
(BA). So, for that we are going to focus on both things the ad and BA. In doing so,
(Vakratassas & Ambler, 2009) Studied that a multipath approach to influence in
Whereas, Batraand Stayman (1990), claims that emotional ads may attract the
customer into the advertisement and permit them to practice vicariously the
practices of the actor. On the other hand, Bagozzi and Moore (1994), suggest that to
the extent the performer(s) related feelings can be experienced by the watcher, the
advertisements may be seen as more conclusive.
Elberse and Verleun (2012) discusses that the celebrity endorsement among
marketers is very famous and have achieves major communication objective such
as brand recall brand attitude and purchase intentions and also achieves marketing
objective of sales and profits
Lee (2009) discusses that consumers likes the favorable attitudes of brand that
matches their personality more.
The self-congruence theory Sirgy (2002) also states that the congruence between
the self-image of the user and the brand image leads to a favorable attitude toward
the brand.
Edell and Burke (1987) found that ad evaluation and moods influenced beliefs and
that feelings influenced views indirectly and directly through ad assessments. We
believe that for advertisements with a touching format this same route arises.
Beliefs may be conditional based on the related feelings and the emotional ad
content evaluations it produces. For example, in Surf Excels Ad they show the
emotional relationship between the child and mother by showing that the child is
trying to help his/her mother.
The purchase intention for many of the products requires physical examination
before purchasing them this includes apparel and other such products. The study
was conducted by (Wi & Chattarman, 2012) The study by the research article shows
that such products involve more risk that is associated with the shopping online. It
is important to study the factors that decrease the different types of risks that affect
the online purchasing decisions. The research investigates and builds a comparison
Positive Affect:
PA shows the degree to which a person experience satisfying engagement with the
surroundings. Watson & Clark,
(Watson, Clark, & Tellegan, Development and Validation of brief measures of
positive and negative affect ,The Pannas Scales, 2008) Claims that the two primary
dimensions of mood are negative affect and positive affect. The focus of this
research is on positive affect, which is normally characterized by, activity, alertness
and enthusiasm. Whereas, Eisenberg & Fabes, (2011) studied that positive affect
has a significant influence positively on pro-social actions.
However, (Watson & Clark, 2010)study that emotions i.e., enthusiasm and alertness
are signs of high Positive Affect, at the same time as tiredness, laziness and sadness
illustrate low Positive Affect. So, thats means that if the person is highly energized
then it create a positive affect otherwise it can also create the negative affect
toward the brand.
(Watson, 2008) also suggest that there are fluctuations in the stages of negative or
positive affect a given individual experiences at different points in time, the
constancy of self-reports of negative and positive affect is exciting.
On the other hand, Beck, proposes that medical depression is characterized by both
strong negative feelings and the marked lack of positive emotions. So thats means
that those people who take the medicine they are more depressed and due to which
the negative feelings increase and then those audience could not create the
positive affect toward the brand.
(Del, D., & D.H&H, 2006) Claim that the satisfaction that high-Positive Affect
persons obtain from different interaction may strengthen their already heightened
level of positive feelings and in turn their need for extra contact. It shows that if the
appeal of an ad is positive then it will more attract the audience toward the brand
attitude in a positive way.
Shimp, Stuart, and Engle, (2013) study that when customers already have some
sort of knowledge and practice with a recognizable brand and they are then
exposed to an ad for that brand, little affect transfer should happen. This principle
has been established by, in a series of experiments, found that for highly
recognizable brands of cola, little conditioning effects were observed in brand
attitude.
Self-reference:
Self-referencing is a process suggest comparative implication where a customers
(Martin, Lee, & Yang, 2013)shows that how self-referencing effects purchase
behavior. People with more self-referencing has a more favorable attitude to the
advertisements and affect their purchase intentions. Marketers now a day should
consider the change in society especially regarding ethnicity. Researchers discusses
how self-referencing influence attitudes and intentions. According to (Burnkrant and
Unnava 1995) Self referencing is a dealing out approach where an character
process in rank by connecting a communication, such as an advertisement, to his or
her own self arrangement. Consumers make judgments by seeing ads and then
picture oneself related to ad, are some forms of self-referencing. So researchers find
out that self-referencing has a positive effect towards purchase behavior.
