You are on page 1of 94

MCKINSEY & COMPANY

COMPETITIVE VENDOR PROFILE

Prepared for

IBM CORPORATION
AMERICAS MARKET INTELLIGENCE
WHITE PLAINS, NY

Prepared by
Renaissance Group International, Inc.
495 Wheeler Road
Ashby, MA 01431
(978) 386-5858
June 5, 2001

FOR INTERNAL USE ONLY

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Page
UPDATE HISTORY

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY

BUSINESS STRATEGY

A.

Research and Development

11

PRODUCT STRATEGY

15

A.
B.
C.
D.
E.
F.
G.
H.
I.

16
17
18
18
19
31
32
33
34

Corporate Finance and Strategy


Global New Economy
Growth and Business Building
Innovation and Technology Management
Marketing
Operational Effectiveness
Organization
Strategy
@McKinsey

MARKET STRATEGY

41

A.
B.
C.

41
46

Customers and Company Size


Account Marketing Approach
Competition

ORGANIZATION STRUCTURE

50

A.

51

Services Delivery Organization

ALLIANCES/JOINT VENTURES/PARTNERSHIPS

65

A.
B.

65
66

Acquisitions
Alliances

FINANCIALS

68

A.

68

International Operations

CORPORATE STRENGTHS AND WEAKNESSES

71

INDUSTRY FOCUS

72

FOR INTERNAL USE ONLY

Renaissance Group International, Inc. (RGI),

495 Wheeler Road, Ashby, MA 01431

978-386-5858

TABLE OF CONTENTS (CONT.)


A.
B.
C.
D.
E.
F.
G.
H.
I.
J.
K.
L.
M.
N.
O.
P.
Q.

Auto and Assembly


Banking and Securities
Chemicals
Consumer/Packaged Goods
Electric Power and Natural Gas
High Tech
Insurance
Media and Entertainment
Metals and Mining
Nonprofit
Payor/Provider
Petroleum
Pharmaceuticals and Medical Products
Pulp and Paper
Retail
Telecommunications
Transportation

73
75
76
76
77
77
78
78
79
79
79
80
81
82
82
84
85

FOR INTERNAL USE ONLY

Renaissance Group International, Inc. (RGI),

495 Wheeler Road, Ashby, MA 01431

978-386-5858

CHARTS

Page

MCKINSEY & COMPANY GUIDING PRINCIPLES

TOP MANAGEMENT CONSULTING FIRMS WORLDWIDE

47

MCKINSEY & COMPANY ORGANIZATIONAL STRUCTURE

50

MCKINSEY & COMPANY HEADCOUNT

53

MCKINSEY & COMPANY CONSULTANTS BY SELECTED U.S. OFFICES

54

MCKINSEY & COMPANY REVENUE

68

MCKINSEY & COMPANY OFFICE LOCATIONS

69

GEOGRAPHIC DISTRIBUTION OF MCKINSEY & COMPANY

70

CONSULTANTS

FOR INTERNAL USE ONLY

Renaissance Group International, Inc. (RGI),

495 Wheeler Road, Ashby, MA 01431

978-386-5858

FOR INTERNAL USE ONLY

Renaissance Group International, Inc. (RGI),

495 Wheeler Road, Ashby, MA 01431

978-386-5858

McKINSEY & COMPANY: UPDATE REPORT

(12/19/2001)

PAGE 1

Prepared by RGI and by IBM Americas Market Intelligence

McKINSEY & COMPANY UPDATE


Intent
IBM Americas Market Intelligence commissions Marketing Strategy Reports on an annual
basis. It commissions Update Reports on most companies to be completed when the original
reports are six months old. These reports are to summarize briefly significant recent events that
alter or augment information contained in the main section of the original report.
This report updates the McKinsey & Company Marketing Strategy Report completed in May
2001 by Renaissance Group International, Inc. (RGI) of Ashby, Massachusetts. Individuals
requiring specific or related information are encouraged to contact Pat Schuett-Luccarelli on
pdschue@us.ibm.com or to contact RGI directly at 978-386-5858.

Overview
McKinsey & Company prides itself on client confidentiality and, therefore, does not issue
press releases on a consistent basis. In turn, helping to promote itself, the company posts recent
articles, as well as the McKinsey Quarterly, which focus on current topical interests. As such, this
update provides summarizations as follows. These topics suggest the technology skills and
business practices strategic to the companys current interests.

A September 2001 article in The Financial Times says that, according to a report
published by the McKinsey Global Institute, New Delhi economists generally attribute
Indias poor performance to its high rate of illiteracy and abysmal infrastructure. The
article goes on to claim that the country easily could achieve double-digit annual
economic growth rates without tackling either of these problems. By taking three
steps -- removing distortions to the countrys property markets, privatizing
government assets, and clearing the thicket of barriers that stifle investment in
product development -- India could add 4 percentage points a year to its current
growth rate of 6%. The report says that as many as 90% of Indias land titles are
under legal dispute in one form or another. This uncertainty, which Indias courts say
would take more than a century to resolve at their current rate of progress, hinders
the incentive for land developers to invest in retail or housing. As a result, India has
the highest property prices in Asia relative to income. The report goes on to
recommend that Indias state governments replace the high 8% to 10% stamp duties
on title transfer with more equitable system of property tax. It also recommends
setting up a judicial agency, along the lines of Germanys Treuhand, which was set
up to resolve ownership disputes in the former east Germany, to cut through Indias
red tape.

The following outlines articles from the McKinsey Quarterly.

FOR INTERNAL USE ONLY

Renaissance Group International, Inc. (RGI),

495 Wheeler Road, Ashby, MA 01431

978-386-5858

McKINSEY & COMPANY: UPDATE REPORT

(12/19/2001)

PAGE 2

Prepared by RGI and by IBM Americas Market Intelligence

Revving up auto branding -- This article states that US car companies spend upward
of $40B a year on marketing, more than any other US industry. However, the
combined market share of the Big Three continues to slide. The authors go on to
question the reason for this discrepancy, placing the blame on a loss of brand
identity. As cars become more alike, car manufacturers often have made price the
main reason for choosing one brand over another. This is a classic trap of a
commoditizing industry, and it destroys healthy profit margins. McKinsey questions
what to do. Car companies must abandon their emphasis on rebates and incentives,
instead putting their marketing budgets behind the holistic management of every
consumer touch point, from product design through after-sales service.

Vaccines where theyre needed -- In this article, McKinsey finds that people in the
developing world often go without the vaccines they need. Vaccines for the diseases
that afflict it are too expensive for countries with annual health care spending of less
than $10 a head. Moreover, the development of vaccines for these diseases is
usually a risky and unprofitable enterprise for pharmaceuticals companies. In
conclusion, by assuming some of the risks borne by the makers of vaccines,
governments and international organizations could reduce the cost of bringing them
to market.

What happened to the bull market? -- McKinsey states that by the time NASDAQ
reached its peak in the recent bull market, many financial commentators had begun
to accept the idea that the traditional triumvirate of earnings growth, inflation, and
interest rates no longer drive stock market valuations. Instead, these commentators
suggested that new factors, such as structural changes in the economy, new rules of
economics, and the value of intangible assets and brands, now underpin stock
prices. In the article, McKinsey asks if they were right. Using a simple model based
on changes in earnings, inflation, and interest rates, the authors found that traditional
factors alone explain most of the medium, as well as long-term, movement of the
S&P index of 500 stocks. They uncovered scant evidence that the market has
changed the considerations it factors into stock prices.

Unbundling the unbundled -- This article states that monolithic and vertically
integrated companies once dominated the utility business. More recently, vertical
disaggregation, such as the breakup of the electricity provision business into
separate generation, transmission, and distribution businesses, sparked efficiency
improvements in utilities. McKinsey goes on to say that a second wave of
disaggregation is emerging. This one involves the horizontal unbundling of core
activities, including ownership, management, and service delivery within assets that
had been disaggregated vertically in the first wave. McKinsey finds that sooner or
later, traditional, capital-intensive service businesses such as utilities will have to
decide what they want to be -- asset owners, managers, or service providers. The
rewards for the best in each class could be large. Yet, for the "also-rans," the future
looks bleak.

Making the most of uncertainty -- McKinsey questions whether companies should


shape or adapt when faced with uncertainty. For years, executives have regarded
the question as perhaps their most fundamental strategic choice. The article asks if it
is better to try to influence, or even determine, the outcome of crucial elements of an
industry's structure and conduct, or whether it is wiser to scope out defensible
FOR INTERNAL USE ONLY

Renaissance Group International, Inc. (RGI),

495 Wheeler Road, Ashby, MA 01431

978-386-5858

McKINSEY & COMPANY: UPDATE REPORT

(12/19/2001)

PAGE 3

Prepared by RGI and by IBM Americas Market Intelligence

positions. As globalization, digitization, and unfettered capital markets raise levels of


uncertainty and rewrite definitions of opportunities and risks, this basic strategic
choice has morphed into a more complex high-stakes problem. In conclusion, the
article finds that there does not appear to be a one-size-fits-all answer for all
companies in all situations. However, by more thoroughly contemplating the level
and nature of the residual uncertainty facing decision makers, strategists can define
feasible alternatives and make better-informed choices to shape or adapt.

Brains abroad -- This article states that foreign-born workers now make up 20% of all
employees in the US information technology sector. This appears to be a boon for
the US as the global war for talent heats up, but also a hardship for poor countries,
from which many of these workers emigrated. The talent drain could have lasting
economic repercussions for the developing world, depriving it not only of the skills of
these workers but also of their influence on the productivity of others. It goes on to
say that for most countries, tackling the fundamental cause of the talent drain will
take years. This instills a requirement for a comprehensive economic reform to
replace the mixture of regulatory and fiscal incentives that emerging markets
generally have offered to lure emigrants back home. Meanwhile, a strategy that
encourages the participation of emigrants in the economic development of their home
countries can mitigate the effects on people seeking employment in the US.

Chips off a new block -- This article questions if the market could get any worse for
semiconductor makers. Market prices for their chips have fallen steadily, even as the
cost of building a new fabrication facility to produce increasingly complex products
has soared to $2B or more. The industry faces its biggest challenge yet in the form
of a new generation of plastic-based semiconductors. McKinsey states that
commodity chip makers, such as Hitachi, Rohm, and Toshiba, may suffer as the new
technology takes hold, and so will manufacturers of chip making equipment, such as
Applied Materials. Likely beneficiaries include plastics and chemical companies,
such as Dow and DuPont, as well as printer manufacturers such as Canon and
Hewlett-Packard.

Thailands chance for no-pain gain -- A McKinsey Global Institute study finds that
improved productivity in Thailand's key industries could lead to faster economic
growth. It also states that most of the needed policy reforms do not require additional
government spending or industry subsidies. The MGI research, analyzing and
benchmarking company- and industry-level productivity against global best practices,
focused on seven important sectors. As a remedy, removing regulatory barriers to
higher productivity, with a careful view to their economic and social implications, can
spur growth in the gross domestic product of Thailand. This would bring tremendous
benefits to its people. Should the opportunity be missed, the country, like Japan
since the early 1990s, might lapse into a prolonged period of stagnation.

Internet services: whos smiling now? -- McKinsey states that Internet traffic has been
slowing. A joint study by McKinsey and J. P. Morgan suggests that in the US, it will
grow at a compound annual rate of just 88% through 2005, far below the industry's
previous performance. The article goes on to say that this appears to be bad news
for the many new companies that gambled on reaching profitable scale on the back
of continued explosive growth in Internet traffic. Overall, the shifting mix and general
slowing of US Internet traffic will put traditional players, such as AT&T, IBM, and
FOR INTERNAL USE ONLY

Renaissance Group International, Inc. (RGI),

495 Wheeler Road, Ashby, MA 01431

978-386-5858

McKINSEY & COMPANY: UPDATE REPORT

(12/19/2001)

PAGE 4

Prepared by RGI and by IBM Americas Market Intelligence

EDS, in the lead. This will leave upstarts that lack the scale and expertise to meet
the demand of large enterprises for help in managing streaming media and the
applications now moving onto the Internet.

FOR INTERNAL USE ONLY

Renaissance Group International, Inc. (RGI),

495 Wheeler Road, Ashby, MA 01431

978-386-5858

MCKINSEY & COMPANY.: COMPETITIVE VENDOR PROFILE

PAGE 1

Prepared by RGI and by IBM Americas Market Intelligence

Update History
IBM Americas Market Intelligence has been preparing competitive vendor profiles with the
assistance of independent consulting companies since 1987. All reports follow the same
standard outline; however, the level of depth and topics covered vary depending on the markets
served by the profiled company. Market Intelligence, through an assigned point of contact, works
with the independent research company during the research phase of the report.
Market Intelligence intends that the report provide a general overview of the vendors
marketing and selling strategies, with sufficient detail to cover company policy and modes of
operation. Individuals requiring specific or related information are encouraged to contact Pat
Schuett-Luccarelli on 8-224-4064 or pdschue@us.ibm.com.
The following report on McKinsey & Company has been prepared by IBM Americas Market
Intelligence and by Renaissance Group International, Inc. (RGI) of 495 Wheeler Road, Ashby,
Massachusetts (978) 386-5858.

FOR INTERNAL USE ONLY

Renaissance Group International, Inc. (RGI),

495 Wheeler Road, Ashby, MA 01431

978-386-5858

MCKINSEY & COMPANY.: COMPETITIVE VENDOR PROFILE

PAGE 2

Prepared by RGI and by IBM Americas Market Intelligence

Executive Summary
McKinsey & Company is a privately owned, management consulting firm traditionally serving
major companies and organizations that are typically leaders in their segments. While currently
serving the market leaders in virtually all industries, McKinsey also helps startups to rapidly
launch and grow their operations. The company focuses on issues of importance to senior
management that relate to key areas of strategy development, organizational design, technology
and operational improvements. McKinsey provides services to companies in most industrial
nations and emerging markets, reaching across a wide range of functional areas and industries.
The client base includes a variety of industries such as automotive, banking, chemicals,
consumer goods, high technology, media, telecommunications, pharmaceuticals, energy,
retailing, and insurance.
Founded in 1926 by James O. McKinsey, McKinsey & Company provided a new approach to
management consulting that differed from the management engineering practices at the time.
The company based its practices on two major ideas:

Client Service -- serving senior management on issues of importance to them and


their enterprises, and

Professionalism -- defined as "putting the interests of clients first and maintaining the
knowledge and skills necessary to serve these clients."

McKinsey, which has grown to a $3.4B firm based on FY00 revenue, continues to
concentrate on solving challenging and complex problems that are of major concern for top
executives at businesses and institutions. The company claims to accept a project only if
McKinsey believes that opportunities for improvement exist and that the proposed solutions can
be implemented. The company draws on its worldwide consultant staff with expertise in several
industries and functional areas to develop practical answers based on analysis and experience.
McKinsey continues to strengthen its electronic commerce practice, called @McKinsey, helping
large corporate and startup clients to create sustainable, high growth e-businesses.
As a major management consulting firm, McKinsey & Company continues to exhibit many of
the same strengths that has made the firm one of the leaders in its field. In addition, the firm has
reacted to changing conditions to position itself for future growth, as follows:

Strong reputation
McKinsey continues to maintain its reputation as one of the top management
consulting firms specializing in strategic corporate issues. The McKinsey name is
recognized and respected among senior management worldwide. The company
points to repeat business as a measure of its success in serving clients and providing
these clients with measurable value several times the fees charged by the firm. In
addition, the company has an impressive network of alumni who have left McKinsey
and now serve as CEOs and top executives of major companies. McKinsey can

FOR INTERNAL USE ONLY

Renaissance Group International, Inc. (RGI),

495 Wheeler Road, Ashby, MA 01431

978-386-5858

MCKINSEY & COMPANY.: COMPETITIVE VENDOR PROFILE

PAGE 3

Prepared by RGI and by IBM Americas Market Intelligence

draw on this network of alumni to secure future projects. The company's reputation
helps in the company's recruitment efforts for new talent.

Strong base values


McKinsey consultants help clients make lasting, substantial improvement in their
performance. The company claims it will not conduct work for a client if it cannot
provide significant value to that customer, accepting only those projects the company
is qualified to perform. The company has set forth a series of aspirations and guiding
principles to direct their activities and preserve professionalism in their work. In
conducting their projects, McKinsey consultants must place client interests first,
observe high ethical standards, preserve client confidences, and maintain
independence and objectivity. In addition, the company's consultants must work to
maintain and develop the knowledge and skills required to serve its clients. While the
firm continues to maintain its general policy of not revealing client or partner names,
McKinsey has relaxed the requirement in its electronic commerce practice where the
company must point to successes to attract new business and talented employees.

Global firm
McKinsey promotes a "one-firm" image of the company, employing a worldwide staff
of consultants who promote the same professional values, mission, standard of client
service, and willingness to collaborate. The company, which believes one of its
greatest advantages is its scale and global experience, operates practices in 17
industries and across 9 functional areas. The company conducts projects through
teams that are grouped from the global base of consultants as opposed to
geographic location, assuring functional and industry expertise. The company
operates over 80 offices worldwide, expanding into new areas through its own
consultant activity as opposed to acquisitions of local consulting operations. This
policy serves to maintain the one-firm image.

Continued emphasis on professional development


McKinsey places significant importance on its employees' professional development
and growth, offering both formal and on-the-job training to enable its employees to
develop a common understanding of approaching problem solving and sharing ideas
with colleagues worldwide. The company assigns associates to projects based on
training requirements relating to skills, industry knowledge, clients, and types of
business problems. This approach helps to ensure a broad exposure to issues and
the development of a general background. As consultants progress in their career,
the company shifts the focus of additional training to client leadership, negotiating
skills, and client-relationship building. The company also requires that consultants
attend training related to their particular industry or functional specialty, referred to as
Practice Learning, to ensure they remain current on industry developments and new
problem solving approaches. The company looks to its team approach to provide
FOR INTERNAL USE ONLY

Renaissance Group International, Inc. (RGI),

495 Wheeler Road, Ashby, MA 01431

978-386-5858

MCKINSEY & COMPANY.: COMPETITIVE VENDOR PROFILE

PAGE 4

Prepared by RGI and by IBM Americas Market Intelligence

mentoring and coaching for its consultants and as a mechanism for consultants to
share their knowledge. McKinsey measures its associates on this criterion as an
important component in evaluating their performance for promotion to partner. To
further its staff's training in technology, professionals within the company's Business
Technology Offices must attend a one-week course developed and delivered in
conjunction with professors at MIT.

Strengthened electronic commerce practice


McKinsey's electronic commerce business, called @McKinsey, has grown over the
last few years, to help create sustainable, high-growth e-businesses. McKinsey
positions its value as combining leading-edge knowledge of new business models,
with expertise in specific industries and global markets to ensure the firm's ability to
identify and capture the full economic potential. The @McKinsey practice helps
clients accelerate speed to market, establish and test the viability of new business
models, enable large-scale marketing of products and services, and develop new
business ideas that build on existing skills, assets and relationships. @McKinsey,
positioned as the fastest growing practice in the company, meets the requirements of
emerging Internet businesses by offering a range of services in three areas:
improving online performance, understanding consumer behavior, and developing
customer relationships. McKinsey now claims that approximately 40% of the firm's
revenue has an associated e-commerce component, serving both startup ventures
and established large corporate clients. The firm differentiates its electronic
commerce business from its competitors as providing expertise in global industries,
utilizing an extensive network of business partners with strong ties to the startup and
venture capital communities, and offering a capability to re-integrate e-businesses
into their parent companies after launch.

Rise of accelerator offices


In an effort to shed the firm's "deliberate pace" image to support the fast-paced
image of companies competing in the Internet economy, @McKinsey has established
a network of "Accelerator" offices. These business development centers provide
hands-on Internet business-building services for clients worldwide, addressing the
development phases of launch, growth, and expansion of e-businesses. These
centers, which combine the expertise of McKinsey professionals and an extensive
third party network of "best in class" service providers and technology vendors, help
businesses launch and integrate an online business in three to nine months.
Accelerators operate either in an existing McKinsey office or in a stand-alone facility
where startups and established companies can work with @McKinsey consultants.
Accelerators offer focused, rapid problem solving at critical junctures and can
complete some engagements in as little as two weeks.

Acceptance of equity stakes in clients

FOR INTERNAL USE ONLY

Renaissance Group International, Inc. (RGI),

495 Wheeler Road, Ashby, MA 01431

978-386-5858

MCKINSEY & COMPANY.: COMPETITIVE VENDOR PROFILE

PAGE 5

Prepared by RGI and by IBM Americas Market Intelligence

To further its ability to win high-growth, startup clients, McKinsey has instituted a
strategy to accept equity stakes in these companies in exchange for services. While
the company claims to prefer cash payments, McKinsey realized that a segment of
these companies could not hire the firm under the previous fee structure. By
accepting equity stakes, the company has broadened its target market of clients.

Relaxed up-or-out policy


To compete more effectively for new employees and retain current employees,
McKinsey now follows a more relaxed "up-or-out" policy. The company recognizes
that the partnership path does not appeal to some qualified candidates, especially in
the IT arena. While the company continues to offer a well-defined development path,
McKinsey now allows consultants to take as few as three years or as many as ten
years or more to achieve the partnership level. This policy provides consultants with
time to pursue graduate degrees or to have children. The company does not impose
strict tenure-based requirements for advancement. McKinsey has established an
Associate Partner level in which promising consultants can share in the
responsibilities and monetary rewards of partnership prior to attaining partnership. In
addition, the firm now allows associates more say in choosing assignments. In early
2000, McKinsey implemented VOX (Visibility, Options, Expression of preference), a
firm-wide system that further extends the influence that consultants have over what
they do in the firm. By providing each consultant with a global view of prospective
engagements, including pro bono projects, knowledge building, and other initiatives,
individual consultants can voice their interests and preferences.

Increased flexibility in corporate policies


While continuing to follow its basic principles and maintains its core values, the firm
has demonstrated flexibility in relaxing some of its corporate policies to compete
more effectively in the current economy. As already noted, the firm has relaxed its
"up-or-out" hiring policy, providing its consultants with more say in choosing projects,
and now has accepted equity for payment of the firm's fees. In addition, McKinsey
acquired a Chicago-based branding practice, which is contrary to the firm's policy of
growing practices from within. These policy shifts point to the firm's ability to adapt to
the changing environment.

Despite these strengths, McKinsey & Company demonstrates some weaknesses and faces
some risks, as follows:

Tight recruiting market


McKinsey must compete with other management consulting and investment banking
firms, and other businesses across a diverse array of industries for quality new hires
from top business schools. Overall demand for top business students, as well as
students in information technology, remains high. To compensate, McKinsey
FOR INTERNAL USE ONLY

Renaissance Group International, Inc. (RGI),

495 Wheeler Road, Ashby, MA 01431

978-386-5858

MCKINSEY & COMPANY.: COMPETITIVE VENDOR PROFILE

PAGE 6

Prepared by RGI and by IBM Americas Market Intelligence

continues to expand its new hire process to include a greater variety of disciplines to
avoid going deeper into the MBA class. Half of the company's new consultants come
directly from industry or with graduate degrees other than MBAs. In addition, the
company now hires employees with established careers in specialized areas of
interest to McKinsey including electronic commerce, brand management, corporate
finance, information technology, law, and medicine. Over the last few years,
McKinsey has taken steps to make the firm's pay structure more competitive with
startup companies that can offer stock options. To attract and retain top IT talent,
McKinsey has taken minority stakes in more than 100 technology startups.
Furthermore, McKinsey has established an Investment Office as a mechanism for its
partners and associates to tap into the Internet and other startup money. The
Investment Office, which is run independently of the firm's consulting services,
invests pooled monies into venture capital funds, leveraged buyout funds, hedge
funds, and index funds managed by independent managers.

Employee turnover
McKinsey has seen its employee turnover rate drop from a high of 20 to 21% over
the last two years, to a low of under 12% at the current time. The firm attributes the
decreased turnover rate to the slowdown in the growth of dot.com businesses.
During the last few years, employees were more likely to leave the company more
quickly for greater equity positions in new dot.coms as well as e-commerce positions
at established vendors. The firm views 17% as the equilibrium figure, providing the
right balance of employees leaving either because they are not McKinsey material or
to pursue careers in startups or at clients.

