You are on page 1of 61

SuitNo.

D/73/15
30.3.2015
Present:

Sh.D.S.Mehtacounselforpetitioner.
NoneforR1&2.
Sh.M.P.ShahicounselforR3.
CounselforR3hasfiledvakalatanama.
FiletakenuptodayonanapplicationfiledonbehalfofpetitionerandR3

forsettlement.
Matterhasbeenamicablysettledbetweenpetitionersthroughtheircounsel
andinsurancecompanyforasumofRs.3,40,000/(Rs.ThreeLacsFortyThousandonly).
Statementofcounselforpetitionersandcounselforinsurancecompanyrecordedinthis
regard.
Videseparateorder,awardpassed.
Insurance company shall file compliance report in the court alongwith
proofofdepositofawardamount,thenoticeofdepositandthecalculationofinterest.
MainfilebeconsignedtoRR.
Thedate20.04.2015standscancelled.
(MOHINDERVIRAT)
Judge/MACT1,NewDelhi
30.3.2015

INTHECOURTOFSH.MOHINDERVIRAT,JUDGE/MACT1,
NEWDELHI
MEMOOFPARTIES
SUIRNO.D/43/15
30.3.2015
Shri.ArizMalik
S/oSH.MahmoodMalik,
R/OI18,DDAFlats,TurkmaanGate,
NEWDELHI

PETITIONER
VS

1. Sh.Vikas
S/OSH.HariPrakash
R/OH.No.67/19,ShantiVihar
Sonepat,Haryana
2. UNITEDINDIAINSURANCECOMPANYLTD.
8thFloor,KanchaJungaBuilding,
BKRoad,Delhi.
RESPONDENTS
AWARD
MatterhasbeenamicablysettledbetweeninjuredandUnitedIndia
InsuranceCompanyLtd.forasumofRs.12,000/(Rs.Twelve Thousandonly).
StatementofShri.ArizMalik,injuredandSh.RaviSabharwal,Ld.counselfor
insurancecompanyrecordedinthisregard.
In view of the statement of the parties an award in the sum of
Rs.12,000/(Rs.TwelveThousandonly)ispassedinfavouroftheclaimantinfull
and final settlement of her claim in this Detailed Accident Report(DAR)

pertainingtoFIRNo.238/15,underSection279/337IPC,PSMandirMarg.The
award amount is payable by Insurance company to the claimant and will be
inclusiveofinterimaward,ifany,alreadypassed.
TheInsurancecompanyshalldeposittheawardamountbycrossed
cheque/draftinthenameoftheclaimantwithin30daysofthepassingoftheaward
failingwhichitisliabletopayinterestattherateof12%perannumfortheperiod
ofdelay.Theentireamountbereleasedtotheclaimant.
Insurance company shall inform the petitioners through registered
postthatthechequesoftheawardedamountarebeingdepositedsoastofacilitate
thepetitionerstocollecthercheque.
Anattestedcopyoftheawardbegiventotheparties.
FilebeconsignedtoRecordsafterduecompliance.

(MOHINDERVIRAT)

Judge/MACT1,NewDelhi
30.3.2015

INTHECOURTOFSH.MOHINDERVIRAT,JUDGE/MACT1,
NEWDELHI
MEMOOFPARTIES
SUIRNO.D/12/15
30.3.2015
Shri.AmitKumar
S/oSH.JainSingh,
R/OVillageBeri,
DisttJhajjar
Haryana

PETITIONER
VS

3. Sh.M/SNipaChemicalsLtd.
19B.P,Neelam,BataRoad
Faridabad.

4. MamanSingh,
S/oSh.S.CYadav
R/oWZ57,Todapur,NewDelhi
IffcoTokioGeneralInsurance
4th&5thFloor
IffcoTower,PlotNo.3,Sec29,Gurgaon.
RESPONDENTS
AWARD
MatterhasbeenamicablysettledbetweeninjuredandUnitedIndia
Insurance Company Ltd. for a sum of Rs.40,000/(Rs. Forty Thousand only).
StatementofShri.YogeshKumar,counselforinjured,andSh.J.P.NShahi,Ld.

counselforinsurancecompanyrecordedinthisregard.
In view of the statement of the parties an award in the sum of
Rs.40,000/(Rs.FortyThousandonly)ispassedinfavouroftheclaimantinfull
and final settlement of her claim in this Detailed Accident Report(DAR)
pertainingtoFIRNo.296/14,underSection279/338IPC,PSMandirMarg.The
award amount is payable by Insurance company to the claimant and will be
inclusiveofinterimaward,ifany,alreadypassed.
TheInsurancecompanyshalldeposittheawardamountbycrossed
cheque/draftinthenameoftheclaimantwithin30daysofthepassingoftheaward
failingwhichitisliabletopayinterestattherateof12%perannumfortheperiod
ofdelay.Theentireamountbereleasedtotheclaimant.
Insurance company shall inform the petitioners through registered
postthatthechequesoftheawardedamountarebeingdepositedsoastofacilitate
thepetitionerstocollecthercheque.
Anattestedcopyoftheawardbegiventotheparties.
FilebeconsignedtoRecordsafterduecompliance.

(MOHINDERVIRAT)

Judge/MACT1,NewDelhi
30.3.2015

SuitNo.D12/15
30.03.2015
Present:

Sh.YogeshKumar,counselforinjured.
Nonefordriverandowner.
Sh.J.P.NShahi,Ld.counselforinsurancecompany.
Matter has been amicably settled between injured and Iffco

Tokio General Insurance company for a sum of Rs.40,000/(Rs.Forty


Thousandonly).StatementofSh.YogeshKumar,Ld.Counselforinjured
and Sh.J.P.N Shahi, Ld. counsel for insurance company recorded in this
regard.
Videseparateorderawardpassed.
FilebeconsignedtoRecordsafterduecompliance.
(MOHINDERVIRAT)
Judge/MACT1,NewDelhi
30.03.2015

SuitNo.D43/15
30.03.2015
Present:

InjuredSh.ArizMalikinperson.
Nonefordriverandowner.
Sh.RaviSabharwal,Ld.counselforinsurancecompany.
MatterhasbeenamicablysettledbetweeninjuredandUnited

