Professional Documents
Culture Documents
TatvamBrahman, as qualied by the sentient and insentient modes (or attributes), is the only reality.
1 Philosophers
The Vishishtadvaitic thought is considered to have existed for a long time, and it is surmised that the earliest
works are no longer available.[1] The names of the earliest
of these philosophers is only known through Ramanuja's
Veda artha Sangraha. In the line of the philosophers considered to have expounded the VisishtAdvaitic system,
the prominent ones are Bodhayana, Dramida, Tanka,
Guhadeva, Kapardi and Bharuci. Besides these philosophers, Ramanujas teacher Yamunacharya is credited
with laying the foundation for what culminates as the Sri
Bhasya.
Bodhayana is considered to have written an extensive
vritti (commentary) on the Purva and Uttara Mimamsas.
Tanka is attributed with having written commentaries on
Chandogya Upanishad and Brahma Sutras. Nathamuni
of the ninth century AD, the foremost Acharya of the
Vaishnavas, collected the Tamil prabandhas, classied
them, made the redaction, set the hymns to music and
spread them everywhere. He is said to have received the
divine hymns straight from Nammalvar, the foremost of
the twelve Alvars, by yogic insight in the temple at Alwar
Thirunagari, which is located near Tirunelveli in South
India. Yamunacharya renounced kingship and spent his
last days in the service of the Lord at Srirangam and in
laying the fundamentals of the Vishishtadvaita philosophy by writing four basic works on the subject.
Ramanuja is the main proponent of Vishishtadvaita philosophy. The philosophy itself is considered to have existed long before Ramanujas time.[2] Ramanuja continues along the line of thought of his predecessors while
expounding the knowledge expressed in the Upanishads,
Brahma Sutras and Bhagavad Gita. Vedanta Desika and
Pillai Lokacharya, disciples in the tradition of Ramanuja,
had minor disagreements not on the philosophy, but on
some aspects of the theology, giving rise to the Vadakalai
and Thenkalai schools of thought, as explained below.
Swaminarayan, the founder of Swaminarayan Hinduism, also propagated this philosophy and based the
Swaminarayan Sampraday (original name is Uddhava
Sampraday) on these ideals.[3]
Vedanta Desika denes Vishishtadvaita using the state- Sri Dharma Pravartaka Acharya (1963-), founder of the
ment: Asesha Chit-Achit Prakaaram Brahmaikameva International Sanatana Dharma Society, is also a follower
1
4 METAPHYSICS
of Visishtadvaita philosophy.[4][5]
Shabda or Shruti, Pramana occupies the highest position in matters which cannot be settled or resolved
by pratyaksa (perception) or by anumana (inference).
Anumana occupies the next position. When an issue
cannot be settled through sensory perception alone,
it is settled based on inference, that is, whichever is
the more logical argument .
When pratyaksa yields a denitive position on a particular issue, such a perception cannot be ignored by
interpreting Shabda in a way which violates that perception.
Epistemology
3.1
Pramanas
4 Metaphysics
4.1.1 Ishvara
Ishvara (denoted by Vishnu-Narayana) is the Supreme
Cosmic Spirit who maintains complete control over the
Universe and all the sentient beings, which together also
form the pan-organistic body of Ishvara. The triad of Ishvara along with the universe and the sentient beings is
Brahman, which signies the completeness of existence.
Ishvara is Parabrahman endowed with innumerable auspicious qualities (Kalyana Gunas). Ishvara is perfect, omniscient, omnipresent, incorporeal, independent, the creator of the universe, its active ruler and also its eventual
destroyer.[6] He is causeless, eternal and unchangeable
and is yet the material and the ecient cause of the
universe and sentient beings. He is both immanent (like
whiteness in milk) and transcendent (like a watch-maker
independent of a watch). He is the subject of worship.
He is the basis of morality and giver of the fruits of ones
Karma. He rules the world with His Maya His divine
power.
Shruti refers to knowledge gained from scriptures - primarily the Upanishads, the Brahma Sutras and the Bha- Ishvara is considered to have a 2-fold characteristic: he is
the indweller of all beings and all beings dwell in Ishvara.
gavad Gita.