Burnkrant&Unnava (2012) suggest that the self is a complex memory and highly
controlled structure that includes both the periodic and semantic knowledge got
over a lifetime. Whereas, Krishnamurthy &Sujan (2012) studied that self-referencing
Sensory Appeal
Sensory brand is the type of branding in which marketing appeals to all the human
senses which are associated with the brand. The human sense is used to measure
customers emotional level.
(Panda, Panda, & Mishra, 2013)says that Ad appeals have a favorable impact on
consumer purchasing behavior. Advertisement is very critical component of
marketing mix of a brand. For brand promotions effectual ad appeal for a special
products or services is very vital to understand. Brand recall always matters in
advertisement. Humor, fear, eroticism and love evoked different thoughts and
difference in the shaping the attitude towards a brand. Normal and exciting appeal
are mostly advertised. Advertisements which are based on emotions make
consumer feel well about product by creating brand associations. To develop a
positive brand attitude emotional appeals are the most useful weapon in
advertising. In forming favorable attitudes marketers have found emotional appeals
superior
(Brown & Lindstorm, 2007) did study which is taken on in twelve countries, Brown
created Sensagram, a more conclusive five-sense elemental approach, in order to
calculate the multiple interaction between the senses, and found that a
multisensory performance mainly affects the brand value and awareness of product
or service excellence. Besides, the amount of sanity stimulated in a brand is
significantly connected to the products price, because brands tempting to all
Brand Image :
According to the study conducted by (Wu, Yeh, & Hsaio, 2011) the store image has a
direct impact on the purchase intention of the customer. Beside the image of the
store the quality of the service also affects the purchase intention of the brands.
This research also studies the indirect effects that are mediated by the perceived
risk and the price consciousness affecting on these relationships. Image and the
service quality of the store will respectively affect the image and purchase intension
of the product. The research shows that when all together investigating these
relationships, the store image directly affects the purchase intention of product.
This research of (Kwon & Lennon, 2009)was conducted by experiments for cross
functional halo effect of multichannel retailers compared to the offline brand image
on the online brand beliefs. Consumers see the website performing more positive
when the website is associated with a strong brand operating brand beliefs offline.
The brand belief in both the offline and the online environment has great impact on
the brand attitude. Prior to the exposure to the stimulus of the websites the
participants completed the prior offline.
The study of (Shukla, 2011)reveals that the luxury brand spends a lot in building
their brand images. If the investment regarding building the brand images are
directed towards the social desirability this will contribute more towards the brand
image. So social desirability is helpful in building the brand image. The emerging
countries that include India, China and Brazil etc are attractive markets for the
luxury goods. The consumption pattern is changing in these countries.
The research paper by (Kwon & Lennon, 2009)reveals the outcome of the play in a
The research of (Kohli, Harich, & Leuthesser, 2005)focuses on the strategies for the
brands for the new products. Those brands that have positive attribute are more
favorable on the basis of likings of other brands. This study was to investigate the
evaluation of brand names over the repeated purchase of same brands over time.
The brand choices differ from meaningful compared to non-meaningful though after
the repeat purchases. The brand name has also an impact on the evaluation and
other product characteristics over the time. This study investigates the implications
of the brand strategies. This research gives us an understanding of how brand
names are perceived. This study suggests that the evaluation of meaningful as well
as the non-meaning full brands increases with increases in exposure. But for
meaning full brands the rating does not change with repeated exposure. This
research supports the mare exposure of the brands and their halo effect. The other
researches on brand equity reveal that the consumer makes their perceptions on
the basis of the brand names. The perception of the brand name also has an impact
on the quality and other characteristic of the product. The findings also reveals that
non-meaningful brand names are evaluated less favorably compared to the
meaningful brand names.
This study by (Schaefer & Burmann, 2008)provides the information that the image
of the industry has a significant influence on the brand image of the industry. If
there is highly significant link between the corporate brand and the industry images
the individually analyzed brand image attributes can be established. Beside this the
causal influence of industry image on corporate brand image for all industry images
can easily be proved. The moderating effects of involvement and corporate
knowledge are also significant.
