Professional Documents
Culture Documents
IN
CUDDALORE DISTRICT
Anu George, IAS (Tamil Nadu)
1
Readings and Case Studies on Disaster Management (Volume : I)
2
Readings and Case Studies on Disaster Management (Volume : I)
DISASTER MANAGEMENT
- The Cuddalore Experience
Cuddalore has always been classified as a multi-hazard prone district. Cyclones and floods
have wreaked havoc in the District several times in the past few centuries. The District also falls
within the zone-3 with respect to earthquakes. A part of the problem owes its genesis to the
location of the district. The District has a long coastline of 57.5 KM. Therefore the district is
vulnerable to the cyclonic depressions and the resultant rains which causes floods. Cuddalore
District has an area of 3678 Sq. km comprising of extremely fertile and well-irrigated lands
benefiting from water draining over fields and through major and minor river systems. The
District however suffers from the flooding when excess water flows down these local rivers
and over the fields due to northeast monsoon rains in the river basins and in the district itself.
The drainage is poor and the encroachments over the drought years have led to a scenario
where, even rainfalls, which are slightly above normal, can cause floods disrupting the normal
course of work. Coupled with this is the perennial problem of low water carrying capacity of
the lakes and eris. Desilting of these water bodies involve huge expenditure and over a period
of time they have been neglected altogether.
The District is one of the most backward districts in Tamil Nadu in terms of social indicators.
Natural disasters often tend to set the clock back in time further accentuating the problem as
they lead to serious disruption of the functioning of a society causing widespread losses. These
losses far exceed the affected society's ability to cope with it using its own resources. In the year
2004 the District witnessed a severe drought, floods in October and then in December -the
tsunami.
The tsunami (in Japanese the word means 'harbour') refers to mighty waves that are triggered
by disturbances on the ocean floor. These disturbances are a result of earthquakes or volcanic
eruptions. A mighty earthquake measuring about 9.1 on the Richter scale (as per the revised
magnitude) caused the disaster. The earthquake itself was caused by the collision of the
Australian and Eurasian plates in the Indian Ocean. The quake triggered a tsunami that is a
series of waves that spread over thousands of kilometres in a matter of hours. In over seven
hours the waves carved a path of destruction across the 4,500 Km Indian Ocean.
The tsunami is formed when the energy from the earthquake vertically jolts the seabed by
several metres. In the process several hundreds of cubic kilometres of water is displaced. The
3
Readings and Case Studies on Disaster Management (Volume : I)
waves moved at a speed of 800Km/Hr and as it neared the coast the speed reduced but the
height of the wave increased and almost without any warning ate up everything on its path.
The Outcome
In Cuddalore alone the tsunami left 618 dead. Livestock loss was put at 29 lakhs. 517.7 Hectares
of land was rendered saline and destruction to property was to the tune of 300 crores. The
humongous tragedy scarred the lives of over 97,000 people in Cuddalore alone and thousands
were rendered homeless in a matter of minutes. The relief and rehabilitation operations that
followed should be looked at keeping the specific nature of the tragedy.
Relief Centres
Though most of the villages had cyclone shelters, the nature of the disaster was such that the
villagers from the coastal areas fled to the interiors of the district. Most of the relief camps that
were opened up almost immediately were the wedding halls of the District. Around 38 centres
were set up for the refugees.
} The next task at hand was to give them food and water till such camps existed. This
was a massive exercise in coordination between the authorities and the voluntary
4
Readings and Case Studies on Disaster Management (Volume : I)
sector. We devised a tracking system whereby; the officials in charge of each centre
would report to the control room the arrangements that were in place for the next
meal.
} Sanitary workers were appointed to clean the place on a daily basis. Their work was
constantly monitored.
} Medical camps were also set up. The arrangement was such that every camp had at
least one visit from a team of doctors every day. Wherever, there was more than one
camp within a short distance a medical camp functioned all day.
} The cooked food brought in by the volunteers was monitored as a precautionary
measure. This was inevitable because in a few places the food, which was brought in
from far-flung areas often, got spoiled in the heat.
} With the help of a few agencies we were able to put up sintex tanks in all the relief
centres ensuring steady supply of water.
} In addition to the officials a few capable members from the camp were given our
phone numbers so that if anything was amiss we could plug it immediately.
While the relief camps functioned, Arun Roy (Another IAS Officer undergoing district training)
and I had to divide between us all the centres and take a trip around them especially before and
after meals to ensure the regular supply of food and water and medical attention. It was a
tough task, as more often than not, the population in the camps would fluctuate so drastically.