Compromising principle concerning independence


By accepting minority equity stakes in clients, McKinsey risks compromising its longestablished reputation for complete independence from its clients. The firm must
carefully balance its stake in these companies against its perceived objectivity in
client projects. In an effort to minimize potential conflict, in many cases McKinsey
keeps its partners shares in a blind trust so partners typically do not know if the
company holds shares in a particular client.

Competitive market
The consulting market has become increasingly competitive as smaller, more
entrepreneurial companies continue to enter the management consulting market
serving niche segments. These new consulting firms provide e-business services as
well as broader strategy offerings. In addition, the Big Five accounting firms
continue to build their consulting divisions that have expanded into management and
technology consulting. Furthermore, technology consulting has increased with
systems vendors housing their own consulting divisions to meet customer
requirements in this area and firms offering online consulting services. In addition to
FOR INTERNAL USE ONLY

Renaissance Group International, Inc. (RGI),

495 Wheeler Road, Ashby, MA 01431

978-386-5858

MCKINSEY & COMPANY.: COMPETITIVE VENDOR PROFILE

PAGE 7

Prepared by RGI and by IBM Americas Market Intelligence

competition for clients, the company competes against these services firms and
Internet businesses for talented employees.

McKinsey has established itself as a leading management consulting firm focused on serving
major Fortune 500 companies; education, financial and government institutions; medium-sized
businesses; and entrepreneurial companies. The firm continues to strengthen its electronic
commerce business to broaden its offerings in the Internet economy and to attract more
entrepreneurial clients. Across all of its practices, McKinsey's strategy remains to help clients
improve performance and profitability. The company continues to compete on the basis of its
staff of partners and consultants providing services across a range of industries and functional
areas, addressing issues concerning strategy, organization, operations and technology of
concern to top executives. To continue to succeed in its various markets, McKinsey must
persevere in its efforts to attract and retain top talent for the company and further develop its
image as a force in the Internet economy. In an effort to compete in the new Internet economy,
McKinsey has relaxed some of its more rigid policies, helping the company to win high-growth
clients.

FOR INTERNAL USE ONLY

Renaissance Group International, Inc. (RGI),

495 Wheeler Road, Ashby, MA 01431

978-386-5858

MCKINSEY & COMPANY.: COMPETITIVE VENDOR PROFILE

PAGE 8

Prepared by RGI and by IBM Americas Market Intelligence

Business Strategy
McKinsey & Company is an international management consulting firm that advises
companies on strategic, operational, organizational, and technological issues. McKinsey's
mission is to help the companys "clients make distinctive, lasting, and substantial improvements
in their performance and to build a great firm that is able to attract, develop, excite, and retain
exceptional people." The firm serves senior management on issues critical to them and their
enterprises, seeking to exceed client expectations and provide high levels of "client impact." In
addition, McKinsey's strategy encompasses recruiting and retaining talent in sufficient numbers to
enable the company to serve its clients properly.
McKinsey defines a set of aspirations and guiding principles to direct its activities, as shown
in the chart below. McKinsey instills these principles in its employees with new consultants
observing the actions of more senior employees. The company's aspirations and guiding
principles remained essentially unchanged over the last year. The firm positions itself as a
values-driven organization, committed to "people over profit" and "impact over fees." In addition
the company operates as a meritocracy, offering a single worldwide standard for its people,
service, and professional integrity.
McKinsey & Company Guiding Principles
Aspirations

To serve the company's


clients as primary
counselors on overall
performance

Guiding Principles

Adhere to the highest professional standards

Follow top management approach

Play an integrative role in problem solving,


implementation, and capability building
Build enduring, trust-based relationships
Strive for superior quality and distinctive impact

Deliver the best of the firm


to every client

Serve all clients as "firm" clients by leveraging the


company's scale and global network
Develop and disseminate state-of-the-art management
practices
Manage client and firm resources in a cost-effective
manner

Create an unrivaled
environment for superior
talent

Develop and excite McKinsey people through active


apprenticeship and stretching, entrepreneurial
opportunities
Foster an inclusive and non-hierarchical working
atmosphere
Uphold the obligation to dissent
Respect the individual's responsibility for balancing
personal and professional life

FOR INTERNAL USE ONLY

Renaissance Group International, Inc. (RGI),

495 Wheeler Road, Ashby, MA 01431

978-386-5858

MCKINSEY & COMPANY.: COMPETITIVE VENDOR PROFILE

PAGE 9

Prepared by RGI and by IBM Americas Market Intelligence

Govern themselves through


a values-driven partnership

Demonstrate care and concern for every individual

Live by the principles of participative partnership through


involvement, collaboration and trust
Benefit from individual freedom and assume the
obligations of mutual accountability and self governance
Maintain a meritocracy
Operate as one firm

Source: McKinsey & Company, May 2001


Marvin Bower, the successor to founder James McKinsey as Managing Partner, instilled the
requirement that the company's management consultants be professionals. McKinsey
consultants continue to adhere to the following standards:

Place client interests first, believing that over the long term, the company can only
prosper if it provides services of real value to clients;

Observe high ethical standards, treating clients with integrity and trust;

Preserve the confidences of clients and their personnel to generate a long-term


relationship;

Accept only those assignments that the company is fully qualified to perform; and

Maintain independence and objectivity, even if it means declining or withdrawing from


an assignment. The company believes it must take positions that are in the client's
best interests even if it adversely impacts McKinsey. The company claims it will not
withhold "unwelcome facts, conclusions, or recommendations" to preserve a
relationship or "protect personal positions."

In order to have an impact on clients, McKinsey believes its consultants must earn the trust of
clients and colleagues through an understanding of the following:

Authority based in ideas, not hierarchy;


Persuasiveness, not power; and
Empathy, not detachment.

The company further believes that its people represent the primary factor in the firm's ability
to serve its clients successfully. The firm's strategy incorporates the attraction, development, and
retention of "excellent" people. McKinsey's strategy continues to rely on a "one-firm" concept,
employing a worldwide staff of consultants that supports the same professional values, mission,
standards of client service, and willingness to collaborate. In addition, consultants have a
common understanding of how to approach problem solving and share their ideas with
colleagues worldwide. The company relies on a collaborative team approach across all of its
offices, respecting local culture and organizations.

FOR INTERNAL USE ONLY

Renaissance Group International, Inc. (RGI),

495 Wheeler Road, Ashby, MA 01431

978-386-5858

MCKINSEY & COMPANY.: COMPETITIVE VENDOR PROFILE

PAGE 10

Prepared by RGI and by IBM Americas Market Intelligence

Across all of its practices, the company's strategy is to help clients improve skills,
performance, and profitability. The company utilizes a top management focus stressing an
objective, collaborative approach while viewing problems from the integrated, cross-functional
point of view of chief executive officers and presidents. McKinsey consultants apply functional
and industry expertise to proven analytical frameworks for its projects, using a facts-based
approach to conduct analyses based on quantitative/logical foundations. The firm provides an
objective, third-party perspective to arrive at an actionable conclusion, recommending actionable
solutions that have a positive, lasting impact on the client's business.
Specifically, McKinsey consultants implement their business strategy through the following
steps:

Develop winning strategies for the client in such areas as:

New products and services;


Market entry strategies;
Restructuring;
Sales and distribution;
Strategic alliances;
Technology; and
Electronic commerce.

Anticipating and responding quickly to business challenges such as:

Regulatory threats;
Increased competition;
Excess capacity; and
Cost pressures.

Building superior organizational capabilities by reviewing strategies, styles, skills,


values, systems and staff; and

Increasing operational effectiveness and productivity considering cost, quality, and


timeliness.

Across all of its services, the company believes it must add value for the client. The company
accomplishes this through the following techniques:

Provide objective, fact-based analysis and advice;


Utilize state-of-the-art processes on critical management issues;
Contribute expertise spanning industries and functional areas;
Offer creative, yet pragmatic, solutions for clients; and
Provide effective support during solution implementation.

McKinsey has traditionally accepted assignments only if the company believes it will have
lasting positive impact for the client, defined as an increase in shareholder value. The company's
strategy is to assist clients in ways that surpass the client's expectation and to strive for higher
FOR INTERNAL USE ONLY

Renaissance Group International, Inc. (RGI),

495 Wheeler Road, Ashby, MA 01431

978-386-5858

MCKINSEY & COMPANY.: COMPETITIVE VENDOR PROFILE

PAGE 11

Prepared by RGI and by IBM Americas Market Intelligence

levels of client impact. The company positions its work as supplementing the client's leadership,
not replacing it. McKinsey will accept a client if it meets the following conditions:

The problem or opportunity is big enough to justify and demand senior


management's attention;

The client is open to new and broader perspectives; and

The client will take action and implement changes.

McKinsey permits client organizations to stop a study at any time during the process if the
client feels the project is not benefiting them. The company believes its strategy has been
successful, pointing to repeat business from clients looking to McKinsey to conduct new projects.
Over the last few years, the firm has tried to re-position itself to address the requirements of
the Internet economy. While McKinsey adheres to its aspiration and guiding principals, the firm's
Managing Director, Rajat Gupta, believes McKinsey has to adapt its approach to analysis,
focusing on using the Web. Mr. Gupta has stated that the firm is currently evolving its
approaches.
The company has recently strengthened its electronic commerce services, creating the
@McKinsey practice. Approximately 40% of McKinsey's current revenue is gained from ecommerce and technology-based business, either for existing clients such as insurance
companies and banks, or for startups. The company was involved with more than 1,000 ecommerce projects in 2000, a three-fold increase over 1999s level.
In addition, McKinsey has slowly implemented a "consulting-for-equity" structure in an
attempt to gain more high-growth companies as clients. As part of its current fee structure, the
firm will accept payment in the form of equity and cash, noting that the company claims to prefer
cash for its services. McKinsey has taken equity stakes in over 100 companies, ranging from
startups to spin-offs owned by larger firms. These equity arrangements may be liquidated over
time.
Along with revising the payment structure to include equity stakes, McKinsey has revised its
team structure to serve these companies. @McKinsey, the firm's e-commerce business,
supports these clients in a more flexible manner than McKinsey's traditional practices. The firm
has established Accelerators worldwide to house client projects for a limited time period. The
teams typically work with these clients from idea inception to actual implementation and ongoing
execution.
While McKinsey's reputation has been built on its relationships with some of the world's
largest companies, McKinsey has leveraged its traditional leadership role to become a player in
the new economy. The firm's e-commerce staff has operating experience in more than 100
industries, including professionals who have been instrumental in more than 150 startups.

A. Research and Development


FOR INTERNAL USE ONLY

Renaissance Group International, Inc. (RGI),

495 Wheeler Road, Ashby, MA 01431

978-386-5858

MCKINSEY & COMPANY.: COMPETITIVE VENDOR PROFILE

PAGE 12

Prepared by RGI and by IBM Americas Market Intelligence

The McKinsey Global Institute represents an independent research group within McKinsey.
The Institute conducts original research and develops "substantive points of view" on economic
issues that the company views as critical for its clients. It continues to help businesses
understand the evolution of the global economy, improve their performance and competitiveness,
and provide a fact base for "sound" public policy-making at the national and international level.
Formed in 1990, the Institute is financed by internal McKinsey investment. The staff consists
largely of McKinsey's consultants plus leading university scholars from schools such as MIT,
Princeton, Harvard, and Mannheim University. The research conducted by the facility combines
economics and management disciplines, relying on the academic views of economics combined
with the real-world, management issues faced by the company's clients. The company believes
that its research results in views of the global economy that challenge conventional assumptions
of corporate leaders and public policy-makers. Broad research topics for the McKinsey Global
Institute include the following:

The relative health of the U.S. economy, assessing whether globalization can
continue in the face of cultural and political opposition;

Manufacturing and service sector productivity, labor productivity, and capital


productivity in the developed and developing world; and the

Economic performance of major economies of the world, including, Germany,


France, the U.K., Brazil, Korea and Russia.

A recent research project studied the lack of growth in the Japanese economy, looking at
structural barriers at the microeconomic level. The McKinsey Global Institute examined the
performance of four critical sectors in Japan -- retailing, food processing, residential construction,
and health care -- comparing their productivity with that of their U.S. and European counterparts.
The company also funds other research projects, which address large issues such as global
capital markets, forces at work in the international economy, and the future shape of corporations,
as follows:

Advanced statistical analysis;


Agriculture interest center;
Analytic services;
Architecture of organizational performance;
Business technology;
Client capability development;
Client communications;
Corporations of the future;
Electronic commerce;
Emerging markets;
Environment;
Family owned businesses;
Foreign affiliated companies;
Latin American desk; and
FOR INTERNAL USE ONLY

Renaissance Group International, Inc. (RGI),

495 Wheeler Road, Ashby, MA 01431

978-386-5858

MCKINSEY & COMPANY.: COMPETITIVE VENDOR PROFILE

PAGE 13

Prepared by RGI and by IBM Americas Market Intelligence

Strategy metrics.

McKinsey uses the results of its research to help position its services to clients. In many
cases, the consultants base their findings on a survey of several companies in the same industry
segment or those performing the same function. The company generalizes its findings to assist
other companies in similar segments or functional areas.
To promote its knowledge base internally, the companys consultants share their knowledge
by collaborating with other consultants. McKinsey extends its knowledge within the firm through
several mechanisms, including the following:

Office transfers;

Practice development meetings;

Project teams, consisting of partners with in-depth knowledge in an industry or


functional area; and

Investments in information technology and human resources, including researchers


and experts to support collaboration in teams.

McKinsey does not create profit centers in functional or industry practices to avoid any policy
that may discourage collaboration across specialties. This supports the concept of "one-firm"
across all offices and practices. The company believes its knowledge base becomes stronger
through collaboration between different types of expertise in functions and industries using a
team-based, integrative approach to problem solving. The company also assumes that it is in the
interactions of different types of knowledge that truly creative and valuable insights occur. In
addition, as client problems become more complex, the company believes that it must rely more
on an understanding of specific industries and functions, while still allowing consultants and
partners to remain generalists. McKinsey claims knowledge per se is of limited value until people
and consulting skills (not merely processes) combine to make it valuable.
McKinsey points to its commitment to building and sharing knowledge and continues to claim
the following:

McKinsey has written more articles for the Harvard Business Review than all the
other major management consulting firms combined;

Each year the McKinsey Quarterly publishes over 50 articles written by the firm's
consultants;

70% of McKinsey consultants have authored practice documents for the companys
internal database; and

McKinsey consulting teams request 4,800 copies of these documents each week.

FOR INTERNAL USE ONLY

Renaissance Group International, Inc. (RGI),

495 Wheeler Road, Ashby, MA 01431

978-386-5858

MCKINSEY & COMPANY.: COMPETITIVE VENDOR PROFILE

PAGE 14

Prepared by RGI and by IBM Americas Market Intelligence

The McKinsey Quarterly is a print and online publication that distills current McKinsey
research and knowledge into focused articles. The firm offers free online access to McKinsey
Quarterly articles by registering at the McKinsey Quarterly website. Recent e-business related
articles address issues such as B2B marketplace success, e-tailing success, m-commerce,
financial services competition on the web, and building digital brands.
McKinsey disseminates information about firm strategy and management through the
company's Month by Month internal news magazine. The magazine, which the company targets
at its administrative and consulting staff, also includes news about McKinsey offices, practices,
and employees. The news magazine features articles about a variety of McKinsey projects
including projects that consultants conduct free of charge for educational, cultural, medical and
social organizations in their communities.
Twice a year, the company includes a collection of new partner profiles written by the firm's
new partners concerning challenges, opportunities, and development at the company. Overall,
the company hopes that the magazine supports its consultants as they progress through their
careers at the company.
The company's Silicon Valley Office (SVO) publishes E-Insights, a series of technology
business articles that examines the business of technology, ranging from e-commerce to e-health
to wireless communications. The reports cover a broad range of issues, such as transforming
website volume into e-business value, multi-channel marketing, the value of intellectual assets,
corporate alliances, the "war" for technical talent, and Internet pricing. The company e-mails
issues of E-Insights to top industry executives and influencers on a bimonthly basis. Recent
articles have addressed the value of B2B E-Commerce, the value of intellectual assets, shifting
power from sellers to buyers, and transforming website volume into e-business value.
The firm's marketing practice also produces a monthly magazine, called Solutions, which
provides information on marketing issues. The firm's Marketing Practice professionals are at the
core of McKinsey's marketing knowledge development. Using industry relationships, client
engagements, and ongoing research efforts, the firm identifies trends and explores issues that
are of greatest concern to businesses and business leaders. The firm then disseminates its
research and ideas through the publication of articles and participation in industry forums,
providing thought leadership to the profession and the business community at large. The
company also develops white papers providing in-depth information on current marketing issues.
@McKinsey produces two in-house publications -- Velocity I and Velocity II -- addressing
issues unique to online ventures and the companies that build and manage them. In Velocity I,
@McKinsey experts discuss fundamentals of successful business models in the e-commerce
arena. Velocity II focuses on issues relating to improving operational performance for ebusinesses. Recent articles provide information on retaining e-customers, building mobile
commerce (M-commerce), building online vertical marketplaces, and building a profitable ebusiness.

FOR INTERNAL USE ONLY

Renaissance Group International, Inc. (RGI),

495 Wheeler Road, Ashby, MA 01431

978-386-5858

MCKINSEY & COMPANY.: COMPETITIVE VENDOR PROFILE

PAGE 15

Prepared by RGI and by IBM Americas Market Intelligence

Product Strategy
McKinsey offers services across a variety of functional and industry practices. The company
defines a practice as a network of people interested in developing McKinsey's capability in a
specific industry, or in a function or issue of particular interest across industries. McKinsey's
functional practices advance the state-of-the-art in addressing problems facing clients, covering
the following types of issues:

Improving efficiency;
Leading organizational change;
Strengthening sales force management;
Redesigning financial systems; and
Shaping new roles for the corporate center.

The firm currently operates more than 70 functional and industry practices that extends the
firm's knowledge and provides support to client service teams. The company's consultants use
an integrative perspective when working with its clients, typically using the following approaches
on a client project:

Looks across various functions when the focus of the work is in a specific functional
area, such as marketing, logistics, or product development;

Considers strategic, operational, and organizational issues when the problem or


opportunity seems to cross only one of those dimensions;

Incorporates knowledge of other industries and countries;

Assesses options from a senior manager's point of view; and

Thinks across different time horizons including the immediate and longer-term
solutions.

By using this approach, the company must:

Be able to keep senior managers involved and help make difficult tradeoffs and
decisions that cut across functions, regions, and planning horizons;

Provide a sense of organizational readiness for change and recognize how much and
what kind of capability and discipline will be needed; and

Earn people's trust, but stay independent.

McKinsey's services combine "analysis with action," with the company quickly formulating
hypotheses and then testing the hypotheses through interviews, fact-finding studies, and

FOR INTERNAL USE ONLY

Renaissance Group International, Inc. (RGI),

495 Wheeler Road, Ashby, MA 01431

978-386-5858

MCKINSEY & COMPANY.: COMPETITIVE VENDOR PROFILE

PAGE 16

Prepared by RGI and by IBM Americas Market Intelligence

economic and organizational modeling. The company also uses prototypes and field tests in
some projects.
Despite using standard procedures in some areas, such as sales force deployment, process
diagnosis and design, and capital productivity, the company does not believe that each problem
can be solved in the same way. The company looks across its consulting practices to determine
the appropriate method but avoids an attachment to any single philosophy due to the speed with
which strategy changes.
McKinsey builds capabilities within its client's organizations and transfers skills to the client in
all of its engagements. The company seeks to instill a higher set of performance standards at the
client. McKinsey sees its role of consultant as supplementing the role of managers at its clients,
with the clients making tradeoffs and the ultimate decisions resulting from McKinsey's work. In
addition, McKinsey relies on the client to provide the "best" people to work with McKinsey teams
to involve them in the process and draw on their expertise of the business.
McKinsey currently operates the following functional practices, described below:

Corporate finance and strategy;


Global new economy;
Growth and business building;
Innovation and technology management;
Marketing;
Operational effectiveness;
Organization;
Strategy; and
Electronic commerce (@McKinsey).

A. Corporate Finance and Strategy


McKinsey established the Corporate Finance and Strategy Practice to support tactical and
strategic initiatives such as corporate valuations, restructuring, and transformations. McKinsey
believes that rapid changes in the global marketplace such as mergers, alliances, and portfolio
restructuring, require increasingly specialized financial and strategic expertise. McKinsey's
practice is comprised of four areas, as follows:

Alliances -- The Alliances group provides independent insight and developmental


expertise to help clients structure effective deals to stay "relevant and competitive,"
including:

Developing strategy;
Negotiating and structuring a deal;
Managing or restructuring an alliance; and

FOR INTERNAL USE ONLY

Renaissance Group International, Inc. (RGI),

495 Wheeler Road, Ashby, MA 01431

978-386-5858

MCKINSEY & COMPANY.: COMPETITIVE VENDOR PROFILE

PAGE 17

Prepared by RGI and by IBM Americas Market Intelligence

Mergers & Acquisitions (M&A)/Change of Ownership -- The M&A/Change of


Ownership group provides seamless, integrated thinking and support along the entire
M&A process, including deal strategy, valuation and negotiation support, and premerger integration. The company currently focuses on the following areas:

Helping clients with strategy development;


Synergy identification;
Negotiation strategy and deal structuring;
Strategic due diligence and valuation; and
Divestitures, pre-merger planning, and post-merger activities.

Principal Investing -- The Principal Investing group provides a value-added role to


principal investing firms in all stages of an investment's life including sourcing deals,
acquiring companies, increasing portfolio value, and monetizing investments. The
firm serves clients in several areas, including:

Developing internal alliance management programs.

Opportunity identification;
Strategic due diligence; and
Portfolio performance improvement.

Post-Merger Management -- The Post-Merger Management group serves clients by


delivering strategic solutions in a high-pressure, time-sensitive environment and
incorporating execution capabilities that ensure value capture that is situationspecific.

B. Global New Economy


McKinsey believes the global new economy requires its clients to become the best in a more
focused set of activities worldwide, as opposed to being good across a broader spectrum of
activities. The firm believes that to be successful clients must leverage their intangible assets
including intellectual property, brands, talent, and networks and reshape industries to their
competitive advantage.
Within this practice, McKinsey focuses on several issues related to the global new economy
including:

Strategic control maps;


Intangible assets;
Global capital markets;
Cross-border arbitrage;
Global management models; and

FOR INTERNAL USE ONLY

Renaissance Group International, Inc. (RGI),

495 Wheeler Road, Ashby, MA 01431

978-386-5858

MCKINSEY & COMPANY.: COMPETITIVE VENDOR PROFILE

PAGE 18

Prepared by RGI and by IBM Americas Market Intelligence

Macroeconomic analysis.

The Global New Economy practice positions itself as a source of strategic and functional
information, part of a global firm with an international knowledge network.

C. Growth and Business Building


McKinsey's Growth and Business Building Practice specializes in helping client organizations
initiate and sustain profitable growth through the following activities:

Designing a growth program;


Laying the foundation for growth;
Developing a growth strategy;
Building new businesses; and
Organizing for growth.

The practice has conducted over 700 growth engagements across all business sectors over
the last several years, offering experience across these areas. The company has established the
McKinsey Growth Alliance, a network of multiple clients grouped around a common objective
such as accelerating growth. In addition, the company holds internal business plan competitions
to identify and nurture new businesses.

D. Innovation and Technology Management


McKinsey's Innovation and Technology Management Practice focuses on helping companies
achieve growth by improving their ability to generate, commercialize, and sustain technologybased innovation. The firm works with clients to help create an innovative context through the
appropriate organizational structures and processes.
The practice is comprised of three groups, as follows:

Innovation & Technology-Based Growth -- The Innovation & Technology-Based


Growth group serves clients by conducting the following:

Raising and focusing innovation aspirations;


Generating and evaluating ideas, and achieving regional redevelopment and
growth through innovation;
Building innovative new businesses;
Commercializing new technologies;
Managing an innovation portfolio; and

FOR INTERNAL USE ONLY

Renaissance Group International, Inc. (RGI),

495 Wheeler Road, Ashby, MA 01431

978-386-5858

MCKINSEY & COMPANY.: COMPETITIVE VENDOR PROFILE

PAGE 19

Prepared by RGI and by IBM Americas Market Intelligence

Product Development -- The Product Development group works in the following


areas:

Creating the context and environment for continuous innovation.