4.1
Ontology
Antarvyapi When Ishvara is thought of as the in- jivas and jagat are its modes (also secondary attributes),
dweller of all beings, he is referred to as the Paramatman, and kalyanagunas (auspicious attributes) are the primary
or the innermost self of all beings.
attributes. The secondary attributes become manifested
He who inhabits water, yet is within water, whom water in the eect state when the world is dierentiated by
does not know, whose body water is and who controls wa- name and form. The kalyanagunas are eternally manifest.
ter from within He is your Self, the Inner Controller, Brahman is the description of Ishvara when comprethe Immortal.
hended in fullness i.e., a simultaneous vision of Ishvara
He who inhabits the sun, yet is within the sun, whom the with all his modes and attributes.
sun does not know, whose body the sun is and who controls The relationship between Brahman and Jivas, Jagat is exthe sun from within He is your Self, the Inner Controller, pressed by Rmnuj in numerous ways. He calls this
the Immortal - Brihadaranyaka Upanishad 3.7.4-14
relationship as one of:
Bahuvyapi When Ishvara is thought of as the all encomposing and the residence of all beings that is, all beings reside in Ishvara, he is referred to as the paramapurusha. The sentient beings and the insentient universe
which form part of the pan-organistic body of Ishvara are
encapsulated by Ishvara.
sharIra/sharIrI (/ ) (body/indweller);
prakAra/prakArI (attribute or mode/substance);
shesha/sheshi (Owned/owner);
amsha/amshI (part/whole);
AdhAradeya/sambandha (supporter/supported);
niyamya/niyanta (controlled/controller);
4.1.2
Chit
Chit is the world of sentient beings, or of entities possessing consciousness. It is similar to the Purusha of
Samkhya system. The sentient beings are called Jvs
and they are possessors of individual consciousness as denoted by I. The scope of Chit refers to all beings with
an I consciousness, or more specically self-awareness.
Therefore all entities which are aware of their own individual existence are denoted as chit. This is called
Dharmi-jnana or substantive consciousness. The sentient beings also possess varying levels of Dharma-bhutajnana or attributive consciousness
rashksya/rakshaka (redeemed/redeemer);
These relationships can be experienced holding Brahman
as the father, son, mother, sister, wife, husband, friend,
lover and lord. Hence, Brahman is a personal being.
What does Nirguna Brahman mean?
Ramanuja argues vehemently against understanding
Brahman as one without attributes. Brahman is Nirguna
in the sense that impure qualities do not touch it. He provides three valid reasons for staking such a claim:
Shruti/ Shabda Pramana: All shrutis and shabdas denoting Brahman always list either attributes inherent to Brahman or not inherent to Brahman. The shrutis only seek
Nityas, or the eternally free Jivas who were never in to deny Brahman from possessing impure and defective
qualities which aect the world of beings. There is eviSamsara
dence in the shrutis to this regard. The shrutis proclaim
Muktas, or the Jivas that were once in Samsara but Brahman to be beyond the tri-gunas which are observed.
are free
However, Brahman possesses an innite number of transcendental attributes, the evidence of which is given in
Baddhas, or the Jivas which are still in Samsara
vakhyas like satyam jnanam anantam Brahma (Taittiriya Upanishad).
4.1.3 Achit
Pratyaksha Pramana: Ramanuja states that a contentless
The jivas possess three dierent types of existence:
cognition is impossible. And all cognition must necesAchit is the world of insentient entities as denoted by mat- sarily involve knowing Brahman through the attributes of
ter or more specically the non-conscious Universe. It is Brahman.
similar to the Prakriti of Samkhya system.
Anumana Pramana: Ramanuja states that Nirgunatva
itself becomes an attribute of Brahman on account of
the uniqueness of no other entity being Nirguna. Ra4.1.4 Brahman
manuja had simplied relationship between bramha and
There is a subtle dierence between Ishvara and Brah- soul.According to him though soul is integral part of
man. Ishvara is the substantive part of Brahman, while bramha it has independent existence.[7]
6 INTERPRETATION OF MAHVKYAS
4.2
Theory of Existence
5 Ethics
5
2. ayam tm brahma from Mandukya Upanishad 1.2
7.1 Moksha
Similarly, when the upanishads declare Brahman is the 7.2 Bhakti as the means of attaining moksha
Universe, Purusha, Self, Prana, Vayu, and so on, the entities are attributes or modes of Brahman.