I remember, a day (29th December) when the population in a camp went up to 1020 in the
afternoon from 200 in the morning. This floating population is peculiar to this disaster and this
made arranging adequate provisions in the camps an onerous task.
Communication
Control rooms were established in the three worst affected areas to coordinate the efforts of the
field staff and also to monitor the relief operation. To some extent the HAM radio operators
helped us in this process. Another priority area was to equip the top officials with mobile phones
5
Readings and Case Studies on Disaster Management (Volume : I)
(some lent and others rented). This eased the channels of communication and helped us no end
in tackling SOS calls.
Mass Cleaning
The area near the coast had been reduced to rubble in most of the villages. 51 habitations bore
the brunt of the ravaging sea waves. It was therefore important to clean up the villages to lend
a semblance of normalcy. It was also a vital move in the control of epidemics and detection of
bodies and carcasses. In the first few days, the assistance of the local NSS and NYK volunteers
were sought in this regard. However, it soon became clear that the district needed a more
massive and organised effort to accomplish this. It was here that we utilised the services of the
army personnel. With the help of JCBs the unit started work in the worst affected of areas on
the 30th. Within a week and a half mass cleaning was completed in all the villages.
The disaster also brought to the district a number of people who just wanted to help. We were
also able to use them for identification of hot spots in the villages. These were places in which
the seawater had stagnated causing considerable stink to spread in the area. The next task was
to clear these spots with the help of the fire force and the septic tank cleaners of the municipality.
Quantity Used
Bleaching Powder 32,200 Kg
Phenyl 2,985 Litres
Lime 20,350 Kg
Community Kitchens
After the tsunami and during the floods the administration
had the onerous responsibility of organising community
kitchens to feed the thousands of displaced people. This was
an exercise in coordination as more often than not, it involved
mobilising huge quantities of vegetables, fuel and other
provisions at short notice.
The help we had got from donors were also channelised
towards this purpose. 7,085 people were fed in the 23 community kitchens across the district
for over a month. The DSO was to provide a daily report regarding the provisions for the next
day to ensure that the supply was never disrupted.
People's Representatives
As I will be mentioning later on the way the People's representatives deal with you also depends
on the track record. Giving their ideas and concerns due weightage helps to the extent that at
times they are veritable sources of valuable feedback and information. Regular meeting with
the local leaders were held religiously. There were times, however, when, the demands had to
be toned down. This was particularly so when it came to identification of beneficiaries and
during enumeration. It was a tough job to keep the undeserving out of the list. The field staff
8
Readings and Case Studies on Disaster Management (Volume : I)
bore the brunt of this and it is commendable that they rose to the occasion. Except for an odd
complaint here and there the whole exercise was a smooth one.
Another aspect, which is closely related, is the high profile visits of national and state level
leaders. These visits are time consuming and diverts scarce manpower to protocol duties.
However, the visits also tend to bring focus on to the issues in hand. Yet another positive
outcome is that the field level problems are easily conveyed to the decision makers. Thus very
often they have borne excellent results for the District.
The same can be said about the community leaders who were a tremendous source of help in
identifying the beneficiaries. They were also instrumental in keeping us posted on the happenings
in the field. But there was also a flip side to this in that at times they tended to bargain a lot
more than was there causing delays and factionalism within the communities. The situation
warranted a lot of tact from our side.
} The doctors and the medicines were channelised through the DD (Public Health)
and JD (Health). This ensured that the medicines and the doctors were always routed
through one central office. Thereby, we were able to keep a tab on the medicines
distributed as well as ensure that the teams were sent to areas that had not received
any medical attention.
} The donors who routed the materials through the administration were given an official
acknowledgement. This also addressed the issue of accountability.
} There were others who wanted to directly distribute the relief in materials in the
9
Readings and Case Studies on Disaster Management (Volume : I)
villages. This was not a good option never the less we had to facilitate the smooth
distribution. So we made a system whereby we knew which villages would require
that particular assistance. The cooperation of the police was sought and the coupon
system was encouraged. This ensured that no untoward incident took place. This
was particularly important as in the initial days people had started comparing the
relief materials they had received from various donors. Yet again, we had to avoid
incidents like this one where, an NGO distributed 50 packets of vegetable biryani in
a relief centre that housed a 1000 people. It was a common sight to see the villagers
run after the trucks.
Health
The yeoman's service rendered by the Department of health has been mentioned in various
contexts. 23 teams comprising of both Government doctors and private doctors were organised.