Product line strategy and platforming;


Design-to-cost studies;
Product development process;
Partner integration; and
Organization and performance management.

Research & Development (R&D) Strategy & Management -- The R&D Strategy &
Management group works with clients to maximize their R&D investment through
Sound Strategy and Smart Management, as follows:

Sound Strategy -- McKinsey's practice helps clients provide R&D support of


corporate and business unit strategies, prioritization issues, and product
development strategies.

Smart Management -- McKinsey addresses management issues including how to


make R&D investments most effective; minimizing the business impact of
reducing R&D activities; drawing on core capabilities; allocating limited budget
and human resources; and recruiting top R&D talent.

E. Marketing
McKinsey's Marketing Practice draws on the firm's global resources to work with clients and
build substantial, profitable growth through "superior marketing." The firm claims to bring to each
business challenge a combination of highly experienced marketing professionals and state-of-theart knowledge, both linked to McKinsey's industry and client knowledge.
McKinsey positions its marketing practice as focusing on marketing issues that are of most
relevance to clients, including issues that reflect real-world concerns of business leaders.
McKinsey concentrates on the most critical marketing issues and keeps the firm's knowledgebuilding at the forefront of marketplace developments. This strategy reflects the scale of the
company's consulting engagements and its constant interaction with thought leaders from
business and academia. The company bases its efforts on a thorough understanding of
customers and their needs. The firm's knowledge and ongoing studies across the entire
spectrum of marketing issues are supplemented by the broad capabilities of professionals
dedicated to supporting clients through the design, execution, and interpretation of custom market
research in B2C and B2B environments.
By combining its knowledge development and experience, McKinsey can provide state-ofthe-art, road-tested strategies in a rapidly evolving marketing environment. The firm commits to
FOR INTERNAL USE ONLY

Renaissance Group International, Inc. (RGI),

495 Wheeler Road, Ashby, MA 01431

978-386-5858

MCKINSEY & COMPANY.: COMPETITIVE VENDOR PROFILE

PAGE 20

Prepared by RGI and by IBM Americas Market Intelligence

providing its clients with a demonstrable impact on performance and reflects the way McKinsey
measures itself. The company believes that its proven ability to fulfill this commitment enhances
its leadership position.
McKinsey builds client solutions on a foundation of in-depth knowledge of both customer
needs and marketing approaches. For each engagement, McKinsey dedicates a professional
team that practices the firm's objective, fact-based approach to problem solving. Each team
draws on professional talent with a combination of industry-specific backgrounds and a creative
perspective built on expertise in the relevant marketing-related disciplines. McKinsey provides an
objective assessment of marketing investments and returns, so that resources are allocated to
accelerate growth and build shareholder value.
Over the past two years, McKinsey has completed over 500 projects across key marketing
and sales disciplines, spanning a wide range of industries including financial services, retailing,
telecommunications, electronics, and pharmaceuticals. The focus of these projects has been 50%
on offline issues, 25% on online issues, and 25% on multi-channel issues.
The McKinsey Marketing Practice engages in work that covers a wide variety of issues for a
broad range of companies. The firm organizes this practice into twelve key areas, up from eight
last year, to facilitate access to the company's growing and increasingly specialized expertise, as
follows:

E. 1 Business-to-Business (B2B) Marketing Strategy

The Business-to-Business Marketing group offers strategic support that helps clients extend
their capabilities, build business, and better serve their customers. McKinsey has developed a
comprehensive approach to B2B marketing that covers strategic issues (i.e., what to offer to
whom), marketing tactics (i.e., what mix of products, sales and channel choices, brands, and
prices will best deliver the desired value proposition), and organization choices (i.e., what are the
best roles for product groups, segment groups, geographic units, and functional specialists).
McKinsey helps clients by first understanding the functional process and relationship needs
of different kinds of customers. This objective can be met through qualitative interviews, a wide
array of survey techniques (e.g., cluster analysis, conjoint analysis), or modeling of customers'
economics. The firm claims experience from its involvement in more than 100 B2B engagements
in the last three years.
Once the customer base is segmented and appropriate strategies are in place, McKinsey
assists clients in developing comprehensive B2B marketing plans. Typically, this involves
reshaping the company's "go-to-market" approach so that the "best" possible channel delivers
each part of the intended value. The company moves from a "one-size-fits-all" sales force to an
approach in which it must build and manage multiple specialized channels (e.g., sales force,
telesales, Web-enabled sales, independent intermediaries). Best practice marketers then
synthesize the data and insights collected from all these customer touchpoints to continuously
refine decisions on branding, CRM, marketing spending, and pricing.
FOR INTERNAL USE ONLY

Renaissance Group International, Inc. (RGI),

495 Wheeler Road, Ashby, MA 01431

978-386-5858

MCKINSEY & COMPANY.: COMPETITIVE VENDOR PROFILE

PAGE 21

Prepared by RGI and by IBM Americas Market Intelligence

B2B concentrates its focus on the following areas:

Value proposition extensions into new products, services, and businesses;

Product/market strategy and customer segmentation;

Developing customer intimacy to better meet customer needs;

Decommoditizing or differentiating products; and

Partnering with customers and other suppliers.

McKinsey's business-to-business knowledge-building initiatives are focused on how to create


and implement new marketing strategies in a business-to-business environment. These initiatives
embrace a broad range of issues that include when and how companies can deliver "solutions"
and other intangibles-based strategies to their customers, new "go-to-market" approaches, and
multi-channel management in an e-enabled world.

E. 2 Branding

McKinsey's Branding specialty helps clients formulate strategies that communicate and
leverage the strength of brand identity. McKinsey's research has indicated that companies with
strong brands consistently earn two to five percentage points higher total returns to shareholders
than their industry counterparts. McKinsey sees the challenge of brand delivery becoming more
complicated as companies enter multi-channel environments where the brand must be able to
prevail across both online and offline businesses.
The Branding specialty works with companies to build shareholder value through their brands
by providing an end-to-end set of branding capabilities across brand strategy, brand architecture,
and brand delivery. McKinsey's approach builds on the firm's experience with business strategy,
identifying where a company can best invest its brand-building resources for profitable growth.
These perspectives help ensure focus on developing integrated, fact-based branding solutions
that are firmly grounded in the customer's needs and wants, as well as in the overall business or
corporate strategy.
Over the last few years, the company has added professionals with deep branding
experience and built knowledge in brand strategy, brand architecture, and brand delivery, as
follows:

Brand strategy -- The firm's branding professionals have backgrounds in McKinsey's


traditional fact-based approach to marketing. In addition, they have gained
experience from working at very senior levels on many powerful brands at leading
marketing agencies. The company positions itself as building "breakthrough brand
concepts," integrating both rational and emotional brand elements to provide lasting
FOR INTERNAL USE ONLY

Renaissance Group International, Inc. (RGI),

495 Wheeler Road, Ashby, MA 01431

978-386-5858

MCKINSEY & COMPANY.: COMPETITIVE VENDOR PROFILE

PAGE 22

Prepared by RGI and by IBM Americas Market Intelligence

impact consistent with the core business or corporate priorities. McKinsey's brand
strategies focus on simultaneously creating distinctive benefits in the marketplace
and satisfying customers. McKinsey claims to have completed over 80 high-impact
brand strategy client engagements in the last few years.

Brand architecture -- McKinsey applies a brand name or names (and sub-brands,


when appropriate) strategically to optimize both the brand assets within a company's
portfolio and the required level of marketing investment. McKinsey has developed a
distinctive approach to brand architecture strategy that identifies and creates clear
roles for brands to play within the customer's purchasing framework and details how
to allocate investments across the brand hierarchy.

Brand delivery -- McKinsey research shows that the key to building brand equity is
consistent delivery on three to five key touchpoints where the brand promise to the
customer is fulfilled. McKinsey's brand delivery work uses its Branding group,
supplemented by McKinsey organization and operations expertise, to identify the
most important customer touchpoints. The firm then defines the most effective
execution at each critical touchpoint and aligns the business system and the
organization to deliver the brand consistently.

In January 2001, McKinsey grew its branding practice through the acquisition of Envision, a
Chicago-based brand strategy firm, as described in the Alliances section of this report. Envision
is regarded for its empirical approach to deriving new consumer insights and brand strategies.
Envision executives combine sophisticated consumer market research and quantitative modeling
with creative insights to develop brand strategies that are grounded in a deep understanding of
consumer behaviors and attitudes. The firm serves blue-chip clients in a variety of sectors,
including financial services, retailing, packaged goods, media, and pharmaceuticals.
McKinsey now provides services in the following areas:

Building and maintaining powerful brands, and leveraging brands for growth;

Capturing the value of brands in M&A transactions, brand consolidation, and portfolio
optimization; and

Dynamic brand value management, including modeling key consumer and market
drivers for a deeper understanding of brand building.

McKinsey invests in building state-of-the-art knowledge through its branding practice. Recent
topics include maximizing shareholder value through brand leverage, new approaches for
accelerating the enhancement of brand equity, new strategies for branding in Internet/multichannel environments, and new approaches for building brand presence. The firm participates in
industry events pointing to its recent co-hosting of the Advertising Age "Brands and Brand
Management in the Next Century" industry summit and its lead role in P&G's FAST Summit
"Future of Advertising: Scenarios & Perspectives."

FOR INTERNAL USE ONLY

Renaissance Group International, Inc. (RGI),

495 Wheeler Road, Ashby, MA 01431

978-386-5858

MCKINSEY & COMPANY.: COMPETITIVE VENDOR PROFILE

PAGE 23

Prepared by RGI and by IBM Americas Market Intelligence

E. 3 Continuous Relationship Marketing (CRM)

McKinsey believes Continuous Relationship Marketing (CRM), including database marketing,


micro marketing, and one-to-one marketing, represents an increasingly valued approach to
building and sustaining customer loyalty. Superior Continuous Relationship Marketing provides a
competitive advantage and can transform business performance by increasing the attraction of
profitable new customers, wallet share, and retention. These customer-centered gains deliver
substantial bottom-line impact, typically increasing sales and profit by 15% to 40% according to
McKinsey research.
Building on its expertise in fields such as customer segmentation and valuation, program
design and management, and organization and capability building, McKinsey consultants
customize CRM strategy and reshape "go-to-market" programs for clients. McKinsey's work
targets the following areas:

Customer acquisition -- McKinsey develops cost-effective acquisition programs


based on data-driven insights that link the choice of creative, and communications
vehicles, with expected customer response and value potential.

Customer loyalty -- McKinsey consultants work with clients to identify opportunities


and formulate strategies to improve customer loyalty and profitable cross-sell. The
firm draws on its value proposition and program development expertise to generate
high-impact customer loyalty programs.

Customer experience management -- McKinsey professionals have expertise in the


definition, execution, and continuous refinement of high-value customer experience
throughout a multi-channel distribution network. The firm assists clients in defining
customer requirements, enabling processes, selecting tools and software, and
institutionalizing management systems and metrics that provide an integrated
customer experience.

e-CRM -- McKinsey works with B2C and B2B Internet companies to exploit insights
into online customer behavior patterns. The firm uses both its data and data from
McKinsey's exclusive partnership with Media Metrix to shape new high-impact
strategies for both site and customer management. McKinsey helps to ensure that
the right information is captured and used to improve targeting, offers, and proactive
management across the entire customer lifecycle, from customer attraction to
conversion to retention/revisit. The firm also helps companies to navigate and
prioritize online customer management technologies.

The company serves clients by:

Applying an analytical focus as a means of enhancing Customer Lifetime Value


(CLV);

Using customer data to understand and leverage behavior, through systematic


processes/programs to drive business; and
FOR INTERNAL USE ONLY

Renaissance Group International, Inc. (RGI),

495 Wheeler Road, Ashby, MA 01431

978-386-5858

MCKINSEY & COMPANY.: COMPETITIVE VENDOR PROFILE

PAGE 24

Prepared by RGI and by IBM Americas Market Intelligence

Incorporating systematic experimentation to gather new customer information


and improve programs.

Over the past five years, McKinsey has completed over 120 CRM assignments in such
industries as banking, insurance, retailing, airline, and telecommunications, demonstrating an
impact on customer acquisition, development, retention, and profitability. Recent topics include
best practices in e-CRM, key imperatives for multi-channel marketers, new approaches to
managing customer loyalty, the role of "infomediaries," business-to-business CRM, databases
and marketing in the banking industry, and the role of CRM for credit card providers.

E. 4 Customer Loyalty

Developed as a separate specialty within marketing over the last year, McKinsey's Customer
Loyalty specialty works with clients across a wide range of industries to develop new, significantly
higher-impact approaches for driving profitable growth through improved customer loyalty. The
company takes a broad view of loyalty focused on patterns of customer migration, defined as the
change in customer value over time. McKinsey research has shown that the broad determinants
of downward customer migration vary significantly across industries and from company to
company. Therefore, the company works with clients to understand the primary drivers of
downward migration in their customer base and to identify the customers offering the greatest
opportunity for value capture. McKinsey professionals then design an integrated approach to
target these sources of value. To maximize speed and impact, the firm uses pilots and a test-andlearn approach. McKinsey then helps clients roll out successful pilot approaches and helps them
build the capabilities to support those that require new skills.
McKinsey research shows that by pursuing a targeted approach integrating multiple levers,
companies can reduce the value lost to downward migration by 20 to 30%. This translates into
significantly improved top- and bottom-line growth. Over the past several years, the firm has
developed this approach with a broad set of clients to build proven knowledge and experience in
four areas:

High-impact loyalty architecture -- McKinsey's experience, proprietary research, and


tools enable the firm to work quickly with clients to quantify the opportunity and
identify the highest-leverage customers and sources of downward migration. The
company then develops a set of high-impact initiatives based on the loyalty tools
most suited to these opportunities. McKinsey designs an overall program of pilots,
selected rollout, and capability building to put the chosen initiatives into place and
support them over time.

Powerful relationship marketing -- The firm helps clients identify high-value downward
migrators; understand at a detailed level the reasons behind their migration; craft
direct, online, and face-to-face programs to influence their behavior; test and roll out
the highest-impact programs; and design and build the infrastructure and capabilities
to support relationship marketing over time.

FOR INTERNAL USE ONLY

Renaissance Group International, Inc. (RGI),

495 Wheeler Road, Ashby, MA 01431

978-386-5858

MCKINSEY & COMPANY.: COMPETITIVE VENDOR PROFILE

PAGE 25

Prepared by RGI and by IBM Americas Market Intelligence

Targeted value proposition and delivery redesign -- McKinsey works with clients to
identify targeted changes that are likely to have measurable profit impact in excess of
the investment required.

Effective and efficient rewards programs -- McKinsey develops a high-impact rewards


program or an improved design of an existing program, adding critical elements of
relationship marketing and developing a powerful partnership strategy.

McKinsey continually invests in new knowledge to push state-of-the art thinking in customer
loyalty. The firm recently completed research across 16 industries, defining key patterns of
customer migration and developing a Loyalty Profile of migration segments for each industry.
This research serves as the foundation of the proprietary tool the firm uses to quickly develop
high-impact Loyalty Architectures for clients. The firm also participates in industry events and
forums.

E. 5 e-Consumer Marketing

As a new marketing specialty, e-Consumer marketing utilizes a combination of consumer


clickstream data and analytic capabilities to develop insight into consumer online behavior.
McKinsey believes that understanding online consumer behavior and identifying the levers to
change those behaviors is essential to achieving profitable growth in the new economy.
McKinsey has a strategic alliance with Media Metrix, described in the alliances section, which
gives McKinsey professionals exclusive access to the individual click-by-click online behavior of
consumers. Through the use of analytic tools, McKinsey can focus site development activities
and marketing programs on ways that will attract greater numbers of consumers in the most
profitable consumer segments. McKinsey can determine the specific site a client's online
customer visits and can then evaluate the effectiveness of different sites as advertising options.
Similarly, by identifying the sites consumers visit when they leave the client's site, the firm can
establish the competitive set facing the client's site and pinpoint specific content that has value for
visitors. The company also examines how these measures change over time as an e-business
evolves.
McKinsey's joint research with Media Metrix yields continually updates insights into the econsumer. A detailed segmentation study of the online consumer population identified six distinct
segments that can be served through different approaches. These insights have been featured
recently in articles in The Wall Street Journal and Business 2.0. Current knowledge-building
initiatives include detailed analysis of the drivers of successful online shopping companies and
the growth potential in online financial services.

E. 6 E-Marketing

FOR INTERNAL USE ONLY

Renaissance Group International, Inc. (RGI),

495 Wheeler Road, Ashby, MA 01431

978-386-5858

MCKINSEY & COMPANY.: COMPETITIVE VENDOR PROFILE

PAGE 26

Prepared by RGI and by IBM Americas Market Intelligence

McKinsey's e-marketing group helps consumer marketers create shareholder value through
existing advertising and direct marketing efforts and by building new consumer e-businesses.
McKinsey uses a holistic approach to e-marketing that reflects the company's e-commerce
experience and deep marketing knowledge. The firm's expertise comprises core e-marketing
disciplines, including business launch marketing plans, e-brand strategies, customer relationship
marketing, and multi-channel management. Consultants begin the e-marketing studies with a
deep grounding in customer needs and use their knowledge of marketing disciplines to develop
an e-marketing strategy that simultaneously delivers profitable growth and a distinctive customer
experience.
Over the past year, McKinsey has completed over 150 e-marketing-related studies. For the
future, the firm is further developing its knowledge of e-CRM, e-branding, e-pricing, multi-channel
management, and e-marketing organizations, in conjunction with professors from Harvard
Business School. McKinsey assists e-marketers in building and expanding their online
businesses through insights into consumer online behavior. This approach includes segmenting
and targeting consumers based on site visits, time spent on each site, and transactions to drive
profitability. The firm can develop custom analysis on any site to analyze changing consumer
behavior over time (e.g., time between repeat visits, sites cross-shopped in the same session),
determine what works and doesn't work, and use the information to improve site performance on
customer acquisition, conversion, and retention.

E. 7 Marketing Organization and Capability Building

The Marketing Organization and Capability Building Practice helps clients develop
comprehensive, targeted, functional skill/capability building programs that deliver market leading
performance. The practice offers expertise in the following areas:

Identifying and evaluating the potential impact of the functional marketing skills each
client needs; and

Designing and delivering programs to build target capabilities and measure


performance.

By focusing on building marketing capabilities that link directly with the strategic and
economic objectives of the business, McKinsey helps clients create marketing organizations that
contribute directly to growth. McKinsey consultants typically begin with an analysis of the
company's strategic and profit goals that define the structure, skills, and style required for the new
organization. Rather than build generic capabilities, the firm builds "precision marketing
capabilities" designed to achieve targeted marketing and business goals. The programs can be
grouped into three broad service lines:

Integrated marketing capability building programs -- McKinsey identifies the two or


three marketing skills a company must excel in to achieve its business objectives and
develop a comprehensive program to pinpoint the talent, build the capabilities, and
design the organizational processes and metrics required.
FOR INTERNAL USE ONLY

Renaissance Group International, Inc. (RGI),

495 Wheeler Road, Ashby, MA 01431

978-386-5858

MCKINSEY & COMPANY.: COMPETITIVE VENDOR PROFILE

PAGE 27

Prepared by RGI and by IBM Americas Market Intelligence

Marketing organizations -- McKinsey helps companies change their organizational


approach to accommodate the greater complexities of online and offline channels
and keep ahead of market pace by moving away from rigid structures to a teambased and rapidly evolving organization. The approach focuses on developing the
accelerated decision-making processes and the more fluid structure required to
anticipate and build the specialized capabilities needed to drive pace ahead of
competition.

Functional skill development -- When companies need to rapidly build a particular


skill, McKinsey consultants work closely with colleagues in the Pricing, CRM,
Branding, and Sales and Channel groups to develop a capability.

McKinsey research in this area has concentrated on developing distinctive, integrated,


"turnkey" capability building approaches for clients. The firm has focused on Venture Marketing
Organizations (VMOs), whose structure enables them to identify and capture new growth
opportunities. This focus allows the firm to concentrate on new approaches to building marketing
capability in several areas including CRM, sales force excellence, customer service, pricing, and
promotions.

E. 8 Marketing Research

The Marketing Research group generates qualitative and quantitative market research that
uncovers insights into consumer needs. The firm uses a variety of state-of-the-art research
techniques, working with a set of outside research vendors. The company then works with its
McKinsey colleagues and uses these insights to develop marketing strategy, branding, pricing,
and marketing spending effectiveness strategies for profitable growth. McKinsey combines its
experience in understanding business issues with a wide range of marketing research techniques
to provide actionable insights to address critical business issues.
McKinsey consultants evaluate and determine the best possible research approaches, which
include an in-depth qualitative observational study, focus groups, or a major quantitative conjoint
or choice study. The company also identifies which of its market research partners are best able
to conduct the research. The firm uses the output of this research to address the client's specific
business objectives, focusing the output on client goals and providing solutions to the client's
business challenges.
McKinsey directs its knowledge efforts in this area at examining new techniques in market
research as well as expanding its marketing knowledge. Through its alliances with top academic
institutions and leading industry organizations, McKinsey keeps up-to-date on state-of-the-art
market research techniques. The firm experiments with new ways to perform market research,
using more efficient techniques that provide superior results. Recently, the company focused on
understanding cross-channel shopping behavior for offline and online shoppers and dissecting
the strength of brands and brand architecture for both offline and online companies.

FOR INTERNAL USE ONLY

Renaissance Group International, Inc. (RGI),

495 Wheeler Road, Ashby, MA 01431

978-386-5858

MCKINSEY & COMPANY.: COMPETITIVE VENDOR PROFILE

PAGE 28

Prepared by RGI and by IBM Americas Market Intelligence

E. 9 Marketing Spending

As a new area for the Marketing Practice, the Marketing Spending specialty strives to
maximize the effectiveness of client spending on marketing. The firm works with clients across a
range of industries to help them build brand presence more quickly and effectively. The
company develops effective marketing spending programs for both new and existing brands,
geographies, and channels, including the Internet. McKinsey positions client benefits from the
company's understanding of the broader strategic issues faced by the business unit, as well as its
experience in improving operations and organization performance.
McKinsey's approach usually entails working through four key steps to take advantage of the
broadening set of marketing options, while focusing the right amount of spending in the right
places, as follows:

First, professionals diagnose the bottlenecks that stand in the way of a brand's
growth, and then set appropriate objectives for improvement.

Second, McKinsey develops a list of vehicles and tactics that could be used to
address specific bottlenecks, drawing on proprietary database and research, as well
as the client's experience. Where needed, the firm will work with clients to test new
vehicles to assess effectiveness against specific objectives.

Third, McKinsey consultants work with clients to map out the dynamics surrounding
the brand, which is critical for selecting and sequencing marketing tactics. Depending
on the situation, the firm may do this qualitatively, or may create quantitative,
nonlinear models of the brand dynamics.

As a final step, McKinsey then determines the level of investment required to hit the
"sweet spot" of impact: above this level, returns diminish; below, the spending
doesn't register with consumers. McKinsey will also work in partnership with the
client's agency and other partners to develop the best solution for the brand.

McKinsey works with many clients to ensure that their organizations can continue to improve
their marketing spending effectiveness by developing and implementing brand/marketing
spending scorecards to provide actionable and timely feedback.
To expand its knowledge in this area, the company has examined strategies and tactics in a
range of industries, including packaged goods, financial services, telecommunications, and
retailing. The company currently is broadening its understanding of the effectiveness of individual
marketing vehicles in different brand situations. In addition, in collaboration with McKinsey's
ePerformance initiative within its e-Commerce practice, the firm is benchmarking the marketing
and operational effectiveness of 200 Internet businesses.