India Insurance Company Ltd. for a sum of Rs.12,000/(Rs. Twelve


Thousand only). Statement of Injured Sh. Ariz Malik, and Sh. Ravi
Sabharwal,Ld.counselforinsurancecompanyrecordedinthisregard.
Videseparateorderawardpassed.
FilebeconsignedtoRecordsafterduecompliance.
(MOHINDERVIRAT)
Judge/MACT1,NewDelhi
30.03.2015

INTHECOURTOFSH.MOHINDERVIRAT,JUDGE/MACT1,
NEWDELHI
MEMOOFPARTIES
SUITNO.D/73/15
1. SMT.CHANDERKALIKASHYAP
W/OSH.SHAMBHUKASHYAP
2. SH.SHAMBHUKASHYAP
S/OSH.SARJUKASHYAP
BOTHR/OH.NO.77,MILPARA,VILLAGELIMHI
TEH.TAKHATPUR,DISTT.BILASPUR,M.P.
PRESENTLYATH.NO.A98,SANJAYCAMP
CHANAKYAPURI,NEWDELHI.

.....................PETITIONERS
V/s
1. SH.RAJKUMAR
S/OSH.LILADHAR
R/OSHAHPURMADRAK
PSMADRAK,DISTT.ALIGARH,UP.
2. ISCKONFOODRELIEFFOUNDATION
R/OKHASRANO.284,ALIVIHAR
OPP.BARATGHAR,SARITAVIHAR
NEWDELHI.
3. FUTUREGENERALIINDIAINSURANCECOMPANYLTD.
303TO310,3RDFLOOR
KAILASHBUILDING,26,K.G.MARG
NEWDELHI110001.
.............RESPONDENTS
AWARD
Matterhasbeenamicablysettledbetweenpetitionersthroughtheir
counselandFurtureGeneraliIndiaInsuranceCo.Ltd.forasumofRs.3,40,000/

(Rs.ThreeLacsForty Thousand only).StatementofSh.D.S.Mehta,counselfor


petitioners and Sh.M.P.Shahi counsel for insurance company recorded in this
regard.
InviewofthestatementofthepartiesanawardinthesumofRs.
3,40,000/(Rs.Three Lacs Forty Thousand only) is passed in favour of the
claimantsinfullandfinalsettlementoftheirclaiminthisDARarisingoutofFIR
No.46/15,u/s279/304AIPC,PSChanakyaPuri.Theawardamountispayableby
Insurancecompanytotheclaimantandwillbeinclusiveofinterimaward,ifany,
alreadypassed.
TheInsurancecompanyshalldeposittheawardamountdirectlyin
bankaccountoftheclaimantatUCOBank,PatialaHouseCourt,NewDelhiwithin
30daysofthepassingoftheawardfailingwhichitisliabletopayinterestatthe
rateof12%perannumfortheperiodofdelay.Theawardamountbedivided
equallybetweenpetitionerno.1/fatherandpetitionerno.2/motherofdeceased.The
entireawardamountbereleasedinfavourofpetitioners.
The bank shall transfer savings account to any other branch/bank
according to their convenience. The claimant shall furnish all the relevant
documentsforopeningoftheSavingBankAccounttoSeniorManagerofUCO
Bank,PatialaHouseCourtBranch,NewDelhi.Nazirtoreportincasethecheque
isnotdepositedwithin30daysofthepassingoftheaward/judgment.Naziris
directedtonotetheparticularsoftheawardamountintheregistertodayitself.
Thepetitionersshallfiletwosetsofphotographsalongwiththeir
specimensignatures,outofwhichonesettobesenttotheNodalOfficer,UCO

Bank,PatialaHouseCourtComplex,NewDelhialongwithcopyoftheawardby
Nazir and the second set be retained to the court for further reference. The
photographsbestampedandsenttothebank.Thepetitionersshallalsofilethe
proofofresidenceandfurnishthedetailsofthebankaccountwiththeNazirwithin
aweek.Thepetitionersshallfiletheircompleteaddressaswelladdressoftheir
counselforsendingthenoticeofdepositoftheawardamount.
Theinsurancecompanyshalldeposittheawardamountalongwith
interestuptothedateofnoticeofdeposittotheclaimantswithacopytotheir
counselandthecompliancereportshallbefiledinthecourtalongwithproofof
depositofawardamount,thenoticeofdepositandthecalculationofintereston
30.4.2015.
Anattestedcopyoftheawardbegiventotheparties.
FilebeconsignedtoRecordRoom.

(MohinderVirat)
Judge/MACT,NewDelhi
30.3.2015

INTHECOURTOFSH.MOHINDERVIRAT,JUDGE/MACT
NEWDELHI
MEMOOFPARTIES

SUITNO.207/14
1.SMT.MUNNIDEVI
W/OLATESH.PARMESHWARJHA
2.SH.DIWAKARKUMAR
S/OLATESH.PARMESHWARJHA
3.SH.PRABHAKARKUMARJHA
S/OLATESH.PARMESHWARJHA
4.SH.SHUBHAKARKUMARJHA
S/OLATESH.PARMESHWARJHA
ALLR/O143/9,NEARGAUSHALAMANDIR
MEHRAULIKISHANGARH,SOUTHWEST
DELHI110070.
ALSOAT
GHARBANDHASURENDRASINGHTOLA
TOWN/VILLAGEBAGULAHA
ANCHAL/THANARANIGANJ
DISTT.ARARIA,BIHAR.
VS
1.SH.DEVINDERSINGH
S/OSH.JASWANTSINGH
R/OH.NO.360,POL.NO.97
HOLICHOWK,VILLAGEBHARTHAL
DLHI110077.
2.SMT.RANI
W/OSH.DAVINDERSINGH
R/OH.NO.360,POL.NO.97
HOLICHOWK,VILLAGEBHARTHAL
DLHI110077.
3.M/SUNITEDINDIAINSURANCECO.LTD.
46,BASANTLOK,VASANTVIHAR
SOUTHWESTDELHI110057.