The camps that were initially set up in the relief centres were later shifted to the villages.
Agriculture
In our District about 517.7 hectares of land was rendered saline. Tests were conducted using
mobile testing centres and it was found that reclamation would take 5-7 years of normal rainfall
as the salinity was to the extent of 90 cm to 1 metre. The administration mooted for an enhanced
compensation package for the farmers. We also tried to pre-empt the excess usage of water by
the farmers by requesting for eco-friendly technologies from the various scientific institutes to
facilitate faster reclamation. This was also important as in many places the farmers had already
watered the land in the hope of planting the next crop without being aware of the consequences.
Animal Husbandry
In a disaster like this it is natural that the animals are left stranded in the villages. There was
also a likelihood of animal carcasses remaining unattended to. Fast disposal of carcasses thus
received topmost priority. Further, 42 tons of fodder was mobilised for the stranded cattle.
20,109 animals were vaccinated and a large number of animals treated for various illnesses.
11
Readings and Case Studies on Disaster Management (Volume : I)
The distribution of relief cheques to the beneficiaries was also done in such a manner as to
eliminate bogus claims by making use of the OP records with the Veterinary Inspectors and the
insurance papers at the various insurance offices. This ensured that the process was a fair one.
Restoration of Livelihood
The disruption of livelihood has been massive during the tsunami. The annual fish production
of Cuddalore is about 25,225 tons. Around 15,000 tons are exported. Therefore, it is nobody's
guess as to the extent of devastation caused by the tsunami. The fishing industry supports a
number of other trades and allied activities. There are boat cleaners, carpenters, boat mechanics,
salvage workers, fish vendors, ice manufacturers, dry fish vendors, transport workers and so
many others. The big question is as to whether the relief will actually reach each and every one
of these affected categories. The only long-term solution is to get the boats back to the sea to
ensure that the cycle gets going.
} Within the first few days of the disaster we tried tying up various villages with the
donors interested in long-term rehabilitation. This was to ensure that the boats and
nets would be ordered well in advance. We also worked out the cost of nets and
boats and the types of nets required with the help of the fishermen. Meanwhile, efforts
were to be concentrated on the repair of boats. To this end the engineers from the
army, navy and the industry were mobilised. These efforts were however, not so
smooth.
The fishermen doubted our intentions and misconstrued that the repairs that were to be carried
out would render them ineligible for the relief. We had to really work hard on that front through
repeated meetings with the community and give assurances.
} The enumeration process of the fisheries department was even more cumbersome as
many of the boats were unregistered. The number of boats/catamarans reported to
be missing was phenomenal in certain villages. The fishermen who were given
compensation for their engines and boats were photographed with their boats so as
to send the message that everything was being recorded and thus double entries
would warrant punishments.
} There was yet another aspect for which we were not initially prepared for . The bigger
villages had by virtue of its size and population suffered much more damage than
the smaller ones. They were also the ones who controlled the fishing operations in
the sea by the virtue of their numerical strength. The smaller villages were mostly
taken care off by the small NGOs who had greater flexibility of operations. This meant
that they delivered faster than the bigger more famous counterparts. Secondly, the
smaller villages were easy to please than the bigger villages that bargained hard.
Therefore, in some of the villages the fishermen could not venture out into the sea
regularly fearing the wrath of the bigger villages.
} Boat salvage works had started within the first few days of the disaster and huge
cranes were mobilised for the process.
} We also had to make repeated forays into the sea to motivate the fishermen.
12
Readings and Case Studies on Disaster Management (Volume : I)
} Fish melas and seafood festivals also had to be organised to quell rumours and also
to ensure that the fishermen went to the sea regularly.
} Toolkits were also given to the carpenters, masons, boat mechanics etc through the
voluntary sector.
BOAT SALVAGE
WORKS
DREDGING OPERATIONS
43
} Yet again, individual assistance in terms of sewing machines, grocery shops etc were
also given so that the family could start afresh.
} Consumption loans were mobilised for the SHGs and a fresh impetus was given to
their training.
Children
How do we address the needs of the traumatised children for whom the beach is no longer a
play area??? How do we wipe away those scars??? This was a question which we repeatedly
raised as we started the counselling process. It was felt that play therapy would be the best
healer. Therefore on a pilot basis a children's park was put up in one of the villages. This made
a tremendous impact in the sense that within a period of one week we were able to set up 68
children's parks across the coastal villages. This was a step that endeared the administration to
the people and at the same time ushered the people into a state of normalcy.