E. 10 Marketing Strategy

FOR INTERNAL USE ONLY

Renaissance Group International, Inc. (RGI),

495 Wheeler Road, Ashby, MA 01431

978-386-5858

MCKINSEY & COMPANY.: COMPETITIVE VENDOR PROFILE

PAGE 29

Prepared by RGI and by IBM Americas Market Intelligence

The firm's new marketing strategy specialty within the Marketing Practice looks to accelerate
a client's profitable growth through innovative marketing strategies. In many cases, marketers are
shifting away from a traditional marketing approach that focuses solely on functional benefits
such as quality or reliability. By adding process and relationship benefits, marketing innovators
are providing multiple benefits that create superior value for customers.
McKinsey's approach begins with a thorough understanding of customer segments and their
needs across the three dimensions of customer benefits: functional, relationship, and process - a
concept that the company refers to as "Three-Dimensional Marketing." The firm analyzes
options for clients, assessing ease of implementation and profit impact to derive the strategy.
Drawing on its expertise in pricing, branding, and sales force management, consultants then
apply ideas using specific tactics and an understanding of technologies to create an
implementable marketing strategy.
During the past two years, McKinsey has been involved in over 300 marketing strategy
engagements across a wide variety of industries. This involvement provides the firm with unique
insights into customer needs. At the same time, its ongoing research partnerships with Media
Metrix and Yankelovich Partners provide additional insights into emerging needs and support
development of innovative customer-driven strategies for clients.
McKinsey continues to study how the three dimensions of customer needs are evolving in
different industries and the implications for branding, spending, and relationship marketing efforts.
At the same time, the firm applies this knowledge to developing e-business strategies in
business-to-business and business-to-consumer environments. Its three-dimensional approach
has been applied to a wide range of industries including financial services, retailing, consumer
packaged goods, telecommunications, automotive, pharmaceuticals, and high tech.

E. 11 Pricing

The Pricing Practice serves clients on three levels:

Supply/Demand -- to improve industry profitability by focusing on the effects of


current and future supply, demand, cost, and other trends;

Product/Market Strategy -- to establish price/benefit positioning of a product or


service compared with the competition; and

Transaction -- to develop per-unit pricing strategies, including the exact price to


charge each customer as well as how to structure the price, such as subscription
versus a one-time charge.

McKinsey's pricing work covers strategic and tactical pricing opportunities. The strategic
pricing approach begins with a strong belief that price needs to be based on value, not cost. The
firm examines how current and future supply, demand, and cost dynamics affect overall industry
price levels. The firm uses sophisticated research to segment markets. This enables McKinsey
FOR INTERNAL USE ONLY

Renaissance Group International, Inc. (RGI),

495 Wheeler Road, Ashby, MA 01431

978-386-5858

MCKINSEY & COMPANY.: COMPETITIVE VENDOR PROFILE

PAGE 30

Prepared by RGI and by IBM Americas Market Intelligence

to determine what price level provides specific products with a price/benefit advantage versus the
competition, while maximizing profitability.
McKinsey's tactical pricing is based on detailed "by-product, by-customer analysis." The firm
uses a number of tools to determine the exact price, including base price, discounts, allowances,
and adjustments, to assign each customer transaction. The firm has developed proprietary tools
in this area, including:

Pocket Price/Pocket Margin Waterfall to determine the profitability of detailed


transactions; and

Pocket Price Bands to assess the variability of transaction prices and the underlying
drivers, both internal and external, of that variability.

The firm has refined its strategic and tactical approaches for application in post-merger
situations that hold large pricing opportunities that McKinsey believes few companies fully utilize.
In addition, McKinsey is focused on e-pricing issues, developing pricing approaches and models
that begin to exploit the pricing power and flexibility of the Internet. The firm has recently
completed work on best approaches to solutions pricing (the bundling of products and services in
one solution for customers) and has developed a unique perspective and set of tools for pricing in
post-merger situations.

E. 12 Sales and Channel Management

The Sales Force and Channel Management Practice creates value-driven sales strategies to
maximize clients' performance in two areas:

Sales Force Management, which covers strategic issues involved with direct
"owned" sales forces; and

Channel Management, which covers choosing and managing third-party


channels.

With the proliferation of new selling channels, such as the Internet, and technology-enabled
selling, most companies now have the opportunity to transform their selling organizations to drive
incremental revenue, with a lower cost platform and improved customer service. McKinsey's
Sales and Channel Management group has been active for over 20 years in developing and
applying leading-edge approaches to a variety of sales challenges. The firm combines the
traditional McKinsey strength in business strategy and customer profitability with an
understanding of changing customer needs, technology evolution, innovative "go-to-market"
strategies, consultative versus transactional selling models, skill building, and compensation
issues.
As in other practices, McKinsey typically begins by identifying and understanding the needs
of key customer segments and combines this with the required cost-to-serve to ensure
FOR INTERNAL USE ONLY

Renaissance Group International, Inc. (RGI),

495 Wheeler Road, Ashby, MA 01431

978-386-5858

MCKINSEY & COMPANY.: COMPETITIVE VENDOR PROFILE

PAGE 31

Prepared by RGI and by IBM Americas Market Intelligence

profitability. Consultants work with clients to develop and implement a "go-to-market" strategy
that is tailored for each segment. This frequently involves selecting the right mix of consultative
sales channels, Web-based selling, telesales, and other technology-enabled approaches. The
resulting go-to-market design is followed by a detailed understanding of the roles, skills,
organizational capabilities, and sales compensation changes required to successfully implement
the new design. Where appropriate, the firm involves consultative function-specific sales partners,
such as Huthwaite (sales training) and Coletti-Fiss (sales compensation), to ensure functional
excellence and a measurable impact. The firm also provides assistance with call center
performance, technology partner selection, and cross-channel integration.
McKinsey's knowledge efforts in this area are focused on new economy "go-to-market"
models, including methods for building integrated multi-channel capabilities, managing multiple
selling models in one organization, and maximizing the effectiveness of Web-assisted selling and
other transactional selling models. In these efforts, the firm collaborates heavily with its Service
Operations, Telecommunications, and High Tech industry practices. The company also focuses
on the transition issues that clients face as they migrate to the new-economy approach, including
channel conflict, skill building, and systems integration.

F. Operational Effectiveness
McKinsey defines Operational Effectiveness as the integrated set of actions required to
deliver value to customers at a capital level cost that produces desired returns, while building
operational capabilities needed to exploit future opportunities and sustain a competitive
advantage. McKinsey's Operational Effectiveness Practice helps clients shape operations,
offering support on such issues as:

Operations/executional diagnostics;
Operations strategy;
Total operational performance; and
Operational architecture and continuous improvement.

The firm organizes its practice around four primary areas, as follows:

Manufacturing -- The Manufacturing group assists clients in a variety of key functions,


including:

Diagnosing manufacturing performance;

Developing manufacturing strategy;

Establishing effective configuration and design of production facilities, networks,


and systems;

FOR INTERNAL USE ONLY

Renaissance Group International, Inc. (RGI),

495 Wheeler Road, Ashby, MA 01431

978-386-5858

MCKINSEY & COMPANY.: COMPETITIVE VENDOR PROFILE

PAGE 32

Prepared by RGI and by IBM Americas Market Intelligence

Using lean production methods to drive front-line productivity and continuous


improvement; and

Achieving maintenance effectiveness and capital productivity.

Product Development -- The Product Development group conducts projects in the


following areas:

Product line strategy and platforming;


Design-to-cost;
Product development process;
Partner integration; and
Organization and performance management.

Purchasing and Supply Management -- The Purchasing and Supply Management


group focuses on the purchasing, procurement, or sourcing of raw materials,
components, capital equipment, services, and indirect items. The group practice
incorporates the following activities:

Sourcing strategy, which reviews the client's make/buy position and their
dependence on critical supplies and suppliers;

Supplier management, which includes selection, development, and management


of supplier networks; and

Purchasing organization and effectiveness.

Service Operations -- The Service Operations group focuses on helping clients in


service and product-based industries improve the efficiency and effectiveness of their
customer service. McKinsey assists clients with designing service operations
strategies, translating these strategies into "service factories," and launching effective
frontline mobilization programs to deliver improvements in customer satisfaction and
performance.

G. Organization
McKinsey believes that to succeed in the current market organizations must excel at
managing performance; stockpiling and exploiting talent; creating knowledge-based capabilities;
developing a new organization design; and providing integrative leadership. The company sees
an increased focus on corporate structure and management with increased globalization, industry
convergence, deregulation, and new technology trends.
McKinsey's European Organization Practice focuses on seven areas:

FOR INTERNAL USE ONLY

Renaissance Group International, Inc. (RGI),

495 Wheeler Road, Ashby, MA 01431

978-386-5858

MCKINSEY & COMPANY.: COMPETITIVE VENDOR PROFILE

PAGE 33

Prepared by RGI and by IBM Americas Market Intelligence

Adaptive firms;
Organizing for global leadership;
Knowledge integration;
Strategies for talent;
Shaping culture;
Corporate renewal; and
Performance management.

The North American Practice focuses on three areas:

Organization Design -- The Organization Design group leverages tools and


methodologies to transform organizations facing an array of business challenges,
such as cost reduction, deregulation, and globalization. The group addresses issues
of corporate center design and roles, formal and informal structure, business
processes, and mechanisms coordination. The practice also helps companies
become more integrated and flexible across multiple products, channels, customer
segments, and functions.

War for Talent -- The "War for Talent" group helps clients build the strength of their
talent pool into a competitive advantage. The group helps companies understand
how to attract, develop, and retain high performers in the executive ranks, middle
managers, and technical professionals.

Performance Management -- The Performance Management Group focuses on the


following areas:

Performance Ethic, addressing how top management teams can create a


performance culture in their organizations through approaches that balance
motivation and control; and

Value-Based Performance Management, addressing how companies can


improve performance by integrating corporate context setting, portfolio,
organization design, value driver definition, business performance management,
people performance management, and value mindset.

The Organization Practice also provides insight and assistance on the topics of change,
culture, corporate governance, knowledge management, leadership, and IT.

H. Strategy
McKinsey defines strategy as "an integrated set of actions that produce a sustainable
advantage over competitors." Strategic decisions are found in a variety of corporate actions,
such as the decision to enter or exit a market; efforts to develop or commercialize a new

FOR INTERNAL USE ONLY

Renaissance Group International, Inc. (RGI),

495 Wheeler Road, Ashby, MA 01431

978-386-5858

MCKINSEY & COMPANY.: COMPETITIVE VENDOR PROFILE

PAGE 34

Prepared by RGI and by IBM Americas Market Intelligence

technology; plans to expand plant capacity; or the decision to extend an old brand or create a
new one.
The Strategy Practice develops "new, world-class thinking" packaged with tools and
frameworks that McKinsey teams can access to serve clients effectively. McKinsey strategy
consultants have developed effective approaches by working with knowledge gained from
academia, such as game theory and scenario planning, and adapting those tools to use with
clients. The company claims its team members do not simply follow best practices, but instead
proactively "shape" the industry through innovation. The company uses a "Killer Ideas" workshop
approach, which provides a way to brainstorm new ideas by reverse-engineering other recent
innovations. McKinsey uses recently developed work to apply complex adaptive systems theory
to business situations. This has led to the development of "fitness landscapes," a tool to help
managers manage multiple strategy options in rapidly changing industries.
In addition, the company employs Strategy Practice consultants to deliver the firm's
knowledge and expertise to teams and clients. McKinsey claims a "very large number" of its
engagements address strategy issues.
The Strategy Practice continues to develop knowledge to answer questions such as:

What are the ways in which strategy might be different in the new world of "dot.com"
startups?

How can the firm help its clients develop more creative strategies?

How can the firm help clients maximize their corporate portfolio options in valuecreating ways to grow without the ill effects of conglomerate discounting?

I. @McKinsey
McKinsey's e-commerce practice, @McKinsey, helps clients create sustainable, high-growth
e-businesses. Established in 1998, @McKinsey's mission is "to empower companies to be ecommerce innovators by combining leading-edge insights with deep, experience-based
knowledge of markets and industries."
McKinsey & Company has conducted Internet/e-commerce consulting and implementation
services for the past six years. @McKinsey consultants conducted more than 1,000 e-commerce
projects in 2000, tripling the number completed in 1999 and positioning the @McKinsey practice
as the fastest growing area within the firm. The @McKinsey practice has shed the firm's
"deliberate pace" image that, at times, ran counter to the faster pace expected by high tech firms.
The company positions the practice as providing a fluid and flexible environment in which to work.
@McKinsey clients are established and emerging-growth companies developing Internet
initiatives. The practice focuses on serving the following industries:

FOR INTERNAL USE ONLY

Renaissance Group International, Inc. (RGI),

495 Wheeler Road, Ashby, MA 01431

978-386-5858

MCKINSEY & COMPANY.: COMPETITIVE VENDOR PROFILE

PAGE 35

Prepared by RGI and by IBM Americas Market Intelligence

Automotive;
Electronics;
Financial Services;
Healthcare;
Media;
Retail; and
Telecommunications.

@McKinsey combines McKinsey expertise in global industries and an extensive network of


business partners to build strong, leveraged businesses for both Fortune 500 and dot.com
companies. The firm believes that this core strength, paired with McKinsey's ability to reintegrate e-businesses into their parent companies after launch, if appropriate, differentiates
@McKinsey services from other market competitors. Services provided by @McKinsey include
the following:

Alliances and acquisitions, from brokering relationships to maximizing opportunities;

Customer experience, from traffic generation to customer retention;

E-Venture management, from organization and recruiting to governance;

Implementation network, from vendor identification and selection to project


management;

Shareholder value, from financing strategy to investor communications;

Technology solutions, from IT strategy to infrastructure design; and

Virtual operations, from process design and integration to accelerating business


performance.

The @McKinsey practice is distributed throughout major geographic centers, including


London, Madrid, Munich, New York, Hong Kong, Toronto, and Silicon Valley -- with additional
offices in the U.S., Asia, and Europe serving clients worldwide. The practice includes 500
consultants and 60 partners worldwide. The @ McKinsey leadership includes the following
partners:

Andreas Biagosch (Munich);


John Brady (London);
Ron Farmer (Toronto); and
Anil Kumar (Silicon Valley.

McKinsey partners with clients to maximize the value realized from the Internet and to create
new, high-growth e-ventures. The company positions the @McKinsey practice as helping clients
in the following areas:

Accelerating speed to market;


FOR INTERNAL USE ONLY

Renaissance Group International, Inc. (RGI),

495 Wheeler Road, Ashby, MA 01431

978-386-5858

MCKINSEY & COMPANY.: COMPETITIVE VENDOR PROFILE

PAGE 36

Prepared by RGI and by IBM Americas Market Intelligence

Establishing and testing the viability of new business models;

Enabling large-scale marketing of products and services;

Architecting operational and IT platforms to efficiently and effectively fulfill customer


needs;

Capturing and using information to drive continuous improvement on the front end
and back end; and

Developing new business ideas that build on existing skills, assets, and relationships.

McKinsey consultants explore the implications of e-commerce by conducting proprietary ecommerce research and completing extensive e-commerce client work across a range of
industries and markets. McKinsey positions the company, due to extensive research, with a
unique perspective on Internet business opportunities.
Over the last year, consultants for @McKinsey have helped clients launch e-businesses,
improve performance, and develop solid business strategies for the future. @McKinsey provides
services in the following areas, described below:

Launching an e-business, utilizing @McKinsey's Accelerators to help the client


launch and evolve an e-business by building a solid foundation;

Improving online performance, through the ePerformance service, using proven


procedures to establish operational performance benchmarks, and offering clients
feedback on how to improve online performance;

Understanding consumer behavior, through the eConsumer service, helping clients


transform website volume into e-business value;

Developing customer relationships, providing eCRM knowledge and tools that can
help clients develop a strategy for managing online customer relationships; and

Building the right partnerships, helping to identify technology issues and partner
needs, offering advice on deal structure, and helping facilitate negotiations with the
eAlliance service.

@McKinsey can also help businesses create financing strategies and technology solutions,
select and manage vendors, and organize for the future.

I. 1 e-Business Accelerators

FOR INTERNAL USE ONLY

Renaissance Group International, Inc. (RGI),

495 Wheeler Road, Ashby, MA 01431

978-386-5858

MCKINSEY & COMPANY.: COMPETITIVE VENDOR PROFILE

PAGE 37

Prepared by RGI and by IBM Americas Market Intelligence

McKinsey launched a series of business development centers to provide hands-on Internet


business-building services for clients worldwide. These centers combine the expertise of
McKinsey professionals and an extensive third party network of "best in class" service providers
and technology vendors. These, together with other services that McKinsey offers, make it
possible to launch and completely integrate a fully functional online business in three to nine
months.
@McKinsey created Accelerators to help speed up business development and provide
dedicated management and resources. Accelerators supply the knowledge and tools to steer ebusiness enterprises through the three critical development phases, as follows:

Launch -- The company designs, builds, tests, and launches the enterprise. Critical
tasks include proving the business concept, raising capital, devising and
implementing a launch plan, and recruiting for and building the organization.

Growth -- The venture refines its business and marketing strategy and strengthens its
ability to support the needs of existing customers. Critical tasks include upgrading the
business plan, refining the product, selecting technology partners, and measuring ebusiness performance.

Expansion -- The e-business forges strategic alliances for further growth and
expands its reach. Critical tasks include leadership training, identifying potential
mergers and acquisitions, integrating operations, and developing global strategies.

Accelerators operate either in an existing McKinsey office or in a stand-alone facility where


startups and established companies can work side by side with @McKinsey consultants. Current
stand-alone Accelerator sites are located in:

Amsterdam;

Atlanta;

Greater China;

London;

Miami;

Munich; and

Silicon Valley.

Accelerators offer focused, rapid problem solving at critical junctures and can complete
engagements in as few as two weeks. Accelerators @McKinsey offer services, as follows:

FOR INTERNAL USE ONLY

Renaissance Group International, Inc. (RGI),

495 Wheeler Road, Ashby, MA 01431

978-386-5858

MCKINSEY & COMPANY.: COMPETITIVE VENDOR PROFILE

PAGE 38

Prepared by RGI and by IBM Americas Market Intelligence

Intensive business-building (six to twelve months) -- For ventures that need to move
at maximum speed, Accelerators @McKinsey can supply a larger team to provide
short-term management ranging from business development to customer care. The
Accelerators also provide day-to-day execution of marketing plan development and
product launch.

Targeted projects (one to six months) -- The Accelerator teams provide in-depth
analytical services that enable startups to pinpoint their market position,
opportunities, and vulnerabilities. The firm can also screen merger or acquisition
candidates and help startups shape a newly combined organization.

Burst services (two days to two months) -- Accelerator consultants and specialists
provide the client's organization with "rapid-fire" market data, valuations, economic
analyses, and other short-term, targeted analyses required for fast decisions and
action. The firm believes few startups have time for lengthy analysis and drawn-out
market studies.

Senior counseling (as needed) -- McKinsey's partners and e-business specialists


offer unbiased, open dialogue with Internet ventures on key issues such as market
entry, financial strategy, company structure, and partner negotiations.

I. 2 ePerformance

McKinsey's ePerformance Practice was initiated in 1999 to measure, diagnose, and improve
e-business performance. It offers a constantly updated index of data from a diverse group of
consumer-focused e-businesses worldwide. ePerformance lets businesses compare their
website performance against an aggregate index of their peers within an industry segment as well
as across a variety of industries. The result demonstrates how one company measures up
against its competitors as a whole, allowing that company to track its operational performance
over time.
McKinseys ePerformance Practice is positioned as providing a better operational
measurement approach, as follows:

Consistently measures e-business performance drivers with McKinsey evaluation


metrics, providing clear definitions and regular timelines;

Measures e-business performance over time using a semi-annual scorecard;

Establishes customized best practices for online operational processes;

Pinpoints critical improvement areas for operational performance as well as potential


pitfalls;

FOR INTERNAL USE ONLY

Renaissance Group International, Inc. (RGI),

495 Wheeler Road, Ashby, MA 01431

978-386-5858

MCKINSEY & COMPANY.: COMPETITIVE VENDOR PROFILE

PAGE 39

Prepared by RGI and by IBM Americas Market Intelligence

Develops high-impact improvement strategies and tactics that lead to bottom-line


results; and

Boosts profitability on a worldwide level combining the performance metrics with


McKinsey international operations.

The company produces an ePerformance scoreboard that provides insights into ebusinesses on operational performance by revealing critical performance drivers and comparing
performance to competitors. The company compiles individual company scores on nine
performance indicators and suggests high-potential improvement areas, which enables ebusinesses to identify appropriate actions for improvement. Over time, the company can
measure the impact of operational improvements.
@McKinseys ePerformance team works closely with participants to collect accurate data on
key performance measures, such as the cost associated with generating site visits and the sites
customer retention rate. The team members interview participants and gather data on recent
financials and website traffic. The team then calculates the metrics and enters the results into a
database designed to measure and compare operational performance of individual companies
against their peers in a particular industry segment. Participants receive a detailed report that
includes a final consolidated score, as well as a feedback form that presents specific steps for
improving their performance.

I. 3 eConsumer

McKinsey's eConsumer service helps companies with B2C sites explore ways to assess
consumer behavior. Based on data from Media Metrix, McKinsey research has identified six
distinct behavioral segments among active online consumers. The firm has found that the
differences between segments are significant enough that marketers risk losing ground if they
attempt to appeal to everyone. Winning a loyal consumer base in one segment is likely to be
more profitable than trying to serve all the segments at once.
The segments are identified as follows:

Simplifiers, representing 29% of active users, using the Internet to make their lives
easier and accounting for over 50% of transactions;

Surfers, representing 8% of active users, but accounting for 32% of total online time;

Bargainers, representing 8% of active users, seeking the best buys on the Internet;

Connectors, representing 36% of active users, going online to connect and


communicate;

FOR INTERNAL USE ONLY

Renaissance Group International, Inc. (RGI),

495 Wheeler Road, Ashby, MA 01431

978-386-5858

MCKINSEY & COMPANY.: COMPETITIVE VENDOR PROFILE

PAGE 40

Prepared by RGI and by IBM Americas Market Intelligence

Routiners, representing 15% of active users, seeking information as well as online


shopping; and

Sportsters, going online to get information, typically in the areas of sports and
entertainment.

Surfers constantly troll the Internet in search of variety and new ideas, while simplifiers focus
their Internet usage on a small number of sites that they have determined can save them time
and make their lives easier.

I. 4 eCRM

McKinsey's eCRM services help businesses convert their visitors into repeat buyers and keep
them interested. The firm provides knowledge and tools that companies use to develop a clear
approach and strategy for managing their customers, not only when they first arrive at the site but
throughout their entire lifecycle.
McKinsey's eCRM practice helps businesses to:

Define and track appropriate metrics;


Attract and convert potential buyers;
Keep customers coming back; and
Get started.

I. 5 eAlliances

@McKinsey's eAlliance practice helps clients identify technology issues and partner needs,
offers advice on deal structure, and helps facilitate negotiations. @McKinsey provides assistance
with four key tasks of structuring an eAlliance, as follows:

Choosing the right deal;


Defining the right deal terms;
Choosing between a strategic deal and an executional deal; and
Tailoring the deal process and the team.

Market Strategy
FOR INTERNAL USE ONLY

Renaissance Group International, Inc. (RGI),

495 Wheeler Road, Ashby, MA 01431

978-386-5858

MCKINSEY & COMPANY.: COMPETITIVE VENDOR PROFILE

PAGE 41

Prepared by RGI and by IBM Americas Market Intelligence

McKinsey markets its services to large multinational enterprises as well as to medium-sized


businesses, smaller entrepreneurial firms, and government institutions. The company conducts
projects that address top-level issues in corporate strategy, organizational structure, operations,
and technology at these businesses. In addition to its various functional practices, McKinsey &
Company also focuses its market strategy on several industry practices, described in the Industry
Focus section of this report. McKinsey markets its services using a team approach consisting of
junior, mid- and senior-level personnel.
The remainder of this section addresses the companys customer types, its account
marketing strategy, and the companys competitive environment.