Chapter 4 :
Theoretical framework
Relationship Diagram:
Self referincing
Positive
affect
Sensory
ad
appeal
Brand image
Brand
attitude
Variables:
Sensory ad appeal (SAA)
Independent:
Variable that influences the dependent variable in either a positive or negative way.
(umasekran)
In this research SR, SAA and PA are independent variable and have impact on
dependent variable.
Dependent:
Dependent variable is of primary interest to the researcher. The researcher
objective is to understand and describe the dependent variable. (umasekran)
In this study brand attitude is the dependent variable and the purpose of researcher
is to find out the impact of independent variables that influence the customers
toward brand attitude.
Hypothesis
H1: self-referencing has positive influence on brand image.
H2: Sensory appeal has positive influence on brand image.
H3: Positive affect has positive influence on brand image.
H4:Brand image has positive influence on Brand attitude.
Chapter 5:
Research Methodology:
Research design
We are conducting a correlational in which researcher tries to find out one or
more variables related to the issue.
Instrument of Measurement:
For primary data collection a questionnaire with closed questions was
developed. According to (Burns, 2010), closed questions have some
advantages, it is easy to process answers and enhances the comparability of
answers. In this study questionnaire is used as instrument of measurement.
We measured sensory appeal, positive affect, self-referencing, brand image
and brand attitude through developed questionnaire.
Sampling Strategy:
A sample plan identifies who is to be sampled and how to select them for study
(Burns,2010). The research has been conducted as a cross sectional study where
data was gathered in the local vicinities of ISB/RWP. The elements of the population
have known chance to be selected as the sample in probability sampling design.
Probability Sampling will be used for this research study.
Population:
Sampling is the process by which we select an adequate number of
respondents from the population to gather data. There are two major types of
sampling design probability & non probability. The elements of the population have
known chance to be selected as the sample in probability sampling design. While in
non-probability sampling there is no predetermined chance to be selected as
subject. The unit of analysis depends upon the problem we are going to address.
According to requirements for research purpose, our population is the housewifes
teachers professional and retired from Rawalpindi and Islamabad. We did probability
sampling for collecting data.
Time Horizon:
In the study we collected the data just for one time to analyze the results. In
these types of studies data is collected more than once. These are called
longitudinal studies. In the study we collected the data just for one time to analyze
the results. So it is one shot or cross section with respect to time horizon.
Unit of Analysis:
The unit of analysis depends upon the problem we are going to address.
According to requirements of study our unit of analysis is individual who uses
washing powder. House wives professional, teachers and individuals are our unit of
analysis.
Data Analysis
In the analysis of data involves entering data into computer files, inspecting it for
errors, and running tabulations and various statistical tests (Burns, 2010). In the
present study we also used the Cronbach alpha to measure the reliability of our
instrument through SPSS. In our study we also used the CFA to check how much our
instrument of measurement is valid.
Software Used:
Spss is used for data analysis.
CHAPTER 6:
Data Analysis & Results
Introduction
Initially the study explains the descriptive statistics illustrating respondents
demography& goodness of measure including validity & reliability of the instrument.
Further, in inferential statistics it will use the technique of structure equation
modeling (SEM) to test the hypotheses through path analysis.
Descriptive Statistics
Overview of Data Collected
Researchers distributed 300 questionnaires to the people of Rawalpindi &
Islamabad. We got back 240 questionnaires that are fully filled. But in the final
analysis 213 questionnaires as were used.
Profile of Respondents
Table 1
Table of Gender Description
Gender
Frequency
Percent
Valid Percent
Cumulative
Percent
Male
Valid
43
20.2
20.2
20.2
Female
170
79.8
79.8
100.0
Total
213
100.0
100.0
As per values of table 1 it shows that female respondents are higher than male
respondents. Females are the main user of washing powder so that we can say that
we got information mainly from guanine user of washing powder.
Table 2
Table of Age Description
Age
Frequency
Percent
Valid Percent
Cumulative
Percent
Valid
20-29
55
25.8
25.8
25.8
30-39
98
46.0
46.0
71.8
40-49
59
27.7
27.7
99.5
.5
.5
100.0
213
100.0
100.0
50 & Above
Total
As per values of Table 2, 46% of our respondents lie in the age bracket of 30-39. We
tried to get maximum response from this age group because people of this age use
washing powder more than others. 27.7% of our respondents lie in 40-49 age group
these are the second most user of washing powder and 25.8% respondents lie in 2029 age group these are the third most user of washing powder.