PETITIONER

RESPONDENT

AWARD
Matterhasbeenamicablysettledbetweenpetitionersthroughtheir
counselandUnited IndiaIns.Co.Ltd.forasumofRs.13,50,000/(Rs.Thirteen
LacsFiftyThousand only).StatementofSh.ManojGoel,counselforpetitioners
andSh.RaviSabharwalcounselforinsurancecompanyrecordedinthisregard.
InviewofthestatementofthepartiesanawardinthesumofRs.
13,50,000/(Rs.Thirteen Lacs Fifty Thousand only) is passed in favour of the
claimantsinfullandfinalsettlementoftheirclaiminthispetitionu/s166and140
MVAct.TheawardamountispayablebyInsurancecompanytotheclaimantand
willbeinclusiveofinterimaward,ifany,alreadypassed.
Inviewof SarlaVermaandOrs.vsDelhiTransportCorporation
andAnother(2009)6SCC121majorchildrenofdeceasedi.e.petitionersno.2to
4cannotbeconsideredasdependentondeceasedandonlypetitionerno.1/wife
shallbeconsideredasdependent. Hencetheentireawardamountisgrantedin
favourofpetitionerno.1/wife.
Forsafeguardingthecompensationamountfrombeingfritteredaway
by the claimants, directions have been given by Hon'ble Supreme Court for
preservingtheawardamountinthecaseofJaiPrakashVs.NationalInsurance
Co.Ltd.andOthers(2010)2SupremeCourtCases607.Inviewofthedirections
containedintheabovejudgmentstheawardamountistobedisbursedasfollows:
1. OutoftheawardamountofRs.13,50,000/(Rs.ThirteenLacsFiftyThousand),
asumofRs.3,50,000/(Rs.ThreeLacsFiftyThousand)bereleasedinfavour
of petitioner no.1/wife by transferring it into her savings account and

remainingamountbekeptinFDRinUCOBank,PatialaHouseCourt,New
Delhiforaperiodoftenyears.
2. ThechequebedepositedinUCOBank,PatialaHouseCourt,NewDelhiin
the name of UCO Bank, Patiala House Court, New Delhi A/c Smt.Munni
Devi.
3. Theinterestonthefixeddepositsshallbepaidmonthlybyautomaticcreditin
thesavingaccountsoftheclaimant/beneficiary.
4. OriginalfixeddepositreceiptshallberetainedbytheBankinsafecustody.
However,theoriginalpassbookshallbegiventotheclaimantalongwiththe
photocopy of the FDR. Upon the expiry of period ofFDR the bank shall
automaticallycreditthematurityamountinthesavingaccountofbeneficiary.
5. Theoriginalfixeddepositreceiptshallbehandedovertotheclaimantatthe
end ofthe fixed deposit period and shallautomatically creditthe maturity
amountinthesavingsaccountofthebeneficiary.
6. Nocheque bookshallbeissued to the claimantwithoutpermissionofthe
court.Noloan,advanceorwithdrawalshallbeallowedonthefixeddeposit
withoutpermissionofthecourt.
7. Withdrawalfromtheaforesaidaccountsshallbepermittedtothebeneficiary
after due verification and the Bank shall issue photo identity card to the
beneficiarytofacilitateidentity.
8. BankshalltransferSavingsAccounttoanyotherbranch/bankaccordingtoher
convenience.

9. Thebeneficiaryshallfurnishalltherelevantdocumentsforopeningofthe
SavingBankAccountandFixedDeposittoSeniorManagerofUCOBank,
PatialaHouseCourt,NewDelhi.
10.Nazir to reportin case the cheque is notdeposited within 30 days ofthe
passingoftheaward/judgment.Nazirisdirectedtonotetheparticularsofthe
awardamountintheregistertodayitself.
11.The Insurance company shall deposit the award amount directly in bank
accountofthepetitionerno.1atUCOBank,PatialaHouseCourt,NewDelhi
within30daysofthepassingoftheawardfailingwhichitisliabletopay
interestattherateof12%perannumfortheperiodofdelay.
12.Thepetitionerno.1shallfiletwosetsofphotographsalongwithherspecimen
signatures,outofwhichonesettobesenttotheNodalOfficer,UCOBank,
PatialaHouseCourt,NewDelhialongwithcopyoftheawardbyNazirand
thesecondsetberetainedtothecourtforfurtherreference.Thephotographs
bestampedandsenttothebank.Thepetitionerno.1shallalsofiletheproofof
residenceandfurnishthedetailsofthebankaccountwiththeNazirwithina
week.Thepetitionerno.1shallfilehercompleteaddressaswellasaddressof
hercounselforsendingthenoticeofdepositoftheawardamount.
Theinsurancecompanyshalldeposittheawardamountalongwith
interestuptothedateofnoticeofdeposittotheclaimantwithacopytohercounsel
andthecompliancereportshallbefiledinthecourtalongwithproofofdepositof
awardamount,thenoticeofdepositandthecalculationofintereston30.4.2015.

Anattestedcopyoftheawardbegiventotheparties.
FilebeconsignedtoRecordRoom.

(MohinderVirat)
Judge/MACT,NewDelhi

30.3.2015


SuitNo.207/14
30.3.2015
Present:

Sh.ManojGoelcounselforpetitioner.
NoneforR1&2.
Sh.RaviSabharwalcounselforR3.
Matterhasbeenamicablysettledbetweenpetitionersthroughtheircounsel

andinsurancecompanyforasumofRs.13,50,000/(Rs.ThirteenLacsFiftyThousand
only).Statementofcounselforpetitionersandcounselforinsurancecompanyrecorded
inthisregard.
Videseparateorder,awardpassed.
Insurance company shall file compliance report in the court alongwith
proofofdepositofawardamount,thenoticeofdepositandthecalculationofinterest.
MainfilebeconsignedtoRR.
Nazirtoputupforcomplianceon30.4.2015.
(MOHINDERVIRAT)
Judge/MACT1,NewDelhi
30.3.2015

D/73/15
STATEMENTOFSH.D.S.MEHTACOUNSELFORPETITIONERS.
ATBAR

Onbehalfofpetitioners,Ihaveenteredintoacompromise

with insurance company for a sum of Rs.3,40,000/(Rs.Three Lacs


Forty Thousand only) in full and final settlement of claim of
claimantsinthisDARarisingoutofFIRNo.46/15,u/s279/304AIPC,
PS Chanakya Puri. A Decree/Award be passed in terms of the
settlement.
Ithasbeenagreedthatinsurancecompanyshalldepositthe
saidamountdirectlyinbankaccountwithinonemonthfromthedateof
passingoftheawardfailingwhichitisliabletopayinterestattherate
of12%perannumfromthedateoftheDecree/Award.