A. Customers and Company Size


McKinsey serves the chief executives and senior management of businesses and
organizations, as follows:

Large enterprises, with McKinsey claiming to have worked for over one-half of the
Fortune 500 companies;

Small and medium-sized businesses including family-owned firms and high tech
ventures;

Emerging growth companies;

High tech startups;

Financial institutions;

State-owned enterprises;

Government departments and agencies; and

Educational, social, medical and cultural organizations.

Historically, most of McKinsey's clients have been large, successful companies, but the firm
now serves many mid-sized and emerging market companies, as well as family-owned
enterprises and startups. Approximately 40% of the firm's projects now contain an e-business
component. While most of the firm's work is in the private sector, McKinsey also advises public
sector organizations. In addition, McKinsey helps philanthropic, civic, and cultural organizations
on a pro bono basis. Past charitable work has included clients such as the American Red Cross,
the Pittsburgh Police Force, the San Francisco Zoo, and the City of Stamford.
At times, McKinsey offers introductory engagements or projects to get to know a new client.
In these endeavors, the firm tries to make a difference in the constrained setting of the project.
FOR INTERNAL USE ONLY

Renaissance Group International, Inc. (RGI),

495 Wheeler Road, Ashby, MA 01431

978-386-5858

MCKINSEY & COMPANY.: COMPETITIVE VENDOR PROFILE

PAGE 42

Prepared by RGI and by IBM Americas Market Intelligence

These engagements last four to six weeks and lead to a recommendation to move quickly in or
out of a business area. The firm believes it makes a difference when it works closely with clients
over a longer period of time on a range of consulting assignments. A single consulting
assignment may continue through various phases over time, addressing issues and building the
client's capability to deal with those issues. McKinsey describes this as a "more patient approach"
on both the firm and the client's part.
As McKinsey has increased its electronic commerce practice, the firm has expanded its
customer base to include a greater proportion of high technology and startup businesses.
McKinsey's e-commerce activities have more than tripled in the last two years, with over 1,000
engagements in 2000. Clients of McKinsey's Silicon Valley Office, which focuses on technology
issues, include the following types of organizations:

Leading, established high tech companies in Silicon Valley;


High-potential pre-IPO startups;
Numerous Internet and e-commerce ventures;
Leading private equity and venture capital firms; and
Influential community organizations.

Traditionally, the company has followed a general policy of not revealing a client's name.
McKinsey also urges its clients not to reveal McKinseys involvement publicly to facilitate either
the companys or the clients withdrawal from a project, if necessary. In some instances, the
company would only acknowledge it had worked for a client if that client first revealed McKinsey
involvement publicly and several years had passed. McKinsey believes this maintains the
companys professionalism and supports the company's conviction that it supplements, as
opposed to replaces, the client's leadership. The company has relaxed this policy somewhat in its
e-commerce operation, where clients and potential employees want to know about a firm's
accomplishments.
Examples of recently publicized McKinsey projects include the following:

In April 2001, Comdisco, a high technology leasing and computer-recovery concern,


hired Goldman Sachs & Co. and McKinsey & Co. to help explore strategic options.

Roche Holding AG hired McKinsey & Company to conduct a review of its operations
including corporate structure, operations and staffing levels in an effort to boost
margins.

In March 2001, McKinsey completed a study for Malaysia's state-owned Multimedia


Development Corporation (MDC) assessing Malaysia's multimedia super corridor.
The MDC is responsible for overseeing Malaysia's effort to build an "Asian Silicon
Valley" aimed at transforming the country's economy to one reliant on technology
from a manufacturing base that sees increased competition from lower-wage
countries such as China.

Chesapeake Corporation, a paper and specialty-packaging company, retained


McKinsey & Co. and Goldman, Sachs & Co. to explore strategic alternatives for its
U.S. display business.
FOR INTERNAL USE ONLY

Renaissance Group International, Inc. (RGI),

495 Wheeler Road, Ashby, MA 01431

978-386-5858

MCKINSEY & COMPANY.: COMPETITIVE VENDOR PROFILE

PAGE 43

Prepared by RGI and by IBM Americas Market Intelligence

While McKinsey will not typically reveal a client's name, the firm publishes information on the
types of projects completed by the firm in an effort to market its services. Within the firm's
marketing practice, McKinsey has completed the following projects:

Business-to-Business -- McKinsey assisted an electronics parts distributor in


improving profitability in its core business while identifying new growth opportunities.
A key segment of the client's customer base had grown sufficiently to be able to buy
directly from the distributor's suppliers, eliminating the distributor from the supply
chain. Consultants focused on understanding the evolution of customers' needs and
buying decisions, and then created new programs and tactics to increase business
from them. The client built a new organization to serve and strengthen relationships
with these high-priority customers; as a result of its recommendations, the client
protected over $100M in annual profits with significant sales increases in the target
segments.

Branding -- McKinsey worked with a leading air transportation company to revitalize


customer service and restore the brand's association with customer service.
McKinsey consultants worked with the client to analyze existing research on
company performance on key metrics (such as time needed to buy tickets and to
retrieve luggage); questioned customers on their experiences with the company; and
interviewed managers responsible for frontline customer service, airport operations,
and relationship management. Working with the client's advertising agency,
McKinsey developed a core brand proposition targeted at the most profitable
segment. The firm then worked closely with the client's functional groups to ensure
collaboration and usage of the same data and analysis. The firm achieved top-level
support for a customer-service initiative that focused on several areas of
improvement, ranging from larger overhead bins to technology enabling faster
passenger boarding. The initiative combined a front-end vision of a stronger brand
with back-end tactics to upgrade operations. As a result of this ongoing program, the
company has improved many aspects of the passenger experience, and the
company's customer service ratings have risen from the middle of the pack to the
top.

Continuous Relationship Marketing (CRM) -- In a recent engagement for a leading


U.S. retailer, McKinsey established three objectives: increase activation and
shopping levels among new accounts, reduce churn among the most profitable
customer segments, and increase profitability. To accomplish these goals, the firm
developed a behavior-based segmentation, assessed underlying customer attitudes
and preferences by segment, identified and launched new targeted marketing
strategies, and eliminated non-performing offers and programs. Implementation
included reshaping marketing skills and tools to support the new programs,
developing a champion/challenger test methodology, refining programs based on test
results, and rolling out successful programs across priority groups. The programs
increased new customer sales and retention by 30 to 50%. The company claims that
tailored marketing programs rolled out to priority high-value potential segments
delivered a 5% sales increase overall with ROIs for customer programs of between
75 and 130%.

FOR INTERNAL USE ONLY

Renaissance Group International, Inc. (RGI),

495 Wheeler Road, Ashby, MA 01431

978-386-5858

MCKINSEY & COMPANY.: COMPETITIVE VENDOR PROFILE

PAGE 44

Prepared by RGI and by IBM Americas Market Intelligence

Customer Loyalty -- McKinsey helped a leading cellular provider, experiencing


significant customer churn, identify targeted micro-segments of high-value, at-risk
customers. The firm then developed and implemented a proactive relationship
marketing program to provide tailored offers to these customers and helped the client
identify targeted improvements in its network and customer service. As a result, the
client reduced its overall churn by over 20% within 12 months.

eConsumer -- McKinsey worked with an entertainment company to reassess the


strategic positioning of its umbrella website and several specialty sites. By leveraging
Media Metrix's clickstream database, the e-Consumer Insights team identified where
visitors to the sites came from, what they did at the sites, and where they went after a
session. Drawing on best practices of competing sites, the team recommended ways
to improve marketing effectiveness, and then developed a target performance index
for customer retention.

eMarketing -- McKinsey worked with a major retail client to make better use of offline
assets that could promote its online operation. The URL and action messages were
promoted through store counters, shopping bags, call center hold messages,
television, and direct mail. By spending less than $1M, the company gained over one
billion impressions. Aggressive conversion programs were implemented to
encourage visitors to buy through discounts, free shipping, and sweepstakes. With
these changes, the site attracted more visitors, and conversion ratios increased by
over 50%.

Organization -- McKinsey worked with a telecommunications firm that needed to


restructure its marketing and sales organization to match a rapidly evolving industry.
McKinsey designed a new marketing organization, which used a combination of
product and segment managers to drive sales. The new organization was then
integrated with a brand strategy and a new brand management process to ensure
that all marketing activities helped build the umbrella-brand equity. The team worked
with management to design the model, identify partners for implementation, and
establish job descriptions and hiring specifications. The firm also identified a success
matrix both for the overall organization and for key marketing and sales positions.

Marketing Research -- McKinsey worked with a food manufacturer to develop a


coherent pricing strategy to support profitable growth. The team developed a discrete
choice to understand the price elasticity and substitutions across items within the
client's own line and that of the competition. The resulting changes in price and
distribution resulted in an 8% share gain for a mature product and incremental profit.

Marketing Spending -- McKinsey worked with a leading food and beverage marketer
to enhance the returns on its marketing spending against its key brand. The
approach involved reducing spending and altering the marketing mix across three
regional markets that historically had been treated homogeneously. A reduction and
reallocation of the marketing budget in each market yielded a 33% increase in
projected value versus the historical approach.

FOR INTERNAL USE ONLY

Renaissance Group International, Inc. (RGI),

495 Wheeler Road, Ashby, MA 01431

978-386-5858

MCKINSEY & COMPANY.: COMPETITIVE VENDOR PROFILE

PAGE 45

Prepared by RGI and by IBM Americas Market Intelligence

Marketing Strategy -- In a recent initiative for a packaged goods manufacturer whose


senior management felt that growth was slowing, McKinsey worked to uncover latent
process and relationship needs on which they had not been capitalizing. In
partnership with their management team, the firm identified opportunities to change
brand strategies and packaging approaches to emphasize an easier way to shop.
The firm also accelerated the launch of their Web-based marketing programs and
helped them launch two pilot tests of new packaging, branding, and spending
models. This led to a fundamental redefinition of their category strategy.

Pricing -- McKinsey worked with a printing company to improve pricing strategy,


tactics, and frontline capabilities. A cost-based pricing strategy had caused this
company to lose orders it should have won, win unprofitable business, and
inadvertently put downward pressure on industry-wide price levels. The firm assisted
its client in developing a new approach that segmented customers and individual
orders by customer size, type, industry, form design, size, color, and application, and
allowed the company to tailor bid prices to these dimensions. The team also helped
the company refine its price structure to influence and reward positive customer
behavior. Finally, the entire sales force received training in value selling and
negotiating. This broad program led to a 4% increase in average price levels and a
nearly 50% boost in operating profits.

Channel Management and Sales -- McKinsey worked with a specialty chemicals


manufacturer to revise its go-to-market strategy based on a new look at its customers
and their needs. The company replaced an industry-based segmentation with a
segmentation based on customers' transactional and consultative selling needs. To
diversify the go-to-market strategy, the client reduced the number of outside sales
representatives from 90 to 60. Their duties evolved from handling almost all pre-sale
and during-sale activities to handling pre-sale activities only for the highest valueadded customers and most complex products. An inside sales force of 15 technical
sales reps took over sales to lower value-added customers with simpler needs. The
company further strengthened its transactional capability with an Internet site that
provided services such as repeat order taking, billing, and customer service inquiries.

McKinsey will accept a project if the client's problem or opportunity is "big enough to justify
and demand senior management's attention." The company asserts that clients typically look to
hire McKinsey when they want to build new management skills and develop a high-performing
organization. The client's top management must be committed to make change happen, be open
to new and broader perspectives, agree to take action, and possess the discipline to see that
changes are implemented.
While the company develops long-term relationships with a client, McKinsey does not
typically engage in continuously billable projects. The company sees repeat business from many
clients but does not work on retainer. The company negotiates each engagement separately with
a different set of issues and objectives. McKinsey claims that active relationships with many
clients extend back several years in most countries. Previous work with a client provides
McKinsey with an advantage of knowing the company's business, its top managers, and its
markets, which allow the company to build familiarity, trust, and commitment. The company
maintains its professional values with these clients, accepting assignments only when McKinsey
FOR INTERNAL USE ONLY

Renaissance Group International, Inc. (RGI),

495 Wheeler Road, Ashby, MA 01431

978-386-5858

MCKINSEY & COMPANY.: COMPETITIVE VENDOR PROFILE

PAGE 46

Prepared by RGI and by IBM Americas Market Intelligence

can make a significant impact while maintaining its independence and objectivity. The company
will decline or withdraw from an assignment if it does not meet these conditions.

B. Account Marketing Approach


McKinsey utilizes a team approach for all of its client projects. The teams typically consist of
three to five members, including a Director or Principal (McKinsey's terms for partners), one or
more associates or business analysts, an engagement manager and, in some cases, a specialist.
The specialist has deep expertise in the client's industry or in the functional area the firm is
addressing. The entire team has the responsibility for planning and conducting the engagement,
maintaining relationships with the client, participating in all phases of the engagement, and
ensuring the ultimate quality of the work and impact delivered to the client. The teams are not
structured in a hierarchical manner since the firm believes that it would reduce the likelihood of
client impact and impede the development and retention of people at McKinsey.
The company assigns teams based on required skills, expertise in the functional area, and
industry segment, experience, and client continuity. Team members typically possess
complementary and diverse skills and come from different offices worldwide. The company
claims that consultants loaned by one office to another perform almost 20% of its work. The
business analyst typically has one years experience with McKinsey before being assigned fulltime to a project with responsibility for discrete analyses. The associate, who typically has two
years' experience with McKinsey and an MBA or other advanced degree, also works full-time on
the project, with responsibility for larger pieces of analysis. Associates and business analysts
play active roles in all aspects of the engagement, including fact-gathering, analysis, development
and communication of recommendations, and implementation. The partner, who works only parttime on the project, typically generates the client work, has responsibility for the overall
relationship with the client, and ultimately ensures the quality of the work.
The engagement manager leads the team, having responsibility for the day-to-day
operations. A team manager typically has worked for McKinsey for four years, also having fulltime assignment to the project. The manager provides thought leadership to the team, plans the
work assignments, and provides coaching to team members. In addition, the team receives
secretarial and administrative support.
McKinsey believes a team approach provides the appropriate mix of skills and experience
required for solving complex problems. Team members present multiple perspectives, exchange
ideas, challenge one another's facts and conclusions, and cross-check judgments. All McKinsey
teams contribute by forming hypotheses and articulating views on major issues. The company
believes this approach helps its employees develop and stay at McKinsey, while enhancing the
impact on clients.
Team members work with top management in the client organization, gaining access to
senior level people who possess an organization-wide perspective as well as authority to get
solutions implemented. Typically, the team includes client managers working "side-by-side" with

FOR INTERNAL USE ONLY

Renaissance Group International, Inc. (RGI),

495 Wheeler Road, Ashby, MA 01431

978-386-5858

MCKINSEY & COMPANY.: COMPETITIVE VENDOR PROFILE

PAGE 47

Prepared by RGI and by IBM Americas Market Intelligence

McKinsey staff on the analytical work. This provides the client with a commitment to the team's
recommendations and develops the client's skills and knowledge.
Teams meet regularly with the client to discuss progress and gain input from senior
executives as issues arise. In addition, the company sees these reviews as a mechanism for
ensuring that consultants clarify and focus their thinking on an issue by assessing the implications
for the client at regular intervals.

C. Competition
McKinsey & Company continues to compete against other management consulting firms
concentrating in strategic issues focused at top management. These competitors include
companies such as the Accenture, Boston Consulting Group (BCG), Bain & Company, Mercer
Consulting Group, and Booz, Allen & Hamilton. In addition, the company competes with other
management consulting firms that specialize in a particular function, such as marketing or
information technology. These companies include Computer Sciences Corporation (CSC), EDS
and Cap Gemini. McKinsey also faces the Big Five accounting firms that have expanded their
consulting practices, including PricewaterhouseCoopers, Deloitte & Touche, Arthur Andersen,
KPMG and Ernst & Young. In addition, McKinsey competes against technology consulting
companies and solutions integration companies specializing in e-business solutions, such as
Cambridge Technology Partners, Sapient, and TenFold. The company also encounters firms
providing online consulting that offer agility, timeliness, efficiency, and responsiveness.
McKinsey sees increased competition from fast-growing e-business consultancies that are
winning clients by bundling strategic issues with skills such as Web design and Internet
architecture building. The company has placed an increased emphasis on its e-business over the
last few years and expects to gain a reputation among the dot.com companies. The e-business
consultancies, such as Viant and Zefer, typically conduct projects in the range of $1M to $3M,
compared to a traditional McKinsey project that could reach $10M to $20M. These econsultancies have high-growth clients with between an estimated 25 to 50% paying their fees
with equity. Historically, 90% of McKinsey's business has been with large corporations. The
company now claims that 40% of its revenue has an e-business component.
The following chart shows rankings for the largest management consulting firms. Andersen
Consulting/Accenture continues to hold the top position. McKinsey & Company continues to hold
the seventh place position among these companies in terms of total revenue, excluding revenue
th
associated with outsourcing. Rajat Gupta, the firm's Managing Director, placed 10 in Consulting
Magazine's list of the Top 25 Consultants -- The Professions Most Influential People in the June
2000 issue.

Top Management Consulting Firms Worldwide


Rank

Firm

Main Office

FOR INTERNAL USE ONLY

Renaissance Group International, Inc. (RGI),

495 Wheeler Road, Ashby, MA 01431

978-386-5858

MCKINSEY & COMPANY.: COMPETITIVE VENDOR PROFILE

PAGE 48

Prepared by RGI and by IBM Americas Market Intelligence

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10

Accenture (Andersen Consulting)


PricewaterhouseCoopers
Ernst & Young
Deloitte Consulting
CSC
KPMG
McKinsey & Co.
Cap Gemini
Mercer Consulting Group
Arthur Andersen

Chicago, IL
New York, NY
Cleveland, OH
New York, NY
El Segundo, CA
New York, NY
New York, NY
Paris, France
New York, NY
Chicago, IL

Source: Kennedy Information Research Group, Consultant News

McKinsey also competes against systems vendors, including IBM, Hewlett-Packard, and
Compaq Computer, that have expanded their operations into consulting and outsourcing. While
the management consulting and technology firms, as well as the Big Five, offer vendor
independence when recommending solutions, system vendors are sometimes viewed as
presenting a bias toward their own hardware. McKinsey's lack of formally announced
relationships with software and hardware vendors further promotes the company's impartiality.
While the firm's independence from its clients has stood to differentiate McKinsey in the past, the
company announced in 1999 that it would accept equity stakes in a number of its clients.
McKinsey differentiates the company by emphasizing its impact on customers, taking on
clients only if the firm can show lasting, positive change for the client, while delivering value
several times higher than the fees McKinsey charges. In addition, the company emphasizes its
top management perspective by presenting an integrated view of the problem and solution.
While the company also emphasizes its global, one-firm nature, McKinsey typically competes
against other major vendors with the same types of global resources available. Like other
management strategy firms, McKinsey stresses functional and industry expertise. At the same
time, it maintains a generalist perspective and ability to integrate knowledge across functions and
industries. The company also believes that the training and development of its consultants
provide a significant differentiator.
Over the last few years, McKinsey has seen increased competition among management
consulting firms, as well as Internet firms, for IT consultant staff. Established consulting firms
such as McKinsey, CSC, EDS, Andersen Consulting, KPMG, PricewaterhouseCoopers, Deloitte,
and Ernst &Young have seen employees leave for Internet service companies. While this trend
has slowed due to the overall slowdown in dot.com businesses, the firms still compete for top
talent.
To attract and retain top IT talent, McKinsey has taken minority stakes in more than 100
technology startups. The firm keeps the shares in a blind trust so partners typically do not know if
the company holds shares in a client. McKinsey has established an Investment Office, run
independently of the firm's consulting services, to make investments of pooled monies into
FOR INTERNAL USE ONLY

Renaissance Group International, Inc. (RGI),

495 Wheeler Road, Ashby, MA 01431

978-386-5858

MCKINSEY & COMPANY.: COMPETITIVE VENDOR PROFILE

PAGE 49

Prepared by RGI and by IBM Americas Market Intelligence

various funds managed by independent managers. The investments represent both pension
funds and after-tax investments by firm members. In this manner, McKinsey staff can gain
access to the "Internet fortunes."

FOR INTERNAL USE ONLY

Renaissance Group International, Inc. (RGI),

495 Wheeler Road, Ashby, MA 01431

978-386-5858

MCKINSEY & COMPANY.: COMPETITIVE VENDOR PROFILE

PAGE 50

Prepared by RGI and by IBM Americas Market Intelligence

Organization Structure
McKinsey & Company incorporated in the 1950s but continues to operate as a partnership,
with the partners owning all outstanding shares of the company. The company has not taken
itself public, following instead the procedure set up by Marvin Bower, a past company leader, of
selling shares back to the firm at book value. McKinsey expects each of its consultants to think
and act like an owner of the firm. McKinsey's Managing Director, Rajat Gupta, has no plans to
take the company public, emphasizing his belief that partnerships represent the best professional
services model. The company believes it can compete with a balance between its traditional
business and new economy accounts.
The company is organized formally around geographic locations, with various functional and
industry-specific practices operating across these offices. Each practice has a primary objective
of helping the company's project teams increase their ability to serve clients. Directors and
principals manage these operations.
While organized geographically, the company does not set up profit and loss centers in these
offices. Reinforcing its "one-firm" concept, the company forms teams for projects from various
offices depending upon the particular expertise and skill set required.
Rajat Gupta continues as the Managing Director of McKinsey, having been elected for threeyear terms in 1994, 1997 and 2000. Mr. Gupta will step down in 2003, due to a three-term limit
for a managing director that he initiated during his first term. To bolster the firm's
responsiveness, in 1999 McKinsey established what it calls the Office of the Managing Director, a
group of about six senior partners who help Mr. Gupta champion issues surrounding both people
development and knowledge building. The new office is focused on speeding up the
consultancy's decision-making. Only a handful of practices report directly to the office, including
the @McKinsey business. The chart below displays McKinseys organizational structure.

McKinsey & Company Organizational Structure

FOR INTERNAL USE ONLY

Renaissance Group International, Inc. (RGI),

495 Wheeler Road, Ashby, MA 01431

978-386-5858

MCKINSEY & COMPANY.: COMPETITIVE VENDOR PROFILE

PAGE 51

Prepared by RGI and by IBM Americas Market Intelligence

Rajat Gupta
Managing Director

Office of the
Managing Director

Donna Rosenwasser
CFO

Stuart Flack
Director
Communications

Anil Kumar
Director
@McKinsey

Jerome Vascellaro
COO

Source: McKinsey & Company, May 2001

McKinsey has seen a reversal of a trend from last year during which time the company faced
an increase in the number of professionals leaving the company.

A. Services Delivery Organization


While comprised of more than 80 offices in over 40 countries worldwide, McKinsey continues
to operate as "one firm" globally. The company's offices follow the same mission worldwide, with
consultants demonstrating a consistent approach to serving clients and a global staff following the
same set of guiding principals. In addition, "one firm" means uniform worldwide policies for
evaluating individual performance, transferring consultants between offices, and electing partners
by a centrally managed process.
In an effort to grow the @McKinsey business, over the last year, the company has increased
the number of its stand-alone Accelerator sites. Accelerators are business development centers
providing hands-on Internet business-building services for clients worldwide. McKinsey's
Accelerators can provide new Internet ventures with:

Physical centers where startups can work with experienced e-commerce consultants,
Web designers, and technical experts under one roof;

A dedicated staff of Accelerator consultants, including partners, senior managers,


and associates;

FOR INTERNAL USE ONLY

Renaissance Group International, Inc. (RGI),

495 Wheeler Road, Ashby, MA 01431

978-386-5858

MCKINSEY & COMPANY.: COMPETITIVE VENDOR PROFILE

PAGE 52

Prepared by RGI and by IBM Americas Market Intelligence

The combined experience of more than 500 e-business consultants worldwide;

The expertise of McKinseys global consulting practice, along with an extensive thirdparty network of "best-in-class" service providers and technology vendors; and

Access to McKinsey's global network of Fortune 500 clients, e-business clients, and
alumni.