Table 3
Table of employment Description
Employment
Frequency
Valid
Percent
Valid Percent
Cumulative Percent
Student
46
21.6
21.6
21.6
Professional
54
25.4
25.4
46.9
Teacher
19
8.9
8.9
55.9
Housewife
94
44.1
44.1
100.0
213
100.0
100.0
Total
Values of Table 3 show that 44.1% of our population is house wives. As we get
maximum response from this segment because they use washing powder. 25.4%
are the professional and 21.6% are student 8.9% are the teachers.
Table 4
Table of washing powder Description
WP
Frequency
Percent
Valid Percent
Cumulative
Percent
Valid
Surf Excel
75
35.2
35.2
35.2
Sunlight
13
6.1
6.1
41.3
Ariel
89
41.8
41.8
83.1
Bright
14
6.6
6.6
89.7
Bonus
21
9.9
9.9
99.5
Other
.5
.5
100.0
213
100.0
100.0
Total
As per values of Table 4, 41.8% of our respondents using Ariel.35.2% are using Surf
Excel 9.9%are the user of Bonus 6.6% respondents are the user of Bright and 6.1%
respondents are the users of Sunlight.
Reliability Test
Table 5
Reliability Test
Cronbach Alpha
No of Items
.747
.78
Sensory ad appeal
.745
Brand image
. 689
Brand Attitude
.836
10
3.797
28
Self-referencing
Positive affect
Total
Reliability table shows Cronbach alpha and number of items. The standard for
Cronbach Alpha is set as greater than 0.6. The values for all variables in study are
greater than 0.6 which shows inter item consistency. It is implied that all items of
each variable are aligned and tend to measure the same thing. Thus the instrument
is reliable
Correlation Test
Table 6
Correlation Test
Correlations
SR
PE
SAA
BI
BA
Pearson Correlation
SR
Sig. (2-tailed)
N
Pearson Correlation
PE
.733**
Sig. (2-tailed)
N
Pearson Correlation
SAA
.768**
.740**
.575**
.581**
Sig. (2-tailed)
N
Pearson Correlation
BI
Sig. (2-tailed)
.592**
N
Pearson Correlation
BA
Sig. (2-tailed)
.694**
.728**
.804**
.706**
.
N
**. Correlation is significant at the 0.01 level (2-tailed).
Hypothesis testing
H1 Self-referencing has positive influence on Brand image
Table 8
Coefficients
Model
Unstandardized Coefficients
Standardized
Sig.
Coefficients
B
(Constant)
Std. Error
2.354
.198
.469
.046
Durbin
Watson
Beta
11.896
.000
10.213
.000
2.254
1
SR
.575
a. Dependent Variable: BI
Table 9
Coefficients
Model
Unstandardized Coefficients
Standardized
Sig.
Coefficients
B
(Constant)
Std. Error
2.206
.209
.502
.048
Durbin
Watson
Beta
10.561
.000
10.375
.000
2.055
1
PE
.581
a. Dependent Variable: BI
Table 10
Coefficients
Model
Unstandardized Coefficients
Standardized
Sig.
Coefficients
B
(Constant)
Std. Error
2.071
.216
.533
.050
Durbin
Watson
Beta
9.591
.000
10.662
.000
2.090
1
SAA
.592
a. Dependent Variable: BI
According to Table 10, SAA has positive influence on BI (0.592). Table 10 also shows
the regression results. Hypothesis 3 is accepted as p<0.05 and t value is 10.662.
This also shows that sensory ad appeal has strong relationship with brand image.
The value of Durbin-Watson is 2.090 which fulfill one of the assumptions of
Regression. Durbin-Watson value should lie between 1.5 to 2.5 range as our value
Table 11
Coefficients
Model
Unstandardized Coefficients
Standardized
Sig.
Coefficients
B
(Constant)
Std. Error
1.563
.194
.640
.044
Durbin
Watson
Beta
8.060
.000
14.462
.000
1
BI
.706
1.572
a. Dependent Variable: BA
According to Table 11, BI has positive influence on BA (0.70 6). Table 11 also shows
the regression results. Hypothesis 4 is accepted as p<0.05 and t value is 14.462.