Bhakti Yoga is not the sole means of liberation in VishishIf the statement tat tvam asi is taken to mean as only the
tadvaita. Through Bhakti (devotion), a Jiva ascends to the
self is brahman, then sarvam khalv idam brahma will
realm of the Lord, where it continues to delight in His
not make sense.
service. Karma Yoga and Jnana Yoga are natural outcomes of Bhakti, total surrender, as the devotee acquires
the knowledge that the Lord is the inner self. A devo6.1 Understanding Neti-Neti
tee realizes his own state as dependent on, and supported
by, and being led by the Lord, who is the Master. One
This is an upanishadic concept which is employed while is to lead a life as an instrument of the Lord, oering all
attempting to know Brahman. The purport of this exer- his thought, word, and deed to the feet of the Lord. One
cise is understood in many dierent ways and also inu- is to see the Lord in everything and everything in Him.
ences the understanding of Brahman. In the overall sense, This is the unity in diversity achieved through devotion.[8]
this phrase is accepted to refer to the indescribable nature However Sri Ramanuja and the Vishishtadvata tradition
of Brahman who is beyond all rationalisations.
accept Saranagati, total surrender at the Lords lotus feet
Taittiriya Upanishad 2-9-1 passage yato vacho nivartan- alone as the sole means to moksha, liberation from samthe.. (words recoil, mind can not grasp...) etc., state sara and going to Vaikuntha. This is a distinguishing feathe same concept regarding Brahman . The visishtad- ture of this school of philosophy, as both Adi shankaras
vaita interpretation is that these passages do not indicate advaita and ananda tirthas dvaita accept bhakthi for moka black hole, but the incompleteness of any statement sha. Swami Ramanuja has supported this opinion with
or thought or concept concerning Brahman. Brahman various citations directly from the vedas, and various inis these and more. This interpretation is consistent with cidents highlighting sharangathi as means to moksha,over
sarvam kalvidam brahma. Antaryami Brahmanam of bhakthi. Observing total surrender at the lords feet guarBrihadaranyaka Upanishad passage yasya prithvi sari- antees moksha at the end of this birth, and in the time be-
10
CONCLUSION
7
the Universe is like the relationship of the Soul of Man
to the body of Man. Individual souls are only parts of
Brahman. God, Soul and Universe together form an inseparable unity which is one and has no second. This is
the non-duality part. Matter and Souls inhere in that Ultimate Reality as attributes to a substance. This is the
qualication part of the non-duality.
11
See also
Turiya
12
References
[1] Chandrankunnel, Matthew (2008). Philosophy of Quantum Mechanics. New Delhi: Global Vision Publishing
House. p. 945.
[2] Jones, Constance (2007). Encyclopedia of Hinduism.
New York: Infobase Publishing. p. 490. ISBN
0816073368.
[3] Williams, Raymond (2001). Introduction to Swaminarayan Hinduism. Cambridge: University of Cambridge
Press. p. 35. ISBN 0 521 65279 0.
[4] Sri Dharma Pravartaka Acharya (2013). Sanatana
Dharma: The Eternal Natural Way. Dharma Sun Media.
Retrieved 7 September 2014.
[5] Sri Dharma Pravartaka Acharya (2010). The Vedic Way
of Knowing God. Dharma Sun Media. Retrieved 7
September 2014.
[6] White Yajurveda 32.3
[7] J.L.Mehta VOl3
[8] http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=
$-$9014610686337442954
[9] Chandrankunnel, Matthew (2008). Philosophy of Quantum Mechanics. New Delhi: Global Vision Publishing
House. p. 946.
13
External links
http://www.hinduweb.org/home/dharma_and_
philosophy/vvh/raghavan.html
14
14
14.1
14.2
Images
File:Ambox_important.svg Source: https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/b/b4/Ambox_important.svg License: Public domain Contributors: Own work, based o of Image:Ambox scales.svg Original artist: Dsmurat (talk contribs)
File:Om.svg Source: https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/8/8e/Om.svg License: PD Contributors:
svg created by Rugby471 from a public domain symbol
Original artist:
Rugby471
File:Ramanujacharya.jpg Source: https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/9/93/Ramanujacharya.jpg License: CC BY-SA
4.0 Contributors: Own work Original artist: Debanjon
File:Swamy_Desikan.jpg Source: https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/9/99/Swamy_Desikan.jpg License: CC BY-SA 3.0
Contributors: Own work Original artist: Neilsuds
14.3
Content license