RO&AC

(MOHINDERVIRAT)
Judge/MACT,NEWDELHI
30.3.2015

D/73/15
STATEMENT OF SH.M.P.SHAHI COUNSEL FOR INSURANCE
COMPANY.
ATBAR
Matter has been settled with claimants through their
counselforasumofRs.3,40,000/(Rs.ThreenLacsForty Thousand
only)infullandfinalsettlementofclaimofclaimantsinthisDAR
arisingoutofFIRNo.46/15,u/s279/304AIPC,PSChanakyaPuri.A
Decree/Awardbepassedintermsofthesettlement.Ithasbeenagreed
thattheinsurancecompanyshalldeposittheawardamountdirectlyin
thebankaccountofpetitionersatUCOBank,PatialaHouseCourt,New
Delhi(asperthedirectionsintheaward)withininonemonthfrom
todayfailingwhichitisliabletopayinterestattherateof12%per
annumfromthedateoftheDecree/Award.
RO&AC

(MOHINDERVIRAT)
Judge/MACT,NewDelhi
30.3.2015

207/14
STATEMENT OF SH.MANOJ GOEL COUNSEL FOR
PETITIONERS.
ATBAR

Onbehalfofpetitioners,Ihaveenteredintoacompromise

withinsurancecompanyforasumofRs.13,50,000/(Rs.ThirteenLacs
FiftyThousandonly)infullandfinalsettlementofclaimofclaimants
inthispetitionu/s166&140ofMVAct.ADecree/Awardbepassedin
termsofthesettlement.
Ithasbeenagreedthatinsurancecompanyshalldepositthe
saidamountdirectlyinbankaccountwithinonemonthfromthedateof
passingoftheawardfailingwhichitisliabletopayinterestattherate
of12%perannumfromthedateoftheDecree/Award.

RO&AC

(MOHINDERVIRAT)
Judge/MACT,NEWDELHI
30.3.2015

207/14
STATEMENT OF SH.RAVI SABHARWAL COUNSEL FOR
INSURANCECOMPANY.
ATBAR
Matter has been settled with claimants through their
counselforasumofRs.13,50,000/(Rs.ThirteenLacsFiftyThousand
only)infullandfinalsettlementofclaimofclaimantsinthispetition
u/s166&140ofMVAct.ADecree/Awardbepassedintermsofthe
settlement.Ithasbeenagreedthattheinsurancecompanyshalldeposit
theawardamountdirectlyinthebankaccountofpetitionersatUCO
Bank,Patiala House Court,New Delhi (as per the directions in the
award)withininonemonthfromtodayfailingwhichitisliabletopay
interest at the rate of 12% per annum from the date of the
Decree/Award.
RO&AC

(MOHINDERVIRAT)
Judge/MACT,NewDelhi
30.3.2015

SuitNo.D/43/15
STATEMENT OF SH.ARIZ MALIK S/O SH.MEHMOOD MALIK
R/OI18,DDAFLATS,TURKMANGATE,DELHI.
ONSA.

Ihaveenteredintoacompromisewithinsurancecompany

forasumofRs.12,000/(Rs.TwelveThousandonly)infullandfinal
settlementofmyclaiminthisDARarisingoutofFIRno.238/14,u/s
279/337IPC,PSMandirMarg.ADecree/Awardbepassedintermsof
thesettlement.
Ithasbeenagreedthatinsurancecompanyshalldepositthe
saidamountdirectlyinthecourtwithinonemonthfromthedateof
passingoftheawardfailingwhichitisliabletopayinterestattherate
of12%perannumfromthedateoftheDecree/Award.

RO&AC

(MOHINDERVIRAT)
Judge/MACT,NEWDELHI
30.3.2015

SuitNo.D/43/15
STATEMENT OF SH.RAVI SABHARWAL COUNSEL FOR
INSURANCECOMPANY.
ATBAR
MatterhasbeensettledwithinjuredSh.ArizMalik fora
sum of Rs.12,000/ (Rs.Twelve Thousand only) in full and final
settlementofclaimofclaimantinthisDARarisingoutof FIRno.
238/14,u/s279/337IPC,PSMandirMarg.ADecree/Awardbepassed
in terms of the settlement. It has been agreed that the insurance
companyshalldeposittheawardamountdirectlyinthecourt(asperthe
directionsintheaward)withininonemonthfromtodayfailingwhich
itisliabletopayinterestattherateof12%perannumfromthedateof
theDecree/Award.
RO&AC

(MOHINDERVIRAT)
Judge/MACT,NewDelhi
30.3.2015

SuitNo.D/12/15
STATEMENTOFSH.YOGESHKUMARCOUNSELFORINJURED.
ATBAR

Ihaveinstructionstomakestatementonbehalfofinjured.

Onbehalfofinjured,Ihaveenteredintoacompromisewithinsurance
companyforasumofRs.40,000/(Rs.FortyThousandonly)infulland
finalsettlementofclaimofclaimantinthisDARarisingoutofFIRno.
296/14,u/s279/337IPC,PSMandirMarg.ADecree/Awardbepassed
intermsofthesettlement.
Ithasbeenagreedthatinsurancecompanyshalldepositthe
saidamountdirectlyinthecourtwithinonemonthfromthedateof
passingoftheawardfailingwhichitisliabletopayinterestattherate
of12%perannumfromthedateoftheDecree/Award.