This also shows that brand image has strong relationship with brand attitude. The
value of Durbin-Watson is 1.572 which fulfills one of the assumptions of Regression.
Durbin-Watson value should lie between 1.5 to 2.5 range as our value lie between
this range. Our study this requirement is fulfilled.
Mediation
We are using Preacher and Hayes method to analyze mediation this method used in
place of Baron Kenny method.
Positive affect
Model = 4
Y = BA
X = PA
M = BI
Sample size
213
Table 12.1
Outcome: BI
Model Summary
R
R-sq
.5812
MSE
.3378
df1
.1475 107.6483
df2
1.0000 211.0000
Model
coeff
se
LLCI
ULCI
.0000
constant
2.2064
PA
.5023
.2089
.0484
10.5608
10.3754
.0000
.0000
1.7946
.4069
2.6183
.5978
(X) PA is the independent variable and significant predictor on (M) mediator BA. As
p(.000) so that independent variable positive affect is the significant predictor of
mediator brand image.
Table 12.2
Outcome: BA
Model Summary
R
R-sq
.8067
MSE
.6508
df1
.0643 195.7116
df2
2.0000 210.0000
.0000
Model
coeff
constant
1.0541
se
t
.1706
p
6.1799
LLCI
.0000
ULCI
.7179
1.3904
BI
.3866
.0455
8.5036
.0000
.2970
.4762
PA
.3770
.0393
9.5939
.0000
.2995
.4544
Table 12.3
Outcome: BA
Model Summary
R
.7284
Model
R-sq
.5306
MSE
df1
.0861 238.5054
df2
1.0000 211.0000
.0000
coeff
constant
PA
se
1.9071
.5712
t
.1596
.0370
LLCI
11.9503
15.4436
.0000
.0000
ULCI
1.5925
.4983
2.2217
.6441
In this table the independent variable (X) has p(.000) value this shows that the (X) is
the significant predictor of (Y) the dependent variable.
Table 12.4
Indirect effect of X on Y
Effect
BI
.1942
.0688
.3803
Table 12.5
.2943
.1444
.4633
Table 12.6
se
.1942
.0296
Z
6.5587
p
.0550
These tables shows the indirect effect of (X) the independent variable on the (Y)
dependent variable so their values of P must greater than zero so here the values
are the greater then zero so that X has significant effect on Y.
Self-Referencing
Model = 4
Y = BA
X = SR
M = BI
Sample size
213
Table 13.1
Outcome: BI
Model Summary
R
.5752
R-sq
.3308
MSE
df1
.1491 104.3033
df2
1.0000 211.0000
.0000
Model
coeff
constant
SR
2.3540
.4694
se
t
.1979
.0460
LLCI
11.8964
10.2129
ULCI
.0000
.0000
1.9640
.3788
2.7441
.5600
(X) SR is the independent variable and significant predictor on (M) mediator BA. As
p(.000) so that independent variable positive affect is the significant predictor of
mediator brand image.
Table 13.2
Outcome: BA
Model Summary
R
.7884
Model
R-sq
.6216
MSE
df1
.0697 172.4584
df2
2.0000 210.0000
.0000
coeff
constant
se
1.1824
BI
.4157
SR
.3185
t
.1749
.0471
p
6.7599
8.8293
.0384
LLCI
ULCI
.0000
.0000
8.2877
.8376
.3229
.0000
1.5272
.5085
.2427
.3942
Table 13.3
Outcome: BA
Model Summary
R
R-sq
.6936
MSE
.4811
df1
.0952 195.6144
df2
1.0000 211.0000
.0000
Model
coeff
constant
2.1609
se
t
.1581
p
13.6692
LLCI
.0000
ULCI
1.8493
2.4726
SR
.5136
.0367
13.9862
.0000
.4412
.5860
In this table the independent variable (X) has p(.000) value this shows that the (X) is
the significant predictor of (Y) the dependent variable.
Table 13.4
Indirect effect of X on Y
Effect
BI
.1951
.0693
.4099
Table 13.5
.2993
.1363
.4819
Table 13.6
se
.1951
.0293
Z
6.6610
p
.03570
These tables shows the indirect effect of (X) the independent variable on the (Y)
dependent variable so their values of P must greater than zero so here the values
are the greater then zero so that X has significant effect on Y.