Similarly, with the help of different universities like the Bangalore University, play therapy
sessions were held for the children in various schools and in the villages. A number of volunteers
were trained and awarded certificates to carry forward the programme.
The Government Home that was opened for the tsunami orphans also received special attention.
The children were provided with all the basic amenities and comforts through various donors.
13
Readings and Case Studies on Disaster Management (Volume : I)
Even today, every weekend a trip is organised for the children. The home was opened bearing
in mind the special needs of the tsunami affected including their psychosocial well being. It
was also important to prevent child trafficking and other such potential dangers.
The schools and colleges were also identified in the fastest possible manner and the students
were provided with books and bags. Immediate steps were also undertaken to reopen the schools
as early as possible.
Shelter
Temporary shelters had to be put up on a war footing, as it was inevitable that the relief centres
were shut down at the earliest. It was also necessitated by the fact that normalcy would be
restored only if people went back to the villages. A large number of temporary shelters were
put up with the help of the voluntary sector and by the Rural Development Department. Based
on the feedback from the field the design of these shelters was constantly improved. A lot of
thrust was placed on the flooring and on controlling the heat. It was also ensured that the
sanitation needs of the rehabilitated were met through voluntary agencies and by engaging
women masons.
Another aspect, which required a lot of effort, was to keep the NGOs, engaged till the
Government announced its policy on the resettlement of the tsunami affected. The policy is still
awaited as I write this paper. During the discussions on what should be the deciding variable it
was invariably conveyed that the willing ness of the people was paramount in any policy. The
issue was of finding lands near to the coast and at the same time, which was located away from
the high tide line. We have also been persistently pressurising the NGOs to convert all the
kutcha houses in the affected villages into pucca earth quake resistant structures. This is
important, as there is likelihood that these may not survive a cyclone though it has weathered
the tsunami. It was all the more important to leave the tragedy behind and to seize the help
pouring in to set a lot of things right.
Tsunami : An Analysis
Though I have mentioned the floods in October 2004 in Cuddalore only in passing, I would like
to reflect on the flood and the tsunami in greater detail for a critical analysis of the whole
15
Readings and Case Studies on Disaster Management (Volume : I)
process. Cuddalore, came in for a lot of praise from all quarters for the way the relief was
handled. As one looks back a few questions are bound to rise. Was there a scope for
improvement? Can we do without certain systems that we are so used to? Has the Government
response been quick enough?
Rescue Operations
Did the training make an impact in the wake of the unpredicted tsunami???
The villagers were the best judges in this regard. In this big village 24 precious lives were lost.
In the neighbouring village of Pudukuppam (a smaller village) the final death toll was 118!
Training did make a difference.
Parangipettai
The Parangipettai (Porto Novo) area, was one of the worst
affected parts of the District in the recent tsunami. It also
shot to fame as a striking example of communal harmony
and humanitarian values in the midst of a humungous
tragedy. The Muslim Jamaat had opened its doors for the
thousands of Hindu refugees. They were offered shelter and
19
Readings and Case Studies on Disaster Management (Volume : I)
the best of food. How did this bright spot come about? In a day?
The answer to this is a big NO. The Parangipettai area is known for its deeply fragmented
social fabric. Differences of class and religion abound here. The muslims of the area are seen as
wealthy and many of them have relatives working in foreign countries.
About a year back the Sub-Collector had started a culture of joint Eid celebrations in the village.
This had brought down a lot of barriers and facilitated the helping hand that the Jamaat had
stretched out. Clearly, it is an indicator that disaster management also involves innovative
solutions to day- to - day administrative issues like law and order.
Track Record
Both during the floods and the tsunami Cuddalore got widespread acclaim for being one of the
better-administered districts. This was a unanimous opinion and even the international media
expressed their appreciation. How was it possible to maintain such a semblance of order when
confusion and chaos reigned supreme in other areas?
The answer is simple- track record.
We could not have found a better time than this one to bank on the support of the people. The
hard work and visible changes, which were brought about in the sleepy town of Cuddalore,
rallied them behind the Collector. Small lapses like delay in getting food in the centres were
forgiven as people had tremendous faith in the District Administration. Even in the wake of
probing questions intended at sensationalizing the disaster the people rallied behind the
administration. The District Administration under the Collector was seen as responding to the
crisis in the quickest possible manner. During the recent floods the Collector had personally
supervised the relief operations in the affected divisions. They knew that we would deliver as
we had done before! This is perhaps the most wonderful lubricant one can hope to oil the
wheels of relief operations.