RO&AC

(MOHINDERVIRAT)
Judge/MACT,NEWDELHI
30.3.2015

SuitNo.D/12/15
STATEMENT OF SH.J.P.N.SHAHI COUNSEL FOR INSURANCE
COMPANY.
ATBAR
Matter has been settled with injured Sh.Amit Kumar
throughhiscounselforasumofRs.40,000/(Rs.FortyThousandonly)
infullandfinalsettlementofclaimofclaimantinthisDARarisingout
ofFIRno.296/14,u/s279/338IPC,PSMandirMarg.ADecree/Award
be passed in terms of the settlement. It has been agreed that the
insurance company shall deposit the award amount directly in the
court(as per the directions in the award) within in one month from
todayfailingwhichitisliabletopayinterestattherateof12%per
annumfromthedateoftheDecree/Award.
RO&AC

(MOHINDERVIRAT)
Judge/MACT,NewDelhi
30.3.2015

SuitNo.74/12
PW1

SMT.KUSUM DEVI W/O SH.SOMESHWAR

BORDOLOIR/OVILLAANDPOSTOFFICEKAURIPATHARVIA
HALEM,DISTT.SONITPUR,ASSAM784170.
OnS.A.
I tender in evidence my affidavit which is Ex.PW1/A
which bears my signatures at point A and B. I rely on copy of
discharge summary mark A, medical bills & attendant bills
Ex.PW1/1(colly.).
CROSSEXAMINATIONDEFERRED.

RO&AC

Judge/MACT1/NewDelhi

30.3.2015


SuitNo.D/52/14
30.3.2015
Present:

PetitionerwithSh.NeerajP.Singhcounsel.
R1&2areexparte.
Sh.M.P.ShahicounselforR3.

Finalargumentsheard.
Onenquiry,petitionerstatesthatheis53yearsofageandworking
inaprivatecompanyandearningRs.8600/pm.Petitionerstatesthathisfamily
consistsofmother,wifeandtwochildren.
Putupfororderat4pm.
(MOHINDERVIRAT)
Judge/MACT1,NewDelhi
30.3.2015

Suitno.D52/14
30.3.2015
At4.00PM
Present:

None.
Videseparateorderanawardforasumof Rs.65,469/ with

interest@7.5perannumfrom25.8.2014tillitsrealization,includinginterim
award, if any passed in favour of the petitioner and against the
respondents.
FilebeconsignedtoRecordsafterduecompliance.
(MOHINDERVIRAT)

Judge/MACT1,NewDelhi

30.3.2015

SuitNo.256/13
OnS.A.
I tender in evidence my affidavit which is Ex.PW1/A
whichbearsmysignaturesatpointAandB.

RO&AC

Judge/MACT1/NewDelhi
13.03.2015

SUITNO:102/14

30.03.2015
Present:

Nonefortheparties.

Recordofthefilerevealsthatpreviousorderhasnotbeen
compliedbythepetitioner.
Stillintheinterestofjustice,matterisadjournedintermsof
previousorderofLd.PredecessorofthisTribunalfor25.05.2015.

(MohinderVirat)

Judge/MACT1,NewDelhi
30.03.2015

SUITNO:D53/15

30.03.2015
Present:

Proxycounselforcounselfortheparties.
Injuredisstillstatedtobehospitalized.Stillintheinterest

ofjustice,beputupforexploringthepossibilityofsettlementandincaseof
failure,forfilingreplyon27.04.2015.

(MohinderVirat)

Judge/MACT1,NewDelhi
30.03.2015

SUITNO:103/14

30.03.2015
Present:

Sh.D.SMehta,Ld.Counselforthepetitioner.
Sh.PraveenPaliwal,counselforrespondentsno.1and2
alongwithrespondentno.1andoneSh.JagdishChander
ATIforRespondentno.2.
Noneforrespondentno.3i.einsurancecompany.

CasewasearlierlistedforPE,however,itisstatedbyLd.
Counselforpetitioner/thatinjuredisstillundertreatment.
An application moved on behalf of claimant for issuance of
directionstotheSuperintendentofanyGovt.Hospitaltoexaminetheclaimant
Sh.ManjeetSinghforissuanceofpermanentdisabilitycertificate.
Heard.ItisorderedthatMedicalSuperintendent,ofG.BPant
Hospital,NewDelhiwillconstituteaboardtoexaminethepetitionerSh.Manjeet
Singhsoastoascertaintheextentofpermanentdisability,intermsofrule17of
the Delhi Motor Accident Claims Tribunals Rules, 2008. The claimant be
examinedbyaMedicalOfficer/BoardofMedicalofficersofG.BPantHospital,
NewDelhiandreportbesubmittedbytheMedicalSuperintendentofG.BPant
Hospital,NewDelhibeforethenextdateofhearingi.e.01.06.2015.Claimantis
directed to appearbefore MedicalSuperintendent, ofG.BPantHospital,New
Delhialongwithcopyoforderin'J'formandhisentiretreatmentrecordtoobtain
adateforexamination.
Acopyoftheorderbegiventothepetitioner.
Putupforconsiderationofdisabilityreport/PEon01.06.2015.

(MohinderVirat)

Judge/MACT1,NewDelhi
30.03.2015

SuitNo.D256/13
PW7StatementofRajender,S/oSh.NafeSingh,R/o Branchoffice,
ESIC,CivilLine,Gurgaon.
OnS.A.
Ihavebroughtthesummonedrecord.Thecopyofledgersheet
incaseofpetitionerreflectinghisbenefitsisEx.PW7/1.
XXXXXbySh.RaviSabarwal,counselforinsurancecompany.
AspertherecordtheinjuredemployeeRajenderNathBishwas
hasbeenpaidRs.1,08,181/from22.06.2013till16.09.2014for431
days in total. After taking the medical certificate we deposit the
amount in the account of employee. His account number bears
95642200042043. We have also sent his case on 18.11.2014 for
consideration of monthly pension amount to (Sub Regional office,
Gurgaon)whichshallbedeterminedbytheboardafterconsideringthe
permanent disability occasioned to the petitioner. I cannot say
anythingwithregardtoamountofthepensionofthepetitioner.Ihave
obtainedthisrecordon27.03.2015.Wedonotkeepthemedicalbills
withusasamatterofrecord.
RO&AC

Judge/MACT1/NewDelhi
30.03.2015

SuitNo.D256/13

Statement of Sh Pratap Singh, Ld. Counsel for petitioner, office


address:ChamberNo.650,DwarkaCourts,NewDelhi

AtBar
As per the instructions of petitioner, I close petitioner's
evidence.