In addition to providing the temporary office space and advisory services of traditional
incubators, McKinsey's Accelerators also bring e-businesses into full partnership with
@McKinseys experienced e-commerce professionals worldwide. The stand-alone Accelerators
@McKinsey are now located in:

Amsterdam -- The Accelerator @McKinsey in Amsterdam helps clients build their ecommerce businesses in specially designed labs, working with @McKinsey
consultants and external ePartners. Each client works in a dedicated plug-and-play
environment designed to ensure maximum flexibility and scalability. The Accelerator
location in Amsterdam helps to promote the interaction between @McKinsey
consultants, other resident businesses, and vendors. The Amsterdam Accelerator will
also organize and host or support events where the Internet community can discuss
the Internet, e-commerce and related topics.

Atlanta -- The Atlanta Accelerator, which serves the region's e-commerce market
shapers, can accommodate four to six clients. The Atlanta Accelerator has helped
dozens of clients develop strategies, scan opportunities, and build their businesses.

Greater China -- The Greater China Accelerator is positioned to help startups and
industry leaders in Hong Kong, Taiwan, and Mainland China. Many U.S. and
European dot.coms are seeking to establish a presence in Asia, and local
conglomerates in Hong Kong, high tech firms in Taiwan, and state-owned enterprises
in China are also aggressively pursuing e-commerce strategies. The Greater China
Accelerator brings together more than 50 business and technical consultants with
industry and e-commerce experience in financial services, telecommunications,
electronics, media, consumer products, and retail. The Accelerator has conducted
engagements for clients in both B2B and B2C e-commerce.

London -- The London Accelerator works with U.K.-based startups, U.S. dot.coms
expanding into Europe, and incumbent clients moving online. McKinsey's London
Accelerator staffs its projects with e-commerce specialists, industry sector experts,
and consultants from the firm's London Business Technology Office.

Miami -- The Miami Accelerator serves Latin America's next generation of ecommerce market leaders. The Miami Accelerator has helped clients develop
strategies, scan opportunities, and build their businesses. The facility has served ebusiness startups in a variety of industries, including a number in the healthcare
arena. In the first six months of the practice, the firm assisted more than 20
companies in such fields as the Internet, pharmaceutical retailing,
telecommunications, medical product manufacturing, and customer service.
FOR INTERNAL USE ONLY

Renaissance Group International, Inc. (RGI),

495 Wheeler Road, Ashby, MA 01431

978-386-5858

MCKINSEY & COMPANY.: COMPETITIVE VENDOR PROFILE

PAGE 53

Prepared by RGI and by IBM Americas Market Intelligence

Munich -- The Munich Accelerator serves Germany's growing e-commerce market,


with 50 e-business consultants throughout Germany and a facility that can
accommodate five e-businesses at any one time. Since opening in March 2000, the
facility has hosted 14 clients. These clients cover a variety of industries and all
phases of business building: incumbent spin-offs, high-caliber startups, maturing
companies, venture capitalists' portfolio companies, globalizing dot.coms, and
consortia. To date, the Munich Accelerator has served clients in the insurance,
software, mobile communications, and professional services sectors.

Silicon Valley -- Located in Redwood City, California, the Silicon Valley Accelerator
serves e-commerce startups and divisions of incumbent companies, using broad
industry and technical expertise to accelerate and incubate ventures, enhance the
profitability of existing operations, or expand the geographic reach of proven ebusiness concepts. The Silicon Valley Accelerator supports focused, rapid problem
solving at critical junctures through projects that can be completed in as little as two
weeks.

The company also operates Business Technology Offices (BTOs), defined as virtual offices
operating as a single global office. McKinsey's BTO addresses the prime concerns of CEOs,
CIOs, and other senior managers at leading corporations and entrepreneurial ventures, linking IT
investments to strategic business priorities. Launched in 1997, the BTO is McKinsey's first
capability-based, global office.
Consultants in McKinsey's Business Technology Office (BTO) help senior managers solve
complex business and technology challenges facing their organizations. McKinsey consultants
advance industry thinking on top management IT issues and are members of an entrepreneurial
group building an expanded McKinsey capability. McKinsey BTO consultants develop an
understanding of technology's impact on business and bring deep technical competence to
solving strategic business problems. In addition, BTO consultants evaluate underlying
technologies and are directly involved in initiatives in such areas as e-commerce, IT
transformation, and IT architecture.

A. 1. Headcount Structure

McKinsey currently employs approximately 6,000 consultants, comprising 60% of the


company's 10,000 employees, as shown in the following chart below. The level of employment
has remained essentially unchanged over the last year.
McKinsey & Company Headcount
(As of May 2001)
Number
Consultants/Partners
Support Staff

6,000
4,000

FOR INTERNAL USE ONLY

Renaissance Group International, Inc. (RGI),

495 Wheeler Road, Ashby, MA 01431

978-386-5858

MCKINSEY & COMPANY.: COMPETITIVE VENDOR PROFILE

PAGE 54

Prepared by RGI and by IBM Americas Market Intelligence

Total Employment

10,000

Source: McKinsey & Company and RGI research


McKinsey & Company employs almost 2,000 consultants and partners in its U.S. offices. The
following chart displays the numbers of consultants employed at selected offices in the U.S.
McKinsey & Company Consultants by Selected U.S. Offices
(as of May 2001)
Location

Number of Consultants

Cleveland/Pittsburgh/Detroit Complex
Southeastern Complex (Atlanta, Charlotte, Miami)
Stamford, CT Office
New Jersey Office

185
185
80
140

Source: McKinsey & Company, May 2001

A. 2. Hiring Practices

McKinsey offers a well-defined development path for its professionals that starts from its PreAssociates position, progresses to the Associate or Specialist level, is followed by the
Engagement Manager, the newly created position of Associate Partner, and ends at the Partner
level.

Pre-Associate -- McKinsey's Pre-Associate program for business analysts, fellows,


and, in some countries, junior associates, provides on-the-job learning opportunities
and formal training to recent college or first-degree graduates and, occasionally,
advanced or second degree recipients, with two or three years at McKinsey. The
entry-level position serves as an introduction into the field of consulting. The level of
a pre-associate's responsibility increases over time, with most second-year analysts
working at the same level of responsibility as a new associate. In addition, like all
consulting staff, McKinsey gives pre-associates extensive support, including report
production and research and information services. Most pre-associates pursue an
advanced or second degree directly after leaving McKinsey, while others choose to
work in industry, with a nonprofit, or for a startup before going back to school. All
business analysts are eligible for financial assistance to attend graduate school if
they complete two years at McKinsey. The company claims that many of its preassociates return to McKinsey as Associates. Business analysts come from a variety
of academic disciplines with analysts from more than 50 different disciplines hired
FOR INTERNAL USE ONLY

Renaissance Group International, Inc. (RGI),

495 Wheeler Road, Ashby, MA 01431

978-386-5858

MCKINSEY & COMPANY.: COMPETITIVE VENDOR PROFILE

PAGE 55

Prepared by RGI and by IBM Americas Market Intelligence

over the last five years.


For the business analyst position, McKinsey hires highly motivated people with
"outstanding" academic credentials and a strong record of extracurricular activity and
leadership. The company requires that candidates possess an aptitude for numbers
and analysis. It looks for the following "relevant personal qualities: resourcefulness,
responsibility, tenacity, independence, energy, and self-confidence." In addition, the
company requires candidates demonstrate "empathy and commitment" to clients.
McKinsey prefers prior summer or part-time business experience in jobs requiring
analytical or problem solving work. Business analysts must be able to work
effectively at all levels of an organization, including team members, managers and
senior executives.
Business analysts work on engagement teams that typically consisting of three to six
consultants led by a partner. They play active roles in all aspects of the engagement:
identifying issues, forming hypotheses, designing and conducting analyses,
synthesizing conclusions into recommendations, and helping to implement change.
Business analysts are usually assigned to an engagement full-time, which generally
lasts for two to six months.

Associate -- Associates typically join McKinsey with an advanced (or second) degree
in a wide range of fields and/or several years of work experience. Initially, associates
generally work across a broad range of industries and functional areas of business.
An associate can choose to develop an expertise in an industry or functional area, or
remain a generalist. Through VOX, described below, the company now provides its
associates with greater transparency, choice, and flexibility in their assignments.
Associates are full members of each engagement team, expected to identify issues,
develop hypotheses, structure and conduct analyses, synthesize recommendations,
and present results to client leaders. Associates advance to the Engagement
Manager level after achieving mastery of consulting and leadership skills.
For its associate positions, the company looks for individuals with "outstanding
academic credentials and a strong record of extracurricular activity, professional
accomplishment, and leadership." Consultants must possess excellent problem
solving and managerial skills and must be able to make significant contributions in a
relatively short period. McKinsey believes successful consultants must "genuinely
care" about their clients and "truly enjoy helping others better understand and
improve their performance." In addition, consultants must be able to take initiative
and work with people at all levels of an organization, from client team members to
chief executives. For associates in the Business Technology Office, the firm prefers
an MBA or advanced degree in computer science or engineering.

Specialist -- Specialists typically have an advanced degree and several years of work
experience, possessing industry knowledge or deep functional expertise. A specialist
may serve as an active member of an engagement team, or as a source of primary
knowledge support on which the team can draw. Most specialists focus more on
knowledge building and on consulting to teams rather than to clients directly.
Specialists advance to experts and senior experts based on their pace of knowledge
FOR INTERNAL USE ONLY

Renaissance Group International, Inc. (RGI),

495 Wheeler Road, Ashby, MA 01431

978-386-5858

MCKINSEY & COMPANY.: COMPETITIVE VENDOR PROFILE

PAGE 56

Prepared by RGI and by IBM Americas Market Intelligence

development, their internal and external reputation expansion, and their ability to
deliver impact to teams. Some experts advance to the newly created position of
associate principal and on to principal, while others remain experts, focusing more on
deepening and leveraging their area of expertise.

Engagement Manager -- An Engagement Manager has an expanded leadership role


on the engagement teams, with greater responsibility for structuring problem solving,
assigning work to and coaching other McKinsey team members, and for managing
the day-to-day interactions with client team members. Consultants typically choose a
specific industry or functional practice at this level. Consultants that are positioned to
advance to partnership are designated associate principals, previously called senior
engagement managers, and must continue to develop four dimensions of leadership
-- client, people, knowledge, and firm.

Associate Principal -- Associate Partners have demonstrated strong partner potential,


and are recognized as a "partner-in-training," beginning to build what McKinsey
refers to as the unique combination of independence and interdependence that
characterize a partner in the firm. Independence comes from focusing on a program
and specific clients, building relationships, and knowing how to generate
opportunities. Interdependence comes from joining in practice and office activities so
that the associate partner can give back to the firm and help colleagues succeed.
The associate principal designation reinforces the values and characteristics that the
firm believes leads top talent to join McKinsey -- meritocracy, early leadership
opportunities, and early freedom to pursue professional interests. An associate
principal becomes involved in client development and participates in most office and
practice decision-making.
McKinsey created the Associate Principal role to accelerate the development of
exceptional people by giving them a "great measure of personal mentorship and
attention and to reward them by sharing some of the privileges and benefits
traditionally reserved for partners" in the firm.

Partner Typically, a successful consultant could expect election to principal


(partner) within four to six years after joining the firm. People who have had
substantial professional experience before joining the firm may be elected much
earlier. From principal, advancement to director (senior partner) is possible after
another five or six years with the firm. As owners-managers of the firm, principals
have wide latitude in what projects they lead, which clients they serve, and how they
commit resources. McKinsey does not place limits on the total number of
partnerships available within the firm.

In early 2000, McKinsey implemented VOX (Visibility, Options, Expression of preference), a


firm-wide system that further extends a consultants influence over what he or she does in the
firm over a range of time -- weeks, months, or years. VOX is McKinsey's preference-based talent
exchange that gives consultants an unambiguous voice in their assignments. From the start of
employment, each consultant has a global view of prospective engagements, including pro bono
projects, knowledge building, and other initiatives. They can voice their interests and preferences
and, as their skills and performance grow, so does their degree of influence.
FOR INTERNAL USE ONLY

Renaissance Group International, Inc. (RGI),

495 Wheeler Road, Ashby, MA 01431

978-386-5858

MCKINSEY & COMPANY.: COMPETITIVE VENDOR PROFILE

PAGE 57

Prepared by RGI and by IBM Americas Market Intelligence

In addition to providing the opportunity to work with a range of clients that includes startups,
nonprofits, multinational giants, and venture capitalists, McKinsey also allows consultants to
pursue entrepreneurial activities. Consultants can help establish a new office, or take on leadingedge issues by helping to found or grow a specialized practice. The focus in any given area can
last the length of an engagement or span an entire career.
McKinsey's college hiring focuses on top candidates from business as well as other
disciplines. Half of the company's new consultants come directly from industry or with graduate
degrees other than MBAs. The company hires primarily from graduate or post-doctoral research
programs in economics, engineering, humanities, law, medicine, and the natural and social
sciences. Approximately 35% of McKinsey consultants have advanced degrees in business.
In addition, the company now hires employees with established careers in specialized areas
of interest to McKinsey, including brand management, corporate finance, information technology,
law, and medicine. McKinsey positions the diversity of its staff's education and nationalities as
making the firm well-rounded, providing a variety of viewpoints and experiences to foster a
creative and dynamic environment in which to serve clients.
Within the company's @McKinsey business, the company hires eBusiness Builders, or eBBs,
which work with a variety of global clients ranging from startups to established enterprises, in
several industries. The @McKinsey group looks for aggressive, creative thinkers with ecommerce knowledge. Ideal candidates have strong managerial and people skills, the ability to
multitask, and personal networks and contacts within the e-commerce community. In addition,
candidates should have experience in one or more of the following areas:

B2B or B2C strategy and implementation;


Organizational strategy;
Technology;
Third-party alliances;
Startup operations;
Internet-relevant marketing; and
Multidisciplinary environments.

McKinsey's Business Technology Offices (BTOs) hire candidates with four main qualities:

Problem solving ability, showing logical reasoning, creative thinking, comfort with
numbers, and an ability to address complex issues;

Personal impact, showing an ability to make a difference through assertiveness,


empathy, open communications, and an aptitude for teamwork;

Leadership, showing initiative and an eagerness to break new ground, to create


opportunities for others, and to take personal risks; and

Drive/aspiration, with the energy and perseverance to make things happen.

FOR INTERNAL USE ONLY

Renaissance Group International, Inc. (RGI),

495 Wheeler Road, Ashby, MA 01431

978-386-5858

MCKINSEY & COMPANY.: COMPETITIVE VENDOR PROFILE

PAGE 58

Prepared by RGI and by IBM Americas Market Intelligence

The company continues to hire BTO consultants from a variety of industries and backgrounds
including science, economics, and creative fields. BTO candidates must add deep technical
competence to solving strategic business problems and be able to evaluate the underlying
technologies. Furthering the company's "one firm" concept, the BTOs support and encourage
short-term transfers and longer-term moves between the BTO's locations and other McKinsey
offices.

A. 3. Training Practices

McKinsey provides three primary types of support to further its employees' professional
development and growth, as follows:

On-the-job learning - apprenticeship;


Practice-oriented learning; and
Formal training.

The company places great emphasis on learning on-the-job with client work starting
immediately for its professional employees. The company's new consulting staff members work
with senior McKinsey partners and, at times, a specialist with knowledge in an industry or
functional area. The company expects its associates to contribute from the outset by having
responsibility as a full team member, placing an emphasis on learning by observing and
performing. More senior consultants coach new team members and provide feedback.
The "engagement manager" and partners on the team give associates ongoing feedback on
their individual performance. In addition, associates are each assigned a "development leader"
who serves as a source of information, support, and guidance as the associate moves between
projects. The development leader, who is a senior consultant, monitors the associate's progress
based on appraisals received at the end of projects. The development leader provides feedback
to the associate twice a year and offers career advice.
The assignment of individuals to projects also furthers the training and education process for
McKinsey. The company assigns associates to projects based on training requirements
concerning skills, industry knowledge, clients, and types of business problems to ensure a broad
exposure to issues and to gain a general background. As consultants gain expertise in a
functional area or industry, the company expects them to share their knowledge with colleagues
on teams and through the knowledge infrastructure. Through these techniques, the company
broadens it knowledge base across its consultants. McKinsey employees also participate in
company-sponsored internal research activities that help the company's consultants stay current
on management issues.
Through McKinsey's various functional and industry practices, consultants build knowledge
and expertise in specific areas. "Practice learning" takes several forms including original
research, shaping the company's thinking on an emerging growth sector, and assuming a
leadership role in building a new practice. The company encourages thought leadership and
promotes consultants efforts at writing for publications. Through the company's efforts at
FOR INTERNAL USE ONLY

Renaissance Group International, Inc. (RGI),

495 Wheeler Road, Ashby, MA 01431

978-386-5858

MCKINSEY & COMPANY.: COMPETITIVE VENDOR PROFILE

PAGE 59

Prepared by RGI and by IBM Americas Market Intelligence

building knowledge, which other consultants then internalize, the company extends its knowledge
and provides informed support to its client service teams. Thought leadership is also
encouraged through involvement in forums including McKinsey's annual Practice Olympics or
practice sponsored learning seminars.
Formal training for new hires at McKinsey focuses on strengthening problem solving, financial
analysis, communication, and interpersonal skills. As consultants progress in their career, the
company shifts the focus of additional training to client leadership, personal impact, negotiating
skills, and client-relationship building. Consultants also attend training related to the industry and
functional areas of their choice, addressing topics such as industry developments and new
problem solving approaches.
McKinsey continues to sponsor formal training programs for business analysts, associates,
specialists and partners, which fall into three categories:

Prerequisite programs for new consulting staff members;


Core role-change programs, focused heavily on leadership development; and
Programs focused on specific consulting skills.

Prerequisite Programs -- McKinsey offers three prerequisite programs for its new staff
members. These programs are designed to build basic functional skills for new consultants with
little or no formal business education and to help all new consultants prepare to be effective team
members:

Mini-MBA -- McKinsey provides an intensive three-week program in the "core-skills"


of a business school curriculum -- marketing analysis and applications,
microeconomic and financial analysis, strategy and organization -- for associates and
specialists joining the firm with advanced and professional degrees but without an
MBA or substantial business experience. The program offers the basic analytical
tools expected of new associates or specialists and helps develop the business
judgement needed to begin functioning as a consultant.

Economics Concept Program (ECP) -- McKinsey offers the Economics Concepts


Program to associates and specialists who have had extensive experience in industry
prior to joining McKinsey but have not had MBA training. The two-week program
focuses first on developing skills in basic accounting and finance, and then
introduces and applies more advanced, consulting-oriented finance tools in a global
environment.

Basic Consulting Readiness (BCR) -- The BCR training program helps familiarize
pre-associates and associates with the skills needed to be effective team members in
early client engagements. The topics include structured problem solving on
McKinsey teams, principles of teamwork, and basic client communications. The
program also offers an orientation to the core values of the firm, its diverse culture,
and professional standards. The company conducts its BCR program at the office
level, although the company establishes a firm-wide curriculum. This gives
individuals an opportunity to interact socially and to work with peers and more senior
consultants from their office.
FOR INTERNAL USE ONLY

Renaissance Group International, Inc. (RGI),

495 Wheeler Road, Ashby, MA 01431

978-386-5858

MCKINSEY & COMPANY.: COMPETITIVE VENDOR PROFILE

PAGE 60

Prepared by RGI and by IBM Americas Market Intelligence

Core Role-Change Programs -- McKinsey designs its role-change programs to help


consultants make a "step change" in their effectiveness and self-awareness as consulting
leaders. The company offers several programs that are timed to take place when the
professional approaches a significant expansion of responsibilities, opportunities, and latitude.
The company offers feedback and coaching support from senior McKinsey faculty, experts, and
peers in its role-change programs. McKinsey conducts most programs on a firm-wide basis to
provide the opportunity for its professionals to build a strong set of professional relationships with
colleagues worldwide.
The core role-change programs consist of the following programs:

Initial Leadership Workshop (ILW) -- ILW offers consultants, who have spent at least
12 months honing problem solving and communications skills, a chance to develop
their leadership abilities. The first week of this two-week program addresses dealing
with conflict, handling different operating styles, influencing with integrity, and
facilitating group work. The second week applies these skills in more complex, "real
world" client situations. As part of the workshop, participants work toward attaining a
top executive mindset, staying ahead of the problem, leveraging the firm's knowledge
resources, and persuading the client to take action.

Engagement Management Basics (EMB) -- McKinsey offers the Engagement


Management Basics program as a follow up to the Initial Leadership Workshop,
targeting consultants who have been with the firm for 12 to 24 months. EMB
represents a two-and-a-half day program, which focuses on key "survival" skills as
the consultant takes on broader task or engagement management roles. The
program reviews a managerial perspective of basic problem solving, best practices in
coaching team members and various project management techniques. In addition,
the program includes an interactive simulation designed to build awareness of the
complex tradeoffs among task accomplishment, client buy-in and commitment, team
leadership, and lifestyle issues. While EMB follows a firm-wide curriculum, the
company delivers the program at the office level.

Engagement Leadership Workshop (ELW) -- This five-day workshop provides an


opportunity to practice the entrepreneurial skills needed to make the transition from
effective team member to successful team leader. Consultants generally attend ELW
within their second or third year as engagement managers. The focus here is on
"experiential" activities, with real end-products, in which participants take on
leadership roles. The workshop provides a structured environment that allows
consultants to assess their leadership profiles and their personal growth within
McKinsey.

Client Leadership Workshop (CLW) -- CLW coaches senior engagement managers


and new principals as leaders in client service within the firm. In association with
McKinsey partners as well as outside professionals, workshop participants think
through their leadership strengths and weaknesses, reflect on professional
development aspirations, and map a course for achieving professional independence
and building a following over the next four to five years. Through executive role-play,
they gain confidence in their peer relationships with top client management. All
FOR INTERNAL USE ONLY

Renaissance Group International, Inc. (RGI),

495 Wheeler Road, Ashby, MA 01431

978-386-5858

MCKINSEY & COMPANY.: COMPETITIVE VENDOR PROFILE

PAGE 61

Prepared by RGI and by IBM Americas Market Intelligence

participants are responsible for coaching and counseling others in the workshop as a
means of further developing their own management and leadership skills.

New Partners Orientation -- McKinsey offers its New Partners Orientation course
shortly after election to partnership. The partner and spouse attend a week-long
seminar designed to "celebrate" and help the partner learn more about the partner's
new role, further the understanding of the firm from an owner's perspective, and
sharpen skills as a client service team leader, geographic or practice entrepreneur,
and leader of other McKinsey staff. Much of the program involves "getting to know"
new partners, with afternoons set aside for sports and other social activities.

The company also places an emphasis on knowledge building through the its various
functional and industry practices. This allows consultants to build extensive knowledge and
expertise in areas of most interest to them. To further this knowledge, the company offers
forums, such as its annual Practice Olympics or learning seminars, to showcase consultants'
thinking and spread ideas throughout the firm. In addition, McKinsey offers its professionals
entrepreneurial opportunities, such as opening a new office or practice, or working in a remote
location. The company encourages thought leadership that can be advanced through writing for
publications, including the company's McKinsey Quarterly, or taking a leadership role in recruiting
or other areas of professional development.
Programs Focused on Specific Consulting Skills -- In addition to prerequisite and rolechange programs, McKinsey offers formal training focused on developing specific consulting
skills. Three two to three-day programs form the current core of these offerings, as follows:

Communications Skills Workshop (CSW) -- Through the Communications Skills


Workshop, McKinsey hopes to enhance participants' effectiveness in face-to-face
client communications, meetings, and oral presentations. The workshop trains each
participant to adapt a personal communications style to different settings. CSW
emphasizes the following:

Meeting the objective and listener's needs;


Organizing material to meet that plan;
Tapping a range of experience and delivery skills to convey the message; and
Using visual aids as reinforcements to effective communication.