The District was blessed with an excellent team. A strong team also meant that delegation of
duty was not a problem. In such a scenario it was not a tough task to be seen doing things. More
often than not, the problems arise when you are not seen to be doing the things you have been
doing.
Last but not the least, the floods in October/ November had in some way inadvertently prepared
us for the bigger disaster.
Conclusion
Disasters both natural and manmade expose the most vulnerable sections of the society to
grave danger. It is believed that the disasters are related to the poverty levels of a society. It is
often the poor who bear the brunt of natural disasters. One just needs to take a look at the
colonies for the scheduled castes in the District. Invariably located in low lying areas the thatched
structures of the most vulnerable are the first to get inundated by floods. During the tsunami
too the maximum lives lost were of women and children. Yet again, the houses that bore the
brunt were the ones that were of the poorest Though the damages caused by the floods is not of
the magnitude of a tsunami it is a more recurrent damage and costs much more than a tsunami
that hits once in a hundred years! It also throws up an interesting question as to whether human
philanthropy is only limited to dramatic happenings like the tsunami. This is also true of the
undramatic drought.
20
Readings and Case Studies on Disaster Management (Volume : I)
Disaster management is also about a sound administration, which is already in place to tackle
such exigencies. A strong system invariably gives a positive response and enjoys the support of
the people. This is reflected in the thinking of the administration.
Very often, it is not possible to envisage a policy of resettlement, which is long lasting as in this
particular case where, the livelihood is inextricably linked to the sea. So what is important is to
ensure the mitigation of the effects of a disaster. The safety of the buildings in the area have to
be mooted rather than looking out for a policy of total resettlement which, may not be monitored
in the long run.
The response of the state Government is particularly important for the simple reason that a
strong backing from the Government is essential to work in extraordinary circumstances. The
Government stood by every decision taken on ground and sanctioned every request made in
this regard. There was no constraint of money or sanction and this made the process a lot
easier.
Last but not the least, the importance of mangroves in saving the lives of hundreds of people
cannot be undermined. In the Pichavaram area of Cuddalore this was the only factor, which
saved the region. At least in the case of some of the disasters like cyclones and tsunami nature
holds the key to mitigation.
Ultimately what we need in addition to warning systems and communication equipments are
people who can manage the situation against all odds. This together with training and
preparedness can go a long way in making this world a better and safer place to live.
This report is still an incomplete one as the process of permanent rehabilitation is yet to start.
We have a number of assurances and commitments and some of them stretch to the non-tsunami
areas in the District. What happens in the next one-year or so will determine the success of our
Disaster Management operations. Only then can we hope to build on this successful initial
phase of operations.
*****
ANNEXURES
ROUTE MAP
TSUNAMI AFFECTED AREAS IN CUDDALORE DISTRICT
22
Readings and Case Studies on Disaster Management (Volume : I)
23
Readings and Case Studies on Disaster Management (Volume : I)
ANNEXURE-III
Following the Tsunami disaster that struck the Cuddalore coast on the 26th of December 2004,
51 villages were badly affected, killing 615 people and affecting 99,704 people. Fishermen bore
the brunt of the disaster and their boats were destroyed or badly damaged. Therefore it is
imperative to help them reconstruct their shattered lives by providing them with boats and
fishing accessories. As requested by your agency I am forwarding the details about the various
fishing boats/catamarans and the rough cost of the same along with other essential details.
26
Readings and Case Studies on Disaster Management (Volume : I)
ANNEXURE-VI
DETAILS OF MATERIALS REQUIRED BY BUILDING LABOURS
WELFARE MUNEDRA SANGAM, CUDDALORE O.T.
27
Readings and Case Studies on Disaster Management (Volume : I)
ANNEXURE-VII
Date :
To
After the initial shock and the painstaking process of immediate rescue and relief we
are in the process of rebuilding the lives of lakhs of hapless victims of the Tsunami waves.
COLLECTOR,
CUDDALORE DISTRICT
32
Readings and Case Studies on Disaster Management (Volume : I)
ANNEXURE-X
ASSISTANCE FOR INDIVIDUAL CASES AND
COMMUNITY ASSETS IN THE TSUNAMI
AFFECTED VILLAGE OF CUDDALORE as on 24.02.05
37
Readings and Case Studies on Disaster Management (Volume : I)
38
Readings and Case Studies on Disaster Management (Volume : I)