RO&AC

Judge/MACT1/NewDelhi

30.03.2015

SuitNo.256/13

30/03/2015
Present:

ShPratapSingh,Ld.Counselforpetitioner.
ShRaviSabarwal,Ld.Counselforinsurancecompany.
ShRavinderKumardriverinperson.
ShBijenderSingh,ATIforDTC.
PW7ShRajenderexaminedinchief,crossexaminedand

discharged.
Ld.Counselforpetitionerhasgivenseparatestatementfor
closingpetitioner'sevidence.Heard.Thesameisaccordinglyclosed.
PutupforREifany/finalargumentson05/05/2015.

Judge/MACT1/NewDelhi
30.03.2015

ExNo.85/12

30/03/2015
Present:

NoneforRRH.
Recordofthefilerevealsthatnoneisappearingonbehalf

ofRRHsincelastseveraldatesofhearing.ItappearsthatRRHisnot
interested in pursuing the present case. Hence, the same stands
dismissed in default. File be consigned to record room after due
compliance.

Judge/MACT1/NewDelhi
30.03.2015

SUITNO:238/13

30.03.2015
Present:

Sh.AmitSushidi,Proxycounselforcounselforthe
petitioner.

Respondentno.1&2areexparte.
Noneforrespondentno.3i.einsurancecompany.

Recordofthefilerevealsthatthereisatypographicalerror
inthelastordersheetwhereinthematterhasbeenlistedforPEinsteadof
RE.
Inrespondent'sevidenceIOASIMohd.Naimhasfailedto
appeardespitehavingbeenservedwiththenotice.
Inviewofthesame,issuebailablewarrantsinthesumof
Rs.10,000/againsttheaforesaidwitnesstobeexecutedthroughSHO
concernedfor11.05.2015.

(MohinderVirat)

Judge/MACT1,NewDelhi
30.03.2015

SUITNO:D376/14

30.03.2015
Present:

Sh.Ajaykumar,Ldcounselforinjuredalongwithinjured.
Sh.YogeshKumar,Ld.Counselfordriveralongwithdriver.
Noneforownerandinsurancecompany.
Recordofthefilerevealsthatthecasewasearlierlistedfor

PE.
An application moved on behalf of claimant for issuance of
directionstotheSuperintendentofanyGovt.Hospitaltoexaminetheclaimant
Sh.BhagwatiPrasadforissuanceofpermanentdisabilitycertificate.
Heard. It is ordered that Medical Superintendent, of G.T.B
Hospital,NewDelhiwillconstituteaboardtoexaminethepetitionerSh.Bhagwati
Prasadsoastoascertaintheextentofpermanentdisability,intermsofrule17of
the Delhi Motor Accident Claims Tribunals Rules, 2008. The claimant be
examinedbyaMedicalOfficer/BoardofMedicalofficersofG.T.BHospital,New
DelhiandreportbesubmittedbytheMedicalSuperintendentofG.T.BHospital,
NewDelhibeforethenextdateofhearingi.e01.06.2015.Claimantisdirectedto
appearbeforeMedicalSuperintendent,ofG.T.BHospital,NewDelhialongwith
copyof orderin'J'formandhisentiretreatmentrecordtoobtainadate for
examination.
Acopyoftheorderbegiventothepetitioner.
Putupforconsiderationofdisabilityreport/PEon01.06.2015.

(MohinderVirat)

Judge/MACT1,NewDelhi
30.03.2015


SUITNO:192/14&193/14

30.03.2015
Present:

Proxycounselforinjuredalongwithinjured.
Noneforrespondents.

Recordofthefilerevealsthatthecasewasearlierlistedfor
PEbyLd.PredecessorofthisTribunal.TodaynoPEhasbeenplacedon
record.
An application moved on behalf of claimant for issuance of
directionstotheSuperintendentofanyGovt.Hospitaltoexaminetheclaimant
Smt.Bimleshforissuanceofpermanentdisabilitycertificate.
Heard.ItisorderedthatMedicalSuperintendent,ofSafdarjung
Hospital,NewDelhiwillconstituteaboardtoexaminethepetitionerSmt.Bimlesh
soastoascertaintheextentofpermanentdisability,intermsofrule17ofthe
DelhiMotorAccidentClaimsTribunalsRules,2008.Theclaimantbeexamined
byaMedicalOfficer/BoardofMedicalofficersofSafdarjungHospital,NewDelhi
andreportbesubmittedbytheMedicalSuperintendentofSafdarjungHospital,
NewDelhibeforethenextdateofhearingi.e.01.06.2015.Claimantisdirectedto
appearbeforeMedicalSuperintendent,ofSafdarjungHospital,NewDelhialong
withcopyoforderin'J'formandhisentiretreatmentrecordtoobtainadatefor
examination.
Acopyoftheorderbegiventothepetitioner.

Put up for consideration of disability report/PE on


01.06.2015.

(MohinderVirat)

Judge/MACT1,NewDelhi
30.03.2015

SUITNO:259/13

30.03.2015
Present:

Sh.FauziSayeed,Ld.Counselforinjured.
Noneforrespondentno.1and2.
Sh.J.P.NShahi,Ld.Counselforinsurancecompany.

Todayinjured/petitionerisnotavailable.Stillintheinterest
ofjustice,beputupforfinalargumentson24.04.2015.Claimanttoappearon
thenextdateofhearingforexaminationintermsofdirectionspassedbyHon'ble
High Court on 11.1.2013 in MACA No.792/2006 tilted as Oriental Insurance
Co.Ltd. VsRanjitPandey andOrs.Claimantshallsubmithis addresses and
addressesofhiscounselforsendingthenoticeofdepositandtwosetsofhis
photographs and signatures alongwith proof of residence and details of bank
account.

(MohinderVirat)

Judge/MACT1,NewDelhi
30.03.2015

SUITNO:D503/14

30.03.2015
Present:

Nonefortheparties.
Stillintheinterestofjustice,letcourtnoticebeissuedtothe

partiesandtheirrespectivecounselsfor25.04.2015.

(MohinderVirat)

Judge/MACT1,NewDelhi
30.03.2015

SUITNO:D373/14

30.03.2015
Present:

Nonefortheparties.
Recordofthefilerevealsthatcomplianceofawarddated

13.01.2015hasalready beenmade. Nothingfurthersurviveinthisfile.