Functional Skills Workshop (FSW) -- McKinsey offers a series of four modules to


introduce early-tenure associates to the firm's core concepts/beliefs, frameworks and
problem solving tools in key areas of the practice. The company hopes to build
awareness, not in-depth skill, and to introduce the available knowledge sources that
can be accessed when needed for a client assignment. The areas covered are as
follows:

Business unit leadership --strategy, microeconomics and marketing;


Corporate leadership -- particularly multi-business valuation and strategy;
Operations effectiveness; and

FOR INTERNAL USE ONLY

Renaissance Group International, Inc. (RGI),

495 Wheeler Road, Ashby, MA 01431

978-386-5858

MCKINSEY & COMPANY.: COMPETITIVE VENDOR PROFILE

PAGE 62

Prepared by RGI and by IBM Americas Market Intelligence

Organizational performance and change.

Negotiating Skills Workshop (NSW) -- As a complement to New Partners Orientation,


NSW offers new partners an opportunity to develop their negotiating skills further.
NSW provides tools and techniques for understanding the client's real needs,
reaching a consensus on those needs, and gaining a commitment to act on them. It
also helps partners learn how to fully leverage the firm's resources to help address
client needs and how to establish realistic arrangements.

BTO Training -- Within McKinsey's Business Technology Offices (BTOs), a staffing


coordinator assists professionals in the assignment process, balancing the client's requirements
with professional development needs and interests. The mix of work in a consultant's "portfolio" of
client experiences, combined with a chance to work with different managers and partners, are
taken into account in the staffing process. The BTO offers training programs to help build skills
and knowledge. During the first 12 to 18 months in a BTO, the professional attends several
weeks of programs. Initially, the professionals spends one week acquiring the basic consulting
"tool-kit." Those who have limited business experience attend a three-week "mini-MBA" program
described above.
All BTO consultants attend a one-week, customized program developed by the firm in
collaboration with MIT. This program covers all areas of business technology, and is taught by
MIT professors and BTO partners. In addition, the company provides training and coaching on
communications skills, and requires attendance at a two-week program designed to build problem
solving effectiveness.
Overall, McKinsey's training programs provide opportunities for its professionals to grow and
advance when ready. The company does not impose strict tenure-based requirements for
advancement. Throughout their careers, McKinsey consultants receive formal training and
personal mentoring to develop expertise and leadership qualities.

A. 4. Compensation and Measurement Criteria

McKinsey operates as a "meritocracy," defined as a place that identifies, encourages, and


rewards talent and leadership. The company advances, and compensates, employees based on
an "explicit, regular, fair, and open evaluation process." Criteria for formal reviews include growth
in skills and demonstrated leadership in the areas of client, people, knowledge, and the firm.
The company believes its salaries are competitive with management consulting firms and
reflect the different levels of skills and experience of the employees. McKinsey points to the
"rewards" of "intellectual challenge; the chance to work with stimulating colleagues; and
exceptional opportunities for professional and personal development." The company expects
long hours of service from its new consultants, estimating an average of 55-hour workweeks for
first-year consultants, plus occasional weekend hours.

FOR INTERNAL USE ONLY

Renaissance Group International, Inc. (RGI),

495 Wheeler Road, Ashby, MA 01431

978-386-5858

MCKINSEY & COMPANY.: COMPETITIVE VENDOR PROFILE

PAGE 63

Prepared by RGI and by IBM Americas Market Intelligence

McKinsey has traditionally operated in an "up-or-out" environment, with the company


"separating" associates as soon as performance demonstrates that the associate does not have
the qualities to become a McKinsey principal. The company reviews all associates annually
against the standards. The company does not employ "career associates" but rather fills the
associate role with new hires that can quickly learn the skills to become candidates for partner. In
addition, the firm holds intellectual competitions among its members through an internal "Practice
Olympics" in which consultants compete to develop business plans. Five or six years after joining
McKinsey, 20% of the company's consultants are elected partners, or principals, by a firm-wide
committee. After another five or six years, 20% of the partners are elected to senior partner,
called "director."
With the rise of the Internet economy, McKinsey has had to relax its hierarchical structure
somewhat over the last few years. The company has become less rigid about requiring new
employees to spend six years as associates before considering them for a partner post.
McKinsey will now allow consultants to become partners in as little as three years with the
company. Alternatively, the company also has relaxed its up-or-out policy, allowing associates to
take ten or more years to reach the partner level. This provides consultants with time to pursue
advanced degrees or to have children. As noted above, the company also gives associates more
say in choosing assignments through the VOX program.
While the up-and-out policy is less rigid, the firm still expects about 17% of its consultants to
leave each year. The current rate has fallen to less than 12%, 5 percentage points below the
historical figure, which the firm claims establishes equilibrium. The firm believes the decline in
the turnover relates to the decline in the dot.com boom. In the height of the growth of Internet
companies, McKinsey saw an increase in its turnover to approximately 20 or 21%, losing a
relatively high percentage of its staff compared to historical levels. While the company still had its
choice of candidates from top graduate business schools, these employees left faster than they
had previously.
McKinsey's newly created position of associate principal provides another means to retain its
consultants. In this position, "promising consultants" can share in the responsibilities and
monetary rewards of partnership prior to being elected to partnership. McKinsey elects new
partners twice a year. Offices nominate candidates to a committee comprised of partners from
various offices. The committee evaluates each consultant and partner against two basic criteria:

The ability to have an impact at clients, and


The willingness to develop younger colleagues and help other employees.

The company claims it does not use "billings" as a measure of "impact" at clients but instead
expects to demonstrate a large financial benefit for the client as opposed to high billables. A
Client Impact Committee oversees the evaluation of the extent of impact McKinsey's work has on
a client. The company also claims that the second criterion is as important as the first. The
committee also evaluates a candidate's leadership and problem solving skills. The firm uses
collaboration as a performance factor for its employees, with several partners working together on
a client service team. The company relies on developing networks between partners and
consultants to draw on the firm's knowledge base.

FOR INTERNAL USE ONLY

Renaissance Group International, Inc. (RGI),

495 Wheeler Road, Ashby, MA 01431

978-386-5858

MCKINSEY & COMPANY.: COMPETITIVE VENDOR PROFILE

PAGE 64

Prepared by RGI and by IBM Americas Market Intelligence

As part of the company's effort to attract and retain employees during 2000, McKinsey
increased the pay levels for its associates. According to a report in The Wall Street Journal, the
company offered pay increases of at least 15%. The article reported that an incoming first-year
McKinsey associate in the U.S. earned $130,000 to $150,000 with bonus. Salaries for associate
principals ranged from $400,000 to $450,000, while newly appointed partners earned around
$700,000. Senior partners at the firm had multimillion-dollar pay packages. In general, the
company's compensation packages were considered "cash heavy," and the firm could not
compete successfully for candidates looking for immediate wealth or those wanting their
compensation packages to include a large equity base. With reduced employee turnover, RGI
believes current base salaries fall into the same range.
In an effort to address the requirement of ownership wealth, the firm developed the McKinsey
Investment Office as a way for its partners and associates to tap into Internet and other startup
money. The Investment Office is run independently of the firm's consulting services. The office
makes investments of pooled monies into venture capital funds, leveraged buyout funds, hedge
funds, and index funds, managed by independent managers. The investments represent both
pension funds and after-tax investments by firm members.

FOR INTERNAL USE ONLY

Renaissance Group International, Inc. (RGI),

495 Wheeler Road, Ashby, MA 01431

978-386-5858

MCKINSEY & COMPANY.: COMPETITIVE VENDOR PROFILE

PAGE 65

Prepared by RGI and by IBM Americas Market Intelligence

Alliances/Joint Ventures/Partnerships
While the company will form alliances with various businesses, such as systems vendors and
enterprise software companies, McKinsey & Company traditionally does not announce any
ongoing partnerships with these vendors. McKinsey will align with an appropriate company to
solve a client's particular problem but generally does not publicly formalize relationships with
these "partners" or provide any information concerning their use during a project.
To compete more effectively in the e-commerce practice, the firm now allows the McKinsey
name to be used more openly in conjunction with some of these alliances. The company
believes it must discuss its achievements to attract e-commerce talent to the firm and to win
startup businesses as clients.
McKinsey maintains a conservative policy toward investing in clients. While the company has
taken stakes in more than 100 technology startups, McKinsey continues to refuse long-term
stakes and board seats in these firms. In addition, the company keeps the shares in a blind trust
so partners generally do not know if McKinsey holds a financial stake in companies that they are
advising. The company's Managing Director, Rajat Gupta, states that the company is not trying
to become an investment company. As noted earlier, McKinsey now runs an Investment Office
that makes investments in various funds operated by independent managers.

A. Acquisitions
McKinsey's strategy has been to grow the company from within, avoiding growth through
acquisitions. The company's policy is to enter new geographic, functional or vertical markets
through its existing consulting staff. The firm follows a "geographic entrepreneurship" strategy,
establishing new practices in developing economies. The policy furthers the company's one-firm
concept, with all professionals following the same values worldwide.
In a departure from the tradition of growing practices from within, in January 2001, McKinsey
acquired Envision, a Chicago-based brand strategy firm, with Envision's employees joining
McKinsey's Branding Practice. The move, which the firm positions as a part of McKinsey's
continued emphasis on investing in knowledge development, builds on an initiative to establish a
dedicated Branding Practice. The Branding Practice has substantially strengthened and
expanded the firm's capabilities in helping clients link business strategy, brand strategy,
organization delivery of brand strategy, and marketing spend effectiveness. The terms of the
acquisition were not disclosed.
David Court, the principal of the firm's overall Marketing Practice views the acquisition partly
as a "mass hiring" to speed the expansion of the firm's Branding Practice. Mr. Court believes that
the team at Envision is highly regarded for their "unique empirical approach to deriving new
consumer insights and brand strategies." According to Mr. Court, the Envision executives
combine sophisticated consumer market research and quantitative modeling with creative
FOR INTERNAL USE ONLY

Renaissance Group International, Inc. (RGI),

495 Wheeler Road, Ashby, MA 01431

978-386-5858

MCKINSEY & COMPANY.: COMPETITIVE VENDOR PROFILE

PAGE 66

Prepared by RGI and by IBM Americas Market Intelligence

insights to develop brand strategies that are grounded in a deep understanding of consumer
behaviors and attitudes.
Envision's current clients include blue-chip companies in a variety of sectors, including
financial services, retailing, packaged goods, media, and pharmaceuticals. McKinsey and
Envision have worked together on a number of engagements and have found their approaches to
be complementary. Through the combination, McKinsey believes its can create a more
comprehensive brand development system that drives overall business performance
improvement for clients. Advertising agencies may view this move as a threat to their own
branding operations.

B. Alliances
Recently, McKinsey has developed and publicized its research alliances with a few
companies, including the following:
Media Metrix -- McKinsey and Media Metrix, a leader in Internet and Digital Media audience
measurement, announced a strategic research alliance to develop a deep understanding of
online consumer behavior and its implications for e-businesses. Combining McKinsey's in-depth
marketing and e-business expertise with Media Metrix's leadership position in online audience
measurement, the new alliance brings powerful insights into the e-consumer to help executives
build, grow and market stronger e-businesses. Through the alliance, McKinsey will leverage
Media Metrix's comprehensive database of actual online usage, further supporting clients across
the full spectrum of developing sustainable e-business models. Media Metrix will gain an even
deeper understanding of online behavior and trends, strengthening its ability to meet clients'
information requirements.
According to John Forsyth, Principal and co-leader of McKinsey's e-Marketing Practice, by
pairing Media Metrix's resource of consumer online behavior data with the firm's experience in
understanding consumer needs and branding, McKinsey can strengthen its position as a unique
consulting resource for e-businesses. In addition to supporting client research initiatives, the
alliance will actively study the growing online world, periodically releasing findings to the public.
Through this strategic research alliance with Media Metrix, McKinsey professionals gain
exclusive access to the individual click-by-click online behavior of consumers. Media Metrix has
a U.S. panel of 50,000 people under measurement. Overall, it tracks nearly 100,000 consumers
in markets that account for 85% of global Internet users. With the firm's unique access to the
disaggregated data through Media Metrix, McKinsey can design and perform custom analysis for
any e-commerce business. The firm positions the net result as improved performance in the
critical dimensions of customer acquisition, conversion, and retention.
Center for Advanced Purchasing Studies -- McKinsey's Purchasing and Supply Management
Practice (PSM) and the Center for Advanced Purchasing Studies (CAPS) published a white paper
that found that the majority of leading sites still fail to deliver substantial, long-term economic
value to users. The Center for Advanced Purchasing Studies (CAPS) is a non-profit, independent
FOR INTERNAL USE ONLY

Renaissance Group International, Inc. (RGI),

495 Wheeler Road, Ashby, MA 01431

978-386-5858

MCKINSEY & COMPANY.: COMPETITIVE VENDOR PROFILE

PAGE 67

Prepared by RGI and by IBM Americas Market Intelligence

research organization co-sponsored by Arizona State University College of Business and the
National Association of Purchasing Management. Its mission is to help organizations achieve
competitive advantage by providing them with leading-edge research to support the evolution of
strategic purchasing and supply management.
The report indicates that the greatest value B2B sites have already produced, and will likely
continue to deliver, stems from knowledge building and the removal of waste from supply chains.
This further undermines the assumptions of many B2B users that the value of marketplaces is
driven by shifting or squeezing supplier profits. The study concludes that a rapid retooling of site
capabilities or a major industry consolidation may be the best options for delivering value to
buyers and returns to B2B e-marketplace investors.

FOR INTERNAL USE ONLY

Renaissance Group International, Inc. (RGI),

495 Wheeler Road, Ashby, MA 01431

978-386-5858

MCKINSEY & COMPANY.: COMPETITIVE VENDOR PROFILE

PAGE 68

Prepared by RGI and by IBM Americas Market Intelligence

Financials
The following chart displays estimates of McKinsey's revenue for the last six years, showing
steadily increasing sales. In FY00, revenue reached $3.4B, representing an increase of over
25% from $2.7B in FY99. As a private company, McKinsey does not release any financial
information.
McKinsey & Company Revenue
($B)

$3.4

$3.5
$3.0

$2.5

$2.5
$2.0

$2.0

$2.7

$2.2

$1.7

$1.5
$1.0
$0.5
$0.0
1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000

Source: 1995-1997 revenue estimates from Kennedy Information Research Group figures; 1998
revenue from McKinsey spokesperson; 1999 revenue estimate from Hoovers Online;
2000 revenue from Financial Times.

A. International Operations
McKinsey considers itself a global company with more than 80 offices located in over 40
countries. The company claims its consultants hold citizenship in over 89 countries. McKinsey
has indicated that it conducts 60% of its work outside of the U.S. Through the company's team
concept, consultants work on assignments of varying lengths in different offices and different
countries. Through these varied assignments, the company believes its consultants become
more aware of the global environment. The company requires any candidate applying for a
specific office to have language fluency for that country or previous work or educational
experience in the requested country.
The following chart displays the locations of McKinsey offices worldwide. Since August,
1999, the firm's Managing Director, Rajat Gupta, and his staff have maintained their office in
FOR INTERNAL USE ONLY

Renaissance Group International, Inc. (RGI),

495 Wheeler Road, Ashby, MA 01431

978-386-5858

MCKINSEY & COMPANY.: COMPETITIVE VENDOR PROFILE

PAGE 69

Prepared by RGI and by IBM Americas Market Intelligence

Stamford, Connecticut. Over the last year, the company opened offices in Austin, Texas and Tel
Aviv, Israel.
McKinsey & Company Office Locations
Americas
Atlanta
Austin
Bogota
Boston
Buenos Aires
Caracas
Charlotte
Chicago
Cleveland
Dallas
Detroit
Houston
Los Angeles
Mexico
Miami
Minneapolis
Monterrey
Montreal
New Jersey
New York
Orange County
Pacific Northwest (Seattle)
Pittsburgh
Rio de Janeiro
San Francisco
Santiago
Sao Paulo
Silicon Valley (Palo Alto)
Stamford
Toronto
Washington, DC

Europe and Africa


Amsterdam
Antwerp
Athens
Barcelona
Berlin
Brussels
Budapest
Cologne
Copenhagen
Dubai
Dublin
Dusseldorf
Frankfurt
Geneva
Gothenburg
Hamburg
Helsinki
Istanbul
Johannesburg
Lisbon
London
Madrid
Milan
Moscow
Munich
Oslo
Paris
Prague
Rome
Stockholm
Stuttgart
Tel Aviv
Vienna
Warsaw
Zurich

Asia-Pacific
Auckland
Bangkok
Beijing
Delhi
Hong Kong
Jakarta
Kuala Lumpur
Manila
Melbourne
Mumbai
Osaka
Seoul
Shanghai
Singapore
Sydney
Taipei
Tokyo

Source: McKinsey & Company, May 2001

FOR INTERNAL USE ONLY

Renaissance Group International, Inc. (RGI),

495 Wheeler Road, Ashby, MA 01431

978-386-5858

MCKINSEY & COMPANY.: COMPETITIVE VENDOR PROFILE

PAGE 70

Prepared by RGI and by IBM Americas Market Intelligence

The company also operates Business Technology Offices (BTOs), defined as virtual offices
operating as a single global office, from several locations including Amsterdam, Buenos Aries,
Chicago, Frankfurt, London, Madrid, Milan, Paris, Sao Paulo, Silicon Valley (Palo Alto, CA)
Stamford, Stockholm, and Zurich. Reinforcing McKinsey's one-firm philosophy, the BTO supports
and encourages short-term transfers and longer-term moves between the BTO's locations and
other McKinsey offices.
The following chart displays McKinsey's distribution of consultants across regions. Almost
50% of the company's consultants are located in the Europe/Africa region, totaling over 2900
consultants. Over 2450 consultants are located in offices throughout the Americas with 80% of
these located in the U.S.
Geographic Distribution of McKinsey & Company Consultants

Asia/Pacific
10%
Americas
41%
Europe/Africa
49%

Source: McKinsey & Company

To expand its operations into new geographic regions, current consultants establish a
relationship with several local clients. The company then expands operations by hiring nationals.
As the nationals become more experienced with McKinsey through assignments in other
countries, McKinsey transfers leadership of the office to the nationals. The company does not
buy local consulting firms or arrange affiliations to expand into new regions.
The new office in Israel, under the leadership of Jonathan Kolodny, offers consulting services
to industrial companies and local startups. The office's fee structure is designed to allow clients
to pay for McKinsey's services in either equity or cash, emulating the model established by
McKinsey's Silicon Valley Office, which has worked with local venture capital funds. The firm
currently is discussing potential working relationships with a few local venture capital funds in
Israel. The new office will attempt to capitalize on Israel's thriving high tech industry and get
involved with smaller companies. McKinsey has provided its consulting services to several Israeli
companies over the last few years, including Bank Hapoalim, Supersol, Claridge, Elite/Strauss,
and Osem.

FOR INTERNAL USE ONLY

Renaissance Group International, Inc. (RGI),

495 Wheeler Road, Ashby, MA 01431

978-386-5858

MCKINSEY & COMPANY.: COMPETITIVE VENDOR PROFILE

PAGE 71

Prepared by RGI and by IBM Americas Market Intelligence

Corporate Strengths and Weaknesses


Please refer to the Executive Summary of this report

FOR INTERNAL USE ONLY

Renaissance Group International, Inc. (RGI),

495 Wheeler Road, Ashby, MA 01431

978-386-5858

MCKINSEY & COMPANY.: COMPETITIVE VENDOR PROFILE

PAGE 72

Prepared by RGI and by IBM Americas Market Intelligence

Industry Focus
McKinsey operates several industry practices that help the company's teams build,
disseminate, and apply their knowledge of the key industries served by the firm. An industry
practice represents a network of people interested in developing McKinsey's capability in a
specific industry. The industry practices assess issues, as follows:

The underlying economics and competitive dynamics;


Key industry challenges faced by clients;
Emerging strategic opportunities; and
How to better serve the company's clients in those industries.

McKinsey currently operates 17 industry practices, having added the Nonprofit Industry
practice over the last year, as follows:

Auto and Assembly;


Banking and Securities;
Chemicals;
Consumer/Packaged Goods;
Electric Power and Natural Gas;
High Tech;
Insurance;
Media and Entertainment;
Metals and Mining;
Nonprofit;
Payor/Provider;
Petroleum;
Pharmaceuticals and Medical Products;
Pulp and Paper;
Retail, Apparel, Leisure;
Telecommunications; and
Transportation.

The company continues to locate its specialized industry practices in the appropriate
geographic markets to enable the company to respond quickly to changes in market trends,
technologies, and competitive forces. As examples, McKinsey locates its financial institution
practice in New York City, while its energy practice operates from Dallas. In this manner, the
company has close access to a large client base while maintaining expertise in recent practices in
the market.
The New Jersey office was created in 1993 to further develop the company's relationships
with companies in the healthcare, pharmaceuticals, medical products, telecommunications,
consumer goods, and chemicals industries. The New Jersey office is the base for a significant
portion of McKinsey's Advanced Materials and Chemicals (AMC) Practice. This practice serves a
large variety of chemical companies, from traditional industry leaders to aggressive new
FOR INTERNAL USE ONLY

Renaissance Group International, Inc. (RGI),

495 Wheeler Road, Ashby, MA 01431

978-386-5858

MCKINSEY & COMPANY.: COMPETITIVE VENDOR PROFILE

PAGE 73

Prepared by RGI and by IBM Americas Market Intelligence

competitors. As McKinsey's AMC industry clients become more global, its AMC Practice has
increasingly staffed internationally, mixing consultants from the US, Europe, and Asia to reflect
the staffing patterns of its client teams and to span different management and work cultures.
McKinsey's southeast complex is comprised of offices in Atlanta, Charlotte, and Miami,
serving a broad range of industries and functional areas throughout the Southeastern U.S., the
Caribbean, and Latin America. The Atlanta office, which opened in 1978, focuses on ecommerce, telecommunications, transportation, retailing, forest products, and banking/insurance.
The Charlotte office, formed in 1996, focuses on financial institutions, retail, manufacturing,
healthcare, and e-commerce. The office positions itself as an entrepreneurial group serving the
fastest moving companies in the Carolinas. The Miami office, which opened in 1997, focuses on
the banking, media, public sector, retail, technology, and telecommunications markets and serves
as an @McKinsey Accelerator office. The office serves Florida, the Caribbean basin, and
northern Latin America.
McKinsey's Silicon Valley office (SVO) serves technology and biotechnology companies in
Silicon Valley, and on the West Coast. In the SVO, teams of industry-experienced consultants
partner with investors, entrepreneurs, and senior executives of high tech, biotech, and ecommerce companies, to accelerate their business development and enhance their performance.
The SVO leads a rapidly expanding high tech practice, and its consultants have strong ties to the
startup and venture capital communities. In addition to building the firm's technology expertise on
the West Coast, SVO serves as one of the firm's Business Technology Offices. SVO hosts
several leaders of McKinsey's North American High Tech Practice, as well as its global ecommerce community, @McKinsey, which helps clients create high growth Internet-based
businesses. The Silicon Valley office also is active in the healthcare sector, focusing on issues
relating to medical technologies and online healthcare.
The Cleveland, Pittsburgh, and Detroit complex focuses on the chemicals, healthcare,
financial institutions, consumer products, high tech, automotive, energy and metals/mining
markets. The complex employs approximately 185 consultants, with 100 in Cleveland, 45 in
Pittsburgh, and 40 in Detroit.

A. Auto and Assembly


McKinsey's Auto and Assembly (A&A) Practice (Sector) serves clients around the world in all
sectors of the automotive industry. The firm's clients include major automobile and commercial
vehicle manufacturers, leading component suppliers who serve them, material suppliers,
companies that focus on the aftermarket, and companies focused on downstream sales and
distribution. Industry areas served include automobiles, trucks and buses, automotive distribution
and retail, automotive suppliers, machinery, mechanical and electrical components, plant
construction, and other related businesses. As in every industry, McKinsey's goal is to help its
automotive and assembly clients make positive, lasting, substantial improvements in their
performance.