Sensory Ad Appeal
Model = 4
Y = BA
X = SAA
M = BI
Sample size
213
Table 14.1
Outcome: BI
Model Summary
R
R-sq
.5917
MSE
.3501
df1
.1448 113.6817
df2
1.0000 211.0000
.0000
Model
coeff
constant
SAA
2.0711
.5325
se
t
.2160
.0499
p
9.5908
10.6622
LLCI
.0000
.0000
ULCI
1.6454
.4341
2.4968
.6310
(X) SAA is the independent variable and significant predictor on (M) mediator BA. As
p(.000) so that independent variable positive affect is the significant predictor of
Table 14.2
Outcome: BA
Model Summary
R
R-sq
.8527
MSE
.7272
df1
.0503 279.8408
df2
2.0000 210.0000
.0000
Model
coeff
constant
BI
SAA
.8709
.3212
.4851
se
t
.1525
.0406
.0365
p
5.7113
7.9172
13.2870
LLCI
.0000
.0000
.0000
ULCI
.5703
.2412
.4131
1.1715
.4011
.5571
SAA (X) and BI (M) is the significant predictor of BA (Y) as p(.0000) so that
independent variable positive affect and mediator brand image are the significant
predictor of dependent variable brand attitude.
Table 14.3
Outcome: BA
Model Summary
R
R-sq
.8036
MSE
.6457
df1
.0650 384.5758
df2
1.0000 211.0000
.0000
Model
coeff
constant
SAA
1.5361
.6561
se
t
.1447
.0335
p
10.6186
19.6106
LLCI
.0000
.0000
ULCI
1.2509
.5902
1.8212
.7221
In this table the independent variable (X) has p(.000) value this shows that the (X) is
the significant predictor of (Y) the dependent variable.
Table 14.4
Indirect effect of X on Y
Effect
BI
.1710
.0667
.3187
Table 14.5
.2869
.1338
.4411
Table 14.6
se
.1710
.0270
Z
6.3385
p
.0783
These tables shows the indirect effect of (X) the independent variable on the (Y)
dependent variable so their values of P must greater than zero so here the values
are the greater then zero so that X has significant effect on Y.
CHAPTER 7:
Conclusion and Recommendations
Managerial Implications
In terms of application, in managerial context, the study provides useful
insights to managers and action plan to rectify the existing problems.
In context of this study, Pakistan is a market which still remains untapped
when it comes to home care products. Still, there is a lot of potential in this market
that needs to be addressed by Marketing departments of multinationals companies.
Companies like P&G, Unilever and Colgate Palmolive are the main competitors in
washing powder market.
The objective of study was to determine the factors that are contributing
towards customers attitude about a brand which ultimately leads to repeat usage
of washing powder which in turns brings revenue and success to the company.
This study provides useful managerial insights that will guide the companies
in reshaping their Advertising strategies and focus on factors that are contributing
more towards building favorable attitude of customers to the brand.
Another important implication for organizations is that they should focus on
managing customer minds by using sensory ad appeal and controlling the selfreference factor.
Companies need to conduct campaigns to aware the customers living in
remote areas. By creating a creative advertising appeal they should focus on
targeting masses to compete in this competitive market.
Limitations of Research
During data collection process, respondents were not willing to provide easy
access to information and their experiences regarding the use of washing powder.
Due to lack of time and resources, the study chose small sample size which may not
be enough to make generalizable conclusions. Further, the access to customers was
limited. Inadequate resources were major limitation.
Future Research
In view of all the previous studies that have been conducted on customer
attitude toward a brand, it can be seen that this has always been an area of concern
for the managers and the companies. Further studies can be conducted on the
moderating effect of social involvement and price between advertising
characteristics and brand attitude.