Filebeconsignedtorecordsafterduecompliance.

(MohinderVirat)

Judge/MACT1,NewDelhi
30.03.2015

SUITNO:208/10

30.03.2015
Present:

None.

NoreportquanoticeissuedtoJD/insurancecompanyhas
beenreceivedback.
Stillintheinterestofjustice,matterisadjournedintermsof
previousorderofLd.PredecessorofthisTribunalfor18.04.2015.

(MohinderVirat)

Judge/MACT1,NewDelhi
30.03.2015

INTHECOURTOFSH.MOHINDERVIRAT,JUDGE/MACT
NEWDELHI
MEMOOFPARTIES
SUITNO.D43/15
30.3.2013
Sh.ArizMalik
S/oSh.Sh.MahmoodMalik
R/oI18,DDAFlats,TurkmaanGateNewDelhi.............Petitioner

VS
1. Sh.Vikas
S/oSh.HariPrakash

......(Drivercumowner)

R/oH.No67/19,ShantiVihar
Sonepat(Haryana)
2. UnitedIndiaInsuranceCo.Ltd

.............(Insurer)

th

8 Floor,KanchaJungaBuilding
BKRoadNewDelhi.
AWARD
MatterhasbeenamicablysettledbetweenpetitionerandNewIndia
Assurance Co. Ltd. for a sum of Rs.12,000/(Rs. Twelve Thousand only).
Statement of Sh. Ariz Malik, petitioner and Sh. Ravi Sabharwal counsel for
insurancecompanyrecordedinthisregard.
InviewofthestatementofthepartiesanawardinthesumofRs.
12,000/(Rs.TwelveThousandonly)ispassedinfavouroftheclaimantinfulland
finalsettlementofhisclaiminthispetitionunderSection166and140of

MotorVehicleAct. TheawardamountispayablebyInsurancecompanytothe
claimantandwillbeinclusiveofinterimaward,ifany,alreadypassed.
TheInsurancecompanyshalldeposittheawardamountdirectlyin
bankaccountoftheclaimantatUCOBank,PatialaHouseCourt,NewDelhiwithin
30daysofthepassingoftheawardfailingwhichitisliabletopayinterestatthe
rateof12%perannumfortheperiodofdelay.Theentireamountbereleasedto
theclaimant.
The bank shall transfer savings account to any other bank/branch
accordingtohisconvenience.Theclaimantshallfurnishalltherelevantdocuments
foropeningoftheSavingBankAccounttoSeniorManagerofUCOBank,Patiala
House Court Branch, New Delhi. Nazir to report in case the cheque is not
depositedwithin30daysofthepassingoftheaward/judgment.Nazirisdirectedto
notetheparticularsoftheawardamountintheregistertodayitself.
The petitioner shall file two sets of photographs along with his
specimensignatures,outofwhichonesettobesenttotheNodalOfficer,UCO
Bank,PatialaHouseCourtComplex,NewDelhialongwithcopyoftheawardby
Nazir and the second set be retained to the court for further reference. The
photographsbestampedandsenttothebank.Thepetitionersshallalsofilethe
proofofresidenceandfurnishthedetailsofthebankaccountwiththeNazirwithin
aweek.Thepetitionershallfilehiscompleteaddressaswelladdressofhiscounsel
forsendingthenoticeofdepositoftheawardamount.

Theinsurancecompanyshalldeposittheawardamountalongwith
interestuptothedateofnoticeofdeposittotheclaimantswithacopytotheir
counselandthecompliancereportshallbefiledinthecourtalongwithproofof
depositofawardamount,thenoticeofdepositandthecalculationofintereston
30.4.2013.
Anattestedcopyoftheawardbegiventotheparties.
An attested copy of the award be also sent to the concerned
MetropolitanMagistrateandtoDelhiStateLegalServicesAuthority.
FilebeconsignedtoRecordRoom.

(MohinderVirat)
Judge/MACT,NewDelhi

30.3.2013

SUITNos
:100/14

30.03.2015
Present:
ShT.RKashyap,Ld.Counselforpetitioner.

Sh Rishab Sahu, Proxy Counsel for Sh Anand Mishra,


Counselforrespondentnos1and2.
Proxy counsel seeks adjournment as main counsel for
respondentnos1and2isnotavailabletoday.Adjournmentisnotopposed.
In the interest of justice, put up for reply/arguments on
17/04/2015.

(MohinderVirat)

Judge/MACT1,NewDelhi
30.03.2015

SUITNos
:35/14

30.03.2015
Present:
ShT.RKashyap,Ld.Counselforpetitioner.

Sh Rishab Sahu, Proxy Counsel for Sh Anand Mishra,


Counselforrespondentnos1and2.
Proxy counsel seeks adjournment as main counsel for
respondentnos1and2isnotavailabletoday.Adjournmentisnotopposed.
In the interest of justice, put up for reply/arguments on
17/04/2015.

(MohinderVirat)

Judge/MACT1,NewDelhi
30.03.2015

SUITNos
:34/14

30.03.2015
Present:
ShT.RKashyap,Ld.Counselforpetitioner.

Sh Rishab Sahu, Proxy Counsel for Sh Anand Mishra,


Counselforrespondentnos1and2.
Proxy counsel seeks adjournment as main counsel for
respondentnos1and2isnotavailabletoday.Adjournmentisnotopposed.
In the interest of justice, put up for reply/arguments on
17/04/2015.

(MohinderVirat)

Judge/MACT1,NewDelhi
30.03.2015

SUITNos
:36/14

30.03.2015
Present:
ShT.RKashyap,Ld.Counselforpetitioner.

Sh Rishab Sahu, Proxy Counsel for Sh Anand Mishra,


Counselforrespondentnos1and2.
Proxy counsel seeks adjournment as main counsel for
respondentnos1and2isnotavailabletoday.Adjournmentisnotopposed.
In the interest of justice, put up for reply/arguments on
17/04/2015.