FOR INTERNAL USE ONLY

Renaissance Group International, Inc. (RGI),

495 Wheeler Road, Ashby, MA 01431

978-386-5858

MCKINSEY & COMPANY.: COMPETITIVE VENDOR PROFILE

PAGE 74

Prepared by RGI and by IBM Americas Market Intelligence

The Auto and Assembly Practice represents a global effort, employing professionals
experienced in automotive, engineering, and related disciplines as well as business management.
The consultants' backgrounds vary from those with MBAs to others with advanced degrees in
related fields like economics or engineering, to experienced professionals from the automotive
industry. Practice professionals meet to share project insights and discuss industry
developments, allowing clients to benefit from global knowledge and experience. The company
addresses industry-specific issues providing perspectives on adoption rates of new materials into
cars, regional forecasting, and the changing supplier/OEM relationship.
McKinsey offers its clients an A&A Extranet providing direct access to:

A selection of A&A news, monthly industry reports, and a calendar of events


worldwide;

Insights into tools and concepts the firm uses in its daily practice;

Links to sites and publications, both inside and outside McKinsey;

On-line moderated discussion forums;

The firm's exclusive speed-search, "Selected Journal Query," providing access to 25


top journals; and

A&A consultants and specialists via e-mail.

The leadership of McKinsey's Global Automotive and Assembly Sector includes:

Gnter Rommel, a Director in the Munich Office, Global Sector head;

Andreas E. Zielke, a Director in the Berlin Office, responsible for regional leadership
in Europe;

Anjan Chatterjee, a Director and office manager in the Detroit Office, responsible for
regional leadership in North America;

Glenn Mercer, a Practice Principal in the Cleveland office responsible for sector
knowledge development globally; and

Snke Bstlein, a principal in the Frankfurt office, responsible for the Project
Engineering, Contracting and Construction sub-section concentrating on developing
knowledge and expertise to serve clients on such issues as technology management,
engineering, project management, procurement, construction, marketing/sales, and
services.

In addition to these partners, about 200 consultants work on automotive or assembly related
engagements at any given time. Most of these consultants have MBAs (or advanced degrees in
FOR INTERNAL USE ONLY

Renaissance Group International, Inc. (RGI),

495 Wheeler Road, Ashby, MA 01431

978-386-5858

MCKINSEY & COMPANY.: COMPETITIVE VENDOR PROFILE

PAGE 75

Prepared by RGI and by IBM Americas Market Intelligence

economics). Many have had automotive work experience before joining McKinsey, and many
have academic and professional backgrounds in areas relevant to the industry such as physics,
electronics, electrical and mechanical engineering, manufacturing, and finance. McKinsey offices
in Dusseldorf, London, Cleveland, and Paris have industry specialists assigned more or less fulltime to the sector. Each of these specialists is knowledgeable about sources of information on
the industry, contacts that can provide more assistance, and frameworks and approaches
developed within the firm. Additionally, these specialists create and maintain very large
databases of "best practice" and other industry information.
The firm holds regular sector meetings that allow consultants to come together to share
insights from their experiences, to discuss significant developments within the industry worldwide,
and to codify knowledge as it emerges. Internal research projects have included developing
insights on the changing supplier/OEM relationship, on the drivers of mergers and acquisitions in
the industry, and in forecasting the Internet's impact on car retailing. The firm's knowledgebuilding efforts in a variety of fields has led to numerous external publications, including articles
(e.g., in the Economist Intelligence Unit, Automotive Engineer, and Automotive Manufacturing
and Production) and books (e.g., Simplicity Wins, Quality Pays, The Automotive Industry at the
Turn of the Century, and Global Automotive Retailing).
McKinsey supplements its knowledge base with the efforts of research partners, to form a
network of resources available to clients. Recent formal research partners include the Technical
University of Darmstadt and the Technical University of Aachen in Europe, and the University of
Pennsylvania's Wharton School, the University of Michigan, and MIT in the U.S. The firm claims
to be the only consulting firm that is a member of the International Motor Vehicle Program (IMVP)
-- a research group that authored the book, The Machine that Changed the World. The company
draws on these and other resources to help solve client problems efficiently and effectively.

B. Banking and Securities


The Banking and Securities Practice works with clients in commercial banking, investment
banking/brokerage, asset management, diversified financial institutions, consumer finance, and
other financial services to make lasting improvements to their performance. McKinsey organizes
its practice around three major centers:

Europe -- The European Banking and Insurance practice area assists clients in four
interest groups: Asset Management, Insurance, Retail Banking, and Wholesale
Banking.

North America -- The North American Banking and Securities Practice similarly has
four interest groups: Asset Management, Investment and Wholesale Banking,
Payments/E-Commerce, and Retail Banking/Consumer Credit.

Emerging Markets -- Emerging Markets works with clients in Africa, Asia, Eastern
Europe, Latin America, and the Middle East and covers a wide variety of
banking/securities and insurance topics.
FOR INTERNAL USE ONLY

Renaissance Group International, Inc. (RGI),

495 Wheeler Road, Ashby, MA 01431

978-386-5858

MCKINSEY & COMPANY.: COMPETITIVE VENDOR PROFILE

PAGE 76

Prepared by RGI and by IBM Americas Market Intelligence

The Banking and Securities Practice works closely with the Insurance Practice to build and
share knowledge.

C. Chemicals
McKinsey's Chemicals Practice serves the chemicals industry across all functional areas.
The firm focuses on such areas as strategy, operations, innovation, and technology management
and covers all major regions worldwide. The company provides specialized research support and
thought leadership on issues associated with both basic commodity chemicals and specialty
sectors.
The focus and scope of McKinsey's Chemicals Practice includes the following:

Corporate and business unit evaluations and strategy formulations;


Targeting, optimizing, and timing investments to maximize shareholder value;
Operations effectiveness and organization, marketing and pricing; and
Strategy and skills development.

Many of McKinsey's consultants in this practice have prior chemical industry experience, and
most have academic backgrounds in chemical engineering, chemistry, materials science, or
physics. The firm conducts research in a variety of areas such as the ongoing restructuring of the
industry, operational excellence, and radical new models for success in chemicals.
McKinsey's Chemicals Practice serves a large variety of chemical companies, from traditional
industry leaders to aggressive new competitors. Client businesses range from petrochemical
companies to those producing a range of specialty products. Due to a restructuring of the
chemical industry, large new players in the market have hired McKinsey to assist in their efforts to
succeed under changing market and environmental conditions. The company's chemicals
practice operates under a global structure, with teams comprised of consultants from the U.S.,
Europe, and Asia to reflect the different management and work cultures within the industry.

D. Consumer/Packaged Goods
McKinsey's Consumer/Packaged Goods Practice helps clients address a full range of
strategic, organizational, and operational issues that impact the industry both regionally and
worldwide. The company organizes its practice into groups in North America and Europe in an
effort to deliver a better understanding of local markets. Over the past three years, McKinsey
claims its Consumer/Packaged Goods practice has served 17 of the top 30 companies in this
industry, focusing on segments such as food and beverage, personal care, household products,
and consumer durables.

FOR INTERNAL USE ONLY

Renaissance Group International, Inc. (RGI),

495 Wheeler Road, Ashby, MA 01431

978-386-5858

MCKINSEY & COMPANY.: COMPETITIVE VENDOR PROFILE

PAGE 77

Prepared by RGI and by IBM Americas Market Intelligence

The New Jersey Office (NJO) is a leader in McKinsey's Northeastern U.S. Consumer
Practice, which includes its packaged goods, retail and media groups. Its clients span a broad
consumer spectrum, from traditional packaged goods companies to over-the-counter divisions of
large pharmaceutical companies, to specialty retailers and grocers. While the majority of these
clients are multi-national corporations, almost all are headquartered in New Jersey, New York or
Connecticut, approximately 30-40 minutes from the NJO.
The European Practice covers the following functional areas:

Corporate finance and strategy;


Growth;
Marketing;
Customer management;
Operations;
Total organizational performance; and
E-commerce.

E. Electric Power and Natural Gas


The Electric Power and Natural Gas Practice assists clients in these markets who are looking
to move beyond their 'traditional' roles through globalization, growth and mergers, acquisitions
and alliances. McKinsey continues to serve three main industry areas:

Electric power;
Downstream natural gas; and
Water utilities.

The practice's extensive experience in industry restructuring has fostered an understanding


of the dynamics of deregulation, and the implications it has, and will continue to have, for the
firm's clients. In addition, the practice has worked in all regions on strategic projects that include
the search for opportunities and investment evaluations, building on the company's extensive
experience in the electric power and natural gas industries.

F. High Tech
McKinsey's global High Tech Practice serves a variety of clients from small, pre-IPO startup
firms, to venture capital firms, to traditional players in the industry, as well as industry attackers.
The company serves large and leading-edge high technology clients on a diverse range of issues
that include strategy, organization, sales and marketing, and operations effectiveness. The
Practice is composed of six groups:

FOR INTERNAL USE ONLY

Renaissance Group International, Inc. (RGI),

495 Wheeler Road, Ashby, MA 01431

978-386-5858

MCKINSEY & COMPANY.: COMPETITIVE VENDOR PROFILE

PAGE 78

Prepared by RGI and by IBM Americas Market Intelligence

Semiconductors and components;


Software and services;
Computing and datacom hardware;
Consumer electronics;
Industrial electronics; and
Aerospace and defense.

McKinsey's global Aerospace & Defense Practice, which includes over 75 professionals
worldwide, is divided into commercial, military, and civil sectors. Over the past five years, the firm
has served 20 of the top 25 U.S. and European companies in such areas as aircrafts, missiles,
military vehicles, space vehicles, satellites, defense electronics, avionics, and navigation
equipment.

G. Insurance
The goal of McKinsey's Insurance Practice is to effect positive significant results on the firm's
clients by impacting their strategy, operations, and performance. McKinsey's Insurance Practice
addresses all segments of the industry, including property-casualty, life and annuities,
supplemental health, and reinsurance. In addition, the company covers segments that provide
asset management and other financial services. McKinsey offers expertise in all areas specific to
risk and asset management, including claims management, underwriting, pricing, distribution, IT,
operations effectiveness, and investment.
McKinseys insurance business is organized on a regional basis, with practices focused on
Europe, North America, and Asia-Pacific. The practice works closely with McKinsey's Banking &
Securities Practice to build and share knowledge between the practices.

H. Media and Entertainment


McKinsey's Media and Entertainment Practice serves global and regional companies involved
in radio and television broadcast; cable; information services; commercial and electronic
magazine and book publishing; advertising; motion pictures; newspapers; and recorded music.
The practice also concentrates in other areas of entertainment including gambling, sports
organizations, and theme parks.
The practice offers a broad base of experience across Europe, North America, Latin America,
and Asia-Pacific in both strategic and operational issues. In addition, McKinsey offers specialized
expertise in five key areas:

Newspapers including editorial customization, building ad sales and strengthening


circulation;
FOR INTERNAL USE ONLY

Renaissance Group International, Inc. (RGI),

495 Wheeler Road, Ashby, MA 01431

978-386-5858

MCKINSEY & COMPANY.: COMPETITIVE VENDOR PROFILE

PAGE 79

Prepared by RGI and by IBM Americas Market Intelligence

Cable TV, including high-speed data service;

Broadcasting, including video technologies and HDTV;

Music, including competitive analysis, new technologies and distribution channels;


and

Online, including content creators, pipeline companies, and purchasers.

Projects conducted by McKinsey consultants address such areas as competitive threats; the
emergence of competing technologies such as satellite, cable and the Internet; content and
product availability; the cost of new product development; and regulation. In addition, the
company conducts projects on advertising in both traditional media and the Internet.

I. Metals and Mining


The Metals and Mining Practice works with clients on a diverse range of global issues.
These include strategic choices faced by mining companies, paths and directional options
encountered by certain players or segments, and the growth and transformation of mature steel
companies.
The Practice covers three major sectors:

The steel industry;


The non-ferrous industry including aluminum, zinc, copper and lead; and
The mining sector.

McKinsey segments its Metals and Mining Practice into two competence centers: the
European center, which is focused on metals; and the Mining Competence Center, located in
Johannesburg, which focuses on mining issues.

J. Nonprofit
McKinsey created its Nonprofit Practice in the summer of 2000 to have an impact in the firm's
external communities and internal groups. The practice's mission is to have "extraordinary"
impact in communities worldwide, through efforts that will shape the nonprofit sector and excite,
inspire, and develop McKinsey staff as a core part of their McKinsey experience.

K. Payor/Provider
FOR INTERNAL USE ONLY

Renaissance Group International, Inc. (RGI),

495 Wheeler Road, Ashby, MA 01431

978-386-5858

MCKINSEY & COMPANY.: COMPETITIVE VENDOR PROFILE

PAGE 80

Prepared by RGI and by IBM Americas Market Intelligence

The Payor/Provider Practice works with healthcare industry clients on issues of strategy,
organization, and operational effectiveness issues. The practice addresses two basic segments:

Payors, such as HMOs, group health insurers, or sickness funds; and

Providers, such as hospitals and hospital systems, rehabilitation clinics, physician


networks, and group purchasers.

The company conducts the following types of projects in this industry:

Developing revised strategies and organizations for regional managed care


organizations;

Consolidating health maintenance organizations;

Charting strategies for pharmaceutical benefit managers;

Revising strategies for physician practice management companies;

Assessing mergers, acquisitions and alliances of hospitals; and

Evaluating hospital purchase practices, such as group purchasing, to improve


hospital supply management.

The global practice operates regional centers in Europe and North America with extensive
experience in the U.S., Europe, Japan, Australia, and in emerging markets such as China, India,
Southeast Asia, and Latin America. The practice's professionals have access to internal and
external experts and information, and maintain extensive knowledge development activities,
research collections, and proprietary databases on industry economics and structure. The firm
has established, through client experience and knowledge resources, a range of insights about
where to compete and how to compete in the changing healthcare industry.
The company takes a broad view of healthcare delivery, analyzing the field from a variety of
points while handling a diverse set of issues. Local McKinsey offices handle a large portion of the
projects in this industry segment.

L. Petroleum
McKinsey's Petroleum Practice serves clients within all areas of the oil industry, from
upstream activities such as exploration, drilling, production, and services, through transportation
and refining, to wholesale and retail marketing. The company organizes its practice around
subsectors including the following:

Corporate center;
FOR INTERNAL USE ONLY

Renaissance Group International, Inc. (RGI),

495 Wheeler Road, Ashby, MA 01431

978-386-5858

MCKINSEY & COMPANY.: COMPETITIVE VENDOR PROFILE

PAGE 81

Prepared by RGI and by IBM Americas Market Intelligence

Exploration and production;


Marketing;
Petrochemicals; and
Refining.

The company further enhances its subsector perspectives through the activities of
McKinsey's Knowledge Colleges and service offerings, such as an annual Upstream
Benchmarking survey. The practice is currently addressing oil company performance analyses,
the industry's recent merger and acquisition activities, and "new" techniques for valuing oil
company assets.

M. Pharmaceuticals and Medical Products


McKinsey's Pharmaceuticals and Medical Products (PMP) Practice serves clients through
two geographical practices: the North American PMP and the European PMP. The firm claims to
have 350 core consultants with significant healthcare experience and includes more than 100
medical doctors and 150 PhDs in various medical fields. The North American PMP Practice
focuses on the "business of medicine," which includes the following areas:

Licensing/alliances;
Mergers and acquisitions;
R&D/pipeline analysis;
Competition and competitive analysis; and
Market size and growth.

The practice focuses on the following market segments:

Prescription drugs;
Over-the-counter (OTC) drugs and medical products;
Medical devices, equipment, supplies and in vitro diagnostics (laboratory tests);
Biotechnology for medical purposes; and
Veterinary medicine.

McKinsey locates its North American Pharmaceuticals and Medical Products practice in its
New Jersey office. This location is within a one-hour drive from the worldwide headquarters of 11
of the world's 20 largest pharmaceutical companies, as well as many important medical products
companies and high tech startups. The practice serves many of the world's leading makers of
prescription pharmaceuticals, medical/surgical devices, biotechnology products, and over-thecounter medicines. The office also serves a number of payor and provider organizations located
in the region. The company operates a Pharmaceuticals/Medical Products Resource Center from
the New Jersey office, which includes a state-of-the-art library and an Internet-based research
lab. In addition, practice leaders and industry experts work from the facility.

FOR INTERNAL USE ONLY

Renaissance Group International, Inc. (RGI),

495 Wheeler Road, Ashby, MA 01431

978-386-5858

MCKINSEY & COMPANY.: COMPETITIVE VENDOR PROFILE

PAGE 82

Prepared by RGI and by IBM Americas Market Intelligence

The practice has worked on a variety of projects, including major mergers of pharmaceutical
companies, global launches of new breakthrough products, development of forward-looking
research and development strategies, and corporate-wide turnaround programs. The practice
also addresses special projects to enhance the firm's knowledge in areas ranging from genomics
to the impact of mergers and acquisitions on the pharmaceutical industry.
The European PMP Practice focuses on many of the same market segments that include
ethical and OTC pharmaceutical companies; medical equipment, devices and supplies;
diagnostics; biotechnology; and the animal health industries. In addition, the practice works with
clients to address such issues as research and development/pipeline, licensing/alliances,
manufacturing, sales and marketing, registration, mergers and acquisitions, and legal
environmental analysis.
The Payor/Provider Practice, which addresses healthcare issues, complements the
Pharmaceuticals and Medical Products (PMP) Practice with information regarding healthcare
utilization, incidence of diseases and conditions, and related topics.

N. Pulp and Paper


McKinsey's global Pulp and Paper Practice supports client activities in several areas, as
follows:

Forestry, including genetics, nursery, valuation and logging;

Pulp, paper and allied products, meeting the needs of producers, converters, and
traders;

Printing, including books, newspapers, and periodicals;

Fiber-based and fiber composites packaging;

Lumber and wood products, meeting the requirements of sawmills as well as


producers and traders of lumber, plywood and engineered wood products, veneer,
flooring, and firewood;

Chemicals and minerals including producers dedicated to the forest products


industry; and

Machinery and equipment meeting the requirements of suppliers dedicated to


equipment for pulp and paper, sawmills, and forest operations.

O. Retail
FOR INTERNAL USE ONLY

Renaissance Group International, Inc. (RGI),

495 Wheeler Road, Ashby, MA 01431

978-386-5858

MCKINSEY & COMPANY.: COMPETITIVE VENDOR PROFILE

PAGE 83

Prepared by RGI and by IBM Americas Market Intelligence

McKinsey's Retail Practice is based in North America and serves clients worldwide.
According to McKinsey, the North American Retail Practice serves more than one-third of the top
100 global retailers and more than one-half of the top 25 retailers in the U.S. The company
supports clients within the following four industry groups:

General merchandise manufacturing including textiles, apparel, footwear, toys,


furniture and home decor;

General merchandise retail including department stores, discounters, national chains,


specialty stores, "do-it-yourself" stores, superstores, drugstores, and supercenters;

Grocery/food wholesale and retail such as supermarkets, wholesalers, convenience


stores, warehouse clubs, liquor stores, and related service providers; and

Food service, hospitality and leisure facilities including hotels and resorts,
gaming/casinos, sports, fast-food and table service restaurants, home meal
replacement stores, and catering.

"Racing for the World" is a global initiative launched by the McKinsey Retail Practice to
examine how forces in the new economy are reshaping the industry and to determine what steps
retailers can take to prosper in the changing environment.
The mission of McKinsey's Retail Practice is to help clients make positive, lasting, and
substantial improvements in their performance. The firm's problem solving approach combines
an integrated total business perspective with fact-based analyses, resulting in new approaches to
tackling business problems. McKinsey's Retail Practice has six service lines, geared to meeting
the specific issues of the retail marketplace:

Strategy & growth;

Marketing & customer experience;

E-commerce;

Operational effectiveness;

Organization; and

Merchandising.

Consultants in these services work with other McKinsey practices to find high-impact
solutions to retail challenges. The firm seeks out ways to sharpen retail performance through
client engagements, practice development efforts, and joint projects with industry associations.
McKinsey works with leading general merchandise, apparel and footwear retailers, and
manufacturers. Its retail clients include department stores, discounters, drugstores, category
FOR INTERNAL USE ONLY

Renaissance Group International, Inc. (RGI),

495 Wheeler Road, Ashby, MA 01431

978-386-5858

MCKINSEY & COMPANY.: COMPETITIVE VENDOR PROFILE

PAGE 84

Prepared by RGI and by IBM Americas Market Intelligence

killers, specialty stores, catalogers, and pure play e-tailers. The firm also serves top apparel and
footwear vendors, textile mills, and other companies who directly supply the retail industry. The
firm believes that its perspective and expertise helps clients meet the challenges posed by the
changing environment.
The Retail Practice also serves leading global, national and regional food retailers,
wholesalers, and distributors on a variety of issues. The firm has contributed to industry
knowledge through presentations to and joint projects with the Food Marketing Institute, the
International Food Distributors Association, and the Grocery Manufacturers of America. The
firm's position on the implications of grocery consolidation, the economics of home meal
replacement, and other issues has been reported in many industry publications, including
Supermarket News and Nation's Restaurant News.
McKinsey serves top national and regional companies across the food service sector. The
firm has created and built new businesses for both incumbents and new entrants, and it has
improved and turned around existing businesses. McKinsey recently published a major work on
achieving profitable growth in the food service industry, with insights into management models,
labor productivity issues, and concept-renewal drivers. The firm is building on those findings
through an industry-sponsored project called Foodservice 2010.

P. Telecommunications
The global Telecommunications Practice serves a diverse set of clients including incumbents
and new entrants. These range from larger, more established companies that are re-positioning
themselves in a fast-changing environment to smaller, fast-growing companies looking to
capitalize on industry changes such as deregulation, licensing, and voice and data convergence.
McKinsey positions the practice as offering "cutting edge" wireline and wireless expertise that
actively supports both service providers and manufacturers, as well as investors, governments
and agencies, and regulatory bodies. McKinsey has conducted over 1,000 engagements within
the telecommunications industry over the past five years, serving 18 of the top 20
telecommunications service providers and 8 of the top 10 equipment suppliers worldwide. The
head of the company's North American Telecommunications Practice is located in the Stamford
Office.
The company's projects span a range of issues across businesses, customer segments, and
geographies. McKinseys telecommunications consultants assess various technologies including
mobile and satellite systems; business lines, including equipment and local, long distance, and
data/Internet services; and functional areas including strategy, operations, and organization.
McKinsey organizes the practice into three separate entities -- the Americas, European, and
Asia/Pacific -- with each division focused on helping clients deal with a variety of localized and
global telecommunications issues. The practice concentrates on issues relating to the following
topics:

Organization, such as restructuring, skill building, and decision-making processes;


FOR INTERNAL USE ONLY

Renaissance Group International, Inc. (RGI),

495 Wheeler Road, Ashby, MA 01431

978-386-5858

MCKINSEY & COMPANY.: COMPETITIVE VENDOR PROFILE

PAGE 85

Prepared by RGI and by IBM Americas Market Intelligence

Operations, such as capital investment, cost reductions, networks and logistics; and
Strategy, including mission, sales, profits, and procurement.

The company positions its practice as providing a global perspective, stressing its network of
international offices and extensive experience to provide local knowledge to clients worldwide.
The Telecommunications Practice has developed working relationships with related practices and
teams, including the High Technology and e-Commerce practices and the BTOs.

Q. Transportation
McKinsey's Transportation Practice focuses on the transport of people and goods, covering
the full range of transportation sub-sectors, as follows:

Airlines and airports, including alliances, cargo, crew relations, e-commerce, fleet
management and maintenance, loyalty programs, and service design;

Railroads, serving both passenger and freight concerns on matters such as growth
strategies, e-commerce, equipment, labor, maintenance, and performance;

Trucking, forwarding and logistics, addressing third and fourth party logistics, IT,
rates, supply chain, and warehousing;

Shipping and ports, working on issues such as cargo, fleet management, freight
management, forwarding, passenger relations, and operations;

Post and parcel, concentrating on delivery, market dynamics, operations,


organization, and strategic development;

Urban transport, including costs, maintenance, management, privatization,


organizations, operations, policy, systems, and suppliers; and

Travel and tourism, offering regional and global perspectives to hotels and
destinations, tour operators, and travel agencies.

The company addresses transportation manufacturing issues within McKinsey's Auto and
Assembly Practice.

FOR INTERNAL USE ONLY

Renaissance Group International, Inc. (RGI),

495 Wheeler Road, Ashby, MA 01431

978-386-5858

You might also like