Conclusion:
It is a fact that when advertisement with high sensory ad appeal it attracts more
costumers toward the companys brand because customers are being influenced by
advertisement and due to which the positive affect created in their minds influence
them toward brand attitude. Purpose of this study was to identify weather the
sensory appeal play an important role in advertisement in order to create a positive
brand attitude. As Yoon and Parker (as we discussed earlier) did research in 2012 in
which they choose the coffee brand only and try to figure out the importance of
sensory appeal toward the brand attitude. But in this research we try to figure out
such affect in Pakistani culture and did the comparison of different brands of
washing powder of similar category to check whether the sensory appeal also
influence the Pakistani audience or not. The results show that on the bases of
creating sensory appeal in advertisement the surf excel and Ariel have strong
competition 41.8% audience are the user of Ariel and 35.2% are the user of surf
excel so they have strong competition and 6.1% user of sunlight and 6.6% user
of brite an 10% are the user of bonus. The main competitor in washing powder
industry in Pakistan is Ariel and Surf excel.
This study covers three variables that were used to measure the customer attitude
towards brands which includes, self-referencing, positive affect and sensory ad
appeal and moderating effect of brand image on the brand attitude.
This study shows that sensory ad appeal has positive influence on brand image
which led
customers attitude towards your brand. Results of the study were
also aligned with previous studies. In this regard, study will help managers to
consider the important element of advertising in devising their promotional
strategies.
Self-referencing and positive affect appeared to be a important factors for creating
brand image in the mind of consumers which ultimately made consumers attitude
towards brand. And it also appeared to be important elements in developing
countries like Pakistan. In order to improve advertising standards this factor will help
companies in modifying their advertising strategies accordingly because of its
increased effect on brand attitude.
Bibliography
Brown, M., & Lindstorm, M. (2007). Sensagram. Journal of qualitiative research.
Cooper, P., & Braithwhite, A. (2010). Synaesthesia : Researching the power of
sensation. journal of qualitative research.
Del, V., D., H., & D.h & H, T. (2006). Feeling the effect of sales promotion on post
promtion brand preference. Journal of retailing, 82(3), 203-213.
Del, V., D., H., & D.H&H, T. (2006). Feeling the effect of sales promotion on post
promotion brand preferences. journal of retailing, 82(3), 203-213.
Dimofte, C. V., & Yalch, R. F. (2010). The role of frequency of experience with a
product category and temporal. Journal of Consumer Psychology, 343-354.
Fournier, S. (2009). Consumer and their brands, developing relationship theory in
consumer research. Journal of consumer research.
Kara, A. R.-M., J., I. K., & Z, H. T. (2009). Consumer preferences in store brands : Role
of prior experiences and value consciousness. Journal of targeting,
measurement and analysis of marketing, 17(2), 127-137.
Kohli, C. S., Harich, K. R., & Leuthesser, L. (2005). Creating brand identity, a study of
evalution of new brand names. Journal of Business reserach, 58, 1506-1515.
Kwon, W. S., & Lennon, S. J. (2009). Reciprocal effects between multichannel
retailers offline and online brand images. Journal of Retailing, 85(3), 376-390.
Kwon, W.-S., & Lennon, S. J. (2009). What induces online loyalty? online vs offline
brand images. Journal of business reserch, 62, 557-564.
Lowengart, O., & Dr.Ghose, S. (2011). Impact of consumer perception and
preferences on brand positioning strategy. Journal of targeting measuremnt
and analysis for marketing, 26-41.
Martin, B. A., Lee, C. K.-C., & Yang, F. (2013). THE INFLUENCE OF AD MODEL
ETHNICITY AND SELF-REFERENCING ON ATTITUDES. Journal of Advertising,
33(4), 27-37.
Panda, T. K., Panda, T. K., & Mishra, K. (2013). Does Emotional Appeal Work in
Advertising?The Rationality Behind Using Emotional Appeal. The IUP Journal
of Brand Management, 10(2).
Peter, C., & Braithwhite, A. (2007). how advertising is done through sensory
appeals. jouranl of qualitative research.
Pradhan, D., Debasis, D., & Sethi, D. (2014). Celebrity endorsement: How. Journal of
Appendix
Research Survey
Researchers the students of Master in Business Administration at SZABIST doing a
research on a The effect of Sensory Ad Appeal, Self-Referencing and
Positive effect on Brand Attitude, Brand Image affect as a mediator.
Researcher focus is to target user of Washing Powder .Kindly spare some time to fill
the questionnaire to your best knowledge and experiences. Your response will be
used only for research purpose.
1
1
2
2
3
3
4
4
5
5
11.
12.
Thank You