(MohinderVirat)

Judge/MACT1,NewDelhi
30.03.2015

SUITNO:706/11

30.03.2015
Present:
ShA.KDubey,Counselforthepetitioner.
ShA.KSingh,Counselforrespondentnos1and2alongwith
respondentno.1.
Vehicleisuninsured.
Today counsel for the parties have agreed to settle the
present case for a sum of Rs 40,000/ which shall be paid by the
respondentnos1and2tothepetitioneronthenextdateofhearing.
Inviewofaforesaid,putupforsettlementon27/04/2015.

(MohinderVirat)

Judge/MACT1,NewDelhi
30.03.2015

SUITNO:74/12

30.03.2015
Present:
ShT.NTyagi,Counselforpetitioneralongwithpetitioner.
ShChandanMalik,Counselforrespondentno.1.
Respondentno.2isexparte.
ShV.Gandotra,Counselforrespondentno.3i.e.,MCD.
TodaycaseislistedforPE,howeversincepetitioner/injured
knowsonlyAssamilanguageandatranslatorisrequired.PEisdeferred.
Counsel for petitioner undertakes to bring official translator
fromAssamitoEnglishlanguageregardingwhichLd.Counselsforparties
havenoobjection.
AttherequestofCounselforparties, matterisadjournedfor
PEfortomorrowi.e.,31/03/2015at2.30pm.

(MohinderVirat)

Judge/MACT1,NewDelhi
30.03.2015

ExNO:10/13

30.03.2015
Present:

Sh.T.RKashyap,Ld.CounselforDH.
NoneforJD.
Recordofthefileperused.
Let recovery certificate be issued against the JD to be

executedbySDMconcernedfor25.04.2015.

(MohinderVirat)

Judge/MACT1,NewDelhi
30.03.2015

D/66/15
STATEMENTOFSH.BRIJESHKUMARS/OSH.DHYANSINGH,
R/OHOUSENO.345,SANJAYKAMAKAN,NEARMOTEDADA
MANDIR,BARTHALGAON,DELHI.
OnS.A.
I am injured in the present case. Iamsatisfied withthe
police investigation and I have no objection if the DAR in FIR
No.987/14, u/s 279/337 IPC PS Vasant Kunj(South) is filed as
untraced.

RO&AC

Judge/MACT1/NewDelhi
21.3.2015

D/88/15
30.3.2015
DetailedAccidentInformationReportfiled.Itbechecked
andregisteredasclaimpetition.
Present:

IO/ASIKamalSinghalongwithinjuredSh.RamSewak.

DetailedAccidentReportfiledbyIO/HCKamalSinghin
formno.54ofCentralMotorVehicleRulesalongwithphotocopiesof
criminalrecord.
ThisisrequestofIOtofiletheDARasuntraced.
Heard.Recordperused.
Injuredstatesthatheissatisfiedwiththeuntracedreport
filedbypoliceandhavenoobjectioniftheDARinFIRNo.92/14,u/s
279/338IPCPSTuglakRoadisfiledasuntraced.
Statementoftheinjuredrecordedinthisregard.
In view of statement of injured, the DAR is filed as
untracedwhichmayberevivedasandwhenclaimpetitionisfiledor
accused/offendingvehiclearetraced.
Filebeconsignedtorecordroomafterduecompliance.

(MohinderVirat)
Judge/MACTI,NewDelhi
30.3.2015

SuitNo.D88/15
STATEMENTOFSH.RamSewakS/OLATESH.R.CGupta,R/O
6/324,Trilokpuri,NewDelhi.
OnS.A.

Iamthecomplainantinthepresentcase.Iamsatisfiedwith
thepoliceinvestigationandIhavenoobjectioniftheDARarisingout
ofFIRNo.92/14,underSection279/338IPC,PSTuglakRoadisfiled
asuntraced.

RO&AC

Judge/MACT1/NewDelhi
30.3.2015


SuitNo:D87/15
30.03.2015
DetailedAccidentInformationReportfiled.Itbecheckedandregistered.
Present:

IO/SIPankaj.
Sh.A.KJha,Ld.CounselLR'sofdeceased.

Sh.VijayKumar,Ld.CounselforDrivercumowner.
Sh.M.PShahi,ProxycounselforMs.MamtaMayarforinsurance
company.
DetailedAccidentReportfiledbyIO/SIPankajinformno.54ofCentral
MotorVehicleRulesalongwithphotocopiesofcriminalrecord.
Copiessupplied.
Claimanttofilehisaffidavitwithrespecttothestatementsmadeinthe
DARintermsofclause24ofModifiedClaimsTribunalAgreedProcedurebythenext
date.
Ld.counselforclaimantandcounselforrespondentno.1and2havefiled
theirvakalatnama.Samebetakenonrecord.
Respondents to file their reply and their affidavits with respect to the
statementsmadeintheDARintermsofclause24ofModifiedClaimsTribunalAgreed
Procedurebythenextdate.
Putupforfilingofaffidavitsbytheparties/reply/writtenstatement/offerof
settlementon19.05.2015thedateasprayed.
(MOHINDERVIRAT)
JUDGE/MACT1,NEWDELHI

30.03.2015


SuitNo:D86/15
30.03.2015
DetailedAccidentInformationReportfiled.Itbecheckedandregistered.
Present:

IO/SIBadriPrasad.
Petitionerinperson.
Driverinperson.

Sh.M.PShahicounselforinsurancecompany.
DetailedAccident Report filedby IO/SI BadriPrasadinform no. 54of

CentralMotorVehicleRulesalongwithphotocopiesofcriminalrecord.
Copiessupplied.
Claimanttofilehisaffidavitwithrespecttothestatementsmadeinthe
DARintermsofclause24ofModifiedClaimsTribunalAgreedProcedurebythenext
date.
Ld.counsel for insurance company has filed memo of appearance and
statesthathewillfilevakalatnamaandwrittenstatement/offerofsettlementbythenext
date.Samebefiled.
Respondents to file their reply and their affidavits with respect to the
statementsmadeintheDARintermsofclause24ofModifiedClaimsTribunalAgreed
Procedurebythenextdate.
Putupforfilingofaffidavitsbytheparties/reply/writtenstatement/offerof
settlementon11.5.2015thedateasprayed.
(MOHINDERVIRAT)
JUDGE/MACT1,NEWDELHI

30.03.2015

You might also like